Land Bill, 1933—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 126–297 of 297. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 33 of 1933 ›
Interruptions do not take the slightest effect on me, good or bad—not even interruptions from Deputy Corry. Even though Deputy Corry did make a wonderful speech at Mylerstown in which, during the by-election of 1932, he pointed to large areas of land and stated that he would have all the landless men around that area placed there within six months, yet nothing has happened.
Comment on this
If there are any more interruptions the Chair will take serious notice of them. Some interrupters are experienced enough to know that they should not interrupt.
Comment on this
Well, a Chinn Comhairle, the case I am making is raising the ire and the wrath of some Deputies on the far side through which there would be a danger of their being suspended. I will conclude by saying that this Bill gives really enormous power by reason of the fact that the Department can take action and the Minister can take action if a farmer is complained of to the Ministry as not giving proper employment. If he is not running his farm to the satisfaction of certain agitators they can turn around and say that his administration can be better done by somebody else. That is a position in which political action can be taken, and the local Fianna Fáil club can make things very difficult for ordinary people. I quite imagine that if John So-and-So, who is a supporter of the Centre Party, is complained of he will not get a very sympathetic investigation. If he is a Cumann na nGaedheal supporter he will probably go out within 50 days. That is the whole danger of the Bill. We heard enough in other directions such as: "If you do not join a Fianna Fáil club you will get nothing. Unless you join a Fianna Fáil club there will be no influence used in your favour and all influence will be thrown in against you." Now it will get to this stage, that it can be said: "if you want to retain your holding you must come and join a Fianna Fáil club; then they will throw in their weight behind you and everything will be all right." That is what it is coming to. Deputy Corry knows how to play that very well. He is doing it all day long. However, I will not try to get him into trouble. A Chinn Comhairle, as I am rather disposed to be too aggressive to Deputy Corry, I think I will sit down.
Comment on this
I wonder what has come over the Opposition during the past hour. It is a full hour or more since we heard either the word "Communism" or "Bolshevism" or "Socialism," and I am sure everybody must have been surprised. Certainly some of us were relieved at the interruption of the monotonous regularity with which speaker after speaker in the Opposition was repeating those words, relieved that they had found something else to talk about. There was not displayed indeed a tremendous knowledge of Bolshevism or Socialism on the part of many speakers. I think the views of those who were taunting the Government about Bolshevism and Communism and so on were not altogether identical as to what those words mean. Deputy MacDermot, for instance, yesterday evening referred to the Bolshevist drive behind this Bill. Then he went on to talk about his idea of what would be right for the State. He had no objection whatever to the biggest farm so long as the owner made proper use of his farm. In that he seemed to me to be approaching very near to Mr. Stalin's idea of the use of land. Mr. Stalin does not mind much either, I understand, as to the size of the farms in his country. Mr. Stalin's principal idea is as to the use of the land.
Comment on this
And, like Deputy MacDermot, Mr. Stalin, so far as we hear from him, does not object at all to the land being worked by a proletariat population. Deputy O'Sullivan seemed to sympathise yesterday evening with that view of Deputy MacDermot. It is not so long, however, since Deputy O'Sullivan was taunting the Government with proletarianising this State. One of the most serious faults he had to find with last year's Budget was that it was proletarianising this State. To emphasise this objection, I remember, he quoted a statement from a friend of his in Germany, who told him that one of the biggest losses which Germany had suffered through the recent troubles in that country was the disappearance of the middle class. He warned this Government that in proletarianising the people they were running the risk of bringing about a state of affairs that had meant great loss and harm to Germany. Yet to judge by Deputy O'Sullivan's attitude yesterday evening when Deputy MacDermot was speaking, and to judge by his attitude now, he does not at all object to a system of land ownership in which the great bulk of the workers would be proletarians. Taking a different view, however, the Government are endeavouring to settle people on the land, and—it does not matter whether they are Fianna Fáil or Cumann na nGaedheal—they will be the real bulwark against Communism in this country.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy will allow me to explain what I meant by referring to Bolshevistic sentiments behind this Bill. I meant not any particular theory in society. I meant a frame of mind based upon class hatred. That is what I call a Bolshevist system.
Comment on this
That is a very narrow definition of Bolshevism. When a Deputy mentions Bolshevism the ordinary person visualises a proletarian State where there is no personal property. Remember that Deputy MacDermot's example was followed by several other speakers to-day—I had almost said that his example was preceded by several other Deputies yesterday. At all events, it is quite evident that the word has been very loosely used. Is it fair of Deputy MacDermot, knowing that the word "Bolshevist" is a particularly opprobrious epithet in a country like this, to use the word in that narrow sense and to let it appear in the Press that he associates this Government with Bolshevist economics?
Comment on this
Class hatred is a thing that is very rare indeed. It is, so far as most of us can see, practically unknown in this country.
Comment on this
If Deputy MacDermot has found it, he must know the country a lot better than some of us. I have not seen any signs of class hatred, and I think that Deputy MacDermot in accusing the Government of being influenced by Bolshevist sentiments, and the attempt he made now to prove that he meant it only in that narrow sense, cast a big reflection on himself. His words have been reported to-day in the Press. His words have gone to every part of Ireland and the people have seen that the leader of a big Party here says that this Government is actuated by Bolshevist sentiments. He says now "I was not thinking at all on the lines that the Government was in any way inclined towards depriving the people of their property or in any way inclined to create a proletarian State. I was only thinking that the Government was influenced by class hatred". I wonder what interpretation the average reader of the Irish Times to-day put on Deputy MacDermot's words?
Comment on this
The Deputy might realise that if I had meant "Communist" I would have said "Communist". Everybody knows what Communism is. I did not use the word "Communism".
Comment on this
On that point—a very educated Deputy spoke two or three hours ago from the Opposition Benches, a Deputy who, one would think, should have better sense, in view of the prominent association, and the very creditable association, of his father with land reform in this country and with very radical ideas of land reform. He referred to the Communist red flag and the Bolshevist red rag apparent in this Bill so that evidently the words are interchangeable, so far as an educated Deputy, like Deputy Davitt, is concerned. In the course of his speech also, Deputy MacDermot said that if people are not making proper use of their land, the position should be left to time, that not many years will elapse before they will have to disappear, because their means will go. Does Deputy MacDermot think that if he were in the President's chair at the moment, in the present state of this country, with so many thousands of people growing up on farms, with no other prospect in life but farming, and who want homes for themselves, he could afford to adopt that attitude? Would he tell the country from his position as Leader of the Government "I am not prepared to take any action whatever with regard to the thousands of acres of land that are not being properly used at the present time. I am going to leave that to the natural working out of events. I am going to leave it to be accounted for by natural cause and effect"? I do not think he would, and, when Deputy MacDermot advocates such a line as that, he is, in my opinion, inviting Bolshevism in this country.
Comment on this
I am sorry to say I cannot accept the Deputy's denial of that, because I have his words noted.
Comment on this
We can see, when the Official Report appears, whether the Deputy said that or not, but the Deputy will admit, I think, that he said that this was an untimely period for this Bill——
Comment on this
I said that, in principle, I agreed that if land was being used in an anti-social manner the State had a right to interfere, subject to safeguards. I said that, but I said that at the same time, the Fianna Fáil Party, in my opinion, did not take sufficient account of the fact that very often natural economic forces were sufficient to cause the disappearance of lazy and incompetent farmers.
Comment on this
I shall have to leave it at that, naturally. I could not attempt to contradict the Deputy without having the printed report before me, but we will see by the printed report whether that is so or not.
Comment on this
I do not think it is, because I took particular notice of what the Deputy was saying. The Deputy will admit, at any rate, that he said that the present period was untimely for this Bill and that in view of the present state of farming and in view of the bad prices that prevailed for farmers' produce, the land question should be left alone. I wonder if a person who was anxious to save this country from Bolshevism or from revolutionary sentiment would seriously say that? If the Deputy wants us to believe that he is really and seriously concerned to keep Bolshevism out of this country, expressions of that kind are hardly the stuff to convince us that that is his position or that he has given the subject much attention. If he thinks that you can allow the congested areas to remain as they are, where, in the past three or four years, thousands of young men have grown to manhood without an earthly prospect in life, on the one hand, and, on the other hand, that you can have, within 25 miles of Dublin, one man owning five farms and not one acre of the five farms, amounting altogether to something like 400 or 500 acres, tilled, with very few cattle on them and with only one man engaged for the five farms, he is living in a fool's paradise. People do not lightly put up with these things.
There have been a great many sneering references to the activities of Fianna Fáil clubs, but when the Fianna Fáil clubs see that state of things prevailing around them, and when the young men who desire to change that state of things, who say it is wrong that people should be living on the hills or merely existing, while land is treated in that indifferent way, while it is left unproductive like that, giving neither employment nor producing corn or produce of any kind, but used only for grazing a few bullocks, see that state of things and urge the Government to change it, they are doing good social work. They are doing much better work than the people who have made the outlandish and ridiculous speeches that have been made on this Bill in an effort to show that we stand for the taking over of the land of hardworking farmers. If this Bill threatened the security of a single farmer in this country——
Comment on this
——who is making any good use of his land, there would not be six people in the Fianna Fáil Party to vote for it.
Comment on this
There is no intention whatever of interfering with the land of any man who is making proper use of his land.
Comment on this
There is the intention to take over farms, such as the farms I mention, where one person is in occupation of five or six farms, which are not being tilled and which are not giving employment, and the land of which is unproductive. There is no intention of leaving all that land in that person's possession, and there is not a Deputy in the House but knows that, in its present state and with the lack of employment there is, the country could not afford to look on while that sort of thing prevailed.
Comment on this
The question of safeguards has been argued. Deputy Dillon knows that there was no safeguard for the past ten years.
Comment on this
On a point of order, for our future guidance if a Deputy states deliberately that black is white, is he entitled to state that without contradiction from another Deputy in the House?
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot opened his speech with a tribute to Parnell, a tribute which he has often paid before. We were told by Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, I think, that in Parnell's time the big farmer was regarded with just the same respect as the small farmer and that the Party made no distinction between the big farmer and the small farmer, that they had as much regard for the big farmer and his rights as they had for the small farmer. In that connection I must call attention to this: if in Parnell's time it did not matter what size a farm was so long as it was properly worked, I wonder why it was that an effort was made, a successful effort, to pass the Labourers Act, which not merely provided a house for the labourer but gave him the ownership first of half an acre and, later on, of a whole acre of land? If Parnell attached no importance to the ownership of land why did he and his Party make an effort to secure land for these men? Deputy MacDermot and Mr. Parnell did not think exactly on the same lines in regard to this question.
Mr. Parnell and, I think, every Irish Leader always had in mind—and I think Deputy MacDermot will find that those throughout the country who are most anxious to safeguard this country are of a similar opinion—a position in which the main population of the country will be a population of substantial middle-class farmers, not owning an excessive amount of land but at the same time in possession of what are generally called economic holdings. In my experience that is the general outlook, and the Government, in passing this legislation, are interpreting that general outlook. I have personally no objection to a big farm so long as it is properly used, and there are big farmers in the country who have made such good use of their land that I would be very sorry to see them deprived of any part of it. One, however, cannot guarantee that on such big farms the maximum number of labourers will be always kept in employment or that there will be no desire amongst these labourers to own some land themselves. Many other countries have had to pass legislation similar to this. Hungary, which is probably the most conservative country in Europe, has been faced with this problem within the past half-dozen years. They went so far as to divide the land into minute farms, so minute that they are now faced with the problem of reuniting them.
Comment on this
However, I think all these questions have been already sufficiently argued. I desire to put one or two special points before the Minister. There is no provision in the Bill with regard to sporting rights. I want to know does the Minister not think that such a big question as that should be settled without delay? Is he satisfied that no particular legislation is necessary with regard to the question of sporting rights? Most Deputies are no doubt aware that under the first Purchase Acts, when sales were arranged by voluntary agreement, in most cases the landlord got the sporting rights. Afterwards, certainly under the 1923 Land Act, sporting rights were retained by the Land Commission. I understand that in the case of lands vested in recent years sporting rights have been vested in the tenants. That is obviously not a proper position in which to leave such a big question as the sporting rights. You have on some estates three different systems; certainly you have two. Where part of an estate was sold by voluntary agreement you have the sporting rights reserved to the landlord, and in another part of the same estate which has been sold compulsorily you have the sporting rights vested in the tenant. It is quite obvious that you cannot have contentment where you have two persons living side by side when the landlord or his friends are entitled to trespass on the farm of one of these persons and is not entitled to go in on the other farm. At all events, it is a very big question to be left in that unsatisfactory position.
There is another aspect of the case to which I should like to call the Minister's attention. I understand that where grazing rights exist on hills, that is, where they are shared by a number of people, it has been the practice of the Land Commission to purchase only the grazing, leaving the ownership, and consequently the sporting rights, in the hands of the landlord. That system prevails in the vicinity of Blessington in regard to the hills in that district. I should like to remind the Minister that it was not merely land reform the people had in mind when they were agitating to get rid of landlordism. They wanted also to get rid of the landlords. The people will try to prevent the landlords, their friends or agents, from shooting over these lands if the Government are not prepared to take action. I would ask the Minister, when he is replying, to state whether he intends to nationalise the sporting rights or by what method he proposes to deal with the question.
There is just another matter that, perhaps, might be more appropriately mentioned on the Committee Stage, but as I have a note of it here I should like to bring it to the Minister's attention now—that is with regard to the £2,000 limit, which is the central point in the Bill. In view of the currency fluctuations that prevail at present, and in view of so much talk of probable big changes in the currencies of all countries in the immediate future, it might be well to insert a safeguard in the Bill in regard to that matter, so that the £2,000 the Minister has in mind may be something that can be identified twelve months hence as £2,000. We have seen in recent times how £2,000 was reduced in comparative value to £1,200 or so in the course of a few months. I presume it will be necessary to safeguard the owners of land against a possibility of that kind. With regard to reduction of annuities, I am rather interested in the section which specially relates to soldiers and sailors. I am not satisfied a reduction of 45 per cent. will be sufficient there. If all the lands purchased for them were purchased on the same terms as the Proby Estate at Woodenbridge I believe a reduction of 55 per cent. in the annuities would still leave these people paying over £1 an acre for land. That land in present conditions could not pay that charge. I think the Minister would find it hard to get people to take land and pay that charge for it. He might further consider that question. It is notorious that land bought at that period, on which soldiers and sailors were settled, was bought at peak prices, at scandalously high prices, and that even a special reduction of 5 per cent. in their favour would not be sufficient. Otherwise I think the Bill is full of promise of valuable land reform in the immediate future, and I hope it will be quickly passed into law.
Comment on this
My principal objection to the Bill is that it interferes with every class of farmer. Fianna Fáil Deputies have stated that if there was any interference with the ordinary farmer they would not support the Bill. I would like to know where there is a safeguard for any kind of farmer, whether his holding is one of ten acres or ten perches. In my opinion when the Bill passes we will be all State tenants. If Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches who are farmers support that, let them do it with their eyes open. The only safeguard I have heard of is that a farmer who works his land well will not be interfered with. Who is to interpret that? It is not set out in the Bill. I believe it is stated that if a farmer works his land properly he will not be interfered with.
Comment on this
Or the man with 40 acres? I do not think there is any farmer, no matter what his acreage— whether he belongs to the old ascendancy that we hear of or is an ordinary farmer—but intends to work his land. Let us face facts. What is the justification for interfering with the rights of the ordinary-sized farm? A farmer may have bought a holding and paid a good price for it—as a good many of them did—or he may have inherited it as a right. Is this Government to come along and resume the holding? They can do so under the Bill. I cannot see how that will strengthen Fianna Fáil clubs in particular areas. We know very well that there is a certain clamour for the division of land here and there, and we know what has prompted that clamour. I am not acquainted with the class of farmers that Deputy Moore alleges exist. I have no idea where there are farms of 1,000 acres or 500 acres. I am only concerned with ordinary farmers. If a farm is put on the market after this Bill is passed, what will it be worth seeing that the Land Commission and the Government can take possession of a holding any time they like? I have known of attempts being made to divide up farms of 50 acres. I can see that being done in the future. I think that is very regrettable and should not be supported by the ordinary rank and file member of Fianna Fáil. Any of us may have to sell a farm that has been properly acquired. If a man wants to go and offer his land as security to a bank will anything be advanced on it? What title is there to land when this Bill is passed? Not a bit.
Deputy Cosgrave spoke about one very peculiar section in the Bill which deals with the case of a farmer who might have a residence on a holding of ten acres and who might have further holdings of 40 or 50 acres. These holdings can be acquired under the Bill. Is it fair or just to give any Government power to interfere with such holdings? I cannot see that it is reasonable or just for the Government to seek such powers. This method of funding the annuities is neither reasonable nor just, because the Government have no right to look for annuities during the progress of the economic war. The annuities due prior to that period have been paid by the local rates. I ask Deputies on the Fianna Fáil benches to think of the moderate sized farm and not to mind the 1,000 acre farm. The section dealing with Government interference with reasonably sized holdings should be withdrawn. It has been stated that if a farmer works his land he will not be interfered with. A farmer might be working his land all right in the eyes of one Government, but probably next year things might not be going so well. No one has a right to leave a question like that to be decided by any official. This section gives the Government power to interfere with moderate sized holdings and that is a power that should not be in the Bill.
Comment on this
I am sorry to confess that I am not disappointed at the way the debate has gone. When introducing the Bill I knew perfectly well that Cumann na nGaedheal would discuss it in the same dishonest way that they have done, and that the Centre Party would discuss it in the same lazy and ignorant way that they have done. It would be all right for Cumann na nGaedheal to use the arguments they used, if they were talking to Fianna Fáil alone, because there would be no damage done. We know Cumann na nGaedheal quite well. I do not think it was right for them to deceive the two poor Babes in the Wood. One of the babes from Ballaghaderreen and the other——
Comment on this
These two gentlemen do not know anything about the land law at all. Deputy MacDermot may know something about land tenure in the Place de l'Opera, but he knows nothing about it in Kiltimagh. Deputy Dillon talked himself into a trance about events of thirty years ago. He wakened up the other day but he forgot to look up what has happened since. Deputy Hogan started off by talking about the hard-working farmer. He led the House and people who do not know him to assume that he was the one bulwark of the hard-working farmer who earned his money well when other people were spouting. He spoke of the farmer who has a holding of 20 acres, with his house, on one receivable order. After his father's death, he worked on and bought 50 acres within half a mile, under another receivable order. The Land Commission, Mr. Hogan said, can now come down on that man and take the other 50 acres. "That," he said, "is the law as it stands in this Bill." He also said:—
"Under the Land Act of 1923, there was an attempt to deal with the very difficult problem of congestion and, at the same time, to preserve the security of tenure the Irish farmer had struggled for and, in fact, achieved since 1880 and even before it."
What was the point of that? To try to deceive ignorant people like the back benchers of Cumann na nGaedheal and members of the Centre Party into the belief that, up to now, the Irish farmer was, as Deputy O'Higgins said, "as secure in his tenure as the rock of Gibraltar." A few back benchers in Cumann na nGaedheal should know that that is not so, and before the Centre Party began to discuss any Land Bill they should, at least, have known a little about what was in the 1923 Act. Deputy Dillon, interrupting Deputy Moore to-day, said that nothing could happen the tenant farmer under the 1923 Act—that he was secure. I propose to refer to two clauses in the 1923 Act—Sections 28 and 29. Section 28 sets out quite clearly that when judicial holdings, on which the farmers were secured by the 1881 Act, vested in the Land Commission, the Land Commission have power to retain these holdings and resume them for the relief of congestion. They have not even to leave that man a single sod. Talk about our cutting down the large farmer to £2,000 value. Under that clause, the 80,000 tenants whose holdings were vested in the Land Commission since 1923 had not the right left to claim that a sod of ground should be left to them, not to speak of a holding of £2,000 value. Deputy Roddy and Deputy Hogan knew that perfectly well, and I think the ignorance of the Centre Party about it is unforgivable.
Comment on this
When Deputy Hogan talked about the hardworking farmer, whom we were going to dispossess, he simply used the arguments used against himself in 1923. If anybody turns up the debate in the Seanad, quoted here yesterday evening by the Attorney-General, he will find that all this argument about Bolshevism, the doctrine of Karl Marx and so forth, was used against Deputy Hogan in 1923. These arguments were used with much more point against him than they are being used against this Bill, because under the 1923 Act, Deputy Hogan reserved to the Land Commission the right to take from 80,000 tenant farmers every sod of their land without giving even an acre of ground in exchange. It was disgusting to see the hypocrisy and dishonesty with which Deputy Hogan and Deputy Roddy and other members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party discussed this matter. I do not mind Deputy Cosgrave. Deputy Cosgrave is so ignorant of the land law that the other day he tried to prevent us from getting an estimate through to pay the Irish bondholders—the people who advanced the money for the purchase of land under the 1923 Act. Fortunately enough, Deputy Roddy was near the tails of Deputy Mulcahy's coat and did not allow him to force the matter to a division. But for one hour, Deputy Cosgrave spoke about the desperate thing we were doing, and he did not know that the money was going to pay the bondholders here. Deputy Cosgrave, alluding to-day to Sections 6 and 11, said they disclosed the British and landlord mentality. He quoted the section. It is a pity Deputy Roddy was not near enough to pluck him by the tails of the coat and pull him down before he made a fool of himself again, because the section Deputy Cosgrave referred to as disclosing the landlord and British mentality, is an exact replica of another section in the 1923 Act. Word for word it is the same.
Comment on this
The Deputy can read it if he likes. Deputy Cosgrave spoke also about a land tax. The reduction of the land annuities he said was putting a land tax on farmers. I think the income tax payers would be very glad if the same kind of tax was put on them and their income tax halved. I was interested in hearing Deputy Cosgrave say that the Government here have power to collect taxes, but that they had not the right to collect taxes. I think if ever there was a statement subversive of Governmental authority it was that statement. For years he ruled in this country, executing people on the plea that he was enforcing the right of Government selected by the people to rule no matter what the majority thought, yet he has the impudence to come here to-day and question the right of the Government to impose taxes. The Government has the right to impose taxes, and so long as the Government has the confidence of this House it is going to act upon its right to impose what taxes it thinks proper to impose in the interests of the community as a whole.
Comment on this
Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Hogan talked a lot about the morality of forgiving arrears. Deputy Hogan said nothing could be more demoralising and declared that the real injury the Government has done to this country is the moral injury of "putting a discount on thrift and honesty, and putting a premium on softness and dishonesty and other forms of weakness." Deputy Hogan was alluding there to the section of the Bill under which we propose to forgive arrears over three years due. That he declared was "putting a discount on thrift and honesty and a premium on softness and dishonesty." He went on to say that in the years prior to 1930 it was easier for the farmers to make money and that farmers who fell behind then should be forced to pay. Why did he not put that principle into the 1923 Act? In that Act, the arrears over three years due were forgiven, but the farmers had made money from 1920 back to 1914, all over the country. That was an easier time to make money for the farmers than from 1920 to 1922, yet prior to 1920 the arrears were forgiven. In every Land Bill introduced by the British the same principle was followed. We have decided to give the people a clean start in this country and not to have them burdened with a volume of arrears. We adopted that old principle.
Comment on this
25 speeches were made against the Bill. Surely that ought to be enough and the Minister should be allowed to proceed.
Comment on this
We are going to collect the arrears that have accumulated in the last three years and we are going to forgive those that accumulated up to three years ago. There is something to be said against that by men of the type of Deputy O'Higgins who announced one day that it was wrong to allow the unjust man to escape even if a couple of just men had to be made to suffer. That was when he was speaking on the Juries Act. Under this section, undoubtedly, there will be some wasters escape who should be made to pay their land annuities. But there are a vast number of people who got into difficulties through fluke and other diseases that attacked their cattle, owing to which they got into arrears and would find it impossible to pay these arrears now. If we were to attempt to collect all the arrears, due prior to three years ago, we would be creating a big problem for the Land Commission, and we would be doing harm to an enormous number of families throughout the country who would be anxious to pay up if they could, but who simply could not. I do not stand for the principle that we should squash these decent people who got into arrears through no fault of their own, and put their families on the roadside, in order to get hold of the waster who should be made to pay his land annuities.
Comment on this
The Government is bearing the loss. If Deputy Cosgrave, when he was in office, had forced the people to pay up, the money would not have been kept for a couple of years in the ratepayers' pockets. He tries now to create the impression that when we came into power he had only left a balance of £20,000 to be collected. As a matter of fact, the balance to be collected in respect of arrears over three years is something over £206,000, and these arrears were on account of the last years of Deputy Cosgrave's régime. We are not going to accept any amendment to collect arrears due prior to three years ago. There was a lot of hugger-mugger and hullabaloo raised by a few lawyers on the sheriffs section. There are some lawyers who would want you to go to court for leave if you wanted to have a tooth extracted. There is no reason why anybody should be alarmed at the sheriffs sections in the Bill. If we were to say that the sheriff could go in and distrain, and if he made a mistake he could not be made amenable, there might be some cause for alarm; but the usual Land Commission procedure will come in there—six days' notice and so on. If in any case the sheriff makes a mistake the farmer who is wronged can proceed against the sheriff, and the Land Commission will have to indemnify the sheriff against any risk he will have to take. There is no reason why we should continue the procedure of putting the tenant to expense on account of money he owes, simply to prove that he owes it, when he acknowledges he owes it, and everybody knows he owes it, and when he would not dispute in court that he owes. One of the principal causes of the amount of arrears left here was the fact that when a farmer got into a half-year's arrears he was taken to court, and, after a couple of weeks, instead of a half-year's arrears, he owed a sum to the Land Commission, when the costs were added, twice, and sometimes three times, his arrears. Once that burden of costs was put on the tenant it made it impossible for him to find his feet again. We are not going to put these costs on him.
Deputies spoke as if it was something new that Land Commissioners should be appointed and dismissed by the Executive Council. Deputy Cosgrave said that under the British régime the Land Commissioners were irremovable. He did not go on to say that it was his Government who turned the Land Commissioners from being irremovable officials into removable officials. Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Hogan tried to leave the Dáil under the impression that there was some dark plot on to confiscate the land in this country and that, in order to do so, we were going to put two removable men in charge of the Land Commission to whom we could dictate policy. As a matter of fact, the Land Commissioners at present are removable. During the 18 months that we have been in office the Land Commissioners held their office at the will of the Executive Council. We did not interfere with them. During these 18 months while we had control of removable officers we had also a provision that was put into the 1923 Act by Deputy Hogan and Deputy Cosgrave which gave the Land Commission power to take every sod of land from the 80,000 farmers who had yet to be vested. People who in the Dáil and down the country make speeches trying to alarm the tenant farmers really do so not to guard the rights of the ordinary hard-working farmer but to make it impossible for the Land Commission to deal justly with the small uneconomic holders and the landless man who knows how to work land and who has some capital to go on the land. The people who will make alarming speeches will be trying to keep uneconomic holders still uneconomic and the landless man, who has capital and a knowledge of working land, on the road looking over the ditch at land going to loss. What has been the position since 1923? When the 1923 Act was introduced Deputies were told that it was designed to put an end to congestion. As time went on, it was discovered that there were certain things in that Act which made it impossible for the Land Commission to carry out the work which the Government said they should be at. The Land Commission officials during the last ten years have been abused by every section of the community and they have been abused, in my opinion, in the wrong. The people were told that the Land Commission had power to divide land and to deal rapidly with congestion. As a matter of fact, in practice, the Land Commission had not power to do it. Take this last 18 months since we came into office. Were the questions about the division of land confined to the Fianna Fáil Party? Deputy Nally and other Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies and Deputies of the Centre Party were putting question after question about particular estates in their constituencies and asking why the Land Commission did not divide the land. When the Minister in charge had to get up and say the matter was still under consideration, that inspectors were looking after it, or something like that, there was a snigger all round the House. The people who should have been abused for that state of affairs were not the Land Commission officials, but those who told the people that the Land Commission were to do certain work and then did not put the tools into the hands of the Land Commission to do the work.
We have to make up our minds once and for all whether it is right to relieve congestion or not. If we want to relieve congestion we will have to give the people who are responsible for the relief of congestion the proper legal powers to do the work. What we are doing under this Bill is just that and no more. Who in the Fianna Fáil Party wants to render the small farmers insecure in their tenure? I should like to know that.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the two Babes in the Wood own an acre of land, but I was born and reared on a farm, and I am working a farm, and I hope to die on a farm.
Comment on this
I did not sit in an armchair or stay on the farm; I went out and fought for my country when fighting had to be done. If I had been resting in an armchair for the same number of years as Deputy Dillon, I would be ashamed of myself if I did not know what was in the Land Bill of 1923. Who on the Fianna Fáil Benches wants to render the small farmer insecure?
Comment on this
We want to see one tenure in this country rendered insecure, and one tenure only. We want to see the man whom Deputy MacDermot talked of, who is using his land in a definitely anti-social manner, rendered insecure. The best fixity of tenure that any man can have on his land is to be able to say to anybody who comes along the road: "There is my land; it is being used to the best possible advantage to the nation; no man could use it better."
Comment on this
The landlords, according to some of the principles outlined here by Deputies, should never have been disturbed in their fixity of tenure. Why were they disturbed? They were disturbed because their tenure was anti-social. Neither the farmers on the Fianna Fáil Benches nor those farmers who supported Cumann na nGaedheal or the Centre Party want to see the small working farmer disturbed in his tenure. All of us have the same desire to see him secure. But what was the state in which Cumann na nGaedheal left us? They left the Land Commission in this condition, that in certain districts, where there was dire congestion and where there were rotten slum conditions with people with large families housed together on a couple of pounds valuation, they could not relieve that congestion unless they took the powers given to them under the 1923 Act to dispossess the man who had a judicial rent fixed under the old Acts. It happened that in certain districts where there was congestion the Land Commission were being compelled to do something by reason of local agitation and they had to take land off a small farmer who was not protected by the 1923 Act and to leave undisturbed a large farmer who was protected by that Act. A couple of old ladies with about 1,500 acres were left undisturbed and 100 acres had to be taken from a small farmer. Is that the sort of fixity of tenure that any Deputy in this House wants to continue? If some of the Deputies in this House want to relieve congestion and want to do something more than merely talking balderdash here in the House and down at the cross-roads, they will have to give the Land Commission the powers to relieve congestion.
Comment on this
Deputy Moore asked me about sporting rights. When the Committee Stage is reached, we hope to introduce an amendment which will give the Land Commission power to take the sporting rights that were left with the landlords in the Acts prior to the 1923 Act. Under the 1923 Act the sporting rights all vested in the Land Commission and the practice has been since then to vest those sporting rights in the tenant. We intend to take power to do the same thing with the sporting rights vested in the landlords in the Acts prior to 1923.
Deputy Moore also raised the question of a further reduction for the people who bought land under the Soldiers and Sailors Acts. I must confess that the 55 per cent. flat reduction is not an ideal solution, and if any Deputy here on any side of the House can give me an ideal solution of the problem, and one that is practicable—so that instead of giving a flat rate reduction on any of the cases under the Soldiers and Sailors Acts and the 1923 Act, we can deal only with the hard cases—I will be quite prepared to accept it. However, quite a lot of research and a lot of thinking was done, and every sort of solution that was put up meant that the Land Commission would have to undertake again the complete revision of the 20,000 holdings that were fixed. It would have meant that, instead of getting on with very necessary work, they would have to retrace their steps and do work which would have taken them about another three years to complete, in order to enable them to sort out the cases which were hard from those in which a fair rate had been fixed. We found that it was absolutely impossible to do it. We examined the price at which the land had been bought, and the rents which had been apportioned on them, and we tried to get some rough and ready standard of value by which we could judge whether or not the rents fixed on these tenants were fair or not. I had some idea myself that, if possible, wherever the land annuity exceeds £1 per pound valuation we should reduce it to £1, but on further examination and after going into certain specific cases we discovered that what we suspected to be true was true, and that the Poor Law Valuation bore no relation at all to the present value of land.
We found that all sorts of things had happened since the Griffith days and that certain lands had been improved while other lands had been allowed to go back to their natural state, so that the valuation on the lands to-day has no relationship at all to their real value. We could get no ready or quick way to do it and that was the reason we had, reluctantly, to adopt the system of giving a flat 55 per cent. reduction to the tenants who secured holdings under the Soldiers and Sailors and the 1923 Acts. Deputy Cosgrave alluding to one section of the Bill where we were taking power to review judicial rents, said that it was immoral and unjust to reduce the sum which the tenant had agreed to pay to the landlord. There has been a lot of new morality preached in these last few years. I wish Deputy Cosgrave would take a few of the old farmers, down through the country, into a room and give them a lecture on the immorality of the fight they put up in order to get a reduction in the rents which the tenants had agreed to pay the landlords. In what way were these rents fixed, I wonder? They were fixed at the point of the gun. The tenants had to agree to pay the rents fixed or to get out, and all we are intending to do in this Bill is that where an unfair and an unjust rent was fixed on the tenant and where the landlord is still being paid for it, we are only going to pay him a just price and we will put that just price on the incoming tenant. If Deputy Cosgrave wants to fight the landlord's battle let him go along, but do not let him be coming in here and telling us that it is bad form, that it is immoral. I do not want lectures on good form or morality from Deputy Cosgrave or from anybody on those benches. I want to conclude by saying this: that if we want the Land Commission to deal with certain problems, problems of congestion, we have to go and give the Land Commission power to do it. All we are asking for in this Bill are the powers to enable the Land Commission to carry out the work that Cumann na nGaedheal promised the people they were going to carry out.
If we are not going to pass this Bill, well, then, let us, for goodness sake, drop the idea of the division of land. There is no use in fooling about it. The Land Commission have only succeeded in dividing about 30,000 acres of land per year, and the price the country had to pay for that was much too expensive. If there was any way of doing what Deputy MacDermot talked about, of letting ordinary economic pressure sub-divide the land, it would be much cheaper and much more effective than the way we are doing it. But it cannot be done at the moment. One thing more I want to allude to is that Deputy Roddy said we had 250,000 acres of land on hands. He gave Deputy O'Higgins a tip afterwards to mend his hand in that regard. Deputy Roddy should know that there is a lot of difference between land registered on a file and the land on hands. One acre of land on hands is worth ten acres on the files.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is not going to repudiate his own statement made on the Land Commission Estimates last April when he told us that there were 430,000 acres of land acquired by the Land Commission?
Comment on this
My statement made here to-day was that there were 240,000 acres on hands. According to the Minister's statement made here in this House, there were 480,000 acres in the course of acquisition.
Comment on this
Yes, in the process of acquisition. It is quite a different thing to say that there are 480,000 acres in the process of acquisition to saying that there are 250,000 acres of land to be divided.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Roddy not know the difference between the process of acquisition and land on the hands of the Land Commission?
Comment on this
Well I am afraid that the Minister does not know it himself. I have a statement here made by the Minister, and I will read it:—
"As regards untenanted land, the present position is approximately that over 430,000 acres have been actually acquired by the Land Commission ... of which some 360,000 acres had already been divided among some 18,500 allottees. This leaves about 74,000 acres on hands, but not yet formally divided."
I said 60,000 acres.
Comment on this
No. The Minister went on, to say:
"This leaves about 74,000 acres on hands ... in addition prices have been agreed upon or fixed for over 42,000 acres and offers have been made or provisional lists published in respect of a further 76,000 acres. ... Then the Land Commission have under investigation with a view to its suitability for acquisition an area of some 700,000 acres of which 256,000 acres have been inspected, apart from a considerable area which has been put aside after preliminary examination as unsuitable for present action but with the possibility of revival if necessary."
Comment on this
Deputy Roddy was trying to leave the House under the impression that we had 250,000 acres on hands ready for division and that for some reason we would not divide it and that in face of that we came to the Dáil asking for powers which we did not want.
Comment on this
I am not going to allow the Minister to mis-quote me. I said 250,000 acres in process of acquisition and I said there were 60,000 or 70,000 acres on hands. According to the Minister's own statement there are 74,000 acres on hands. I have it here.
Comment on this
Not alone did the Deputy say there were 250,000 acres on hand but he was quoted by some innocent Deputies on the Farmers' Benches as saying that. He gave the tip to Deputy O'Higgins to mend his hand.
Comment on this
Well then Deputy O'Higgins was not so simple as the others. The fact is the Land Commission has the balance of the lands that were not distributed. There is a big difference between lands that were taken over for distribution and lands on hand. There is also a big difference between lands in process of acquisition and lands acquired.
Comment on this
Nobody wants to know anything about land to see the difference between lands in process of acquisition and lands on hands.
Comment on this
May I ask why the Minister has not distributed the 74,000 acres? Portions of that land have been lying there for 18 months.
Comment on this
A lot of it will lie there for the next hundred years because it is mountainy land which can be given to no one. But we will drop that now.
Comment on this
We will drop it by saying this, that it is quite evident to everybody in the House that Deputy Roddy was trying to leave the Dáil under the impression that we had 250,000 acres of land on hands.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney should take out Deputy Roddy and give him a few lessons.
Comment on this
It is impossible to put any sense into Deputy Roddy's head or Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's head.
Comment on this
We are still awaiting the Minister's explanation as to why the 74,000 acres are not divided.
Comment on this
We are not going to be satisfied with a distribution at the rate of 30,000 acres per year. We want the Dáil to give us power to divide the lands as quickly as possible. If the Dáil is not prepared to give us the powers to divide land quickly, well, then, we are not prepared to carry on. We believe that one of the greatest social needs of the moment is to see that the land of this country is utilised to the best possible advantage. We want an outlet for men who have experience—and some of them have a little capital to work lands that are not now being worked. We are asking the Dáil for those powers, and we are not going to fool the country or the Dáil as Cumann na nGaedheal did for a number of years by pretending that the Land Commission had the power to do the work but that there was something wrong with the machine.
Comment on this
The distribution has been carried on at, roughly, the same average for the last ten years.
Comment on this
In one year the number of acres went up by putting into it a lot of work done by the Congested Districts Board years ago. The average was 30,000 to 35,000 acres, but we are not satisfied with that. That is only tinkering with the problem. Either the Dáil will give us powers to go on with the work or they will have to give them to somebody else.
Comment on this
How much does the Minister aim at dividing per year in the future, and what amount of money does he expect will need to be provided by the Oireachtas in order to achieve that distribution?
Comment on this
Not one word was said here with regard to the evicted tenants. I would like to know from the Minister if they will get priority when land is being divided.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."
Do you agree with this result?
It was definitely arranged in the House, when it was agreed to postpone the Second Reading, that the Committee Stage be taken on the 25th July.
Comment on this
Surely a little longer might be allowed to draft amendments to the Bill. Surely it would not unduly inconvenience the Government if the Committee Stage is taken on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.
Comment on this
If there were any means by which we could get one member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and one member of the Centre Party to speak for each Party we might be able to make some arrangement. I will say that if the Centre Party makes an arrangement they will keep to it, but it has been found hopeless to get an agreement with the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. You will get an agreement with one man, and it is repudiated by all the others. The Committee Stage was fixed three weeks ago for the 25th July. This Bill has been before the Dáil for three or four weeks.
Comment on this
Does the Government Whip suggest that there was any difficulty in making an arrangement in connection with the Committee Stage of this Land Bill? Whom did he make any arrangement with?
Comment on this
It was agreed here by the President to postpone the Second Reading, and in doing so he announced that the Committee Stage would be taken on the 25th July.
Comment on this
If the Minister remembers, the President consented to the postponement of the Bill until Tuesday if the Minister could produce the Bill. The Minister was unable to produce the Bill, whereupon it was further postponed to Thursday. Surely if it were agreed that the Committee Stage would be disposed of on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday—and finished on Friday—that would meet the Government fully.
Comment on this
There was a provisional announcement, but it is usual to fix the date for the Committee Stage when the Second Stage is passed. It so happened that the Minister in charge of this Bill knew nothing whatever of what he was talking about. In the first place, we were approached last week as to whether or not the Appropriation Bill and the Estimates would be taken by 12 o'clock at night. It was under consideration, and was put to us whether we would have a long sitting on Thursday or Friday. We heard nothing about it until Friday morning. No decision was taken. It so happens that nobody on the Government side knows the first thing about any business that is before the Dáil, and they are blundering on, from day to day, in that fashion. This evening, for the first time, there has been an attempt, so far as the Opposition is concerned, to work out a programme for the Government, and a sort of provisional agreement was reached to take the Committee Stage on Wednesday. We will divide on the motion to take the Committee Stage on Tuesday.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Cosgrave nominate somebody in his Party who can speak authoritatively for his Party in the arrangement of business?
Comment on this
We have never found it possible to ascertain what the Government wants. Might I point out that the case the Minister makes on this matter is that a certain date was fixed for the Second Reading and a certain date announced by the President for Committee Stage, allowing a certain interval between the Second Reading and Committee Stages. The Second Reading was postponed from the date announced by the Government and is it not obvious that the Committee Stage should equally be postponed?
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that the Second Stage of this Bill was postponed because it took three meetings of the Fianna Fáil Party to agree amongst themselves about the Bill?
Comment on this
Question put: "That the Committee Stage be taken on Tuesday, 25th July."
Do you agree with this result?
If amendments have to be in by that date for the Committee Stage, will there be a certain amount of latitude allowed in putting in amendments for the Report Stage?