Resolution No. 3.
Contributions 1–208 of 398. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
With regard to the Resolution and the Schedule I should like to ask the Minister if he would give us some idea of what is contemplated under sub-section (7) of this Resolution whereby power is taken to authorise by licence any particular person, subject to compliance with certain conditions, to import without payment of the duty mentioned in the Resolution any of the fruits mentioned in the Schedule. I should like the Minister to give us some idea of what is contemplated in this, particularly in view of the fact that the Minister applies the tariff on cherries, strawberries and raspberries for a very limited period, and applies it over the whole year, apparently, on apples, pears, plums, currants and gooseberries. What is the particular reason for applying the tariff during a restricted period in the cases of numbers 4, 5 and 6 of the Schedule and leaving the period unrestricted in the cases of, say, 7 and 8, not to speak of numbers 1, 2 and 3? I should like to know what is the general policy enshrined in sub-section (7), because if there is no policy enshrined in sub-section (7) then there is, apparently, an all-the-year-round tariff to be put upon apples, pears, plums, currants and gooseberries. I should like to know if that is so.
Comment on this
Nos. 7 and 8—currants and gooseberries —are grown in sufficient quantity to supply our demands for the whole year. If the Deputy would look up the figures he would find that, as a matter of fact, there is a small export trade in these fruits.
Comment on this
Yes; it applies certainly in the case of gooseberries. I am not quite sure with regard to black currants, but it is admitted that there are more gooseberries than we require for our own use. As soon as we get the full figures from the jam manufacturers—which we have asked for—we will be in a position to give definite information. There is no intention to issue a licence with regard to cherries, strawberries and raspberries, within the dates mentioned, as dessert fruits; but so far as the jam makers are concerned, as soon as we get the returns we have asked for, consideration will be given to the issuing of a licence for a certain percentage of what they have been importing up to this.
The case of apples, pears and plums is different. The crop in regard to these fruits is rather variable. It is not like strawberries and raspberries which are fairly regular from year to year. The crop in the case of apples, pears and plums depends on the season and on the sort of weather that obtains, particularly in the month of May. Because of this we cannot foretell with any degree of accuracy at all for how many months our home supply of these particular fruits would last. As a matter of fact, we have issued licences freely for the importation of apples up to 31st July. From that date up to, say, the last day in August we intend to issue licences with regard to the quantity so that there would not be an over supply of apples when our own supply comes in. As soon as we are satisfied that all the apples in the country are used up we would issue licences freely again. I think that, as far as dessert fruits are concerned, apples are the only exception that will be made with regard to the issuing of a licence. With regard to jam making, it is uncertain for the last few years and I cannot reply on that for the moment because the returns from the jam manufacturers have not yet come in in detail.
Comment on this
If the prices go up substantially in the case of these dessert fruits, would not licences be issued then?
Comment on this
If there was a substantial increase in prices and a great scarcity in the country it would be different; but I think that, as far as we can judge from the figures of the acreage under raspberries and strawberries, and the demand from the Dublin market—we have not got the others— we can come to the conclusion that no licence will be necessary within the dates specified.
Comment on this
The Minister has been kinder to the jam manufacturers than to the ordinary consumer of fruit.
Comment on this
I should like to know does the term "currants" cover what the grocer ordinarily means by that term?
Comment on this
Should not that be expressed in the Bill? The customs officers are very nice people, I know, but if you give them an inch they are inclined to take an ell.
Comment on this
That is a new one on me. I have never met a fresh prune. Has anybody in the House ever met a fresh prune? I understood that it was a dried commodity.
Comment on this
Possibly, but we do not know what may be grown in this country yet.
Comment on this
I should think that a fresh prune would be beyond the persuasive powers even of President de Valera.
Comment on this
I submit that it is a commodity very largely used on the tables of the poor. The tariff proposed to be imposed is not a very heavy one, I admit—a penny in the pound—but I should be surprised if the bulk of the prunes consumed is produced in this country, and I doubt if there are facilities for producing them in this country. I think that the Minister should examine the matter, and, if it is not practical to produce them here, that the tariff should be removed in the case of prunes.
Comment on this
I think that a Minister for Agriculture ought to be able to define what are fresh prunes and whether the prune grows on a bush or a tree, or is a root.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that there has been an over-abundant supply of apples in the country for a great many years, and a very poor demand for them, I should like to know why does the Minister intend to remove the tariff as regards apples.
Comment on this
The tariff will be removed as soon as all the apples in the country have been used. I am at a loss to know whether the Deputy is for or against the tariff on apples.
Comment on this
The apples would last the whole year round if imported apples were coming in at the same time, but we hope that, by keeping the foreign apples out for a certain period of the year, the home-grown apples will be used up.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say to what class of person licences for the import of apples will be issued before the apple season this year and after the apple season this year?
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, they are being issued at present to any person who applies.
Comment on this
This Resolution does not impose any new duty. The duty on mineral hydrocarbon white oil imposed last year was evaded by certain importers adding a colouring matter to the oil. We have got here in this Resolution a new definition which will prevent that system of evasion. Chemists have been working on this for some months and have produced this definition. We think that even it is not quite watertight, and that it will be necessary to have some slight modification of it later on. The duty position is not altered at all. This is merely a device to prevent the system of evasion which grew up during the year.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say if the Revenue Commissioners are now letting motor oils come through? I think they were being held up for a considerable time at the ports.
Comment on this
This Resolution does not deal with motor oils. If motor oils were held up. I do not know what the reason was.
Comment on this
The Revenue Commissioners, apparently, were not satisfied that motor oils were outside the definition.
Comment on this
On examination, I think the Deputy will find that occasionally a consignment of motor oils may have been held up for test, but there has been no hold up of motor oils as such.
Comment on this
They are at present being produced by one firm in Cork. I am not quite sure to what extent, or if they have all their machinery installed. I have one of their hats myself, and I find it a very excellent article. They anticipated that at about the present time they would be able to supply about 25 per cent. of the requirements of the country. There are two other firms also in touch with the Department. They propose to establish factories for the manufacture of these hats within the present year. I anticipate that by this time next year we shall have 100 per cent. of the requirements of the country being produced by the factories established here if existing plans work out as anticipated. One firm has definitely gone ahead by having the necessary machinery installed, and the other firms are prepared to go ahead as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say what is the price of these hats, or was the one he got himself a presentation copy?
Comment on this
The effect of it is to change the emergency duty into a permanent duty. The duty on cloths was increased very largely in consequence of the lowering of prices and of attempts to produce cloths at uneconomic prices. The increase in the duty on cloth necessitated a corresponding increase in the duty on articles made from the cloth. The duty on wearing apparel, men's and women's, "made wholly or mainly from woven tissues wholly or partly of wool or worsted" was increased by an emergency order. It is being made a permanent duty in this Resolution.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that the operation of the duty on woollen cloths and readymade clothing definitely resulted in the public being unable to get the cheaper ends of women's outer wearing apparel at the price they used to be able to get them at? It is now virtually impossible to buy here a woman's coat under about 25/- or 30/- which used to be available at £1. I think if the Minister looks into the matter he will find that the manufacturers of women's outer wearing garments have practically given up the attempt to produce a woman's coat under 22/6.
Comment on this
I cannot say at the moment at what price these are being produced—I mean the cheaper grade of women's outer garments. There is a substantial leeway to be made up in that industry because nothing had been done in consequence of the low rate of duty that prevailed until this time last year. During the past year substantial advances were made, but still we have a long way to go before we can hope to be self-sufficient in the matter of factory-made women's outer garments. At the moment a certain amount of leeway is being made up by the home manufacturer: by dressmakers and others as well as those who intend wearing the coats and dresses and things of that kind which they make themselves. I am not at all sure that it is not just as desirable to have production in that form as in the factory form. The information at the disposal of my Department would indicate that there has been a very substantial increase in the number of persons engaged in the dressmaking business in their own homes and in the output of those so engaged.
Comment on this
I find it difficult to follow the Minister's explanation: whether it is that in fact coats are being produced and that there is no scarcity, or whether, on the other hand, there are no factories producing cheap women's outer garments, but that the trade has passed into the hands of home dressmakers operating on their own.
Comment on this
The position is that up to this time last year we had practically no factory production of women's outer garments at all. Now we have. There are a number of firms engaged in the factory production of women's outer garments. These firms are not sufficient to supply what would be regarded as the ordinary demand for factory produced articles. This deficiency is made up in two ways: by continuing imports on the one hand, mainly of high-class goods in respect of which the import duty does not make much difference, and by the output of the home dressmaker. Ordimarily speaking, if this situation did not exist there would be a larger consumption of the factory produced article as against the dressmaker produced article. At the present time you have a larger production of the dressmaker produced article than of the factory produced article.
Comment on this
The people who will have to pay this duty are the poor. They are the principal purchasers of these cheap outer garments for women. They will suffer most under this. The country dressmaker will charge from 10/- to 12/- for making a coat. About three yards of material are required for the making of a coat. If 12/- is charged for the making of a coat, the total cost of which is £1, there is only 8/- left for the purchase of the material and trimmings. My experience has been that the Irish manufacturers are avoiding the cheap end of the trade in women's outer wearing garments.
Comment on this
On the contrary, so far as there is factory production of women's outer garments at all it is the cheaper class of garments that is being produced.
Comment on this
I put it to the Minister that if such representations have been made to his Department they do not give the position correctly. There are, so to speak, three classes of trade. First, the highly expensive class—those who send to London or Paris for their clothes; then there is the middle trade of good quality; and thirdly, there is definitely the cheap trade which caters principally for the poorer classes in Dublin and the rural areas. I quite agree that the middle trade is being surprisingly well done in Irish factories, but I think that, if the Minister examines the lower end of the trade, that is, the garments which will not retail at a price higher than 25/-, he will find that these are practically unprocurable from Irish manufacturers and he will find that no dressmaker, working at home, could by handwork, produce it. It is purely a factory product and Irish manufacturers are not trying to produce it. They are avoiding it and trying to take all the middle-class trade, on which they can make a fair profit by getting a price from 35/- to 75/-.
Comment on this
What is the effect of this Resolution? Does it remove mops from the operation of the tariff?
Comment on this
I am surprised to find that, in regard to these excise duties on moneylenders, there is no differentiation between Irish-speaking and non-Irish-speaking moneylenders.
Comment on this
The Moneylenders Bill, lately under consideration, definitely introduced a policy of Gaelicising moneylenders and these excise duties offer an opportunity of giving that policy some assistance.
Comment on this
If the Deputy had really seriously considered this matter, he would have realised that a duty on Irish-speaking moneylenders would be an anomaly. The Irish speaker would not lend money; he would give it to you.
Comment on this
Reference No. 1 brings component parts of umbrellas other than those specified subject to duty. Reference No. 2 makes permanent a duty at present in force under an emergency order. With regard to Reference No. 3 it will be remembered that the duty on woollen cloth was 20 per cent. on cloth under 2/- per yard, and 30 per cent. on cloth over 2/- per yard. The point of difference is being brought down from 2/- to 1/3, so that the duty is now 30 per cent. on cloth over 1/3 per yard, and 20 per cent. on cloth under 1/3.
Comment on this
Might I remind the Minister that that touches on exactly the same problem that I mentioned a few moments ago? These cloths are used in the manufacture of the cheap type of women's underwear, and the Minister is now bringing these cloths under a duty of 30 per cent.
Comment on this
Cloth subject to duty and of a kind not produced within the country, required by the manufacturers of women's garments only, is permitted in free of duty under licence. We gave that concession to that particular trade as a means of fostering its growth here. The same concession is not given in respect of men's garments or other classes of garments, but, in respect of women's outer garments, cloth of that particular kind which is not produced in the country—cotton cloths—is imported free of duty. The change does not affect them.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would now explain to the House how he reconciles that with the policy of the Executive Council to decentralise industry? The factories are to get this cloth free of duty, but the rural dressmaker, who represents the most perfect form of decentralised industry, has to pay 30 per cent.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy misunderstands me. A great deal of the cloth used in women's garments is woollen cloth in respect of which there is no concession given at all. There is, however, in the manufacture of the other cheap garments, a cloth which is mostly cotton but which is subject to duty because it has some wool mixed through it. That cloth which is very cheap—it is sometimes 9d and 10d a yard—is allowed in free of duty. That cloth, I think, is not used and would scarcely be used by the home dressmaker. It is suitable only for factory production of very low-grade cloths.
Comment on this
The Minister may rest assured that no cloth coming into this country under 2/- per square yard was pure wool cloth. They were all adulterated more or less by cotton. They were mixed cloths known in the trade as woollen cloths and I think that, if the factor is to get the concession the Minister indicates he is to get, the Minister ought to consider the claims of the country dressmaker. It simply means that he is taking the business away from the country dressmaker. His eventual objective will be to wipe the country dressmaker altogether out of the cheaper end.
Comment on this
The class of goods I am referring to are not, and could not, be made by a dressmaker at all. They are a type of goods that can only be sold at the prices at which they are sold because of the fact that they are produced in huge quantities. They can cut out one hundred garments on one machine at the same time and sew them on the one machine in half-an-hour. It is that type of goods, which can be sold at that price because of mass production methods, that I am referring to but the type of garment that has to be made individually is the type that requires a somewhat different kind of cloth and in respect of which no concession is given.
Comment on this
With regard to Reference No. 4 which deals with saddlery and harness, these materials were excluded last year, under Section 9, from the tax in respect of woven tissues or blanketing for use in saddlery or harness work but saddlery and harness materials are now introduced in one or two sections in the Schedule to Resolution No. 11 and in the following Resolution 12. It is introduced there in sub-section (3) and I think I saw it somewhere else. The Minister probably knows that saddlery is a very important matter for horses. If the quality of the material be not up to the mark, they may possibly get sores. There must have been a reason for excluding it. Can the Minister tell us if there has been any expert examination of the quality of the material which shows it to be suitable? I do not remember that there is any tax on saddlery coming in here.
Comment on this
I know it is not, but it refers to woven tissues for use in saddlery and harness and, while there is no tax in respect of saddlery coming in here, if you are going to tax the material coming in or the local material is not suitable, it is a disadvantage to the harness makers here. The harness makers here are very expert. They make excellent saddles and other equipment for horses, and it would be a great pity to interrupt their business. Is the Minister satisfied, from any examination he has made, that the quality and price of this material are as good as that in use at present? I do not know but that they are using local material, but as it was excluded last year it must have been excluded for some reason. I have not heard that there has been any production of this particular quality of material that would be suitable for this trade.
Comment on this
In fact the exclusion was made in 1928 or 1929, when the duty on woven tissues was first imposed. Harness cloth was excluded at that time because the Irish woollen mills were not producing it at that time, but since then they have been producing it in first rate quality and in adequate quantity, so that the exclusion, which was agreed to in 1929, has now been removed and the duty on woven tissues has been applied to these cloths. The Deputy can be satisfied that there will be an adequate supply of them in first rate qualities.
Comment on this
One mill started and then another. I could not say when the first mill started, but there are a number of mills making it now.
Comment on this
The only change made in last year's Finance Bill was to increase the duty upon woollen cloth. The original woollen cloth duty was imposed in 1929, following a report from the Tariff Commission. Subsequently, a motion was brought forward excluding this cloth because, at that time, it was not being supplied by the existing mills. It is now being supplied by them.
Comment on this
Yes. We are hoping to export some of it. As regards Reference 5, these items are being removed from the furniture duty because they are already dutiable under other headings. Reference 6 provides for the granting of licences in the case of certain horse-drawn vehicles. During last year, some extraordinary types of horse-drawn vehicles were presented to the Revenue Commissioners. These vehicles were of a type that could never be made here and were for exceptional purposes. We have decided to introduce a licensing system in case there are any more of these unique vehicles offered.
Comment on this
One of them was a peculiar sort of watering cart. Reference 7 imposes on plough parts a duty which is already in existence under Emergency Order. Last year, we exempted plough parts from the duty then imposed. That led to wholesale evasion of the duty. There is now production here of plough parts for all makes of ploughs.
Comment on this
That repairs a drafting mistake in one of the Finance Acts of last year which left shaped parts of uppers free of duty although it was intended that they should be dutiable, as are other parts of shoes. Shaped parts of uppers were really duty free during the year. We kept that fact dark lest anybody should attempt to import them. They cannot do so now because the mistake has been rectified.
Comment on this
I move: "That the Dáil agree with the Committee in Resolution 12." Reference 12 makes fish paste and similar pastes subject to package duty.
Comment on this
A number of firms are manufacturing it. Reference 2 is consequential. As regards Reference 3, we have been giving to cap manufacturers free importation of cap cloth. We have decided to withdraw that concession. We find that some of the manufacturers are using imported cloth exclusively, while some are using as high as 50 per cent. of home-produced cloth. We have decided to withdraw the concession and to impose the woollen duty upon cap cloth, as upon other cloths, and thus encourage the use of Irish cloth. The duty payable is, in any event, trivial—20 per cent. On a yard of cloth costing 10d., only 2d. would be payable and out of that they would be able to make a dozen caps. As regards Reference 4, we exempted from duty last year, at the request of some Deputies, steel frames used for stained glass. These are now being produced here and, with the agreement of everybody concerned, the exemption is being withdrawn. Reference No. 5 is largely consequential on the withdrawal of the exemption from duty of saddlery and other cloths. In effect, it increases the duty on blankets and rugs from 20 per cent. to 30 per cent. Reference No. 6 doubles the duty on down quilts. Reference No. 7 has two effects. It makes greeting cards—Christmas cards and the like—subject to the stationery duty. It exempts from duty printed wax paper. We kept that duty on during the year and approached some firms with a view to having the work done within the country. No firm has yet started to do it. We have, therefore, taken off the duty, but we shall continue our efforts to get some firm to undertake the work, in which case the duty would be re-imposed.
Comment on this
Fifty per cent. full, with ten per cent. preferential rate. The first portion of Reference No. 8 is merely a matter of drafting. It exempts the articles set out from the cast iron duty because they are dutiable under another Reference. Paragraph (b) has the effect of making certain classes of pipes subject to duty. These articles can be made here although this change is mainly being made because of the evasion of duty on rain-water pipes. These were being imported as smoke pipes and ventilation pipes and were thus escaping duty. To bring that evasion to an end, it is necessary to make all these classes of pipes subject to duty. They are all being made here.
Comment on this
I move: "That the Dáil agree with the Committee in Resolution 13." Reference 1 imposes a duty on rear half-axles. Deputies will remember the discussion which took place in December last when the duty on motor chassis parts was removed. We kept the duty on certain assemblies of parts—work which was then being undertaken in the country. We have been looking into the matter since, and we have decided to keep the duty on rear half-axles which are also being manufactured here. This will not interfere with the policy enshrined in the Finance No. 4 Act, under which the duty on other chassis parts was removed.
Comment on this
With regard to the manufacture of rear half-axles, the people who will be making these axles will be the same people who are making the axles for ordinary carts.
Comment on this
No. The people who make these axles are engineering firms who grind cylinder blocks and do gear-transmission work. They are different from the coachbuilders who go in for cart axles.
Comment on this
The people who turn out cart axles are not coachbuilders, but foundry men. Representations were made that if a tariff were put upon axles and cart boxes, into which the axles fits, they could be made in this country. The result is that cart boxes are being manufactured here which are not up to specification. My experience is that it is impossible to get cart boxes which correspond with the specification. Anyone familiar with the trade knows that the difference of a fifteenth of an inch makes a cart box perfectly worthless. Has the Minister satisfied himself that the firms who will manufacture rear half-axles will be able to do so with that degree of accuracy which is necessary in an engineering job of that kind?
Comment on this
I am satisfied that the work is being done with reasonable accuracy, expedition and efficiency.
Comment on this
No. 3 refers to certain additions to the duty on brass goods. There are a number of changes in No. 4. The component parts of window shutters are being made subject to the same duty as window blinds. Deputies will remember that in the autumn of last year, after a great deal of persuasion, I removed the duty on extension ladders. I had hardly done so when two firms started to make them here. After leaving the Dáil on a Friday evening, having removed the duty, I found representatives of two firms in my office who proposed to make ladders here. There are two firms making ladders now and we are imposing the duty again.
Comment on this
Yes. The idea in imposing a duty on shaped flooring is to that such items are brought in as being subject to the duty on articles of wood. As we found it inconvenient to administer we repealed it. We then imposed a duty on specific wooden commodities. The list was not exhaustive. We tried to make it exhaustive and, in the period that has elapsed, we have had an opportunity of examining the matter further, and I am glad to say we are able to extend the list fairly considerably.
Comment on this
Would the Minister look at 34 and 45? For instance, take No. 34. May there not be serious difficulty about the definition of flooring?
Comment on this
Does the reference here mean a stretcher to carry a prostrate corpse or a stretcher to make shoes fit?
Comment on this
That is intended to cover box-boards. The duty which was imposed on parts of wooden boxes has been evaded by the importation of the wood roughly prepared, but cut to certain lengths, so that it has only to be sawn in two to become parts of a box. We are meeting that by imposing a duty on the boards. This catches box-boards.
Comment on this
I do not think so. We have gone into the matter. We do not catch any boards that we do not want to catch.
Comment on this
That is the difficulty. We may find subsequently that the Commissioners will apply this otherwise.
Comment on this
There is, in relation to this, a licensing clause, and if it is found that there is something we did not foresee—although we had an examination into it—the licensing provision would operate to deal with the difficulty.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister will not contend that the words are not open to question: "Boards and planks of soft wood, the minimum thickness of which does not exceed one inch"? These boards are generally 12x9x3. Are they not liable to duty?
Comment on this
Surely, as Deputy Good contends, that consists of 30 per cent. of the timber that comes in. I am referring to ordinary scantlings which are used by builders, 30 per cent. of which, at a conservative estimate, will be affected by this proposal. Does the Minister deem it prudent to do that in existing circumstances, in order to prevent the introduction of parts of boxes?
Comment on this
Yes. The wood to which Deputy Good refers has always been dutiable. It was made dutiable under the Act of last year as builder's woodwork.
Comment on this
I am talking of ordinary scantlings, 12 x 9 x 3 and sawn here. There are certain other classes of timber, some of which comes in as scantlings of less than one inch thick.
Comment on this
I have looked into the question. There is no reason why these should not be sawn here.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that this proposal is not going to create considerable confusion regarding timber supplies?
Comment on this
The Minister pointed out last year, when we had flooring under consideration, that he was prepared to allow rough boards in free, but that the preparation should be done here. In order to ensure that he put a heavy penalty on machine flooring. It strikes me now that a duty of 50 per cent. will be put on a commodity that was free last year, thus killing the other proposal.
Comment on this
I would like the Minister to clear up the situation, because it appears to be full of difficulties.
Comment on this
As I explained to the Deputy, the duty he has been talking of, that on parts, has been evaded by importers bringing in prepared wood, cut to lengths. It is necessary to prevent that type of evasion by imposing this duty. After examination and consultation we have satisfied ourselves that we have caught nothing we do not want to catch. Any wood subject to this duty should be subject to duty in order to get the work of preparation performed here.
Comment on this
But the Minister, in order to catch other people, may catch those it is not intended to catch. It was clearly expressed in this House, when the proposal was under consideration some months ago, that it was the intention to admit rough material free so that it could be prepared for the saw mills here. In order to catch box-makers the Minister may now tax the rough material. In his attempt to get the box-maker he is going to catch the rough commodity from which flooring is manufactured.
Comment on this
It may be much less. You can get three-quarter inch flooring and half-inch sheeting. They are all under an inch, and are imported in the breadth with the intention of getting certain workmanship done here. This is going to cut across the proposal.
Comment on this
The bulk of the wood that will come in for use by builders will not be subject to this particular definition. There is no question of that. If there is any type of wood that might be subject to this definition and that is required for purposes other than box-making, then the licensing provisions may be operated to permit it being imported free of duty. This duty in the main achieves our purpose, which is to prevent the importation of component parts of boxes, particularly egg-boxes.
Comment on this
I am not questioning the Minister, but I am questioning the method by which the intention is to be carried out. Where is there any limitation in the wording confining this to timber imported for box-making purposes?
Comment on this
Why? You have defined the dimensions of the wood. One way out of the difficulty would be to say: "boards and planks of soft wood, the minimum thickness of which does not exceed three inches by one inch." That might get over the difficulty. Personally, I think the Minister's attitude in regard to the component parts of egg-boxes is exceedingly silly, and will do very material injury to the egg trade. The egg-boxes at present manufactured from wood sawn in this country are by no means comparable to the egg-boxes that used to be manufactured from foreign sawn timber. I believe the Department of Agriculture knows that.
Comment on this
Then the Department seem to have changed their mind since I first knew them, if that is their attitude at the present time. If the Department knew anything about the egg trade they would make every effort to end this tariff. If the Minister knew anything about the egg trade he would put an end to the tariff immediately. Unless the Minister is going to create great inconvenience in the building trade generally, he ought to revise his definition of the timber he wants to catch under this Resolution.
Comment on this
The building trade will not be inconvenienced in the least. If there is any woodwork for which a special case can be made, the licensing provisions will be made available.
Comment on this
I may tell the Minister that the building trade is being very seriously inconvenienced at the moment by his tariffs. I suggest, where it is not his intention to add further difficulties to that large industry, it should be made quite clear in the Schedule. All I ask is that this expression be clarified so that we will not add further difficulties where there is no intention to do so. If the Minister will look into that point it will save a great deal of trouble to his own Department and to others.
Comment on this
It excludes road springs from exemption. They have been made subject to duty by agreement amongst all parties concerned.
Comment on this
There is a duty at the present moment on roofing felt. There seems to be no purpose in having it on roofing felt without having also a duty on damp courses. The duty therefore has been extended to cover damp courses.
Comment on this
The proposal sets out to delete the word "roof" and add the words "or as a damp course." Is it the intention to admit roofing felt and put the burden on to damp courses?
Comment on this
If the Deputy relates this proposal to the original proposition he will observe that it is purely a matter of wording.
Comment on this
It is merely giving effect to the Budget statement in relation to excess profits duty.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say if persons who initiated legal proceedings, as they had a perfect right to do under the law as it stood, will be indemnified in relation to any costs incurred? The law was in a certain position and under it they had the right to take these proceedings and they incurred costs. Now the Minister puts them out of court. I think it is grossly unfair and something should be done for those persons because they are deprived of their rights in regard to the costs they have incurred by the Minister's act.
Comment on this
The original intention of the Legislature in imposing excess profits duty was to impose it on the person or persons engaged in business at that time. So far as I have been able to examine the Act of 1915, in respect of which this duty first became chargeable, it is fairly clear the intention was to get the excess profits duty from the persons then owning and carrying on business. This particular amendment effects quite a different purpose.
Comment on this
The first portion of my remarks was directed to the Act of 1915—the substance of the Act. Reference No. 15 here seeks to alter that, but the person who is affected by the terms of the Act is referred to in No. 14:
that the charge of excess profits duty effected by Part III of the Finance (No. 2) Act, 1915, and the Acts amending or extending that Act was not repealed, prejudiced, or affected by Section 32 of the Finance Act, 1926 (No. 35 of 1926).
First, there is the principle I have stated, that it was the person carrying on the business at the time this imposition was made in the Legislature, who was affected. The terms of the 1915 Act are quite clear:
The duty may be assessed on any person for the time being owning or carrying on the trade or business or acting as agent for that person in carrying on the trade or business, or, where a trade or business has ceased, on the person who owned or carried on the trade or business or acted as agent in carrying on the trade or business immediately before the time at which the trade or business ceased,
Comment on this
I do not wish to interrupt the Deputy, but I should like to know are we discussing Nos. 14 and 15 together?
Comment on this
I think it would be better to discuss them together; 16 is different. There is a slight difference between 14 and 15.
Comment on this
I think if we decide the principle in 14 and 15, then 16 could be quite easily disposed of.
Comment on this
If my interpretation of that enactment is correct it would make the person carrying on the business now liable. We entered into possession of that asset under an agreement. That is the agreement which has been referred to by the Minister as the "Secret Agreement." When speaking of it as a "Secret Agreement" there has been no reference made to the advantages derived under that agreement. The final clause of that agreement gives us all the arrears of taxes due to the British Government in 1922. These were given to us. It is in respect of that agreement which the Minister and his Party refer to as the Secret Agreement that these moneys are being collected. Those moneys, such as they were, were due from persons owning the business. This amendment, if I interpret it correctly, alters the situation entirely, and it harnesses responsibility on any person who entered into possession of a business by purchase or by any other means, by bequest or anything else of the sort. That was not the intention nor the words of the Act which gave the right to collect this particular tax. Section 15 here states:—
(1) That sub-section (2) of Section 45 of the Finance (No.2) Act, 1915, shall be construed and have effect and be deemed always to have had effect as if the words "at the date of the making of the assessment" were inserted therein in lieu of the words "for the time being" now contained therein.
What is the meaning of that section? It has only one meaning, and that is that the persons who were originally legally responsible for the excess profits duty, which runs from that enactment of the 1915 Act, are not to pay, but their successors in title, without knowing what their liability was, must do so. Recollect it is 18 years ago, and they are having placed upon them a tax for which they were not liable at that period. If I am wrong let the Minister correct me, but I submit that is the meaning of this section. If it is not a question of changing, altering, amending or extending the imposition which is made by reason of Section 45 of the Finance (No. 2) Act, 1915, passed by the British Legislature, then I do not know what it is. If my recollection is correct, Section 32 of the Finance Act of 1926 was amended last year. It was amended to the disadvantage of the taxpayers liable under it. It read in any case as originally drafted and was law until last year:—
Subject to the provisions of this Part of this Act and notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in Section 39 of the Finance Act, 1921, no repayment or adjustment of excess profits duty may be obtained or made and no assessment or additional assessment to excess profits duty may be made after the 30th day of September, 1926, except in a case which is by virtue of this. Part of this Act deemed to be an undetermined case.
Apparently in any case which is not a determined case there was an end of it so far as excess profits duty was concerned. Anyone who is acquainted with business accountancy knows when you read of a case like that and take that as an undetermined case, you can go on with your business.
Comment on this
Except in a case which was deemed to be an undetermined case. I presume what that means is this: If Murphy & Company, Limited, were in business, and they had no notice in respect of assessments in respect of excess profits duty other than they had paid, and there was no case pending against them otherwise, if there had not been an assessment then that they might regard themselves as being immune and not liable to be assessed——
Comment on this
I am very much afraid that in the eyes of the Revenue Commissioners wilful neglect is equally serious with fraud. There is no difference between the two as far as Finance is concerned. They would be both offences. Fraud and wilful neglect will be regarded equally as offences.
Comment on this
That would be a matter for the Revenue Commissioners. I am quite sure they would not be long making up their minds on it. What they do, what they are empowered to do and all their authority is derived from this Act of the Oireachtas. They keep within this Act and they must keep within the law. They are liable to be tried before the courts for a breach of the law but they are not entitled to be brought before the courts on a question of fact. Whatever we do here, it is we who are laying down the law and everybody knows what the interpretation of that will be. Everybody knows what that Act of 1926 gave or granted. Fraud or wilful neglect in the interpretation of the Revenue Commissioners is the same thing. There is a bigger question as to the person who is liable for this excess profits duty. If I interpret this new change correctly the scope is extended. Persons succeeding by purchase or otherwise entering into possession become liable if these amendments are passed. This Section 14 says: "that the charge of excess profits duty effected by Part III of the Finance (No. 2) Act of 1915, and the Acts amending or extending that Act was not repealed, prejudiced or affected by Section 32 of the Finance Act, 1928." What is the meaning of passing it? What had the Legislature in mind when they enacted the original clause? They meant to do something. And we are told now, according to this amendment, that it was not repealed, prejudiced or affected by Section 32 of the Finance Act of 1926. So much for that particular aspect of the case.
Take the general question. Take this particular tax, started as far back as 1915. Take, as a standard year, 1913 or 1914. Now while a great many firms do keep their accounts in regular order, quite a number do not. To go back to that period of years now, particularly with a clause of this kind, is taxing business people in a way which, to my mind, is unreasonable. I mean a tax on their understanding rather than a tax on their pockets. Ordinary business accounts ought to be able to be closed from year to year. The Statute of Limitations runs as against individuals. It is not running here. As far as the State is concerned, it should be in no stronger position than an individual, and business accounts ought to be closed each year and people ought to know where they stand exactly with regard to their accounts. I do not know what sum of money is involved in this. No matter what the sum is, I submit that what the tax was originally conceded to be and accepted to be should not now be extended, eighteen years afterwards; that if there was a concession in the Act of 1926 it ought to be maintained rather than refused, and that business generally will be all the better for having these things more up to date in future.
Comment on this
It was apparently such a concession that it is now going to be withdrawn. Will the Minister tell us why that is—why he altered it last year?
Comment on this
Do I understand the Deputy to argue that there has been any change in the practice of the Revenue Commissioners in regard to the operation of that?
Comment on this
I do not know. I am not in the confidence of the Revenue Commissioners and I have not any responsibility for that. The Minister knows, and it is the Minister's duty to tell the House. The Revenue Commissioners, as I said, interpret the law as we make it. It is we who are making it and they have no option.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister a couple of questions. Before doing so, I might say that I cordially agree with Deputy Cosgrave that the Revenue Commissioners should not be exempted from the operation of the Statute of Limitations. I would remind the Deputy, however, that at one time he filled the high office of Minister for Finance in this State with distinction and I cannot remember his introducing legislation to bring the Revenue Commissioners within the operation of the Statute of Limitations. I think his name would go down to the posterity of the taxpayers in high affection if he had done it. I trust he will see, if he ever has the control of a Minister for Finance in future, that it will be done.
Comment on this
Might I correct the Deputy to this extent? We entered into the possession of certain arrears of taxes. They had not been paid, while other people had paid. That was ten years ago. I submit that a large amount of the arrears was collected in that time and we did not strain the law to get them.
Comment on this
The Deputy did not want to give the taxpayers the benefit of the Statute of Limitations until he was finished with them. However, that is by the way. I want to ask the Minister this: As I understand it, the excess profits duty was repealed in 1926. Is it still in force, so that any person in trade, making a profit greater than he made in the scheduled year, is still liable to excess profits duty?
Comment on this
Only in respect to the period to which the excess profits duty applies. That is between August, 1914——
Comment on this
From a certain year. Would a trader be liable to assessment for excess profits made in the year 1927?
Comment on this
For excess profits duty beyond 1921 the proposal is that, where a person bought a business that had outstanding on it a claim for excess profits duty that ought to have been paid prior to 1921, whoever owns the business is liable?
Comment on this
The contention raised in the courts has been that where a person was only the successor in the business since the liability for excess profits duty accrued, he was not liable and that the Revenue Commissioners ought to go after the man who owned the business when the duty became due. That is the contention raised in the courts.
Comment on this
It is apparently a question of considerable obscurity, and it is difficult to find out what the effect of this Resolution is.
Comment on this
At least I have no intimation that that point in fact has been raised in the courts.
Comment on this
It would be of material assistance to all of us if the Minister would state briefly what the position is. He referred in his Budget statement to his right to collect this being questioned, and said he proposed to make it clear. I think he might go further and give a short explanation of what the exact effect of this Financial Resolution is.
Comment on this
When this debate started on the Report Stage of the Financial Resolutions, I allowed considerable latitude, owing to the fact that there were schedules covering a number of articles. The two Resolutions now before us deal with a specific matter, and I intend that the ordinary rules of debate shall be followed; that is, that on the Report Stage a Deputy can speak once.