In Committee on Finance. - Local Services (Temporary Economies) (No. 2) Bill, 1933—Committee.
Contributions 1–139 of 273. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 67 of 1933 ›
May we discuss the part of the section to which there is no amendment first? I ask this merely as a matter of procedure.
Comment on this
I propose to put two questions to decide the issues raised in these amendments: First that the words "a school attendance committee" and a "committee of agriculture," lines 32 and 33 stand, secondly that the words "vocational education committee," in the same lines stand. There will thus be two divisions if two divisions are claimed. Amendments 1 to 6 inclusive.
Comment on this
That includes 1 to 6, but amendment 6 not merely deals with the teacher employed by the vocational education committee but, also, an officer employed by that committee. I would like some distinction. There might be some administrative officer in connection with this type of work who operates under the vocational education committee, who is not employed in teaching. I have joined them together I admit.
Comment on this
It might be possible to deal with that particular type of differentiation on Report.
Comment on this
The only thing is, whether, if this is dealt with now by division, we would be precluded from raising the question of differentiation between an officer and a teacher on Report.
Comment on this
What does the Deputy suggest? I propose to put two questions on amendments Nos. 1 to 6.
Comment on this
What about sub-section (1), paragraph (a), to which there is no amendment? Can we not discuss that now?
Comment on this
The point might be raised on the section. No amendment has been offered to that portion of the section.
Comment on this
No. There is no amendment, but it is to delete paragraph (a), I move to wipe out all three. Deputy Norton has a restricting amendment.
Comment on this
Might I suggest that we should have the debate in two sections? First we could debate the question of cutting out all reference to educational committees, and secondly, to cutting out all reference to the school attendance committees, but not to debate them both together as there are two questions to be put.
Comment on this
Why not debate the two together and have separate divisions if the Committee desires? They are closely allied matters.
Comment on this
I will move my amendment in its restricted application to the vocational committee, but that is the same practically as Deputy Norton's amendment. I am proposing to move that portion of my amendment that deals only with the vocational committee. Deputy Norton's amendment is restricted to that point.
Comment on this
I propose amendment No. 1. The sub-section says "a school attendance committee, a vocational education committee, and a committee of agriculture." The effect of bringing in these three bodies here is, that in a later section of the Bill those employed or operating under the auspices of these three committees, whatever their emoluments or commission, everything they get is subject to a certain cut. I want to exempt those employed by the vocational education committee. We have been told by the Minister that the whole Bill is going to effect a saving of £35,000. We know, as we read through the Bill, that that money is not going to accrue either to the taxpayer or the ratepayer in any single respect. Whatever is saved will scrupulously fall back into the fund out of which it was previously paid. There is going to be no saving so far as the taxpayer is concerned. It seems to be an absurd thing, in order to allow a very small sum of money to fall back into a fund raised by local authorities, to upset a committee such as the vocational education committee and to disturb those employed under it. I want to segregate this service particularly because it is the only service the inauguration of which was attended with a considerable amount of debate. There was what amounted to agreement, that the emoluments of the people coming into these services in this way were small. It was indeed expressed as an excuse, for the point at which they are fixed, that they were more or less experimental, and even with that excuse it was admitted that the experiment was on the low side.
The Minister for Education who was speaking at the time did give a promise that mandatory salaries would be prescribed for the vocational education officers. He took power to prescribe salaries. In other words, it was apprehended that the salaries likely to be fixed would not be sufficient or adequate to the work to be performed, and with the consent of the House it was then proposed, and accepted, to give powers to the Minister afterwards to establish salaries which could not be interfered with. Since then these mandatory salaries have not been established. So far from being established, and so far from the power given by the House being exercised, for that particular purpose, it is now proposed to take away something of what was since given. Let us get a balance on all this. This is not going to save the taxpayers at all. There is no chance of saving the taxpayers or the ratepayers anything at all measurable. Take out all that is to be saved under the whole Bill and it has no force in relation either to the moneys that can be saved or the work that is being disturbed. On the other hand, face up to these facts that we are dealing with people who have only recently been in the position I have described, and, add the further fact, that we are dealing with these in a group that got a promise of an upper grade. There is now a tendency downwards and you are certain to have an amount of discontent sown amongst those people. It is going to spread naturally from those people. The Vocational Education Act was supposed to be the beginning of a new system and the people who were to be appointed under it and who were to operate under it were supposed to be the inaugurators of a new scheme of things under the auspices of those vocational education committees in association with local authorities. Instead of being allowed to do their work even under the restricted circumstances held out to them, they are going to be further restricted. No real excuse has been given for it. Again I urge, as I did previously when the main Economies Bill, which has been a fiasco as far as saving is concerned, was introduced, that it is a grossly immoral thing to pick out people to have their salaries cut against whom the allegation cannot be made that they are overpaid either in relation to the experience or talents they have or to the work they do and to hack at their salaries simply because they are people in the second remove from the Government. What makes them open to attack is not anything inherent either in the work they do or the importance of the posts they occupy, but simply that they are near the Government, and that is the sole reason for this choice.
There has never been an argument put forward in the House with regard to these people or the other people in the public service whose salaries were cut that they were not doing the work for which they were paid; that the work was not of the importance which entitled them to the old-time sum, or that the work had become lessened in any degree. None of these arguments was made. It is simply that these people are near the Government when they are striking out blindly. These were the first people on whom their fists lighted because they were in close proximity. They have now moved down another step from the people immediately under the State to the people under the local authorities. There is no pretence made that there is economy in this. The only excuse made is that they are determined to spread the hardship all round; that they have come in here and done a certain amount of injury to the country and everybody must share in it. That is not an argument that should weigh with regard to people in a service inaugurated under the circumstances I have explained. I am going to press definitely to a conclusion the amendment that vocational education committees should be excepted from this.
Comment on this
I want to support the proposal to delete the officers of vocational education committees from the scope of the Bill. There are many unwarranted things done under the Bill, but there seems to be the least possible excuse for bringing within the scope of the Bill the employees of vocational education committees. As Deputy McGilligan pointed out, the imposition of a cut on the salaries of these officers will yield no revenue to the State. It will yield no easement to the burden of taxation of the local ratepayer. It seems to me that the proposal to include such officers is based either on a complete misconception of what is involved or merely a desire to impose a cut for the sake of imposing a cut. The rating authority for the vocational education committee is the county council. Even if this Bill is passed, and assuming that these cuts are imposed, the rating authority would still continue to levy a fixed rate for vocational education purposes and to that extent the local ratepayer gets no relief. Assuming the vocational education committee cuts the salaries of its employees, then, under Section 20 of the Bill, the Minister will deduct no grant from any local education authority which complies with the terms of the Act. So that you have got the position that when the local authority cuts the salaries of its employees the State saves nothing, because it continues the old grant, and the local ratepayer gets no relief because there is a statutory obligation to levy a fixed rate for the purpose of vocational education. There is no saving whatever to the local ratepayer. There is no saving to the central State funds. What merely happens is that the local authority has still the old sum available for vocational education purposes but is definitely prohibited by the Minister from continuing to pay the old salaries even though the local vocational education committee felt it was bound to pay the old salaries as a matter of equity between themselves and the employees.
As Deputy McGilligan said, vocational education is relatively a new service here. It ought to start under the happiest possible auspices and under the most congenial possible circumstances. It seems to me hardly likely that a Bill of this kind is going to promote that efficiency and contentment which are so necessary at the outset of a move of this kind in our national life. Vocational education officers, as most people know, are notoriously underpaid. The overwhelming majority of those officers are paid salaries which nobody could possibly justify either in relation to the work they perform or to their human or civic responsibilities. When the Vocational Education Act of 1930 was passing through the House they were promised that something would be done in the way of prescribing for local vocational education committees a mandatory scale of salaries which it was then felt would have to be forced on the local vocational education committees in order to get them to recognise the responsible work which the officers of the committees were performing. That was in 1930. In the intervening four years nothing has been done to implement the promises then made or to take advantage of that particular section of the 1930 Act to endeavour to create a national scale of salaries for people employed by such local authorities. Instead of the State facing up to its responsibility under the Act and realising it ought to pay reasonable salaries to those employees, instead of some effort being made to put the remuneration on some kind of reasonable basis, it is now proposed to brush aside all that was said and implied when the Act was passing through the House, and instead of presenting them with a decent scale of salaries to present them with cuts which will only aggravate instead of improving their position.
Under the Vocational Education Act of 1930 certain employees of the old technical instruction committees were taken over by the new committees and a special section in that Act—I think Section 99—provided that those who were so transferred should hold their office on the same terms and conditions as formerly. That seemed to be an implied promise by the State that there would be no reduction whatever in the remuneration of the officers transferred from one committee to an entirely new committee, functioning in a different way. Now apparently under this Bill that particular section of the 1930 Act is to be torn up and cuts imposed, as I contend, in flagrant defiance of the definite guarantee given to them under Section 99 of the 1930 Act. There is no case for including those officers. I think all sections of the House, including the Minister's own Party, would very much prefer that he came to the House prescribing a reasonable rate of salaries for vocational education officers instead of asking them to cut salaries which are disgracefully low at present, and which I say are not calculated to make officers of vocational education committees either attentive to work or efficient in its performance.
Comment on this
It is worth noting the different type of speech that has been made in the House here, such as the one which has been made by Deputy McGilligan on this question of salary cuts for teachers employed under vocational education bodies, and the type of speech that his colleagues in the Party have been making during the last few months all over the country. There we are told that the country is fast being driven into bankruptcy, that the farmers are in a state bordering on destitution, that there is no money for anything in the country. That is the type of speech to which we have been listening for a long time, and I have no doubt we will hear it again from many of the Deputy's colleagues, and may be from the Deputy himself when he is in other places. I am sure Deputy Keating, when he is speaking on behalf of the farmers, will be shedding tears —I will not say crocodile tears——
Comment on this
So far as the Minister is concerned, the farmers are prosperous, but he will hear a different tale when he goes amongst them.
Comment on this
Deputy Keating's friend, who is sitting beside him, will be doing the same thing, shedding tears in County Cork, as he has been doing for many weeks. Other Deputies on the Party opposite, for their own good political reasons, will be making the country appear in the very last stages of destitution, and particularly the farming community. Now, when a proposal is made to effect more economies, Deputy McGilligan, one of the leaders of the Party opposite, makes a howl about the teachers, the poor salaried classes.
Comment on this
I am sure there are many colleagues of Deputy McGilligan who will feel they are being placed in an awkward position. They will have to go around the country and try to explain away Deputy McGilligan's speech. Many of the Deputies opposite have told us time and again that there are not enough economies. All over the country they have been howling for economies and for the reduction of salaries.
Comment on this
I am aware that they were howling for the return of their markets, which is quite a different thing.
Comment on this
They have been howling for economies, reductions in salaries. I have files here, newspaper cuttings.
Comment on this
I have here newspaper cuttings showing that various local authorities, of which Deputies opposite are members, have been howling out for cuts, and not alone that, but they have actually adopted cuts not of 5 per cent., 10 per cent., or 15 per cent., but of 20 per cent. and 25 per cent. in relation to the salaries of local officers. Deputies over there know that is quite true, and are aware that they have done that in all parts of the country, north, south, cast and west. Deputy McGilligan's colleagues have been cutting salaries to the extent of 25 per cent. in some cases. There are some here who will say that a cut of 5 per cent. is not enough. I know that the colleagues of the Deputy, if they were free to speak, would rather have a cut of 10 per cent. or 20 per cent.
Comment on this
I was never a cutter of wages or salaries, and I could never approve of a Party that has thrown away the staple industry of the people.
Comment on this
Colleagues of the Deputy all over the country have advocated huge cuts. They have demanded cuts in the salaries of civil servants and public officials of all kinds. I do not think any member of the Party can deny that. I do not think that the opposition of Deputy McGilligan and his Party—I presume he speaks for the Party—to this proposed cut, is serious. In the case of officers of vocational education committees, if the proposed cut were eliminated it would place them in a position that I do not think, as public servants, they are entitled to be placed in, particularly when it is proposed to cut the salaries of all other servants of public authorities.
Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Norton reminded us that these officers were paid on a lower scale some years ago and that when the Act of 1930 was being put through the House certain promises were made to those officers of improved salaries. While the Minister has not availed of the authority to prescribe salaries, he has used his influence with the local authorities to have the salaries of these people raised to what he believed was a proper amount. The suggestions made by him to these local authorities dealing with vocational education, to put the salaries of their officials on a basis that he considered reasonable, have been adopted by authorities all over the country, with three exceptions. There are three local authorities that have refused, so far, to raise the salaries to the rate that the Minister considered would be commensurate with the duties performed by the officials. In all other cases the salaries have been raised in accordance with the promise given by the then Minister in this House. I think that disposes of the arguments of Deputy Norton and Deputy McGilligan.
Comment on this
I am told that the salaries of these vocational education officers have been raised in accordance with what the Minister believed should be their salaries.
Comment on this
I am aware that the salaries were raised by all the local authorities, with three exceptions.
Comment on this
Can you give us a general picture of the existing scales and indicate what are the annual increments that are being provided?
Comment on this
Under a circular dated in April of last year the scales would appear to be:— Men, £130, rising by annual increments of £10 to £200; women, £120, rising by annual increments of £10 to £170, together with such cost of living bonus on the Civil Service scale in each case as may be approved from time to time by the Minister for Finance. The circular points out that manual instructors will not be eligible for increments on the scale beyond £150 unless they have obtained a manual instructor's certificate. That, in general, shows an increase, in some cases a fairly considerable increase, on what were the salaries paid before this cirucular was issued to and adopted by the local authorities. The improved scales have been adopted by 38 committees and there were three exceptions, namely, Kilkenny, Monaghan and Leitrim. That, I think, disposes very largely, if not altogether, of the case made as to the poor salary that was paid to these teachers previous to 1930. It is true that the Minister has not prescribed but he has written to and circularised all these bodies and he has induced them to raise, and to raise in some cases very considerably, the salaries paid these officials to the level that he thought was within the capacity of the committees to pay and up to the standard of the work that they were doing for the public.
It is not true to say that none of this money saved by this Bill will be saved to the local authorities. The money will be credited to them. The saving made will be credited to the next year's estimates and that money will be available for their work in the future. There will be a certain saving, a saving which some people may say is not sufficient. But this is the minimum scale and there will certainly be recoupment to the State, not of a very large amount but nevertheless there is economy and there is a saving, a saving both to the ratepayers and to the taxpayers. While, as Deputy Norton says, the committees will have to raise the amount specified for education in the coming year, nevertheless this money saved in this way will be saved to them and it will be at their disposal for next year's work.
Comment on this
The Minister has mentioned certain salaries for teachers under the vocational education committees. These salaries are below the scale with which this Bill deals. I do not think there is any bigger blot on our whole system of building up the country than the scale of salaries paid to technical instructors and technical instructresses. A number of affairs operated to make that so, but the fact that it is so, with all that comes later on from it, explains why our technical education is in the backward position in which it is. The salaries that are dealt with in this Bill are the salaries paid to people who have the higher responsibilities under these local bodies, but they do bear a relation in the smallness of their size to the more disgraceful salaries that exist lower down.
The Minister is, no doubt, sensitive with regard to the position in which the farmers find themselves. We find a report in this morning's Press that for the payment of an outstanding sum of £25 in rates, a woman in South Tipperary had her 11 in-calf cows seized by the sheriff. We can understand how sensitive the Minister is with regard to the position of the farmers. But the condition of affairs which brings about a situation that makes the Minister sensitive with regard to that, also brings about a situation for him and the Executive Council in which they are asking for a complete revolution in our farming methods and a complete revolution in the work to be done by the instructors and instructresses under the agricultural committees.
The instructors have a very big function to perform in the sphere of education. The students leaving the secondary schools, who are going to carry on the farming industry, have very important functions. Unless the machinery has been functioning, and unless those who are to direct the machinery for giving instruction in agricultural work under our agricultural committees have enthusiasm, the results that the Minister hopes for, and the results that we hope for, generally, for better agricultural education in the country are not going to be reached. On the purely agricultural side alone, an effort is being made to increase our agricultural output and to increase the efficiency and the adaptability of our people. But when they have gained their education, fitting them for engaging in industry, this is a step that will not lead to increased enthusiasm.
We look to the teachers under the vocational education committees to supply not only instruction, but to be prepared to work to influence the minds of our growing people for engaging in industry. We look to them also for enthusiasm, and if we do not get that enthusiasm we are not going to get the results that are necessary in our vocational education. Anyone who has had experience, say, of technical schools in the City of Dublin, whether in Kevin Street or Bolton Street, and who has seen the pupils coming from ordinary schools to take up work there under the type of teachers which Dublin has been able to provide, realises what the new outlook on secondary education is and what the students are going to get from being brought into touch with the type of teacher that exists in the City of Dublin.
The Vocational Education Act, passed some years ago, was intended to take some of the anaemia out of the educational system in the country. I do not know that it has achieved much in making our technical education schemes bear more on industry than they did in the past, but, nevertheless, since that Act was passed, a number of young teachers have been drafted into the scheme. A number of executive officers have been brought in. A new ideal has been set before them and new hopes have been built that not alone will they get assistance to carry on their work, but that they will have an opportunity of serving the State in preparing boys and girls leaving schools for a more suitable and more effective entry into the technical life of the country than did the technical schools in the past. Here, again, the enthusiasm and efficiency of the particular scheme that is dealing with technical education is going to be impaired.
The Minister for Education wanted certain clauses referred to himself to secure that adequate salaries would be paid to the teachers working under these bodies. The other day, in Kilkenny, he declared that it was the duty of the State to provide provision so that young men with patriotic fervour and patriotic aspirations would have an opportunity of working for these things. And within the last week we passed a Vote here which, even for the few remaining months of this financial year, is double the amount of the saving that would be made under this Bill. I submit, when you take into consideration the statements made on behalf of the Executive Council with regard to the new hope, the new activity and the new developments that they say are taking place, and that they hope will take place more and more widespread throughout the country in both industry and agriculture, one cannot understand this Bill. When we hear that they are to have an enthused machinery that must be utilised to bring about these things, and when we compare what they are doing on a more futile and destructive side, we have a measure not alone of their competence but of their wisdom. I am of opinion that the proposals in the measure, as far as vocational committees and committees of agriculture are concerned, are going to undermine the enthusiasm and efficiency of a body of men and women throughout the country whose services and whose enthusiasm are so urgently needed at the present time.
Comment on this
The Minister for Local Government and Public Health commented upon the speeches that were made through the country, pointing out that the country is in decay and despair, and he opines that it will be very hard to reconcile the speeches made here to-night with those phrases. People who really believe that this country is in decay, and have grounds for that belief, will not take much solace from £35,000 being saved on this measure, when they think of the extra expense that has been brought on the State, say, in the last week, by the present Minister. If the Minister wishes to create any confusion or embarrassment about speeches in this House and speeches outside it, will he let us know how he will feel when he next addresses the people and tells them that everything is rosy? That was his phrase—everything is rosy. I wonder if he has ever read Dickens, and found the Marchioness asking the person who used that phrase to pass the rosy. He ought to pass the rosy prospects on to other people. How are the people being benefited by £37,000 being saved through cuts this week, and maybe a quarter of a million pounds paid out next week? Go and tell them that £1,000 is going to be saved on the cutting of the vocational education officers' and teachers' salaries this week, and that to-morrow we will establish a new publicity department for the Government at the cost of a couple of thousand pounds.
Think of the speeches that will be made. Everything is perfect in the country according to the Minister. Never was such an effort made to get the country saved. The battle has been won according to the three times statement of the Minister. What he says three times is presumably true. The country is being saved. We are well out of the old decay. There are the 300 factories, which have not yet been discovered, the vast number of people who are crowding into employment, the money that must be in circulation through the country by reason of the vast increase in the industrial development of the country. How does all that square with this attack on the salaries of people who are not expressed in this House as being overpaid? What about the other economies that were promised without touching anybody's salary? Has the Minister forgotten the advertisements—the million pounds that were to be saved, the close calculation that had been made upon the examination of the current estimates of about three years ago? The Minister was one of the people who was satisfied that a saving of £1,000,000 could be achieved without cutting salaries. Does he remember the old speech I have often referred to which Deputy Cooney made—appropriately, as I always said—at Grangegorman, where he talked about the administrative programme including a saving of £2,000,000 on the Army? Deputy Cooney must have been temporarily located there in the last fortnight, when he allowed, not a saving of £2,000,000, but an increase of a quarter of a million pounds. He must have known that his Minister was coming in with an attempt to cut the salaries of local authorities and save this miserable £35,000. Deputy Cooney, in that same speech, promised a saving of half a million pounds on the Civic Guards, instead of which we have got the Broy Harriers. Those are some of the things which the Minister might reconcile when next, if at all, he attempts to address the people of the country.
This measure effects no economy. It is a miserable attempt at economy. It does not show that there is any seriousness in the talk of economy. It is not based upon any principle. It does not proceed upon the grounds that the people attacked here are being overpaid, that their work is unnecessary, or that the services they render to the country do not, or would not ordinarily, warrant their getting the moneys that are being paid to them. None of those arguments on the merits is put up. The Minister simply comes in here and says "I happen to have a body of people under my thumb, the civil servants. I am going to take something off their salaries; when I have finished with those I am coming to the second group." His best argument here to-night was that it would be an impossible position to leave those people uncut when everybody else in the local services is going to be cut. He has not yet said why those people are going to be cut—just that they are; just because of the Minister's inefficiency, just because the Minister and his Government blundered into an economic war. It has been declared here recently and shown conclusively that we are actually having more extracted from us in taxes on our produce than what we have withheld. Because more money is being paid to the British through the economic war the local authority services have got to be cut! Who is held out for cutting under this particular amendment? First of all, those people—let me repeat—were promised that their salaries would be fixed on a particular scale and that that scale would be made mandatory on the local authority by act of the Minister for Education, or of the Minister for Finance. That has not be done. That promise has not been carried out. The Minister tells us to-day that some time recently the Minister for Education wrote to the vocational education committees and used some influence to get certain things done. When was that letter written?
Comment on this
In April last. Speaking in this House in regard to the whole measure in June of last year the Minister did not say he wrote that letter then. Imagine the views that the vocational education committees must have taken of the Minister who came to them and said: "Put up the salaries or give some boost to the salaries of those people," when they knew that he had previously put in a "Cuts" Bill, and only went to the local authorities because he was afraid to face the Division Lobby on it. The salaries have not been raised. They certainly have not been raised in fulfilment of the promise as to mandatory salaries that was given. That is the first thing. We have said there is no saving to the taxpayer. That has not been argued. There is not a shilling of saving to the taxpayer. I have argued, and still contend, that there is no saving to the ratepayer. The Minister says there is—that next year they will be eased in their Budget. How is that? I had understood that the rate that had to be levied for vocational education was fixed—that it was compulsory. What is the saving, therefore? They are going to save money, and in these times when money is required to be spread over the people of the community for their spending, what is going to happen is that the same compulsory rate will be levied, but instead of being paid out as previously to those people in salaries it is going to be saved. We said this was no saving to the ratepayer. That is correct. Again, taking the position as I have described it, that this mandatory arrangement was not made, what is the situation with regard to those vocational teachers at the moment? They claim—the claim may be somewhat exaggerated but it is very close to the truth—that they are so lowly paid that 90 per cent. will be below the scale at which the cuts begin. I do not think it is so high, but certainly there will not be very many of them. In the main, as a body, they are below the attacked scales, so it is only a certain percentage of them that is going to be attacked. There is another thing which particularises those people from anybody else. First of all, they did not get their salaries raised as they were promised; they are generally on a low scale; because of the fall arising from the cut in the bonus they have lost in the last number of years, and, unlike other people, they have no ordinary increments to set off against that.
Comment on this
They may have as from a particular period. At any rate, there is the position: these people have for some time past been suffering as the bonus fell, and up to recently had no incremental scale; they are at a point where only a small number emerge above the accepted point—they have not got the salaries that were promised to them; there is going to be no saving to the taxpayer, and I yet can see no saving to the ratepayer; yet those people are being held up here for a certain amount of cutting. I do not bring out any weakness in my own argument when I say that this cut, if it is operated at all, will hit only a small percentage of the vocational education teachers. I think it is necessary to stress that point because it shows just how little the saving will be, anyway, even though it is only money saved to lie by idly. There is nothing saved, but the loss on the individual, and particularly the individual who has to work on a very low salary and, possibly, has made commitments in respect of it, is going to be pretty severe. Again, I stress that no reason has been given for it. There is not one of these individuals can sit back and think, after the arguments here to-night, that a good case was made for his cut. "It was proved that I was getting too much; it was proved that my salary was incommensurate in comparison with the work I do; it was proved that the work I do is not required in the present circumstances of the country"—not one of them can say that that was argued here. All he can say is: "For some reason unknown to me and for some reason which the Minister may know but was not fit to speak of, my salary has been cut." The saving, as I say, if there be a saving at all, in the sense of money idly put by, is going to be very small indeed, while the loss to the individual will be very big.
We are told that we have a great industrial revival on, and certainly, at the beginning, it was intended that those who got any sort of instruction through the medium of these vocational education teachers were to have their minds directed towards industry and to have whatever talents they had in their heads and in their fingers directed towards industrial production. We are in a great industrial movement. Sometimes we are told we are, but, at any rate, it is the argument, it is the pretence, that we are, and anything that is done concretely shows that the Ministry do not believe one bit in all they so often say about industrial revival. These are the people on whom it was expected we would lean for the better provisioning of the future workers of the country in industrial matters—and they are being cut now. It is a good recommendation as to the sincerity of the Ministry's promises in regard to education and in regard to industry.
There is one last matter. Some day we will get a proper equation of the moneys that were, in fact, saved on the first cuts Bill and the moneys the State lost on the first cuts Bill through the people who went into retirement because of the material change made in their conditions, and some day we will get added to that, on the debit side, not merely the moneys the State has lost through having to pay earlier what might have to be paid—moneys to people who have gone into retirement —but some calculation as to the loss the State has suffered by reason of good men leaving the service earlier than they might have been made to leave. I doubt if anybody, even accounting the moneys alone, could say that last year there was any saving to the State, mean and mangy as the saving might be. There were transferred officers with rights. There was an attempt made, when the measure was going through the House, to get these rights taken away from the people who had them, and that was beaten. There was an attempt then made by administrative action to prevent these officers from getting their rights, and they had to go to the courts for their rights, but they did get them. There are transferred officers here, too, and it will not take many people to assert the rights which they have as transferred officers to wipe out the odd thousand that will be saved by this absurdity, and the Ministry will have again exposed themselves to the very natural comment that they tried to do an illegal thing as well as an inequitable thing in trying to get cuts forced through without any excuse on the merits being given in the House. I think it is well that we have segregated the vocational education teachers and officers because it shows up, as under a magnifying glass, the meanness and the futility of all this nonsense. I should like to bring the Minister back to what he started with—if he thinks that this will appear before the public either as a proper answer in the way of economy to those who believe that the country requires economy or that it can be argued as a just thing before those who hold that the country is prosperous, he is making a mistake in both cases, but it is good to have him say what he did say.
Comment on this
I am opposed to these cuts. I am opposed to them as I am against the policy of the Government. The Minister sneers at farmers. He sneered at the position of the farmers. He can well afford to sneer when he and his wife draw £2,000 from this State, and draw it free of income tax. That is the type of politician we have in this country at the present time who sneers at unfortunate people who are on the verge of bankruptcy. I have before me here the case of an unfortunate man who sent 12 turkeys and 34 geese to London at Christmas. They realised a sum of £20 Is., from which £1 10s. 10d. was deducted for expenses and £9 15s. 9d. for tax. There is another constituent of mine who, last October, sent 24 cattle from Kanturk. They realised £400 10s., from which was deducted a sum of £144, together with £56 17s. 9d. expenses, with the result that he received £199 12s. 3d., and the Minister is going to compensate him by giving him 1d. in every £100.
Comment on this
The Minister, in the course of an attempt to justify this cut, referred to speeches made throughout the country by the Party opposite indicating the position of the farmer, and while that may have suited the Minister's particular line of argument, the real position is that it is very doubtful if he could produce for this House a single request from a vocational education committee to be permitted to cut the wages or salaries of its employees. If there is a single case of that kind from a local vocational education committee, I should be glad to hear it and to know the local authority concerned and to be able to examine the mentality of those who comprise it, but I venture to say that the Minister has had no demand whatever from vocational education committees to be permitted to cut the salaries paid to their employees. That is the real test—that these vocational education committees, responsible to local public opinion, are not in favour of cutting the remuneration of their employees. I think it has been proved perfectly clearly that there is no saving to the Central Fund; there is no saving to the rating authority, and there is no saving to the local vocational education committee by cutting the salaries of the employees of these committees.
The Minister has said that if the money for one year proves more than is necessary there will be a certain credit next year. I should like the Minister to tell the House in what way that credit is going to be brought to account and in what way it is going to save the local taxpayer in the subsequent year, because, presumably, the same levy will continue and, if the Bill should be continued, will yield an accumulating surplus. The local vocational education committee, presumably, will not need, if the salaries of its employees are cut, all it formerly needed, and, as Deputy McGilligan pointed out, it will then be put in the privileged position of saving money but saving it at the expense of the underpaid employees of the committee. I think the Minister when he indicated that the Department informed the vocational education committees that they were willing to sanction a certain scale of salaries might have been a little more generous in the scale of salaries prescribed. Many of the chief executive officers of these committees are men of high educational qualifications. Many of them have legal qualifications, many have engineering qualifications; and to prescribe a basic scale of salary of £140, rising by annual increments of £10 to £200, to people who possess the educational qualifications that many of these people have is not placing any premium whatever on intelligence or ability or adaptability.
The scale of salaries set out in the Minister's circular is one which is in no way over-generous. In my opinion it still perpetuates the gross underpayment from which this section of the community suffers. If the Minister thought that a fair scale of salaries in April of last year I cannot for the life of me see what has happened since to justify him in cutting it in February of this year. Nothing has happened in the meantime to justify the cut. It is a very poor argument for the Minister to say: "It is because these officers are in the group and I cannot conveniently segregate them, I must impose a reduction on them." That is a very poor line of defence for the Minister to take in his attempt to justify these cuts. I suggest to the Minister that this Bill could well be withdrawn. It is really a jest to say that this country urgently needs the £35,000 which it is estimated will be saved under the Bill. That sum means absolutely nothing to the country. If our problems are to be measured economically, financially or industrially, by a saving in one year of £35,000, then we have no problem of any kind to face up to, and I suggest this Bill ought to be withdrawn. If the Minister persists in going ahead with it, then I think the employees of the vocational education committees ought to be excluded. Their inclusion cannot possibly be justified simply because there is alleged to be a clamour in the country for cutting down the salaries of the employees of local authorities.
I can tell the Minister that you have a dangerous kind of democracy in this country if it is the kind of democracy that takes the form of advocating the slashing of wages as a means of getting rid of all our problems. It is very unstable and sandy and, in my opinion, ought not to be pandered to. Rather our endeavour should be to build up a decent standard of life for our people. We ought to say in connection with these employees of vocational education committees: It is not that we are too poor to be able to pay a decent rate of wages, but that we are too poor in the matter of vocational education to dream of cutting their salaries because inevitably the effect of such cuts will mean for them a lessening of enthusiasm and the benefits of that enthusiasm in the case of those who are pupils of vocational education committees.
Comment on this
I do not think there is anything more that I can say in connection with this amendment. I still maintain that there will be a saving to the ratepayer and to the taxpayer. In the majority of cases all over the country the minimum rate fixed for vocational education committees is exceeded so that the saving effected will enable counties, in some cases, perhaps, to approximate nearer to the minimum rate fixed. At any rate, there is not much point in Deputy Norton's case. The Deputy talks of cutting small salaries. No salary below a maximum of £300 will be cut. Therefore, the people with small salaries that he talked about will not be cut. The point he made about cutting what he called the miserable salaries of these teachers, therefore, falls to the ground. The same remark applies to the point made by Deputy McGilligan. The Deputy may have been exaggerating, but I think he took the figure of 90 per cent. and said that number of teachers would come under the authority of the vocational education committees. I do not know what the exact figure is, but I should say that the vast bulk of these teachers will not be cut because their salaries do not come up to the figure of £300.
Comment on this
I do not know about £210. £300 is the figure that is being fixed, and so far as I know the majority of these teachers will not come near that. I did not sneer at the farmers. I believe that the farmers in many parts of the country are having a hard time. I did not sneer at the Deputy or at anybody in this House. I simply reminded the Deputy and the House of a certain type of speech that is being made, one that he must have read in the newspapers as well as I did, about the condition of the farming community. I did not say whether it was correct or not. I did say that Farmer-Deputies sitting in all parts of the House have made speeches here demanding and clamouring for economies. They have made in this House that particular type of speech to which I have referred; clamouring that those high salaries, as they called them, should be cut down. When they spoke of high salaries I do not know what figure they had in mind, whether it was £300, £400 or £500, but their demand has been that these salaries should be cut when the farmer's price for his produce has fallen so considerably. That demand has been made insistently from all sides of the House.
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy said it. It was said on all sides of the House: that these high salaries, as they were called, must be cut. Deputies have said that and I am sure they will not deny it. Now they are getting an opportunity of cutting them, and we will see where they will go when the Division is taken.
Comment on this
If Deputy O'Leary thinks that anything I said was any reflection on his character then I certainly withdraw it.
Comment on this
Would the Minister tell us whether, in dealing with the officials of vocational education committees, we are not dealing with a class that is going to be hit twice? Under Section 11 of the Public Services (Temporary Economies) Act, 1933, provision is made by which the Minister can withdraw portion of the grants payable to certain local bodies, having regard to deductions from salaries made under Part II of the Act and the other circumstances of the case, the deductions being from salaries earned during the current financial year.
On 31st January, this year, I asked the Minister for Finance whether any deductions had been made from any grant under Section 11 of the Public Services (Temporary Economies) Act from any local authority or from any committee or other body, the members of which are appointed wholly or partially by a local authority. The Minister in his reply said: "It is not proposed to make a deduction from any such grant. Section 11 of the Public Services (Temporary Economies) Act will be applied only to the grants payable to vocational education committees and to county committees of agriculture. No deduction has yet been made under Section 11 from any grant payable to a vocational education committee or a county committee of agriculture. It is intended, however, to make a deduction from the grant payable to each such committee in the current financial year." I then asked the Minister whether "reductions will be made in the amount of salaries paid to the employees or some of the employees of these bodies in respect of the current financial year," and the Minister, in reply, said that he was not in a position to say that. In view of the fact that the Act of 1933, giving the Minister power to withdraw certain grants from these committees, contained a provision to the effect that the amount so withdrawn would bear some relation to the deduction made in the salaries of some of the officers of these committees, earned and payable during the financial year, 1933. I would like the Minister to tell us whether, in fact, the employees or any employee of vocational education committees are going to have deductions made in their salaries under the 1933 Act and also under this Act for the year 1934. If that is so will he say what is the reason for it? If it is not so, why does the Minister for Finance propose to withhold from some of those committees grants normally payable to them, and withhold them under Section 11? I submit he is not entitled to withhold them.
Comment on this
I am in favour of this amendment. As a member of a vocational education committee for a number of years, I am perfectly satisfied—I can speak, of course, only for urban vocational committees, because my experience is limited to those—that in a great many cases these men are not sufficiently paid for the work they do. I should like to hear from the Minister how it is proposed that a saving will be effected on behalf of the local authorities. The Minister is, I am sure, aware that under the recently passed Vocational Education Act the minimum rate for an urban area, like the town of Wexford, is 3d. in the £. That increases by ½d. in the £ each year until it reaches the maximum of 6d. in the £. That is settled by statute. I wonder how any relief will be given to the ratepayers if that provision of the statute is insisted upon. I cannot see how the ratepayers are going to benefit if this provision is insisted upon.
Comment on this
I am surprised at some of the statements made here to-night. I do not consider that any official with £300 a year is badly off. I understand that this Bill does not apply to officials receiving less than £300 a year. If Deputy O'Leary considers that it is a reflection on his character to say that he was in favour of cuts in wages or salaries, I wonder where Deputy MacDermot, Deputy Dillon and Deputy Curran come in, as they voted for the Second Reading of a similar Bill. Do they change their policy as they change their seats? Some of these Deputies were annoyed with me because I did not move for a harsher cut than was proposed previously. I am sure that Deputy MacDermot will remember that. He was very much annoyed because I did not move an amendment which I had down, which proposed to impose a harsher cut than was proposed in the Bill. Since he changed his seat he is, I suppose, prepared to vote against these cuts. Instead of Deputy MacDermot and his Party swallowing the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, I think that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party have swallowed them. The proof will be the way in which they vote on this proposal.
For the past seven or eight years there has been a demand in the country for a cut in salaries—a far larger cut than is proposed in this Bill. Local bodies, which are more in touch with people in the country than the Dáil, are crying out for cuts in salaries. I realise that the farmers' representatives on local bodies are far more inclined to cut the wages of a labourer than the salary of an official because, in ninety-nine cases out of a hundred, the official is some relative of their own. At the same time I should like to hear Deputy MacDermot justify his change of front within a few short months. If he is going to vote for this amendment, I should like to hear his reasons for the change. There has been a change of front or, as my friend here suggests, a change of shirt, on this question. I should like to hear from Deputy MacDermot, Deputy Dillon and Deputy Curran some reason for their change of front, or shirt.
Comment on this
With all that Deputy Corry knows about the country and the anxiety there to get after salaries, I presume that the local elections will no longer be postponed. The Deputy will then be able to get in the people who will engage in this cutting of salaries to his heart's content. Perhaps he would ask his Minister why he postponed the local elections if he could get in men of the calibre that Deputy Corry wants.
Comment on this
I should like to know from the Minister in what way local authorities will benefit by the reduction of salaries.
Comment on this
I heard Deputy Corry ask a similar question—whether there was to be any form of bribe to local authorities to reduce salaries by giving them an extra grant, or some allowance. I am only supporting him.
Comment on this
The Minister says that he has explained this matter and that Deputy Minch was not here. I was not here either, and I ask the Minister to be a little more detailed in his explanation. What number of county councils will benefit by the reduction, and to what extent will they benefit? The Minister should not content himself merely with a statement that in certain cases the rate struck is higher than the compulsory rate. He should tell the House in how many cases that is so. Is it the general rule that a higher rate than the compulsory rate is struck? What will the saving be in those cases? In the case of those county councils and local bodies that do not strike a higher rate than the compulsory rate, perhaps the Minister will attempt to answer Deputy Minch's question. Where there is a higher rate struck than the compulsory rate the benefit of the saving must, I presume, remain with the vocational education committee. That being so, why is the money not to be spent in the way in which it ought to be spent—in securing that there will be proper teaching? Does the Minister think that it will conduce to proper teaching to cut salaries merely for the sake of cutting? It is quite obvious that a cut is now being made not on account of the money that will be saved, but because, having damaged certain portions of the community, you are determined to damage others. If there is not a higher rate levied than the compulsory rate, there will not be a saving to the local authorities. Am I correct in that? The Minister does not answer, but I think I am correct. Where there are savings why cannot they go to the committee to be utilised in the best way—in securing that teachers are satisfied and that they are properly paid? Now, this is a branch of the teaching profession in regard to which, I think, the whole House recognised, when the Technical Instruction Bill or the Vocational Education Bill was going through this House, that even if teachers as a whole are not well paid here, this branch was not even so well paid. Not merely was that recognised, but again and again the case was put forward—and I must say that I was sympathetic towards it—that it would be a good thing for education if this particular type of education was held in higher esteem in this country than it is. I suggest that the Minister is doing no good to the county councils, to the ratepayers, or to anybody, merely by sticking to the mere mathematical logic to which his Party or the Government seem to be so wedded.
Deputy Corry refers to the fact that there have been demands for this for a number of years. There have also been demands for a number of other things for a number of years, demands to which the Party opposite and the Government are particularly deaf. There have been demands for a reduction in taxation, and I suggest that they have been much stronger and much more insistent demands than in this particular case. There have been demands for a market. There have been demands for all these things, and yet to these things the Party opposite and the Government shut their ears; but they are quite satisfied if they can inflict this damage on a certain number of teachers. There is and has been a great deal of talk from the Government side about about our new industries, and complaints have been made that the proper personnel are not there; and, as their little contribution to doing that, the Government cuts the salaries of precisely those technical teachers who might be able, if they got some assistance and encouragement, at least, to prepare the proper personnel of these new industries. In reality, the Ministry do not really believe in those new industries. Probably they do not believe that, by cutting in this way the salaries of the technical teachers, they are doing any damage to these industries in which they do not believe and which are mere moonshine so far as the majority are concerned. I trust that the Minister will give us more information than he has given, and will not ask the House to be satisfied with the mere statement that there are cases in which a higher rate is struck than the compulsory rate, and that he will indicate the number of such cases and to what extent that happens to be so.
Comment on this
I do not want to appear discourteous by not replying to the challenge of Deputy Corry and, therefore, I rise, for a few moments, to do so. I think, however, that Deputy Corry is showing considerable audacity in accusing anybody else of inconsistency in connection with this particular matter. I am sorry that I have not got before me the reports of the speeches he made in connection with the Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, but I do remember that he was extremely eloquent on the subject of the burdens that were pressing on the farmers of this country, and upon the necessity for lightening those burdens. I cannot help asking myself the question how a zealot for economy like Deputy Corry, and a man who is as anxious as he is to lighten the burden on the farmers, can be supporting the Government policy of spending an entirely unnecessary quarter of a million a year on a new Defence Force. In my opinion, the recent acts of the Government, in regard to the Defence Force for instance, and also through expenditure on creating a new Special Civic Guard force—
Comment on this
As I was saying, these actions make it quite impossible for anyone, who is keen about economy, to think that this Government, in general, deserve support, and make it quite reasonable for anybody, in indignation at their hypocrisy, to stop supporting them, and even to oppose them on a Bill such as this. Deputy Corry assumed that I was going to vote in favour of the various amendments to this Bill. He was rather rash in that assumption. As a matter of fact, I am not; but if I or any of the members of the former Centre Party chose to do so I think we have sufficient justification so far as the Government are able to furnish such justification.
Comment on this
It seems to me that the allegation that the new industries claimed by the Government are largely moonshine is, in itself, ample justification for the Bill. The same Deputies who allege that the new industries are moonshine allege that farming is in a bad state. If farming is in a bad state, and if the country has only a few paltry industries, surely the justification for a Bill to promote economy is fully proved.
Comment on this
How are the salaries to be paid at all if these two sources of wealth are in that decrepit state? Surely it would be more consistent for the Opposition to claim that the Minister is not going far enough in his demands for economy? How can the Party opposite make these allegations about the state of industry and agriculture—particularly about the state of agriculture—and at the same time claim that a man earning over £300 a year in a provincial town cannot afford a reduction in his salary? Of course, I do not believe that the point now being emphasised—that it does not mean any saving to the ratepayer—is sincere. I do not think there is a county council in Ireland that is not contributing, for instance, to the erection of new buildings for vocational education, and surely the saving that will be effected through this Bill will help, to some extent, to relieve the ratepayers with regard to the contributions to which they have committed themselves in respect of new buildings.
Comment on this
Anyhow, I think there is something very unreal indeed about the arguments that have been put forward in the last five minutes. The talk about new industries is so shallow that even the Minister knows it to be moonshine. It is also alleged from the other side that agriculture is absolutely bankrupt and, at the same time, they say that there is no need whatever for a Bill to promote economy and that it is unjust to ask public servants, who are paid over £300 a year and who live in provincial towns, to bear even a small sacrifice in the present situation. It is too unreal to occupy time.
Comment on this
Arising out of another Bill that was before the House to-day, dealing with the giving of plots to the unemployed in Bray and Arklow, the Deputy opposed a suggestion from these benches that the county instructor in agriculture should superintend any work required in connection with these plots. Will the Deputy explain why he supported the Minister in insisting on the necessity of appointing a special instructor to supervise such work while he now insists, under this Bill, that it is necessary to cut the salary of the county instructor in agriculture in County Wicklow?
Comment on this
I wonder if Deputy Mulcahy believes that to be a correct statement. I did nothing of the kind.
Comment on this
I am asking for an explanation from the Deputy. This Bill proposes to cut the salaries of the county instructors in agriculture. The previous Bill, on which the Deputy spoke, deliberately proposed to appoint a special instructor, and as far as County Wicklow is concerned he will simply have to see what is being done on any plots that the urban councils in Arklow or Bray may provide for the unemployed.
Comment on this
To show the dishonesty of that remark I gave as a reason for supporting the Minister that there might be occasions where inspectors who might not normally be civil servants might be temporarily employed for a purpose by the Government. I gave that as a reason for resisting the proposal, yet Deputy Mulcahy says I was supporting the Minister in a desire to appoint a special official.
Comment on this
The Minister rather suggested that on this side of the House there was a general demand for the cutting of salaries. I have no doubt that there was such an expression of views in various parts of the country, mainly confined to the supporters of Fianna Fáil, for the cutting of salaries. I have never been an exponent of that type of economy. This Bill clears the air as far as the measure of saving that will result by any attempt to cut even fairly average salaries. The ordinary person, I dare say, believes that the cutting of official salaries should amount to a very large sum. I have no doubt that the Minister very carefully considered the Bill and brought every class that he could under its provisions, but, lo and behold, the saving for the nation is mentioned as £35,000. As Deputy Mulcahy pointed out, coincident with this Bill the Minister has brought in other Bills which will place ten times that amount of expense on the community. I am sorry Deputy Moore has left the House, because I wanted to refer to something he said. A great deal has been said about vocational education and other committees, but I should like to say a few words about the committees of agriculture.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I think it was understood that there would be two separate divisions, one dealing with vocational education committees and one with agricultural committees.
Comment on this
I understood that there would be two divisions but that the debates would go together.
Comment on this
There was no agreement that there would be two divisions immediately on the conclusion of this debate. If so, I am going to speak three or four times on this amendment.
Comment on this
I am not going to hamper the Deputy. I under stood that there would be two divisions and that the debates would go on together.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, they have not gone on in that way. Until the Deputy introduced the agricultural committees the debate has proceeded entirely on vocational education committees.
Comment on this
It is true that the debate has continued on the vocational education committees, but the declaration of the Ceann Comhairle was that it should be on the whole ambit of the amendment.
Comment on this
I understood that there would be two divisions and that the debate would range over the two amendments.
Comment on this
If that was the arrangement the Chair realises that it will lead to a loss of time. Trying to carry on two debates generally leads to a great deal of repetition. If that was the arrangement it will lead to a loss of time.
Comment on this
Deputy Moore suggested, in regard to another proposed appointment, that possibly some of the agricultural instructors in the employment of the State could be used for the work that was referred to, instead of having to appoint new men. I suggest that if there is one class of officials whose salaries should not be cut it is the agricultural instructors and men in kindred occupations, because, as far as we know the policy of this Government, it is not going to relieve these officials but rather tends to increase their duties. If all the experiments and new legislation that this Government is putting into operation continue I can see the time coming when the services of agricultural instructors will not be available, because they will be engaged teaching people how to grow beet, how to convert calves into cash, how to get rid of surplus dairy cows, and how to make wheat millable. Deputy Moore spoke about "moonshine." The instructors might have to have an investigation into the making of "moonshine" out of some barley.
Comment on this
I predict that there is more likelihood of that, because certain people have been endeavouring to manufacture "moonshine" for many years. Agricultural instructors, as a class, are not very well paid. As their duties will now be greatly increased, this is not a time to include them under the provisions of this Bill. I will not argue on behalf of the vocational education officials. I agree with what has been said on their behalf by previous speakers, but I am not as well acquainted with their duties. I appeal to have men engaged in agricultural instruction excluded from this Bill, because it is almost certain that their work will be increased fivefold by the legislation of this Government.
Comment on this
It is an interesting confession to have it on this Bill that we have to pull up in our expenditure, notwithstanding all the signs of prosperity that we heard of. It is interesting also to learn that the instructors under the committees of agriculture could not be used for other jobs. Speaking with nine years' experience, and as a chairman of a committee of agriculture, I know that in the last year we failed, even in County Dublin, to get people to take up premiums for bulls, boars, etc., to meet the requirements of the county because the game does not pay. I do not share the views of the last Deputy, who spoke about utilising the officials of these committees. The Minister should have looked at the matter squarely and shut down the committees of agriculture. He would then have effected a real saving, because when agriculture is dead—as far as being profitable—I do not see much use in paying salaries to instructors in agriculture.
I do not see what use there is in carrying out the various experiments which the committees have been carrying out when, whether they are successful or not, they will not pay. The Minister thinks that by taking a bit off salaries it will effect economy. If there is one thing that the Minister and his colleagues have preached for the last two years it is the policy of self-sufficiency, whatever that means. Does he not realise that a policy of self-sufficiency means to be self-contained?
Comment on this
Finding, in his attempt at self-containment, that he cannot afford it, he proposes to take a slice off these salaries. The carrot that is held up before the country people is: "The farmer is in the trenches, therefore the other fellow must get into the trenches." But they have not the courage to put him in step with the farmer who has lost his entire income. Why, if you are going to put all in step, do you not face the thing boldly and make a reduction commensurate with the reduction that the agricultural community have had to suffer in their incomes, as a result of your insane policy? I do not say that I would even vote for a proposal of that kind but it would have this merit—it would be honest. This thing is not honest. I am sorry that our two-gun friend, the Minister for Finance, is not here. I wanted to tell him that the policy which I have always preached and that the farmer should be strongest in favour of, is high wages and if the export market is gone from the farmer and we thank God it has gone from him, according to the new economy opposite, well then if ever there was a need for high wages and salaries in this country, it is now. Otherwise you are going to cut the bottom out of the farmer's market. To take off a small percentage from people with over £300 a year is an insult to the intelligence of people who have had 75 per cent. taken from them.
We had Deputy Moore getting up and talking about the unreality of this debate. Nothing could be more unreal than that a Deputy representing Wicklow should preface his remarks by these words "If agriculture is in an impoverished condition." It shows how much Deputy Moore knows about the agricultural constituency he represents. "If agriculture is in an impoverished condition!" Let him go down to the sheep farmers of Wicklow whom he has fooled for the last seven years—and unfortunately I helped him to fool them when I asked them to vote for him—let him go down and ask them——
Comment on this
I am afraid I will not. It is one of the most deadly sins I have ever committed. This Bill is pure eye-wash. It is pure eye-wash to say that if you take a small percentage reduction off the salaries of the secretary of a county committee of agriculture you are going to help anybody. There are some secretaries and instructors of committees of agriculture who are getting £500 or £600 a year. I take it it was considered that they were worth that. I see a Deputy opposite taking a note of that figure. I suppose he is going to use that and ask me to name the farmer who has that income. I know that no farmer in Ireland has that or even half of it, thanks to the Government over there, but are we going to put the farmer right by putting other people wrong? There is one way out but you will not adopt that course. Let it be clearly understood that we are not opposed to real economy but you are never going to economise by lowering the standard of living. You are never going to help the market by taking money out of that market and if the agricultural economy practised by the Government in power for the last two years is going to be the national economy of the future, then the purchasing power for agricultural produce in this country will depend upon the standard of wages and the standard of salaries here. That should be quite plain even though there are only a few representatives of the Government opposite and even though most of them appear not to have had enough sleep last night.
Comment on this
The Deputy is taking a great interest in agriculture, and he should show some interest in the few remarks I am making considering that he kept the House spell-bound for an hour and a half here one night speaking to a motion on agriculture. He prefaced his remarks by saying that he knew nothing about it, and he reminded us when he was finishing that he knew nothing about it. We knew only too well that he knew nothing about it long before he had finished.
Comment on this
There is another side to this, that we should not reduce the salaries of those engaged in technical teaching. Agricultural teaching is technical teaching, for not only do the instructors conduct experiments in agriculture round the country, but they hold agricultural classes as well throughout the winter months. Even though we could do without them for the present, we shall not always be under the present regime, and it would be false economy to impair their efficiency even though there is no outlet for agricultural produce just now. It would also be only proper to honour the contract that was made with the instructors and to retain them at the salaries which the county committees contracted to give them. They were told that the emoluments of their office would not be interfered with except for reasons of inefficiency. That is going to be done now under this section of the Bill. As far as I am concerned, I am going to oppose it for two reasons. Firstly, I am against cutting salaries or wages. Secondly, the proposal is dishonest, because if we all had our minds made up that every citizen in the country should bear an equal share in this fight, then a proposal should be put before the House, and it should be proved mathematically that that proposal was going to impose an equal burden on all. I would be glad to hear anybody from the Government Benches proving that a little slice from a £300 or £400 a year salary is commensurate with what has been taken off agriculture through the Government policy in this country. There is no comparison between the proposed cut and the cuts imposed upon the agricultural community. Will they go down to the labourers in the towns and tell them what they are doing? Deputy Kelly's friends, employees of the Dublin Corporation, are getting £2 19/- a week. That is not too much. I would resent a cut in the wages of the Corporation workers. Do Deputies opposite want to reduce these men's wages to the level of the farm labourers —15/- a week? If there is to be equal burden, let it be an equal burden, but this proposal does not suggest an equal burden. This proposed cutting of salaries is merely eye-wash. It proposes to enable certain people to go to the cross-roads and say, "We propose cutting the big salaries in Dublin." But, again, I ask, will they propose a cut commensurate with the cut the agricultural community has suffered? If they did that it would put a different complexion on the matter. But they will not do that because their proposal is dishonest and will not stand examination.
Comment on this
I agree absolutely with Deputy Moore that there is something very unreal about this debate. I go further and say there is something farcical about the whole debate when one considers the times we are living in. We are living in circumstances when the bottom has fallen out of the greatest market the country has ever had, and when the roofs are being blown up over the heads of the people in the country. This Parliament has nothing better to do in such circumstances than to discuss for three hours how best to victimise 50 or 60 little individuals in the country in order, mar eadh, to assist the agricultural interest in the country and to assist the finances of the county councils and the local boards. Is there any genuine necessity for these proposals? As far as I can learn, the average amount of money to be saved by these victimisations is a matter of £37 per county. Everyone knows that £37 per county matters as little to the finances of the country as would an extra tear to the Atlantic Ocean. The only result of this proposal is that no potential results will accrue to the finances of any county council. If this proposal is passed, 50 or 60 individuals will have to economise in their modest homes, and the people behind them as usual —the housewife or the children—will suffer drastically with no benefit to the community as a whole. The thing is nothing more or less than a bit of political humbug. I re-echo what Deputy Belton has said, that this Bill is introduced in order to put a phrase into the mouth of the cross-road politician and enable him to say "We have cut the big salaries in Dublin; we stand for the little man." These men, no doubt, are little men. They may be small, but they are not half as small as the sponsors of this Bill.
Comment on this
It is rather amusing to hear the statements that we have had to-day from the other side of the House. I am prepared to admit that the cut is not quarter heavy enough. I admit that straight off the reel. But the arguments we have heard put up against the cuts are rather amusing. We heard Deputy Belton declaring that the agricultural instructors have not got half enough. He said that he knows some of them who have only £500 or £600 a year. In my county their salaries are round about £400 or £500 a year. If the condition of agriculture were as good as it was in 1917 to 1919, and prices as high as they were then, I would still be in favour of a cut in salaries. We could not, at any time, afford these salaries. When this State was set up here apparently there were so many people pitchforked into jobs that it was not a question so much of position as of salary. We had O.C.s of the coal scuttle getting £600 a year. I wonder if Deputy Belton, at any time, ever saw farm labourers' wages compare with the wages of the town workers.
Comment on this
The matter is entirely different. If Deputy Belton thinks it strange that Deputy Moore should be representing Wicklow, I think it is more strange that an agricultural Deputy, like Deputy Belton, should be representing Dublin.
Comment on this
Deputy Finlay is not long in the House, and I shall be here to see him out of it again.
Comment on this
That is the position. I am sorry I could not get a straight answer from Deputy MacDermot when I put a question to him. I would like to know the reason why Deputy Finlay and Deputy Curran, who were in favour of cuts in salaries last year, and fought for them, are now going to fight against cuts in salaries. I would like to have heard some reason for the same Deputies making such a change in so short a time.
Comment on this
The proposed cuts are all eyewash. As we have been told, they will amount to about £37 in each county.
Comment on this
Wait until Deputy O'Higgins counts up the cuts in his salary, and see how much comes off. I do not think he will call that eye-wash. I would like to hear something more definite from Deputy MacDermot. He was very anxious last year that I should press an amendment demanding four times a heavier cut. I am surprised at the change that has taken place, and I see no excuse for it. It would take more eyewash than has been supplied to convince the people as to the reason for this change on the part of Deputy MacDermot and his friends. The real position is that at no time since this State was set up could we afford the salaries paid in the country. Neither now nor ten years ago could we afford those salaries. The proposed cuts do not go one-fourth as far as I would go, and I make no bones about that. If Deputy Belton thinks an agricultural instructor with £400 a year, with bonus and travelling expenses on top of it, could not afford a nine or ten per cent. cut in his salary without his woman and children having to suffer, I wonder has he thought what kind of eyewash that is.