Wearing of Uniform (Restriction) Bill, 1934—Committee.
Contributions 165–350 of 350. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 13 of 1934 ›
I am supporting this amendment. I think, Sir, this amendment resulted from my intervention on the Second Reading of this measure. I then suggested that perhaps it might easily occur that a member of a trade union, who was wearing his trade union badge, could be held up on the street and charged with an offence under this section.
Comment on this
It is exactly the same thing—"or badge." Under the amendment which the Minister has accepted he agrees that a person wearing a trade union badge would not come within the ambit of this Bill. I feel that even under its altered form the section is capable of being misconstrued if the words suggested by Deputy Mulcahy are not inserted. I, therefore, support the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not know if Deputy Mulcahy knows what a trade union is. Certainly he does not know what a trade union is for the purposes of an Act of Parliament. There are very extraordinary associations registered as trade unions, a number of which have nothing to do with labour, or the organisation of labour. The effect of the amendment proposed would, of course, be very largely to nullify the Bill, inasmuch as it would be open to any organisation to adopt to itself one of those associations which are in existence and which have nothing to do with the organisation of labour. I think the Deputy is aware of one well-known person in Dublin who adopted this attitude and made quite a lot of money out of it. The effect of the amendment would be to open the gate so wide that the Bill would be entirely futile.
Comment on this
We have come to a very desirable position, and it is a very good thing that this point has to be decided. Now, the Labour Party is beginning to feel coercion. Now, the members of the Labour Party are being brought to a realisation of what the significance of this Bill is. The Labour Party are going to be put to the test now of voting in this House whether that Government should have the right to suppress every trade union in this country, or whether they should not. Deputy Corish got up in Wexford a few days ago, and announced that he had voted for the Blue Shirts Bill because he was satisfied that Deputy Cosgrave and others were aiming at setting up a dictatorship in this country. I wish Deputy Corish were here to repeat that.
Comment on this
I will not look it up again. I know very well what the Deputy said. Deputy Davin cannot deny that he said he voted for the Blue Shirt Bill because he knew, or believed, that Deputy Cosgrave and others were trying to set up a dictatorship. That statement Deputy Corish cannot have believed. That statement everyone in Wexford knows was made without the belief which would justify making it. To-day we have the position in which Deputy Corish's own colleagues are going to walk into the lobby for the purpose of giving that Government the right to set up a dictatorship in this country, and to suppress every organisation, labour and otherwise, which may seek to defend the rights of the citizens of this country against that Government, or against any other force which seeks to suppress the rights and liberties of working men and every other man in the country. The Labour Party ought to realise what they are going to do. Deputy Norton has opened this pit under his own feet. It is up to him now to show the country whether he has the courage of his convictions, or whether he has any convictions at all. There are a good many people in this country beginning to doubt whether he has any, or whether he ever had any. There was a time, in this country, when the Labour movement stood resolutely and consistently against coercion. They sold their souls to the Fianna Fáil Party and they alone know what they got for them.
Comment on this
They have sold their souls to Fianna Fáil, and they are now being required to pay the price. They are now being required to deliver themselves. They are now being required to sell every labouring man in this country into the bondage of the Ministers on those seats. They are now being required to set their names to something which for the first time in the history of this country, since trade unions were set up, gives the Government the right to suppress a trade union because it is a trade union. And the Minister knows it. The Minister tries to make the case that there are more forms of trade unions than one. It will be a poor consolation to the working men of this country to know that their rights, which every Labour leader in the history of the Labour movement of this country, and every other country, has fought for, have been bartered away to-night by the Irish Labour Party. There is no Labour representative in the whole of Europe but would vote for that amendment, except the Labour representatives of the Irish workmen. There is not a Labour representative, no matter how depraved, in any country in the world but would resist that attempt on the part of that Government to take the powers they seek to take under this Bill. It is up to Deputy Norton now to show whether the stand he pretends to take is a fraud or not. He has got his chance, and he ought to demonstrate to the working men of this country that he is prepared to defend them when it costs something to defend them, or he ought to clear out for ever from the working men movement in this country.
Comment on this
Occasionally, Deputy Dillon shows himself in his true colours. Formerly, he used to pose in this House as a true democrat, an admirer and defender of the Labour Party and of the rights of the worker. To-night, he said—and it shows his real mind in regard to Labour movements everywhere—that there is no Labour leader, no matter how depraved, but would vote for this amendment.
Comment on this
No Labour leader, no matter how depraved! What depravity is there in being a Labour representative or a Labour leader?
Comment on this
What depravity in the minds of all true democrats, or what depravity in the mind of Deputy Dillon, is there in being a Labour leader?
Comment on this
Nobody opposite will be able to answer that question and no member of the Fianna Fáil Party will be able to answer that question because no person in this House knows how deeply and how sincerely in his heart Deputy Dillon hates the cause of Labour. His unguarded word has exposed for the first time in this House the real mentality of Deputy Dillon. He said that if the Labour Party do not vote for this amendment they will vote to hand over the control of the Labour movement to the Ministers sitting on these benches. I do not know whether Deputy Dillon was as insincere in May, 1932, as he was sincere to-night when he let slip that unguarded expression which reveals his true mind, because I remember him voting here for a Budget, introduced by members of the Government on these benches, because it was a good Budget and a Christian Budget, as he said, and a Budget that was going to do something at last for the workers. He believed then that we could do something for the workers and that we had the cause of Labour and the labouring classes at heart.
Comment on this
We have not changed. We still remain on these benches. We still stand in public for the same programme but Deputy Dillon has changed. He has undergone a translation——
Comment on this
——from the benches that were formerly occupied by a Party ever doomed to vanish—the sectional Farmers' Party in this country—and now occupies, as Deputy Norton said, a position on the Front Benches opposite. It is that gentleman, who has changed his position but who has not changed his spots, and who remains still as he was then, the enemy of Irish labour, the enemy of Irish freedom, who now ventures to condemn the Labour Party in respect of this amendment. It is pointed out that General O'Duffy to-morrow might take over one of these moribund organisations and call himself a trade union—and there is nothing to be wondered at in that, because the General has the audacity to call himself many things and poses as many things before the Irish people; one of his latest poses is to exhibit himself as a friend of the workers—it would not be any sort of difficult transformation for that gentleman to change himself to-morrow into, as I have said, a trade union and claim exemption for any association of persons, who might band themselves together under one of these resurrected names, from the provisions of this Bill.
Comment on this
This is an important amendment. I do not think there is any use in endeavouring to cloud the issue by rising to any heights of oratory on this simple amendment. Anybody who has any experience of trade unionism knows that the things referred to by the Minister for Finance could not possibly happen. The wording of the section as it stands is very clear. This section will apply to the members of any trade union in this country and it will give the Government power to prevent the members of a trade union from wearing the badge of the particular trade union to which they belong. I do not think there is much use in going outside the scope of the amendment or of bringing in matters that are quite irrelevant. The wording is very clear. It refers to "any combination of persons" and Deputy Norton's amendment has one purpose and one purpose only—to ensure that before the Bill is passed, this section will not apply to the members of trade unions in this country. I think it is quite obvious that, as it stands, at the moment, it can apply and can be made applicable to the members of a trade union and prevent them from doing anything in furtherance of the objects for which trade unionism stands if those objects might, at any time in the future, be at variance with opinions held by Ministers at present. I think the thing is very clear and I would ask the Government to accept the amendment proposed by Deputy Norton.
Comment on this
The deletion of the word "badge" from sub-section (2) of Section 2 will make the section read:
"Every person who wears any uniform in contravention of the foregoing sub-section of this section shall be guilty of an offence under this section."
The exclusion of the word "badge" means that a person who wears a badge is consequently not guilty of an offence under the section.
Comment on this
I have looked at amendment No. 13 and amendment No. 18, which deletes the word "badge."
Comment on this
What is all this concern for the trade unions to-night? The trade unions have some curious advisers to-night.
Comment on this
If one did not know that Deputy Dillon could not stop talking, and was a kind of political parrot in this House, one would be inclined to take, at its face value, the concern which he pretended to display for the trade union movement to-night. But look who is displaying the concern for the trade union movement—Deputy Dillon, who was one of the prominent people, in Ballaghaderreen, associated with a lock-out a few years ago, and one of the people associated with a wage-cutting campaign in Ballaghaderreen a few years ago. This is the gentleman who is interested in the trade union movement to-night. Insolence and hypocrisy never went further. Then we had Deputy Mulcahy bubbling over—he cannot contain himself——
Comment on this
I will come to the Deputy in a minute. We had Deputy Mulcahy bubbling over in his anxiety to assist the trade union movement to-night—the Deputy, who, as a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, prohibited a trade union from going on strike and issued a proclamation to that effect and who, when speaking in this House on the Saorstát Eireann United National Health Insurance Bill, made a most disgraceful and slanderous attack on a trade union insurance society which proved to be perfectly untrue and in respect of which the Deputy had subsequently to make a kind of apology. His dignity would not enable him to make a decent apology. These are the two gentlemen who are concerned about the trade union movement tonight—one Deputy who prohibited a strike and slandered a trade union insurance society, and another Deputy who was associated with a wage-cutting campaign in Ballaghaderreen and with a lock-out of the workers there. Those are the two advisers we have to-night.
Comment on this
The Deputy has got something to chew on now that he did not think he would get. I shall come to the amendment in good time. Deputy Dillon says that this Bill enables the Executive Council to suppress a trade union. Under what section does that come? Deputy Dillon is a lawyer. He has King's Counsel beside him to advise him. Where is the section in the Bill that gives that power?
Comment on this
I should like Deputy Dillon to tell us where is the section which enables the Government to prohibit or proscribe a trade union.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy read the section again, or will be get his legal adviser beside him to read it for him, and tell us under what section it is possible to proscribe a trade union? The Deputy has stated that it is possible to do so. Let us know under what section it can be done.
Comment on this
We have senior and junior counsel on the case now, and Deputy Mulcahy should not interrupt.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon is consulting his counsel—not I. Deputy Dillon is the client. Is he willing to indicate the section under which this can be done? He cannot do it.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not long enough at the Bar. Deputy Dillon is silent now. He knows perfectly well that there is no section in this Bill under which a trade union can be proscribed.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon knows now that the statement he made was incorrect in that respect, and that even if the Bill went through without amendment there was no section in it giving power to proscribe trade unions. I have not the slightest fear that trade unions will be proscribed by this Government; but if the Deputy's Party were in power, having regard to their known record in the past, I would have considerable doubts as to whether they would not exercise their powers and probably arrogate to themselves powers to suppress the trades union movement. If one had any doubt on that, we have had it recently proved by the statements of the leader of that Party outside. He has a scheme of his own—a new Italian scheme.
Comment on this
If the ice were on the leader's head when he was making those statements there would be less nonsense in them. To give us an idea of what the Party opposite stands for in the matter of trade unions, we have the leader of the Party outside stumping the country with a ready-made Italian system to enable the trade unions to come in close contact with their employers, and to get a line on Deputy Dillon and his Party in the matter of trade unions, we have only to read the statements of General O'Duffy at Kildare, that the dearest right of workers, the right to withdraw their labour, is going to be prohibited under this great corporative State that the General talks about in Kildare. The Deputy talks about trade unions and his concern for them, and the leader outside says in Kildare that they are going to organise the State on such a basis as to withdraw from the workers the right which they fought for since the beginning of the trade union movement, namely, the right to withdraw their labour. It is a nice state of affairs when we get a Party of that kind, represented in this House by Deputy Dillon, with the leader outside wanting to suppress the trade unions and Deputy Dillon inside pretending to be concerned about them. Is not the whole attitude of the Party opposite towards trade unions abundantly illustrated by this corporative scheme of General O'Duffy, which is going to have Deputy Good and his bricklayer in the one organisation? Deputy Good laughs. Of course he laughs. Why, a cat would laugh at the scheme of organisation. We are to have Deputy Good and his bricklayer in the one organisation. There is to be no right to strike at all —no right to strike for the bricklayer. He may be permitted to work for his employer but he can never withdraw his labour, and, being economically inferior to his employer and having no right to withdraw his labour, what is going to happen is that the employer will have the right to dictate to him all the time. And we have this from a Party that to-night pretends to be concerned about trade unions. Deputy Dillon above all people on that bench, after his activities in Ballaghaderreen in connection with strikes and lockouts, ought to be the last to stand up and pretend to be concerned about trade unions.
Comment on this
I just rise to say a word or two about Deputy Norton. He has got up in this House and, like a good lawyer with a bad case, he directs all his attention to abusing the Opposition, but does not say a single word about the amendment before him. He simply asked one question in connection with it and made no statement whatever. He asked one question, and that was to state one section under which trade unions could be prevented from winning a battle. I am not a lawyer. I am a layman, but I think that it is quite evident that the Executive Council can do so under Section 2 and I think under Section 1, taken together. Section 2 says:—
It shall not be lawful for any person to wear any uniform or badge which is indicative of membership of, affiliation to, or support of a political party or an association ancillary to a political party.
Now, what is to prevent the Executive Council declaring any Labour Party or any Labour organisation to be a political party or an association ancillary to a political party?
Comment on this
Supposing Deputy Norton and his Party came over here to the Opposition, could not the Executive Council declare that his organisation was an organisation ancillary to a political party? Deputy Norton, on this occasion, sells his liberty and gives himself over completely to the Government. He sells his independence and freedom and the independence and freedom of all those he represents. I challenge him to deny it. I shall leave it to others now because I am only a layman. The simplest man in the Assembly can see that under Section 2, taken in connection with Section 1, they have power to declare the organisation the Labour Party represent an ancillary to a political party, if the Labour Party do not do what they want them to do.
Comment on this
I listened with considerable astonishment to the discussion which has taken place here. It is quite evident that, after spending three days on this Bill on the Second Reading and the whole of to-day on the Committee Stage, Deputies opposite have not yet found out what it is about. I suggest to Deputies opposite that before they come in here to waste the time of the Dáil making speeches on a Bill they should at least read it. You cannot proscribe or suppress any organisation under this Bill, whether it is or is not a trade union. This is not a Bill to suppress any organisation.
Comment on this
Under Section 5 or any other section a trade union or any other type of organisation cannot be suppressed under the Bill. This is a Bill that prohibits the wearing of uniform.
Comment on this
And to prohibit the wearing of badges under certain circumstances. Now Deputies will perhaps realise how relevant Deputy Norton was when referring to amendment No. 18, because amendment No. 18 takes badges out of the Bill except under Section 5 where a proclamation is required in order to proscribe a particular badge, in particular circumstances, in a particular district. I am sorry Deputy Dillon is not here. He might have found out what the Bill was about and saved himself the trouble of coming in to make another stupid speech based on ignorance, like all the speeches from Deputy Dillon. I am certain that if I had not intervened in time we would have the same type of stupid and ill-informed speech from Deputy McGilligan.
Comment on this
You are going to get one now that you would describe in that way and you will not be able to answer it.
Comment on this
I want to make it clear for the information of Deputies, who are apparently too lazy to read the Bill, that no organisation can be suppressed under the Bill. It is a Bill to proscribe the wearing of uniforms by any political organisation or any association ancillary to a political Party.
Comment on this
What is the purpose of the amendment then? Why was Deputy Norton's amendment on the Paper?
Comment on this
As the Bill stood, the wearing of a badge by an organisation ancillary to a political Party was made illegal without reference to any description of badge. There is a Government amendment deleting that particular provision of the Bill, so that it is possible for any member of a political Party or an organisation ancillary to a political Party to wear a badge unless and until, in the interests of public order, the Commissioner of the Gárda Síochána prohibits it.
Comment on this
Now that Deputies are better informed about the Bill, perhaps they will be more pointed in their speeches.
Comment on this
We are nearly as wise now after the Minister has spoken as we ordinarily are after he has spoken.
Comment on this
We got a lot of what the Americans call "Chicago bull," but no information. We have heard about a "royal flush," but I think the Minister can be called a "four flusher." Deputy Norton continually talks about a parrot. It is very easy to teach a parrot small, simple words like "withdraw." I am sure he has said "pretty polly" to himself very often, but "withdraw" is the word he has learned best. Deputy Davin talked about getting a red shirt. It would fade to the faintest white with a tinge of yellow in it if any Minister held up his hands to the Deputy. Really nobody should have any interest in trade unions if trade unions have any interest in the two Deputies who have put up such a craven show to-night. What was the meaning of putting down the amendment? Did the Deputies apprehend some danger? They surely did, and they are now relieved because the Minister for Industry and Commerce stood up and said they must have power to suppress trade unions.
Comment on this
Those were his words. Whether he read the Bill before he used them or not I do not know. He distinctly used them. He said that there were many associations masquerading as trade unions and that there must be power to suppress. These are the very words he used. The Minister for Finance talks about translations. When he is translated I hope he will be expurgated, as he tried to expurgate others. They will not expurgate that. That is what the Minister for Industry and Commerce wanted. Do not let cravenness overcome the trade union representatives in the House too soon. There is something to be stood over; there is some danger. The man who drives away speeches, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who has not made a good example of himself, told us to-night that "badge" has gone from the Bill. It has not. I will make the statement without fear of contradiction that "badge" has not gone out of the Bill. "Badge" has not gone out of the definition clause; it has not gone out of Section 5; it has not, in effect, gone out of Section 4. With the repercussion of all these sections, one on the other, there is not the slightest doubt that if the Government want to get after a trade union they can get after it. Any Chief Superintendent of the Gárda Síochána can prohibit the wearing of trade union badges in his functional area. That is clear. It will be an offence under the section for a trade unionist to wear a badge. Notwithstanding the amendment accepted, notwithstanding the parrot cry of "withdraw," it will be an offence to wear a badge, and under Section 9 any member of the Gárda Síochána may enter any trade union premises and search.
Comment on this
Let me read the section about the proclamation:
The Commissioner of the Gárda Síochána in respect of the whole of Saorstát Eireann, and any Chief Superintendent of the Gárda Síochána in respect of his functional area, may by proclamation prohibit the wearing in Saorstát Eireann or in such functional area (as the case may be) of any particular uniform or particular badge specified in such proclamation....
That saves you! Is that the answer?
Comment on this
It does. Are you willing to go to a trade union and say: "We are convinced that there is not a single Chief Superintendent of the Gárda Síochána in the country fool enough, anti-trade union enough, so much under the thumb of the Government that he would prohibit the wearing of a badge belonging to a trade union in any area?" Is that the defence? It that what the Deputies think is safeguarding the trade unions? Will they say that in any of those areas inside the functional area of a Chief Superintendent a search warrant may be issued and under the warrant premises may be raided and private homes may be raided? Is that safeguarding the trade union organisations? You need not go so far as Section 5. Section 4 gives the Executive Council power to declare any association a political Party and once that has happened anything that can happen under the Bill can happen to trade unions.
Comment on this
And the Minister for Industry and Commerce puts a little saucer of milk in front of Deputy Davin and Deputy Norton and says:
"It is not meant that we will ever want to suppress a trades union; we will not want to do that, all we can do is to prohibit the wearing of badges."
A certain member of the Broy Harriers who planted ammunition——
Comment on this
I think exception has already been taken to describing forces of the State as Broy Harriers. This is against the ruling of the Chair.
Comment on this
I am not describing the forces of the State as Broy Harriers. I said a certain member.
Comment on this
It has been ruled by the Chair that such an expression with regard to members of the State forces should not be used. That has been already stated.
Comment on this
I said that such an expression with regard to certain members of the State forces should not be used and that had been already stated. It had been already ruled that referring to certain sections of the Gárda Síochána as Broy Harriers is a disrespectful description.
Comment on this
Then I will say that the planters of ammunition belonging to the State forces can be sent into the house of a trades unionist to plant ammunition.
Comment on this
It has been done and the man was brought up in court and he was backed by the Attorney-General.
Comment on this
That statement is not true and I submit the Deputy is out of order.
Comment on this
I respectfully suggest that any statement I make here is a statement that I can back up by the newspaper reports of the Military Tribunal and I repeat it. The Attorney-General backed the man whom the Military Tribunal found to have planted ammunition in the case of Commandant Cronin.
Comment on this
I challenge that statement as untrue. There was no finding that the ammunition was planted by the Guards. The Deputy should not make the statement unless he can substantiate it.
Comment on this
There is not a particle of untruth in it. The man planted ammunition and that was the case before the Military Tribunal. I can substantiate it from the newspaper reports of the case.
Comment on this
The position is that State forces are directed to do certain duties. We are not discussing here what they are to do. It does not fall under this Bill that they are to do certain things or not do them.
Comment on this
I want to point out to the House that trades unionists are not so completely protected as the Minister for Industry and Commerce would ask the House to believe and I wish to point out again that under Section 5 of the Bill trades unionists may be prevented from wearing any particular badge. Under another Section it is provided
if a member of the Gárda Síochána ... is of opinion that there is reasonable ground for supposing that there are, in any place or premises, uniforms or badges, the wearing of which is prohibited by or under this Act, he may issue an order in writing ... to any one or more members of the Gárda Síochána under his command and named therein to search such place or premises.
In that connection I put it as reasonably fair that there may happen to trades unionists what happened to Commandant Cronin—that they will find arms planted on them.
Comment on this
In dealing with the Gárda Síochána I think the Deputy should really adduce some proof that such finding was made by the Military Tribunal.
Comment on this
The Deputy has referred to State forces as persons who planted ammunition. He has repeated that and I submit that that is a much more serious offence against the Rules of Order than the previous offence.
Comment on this
It was unfortunately an offence against order in the country and it was committed by members of the Police Force.
Comment on this
Charges of this kind should not be made against State forces in this House. If members of the Police Force are guilty of offences and if such charges are to be made against them there is a place where these can be substantiated. Deputies should not make such charges unless they are prepared to substantiate them.
Comment on this
There has been a particular event and it was tried before the eyes of the people of this country who can read. I make the allegation that what I have said is perfectly correct and I will not withdraw an inch from that point. A particular charge was made before the Military Tribunal and the defence of that charge was that the ammunition was planted. That defence was accepted by the Military Tribunal.
Comment on this
No. There was no finding by the Military Tribunal that that ammunition was planted. The Deputy should not make such a statement unless he is prepared to substantiate it. It is a charge that should not be made in this House.
Comment on this
That is what I have endeavoured to prevent and I have asked the Deputy to substantiate the statement.
Comment on this
I put this up as a reasonable apprehension on the part of trades unionists who might have reasonable fears that ammunition may be planted on them and——
Comment on this
Do I take it that Deputy McGilligan withdraws the statement that certain members of the State forces planted ammunition?
Comment on this
No. I am not withdrawing it. I am prepared to substantiate it. I made that statement and I give as reference the daily Press at the time. I did not come into this House with copies of the daily papers of the time of the trial, but I can produce them. This thing is not challenged by anybody who knows the facts.
Comment on this
The charge before the Military Tribunal was a charge against a man for having ammunition. There has been no finding by the Military Tribunal that any member of the State forces planted ammunition in that case. I now ask the Deputy to produce any finding by the Military Tribunal that any member of the State forces planted ammunition.
Comment on this
Until such time as it is substantiated, I will ask the Deputy to withdraw the statement.
Comment on this
I will withdraw solely on this ground—in deference to the Chair—but the fact is beyond all doubt.
Comment on this
A withdrawal cannot be taken like that. Deputy McGilligan is withdrawing the statement and at the same time making a further charge by saying the statement he is withdrawing is true.
Comment on this
If Deputy Davin is going to talk about courage we will get into another dispute immediately.
Comment on this
When a withdrawal is made I do not think it is fair for another Deputy to comment on it.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin knows too much about it to have any sincerity in any comment he makes on it. Here is what Deputies are faced with:—The badge has not gone out of the Bill. If there was any sincerity in the Minister's statement that the badge was not to be used for the purpose of doing down trades unionists, the word "badge" could be lifted out of the Bill altogether. Why has not that been done, and why does the Minister say it is necessary to have this power in regard to trades unions?
Comment on this
Did not the Minister say it was necessary to have this power in regard to trades unions? What power does the Minister want against trades unions? Why does he want against trade unions all the powers that at the moment he wants against the Blue Shirts? Is Deputy Norton willing to give him this power against trades unions? The Minister for Industry and Commerce claims that a subterfuge may be adopted and that the Blue Shirts may adopt a trades union, even though the amendment is limited to a trades union which was in existence on a certain date. Every power the Minister has against the Blue Shirts he might want against the trade unions.
Comment on this
Automatics is an ugly word to use in that connection. Automatics go off. They will go off against the trade unions one of these days, but there is a sure shield in the amendment.
Comment on this
I am glad to be able to join in that compliment to the workers, but not in the compliment to some of their representatives. It is worth while considering why the Deputy put down the amendment about badges. He said that it was to prevent the wearing of such badges relating to trade unions being made an offence. He thinks he has got his point. That is either due to a lack of intelligence or else he has realised for some reason that the words were not sufficient. He wants by the amendment to get an association of persons defined in such a way that these associations could not include trade unions which were in existence on 23rd February, 1934. The Deputy withdrew that amendment. Why? Does he still see no danger in the operation of Section 5, no danger in the operation of Section 4, no apprehension, with regard to Section 9, and has he no possible apprehension under Section 11, which allows any member of the Gárda to seize a trades union badge worn in contravention of the Act. That is what Deputy Norton presents to the trades union associations.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan has made a lot of play about Section 5. In that connection he has referred particularly to the risk of search, but he has not disclosed to the House that there is nothing in the section about searching or anything about raiding for these badges. There is something about wearing them but, for the rest of Deputy McGilligan's speech, there was no foundation whatever in Section 5. It was merely dragged in in order to conceal the anxiety——
Comment on this
——of the gentlemen on the benches opposite—to use trade unions as a last hope, as camouflage. In the course of the debate on the last amendment, Deputy MacDermot said that they wore blue shirts because they thought they would be an adventitious aid in making their peculiar virtues attractive. In that connection, if they want adventitious aid why not use rouge or lipstick or patchouli?
Comment on this
Is it that they may create around their dying movement the glamour of trade unionism that they are now anxious that the words in the amendment should appear? It is quite true, of course, that they could quite easily convert themselves. Fine Gael, having undergone so many transformations, might easily reappear in public life as a trades union, say either as the Land and Labour League of Deputy Belton, the Farmers' and Ratepayers' League of the Centre Party, Cumann na nGaedheal, or the United Ireland Party. Why not form themselves into a trade union of discredited politicians? They could do so quite easily. I can see them remaining a political organisation if the words in the amendment were inserted, but remaining outside the scope of the Bill. They would then have around them the glamour not only of the Blue Shirt but also the glamour of a trades union.
Comment on this
Glamour is a word that has been used frequently in this debate. I think it used to be associated with the poets of the Celtic twilight. Now, we are having associated with politicians of the Cumann na nGaedheal eclipse, the glamour of trades unionism. Do these people think that a blue shirt, or any sort of shirt, will make the dead walk, or imagine they are going to get away in the guise of trades unions? Is that the reason Deputy Dillon, Deputy MacDermot or Deputy McGilligan and the rest were so concerned about the amendment—because they saw in it a way of escape? They have proved themselves quick-change artists. They are adepts in changing names. They can have as many aliases as they like. They have no difficulty there, as the name or the object does not matter to them. They are going to appeal to the most virtuous purposes, as Deputy MacDermot indicated, and to try to lend to it a little adventitious aid like a blue shirt or a set of trade union rules. Under it all, we know the real motive. The Labour Party knows that no organisation that the gentleman who made the speech in Kildare is associated with is going to be friendly to the cause of the workers in Ireland. I think they are well advised not to allow this amendment, which was put down when the word "badge" was in Section 2, and before amendment No. 18 was accepted by the Minister for Justice, to be misused.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 13 was moved by Deputy Norton, but he asked permission to withdraw it. I opposed the withdrawal but, in view of the persistent attitude of the members of the Labour Party and the Government, I do not want to persist in my attitude.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:—
In sub-section (1), line 26, and in sub-section (2), line 29, to delete in each line the words "or badge."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:—
In sub-section (1), line 27, after the word "Party" to insert the words "which aims at overthrowing or changing the Constitution of Saorstát Eireann by force of arms."
When this measure was first spoken of a certain amount of comment was made on the amount of arms that were in the country uncontrolled, and further comment was made upon the necessity of getting all the arms together. Even the pious hope was held in this House that eventually the people might gather together all these arms and erect them into a magnificent cross, something like what was done elsewhere. I hope if that day comes to be asked to write one or two epitaphs. I can suggest things about "wading through blood,""hands being clean," and things like that. I would like to get these arms collected. In an assembly that is facing me with so many warriors I hope to say something about it. I am against any political Party which feels unfit to convert any opposition in the country by argument, or by reason, but which has to have resort, failing reason, to arms. There is no use in the country for the man who feels that the only way he can get an argument into another man's head is by bludgeoning him or beating him into unconsciousness.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is going to broadcast any further, he should get a better spot and get an expurgator.
Comment on this
I want to ban the wearing of uniforms or badges to indicate membership of, affiliation to or support of a political Party which aims at overthrowing or changing the Constitution of Saorstát Eireann by force of arms. I think that we should all set out to prohibit the use of arms. We should all set out to establish that the only parties that will be given any countenance in this State are those who are going to operate by ordinary, democratic methods— deliberation, argument, persuasion, even, if necessary, by the rather heroic method of trial by error, which we are going through at the moment. If we are to reach sanity and sense in the end, one thing we should stop at and one thing that should be prohibited is the use of arms by anybody for the purpose of changing the Constitution of the country or trying to convert people's minds by terror. One of the Fianna Fáil posters which were scattered amongst us before the last election, asked "What is the alternative to Fianna Fáil?""The only alternative to Fianna Fáil," we were told in that poster is "Government by coerction." It was an alternative then; it was not identical. The poster went on to state as the alternative to Fianna Fáil Government,—"the renewal of the régime of the military courts, special prisons, widespread raids, the revival of the civil war atmosphere, which is so deadly to all progress.""Fianna Fáil," we were told, "gave you peace. Cumann na nGaedheal only gave you coercion." Now Fianna Fáil gives us the Blue Shirt Bill. That in one hand and this poster in the other.
All I seek is that if there is going to be coercion the coercion should be properly applied. I have in my hands a pamphlet which contains the governmental policy and constitution of Oglaigh na hEireann, as adopted at the general army convention held in March, 1933, and issued with a foreword dated January, 1934. This is, I suppose, the most up-to-date of these documents. I hope it is not an official secret. It is sold for a penny, not like the other "official-secret" document, for which twopence had to be paid. This document states that the army is to be known by a certain title, that membership is to be open to all Irishmen of particular ways of thought and so on. The objects include the establishment and upholding of the lawful Government in sole and absolute control, and the means by which Oglaigh na hEireann shall endeavour to achieve its objects include (1) by force of arms. Is that organisation with its open profession regarding the use of arms for a particular purpose going to be tolerated and this Bill left in a state in which trade union badges can be coercively abolished? Do Deputies want to have this Bill limited to useful purposes? Is there anybody who would not in his sane senses agree that the crying need of this country is to get rid of those people who are endeavouring by force of arms to do what they cannot do by persuasion?
Comment on this
Will there not be general agreement that, in this particular year of enlightenment, we should look to argument, to persuasion, to the effect of the clash of mind on mind, to speeches, to democracy and appeals to their reason and intelligence? That is the proper way to convert people to a change of the Constitution, if it has got to be changed, but one thing that everybody who believes in man as a reasoning creature and believes in appeal to the highest part of man should be against is the use of guns and this business of people professing to attain their objects by force of arms. Why not make a start with them? There is an organisation which flaunts itself before you. It is going to bring about certain changes by force of arms. It is not content with your puny methods of democracy—talking to people, arguing with them, trying to get a man to see your point of view, trying to get a man to believe that your course is the better one and is going to lead to a better situation for the country. They despise that. That is not their method. Their method of attaining their object is what they have stated in the forefront—force of arms. Why shirk the issue with them? Does the Government believe that it is a democratically elected Government? Does it believe that it holds power because the majority of the people, freely and of their own accord, have chosen it to be the Government? Do the members of the Government believe that in a new election their appeal to the people to reinstate them to power should be based on reason, telling them what good they did for the country, telling them what progress they had made, telling them what difficulties they encountered and how they got over them. Or do they think that appeal should be made to the people merely on grounds of terror—"if you do not do something, we will see that you, or the people belonging to you, will suffer; we will see that certain people will be shot; we are going to have guns produced from dumps and produced for use." Is that a position that anybody wants to have in the country? Is not that the biggest evil we could have and one which should be put down? Why has there not been a bigger approach made towards dealing with that evil than there has been? The Minister for Justice knows that there are guns in the country. The Attorney-General knows that there are guns in the country. Both of them had experience of a recent case in which guns were used to fire volleys over a grave. Those guns did not come from lawful custody and were not sent back to lawful custody? Were the men interrogated as to where the guns came from? Were the men interrogated as to where they had gone to?
Comment on this
The Nyham case. There might have been other cases and somebody might consult them. The Minister for Justice is looking embarrassed. He might know of other cases. At any rate he knows of that case. Can anybody object to my amendment? Is it not a good and proper thing, in this democratically constituted House, to say that people ought not to be allowed to coerce other people in the country by force of arms? Or are other people so slow to admit their own deeds, or to face the things that might be said about them if they suddenly turned round and took that line? Are they not going even now to attempt a decent statement that they themselves should welcome the disappearance of armed forces other than the forces of the State? Will they go further and say, not merely that they would welcome such a statement but that they will take active steps to see that such forces shall disappear? Will they say that? Will they, even at this late moment, assert the power and majesty of the law so that the only armed organisation in the country shall be that which is under lawful control? or will they go on with the pretence of being a democratically elected assembly in this country.
We were told, in February, 1932, by the President of the Executive Council:
"During the ten years since the Treaty ... there had been put on the Statute Book of the Free State no less than six Public Safety Acts, three Firearms Acts, three Infringement of the Law Acts, four Jury Acts, one Treasonable Offences Act, one Protection of Community Act and the Perpetual Coercion Act recently passed, entitled The Constitution (Amendment) (No. 17) Act."
How many of these Acts have been withdrawn since the present Government came into office? How many of them have been actively withdrawn by any action on their part? Does that mean that the present Government find that they have to keep this list of Coercion Acts on the Statute Book and to add this proposed new Act to them so as not to limit themselves? I want this Act limited to the suppression of those who aim at the overthrow of the Constitution in this country by the force of arms. We used to hear about "Bloody Balfour" and about "Buckshot Forster." Are the Government bloodier than Balfour?
Comment on this
Are the present Government to have one more weapon in their hands? Are they fuller of buckshot than "Buckshot Forster?" The President also said:
"They did not believe that in this country they were so vicious minded that there was a large section of the people that had to be governed by Coercion Acts. That was the British attitude to the country. Was it to be their fate in this country that they were always to have Irish Governments like that?"
I re-echo these words. It was the British attitude to have coercion always here. What they wanted was plenty of Coercion Acts and any amount of enforcement of them in the country. The present Government are to-day presenting that point of view to the people. If their point was to oppose people who want to overthrow constitutional Government by force of arms, and if they want help against such people they will get it, but they have not shown themselves inclined to proceed against such people. Instead of that they are going out to suppress a political association because its members are wearing uniforms or badges. Is there any harm in the wearing of badges or is there any harm in the wearing of uniforms indicating membership of a political party if the aims of that party are proper? Is there nothing good in having aims like these? Are objects only to be achieved and are aims only to be achieved by force of arms? Would it not be a proper thing to attack the big danger first? When this Bill was introduced there were comments about foreign States and about what Belgium did, and what Sweden did, and what other countries had to do. In the end the Minister for Justice was forced to fall back upon what Britain had to do and Ministers followed up the discussion in regard to what are called private armies when this matter was discussed in the House of Lords. There you got a unanimity which you might expect in any democratic assembly. There should be, and was in fact, a junction of opinion by all parties upon this: that it was a good thing to have political parties in the open, indicating their points of views even by emblems and objects and devices of that kind; and that the only thing that was to be feared was that any section of the people, either small or large, should decide to found its policy, not upon argument and reason, but upon coercion by arms and by force.
If the President is looking for a precedent that private armies are disliked he has that example to follow. Let him follow the words that were used there which, as the discussion shows, were words that were meant. The only point that was queried about the particular organisation on the other side was whether or not it had armoured cars, as alleged against it. And even those who said that they themselves would not appear in a political uniform or wear a badge, indicating a political association, also said that they could see no harm or danger except in the case of a political organisation which became confounded with one that relied upon arms, or force of arms. They all agreed that once force was shown as the background of any association it ought to be put down by the forces under the control of the State. I want associations like that to be declared in this House to be unlawful associations. I want Ministers to forget their past and to say that this armed association shall have no place in Ireland at this moment. And I want them not merely to say that but to include that association if they can be brought to do so in this measure. No matter what they are going to do against an association of a harmless type, with badges and devices indicating the bearing of that political association, let them show that they are certainly going to use the full force of any power the law, the police or the military affords them against those who set out to overthrow the Constitution of the country by force of arms.
I move to report progress.