Wearing of Uniform (Restriction) Bill, 1934—Second Stage.
Contributions 185–400 of 400. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 13 of 1934 ›
The only information I have about the I.R.A. was given in a speech by General O'Duffy, who said that they are all joining the Blueshirts. Deputy O'Sullivan says that the President wants to dictate not merely the tactics of his own Party, but the tactics of his opponents. If the President was allowed to dictate the tactics of the Party opposite they would be a lot better than they are. I suggest that the biggest mistake they ever made was opposing the introduction of this measure. I thought that responsible members of that Party would have been delighted to see this Bill before the House as affording them a way out of a very awkward situation into which they allowed themselves to be dragged. I am quite certain that there are in that Party a number of men who do not like the course of events in recent weeks—a very large number of them who were never noted for the zeal and enthusiasm with which they sacrificed themselves for any cause in the past and who do not like the prospect of having to make a sacrifice for a new cause in future. I suggest to them that they should take the opportunity of securing the passage of this measure either by voting for it or taking the course which is more likely to commend itself to them, of staying away and not voting at all, because the passage of the Bill will not merely serve the governmental aim of preserving order and securing normal development in the political situation here, but will also help them to rectify some of the blunders made by their leaders and get out of a situation in which, I am sure, very few of them are comfortable.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass is Minister for Industry and Commerce, but he will never be more than a Party politician, and he will never be more than a cheap-jack. Whatever brains he has, that is all he is.
Comment on this
That is the sort of thing we have to put up with. I would rather have that from that Deputy than a compliment, because I regard him as nothing but a creature. Let me deal with this man who is going out of the House now.
Comment on this
There has been quite a lot of hard hitting. I feel fairly strong on this matter, and I submit, sir, that I am entitled to express it.
Comment on this
I do not want any veiled questioning of the Chair's ruling. Ministers in this House must be referred to as Ministers. I have listened to most of this debate and I have not heard any personalities introduced into it up to now.
Comment on this
Better late than never. The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated that the difference between the people who followed him, or who followed the Fianna Fáil Party, and the people who followed us was that his followers were sensible and that ours were not. I did not get up to say anything bitter. The fact that I have been away from this House for some time, perhaps, has put me in a better position to judge and I say with all the experience of the last 12 years as a Minister and in Opposition and after seeing the Party opposite in Opposition and in power that the real difference between the two Parties and between their followers in the country is this, that we are fit for self-government and they are not. That is the distinction.
Comment on this
I commend that to the Labour Party. To listen to this debate and to read this Bill would make any Nationalist in this country, or any man with a Nationalist tradition sorry—it would make him sad. The Minister for Industry and Commerce made, I am quite willing to admit, quite a clever debating speech. I have been watching him, however, and his persistent rôle in this country and in the politics of this country for the last seven or eight years is the rôle of a man who deliberately sets out to darken counsel. I heard all these terms—militarism, militaristic, military organisations—thrown across the House. What is the idea of using those terms in an equivocal sense? Any one or two or three might differ on the definition of the words militaristic, militarism or military organisation. There is nothing to prevent any Minister getting up and accusing this Party of being a military organisation. There is nothing to prevent me from getting up and accusing members of the Party opposite or the I.R.A. of being a military organisation. Leave out those words. Is not the real issue here—and I put this to the Labour Party—that action is being deliberately taken against an organisation which is keeping within the law? Members of the Labour Party especially know well that the word "militaristic" is being prostituted in the mouths of Ministers. They were fed and suckled on militarism. The Fianna Fáil Party were fed on it; they got their inspiration and their strength from it. They used it—and well the members of the Labour Party know it—to destroy the State, to corrupt and intimidate the country. They did it and they gloried in it up to two years ago.
It does not matter about those words militarism, etc. They do not count. We can all use those words. Let us get down to the meaning of them. There is one principle in this country that we might all unite upon. We hear calls for unity in this country time and time again—unity on this issue and on that issue. Should we not unite on this issue—that every man in this country must keep within the law? I go further and say that every man in this country is entitled to exercise his legal rights, and that is even more important. If all Parties cannot join on that fundamental principle then face up to it that this country is not fit for self-government. That is the long and the short of it. All the jargon and the pettifogging and the equivocation of the Minister for Industry and Commerce or of the Attorney-General will not blot out that fact. I commend that to the Labour Party. It is not to-day or yesterday that I stated that and believed in it and worked for it. I always believed in majority rule and I always believed in the rule of law. But I have enough civilisation, if you like, I have enough of international standards in me, of education, of ordinary decent instincts to know that there is no safeguard for the law if the law breaker on the one side is not dealt with and if the peaceful man on the other side is not allowed to exercise his legal rights. There is no safeguard for the law here to-day. What is the position we are in? I say here, speaking for the Party to which I belong, that we are not allowed to exercise our legal rights. We are subjected to every form of blackguardism, every form of intimidation. Every form of cowardly and dark blackguardism and intimidation is being used against us in the country, and well you know it, and the Labour Party are standing for it.
Comment on this
That is not wrong. They could not live for 24 hours only for you.
Comment on this
You have not got your price. Whatever any one of these Deputies may think, I think I had always a fairly liberal instinct. I always gave fair play to Labour and I think I have a good genuine outlook on the matter. Labour has been prostituted for the last year, and is finished in this country.
Comment on this
I remember the liberalism displayed by the then Deputy Johnson when the Public Safety Bill was introduced. Worse than that, and what makes me sick, is that I believe he meant it. I sympathised with him. I believe he meant it, and I believe the Labour Party meant it. What does it come to now? I had differences with the Labour Party. I had a different outlook, a different philosophy, if you like, on all these things, but I believed they were serious then. What do we come to now?
Comment on this
We have the Labour Party standing for the most obscure and illiberal tyranny existing in Europe to-day. The Minister for Industry and Commerce had the assurance to tell us that we have the full benefit of the law. Look at my own county, Galway. We have two organisers and we have been engaged, as we are perfectly entitled, in organising for the last year. One of our organisers, a local man, was a candidate at the last election. He is a thoroughly decent young Irishman. He went into two areas, out of many, to attempt to form clubs. He was received in one place by a considerable section of people, but they were all dispersed. With what? With a rifle. They were fired upon—not fired at. After all, you do not need to fire into civilians to intimidate them. Of course we are getting used to that now. That is the trouble. These people were fired on. That meeting was interrupted and people were not so anxious to come the next time. At the next meeting when they came out from the meeting the place was riddled with bullets. That took place, let us say, to-day. What was the reaction of the State forces to that? Our organiser's house was searched. That man applied for a gun. Has he got it? No. And the Labour Party is standing for that. That man has got no gun, although he has been fired on twice. The last time it looked pretty nasty, but he has got no gun. Everybody in the district knows who were implicated in the outrages. Have they been arrested? Have they been questioned? Have they been put through the rather severe cross-examination that they might be put through under the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act? Not a bit of it.
Comment on this
There were three arrests in Maree. I suggest that that is information for the Deputy.
Comment on this
They must have got out very quickly. Was the Public Safety Act put into operation?
Comment on this
The reaction to that was that our organiser's house was searched. Yet the Attorney-General has the impudence to say that we have impartial administration of the law. I will give an example from another part of the country. There is a semi-reign of terrorism at the moment in Cork city. By whom? The I.R.A. Who are the I.R.A.? I defy anyone in this House to draw any distinction between the I.R.A. and the Fianna Fáil mob. They are working in, and always worked in.
Comment on this
And we have another in Cashel by Jerry Ryan, a member of your own executive. Do you know anything about that?
Comment on this
No. If there was he would be in Arbour Hill. I am in politics for 12 years, and hardly ever did I address a meeting that there was not gross intimidation and blackguardism prepetrated against me or my supporters by your followers. It got worse for the last two or three years, and particularly so during the last year. Things are getting better now and I can go anywhere to address a meeting. Why? The Blueshirts. There is no other reason. Here is a true story from Cork, one that happened in this land of liberty where we have a Fianna Fáil Government—with the British Government gone. We have an Irish Ireland now, a Gaelic Ireland, the sort of Ireland you would get from Deputy Cleary and those other liberty lovers. A young man in Cork, who was in the university, against whom there has been no charge, was walking out of a lecture when he was arrested by members of the new force. Present at his arrest was a prominent member of the I.R.A., who accompanied them to the barracks, where this young man was left for a long period. He was finally brought before the Military Tribunal, charged with having a baton, but was acquitted. This young fellow was a good citizen, who always kept within the law. He was a decent, honest citizen, the sort of man that would be looked up to in any other country. That is the treatment he got. He was pulled up and brought before the Military Tribunal and acquitted, but he had spent a week or ten days in jail. What happened afterwards? His house was raided three times. He is a hardy fellow and dealt with the raiders each time. I am willing to admit that the men who raided him have been brought before the Military Tribunal, and that some of them were sentenced to-day. Who are they? They are members of the I.R.A. Every one of them are strong supporters of Fianna Fáil. Incidentally, one is a well-known robber, a man whose record was stated in court to-day.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Hogan know anything of Conroy who is a member of the Blueshirt organisation?
Comment on this
The Deputy ought to, because his Government allowed him to go free when he should be in jail for murder.
Comment on this
The Minister always gets hysterical and loses his nerve. Here is the point. If I could I would like to bring before all Parties the fact that this man is in danger of his life. I believe that. People I respect and trust in Cork believe it. Remember the last time his house was raided it was raided with guns. Only he is a very tough fellow, and only it is believed he is not alone that man is in danger of his life. He has applied for a revolver. Will he get it? Not at all. If he goes down the streets in Cork amongst any of those blackguards the I.R.A., or Fianna Fáil, who are armed, he will be assaulted and blackguarded. He cannot even keep a baton in his pocket to protect himself. Is not that true?
Comment on this
That causes a laugh. That that situation can be received here with a laugh shows that Party is not fit for self-government. There you have a young man who never committed an offence, whose personal character is above reproach and who is a good, decent, Irish citizen. He has been attacked and blackguarded with impunity by your supporters in Cork. He himself has been brought before the Military Tribunal. He has been acquitted by the Military Tribunal, but his house has been raided on three successive occasions since by blackguards with guns. That man's life is in danger, or was in danger, and certainly would be in danger but for the fact that he is a tough man and a member of an organisation. He will not get a gun and he has even been penalised because he carries a baton. What is he to do?
Comment on this
Will not the Deputy admit that one man who raided that house has got three years?
Comment on this
What more does the Deputy suggest I could do? I could do no more than prosecute.
Comment on this
I will come to that. That man now will not get a gun. Why? He cannot even carry a baton. He is a hardy man and ready to put up with a good deal of blackguardism, but is it fair to expect an ordinary citizen of the country to have to put up with that sort of thing before he can exercise his legal rights and go into a political organisation? Is that your idea of liberty, and is that the liberty that we are to have in this country? That is the treatment that we are getting. I have addressed meeting after meeting in the County Galway within the last two years. At every meeting, before, during and after there were determined attempts to intimidate our followers by your supporters, by Fianna Fáil supporters and by the I.R.A. They are both the same—they are mixed up and they are playing into each other's hands. A year ago, before a meeting word was sent round: "Do not go to that meeting; you are marked." Their children were shouted at going to school; they were told they were traitors and that they were playing England's game.
Comment on this
That is the sort of thing that we have to put up with in Galway. That is the way to get away from the civil war atmosphere. During our meetings, a year ago, what used to happen? You might have a meeting of 500 people at a cross-roads, or 1,000 or 2,000 people at a town meeting. Two hundred young fellows would be there. They would keep interrupting, causing confusion and blackguarding generally during the whole meeting: slinging stones and endeavouring to intimidate middle-aged people—endeavouring, in other words, to show that it is bad business to be identified with that other political Party.
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy one question? Is it not a fact that six men are at present in jail for interfering with one of his meetings?
Comment on this
Has there been a single meeting of your supporters attacked? Of course you will find exceptions to the rule, but would I be right in going this far: that there has scarcely been one single act of blackguarding at the expense of your Party? Does all that arise by chance? It does not, and I will tell the House afterwards why. Now it was absolutely essential for our political life that that sort of thing should stop. The Government were not stopping it, and the Guards were not stopping it. Why would the Guards stop it? What has happened? Take a big meeting like Castlebar. You had four, five or seven thousand people attending there and three or four hundred brats—that is the only word I can use. They kept up a constant din, throwing stones, trying to cut off the loud speakers and so on. What did the Guards do? They do what they are told and no more. They draw a cordon between these three and four hundred and the seven thousand people, so that the three hundred or four hundred people are free to interrupt the meeting, to create all the confusion possible and carry on this blackguardism under police protection. That is what it comes to. I do not blame the Guards. That is Government policy. I put this to the Minister for Justice: I have seen that occur time and time again at our meetings. I have seen meetings where we had five or six thousand people present and where there were two or three hundred people making it impossible for us to speak. Were we free to do so we would remove these two or three hundred people in a short time. It would not take much to deal with some of them. But we dare not because the Guards were standing between us and them. Is there a single Deputy who has not witnessed the same kind of thing? I wonder is all that by chance? On the few occasions when the Guards did deal with them, what happened? The local Fianna Fáil club met and passed a resolution so that the Guards did not do it again.
I assure the Minister for Justice that I am not trying to make any debating points. I am only stating what I have seen all over the country. That has been my experience. I say that there has been a grossly partisan administration of the law. I say that, so far as the Attorney-General is responsible for it, he is prostituting his office, and I say that deliberately. There has been a grossly partisan administration of the law, and, worse than that, it is demoralising the country. Everyone sees it. So far from giving an image of law to the country, so far from teaching the lesson that above all should be taught in this country: that every man must keep the law and at the same time that every man can exercise his legal right, what are you teaching by your actions, by the way you are handling public meetings? You are teaching this, that it is blackguardism, confusion and militarism is the thing that pays in this country, and that is what the Labour Party stands for.
Comment on this
Give the Blueshirts another year and there will be no blackguardism, and if there is no blackguardism it will not be due to the Government. I noticed the other day that there was a strike of school-children. Why not? What have they been taught for the last three years? That indiscipline and disrespect for authority is the thing. Is not that what they have been taught? What is the attitude of the Party opposite on this Bill? Your admitted attitude is this: you may be within your legal rights in doing certain acts, but other people object and we are not going to attack the other people; we are going to attack you. What lesson is that for the country? It is this: that if you want a man to refrain from exercising his legal rights, or one organisation exercising their legal rights, take illegal action against them and you will be supporting the present Government. We had the example quoted by a Deputy on the opposite side in support of this Bill—the example of illegal action being taken against people who were exercising their legal rights. That is in support of this Bill. What demoralisation that must mean to the country. But now who are really to blame? The country is in a sad state, I admit, at the present moment. There is no conception of law in the country. There is every sign of trouble, of anarchy, of confusion; but who are really responsible for that state of affairs? The people who are responsible for it—and I charge them with it—are the members of the present Government sitting opposite there. Look at what they have done. They have gone round the country— especially the President—naming us as traitors and telling the country that there is a war with England, and that we are supporting the English enemy. They have not gone so far as to say "They are traitors and give them a traitor's death; give them the treatment traitors should get." They have merely said "They are traitors" and have left it to their followers to draw their own conclusions. I say that the man of all others most responsible for the present blackguardism and confusion, and for the breakdown of law in this country, is President de Valera. I have far and away more respect for the little blackguard that went in to raid the house in Cork than I have for the President. He is a better man than President de Valera. President de Valera is the real father to that man; it is he who made him and who demoralised him. It is that campaign of branding us, who are better men than ever you were, as traitors that has caused all the blackguardism, confusion and demoralisation in this country at the present moment.
Then we are told: "Look at what the English, the Swedes, the Dutch, the French, and so on are doing." We are told that England does not need a Blueshirt organisation in order to maintain the law. England does not need it, but remember that England is a great country.
Comment on this
Is. Remember that England is, and always was, a country with a great democratic instinct. What made England great? Respect for the law—the law made by themselves. I am not talking now of her relations with outsiders. What made her a great country? It is laughable to have us talking about and criticising England—a country with 40,000,000 inhabitants that started the same as we did, and here we are criticising like a terrier barking at her heels. What made England great was a liberal, decent instinct and a respect for the law and a belief in the majesty of the law. That is the reason she does not need her Blueshirts. What is the position here? Where is the respect for the law taught by the Government? We have only partisanship of the worst kind and tyranny of the worst kind. We are told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that we have committed the unspeakable crime of putting children in our uniform. What is wrong with putting children in our uniform? Is the uniform illegal? If so, take us before the courts. Is it immoral? If so, take us before the bar of public opinion. You say that the objects we state are not our real objects. If you find that, prosecute us. Is not that the guarantee of all liberty? What is the use of Minister after Minister getting up and saying: "Your objects and your actions, your overt actions, may be all right, but in your hearts and minds you think differently"? That is the case made for this Bill. If the uniform is wrong, take us before the courts. I am not baulking at the word "uniform." If it is wrong, take us before the courts. If our objects are wrong, bring us before the courts. If they are right, why should not our children get into that uniform, and who are you to complain that our children are getting into it? Look back on the last eight or nine years. Look at the children who went into the Fianna and look at what they were taught there in the name of nationality, in the name of progress, even in the name of religion. Look at all the murder that developed out of that organisation in the last few years. I will put this to the Minister for Education. Look at the lesson they got. Was it respect for authority or for the law or for majority rule? No, it was the exact opposite, and during the last eight or nine years, for your own dirty, party, political purposes, you made use of that organisation and of the children who went into it. You ought to be ashamed of yourselves. What lesson did the man who went into the I.R.A. in the last eight or nine years learn—the I.R.A. that the President announced even two years ago were the really legitimate authority in this country? What lesson did they learn? Am I stating a word that is not true? They learned disrespect for majority rule—the most obscure and arrogant and, I might add, inefficient type of militarism, that was not even able to fight but had to resort to murder. Is not that what they were taught and who took advantage of it? You did; not only up to 1931 but up to the last election. Look at the manifestos—"Vote Fianna Fáil anyway." You took advantage of it and you will do it again.
You could ban what you liked if you gave a fair crack of the whip all round. I do not expect liberty from you. One can hardly expect liberty in any country. It is always a matter of circumstances. But we do want fair play. Fair play is greater than the Republic; it is greater than any of your political shibboleths, and the only way to inculcate it is to give equal law to everyone. Is there a Deputy there on the benches opposite who says we have got fair play? Why should we not get fair play? After all, we have put an image of law before this country, both in office and outside. We have fought for majority rule and established it. While we were in office we did try to give equal law. What was I told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and by the Minister for Finance a moment ago in an interruption? I was told that we have been consistently inciting the people to illegal acts; that we have been endeavouring to sap the authority of the Government and that we have been suggesting to the people that the present Government is not the legitimate Government. That would be a serious charge. If I thought that this Party did this, I would leave it, and so would every member on these benches. When and where have we been doing that? Actions speak louder than words. We taught and we spoke majority rule and we did majority rule for ten years. It was said by you that our belief in majority rule would only last as long as we were the majority and that the moment we became a minority people would see what respect we had for majority rule. That was your jargon. That was your propaganda, and you tried to corrupt this country with it. Well, we became a minority, and what did we do—no thanks to us and no thanks to anybody in a minority in any country? We walked out. That was easy to do, but what did we leave after us—and it is by that you have really to judge us? We left an army as disciplined as the English army, and I could not give them higher praise than that. We left an army that are as much your servants as they were ours, even though they fought against you. Was not that a magnificent performance? Was not that a fine example to the country, if the people could only profit by it? We left you a police force and a loyal Civil Service. They would be loyal, in any event. We walked out and, since then, all that we asked were our legal rights. Whether you pass this Bill or not, the principle for which the Blue Shirts stand, the principle of "equal law for every body and every man within the law," is going to win in this country.
Comment on this
"The principle of equal law for every man and every man within the law." When Deputy Hogan talks in those terms, one is uncertain whether he is a cunning hypocrite or only a mere hoodlum.
Comment on this
On a point of order, at the beginning of Deputy Hogan's speech he was rebuked by the Ceann Comhairle for alluding to the Minister for Industry and Commerce as a "Cheap Jack." The Deputy has been alluded to now as a "hooligan" or something more offensive.
Comment on this
It is necessary that I should say, on the facts before me, of which Deputy Hogan is aware and of which every member of the Government which was charged with the administration of the law from 1923 was aware, having listened to the speech Deputy Hogan has made and having heard him say that he, when in office, stood for the principle of "every man equal before the law and every man within the law," I do not regard Deputy Hogan as having made anything else than a hypocritical statement in using those words. Deputy Hogan made, in the course of his speech, great play of the fact that there are blackguards in this country, as there are in every country, and that they sometimes—unfortunately, too often—get away. Every time an offence has been committed against the liberty of the subject, every time that there has been violation of the right of freedom of speech and nobody has been punished, Deputy Hogan put the blame on this Government. Does he wish the record of this Government and of its predecessors to be judged by the same standard? Whom did his Government punish in 1931 for the murder of Armstrong or the murder of Superintendent Curtin? Whom did his Government punish in 1923 for the murders of Kahn and Goldberg, for the armed raid on the offices of the London, Midland and Scottish Railway Company in May of 1923, or for the armed robbery in College Green in August of 1923? Whom did Deputy Hogan's Government punish for these crimes? Will Deputy Hogan answer me that?
Comment on this
The man who committed these crimes, as I have already stated to-night, is a member of the Blue Shirt organisation at the present moment. He was allowed to go free even though those charged with the administration of the law at that time were well aware of the crimes he had committed, even though a member of the detective division identified him in a public court in February of 1924. That detective, when he referred to headquarters to ask whether he could arrest that man or not, was told he should not arrest him until he got further instructions. He received no instructions to apprehend that man until December, 1924, ten months afterwards——
Comment on this
I am not going to be interrupted by Deputy O'Sullivan. I shall make my speech in my own way.
Comment on this
I am now dealing with the application of this principle of "every man equal before the law and every man within the law."
Comment on this
When a man was arrested in December, 1924, a brother of one of the two men implicated in the shooting not merely of the man called Kahn but also of a man named David Miller, and when that man, on 23rd December, 1924, made a voluntary statement in which he said that not he but his brother had been guilty of that dastardly crime and that with his brother there was associated another man, what action did the Government take—the Government which, according to Deputy Hogan stood always for the principle of "every man equal before the law and every man within the law"? Remember the then Executive Council had information who these men were, and knew that on the night of the 14th November the two of them were missing from Beggars' Bush Barracks and were driving around in an Army car through the city. A member of the detective division—a detective-ser geant—identified the two of them in Green Street Courthouse on 22nd February, 1924. I have it here on record that, when he communicated this fact to his superiors, he was told not to take action and not to dare to apprehend the men until he received further instructions from headquarters. He received no instructions from headquarters——
Comment on this
On a point of order, I understand that the rules of this House provide that when a Minister purports to quote from a confidential document, the document must be laid before the House. I assume that the rule will be applied in the present case. The Minister has drawn our attention to the contents of his file and he has stated that he is quoting from a document in that file. I submit that the Minister should in those circumstances conform to the rule and lay the document on the Table.
Comment on this
When a document is quoted from and a demand is made that the document be laid on the Table of the House, the person using the document must either cease to quote from it or lay it on the Table. I did not understand the Minister to quote from a document. He said he had it on the file.
Comment on this
The Minister held up to the House a confidential file and said "I have here on this file a categorical statement that two men left Beggars' Bush Barracks and travelled through the streets in an Army car——"
Comment on this
I am making a point of order and I shall insist on making it. The clear implication was that the information the Minister was giving the House was contained in a document which is not at present before us. Having quoted so far from a confidential document, I submit that the Minister is bound to lay the document before the House.
Comment on this
There is a very material difference between quoting from a document and referring to it. Obviously, Ministers must have some source of information. These sources of information are contained in files. Unless the Minister gives us the exact words of a document, clearly he is not quoting it.
Comment on this
If the Minister says he has a document before him and holds up a file, the implication is that he is not giving the information which he purports to give from memory, but that he is quoting what is before his eyes.
Comment on this
No. The Minister has not quoted any words from the document. He has merely stated that he has the information on his file. I might say that I knew something which is contained in this book, but if I did not use the exact words, I should not be quoting.
Comment on this
He has threatened the House that he has the information on a file and it is possible to take words out of their context and give them a meaning which they ordinarily would not have if the whole information were before the House.
Comment on this
Clearly the Chair does not know whether what was said was taken from the context or not.
Comment on this
With great respect, I submit that the words are taken from a document upon their construction and, therefore, the rule of the House is that the whole document will have to be submitted. I submit that when isolated facts are quoted from a document in a Minister's hands the same rule should apply, and the whole document should be submitted to the House so that the House can see the facts in their proper surroundings.
Comment on this
Extracts were not quoted. The Minister did not quote any words from the file. He said "it is here in this file," as I might say certain words were here in this rule book, but he did not quote the words.
Comment on this
I think I saw the Minister read out certain dates from the file. (Deputies: No, no. Sit down). The Minister can deny it if he likes.
Comment on this
I did not read a single date out of this file. The dates are fixed in my memory. If anyone read this file, as I have read it, the details of this horrible incident would never be absent from his memory; he could, if he desired, at any time recall them. They were recalled to my memory by the speech of Deputy Hogan, who said he was a member of the Government that regarded every man as equal before the law and that insisted that all men should live within the law. I said a detective sergeant of the force recognised, within the precincts of a court, in this State, two men whose descriptions were given to the police authorities by one of the men attacked upon the occasion to which I have referred, and who, more fortunate than Kahn, escaped with his life. The detective communicated that fact to his superior officer and was told and instructed to do nothing until he received further instructions. One would think that he would receive such instructions by return with the telephone receiver still in his hands, but he was told to do nothing. Yet we are told now that all men were equal before the law. One would think that he would have been ordered to do his duty by the laws of God and the community and bring these men whose hands were red with the blood of their fellowmen to justice. He received no instructions, I repeat, until the 22nd December, more than 12 months after the date of the murder, and more than ten months after he had identified these men in court. Then he arrested one of them, the driver of the car, the brother of one of the murderers, who confessed he was there that night. I shall read the whole document if you like. There was now before them the confession of one of the gang that these two people had been implicated in this murder. Did they go then and immediately arrest these men? Not at all. They did not apply for a warrant until the 6th March, 1925. Then, when the essential witness in the case, the driver of the car, was brought up, and was acquitted of the charge of murdering Kahn, and when he had yet to stand his trial for shooting at with intent to murder Miller, instead of opposing bail and holding him in custody, as an essential witness, in the prosecution against the other men, what did the then Government that we are now told stood for equal and impartial enforcement of the law do? They allowed that man to get bail and abscond in July, 1925, so that the essential evidence in the case was wafted out of the country. Now the witnesses are gone, but the criminals came back and some of those men—I am giving no names— are known. Deputy O'Higgins knows them well and knows some others who were accomplices in this crime as accessories after the fact, they made themselves that by destroying attendance books in Beggar's Bush Barracks in order that the police might not get to know them.
Comment on this
As a matter of personal explanation, the Minister says I know the names of certain individuals whom he refuses to name. I wish to deny that most emphatically. That statement is not true.
Comment on this
Very well, I shall accept that statement from Deputy O'Higgins, but there are others of his comrades in that organisation who know these men.
Comment on this
You ought to know them. You made arrangements that one of the men should be arrested when going before a board in order that he might get a pension.
Comment on this
This is really a serious charge made against a member of this House. I want to know what the Minister is talking about. Does the Minister suggest that I was associated with the murder of Kahn or of anybody, or whether I sheltered, subsequent to the murder, a person responsible for murder? I would ask, in view of the position of members of this House, that the Minister should state here and now whether I was or not?
Comment on this
I never suggested Deputy O'Sullivan was a party to the murder of these men and I never said he sheltered those responsible.
Comment on this
I did not say Deputy O'Sullivan was associated with them. If he thinks I said so I withdraw it.
Comment on this
If the Deputy thinks I said so, I withdraw it. If the Deputy wants more information he can put down a motion on the Order Paper, or he can get Deputy Cosgrave to put down a motion inquiring into the statements I am making now. Let Deputy Cosgrave put down a motion of that kind and we can have an inquiry. I am merely now dealing with the hypocritical statement of Deputy Hogan that when he was a member of the Government that Government regarded all men as equal before the law, and made certain that all men should live equally within the law.
Comment on this
Do not drive me too far. I could tell of another man, too, if I liked, who was guilty of a most brutal murder.
Comment on this
I am at a loss to know the relevancy of all this. I think the Minister has been allowed sufficient latitude in dealing with the statement of Deputy Hogan in reference to all men being equal before the law.
Comment on this
Were these men Blue Shirts, and, if not, what relevancy has all this to the question before the House?
Comment on this
I am showing these men are Blue Shirts now and if there was no other justification for banning that organisation, but enlisting these men who must be known to men in that organisation, who knew that they were enlisting men who were guilty not of one murder but of more, that was more than sufficient justification.
Comment on this
I feel that the fact of charging anybody with murder or with knowing that persons moving around the streets of Dublin with Blue Shirts were implicated in murder, is not what one should expect from the Government Benches. I think we are entitled to have it stated whether there are any persons wearing Blue Shirts in this country who were guilty of murder as the Minister has stated.
Comment on this
Let us be clear about this matter. In my opinion there is too much talk about murder. There has been talk from the Opposition Benches regarding certain associations in this country. There has been talk of murder by the Minister for Finance regarding certain times without particular reference to associations. I think there has been too much talk of murder and we might get more helpful criticism if we followed the subject matter of the Bill.
Comment on this
The Bill we are discussing is to deal primarily with a certain organisation. It is candidly admitted by the Government that the object of the Bill is to ban the Blue Shirts. The Minister for Finance has stated, as an argument for the Bill, that certain murderers have been recruited into the Blue Shirts. We now ask him to prove that false statement.
Comment on this
The Minister has not indicated specifically any persons so that nobody can be recognised as the persons to whom he refers. The Chair has no function in the matter if nobody can be recognised. If the Minister had mentioned anybody I would ask him to withdraw.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister has said that we are recruiting murderers into the Blue Shirts. That is a statement that the Minister should not be allowed to make and we will not stand for it.
Comment on this
I do not remember that when Deputy Hogan said that whom he alleged was an I.R.A. man, was a well-known robber, that I heard any shouts of indignation from the Back Benchers. I did not hear Deputy O'Sullivan getting up and asking Deputy Hogan to withdraw, as I did not hear Deputy Bennett asking him to withdraw.
Comment on this
I dare the Minister to give the name of one man in the Blue Shirts whom he calls a murderer.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants any further information on the matter let him put down a motion.
Comment on this
There is a court of law to decide who or who is not a murderer. We are not here to discuss that.
Comment on this
I say that I was never connected with a murderer and I will not allow anybody with whom I am associated to be called a murderer.
Comment on this
The Minister did not indicate in any way whatever that Deputy O'Sullivan either sheltered or was associated with any murderers. That finishes that point.
Comment on this
I do not want to cause any scene in this House but I must say that I must leave the House if the Minister will not withdraw the statement that persons have been recruited into the Blue Shirts who are guilty of the murder of Kahn, as he said on Friday last. I would ask the Chair to ask the Minister to withdraw that statement because you know, sir, that the Minister and his associates are now responsible for the government of this country and if they think that a person is guilty of murder, they can have that person arrested. I certainly shall not be associated with any such statement. I think it is a cowardly statement for the Minister to make.
Comment on this
I said that it was a cowardly statement on the grounds that the Minister gets up and associates me and other members of the Party here and outside who wear blue shirts with persons who were, as he says, guilty of murder. If that is not a cowardly statement, I withdraw.
Comment on this
On a point of order, until the Minister withdraws his statement I intend to take the same action as Deputy O'Sullivan. Unless the Minister is asked to withdraw, or withdraws of his own goodwill the statement made that the Blue Shirts are murderers, I shall not remain in the House and listen quietly to the Minister. Rather than upset the dignity of the House by interrupting the Minister, as I shall be compelled to interrupt, I shall withdraw.
Comment on this
Unfortunately I cannot here unsay what I have said. If the Deputies want any more information they have a way of getting it.
Comment on this
The fact has been mentioned that all men are equal before the law and that the law is above all men. It has been said that I have been associated with persons who have stood for that principle. I am sure the Minister does not quite understand what I have said, but if he does not withdraw I shall have to withdraw from the House. He has said that persons who were wearing blue shirts were comrades of murderers.
Comment on this
I am perfectly certain that Deputy O'Sullivan would never knowingly associate with a person of that type. That is as far as I am going. I am not going to allow my regard for Deputy O'Sullivan to throw a cloak over another person.
Comment on this
That is really worse, because the suggestion is that I knew the person who did this. That is a very serious suggestion, that I knew the person who committed this horrible crime.
Comment on this
The suggestion is that this person is going round the streets of Dublin in a blue shirt.
Comment on this
The Minister definitely stated that the Deputy would never knowingly associate with murderers. Surely that satisfies him.
Comment on this
If you make that ruling I must accept it but I am sure that even his own Party realises that that is an unfair, indecent and, shall I say, almost a cowardly statement. I want to say that I personally do not know, and that I did not know in 1923 or 1924, when that man was murdered, who murdered him and I had nothing to do with the Beggar's Bush records.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister stated that certain murders had been committed and that the people guilty of them had not been brought to justice owing to the connivance of Deputies on this side.
Comment on this
I am sorry that I had the misfortune to be in the House when Deputy Hogan was speaking, otherwise I should not have referred to this incident at all, but I knew it was well within Deputy Hogan's knowledge. I do not want to say any more than that. I do ask what is the purpose of an organisation which would knowingly or unknowingly, wittingly or unwittingly, have men of that sort in its ranks? Let them expel them. We are told by Deputy Hogan about the I.R.A., and he states "There is no distinction between them and the Fianna Fáil mob." There is no Fianna Fáil mob. There never has been a Fianna Fáil mob. Those who are members of the Fianna Fáil organisation are decent, law-abiding, honest citizens who, in putting a Government like this in power——
Comment on this
——have given the fullest possible acceptance to the principle of fair-play without which, Deputy Hogan said, there could be nothing in this country. In what way can you accuse us of having violated that principle? Deputy Hogan referred to all the public services. It is quite true that we have no reason to doubt the loyalty of any one of these services, but can anyone say that we had any hand, act or part in manning these services? We came into office with our followers starved and hungry after ten years; many of them had been denied the right to earn a livelihood in their own land. We came into office after four years in which it was a common, everyday occurrence for the police forces of this State to be used to harry men, to arrest them in their employment, to take them from the bench or the workshop in order ultimately that employers would be compelled to dismiss them. We came into office after having seen hundreds of men brought before the Military Tribunal and convicted there. We saw an attempt made to sabotage the newspaper which we established.
The first thing the Commissioner of Police told us was that he had destroyed 20,000 files, some of them relating to members of the Government, many of them relating to our known supporters, 20,000 files in which we would have seen the names of every agent provocateur employed by our predecessors, the name of every intelligence officer and of every secret service agent. We could have told that man that we had no further use for his services, that he had been guilty of disloyalty to the Government elected by the people, the day after the result of the 1932 election was declared. Did we go back and try to open up any one of the things that we regarded as dead and wished to be buried in the past? No. Instead, we told the people that we were turning over a new leaf and that we were honestly seeking to end the bitterness and dissension of the civil war; that our desire was to bind together the people in one common effort, in one common toil and common labour for the common good of every man and woman in this country. I ask you if that was not giving practical effect to the principle of fair-play? The facts of the incident that I spoke about to-night were known to every member of the Government, and there are many more like it. It could be paralleled, but yet nobody has ever heard of it or found us trying to seek a mean Party vengeance for anything any one of us might have endured during the preceding ten years. What is the fair-play we hear so much talked about? I could tell stories of women who, when their husbands were in jail, were dismissed from their employment.
Comment on this
All the time that this Government has been in office they have tried to give effect to the principle of fair-play and there is nothing in this Bill that is contrary to the principle of fair-play. We have to take stock of the situation as we find it here, and it is a very dangerous one. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has already challenged the Opposition to answer this question: If you can put yourselves into uniform for the purpose of protection, why stop at uniform? Why not revolvers and rifles and machine-guns? I would ask a further question in view of what appears in the newspapers this evening. Do your men not carry revolvers? Have they not rifles cached away and. God knows, don't we know that? Your own leader, General O'Duffy, has told us that Jerry Ryan and those others who left Templemore Barracks took a lot of military equipment with them. And if you are to wear uniforms and have rifles and revolvers are we going to put our organisation, and it is a more numerous organisation than yours, in uniform also? Are we going to give them rifles and revolvers and are we going to see the people of this country divided into two armed camps waiting for the day when one or the other, by a coup d'état, will overthrow the established Government of the country.
Comment on this
And yet that is the inevitable consequence of the policy which you are pursuing to-day. Either we agree that both Parties organise upon a militaristic basis or else we agree that the Bill now before the Dáil becomes law within the shortest possible time. That is the dilemma and there is no escape from it. We are told, and none of you deny, that the outcome which you are looking for in the present situation, in the situation which you are hoping will develop, is that which developed in Italy, is that which developed in Germany, is that which apparently is on the brink of development in Austria when the Party machine will dominate, not merely the Dáil and the Oireachtas, but will dominate the whole State and the whole people. That is the philosophy which is behind your movement, that it is inspired by introverted Communism which has been responsible for the development of a situation on the Continent in which every man must surrender himself to the State. Mussolini, we are told by Deputy Costello, has won; Hitler has won, and the Blue Shirts are going to have their victory, too. What sort of a victory has been won in Germany? The most sacred rights of the individual are being made subject and inferior to the presumed advantage of the race and no man dare call his soul or body his own when the very foundations of Christianity are being assailed.
Deputy Cosgrave, last week, referred to the pronouncement of the Hierarchy, but I would ask Deputy Cosgrave to read the recent pronouncement of the Holy Father regarding this Hitlerism which, according to Deputy Costello, has won in Germany. We have Odin and Wodin-worship on the Continent, and there is an endeavour to establish an Eoinod cult here in Dublin. The great generalissimo is going to take the place of the pagan gods of Rome in the new mythology which is now being popularised. That is the sort of ideal that those people seek to attain, to establish here a corporative State, where a man will be no more in the community than an ant in a nest or a bee in a hive; where he will not be allowed to have a soul, to have nothing that does not belong to the great Magog that rules over him.
Comment on this
Those of us who are in this Party, in this Government, are here because we believe not merely in the principle of national liberty, but of individual liberty also. If this issue has to be fought out, whether it be fought out with private armies or public armies, fought out it will be before we will allow the situation which has developed in Austria to arise here.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance began his speech to-night with references to murder. The House should know and every Deputy should know that from every charge he made he ran away when he was challenged. Now, sir, I am not going to pursue the Minister into a discussion of events that took place ten or 12 years ago. I deplore their introduction here to-night and I think it is only right that the House should remember that in every single case where the Minister was challenged to produce his facts he ran away. The Minister began his speech with talk of murder and he ended with talk of civil war. The Minister chose to say here, as a conclusion to his contribution to this most important debate, that if the policy of the United Ireland Party recommended itself to the people of this country——
Comment on this
The Minister to-night alleged that the Blue Shirts were an armed force. If the Blue Shirts are an armed force this Bill is not necessary. If the Minister and his colleagues are doing their duty by this State, and can prove that the Blue Shirts are an armed force, it is their duty to suppress it and arrest its leaders.
Comment on this
It is their duty to suppress it and to arrest its leaders, and that goes for the I.R.A. as well. If we are sponsoring in this country an armed force which carries arms without the authorisation of the elected Government of the people it is your duty to arrest us and make us responsible to the law. You are afraid to do that in respect of the leaders of the I.R.A. because the back benchers of your own Party are dependent on the I.R.A. to retain their seats by intimidation and they would not allow it; everyone knows they would not allow it. You are afraid to do your duty, which is to take the arms out of the hands of unauthorised persons in this country. You know we have not got arms, and that is the reason you have brought in this Bill. You have combed our records; you have searched our correspondence; you have paid your spies; and you have been able to find absolutely nothing which would substantiate the case against us in any public court that we broke the law, that we assaulted any citizen of this State, or that we ever conspired against the institutions of this State. If you could find out any of those things you would not look for that Bill to break us; you would break us with the Public Safety Act; but you know perfectly well that there is sufficient public opinion in this country still to call you to render an account for doing that when you have nothing that you can prove against us. You can search our offices; you can search our letters; you can pay your spies; but you will find nothing, for there is nothing to be found.
Comment on this
I should be glad if some of the industralist Deputies there would go out and invite the Attorney-General to come in to this House——
Comment on this
——and I will challenge the Attorney-General that he knows there is nothing which justifies the suppression of the League of Youth; that he knows there is nothing, and that he has communicated that knowledge to his colleagues; that he is sponsoring this Bill in the knowledge that it is a tyrannical Bill—that it is a Bill directed to do an injustice against a law-abiding section of the community of this country. There was much talk here to-day about the endeavours of the Fianna Fáil Government to maintain peace and order at meetings. It was suggested by responsible Ministers that there was no serious disorder until the Blue Shirts appeared. I am sorry the President is not here. The President will remember standing in Glenties with me; he was addressing a meeting—it was at the time of the General Election of 1933—and I and my supporters deliberately kept away and avoided passing his meeting lest we should disturb it while he was speaking. When his meeting was finished our meeting began, and two of the most prominent supporters the President had on his platform led a crowd down into the meeting which I was addressing and deliberately incited the people to shout me down. The President was sitting no farther from me while that was going on than that door is from me now. Two men who were standing on the platform with him ten minutes before I began to speak were two of the men who came down to interrupt my meeting.
Comment on this
I will name them if the President challenges me. The President knows the names of both of them, for I took good care he should hear them. If you want those names ask the President to challenge me for them.
Comment on this
I suggest that if the Deputy wants to make a speech on this matter he can get up when I am finished.
Comment on this
Ask it when I have finished, and I will answer it. If the President challenges me for the names of those people, I will give them to him. That was the situation, and that situation was repeated at meeting after meeting all through the country. A small crowd of people, supporters of the President and of the Fianna Fáil Party, would come to our meetings and deliberately break them up. There is no use in maintaining the farce that it is possible for the Civic Guards to protect a meeting if an organised gang comes to break it up, because the very intervention of the Guards in endeavouring to peacefully remove individual interrupters can effectively destroy a public meeting and prevent a person from addressing it.
I went, shortly after that, to Macroom. I there addressed about 700 people, and shortly after I began 30 or 40 supporters of the Government came down and started to shout "Up, de Valera" to prevent me from speaking. At that time the Army Comrades Association was in existence, but I had no connection with it. They stood for the right of free speech. About 60 members of the A.C.A. in Macroom went back and, in my hearing, said to those young men who had been interrupting "Now stop interrupting or go away and let the speaker address the meeting." They would not do so. The man in charge of those A.C.A. looked up at me and said "Wait a minute, Mr. Dillon"; he then went back to those 50 men and wiped the square of Macroom with them, and there were no more interruptions. At the conclusion of that operation, when he had wiped the square of Macroom with them, there were no more interruptions, and I was able to hold my meeting, but if he had not been there not one word would I have been allowed to utter in the town of Macroom that day. It does not matter whether the people of Macroom were in my favour or against me. It was my right to go there and peacefully address a public meeting. That gang tried to stop me, and if it had not been for the A.C.A. that day I would not have been allowed to say a word and the Civic Guards could not have prevented the interruptions. What has been our experience during the last two months? When the Blue Shirts first gathered strength in this country we went down to Limerick, and one of the Fianna Fáil Deputies from Limerick, out with the crowd—I do not know what for—got a stroke of a baton.
Comment on this
I do not give way. He got struck with a baton, in any case. I suppose he was going out picking daisies in Limerick. I went up the main street in Limerick, and in every side street there was a Fianna Fáil gang pelting bottles at us.
Comment on this
We will stop talking of murderers to-night. There has been enough talk of murder. Drop it. There was a Fianna Fáil gang in every side street pelting us with bottles.
Comment on this
I saw men walking in blue shirts, with their heads split open and blood streaming down their faces and they never left the procession to strike a return blow so long as the march was going on to the place of the meeting. I saw that repeated here and there through the country until the beginning of this year and then I went to one meeting after another and there was not a stir or a whimper because the Blue Shirts were there. Until when? Until this Bill was published and the blackguards turned up at Kildare last Sunday. They are taking heart of courage again. They think that at last the Government has come to their aid after the Blue Shirts had wiped them out and restored the right of free speech, not only to me and everybody on this side, but to everybody on that side opposite, because no meeting of the Fianna Fáil Party has ever been interfered with.
Comment on this
They have been revived by this Bill. We have heard to-night an attempt made to suggest that membership of the League of Youth is, in part, criminal. I have here a list of crimes, two or three outrages every day since the 1st of last October. I am not going to go into them——
Comment on this
Here are the outrages and not one single one of those outrages can be brought home to a member of the League of Youth. Every single one of those outrages has been directed against members of our Party or the property of members of our Party. They average two or three a day ever since the 1st of October. I am proud to say that in spite of the most savage provocation, there has not been one single act of retaliation by members of our organisation and I fervently pray that there may not be. I believe I can answer for the members of our organisation, that so long as they are given a fair chance, so long as they feel that the Government is not going to take the side of the blackguards and the murderers against them, there will be no act of retaliation. There has not been, and it is something we are proud of, but one would imagine that having a file of outrage and murder of that character before them, the Government would devote its attention to devising ways and means of bringing to justice the people who are responsible for these murders and for these outrages, outrages to which President de Valera referred not long ago. The President said:—
"The only names I can honestly apply to items in this list are outrages and crimes. The police, the guardians of order, have been attacked. Homes have been fired into. There have been several cases recently and it is a miracle that nobody has been killed."
Two men have been murdered since the President uttered those words. He went on:
"Citizens have been assaulted. If a citizen does wrong, there is a way to bring him to justice. We want ordered society in this country, and if we have not that, then there is no future for the nation. Property has been wilfully destroyed. Organised groups have taken it upon themselves to decide, without any legal or moral right whatever, how much liberty their fellow citizens may enjoy."
Every single one of those reproaches applies to the supporters of President de Valera himself and he went down to make them to his own supporters. It was to reproach his supporters in County Kerry that he went down to Tralee. Having taken tea in Arbour Hill barracks the night before, he went down to Kerry the next day in order to tell them what naughty boys they were and this splendid high falutin' was indulged in. But how does the President evince his indignation at those outrages? How does he evince his resolution to deal impartially but courageously and strictly with the people who have been responsible for them?—by introducing a Bill to outlaw a body of young men in this country against whom he can bring no charge whatever except that they are opposed to his Party and opposed to the people who are responsible for the outrages which he condemned when he spoke in Tralee. How can any man with any sense of justice in him stand for something of that kind? Charles Lamb, the Essayist, divided men into two races—the men who borrow and the men who lend— but there is another division. There are the men who are born freemen and the men who are born slaves. The man who is born a freeman has a sense of justice and of liberty but the man born a slave has a sense of neither and it does not matter whether he is doomed all his life to be a hewer of wood and a drawer of water, he does not recognise injustice when he meets it—he lies down under it—or whether he is called to high office, he does not realise when he is doing injustice. He just does it whenever it suits his purpose.
I think it was the Attorney-General who said that the Government has got to bear in mind that organisations which, at first, seem quite innocuous may subsequently become very dangerous and that then the time has come for Government action. Dangerous to what? Where has there been any attempt made to prove before the bar of public opinion in this country that any section of our movement is dangerous to the institutions of this State? No attempt has been made because you know that you cannot prove it. There is no use charging us with desiring to set up in this country a pagan deity or a pagan religion. The Minister for Finance knows that that charge is not true. It is just as futile and as silly and as imbecile as the charges that his meanest followers make down the country. He knows that the men on these benches have no such intention in their minds. What justification can there be then for introducing a Bill of this kind—the justification which the Attorney-General admitted by innuendo, that the Government has come to realise that if our movement is not a danger to the institutions of the State, it has become a formidable danger to the Fianna Fáil Government. It is no crime in this country to be a constitutional danger to the Fianna Fáil Government. The danger of it is that there is a frame of mind growing up along those benches and amongst the supporters of the occupants of those benches in the country, that any man who does not accept President de Valera's outlook is a traitor to Ireland instead of an opponent of Fianna Fáil.
There is all the difference in the world between a man who would not serve this country or who would help its enemies and a man who wants to deliver this country from the thraldom of Fianna Fáil. We are a danger and a growing danger to Fianna Fáil. It does not matter what Bill you introduce or to what lengths you go here in the way of coercion, you are done for and you know it. That is the situation: you are done for and you know it, and you are following the same old silly course that every British Government that was on the run in this country ever followed. You first begin to elaborate talk about conciliation. One can hear the accents of Buckshot Forster, "conciliate them,""kill them with kindness." Then you discover that you are dealing with people who cannot be dealt with in that way and then you get cold feet and you go for coercion. You explain your Bill and you say this Bill is not coercion but a shadow. You next find that the confusion you have brought about is worse confounded and you find yourself dragged down the slippery slope and that you are faced with the people rising up against you and sweeping you out of office. (Interruptions).
Jeering will not help you; whistling to keep up your courage will not help you. It would be much better for you to realise that this country means more to us all than do our respective Parties. But you are disgracing this country in the eyes of the world. There is no country in the world to-day that has a Government practising tyranny on its people to the same extent to which you are. And you are holding up this country to the odium of the world. This country was maligned for generations by British politicians as a country not fit for self-government, not fit to govern itself. You as a Government are vindicating to-day all that these men said and you are plastering the reputation of every man who for generations staked his reputation on his faith in the fact that our people were fit to govern themselves. You are saying to the world that we are not fit to govern ourselves without instruments of tyranny being put into your hands in order to carry on the government of this country. It is nothing to be proud of. It is everything to be ashamed of. It is because you have forgotten that this country should mean more to us than any Party or Parties and it is because you are filled with fury against the Cumann na nGaedheal Government that you want to prove to us that they were murderers, dastards and traitors. What does it matter now if they were? What matters is the things we have before us. What consolation is it to the Minister for Finance to prove that the men who for ten years were the chosen leaders of this country, the chosen leaders of the Irish people, were murderers, dastards and traitors, even if it were true? I deny that it is true. Does it not redound to the shame of our people that for ten years they chose such people to lead them and to carry on the government of the country?
Is it a worthy thing to be flaunted before the world by a responsible Minister who, with the facts before him, comes here and before the world says that during the first ten years of Irish self-government, the government was carried on by murderers, dastards and traitors to the people? I am satisfied that those gentlemen who constituted the Government of this country for ten years have very little to be sorry for, but it redounds little to the credit of the Minister for Finance to try to make such a case. The whole argument taken up by the Fianna Fáil Party and the whole line pursued by that Party and Government is calculated to blacken and disgrace the good name of the people of this country in the eyes of the world. And all that is being done for no reason except an attempt to get Party advantage.
Those Ministers know positively that there is no danger to the institutions of this State in any part of our movement. They know positively that not a single man sitting on these benches would continue in support of a movement that contemplated the possibility of the prospect of civil war in this country or aimed at upsetting the elected Government of the Irish people by a dictatorship. Not for one single moment. They know that. But nevertheless they want to destroy the rising tide of constitutional opposition. They hold up their own fellow-countrymen to the odium of the world. They hurl charges at us that we are conspiring to overthrow this State and that the only way in which to protect the State from us is by the introduction of coercion, which is unparalleled in the history of this country by banning the wearing of a blue shirt.
Comment on this
We heard the Minister for Justice here when he asked leave to introduce this Bill. He rose and spoke in the most pious accents of his desire to restore peace in the country. Dismay was registered on the faces of his supporters when I drew attention to the fact that while Dr. Jekyll was expounding to the House the pious purpose of the Bill, Mr. Hyde was plastering out in the columns of the Irish Press that his purpose was to ban the Blue Shirts. But Dr. Jekyll is now thrown aside in this House and the Minister gets up and says: “I make no disguise about this Bill, it is not a Bill to preserve the public peace; it is a Bill to ban the Blue Shirts and I make no apology for it.” And then he tries to make a lame excuse and a lame case for the Bill.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce asks us why do we want to wear the blue shirts. The most potent answer I can make to him is this: six months ago his supporters, armed and unarmed, were able to go to our meetings and break them up. They were able to intimidate our people. They were able to threaten them, intimidate them and injure them in person and property. The Young Ireland Movement and League of Youth provided in their uniform a rallying point for the decent people of this country and after six months wearing of the blue shirts the Minister's supporters, armed or unarmed, are unable to face the boys who are wearing the blue shirts. That is why we are wearing the blue shirts. Because if the rights of public men or private citizens to go about their business undisturbed are to be preserved in this country, we need not look to the Government to preserve those rights because they failed to do so. We preserved these rights for ourselves and we will continue to preserve them. It is because we preserved these rights that an attempt is now being made to destroy our movement and to take away from us the rights we won with our own strong arms; rights which the Government has done nothing to preserve to the people.
Comment on this
I used an expression which is perfectly clear to the Deputy. I said we won that right with our right arms. We carry no lethal weapons and we issued a challenge to the Government that if they found members of the League of Youth with arms let them arrest them. If they find that we are an armed body let them arrest us. I tell them here and now that the I.R.A. is an armed body. It is their duty to take the arms off these people, but they are afraid to do it, because their own followers are in the I.R.A., their own followers here in the House are in the I.R.A. and they are supporting the I.R.A. and everybody knows it.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin can intervene in this debate when I am finished and I will be glad to hear him. The questions which we have to consider here are nothing for jeers or jocularity. Deputy Davin will have to wake up to his responsibilities. He will have to give a vote and then we will see whether he stands for coercion or justice. The Minister for Justice has said that the powers in this Bill are no more than the powers which we put into the Public Safety Act and he asks why should there be any reluctance to give them the same powers as were put in the Public Safety Act. He says "we did not misuse the Public Safety Act." He says that, while we have before us the flagrant misuse of that Act at Westport, was there not every attempt made to misuse that Act at Westport? Was there not an attempt made to arrest the leader of this Party at Westport and to hold him illegally in custody? But for the exercise of the functions of the courts which this Bill seeks to supersede the leader of our Party would be still in custody. Was it not the action in the High Courts which got him out of illegal custody? Why should we trust a Government that sought illegally to use the powers of the Public Safety Act? Why should the Oireachtas trust such a Government with the far more extensive powers of this Bill?
Comment on this
I am going to finish what I have to say and then Deputy Davin can intervene to jeer or joke, whichever he likes. The last charge the Minister for Justice had to make to-day was that at every meeting where Blue Shirts appeared there was a disturbance. That is not true. It is quite true to say that when the Blueshirts were growing in strength every meeting they appeared at there was a disturbance. There had to be a disturbance or we would not have been allowed to speak. There was just so much disturbance as was necessary to put the blackguards out of the crowd and to give the people who came there to speak the right to speak. There has been no disturbance of any kind at Blueshirt meetings for the last four or five weeks until this Bill was introduced. The moment the blackguards heard of this Bill or read of it in the Irish Press, they turned out again because they believed that the time had come for their immunity.
Comment on this
I do not think Deputy Brodrick would agree with you there. There was a disturbance in Clifden a fortnight ago.
Comment on this
I want the House to realise one or two points in this Bill which I do not believe most of the supporters of the Government have even bothered to read. All they wanted to know was that an effective instrument was being created to destroy their political opponents. They ought to read Section 7 (1) which makes it an offence directly or indirectly to incite, encourage or condone the commission of offences. So that any person now who dares to criticise a proclamation of the Chief Commissioner of the Gárda Síochána or the Chief Superintendent in his own area commits an offence under this Bill. We are now not only prohibited from doing certain things but we are going to be prohibited from thinking or saying them. That is Fianna Fáil liberty; that is the liberty which, no doubt, the Labour Party will play its part in ushering into this country. We have Section 11 under which every member of the Gárda Síochána is authorised to assault a citizen who he believes is committing a breach of the law. We have Section 12 (2) which withholds the right from the people of the country to appeal to a court of competent jurisdiction to review a decision of the District Court, for no reason except that the Minister for Justice says that there will be too much time and money spent going from one court to the other. One wonders why he bothered to provide for the bringing of charged persons to court at all.
Comment on this
If the Minister desires to dig up and delve in the memories of the past and model his court on what happened in this country in times gone by he is quite welcome to engage in that task, but I am not competent to advise him. I do not want to be dragged into a discussion of the Minister's past or the past of anybody else.
Comment on this
I am not bit sorry for linking my fortunes with any colleague with whom I am associated. Any colleague I have got I am proud of him and I am glad and happy to be standing beside him. The Minister can set his mind at ease on that. So far as I am concerned, all I appeal to this House to do is to consider well what they are doing. Because the Government are afraid of the opposition which is growing up against them in this country this House is being asked to pass a coercion Act which leaves the worst of the British coercion Acts in the shade. This House is being asked to vindicate every enemy of Ireland who asserted that her people were unfit to govern themselves. This House is being asked to show the world that a Government elected by the Irish people is unfit to govern in Ireland without instruments in its hand that would bring the blush of shame to the cheek of a Czar of Russia. All that is being asked to be done while the Government cannot produce one scintilla of evidence against the League of Youth of having engaged in any sort of activity that constituted a danger to the institutions of the State. All this is being done while the Government have ample powers to deal with any danger that might arise to the State. The introduction of this Bill is due to the one fact that the Government know, and I repeat again that the Attorney-General knows above all, that the activities and the programme of the League of Youth are legal, have been legal and always will be legal. This is being done while every member of the Government, and the Attorney-General above all, knows that this organisation has not, and never will, engage in any activities subversive of the institutions of the State. It is because they have that knowledge that they have to introduce a Bill of this kind.
They are asking the House without any reason, without any justification, with manifest injustice, to impose upon us the most ferocious measure of coercion ever introduced in this House. For five months we have stood disciplined and within the law in the face of intimidation, in the face of libel, in the face of assault, and in the face of murder. Those who perpetrated those outrages upon us are to go unscathed. They are to go uncondemned. They are to be looked upon by a great many members of the Party opposite as the real authority, the legitimate authority in this country. Those of us who have organised the young men of this country to go out unarmed, to go out bearing in mind always that the supreme authority in this country is the Government elected by the Irish people, are to be outlawed, to be coerced. We are the people to be dragooned while the others, who deny the right of this House to sit, who deny the right of the Government to be the Government, are to be belauded as Irish patriots. We, who are working for Ireland and whose people were working for Ireland before a great many of the latter-day patriots were ever heard of in this country, are to be dragooned as the enemies of this country, as the servants of Great Britain and as suitable objects of Fianna Fáil coercion.
I know our record; I know what we have been doing and what we are doing for Ireland; I know what all belonging to us have been doing for Ireland; and if that is deserving of Fianna Fáil censure, I am proud to be deserving of it. You may pass all the coercion Bills you like; you may go to any extreme and hold this country up to any odium before the world that you like; but, sooner or later, by constitutional means and by the vote of the Irish people, we will clear your Government out. It will be a long and weary job to get the name of this country back where it ought to be. You have tarnished and disgraced it. But there are still sufficient decent people here to recover all the ground you have lost. I believe that, perhaps, sooner than most of you imagine, the people will give us the right to undertake the work; and when they do we will undertake it just as lawfully and just as solicitously for this country as we have been working for the last two years.