We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Adjournment Debate.

Contributions 116–238 of 238. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

As I say, I am not a legal authority and I do not know how far it is legitimate to go; but we have said, while standing against any campaign for non-payment of rates, that it is our desire and intention to help, so far as we legally can, against victimisation persons who are genuinely unable to pay.

So much for the question of rates. I venture to suggest that that is something of very minor proportions and very minor seriousness as compared with the issues of violence and intimidation that we have been raising. Now, I am going to make the Government a present of one admission. Allusion has been made from this bench to the fact of the legality of wearing blue shirts. I once heard the Attorney-General say, or, at any rate, imply—I think he explicitly said it in this House—that nobody could blame you for doing anything that you were legally entitled to do. That is a doctrine to which I do not assent and, even if it were legally, perfectly proper for an organisation to clothe itself in blue shirts, if, in fact, it had the effect of damaging the general conditions of peace and order in this country, I should be against their doing it. But the truth of the matter is that the Blue Shirt organisation is not the cause of the conditions of violence and intimidation of which we are complaining but, on the contrary, is the result of those conditions. Those conditions are conditions of which I have had personal experience back at the last election and before it in districts where a Blue Shirt had never been seen; and the reason that young men feel called upon to come together and give themselves a certain corporate spirit by adopting such a costume as a blue shirt is that they feel the necessity of coping with that state of things: that they feel that the Civic Guards by themselves are not in a position to create conditions of true liberty in this country. It is not merely a question of preventing free speech. That is very bad, but there is something in addition to that. There is the prevention even of attendance at meetings. I have been told by people in a great many parts of the country that they did not like to come to meetings and that they stayed away because they were afraid of being penalised and attacked if they went. There is not a Deputy in this House who could not confirm the truth of that by any sincere inquiries in his constituency.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding the fact that they were provided with free buses.

Comment on this

That is a valuable interruption.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows all about that game.

Comment on this

It is no good shutting our eyes to the fact that intimidation is a very serious problem in this country. I do not believe it is an insoluble problem. We have had rather a turbulent history in this country and, perhaps, we Irish are rather a turbulent people, but if we are, we are a goodhearted people at the same time and I do not believe that the violence and intimidation of which we complain are a necessary concomitant of political life in this country. If there were no question of so-called war with England, if there was not a resuscitation of the so-called national issue which always poisons anything in the nature of charity and commonsense in this country, I do not believe that intimidation in this country would get anywhere. There may be sinister forces in this country that would like to see general anarchy followed by Communism. There may be, at any rate, forces that are more interested in seeing people who have any property despoiled of that property than they are in anything else; but I do not believe that such forces would succeed even for a short time in this country except under the cloak of patriotism. What I deplore is that it is made so easy for them to succeed under the cloak of patriotism, and it is made easy for them by the policy of the present Government. Mind you, what occurred at Tralee the other day is already having a very bad effect outside Tralee. In other parts of the country—at Castlebar, at Limerick—the shouts that I heard of "Up Dev" were mingled with shouts of "Up Tralee" and "Up Kerry." It is all becoming part of the gospel of the true Fianna Fáiler, that all that is good—that it goes together. None of the Ministers sitting over there can afford to allow that sort of thing to go on if they have any patriotism in them.

The root of the whole matter is that what is called the national policy of the Government does not make one scrap of sense.

Comment on this

That is the Deputy's opinion, not the people's.

Comment on this

Well, it will be the people's. Now, I can understand a policy which consists of going all out for a Thirty-Two-County Republic. If that is the policy there is only one way to try to implement it and that is to have conscription, preceded, I suppose, by universal military training—to have conscription, to declare war and to fight for it. The chances of success might be small, but, at any rate, it would be a try and it would be the only way to try. The prospect of getting a Republic for the 32 counties in any other way is absolutely non-existent. Your policy, on the other hand, may be to have a Twenty-Six-County Republic in view of the fact that the Thirty-Two-County Republic is unattainable. If that is so, for Heaven's sake go ahead and declare your Republic and take it, and then it will not be possible for blackguards to go about the country disguising their blackguardism under the name of patriotism. Perhaps that may be a necessary step towards the ultimate destiny of this country. I am quite certain what that destiny is. I am certain that Partition is not going on forever, but that it is artificial and founded on artificial passions. I am perfectly certain that, sooner or later, the people of this country will realise that it is worth while to conciliate the feelings of a quarter of our people, and to accept free and equal partnership with Great Britain, Canada, Australia and South Africa, but it may take a long time, and it may be that experience of the Twenty-Six-County Republic is necessary first. It is hard for me to judge. Of course, I should much rather cut out that departure from the straight road to national unity, but, at any rate, if the Twenty-Six-County Republic were brought in, it would go a long, long way towards solving this problem of disorder and intimidation, because where that sort of thing flourishes is amongst the worst elements of the community who manage to disguise themselves as patriots, and to whom a certain number of people who are genuinely excited about the national issue, but who are unbalanced and hysterical, attach themselves. I said last night that I wished to Heaven that we could have co-operation among all Parties in this House in putting down violence and intimidation and interference with the free exercise of citizenship, and I meant that from my heart. Any co-operation that we could give in that direction we certainly would give. I only wish that co-operation in that matter could be a prelude to a larger co-operation, for I often feel that all the strife and contention in this country are absolutely stupid and unnecessary. I often feel that at bottom we are all out for the same things, and if we could only get together, believing in each other's good faith, in each other's goodwill and in each other's patriotism, we could achieve more for this country in our lifetime than any one of us can hope will be achieved under present conditions.

Comment on this

It is a pity you did not cross the Channel years before you did.

Comment on this

I should have thought that a Government would regard it as a healthy thing to have a criticism at the end of a session and before an adjournment, of their policy and their work during the previous period, and that certainly would be true about a Government that was doing its work honestly and fearlessly and governing the country, but we had an attempt here to-night by the President to prevent any discussion on this adjournment. It was an attempt to prevent it because he does not want to face up to an exposure of the recent happenings that are a disgrace to the Government sitting on those benches. The technique has been adopted recently by this Government of sitting there and looking like a crowd of dummies and refusing to answer speakers from these benches, but the new policy adopted this evening of trying to prevent any discussion at all is the best policy of the Government. The Minister for Education was the first speaker from those benches, and he did not attempt to deal with any single charge in the grave and serious indictment of the Government that was put forward by Deputy O'Sullivan. Instead, he adopts the usual policy of attempting to make an attack on the Opposition Party. He told us that the Opposition Party have no policy. I should have thought that if the Minister is too busy to read the newspapers himself, some of the secret service aides of the Government would have brought under his notice the fact that there was a preliminary statement of policy published by this Party, some months ago. For the information of the members of the Government who seem not to have read it, I should like to call their attention to one or two items in it. It says:—

"The United Ireland Party stands for the voluntary reunion of the Irish nation as the paramount constitutional issue in Irish politics and considers that to achieve this end the first essential is solidarity of purpose amongst the citizens of the Free State."

That is the first item in the programme of this Party. The next one is this:—

"It maintains the fundamental right of the Irish people to decide for themselves at all times their own constitutional status. It rejects as fatal to Irish unity and in every way disastrous, the Government's double-faced policy of retaining the present constitutional position and at the same time discarding its advantages. The people are being brought to beggary and defrauded of all hope of getting rid of partition by a sham Republicanism which only uses the name Republic as a pretext for self-glorification, for claiming a monopoly of patriotism and for perpetuating disorder."

I say that if the Government were doing their job honestly and fearlessly and governing the country, giving even-handed justice to every section of the people, they would not be ashamed to face this discussion here to-night as apparently they have been. Their President tried to run away from this discussion to-night. Why is that? Because he is not administering even-handed justice between the different sections of the people. A lot of nonsense is talked from the Government Benches about people wearing blue shirts. What is wrong with people wearing blue shirts? What is illegal in it? You have your Attorney-General there to advise you if he thinks it is illegal and why not prosecute for it? The reason you do not do it is because you know that there is nothing illegal in it. We hear nonsense talked by Ministers, both inside this House and outside it, about provocative displays in the country and about people wearing blue shirts. What is wrong with it? Is it wrong for people to wear blue shirts who have no arms and is it right for other people to go around with guns in their pockets, breaking up meetings, because one section are the pets of the Government and the other people are not?

(Interruption).

I do not want to be interrupted by any Deputy of the calibre of Deputy Cooney, who is one of the drones in the hive opposite and who never makes any useful contribution to debate in this House.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy answer a question?

Comment on this
Deputies

Order, order!

Comment on this

What would the Deputy call a shirt without arms?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

If the Government think that there is anything illegal in the wearing of blue shirts, let them prosecute people who wear them. The Government are carrying on the government of this country, such as it is, for the benefit of one section of the people only and I should like to remind them, and the Attorney-General, who is a learned lawyer, of course, of a principle of government stated fifty years ago by a great thinker. I should like to commend it to his attention and he might bring it under the notice of his Government. It is:—

"If any Government should be tempted to neglect, even for a moment, its function of compelling obedience to law, if a democracy, for example, were to allow a portion of the multitude of which it consists to set some law at defiance which it happens to dislike, it would be guilty of a crime which hardly any other virtue could relieve and which century upon century might fail to repair."

That is what the Government of this country are doing at the present time. They are condoning crime on the part of a section of the people and they are trying to impute crime to other people who are law-abiding and decent. The President, from the formation of this new Party, and the junction up of the different elements of opposition who want to save the country from the disorder into which it is being pushed now, has gone through the country, again and again, on an orgy of tom-tom beating and Deputy Norton goes into another district and plays the little kettle-drum at the same time, and says: "O'Duffy and the rest of them ought to be put in jail because they are breaking the law." What law are we breaking, and what item in the policy of this Party is there that is against the law? This Party stands for obedience to the law and, however grossly maladministered the law may be, this Party does respect and has respected, and will respect, the law. We have never stood for the non-payment of rates. Deputy MacDermot, as he told you to-night, has always stood for the payment of rates and for obedience to the law. Deputy Dillon has done the same thing and every member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, as it was, has stood for the same thing.

General O'Duffy, when speaking in Castlebar—I hope that none of the Deputies present at the moment will object to my calling him "General;" some of them did the other night object to that term being applied to him but I do not know why—advised the people there that they should, and must, pay their rates. Deputy MacDermot was present at that meeting, too. That is the policy of this Party—to obey the law—and we are not going to have it put out to the country by imputation such as the Attorney-General tried to make here to-night, that there is any connivance at or encouragement to a breach of the law on our part. I was surprised, indeed, that the Attorney-General drew my name into the discussion. He said I was "bobbing up again and again." I pass over the expression. It is not English but we understand what it means. I did get up but I had not the Attorney-General in mind at all. He is only an item in the issues that have to be dealt with to-night. He did call my attention to Prussia Street and the incidents that led up to it. I wish to say this about it—that, as regards the finding of any court in this State, I have no criticism to make, whether it be the court that tried the Prussia Street case or any other court. Whether people are found guilty or innocent, I respect the verdicts of the courts of this country. Whether a verdict be given by the Military Tribunal or any other court, I adopt it as an honest verdict, given as the result of honest belief. I was amazed to hear the Attorney-General talking about "this conspiracy" in Prussia Street and speaking of the people tried there as having been guilty of conspiracy. Does he forget the counts on which he himself indicted them? Is he ignorant of the fact that, having charged these men with conspiracy, they were found not guilty of conspiracy by the court? It is an amazing thing for the Attorney-General to get up and make these charges against those who stood their trial like men and suffered the consequences like men.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

On a point of order, I do not think that the Deputy is representing me correctly. I did not for a moment intend to suggest that the four men acquitted of the charge of conspiracy were guilty of conspiracy. The conspiracy I referred to I described. I referred to the conspiracy which, I believe, existed from the date when, in Clonmel, these cattle were taken up to the date of the attempt in Prussia Street to prevent the cattle being sold.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

You referred to the conspiracy——

Comment on this

There was no conspiracy but his and Killeen's.

Comment on this

You paid the rates anyway, Paddy.

Comment on this

I can pay them and I do not squeal about it.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

The Attorney-General referred to the men tried in connection with the Prussia Street incident and to "the conspiracy". When he says he did not mean that, I accept it.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I do not think I referred to it as a conspiracy.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I accept the Attorney-General's statement that he did not mean that. He has invited me to discuss this question of Prussia Street and I am going to do that. I put down a question in this House as to who was the person who paid for the cattle and who was behind him; who was the purchaser and who was supplying the money. It was obvious to everybody that the auction was a bogus auction, so far as it was held. But it was with pain and surprise that I learned afterwards what the truth was. The Minister for Justice, with his usual cleverness and discretion, refused to answer my question. He said it was not in the public interest to give the information I sought. It was certainly not in the public interest to have revealed to the people of this country that the Attorney-General, in his own office, arranged a mock auction in this sordid manner and arranged for a secret bidder to be procured and a police officer to be sent to the auction disguised in plain clothes and calling himself "John Brown." He was to say that he was the purchaser. There is a law dealing with bogus bids at auctions and the Attorney-General sailed very near a breach of the law in the performance he arranged in his own office. It pains me as a member of an honourable profession to find that a member of my profession holding that office should take part in a performance of that kind.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The Deputy has charged me with having arranged a mock auction.

Comment on this

It was sworn in court.

Comment on this

Your oath was not believed in court, so you had better shut up.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The evidence as to what happened in my office was given in court. I think that it is an extraordinary thing that the Deputy should charge me with what would be a criminal offence—practically arranging a bogus auction. There was no such finding by the court.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I read the published evidence, and the same attempt was made at the Military Tribunal, under your instructions, to prevent the public from knowing about this bogus auction as the Government made here. I was refused information in this House as to the circumstances of this auction on the ground that it would be against the public interest. The same point was made before the Tribunal by the Attorney-General's counsel. When that question was put on behalf of the accused to "John Brown," privilege was claimed, but the court overruled that plea and ordered the question to be answered.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

On a point of order, the Deputy has now gone away from the first charge, which I repudiated. I think it was most improper for the Deputy to make that charge and to persist in that charge. He has now made a second charge, that I objected to this evidence being given. That is absolutely incorrect. I gave direct instructions to everybody concerned in the case—personal instructions—to tell the court everything that happened. When the question was raised, we said to the Tribunal that, though we could have claimed privilege, we preferred that everything should be stated to the court.

Comment on this

Privilege was claimed and overruled by the President of the court. I challenge contradiction of that by Deputy Geoghegan.

Comment on this

On the point of order, Deputy Rice is, I am sure, unintentionally inaccurate. I should like, therefore, to draw his attention to the actual facts—that the police officer in question pointed out to the court that his regulations prevented him from giving this evidence and sought a release from the regulations by the court. That court granted the release, and counsel did not intervene except to intimate that the prosecution desired that every fact should be made public.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I want to contradict——

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Will the Deputy withdraw the charge he has made against me?

Comment on this

If he does, I will repeat it when I get up.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Deputy Geoghegan, who acted as counsel, has stated that he personally did not claim privilege and, of course, I accept that.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I have stated my instructions.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I said and I repeat that privilege was claimed by a person employed by you. The police officer claimed privilege. I read the report of the evidence and it stated that privilege was claimed.

Comment on this

By the police officer.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

And the report stated that the claim of privilege was overruled by the court.

The Attorney-General rose.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Attorney-General has made a statement regarding his action in this matter. The Deputy distinctly stated that the Attorney-General claimed privilege or had suggested the claiming of privilege. The Attorney-General has denied this.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

When an officer of the Attorney-General, whether he is his counsel or a police officer sent there by him, claims privilege, it is claimed by the Attorney-General. That is the point I wish to make.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

You do not know what you are talking about.

Comment on this

Deputy Geoghegan has stated that the officer in question explained that he was bound under his regulations to claim privilege and that he sought a release from those regulations.

Comment on this

Did Deputy Geoghegan tell him to answer when he claimed privilege?

Comment on this

Does Deputy Rice withdraw the statement?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I do not care whether he withdraws or not. Nobody pays any attention to him.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

That is a remark which is quite unworthy of anybody holding a responsible position in this House. It is a very foolish observation——

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

It was very foolish of you to make the observations you did.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Not quite as foolish as the action of the Attorney-General in arranging a bogus auction. Even if it were not part of the policy of the Government, the Attorney-General, seeing what happened in the disastrous bogus auction, perhaps will explain to me why the answer to my question on the subject was refused in this House and privilege claimed on the grounds of public interest. I have said that the Government are not governing this country——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Attorney-General has made it clear that he did not arrange a bogus auction.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I do not know whether the Attorney-General is differing with me as to what is meant by "bogus auction" or not. I explained that what is meant by a bogus auction is that the Attorney-General brings persons into his office, gets a secret bidder, gets his name and then arranges for a police officer to bid at that auction in a bogus name—it is a matter of opinion as to what is a bogus auction.

Comment on this

Might I suggest to Deputy Rice and other Deputies that we might get away now from Waterford and these other matters and deal with something of more importance to the country. We have unemployment, two armies and two police forces. Let us deal with them and not mind the bogus auctions.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy know about armies?

Comment on this

You would not be taken in any army, not even in the County Down Militia.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I have said that the Government are not governing the country in an even-handed way——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I want to get this clear. My slight knowledge of law leads me to believe that to arrange a bogus auction is criminal. That charge has been made against the Attorney-General by Deputy Rice. I want to know whether Deputy Rice persists in the charge.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I described the incidents that happened in the office of the Attorney-General as arranging a bogus auction—namely, procuring a secret bidder, sending a police officer there to bid. That is a bogus auction. If the Attorney-General agrees that the incidents that I have described happened in his office I will not quarrel with him as to the description of that auction. A man was sent to bid at that auction, and told to give a false name.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I had nothing to do with arranging that the police officer be sent there, and that was stated in evidence.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

The only thing I saw was that it was stated by court witnesses that this arrangement was made in the Attorney-General's office, and I accepted their evidence.

Comment on this

Does the Attorney-General deny that he sent for Mr. Killeen?

Comment on this

Have you paid your fine yet?

Comment on this

Never mind. I am able to pay it. I am paying my way as a farmer, and not paying my way as the son of a British spy.

Comment on this

The less Deputy Belton says about spying the better.

Comment on this

I did not miss my train anyway——

Comment on this

And you were not at Ashbourne either in 1916.

Comment on this

I was, and you suspended the man who saved my life on coming out of the Viceregal Lodge after having been sent there by James Connolly to get certain information.

Comment on this

You were not there.

Comment on this

Where were you?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I stated that the Government were not administering even-handed justice to the people of the country. I stated that they were favouring sections of the country. The most flagrant example of that is now in force in the one-sided administration of the Constitution (Amendment) Act No. 17, or the Public Safety Act. That measure, when it was introduced in this House, was introduced for the purpose of stopping murders. There can be no controversy about that. It was extremely unpopular with the Party opposite who are now the Government, and who are now using that Act. The Minister who is in the main responsible for enforcing its provisions, described it not as a Public Safety Act, but as a Public Provocation Act. That was the view the Minister took of it in those days. He has changed his views many times on various matters in the last 15 or 16 years.

Comment on this

Who is speaking now?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I am. The Minister for Justice in 1916 placed it on record that the proper policy for the people of this country was to stand by the Empire.

Comment on this

That is untrue.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

It is published in the official records, in the Irish Law Times.

Comment on this

I have denied it twice already. I say it is untrue, and the Deputy knows it is untrue.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I have never heard it said that it was untrue. I have never heard it was denied.

Comment on this

If the Deputy was as keen in reading the truth about misrepresentations as he was in reading the misrepresentations he would have seen that I denied that twice.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I have never seen the Minister's contradiction. I have seen the statement on the official records.

Comment on this

Bring the report here at any time and I will point it out to you.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I hope I will be able to procure a copy of the Minister's address and I can show him the words.

Comment on this

I can supply you with it.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

The Minister, who is responsible now for the enforcement of this Act, described it, when it was introduced here, not as a Public Safety Bill but as a Public Provocation Bill. I am sorry that the Minister for Finance has run out of the House now, because I wanted to quote one of his gems in a speech made in reference to the Tribunal established under that measure. The reputation of the Minister for Finance depends, I think, on the choiceness of his language and his extreme moderation. In the debate on the Public Safety Act, as reported in column 170 of volume 40 of the Dáil reports, we have his words. In the course of that debate, with all the choice moderation of language which distinguishes him, he referred to the five officers who were appointed to act on the Military Tribunal as judges as "five bloodhounds."

These were the remarks made at that time by the Ministers, who are now sitting on the Government Benches. These were their remarks on the Public Safety Act. Deputy de Valera, as he then was, the present President, on that occasion took the view that there was no need whatever for anything beyond the then existing powers. He took the view that the Executive Council had no need of further powers. Murders were being committed, but the ordinary law was sufficient to deal with them, quite sufficient. Later on he said that the Government preferred to imitate the activities of Hamar Greenwood. This was the criticism of a Government who were bringing in a Bill to stop murder. Now that Act is in force.

Who are the people who are now brought before the Military Tribunal? A number of farmers charged with conspiracy and so on in connection with the non-payment of their rates. Was there ever a greater travesty of justice than we have here? The people who now form the Government stated at that time these powers were unnecessary even for stopping murders. We have these people now putting that Act into force and applying it to the cases of these men from Waterford and not applying it to grave and serious disorders. There is grave and serious disorder in the country now. There is an increasing campaign to prevent free speech. I am sorry to say that recent indications suggest that the police are not able to cope with it whatever the cause may be. We had an incident referred to by Deputy MacDermot yesterday evening in which men actually arrested and brought to the barracks are released because a crowd of hooligans and rowdies assembled outside the barracks and shouted for their release.

I say that police officers who act in that way are not carrying out their duty, whatever may be the explanation of their not doing so. That Bill was criticised in that way by the members of the present Government and the attitude of the Labour Party was, of course, somewhat similar. They could not see any occasion for it at all. Deputy Davin said he was not a dummy Deputy and he was not going to walk into the Lobby behind the President to vote for it unless he could see good cause for it, and he would not do the same for Mr. de Valera if he were President. While I do not admire Deputy Davin's courage, I must express a modified approval of his conscience, because he certainly did not appear here last week. He was here the day before the vote on the censure motion was taken, but he was not here the day the vote was actually taken. I should be sorry if he were ill, but I am sure he is not ill. The only thing he is suffering from, to my mind, is the shock his nervous system received when he found his colleagues intended to vote in favour of the enforcement of an Act that they repudiated so strongly when it was introduced two years ago.

There is only one other incident to which I will refer before I conclude, and that is the shameful charge that was made last week against a distinguished member of this House who sits on these benches by no less a person than the President. A number of members on these benches, when the President on a later occasion withdrew that charge, when he apologised in unqualified terms, then accepting the apology as sincere, applauded him. He promised, and he reiterated his promise, that a tribunal would be set up to inquire into the disgraceful charge. Why is that tribunal refused now? Why is that promise withdrawn? When the President makes a promise in this House only for very grave and serious reasons should he go back on it, and those grave and serious reasons should be judged not by him, but by the House. He has given the House no reason whatever for withdrawing the undertaking to have an inquiry.

It has been stated here to-night that he is shielding a criminal in refusing to set up an inquiry which will bring to light the author of this foul charge. In the previous Pigott case a court was set up with full power to compel the attendance of witnesses, to compel the attendance of people like the Pigott in this case. Any Deputy who likes to look back on the report of the Pigott case will observe a peculiar parallel between that case and the present one. The people who accepted Pigott's statement that he had letters written by Parnell never inquired into the truth or otherwise of the statement, and that was because they were so anxious to believe that the statement was true. The same applies to the President in this case. He was so anxious to believe anything that would besmirch the reputation of a distinguished Irishman who is on these benches that possibly he never inquired into its truth until after he had lodged this foul charge in the House. Then he made and repeated a promise that he would set up an inquiry.

Deputy Coburn seemed to have a better appreciation of the President's mentality than others of us here, because when Deputy Mulcahy asked (Parliamentary Debates, vol. 49, col. 1929) “Can I have the President's assurance to this House that he will do that?”—that is, to set up a tribunal—the President replied “I am delighted—more delighted than I can say.” Deputy Hogan of Galway asked “What about the assurance?” and the President said: “I shall speak in my own way and I will not be dictated to by Deputy Hogan or anybody else. I am delighted more than I can say——.” Deputy Coburn then said: “Do not wriggle. Give the assurance. You are always wriggling.” Deputy Coburn, even in the midst of the general enthusiasm, had a better appreciation of the situation than many of us. That assurance was given and reiterated by the President, but there was one Deputy who had, at any rate, the sense not to believe it and that was Deputy Coburn. Deputy Coburn has been justified in the view that he took by the course taken by the President yesterday when, without any excuse or explanation, he refused to set up the only tribunal that would have a right to compel the attendance of the person who made the foul statement. The President has gone back on the undertaking he gave the House. The inquiry has been refused and the charge would never have been made if the President had not adopted the same attitude as the people who bought the Pigott letters years ago. He was just anxious to believe that it was true.

Comment on this

I was rather disappointed to-day by the President's opposition to the idea of giving any opportunity, before the adjournment, to the Opposition to discuss things which, at any rate, appeared to be of importance to them, arising out of the present situation in the country. At all events, as long as I have been a member of this House it was always the custom that, before the Dáil closed down for a lengthy period, the Opposition got an opportunity, a full and adequate opportunity, of raising any questions which appeared to them to be of major importance. The reason for such a course is that during the normal session, in order that the work of the country will go on, practically all the time is at the disposal of the Government and there is little or no time at the disposal of the Opposition.

Heretofore, a general debate on the adjournment of the Dáil was always around the question of unemployment and, if the debate to-night does not particularly revolve around the question of unemployment, it is not because unemployment has lessened and it is not because the unemployment situation is not more serious than ever it was at any former adjournment. In the words of the leader of the Labour Party, we are passing at the moment through an unemployment crisis unparalleled in living memory. Again, he tells us that the number of unemployed in this country is considerably in excess of 90,000 men. If the debate from this side of the House this evening has directed attention to other questions than that of unemployment, it is not because unemployment has lessened but because, evil and all as unemployment is, serious and all as it is, there are bigger questions and more serious questions menacing and threatening the life of this country at the present moment than even widespread, general and increasing unemployment.

The gravest question and the gravest matter that is active throughout this nation at the moment is a general, rapidly-increasing drift towards mob law instead of ordinary parliamentary or democratic law. The people who shriek most about dictatorships and the crime of even mentioning the word "dictatorship" are those who are primarily and secondarily responsible for this increasing mob law throughout the country. Although I am opposed to any form of dictatorship, I would rather by far have a responsible dictator in the country than an irresponsible mob dictating to a weak Government in the country. We have every and ample evidence of the mob gradually getting out of hand, out of your hand, and getting into the saddle and driving you little by little. We have ample evidence in their references, 18 months' evidence, that when a thing is demanded this week in the journal, An Phoblacht, within one or two months that demand becomes a Government act. The thing has happened, as we have seen, in the removal of the Governor-General from office, in the removal of the Commissioner of Police from office, in the removal of the head of the Detective Department from office, in the Pensions Act and in the bludgeoning of the Government's political opponents. It has happened too often to be merely a coincidence. There are one or two explanations. Either these people rule or they have advance information of the Government's policy. The position is either that they rule the Government or that knowledge of Government action is given in advance to that organ of that illegal organisation which was banned by this Parliament and by the Church in this country. It has got to be one thing or the other, and we have got to know whether it is one way or the other, and we have to know to what extent there is cooperation and understanding as between this Government, the army of the Irish Republic outside, and the mob which has become the militia of that Army and Party.

We have the mob moving. We have every and ample evidence of it in connection with political meetings. We have that mob on the move; and we have an organisation that grew up in this country primarily to oppose the mob—we have that organisation being bludgeoned with all the power of a vindictive Government. We have every politician opposite from the President down slandering the members of that organisation, distorting their very phrases, and abusing them to the minds of the public. That action is being taken in order to bludgeon the members of an organisation which stands up against the mob and, further infuriating the mob against those who stand up for law and order. We have this drift towards mob law as a direct result of Ministerial utterances made in public and circulated through the Press of the world, calling upon the mob to prevent those who stand against Government policy being heard in this country. We have direct incitement out of the mouths of Ministers. We have the humiliating position in this country of the people being told that those who stand for what we stand for should not be allowed to speak openly and publicly before the people. As a result of these utterances, as a result of a statement by the Minister for Finance publicly made, that the Leader of the Opposition is a man who should be spat upon and similar utterances and incitements by other Ministers, the mob began to move. And when there is an effort made to stand between people on public platforms and the ferocity of an incited mob we have the demand made from the organs of the mob to suppress the organisation that stands between them and the speakers on public platforms. We have Government action accordingly; we have had it for the last 18 months inside and outside this House. I could produce weekly publications demanding that course, and I could make a fortune by betting even money that each week the demand made would be complied with. The highest people in the land, and the highest officers in the State, have been thrown out of their positions in response to those demands. Now when for the first time this country has thrown up an organisation to preach that it was decent to live a life within the law, and that it was decent to see fair play amongst the politicians within the Free State, against the policy of surrender to the mob, and the work of the mob, we have that organisation bludgeoned up and down the country. When that organisation, in response to that attitude, makes one great effort after another even in reply to unjust laws or through the misapplication of the law still to continue within the law they must be bludgeoned because of the very colour of the clothes they wear.

I consider that no matter how serious unemployment is, no matter how grave the whole labour situation may be in this country, incitements of that kind are still worse. We have had them this evening when the only Minister who intervened in this debate made a speech that was a deliberate incitement to mob fury to continue. He told us from the Government Front Bench that if a certain coloured shirt were worn in connection with particular meetings then we must expect a continuation of such episodes as occurred in Tralee. It was more scandalous than the hysterical vapourings of the Minister for Finance which started the whole thing. It was more disgraceful than the statement of that Minister that the Leader of the Opposition should be spat upon. We have had lectures from the Attorney-General on misbehaviour in Prussia Street, and on the assembly of 700 men in Clonmel. At any rate there was no life endangered on those occasions by missiles hurled and blows struck. There was only good humour but according to him there was interference with the law. Let us admit that. Is it that type of mild, and what I might call semi-constitutional breaches of the law that is agitating the minds of the Government and the journals that support them? Look at what is happening Sunday after Sunday in the country. You are starting up a demon in the country. Just think what will happen if it gets out of hand. That demon was brought into being through the mind and utterances of persons responsible for the Government of the country. The whole thing has been sinful from beginning to end. The whole thing has been most un-Irish, most un-national and most unnatural from beginning to end. The minds of the Government even at this late stage should be directed towards curbing a position which they have enloosed in the country rather than bludgeoning those people who, urged by their convictions, whether you agree with them or not, have, Sunday after Sunday, tried to meet that kind of thing.

Remember we are living in times where one shot might produce 20,000 shots within a night. We are a people, you might say, just emerging from a revolution, just emerging from a civil war, with arms—as the President knows—dumped up and down the country, arms not under the control of the State. I do not mind who has those arms; they are obtainable. Any man with a mob charging his platform, or with a mob attacking his leader until he is left with blood spurting from his head, knows that any one Sunday one shot may start a state of affairs in this country which everyone of us will regret but which none of us will be able to stop once it is started. I say that there is a responsibility on all sections of this House to agree and join together at least on this much— that we will all set our faces against that kind of thing, that we will all stand up against the mob whether that mob supports you or supports me, and that we will all join together in condemning any interference with any public man. There was a challenge thrown out from that side to-night, perhaps politically awkward to accept. A challenge was thrown out from the Government to the Opposition as to whether the Opposition would join in aiding the Government in seeing that certain sides of the law are respected throughout this land. The response was prompt; there had to be no putting of heads together before answering. The acting Leader of the Party answered there and then, and his answer was "yes." Now there is a counter-suggestion, that members of all Parties—but particularly the leaders of Fianna Fáil— should condemn this kind of thing and stand against it, use all their influence honestly against it and do it in really clear, expressive, and explicit language.

We do not want the kind of thing that happened before, the kind of Presidential utterances to the effect that he regrets that that kind of thing is going on but he cannot make any speaker popular. It is the "buts" that do the harm. The statement without the "but" would be milk and water, but it would not be harmful. It is those afterthoughts that are the curse of this country. It is that kind of speech we listened to from Deputy Derrig, Minister for Education, to-night. It is that kind of double shuffle—one foot in Parliament and one foot with the mob—that is doing the harm. Whatever the consequences are they will all be traced back to that kind of thing. I will leave the Minister for Finance out of it. When he is on his feet I never regard him as being a person responsible for his own utterances, but we have other types of men in the Government; we have men who, no matter how heated they are, are able to come out with considered phrases. It is those men I want to do a bit of thinking. It is those men I want to do a bit of leading, because, although we may get the beating, although we may be the first in the dust when the mob goes just a shade further than it has gone, it is the Government will pay the penalty, and it is the Government will have to clean up the mess. When they clean us up, or what is left of us, they have then got to face that same mob, blooded and encouraged by having their opponents in the dust. I would suggest this to the people opposite, that they are not doing that by tinhats and tanks. That is merely a display. That is merely playing up more to the mob, by giving the impression that but for those tinhats and but for those tanks, those men are so hated throughout the country that they could not be here. That is merely play-acting. Use your verbal and vocal influence and it will be far more powerful with the mob than tinhats and tanks.

I am not talking in any Party spirit when I raise those matters on the adjournment. I believe the responsibility is definitely there. The organ An Phoblacht claimed even last week that in their various actions against the law, in their Bass raids, in their interference with property and in their looting of shops, they are merely doing what was done ten years ago; that President de Valera told them he never changed in the last ten years; that neither did they; that they were merely acting in the same way as they acted ten years ago. They further point out in that statement that it was they put him in. I believe it, but that is no reason why they should be boss. As citizens with a vote they put in that Government, but that is no reason why that Government should be their tool. Governments should be masters; governments, above all, should be manly. This half-hearted jack-acting and playing up to the crowd, and then putting a face on things by rumbling out a tank, is not facing up to the responsibilities of office. One clear-cut statement from the President, and from each one of his Ministers, condemning that kind of thing as really blackguardly and cowardly, as it is, would do more than all the tanks you had in Cork. Remember the people that have been banned because of their attempt to stand against that kind of thing, the people who are still bullied because they continue to stand against it, have so far been going right and left, up a street or down a street, even at the request of one policeman, and even when they give the impression that they are running away from a mob, they are doing that under the policy of the man at the helm, which is that they will continue to keep within the law, no matter how difficult it is made; but that will not always hold. I said before that young blood is hot blood, and one of those days an episode will occur which will start a situation in this country that you cannot control.

Comment on this

What about the prominent members of your Party who are going around the towns brandishing revolvers and using filthy language to the decent citizens? What about the prominent chairman of your meetings in Thurles?

Comment on this

It is because there are revolvers in every county in this country, not under responsible control, that I am making this appeal to-night. I see no glory attached to a gun; I see no heroism attached to a gun. Any heroism that was ever attached to a gun depended on how the gun was used and against whom. There is no glory or heroism, either for people on your side or people on my side, in using guns in a dirty dog fight. Such heroism as I saw was displayed after the echoes of the rifle shots had ceased. When you see faces being patched together in order to try and find out who they once were, that kind of thing would make anybody pause and dread that they would ever see such a situation cropping up again in this country. We are very near it, and every Sunday is bringing us nearer to it—the mob being incited by such statements as we heard here to-night, the mob being incited by such statements as the Minister for Finance has repeatedly uttered, and the mob not being discouraged by the kind of statements which we have had so far from the President with regard to the situation. All that is going to have serious consequences if it is not stopped. My only reason for intervening in this debate here to-night is to ask this; will we all agree to this pact on the eve of the adjournment, that any attempt to break up or interfere with or start a riot at any public meeting, whether it is Fianna Fáil or Labour or United Ireland Party, will be condemned by everyone of us in clear language; that the people engaging in that will be called enemies of Ireland, traitors and a menace to this new Irish State; that we will call a spade a spade and that we will call them cowardly blackguards, every one of us? One week of a Party campaign on that particular subject would finish for all time in public life the necessity for bringing out armoured cars, either to protect a meeting or to prevent a riot when the cars are withdrawn.

Comment on this

For the first time since the debate began I am beginning to think that there is, perhaps, some value in having speeches on this adjournment motion. I objected at the beginning of this debate because it is only a couple of weeks since the Dáil came back. We had an adjournment debate on the Dáil ending its ordinary summer session. We had a "no confidence," or censure motion when we came back. We have had two or three debates in a period of two or three weeks on the particular matters that are being raised now. This adjournment simply means that we are keeping away until business is ready. It might have been an adjournment for one week or two, but I found out from the Departments that we could not have sufficient legislative proposals to keep the Dáil engaged before the expiration of three weeks at least. I regarded this adjournment debate as the ordinary adjournment debate we have been accustomed to. My understanding, this morning at any rate, was that after the business was completed, if there was to be an adjournment debate, it would be the ordinary half hour's debate. However, perhaps, as I say, there is some good in it and if it brings to the Deputies on the opposite side a realisation of what I have realised all the time, that it is very easy to unloose passions in this country, but very difficult to curb them when unloosed, we shall have done good work. Several times in the Dáil, in the past, I explained to Deputies what the Government policy was in regard to restoring peace in this country, genuine peace. We pursued that policy with patience for a period of over a year and I believe that the results justified the policy. Everything was not at all right, everything was not perfect, I admit, but it was heaven in comparison with the situation we had been passing through for years before. That is my opinion.

We were getting along in that situation. We had to stand attacks from the Opposition week after week and to me it appeared that the Opposition were really sorry that our policy was being so successful, that it was possible for us by pursuing that policy to bring about a state of peace that every good citizen must desire, because without it there can be no progress. It does not matter what direction we are going. If there is disorder in this country, if there is anything, such as has been suggested, such as mob law, then it is the end of all of us and the end of all the efforts of the nation.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Everybody must recognise that that was the considered policy of the Government. The very organisation that put us into office, the Fianna Fáil organisation, was founded on the principles that we were going to bring back again the people who had been, unfortunately, from the national point of view, divided as a result of differences on the Treaty policy, and giving them an opportunity of coming together, so that as far as possible all the old differences would be forgotten. That was a policy of permitting every Nationalist, who had any aspirations for the independence of the country, to pursue these aspirations in a peaceable way, in a way in which he could settle his differences with his neighbour by the only rule of order that human beings have been able to discover. I have been attacked for want of consistency. It has been suggested that my devotion to majority rule is quite a new thing. I deny that. There is absolute, positive, documentary evidence in the last ten or 12 years since these differences began that I recognised the fact that every sensible person must recognise that either we have got to settle our political differences by force or settle them by some rule of order.

I never suggested that there was in majority rule anything more than a rule of order, but that it was a precious rule of order I have held at all times, and the greater part of the efforts we made immediately after the Treaty to get a proper register, the efforts we made in the Pact to have the Constitution put before the people before they voted, the efforts we made when the "cease fire" order was issued, in which we made an offer to the Government of the day that once it were made possible to be represented in the national assembly, no matter what views one held, that then it followed that the Party that got a majority should be the Government and that that Party should be in effective control of lethal weapons—all that was a natural corollary. There is documentary evidence to that effect. Not merely were those principles accepted by us who were in command at the time, but the principles that we offered in the "cease fire" order were accepted by the whole of those who were at the time in the Republican ranks. At least, there was no protest against them. We were proceeding along those lines that that was the only principle that should be accepted as a rule of order.

It is not human that we should all think alike. It is not human no matter how sincere we may be in advancing the country's interests, that we should all have the same methods of trying to secure the country's interests. We are bound to differ, and as we are bound to differ it is necessary to have in the general interests this rule of order. We wanted to get it, and we founded the Fianna Fáil organisation in order to secure it. We were satisfied that if we could get rid of the Oath we would have 99 per cent. of those who stood against the Treaty at the time of the Treaty debates, with us in the future. We were succeeding. We were succeeding even beyond my hopes, and I had hopes that we would succeed, but Deputies on the other side, apparently, wanted to create friction by suggesting that we were simply the tools of some people outside, as Deputy O'Higgins has suggested just now. It is not true, and it never was true. We went on our own policy. A number of them supported us in the elections, I have no doubt whatever, because though they did not agree with us in policy generally, they considered the line of policy we were adopting was more in the direction of national interest as they conceived it. When we became a Government we made clear to everybody that we intended to be a Government and not to be the puppets or the tools of anybody, as somebody has suggested. I think General O'Duffy suggested that I went round the country—I am not quite sure of his words, it is perhaps doubtful if I am quoting him correctly —but my impression of what he said was that I went round organising a secret society. I never had anything to do with the organisation of a secret society. I refused from the first day I was elected as a public representative to have anything to do with a secret society, because I would not be the tool of any secret people. That is on record and it is known. Since we became a Government we have acted on our own view as to what was best in the national interest. In indicating what the Government policy was, I said that we wanted to be patient, but there were certain things we would regard as really dangerous, the beginning of a situation in which we would have to take immediate and direct control, and that was anything like a parade of armed or uniformed people in the streets. Immediately, when a man, who should have known something about the dangers of disorder, began to take a political part directly, the first thing he did was to associate himself with a certain organisation, and if he has been misrepresented it is he who has been at pains to misrepresent himself. If this was intended to be a peaceful political organisation he went an extraordinarily strange way about conveying that impression. We have been accustomed to politics in this country. Why did not General O'Duffy, if he wanted to take part in politics, take part like the ordinary political parties? He associated himself with a military movement. Is not that a fact?

Comment on this

It may become a joke in the end. I sincerely hope it will. I hope the statements made by the deputy Leader of the Opposition and the statements made even more powerfully by Deputy Hogan a short time ago will teach these people sense; that they will give up play-acting; and if they want to become a Government that they will go about it in the ordinary way. The suggestion has been made that they are being forced into this line because it is necessary to supplement the ordinary forces of the State in order to keep order. I know perfectly well how difficult it is, if meetings are held at the one time all over the country, to have any special force that can cope with them. I can quite understand that. But, in the circumstances of this country, does any sane person think that the way to do it was to go and put on blue shirts, to put on a sort of semi-military garb and come out with the proclamations and statements made by General O'Duffy which were intended to usurp power here? Was that the way to do it? The proper way to do it was this: to give every support that could be given to the Government and the forces at their command to keep order.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

How will support be given? Not by usurpation of their authority, not by irresponsible people, irresponsible in the sense that they had no responsibility, taking action. The proper way to do it was this: to say to the Government: "If you have not got the ordinary forces and are not capable of keeping order it is your duty to organise the whole citizenry if necessary in order to keep order." We would have done that if it were necessary to keep order and to guarantee under this system we are working that people with different political views to ours should have an opportunity of freely expressing these views. If it were necessary, in order to guarantee that, to enrol half the citizenry of the country we would have done it and we would have got a force which would be definitely under control, definitely responsible, and that would have guaranteed that. You cannot guarantee it in a partisan way. You cannot guarantee it if the Opposition tries to use its organisation to usurp the functions of government. What I say to the Opposition is this: Give up this nonsense of blue shirts. It can lead to nothing but damage and disorder over the country. It is going to unloose things that you will not be able to control and that it will be difficult for us, even with the whole citizenry, to end. If these extreme means are going to bring this country into discredit, damage and danger, by Heavens, we will come out and ask the sane people of the country to knock the heads of both parties together. That is what we will do if we have to do it. We will be well able to do it. The sane people of the country would be well able to knock the heads of both parties together if they continue with this nonsense.

Comment on this

The sane people will soon organise themselves.

Comment on this

They will. This sort of thing makes it impossible for anybody to make progress. I am asked to talk without "buts." The deputy Leader of the Opposition had many "buts" in his speech and I hope he will study his own speech carefully when he sees it in print, and the next time he talks to Ministers here about qualifying statements he will understand what I mean. He put as many "buts" in the case of the no-rates campaign as ever I put. I do say that the present situation is one in which we will have to be very careful about our "buts," no matter what side we are talking about. We want, and we assure the public that every force at our command will be used, to keep order. At the first meeting which I addressed recently, I said that the one thing I feared for the future of the country was disorder and that anybody who created disorder, no matter what side he was on, was really an enemy of the country. I said that. I did not have to be prompted to say it. It was one of the first things I said, because I was looking ahead and realised that we were not very far off from the time of the civil war; that most of us were fairly young men, that we are still not too old, that our memories are pretty lively and our feelings pretty hot, and that it was very unwise, when the country was such a short distance from the civil war, to stir up passions such as have been stirred up recently. There is no use in casting recriminations across the floor of the House. I am accused of unloosing them. In my opinion, and I say it honestly, that was the main damage that was being done by the Opposition recently when they were unloosing these things. It would tax us all to the utmost once they were unloosed to curb them. I was delighted to hear the speech of Deputy O'Higgins. It was the most hopeful thing I have heard for a long time. The other hopeful thing was the speech I heard from Deputy Hogan recently, although it was interlarded with a good deal of personal attack. I hope the members of the Party opposite will follow the lead Deputy Hogan and Deputy O'Higgins have given in this matter and that they themselves will act honestly in accordance with it and will not set out and tax the resources of the Government in maintaining order.

I do not think there is much use in speaking any further on the matter. My mind is clearly known upon the matter. The attitude and mind of the Government are known upon the matter. We want to maintain order and we pledge ourselves to use all the resources that the community can give us to maintain order, provided that other people in the community, who ought to be as interested in keeping order as we are, do not set out deliberately to create conditions which we cannot control or which will tax us beyond what is reasonable. What are the forces at our command? We have got the Army and we have the Guards. What is the attitude of Deputies on the benches opposite with regard to the Guards? There is scarcely a speech that they make that they do not attempt to undermine the morale of the Guards. The influence of the Government with the country is attempted to be undermined by statements like Deputy O'Higgins made to-night, that we are the puppets of people outside. What if some newspaper does happen to anticipate things which anybody who knew what our programme was could have anticipated once he saw the circumstances? Was it not quite obvious that the moves we were going to make with regard to the Governor-General and so on were in line with our programme? Did it require a wonderful acquaintance with Government policy or any influence over the Government to be able to anticipate that the Bills which we passed through the House to-day would be brought in? What is the use of pretending that we are under the influence of certain people because they, happening to understand what our policy is, are able to say that such and such a thing should be done? Do not Deputies know well that that is one of the political methods of trying to get credit for things by trying to anticipate what other people are going to do and to suggest that they are doing them because the pressure is being brought to bear upon them? It is perfectly obvious that anybody who knew our programme and saw the conditions would be able to anticipate a number of things. The suggestion is that, through a demand like that, we dispensed with the services of General O'Duffy when he was Commissioner of Police. Nothing of the sort. We held him for a year and odd months and dispensed with him only when we felt that there was a situation in which it was essential that the person in charge should have the full confidence, the absolute confidence, of the Government. I think that some of his actions recently at least ought to show people that there was a certain amount of justification anyhow for the feeling that we could not have complete confidence in that position in General O'Duffy. Now we have to be the judges. We may not have been the best judges. I suppose Deputies opposite differ from us, but we acted in accordance with our own judgement of the situation. We acted, we believe, in the best interests of the country, and I believe that in that regard anyhow subsequent events have proved that we were not unwise.

But coming back to the Guards, what is the use in Deputies opposite suggesting that if the Guards do their duty, as we ask them to do their duty and to do it impartially, that they are going to be penalised by us? There is not the slightest shadow of justification for any such charge. When General O'Duffy was in charge and when the elections were coming on I brought him to my own room and said: "We want to guarantee freedom of speech and we want to guarantee freedom of public meeting to our opponents. The whole forces of the State are at your command to do that." Was there any evidence there that we were not prepared to put all the resources of the State, such as we had immediately at our disposal, or to get more if they were required, in order to guarantee these things? There is not the slightest justification for any such suggestion that we do not want the police to carry out their duty. We do. I have guaranteed before in public and I say it now to every single Guard throughout the country, of high rank or low, that if they do their duty they will have the complete support of this Government. It is necessary for them to have the support of the Government. They have a difficult task to do, and it is not fair and is not in the best interests of the community and of the country as a whole that Deputies on the Opposition Benches should be suggesting that the Guards who have a very difficult task to do, a task that requires plucky men to perform very often, if they do their duty will not have the full support of the Government. They will have it.

As I have said, there are many things that could be said in this debate that I do not think it is necessary to go into now. There is one thing that I hope everybody will realise and it is that we are in a serious position. There is a serious position in this country and we will require the help of all right-minded citizens, of everybody who has a sane view of what is best for the country—the assistance of all on both sides in this House and of those outside who take a different side in politics— in order to pass through this situation unscathed. It is a dangerous situation and could develop to be very dangerous. It was because of that that we brought in the Public Safety Act at the start. We felt that it was sufficiently dangerous to see that the necessary steps were taken to maintain the authority of the Government and that the position did not get out of hand.

There is one other matter that I want to refer to before I sit down: that is the question referred to by several Deputies about Deputy Mulcahy. Giving the information which I honestly had and giving it as I did in front of Deputy Mulcahy when he was in a position immediately to deny it if untrue was, in my opinion, the fairest way in which that could be done. There are other people who would go round as I well know in a whispering campaign. I knew that the thing was talked of elsewhere and I gave Deputy Mulcahy an opportunity of denying it. I would have taken his denial at once. When he asked for a tribunal my understanding of it was that he was afraid that his denial would not be accepted by others as it would have been accepted by me.

Comment on this

Yes, exactly. That is so and every honest-minded person in the House will believe me when I say it: that what Deputy Mulcahy really wanted the tribunal for was that he feared that his denial would not take with it full conviction.

Comment on this

And why not the tribunal?

Comment on this

I offered it then to give him the chance of making it clear that he did not do this thing.

Comment on this

What are you going to do about Pigott?

Comment on this

Then afterwards when I set about the tribunal I found that there was not evidence forthcoming that would justify the setting up of the tribunal.

Comment on this

I did not have to wait until now to make that statement. The moment that I gave the promise to the Dáil I set about it to see that everything would be ready for the tribunal and that there would be no delay. Then I found that the person who gave the information was not going to come forward, that he admitted that a portion of his statement, a vital part of it, was not true. The moment I got that I came to the Dáil. I gave the facts to the Dáil which completely exonerated Deputy Mulcahy, and there is not one in the country at the present time who has the slightest doubt about the matter. Therefore, there was no need whatever for an inquiry.

Comment on this

You told the lie all the same.

Comment on this

I told no lie. I am not in the habit of telling lies.

Comment on this

I think we might justifiably ask the President why he did not make the very small amount of inquiry that was needed before instead of after giving publicity to that statement.

Comment on this

That is a fair question. There was a fair amount, what I consider a fair amount, of inquiry. As the Deputy well knows I did not charge or suggest that I believed it further than that there were circumstances to be taken into account.

Comment on this

Go and read what I said. The Deputy's interruption is just the same as Deputy MacDermot's the other day when he talked about gall and wormwood. He will not take the pains to see the connection. It is very easy to take one part out of a statement.

Comment on this

I do not know why the President should refer to me at all.

Comment on this

I am referring to him because it is the same sort of thing. I suggest that if anybody reads the statement that I made, the circumstances and the way in which I said it, it is quite clear that I gave Deputy Mulcahy an opportunity there and then of denying it. I did not charge him with doing anything. I said that information came to the Government —came to me, that was a fact. Everybody who has ever had anything to do with getting evidence knows that very often you get people who will satisfy you up to a certain stage. They are prepared to give evidence and then when put to the absolute test they will fail.

Comment on this

I did not say that the President made a charge, and I do not know why he thinks I said it. What occurred, as well as I recollect, was that the President said that was one of the reasons which induced him to apply the Public Safety Act. Then there were two or three mysterious allegations, one by the President himself and one by the Minister for Finance before the statement was actually made at all about an Austin car in Glasgow which bewildered Deputy Mulcahy.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact I might not have made the statement at all were it not for the fact that Deputy Mulcahy in a most wanton way started again talking about firing from behind hedges in Kerry or something like that.

Comment on this

He did not talk about firing.

Comment on this

Well, what was it— ambushing?

Comment on this

He said lying behind a hedge. Use the exact words as you so often tell us to do.

Comment on this

Well, if lying behind a hedge does not suggest ambushing or firing I do not know what it suggests. At any rate, I believe that any due amends that were required were made and were made not ungenerously, and that Deputy Mulcahy does not labour under any grievance in regard to the matter. All that can be said or even be suggested about the whole thing was that I should have gone further, as suggested by Deputy MacDermot just now, before I made the statement by having it substantiated and verified. I had it substantiated and verified to the extent that I said while these happenings, which were reported and which were a danger, were going on, I had, at the same time, information that was adduced as truth. I do not propose to say anything more about that. I say that so far as it was possible to do the thing honourably and straight, and to make amends, if there was any harm done to Deputy Mulcahy, I made them. Of course, the people on the opposite benches do not care a thraneen about the thing. All they want to do, if they can, is to make some political capital out of it. Is not that obvious here, and is it not obvious to the people in the country as well? The people know just as well as we do how to set a value on these sort of manæuvres—the sensible people who can be organised, if needs be, to knock the heads of people creating this together. I have dealt with the various matters that were raised, although in my opinion this one was not strictly in accordance with precedent. At the same time, it has not, perhaps, done any harm.

Comment on this

I move: "That the question be now put."

Comment on this

I do not know if I would be in order in correcting one statement that the President made. He said I had accused him of having qualified his condemnation of disorder. I am not saying that such an accusation would not be justified, but, in point of fact, I never made it. He said that I had qualified my condemnation of a no rates campaign.

Comment on this

What else did the Deputy do?

Comment on this

I wish to deny absolutely that I in any way qualified my condemnation of a no rates campaign.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am accepting the motion.

Comment on this

Might I ask a question by way of a change from what we have had? Some time ago, the Minister for Agriculture told farmers to hold the oat crop and that they would get a good price—a better price for it——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have accepted the motion.

Comment on this

I would like to know if the Minister has made arrangements to enable the farmers to get that price, in view of the fact that the farmers have the oats ready for sale. I think the Minister for Defence also told the farmers of Louth to hold the oats and that they would get 14/- instead of selling at 7/- a barrel. This is an important matter, as it affects the welfare of the farmers.

Comment on this

The President has made a remarkable——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have accepted the motion.

Comment on this