Proposed Suspension of Collection of Land Annuities.
Contributions 299–465 of 465. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Deputy Gorey knows perfectly well that there has been no interference with them. There are certain officials in charge of that particular matter. I had to make representations when I was a Deputy to the Land Commission when I was conversant with it and put it before those officials for investigation of it.
Reference has been made to the proposal that was indicated by the President with regard to the permanent reductions that were contemplated. Some Deputies have stated that that indicates that we visualise the tariff as being there in perpetuity. That is not the position which we visualise, but what we do visualise and have definitely made up our minds to is this: that the land annuities will not be paid over to Britain by this Government and that it is our duty as a Government to try to meet the farmers who are paying those annuities as best we can and give them what relief we can, having retained those annuities here. It has been stated that what we contemplate will be inadequate. I ask Deputies to bear in mind that out of £4,163,000 collected in annuities, the sum of £1,082,300 represents the annuities of people coming under the 1923 Act. Those annuities are not being paid over to Britain at any time. It would seem unfair and unjust that in any arrangement as to a permanent reduction of the annuities these people should be left out. It means that there is a sum of £1,082,300 involved which is not part of the disputed annuities and that money has got to be found, or the money necessary to give a reduction in those annuities has to be found, and Deputies should realise, and certainly those in the front bench realise, that a Government has not an Open Sesame and that there is a limit to its purse.
Comment on this
I understood from the President that he was not going to touch the 1923 cases—that the problems were insuperable.
Comment on this
That is not so. I am sure the President did not intend to convey that in any case, because that has not been the decision of the Council in the matter.
Comment on this
No. I think that what Deputy Norton wanted was to ascertain or to find out about particular cases of what I have already mentioned and the President stated that there would be many difficulties in the way of finding out the particulars of these cases. One would be that you would really want a revaluation in this country which would take five or six years, and you could not give a definite statement on the matter. So far as possible, and so far as it can be done, particular cases of hardship, or cases which seem unfair, will have to be dealt with in the best way possible.
The proposals that are indicated to reduce the payments are, I submit to the House, much more favourable than the proposals embodied in Deputy Cosgrave's motion. I cannot see why Deputy Cosgrave wants to put forward a motion and to press it to a division in this House, the terms of which are less favourable to the tenant farmers in this country than the proposals indicated by the President here to-day. I do not think that there will be anybody, or at least any of the tenant farmers of this country, misled or fooled by that position. We propose the permanent reduction of the annuities, the funding if you like of the instalments for November and December and May and June over a period at 4½ per cent. That period will not be less than that to which the present annuities are yet to run. A Deputy asked does it include principal and interest and I say it does. These proposals should commend themselves to the House. They are an effort to give the benefits of those moneys retained here, so far as the State can give that benefit, to the tenant farmers of this country. References have been made to the conditions prevailing with regard to markets and so on. I am sure Deputy Cosgrave will agree that even if he were in office and on terms of amity with the British Government he would probably have an appeal from the British Government to reduce exports to Great Britain.
Comment on this
The British Government have appealed to other members of the Commonwealth to reduce their exports. Is it contended by the Opposition that the agricultural conditions in England are so favourable that were it not for this 40 per cent. tariff being imposed, we would have as good conditions here as last year and that the same prices would obtain?
Comment on this
That is the difficulty one has. A number of Deputies on the opposite Benches, I am sure, know people who have farms in England as well as here. I have met a certain number of them who have fairly extensive farms in England. I am sure Deputy Hogan knows a number. They will tell you that they cannot dispose of their stock over there, which had not been tainted by having come from the Free State, conditions are so bad. If conditions are bad there, are not they, to a large extent, apart from the 40 per cent tariff, largely responsible for the conditions here? We are trying now to deal with the position as we have found it, and what we have done, and are doing, is certainly the farthest we can go to meet the difficulty.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that the percentage reduction in the tenant farmers' annuities has not yet been decided upon. Assuming, for the sake of argument, that it is a 75 per cent. reduction, on whom is the burden going to fall of finding that shortage in the future?
Comment on this
I can give no indication until this question, which is a rather difficult one, has been examined fully. The Land Commission have been examining it for some time and various figures have been taken with a view to seeing what this would cost. The Deputy cannot assume, however, that it will be 75 per cent. or anything else. There is no such figure in mind. No particular figure has been taken into consideration at all. As to where it will come from, it will mainly come from the moneys retained from the British Government.
Comment on this
The Deputy who asked the question can take it that, whether the reduction is 75 or 25 per cent. the money will come from where the bounties are coming from—taxation. I only hope that the reduction in the annuities will be more valuable to the farmers than the bounties have been. I was glad to hear the Minister pay the tribute which he has paid to the integrity of the officials in the Land Commission. While I have been in the House, at no time were accusations of partiality made against officials of the Land Commission or any other Department except those which came from the Minister's own Benches.
Comment on this
From my experience I can say that I believe the administration of the Land Commission was in the past and is to-day absolutely fair and impartial. The President in his speech to-day covered a very wide field. As a matter of fact, I think the President's speech would have been a better speech on the motion before the House yesterday than the one he made. It certainly covered more ground. The President dealt with a number of matters with which I had intended to deal. I am sure Deputies will be glad that they have already been dealt with, and that they will be spared listening to me on these matters. I want, however, to reiterate and emphasise this point arising out of the President's speech, when he stated that there is an obligation and a contract on the part of the farmers to pay the annuities to this State. I am not going to go into the very fine points of that, but I want to put this in a commonsense way, which, I think, will be understood by every Deputy and by every farmer: that if you do not owe money to the person who lent it to you, you certainly do not owe it to anybody else. If there is no moral or legal obligation upon me to repay money to a person who has lent me money, then I cannot conceive how there could be either a moral or a legal obligation upon me to repay it to a person who did not lend me the money. Whether it was the British Government or the bondholders, or the bondholders and the British Government lent the money, one thing is quite clear, that the Free State, whether headed by Deputy Cosgrave or President de Valera, did not lend any of it. I agree with the President that the farmer is under an obligation to pay for his land. I, personally, during the last election, in my own county warned the farmers that the only title they had to the land was the fact that they were paying for it, and that if they did not continue to pay for it the man working in the City of Dublin or Cork or in any provincial town or village had as much claim to the land as they had.
Comment on this
There is no question about a grabber at all. The only title any farmer has to his land to-day is that he is paying for it. If he does not pay for it, he has no more title to it than I have; and I have as much claim to it as he has. Coming back to the main point, I say again that if he does not owe the money to the British Government or to the land stock-holder he does not owe it to the Free State. If the President is prepared to admit that, and to admit that he must introduce legislation to make the money payable to the Free State, then we know where we are. But, without that legislation, he has, I submit with all respect, no authority to collect the money.
The President told us that the Government had taken measures to meet the losses sustained by the farmers. He was careful to say that he was not going to submit that the measures taken had met all the losses which the farmers have sustained for some months past. He said, however, that measures had been taken by the Government which very largely, if not altogether, met these losses. Does any farmer, businessman, or Deputy, either of the Fianna Fáil, Cumann na nGaedheal, or any other Party, believe that statement?
Comment on this
Does anybody believe for one moment that 5 per cent. of the money paid out by way of bounty by the State has found its way into the farmers' pockets? I put it to Fianna Fáil and Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies that not 5 per cent has found its way into the farmers' pockets. Can the Minister for Agriculture tell me how much of the bounty in respect of farmers' butter has found its way into the farmers' pockets?
Comment on this
I say they have not got it. There is very little use in the President or the Minister for Agriculture or the Minister for Lands and Fisheries telling us that the measures they have taken to relieve the farmers have been sufficient to offset any losses. They have not been sufficient —far from it. I might say that the efforts to relieve farmers in this respect are about as successful as the efforts made by the Government since June last to meet the problem of unemployment. The President said that the Opposition were taught sense at the last election. There is one thing I am quite certain of, in view of what has happened since the last election, and that is that the members of this Government were not taught sense at the last election. Let us hope that we are not far from the next election.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance should not talk about my hopes of an early election. The Minister did his best, or his worst, at the last election in Tipperary, and most of the other Ministers as well. All I have to say is that were it not for the assistance given me by the Minister for Finance, the President, Senator Connolly and a few others, I would not be in this House to-day. The people of Tipperary, being on the whole a fairly sensible people——
Comment on this
——listened to the Minister for Finance and then said to themselves: "Well, if Morrissey is worthy of all the abuse that he has got from this gentleman, then he will be a very worthy representative of ours in the Dáil." I do not want to say much about the Minister for Finance. The Minister said more than enough about himself last night and I think we will leave it at that. I am quite prepared to agree with the Minister for Lands and Fisheries that the present Government is not altogether responsible for the fall in prices. I will not suggest that if there had not been a change of Government there would not have been a fall in prices. I am prepared to go further than many Deputies and I will say that the only difference between this Government and the last Government, or for that matter any other sane Government, is a difference of 40 per cent. But that is a very material difference.
The President this afternoon made great play with some speeches made by either Deputy Hogan or Deputy Blythe in reference to £2 a head on cattle. He scoffed at that. I had the temerity to suggest that to-day it is nearer to £6 a head and the President was amazed. If the President will consult some of the practical farmers amongst his own Party who had to sell cattle within the last month or two at any Irish fair, or had to sell pigs or sheep, they will be able to enlighten him. Three years ago I listened here to Deputy Gorey abusing—and I need not tell the House that when Deputy Gorey starts on that line he can do it fairly well—his own Party and asking how could farmers produce beef at 38/- per cwt. I ask the present Government, and incidentally Deputy Gorey, how can farmers to-day produce beef at 15/- to 18/- and 19/- per cwt. and produce pigs from 16/- to £1 per cwt.? The Minister knows that that is exactly the position.
If this senseless war had not started, whatever the fall in prices may or may not have been—and certainly there would have been a fall—the great thing, as the Minister knows, is that we would be able to sell our stock, we would have retained our market and we could look forward to some hope of an improvement in that market. At the present time we cannot do that. What is making people really despair is not the actual position at the moment but the fact that nobody can say whether this position is going to last for one, two or six months.
Comment on this
Nobody can say now, as one could say in the case of ordinary slumps or ordinary times of depression, that we can carry on and hope for better times and an improvement in the market in six or nine months' time. What the people are really faced with is whether they will have any market in six or nine months' time. The Fianna Fáil Party cannot deny that for the last five or six years they have been preaching to the people that we should not be dependent on the British market. I have heard over and over again, in this House and outside, the present Minister for Industry and Commerce preaching that there was no reason whatever why we should depend on the British market; that there were several alternative markets, and that we could sell our stuff in any part of Europe. Then the President, when he has got the people to vote himself and his Party not into power but into office, says there is no alternative market. The Minister for Lands and Fisheries talked about the financial settlements that were made in 1925 and 1926. He quoted Deputy McMenamin. I have no fault to find with the Minister because he quoted the Deputy; I think he was quite right.
The Minister for Finance, last night, worked himself into a fever heat, with one eye on the Speaker and the other on the gallery, about the traitors and the perfidy and the way in which this country had been sold from 1923 to 1927. He talked about less than half of the elected representatives of the people voting it away here. I wonder how did some of my late colleagues like that statement? First and foremost, it is absolutely incorrect. There were at least two-thirds, if not more, of the elected representatives of the people sitting in this House. The fact is that for anything which happened from 1922 to 1927 the present Government Party are as much responsible as the late Government Party, because if they had been in this House it would not have happened. I have heard the President, the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Lands and Fisheries talking about what happened in 1925 and 1926 when Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Blythe came back with the Ultimate Financial Settlement and other agreements.
I would like to ask the President, the Minister for Finance, and the Minister for Lands and Fisheries do they remember the members of the Labour Party, certain members of the then Cumann na nGaedheal Party, and certain members of the then Farmers Party going on their knees to the then united Sinn Féin Party at the famous Shelbourne Hotel Conference, and asking them for God's sake to come into this House to prevent the House ratifying the annual tribute to England —the tribute that we have all the talk about now? Some of us, at the request of Senator, then Deputy, Johnson, Deputy Baxter, Deputy O'Maille and Deputy Magennis, went to the Shelbourne Hotel Conference. We met the whole of the then united Sinn Féin Party and the matter was put up to them there and discussed for three hours. It was definitely put to them that if they had the interests of the country at heart they should come here and take the Oath and vote against the proposal. It was put up to them, as they said themselves, that if this agreement were to be sanctioned by the Dáil, it meant permanent partition for Ireland. We said, "Very well; come into the Dáil, because with your vote and the votes of some members who are prepared to leave the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, we can beat them on it." They said "No." The only excuse given— I made this clear before, and I defy any member of the opposite Party or any member of the Labour Party to deny it—as to why they could not come into this House and save us from the annual tribute of 5½ million pounds and permanent partition was that they could not take the Oath.
In two years afterwards, when the late Government, using their majority, passed a special Bill through this House to secure that candidates for the Dáil should be compelled to take the Oath, not before they entered the Dáil but before they could be nominated for membership of it, the majority of the members—I want to be fair; not all the members were concerned, because there had been a split in the Party in the meantime—whom we met at the Shelbourne Hotel Conference, in 1925, came in and took the Oath, which they described as "a mere empty formula." My reply to the statements they have made to-day, and to the statements that they have been making for the past four years, is that for the sake of a mere empty formula they were not prepared in 1925 to come into this House and save the State from the burden of 5½ million pounds and permanent partition.
Mr. Hogan (Galway) rose.
Comment on this
I understood that Deputy Cosgrave is to wind up this debate. Are we to take it now that Deputy Hogan is going to wind up the debate?
Comment on this
I am not winding up. You had all the evening to talk.
Comment on this
Unless there is some agreement between the Whips, the Chair has no authority to bring the debate to a close.
Comment on this
The Chair has no authority to bring the debate to a conclusion unless there is agreement between the Parties.
Comment on this
There is an arrangement whereby a decision is to be taken to-night. I want to know whether Deputy Hogan is now concluding, in view of that fact.
Comment on this
I think I should have some protection against the disorderly conduct of certain Deputies. Am I or am I not entitled to put a question to you, a Leas-Chinn Comhairle, as to whether there is such an arrangement?
Comment on this
Every Deputy will get the protection of the Chair in so far as the Chair is upheld by the House in affording that protection.
Comment on this
The Minister could have spoken during the evening instead of other Deputies from his side whose contributions were not very valuable. I shall not keep him very long, in any event. The Minister for Lands and Fisheries stated that he never advised farmers not to pay their land annuities. He said that in a most specific way and challenged contradiction. I have in my hand a paper of the Seventh Year of the Republic. For the benefit of Deputies who do not know what that year is, I may say that it is 1922, and the date is 13th December. I read from that paper an extract:—
Now, therefore, all citizens of the Republic are hereby enjoined to refuse payment of income tax, Land Commission annuities, annuities or other rents or payments to the Congested Districts Board.
Underneath in the Irish language— though I believe it is not good Irish— is the name "Pádraic O Ruitleis." That is the Minister who denied most explicitly that he ever advised the farmers not to pay their land purchase annuities. His advice was taken.
The Minister said also that the collection position was bad even up to the date on which the Fianna Fáil Government took over. That is not so. The House will remember the figures which were quoted. There was an average of about £400,000 arrears each year, which went down in 1930-31 to something like £300,000. That was an extraordinarily good collection, and it is an extraordinary tribute to the farmers of this country. Deputies should understand the significance of those figures. There was in arrear £300,000 in 1922. In 1924, the figure was £350,000, and in 1925, 1926, 1927 and 1928, £400,000. What does that mean? It means, in fact, that practically all the annuities were paid within the year, though some of them might be late. The people who owed £400,000 in 1925 had paid before 1926. Otherwise there would have been £800,000 due. The same people had paid again before 1927. Otherwise, there would have been £1,200,000 due. The figures reveal that there was a hanging gale, or something like a hanging gale of £400,000. But it was only a hanging gale. That is an extraordinary tribute, to my mind, to the Irish farmers, when you remember that during the Civil War they were told not to pay the annuities. In fact, they were warned not to pay them or they would suffer the penalties that a traitor should suffer. That campaign died down and, in 1926, Deputy de Valera started his land annuities campaign. In that, he followed Peadar O'Donnell, the well-known "Bolshie." He thought it was a good political line and he took it up. I said before and I say again that the worst day's work that was ever done for this country was done when the Fianna Fáil Party started to throw doubt on the obligation of the farmer to pay his annuity and the right of the stockholder to get it. I said on many platforms, and I repeat now, that it was the first time in the history of this country that Irish nationalism was defined in terms of sharp practice. Apart from that, the difficulties that that campaign begat and that are evident even to-day will be more and more evident as time goes on. It is evident that the President has already seen some of them. He pointed out the difference between the farmer who purchased under the 1923 Act and the farmer who purchased under previous Acts.
Yes, but we all saw these difficulties that time, and pointed out that if annuities were not paid land purchase would become impossible. President de Valera himself pointed out that to-day. Why did they not do that in 1926? The Government Party have got away with a lot and, mind you, propaganda is very powerful. But there is one thing they cannot succeed in getting away with. There can be no doubt whatever that, under the ægis of the man who sits in the President's chair here to-day, the Party opposite went round the country and for purely political reasons they told the farmers not to pay their annuities.
Comment on this
What is the use of that? Why, I listened to them myself, time after time, telling the farmers not to pay their annuities.
Comment on this
I did not go to Dublin meetings. Just a while ago the Minister for Lands and Fisheries said that the annuities payable under the Acts previous to 1923 were £3,000,000 and that the annuities payable under the 1923 Act were £1,000,000. And he proceeded to draw a distinction. This statement was made by the Minister for Lands and Fisheries:—that the 1923 annuitants' money is not payable to the British Government. What is the inference? That the money due under the previous Acts is. How can we, in debating a question like this, arrive at any reasonable conclusion or even agree to differ in any decent sort of fashion, if the whole basis on which the discussion proceeds is false? The Minister for Lands and Fisheries knows perfectly well that the moneys paid by the tenants under the Acts previous to 1923 are no more paid to the British than are the moneys payable by the tenants who bought under the 1923 Act. His own analogy makes the point clear. The Minister knows perfectly well that the money paid by the tenant under the 1903 and 1909 Acts goes, and always went, towards the service of the land stock issued previous to 1923. He knows perfectly well that the holders of that land stock, while they to a great extent live in England, yet some of them live in Ireland. Equally he knows perfectly well, and in exactly the same way, that under the 1923 as well as the earlier Land Purchase Acts there is a guarantee given by the British Government. There is a guarantee given by the British Government for the 1923 Act securing that the moneys will be paid to the holders of stock issued under the Irish or English Government. That guarantee is given to the holders of the 1923 land stock, some of whom live in Ireland. Really the arguments used on the opposite benches apply with just as great force to the money paid by the tenants under the Land Act of 1923 and the guarantee is the same as that given to the stockholders who hold land stock issued under the previous Land Purchase Acts. There are plenty of the holders of the 1923 stock in Great Britain.
All this debate for propaganda purposes is on the basis of false suggestion, false inferences, half statements and half truths by the Government Party, and it had to be, because the long and the short of it is that this campaign about the land annuities was adopted and inserted in the programme of the Fianna Fáil Party for one reason only. It was considered, and rightly considered, to be good politics. And I pay a high tribute to the farmers of this country who withstood that campaign so long. It took extremely bad times before a certain proportion of the farming community fell for that campaign of falsehood.
Now that their point of view is accepted and that the Fianna Fáil Party have got power they have got to find some respectable, good and meritorious reasons to defend the programme which was taken up by them for purely political reasons. But look at the position to which they are reduced. Even again you have statements about this so-called secret agreement. I have been, unfortunately, over ten years in politics, and I have come to realise that there is a lot of parrot talk; that political exigencies will force a man to make certain statements. I put it to the Independents and the members of other Parties who have only recently come into politics, what would they think of the point that, in face of what has occurred even recently in the Dáil, some Deputies and even Ministers will insist on still calling this a secret agreement? In view of the fact that the Minister for Finance last night said it was only published in an obscure corner of the paper the agreement is still called a secret agreement! The Minister for Finance said that last night. The Minister himself admitted that we agreed to pay this money; that the money was, in fact, voted by the Dáil; that the payment was commented on by the leaders of the Labour Party and the Farmers' Party in the Dáil and was passed in an Appropriation Act. All that is admitted, and still the Minister for Finance will get up and say that agreement was a secret agreement and that it was kept from the Irish people.
Comment on this
To me it is a peculiar and astonishing thing. In every village in Ireland—and I have addressed meetings in every village in Ireland— and when it was highly unpopular to do so, I said in answer to the then Opposition speakers from the time this question was first raised, that we should pay it. My theme was that we made an agreement to pay that money to the stockholders and that we should honour that agreement. And that was a secret agreement!! We are told that no one in the country up to 1931 knew that we were paying that money over to England. The Minister for Lands and Fisheries said we were doing that secretly. He and other Ministers and Deputies have said so. Definitely, in spite of it all, our policy in paying that money which was secret since 1926 is most extraordinary.
But what happened? President Cosgrave announced in the Dáil in 1923 that a Provisional Agreement had been arrived at. That Provisional Agreement was made, and as a result of that Provisional Agreement we were paying annually three millions of money to the British Treasury. We asked the Dáil to ratify that bargain and we put it in the Appropriation Act. Deputy Johnson, the then leader of the Labour Party, and Deputy Wilson, the then leader of the Farmers' Party, spoke on that agreement. What did they say? What was their concern? Their only concern was to ensure that not more than the annuities was being sent to England!! That concern may be relevant or irrelevant, but it makes one realise that all the Parties then present in the Dáil adverted to the fact that that money was being paid to the British Government for the purpose of having it transferred to the stockholders.
Yet, in spite of that happening in the Dáil debates in 1923, in spite of the fact that the payments came before the Public Accounts Committee in every year up to 1926, that they were commented on there, this agreement, we are still told, was secret. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle knows how throughout they were commented on by the Public Accounts Committee, which contained representatives from every Party in the House. The Chairman of the Committee was leader of the Opposition in the Dáil. Nevertheless we are told the agreement was secret. In face of that how can we have any decision or any honest decision that will result in any permanent good to the country if we, in debating this serious question which has landed the country in so much trouble, go on in an entirely irresponsible and in an entirely cynical fashion?
I want to forget the fact that this campaign started in 1926, and that many an honest man was made a rogue by it, and that many an honest man was made a bankrupt by it. I know perfectly well that in 1926, 1927 and in 1928, people did get into arrears. In a great number of cases they were people who were able to pay. But men who are well able to pay their December annuities listened to the Fianna Fáil orators who said to them "do not pay; you will embarrass the Government by not paying and when Fianna Fáil gets in they will not ask you to pay." That happened in December and the man did not pay. On the following May he did not pay either, and neither did he pay on the following December. The man was then insolvent. That has been the fate of a great many farmers in this country. Well, forget that. Here we are now with an economic war, and Deputy Cosgrave has moved this particular motion. It is that while the economic war lasts the farmers shall not be asked to pay their land purchase annuities. I do not propose to waste the time of the Dáil on the point made by the Minister for Lands and Fisheries when he said that Deputy Cosgrave's motion in fact suggests that we are to cease paying but to collect the arrears afterwards. What is one to say about that? The Minister is not entirely without ears and brains, and every Deputy in this House knows that Deputy Cosgrave justified his motion on this basis, that the farmer should not be asked to pay more than once; that the farmer should only be asked to pay once, and that paying once was all any Irishman should be asked to do.
The standards seem to me to be up-side down in this country. A year ago or two years ago, according to the Deputies sitting on the opposite benches, the farmers should not pay once. They told them at every cross-roads not to pay once. Now apparently that is bad morals, that the farmers should not pay once. That is all humbug—political cant. That is our way of being exaggeratedly moral when we want to be. He is an honest man who pays once, and that is all we are entitled to ask of any man. It would be a good day for this country if paying once were preached by every Party in it. The basis of Deputy Cosgrave's motion is that farmers have already paid the British Government at least once, and that as long as they are paying once they should not be asked to pay twice. Now I think that that proposition would be regarded as speaking for itself in any other assembly in the world, but owing to the subtleties of our Irish philosophy, as it flourishes in the benches opposite, they cannot see the difference between our attitude before when we said the farmers should pay once and our present attitude when we say the farmers should not pay twice. They cannot see it, but I think the country will see it, and I think our attitude is perfectly sound.
In answer to the Minister for Lands and Fisheries, I just want to make this point, that it may be—when the accounts come to be made up—it will be found that the stockholders have not got the whole of their annuities. I think then it will be for this country to consider very seriously how the whole of their annuities should be paid. From that point of view, one thing is quite certain, and that is that the farmers should not be asked to pay them. I am not one of those who pretend that the present depression, the present shocking state of our agriculture and our industry, is entirely due to the tariffs imposed by the British, or even to the muddling of the present Government. We all know that prices have fallen lamentably. Our case is this, that the time when prices have fallen, have collapsed and gone extremely bad, is not the time to make them 30 per cent. or 40 per cent. worse. That would be regarded as a truism in any country in the world, but it cannot be seen by the members on the opposite benches. Let us say that is what this Government and the British Government between them have succeeded in doing. I put this to the Deputies. There are some of them from the country. The farmers paid their annuities in 1930-31 in spite of all the campaign. A big bulk of them paid them. With the fall in prices that has come about it would put them to the pin of their collar to pay now. Personally, I may say that the experience I have had for the last six months, during which time every working man of the country has been denuded of money by taxation, and every workingman's market has been dislocated, surprises me. I did not believe there were such reserves in this country. There were big reserves in this country undoubtedly. This country was, comparatively, in a very strong position at the beginning of this year, in an extremely strong position to stand the world collapse that has come this year, and I do say that it was—well, to some extent. I will put it—due to the wise financial policy of the last Government. The last six months have shown that the country was undoubtedly in a very strong position. There were great reserves amongst the agricultural community, and especially amongst the small farmers of the country. There were great reserves; they are now being taken and ruthlessly wasted, but they were there. Even if there were no taxation, even if you had not this 30 per cent. tariff, even if we had to face only the collapse in world prices, nevertheless in this year the farmers would have been put to the pin of their collars to pay those annuities, but most of them would have done it.
Do the Deputies on the opposite benches really believe they can do it when you have a complete dislocation of the market—admittedly now the only market they have for half their total production? Is there a Deputy from a country constituency in the opposite benches who will say to me now that in that state of affairs a big proportion of the farmers could pay their annuities? Would they agree with me that a very big proportion could not, with the best will in the world, when you add that dislocation to the collapse of world prices? I do not think there is any Deputy in the country who would not go this far, that it would be extremely difficult for them. I consider that the members on these benches are in a strong position in that regard. We have always stood for the payment of land annuities, but now that the farmers have paid their land annuities not only once but much more should they be asked to pay again? The Minister for Agriculture told us the other day that the farmer is losing only 1/- in the price of cattle. Surely that is nonsense? First of all they are losing 20 per cent. up to the present, and, even if they were getting the bounty, who pays it? Does the Minister think that that bounty of 12 per cent. is 12 per cent. to the farmers, even if they were getting the whole of it? What amount of the money comes out of their own production?
Comment on this
From their own production of course. I have not denied that. The Minister makes a set off of the bounty. What is your set off worth— even if the farmer, which I deny, was getting every penny of the bounty? The fact of the matter is that whether the farmer gets the bounty or not he pays the full 20 per cent. What does 20 per cent. mean? The President told us the other day that the annuities amounted to two and a half times our total butter exports. I have not looked at the figure recently, but in my time, when the industry was flourishing, our exports of butter and milk products amounted to close on £5,000,000.
Comment on this
Our exports of milk products in any normal year amounted to close on £5,000,000; our exports of cattle and live-stock to £12,000,000, and our total agricultural exports to round about £30,000,000. Twenty per cent. of that is not a difficult sum to calculate. You do not require to be a mathematician to calculate it at £6,000,000. I ask the Deputies on the opposite benches to remember that. That is not the total loss by any means which the Irish farmer suffers. He loses twenty per cent., not only on his exports but twenty per cent. on all the agricultural produce that is sold in the country. That is twenty per cent., not on £30,000,000 but on £50,000,000, and the loss to the farmers up to the present on that head alone cannot be much short of £10,000,000. When you add to that the dislocation of trade and the loss of goodwill it is very hard to compute what the farmers have lost this year in hard cash. They have certainly lost twice their Land Commission annuities. While they have lost twice their Land Commission annuities and while paying their Land Commission annuities in tariffs, they should not be asked to pay again. The fact is that they cannot pay again.
Now, the President announced that he had a plan of his own. It seemed to me it came out very hurriedly, and it was obviously not carefully thought out. It seemed to me the sequence was something like this. The men on the opposite benches said: "This is good politics. Cosgrave must not be allowed to get away with this. You must chip in." He chipped in and promised something which was very badly considered. I do not care twopence whether this is good politics or not. I know in the interests of the country as a whole it was a bad day that Deputy Cosgrave found it necessary to make the suggestion, and it was a worse day that President de Valera found it necessary to reply as he replied. I want the Dáil to examine his proposal. It quite clearly envisages the continuance of the economic struggle. I have shown that any continuance of the economic war between England and Ireland will involve us in very much greater losses. There is only one sound basis for remission of the annuities to the Irish farmer, and that is that the people to whom they owe the annuities should forgive them. That is the only sound basis. Note that Deputy Cosgrave's motion is that these annuities should be remitted only while the economic war lasts, and while the British are collecting these annuities by tariffs. As I have said already, it may be that even during that period accounts will have to be made up, so as to ensure that the stock-holder shall get the difference between what was collected and what is due to him. In any event, that is Deputy Cosgrave's motion. It goes no further than that.
With regard to future land purchase annuities, personally I regret that it should come to this, that relief to farmers should, under any circumstances, take the form of relief in the annuities. But we have been landed into this position now, and it is perfectly obvious there is no use closing our eyes to it, that the farmers themselves thought to expect relief in their annuities. i have only one comment to make on that. There is only one body who can make relief, and these are the people to whom they owe the annuities, and it is perfectly clear to me that that body would give them relief in consideration of the British Government taking over liability for a certain portion of the debt. When that time comes there is no doubt that the farmers will expect and get whatever remission is got as a result of negotiation with England, but relief in that direction in regard to the annuities is the only relief that can be permanent. It is no use for you talking at the present moment of relief in regard to the future annuities. You are not entitled to talk about that. It was by question this was raised. I have made my comment on it, and that is, if the English Government, as I believe they would, would take a certain proportion of the annuities, the farmers are entitled to relief. For the present situation, the farmer is not to blame and the Opposition is not to blame. The Irish farmer is paying his annuities directly, and indirectly, more than twice, and while that lasts the Irish farmer should not be asked to pay them to the Irish Government. In saying that, I want to make this point final and clear, that whatever about our struggles here, whatever our politics may be, whatever the position of the Irish farmer may be, or whatever concessions he may get from the British Government, it is absolutely vital in the interests of the good name and of the financial standing and progress of this country, that stockholders, who loaned the money, should not lose one single penny.
Comment on this
I do not know whether Deputy MacEoin wants to give a display of buffoonery. A Leas-Chinn Comhairle, is it permissible to display posters here?
Comment on this
We had a very interesting dissertation at the beginning of Deputy Hogan's speech, in which, among other things, he referred to the debate arising out of this motion as being a debate for propaganda purposes, a debate, in the words of Deputy Hogan, based upon half truths. Half truths for the most part, half-truths— the most mendacious and misleading form of false hood—on the part of most people, but on the part of Deputy Hogan full and complete untruths, as for instance, when he described this Party as having advocated at every cross-roads the non-payment of his annuities by the tenant purchaser to the Irish Free State Exchequer. Deputy Hogan said he heard speakers on the Fianna Fáil Benches advocating that policy. He could not name one.
Comment on this
When was he a Deputy of the Fianna Fáil Party? This is only another instance of the muddle-headedness of members on the Opposition Benches. Deputy Hogan was a member of an Administration that had a fairly efficient secret service in this country. On many occasions, Deputy Hogan produced intercepted documents in this Dáil and read them. I am perfectly certain there was not an agenda before the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis during the last four years which did not come before Deputy Hogan's notice, as Minister for Agriculture, or at least, before the notice of the late Executive Council. Ever since these land annuities became the burning issue, one of the proposals which was often submitted to the Ard-Fheis and rejected categorically by the Executive of Fianna Fáil, by the leaders of what, at that time, was the Opposition Party in this House, were proposals for the cessation of the payment of the annuities by the Irish farmers. I am sure Deputy Hogan was perfectly well aware of that, as was every colleague of his on the Executive Council, when he got up here and said that Fianna Fáil, during the last two years at every cross-roads, had advised the Irish farmers not to pay their annuities. We did not advise them not to pay their annuities. We told them, if they elected us, that so far as we could see to it when times were normal they would pay the land annuities, but that we would not pay those land annuities over to Great Britain. So much for one complete untruth uttered in this debate by Deputy Hogan.
When is an agreement not a secret agreement? According to Deputy Hogan it is not a secret agreement when it is marked "secret." According to Deputy Hogan it is not a secret agreement when Deputy Hogan, as Minister for Agriculture, writes to Deputy Blythe, as Minister for Finance, and calls his attention to the fact that this agreement is marked "secret" and that it would be advisable to obtain the consent of the British Government to its publication. It is not a secret agreement when the British Government, in order to defend a case before the British courts, writes to the Irish Government and asks them to permit this agreement to be produced in an English court of law.
And when after considerable and prolonged correspondence the Minister for Finance or the Department of Finance writes back to the corresponding British Department and says "Yes. We will allow you to produce the agreement in your court of law; we will allow you to publish this agreement which up to this has been marked secret and has been regarded as confidential provided you paste over Part I of the agreement which includes this provision:
‘The Free State Government undertake to pay at agreed intervals to the appropriate fund the full amount of the annuities accruing due from time to time, making themselves responsible for the actual collection from the tenant purchaser,'"
Of course it is not a secret agreement! It cannot possibly be a secret agreement because if it is going to be published at all it is going to be published with that passage pasted over! Deputy Hogan says it is not a secret agreement. It is not a secret agreement when once more the British Government asked to be permitted to publish it and the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Blythe, replies to the British Government and states that he cannot permit it to be published because it would be "politically inadvisable" to publish this instrument which Deputy Hogan has declared was not a secret agreement.
I am rather sorry Deputy Hogan has left the House because, on the 22nd July last he stated: "I am going to explain now why that agreement was marked secret." But I think after the speech which he made to-night, at least it is up to him to tell us why that agreement was marked secret if it was not a secret agreement —why it was that Deputy Blythe, the then Minister for Finance, would not permit Deputy Hogan to publish that agreement if it was not a secret agreement, and why Deputy Blythe as Minister for Finance considered it politically inadvisable to publish that agreement if it was not a secret agreement. Neither when he was speaking on the 22nd July nor when he was speaking in the House to-night did Deputy Hogan tell us why the agreement was marked secret if it was not in fact a secret agreement.
I was dealing with the half truths and the full and complete untruths. I want in that connection, though I think it is scarcely worth while in any other connection, to refer to the speech which Deputy Morrissey made. Deputy Morrissey said that we could not come into this House some time in 1925 to protest against this tribute. I do not know whether or not Deputy Morrissey knew what he was talking about, whether that statement of his was wilfully designed to mislead the House or whether it was due either to lack of intelligence or deficiency of memory —probably both—because when that conference to which he referred was arranged at the Shelbourne Hotel, it was arranged in December of 1925. If my memory does not mislead me it was arranged for the 11th or 12th December, 1925. It was arranged then to protest against what all Nationalists referred to as, and what all Nationalists believed was, the Boundary betrayal, in which the then President had such a significant part. But the agreement which said these annuities——
Comment on this
It is usual to give half-an-hour to the mover of a motion such as this to reply. That was understood to be the case in this instance. I understood that I was to reply at 10 o'clock. I have given the Minister five minutes after that time.
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that the Chair has no power to enforce an agreement of that kind, but I recognise that that has been the practice.
Comment on this
We started this debate soon after three o'clock, and the benches opposite were practically empty for several hours afterwards. For the last hour or two, three or four Ministers have come into the House. One has spoken, and another wants to speak now. This is certainly an attempt to endeavour to crush out a reply. It was understood that there was to be a reply. There were questions asked by the President and the Minister for Lands and Fisheries. Do they want replies to them?
Comment on this
He had a right to come in earlier. I want to know if there is any proposal to allow——
Comment on this
I had nothing to do with that; I am concerned with the ordinary decencies of debate. I want to know if the practice recognised since this Parliament was first established is now to be turned down.
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that the Chair has no power to closure discussion. It is for the House to make any arrangement it wishes.
Comment on this
I would remind the Ceann Comhairle that last night on another motion I was to reply at 10 o'clock. I waived five minutes of that time. That will be within the recollection of the Ceann Comhairle. It has been the invariable rule to allow sufficient time to reply on a motion of this kind.
Comment on this
The Deputy is right in stating that time is usually allowed to the mover of a motion such as this to conclude but the Chair has no power to enforce the practice.
Comment on this
May I point out that I spoke only for about twenty minutes in introducing the motion? The President of the Executive Council replied in approximately thirty or thirty-five minutes. I have not wasted any time.
Comment on this
I should like to understand from the Minister whether he is going to speak for the rest of the evening?
Comment on this
Is there not a Standing Order that the mover of a motion such as this has a right of reply?
Comment on this
That was not carried out when this Party was in opposition. I submit that if Deputy Cosgrave wanted to reply, Deputy Hogan had a right to give him time to reply.
Comment on this
The mover of the motion has a right to conclude the debate. Whether that be to-night or to-morrow I cannot say.
Comment on this
As a Deputy representing an agricultural constituency, I say that I have a right to speak on this motion and I have not got an opportunity of doing so. I enter my emphatic protest against action of this sort. I want to state that this motion affects us directly.
Comment on this
There was no chance given me to speak to-day. I claim I have a right to speak as a representative of an agricultural constituency.
Comment on this
I am not disorderly. I am making a protest against the disorderly action of the Minister.
Comment on this
This debate was on a private Deputy's motion in Government time. An understanding was, I understood, come to, to conclude to-night.
Comment on this
There has been an invariable rule of allowing time to the mover of the motion to reply.
Comment on this
There was no understanding that Deputy Cosgrave would be permitted the rest of the time after 10 o'clock to conclude the debate.
Comment on this
On a point of order. First of all, for the last hour, as far I can see, we have been discussing some secret agreement and a meeting at the Shelbourne Hotel. I hold that that has no relation to the matter before the House. Secondly, as one of those who represent the farmers, I want to speak in this debate, and I have been six times on my feet and did not get an opportunity of speaking. I would misrepresent my constituency if I allowed this opportunity to pass without raising my voice in the debate. I ask, therefore, that another hour be given to the debate to-morrow if necessary. It can be carried over to to-morrow and a further hour given for the discussion.
Comment on this
If Deputy Cosgrave will agree to let the Minister for Finance continue his speech, then he will get time to-morrow to reply.
Comment on this
Will other Deputies get time to speak to-morrow? I have been in the House all day and I was eight times on my feet.
Comment on this
On this understanding, that the conclusion of the debate will take one hour to-morrow, I am disposed to agree and to allow five or ten minutes to various speakers. I only want ten minutes, but I want an hour altogether to-morrow. What is the difference after all between half an hour and an hour? I could take the whole hour, but I am prepared to waive that right in respect of the claim of other people who remained here all day with a view to being heard in this debate.
Comment on this
I protest against the time limit. We want full time to give expression to our opinion. I will not be bound by any time limit.
Comment on this
I have been doing my duty as well as any man on the opposite benches during the last ten years, and I insist upon getting time, to-morrow, to speak on this motion.
Comment on this
I believe Deputy Cosgrave is entitled to time to reply. In the ordinary course he would be given that time to-night, but for the arrangement of speakers. There were several speakers upon one side without one being allowed to this side of the House. Therefore I think the Minister for Finance is not unreasonable in asking to be allowed to conclude his speech. If Deputy Cosgrave wants half an hour at any time to-morrow, and that satisfies him, we will facilitate him.
Comment on this
If there is only enough time to be given to-morrow to enable Deputy Cosgrave to wind up the debate I hold it is unfair.
Comment on this
I represent the farmers of my constituency and I want to present their views on this debate.
Comment on this
We are disputing about half an hour and we are wasting time here at the moment. I believe accommodation can and should be found for speakers who have been here all day and who are anxious to be heard. I shall be very brief in order to allow them time. If one hour is allowed to-morrow I think we could conclude.
Comment on this
I want to get a guarantee that I shall have an opportunity of speaking to-morrow, even for ten minutes.
Comment on this
As far as we are concerned I am not anxious in any way to be a party to closuring this discussion, but, if I may say so, I think it was rather unreasonable for a gentleman like Deputy O'Donovan, who has been dumb for ten years, to get so noisy now in his desire to speak. I am quite happy, and my colleagues are quite happy, in allowing some more time for discussion to-morrow. Speakers can divide it up amongst themselves. One hour will be given for the discussion to-morrow at a time to be arranged.
Comment on this
I was referring — and it did not seem palatable to some people — to the complete untruth uttered in this debate by Deputy Morrissey, and I presume, as Deputy Morrissey's remarks were held to be in order by the Chair, I am, also, in order in dealing with them. We were asked why we did not come in here to vote against this tribute in December, 1925. I was going to ask Deputy Morrissey, only that I did not think his eloquence would bear the interruption, what tribute he referred to, but he went on to supply the answer himself and said the agreement that saddled us with five and a quarter millions. The only thing that occurred to me was whether Deputy Morrissey, at that time, was more in the confidence of Deputy Cosgrave than he pretended to be. What is it he seems to have known: That in December, 1925 — I think the date was the 11th December, 1925 — this question of a tribute of five and a quarter millions was not apparently under consideration at all; Deputy Cosgrave had just come back from his famous conference in London telling us about "the damn good bargain" he had made and telling us that all our liabilities had been assessed at one big nought as a justification for the surrender under the Bounday Betrayal of every part of the Six Counties; and it was to consider whether the Boundary Settlement was a good one or not that we were asked to come into the House, and not any mysterious financial imposition consequent upon its passage.
The agreement for a financial settlement, that is the agreement to which Deputy Morrissey referred, was dated March, 1926. We were not asked at that time to come into the House and to oppose the signing of, or the ratification of, this ultimate financial settlement.
Deputy Morrissey further said that there was one thing he was certain of, and it shows the mentality of this gentleman, and that was that if the annuities were not paid to the British Government then the Irish State had no right, no moral right, to collect them.
Comment on this
He said to whomsoever this money is owed it is not owed to this State. I would like Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Anthony, who is now in eruption——
Comment on this
Why, then, if they were not due to this State, why were they collected for this State by Deputy Cosgrave, and why was it necessary for Deputy Cosgrave to introduce legislation to suspend the Constitution in order that he might hail before the Military Tribunal any person who got up to advocate that the annuities should not be paid to this State if they were not due to this State? Why did Deputy Cosgrave embody in that Statute a provision for imposing the death penalty, if necessary, on any man who advocated the non-payment of these annuities into the Irish Exchequer, and why, if the moneys were not owed to this State, did Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Anthony, and the whole of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, including Deputy Gorey, Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Esmonde — every single one of them— march into the Division Lobby in order to make these annuities collectable, under pain of death, if they were not owed to this State?
Comment on this
On a point of order. We walked into the Division Lobby to prevent murders and assassinations.
Comment on this
Is it because that from the moment the secret agreement was signed, aye from the moment that they——
Comment on this
——attacked the Four Courts, the Cosgrave administration were, in regard to the land annuities and everything else——
Comment on this
Deputy Anthony having persisted in interrupting will now leave the House for the remainder of this day's sitting.
Comment on this
I obey your ruling, a Chinn Comhairle. I apologise to the Chair for things I said in a moment of haste. As the Chair has requested me I will withdraw, but I will repeat my statements outside of the House.
[Deputy Anthony withdrew from the House.]
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I ask whether the Minister is in order in stating that members of this House are agents of the British Government, and if when he states that he would adduce proof for the gravest charge that can be made against any man in public life in this country?
Comment on this
It is not in order to state that any Deputy in this House is an agent of any authority outside this State.
Comment on this
I submit that the Minister has just made the statement that in this, as in other cases, the Cosgrave administration were the agents of the British Government. If you rule that is not in order, I take it the Minister will withdraw it.
Comment on this
I should like to point out that is not what I said. I said that if these annuities were not properly collectable and properly payable into the Exchequer of this State to be disposed of as the Government and the Executive Council determine, whether we pay them over to Great Britain or keep them here? If the argument of the Opposition is, as it has been that, unless we collect them for the purpose of paying them over to Great Britain, they are not properly collectable by us, we can, therefore, regard the collection of the annuities as nothing else but the carrying out of an agency service for Great Britain. On their own statements they can be held to be nothing else but agents for Great Britain.
Comment on this
I want to put a further point of order to the Chair. I want to know if it is within the competence of the Ceann Comhairle and, if so, will the Ceann Comhairle quote the Standing Order that gives him the authority to order a Deputy to leave the House?
Comment on this
The Minister's statement, as I heard it, coupled two things: the attack on the Four Courts and something which I did not quite catch. The statement specifically made was that the Cosgrave administration were the agents of the British Government. What I want to make clear is this: that the Minister makes a charge and then he runs away from it.
Comment on this
We will leave that, but, anyhow, a lot of people will go down to posterity for other things than their courage.
Comment on this
One rather peculiar thing about this is: why was it that before the Agreement of 1923 was signed the annuities were collected by the Provisional Government?
Comment on this
And the Land Commission is collecting them now and has been collecting them for nine years.
Comment on this
The Land Commission which collected the annuities up to 1st April, 1923, was under the control of the British Government.
Comment on this
Now we know. Of course the Land Commission were here collecting the annuities prior to the Agreement of 1923 as agents of the British Government.
Comment on this
They were collecting them and handing them over. Then the Agreement of 1923 comes along and there is an ostensible change in the agent of the British Government. The Executive Council of the Irish Free State takes over the Land Commission, runs it free of charge for the British Government, collects the annuities and, in the words of the secret Agreement of 1923, "make themselves responsible for the actual collection from the tenant purchaser," not only that, but agrees to hand over "to the appropriate fund the full amount of the annuities accruing due from time to time" whether they collect them or not. Could there be a more reasonable or a more altruistic agent than that? It is usual, if one is collecting rents on behalf of another person, to make an agency charge of about 5 per cent., but a well bred gentleman like Deputy Cosgrave, well reared and well mannered, could not possibly think of descending to that low commercial tactic, and of asking, when he was acting as agent for the British Government, that at least he should be paid his agency fee.
I beg to move the adjournment of the debate.
Comment on this
Before the House adjourns, I desire to say that the Standing Order which Deputy Morrissey asked me to cite is Standing Order 48.
Comment on this
At what hour is it proposed to take to-morrow the motion which the House has been debating to-day?