We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Appropriation Bill, 1932—Second Stage.

Contributions 109–236 of 236. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Appropriation Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 29 of 1932 ›

Seán O'Grady Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands and Fisheries (Mr. O'Grady) Fianna Fáil

The net total of the Estimate for this year is £214,049, as compared with £432,157 for last year. I shall deal with the causes of the variation under the principal sub-heads. Under sub-head A, there is an increase of £3,749 as compared with last year, the figures being £35,119 and £31,370 respectively. It will be seen from the details that the increases occur practically under, or in connection with, the Gaeltacht Services. There has been a new appointment of a responsible officer in charge of the section dealing with kelp, carrigeen and other marine growths, also an outdoor inspector. There has been an increase of £1,082 on staff in connection with the administration of the Housing (Gaeltacht) Act, due to increases in the numbers of both indoor and outdoor staffs. The increase is, in fact, greater, because whereas the salaries of the five temporary surveyors were last year included in this Vote, the salaries of three of them who were seconded from the Land Commission are this year provided under the Land Commission Vote.

Under Accounts and Establishment, there is an increase of £1,923. The increase of work in the executive branches has resulted in throwing a corresponding burden on the accounting section of the Department. Under sub-head B — Travelling Expenses— there is an increase of £1,200, of which £1,000 is in respect of the staff dealing with the Housing (Gaeltacht) Act. Building operations under this Act are now taking place on a larger and wider scale and a larger staff is engaged in coping with the work of inspection and supervision. There is a small increase of £25 under the heading of Telegrams and Telephones, due to the extension of the latter service.

Sub-head E relates to fishery services. Under "Vocational Instruction including boat building," there is an increase of £500, due to the building of boats at the Department's boatyard for the Sea Fisheries Association. This is more than offset by an estimated receipt under sub-head O of £700 for sales of boats to the Association. There is no change under E (2). Under E (4) there is a reduction of £325. The provision of loans for boats and gear has gone as this service has been taken over by the Sea Fisheries Association and is now provided under G (3). Under sub-head F (1), which relates to Inland Fisheries, there is no change. Under sub-head F (2), there is a reduction of £200, the provision in the previous year having been found to be rather more than required. There are no changes in F (3) or F (4).

Sub-head G relates to grants to the Sea Fisheries Association. The grant in respect of administration is the same as last year. The provision under G (3) — Advances for Boats and Gear — is down by £15,000. The sum provided is as much as the boat-yards of the country can absorb. The Association is at present keeping every boat-yard busy and would be glad to see additional facilities provided for the output of boats. The Committee is very loth to go to boat-yards outside the country for boats. The provision under sub-head G (4)— Advances for General Development— is intended to make provision for works of a permanent nature such as lobster pots. Although the sum is much less than last year, it will probably be adequate for any works the Association may wish to carry out during the year. It is proposed to erect a mussel purification plant on the East Coast, and it had been hoped, when these Estimates were prepared, that this work would have been carried out in the last financial year but circumstances arose which made this impossible.

Under sub-head H, relating to rural industries in the Gaeltacht, there is a net reduction in the total provision of £12,250. There is an increase of £1,300 under sub-head H (5), this amount being provided for exhibits at the Cork Exhibition of produce of the Gaeltacht industries. Working exhibits were provided at this Exhibition and the workers had to be brought from the Gaeltacht and maintained in Cork. Under sub-head H (6), there is an increase from £700 to £2,500 for advertising and publicity to further the sale of Gaeltacht goods. Under sub-head H (7), there is an increase of £550 under the heading of freight. As against this, it will be noticed that there is a reduction of £1,000 under freight in J (3), in connection with the marketing depôt. The latter sub-head bears the freightage charges outward from the depôt and it was found that the division last year did not represent the proper relationship.

Sub-head I relates to Marine Products. Sub-head I (2) shows a reduction in travelling expenses. Under I (3), which relates to the scheme of collecting, dealing in kelp there is a reduction of £4,750. The figure last year was found to be too great and it has been somewhat reduced. I (4) relates to carrageen development, and in that item there is a reduction of £500. J (1) deals with the expenses of central marketing for the Gaeltacht industries. In J (2) there is no change and in J (3) there is a reduction in general expenses of £950 to which I have already referred. Sub-head K deals with "Loans for Industrial Purposes" and stands at the same figure. In M (1) and M (2) there is no change. There is a reduction of £35 under sub-head N due to the sending of only one technical adviser to the International Council for the Study of the Sea instead of two as heretofore. In appropriations-in-aid there is a reduction of £10,900 which arises chiefly under the sale of the products of rural industries.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I am afraid that I must have succeeded in getting myself completely misunderstood.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy was completely out of order in discussing this Estimate.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

In connection with the Estimate at this stage, I must say that I would not care to go into the matter in the way in which these Estimates have been accustomed to have been gone into in the past, but there were certain points about which I wanted to be clear. I have not got the information I wanted about them. For that I do not blame the Parliamentary Secretary because he has been appointed only within the last few days and it will take him a couple of years to learn all the ramifications of the Department. I would be very far from blaming the Department, too. But I wanted to hear a statement on the operations of the Sea Fisheries Association at the start and a few things about the Gaeltacht and the carrageen side of the industry. At any rate, the principal thing about which I wanted to hear was the Sea Fisheries Association. I did not want to hear about this merely from the point of view of personal curiosity or because I am an ex-Minister of the Department. I want to hear them because I believe it would be fair to the Sea Fisheries Association to hear now when they have had an opportunity of saying what they have done that that should be known.

It is not that I want to find fault. It is because I want to praise. I want them to tell the country exactly what they have done. They have done it at at great cost of money. I do not regret that money, and I believe that this House would be terribly foolish to regret the money that is being spent in the operations of the Sea Fisheries Association. I want them to go on spending the money in that way so as to try out the position and to make a complete investigation of the situation. That is really why I wanted the statement. I regret that statement was not made in that way. I do not blame the Parliamentary Secretary, and it is possible that the staff of the Department did not understand what I was at from what was reported to them here. The Sea Fisheries Association are operating at considerable cost to the country. They are doing certain work, but the Deputies must remember that they are getting us away from the position that we used to be in on giving a Vote to the Fisheries Department for the lending of boats and gear on solvent sureties. When you came along to get the money off these solvent sureties you were begged and requested to let them off. The Sea Fisheries Association must be able to get away from that position. They are giving boats in another way to the members of the Association, to men who are proved fishermen. As members of the Association they have to give up their catch to the particular official of the Association in a particular district. From the catch the State grant towards the provision of the boats will be repaid. That is a brief statement of the position.

I believe that we should be prepared to face a considerable loss for a number of years so as to try this scheme out. So far as I am concerned, as a Deputy in Opposition, if we are still in Opposition, and if my friend is still on the Government Benches when this Vote is next before the House, I, as one member of the Opposition, will stand for trying that job out. Let us try out whether or not we really have a fishing population who are prepared to work. Let us try out all the talk we had from platforms and in the Press of the hard-working toilers of the sea and all the talk about our seas teeming with fish. I should like to see that tried out. The way to try it out has been found at last. The foundation is there, in the Sea Fisheries Association, for trying it out. I want that tried out for a number of years, and let us find out exactly where we stand. Then, if we find out that the giving of boats and the giving of gear to our people along the coasts, whether in my constituency in Dingle or Caherciveen or in the Gaeltacht or anywhere else, is not a paying proposition, we can stop it. That is my point of view, and I believe it is the right point of view. I believe that in the building up of the Sea Fisheries Association we have the right point of view, and I believe in the building up of that Association. After a number of years we will find out what the situation is. I am not optimistic, but I believe that there are fishermen who will prove themselves well worth being given boats and gear. I also believe that a great many others who pretended they were fishermen will be found out. That was the principal thing that I desired to hear from the Department. There were a few other things that I wanted to hear a little more about. The Parliamentary Secretary merely glanced at the kelp industry. I do not want to stress it, but it is one of the things that I would like to hear something about. It is one of the things that is not the fault of the Government. I am anxious to hear what are the hopes of the Department as to the future of kelp. Up to the time that we left office, undoubtedly everything looked rosy. It is not because we left office that things may not be looking so rosy now — I make the Parliamentary Secretary a present of that — but because we are so far away from Chile and of the change in the position with regard to Chile. At any rate, I am afraid that the future for our kelp is very much jeopardised. I would like to know whether the Department has investigated that aspect of the matter. I admit that up to a year ago we had great hopes, because of the Galway iodine factory and of the prospects of a factory in Donegal, for our kelp gatherers. I am afraid that we cannot say the same to-day, that at the moment one does not know what the future for our kelp gatherers will be. The value of crude iodine has fallen by nearly 70 per cent. There will be a natural fall in the iodine produced here from our kelp. While we hoped a year ago that we would get great things from our iodine factory in Galway, I am afraid that is not so to-day. I would like to hear the contrary if it can be said.

As to carrageen and the Gaeltacht industries, I will not adopt the attitude that many Deputies on the other side used to adopt when they were on this side of the House. I will not attempt to criticise everything that the Government and the Department are doing. I feel that the Department at least is doing its best so far as carrageen and the Gaeltacht industries are concerned. At this stage I may be permitted to say that the Minister, in taking over from me, took over at least a staff — I will not say anything against the Civil Service — that were not merely civil servants, but were apostles so far as the Gaeltacht was concerned. They were enthusiasts for the Gaeltacht, apart from their daily work from half past nine to half past five. In fact they did not care when their day ended. I say that especially for the secretary to the Department and the assistant-secretary. I do not like to mention names, but certainly in the case of Mr. Moriarty and Mr. Bradley, their work never ended.

As to the position with regard to carrageen and the Gaeltacht, I do not want to press the Parliamentary Secretary for information, as I know he has had no opportunity of investigating the affairs of the Department. But as to carrageen, I presume he feels the same in relation to it as to every other industry in this country, that it has felt, unfortunately, the effects of the breeze through the hostility across Channel. Before I left the Department we started an intensive advertising campaign of carrageen. We had medical advice about it. We were able to put in our advertisements statements about carrageen that were substantiated by good medical advice, statements that would prove attractive especially, perhaps, in the British market. I am satisfied that policy could not have developed in recent times, and for that situation I naturally do not blame either the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary recently appointed.

I was glad to hear the statement made, I think, by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in connection with boat building. He said that they were loath to go outside the country for boats. I clap him on the back for that. That was entirely our attitude. Between Killybegs and Baltimore, as well as in Arklow and other places, we did our best to organise persons who would provide the boats necessary for the fishing population of the country. If the Government resolve to continue that work I, at any rate, will pat them on the back for it. If they impose tariffs against boats suitable for the fishing population that can be produced in this country I will pat them on the back.

The Parliamentary Secretary referred more or less en passant to the mussel purification grant. I have not heard much about that in the last six months. It is a thing that I was interested in. There was a question at one time of having the plant at Drogheda. I would like to know whether it is feasible to have it there. From many points of view Drogheda would be a most suitable place, because near Drogheda, at a place called Mornington there are mussel beds. But I have an idea that just before I left office there was a decision that Drogheda was not so suitable: that Dublin might be more suitable. But wherever it is to be I would be glad to hear that money is to be spent in the direction of providing a purification plant. If we cannot do that there is only one other thing for us to do for the mussel fishermen, whether at Mornington near Drogheda or at Cromane in the County Kerry, and that to to provide subsidies for them to have their mussels purified at Conway in Wales. I understand that purification plant is a simple one. It was considered twelve months ago that the capital expenditure would perhaps be very large — eight, nine or ten thousand pounds. We considered that a very large sum. Of course such a sum is only a mere bagatelle to the present Government. I can assure the Parliamentary Secretary that the capital expenditure on the plant would not be more than £9,000 or £10,000. Of course he could get a more accurate estimate from Mr. Hassard or Mr. Greene. I think it would be a wise expenditure of money because by means of it you would be providing something of perpetual value. You would be providing for these mussel fishermen in out of the way places, whether at Mornington or in Cromane, a means of earning a livelihood. Those at Mornington are even worse off than the mussel fishermen in Cromane. If they could get their mussels cleaned at a cheap rate near at hand they would be in a position to make a living out of their industry. As it is the mussels are very often condemned in the British market. Nothing that the Parliamentary Secretary's Department can do will prevent that, because it is the medical officer of health in some English centre, whether it be Manchester, Birmingham or some other place, who will certify whether the mussels will be allowed in or not. If he can get mussels from Mornington passed into these markets, the people down there — some 130 families — will have a living and it will be worth while.

Leaving the nice things about the Department, I should like to refer briefly — and I am not saying that the Parliamentary Secretary is at all responsible — to this question of the remission of fines for offences in connection with the fishery laws. First of all, I might explain this, that for a short period the Department of Justice was either remitting or reducing fines, or saying that the law should take its course with regard to these fines, without consultation with the Minister for Lands and Fisheries. This was while I was in charge, and it was for a very short period. The matter was drawn to my attention because I found the Department of Justice particularly ill-informed about many matters that were brought before them at the time. I took the matter up with the late Mr. Kevin O'Higgins and, after a rather acrimonious talk, he agreed that no decision of the Department of Justice would go to the reduction or remission of any fine, in regard to fishery matters, without the imprimatur of the Minister for Fisheries. This is just by way of introduction. I need not say that day after day and week after week, during all my time in office, these cases came along. There were at least half a dozen such cases each day sent over to the Minister for Justice — involving a report from the Conservators, a report from the Justice who tried the case, a report from the Gárda Síochána, and the memorial put before him. The Parliamentary Secretary will find many of them before he is many days older. I scrupulously read through many of these files and in a very short time made up my mind that at least for some years a lesson should be taught to the poacher and the poisoner and so on. Over a number of years— and I invite the Minister to go back over the files in order to see that it is so — my recommendations were normally that the law should take its course. We brought in very stringent Acts in 1924 and 1925 governing inland fisheries. There were minimum penalties. The District Justice had no option, when a certain person was convicted of a certain offence, but to impose a certain penalty. There is undoubtedly room there for the prerogative — I make a present of it to the Minister for Justice — but the cases came along and, as I say, over a number of years I recommended that the law should take its course. Afterwards, I pointed out exactly what remissions should be made, but normally, up to the very day I left office, the proportion of remissions of penalties was comparatively small. They should be easily got from the Department, and there is an official of the Department of Lands and Fisheries here who should be able to verify easily whether what I say is correct or not. I felt that this was something which we had, if we would only conserve it.

As Minister for Lands and Fisheries, there was one thing that I could do by legislation and by administration. There was another thing that required a great deal of work by the Sea Fisheries Association. But in the inland fisheries we had an asset which required only to be conserved. As I said, by legislation and administration you could create a big asset for the country. I felt that that was something that we had to conserve and that the administration should go that way. If the Parliamentary Secretary will look up the files he will find that all that I have said is absolutely true. I have the greatest sympathy with the Parliamentary Secretary. I know that he has come here to answer questions and to speak on things of which he has only a few days' knowledge. It would be utterly impossible for him to answer all of them and it would take him a couple of years to go into all these matters. I am merely raising them in order to bring them to the notice of the Government, especially with regard to the remission of penalties. I want the Government to examine these things closely, because eventually the Board of Conservators will be found throwing up the guns. There are a great many people always anxious to take the easy way out. But there are others who want to do their work conscientiously. My information on the matter to which I referred earlier, and as to which I was challenged, came from a member of the Board of the Limerick Fishery Conservators. I will give his name if it is required — he is not afraid — Fred McKibben.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Minister for Justice (Mr. Geoghegan) Fianna Fáil

On a point of accuracy — I did not challenge the Deputy as to where he got his information. I asked him if he was authorised by the Board of Conservators to protest against the return by them of a penalty which, according to the police, they ought not to have received and to which they were not entitled. The Deputy is entitled to get his information as he pleases.

Comment on this

The Minister must be aware that it is from a member of the Board of Conservators, who was Chairman of the Board, if he is not Chairman now, and he got it from the Clerk of the Board, who got the instruction from the Department. The Limerick Board of Conservators did not feel at all pleased at the instructions which they got and they felt that they might as well stop paying bailiffs, and they are a Board that in the last year reorganised their bailiff system in an extraordinary way, scrapped several bailiffs, putting in a new system of bailiffing which has culminated in the most excellent provision against poaching and similar offences in their area. I hate to discourage persons who have a public spirit of that kind. They have nothing to gain by such action, but they are public-spirited men. Mr. McKibben, I think, owns a salmon weir on the Shannon, but most of the persons who stood with him on this matter are persons with no axe to grind. They are persons who are only actuated by public-spirited in seeing that public fisheries are protected in the State. These fisheries are an asset. We are boosting tourist traffic and trying to encourage visitors, and if we let these things go by default it will be known and the country will suffer.

Comment on this

Deputy Lynch has reminded me of a few things I should like to say with reference to mussel fishing and inland fisheries. I am glad that he devoted his attention to a matter over which we have genuine control, and industry of considerable importance. He mentioned Mornington and the demand there for a purification tank. Of course, this demand did not arise yesterday.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

No.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

The tank has been in demand for a couple of years. The industry is of great importance to an area like Mornington, and the purification tank became necessary because of certain sanitary rules and regulations made for marketing in England. This industry in Mornington gave a living to a number of people. They were all deprived of their employment last year and the year before because they were not provided with a purification tank. The control of this matter rests with another body in Dublin, a body which is a branch of the Department of Lands and Fisheries. I suppose they call themselves the Sea Fisheries Association. That seems to me to be a rather sleepy Board. They seem to spend most of their time dreaming. I have approached this Board on many occasions and my representations have always met with a deaf ear. Some six months ago I had a letter from them stating that the matter was to receive immediate attention and that they were deciding on erecting a tank. I think they ultimately decided on erecting a central tank in Dublin, which would do the whole lot.

The erection of the tank could not cost very much. It is not a very intricate business and would not entail the employment of any specialists. At any rate, the result of the matter is that these men and their families are absolutely idle. This has led to very serious abuses. There is another river close to Mornington, and I am informed that it has been the practice to take mussels from the Boyne and dump them for a couple of hours into the Nanny. That is a serious matter, and it has arisen because this body, to which I refer, went asleep. I have not a terrible lot of sympathy for the Sea Fisheries Board. Their objects are good, but they need some stimulation. They require to be shaken up a bit. Deputy Lynch stated that people in his constituency were in the same position as those in mine. The people in this area for generations lived on the collection of mussels, but by the action or inaction of this Department they have been left idle for the past couple of years.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I must not be taken as being in agreement with the Deputy on that, that by the action of the Department these men were left idle.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

I took it that the Deputy meant that they had not done their duty.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Any statements I made certainly did not convey that either my constituents or the Deputy's constituents, were left idle as a result of the action of the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

In any case I can say that they were left idle in my constituency because they did not get the tank.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

The Deputy's information about the tank is so very bad——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

Is it so very bad?

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I am afraid it is.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

Any information I have in regard to the tank is quite good. This information is correct anyway.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

It is a bit too good, but I shall not have to answer the Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

The information is that they are still without it and have been without it for a considerable time. That is surely unfair. In regard to the question of inland fisheries I have had many complaints. I have had complaints from the fishermen at the mouth of the Boyne that the length of their nets was curtailed by a couple of yards. Further up the Blackwater and the source of the Boyne, in fact around Trim, and from Navan to Kells there have been complaints by fishermen that they catch nothing. I could not understand what had happened when more fish did not get up the Boyne, because the nets were specially shortened for the purpose of letting them up. And it rather puzzled me for a long time. At one court in Navan I saw it reported that one of those people who had rights on the Boyne to catch salmon in traps—they are very old rights, and historically most interesting—was prosecuted because he had not closed his trap when he should have closed it. In fact he had kept it open all night. I made inquiries at once to know what amount of fish these people could catch in the traps and I found if they left them open constantly they could catch a great deal more fish than the ordinary poor fisherman, who has nothing else to live on, could catch at the mouth of the Boyne.

I further made inquiries as to what became of the fish when the inspector caught them in the trap, and it seems the fish were not confiscated. Here is a case in which these old rights, historically very interesting, remain in existence. The fisherman at the mouth of the Boyne must be deprived of his living, as well as other people further up the river who pay licence to fish, and cannot catch any fish because there is none to be caught. I take it that system is inequitable. As to salmon it is not every year they come up. I admit that that is the case— that there are years they do not come up—but I do not believe for one moment that the shortening of the nets in the Boyne is going to prevent so many of them coming up. When they do come up what happens them with those numerous traps that are along the Boyne the whole way? I should like that question to be examined to see if the law works out equitably. After all I think it is only fair that those men who have no other means of living, at the mouth of the Boyne at Mornington, but through salmon fishing, should get a fair and reasonable chance of getting that living. I think it is not fair that so many of those traps should be allowed, even with those rights and royalties, giving men who really do not want an income a considerable income from them. Those fishermen should get something better than they have been getting in the past.

I do not want to labour this particular point, but fines have been imposed, and Deputy Lynch objects to some of those fines being reduced. Now I have known fines for the last couple of months being imposed on one particular individual by accident. I know it is by accident. He caught pike, and there seems to be some reward given for pike if they are caught. He was actually catching pike, and he was prosecuted for salmon poaching and fined £20. I do not think in his whole life he could pay £20. If the fine is not reduced he will have to go to jail, and he has six children.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

That statement, in comparison with what I have been stating, is utterly ridiculous. The taking of a pike out of the river is an entirely different question. I do not know how he could possibly be fined £20, but if he were it was utterly ridiculous. Mind you, there is an Appeal Court. The cases I asked about were not appealed against.

Comment on this

Of course I am not criticising Deputy Lynch. I am glad he brought that up.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

If the person was fined £20 for taking pike it was utterly ridiculous I agree, and the fine should be remitted.

Comment on this

It should certainly. What I want to call the attention of the Minister to is that I certainly, and perhaps many more Deputies, would want to be satisfied exactly as to the reasonableness of the laws and regulations that those sea fishery people, as well as the inland fishery people, have at their control. I do not believe all the revenue we are getting from them compensates in any way for certain rights and privileges that certain people who live by that particular trade should enjoy.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin a few moments ago in the course of his speech referred to the duty of the Government in keeping order at public meetings, and the right of free speech. He went on to refer to a meeting at Trim. I do not know whether or not Deputy Davin was present at that meeting in Trim, but I was there, and it is because I was there that I rise to give my view of what happened at Trim. I think if Deputy Davin had been at Trim, from the speech he made here to-night, he would have been the first man to pat the Army Comrades on the back for what they did, because in the speech he made here he stood up for the right of free speech.

He referred to the parade at Trim of the Army Comrades' Guard of Honour for ex-President Cosgrave. A Chinn Comhairle, if the Army Comrades were needed at Trim I think it was because the right of free speech was denied to ex-President Cosgrave when addressing his constituents in Cork. At that meeting in Trim a Deputy of this House, Deputy Eamonn Duggan, who is the elected Deputy for the constituency, was the first speaker on the platform to address his constituents. He was not allowed to proceed with three sentences when an armed mob of hooligans right in front of the platform tried to shout him down with cries of "Up de Valera." There was an appeal made to them to keep quiet, and although they may not agree with what the Deputy had to say, at least they could give him a hearing in his constituency. All the time the reply was "Up de Valera," with the result that the Army Comrades who were there walked over and said: "Look here boys, if you do not allow the speakers on the platform to proceed we will have to remove you from the meeting——"

Comment on this

Did they say it like that?

Comment on this

——and anything that occurred at Trim happened because the right of free speech was denied to the speakers. I think if Deputy Davin had been at that meeting he would not have made the hostile remarks he made here about the Army Comrades. I will guarantee to Deputy Davin that at any time in the future when the right of free speech is allowed at public meetings there will be no need for the Army Comrades.

Comment on this

A Chinn Comhairle, I want to get back to the main point if I can. The Minister for Finance, in opening the discussion, said that the Government were in a strong position financially to carry on. We are all glad to hear that, and I hope that the Minister has in his mind provisions for all the interests of the people at the moment and in the future.

Yesterday, those of us who are interested in agriculture were staggered at the announcement that the tax of 20 per cent. imposed by the British on our cattle and other agricultural products had been doubled, or increased to 40 per cent. Now we agriculturists have been, within the last five or six months, given the solace from the Ministerial Benches that we would not suffer very much. As long ago as July last the Minister for Finance, in introducing—I think it was our emergency tariffs, said that it did not matter one whit whether the duties were 20 per cent., 40 per cent., or even 100 per cent., if the British liked to make them as much, as everybody knew that the British farmer and consumer would have to bear the cost himself. I do not think that that statement was borne out. Those of us who have had experience in farming for the last five months know that that statement has not been verified.

The Minister in that same speech told us not to worry, that new and alternative markets could and would be found, and at a later stage in the House—carried away, I expect, by the enthusiasm of his Minister for Finance—the President in this House in introducing another Vote said that one of the two objects of the Vote was to find new markets. There was naturally on this side of the House a belief that the discovery of new markets was not so simple as it appeared, and we said so, and after considering it for 24 hours and sleeping over it, the President himself—notwithstanding the enthusiasm of his Minister for Finance—came to the conclusion that new markets could not be found, and he was honest enough to get up in this House and state it to us. Regardless of the declaration of the President, and, I suppose, desiring to give some semblance of life to the statement of the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Agriculture has been attempting to find new markets, and has been purchasing cattle in our Dublin market for export to Belgium—to supplant the export of horses to Belgium by the export of cattle at a somewhat similar price—and the Minister refused to tell this House what he paid for the cattle or what he got for them or hoped to get for them.

To-night, when we should naturally expect from the Government Benches some voice of sympathy for the unfortunate plight of the agriculturists, practically the only Minister who did get up outside the Minister for Finance, worked himself into a state of frenzy. His main speech consisted of taunts to those of us on this side to answer this question and that, and in the end he wound up in a fervour of enthusiasm for the nationality of the people—he did not say the common people, but the people of this State.

I do not want to work myself into a frenzy of nationalism. Our nationalism on this side of the House is just as fervent as the nationalism of the gentlemen on the Government Benches, but there is something nearer to us than nationalism at the present moment. I will admit if you wish that the present Government Party did in the last election get perhaps a limited mandate to engage in some sort of negotiations about the annuities question. I do not want to go into that matter very much, but they did not get, nor did they ask for, a mandate to involve the farmers and the workers of this country in a war such as they are engaged in. There was no mandate given nor demanded for that fight. We, the farmers, were put into the front line trenches against our will. We were conscripted, and as conscripts we should have been, in the ordinary methods of warfare, between civilised Governments entitled to some subsistence allowance, some allowance to carry us over during the continuation of that war, to help us, ourselves, to exist, as well as our families and those dependent upon us—the unfortunate workers in the agricultural farms. The Minister will answer me that they did make an attempt—that they gave us bounties. The bounties that were given to help to tide the farmer over that difficulty did not reach the farmer. The Minister for Agriculture said a night or two ago that they did, but every farmer to whom any Minister speaks will refute that statement.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce to-night, speaking on a subject of which he knows nothing, told us deliberately that the difference between the price the farmer receives for his cattle in this State and the price the farmer on the other side of the water receives is one shilling. Every schoolboy and every schoolgirl who has read anything about agriculture knows that there is not a semblance of foundation for that statement. We have a responsible Minister in the Government Party getting up and in his reply the only tangible allusion he did make to the agricultural question was to say the price we got for our cattle only differed from the price of the English farmers by 1/-.

Comment on this

Is that all he said?

Comment on this

That was all he said so far as it relates to the export of cattle.

Comment on this

He did not say 1/-per cwt.

Comment on this

1/- per cwt. if you like. If 1/- per cwt. is the only difference in price between cattle here and cattle in England, then why in the name of commonsense would any man, that God gave any reason to, engage in the operation of buying cattle here and selling them in England at a difference in price of only 1/- per cwt? It cannot be done and the Minister knows it could not be done.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce was in a difficulty as to what kind of speech he should make in this House and he asked us a number of questions. He began by asking us if we were in power instead of they being in power, and if the same situation arose what would we have done? We would not have lost our tempers, that is one thing we would not have done. We would have attempted to keep out of trouble; we would have thought better before we entered into a fight, and anyhow if we conceived that a fight such as has taken place would have taken place, we would have deemed it our duty to tell the people concerned, namely, the agriculturists, that they were going into the fight, and let them be the judges as to whether it was reasonable or not. The Minister said he was quite satisfied he had funds enough to carry himself along. I am not satisfied that the Minister has funds enough to carry him along. If the Minister has to provide an adequate substitute for the farmers' loss of market, if he is to make any effort to keep the farmer on his feet for the next few months while that market is in suspense, because that market has ceased at the moment, the Minister will need a much greater sum of money than he has already made any provision for. I do not know whether the Minister, or his advisers, have made any attempt to discover the number of unsold cattle there are in this State—the number of cattle that must be, or should be, disposed of within the next six or seven weeks. If he has, and if he has any regard for the unfortunate owners of these stock, and if the Government has any material regard for the owners of these stock, he must make some provision and see, as I said originally, that something akin to the subsistence allowance a conscript would be allowed in an ordinary war be provided for them. We, the agriculturists, did not ask for this fight. The Minister will tell us we did. We demand, and there is justice at the back of our demand, that the Ministry having unfortunately driven us into the position against our will that we now find ourselves in, must make some attempt to drag us out of it.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce talked a lot about Ottawa and about their negotiations. I do not think we gained anything new from the Minister's exposition as to what did happen at Ottawa. He began by saying there were no discussions with Great Britain. I think he meant there was no discussion on the larger issue, but he did not say that. He followed it up later on by saying he had discussions with Ministers of Great Britain, and that certain things came to light in these discussions, notably that the British blamed us for a certain condition of affairs or rather they thought certain things happened by which we gained. But he refused, when he was interrogated, to say that any Minister told him that because they had not. If the Minister for Industry and Commerce attempts to come up here and make a speech containing what I might term such eye-wash as that, we do expect some other Minister, with a greater appreciation of what this House should expect from a Minister, to deal more fairly with the House. The Minister said, I think, they had engaged in giving bounties long before there was any talk of a war with Britain, and that they began by giving bounties on butter. They did give bounties on butter, but not bounties in the regular way—but bounties in which people should find themselves directly, without the intervention of the Government, lifting money out of one pocket and putting it into the other, without any reference to Parliament whatever, or without any levy upon Parliamentary funds—that was the method. The Minister for Agriculture in introducing the Dairy Produce Bill was good enough to say there was nothing new in the Bill; that the Bill served no new purpose except this: it was to put into effect the legislation passed by the previous Minister for Agriculture, which enabled the farmer to achieve all that the Dairy Produce Bill could achieve for him if he wished to achieve it. The only new element in the Minister's Bill was that it compelled the farmer to do what he might have done if he wished. On the admission of the Minister for Agriculture himself, that was the only new thing that the Dairy Produce Bill gave him. I will admit that later on there was an attempt made, but that was subsequent to the beginning of the economic war, to keep up the butter industry. There was a definite subsidy price of 117/- laid down. That would have been necessary to my mind, anyhow. We all know that the butter industry was possibly going to be in a perilous condition this year.

All during the election those of us that knew anything about the dairying question, in our talks with the ordinary farmers, told them that the position of the dairy farmer was not a happy one. We made no secrecy about it. We told them that if the position of the dairy farmer became worse no new Government, whether it was the late Government that was returned to power or not, could afford to let a main section of the greatest industry disappear. We told them that it would be the duty of any Government that came into power to see that that did not happen. As far as those of us, in the Southern Provinces at least where dairying is mainly carried on, were concerned, we told our people that that would be the duty of any Government, and if we made any promise it was that that would be one of our first duties if returned. It was the duty of the Fianna Fáil Government as well, and they knew that that was the obvious thing to do. The Minister taunted us with the question: "What would Cumann na nGaedheal have done in these circumstances?" The Cumann na nGaedheal Party would have done, as regards butter and dairying industries, something similar to what the Government have done except, perhaps, that they would have bettered it.

Comment on this

They would have taken the fat out of it.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce asked another question: "Did we wish the Relief Grant to stop?" He knows full well the answer to that. No individual and no Party, in this House, wishes the Relief Grant to cease. If it was the Cumann na nGaedheal Party that was in power, instead of the present Government, there might be the same necessity for the Relief Grant as now, but we would not have allowed the present conditions in regard to unemployment to creep upon the people unawares. It would not have been our policy to go out, week after week, to tell the people that all was well. We would have told the people—and that is the record of the late Government when in office—that the position was serious. They always told the people the worst end of it and the methods they proposed for the redress of the grievances that the people suffered from.

There will be in this House, in the next week or two, a great debate on another aspect of the situation. But to my mind the position, at the present moment, is almost so serious that it cannot wait until next week. The position of the farmer, who has perishable commodities in the nature of fat cattle to dispose of at this late date in the year, is so unfortunate that even a day, not to mention weeks, is injurious to him if there is a hope of a remedy. I hope Ministers are not losing sight of that great question, and that they are not going to wait until they come to this House to answer the Vote of Censure, or some other motion, to do what it is their imperative duty to do, and that is to see that some immediate action will be taken to tide the farmers over the unfortunate position that the Ministry has driven them into. The Minister for Industry and Commerce would ask: "What would you do?" I do not know what we would do if we were in the position of the present Ministry. I can only say I cannot conceive our Party being in the position in which the Government and the Ministry find themselves to-day. But having played the fool with the farming industry under the guise of nationality it is the obvious duty of Ministers to set about remedying the circumstances in which we find ourselves before it is too late. Within the last week I believe writs have been issued for the farmers' annuities—so I am told. How are they to be met? How is an unfortunate farmer going to meet the liability as to his rent or his rates if he cannot sell his produce? The position is simply intolerable for any one even remotely connected with agriculture, and for the workers to whom the Ministerial supporters in the Labour Party are responsible.

Comment on this

For what annuity is the farmer being writted? Is it for his June instalments?

Comment on this

I have not seen any of the writs.

Comment on this

It is scarcely for the November instalment?

Comment on this

If it is for the previous one I am rather surprised inasmuch as the Ministry gave a moratorium for the old ones.

Comment on this

It would be a wonder if it was in June, because it was a lengthy and prosperous period.

Comment on this

It was an interregnum, the moderately disastrous period. The very disastrous period came later. The central period was June. It was between March and November. At that period they had done a certain amount of damage, but not as much as later.

Comment on this

If it was June it should have been prosperous after ten years of administration by the Party opposite.

Comment on this

We do not say the farmer was prosperous in June. We were not responsible for last June, but for June twelvemonths, and any person who knew the farmers' position in June twelvemonths, knew he was in a happy position relatively.

Comment on this

So happy that he kicked you out twelve months later.

Comment on this

He did not kick me out, nor if the Minister himself came down, and attacked me in my constituency with his knowledge of agriculture, would he be able to kick me out.

Comment on this

Are you throwing down the gauntlet?

Comment on this

There are some Deputies on this side who know something of the difficulties of agriculture and are not afraid to tell the farmer and the agricultural labourers about these difficulties, and that these difficulties are very real. If we were in the position of the Government opposite we would not be afraid to admit that we were responsible for some of those difficulties. One of the reasons why the Minister for Finance and his brother Ministers find themselves on the Front Bench is that we were the Party that told the whole truth to the people. We were the Party who never denied the result of any legislation on which we embarked, whether it was unpopular or not. We were the Party who refrained from making mountainous promises, knowing in our hearts that they could not be fulfilled. And it is because of the bounteous promises made by the Fianna Fáil Party at the last election, and their unfortunate attempt to fulfil some portion of these promises that the people—the agricultural people, at least, and, incidentally, the commercial people of this State— find themselves in the position in which they are.

The position of the commercial people is perhaps only very little removed from the disastrous position of the agriculturist, because on his welfare depends their welfare, and they know it. I hope that the Minister's declaration, that he has quite sufficient funds at his disposal to tide us over all these difficulties, is correct. I hope that his statement means that he is convinced that he has at his disposal sufficient money to recoup the farmers, because the farmers look to him to recoup them for the losses that the Ministry have caused them. I hope that the Appropriation Bill we are now discussing gives the Minister all that he needs to tide the people over the difficulties I have mentioned. I warn the Minister that the people expect that the Ministry will do that. They expect, and they demand, immediate and ample relief for the agricultural community. I will admit that it appears to me impossible that the Minister could give such relief. But, to a Ministry to whom nothing was impossible at an election period, it should not be impossible. To me, a back bencher of the ex-Government Party, and to some of my colleagues, it appears almost impossible that the Ministry can provide adequate relief for the farmers. The farmers, unfortunately, expect the Minister to face up to the impossible circumstances in which he has placed them, and in the end they must get that relief or the Minister and his colleagues must fall. I believe that the temper of the average farmer is nearly at breaking point.

Comment on this

He will not stand much more of you.

Comment on this

He will not stand much more of it, as Deputy Corry says, if I interpret Deputy Corry's language rightly.

Comment on this

Not from you.

Comment on this

The Deputy has put it in a nutshell. I am only sorry that with Deputy Corry's knowledge of agriculture, on which he speaks such a lot, the Ministry passed him over when making an appointment within the last few days.

Comment on this

Wait for your turn.

Comment on this

You have a sense of humour.

Comment on this

I must have a sense of humour when I suggested any such possibility. I am afraid, however, that my capabilities for expressing humour at the present time are tempered by the tragic circumstances of agriculture at the moment. Possibly there are not many Deputies on the opposite benches who have to exist solely on the output of agriculture, as some of us here have. I do not know how many of them have. At any rate, to those of us whose sole means of existence is agriculture, and the disposing of agricultural produce, this is no laughing matter. This is a serious matter not alone for us but for the people who sent us here; and the farmers, big and small, whom the Ministry have driven into a position that farmers themselves could not have envisaged even six months ago; a position that farmers never even dreamt of; a position that I, as a middle-aged man with a knowledge of farming extending over forty years, have never seen anything like before. I remember when farming was at its worst state in the late eighties. At that period and since, there have been ups and downs in the world markets, just as there are now, but even at the worst of times the position of agriculture or of the agricultural workers was never as bad as it is in this November of 1932. I will admit that possibly there were some circumstances over which the Ministry had no control; circumstances of universal depression. Those circumstances, however, have existed for the last three years. They have, perhaps, been progressing and extending. The full force of them had not, perhaps, reached us; but a great amount of depression did reach this State a year or two ago. If the State survived, and did not feel the consequences of the depression of that period, it was because there was a sane Government in charge of the affairs of the State. We are not going to deny to the Ministry the existence of world-wide depression. We do say, however, that the Government Party were not as generous to us in the last few years, because they did deny it. Everybody knew there was a period of depression encircling the globe during the last three years. The Party who are now the Government denied the existence of that depression. They said it was not there; that it was not one of the things which created difficulties for the Government. They were not, however, ten days in office when, miraculously, depression suddenly descended on the State. It looks as if the Ministry were unfortunate, or to put it in another way, that we were fortunate: that the depression centred on this little State just as the Ministry came into office. They know as well as we do that there was depression in this country for two years past. The people know now, even if they were carried away by the almost inconceivable promises of the Ministry, that depression did exist then; that it was only by the wise legislation, the wise and careful use of the country's money that the position was tided over until March, 1932; that our financial position was preserved in such a way that we were able to carry on, meet our liabilities and look the world in the face; that we were not in the ignominious position in which the unfortunate farmers are at present. The farmers have no hope of redress unless and until, like the workers in some parts of this State, they summon up their courage, march on Dublin and on Government Buildings, and demand what they have a right to expect, relief from the consequences of the position to which the Ministry, almost distracted by their enthusiasm for an impossible transaction, had brought them.

Comment on this

Tell us about the thirteen farmers.

Comment on this

The Deputy might have said "impossible farmers."

Comment on this

I hope I have not encroached on the debate that is to come next week. I did not mean to. But it was impossible to talk about the things I mainly want to talk about— the sudden stoppage of the farmers' market—without in some manner adverting to other events.

Comment on this

What about the resolution your thirteen farmers sent to Thomas?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

I wish the Minister would conscript Deputy Corry and utilise his unpaid services solely for the farmers' purposes. The Minister, or the Minister for Agriculture, was, to my mind, rather ill advised in deciding not to select him as his righthand man. Perhaps it was Deputy Corry's sudden conversion a month or two ago, to the views of the commercial section of the community, his sudden temporary desertion of the agricultural brief that left him in the position he is in at the moment. Perhaps that is one of the causes why Deputy Corry does not assume a higher position in the ranks of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is now inviting interruptions instead of avoiding them.

Comment on this

The Deputy looked for a retort and he is going to get it from me, when he interrupts, until the Chair intervenes. At any rate, I, on behalf of the people who elected me, and they were mainly farmers, demand from the Government some redress for the position into which, as I said, we are forced against our will, chiefly by the action of the Minister.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Minister for Justice (Mr. Geoghegan) Fianna Fáil

I would like, in the course of this debate, to deal with some questions that have been raised here which affect all the people of this country— the dispute with England, the legal and other merits of our claim to retain the land annuities and to retain the R.I.C. pensions—but I feel that I would be acting unfairly to other Deputies in this House if, having regard to the comparatively short time that is now available, I did not confine myself to matters appertaining directly to my own Department, and, for that reason, I will be much briefer than I had intended to be when, about five o'clock this afternoon, I decided to take part in this debate.

Deputy Fionán Lynch is the last speaker, so far as I am aware, to deal with this new grievance of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party—the manner in which the prerogative of mercy is exercised and the manner in which the statutory power to remit fines is given effect to. Deputy Lynch was concerned, in the main, with fines in fishery cases, but his contribution to this debate has a value which extends far beyond fishery cases. It is a remarkable contribution, because I think it reveals the mentality and outlook of the Party opposite, whether they are seated on the Front Bench or on the back bench, or, I should say, whether he is seated on the Front Bench or the back bench, because the Party consists of two at the present moment. In regard to the exercise of this prerogative, Deputy Lynch said that for a short time after he became Minister for Lands and Fisheries, the Minister for Justice, and the Minister for Justice alone, dealt with the remission of fines in fishery prosecutions. He said, and I quote his words:

I found the Department of Justice particularly ill-informed. After an acrimonious discussion, Mr. O'Higgins agreed that he would not reduce fines without

The Deputy said, I think, "ultimatum," but he meant "imprimatur";

of the Minister for Lands and Fisheries,

I can hardly imagine acrimony on the part of Deputy Lynch. In another legislature, the angry sheep was once spoken of, and, while I would not make such a comparison in the case of Deputy Lynch, I certainly would not accuse him of acrimony. The acrimony must have been on one side in the course of this discussion, and, really, if Mr. O'Higgins then foresaw what Deputy Fionán Lynch says afterwards happened, one can readily forgive Mr. O'Higgins a certain acrimony. What does Deputy Lynch say?

Mr. O'Higgins conceded the claim of the Minister for Lands and Fisheries to deal with the petitions in the fishery cases save in so far as the Minister for Justice, in fact, registered his decision,

and I may say that under the present administration anything that I do in regard to the fines in fishery cases is pursuant to a report of the Minister for Lands and Fisheries. Deputy Lynch, having asserted that right, what do we find him doing? Deputy Lynch says here to-day:

I made up my mind that for some years a lesson should be taught to the poachers and my invariable decision was that the law should take its course.

I would like the House to consider what this power is, whether it be the power of reducing or remitting a sentence of imprisonment or reducing or remitting a fine. It is something in the nature of a judicial power. It is not strictly judicial, in the ordinary interpretation of the expression, because it is the duty of the person exercising that power to acquaint himself with the facts from any source that is within his reach and by any reasonable means within his command. He must receive them, perhaps, from persons who have had them only at second hand. He must get the facts, but, subject to that, it is a judicial power. It is a power that is vested in some particular individual in order that he may exercise it in every particular case brought before me and such is my conception of the responsibility that attaches to the exercise of that power and to the weight of the duty cast upon me, that every single case, be it great or be it small, is considered individually, on all its own facts and all its own circumstances, and, then, acting on the evidence and on the knowledge that I have, I proceed to exercise the power. Contrast that with the exercise of the powers newly found, newly taken away from the late Mr. Kevin O'Higgins after what Deputy Fionán Lynch describes as an acrimonious discussion. Deputy Fionán Lynch does not feel that there is anything terrible in confessing to this House that after getting that power, after finding that the petitions were coming in, he there and then, to use his own words, made up his mind on a certain matter—"I made up my mind that for some years a lesson should be taught to the poachers"——

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

"My invariable decision was that the law should take its course." Another Deputy has confirmed the inference I drew, that Deputy Fionán Lynch has really voiced the individual and collective wisdom of the Opposition Benches because the Deputy applauds that manner of exercising such a sacred trust as the prerogative of mercy or the power to remit fines—that before you receive the petitions you solemnly lay down for yourself an invariable, and inflexible rule of conduct. That may commend itself to Deputy O'Connor, I am sure in all good faith he thinks it is a very admirable thing to do, to lay down beforehand what your rule is to be in regard to offences not yet committed, in regard to petitions not yet drawn up or signed, in regard to a whole crop of cases extending over years. Instead of taking each case separately on its merits, you are to make for yourself that easy road. If any one's intellect or conscience would allow him to make that rule for himself, he would ease greatly the burden of the discharge of this unpleasant duty.

I am sure that the Minister from whom Deputy Lynch got this power after an acrimonious discussion—the late Mr. O'Higgins—did not take that view of his obligations. I am quite sure that every case that came before him was considered without any preconceived idea, without any prejudice; that it was not judged by some inflexible, unbendable rule that the Minister had laid down for himself beforehand, but that there was an effort, a striving, to do justice in each case. Deputy Fionán Lynch is so oppressed with the excellence of that system and I am sure Deputy O'Connor is quite pleased with it——

Comment on this

——Deputy Fionán Lynch is so delighted that, nothwithstanding the answers he got to his questions to-day in regard to the fines on Mr. Michael Cullinane, Main Street, Brosna, Co. Kerry, he returns in the course of his speech to condemn the manner in which clemency was exercised in Michael Cullinane's case. Will anything convince him? He knows that the local police inquired into the Cullinane's case; that they satisfied themselves and every reasonable person who has taken the slightest interest in the matter that the water bailiff was in error; that Michael Cullinane was never next or near the place but, on the contrary, was miles away from it and had as much to do with the offence in respect of which this fine was imposed as Deputy Lynch himself or Deputy Batt O'Connor. Notwithstanding that, Deputy Lynch condemns the exercise of any clemency in that case, such as the return of the fine, and Deputy Batt O'Connor, who knows nothing at all about the case——

Comment on this

I would like to tell the Minister that I am a native of the very village that Cullinane was charged from. Now, do I not know something about the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

On a point of explanation. I can assure the Minister that I have no personal knowledge of the case at all. I merely asked a question as to why certain fines were returned, and on what authority they were returned. There was no appeal. There is always a chance of an appeal in a District Court case. The man was fined by a competent District Justice. Whether that was right or not we do not know. I am not disputing the fact that afterwards something apparently transpired in this case. Why was there not an appeal, or, if the time for an appeal had passed, why was there not information given to the Board of Conservators when they were instructed to repay the fine and costs? They were told baldly to return the £4 to Michael Cullinane, Senior, whom I do not know. I know Brosna, because it is part of my constituency, but I do not know the man. I do not know whether he is a supporter of the Minister or of mine. The Limerick Board of Conservators were baldly told to return him the money.

Comment on this

Deputy Lynch was informed this afternoon at 3.15 p.m. of the facts. He may or may not deny that he had been previously informed of the facts; that he had been told what the police found. If the Deputy says that before 3.15 this afternoon he did not know what I told him in answer to his question, then I will make him a present of that. At all events, he had that information then, and at 7.15 he comes in here fresh as a daisy and he repeats the whole story. Perhaps in the meantime he has seen Deputy Batt O'Connor, who is a native of Brosna, in the County of Kerry, and who, I suppose, is ready to raise his right hand and say that the Chief Superintendent and the police are wrong and that Cullinane did it.

Comment on this

Deputy Lynch did not approach me. We never spoke about the case. Caught again.

Comment on this

The House has now in broad and vivid contrast the two methods of approaching the exercise of the prerogative of mercy. The House can choose, the public who read the official reports of this House can choose as to whether the O'Higgins and the Geoghegan method of taking each case by itself and looking into the facts of each case is preferable to the Lynch and Batt O'Connor method of beforehand making up a rule and saying that for years that rule will not be interfered with.

That brings me to the specific charges that have been made against me here this evening by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. The Deputy referred to the Kilrush case and he said that he rejects the findings of the tribunal altogether. Of course he said that last week and I am afraid he did not impress anyone very much. Last week, he seemed, by a studied vagueness and haziness of language to convey the impression that I had resorted to something novel and unheard of in having the Kilrush Inquiry at all. To-day he says: "Oh, there were several others of these inquiries." In the whole period during which Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was Minister for Justice there was never one single inquiry held by a tribunal appointed by him in the way Mr. O'Higgins appointed the tribunal in 1926 or, in the way I appointed it in 1932. Not one. If there had been possibly the police of this country would not have fallen into the disfavour and the unpopularity into which they fell from 1927 onwards. We know they were not in that position when Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was nominated Minister for Justice.

Since I had the honour to fill that office I have endeavoured to retrieve them from that position, and I venture to think that my endeavours have not been in vain; that the confidence and the respect of the general public in the Gárda Síochána has been growing, and rapidly growing, since March last, and that that growth has been greatly accelerated since the report of the Kilrush Inquiry and the action taken pursuant to that Inquiry. While I am Minister for Justice I will not allow the whole police force of this country to be judged by the standard of the blackest sheep in the flock; I will not allow them all to be tarred with the same brush. When occasion arises —and I believe, from such knowledge as I have acquired of the Gárda Síochána, it will rarely occur—for an inquiry similar to the Kilrush Inquiry, it will be held, as the Kilrush Inquiry was held, on oath. It will be held, as the Kilrush Inquiry was held, by men of unblemished reputation; men whom members opposite may be willing to wound but whom they dare not strike. Such inquiries will be held in the interests of the public at large and in the peculiar interests of the police force themselves, because, nothing is more calculated to inspire confidence in the police force, and nothing is more calculated to marshal and to mobilise public opinion behind the enforcement of the law, and the vindication of justice, than the feeling that those who are responsible for the police force of the country will see that that police force—as indeed it generally is—is discharging its duty in a perfectly honourable, straightforward, and scrupulous fashion.

Nothing that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has said about this Inquiry, or about the members of it, will have an intimidatory effect upon me, or the Government to which I belong. We will support the police in the proper exercise of their functions—as we have supported and encouraged them—but we will be also keenly alive to the equally high and solemn duties we owe to the public at large, that the servants whom we employ on their behalf—because they are the servants of the public— will not be either violent towards that public in whose service they are, or even impertinent to that public. We will ensure that for the people of this country. As I said, there has been a contrast in the way the prerogative of mercy is exercised on both sides. We hope also that the contrast will be no less striking, no less colourful, in the manner in which we enforce proper discipline in the police, to the manner in which it was enforced for a few years preceding the change of Government.

Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney talked about some fancied invasion of ordinary constitutional rights in regard to this Inquiry at Kilrush, its institution and its conduct, and with the glee that, I am sure, he has often exhibited at Claremorris Quarter Sessions, he said that the Minister for Justice announced last week that the charges against Ryan, Gilmore and Lowe could have been brought to Ennis Circuit Court whereas they were only triable at the Central Criminal Court. Of course, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, if he lives to be 120 will never learn his facts. He will never appreciate the importance of learning his facts before he ventures to fulminate. That was his weakness as a Minister; that is his weakness now in Opposition. If he had been aware of the facts he would have known that before either the Attorney-General or I had an opportunity of expressing anything in the nature of an opinion upon the matter of the Kilrush occurrences the responsible police officer— not a local police officer—but an officer for the time being in charge of the entire police force in the country had stated on the 17th August, 1932:

As you are no doubt aware the prisoners are charged with attempted murder, conspiracy to murder, and unlawful assault and obstruction. Having regard to all the circumstances of the case I beg to recommend that the charges of attempted murder and conspiracy be dropped, and that they be charged only with assault and obstruction. If this course were agreed upon ....

The charges of attempted murder and conspiracy to murder had been fully gone into by the police on or prior to the 17th August and there is the recommendation. The charges of assault and obstruction of duty could, of course, have been brought at Ennis Circuit Court. It is nonsensical to suggest that they could not have been tried there, but should have been transferred to the Central Criminal Court. Ennis is the obvious, natural and statutory place for the trial of these charges if they were to be proceeded with at all. To use the words of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney: "He hopes the Minister for Justice will do what he was hesitating about; that is to make the evidence in the Kilrush Inquiry available so that the public may have it."

The only hesitation I evinced last week was in asking the House, and in particular Deputy Cosgrave, to consider whether the expense of printing and publishing the very voluminous evidence given at a hearing lasting four long days was justified in the public interest. I said that if, on consideration, Deputy Cosgrave advisedly asked me to publish that evidence, I should certainly go to the Executive Council and have the matter considered. Deputy Cosgrave did not then repeat his request and has not since repeated it. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has now put it forward and I shall do this without waiting to consult the Executive Council— I shall have a typewritten copy of the stenographer's typescript of the evidence made, and I shall place it in the Library of Leinster House so that it will be available to every Deputy. That will provide reasonably wide publicity. When Deputies and members of the other House have read the evidence in the Library, it will be for them to say if it merits a still wider publicity and if the State ought to incur the expense of printing and publishing it. It will be for them to say that, but in the course of a week or so—as soon as such a very big job can be undertaken and carried through—I shall have a complete copy of the verbatim report made by the sworn stenographer at Kilrush placed on the Library table at Leinster House.

Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney glides away from Kilrush to a case on which he is able to voice even more frothy indignation. He goes straight away to the Dullea case. He says: "Look at this Minister for Justice; even when a person is charged with rape, he exercises the prerogative of mercy." I am sure that it occurred to Deputies, when they listened to Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, that the more heinous and terrible the charge is the greater is the measure of duty cast upon me to look into it. If the charge be trifling—something that does not entail a long period of penal servitude or imprisonment or other serious consequences— I may reasonably treat it in a more prefunctory manner, but when it is a charge as grave as that made in this particular case, I must, of course, look into it with care. That I would have done in this Dullea case where the charge was rape and the sentence penal servitude, even if I had nothing more before me than the petition which the Governor-General transmitted to me. But I had something more. I had a letter bearing date, 14th May, 1932, from a Deputy on the opposite benches —quite properly written by that Deputy for one of his constituents—in which he said:

I have had some inquiries made in this case and some solicitors who were present in court told me that from the evidence given it was clear that consent——

He puts "consent" in inverted commas.

should have been presumed in the case. The petition speaks for itself, and I may have a chance of seeing you in the lobby next week about it.

When I have not merely a petition, but when I have my attention drawn to a salient point in the case by a Deputy in this House, I naturally give the Dullea case all the attention I can possibly give it.

Comment on this

I think the Minister will agree that all that letter states— I have only heard its contents just now—is that certain solicitors have said that consent was present. The Minister seems to me to be suggesting to the House that the Deputy stated, as his own conviction, that that was the case. The text which the Minister has read shows, I think, that the Deputy is informing the Minister of what certain solicitors who were in the court stated. That seems to me to be a thing which the Deputy might tell the Minister, but it has no bearing whatever on the case. It does not make the case so or not so.

Comment on this

The Deputy must have been having an after-dinner nap. He only half-heard what I stated or he could not possibly have drawn that conclusion. He certainly would not have the nerve to impute such an inference to a member of the House who was awake and listening to me. What I stated was perfectly clear—that having got a statement of that sort from a Deputy, drawing my attention to the fact that solicitors who were present in the court when this case was tried had formed the opinion, from listening to the evidence, that consent must be presumed—that having that before me, I must go into the facts with the greatest care. And I did. I found that the Deputy who wrote that letter was merely discharging his duty in writing it and that the solicitors who were present in that court and listened to that trial were merely voicing a sense of justice and doing their duty as citizens when they conveyed to the Deputy what their opinion was, because that opinion coincides absolutely with my opinion. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney says that afterwards, when a civil action was brought, the same point could be made in that action. I wish Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was here now to listen to a statement of what the position is. Quite a different degree of proof is necessary in a criminal charge involving penal servitude from what is necessary in an action for damages. You must have, in a criminal action, the case proved home beyond all doubt and, in a sexual case of this sort, while you can get damages in a civil action merely on oath against oath, you need something more in a criminal case.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It was, I understand, agreed to get through all the stages of this Bill to-night, as it must be law by the end of the month and it should be in the Seanad for twenty-one days.

Comment on this

I am not aware of such an agreement.

Comment on this

There was an agreement.

Comment on this

The Minister affirms that there is an agreement?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Very well.

Comment on this

When was that agreement made? I have no knowledge of such an agreement.

Comment on this

I may have been misunderstood. I do not think Deputy Coburn was here on Friday when the Estimates were disposed of. An agreement was formally arrived at between the Whips, that the Estimates would be disposed of on Friday and the Appropriation Bill on Wednesday.

Comment on this

I am quite aware that there was an arrangement that the Estimates would be allowed to go through without very much discussion. I am not aware that there was an agreement that the Appropriation Bill would be allowed to go through to-night to a schedule time.

Comment on this

Did the Minister reaffirm that that agreement was arrived at?

Comment on this

Yes—on Friday.

Comment on this

I should like to say a few words on this Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It must be through all stages before 9 o'clock. Private Members' Business is to be taken at 9 o'clock.

Comment on this

In connection with the Dullea case, is the Minister prepared to place more confidence in the opinion of solicitors listening to a case than in the opinion and the verdict of the judge and jury?

Comment on this

It is my own opinion; it is not the opinion of the listeners.

Comment on this

The Minister was very dignified just now and took half an hour to say what any plain man would say in five minutes. He was going round corners all the time. As representing a section of the people who are seeing through all this game and as one who is trying to confine the issues between certain Ministers on the Front Bench and certain exMinisters on the Cumann na nGaedheal Bench—and there are large numbers of people in this country who want to end it all—I am proclaiming my right in this House to object to this Bill being gone through without my having an opportunity of expressing my opinion in regard to the amount of money that is going to be expended when the Bill is passed. I want to know from the Government now whether it is their opinion——

Comment on this

If the discussion is to be carried on, I think the Minister for Justice is in possession.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Justice was interrupted by me to call his attention to the fact that it was 9 o'clock. If the House decides that the discussion is to go on the Minister for Justice resumes.

Comment on this

I want the discussion to go on.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not know that any section of the House so desires.

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will sit down.

Comment on this

If there is intimidation outside I for one want no intimidation here. If intimidation is going on outside there will be none here.

Comment on this

Order.

Comment on this

The great man who was going to do away with capital is not to keep me in order.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This debate has been going on since 3.30 to-day and the Deputy had an opportunity of rising to speak during the six hours' discussion.

Comment on this

I have risen to speak now in my own time.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It was decided at 3.30 p.m. to-day that Private Deputies' Business would be taken up at 9 o'clock.

Comment on this

I am glad that the discussion has ended and——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to want to resume it.

Comment on this

I just want to remark that I rose six times to-day during this debate and I did not get an opportunity of speaking.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Question is: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."

Comment on this

I object. You have decided already that the Minister for Justice is to continue.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I ask for the opinion of the House as to whether the debate is to conclude now.

Comment on this

I think I am entitled to speak.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No. If the debate is to be resumed the Minister for Justice is in possession.

Comment on this

It was agreed to-day by all Parties in the House that Private Deputies' Business was to be taken up at 9 o'clock.

Comment on this

All Parties—you represent nobody and neither does your Party. I will resign my seat and fight any one of the seven of you in the morning.

Comment on this

Deputy Coburn is after twisting enough already. The Deputy has represented a good many Parties in his time. I suggest that it is quite unfair to Deputies who attend here every day in the week, as distinct from Deputy Coburn who comes here whenever he likes and then passes out, that their time should now be wasted listening to the turbulent eloquence of Deputy Coburn.

Comment on this

I have attended here every day since the Dáil met and I resent that remark of Deputy Norton.

Comment on this

Are we to have Private Deputies' time at 9 o'clock?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a decision of the House. I want to know whether the House now desires to carry out that decision.

Comment on this

Would I be in order in moving that the Question be now put?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I accept the motion.

Comment on this

I think I am entitled to speak in this House, and no Deputy can prevent me from speaking, if I like.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The decision of the House is about to be taken. The Deputy must sit down. I shall now put the Question.

Comment on this

I object. I think I am entitled to say a few words now. I think it is most unfair that I should be prevented from speaking. This decision has not been reached——

Comment on this
A Deputy

Chair!

Comment on this

I have as much respect for the Chair as the Deputy has. The Deputy never had much respect for the Chair.

Comment on this

I move that the Committee Stage be taken now.

Comment on this

I beg to move that the Bill be received for final consideration.

Comment on this

Before it is received for final consideration I should like to say a few words on this Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On the next Stage, if at all.

Comment on this

I move that the Question be now put.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I accept that motion.

Comment on this

I now see that I will not be allowed to speak. There are great defenders of liberty on the Front Bench there. They do not want to hear the truth.

Comment on this