We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Proposed Suspension of Collection of Land Annuities.

Contributions 1–161 of 465. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I move:

That as the British tariffs on Saorstát agricultural produce impose on farmers a burden at least equivalent to their Land Commission annuities the Dáil is of opinion that the Executive Council should take appropriate steps to suspend the collection of annuities during the period of the operation of these tariffs.

Under the law as it stands in this country farmers are liable for the payment of Land Commission annuities. It is unnecessary to go into any history as to how that came about. Legislation was passed arranging for a transfer of the ownership of the land from landlords to tenants, and money was provided to make that transaction possible. The half-yearly collections pay for the interest and sinking fund in respect of the advances made. Notwithstanding the gigantic proportions of the various transactions, which culminated some nine years ago in finishing up that important problem, during the whole of the period, despite difficulties, falling prices, and other obstacles, those annuities were paid regularly and met the purpose for which they were originally designed in paying the interest and sinking fund on the land stock, thus repaying the amount that was borrowed in connection with the transactions. The land annuitant undertook when purchasing his land to pay for that land and to pay for it to one Government only. He never undertook to pay two Governments, and that is the position in which the land annuitant finds himself to-day. He has been in that position at least since 15th July last. He has been put in a slightly worse position quite recently. Some appreciation of the difficulties affecting farmers was present to the minds of the Government last June, and I think it was on 22nd June that a moratorium was announced by the Land Commission or the Minister responsible. The date is of some consequence, because it was previous to the imposition of the British duties. The opinion of the Government at that time—I presume it was not the Minister's only—was that some concessions had to be made to those responsible for the payment of Land Commission annuities.

In order to meet that situation it was provided that annuities due for the previous December would be, as well as I can recollect, spread over a period of two or three years and that the collection would start about 1st May, 1923. It subsequently transpired, in answer to a question by Deputy Dillon, that it was proposed to fund that arrangement by deduction from the rates. We then discovered that the moratorium which was granted was really an act of grace—those who had paid land annuities would be assessed in respect of a portion of it; those who were unable to pay or who had not paid annuities would be assessed for a portion of it. Whatever explanation or recommendation can be made in respect of that moratorium, it must be noted that the decision to grant that special act of grace was come to on 22nd June. On and from 15th July an entirely different situation developed. On and from that date certain tariffs were imposed in the principal export market to which the farmer sent his produce. They were imposed, if not directly, indirectly, and whether directly or indirectly, the result has since been falling prices, lower receipts and, what is worse still, the holding up of certain supplies, that holding up occasioning upon the farmer very considerable extra expense. During the period when he was confronted with this extra expense the costs of various foodstuffs which hitherto had been imported free of charge underwent a slight change as against the farmer.

I do not propose to enter into any detailed explanation of the bad business foresight in connection with that whole transaction. One of the causes of falling prices is fairly well known to be considerable quantities of goods. If, from any market, considerable quantities of goods are held up and are subsequently poured into that market, the result is bound to be a falling price. Through this whole transaction there would appear to have been an entire lack of foresight and statesmanship. I referred yesterday to the point that if the country has to endure anything in the shape of an economic war, the time for it was of the first importance. The months from July to December are the months in which pretty considerable exports of cattle usually take place. This year these exports have been contracted. We have now, I presume, a much greater number of stock in the country than the country is capable of maintaining and that will seriously affect the price that is going to be obtained. Since 15th July a remarkable contraction in the price of agricultural products has taken place.

It was not in the light of circumstances such as these that farmers undertook to pay, and have paid, the Land Commission annuities. If a bargain had now to be made in respect of the purchase of land it would not be at the price which farmers undertook to pay nine, ten, thirty, forty or fifty years ago. The fact is that, whether we like it or not, there is now in respect of our agricultural exports such a reduction in price as exceeds the sum total of all the annuities collected or paid or to be collected in this country. The taxes which have been imposed and which are expected to be collected exceed the sum total of the Land Commission annuities by over £1,000,000. Prior to 1923 the ordinary Land Commision annuities amounted approximately to £3,000,000. The Act of 1923 brings the amount of the annuities to, roughly, £4,000,000 in all. In respect of that £4,000,000 farmers are being charged £5,000,000.

These interruptions of markets, these losses in prices are of very considerable moment to farmers. They never undertook to pay two Governments. They undertook to pay only one Government. They are liable at this moment, according to the law, for the Land Commission annuities here. They are being taxed in respect of agricultural imports by another Government for a sum in excess of what they undertook to pay. I submit that that is a profound injustice to the farmers. It is morally wrong and, even though this particular motion, if passed, will not rectify the situation, will only contribute in a small way towards a rectification and could not possibly be expected to equate the losses that have been sustained, it is at any rate the biggest effort that can be made in present circumstances.

It is in the light of these facts that I put forward this motion. I suggest to the House that, in pure justice and morality, if we are to see the agricultural industry survive at all, the only way in which it can be done is to cease this collection. In this fight the farmers, the agriculturists, are the soldiers. They are not only the soldiers, but they are also the suppliers of the costs of the war. That is not done in any other war. The people ordinarily are expected to bear at least some portion of the impact of conflicts, but here we are asking one particular section that has been subjected during the last twelve months to falling prices and to the difficulties of a dreadful competition, to pay twice. We are, in fact, asking them to pay more than twice the amount of the Land Commission annuities which, since they undertook to pay them, they have faithfully paid. I submit they had no information regarding this particular burden that has been placed upon them. They were promised by the Party now in power, when being asked for votes, greater security. What is the maximum security which can be afforded to an agricultural country such as this? The obvious answer is the sale of its products.

Were the farmers at any time warned by the present Ministry, when they were being asked for votes, that they would be faced with this situation? I have one of the Fianna Fáil advertisements here:—"For all it means less taxation, lower rates, better times. It means security." Having regard to what transpired here yesterday, the only security and assistance that we can give to the farmers in this instance—it ought to have gone out from the House and there ought to be no necessity for this motion at all because common sense or common justice, as a Deputy here corrects me, ought to have suggested it to the Ministry—is an opportunity for the sale of their products.

To any sensible person, that would appear to be a commonsense proposition for the consideration of the Government. Within the last few days, the taxes on agricultural exports have been increased. Yesterday, I pointed out that there was, apart from these taxes, a disposition in the market to which we have been sending our goods to buy other goods. I instanced the case where eight yearlings were bought here in the Dublin Show for 400 guineas, seven being sold in England for 1,680 guineas, 400 guineas being received for the other one. That is only a single example. If the goodwill of the market be lost, nobody can possibly estimate the cost to the supplier or the salesman. It would be impossible to compensate the various parties who are losing money in connection with this business. Take one simple example. Approximately £2,000,000 have been kept out of circulation. There is, first of all, the money that was passed here in the Appropriation Act for payment of pensions, and there are the land annuities. These are not times in which huge sums of money such as those can be withheld without entailing losses. It is absolutely idle for Ministers to get up here, as the Minister for Education did yesterday, and tell the House that they are spending £3,000,000 on agriculture or for the benefit of the farmers, or to give employment throughout the country. Where does the money come from? It ought to come in the normal course from the profits of industry and trade. But nobody who has any association with either industry or trade can say that, in present circumstances, they can afford the £3,000,000 or £4,000,000 to which the Minister referred yesterday. That expenditure must come from capital, ultimately injuring and, perhaps, crippling the industry of this State. The major portion of the wealth of this country comes from agriculture and even if this money came from taxation, derived from profits, it is the agriculturists themselves who would be called upon to make the payment. I have yet to learn that the people cannot spend their money to better advantage than a State or a municipality or any public body can do it. In these circumstances, I move this motion. It is not enough compensation for the losses the agriculturists have suffered, but it is something. I move the motion also with a view to drawing public attention to the injustice and immorality of imposing this charge upon people who undertook to buy their lands any time during the last forty or fifty years, and who undertook to pay only once for them. No State and no Government has the right to make them pay twice.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave got an opportunity of explaining his motion and he has not done it. I should like to know what he means by the word "suspending." If we are to pass a motion or reject it, we ought to know exactly what it means. The Deputy has not explained what he means by the words "suspend the collection of annuities during the period of the operation of these tariffs." Does he mean to remit them entirely? What does he mean to do with them? I think we should have some understanding on this point before we start to debate this motion.

Comment on this

I mean that the Government should introduce an Act to suspend the collection and payment of these Land Commission annuities by the tenant purchasers until the British tariffs have been withdrawn.

Comment on this

What is going to happen in the meantime? Are these moneys to be completely remitted—not to be paid at all?

Comment on this

The motion does not state that and the Deputy did not state it. Now, for the first time, we really understand what the motion means. There is to be complete remission of these annuities. Deputy Cosgrave has shown to-day an anxiety on behalf of the farmer that he had to change sides to acquire. When we were on the opposite benches, during the past five or six years, we tried to get the Government of the day to realise, as apparently they were not realising, that there were hard times in store for our farmers, that these hard times were coming upon them by reason of the fact that they were depending upon one market and that in that market the purchasing power was diminishing. On account of the diminution of that purchasing power, instead of the fresh meat which we were supplying, the people of Britain were getting chilled and frozen meat from distant countries—countries in which the population was only a few persons to the square mile, relatively prairie lands, with which our people could not hope to compete unless our population was to be diminished to a similar sparsity. During that time, if I recollect aright, there was a Bill passed in the Dáil which made it a penal offence for anybody to suggest that the land annuities should not be paid. That was because it was suggested that we were urging the farmers not to pay their land annuities. Just as the Opposition have turned from callousness, with regard to the farmers' position, to apparent anxiety, so also they have turned from being upholders of contracts between the individual and the State, threatening anybody who suggested that there was no such contract, into people who are deliberately—a number of them— asking farmers not to meet their obligations. We have been asking the farmers to meet their obligations to this State, to this community. They were asking them to meet obligations, as they called them, not to this community, but to an outside Government. They showed tremendous anxiety in collecting these annuities when they were to be passed over to an outside Government, but now, when these annuities are to be kept at home for circulation in this country and for the betterment of all classes within the community, because they think it will embarrass the Government at the present time and deplete the funds with which it hopes to conduct this struggle successfully, they go out on what I regard as an outrageous campaign—some of them— and suggest to the farmers that that debt is not due at all—that, in other words, unless that debt is a debt to England, it is not a debt at all. Our position is that it is a debt, by the individual farmer who purchases land, to the community as a whole—to the State—and that that debt, so far as it is at all possible, ought to be paid and met as one of the principal obligations. Looking into the future, and to the necessity for the State as a whole, if we are to have any reconstruction here, to go occasionally to the aid of one section or another of the community, we regard it as a matter of first principle that a debt by a member of the community, or a class of members of the community, to the State should be one which will not be evaded.

Comment on this

When it is due.

Comment on this

Yes. Who suggested it is not due?

Comment on this

It is due to the British Government, we are told.

Comment on this

No, and well you know it.

Comment on this

The British Government have not put up that claim.

Comment on this

Of course, not.

Comment on this

It is not a debt between the individual farmer and the holder of the land bonds.

Comment on this

Yes, it is.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

It makes no difference even if it is not. You are not a holder of land bonds anyhow, and you are not responsible.

Comment on this

It is a debt by the individual farmer to the State. The State, at the time he contracted the debt, was the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland.

Comment on this

There was a dissolution of that partnership and in accordance with a special Act, part of the assets—that is, these annuities— was transferred to this community here in this part of Ireland as they were transferred to the other community in the Six Counties. And just as those who in the Six Counties did not transmit the annuities, did not thereby deprive the bondholders of their dividends, so the position that we took up, of holding on to the annuities here as our right in this State, is not depriving the bondholders of their dividends.

There is no contract as such between the farmer and bondholder, and anybody who suggests there is is only deceiving the people and misleading the people. There is no contract between the private individual farmer who purchased his land and any bondholder who holds the land stock. None whatever. The contract of the individual farmer is a contract with the State that advanced the money, and we are the successors of that State so far as these annuities are concerned. There is a debt due by the farmers, and, moreover, I would warn the farmers not to allow themselves to be misled by the arguments of the gentlemen yonder. When it suited their purpose —or rather when it did not suit their purpose to say otherwise—they gave the very same warning to the farmers that the title to their land depended on the payment of these annuities. If the farmers are foolish enough to listen to those who suggest that they should not pay these annuities, who suggest that they can get out of these obligations and continue to hold their land, they are making a mistake. I warn them here now that they are making a mistake in the present position of the world and world tendencies.

The position is that as long as we have responsibility for the Government we are going to insist on the obligations of the farmer to the State in respect of moneys advanced to him for the purchase of his holding. We have taken stock of the present situation and we are taking stock of it. We have given certain relief up to the present. We have relieved in particular ways the farmer.

Comment on this

It may be said that that relief does not correspond to all his losses, but it more than corresponds to all the losses he has incurred in respect of the present tariffs and the present situation so far as it arose from our dispute with the British Government.

Comment on this

Question!

Comment on this

We are not able completely to meet the losses he was bound to suffer because there was not foresight enough on the part of those gentlemen on the opposite benches. During the period when we asked them to look ahead and foresee the time when the people would not be able to continue paying these annuities—when we tried to do that the gentlemen yonder tried to hold out this hope to the people:—"Oh you are going to get preferences in this and that from the British," as if they were going to get these preferences without giving a quid pro quo for them. Everybody knows it.

Comment on this

Who is everybody?

Comment on this

We came here on another occasion when it was recognised throughout the world that the burden of these inter-Governmental debts was one of the chief causes of world depression, and we suggested, first of all, that time should be given here for the consideration of that question. The Chair would not give it to us at the time. Then we suggested to the Government that it should be followed up by a moratorium. But no, there was no such thing that time as looking forward to consider the position of our agriculturists. The position of this country in continuing to pay five millions annually was much worse than the position of any of the Governments in Europe who were making inter-Governmental payments which we were told were beggaring those countries. At that time we asked the Government to look ahead. The Government did not look ahead until they were taught sense by the electorate. Now they come forward and pretend they are the people who were able to foresee these things and that we were blind people dashing along without raising our heads to look in front of us.

The moratorium or the suspension of those payments which I asked for was not listened to. Now the suspension of the payment of these annuities is the suggestion by Deputy Cosgrave.

We have been considering that and asking ourselves what is the ability of our people to pay and what we propose to do is this: We propose to introduce, as early as may be, legislation here, to provide for the perpetual remission of a substantial portion of these annuities.

Comment on this

That is one up to the Labour Party anyway.

Comment on this

It is one up for commonsense, but it does not matter for whom it is one up. We propose to give a substantial remission of the annuities perpetually as regards the instalments pending in November and December and similar instalments in next May and June. The proposal of the Government is to fund these instalments over a period not less than the period that is to run for their respective annuities—to fund them at four and a half per cent. We are not going, therefore, to remit. We are keeping the obligation on the individual farmer to the State which is to ensure him his title to his land, so that nobody can come along afterwards and say: "You have got that plot of land and have no right to it!"

Comment on this

Are you going to withdraw the civil bills?

Comment on this

As an obvious corollary, remember we are suspending the payments in the case of those who plead inability to pay.

Comment on this

Who proved inability to pay?

Comment on this

Those who plead their inability to meet their obligations can have their instalments for November and December, and May and June funded over a period at four and a half per cent. That will be for a period not less than that to which the present annuities are yet to run. As a natural corollary to that, we are not going to withhold from the local authority the grants which are normally withheld to cover the payments that have not been made by land annuitants. We are not going to do that. To meet the point with regard to the extra amounts that have been withheld in respect of the instalments that fell due in May and June this year and in order to relieve further the finances of the local authorities we propose to release the moneys paid into the Purchase Annuities Fund in respect of the amounts withheld for the May and June instalments this year to the extent to which these were in excess of the amounts withheld in respect of the corresponding instalments of May and June of the previous year.

That is our attitude, and we believe that everything that can be done for the farmers in the present situation, done for them by the community as a whole, is being done, and that the farmers are not being asked to be the only body to bear the brunt of this whole struggle. The burden and the brunt is being spread over the community as a whole and the community as a whole is standing for this.

Comment on this

Are any of them prepared to buy the farmers' calves and yearlings at present?

Comment on this

I would remind you that there are in this country not merely the farming community but others—that there is another section of the community whose wants have to be attended to also. They are the unemployed, and the attention of the Government has got to be turned not merely to the farmers but also to that section of the community that is unemployed.

Comment on this

And to the employed.

Comment on this

During the election time we pointed to the goods imported here that could be made at home and said: "There is employment here for as many as are at present unemployed in the country. There is employment here, if we simply build up our industries and make for ourselves the things that we are at present paying others to make for us." That was our programme. Time after time we made it clear that we could not expect and did not expect that that could be done overnight. It is suggested that some of the present hardships, for instance, were not pointed out to the people. The gentlemen on the opposite benches took very good care that not merely anything that has happened would be pointed out but that hardships far greater than those which are actually upon us were in store for us if Fianna Fáil was elected. The people knew perfectly well that if they were going to get out of this £5,000,000 a year which was being unjustly paid, if they were going to get out of that payment which the previous Government had made during a period of ten years, if they were to be saved from that payment they would have to make a fight—they would have to struggle for it—and they know perfectly well that what is going to be saved to them is this £5,000,000 a year.

I gave last night a figure to indicate what the payment of £5,000,000 a year did mean to this country. I pointed out that it represented 40 per cent. of our cattle trade, that it represented 2½ times the total amount of our butter trade of the last year, and so on over a number of other items. I think in one of the cases it was actually 4¼ times the whole of our produce. In other words, continuation of the payment of these annuities meant that we were to be saddled, as long as land annuity payments and those other payments were to continue, with a perpetual burden, representing something like 40 per cent. of our cattle trade of last year. Deputy O'Sullivan went down to Kildare and told them a tax of £1 a head might be put on their cattle, that perhaps the British might even get very vexed and put £2 a head on our cattle, and he said that when as a matter of fact the burden that was actually being borne at the time amounted to over £3 a head on our cattle.

Comment on this

It is £6 a head now.

Comment on this

What nonsense.

Comment on this

Not nonsense. It is the truth.

Comment on this

It is nonsense that 40 per cent. amounts to £6 per head. What happened was this, that in this country, the same as in Great Britain, there has been a terrific fall in agricultural prices.

Comment on this

You drove them down. You drove them down in the beginning.

Comment on this

By putting on a tariff, as Britain did against our cattle, we drove them down? Did you ever hear such nonsense?

Comment on this
A Deputy

What about your alternative markets?

Comment on this

The fact of the matter is, and nobody can deny it, that agricultural prices have fallen in Britain as they have fallen here. We would be in a desperate situation here in any case. I am quite willing to admit that the last straw is a very serious matter in a case like this. I am quite willing to admit that this is an extra hardship, but I say we had to face that extra hardship unless we were going to continue to pay £5,000,000 a year. The Irish people had that before them at the Election. They decided, and they decided wisely, that it was better to end that payment and to endure whatever hardships might have to be endured rather than have that burden imposed on them. A former British Prime Minister, when he was talking of a sum of £5,000,000 a year in connection with the arrangement which was being made about the American debt, said that a burden of £5,000,000 a year was going to be a crushing burden on the people, which might affect not merely their children but their grandchildren. We are paying a sum to Britain which corresponds to £330,000,000 a year. If £5,000,000 a year was a burden on the British which that Prime Minister said he would rather resign than accept, what is this burden on us?

We have, as I pointed out last night, in our diminishing population, in the diminution of tillage here, in the reduction of our stock, in everything that indicates gradual decay, the results of that payment of £5,000,000 a year, and if it was to be got rid of there was only one way to do it, and that was to stop the payment until the others are able to prove their title to it. There was no other way. The people who talk about bargains had a time for making a bargain when we put forward a moratorium. Why did they not make a bargain? They told us last night what we should do. When that opportunity was offered to them why did they not go along and point to our emigration, point to the diminution of our tillage and to the general decay in this country from an industrial point of view? Why did they not say to the British at that time when they had an opportunity: "We cannot continue making those payments. It is not fair to our people that they should be made. You have yourselves admitted that those inter-Governmental payments are responsible for a great deal of the present misery in the world"? Why did not these people who had the power then (they were on such good terms with the British apparently that they could get any preferences they wanted) get those preferences and make those terms when they had the opportunity? Now that they are elsewhere, now that they are on the opposite benches, they can tell us what we should do. I put it to every Deputy in this House, and to every commonsense individual in the country, that there is no way in which we can hope to deal with the legacy that was left to us by the outgoing Government except to do exactly what we are doing and make up our minds that those payments are not going to be made. We, at any rate, have made up our minds that they are not going to be made. We believe them to be unjust, we believe them to be intolerable, and we are not going to make the payments——

Comment on this

What has this to do with the motion?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yesterday was given largely to a debate on the land annuities. That question has been debated several times. The motion before the House deals with a moratorium or suspension of the collection of annuities, and the question of the right of retention of these annuities in Ireland does not arise on this motion.

Comment on this

Except in so far, a Chinn Comhairle, as it indicates the cause and circumstances which bring a motion of this sort. I do not wish to pursue the matter. We have had it here time after time, but it is rather difficult to listen to the present Leader of the Opposition who, when in this seat here, had an opportunity of doing things if he had the foresight. If there was the posturing he speaks of, all we have to say is if that posturing was not there at that time, and if it were not continued at this time, he would see quite clearly that the present position is due directly to their want of competence; to their failure to take time by the forelock; looking ahead, and so preparing our agricultural community so that when the necessarily difficult times that were bound to come came, and whoever was in office, that the hardships farmers have to bear now would not have to be borne. At any rate, I have indicated that this Government is not prepared to accept anything that would suggest that the individual farmer, who has bought out his land, has not an obligation to the community as a whole to pay his annuities. We are prepared to give relief, in so far as we can, bearing the interests of the other section of the community in mind at the present time. We want you to remember we have got to meet the annuities on the 1923 Land Bonds. These have got to be met, and I say that to push this matter any further than on the footing we have suggested is to run away from two important principles. The first is that the individual farmer has a debt to the State which he ought to pay, and which it is vital he should pay either by deferred payments or immediate payments. If there is ever again to be any hope of the State, as a whole, coming to the assistance of individuals in the State, I believe our policy will lead us—it does not matter what Government is in power—of necessity to a time when it will be to the advantage of the community as a whole should succour a certain section of the community. That can be done by giving loans and advances and by enabling a section of the community to do certain things. These loans and advances will be given by the community, as a whole, and they ought to be regarded as a sacred obligation by the section that have suffered. We are told about the hard times. Recognising the hard times, we are prepared to fund the debt, and we are prepared to fund it at a reasonable rate of interest.

Comment on this

Might I ask the President is any relief going to be given to the farmers who were unable to pay the annuities that were due last May or June?

Comment on this

There have been people going about the country in a deliberate campaign encouraging people not to pay. We know perfectly well there are a number of people who could pay and did not pay last May. The position of the Land Commission with regard to this is there is an old Land Commission practice by which, when a case for easing for a time, by instalments or otherwise, comes up, consideration is given to hard cases. That is an old established rule which has been followed out and will be followed out, in so far as it can, in the present circumstances. But we are not going to be a party to, and we are not going to encourage in any way whatever, the campaign that was abroad for some months past, and which was participated in by members of this House and was encouraged by people who could well pay their land annuities.

Comment on this

On what side of the House?

Comment on this

Not on this side of the House. At no time did any responsible person on this side say to the people that the land annuities, by the individual farmer, need not be paid.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Did you not say it in this very House?

Comment on this

At no time did any responsible person on this side of the House——

Comment on this

Who are the responsible people on that side?

Comment on this

Time after time——

Comment on this

A Chinn Comhairle, I want to know who are the responsible people on that side of the House?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has put a question, not a point of order.

Comment on this

Is it in order for the President to describe a Deputy as not being responsible?

Comment on this

They are best on the other side at misrepresenting words. I said no responsible person on this side, and I know of no person in the Fianna Fáil organisation——

Comment on this

Who are the responsible people on the other side?

Comment on this

We are responsible for the Executive policy. I say nobody who took responsibility for the direction of the campaign for the retention of the land annuities has ever suggested that the debts of the individual farmer to the State were not to be paid. I remember the first time I spoke on it I went out of my way to make it quite clear, and Deputy Hogan, on the other side, followed up then by telling the people they were not going to get much advantage out of it; that they might as well pay to Mr. Lloyd George as to Mr. de Valera or the Fianna Fáil Government, showing quite clearly that they understood that we were seeking, not to relieve the farmer of his annuities, or to ask him not to pay, but seeking a campaign by which the people of this country would not continue to send £5,000,000 of their money annually to another country.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do not want to interrupt, but I would like to remind the President that is not the first time he said that. The first time was when he gave his interview to the "Manchester Guardian" and he then stated that he would not collect the land annuities.

Comment on this

I did not say any such thing.

Comment on this

Yes, you did.

Comment on this

I think I am in a position at the moment to give the full text of this interview. I said at that particular time that there were inequalities in regard to the land annuities and so there are, and Deputy Hogan's 1923 Land Act introduced the greatest of all these inequalities. It would be too great a task for the present Executive or any future Executive to take in hand and cover up these inequalities. I said there were inequalities and it would probably be a better way in order to relieve these inequalities to act otherwise.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

Land tax.

Comment on this

It does not matter what it was. It would be very much better that the people who were paying the present exorbitant annuities under the 1923 Act were paying a sum one-third or one-fourth of that, call it whatever you like.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

Your idea was land tax.

Comment on this

Whatever you like to call a reduction of the present land annuities and the settling of the inequalities.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies must observe the rules of order and if some Deputies do not like the tone of the President's speech they have a remedy and will have an opportunity of replying. They have an opportunity of replying later on, but Ministers and Deputies must get a hearing.

Comment on this

Why was not the same facility accorded to ex-President Cosgrave when he spoke yesterday? (Interruption).

Comment on this
Deputies

Sit down. Chair.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy who has just interrupted has on three or four recent occasions remained standing while the Ceann Comhairle was on his feet. That is not orderly.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy has any objection to the conduct of the Ceann Comhairle yesterday or on previous occasions, he has, as he knows, a remedy. But he has only one remedy.

Mr. Anthony rose.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No question can be raised on that issue.

Comment on this

I apologise to the Chair if I have offended, but what I rose to say was that President de Valera got perfect order yesterday when he was speaking, but order was denied to ex-President Cosgrave.

Comment on this
A Deputy

That is the game now.

Comment on this

I would ask the House not to treat this as a joke. It is a serious matter for this country.

Comment on this

I was speaking of the first time I mentioned the land annuity campaign to the Irish people as a definite part of the Fianna Fáil policy. That was quite clear. Knowing that there was a misrepresentation of that policy, I went out of my way to make it quite clear that the policy did not mean that individual farmers were not to pay their annuities to the Land Commission as representing the community; that it meant that we were not going to transfer these annuities across the water. It was thoroughly understood. It was undoubtedly misrepresented by a number of people, but it was understood. I cited Deputy Hogan as an example who, as one in authority, would have been, I take it, the very first to expose any such campaign as a campaign for non-payment by individual farmers. He did not expose that because it was not the campaign. But he tried to suggest—as some other Deputies sitting on the Front Bench opposite want even still to represent it—that it did not matter to the Irish farmer, so long as he had to pay, to what Treasury the payment was made. Deputy Cosgrave spoke about the circulation of some £2,000,000 in this country. I found it difficult to understand what £2,000,000 he had in mind. There was, however, a sum of £5,000,000 going out of circulation here and going to a foreign country that he stood for every year, and I daresay, if he were back on these benches now that he would stand for it. We do not stand for it. We are trying, as far as we can, and as quickly as we can, to adjust our present economy to the circumstances not merely of the present time, but to the circumstances that anybody can foresee are going to be the circumstances of the future. That is the position. Whilst relieving, as far as it is possible for us to do it, the section that most immediately is affected, we hope that we will ultimately bring about the restoration of our industries and a balanced economy in this country which will give a livelihood to the people who in the past had to emigrate to get that livelihood. That is our policy. With regard to the present motion. I have indicated what our policy is. We are going to vote against this particular motion because it implies something that we are not prepared to stand for.

Comment on this

On a point of order. A statement was made in the House yesterday by Mr. Cleary to the effect that I had advised the farmers of this country not to pay their land annuities. I formally contradicted that statement. It was repeated by way of an interjection just now by Deputy Kennedy. I want to know whether it is not a rule of the House that a formal assurance by a member of the Dáil should be accepted.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is the rule. The Chair did not hear the interjection to-day.

Comment on this

Might I ask the President whether, arising out of the Government's proposals as indicated by him now, consideration will also be given by the Government to the question of an equalisation of the annuities under the 1923 Act?

Comment on this

As I have indicated in my speech, that is our desire. In fact, a superficial examination has already been given to it—not a detailed examination—but even from a very superficial examination the difficulties appear to be very great. I could not promise definitely at this stage, on account of the practical difficulties, that we can do it. If there is any way of meeting that situation and meeting it in a practical way, we hope to be able to do it. I am not giving a promise now. I could not promise that, because the difficulties may be insurmountable.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton has asked a question which I was about to ask. Am I right in saying that the President's proposal is to fund the June arrears and the December instalments and to give remission of a proportion of the annuities after that? Is that the proposal? The idea is to fund the June arrears, fund the December instalments, and, after that, to give a permanent remission of a high proportion of the annuities?

Comment on this

I shall repeat the proposal. As to the instalments that are pending now in November and December, and the instalments of next May and June, if any annuitant makes a claim that he is unable to pay, then the amount will be funded at 4½ per cent. over a period not less than the period that his present annuity is to run. That is with regard to the future. Arising out of that, in fair play to the local authorities, we are not going to make any deductions from the grants, even the average deductions that would have been made in any ordinary normal year. We are going to make no deduction, therefore, from the grants to the local authorities, which will relieve the local authorities to that extent. With regard to annuities due last May and June, we are proceeding in the usual way with the collection of these annuities, and the usual procedure of the Land Commission with regard to them will be followed. In other words, if a case can be put forward and a fair offer made to pay within any reasonable period, especially when they are getting relief in regard to future annuities and getting a better chance, we are not going to press them too hard. That is the usual practice of the Land Commission in the circumstances. With regard to the moneys that have been deducted from the grants and put to the Purchase Annuities Fund, the amount by which they were abnormal, the amount by which they were greater than the amount of the instalment of the previous May and June of 1931, will be refunded to the local authorities.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Did I understand the President to say that, in addition, he would give a substantial remission of the annuities in future?

Comment on this

Yes. With regard to the future, legislation is under consideration at present which will provide for a substantial reduction of the land annuities in future permanently.

Comment on this

Might I repeat a question which I put to the President yesterday with regard to the promise of full derating for the agricultural community. That promise was made before and during the General Election. It was stated that he would indicate the Government's intention in regard to that to-day. The President has not referred at all to derating, and I want to know what is the position with regard to the people who cannot pay their rates.

Comment on this

It is quite obvious that there are some people who will never be satisfied, that there are some people who, the more they get, the more they want.

Comment on this

There are some people who never give up promising.

Comment on this

A very big agricultural grant has already been given, and we are relieving the agricultural community to a very large extent in regard to rates——

Comment on this

By destruction of their markets.

Comment on this

—— and if we change to a policy of relieving them with regard to annuities, I do not think they have any ground for complaint.

Comment on this

I rise to deal with one aspect of this question as enunciated by the President. He bases his case regarding the collection of these annuities on the assumption that the annuities are a debt due by the tenants to the State. As to the suggestion that prior to the election the President said that these annuities were not to be paid by the tenants, that is a matter between the President and the tenants. Everyone who is associated with the public life of this country is aware that one of the main reasons for the success of Fianna Fáil at the last election was that there would be no land annuities paid. The President solemnly tells the House that these annuities are due by the tenants to the State. Who advised him in this respect? Was it the Attorney-General or was it the Minister for Justice?

Before Deputies vote on this matter it is desirable to have a clear view of the essence of this contract. It would be well to remember the conditions that existed at the passing of the Land Acts of 1881, 1903 and 1909. What really took place when the respective Acts were passed was that the landlords agreed to sell and the tenants to purchase and, after certain preliminaries, a formal contract was entered on by individual tenants and individual landlords. The landlord agreed to sell for a specified sum, and the tenant agreed to purchase his holding at that sum. There was no reference to States, Governments or bondholders in the contract; it was a simple contract between two parties, the landlord on the one side and the tenant on the other. I challenge the President or any of his legal advisers to say that there is any liability on any party in this country or in England, except the tenant on the one hand and the landlord on the other, for the amount specified in the contract.

The Act which empowered tenants to purchase provided for other things. It was well understood by the Legislature that the tenants could not put up the money when they signed their contracts and certain financial arrangements had to be made. The Act provided that stock would be issued to the public and on the day that stock was subscribed the landlord was paid off. That placed the bond-holder who subscribed the money in the position of the landlord and he was made the other party to the contract. The public who subscribed this money desired some guarantee in case of default. In order that the question of land tenure in this country would be finally settled, the Government decided to guarantee the money. No more fallacious suggestion could be made than that this money is due to the State. There is no legal liability between the landlord and the State; it is a liability between the tenant and the individuals who put up the money. The State came in as guarantors.

It is wholly untenable to suggest that the State are entitled to collect these moneys for their own use. They can only collect them as agents for the bondholders and pay them over to the bondholders. The motion merely asks for the non-collection of these annuities during the period of the tariff war. The President, in order to justify the continued collection of the annuities, says that he must get them because they are a debt due to the State. He never gave an explanation in that respect, because he could not. No one can validly hold here or outside that the annuities are due to anyone except to those who originally put up the money. The people who are not bondholders have no interest in this money and have no more right to it than the residents in the Fiji Islands.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell the House who pays the bondholders in Ulster?

Comment on this

A very ignorant interruption.

Comment on this

I am not now concerned with matters outside the Free State. I am dealing with the motion before the House and if, on some other occasion, the Deputy wants to hear from me who pays the bondholders in the Six Counties, I will answer him. At the moment, I will not allow myself to be dragged into irrelevancies.

Comment on this

Answer the question, it you are able.

Comment on this

Will the Ceann Comhairle allow him?

Comment on this

We are told by the President that the suggestion contained in the motion is an outrageous one. There was also the suggestion that Deputy Cosgrave had to cross the floor of the House in order to discover that he could make a proposal of the sort. At what other period did such conditions exist as exist in this country to-day? Were the farmers ever in such a position since 1850? Why are the farmers in such a position as they now occupy? They are in that position because of the tariff war that has arisen between the two countries. The merits of that tariff war do not now arise. One of the countries, in order to compensate itself for moneys that it alleges were detained from it, puts into operation a system of tariffs calculated to raise an equivalent amount. As Deputy Cosgrave pointed out, that country has done much more. The farmers here are under no obligation to pay anything except the actual sum prescribed in their contracts with the bondholders. They are now asked to pay other moneys that were payable to England under certain financial agreements. Not only are the farmers asked, so far as England is concerned, to pay their annuities, but they are asked to pay all the pensions payable to servants of the Government who were pensioned off in 1921 as a result of the Treaty.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is the Deputy in order in referring to that matter?

Comment on this

Are you, a Chinn Comhairle, going to permit these ignorant interruptions?

Comment on this

We would not know the Deputy was ignorant if he did not interrupt. The farmers are not only asked to pay their annuities but they are asked to pay, in addition, other sums which have to be met by the State generally. That is not the worst. This is not a question of 40 per cent. If it were confined to 40 per cent. of the value of the farmer's products, it would be a small matter. But the entire bottom has fallen out of the market for agricultural products. If I go into a market or fair at present, I am sure to see a man with a herd of cattle who is in urgent need of money. He will probably be a poor man with a large family. That family has to be fed and clothed. The ordinary accounts must be met and the cattle must be sacrificed at any price in order to obtain the necessary money. The dealer knows that and he makes a blind shot at about a quarter of the value of the stock. The poor farmer must accept the price he is offered, so that his loss is not 40 per cent., but 75 or 80 per cent. For that reason, I submit that the collection of these annuities should be suspended during this period. I do not want to be taken for a moment as urging the non-payment of debts. That is a policy to which I have never given support. But I submit that the Government and the House might as well take their courage in their hands and adopt this motion. If it is not adopted, they will not be able to get the money. What is the alternative? Speaking on a vote for the Department of Lands and Fisheries last session, I asked the Minister to contrive some machinery for the collection of the annuities other than the taking of legal proceedings against men who are unable to pay. By the taking of legal proceedings, enormous costs are involved. Sometimes the costs are in excess of the land annuities, thus making the position of these men much worse. The President tells us that the Government is going to collect these annuities by legal means, if necessary. On the other hand, he tells us that if anybody comes and says he is unable to pay, the annuities will be funded at 4½ per cent. I was surprised to hear that. The ordinary man knows nothing about that stylish and fancy financial term, "funding." What it means in plain language in this case is that the tenant farmer, having already paid an excessive sum under contract for his lands, will be asked to pay an extra 4½ per cent. for the funding of that money over a longer period. I submit that that is a diabolical suggestion. Everybody knows that, because of certain circumstances which we need not now go into, the prices paid by tenants under the 1903 and 1909 Acts were far in excess of the value of the lands. The farmers are told that they are to pay an extra 4½ per cent. on the exorbitant price they paid under the 1903 Act. It may be forgotten that the prices paid by tenants under those Acts were far in excess of the value of the lands. Bonus shares were issued so that landlords could be paid off forthwith. Land Stock had been issued under par. When the Government came to pay off the landlords, an additional sum had to be provided. That was done by issuing bonus stock which was added on by the method of the "zones" in various parts of the country. Hence tenant farmers under the 1903 Act—they were not so bad under the Ashbourne Act or the Act of 1881—which was the Act under which a very large portion of the lands of the country was acquired, had to contract to pay a sum far in excess of the value of the lands. Now, the President tells those farmers that they must pay an extra 4½ per cent. I say that that is an outrage on men who are already overburdened, who are already crushed, whose markets are already destroyed and whose capacity to pay has been filched from them by the Government, rightly or wrongly, stupidly or otherwise. In the name of those farmers, I say that this proposal is an outrage and I ask the House to register its protest by voting for this motion.

The President says that he never suggested that these annuities should not be paid. The President must think that the people of this country have very short memories, or that those who lived in 1925 and 1926 have disappeared from the face of the country. I have no desire to go into this question, but I do not want a statement of that kind to go uncontradicted. I remember when the President, then Deputy de Valera, in 1926 made the speeches that he referred to in Clare and elsewhere. His first attitude was that these annuities should not be paid at all. I do not want to misrepresent the President and I speak subject to correction. However, his original attitude was "We will not pay the land annuities."

Comment on this

On a point of order, the President gave his word that he never made that statement. In spite of that denial, Deputy McMenamin accuses him, in his absence, of making the statement.

Comment on this

It is a fact.

Comment on this
Mr. Brady

Let him quote the words.

Comment on this

The President explained the speeches he made, but I do not think he denied making the statement.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The President stated categorically in this House that he had never stated that the land annuities should not be paid to the State.

Comment on this

To the State.

Comment on this

He also stated that no responsible person on his side had made that statement, which is directly contrary to the fact, to my own personal knowledge.

Comment on this

I wish to state definitely that I do not want to misrepresent the President in this House or outside it. The statement he made is open to ambiguity. The ambiguity is in the fact that the State that guaranteed the Land Bonds was not this State. This State was then a portion of the State that guaranteed the Land Bonds and therein lies the ambiguity, so far as the President's statement is concerned. Certainly, this State did not guarantee the Land Bonds under the Acts of 1881, 1903 or 1909 because it did not exist then. I do not know what was in the President's mind in this connection. It may be that he meant that the annuities should not be paid to England but to this State. However, the speech that he originally made impressed me—lacking in intelligence as I am—so much that I consulted a man whom I regarded as an authority on this matter—a man who had been connected with the Land War and the Plan of Campaign and who had been in the British House of Commons when the Acts of 1881, 1903 and 1909 were enacted. I refer to the late Mr. John Dillon. I considered that the suggestion of Deputy de Valera was not cricket, to use a sporting phrase, and I consulted Mr. Dillon.

I asked the late John Dillon one question about this matter of the land annuities. I asked him did he read the speech made by Mr. de Valera and he said "I did." I asked him what he thought of it and of the then policy on the land annuities and his answer simply was this: "It is thoroughly dishonest." Now assuming my intelligence to be sub-normal I put it that nobody will assert that, no matter what they might say about John Dillon's intelligence in other matters, that he did not know what he was talking about when talking about the land annuities and the Land Acts. The whole driving force behind the Fianna Fáil Party during the last five or six years was the non-payment of the land annuities. Everybody knows that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy hold it relevant on this motion to discuss what Sinn Fein did four or five years ago?

Comment on this

I am only dealing with the President's speech as I submit I have a right to reply to it. I submit that if the President is justified is dealing with these matters in his speech I am also justified in dealing with them when I am replying to it. This is not denying that the debt is due by the State. That is beside the question. I submit, sir, that no motion that has come before this House in its history has been regarded with such grave and weighty attention as this motion and whether or not the House agrees with it, the people outside, the farmers of the country, are going to decide the matter. They will not pay because they cannot pay. This House therefore had better take that view of the position of the farmers of this State and agree to this motion.

Comment on this

It is with some sense of responsibility I rise to talk on this motion. If I were to pursue the line of least resistance I would not intervene in this discussion. I would leave it to the irresponsibles of the Government Party to continue it. I want to suggest to the House that within this motion we can talk about many things affecting the lives of our people to-day. It is suggested in the motion by Deputy Cosgrave that the pursuing of the policy adumbrated by the present Government causes and is causing grevious injury to the agricultural industry, and is also causing heavy losses to the community and gravely increasing unemployment.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It seems to the Chair that the Deputy is reading the wrong motion. He has quoted from the motion that was disposed of last night. The House is now dealing with Deputy Cosgrave's motion— Number 1 on to-day's Order Paper.

Comment on this

I quite understand, sir, that this motion deals with the retention of the land annuities, and I want to relate that to what has occurred already. It is practically the same motion and I want to relate it to the motion dealt with last night. The motion says:

That as the British tariffs on Saorstát agricultural produce impose on farmers a burden at least equivalent to their land commission annuities the Dáil is of opinion that the Executive Council should take appropriate steps to suspend the collection of annuities during the period of the operation of these tariffs.

Now, I want to relate that motion to the motion before the House yesterday. In my view, as in the view of many other persons in the State, much the same speech could be made last night as could be made this evening on the motion that is at present before the House. The matter which concerned this House yesterday, and which again concerns the House to-day, deals with negotiations between this country and Britain in connection with the whole policy of this Government in its relations with the Government at the other side of the Channel.

We have been told that this Government got a mandate to abolish the Oath. It got a mandate to retain the land annuities in this country. Other speakers have already dealt with that particular aspect of the situation, but I am concerned primarily with the question of the mandate and it is rather a sorry spectacle to see in this House the Government represented by one person and that person the Minister for Lands and Fisheries. No other Minister of the Government is present except that one Minister, and there is no member of his Party behind him.

Comment on this

I beg to contradict the Deputy.

Comment on this

Oh, well there are two, I stand corrected.

Comment on this

Look at the Opposition.

Comment on this

It emphasises the fact that the Government take so little interest in the farmers of the country, in the agriculturalists and workers of the country that there are only two persons present—one Minister and one obscure back bencher. That is all that could be prevailed upon to attend. I was going to ask, on the matter of the land annuities and mandates, dealing as I am with a much wider matter, whether——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will be out of order in referring to mandates or to negotiations with England. Those matters where discussed yesterday and must be looked upon as closed now. The Deputy must deal with the matter before the House. He must confine himself to the matter of British tariffs on agricultural produce, and the need for a moratorium on land annuities.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling and I am proposing to address myself to this motion. The motion of Deputy Cosgrave suggests that the tariffs on Saorstát agricultural produce imposed on the farmers a burden at least equal to their land commission annuities, and that the Dáil is of opinion that the Executive Council should take appropriate steps to suspend the collection of the annuities during the period of the operation of the tariffs. I want to relate to that the effect on the cities and towns in the Saorstát of these British tariffs imposed on Saorstát agricultural produce. I have had contact, and still have contact, with agriculturalists in this country, and my experience goes to show that they are very much disappointed and seriously disgruntled with the action of the present Government in bringing about the state of affairs which inspired or urged Deputy Cosgrave to place this motion on the Order Paper this evening. We have got to ask ourselves one or two questions. The first question that I would put to the Government Party is this.

Comment on this

Including the undesirables?

Comment on this

I do not know who this vulgarian behind me is.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a term which should not be applied to any member of this House.

Comment on this

I withdraw it. We have some of them here, at any rate. They cannot even make an intelligent interruption. Will you get this vulgarian to sit down?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not repeat his offence.

Comment on this

If he cannot make an intelligent interruption he is a vulgarian in my opinion.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this

What is the point of order before I sit down?

Comment on this

I wish to state that the reference made to me by Deputy Anthony that I am a vulgarian——

Comment on this

I did not say "Bulgarian." I said "vulgarian." The Bulgarians are a cultured people I want to say.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not a point of order.

Comment on this

Deputy Anthony has also stated that in the Government Benches there have been undesirable representatives.

Comment on this

Surely that is not a point of order?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has ruled that it is not.

Comment on this

I am not called upon to make an explanation at all.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has been called on to deal with the motion before him. He might begin now.

Comment on this

I am prepared to deal with it, in spite of the Bulgarians and the vulgarians. How the British tariffs have affected the people of Cork City and Cork County is a question with which I think I am entitled to deal, under the terms of this motion and within the terms of this motion. What is our experience in Cork City and the Borough of Cork? Let me say for the information of some of those intellectuals—with a query mark after the word "intellectuals"—of the Government Party, that what I mean by the Borough of Cork is this. It embraces——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not proceed to give a detailed definition of what the Borough of Cork denotes or connotes.

Comment on this

I want to explain.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will discontinue his speech.

Comment on this

You do not give us time to sit down. You do not give anybody time except some of your own family.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must withdraw that remark.

Comment on this

I withdraw it, yes.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy would be in order in advocating a moratorium, explaining the need for it, or the effects of British tariffs on the prices of agricultural products, and the consequent burden on the farming community, but not on the citizens of the Borough of Cork.

Comment on this

I was proceeding to talk of the burden on the farmers. I wanted to inform the Ceann Comhairle that in my area there are many thousands of farmers, and because of the fact that it might not be known to the intelligentsia of the Fianna Fáil Party or the Government, I wanted to let them—not the Ceann Comhairle of course—understand that although I represent a city it is known as a county borough, which embraces numbers of farmers and agriculturists. These British tariffs, which are referred to in the motion of Deputy Cosgrave, have been termed "retaliatory tariffs" by many members of the Government Party when they spoke here yesterday, and, I understand, again to-day. I want to ask the House and I want to ask the Government, do they believe or did they for one moment think that it is their prerogative only to enforce tariffs against another country? Again I want to put it to any man in this House, who is even half a sportsman, does he believe that if one party in a fight hits out the other person is not entitled to hit back? This Government has only been in office some six or eight months, but the last Government were in office for some time, and during that period the last Government enforced tariffs against other countries. Surely we must admit, if we are sportsmen at all, that the other fellow was entitled to hit back. I always felt that way at any rate.

This present Government, when they came back to this House as a Government, said that they had a mandate to enforce certain things. I am rather sorry that the Labour Benches are empty to-night because I want to ask any member of the Labour Party did he get a mandate from his constituents to support tariffs which would in turn involve the other persons—by the other persons I mean the British Government—in imposing retaliatory tariffs on this country? It is about time, a Chinn Comhairle, that we stood up to the truth, faced the facts in the face, and faced the realities of the position. We have been told that the present Government sent over their President and other persons to negotiate in relation to the land annuities and other matters, but again I ask you what mandate had the Labour Party? Deputy Corish is now present. Did Deputy Corish get a mandate in Wexford in connection with the land annuities? Did he get a mandate in Wexford to abolish the Oath?

Comment on this

Look after Cork and do not mind Wexford.

Comment on this

Oh, no. I am very fair you know. I can look after Cork. Cork people acknowledge that I look after them very well. I am asking Deputy Corish a straight and honest question, which demands an affirmative or a negative answer. Yes or no? Did Deputy Corish, for instance, seek a mandate from his constituents in Wexford that he should, if he ever got into the Dáil, support any motion which suggested that the land annuities should be retained?

Is not that a fair question, Deputy Corish? Did you get that mandate? You did not, and I know you did not. No member of the Labour Party got that mandate. No member of the Labour Party even asked for that mandate but, on the contrary, they suggested, as I suggested, in every speech I made at any political meeting, that I would not do anything that would in any way upset anything we had got under the terms of the Treaty. I suggested in all my public speeches that I would not upset the Treaty position because I was aware of its advantages, and that we had the best and the widest franchise of any country in the world. Now our representatives went as negotiators——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has been told twice already that the negotiations are out of order on this motion. He has failed to come to the motion in fifteen minutes and will now resume his seat.

Comment on this

I want to suggest that I have not gone outside the terms of this motion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Ceann Comhairle definitely rules that the Deputy has not come within the terms of that motion during his quarter of an hour's speech and he must now resume his seat.

Comment on this

With all respect, I will resume my seat if you order me, but I respectfully suggest that you allow me to read the terms of this motion and show me then in what way I have gone outside the terms of the motion. I am entitled to that in any court of law—even in a British court of law.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will resume his seat.

Comment on this

Might I ask a question?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

I want to show, sir, that I have not gone outside the terms of this motion which reads:

"That as the British tariffs on Saorstát agricultural produce impose on farmers a burden at least equivalent to their Land Commission annuities the Dáil is of opinion that the Executive Council should take appropriate steps to suspend the collection of annuities during the period of the operation of these tariffs"

and I want to say if I am allowed that though you have paid——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must sit down.

Comment on this

My advice to the farmers is not to pay.

Comment on this