Supplementary and Additional Estimates. - Vote 69—Relief Schemes.
Contributions 143–305 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
And I expressed my appreciation of the fair and liberal way in which the Minister for Industry and Commerce dealt with it.
Comment on this
To the extent that I have misjudged the Deputy in connection with this letter I apologise. But that statement did cover the whole body of the surveyors and deputy surveyors in County Donegal and I made the same inquiry of each, but I found that I could not find one case of the kind referred to. It is just stories like that and there are millions of them in that vague way.
Comment on this
I must ask the Parliamentary Secretary not to refer to vague stories of that kind. I made a statement and I said the moment the House rose I would wait on the responsible Minister and place the facts before him. I waited on the responsible Minister and put all the facts to him. There was nothing at all vague in it, no general attack. It was a specific case for the Minister and at the earliest possible moment I placed all the facts before him.
Comment on this
No man in this House is an enemy of this Government who exposes anything that is wrong in the expenditure of this relief. No man in this House is a friend of the Government who hides anything. We want all these cases exposed and I hope that is understood. Now there have been abuses. The questions raised by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and Deputy Mulcahy were all practically in relation to Mayo and have nothing whatever to do with these roads. There were attempts in Mayo—and I will take that specific case under the Minor Relief Schemes—of individuals to abuse the relief schemes. Certain people did attempt to run it but I want to know whether any of them got away with it after we had knowledge of it? If any one starts trying to get away with a game of that kind it is the duty of every Deputy to put the information in writing before the officer who is responsible to this House for the honest administration of these schemes and strict inquiry will be made into the matter. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney wanted works of permanent value. He was full of these works until he was asked for them. It was another bluff. For ten years—and I am sorry that item has to be dragged into it—the previous Government had been administering these schemes. They did not leave on their files any of these permanent works that we could indulge in. If they had left these on their files I would have investigated them.
Take the question of land reclamation. I have half a dozen land reclamation schemes covering 800 or 900 acres. I did not get one in which the value of the land would be a quarter or a fifth of the value of the money which would have to be spent, and one-eighth of the value which went into the labour working in any one of them. It goes to my heart to spend money on things which are unproductive. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has brought forward certain schemes in relation to mineral development—going in and taking over the burden of minerals of various kinds. If we can find any case which we can fit in under the mineral schemes we will do so. I merely complain that there are no permanent schemes but if any Deputy has them let him bring them along. Somebody in England suggested that as they were up against the problem of unemployment, they should use the railways to bring the refuse from the dumps in the mines in the North of England down to fill up the lakes in the South. I do not know if anyone here is going to suggest anything quite as large or as foolish as that. But if anyone is going to suggest any new lines in which we can use money for relief in the future we are only too glad to have these suggestions. I have tried drainage schemes. The difficulty with drainage schemes, as has been admitted by some Deputies, is that you may get the money spent in the areas you want it spent, but you cannot spend it at the time you want it spent. The time we want to spend it is from November to March. You are then in the dark days, the wet days and the short days. In addition to that, the specific value of an hour's work done at that time in wet ground and so on is altogether lower than the other. There again it is a question of fitting it in.
As far as lime kilns and so on are concerned, we are spending money on lime kilns in Kerry to the great joy of Deputy Flynn, even if he did not know it. It is being spent there in three or four places. It is being spent in West Cork, in Laoighis and in Galway. We hope to spend a good deal more money upon things of that kind if we can get them. For instance, I did go to the trouble of reading—it was only a summary unfortunately which came into my possession—a memo. prepared by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney under the old system in relation to the grinding up of stone as distinct from the burning of limestone but we could not fit that in. Again I say if any of you know anything, this is the time to speak.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary let us know how he is managing the lime kilns in Kerry and other counties?
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, every lime kiln job is a difficult one because as a rule it is on private property. In certain cases it means financing the repair of an existing derelict kiln. In some cases it means putting a road into a limestone deposit which is not otherwise available. In other cases it means financing the production of a lime kiln. There was a rather curious but fortunate case in West Cork, where there is one single out-cropping of limestone in a great big boggy area. The land has been vested in tenants and curiously enough this piece of limestone is vested in tenants surrounding the boglands who have no bog. It has been necessary for us to set up a little Public Utility or Co-Operative Society in order to have someone to whom we could make the grant which would enable us to open that limestone quarry for them. In practically every case where we have run up against limestone we have run up against difficulties of that kind. All I can tell you is that there are a couple of members of the Dáil who are a little committee on the subject—Deputy Fred Crowley and Deputy Seán Moylan —who have a very close knowledge of the particular problems engaged in it and if any Deputies have a limestone proposition of their own that they want to put through I would rather suggest that they should discuss with these two Deputies the difficulties in relation to it and see what can be done.
Comment on this
I am very sorry. It is a purely advisory committee who look into and see what is the title to land or whether there are rights-of-way into the lime kiln after we have made it, or whether in fact the benefit would inure to an individual instead of inuring to the district.
Comment on this
Do I take it that these Deputies are investigating matters in other Deputies' constituencies in respect to limestone?
Comment on this
You can take it any way you like. They are two people who have knowledge and who are helping me.
Comment on this
The naked fact is that this is a committee of the Fianna Fáil Party in respect to these limestone quarries for the purpose of the Party.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Parliamentary Secretary should make the committee representative.
Comment on this
In North West Cork, otherwise in Tower, Banteer, and in places on the borders of Kerry.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary does not know what he is talking about. He has admitted that there are no such deposits in West Cork.
Comment on this
I am not going to say there are not. There are in North Cork and in East Cork, on the borders of West Cork and on the borders of Kerry and Cork. Deputy Davin suggested that unemployment should be a national and not a local charge. I do not quite know whether we are in a position to discuss that on this particular Estimate or not.
Comment on this
I said the maintenance of those for whom employment could not be provided should not be a local charge, but a national one.
Comment on this
It amounts to the same thing when you boil it down. You can only get the money out of the same pockets whichever way you get it.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin said that the regulations in relation to the labour exchanges were faulty. I certainly would like to see included, and I think there will be included in it, a certain clause. The two classes, broadly, up to the present have been married and unmarried. It will be with dependants and without dependants as a beginning. In other words, a single man with dependants, if his dependants were somewhere approximate to the same conditions as a married person, certainly ought to be somewhat on the same level. In addition, I think, there ought to be some provision for men who are neither single men with dependants nor married men with dependants, but are simply single men. I cannot take the line myself that the mere fact that a man is single is to leave him out of the whole ambit of unemployment schemes. I should like to see a certain proportion of single men definitely included in that.
Deputy Davin, I think it was, wanted the charges on local authorities reduced from the point of view of sewerage; in other words, a larger proportion of grant for sewerage schemes. In this particular case you got £500,000 of an additional grant which was to be used for all these purposes, and side by side with that £550,000 of money raised out of revenue this year to be used as loans for local authorities. It is simply a question of the proportion in which they take it. I think the proportion there is about £103,000 gone out as grants to energise loans for public health purposes.
Comment on this
In that connection might I ask the Parliamentary Secretary a question. On the money advanced from that fund there is an interest charge of 5¾ per cent. Does not the Parliamentary Secretary consider that too high? If it could be lowered, certainly that fund would be taken advantage of to a greater extent than at present.
Comment on this
There is a hope that it may be. Roughly speaking, the grant varied from 30 per cent. up to 70 per cent. Seventy per cent. was given in cases in which the local authority had refused to do the work at any price but where, on public health grounds, it was absolutely essential it should be done. In connection with public health schemes, what happens is that all applications for sewerage and water supply schemes first go through to the Local Government Department, where they are examined on their merits. They then put them forward for a grant out of the unemployment fund, and, to be quite frank, on as low a basis as they think they can get away with for the purpose of getting as much work done as possible out of whatever limited sum we have. In every case it is a question of working within the limits we have. When we came to the allocation of the £500,000 this year, we allocated about £100,000 for the purpose of grants for sewerage schemes and that sum energised, roughly speaking, two and a half times that amount of money.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary consider the advisability of fixing a maximum rate to be borne by the dispensary area in the case of all such schemes if that be possible?
Comment on this
All these things—every single condition that you put there— will limit your freedom in the matter of making relief schemes in the future. Deputy Brodrick, of Galway, spoke of dismissals by the board of health on a relief scheme. Up to the present I have not been able to trace that. I know of no minor relief scheme that took place in the City of Galway, though in the County Galway there were a great number.
Comment on this
I will supply the documents in the course of a week.
Comment on this
I will be glad. We have no knowledge of any such thing, and if the information comes to our possession we will do the best we can with it. The allegation was made that, in relation to some of this £350,000, certain board of health people in Galway did, under conditions of victimisation, dismiss certain people. If Deputy Brodrick gives us the facts we will go into them. All that I am concerned with is that so long as the Deputy gives me the facts I will see what I can do with them. Again, I say to the House that there is nothing that we want to conceal. If anyone tried to play games of that kind let us know. We have no right to do anything except to administer the money fairly.
Some Deputy said that no money had ever been given out of a relief vote on drainage. Money was given in two cases, in the case of the Fergus in County Clare and of the River Sow in County Wexford. Broadly speaking, we are very anxious not to mix up drainage work of a fairly large order with minor relief work. The reason is this: that if you take an ordinary drainage scheme it is put forward for the purpose of benefiting a particular agricultural area. What happens in that case is that three people are asked to subscribe to it: the people whose land is benefited; the county council that benefits by the benefit that the people get, and the central authority which is unable to resist the pressure to provide the largest sum of money possible for the purpose of carrying out the scheme. All these things have to be worked out in an engineering scheme and have to be reduced to a definite price. If that is so, you are going to get into grave difficulty if, in the employment of people on those schemes, you are going to have a purely relief atmosphere worked into them. You have got to get full value for all the money you spend, because, otherwise, when the whole thing is over, if the estimate is exceeded, then in every case you are going to have a row with the central authority which will be asked to make a larger grant, with the local authority which has already granted more than it believed it ought to have granted, and with the beneficial owner of the improved land who will be difficult to convince that he ever got value at any time. For that reason we do not want to mix up the two. The only drainage works carried out have been minor ones. The following are some fairly good examples:—(1) the removal of rock obstruction in a river, (2) making a new road in a district where previously tenants had to carry their meal and flour on their backs, (3) the erection of a bridge to render a road passable, (4) the drainage of flooded lands, (5) another removal of a rock obstruction which was causing a river to flood plots of land, (6) repair to a damaged bridge, (7) clearing floods. Small floodings of that kind can be done, but when you come to deal with schemes where there have to be contributions from two or three authorities, if you mix them up with relief schemes then you are going to get into trouble.
Deputy Dolan is under the impression that there are a lot of drainage schemes which, while uneconomic, would do untold good if carried out. I do not quite know what the Deputy means. I can tell the House that I have been through all the schemes—remember these are the chosen pet ones—which have come forward up to the present: the ones that the Board of Works have carried out, the ones that they are carrying out and the ones that they intend to carry out. So far from being economic, the position with regard to them would be represented in this way: that for every £4 spent only £1 is effective in the sense of realised improved value due to the work done. If that is the position in relation to what one may call the choice schemes, I need hardly tell the House what it would be in regard to the ones rejected. Against that, there are small works such as what you might call local drains and things of that kind which, under a relief scheme, if a relief scheme were wanted during the dry weather, would be very valuable. These schemes are very difficult to carry out with any economy during the wet and dark winter months in which the work is really required.
I come now to the question which I think has been worrying a good many and that is the wages paid upon minor relief schemes. Minor relief schemes are really an extension of the work that used to be done by the Land Commission and by the old Congested Districts Board. The ordinary way of making a relief grant in this House in the past was to make that grant to the Land Commission. It was really a very ingenious method. It really did not cost anything—the giving of the money to the Land Commission to do unemployment relief work. The unemployment relief work they did was on those bog roads and so on which they previously used to do and they found that their establishment and activity were only capable of reaching on a given total which they had done in the last year and, therefore, anything you added to them —this is their own contention and not mine—to do new unemployment work meant that they could not do their own work. The result was that while you issued £240,000 or whatever it was for unemployment relief, it simply meant that you had coming back out of the Vote something approaching the same amount.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary say whether the Land Commission carried out any repair work on bog roads outside the congested districts?
Comment on this
Yes, the £240,000 voted for relief work last year was put through the Land Commission. They did the work and we wanted them to continue to do it. However, what we are dealing with now is a simple question. The work we are carrying out under minor relief was the work I speak of here and these works were carried out as a rule, in the old areas, that is, the old congested areas, and, at the present moment, I think there are between 9,000 and 10,000 people employed on minor relief works in the different districts and there has been no difficulty and no complaint of any sort or kind in relation to the wages paid for those works in these old areas. In fact, the position is entirely different. I am satisfied that there is more enthusiasm and more interest and more willingness to work on these particular schemes than there are in any other portion of the work which we have to do. However, in probably a mistaken sense of fairness, in this particular year, we did extend the minor relief schemes into areas in which they previously had not been. There have been no such works done, for instance, in Wicklow, Wexford, Waterford or Leix, or any place of that kind, and, to a limited extent, we have had complaints in those areas in relation to the wages paid on the minor relief schemes. What the House must remember is that this is a mixed scheme. Two million pounds have been provided for the purpose of relieving unemployment and of relieving distress. The money which is being spent, as the House knows, in Donegal, Mayo and places of that kind is more in relief of distress than it is in relief of mere unemployment, and the standard of distress was that men desired to get work at agricultural wages. That is the test. That is the test under which all the work is done under drainage schemes and that is the test under which the whole of the Land Commission work is done. It is exactly the standard under which the work has been done for the last ten years. There has been no change of any sort, kind or description in doing that except that, in a mistaken sense of fairness, we have extended into the areas which were comparatively prosperous the kind of work which used to take place in the really distressed portions of Ireland—Clare, West Cork, Kerry, Galway, Mayo and Donegal. What we have done there is that we have simply allocated money to the different areas as fairly as we can on a money basis. We can do two things. We can leave the position as it is in relation to carrying out that number of minor relief works on the same basis in Leix as they are carried out in Galway, or we can use the same amount of money to employ a lesser number of men to do a lesser number of works relatively in Leix than we have in Galway. Either of those are fair methods. Neither of them are popular methods.
Comment on this
There is not. That is the plain English of it. Is it suggested that Leix should get more money—I am putting this up to Deputies and I do not regard this as an easy proposition —for its unemployment relative to Galway for the same unemployment?
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary justify the payment of two different rates of wages for the same class of work in the same place?
Comment on this
That is the point. That is the difficulty I said I had. My difficulty was to justify having extended the minor relief works into places like that because there were not in those areas the kind of works that used to be done under minor relief schemes in other places. In Kildare and places of that kind, men were not carrying turf two miles on their backs over a mountain in order to get into their houses because they had no road. They were not carrying flour halfway across a mountain because they had no road. The people who speak of that have no conception of the difference of distress, the difference of need that the people have who are eagerly anxious to get work done at this rate. If we have a limited sum of money, I put it to Deputies simply as a matter of fairness, how should we spend it. Should we do a lesser number of jobs at a higher wage or should we do a larger number of jobs at a lower wage and, in an agricultural district, are we to make as a standard for relief a standard higher than the standard of agricultural wages?
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary whether he is aware that, under instructions from the so-called Centre Party in this country, farmers are actually cutting wages to a point below a living rate. The standard he has been preaching now is the standard adopted by the previous Minister for Agriculture here.
Comment on this
One does not bother to contradict Deputy Corry but, of course, his statement is entirely false.
Comment on this
This is really a serious and difficult problem and it is perfectly easy for all of us to get on each others necks and say the popular or unpopular thing, but every day, so far as relief works are concerned, I am up against all these horrible problems. I am up against refusal where I should like to give money. I have only a limited amount of money and what I am concerned with is to let the House understand that, so far as I possibly can, I am trying honestly to face up to the difficulty and that, if people will find a solution, there is a solution. In Leix, at present, am I to reduce the number of works and what works? Am I to give to Leix and other places of the kind—I am only using Leix because it was the first one that came into my mind—more money relative to their unemployment than I am to give to the distressed districts of Kerry, Connemara, Galway, Mayo or Donegal? That is my difficulty.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary should not use this Vote passed by this House for the purpose of telling a local authority to reduce wages.
Comment on this
I am told I am giving instructions. I am not. I am issuing to the City of Cork a first allocation of £3,000 to be used on specific work in which the local authority is not concerned, except to the extent that its surveyor acts as my agent, and his business is to carry out those works of that character on the same basis as that on which they have been carried out for the last ten years, on the basis of agricultural wages for agriculturists.
Comment on this
That is my difficulty. My difficulty is to justify having brought those works at all into these areas.
Comment on this
Surely the Parliamentary Secretary will not in this instance justify what Cumann na nGaedheal did for twelve years, while condemning them when they were in office.
Comment on this
The Deputy may not recognise that there are other people in the House and that the other people who made complaints have their difficulties. He may be vocal. It does not mean that we do not feel it. The question is: In agricultural districts am I to go out deliberately to provide, at the cost of the community, relief at wages other than agricultural wages?
Comment on this
If the Deputy will give me a particular instance of that I will be very glad to have it.
Comment on this
No, the Deputy knows it, and will give me an instance in which I am paying that. If it is being done it is done in violation of orders.
Comment on this
The instructions are 24/-. I do not care for anyone in this matter. If the Deputy makes the statement that we are paying less than agricultural wages, he must be in a position to put me in possession of such facts as will enable me to deal with what is a breach of my regulations.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary is only playing with the matter. The Minister for Agriculture knows it very well.
Comment on this
I am not playing with it. I am bringing the Deputy to the point of getting the facts.
Comment on this
When in Opposition he preached the very same economy, and the very same wages policy.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary and the Deputy would address the Chair much of this cross-fire would be avoided.
Comment on this
I am putting the proposition of being given a certain amount of money to administer. It is not a question of so many days' wages, or of a certain allocation of wages for certain districts. Am I to reduce the number of jobs for particular places where they say agricultural wages are not wanted in relief? Deputy Mulcahy stated that there was a wave of unemployment. I do not believe there is.
Comment on this
I am in the position this year, broadly speaking, of saying that things are not by any means critical. I speak with knowledge of Deputies of all sorts coming to my office.
Comment on this
I have had Deputies coming to my office who wanted money for unemployment, wanting to know if they were going to get a share. I have not found any suggestion that the position was critical. I said to them: "So long as you are satisfied that you are going to get your share for your county and district do you want the money now?" The answer was "No." They did not want it then. "Did they want it critically," they were asked. "No, they did not," was the reply.
Comment on this
That is altogether wrong. It is incorrect. It is against the argument you used for half an hour.
Comment on this
If it was true I would not have put down the question the Parliamentary Secretary answered to-day.
Comment on this
Deputy Davis is again on the point that there is something going wrong in Mayo, and that we do not know anything about it. Again I tell the Deputy: "Put it in writing." As to the allegation that farmers are working when others are unemployed, there may be cases where farmers are just as unfortunate as other people, just in as critical a position, for instance, as Donegal people, or those in Mayo. A good many may be little farmers. It does not follow that there are not certain cases where men have been employed who should not have been employed. We have done our best to alter the fact. I want to see a fair solution. I come back to the question of wages. What I suggest is that in future in cases where we are dealing with areas that are not congested areas, where there is no work of a bog road character, that in order to get over the difficulty of two people doing work that is similar, only minor relief schemes are put forward, or minor county roads. In that particular case the only way I can see that we can justly meet the difficulty in these areas is to add to what might be called the ordinary relief the proportion which otherwise would have gone into other relief funds, and the county surveyor can carry out of the Road Fund minor relief to the extent to which he could do it within the amount of money, but at the same rate of wages. That is my difficulty. The only way I can see that we can meet Deputies—and I am anxious to meet them—is that in future there will not be a separate allocation of minor relief money for areas in which that money was all spent before; that a sort of composite fund would be made out of which such work would be met. Otherwise I find it very difficult to find a solution. As far as I know we have about 34,000 men employed on relief schemes. At the end of September we had about 20,000, at the end of October about 23,000, at the end of November about 27,000, and at the end of December about 37,000. As the money runs out towards the 31st March we will be dropping down again to the level of September. As the House knows the object was to spend that money during the peak portion of unemployment. From the diagram it will be seen that we have, as far as possible, followed in our unemployment allocation the actual necessities of the case.
Comment on this
I want to raise a question of privilege. During the concluding remarks of the Parliamentary Secretary he made the allegation that on some mysterious occasion I informed him that money he was prepared to allocate need not be sent out immediately. During my membership of this House, over a period of almost eleven years, I have conducted all my correspondence with every Government Department and Minister by letter. I am luckily in the position of having a copy of every proposal I submitted to the Parliamentary Secretary in connection with the proposal for a grant for relief work. I want here and now to ask the Parliamentary Secretary to name the time, the place and the scheme in regard to which I made any observation of that kind. I want to assure the House that on not more than two ocasions had I any consultation of any kind with the Parliamentary Secretary since he was appointed, unfortunately appointed, to that particular position.
Comment on this
There may be a slight misunderstanding and I hope to remove it. As the House will remember this grant of £2,000,000 was made somewhere in March or April. All sorts of Deputies came to me in relation to their constituencies. This lasted through March, April, June and July. In all cases when I produced the graph showing the unemployment level, they were all satisfied that the money should be spent, not in the summer—that is the point I was concerned with—but over the winter months. My recollection was that Deputy Davin was one of those. Deputy Davin says he was not and I will accept that.
Comment on this
I want to say that on these two occasions to which I referred, I remember I was accompanied by Deputy Patrick Boland and Deputy Gorry. I want the Parliamentary Secretary to say now what were the schemes I referred to.
Comment on this
I withdraw the statement if I in any way misunderstood the Deputy but I certainly understood that what he wanted, like everybody else, was that the money spent in his constituency, should be spent during the period of greatest necessity, that is, during the winter months.
Comment on this
That is not the charge the Parliamentary Secretary preferred against me in his concluding remarks.
Comment on this
Now that the Parliamentary Secretary has concluded will he see that a copy of his speech will be circulated to every wage-cutting employer in the country so as to incite them to reduce wages?
Comment on this
Could we get from the Parliamentary Secretary any ruling showing whether a man working on a drainage scheme is not entitled to have his cards stamped? He said in his concluding remarks that there would shortly be a drop back to the number of people employed in September. That would mean that a large number would be unemployed and they would not be entitled to draw insurance benefits. To suggest that some of the work they are doing is agricultural work is something I could not stand over. I want to know what decision the Department has given, and whether they are stamping the necessary cards to enable these men to get unemployment insurance benefit when they are unemployed.
Comment on this
My difficulty is to know how the men are employed. I should like to know whether those who are engaged on relief schemes——
Comment on this
It is a matter of legal responsibility. I understand that if the Parliamentary Secretary neglected to stamp the insurance cards of these employees, if the matter were brought to the courts, he would have to pay up.
Comment on this
I am asked for a ruling. We have had previously on the files a ruling that this drainage work was treated as agricultural work. I would have that taken up again and if it is ruled that it is not agricultural work, then obviously these cards will have to be stamped whether we like it or not. The difficulty always has been that what you do in relation to one particular thing you must do in regard to the whole of these schemes.
Comment on this
We have a ruling on the files at the moment from whatever legal advisers the Government had that this was agricultural work. I shall have another ruling and see what we can do.
Comment on this
I understood that Deputy Corish wanted a precise statement as to what prohibition had been imposed on the stamping of cards in connection with those engaged on relief works. Deputy Corish did not discriminate between drainage schemes by way of relief work and other schemes. I understood the Parliamentary Secretary's reply to be this, that drainage works have previously been declared agricultural work and that, therefore, they would not be obliged to stamp the cards of those engaged in these works. I understood him to make a discrimination with regard to drainage schemes and that only. Is that a fact?
Comment on this
I understand that on the whole of the Land Commission schemes up to the present the cards were not stamped.
Comment on this
Might I put it another way? Road works, even though in the guise of relief schemes, certainly entail the stamping of workmen's cards.
Comment on this
I understand that in any work of this kind under the régime of the Deputy opposite the cards have not been stamped.
Comment on this
We know what relief works are. Does the Parliamentary Secretary assert that road works even under the guise of relief schemes do not entail the stamping of cards?
Comment on this
What I had in mind was that I know of two minor relief schemes where the men are engaged in quarrying work. I say that is an insurable occupation, no matter what the Parliamentary Secretary may say. It might be held that men engaged in erecting a hay barn were engaged in agricultural work. It is not a question of the Department they are working under.
Comment on this
May I ask whether the wages payable and the working conditions on minor relief schemes are a matter for Cabinet decision, or whether they are going to be left to this wage-cutting Parliamentary Secretary?
Comment on this
Might I get my point clear? May we take it that three things are now being done under the relief works that are going on— road works, land improvement schemes and the item to which Deputy Corish has specifically referred, quarrying work. As far as quarrying work is concerned, it was always regarded as an insurable occupation, no matter at what time of the year carried out. The same applied to road work. I understand that drainage schemes were held to be agricultural work and that, therefore, they did not entail the stamping of cards. On these three things has there been any change made? Quarrying was certainly an insurable occupation and so was road work, but drainage work was not.
Comment on this
As far as I can see the position is that on any work that is labelled a minor relief scheme no insurance card is stamped. The Parliamentary Secretary may not know that, but that is the point.
Comment on this
I may be wrong but I have been under the impression and I have been informed that there has been no change whatever in relation to the stamping of cards and in relation to the amount of work we are doing, but I shall have that investigated if you like. That is what I am informed and what I believe to be the fact.
Comment on this
I think the Parliamentary Secretary will find on examination that there was a variation.
Comment on this
I think the case has been put up by Deputy Hogan in relation to the drainage side of the works. I am faced by the decision of those who are competent to decide—I cannot say it is entirely obvious—that a man who is working on a drainage scheme is an agricultural labourer.
Comment on this
That is only on through drainage. That would not apply to a scheme like the Barrow Drainage.
Comment on this
No, but in the same way as minor drainage. What I intend to do is to get a review of the position and get a decision. The only thing that one wants to be perfectly satisfied about is that the men themselves do want it. Whether we should press in that direction or not is another matter, but in the meantime I will get a review of the whole position, as I said.
Comment on this
I should like to get this matter cleared up further. The last phrase which has been used by the Parliamentary Secretary certainly does not relieve anxiety. The Parliamentary Secretary has now said that he would like to have it clear as to whether or not the men desire it. I submit that it is not for them to desire it. It does not depend on the men at all, and I suggest that it would be a very retrograde step to have unemployment insurance remitted, even in doubtful cases, just because the men themselves desire it. It is going to lead to a certain type of man being employed, because county councils and other such boards will say: "We have not any obligation to stamp cards and it is therefore cheaper not to do so," and it will mean that in the end nobody will be able to ask for his unemployment insurance to be paid for him on this type of work. Otherwise, it would be almost blacklegging in a sense, to interfere in the matter. We are dealing at the moment with a sum of £350,000, and I should like to know what proportion of that sum roughly, has been expended, or is likely to be expended, on what I have described as "insurable occupations"—say, quarrying, roads, or big reclamation works—and what proportion of it has been or is likely to be expended on the type of drainage work which has been declared to be a non-insurable occupation?
Comment on this
Of the £500,000, about £160,000 has been spent on minor relief. Some of that would be road work and some drainage.
Comment on this
The Board of Works spent £31,000 on agriculture, and I think that most of that would be on agricultural wages. The Department of Industry and Commerce has spent £27,425 on insurable occupations. On public health work £103,000 has gone out in grants along these lines, and most of that, I think, would be insurable. The Dublin Corporation— £122,000—all insurable. So that, practically the major portion would be insurable.
Comment on this
I should like to know whether the Parliamentary Secretary can assure the House that the condition of affairs, which existed when this Vote was last discussed in the House, does not now exist, and that the report from the county surveyor in Mayo with regard to the provision of employment has not been shelved and the scheme of the Minister for Industry and Commerce been completely knocked on the head by gangers who repudiated the authority of the county surveyor?
Comment on this
The whole of that is in reference to a Vote of £1,000,000 for roads and has no relation whatever to the £350,000 being discussed at present.
Comment on this
But the expenditure on the roads is being done subject to the report of the county council's surveyor.
Comment on this
I submit that that should not be discussed here. It has to do with the maladministration of an entirely different Vote.
Comment on this
I should like to know whether, in view of the very great anxiety raised in the minds of Deputies in this House as a result of the previous discussion of this matter on this Vote, the Minister for Local Government and Public Health has anything to say on this matter or, if not on this Vote, would the Minister take an opportunity of informing the House on another occasion.
Comment on this
—The Minister says that he has nothing to say with regard to a report from a county surveyor.
Comment on this
I am submitting that the minor roads dealt with in this Vote and under the direction of the county surveyor in Mayo are involved in this Vote.
Comment on this
I tell the Parliamentary Secretary that they are, and that it was because of this that this matter was discussed the last time in the House and in connection with moneys being spent in Mayo.
Comment on this
Can Deputy Mulcahy give any proof that it was in connection with the minor relief schemes that the county surveyor in Mayo reported and can the Deputy mention the date upon which that report was made?
Comment on this
On 17th November, and it was discussed on this same Vote on 30th November last. On that occasion the Minister for Local Government and Public Health said that he had got a copy of this report and was inquiring into it.
Comment on this
I submit that in the discussion on 30th November last this whole matter was gone into and that the report of the county surveyor in question was dealt with at length. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health said on that occasion that he had received a copy of this report and that the matter was being inquired into. I submit, therefore, that unless an endeavour is being made to cloak over this matter, it is in order. All I am asking for is that the Minister should give us something to reassure this House that the scheme is not being completely overridden in Mayo, as reported by the county surveyor there, so that less than 60 per cent. of the value of the money expended is being got in Mayo. A few words from the Minister on this matter would reflect credit on his outlook, on his own responsibility, and are certainly due to the House.
Comment on this
When is it likely that this matter will come before us again on an Appropriation Bill? On account of the revelations made here to-night about the rates of wages, the Vote would require much longer debate.
Comment on this
May I ask for an answer to my question? When is it expected that the Appropriation Bill will be brought before the House.