We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote 41—Local Government and Public Health.

Contributions 1–183 of 328. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Seán T. O'Kelly Minister for Local Government and Public Health (Mr. O Ceallaigh) Fianna Fáil

I beg to move:—

Go ndeontar suim ná raghaidh thar £566,380 chun slánuithe na suime is gá chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1935, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Oifig an Aire Rialtais Aitiúla agus Sláinte Puiblí, maraon le Deontaisí agus Costaisí eile a bhaineann le Tógáil Tithe, Deontaisí d'Udaráis Aitiúla, Ildeontaisí Ilghnéitheacha agus Ildeontaisí-i-gCabhair, agus costaisí áirithe bhaineann le hOspidéil.

That a sum not exceeding £566,380 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1935, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Office of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, including Grants and other Expenses in connection with Housing, Grants to Local Authorities, Sundry Miscellaneous Grants and Grants-in-Aid, and certain charges connected with Hospitals.

Of the total amount required for the present year a sum of £401,578, or approximately one-half of the whole Estimate, is for housing. The rate of progress may be considered satisfactory. Every local authority is participating and, if local authorities act energetically during the next few years, we should be well ahead of our scheduled programme for the clearance of slum dwellings.

Comment on this

On a point of correction, is the figure not £4,000,000 odd instead of the figure the Minister is indicating?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is on the Order Paper a motion in the name of Deputy O Braonáin to refer back this Estimate for reconsideration. As the Deputy is not in the House, arrangements should be made to move that motion, if it is desired to move it, as soon as the Minister has concluded his opening statement.

Comment on this

It will be moved when the Minister has concluded his statement.

Comment on this

I would like to draw the Minister's attention to his figure of £400,000 odd. Is not the figure £4,000,000 for housing?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will look up the book of Estimates he will see the total in the Estimate for the Department of Local Government. At the end of last month the number of houses completed by local authorities was 4,989, and the number in course of construction 6,115. The number of houses for which tenders have been accepted or invited amounts to 7,311, and the number of houses for which land has been acquired and plans approved amounts to 6,499. Up to the present, 4,989 houses have, therefore, been actually completed, while 19,925 houses are either in course of construction or about to be commenced. In addition, there are 5,843 houses in schemes that are being prepared by local authorities.

Most of the houses that are being built by local authorities are for the re-housing of persons living in insanitary houses. The necessity for demolishing the houses unfit for habitation as soon as alternative accommodation is available is being impressed on local authorities, and it is being made clear that the higher subsidy provided for in the 1932 Act will be paid only where such houses are actually demolished. Every effort is made to ensure the use of Saorstát materials, and a list of manufacturers of Saorstát materials and appliances has been prepared and issued to local authorities. A great improvement has taken place in the supply of these materials, especially in roofing materials.

Of the houses actually completed, 4,146 are in urban areas and 843 in rural districts. I may say 11,305 of the houses in course of erection or about to be commenced will be situated in urban areas and 8,620 in rural districts. The number of houses erected by private persons and public utility societies up to the 31st March, was 3,904 of which 2,010 are in urban areas and 1,894 in rural districts. The number in course of erection at the same date was 4,807 of which 1,857 are in urban areas and 2,950 in rural districts.

Of the new houses built and in progress in rural areas, 726 are for agricultural labourers, 2,246 for farmers with valuations not exceeding £15, and 373 for farmers with valuations between £15 and £25. As regards reconstructed houses, 343 had been completed at the 31st March and 3,581 were in progress, making a total of 3,924. Of this number 362 are for agricultural labourers, and 3,562 for farmers with a valuation not exceeding £25.

Progress in carrying out sewerage and water supply schemes is well maintained. Grants amounting to £120,000 were allocated to schemes of this nature during the past financial year and many important works were undertaken. Loans advanced for the purpose amounted to about £190,000. From a public health point of view the record of the year 1933, which was remarkable for its favourable climatic conditions throughout the year, was distinctly satisfactory. The incidence of mortality from all causes shows a definite reduction as compared with the preceding year. The number of deaths registered in 1933 was 40,650 as against 42,984 in the previous year and represented a death rate of 13.6 per 1,000 of the population as compared with 14.45 for 1932. The improvement was shared in by both urban and rural districts, but was greater in proportion in the latter areas.

There was a welcome decrease in infant mortality. The number of deaths was 65 per 1,000 births registered as compared with 72 for the preceding year and an average of 70 for the ten years from 1923 to 1932. The improvement in this respect extended both to urban and rural districts in somewhat similar degrees.

I am also glad to say that typhus fever which has so long been endemic in the poorer districts on the Western seaboard was responsible during 1933 for only two deaths, the smallest number ever recorded in respect of that disease for any year. The total number of cases of typhus notified during the year was 12, compared with 30 for the preceding year. The active measures that have been organised to combat this disease should soon be successful in entirely eradicating it from the country. The number of deaths from enteric fever in 1933 was 69, being a reduction of 13 as compared with 1932. The number of deaths is smaller than in any previous year except 1931 when the number was one less. Notifications of cases of the disease were also fewer in 1933, being 408 as against 440 in the preceding year. The improvement was mainly noticeable in the urban districts.

The prevalence of diphtheria showed a serious upward tendency. The number of deaths was 414 as compared with 383 in 1932. Outbreaks in epidemic form in Dublin and Limerick cities were mainly responsible for this setback. Measures for the immunisation of children against the disease are being more widely adopted. To combat a recurrence of the disease in the Dundalk district an immunisation scheme was organised in 1932, and resulted in 500 children being inoculated. It is a striking fact, indicating the success of the immunisation measures previously carried out, that of 380 cases of diphtheria that occurred in Louth County since the scheme was started in 1928, only one out of 2,000 children completely immunised was again attacked with the disease. In Cork County Borough, where an extensive campaign against the disease was also carried out during the latter half of the year 1929, the results obtained were likewise favourable. From a high record of 626 cases in 1930 there was a continuous decline to 282 cases in 1931 and to 90 cases in 1932. Of the 17 deaths registered as due to the disease in 1932, ten were of children whose parents refused to have them immunised. Of the 6,878 children immunised not a single death was recorded. The position in Limerick and Dublin is receiving close attention. The Corporation of Limerick have initiated a campaign for the immunisation of children against the disease, and the municipal authority in Dublin has been urged to adopt an effective system of immunisation and to take all preventive measures to combat the disease.

The organisation of public health services, especially in the counties in which county medical officers of health have been appointed, is proceeding satisfactorily. Child welfare schemes are being well maintained, while schemes for school medical inspection are now practically complete in the four county boroughs and in 18 counties in which county medical officers of health are in charge. In some districts delay has taken place in the provision of staffs and of the corrective treatment necessary to remedy the defective conditions that were ascertained upon medical inspection of children. These delays are being gradually overcome, and during the coming year the schemes generally will have reached a full stage in their development. It is estimated that the number of children who came within the ambit of the schemes in force during 1933 represents about 80 per cent. of the elementary school population in the country. The number of children inspected by the school medical officers in 1932 was 112,776. The figures for 1933 are not yet available. Of the numbers examined in 1932, 37 per cent. were found to suffer from dental defects, 22 per cent. from tonsils and adenoids, 11.9 from defective vision, 3.9 from other eye defects, and 6.2 from malnutrition. The percentage of defective children in 1932 showed a decline as compared with that for 1931, except in the case of children suffering from dental defects. Great interest continues to be shown in this service by school managers, teachers and parents of the children. The individual and social value of the service is widely recognised, and its successful working is now well assured. Very many of the school medical officers comment on the relation between the diet of the children and their health. In practically every case the advice of the county medical officers of health in regard to proper dieting has borne good results, and the number of children suffering from malnutrition is on the decline. The provision of free milk, for which a sum of £100,000 is included in this Estimate, has helped largely in this respect.

Arrangements for school meals in urban areas are in force in four county boroughs, 36 urban districts and two towns under town commissioners. The average number of children provided daily with meals during 1933 was 21,117 as compared with 19,225 for 1932. The total number of meals supplied in Dublin City during 1933 was 1,690,144 as compared with 1,580,869 in 1932. Meals are also being supplied in most of the eligible schools in the portion of the Gaeltacht to which the Acts of 1930 and 1933 apply. There has been close co-operation between the Department and the local authorities and the county surveyors in regard to the maintenance and improvement of roads. The gross estimates of the county councils for the present financial year in respect of the maintenance, as distinct from the improvement, of main and county roads, amount to £1,442,949, being a reduction of about £50,000 on the gross amount provided for the maintenance of roads last year. When the grant for maintenance as taken into account the net decrease in the amount provided will be about £37,000. The decrease will mainly affect the upkeep of the main roads. It was necessary to take up with the county councils of Carlow and Wexford the question of the provision made for the upkeep of roads in the current year, and it was pointed out to these councils that unless adequate provision was made no grant could be made for the upkeep of main roads. A satisfactory agreement was ultimately arrived at between the councils and the Department. The provision made for surface dressing is approximately the same as that made for the previous year. Wicklow County Council is the only body that has made no provision for work of this kind on main roads, although the county surveyor is of opinion that there are 50 miles of such roads where it is absolutely necessary that surface dressing be carried out. Surface dressing is essential to the preservation of steam-rolled roads, and it is of primary importance from a public health point of view.

The compulsory insurance provisions of the Road Traffic Act of 1933 were brought into operation on the 1st February last. The bringing into operation of this portion of the Act involved a considerable amount of work to everybody concerned. A booklet was prepared by the Department setting out the compulsory provisions of the Act. Sixty-thousand copies of the booklet were printed and sent, on the 7th December, 1933, to local authorities for distribution to all motor owners on their current registers. In addition, a paper on that part of the Act was broadcast through the Athlone, Dublin and Cork stations on the 16th January. Every step which the Department could take to bring to the notice of motor owners their responsibilities in the matter was taken. The local authorities were supplied with full lists of the insurance companies entitled to do motor vehicle business. The Department is at present engaged in the completion of regulations in respect of the use and construction of motor vehicles, driving licences, the construction and equipment of public service vehicles and the regulations with respect to lighting. In the making of regulations, the Department consults, so far as possible, all interests affected. This naturally takes time and considerable labour, but it is considered to be in the long run the fairest and most satisfactory way of dealing with the matter. It has this disadvantage, however, of involving delay in bringing the Act fully into operation. Arrangements are at present being made to bring in, within the next two months, Parts II, III, IV, VI and X. It is scarcely possible that Parts VII and VIII (public services vehicles) can be brought in much before the autumn.

As regards local government, generally, the collection of rates by county councils for the past year has been unsatisfactory. The deficit in the revenue will largely be offset by a special payment in respect of grants absorbed in the Guarantee Fund on account of arrears of annuities that are being funded under the Land Act, 1933. I understand that in several areas a good recovery has been made since the close of the financial year. I trust that the improvement will be maintained as, otherwise, the failure to collect revenue will inevitably react on the obtaining by these councils and subsidiary bodies of further loans for capital works.

Comment on this

I move the amendment standing in the name of Deputy Brennan:—

That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration.

We have listened to an interesting statement by the Minister, but it is easy to deliver an interesting statement in respect of a Department that is essentially a spending Department. There are many reasons why this Estimate should be reconsidered, the main reason being the signals which the Minister for Local Government must have seen in his path last year. At the end of his statement, he mentioned one of them. He is not satisfied with the rate collection. I am sure that he and the Government were not satisfied with the result of the National Loan that was floated recently. It is regrettable. I believe the Minister for Finance in his Budget statement featured this sum of £4,000,000 odd which the Minister for Local Government proposes to lend for housing. That amount is to be borrowed. I do not know if the Minister is going to give anything to widowers, but widows are to get pensions. Widowers, perhaps, may get pensions or they will be next for consideration, if there are any males left who have not got pensions by the time the promises in the Budget statement are carried out. I suppose that is why it was not necessary to mention widowers—that all the males would have pensions. That is all splendid.

The Minister, by the way, did not say for what period the houses which he mentioned had been built. He said that on a certain date, so many houses were completed, so many more were under construction, so many more were being thought of, and so many more were probably being thought of. He gave us a large number of houses running into 20,000 or 30,000 altogether. To build those houses you want money. Ministers are fond of quoting financial journals. I remember listening to a speech by a Minister last week, and last night I read an article in a financial journal, which is about a month old, in which I could see the Minister's speech.

Comment on this

Was that in the United Ireland?

Comment on this

No, nor the Voice of Labour.

Comment on this

They did not agree with what it said.

Comment on this

I noticed that in that speech of that particular Minister there was one paragraph omitted. That paragraph dealt with a statement by the Chairman of an Irish bank at the annual meeting of the bank, in which he warned the Government of the dangers ahead in coming back to the money market soon. He pointed out that of two public loans—one by the Dublin Corporation and the other by the Government—the Dublin Corporation loan while it could hardly be called a failure, was not up to expectations— I suppose it was due to the confidence the public had in a majority in the Dublin Corporation—and the Government loan was a failure. I do not think that one-third of it was subscribed in the open market. When it is so hard to get money in the open market, notwithstanding the fact that 1½ per cent. more is being offered for money than the current bank rate of interest, and when we consider, side by side with that, the fact that previous loans by this State were subscribed by the public when offered a rate of interest that was then substantially the current bank rate of interest, there is something wrong somewhere.

The Minister, of course, did not deal in his opening statement with the difficulties in the way. The only difficulty was that that rascal the farmer will not pay his rates. That was the only difficulty the Minister saw, but the Minister knows quite well that in respect of the big schemes he has in front of him and in respect of the big housing scheme he elaborated here, he has met with more difficulties and there are more difficulties still ahead of him in providing finances for those schemes than any difficulties that have been provided by the farmers' obstruction. He did not mention that. The Minister elaborated the number of houses that are being built by local authorities, boards of health, in other words, for agricultural labourers. The Minister and every Minister ought to take cognisance of what has happened round about us in recent years. Anybody in the responsible position of the Minister should have made himself wise as to the conditions that existed prior to the great American financial slump. Never had housing boomed so much in the United States; never was the building trade so prosperous in the United States or in any country in the world as just on the eve of the collapse. The great trouble that both mechanics and labourers had was to find room around the building sites to park the cars in which they travelled to work. The slump came in America. The Minister should consider the signs that are staring him in the face, and take care that he is not going to run local government on the rocks in this country.

The money used for housing by the Dublin Corporation and the Cork Corporation is borrowed directly, but the money used by local authorities to build houses or renovate them is loaned by the Minister's Department at 5½ per cent. I wonder does the Minister think that that is an economic proposition. I wonder do his allies here on the Labour Front Bench think that that is an economic proposition. The Minister knows that there is a limit to the powers of boards of health, and to the number of houses they can build. That is limited by the relief for the repayment of a loan for the tenants which has to be borne by the local rates up to a maximum of 2/6 in the £. In some parts of the country that limit has been reached, and the local authority cannot go any further. The facilities offered them by the Minister are that the Local Government Department—or I think it is the Board of Works—will lend at 5½ per cent. money to build cottages. If all the services, engineering, architecture, survey, etc., were charged to those cottages, even with the 60 per cent. relief given by the Government, at the present cost of materials and the present cost of construction, those cottages would be far too dear for the agricultural labourer. The agricultural labourer, like the farmer, thanks to the Government and to the representatives of Labour here——

Comment on this

And the Blue Shirts.

Comment on this

——thanks to the Government and to the representatives of Labour is now enjoying the lowest standard of wage that he has had for about 20 years.

Comment on this

Does that apply to the farmer who was prosecuted in Naas recently?

Comment on this

That applies to agriculture, which is a subject that I am afraid the Leader of the Labour Party is not very conversant with.

Comment on this

No agricultural constituency will have the Deputy.

Comment on this

Although the Deputy has the capacity "to put the works on the agricultural labourer"—to quote a Deputy opposite—and get him to vote for him, like the proverbial pitcher I am afraid he will go to the well once too often.

Comment on this

The Deputy's pitcher has been broken pretty often at political wells.

Comment on this

The Deputy enjoyed the pleasure of a seat, and on the first opportunity his constituents got they sent him away. He left his money behind him.

Comment on this

What about County Dublin?

Comment on this

County Dublin I am speaking of. They got one does of Deputy Norton, and in a year after, when they got the chance, they sent him back, and he left his £100 behind him.

Comment on this

I got more votes than the Deputy.

Comment on this

I had the pleasure of being elected on the first count, and the Deputy did not get his money back. I am speaking of the agricultural vote, which the Labour Deputies, together with the one Fianna Fáil Minister opposite, misrepresents. In most cases in the country, and I find it particularly in County Dublin, we build houses and let them at a loss, notwithstanding the subsidies from local government. In present conditions we cannot give houses to the people who are most in need of them, because if we did, we would have to give them the rent to pay it back to us, owing to the economic conditions produced by the Government's policy. The housing by the local authorities in rural districts, stripped of all its trimmings, means the housing of the agricultural labourer. The agricultural labourer is to a large extent out of work, and those who are working are doing so for a wage on which, considering everything, they cannot afford to pay any rent at all, because agricultural prices have been brought to that level by the policy of the Government, aided by the Labour Party.

Comment on this

You will not get that portfolio if you go on like this.

Comment on this

I will have a portfolio before the Deputy has it. When he did not get it with his last allies it is gone, because both combined will not offer a decent opposition on the next occasion. Evidently these cold facts——

Comment on this
A Deputy

And portfolios.

Comment on this

I will not be looking for a job whether I get a portfolio or a seat.

Comment on this

You know where to jump from where you are.

Comment on this

Those interruptions are interesting, because they show the delicacy of the position in which Deputies find themselves. The Minister, with a flourish, told us of all the money he was going to spend on rural housing. What hope has he of getting that paid back, and why does he not consider the necessity of cheap money for rural housing and all kinds of housing? He told us that Irish building materials are used to a greater extent than ever before. We all welcome that, but what is the Minister doing to ensure that those building materials are provided at reasonable prices? Has the cost of those materials not gone up? Have we not sufficient slates in this country, if they were quarried out, to roof in the whole country, and we cannot get them? I see here that the Chairman of the National Housing Board has £1,000 a year. What is he doing? Of course, it will not be questioned by the Government Party. It is certain not to be questioned by the Labour Party, because I see that one of the wounded soldiers of the Labour war has got a job on this Board—the Leader. When Kildare goes wrong there may be another applicant for a job on this

Board. I give him this credit—that he will know as much about building and no more than the present members of this Board. If the Minister wants advice from a Housing Board, why are not men put on it who know something about building?

Comment on this

Builders, you mean.

Comment on this

If you like, yes. If the Deputy wants a suit of clothes he will not go to a blacksmith; he will go to a tailor. Considering the good cut of his clothes, he evidently goes to a good tailor, whether Jew or Gentile. Certainly, a builder or a builder's provider like my colleague, Deputy Dockrell here. Of course, he must not be put on it. Some popular demagogue who shouts for Labour, but never does any labour—give him the job; he represents democracy under this dictatorship. He need not be a builder or a builder's provider, but a man efficient for his job. Results are the test of efficiency. Have we got them? What about the slates down in the tail-end of the Deputy's constituency? They are lying dormant.

Comment on this

Where is that?

Comment on this

If the Deputy has not done any prospecting in his constituency after ten or 12 years, I should not like to draw his constituents' attention to it.

Comment on this

How many votes did you get in that part of the constituency?

Comment on this

I was down there on Sunday.

Comment on this

I am sure you will be there again.

Comment on this

I will not be put out of it either, notwithstanding the threats used. Can the Minister not come down to business in this matter? He is going to lend money to build houses for people who, I agree, want them, and wanted them ten or 20 years ago. But he is going to lend out money at an exorbitant rate of interest that cannot be paid back under existing conditions. The Minister should put two and two together and see the balance sheet of each county. He complained that the rates are not paid. Why? Because of the charges imposed on agriculture by the present Administration.

Comment on this

What happened in Mayo?

Comment on this

I am making a statement—because of the charges imposed on agriculture by the present Administration. Agricultural prices were never so low. Consequently, everybody engaged in that industry must take less. The agricultural wage-earner finds himself at the bottom. We are asked here to approve of schemes and the spending of money for the building of houses under those conditions. That is not the point to which I take objection. That money has to be borrowed. We know that when the Government went to borrow money the last time they did not get it. Why? Because the security offered was not good. The security is the economic strength of the country. Everybody with money knows that the economic strength of the country has weakened. If you want a proof of that you can see that money is going out of this country because it cannot find profitable investment here.

Comment on this

That started before the economic war.

Comment on this

No. It did not start until about a year ago. The balance turned the wrong way for us. More money was leaving the country than was coming in, and that is the position up to the present moment. The Minister also told us in his statement about a special grant of £300,000 that is being given to meet, I think he put it, the deficiencies of the rate collection. Previously it was described as being given to reduce overdrafts. The Minister tried to be smart. He withheld that £300,000, or the promise of it, until the county council estimates had reached a stage when there was no going back. Then he told us that this was to be given. In fact, I think the first we heard of it was from the President at a meeting in Clonmel. Before anybody else knew anything about it, it was handed out to the country as a piece of political propaganda that £300,000 was to be given by the Local Government Department for the relief of rates on agricultural land. Then we were told that it was not to relieve rates, but to reduce overdrafts. That is a distinction that I do not very well see, because we have only one account in the local bodies. If it reduces the overdrafts, then, if we get all the rates which are outstanding, we shall have a surplus and the rates must go down. But, in this year of keen depression, the Minister did not disclose that at a time when we could consider it and make allowance for it in our Estimates.

Why does not the Minister call things by their proper names? This £300,000 is being paid out of the funded arrears of annuities. We were given a promise a year ago, or less than a year ago, when the 1933 Land Bill was going through that that Bill, when it became an Act, would not alter the position of the arrears; in other words, that those arrears when paid to the Government would automatically go back to the local authorities to whom they belonged. So that giving £300,000, which has been boosted so much, is only handing back to the local authorities their own money.

A sum of £200,000 was also promised for the relief of rates. That is being given effect to in a very peculiar way. Relief is to be given to farmers of £20 valuation and under. I think it is that £12 10s. of poor law valuation is relieved for each person over 17 years of age employed; and that includes members of his family and I think only male members of his family. Take the case of a man of £32 10s. valuation, with a son 18 years of age working. He gets relief to the extent of £12 10s. But a man with a small family, of young children below 17 years of age, gets no relief. Who wants it the more? One man has an assistant in his family in a young fellow of 18 years of age, who can do most kinds of work on agricultural land; and that man gets relief, but the man with youngsters going to school and no assistance from his family gets no relief. The inequity of this is quite obvious. But the most important of all is the lavish expenditure contemplated by the Minister— very advisable and useful expenditure if we could afford it. Nothing would delight me more than travelling through Europe and America in a Rolls Royce, if I could afford it, but I cannot, and never will. There are a great lot of things that I would like if I could afford them. Speaking of one's own household we spend as we can afford it, and if we meet a bad time we do not spend. Now we have struck a bad time, in rural Ireland, and this is the time the Minister has chosen to go in for lavish expenditure with no hope under heaven of getting paid back. The signs of the times, which show that roughly 40 per cent. of the rate collection is in arrear, should make him think hard. That is the extraordinary position that we find ourselves in to-day. We are supposed to be waging an economic war.

When war of any kind is on it is usual, in protagonist countries, that they spend on essentials only. For example, during the Great War there was no house building in this country. I suppose the same applied to all the belligerents. Now, the Minister thinks that the economic war, which is more exhausting on this country than the Great War was, can be waged at the same time that he is spending lavishly. When he goes out to borrow he cannot get the money even when he offers a comparatively exorbitant price. He is lending the money at the price that, at the present time, no other industry could survive on. Local authorities will be found to borrow this money and use it for building these houses. But with the terrible conditions of unemployment in the country, particularly the rural parts of the country, I put it to the Minister, is he wise in spending all this money not yet in his hands, but which he has to borrow at a high rate of interest, in this unusual way, and when he is not quite sure whether he will get the money or not? If, for no other reason than to have a national stocktaking on the economic strength of rural Ireland to-day, while this economic war is being waged, I think the Ministry should move slowly in the direction of borrowing money now at a high rate of interest over a long term.

With regard to the supply of materials there are one or two words about those cottages which I wish to say. We have had, since the Local Government Act of 1898 came into operation, a British tyranny here which did not permit of democratic rule and control by the local bodies—at least, so we were told. But from my experience of the Local Government Act of 1898, and the district councils, up to their abolition, and then from their successors, the boards of health had full power when they had the cottages built, without any veto from any quarter, to select the tenants for these cottages. Even during the Cosgrave régime, which, according to the democratic thought of the day, was an imperialistic régime or an autocratic régime——

Comment on this

Did not the Deputy say it was?

Comment on this

I am quoting the Deputy opposite now, I am not being original.

Comment on this

Read your Naas speech?

Comment on this

I am quoting the Deputy. As to my Naas speech, I can stand over it.

Comment on this

Can I have the date of the quotation for my speech?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not an official document.

Comment on this

It is an invention.

Comment on this

Of whom? I made many speeches in Kildare, and have not made my last one there yet. I shall be glad to meet Deputy Norton, who misrepresents County Kildare, there on any date he specifies.

Comment on this

Will you get the square filled with the motor cars of the ruined farmers?

Comment on this

Any farmer is as much entitled to drive his motor car as Deputy Norton should be to drive his.

Comment on this

But they ought to pay their rates.

Comment on this

There was not one of the farmers present at meetings in Kildare who had not paid his rates and annuities.

Comment on this

What about O'Farrell?

Comment on this

He paid his rates, and if the Deputy wants the information I will give it to him.

Comment on this

Give us your Naas speech of a couple of years ago?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies ought not to interrupt, and Deputies of experience should not need to be reminded of that fact.

Comment on this

We have Deputies on his own side who are asleep.

Comment on this

Evidently my remarks are so soothing to some Deputies that they will slumber upon them, but there are other Deputies whom my remarks get on the raw, and who are not going to sleep upon them; and I shall continue for fear of their going to sleep. I have no intention of being diverted in my remarks by Deputy Davin or other Deputies.

I was a member of a board of health prior to the change of Government, and I remember the criticisms that were levelled against the autocrat of local government then—Deputy Mulcahy. To be frank, I often indulged in those criticisms myself, but it is extraordinary that Deputy Mulcahy when he was Minister, never interfered with us in the allocation of a single labourer's cottage. He was true to the tradition of democratic control of those cottages, a tradition carried on since the passing of the Local Government Act of 1898. We had to wait until the democrat, my friend the present Minister for Local Government, got into the saddle, and then what happened? Last year a ukase came out.

Comment on this

What is that? What did the Deputy say came out?

Comment on this

An order. Is the Minister not aware of it?

Comment on this

Ukase the Deputy said.

Comment on this

It is not identified by its Christian name.

Comment on this

An order came out from the Minister that even the secretary of a board of health could not give out the key of a labourer's cottage to a prospective tenant until the sanction of the Minister had been received. I hope the Minister will divest that innovation in policy of any political flavour or favour, but many of us will find it very hard to agree that there is not a political flavour about that new departure in policy. An extraordinary thing about it is this: that the members of the board of health on which I sit who were the most critical of the previous régime in local government, turned over when this new order was issued and said that the Minister was right, that he should have a veto over those boards. Their change over was so complete that one is led to think they were more acrobats than democrats. Thinking, apparently, that he had not legal power to do that, the Minister used the threat that the 60 per cent. annual relief, given towards the payment of rents, would be withdrawn in the case of any cottage of which the tenant had not been approved of by him. That is surely a new idea of democracy.

Comment on this

Was it not necessary? What about the members of those boards who had been in prison?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy would put all his interruptions together he might make a speech at a later stage.

Comment on this

It is news for me that a board of health can imprison anybody.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I said that members of boards of health were imprisoned.

Comment on this

So far as I know no member of a board of health was in prison or had been imprisoned. If Deputies want to back that policy the sooner they shed the veneer and the mask of democracy the better. Let them come out and proclaim themselves for what they really are. The less autocratic predecessors of the present Minister were called tyrants. Well, if they were, I do not think there is a word left capable of expressing what the present Minister is. There was another piece of autocracy that the previous Ministry was blamed for. It went away from the British tradition in the matter of appointments by local authorities. It took from them a power that they previously had and set up the Appointments Commissioners. Of course, I am now treading on thin ice. To be frank, I did not know until lately that you, A Chinn Comhairle, were nominally the head of the Appointments Commissioners.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not only nominally, sir, but actually.

Comment on this

Well that makes the ice thinner, so that I have to be super-careful now. We all know how that institution was criticised and condemned. I have listened to its condemnation time and again at meetings of the General Council of County Councils, and all the condemnation came from men who are now supporters of the Party opposite. When the present Minister came into office he did not abolish that system, but made arrangements that three names should be sent down to the local authorities to make a selection from, the Appointments Commissioners not to indicate any priority in the three names sent. It was left to the local authorities to put the three names in the order they thought proper, and then to send them back to the Appointments Commissioners. That system worked for a while, but it has been abolished since the 1st July last. The position, therefore, is that the system condemned by the Party opposite during the time that their predecessors were in office has now been re-adopted fully by the present Ministry. It is curious how we work round in a circle and come back to the point from which we started.

On the question of building materials, the Minister could give great help to industry and commerce in the country if he were to use his powers to hasten the production of materials. Seeing that he has control over the National Housing Board, he should endeavour to get the production of slates increased. I was speaking to an authority on slates, and he told me— he is an architect; to be exact, the architect for the Dublin Corporation— that in the area from Nenagh to Killaloe there are richer slate deposits than in North Wales, and that there are some veins of slate there that is better than the best British slate, which is known as Westmoreland Green. Slates cannot be obtained at the present time. No man building a house at the present time can take the risk of starting to put on slates, because he may be left high and dry before he is through with the work as he cannot get Irish slates. So far as tiles are concerned, I am not going to say anything against tiles as roofing material, but the public taste is for slates, and we have slates in the bowels of the earth here. We have men idle, and why are these slates not quarried out? That is a matter, perhaps, with which the Minister is not directly concerned, but I would respectfully suggest that it is a matter which, with profit, he could take up with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and a matter which he could get the Housing Board to investigate. I put on an odd roof. I know practically all the people in the building trade in Dublin and they have all a decided bias for slates if they can get them. Of course, in the last resort, the customer for any commodity is the person you want to satisfy and the customer in ninety-nine cases out of a hundred, who is going to put down his or her money, likes a slate roof. From what I know of the Minister I am sure that he will do what he can in that regard, that he will help the production of slates here, and that he will help the public who want houses to get the article they want.

I am afraid that after having said these few nice words to the Minister, I have to refer to the fact that he is going about making selections through the country—I could not very well call them natural selections—suppressing a council here and investigating the affairs of a council there. It is most peculiar that in those councils that are coming under the Minister's lash, the chairmen do not kick with the same political foot as the Minister. However, that might only be an accident and not a design. The local elections are in the offing, and, of course, it would be no harm to throw some obstacle in the way of holding the local elections in certain counties where it is certain the Minister's Party will be defeated. That, again, is probably only an accident.

I move this amendment in the name of Deputy Miceal O Braonáin: That the Estimate be referred back for consideration. I do so on many counts but, above everything else, in order that the whole economic position of the country be surveyed comprehensively, so that the present Government or any future Government will not be loaded with charges that will inevitably accumulate if economic conditions are going to remain as they are, and if the expenditure that the Minister contemplates is going to be made at the price that he proposes. Of course, Deputies on my right want me to drop some statement that can be used against me, such as that I am opposed to the housing of the working classes.

Comment on this

You said so.

Comment on this

That statement is not going to be dropped because if I said it, I would be untrue to myself. I want to remind Deputies opposite who tell the labourers in their constituencies that they want houses built for those labourers, and built at high rates for skilled tradesmen and labourers at those works, that the men who have to pay the high rents that high costs necessarily impose, are going to be refused any decent wage at all because the produce of the agricultural labourer has to be sold for scrap. There is no louder advocate of that in this country than Deputy Norton, Leader of the Labour Party. The only contribution that I saw him giving to the rural economic situation in this country was in the form of a question which he put a week or two ago, when he wanted to know when cheap meat would be available. Deputy Norton wants cheaper meat still. Deputy Norton seemed to overlook the fact that he was elected by labourers whose work it is to produce meat, and if that meat is to be sold at scrap prices, these labourers can have no wage except a scrap wage. Will Deputy Norton, or any of his colleagues, advocate scrap prices for clothes, scrap prices for boots, scrap prices for houses?

Comment on this

What about beet and wheat?

Comment on this

Scrap prices for beet and wheat?

Comment on this

The Deputy voted for 30/- a ton for beet, whereas in the Deputy's constituency during the beet strike three or four years ago, the price offered was 38/- a ton for beet with a sugar content of 15½ per cent. Organised gangs went around threatening farmers not to grow it at that price, and told them that they would not be able to grow it.

Comment on this

Who organised them?

Comment on this

All I can say is that all those in the gangs were supporters of Fianna Fáil, and are, to-day, in Leix-Offaly, Carlow and South Kildare.

Comment on this

What about your friend, Mr. Kennedy, in Abbeyleix?

Comment on this

I do not think it is fair for the Deputy to mention a name. I did not mention a name. I do not know whether the man referred to by the Deputy had anything to do with this, one way or another. He was not in my mind at all.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not hear about it?

Comment on this

I did not. I would not mention a man's name here.

Comment on this

It does not suit you.

Comment on this

The Deputy is rambling. The fact is there was a strike and the acreage of beet was greatly reduced.

Comment on this

The man whose name I mentioned is chairman of Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Minister responsible for all that happened about beet?

Comment on this

The only connection, apart from the interruption of the Deputy, is this: that I was indicating that Deputies opposite wanted to build dear houses. That is really what their policy amounts to, build dear houses for people who have scrap wages, and who have scrap wages because of the policy supported by the Labour Party, and carried through by the Fianna Fáil Party. Deputy Norton, as the Leader of the Labour Party, has waved aloft the banner of cheap meat, and I was showing that the agricultural labourers who elected him to this House make their living by producing meat. If that meat is to be sold at scrap prices, well then the labourers can only get scrap wages. How then can they be expected to pay inflated prices for houses, built by skilled mechanics, whose labour no member of the Labour Party will say should be sold at scrap prices? No member of the Labour Party will get up and say that a carpenter should get less than £4 a week. Members of the Labour Party, who are voted into this House by agricultural labourers, have nothing to say on behalf of these labourers when, for their work, they get from 15/- to £1 a week. I challenge any member of the Labour Party to show that the average wage in their respective constituencies of agricultural labourers reaches £1 weekly—even for cutting turf. That is a queer one. How can it be otherwise when the Leader of the Labour Party shouts for cheap meat? How could a tailor get a good price for clothes when Labour shouts for cheap clothes? How could a weaver get a good price for cloth when the Labour Party shouts for cheap cloth? They could not get it under these circumstances. The agricultural labourer is the only man who is to be fooled. Evidently he is the only man who can be fooled, for no other section of labour will send Labour representatives here. Despite the terrible plight to which people have been reduced by the policy of the Government, supported by the Labour Party, the country that sent them here——

Comment on this

Sent us here instead of you in some places.

Comment on this

The best intentioned people in the world make mistakes sometimes.

Comment on this

You will be found out the second time.

Comment on this

The country has been reduced to the present position by those on the opposite benches, particularly the agricultural community, whose produce the Labour Party demands should be sold at scrap prices. The agricultural industry has to carry on its back all other industries, and all professions, even the profession of the Labour Leader and Labour organiser. That is the unfortunate sort of structure under which agriculture has to carry on whether it likes it or not. Even if it did not always like the load, agriculture has to carry all other industries, as well as the Government that told the poor deluded voters three years ago and two years ago, that when they got into power they would no longer be burdened by certain payments to an outside Government. These payments have still to be made, and on top of that the Government is collecting them from the farmers a second time. Deputy Norton was perturbed when he saw the farmers meeting in the capital of his constituency to protest against the seizure of cattle for a debt that had long been liquidated. While agriculture is passing through a depression greater than ever experienced, while it is further depressed by the economic war with Great Britain, in having to pay annuities to the British Government, which are equivalent to the local rates, and having further to pay annuities to the Irish Government, and to pay rates to the local authorities, the position is further accentuated by quotas imposed on Irish produce.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot make a rambling statement on the economic war. He can only deal with the Minister's responsibility.

Comment on this

The Minister is responsible for spending £4,000,000 on housing, every penny of which will have to be borrowed by the Government in the form of a loan in order to build houses in the country. They are not to be built in the cities, because there they can get the money much cheaper than the Minister will give it. The security for the money is the economic strength of the country, and that economic strength depends on the prosperity of agriculture.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely we cannot traverse the position of farmers in all its aspects now.

Comment on this

If agriculture is not a paying proposition, and if there is no likelihood of it being in that position, is this a time for the lavish expenditure of money on such schemes, seeing that the repayment of the money must depend upon the economic strength of the country? Is it not the all-important factor that agriculture should be in a flourishing condition? If it was, the Minister's proposals would be a good one. But, when agriculture is on the verge of bankruptcy—and is bankrupt—is that the time to spend money, money that has to be borrowed, after the public disclosing their want of confidence in the economic strength of the country by refusing to subscribe to the last National Loan? Is the public going to subscribe to the next loan? I submit that this Estimate and other Estimates cannot be considered by this House without considering the condition of agriculture.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have allowed the Deputy to ramble a good deal. Surely we cannot traverse the entire position of farmers, and we cannot discuss the prices of butter, eggs, cattle, hay, oats and other farm produce, with which the Minister has nothing to do. The Deputy can make a passing reference to the condition of the farmers, and relate that to the extent that the Minister in charge has any responsibility, but beyond that he cannot go.

Comment on this

What will it cost the farmers to have the Deputy's speech recorded?

Comment on this

It is well worth it. Look at all the rubbish talked by the Deputy and his comrades. I did not mention the price of a single one of the commodities to which you, A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, referred. I made only passing reference to the general condition of agriculture, and I referred to the cheap meat mainly because it was advocated by the Leader of the Labour Party. Agriculture is depressed for the reasons I have given. The industry is unable to pay an economic wage to the agricultural labourer. The farmer is not able to meet normal commitments because of the losses sustained owing to the economic war and the double overhead charges he is called upon to bear, including the sheriff's fees. I suppose the next thing will be the battering ram, the emergency men, and the land grabbers.

Comment on this

They are all on your side.

Comment on this

They will inevitably follow. I move that consideration of the Estimate be deferred until the Minister takes the time and trouble to regard it in its true perspective, until he reviews the whole economic condition of the country and finds what his borrowing capacity is, and what hope he has of redeeming his promises to the investors to repay the capital in a specified time, while at the same time giving these houses to the workers in the country at a rent that they can afford to pay, taking into account the enormous amount that has to be paid in home assistance and outdoor relief. I am afraid, because of the complacent smile of the Minister, that the Estimate will not be reconsidered. Perhaps it would be more correct to move that it be referred back for consideration, because, if it had been really considered, it would not have come before the House in its present form.

Comment on this

At first I was going to sympathise with the Minister for Local Government and Public Health in having lost the services of a potential colleague in Deputy Belton. The Deputy went down to Naas recently to tell the farmers that he was very nearly being a Minister of State. I listened to the Deputy's oration this evening. I suppose he regards it as an oration, but for bowdlerised nonsense I never heard anything like it. I think I can congratulate the Minister that, whatever disabilities or deficiencies attach to the Government, at least they have not Deputy Belton as a member of the Front Bench. If the Deputy had not told us that he had read a financial paper last week, I should have said that he spent too long in the sun. When he tells us that he read a financial paper last week, that is an explanation of his whole speech to-day. The Deputy should give up reading financial papers. That sort of reading is not good for him. He cannot digest it, and, if I might make a suggestion, it would be that he should commence with Comic Cuts and work up to the financial papers. In the course of time, by chewing the matter up, he might develop a digestion for financial papers.

Comment on this

I see enough of you without seeing you in Comic Cuts.

Comment on this

The Deputy made clear to us to-day that financial papers are very bad fare. I hope he will not attribute all the fault to the fact of his having read a financial paper on Whit Monday night. The Deputy should confine himself to something less heavy than financial papers. If he does, his speeches will improve accordingly. The Deputy was at his old game of misrepresentation. When a Deputy has made as many speeches as Deputy Belton has made, it is very difficult to be consistent. The Deputy has been in all Parties that were willing to take him and he finds it extremely difficult to get any consistency into his speeches. He seemed to be suffering from introspection during his speech this evening. At one time, he said, he regarded Deputy Mulcahy as an autocrat. I do not want to raise any difficulties for the Party opposite——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I have no objection to the Deputy rambling as far as he likes but it is an estimate and not a Deputy that is before the House.

Comment on this

You forgot that.

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy woke up and discovered that. The

Deputy told us that, at one time, he joined with the crowd in describing Deputy Mulcahy as an autocrat. I suggest to Deputy Mulcahy that he will yet find Deputy Belton in another Party calling him an autocrat because it is too much to expect that Deputy Belton will stay in any Party for any considerable length of time.

Comment on this

Where will he get the Party?

Comment on this

At one stage, Deputy Belton said:

"We will go back to where we started from."

The Deputy does not know where he started from. If, by any chance, it could be pointed out where he did start from, he would find it very difficult to discover to what point he was going back, because he has a very wide ambit to cover, from the point of view of his Parliamentary gyrations, and there is no indication that he is near the end of them yet.

Comment on this

He is not here for a job. He could live without it, not like the Deputy.

Comment on this

If there were any test or qualification required for a job, the Deputy would never get one.

Comment on this

He had not to fool others to make a living. He was able to make a living on his own.

Comment on this

The Deputy manages a soft living.

Comment on this

He earns his living, not like the Deputy.

Comment on this

If the speech which the Deputy has just delivered is a sample of the ability he brings to bear on earning his living, he gets his living very easily.

Comment on this

You are incapable of judging ability.

Comment on this

The Deputy told us about cheap meat.

Comment on this

Come on to it now.

Comment on this

The Deputy wondered if the Labour Party were standing for cheap meat. He asked if the Labour Party advocated the supply of meat at scrap prices, which would mean scrap wages. The Labour Party has never indicated that it stood for a policy of scrap prices and scrap wages. It stands for a policy of reasonable prices and high wages, because there seems to be no prosperity whatever in any policy which would give you bankrupt prices, on the one hand, and low wages, on the other hand.

Comment on this

Where does the cheap meat come in?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will restrain his impetuosity, I shall try to tell him.

Comment on this

He cannot.

Comment on this

That confession by the Deputy is good. The Labour Party did not advocate cheap meat so far as the producers of beef were concerned. They advocated that the farmer who had meat to dispose of on the hoof should be given a guaranteed price for his cattle, a price higher than he is getting to-day, and, certainly, much higher than he can get without an export licence. I suggested that if there is any difficulty in disposing of our surplus goods in an extern market we should do something to popularise the use of beef at home amongst our own people and that if necessary we should give the farmer a guaranteed price for his beef—that even though the meat had to be disposed of to our own people at an uneconomic price the farmer should get a guaranteed price for that meat——

Comment on this

Deputy Norton is up in the air. Let him come down to earth and tell us how it is to be done.

Comment on this

I have already explained the scheme at public meetings around the country, and I made it perfectly clear even in the Deputy's own daily organ. Even that organ stated that in existing circumstances it is a good scheme. It was only intended to deal with existing circumstances, although there may be within it the sound roots of a permanent scheme for dealing with any difficulty there may be in disposing of the surplus cattle of the country. What Deputy Belton advocated—if English has any meaning at all—was "pay your rates and pay your annuities if you like."

Comment on this

I said nothing of the kind, and I do not want, by implication or otherwise, that that statement should be attributed to me. I never stood for it. I never stood for the advice "Pay your rates or annuities if you like," for I have always acknowledged that rates and annuities should be paid.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy stand for the payment of rates and land annuities as they are due?

Comment on this

Or does the Deputy want to seek refuge in the plea that these rates and annuities have been already paid? Does the Deputy say that they are due and should be paid on demand, or does he take refuge in the plea that these rates and annuities have already been paid to Britain? We are entitled to know where the Deputy stands.

Comment on this

They have been paid to Britain already, and Deputy Norton knows it.

Comment on this

It is quite clear that the Deputy's first speech revealed his real mind. "The rates and annuities have been paid already; therefore do not pay them again." That is the philosophy of the Deputy's speech, and I say it is the most disgraceful speech ever made in this House, because it is really payment by option, and the Deputy has enough experience to realise what the effect of such a speech will be in the country. It is meeting obligations by option.

Comment on this

On a point of correction, Sir, I said no such thing, and I protest against Deputy Norton deliberately twisting what I said.

Comment on this

Well, then. I will put this question to Deputy Belton: Does he believe that the rates and annuities are due on demand now and must be paid now, or does he stand for a policy of taking refuge in the plea that these rates and annuities have already been paid to Britain, that they should not be paid again, and that they must not be paid again? The Deputy does not reply. He is silent now.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not silent now. If Deputy Norton will give way for a moment I will answer him. These annuities have been collected by Great Britain, as was disclosed in the House of Commons recently by the British Chancellor of the Exchequer, Sir Neville Chamberlain. The British Chancellor of the Exchequer said he had collected £4,532,000 from the farmers of the Free State. He said that. When you allow for the Sinking Fund that has not been collected, the British have collected the equivalent of the land annuities and the rates. That shows clearly that the annuities have been paid by the farmers to Britain. I say that the equivalent of the rates on agricultural land has also been paid to Britain; that our Government has benefited to a corresponding amount. Consequently it is clear that agriculture has met its obligations. Having met its obligations, it should not be asked to meet them again, and I stigmatise in this House the seizure of cattle for land annuities—already declared publicly by the British Chancellor of the Exchequer to have been collected by them—as nothing short of the highwayman's profession.

Comment on this

The Deputy is trying to walk on a tight rope now. In the course of his attempted clarification of his speech he is walking on a tight rope. The Deputy's position is quite clear from his speech. Britain has collected annuities and the rates and annuities have already been paid and therefore they have not to be paid again. That is what the Deputy has said.

Comment on this

I will not correct Deputy Norton any longer. He is deliberately misquoting what I said, and I do not think it worth while to correct him any longer.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy read his own speech? Will he look at that speech again?

Comment on this

I am quite clear on what I have said.

Comment on this

In the course of his speech the Deputy said:

"In view of the ruined condition of the farmers"

—we had an example of one of the ruined farmers in Naas recently——

"we should consider whether we would go on building houses."

Comment on this

Again I protest against a misquotation of my speech. I did not speak of the ruined condition of the farmers. I spoke of the ruined condition of agriculture. Deputy Norton is at his usual trick trying to drive in a wedge between different classes and trying to create class distinctions in this country.

Comment on this

Well then Deputy Belton said in consequence of the ruined condition of agriculture we should consider whether it is desirable to go on building house. As I say, we had an example in Naas recently of the ruined condition of agriculture. It was a shining example of one gentleman who would not discharge his lawful and legal liability to the State. And because he did not pay his legal liabilities that man's cattle were seized just the same as one of Deputy Belton's constituents in Gloucester Street might have his chattel property seized if he were not able to pay charges that were legally due by him. If that happened to one of the Deputy's constituents in Gloucester Street you may be sure Deputy Belton would not be down there as he was down in Naas, where he went down helping to make things, from the point of view of local administration, more difficult than they were. We had as an example of a ruined agriculturist this man who refused to pay his rates and annuities. He was one of the ruined agriculturists that the Deputy talks of. Can we have an answer to the question as to whether the farmers should pay their annuities and rates?

Comment on this

I object to answering Deputy Norton when he is deliberately misquoting me. I did not mention a word about a farmer or an agriculturist. I mentioned the industry of agriculture but this is so foreign to the Deputy that he does not understand the difference.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton speaks about the ruined condition of agriculture. Are not the persons engaged in agriculture farmers?

Comment on this

Yes, and labourers. An agriculturist might be a labourer.

Comment on this

We had one of these ruined agriculturists in Naas recently. Does the Deputy plead there was inability there to pay?

Comment on this

I never pleaded inability on the part of that agriculturist to pay rates.

Comment on this

What was Deputy Belton advocating in Naas when he went down there? Does the Deputy assume that the person who refused to pay rates in Naas was unable to pay?

Comment on this

He had paid them already. That was why he refused.

Comment on this

He had paid the bookmaker.

Comment on this

Never mind about the bookmaker. He had paid his annuities and rates already.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

If Deputy Belton were sitting in judgment on that case he would know that the person whose cattle were seized could have paid these rates a thousand times over.

Comment on this

He had paid them once already and that was enough.

Comment on this

He had not paid them to the local authority cited here, and it was because Deputy Belton wanted to urge on that person that they had been already paid and collected that he wanted the man to default——

Comment on this

The man had paid his rates and annuities already. There was no default.

Comment on this

What was it?

Comment on this

If Deputy Norton will give way for a moment I will explain it. Every annuitant signed a purchase agreement to pay a certain annuity. Now that annuity has been already collected by the British. It is the Government's function and duty to protect the citizens of this country from all enemies, domestic and foreign. Why does not our Government protect the farmers of this country from having to pay rates and annuities in addition to paying nearly £5,000,000 seized from them by the British Government? They cannot pay it twice. Where now is all this bunkum and nonsense that had been put up all over the country as to the retaining of the land annuities? The British are getting them. What has become of all the talk that our Government would not pay these annuities to the British? Deputies on the Government Benches want, like the ostrich, to bury their heads in the sand. Why not be honest about it? It is all very well for people like Deputy Kennedy, who has not a bob to pay no matter what happens—it is all very well for him to interrupt.

Comment on this

Now we see where Deputy Belton's strategy is leading the country. The Deputy, speaking in Rathcoole, on the 11th December, 1926, said——

Comment on this

What date did the Deputy say?

Comment on this

The 11th of December, 1932. Does the Deputy deny that? He went down to Rathcoole and made a statement there.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let me remind the Deputy that 1926 is very far removed from 1933-34.

Comment on this

I am merely replying to a point raised by the Deputy. He was permitted to talk about land annuities and, in fact, everything except the Department of Local Government and Public Health. Anyhow, he made a speech in Rathcoole dealing with land annuities. The issue at the meeting was whether high rents, which the Cumann na nGaedheal Department of Local Government wanted to charge tenants, should be charged. The meeting was purely concerned with the rents of labourers' cottages.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The meeting was concerned with nothing of the kind. It was concerned with the division of a ranch in Rathcoole.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Anyway, it does not concern this Estimate. What the Deputy said in Rathcoole in 1926 is not relevant to the question before the House.

Comment on this

The Chair is trying to save Deputy Norton from himself.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am merely trying to save the House from disorder.

Comment on this

The Chair will not permit me to refer to what the Deputy said in Rathcoole. In any case, it is known history that the Deputy advocated the non-payment of land annuities to the British. He said that the only royal road to prosperity in this country was to hold the annuities for the use of the Irish people. On the occasion when the Deputy made the remark advocating the retention of the annuities, he even abused Deputy Batt O'Connor for being a party to the export of the annuities to Great Britain. Now, when the annuities are being retained, the Deputy wants to tell the House that his whole strategy has fallen like a house of cards.

Comment on this

I think that the Deputy ought to quote, if he has anything to quote from. Of course it is easy to invent a thing.

Comment on this

The Deputy advocated the retention of the land annuities in 1926. He did not then wish them exported to another country.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton was then a member of this House. Did he protest at that time against the payment of land annuities to England? I remember that he supported a statement made by Senator Johnson at Blackrock saying that the settlement was a good one.

Comment on this

On that occasion the audience took very little notice of what Deputy Belton said.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I would like the House also to take very little notice of what was said on that occasion. Let us get back to the Estimate.

Comment on this

In the course of his remarks about the Housing Board, Deputy Belton's chief contribution was to question the remuneration of one of the members of the Board. He said that that member is an ex-member of this Party, and that the job was specially provided for him.

Comment on this

And he knows nothing about housing.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton mentioned also that the person concerned knows nothing about housing.

Comment on this

The only work he ever did in this country was to sell cattle medicines.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no need to make references of that kind. Deputy Belton has already got a good deal of latitude, and I think he ought to permit Deputy Norton to make his speech.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton has been addressing questions to me.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

His questions were largely of a rhetorical character, and if the Deputy wishes to reply to them he may do so later, but he ought not interrupt so frequently.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton used his privileged position in this House to abuse a member of the Labour Party who is also a member of the Oireachtas. Deputy Belton has a very short memory. Does he not know of the strange positions which some people on the Cumann na nGaedheal Party got within the last few years? He is not sitting very far from colleagues who could tell him of the generous way in which supporters were treated by the Government then in power and of which they were members. Did he ever hear of the notorious example of the person who was connected with the Oireachtas Kitchen Committee, the person who was promoted to Ministerial rank and, when he lost that, because he lost his seat in this House, was put in charge of a certain board at £1,000 a year and when that board finished its work, was appointed to another board at £800 a year? The Deputy sat very silent while all that was being done.

Comment on this

What were the boards?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not know them?

Comment on this

I would like to have them, if the House desires to have them.

Comment on this