We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Control of Prices Bill, 1932—Committee Stage.

Contributions 141–286 of 286. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Control of Prices Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 20 of 1932 ›

The Deputy said that if they were not continued on the Commission the Minister would have to explain why they were not. The Minister is an officer of the Dáil, responsible to the Dáil if he removes any member of the Commission. Under sub-section (4), Section 5, he is liable to be questioned here in regard to his action in that matter. It is obviously desirable in view of the powers which Deputy McGilligan read out as being conferred on members of the Commission, that the Minister if he wants to make the Commission effective and to ensure that it is going to get the co-operation of the general public, should be able to remove any member of the Commission if he thinks there is a case for his removal.

Comment on this

Why not put that down here?

Comment on this

Is it necessary?

Comment on this

Where does the necessity arise?

Comment on this

Personally I would not take office under these terms.

Comment on this

The Deputy will not be called upon to do so. I have no doubt we will get competent people to take office under these terms.

Comment on this

Define competence.

Comment on this

No doubt the Deputy wants a definition. It is one that is new to his vocabulary.

Comment on this

The Minister's view of what is competent would amuse me.

Comment on this

I have no doubt. Obviously when we are setting up the Commission the members are going to be appointed by the Minister and are removable by the Minister. They need not be removed and will not be removed unless there is cause to remove them and if he does remove them the Minister will have to defend his action here. The Minister may have to defend it if any member of the House is convinced that the removal is not justifiable. If we want to get an effective Bill—and we on this side of the House do want an effective measure to deal with profiteering—this section is necessary.

Comment on this

In regard to the question of not getting applications for membership of the Commission on those terms, I have not the slightest hesitation in saying that the only apprehension I have is that the Minister will be killed in the rush. Government Buildings will be stormed and stampeded by persons who will be glad to take these jobs on any terms, but the fact remains that no man who has any respect for himself will take the position under these terms. There are a number of ways of getting out of it, if the Minister will accept the principle that it is not desirable that there should not be the power of removal without cause stated.

Comment on this

I think it is very desirable that we should have the power stated.

Comment on this

It is a desirable principle, quite apart from the question of convenience or expediency.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not consider that that amendment would water his powers?

Comment on this

Would the Minister be prepared to say that he does not like the principle but that it is necessary? I quite agree the Bill is something like a Heath Robinson cartoon and creaks and groans in every section, but if it is only a means of making the Bill work he might consider on the Report Stage some other scheme to make it workable. Is he prepared to consider any other method except this absolute power to kick any man off the Commission he wishes? If an alternative proposal is made which will put a reasonable tenure of office on any commissioner and at the same time protect him from such arbitrary powers, will the Minister consider such a proposal?

Comment on this

I am prepared to consider any reasonable proposal, but not if it is put in by people opposed to the Bill nor if it is designed to defeat the purpose and effectiveness of the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister operates his power under sub-section 4 of Section 8 and at his pleasure dismisses a member of the Board. Two very disgusting cases were raised at question time to-day, and are to be raised further to-night. It was asked why did the Minister for Justice act in a particular way in these cases——

Comment on this

Does this arise?

Comment on this

——and we were told that this was a prerogative and should not be discussed here. Will the Minister answer more amiably if in the future he is asked why did he dismiss so-and-so from the board? Will he give the answer that immediately jumps to his mind, that it might be damaging to the reputation of the person? There is quite a number of counters to questions of that kind that are put up in such cases, which will close down discussion. If a member goes on this board with sub-section (4) of Section 8 replaced by some such provision as this: That every ordinary member shall hold office for a period to be specified by the Minister when appointing him, which period shall not be less than a year, and during that period may not be removed except for cause stated to the Dáil by the Minister and approved by a resolution of the Dáil— if a member accepted appointment under these conditions, he would then know that the conditions under which he might be removed would have to be explained to, and accepted by, the Dáil. He would take office knowing what would be the consequences. He would be forewarned and would act accordingly, but he also would have it before him that the Minister had got to come down here and make a statement giving the reasons why he had been dropped from the board. It would not be a question of merely dropping him and then have a fobbing off of questions with the usual type of answer—that it was undesirable to have certain things discussed. We have two things clearly before our minds with regard to this Commission. A colleague of the Minister was spoken to in the Seanad with regard to Commissions in general. He was then objecting to a Commission being set up —that the Minister should have all the power.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy please give the reference?

Comment on this

Seanad Debates, Vol. 15, No. 17, columns 1826-7. There is a later reference, which I shall give:

"There are many objections to a Commission that we need not go into now, whether that Commission be one composed of civil servants or of independent people called together as an advisory body. We have had some experience of Commissions. I must confess that even the experience which I thought I had did not fully cover what I have seen since I went into this Department. Commissions are very often slow. Civil Service Commissions are inevitably slow, because they must run within the red tapes afforded by the Department. Other Commissions, independent or socalled independent Commissions, have in fact operated in the State within the last few years, and I must confess that I have been more disappointed even than I thought I was by realising what some of those Commissions did."

Then he went on to say that the Minister in charge of a particular Department, working in close conjunction, as he must, with his Executive Council and subject to the Oireachtas—apart from his Executive Council with his work shown to the public and with everything being known—is better than any Commission. Later on, in column 1833, we get this ponderous statement:

"I do not want to refer again to the experience of Commissions—and I speak with a considerable amount of knowledge of rather disturbing things"—

the Minister for Finance need not be worried. It does not refer to him—

"but I do not want to see any Commission, and I do not want to see outside or advisory Commissions of so-called independent people."

And then there was this grand finale:

"I know what I am talking about."

That is Senator Connolly. We are entitled to look at the Commission which is being considered to try to get a view of what it is likely to do. A Housing Board is being set up of three salaried people. Who are they? An individual representing the Labour Party, or who, I suppose, could be described as representing Labour interests, is upon it. What had he to do with housing?

Comment on this

What has this to do with this section?

Comment on this

It shows the type of men who might be put on the present Commission.

Comment on this

Is it relevant?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

An analysis of the Housing Board is hardly relevant.

Comment on this

We did not get on that Board a person familiar with the matter with which it has to deal. What are we likely to get here? Some other needy Labour person. They have got to be kept in good form this weather.

Comment on this

Another handful of mud. Some day I must publish a list of the jobs arranged by the ex-Minister.

Comment on this

And that will not be mud, I suppose. We have this example. There were many Labour men who could have been appointed on a Board like that, or that may be appointed on the proposed Board, but look at the choice that was made in the former case. Will the same motives that operated there operate with regard to this? It has been described by a number of people as simply an opportunity to provide jobs. There is no evidence that this Commission is required. There is no profiteering. There are only complaints, and we are going to have people appointed, at salaries presumably, to investigate complaints. The Minister has given us no information as to the types who will form the members of the Board. He has not stated whether there will be an accountant or an agriculturist or an experienced person of any kind, and we have all the time to bear in mind that among these representatives there must be two women on the Commission. We have not got that statement from him and any attempt to get it from him is described either as obstruction or throwing mud. He could stop any criticism of this type by stating if he has in his mind types and not persons and if he has not individuals before his mind as the suitable people to appoint. Has he a category of people from whom he is going to draw the members? Let us eliminate, at any rate, certain undesirable categories. If the Minister likes to sit in a sort of sulky silence certain conclusions will be drawn from that. The Minister is going to accept, or he will consider, an amendment, provided it is not put down by people who are obviously opposed to this Bill. This rules out this Party.

Comment on this

The profiteers' party.

Comment on this

And the profiteers do not exist.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Nor does the mud!

Comment on this

When the Minister is here himself he cannot speak of profiteers because he cannot produce evidence with regard to them. There was a lot of bawling down in the country about profiteering and prices, and about people battening on the poor, and so this had to come along. There is no evidence of it and there is no evidence that the Minister is serious about this Commission. He has not given us any indication that he has thought about the people he wants to appoint or the categories from which they are to be drawn. This is flung out with the statement that he did not believe there would be very much work for this Commission. The Minister reiterated to-day that he has not had evidence produced to him of a prima facie type establishing profiteering. Is the Minister prepared to consider on Report an amendment substituting sub-section (4) by what I have said? Is he prepared to consider on Report an amendment of this type:—"That every ordinary member will hold office for a specified term not less than one year, and during that specified term he may not be removed except for cause stated to the Dáil and approved by Resolution of the Dail?"

Comment on this

This Commission will be set up by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to carry out for that Minister certain investigations. The Commission will then report to the Minister. I am not prepared to accept an amendment of the kind indicated. It is quite right and proper that the members of the Commission should be removed by the Minister if their removal is necessary to enable investigation to proceed in a proper manner and with the necessary expedition.

Comment on this

The Minister is not prepared to have an obligation put upon himself to come to the Dáil and state why the investigations are not proceeding properly through one member. That is what it comes to.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That Section 8 stand part of the Bill."

Tá 65
·
Níl 48
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

The fact is that objecting to sections of this Bill really brings home to one more and more how fundamentally rotten the Bill is and how dangerous it is. We used to regard as one of the bogeys in our youth a person who was known as "Peter the Packer." It was regarded as a great instrument of oppression on the part of the British Government in this country to pack a jury. You did not pay the jury. They simply got into the jury box and their only inducement to hang you was that it would get them out quicker than if they disagreed. But the Minister, under Section 9, when he proposes an investigation into the price of any particular commodity, can promptly appoint extra persons to the already established Commission to hear that particular case. The danger in that is obvious. If the Minister has already five people on it, in 99 cases out of 100 he would simply appoint one or two more who would be specially qualified to deal with some particular commodity. But it does not give him the power to do this. If, for some unscrupulous reason, he desires to discredit some particular merchant or manufacturer, he could arrange that an inquiry would be launched by this Commission and persons could be appointed with a certain knowledge with the deliberate intention of overbearing the Commission and with the purpose present to his mind. Ordinarily, when he appoints his five Commissioners, they are persons whom he will appoint for general qualities, such as one being a good accountant, another a lady with a wide experience of shopping, a lawyer and so forth. Having, according to himself, provided a Commission giving scope for a reasonable representation of relevant interests, he takes further powers to put on special members in special cases. Normally, that power will not be wrongly used, but it can be, in the hands of the Minister, a weapon of great oppression and of great danger. The tragedy of this is that a price-fixing Bill looks a mild thing, a thing that can really hurt nobody except the wicked profiteer. As a matter of fact, it can become an instrument of very grave oppression. In this particular case, if the section were being used by an unscrupulous Minister, it could be used to the very grave detriment of the citizens of the State, who would have very little power to defend themselves against him.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy's trouble is that he has not grasped the fact that this Commission is appointed for the purpose of carrying out, on behalf of the Minister, certain investigations and reporting to the Minister.

Comment on this

I grasp it very well.

Comment on this

Therefore, the power is given to the Minister to appoint the members of the Commission, and Section 9 is inserted to ensure that, whenever there is an investigation of a kind that will require specialist knowledge, a person with that knowledge can be added to the Commission. It seems to me eminently reasonable that power to appoint these temporary members with specialised knowledge in certain special circumstances should exist. Section put and agreed to.

SECTION 10.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister if he has made up his mind that it is really essential to the success of the Commission that the members should be permanent. I do not know that we have any evidence before us which would lead us to the conclusion that a permanent Commission is absolutely essential. The Minister might, as he is aware, set up a Commission for a period of three or five years. If, at the end of that period, the Minister thought that the circumstances justified the continuance of the Commission, he would have power to continue it. I think it is hardly wise for the Minister at this stage to express the opinion that a permanent Commission is necessary. I do not think that the Minister has such evidence before him as would justify him in coming to the conclusion that a permanent Commission is essential. At least, if he has, he has not expressed it.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give the House any information as to the salaries to be paid to the members of the Commission?

Comment on this

Deputy Good's point hardly arises on this section. Under Part 5 of the Bill it is intended that the Commission should carry out a more or less continuous investigation of the prices charged by manufacturers for protected commodities. I think it is eminently desirable that there should be a permanent body in existence to watch the course of prices in respect of protected commodities, a body that will report to the Minister when anything unusual occurs or where, in their opinion, an unnecessary increase in price takes place so that, if necessary, action can be taken. The position is quite different in respect to the functions of the Committee under Part 3 of the Bill. It would suffice there, perhaps, to have a body that could be brought into existence whenever there was a case for investigation. But under Part 5 of the Bill I think a permanent body is necessary at present. When we have had experience of its working we may reconsider the position as to whether the Bill is necessary or whether it can be modified in any way.

Deputy Cosgrave's point does not arise on this section, but on the following one. We hope to secure—this is a point that Deputies who have spoken earlier might note—that the members of the Commission will act without any remuneration. I do not think we will have much difficulty in that. But, of course, it is easy to conceive that it may be desirable to have a person with legal training or an accountant of high standing in his profession a member of the Commission. In such a case it would be unreasonable to expect that they would give the time necessary without some remuneration. Consequently, power is taken to pay that remuneration where necessary, but we hope to be able to get members to act without any remuneration.

Comment on this

At the outset I think it would be well if the Minister were to fix a limited period during which the members of the Commission would act. If the Minister were to adopt that suggestion it would, I think, make his task easier in getting members to act. I am sure, as the Minister says, it may be possible to get citizens to discharge these duties in an honorary capacity. It would be much easier, I think, to get citizens capable of discharging these duties to act if they were not expected to continue as permanent members. If the period of membership were to be, say, for three to five years I think it would be much better. It may not be an easy matter at all to get citizens suitable for the position to act on a permanent body. I think that at the outset at all events the Minister ought not to make it a permanent body.

Comment on this

It is quite clear that there is power to do that under the Bill as drafted.

Comment on this

Until the Minister has had some experience of the necessity for such a Commission, I think he ought not to make it a permanent body. I think it is undesirable to do so.

Comment on this

I think the Minister's references to the question of examining the prices of the protected commodities was slightly irrelevant on this section. I think it would have arisen more appropriately on an earler section.

Comment on this

It strikes me as an extraordinary thing that the Commission should at one and the same time examine into the ordinary price of goods in retail shops and the commodity prices of protected manufactures. The class of person that would be useful for the one might be quite unsuitable for the other. I suggest that there are very few women who have had sufficient experience of prices, costings, etc., of a manufacturing business. They might be suitable for the other type of inquiry on the prices side. I think it is a ridiculous proposal.

Comment on this

On behalf of women I must disagree with the Deputy.

Comment on this

Is there any danger, under the terms of the Bill, of the Chairman and members of the Commission becoming established civil servants with pension rights?

Comment on this

None whatever.

Comment on this

Under this section is it the intention of the Minister, when inviting persons to become members of the Commission, to attach a salary in the first instance?

Comment on this

I would like to know from the Minister why the word "substantially" is introduced into the section. It says: "Substantially interested in any industry." As the section reads a person investigating the price of a certain commodity might be in business dealing with one thing and might be a large shareholder in another industry taking in this commodity. I think if the word "substantially" were deleted the section would be improved.

Comment on this

If you deleted the word you could not for instance put anyone that eats bread on a Commission appointed to investigate the price of bread.

Comment on this

I think that is going to extremes.

Comment on this

It is necessary to have some qualifying word.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say what was the effect of the words in a marginal note of the section "prohibition of interested persons acting as members"? I do not know whether these words would leave the Minister in any difficulty at a later stage.

Comment on this

The section itself in fact prohibits a person substantially interested in any business from investigating the prices charged in that business. The important point is that it is the opinion of the Minister that will operate as the determining factor, whether or not a particular person is substantially interested in a business or not.

Comment on this

I want to assure the Minister that I did not raise the point with a view to limiting his discretion on the matter. I thought the matter might have escaped his attention. If, say, Joseph Rank could get a seat on a Board appointed to examine the flour milling industry without your noticing it all would be well. He would be subject to no penalty under the Bill, but if the Minister noticed it he was undone.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Is it the intention of the Minister to appoint an existing civil servant to the post of Controller of Prices? I would like to know what kind of person he has in his mind. Apart altogether from his statutory powers, the person appointed will have very considerable powers, and be a person of considerable influence. I would like to know what the Minister has in his mind with regard to the type of person to be appointed. Will it be a person from the existing Civil Service by way of promotion, or a person from outside?

Comment on this

My intention is to appoint a member of the existing Civil Service.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

This section sets out that the Commission may make regulations for the governance of its own proceedings. There is no mention in any part of the section that the regulations are to be subject to the approval of the Minister, and as far as I can gather from the Bill they are not to be laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. The Commission can make regulations for the conduct of its business, but there is no obligation on it to submit these regulations for the approval of the Minister or of the House. That seems to be the position as far as I can gather from the Bill.

Subsequently the Commission is given power to enforce the attendance of witnesses, to examine them on oath similar to the powers vested in the High Court, and subsequently again, the Commission may certify an offence to the High Court for punishment. It seems a rather strange thing that the Commission shall have power to make regulations, and may make regulations that may be unreasonable, yet a contravention of these regulations would be punishable by the High Court. It does not seem reasonable that these regulations should not be first submitted to the Minister, and secondly to the House by being published in the House. For example, the Commission may decide, at any given moment, to hold a meeting in public. It may summon Patrick Murphy to appear before it according to the regulations which it made. Patrick Murphy may think in his own interest that to give certain evidence in public he would be reported to the High Court. To my mind it is not clear, but perhaps the Minister has had legal advice as to how far the High Court is expected to make enquiry. "The High Court," it says in sub-section (2), Section 17, line 14, "may, after such inquiries as it thinks proper to make, punish or take steps for the punishment of that person." Would the High Court have power to inquire into and examine into the regulations that the person had contravened. My point is that the Commission itself makes regulations and that for the contravention of these regulations a man may be punished. In other words, the Commission is doing something that the House should only do; it is defining what should be punishable by law.

Comment on this

I shall look into the point whether there is any necessity to have these regulations approved by the Minister or laid before the House. The section there has power that has been given in a great variety of Acts. It appears specially in the Merchandise Marks Act; it is transferred from that measure.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Plus 17; it takes 16 and 17.

Comment on this

As far as 17 is concerned the offences are if any person summoned as a witness defaults in attending, or refuses to take an oath legally required by the Commission, or to produce any document in his power and control legally required by the Commission, or to answer any question to which the Commission may legally require an answer, or does any other thing which would, if the Commission were a Court of Justice, be contempt of such court. These are the only offences upon which a certificate can be issued. The other matters upon which the Commission may make regulations such as the holding of its sittings, the time of its sittings, do not arise. The Deputy has put his finger on a particular difficulty. That is the difficulty which arises when a person is summoned as a witness and, at a public sitting, is asked to give information concerning his own business which he does not wish to give in public. We will have that discussed again on an amendment tabled in the names of Deputy Good and Deputy Dockrell. We have tried to safeguard that position by putting in a rather elaborate provision prohibiting disclosure of things available only by virtue of the powers of obtaining information conferred upon the Commission. That is a matter that we will discuss later. But the particular point of having the regulations of the Commission subject either to the approval of the Minister or the Dáil is something that I shall look into. At the moment I am not clear as to the necessity or whether the particular point made by the Deputy is one inherent in the Bill or whether it does not necessarily arise out of the regulations, but out of the whole scheme.

Comment on this

There is one other point. If my recollection is correct I heard of a case in which some witness appeared before one of those statutory bodies and, refusing to answer a certain question, was committed. My recollection is that he was forgotten, and was in jail for a considerable time, so that I think there should be a time limit. It should not be for a longer time than the Commission lasts. My recollection is that this man was in jail long after the Commission passed out of existence.

Comment on this

That would be a difficulty in the High Court. We could not amend the powers of the High Court.

Comment on this

It was not for the High Court as long as the measure was in existence. This man was committed for contempt of the Tribunal and kept in prison after the Tribunal had passed out of existence.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

Under what Government did that happen?

Comment on this

Under a much better one than the present one.

Comment on this

It had a good conceit of itself.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

One other point—it all hangs together the section says: "The court may after such inquiry as it thinks proper to make." Is the Minister satisfied that that imposes no limitation upon the High Court.

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

It can make no inquiries. The court cannot make any special inquiries into any regulations made by the Commission.

Comment on this

The regulations made by the Commission could not be nullified in consequence of some judgment of the High Court.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2. At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—

"(3) In this section the word ‘person' includes a trade association and the representative of a trade association acting for such association."

I do not know how far I am preaching to the converted in proposing this amendment. Does the Minister realise that in these days when practically every trade has some sort of organisation, if he could get a trade to appear officially before him and to make representations, that if there is anything to investigate and anything to alter, an arrangement made officially with the trade could be more easily carried out, and would be less likely to lead to any misunderstanding or any feeling that the individual representative of the trade had allowed something to go by default, and that if he had realised the question that he was actually asked he might have made a proper submission of all the facts? I suggest to the Minister that in a case where he could get the representatives of the whole trade in front of him, and with the evidence submitted officially, the Commission will more easily and quickly arrive at a proper finding of all the facts.

Comment on this

The amendment is not necessary. Section 1 (c) of the Adaptation Act of 1923 enacts that the word "person" in every case shall include any body of persons corporate or incorporate. It appears that an association of the kind is covered by the word "person,"

Comment on this

In other words, it is quite clear that trade associations can appear and make representations.

Comment on this

Quite clear.

Comment on this

I move amendment 3:—

At the end of sub-section (2), line 42, to add the words:—Provided always that where a sitting of the Commission is held which is open to the public a report of the proceedings of such sitting may be published.

Owing to sub-section 2 there appears to be some ambiguity in the minds of many people as to how far the proceedings of the Commission may be made public. (Sub-section read.) As it stands that sub-section leaves it very indefinite as to what can be published, and I would like to get from the Minister some information as to whether this Commission will follow the procedure that was followed by the Tariff Commission, which was somewhat analagous. As the Minister will remember, the Tariff Commission held private sittings at which private matters were discussed in detail which it was not desirable to make public. The Commission at other times held public sittings. What this amendment aims at is, that the Press shall be at liberty to publish the proceedings of public meetings of the Commission.

Comment on this

I do not think the analogy of the Tariff Commission holds in this case. Obviously the inquiries that are going to be made by this Commission will be of a more intimate nature than those which the Tariff Commission had to conduct. There is a clear difficulty here which gave considerable trouble in the drafting of the Bill. If we were to accept the Deputy's amendment, and put in the proviso he suggests, the Commission, I think, would be compelled to hold private sessions every time they were examining a witness who was summoned to attend, and perhaps every time they were examining witnesses in relation to matters likely to be investigated by the Commission. The questions asked and the information given might be of a very confidential nature relating to the trade of the person concerned.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

Therefore, we put in this section, sub-section (2) of which makes it unlawful for any person present at a meeting of the Commission to make public "any information acquired through being present at such sitting and which is available only by virtue of the powers of obtaining information conferred upon the Commission or an inspector by this Act." It seems to me that that would preclude the reporting of any evidence given on oath, unless the Prices Commission and the witness agreed to its publication. In effect, by the section we are leaving the nut to the Commission itself to crack, and to make any regulations, in order to ensure a witness appearing before it against damage for publication of evidence. We are making it illegal for the public to give private information which the Commission obtained in exercise of its powers under this Bill. On the other hand I think it would be unwise to accept the amendment, because it would practically force the Commission always to sit in private. What we desire is that the Commission, in so far as possible, will do its work in public, while at the same time protecting the witness against damage for publication of the evidence. The Commission will have to reconcile these two things within the limits prescribed by the section.

Comment on this

I am very glad to hear the Minister say that publicity is desirable, because I think one of the great advantages of a Commission of this kind is wide publicity of the proceedings. We will all be in favour, at all events, of making the task of the Press as easy as we can, so as to get wide publicity. I am afraid under this sub-section as it stands the task of the Press will be exceedingly difficult. Is it the intention of the Minister that a report of the proceedings shall be supplied to the Press and that they shall not be at liberty to take their own report, which, as the Minister knows, is customary at such Commissions?

Comment on this

It would work out, in my opinion, by the Press reporting speeches made by counsel, and general statements of that kind, and also the evidence of witnesses, except the members of the Commission intimated in advance, or the witness requested the Commission to intimate in advance, that the evidence would not be published, in which case it would be illegal under the section for newspapers to report such evidence. It is obviously a matter in respect of which it is difficult to make a general rule, because one trader in a particular commodity might say that he had no objection whatever, while another trader in the same commodity might say that there were special reasons which made it desirable that the evidence would be heard in camera. The Commission has to try to adjust its proceedings, and to go into the difficulties of the situation, while, at the same time, we make it definitely illegal—except with the general consent of the people concerned—to give any information that the Commission obtained as a result of the exercise of its powers in Section 17.

Comment on this

I do not see how the Minister is going to solve the matter. I know some persons who would like to give evidence, and who would desire that that evidence would have the widest possible publicity. In fact, they would be disappointed if it did not get the fullest publicity. Other members of the Commission might consider that it might be undesirable to publish that evidence and there might be a difference between the witnesses and the Commission. In the circumstances, what is the Press to do? I think we should settle the matter. The procedure at previous Commissions has been settled and it should be settled in this case.

Comment on this

It was interesting to hear the explanation given by the Minister. I think this shows how different people get different impressions. Deputy Good stated that he was glad to see that the Minister desired publicity. I listened carefully to the Minister, and it struck me that the Minister was aiming precisely at the opposite. I am not entering into this in a political sense but, on reading the section, I understood that there is prohibition of publication. Just as a door must be open or shut, the meetings must be private or public. I do not understand how you are going to get over the situation. Take a country town where the Commission meets, and the Press is present, apparently members of the public may be present.

Comment on this

That is a matter for the Commission to make regulations about.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

The Press may be present.

Comment on this

If the Commission so decides.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

That is the whole difficulty. Can the Commission decide to hold a public session? If it does what will happen under sub-section 2 of this section? Anything that the Commission decides cannot override sub-section 2 of Section 19 when it is passed. This section prohibits the publication of the evidence. Practical commonsense tells us that if, in a country town, a meeting of the Commission is held at which persons other than officers of the Commission and witnesses are present, something almost as good as publication in a newspaper, in so far as that country town is concerned, will take place. That is absolutely certain. We all know what a country town is. If a local person is present at a meeting of the Commission in a country town, information as to what takes place at the Commission will go all over the place and in a much worse manner than if it were published in the newspapers. If it were published, publication would take place according to the ordinary practice of the Press, with certain exceptions, as, for example, when the "Irish Press" is reporting disturbances at political meetings. In the ordinary way, however, one gets some sort of accuracy in a Press report. What would appear to happen here would be: You would have Pressmen present but you would not get a Press report; you would get local rumours as to what happened at the Commission and the result, from the point of view of the trader or any interested party attending before the Commission, would be very much worse than if there was a newspaper report of the proceedings published. I think that, in the ordinary case, the result of the operation of this section would be more damaging to a trader than a fair newspaper report, such as would be given by any reporter and published by a local or Dublin newspaper. I realise the Minister's difficulty but I think that he is endeavouring to reconcile things that are really irreconcilable. Either the Commission should be given instructions to hold its meetings in private or it should be allowed to make regulations for holding its meetings in public. It should be provided in the Act that, in the case of a public meeting, a newspaper report may be published. Let these two kinds of meetings have their normal meaning and take their course.

As regards the speeches of advocates, I do not know what sort of regulations this Commission will make. They may allow counsel to appear before them. They may not allow anybody but counsel and witnesses to appear, or they may allow representatives of organised bodies—organised bodies of consumers, trade associations or trade unions—to appear before them. In that case, a speech made by such a representative would surely be privileged. That is to say, he would be allowed to make the same kind of speech as counsel would make in a court. If published, that might do considerable damage, because it might contain several accusations. If portion of it were published and the other portion withheld, you might get a very unfair result. I cannot understand how this section would work. I submit to the Minister that the Commission could not, by any kind of human ingenuity, make regulations which would enable them to hold meetings which would be neither public nor private.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Hayes that a sitting must be either private or public. After all, the Press ought to get a fair hunt. If they arrive at a Commission, find the doors shut in their faces and ascertain that it is a private sitting, if they publish anything about it, it is their funeral. Equally, if they arrive at a meeting of the Commission which is open to the public, they should be entitled to publish the proceedings. But it seems to me that the Minister envisages some sort of situation like this—that at a meeting where opening statements have been heard, and the evidence of A, B and C taken, it may be suggested that the evidence of D be treated as private. Is that the Minister's idea? If it is, I suggest that it is not quite fair. I do not know whether the Controller is to make that announcement or whether reference to the evidence of that party will appear later. I suggest that the Minister will have to make up his mind that the meetings of the Commission will be either public or private. He cannot have a mixture of the two.

Comment on this

There comes to my mind a situation that arose in regard to the Liquor Commission. A consumer appeared and gave evidence in which he assailed a company in a provincial town. He made very serious charges again them. The newspapers reported a very small part of the evidence in this case. The company which was assailed had to be communicated with. When their witness came to give rebutting evidence, the only way it could be done was by those of us on the Commission who had taken notes of the statements made asking him whether these statements were true or not. That opens up a question with which the Minister should try to deal. A notice had to be sent to this gentleman to say that his company had been assailed. When he came to rebut the accusation, he did not know what he had to rebut, because a full report had not been published. I think it is very difficult to decide whether the Commission should sit at certain times in private and at other times in public. I cannot make up my mind at the moment what would be the best procedure to adopt but I should like to secure that no charges could be made against a person or company without their getting a proper chance of stating their side of the case.

Comment on this

In the amendment which is in the name of Deputy Dockrell and myself, it is provided that where a sitting of the Commission is held which is open to the public, it should be permissible to publish a report of the proceedings. It is only with regard to a public sitting that this permission is given under the amendment.

Comment on this

That amendment does not, in my opinion, meet all the difficulties. What we want to ensure is that, so far as it is possible to do it, the proceedings of the Commission will take place in public, while at the same time ensuring that nobody who appears before the Commission and helps it by giving evidence will be prejudiced in their business or injured in any way as the result of their action.

Comment on this

We are with you in that.

Comment on this

It might be possible— I am prepared to consider how far it is possible—to insert provisions to enable the Commission to declare certain meetings to be public meetings which may be reported in full by Press reporters present and other meetings to be private meetings, publication of reports of which would be debarred under Section 2. If the Deputy will leave over his amendment until Report Stage, I shall have another effort made to solve the difficulty.

Comment on this

This is really the vital part: Suppose there is a session being held at which the confidential evidence the Minister is thinking of is to be given. The witness, when he comes to give that evidence, if the meeting is not called a private meeting, will say: "While I am giving this evidence, somebody in the neighbourhood who is really interested in what I am going to say may walk in." While the evidence may not be disclosed by the Press, it may be disclosed to a person to whom it will be of real importance and who may walk in at any moment. That will, undoubtedly, affect the evidence such a person will give. I do not think that there is any alternative to allowing confidential evidence of that kind to be given in private, if the person giving the evidence so claims. I ask the Minister to consider that point.

Comment on this

Those were the lines on which I was thinking of proceeding —to empower the Commission to declare, in respect of certain meetings, that there will be no limitation on the report of proceedings and, in respect of other meetings, that not merely will a report not be published, but that only particular persons shall be present when the evidence is being given. Under Section 16, the Commission has power to make regulations as regards the admission or exclusion of persons from the sittings.

Comment on this

Even part of one meeting should be provided for.

Comment on this

Yes, no doubt the regulations which the Commission will make will cover the various difficulties which will arise.

Comment on this

I am glad that the Minister has reconsidered this. Take it in the case of a private session where evidence of the nature mentioned by Deputy Thrift will be given. If serious charges are made against a number of persons in a district or town, or loose charges of profiteering, look at the position. A person comes in and makes these charges. Will there be an obligation on the Commission to see that these charges in detail are inquired into—not certainly the name of the person that made them, that is another matter, but at all events that they will be brought there knowing that these charges are made and that these traders will have an opportunity of rebutting them? If the Commission is to hear vague anonymous charges like that, will there be an obligation on them to bring that to the notice of the traders in pretty fair detail so that these people will have an opportunity of rebutting these charges?

Comment on this

I assume the Commission will do so, but there is no definite obligation upon them to do so. The Commission makes its own regulations governing its own procedure in these matters. It certainly has full power to ensure the attendance of everybody.

Comment on this

But it may lead to the ruin of a number of traders who may be quite innocent and who may not know that these charges are made. Is there any obligation on the Commission in that respect? If the Minister reconsiders this section he might reconsider that point as well.

Comment on this

Charges cannot possibly damage the traders unless they are published.

Comment on this

But the order may be made and they may not have been given an opportunity of rebutting them.

Comment on this

Yes, the Commission may make an order.

Comment on this

I am asking the Minister to reconsider that.

Comment on this

What the Deputy is suggesting is that some public notice should be given that these charges had been made.

Comment on this

And also that if a charge is made against a class or a shopkeeper in the town the Commission will notify that such a charge has been made and give an opportunity of rebutting it.

Comment on this

In view of the undertaking that the Minister has given I ask leave of the House to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 4:—

Before Section 21 and in Part II of the Bill to insert the following new section:—

(1) The Minister may appoint the Commission to hold a public inquiry for the purposes of Section 17 of the Housing (Financial and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1932 (No. 19 of 1932), and whenever the Minister so appoints the Commission to hold any such inquiry, the following provisions shall have effect, that is to say:—

(a) the Commission shall hold such inquiry;

(b) the provisions of this Part of this Act relating to the following matters, that is to say, regulations for proceedings of the Commission, powers of the Commission, notices of investigation by the Commission and submissions by interested persons, prohibition on disclosure of information and annual reports by the Commission, shall not apply in respect of such inquiry.

Under Section 17 of the Housing Act of 1932 the Minister for Industry and Commerce has power to hold an inquiry into the prices charged for building materials. The purpose of this amendment is merely to provide that the Minister may appoint the Commission established by this Bill to hold that investigation. That Act gives him power to appoint a Commission to hold a public inquiry and have a report. This is intended for the purpose of enabling the Minister to appoint a Commission to hold a public investigation subject to this, that the regulations for the proceedings of the Commission, powers of the Commission, notices of investigation by the Commission, and submissions by interested persons, prohibition on disclosure of information and annual reports by the Commission shall not apply in respect of such inquiry. The only provisions that can apply in respect of such inquiry are those contained in the Housing Act. It is clear that the Minister could appoint five individuals constituting the Commission to hold the inquiry under the Housing Act, but he could not appoint the Commission itself without this amendment. The Minister will have the staff of the Commission as well.

Comment on this

But there is no obligation on the Minister to appoint the Commission because it appears to me that the problem will be entirely different. Of course it may be within the jurisdiction of the Commission to deal with these problems but the ordinary cases will be quite different from the problems they will have to deal with under the Prices Commission.

Comment on this

It would be quite possible under the Housing Act. Then the Minister may use the Commission and its machinery to carry out that investigation.

Comment on this

Does that mean that the Commission could not hold a private session?

Comment on this

It means that they would have to act in the manner prescribed by the Housing Act. We could not amend the Housing Act by an amendment here. One thing we can do is that the Commission may hold an investigation but it must be in accordance with the provisions of that Act.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:—

Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) Before sending under the immediately preceding sub-section a request to the Commission to make an investigation into the price (whether retail or wholesale) of butter the Minister shall first consult the Minister for Agriculture."

This amendment and the majority of the remaining amendments all relate to the same thing. They are designed to secure that before an investigation of the wholesale prices of butter shall take place, the Minister shall consult with the Minister for Agriculture. This is required in consequence of the powers conferred upon the Minister for Agriculture in connection with the Bounty Bill. These are drafting amendments but they are intended to safeguard the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment 6:—

In sub-section (2), page 7, line 21, to insert after the word "make" the words "subject to the provisions of the next following sub-section." This amendment is consequential.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

At the end of the section to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(3) Where a representation under the immediately preceding sub-section relates to the price (whether wholesale or retail) of butter, the Commission shall refer such representation to the Minister for Agriculture and shall not make any investigation into the subject matter of such representation except with the consent of the said Minister."

Comment on this

I move amendment 8, which is consequential:—

In sub-section (1), page 8, line 4, to insert after the word "fit" the words "and subject to the provisions of this section."

Comment on this

I move amendment 9:—

In sub-section (2), page 8, line 11, to insert after the word "fit" the words "and subject to the provisions of this section."

Comment on this

I move amendment 10:—

"To insert at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

"(5) Before making a price order in relation to butter the Minister shall first consult the Minister for Agriculture."

Comment on this

I move amendment 11:—

To insert at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

(2) Before making an order under this section revoking or amending a price order in relation to butter, the Minister shall first consult the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

I move amendment 12:—

Before Section 27 and in Part IV of the Bill insert a new section as follows:—

The Controller shall not do any act or thing or make a certificate under this Part of this Act in relation to the price (whether wholesale or retail) of butter except he is authorised in writing by the Minister for Agriculture to do such act or thing or make such certificate.

Comment on this

I move amendment 13:—

Before Section 31 to insert a new section as follows:—

(3) Whenever a price certificate in force in relation to a scheduled commodity has been served on any person who carries on any business by way of trade or gain and such person is satisfied that the price fixed by the Controller is not a fair price for such commodity, such person, or the trade association of which he is a member, may send a representation in a form to be prescribed to the Commission for an investigation into the price of such commodity and thereupon the Commission shall hold such an investigation and pending the result thereof the said price certificate shall not take effect.

Comment on this

I am disposed to accept this amendment, in principle, but, if the Deputy will withdraw the amendment, I will produce an amendment on Report Stage which will, I think, serve the purpose he has in mind.

Comment on this

With permission, I withdraw.

Comment on this

I move amendment 14:—

Before Section 32 and as a new Part of the Bill to insert the following section:—

PART V.

Display of Retail Price Lists in Shops.

(1) The Commission may make a report (in this Part of this Act referred to as price list report) to the Minister stating that in their opinion it is desirable, in the public interest, that the Minister should make an order under this Part of this Act requiring every person who carries on the business of selling retail either (as may be specified in such report) at any place in Saorstát Eireann or at particular places in Saorstát Eireann any scheduled commodity or commodities to display at the premises where such person carries on such business a list stating the retail price of such commodity or commodities.

(2) Every report under this section shall specify:—

(a) the reasons why the Commission consider it desirable that the order the subject of the report should be made;

(b) a specification of every commodity to which the proposed order should relate;

(c) the date on which the Commission recommend the proposed order should come into force, and the duration of such order;

(d) the area to which the Commission recommend the proposed order should apply;

(e) the manner in which the Commission recommend that the proposed order should require the price list of every such commodity to be displayed.

During the discussions on the Second Reading, I announced that we had been giving consideration to the possibility of providing that, in certain circumstances, traders would be required to publish a notice indicating the price they were charging at the time for certain commodities. I also indicated the various difficulties we foresaw would arise if we had a general provision in relation to the publication of prices—the variety of commodities, the difficulty of distinguishing one quality from another and the fact that a regulation which would apply in one area, and which could be enforced in one area, might not be applicable to the circumstances of another area at all. We have endeavoured to get over these difficulties in the way set out in the amendment, in which we enabled the Commission to make a report on the question as to whether it is, in their opinion, desirable that an order should be made by the Minister requiring the publication in a specified manner of prices relating to specified commodities in specified districts. In other words, we provide that no order, requiring publication of these prices, will take place until an investigation into the matter has been made by the Commission and a report furnished. The report will indicate the reasons why it is considered desirable that an order should be made. It will specify the commodity or commodities to be covered by the order, the date on which it should come into operation, and the area in which it should operate, and, of course, and this is a matter of considerable importance, the manner in which the price list in respect of the commodities concerned is to be displayed. There is a feeling in a number of quarters that the publication of these price lists would conduce to better shopping on the part of sections of the community. Deputy Sir James Craig quoted a statement, made by a member of the Commission on which he served, that if people would only use the necessary diligence while shopping there would be no profiteering and they could procure supplies at the lowest prices. It may help to develop that attitude, because shoppers, by requiring in respect of certain commodities, where it is feasible to do so, the shopkeeper to publish in some particular manner, outside or inside his shop, a notice indicating the price at which that commodity is on sale on the day on which the notice is displayed. It will then be feasible for people without undue difficulty, or without placing themselves in circumstances of undue embarrassment, to ascertain, in respect of that commodity in a number of shops, the price at which it is available and that might tend undoubtedly to induce the necessary element of competition and reduced prices. We are, however, putting the onus on the Commission of finding a way out of the various administrative difficulties which it is easy to foresee.

Comment on this

It is very easy for the Minister to read it off and to say that it is easy to foresee administrative difficulties. There are certainly going to be administrative difficulties from the point of view of his Department. but the more I listen to the Minister talking about this Bill, the more it is driven in upon me that the Minister has allowed himself to be manoeuvred into the position of regarding the mercantile community in this country as a gang of desperadoes. Every kind of harassment is to be allowed under his æs, and the latest performance is this list of prices. Now, I have the most profound respect for the experiences of Deputy Sir James Craig in most matters to which he refers in this House, but he is not a merchant, and I do not think he can be familiar with the variety.

Comment on this

That is all the better from the point of view of my judgment.

Comment on this

I do not know so much about that, but if I started to give Deputy Sir James Craig a brief lecture on the best way to treat typhoid fever——

Comment on this

I would not listen to you.

Comment on this

He would not listen to me, and very properly, but, similarly, when he proceeds to tell me that his detachment helps him to form a true judgment of the difficulties of the mercantile community, he must pardon me if I do not listen to him. The existing Schedule provides that the Commission will take into consideration articles used as food, clothing, material for clothing or fuel. It is manifestly absurd that a schedule of prices should be put up about clothing. "This shop sells trousers at 3/6"— that is manifestly ridiculous. "This shop sells navy blue serge for 7/11"— that is manifestly absurd and, obviously, this proviso cannot apply there. It is meant to apply in respect of foodstuffs. I know that the Minister is acquainted with certain branches of what may be described as the dry goods trade, but I do not know that he is acquainted very extensively with the food and provision trade. If he were acquainted with it, he would know that, in the principal items of the food and provision business prices vary from day to day and week to week, and an order is to be made requiring.

every person who carries on the business of selling retail, either at any place in Saorstát Eireann or at particular places in Saorstát Eireann, any scheduled commodity or commodities, to display at the premises where such person carries on such business a list stating the retail price of such commodity or commodities.

Is the suggestion here that the retailer —I assume it only applies to retailers —should expose a list of prices at which he is retailing on any given day? Suppose the Commission fixes a price, say, for Indian meal. That is the fixed price in that area. They can fix a price for a given area——

Comment on this

A maximum price.

Comment on this

They can fix a maximum price in that given area. Presumably, it will be against the law for anybody to sell Indian meal for anything over or above that price in that area, even though the price varies to such an extent that it becomes necessary to sell at an increased price. Without further reference to the Commission, the sale of Indian meal must stop in that area until a further order is made revising the price. I see now, on closer study of the section, that it simply puts an obligation on a man to schedule his prices for certain commodities. I confess that when I first read the section I thought it meant that the Minister might fix a certain price which a person would have to display, but it simply requires the publication, in a form to be prescribed, of the prices he is actually charging?

Comment on this

I withdraw, then.

Comment on this
Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

It is like the Electricity Supply speech.

Comment on this

I hope it is more intelligent than the Parliamentary Secretary's contribution to the debate.

Comment on this

I want to ask a question on Section 32, line 48. The section reads: "The Minister may from time to time send to the Commission a requisition requiring the Commission to investigate the price charged for any protected commodity which conforms to the specimen set out in such articles by persons manufacturing such commodities in Saorstát Eireann." Would the Minister explain what the words "which conforms to the specimen set out in such articles" mean? It appears to me as if that phrase were superfluous.

Comment on this

Well, no. It might be considered necessary to investigate the price charged for one particular class of article, which would be in a general range subject to the term "protected commodity." For example, it might be decided to investigate the price of agricultural labourers' boots without at the same time carrying out an investigation into the entire range of boot and shoe prices. That is why the qualifying words are put in there.

Comment on this

That settles it.

Comment on this

I move amendment 21:—

In sub-section (1), page 12, line 26, to insert after the word "fit" the words "and subject to the provisions of this section."

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept the amendment on principle and I will have it included.

Comment on this

In the circumstances, I ask the leave of the House to withdraw it.

Comment on this