We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote 52—Agriculture.

Contributions 155–314 of 314. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Dr. Ryan

That was before they knew you.

Comment on this

To make wheat a success in this country we have to take the market that is there.

Comment on this

The Deputy is drawing on his imagination.

Comment on this

And he calls himself a success!

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy will not rise to the high flights of imagination to which he did yesterday. To get the market in our own or any other country we must produce for that market and while bread is made out of flour and flour is made out of wheat, it does not follow that every wheat that is grown is going to produce—cut out the intermediate stages—good bread, especially the bread the people are accustomed to now, and that is bakers' bread. On the previous occasions that I spoke on this matter I asked the Minister to mention one strain of wheat grown in this country that will produce a flour sufficiently rich in gluten to give us good bakers' bread. The Minister has not mentioned one. I can make the positive statement, without fear of contradiction, that there is not one that is economic.

Comment on this

What about Arthur Griffith!

Comment on this

Arthur Griffith is not a wheat.

Comment on this

Why does not the Deputy read "The Economic Salvation of Ireland" by Arthur Griffith?

Comment on this

I read it before the Deputy ever heard of Arthur Griffith.

Comment on this

Would you not eat the Irish wheat in '47? Would it be good enough to eat in '47?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies Hales and Donnelly are repeatedly interrupting and they will have to desist from now on. Deputy Belton will proceed.

Comment on this

In reference to that, I may say that the wheat grown here in 1847 was infinitely superior in baking quality to any wheat we have now. Furthermore, the bread then used was generally griddle or pot-oven bread. The bread that is generally used now is bakers' bread, and that makes a very great difference. If the Deputies opposite were sufficiently interested in this matter they would know that, when the Glasnevin plant-breeding section interested themselves in the propagation of old native strains of wheat, they introduced the old native wheat from Tipperary into Glasnevin Experimental College. That wheat was supposed to be the direct successor of the wheat that was grown there about 80 years ago and which was considered to be the best strain of wheat grown in Ireland at that time. When that was examined here it was found that the one sample contained 65 different varieties. That is where Irish wheat seed had deteriorated for want of proper attention. The Minister, I notice here, has neglected even giving the proper attention to that aspect of this important subject of agriculture, and the important subject of wheat growing.

I notice here that the Faculty of General Agriculture that has taken over the Glasnevin College proposes to spend £24,000 as against £23,700 last year. The most important branch of that Faculty is the plant-breeding branch, to which a lectureship only has been given and, apparently, there is no provision to be made under this for a professorship. I can speak with authority on that for, as a member of the governing body of the university. I was a member of the committee that drafted the statute of this Faculty. I did my best there to have a professorship of plant-breeding, but I failed. I was, however, responsible for a lectureship in agricultural engineering, but the post was not filled, and apparently the Minister is not going to fill it now. The Minister ought to know— it would not be much trouble to him to find out—that the growing of wheat is essentially a matter for the laboratory first. Good hard milling wheat will grow in any country and in any climate in the world, but the same strain will not grow successfully in every country.

I have here a pamphlet issued by the Dominion cerealist, L. H. Newman, Ottawa, Ontario, in which he traces the development of wheat growing in Canada. When it was attempted there first it was a failure both in yield and quality. The first success that attended wheat growing in Canada was with the production of a breed of wheat by David Fife, a cross between Indian, American and Siberian wheats. This produced a wheat that suited the soil and climate of Canada. The Minister laughs at that, but that canny Scotchman knew what he was doing. It is a pity the Minister has not a little of his horse-sense. If he had he would make progress slowly, and would not start breaking up good grass lands in order to grow wheat to feed pigs and cattle, the market for which the Minister has killed. The Canadian plant-breeding station bred a wheat that enabled them to grow an additional 15,000,000 acres. If I may instruct the Minister a little, here is the result of the Canadian venture:

"Assuming that Marquis now occupies 15,000,000 acres, or approximately 75 per cent. of the area devoted to wheat in Canada, and that this area yields five bushels more than Red Fife would have yielded (had it been possible to grow Red Fife on the same land) we find that our harvests have been increased by 75,000,000 bushels annually. In other words we are able to realise probably £100,000,000 more from our wheat crop annually than would have been possible had we still to rely upon the variety with which we started."

Perhaps the Minister will learn something from that.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

When was it written?

Comment on this

In 1928. In Canada they wanted a particular quality, and if they could not get that quality they knew wheat growing would not pay. The Minister has not a particular quality for the market here, and therefore his scheme could not be successful. If he had a strain which would give the desired quality, I would be as enthusiastic as he is himself. But he has not the necessary strain, and he is growing for the market something that the market does not want. In Canada they had a good strain, but they could not go any further north because it took Red Fife too long to mature. They had to get a grain that could be put in in the late spring, when the frost would be gone, and would mature in the early autumn before the frost would come again. They got that breed and the area was increased to 15,000,000 acres, with the added advantages I have read from the official pamphlet. The Minister is doing here what Canada would not do. I need not labour the point any further.

Take another aspect of this wheat experiment. It is necessary that the wheat product gives a good average yield and is of sufficiently good quality to produce the flour we want. The Minister knows that in this country we have to run over a six years' rotation. He knows that the best wheat crop is not all immediately convertible into human food. He knows that over the six years' rotation 80 per cent. of the entire production of the land is animal food; it must be used directly through the bodies of animals. He knows also that 80 per cent. of the produce of tillage land represents more animal food than 100 per cent. of the produce of the same land under grass; in other words, he is increasing the live stock carrying capacity of the land when he increases tillage.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is right.

Comment on this

It is well the Minister concedes that.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Why are your colleagues saying that I want to get away from live-stock?

Comment on this

We will tell you all about it later on.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It is time for the Deputy to make a speech.

Comment on this

I did not quite catch what the Minister said to me.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Why are the Deputy's colleagues always saying that I am trying to get rid of the live-stock of the country?

Comment on this

That is only one front on which to attack the Minister. I am afraid I will have to attack him on two fronts. Not only is the Minister's policy killing the live-stock industry, but it is going to kill the tillage industry as well. The Minister will concede from the rough data I have given him that 80 per cent. of the production of the rotation must pay its way, or else the whole rotation will be run at a loss. I wonder will the Minister deny that 80 per cent. of the rotation production will be animal food.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not agree with the six years' rotation at all.

Comment on this

What rotation does the Minister favour?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Four or five years.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not leave the land for at least a couple of years under rye grass meadow?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not count that in the rotation.

Comment on this

I have to learn something about rotation so.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

You have, and others must learn something about it, too.

Comment on this

No matter what rotation the Minister will approve of, he will hardly deny that approximately 80 per cent. of the entire production would be animal food. If 80 per cent. of the entire production is animal food it follows that to make the whole business a paying concern it is absolutely necessary that the animal food must be a paying proposition in itself. Is there any practical man in this country who will say that if we lose the English market permanently we are going to make the increased animal food production in this country a paying proposition? Eighty per cent. of the rotation which is set going by the Minister's scheme of wheat growing and producing wheat will mean 800,000 acres, and this will amount to an increase in tillage of 5,000,000 acres. And 80 per cent. of the production of the 5,000,000 acres will be infinitely more than 100 per cent. of the present grass production of the best land in the country. Yet the Minister has cut away the market to make live-stock production and the production of live-stock products profitable. How is he going to make a little bit of wheat profitable, when it is only 20 per cent. of the entire production? Even if that wheat were all of the best millable wheat, it could not be made profitable. It cannot be of the best millable wheat, because we have not the proper strain of wheat in this country to produce flour fit to make bakers' bread. But even presuming it was so, and that we have 80 per cent. of animal food, that will not pay.

Will tillage pay at £1 for lambs? Will it pay at the price at which eggs are sold as stated by Deputy Dillon to-day? Is not the Minister rushing headlong and bringing the country headlong into a swallow hole? He tells the farmers to till for the home market —for "the best market." If the Minister knew the tillage problem thoroughly and what intensive cultivation could produce he would know that the County Dublin and the County Meath would produce as much food as would feed every man, woman and child in the Free State. These two counties would suffice for that without going into any other county. I do not propose to go into the land policy nor to the acreage of farms. We are dealing just now with agriculture and the question of land is on another Estimate.

The Minister tells the people that we have the home market but I tell him again that if tillage in an intensified way is carried out in the Counties Dublin and Meath enough food would be produced to feed the whole population of the Saorstát, without any other county producing anything. Yet the Minister tells us that we are to increase tillage. The Minister and his colleagues say that they will take the land from the man who does not till. They are telling this to the poor "yahoos" at the cross-roads. Let the Minister tell it to the people in the Dáil.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

When the Bill comes in we will tell you what we will do and what we will till.

Comment on this

I have no doubt but the Minister would till the whole of Europe in a Bill but will he till it behind a plough? It is the easiest thing in the world to till on paper but it is another thing to get behind a plough and do it.

Comment on this

It is no use unless you reap.

Comment on this

I am afraid it is wild oats the Minister will reap this time. Deputy Hogan in the course of the debate pointed out that a case was made that the ordinary animals did not pay and he asked the Minister several times what new animals did he suggest would pay. I felt very much tempted to interject that if we import musk rats they would pay better——

Comment on this
A Deputy

Or asses.

Comment on this

It is too many of these we imported and it is a pity we did not realise it at the time. If we did we would be better off now. Deputy Hogan made a very good point a few minutes ago. I saw it in correspondence in the Press last January and February. It was then stated that the small farmers in the West of Ireland were never better off than now because they have plenty money. They are getting work on the roads from the Government. Yes, but the land is idle. I would strongly commend the Minister and his colleagues to read John Mitchel's "History of Ireland."

Comment on this

John Mitchel's "Jail Journal."

Comment on this

No, but John Mitchel's "History of Ireland." John Mitchel wrote there that from the siege of Limerick the British Government had devoted themselves to manufacturing paupers in this country. Well our Government is precisely at the same job to-day, manufacturing able-bodied paupers in this country.

Comment on this

Is the analogy complete?

Comment on this

Yes. Mitchel pointed out how roads leading to nowhere were built during the famine period. To-day our Government are straightening corners to nowhere. Last January they were at this work, but then the object of spending this money on the roads was a different one. There was a general election on the horizon——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not within the scope of this Estimate.

Comment on this

——The Minister has an Estimate for agriculture, and instead of attending to agriculture he is attending to the roads. My point is that it would be a saving to the country not to pass this Estimate for the Department of Agriculture. Instead, let the land run fallow. If I may use an old agricultural term it would be better really to let the soil of this country run fallow than to be putting in crops that will never come to maturity. We are growing beet, and we could buy sugar as cheaply if we did not grow it at all. Of course this beet is subsidising certain favoured counties, but getting the subsidy from other counties that get no benefit from it. A Deputy here said that the Government should do something for the dairying industry. Deputy Hogan went over the position of agriculture and spoke of the policy pursued. I wonder what people three years ago would think of that policy. Let us take the position with regard to butter prices. Take the constituency I represent, North Dublin.

Comment on this

North City!

Comment on this

I know more about North City than the Deputy knows about agricultural matters in Leix or Offaly.

Comment on this

This is the part of the city that raises the pigs.

Comment on this

Yes, and it makes sausages too.

Comment on this

North City?

Comment on this

Yes, and makes sausages successfully. I can see the friendship that has grown up between Deputy Briscoe and Deputy Harris. I am afraid it is a sausage friendship. North City feeds more pigs than any other area in the Free State except South City. Deputy Briscoe gets his votes there. Cork Street feeds more pigs than any other area of its size, but the Deputy does not know much about it. All he knows about Cork Street is when he is canvassing there. I do not canvass for votes in Cork Street. I go there to deliver them pig feeding.

Comment on this

And pig feeding does not pay according to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I represent North City and it is as natural for a farmer and a pig feeder to represent a city constituency as it is for a doctor to represent an agricultural constituency.

Comment on this

And the doctor is sitting next the Deputy on his own benches.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This has nothing to do with the Estimate.

Comment on this

I am replying to an interruption made by a more responsible member of this House than I am, an interruption made by a Minister and I want to emphasise to him that it is more natural for a farmer, a builder and a pig feeder to represent a city constituency than it is for a doctor to represent an agricultural constituency.

Comment on this

You have a doctor on your left.

Comment on this

In the constituency I represent the shopkeepers have to pay 48/- per cwt. for margarine, while we are delivering our butter to John Bull at 40/- per cwt.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We are not.

Comment on this

Would the Minister correct me?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I will.

Comment on this

I am afraid that the Minister's Party is a pro-margarine Party.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Is that why you left us?

Comment on this

The Minister will not deny that the basic price on which the British Government bases the tariff is 68/- per cwt.?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I will. Go up another bit.

Comment on this

Then he is denying the official reports of the British House of Commons.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do.

Comment on this

I am sure you would. In that frame of mind, I shall not carry on the argument any longer. If the Minister denies everything except what he thinks himself, there is no use trying to convince him. The official statement in the British House of Commons was that 68/- is the basic price on which the tariff is paid.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It is wrong.

Comment on this

There is 28/- taken off that, which leaves us 40/- per cwt. for our butter. There will not be a cwt. of butter let out to the citizens of Dublin under 133/- per cwt. wholesale, while, counting the transit and commission charges, the price received in Great Britain is 40/-.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is wrong.

Comment on this

That is all that comes here. In the City of Dublin the wholesale price of margarine at present is 48/-. I wonder what interest has the Minister and his Administration in margarine that the people whom I represent should be charged 8/- per cwt. more for margarine than we charge the British for Irish butter. I am sure that the dairying districts of this country do not want that kind of prosperity, because they know it cannot last. In addition, the Government is cutting the salaries and wages of these people and depriving them of Irish butter. They are forcing margarine on them, and that is the Party that was to give the El Dorado to the working man! As to the question of drainage of land, I have experience, as a member of a drainage board, of the difficulty of getting people to pay drainage rates.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is there any money provided in this Estimate for drainage?

Comment on this

It was news to me that it could be discussed on this Estimate, and when Deputy Dillon was speaking I raised a point of order, as I thought that it would come under the Board of Works. The Ceann Comhairle, however, said that it is not directly under either and that it could be discussed on either of them. Let us forget the economic position consequent on the economic war. There are just a few points that could be attended to and to which I would direct the Minister's attention. One is the Weeds Act. I think the Minister would be well advised if he could make the cutting of weeds simpler and more direct. I believe I am right in stating that the weeds inspector is appointed directly by the Minister's Department. I think it is an annual appointment, and very often he is not appointed in time. The Minister might consider the advisability of having that officer under the control of the Committee of Agriculture, say. I am not recommending it, but we have found that these inspectors are inclined to travel the main and trunk roads and forget that weeds grow on lands near the smaller roads. The matter would be worth consideration and, in considering it, it would be well if the Department got the opinion of county councils and county committees of agriculture to see how it works in the various counties.

As to drainage schemes, the method of working these schemes at present is hardly fair. I believe that two or three people can make an application to the county council to consider a proposed scheme for draining a district or area. The county council has not any discretion in the matter. They must act on the requisition of two or three ratepayers and they must have an inspection made by a competent engineer and a scheme drawn up, with the expenses, costs, and everything worked out. When the scheme is ready for putting into execution, it is discretionary with the people whose lands it is proposed to drain whether they will have the scheme carried out and foot the bill. If they say that they will not, the scheme falls to the ground and the county rates have to bear all the expenses incurred up to that. If the Minister takes up this matter, I suggest he should get the opinions of the county councils on it. My experience is confined to one particular county that may not be analogous to any other.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Does this involve new legislation?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It does not come under the Department at all.

Comment on this

That was my opinion, but the Ceann Comhairle said that this was duplicated by the Board of Works and by the Department and that he would allow the discussion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There have been a Minor Drainage Act and an Arterial Drainage Act passed. One gives certain power to the county councils, and the other is carried out through the Board of Works. If anything further is to be done in connection with drainage, other powers would have to be got, and that is suggested legislation.

Comment on this

I am not in a position to say whether this would require new legislation or not, but the Minister will know how far he can go without legislation. Horticulture should get more attention in this country. While I would agree in normal times, looking a bit ahead, with the policy adopted by the Minister in protecting the home market from the importation of horticultural produce, he did not help horticulture by putting up a protective barrier in a night. He did a lot of damage, a lot of harm, and a lot of injustice— I am sure without knowing it—to a very hard-working class of poor traders in the city. There is a big scope for horticulture here, in strawberries, raspberries, logan berries, currants and I might include also rhubarb. As the Minister will appreciate, there is no use in giving protection suddenly. He would want to have a policy working that would develop production, or have protection on a graduated scale over a number of years. With some fruits, such as apples, it should not be allowed to reach its maximum for seven or eight years. In the case of gooseberries it could reach its maximum in two years; in the case of strawberries it could reach its maximum in two years; and so on, according to the time it should take for the particular fruit to mature, so that we would be able to produce in this country a crop to meet our requirements by a certain time. When that time would be reached we should have our production at its maximum, so as to protect the growers. That would have to be accomplished through a well thought out scheme. There is plenty of scope for it, and plenty of people in the country who are prepared to avail of it. It only requires a little knowledge to save the thousands of pounds that annually leave this country to bring in forced rhubarb. It can be done in this country, and will be done when the dumping that has been going on here for years is stopped.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy woke up. I suppose, a Chinn Comhairle, it was because I was on a tart subject. This will have to be worked out by schemes carried through in a spirit of goodwill, and in a graduated way. Experiments have shown here that we can supply the market with rhubarb every month in the year, except two. Those two are October and November. In all the other months of the year it can be supplied. Normally it was dumped here from December until March every year, and sold much cheaper than it was sold in Covent Garden. Generally, the surplus that would rot in Covent Garden was dumped over here. While naturally I would be interested if protection came, I should like to warn the Minister, if he contemplates protection for the sake of the consumer, to give timely notice. If people went to him and asked him for a tariff on rhubarb next November, and he thought a case was made for it, and imposed a tariff in November——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Is the Deputy aware that there has been a tariff on rhubarb for 12 months?

Comment on this

He is waking up now.

Comment on this

He must not have made any money on it if he did not know it.

Comment on this

I did not get time to answer, but it will be interesting to the Minister to know that I, and not the Minister, was responsible for that tariff, because I was behind the deputation that put the case up to him.

Comment on this

Then why are you asking for it?

Comment on this

I am not asking for it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Why did you not come with the deputation?

Comment on this

My idea went, and it was better. I was glad the Minister acted on it, because if I went in person he would not have acted on it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Oh, now I see!

Comment on this

So my absence did more than my presence would have done.

Comment on this

Pity you would not apply that here!

Comment on this

I hope my presence here will have the effect which the Minister suggested it would have if I had gone with that deputation. On behalf of the growers, I thank the Minister for having imposed the tariff, although unfortunately I had no forced rhubarb last year, which has not been the case for a number of years. I want to advise the Minister, so that he will not make a false step. I want him to understand that I am not speaking politically. If representations were made to him to impose a tariff, say, next November, and that is not his fixed policy up to this, he should be very careful about it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

There has been one.

Comment on this

And is it continuously running?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes.

Comment on this

That is all right then, because that is a sufficient warning to people who produce for the market.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The deputation must not have reported back to the Deputy.

Comment on this

Not being interested at the time, from the point of view of my pocket, I did not retain all the information, but I can assure the Minister that I would make sure how the land lay before I would fill my house with rhubarb to force. I have got my information from the Minister and will pass on.

Comment on this

I hope you will do well now.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy it is a better-paying job than making sausages. I will not tell the Deputy how paying it is, for fear he might enter into competition.

Comment on this

I am glad you recognise that you are inferior to somebody.

Comment on this

Is there a tariff on sausages?

Comment on this

I do not think there is much more to say on the subject, considering we have no market in which to sell our products. There is nothing else left to be said. We could make a lot of useful suggestions if we could find a market.

Comment on this

If we could get a market for our talk we would be better.

Comment on this

Then I would have a fair return, but I am afraid the Deputy opposite would not only have to tighten his belt but he could put it around him five or six times. There is one thing he does not do here, and that is talk on behalf of his constituents.

Comment on this

I am glad that Deputy Belton is sitting down. I have no doubt but the position of agriculture generally is very serious. When we look at those countries that have the full advantage of the British market, the more we think of their position to-day and the more we think of ours the more we admire our Minister for Agriculture. I will read for the House from "Our Scottish Letter" in the "Farmer's Gazette" of May 27th, of this year. Here is what it says:—

"No real improvement is visible in the farming industry. There is a feeling of hope in the future but that is about all that can be said. Faith and hope have kept the courage going of many farmers for several years past, but all the time their pockets were being emptied instead of being filled. It has been a case of motion without progress. Those engaged in agriculture have come through the crisis and crash of prices with a tenacity peculiar to the Scottish farming race. They are not yet out of the wood. The worst fright may still be strong about them. They do not see how direct benefit is to come to the industry by trade agreements with foreign countries and with home marketing schemes.

In the great oat-growing County of Aberdeen this grain of the very best quality is selling at 4/8 per cwt."

I wonder whether Deputy Hogan, when he complains of 8/- a barrel here, knows that they are getting 4/8 per cwt. in Scotland where they have a complete free noble John Bull market open to them.

These figures are 78/- per qr. below the cost of production. "The number of unemployed" we are told in this report, "on the land is largely increasing. Wages have been cut and economies effected in every department of farming. The labour bill is still a serious item of expenditure on farms when compared with the income from grain and live stock. Farmers are doing with a man less and in many instances they are doing away with a pair of horses. This means that more land is going back into grass, and that is not a good thing for the prosperity of the industry or the country. Mechanical traction is also doing away with horses and men. If agriculture got a fillip and was set on the road of prosperity it would absorb more unemployed men than any other industry in Great Britain."

Comment on this

What about the Free State?

Comment on this

The paper continues: "No Government should neglect its food producing industry, and it is only natural that the people of a country would thrive best on the food produced in their own country." It goes on to state: "Garbity Shorthorn dispersion last week made a remarkable contrast in result to the one that took place on the same farm 13 years ago. The top price at Mr. McWilliam's sale last week was 42 guineas; when his father's sale took place in 1920 it was 2,200 guineas. The total amount realised 13 years ago was over £28,000; the other day for a greater number of animals it was under £800."

Comment on this

And no economic war between England and Scotland!

Comment on this

These are in brief the facts in Scotland where they have a free market, namely the British market, at their very door. That is the market where they are compelled to sell their oats at 4/8 per cwt., and where the price of cattle has gone down from £28,000 to £800. That is the market, which, if the Deputies opposite had their way, we would pay five millions a year for. We have the fact now that Deputy Belton has joined the ranks of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. He told us here to-day that his policy is wheat growing. If he believes in wheat growing, and if it should happen that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party should come into office, which God forbid, would Deputy Belton come in under a Minister for Agriculture that would prevent wheat growing?

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, I shall support and defend wheat growing for this country when we breed the kind of wheat that is suitable for the soil and climate of this country and rich enough in gluten to produce a good loaf. That point has not been reached yet, and I challenge the Minister to say that it has.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton was talking long enough already; I grew wheat from 1918 to 1926, and made it pay, and am growing it again this year and it will be better than ever. I know what I am talking about. Deputy Belton was talking about a particular strain of wheat—Red Stettin wheat. He knows that the Red Stettin we have in this country would not pay any farmer to grow. I tried it, and I know the result. I am as good a farmer as anybody.

Comment on this

That does not meet my point.

Comment on this

But you are all points and you have already been talking long enough. Deputy Hogan said that the Department of Agriculture was following the same policy all the time, and that there is no change between the policy of the last Minister and the present one. If we followed the policy of the last Minister there would not be a creamery left in this country to-day. He voted against the stabilisation of butter produce. The price that the Irish farmer would get for milk to-day, if the ex-Minister for Agriculture was still in office would be 2½d. per gallon. Let us face the real facts. Deputy Hogan also made another case. You can never hold the market here as a market gardener and a farmer. I tried it here once and failed and I have benefited by my failure. Deputy Hogan repeated here to-day the tale of woe he gave us some six months ago. I did not think I would have the pleasure of hearing him repeat that statement so soon. It will be found in volume 44, column 991. Here it is—the statement of the greatest Minister for Agriculture in Europe. He said: "Just before I left office, however, I was coming to the conclusion and my experience since then has strengthened that conclusion, that the Live-Stock Breeding Act, as it is operated, is operating against the dairy cow and in favour of the beef animal. I think if it is operated as it is being operated at present, without making some attempt to encourage milk as against beef, that in a comparatively short time you may find yourself with magnificent looking cows, very fine cattle and pigs but that it will be extremely hard to get a good looking dairy cow in this country."

That is a statement made by the ex-Minister for Agriculture. That is the same Minister who brought in the Act of 1925 and kept it going until 1931 when he was put out of office. He is the Minister who kept it going and paid for it and made the people pay for it as well.

Comment on this

Is not that Act in being at the present time?

Comment on this

I am giving the Minister's condemnation of his own Act. I am stating that the farmer Minister for Agriculture kept that Act going, compelled farmers to license their bulls and paid something like £7,000 a year as a minimum to his inspectors from 1925 to 1931. Now he has the impertinence to stand up here, after he has been put out of office, and say that as a result of his bringing this Act into operation, the effect is that there is not a good milch cow left in the country.

Comment on this

Are these inspectors there at present?

Comment on this

You are too found of crying. I will give you a chance in a moment. You are always crying here while I am speaking. Now, that has been the effect. I say this much, that I agree with Deputy Hogan on that particular point. I entirely agree with him, and I put it up to our Minister for Agriculture that if he is going to spend this year £24,898 on the improvement of milk production, if he is going to give grants to the county committees of agriculture of £80,000, and going to pay at the same time £3,275 for the operation of the Live-Stock Breeding Act in this country, he cannot have the two together, and one of the two has got to go.

Comment on this

Which of them should go?

Comment on this

The Live-Stock Breeding Act should go. We have the experience here of a lawyer Minister for Agriculture who tells us that he has had the experience of seven years of it and that after seven years of that policy he has ruined the milk trade of the country. They are his own words. I have dealt with one change of programme that our Minister for Agriculture has brought in, and that, at least, has prevented the dairying industry of this country from being wiped out. If the last Minister for Agriculture had been here for the last 12 months there would not be a creamery running in this country to-day.

Comment on this

Prove it.

Comment on this

The proof was there that Deputy Hogan walked into the Lobby and voted against the Bill that increased the price of farmers' milk from 2½d. per gallon to 4d.

Comment on this

Out of the taxes of the country.

Comment on this

You want to have it both ways.

Comment on this

That was the first change. Now I come to the second change. When I was over there on those benches for four years I kept appealing to the then Minister to put a tariff on foreign barley. I was sneered at. We were told that Guinness's Brewery would go if there was a tariff put on foreign barley. A tariff has been put on foreign barley and, in addition, a home market was provided for our home barley, as a result of which we got this year an increase at the minimum of from 4/- to 4/6 per barrel on our barley over and above what we would have got if the last Minister for Agriculture had been still in office. We also got a market for our oats despite what Deputy Hogan says about the man who sells it to-day. The man who kept oats from October until to-day must be one of those who refused to pay his land annuities, or he must not be any one of those distressed farmers about whom Deputy MacDermot is always talking, because no distressed farmer would keep his oats in the loft from November until June. I sold my oats this year at £6 15s. a ton at the very time when the price of the best of white oats in the English market was £4 10s. a ton. In other words, I got £2 5s. a ton more for my oats than I would have got with the free market that all the talk is about. Deputies should face facts. And these are facts. In Scotland also, where there is no 40 per cent., in the great oat-growing country of Aberdeen, grain of the very best quality is selling at 4/8 per cwt. That is the price of oats. Deputy Hogan complained a while ago because they can only get 9/- a barrel here.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy aware that in many parts of the country it is impossible to sell oats at any price?

Comment on this

I suggest to Deputy MacDermot that he should have some land himself, and know something about it before he talks on the subject. The Deputy is completely out of touch with the farming community, and if anything proves that it is the Deputy's bewailing the state of the farmer who cannot sell oats in June that he harvested last September. I harvested last September and I had no trouble in getting over £2 more for my oats than I would have got with the free market. And if I had sold it a week sooner I would have got £7.

Comment on this

If it was all sold what are we to do now?

Comment on this

The Deputy has a complaint on the brain. We come now to a subject on which Deputy Belton is particularly interested. I am sorry that Deputy Dillon is not here to hear all about it for both these Deputies spent a whole day here telling us about pigs.

Comment on this

About what?

Comment on this

I do not know that I mentioned that at all.

Comment on this

Yes, you did. You spoke here for an hour and three-quarters the same day all about pigs and curling their hair and manicuring their toe nails.

Comment on this

He was talking for export.

Comment on this

In 1931 there was imported into this country £1,852,000 worth of pig meat. In 1932, the first year in which we took office, £1,145,000 worth of pig meat was imported. That is, £707,000 worth of a market kept here for the Irish farmer. If we take the first three months of this year and compare them with the first three months of last year, we find that for the first three months of last year 366,000 cwts. of pig meat were imported and for the first three months of this year 363,000 cwts were imported. That was a market of 3,000 cwts. for the Irish farmer.

Comment on this

What were the relative figures?

Comment on this

I will give the Deputy all the relative figures he wants. Perhaps I will give him more than he wants. The average price of pigs last week was 51/- per cwt. and the average price for the corresponding week last year was 49/—economic was, 40 per cent., and everything else.

Comment on this

What is the average price for six months? (interruptions.)

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I had to appeal for order for Deputy Belton when he was speaking.

Comment on this

We are only asking for information.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton is always at it. Deputy Corry's common sense and knowledge are too much for them.

Comment on this

I am giving the exact figures for the benefit of this House. I say that our Minister for Agriculture preserved a market worth well over £1,000,000 for our farmers in the last 12 months in pigs alone, and that despite that fact, and despite the 40 per cent. and all the rest of it, the price of pigs this week is 2/- per cwt. higher than the price was this time 12 months ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

And potatoes £1 per ton.

Comment on this

Are you starting now? I shall have a few nice facts for you, too. I have dealt with butter produce. I have shown that the difference in the policy of our Minister for Agriculture and the policy of his predecessor in the Cumann na nGaedheal Government has been to the advantage of the dairy farmers. I have dealt with oats and barley. I would like to deal with wheat, since Deputy Belton is so anxious about wheat. The world price of wheat is about £6 or £7 a ton. I know that in 1926, when I gave up growing wheat, the price of the best wheat was between 6/- and 7/- a cwt. We are guaranteeing a price of £9 15/- a ton.

Comment on this

Out of our own pockets.

Comment on this

My dear man, you never had anything in your damned pocket, and what are you talking about? Deputy Hogan does not agree that we can produce suitable wheat in this country. I do not know what are the views of the other lawyer-leaders of the farmers, but Deputy Belton at least believes in wheat. We taught him that much.

Comment on this

I taught some members of the Fianna Fáil Party that much.

Comment on this

Short and all as was your stay, you learned something. Those matters are of very grave importance to the working farmer, who tills his land and provides employment; to the milking farmer in County Limerick and the tillage and dairy farmer of East Cork, who produces grain and wants a price for it, and who has cows and wants a price for their milk. I have no sympathy with the rancher. The sooner he gets out of ranching and the land is divided amongst other people the better for everybody. Possibly Deputy Belton visualises himself as a Minister for Agriculture if the Cumann na nGaedheal Party ever get back; but I would not give three farthings for their chances. It all depends on whether he will stop with them long enough. I do not think he will.

Comment on this

He might be a Minister to-day if he stayed where he was.

Comment on this

We hear a lot of talk about the price of cattle and the effect of the 40 per cent. tariff, and we hear a lot also about the great English market. Again I must have recourse to the farmers' bible, the "Farmers' Gazette." In the Scottish news we see that a gentleman who a few years ago got 2,220 guineas as a top price has now received as top price 42 guineas. We read of one sale where a man realised £28,000, and out of far more cattle this year he got only £800. Those are facts that Deputies opposite should remember. I suggest to Deputy MacDermot that he should leave us as an apostle, and go over to the Scottish farmers and endeavour to convert them. When he tells them about the 40 per cent. and how happy they should be and what this great market would be worth to them, I doubt very much if he would get them to pay £5,000,000 a year for it.

We heard Deputy Hogan and other Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies complaining about the terrible conditions following the English tariff. Deputy Hogan knows that from 1924 to 1931 the price of our agricultural produce in the English market dropped to the extent of £13,000,000. He knows that in the 12 months from 1930 to 1931 the price we got for our agricultural produce in the famous English market dropped by £6,000,000. Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies have got up one after another like unconverted heathens. On behalf of the ordinary working farmers I wish to thank the Minister for Agriculture for the efforts he has made to improve conditions. He has done a lot for the dairying farmer who is in a position to employ labour and who is now, thank God, owing to the Minister's policy, getting a price for what he produces.

Comment on this

A voice crying in the wilderness.

Comment on this

It is a voice that, despite all the machinations of the Centre Party at the last General Election, got me 11,000 votes, more than all the members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party in the constituency.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

Will the Deputy thank the Minister on behalf of the small farmers for the 12/- duty on lambs?

Comment on this

As far as lambs are concerned——

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

The Deputy knows nothing about them.

Comment on this

He is one himself.

Comment on this

I do know a lot about them. I will give the Deputy the price of lambs in Scotland.

Comment on this

They were 25 cents in Canada.

Comment on this

I got 25/- each for 40 of them.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

40 lambs on 300 acres!

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must be allowed to make his case without further interruption.

Comment on this

I move to report progress. I will tell Deputies about lambs the next day.

Comment on this