We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Vote No. 3—Department of the President of the Executive Council (Resumed).

Contributions 1–141 of 271. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The President, on this Estimate, has been charged with the complete mishandling of the work of his Department. He has been charged with disturbing the general relations that existed between ourselves and Great Britain—a relationship arising out of which a very considerable amount of progress was being made, a relationship under which we had achieved, between this State and Great Britain, a position of absolute equality in status, one with another, and in no way subordinate one to another in any aspect of our external and internal affairs; the prejudicing and the making unsatisfactory of the economic arrangements between ourselves and Great Britain; the destruction of our farming industry; the stifling of our general industrial development and the burdening of this country with enormous sums of taxation. In reply to the general and detailed criticism directed against him during the discussion of this Estimate, the President simply states that he is a statesman, that he recognises the true aim of statesmanship, but that a statesman can only work in freedom, and the statesman at the head of our Government to-day has not a sufficient amount of freedom to enable him to work. He stated on Friday last:

"...the true aim of statesmanship in this country or in any other country should be to secure for as many of the citizens as possible the highest standard of living, not material merely, but spiritual as well."

And again:

"...that it is only in freedom, through the freedom of the nation, that it is possible for statesmanship to effect its aims in regard to the people."

Deputies opposite, as well as the people of the country to whom the President addressed himself, know very well the condition of affairs that existed in this country about 1918. They know that the same tyranny that had dominated and practically destroyed both the material and the spiritual welfare of the people was so entrenched here that as recently as 1918 they threatened to take the whole manhood of this country by force to send them to the battlefields of Europe to fight. Fight for what? To fight for the material interests of the country that had been wiping its feet in this country for so many generations. Not only that, but three years later I saw as big a machinery of tyranny as that Government had ever employed in this country trampling the men, the women and the children from one end to the other of the country in an attempt to destroy the spirit of its people and destroy any material interest they might have in order to crush out this nation. Then a couple of years after that Deputies opposite, as well as the people of this country, saw pass from the face of the country every vestige of that tyranny.

Comment on this
Gerald Boland Minister for Posts and Telegraphs (Mr. Boland) Fianna Fáil

Not at all.

Comment on this

Deputies opposite saw every vestige of that tyranny pass from this country.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

We hope we will see it.

Comment on this

And they will not tell you to-day how it passed. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is not going to get up here and say that the people of Roscommon rose in their might and, with their arms, put the R.I.C. and the British military shipping out of the port of Dublin. Who took the English Government out of Dublin Castle and enabled the people to set up their own Parliament? Deputy Corry will not say the people of Cork did it. They helped; young men in every part of this country helped to bring about the circumstances when the British military were shipped out of the port of Dublin and when our people had the opportunity put into their hands of setting up their own legislature and taking over control of their own country.

Comment on this

But the military landed in Belfast after they had left Dublin.

Comment on this

And Deputy Donnelly will not say that he and his people alone were the people who shipped the British out of this country.

Comment on this

They are not gone out.

Comment on this

They are not gone out of it because the President wants some excuse for not being able to bring about the material wellbeing of this country, for not developing the spiritual welfare of the country that he talks so much about. However it came about, there did pass providentially from this country the terror and the tyranny and the alien laws that our people had suffered under for generations until 1922. The Minister for Local Government visited Canada in 1932 and when leaving Canada he said at the final meeting there:—

"Nothing can ever make us forget our debt to Canada and whatever changes the future may bring about one very certain result of the conferences as far as the delegation of the Irish Free State is concerned is a determination to do everything in our power to cement more closely the bonds of friendship between the Irish and the Canadian people."

What was the debt that the Vice-President was thanking the Canadian people for? Was it that they had stood him a couple of luncheons or dinners or had enabled him to attend at a few State functions or a few balls? What was the debt? Was it that he had made a satisfactory trade agreement with them? We know it was not, because our trade with Canada has suffered since. But we here on these benches have an appreciation of what our debt to Canada is and the Vice-President, if he were speaking his mind, would know something about it too.

At the time we had the old tyranny attempting to conscript our people in 1918, at the time when we had the old tyranny trampling our people under the feet of the Black-and-Tans in 1920-1921, there was rising up in the world a spirit of nationality. Young nations were growing up throughout the world, young nations, many of them having their foundations inspired by a spirit of freedom, a spirit of courage and a spirit of determination brought to these countries by the young men and women and the old men and old women who were forced out of our country by the tyranny that ruled in it up to then. Canada was rising as a young nation during the war years; so also were Australia, New Zealand and South Africa. Part of the providential circumstances that enabled us to get rid of the tyranny that trampled this country under its feet for so many generations was the rise of these young nations. When we swept from the face of this country the terror and the disgrace of war made upon it by Great Britain and when we sat down in council with Great Britain to argue out the problems that then remained between us, we found that, having been providentially assisted in our progress to the council table to argue out our problems with Britain, we had the representatives of the rising nation of Canada on our right hand side, South Africa on our left hand side, Australia in front and New Zealand beside them. And when, as Collins truly foresaw and foretold, we were round that council table we were arguing their fight for nationality as well as our own and we had their assistance in arguing our fight. So that after the few years of negotiation and argument had passed, we found that, together, we had reduced Great Britain to a state of declaring and administering her own laws; that we were co-equal in status with them, as there was also co-equality between them and ourselves—Canada, Australia, South Africa and New Zealand. There was no subordination in any one towards any other in the aspect of their internal affairs.

Then came a time to discuss our economics when the Vice-President and the Minister for Industry and Commerce went to Canada. When they came home from Canada the Vice-President told us that they had laid the foundations of an agreement with Great Britain, but nothing has been raised upon these foundations; he praised Canada for the debt we owed Canada. So well he might, but the only tragedy is that he did not praise Canada for the debt that we owed them in different circumstances. The people of this country, by their efforts, and by the efforts and the work of their leaders, put the President into the position in which he is, as head of the Executive Council here, with sovereign powers over all this State of the Twenty-Six Counties. It would be better still if we had more intelligence shown on the part of other members of this House even this year in regard to these matters if not as long ago as 1922. At any rate, such as it is, he has all the resources of this State of Twenty-Six Counties at his command as a result of their efforts and of their work.

He sat as President over the League of Nations Assembly, a year or two ago, and he presided in that position in the name of this State. It is an assembly consisting of all the biggest nations in the world. Then he comes here, and when challenged to give details of his administration here, and the result of his policy here, he says: "I am not a politician, I belong to the statesman class, and I can only work in a free state." It would have been a poor day for this country if its leaders in the past had been that class of statesman or politician. If they had been, he would not have been President of the Executive Council in this country to-day and he would not have been able to occupy the privileged and powerful position that this people placed him in as President of the League of Nations. He would never have occupied that position if there had not been different leaders from him in the past. He tells us now that our agriculture is destroyed and depression falling upon the whole spirit of our people. But he tells us that what is really wrong is the absence of freedom. He tells us that this country is threatened by invasion in the same way as it was in the past. He tells us that the British military are in our ports, that threats of war are made against our people; that we are in danger of being dragged into foreign wars, and that we are not allowed to pursue our foreign development without Britain taking steps that will prevent our future agricultural or industrial development. These bogeys are paraded before the eyes of our people for the purpose of blinding them exactly to what has happened in this country; for the purpose of preventing them raising their heads in the manner that the manhood of the Irish people did in the past when they followed leaders who would not be hindered from going ahead with their work by any bogeys or threat of trade interruption. Some of our old stories contain many objects with morals for our people. There was one thing enshrined in our country but historians never sought traces of it in our people.

When Alexander was going into the East on one occasion on his campaigns he found occasion to terrorise people living near the rock of Narsinga. But when his policy necessitated it he withdrew his army but the people of the villages, hearing horns blowing in the Castle in the morning and in the evening, still hung their heads in terror. They were afraid to look out on the mountains even when the horns did not blow lest they should start again. When the young people did not understand why they could not look over their mountains and walk over them the people said to them: "Alexander is on the mountains with his army. The horns tell us he is there." But the boys went up to the mountain and they found big stones with holes in them. Birds' nests were built in the holes and when the nests were taken out and the wind blew through the holes they sounded like the blowing of horns. That was the position of President de Valera in 1922, that there were bogeys on the mountains in our country. But some of the birds' nests were taken out of the rocks since 1922, and it is an astounding thing that we should have young men in our country to-day and that, sitting behind the President and Vice-President, we should find Deputies capable of listening to the particular kind of stuff that is preached to them about these bogeys. What is the freedom that is lacking to a man who can sit as President of the Executive Council here, and who can take from the pockets of the people of this country the amount of additional money that he has taken out of their pockets? What is lacking in freedom to a man who can go and preside over an assembly like the League of Nations in Geneva, as President of this State, but who will come back and say that the reason why he cannot get on with the work in this country is because of the internal affairs of this country and talks of war and the British sitting round our shores, and says that until we get rid of them the people of this country are not capable of getting on with their work? As I say, it is astounding that we have in this country, at this hour, people who can take that kind of stuff from the President in the way that Deputies opposite take it. No wonder then that we have the situation that we have in this country, and that we have people who can be ruthless in the matter of taxation, but regardless of the interests of the people who provide the foundations of our prosperity, the farmers. In these circumstances it is no wonder that we have the conditions we have. But would the President forget his bogeys for a bit and tell us exactly what he wants to do in this country. The position of the country is that we get generalities in philosophy from the President, descriptive of the dangers and difficulties that lie around our people, but not one clear scrap of description as to what he wants to do with the people of this country or how he wants to do it.

We would have no progress in this country, no development of economic life and no development of social life if our leaders in the past talked airily of Irish freedom and did nothing to objectivise it in any way or took the steps which were from day to day necessary to progress along the path both to freedom and economic development here. The President does not accept the step-by-step idea. The person in our country's history, one whose life has left the biggest tradition as builder and whose name is synonymous with building had as his motto "cloch ar dha cloich agus dha cloich ar aon cloch," or "one stone on two stones and two stones on one stone." He was the man who had the reputation for shortening the road with song and story-telling. That was the great builder, the Gobán Sáor. The President is providing the country with a long-drawn-out agony of waiting for one big leap to victory, and in the days while they are waiting he is talking about peace for the people of this country. In October last he told a meeting at Ballaghaderreen, "I do not say that the goal will be easily reached but we have already reached things that our forefathers thought difficult."

What is the goal? The President is sitting in a position and occupying a position to-day in which he has acquired all the resources of men and all the resources of money and all the power of law in his own hands. And what progress are we making? His excuse is that the "aim of the Opposition was to break down the morale of the people and that they wanted to organise so that they would be in a position to seize power by force if they got a chance." Truth! Truth in the News! Truth in the President's mouth! Every line of this on its face shows that it is untrue. He cannot point to a single section of the people of this country except a bit of his own tail that would show that in working their salvation, political or economic or in any other way, there is anybody in this country who wants to seize from the people power by force, except, as I have already said, a small section amongst his own tail and in respect of that we know from the speech of the Minister for Justice the other day that that situation is well in hand. Where does the President stand? The President told us in his address to the Ard-Fheis at the Mansion House on the 9th November last "some people say we have accepted the Treaty. Like soldiers we have appreciated the position. We have made our calculations as to how the nation, from the position in which we are now is going to advance. We have accepted nothing."

The President has accepted something. He has accepted the power. He has accepted the control of the resources of the nation and he has accepted the emoluments of his position and of his office in Government Buildings. He has accepted all that but he has not accepted the responsibilities of the position and, as behind his old wall of glass, he takes his ground on the position and has driven the unfortunate farmers into the fight in front without telling them in any way what they are to fight for and what is the goal. "In one of my first dispatches to Mr. Thomas," he tells us, "I pointed out that the Treaty was forced upon the Irish people and could not be accepted as having any moral value. According to the strength of the people we propose to advance so as to secure for our people everything that is theirs." What are the things to which we are going to advance? How are we going to advance to them? The President gives his own answer. He went on to refer to the economic war and said that "‘war' was an unfortunate word" because it brought to the people's mind a line of action which was not going to win the fight. Many people did not understand the line they were pursuing. He put it to them that if a city were besieged with a strong besieging party outside with a policy of starving the people into surrender it might be a good policy to take the people from manning the walls to producing food. The man who would help in winning this war would be the one who could show them how to change their economy. If they meant to win this fight they had got to put petty things aside; to lose would be disaster to the nation." The man who would help in winning this war would be the one who could show them how to change their economy!! And so the President is sitting down inside his screen protection wall and the people throughout the country are suffering in this economic war in which he tells them he fired the first shot and he tells them now "no surrender.""All we want" he says, "is the man who will help in winning this war by changing their economy." Are we then in the position that the President—standing as far as this State is concerned of being co-equal in status with Great Britain, in no way subordinate in any way or in any aspect of our internal or external affairs—knows well that he is not going to look the British straight in the eyes, and is not going to sit down around the Council table that others of our people have provided for him? What are the difficulties with Great Britain and what agreements can be come to to secure a solution of those difficulties? In facing up to a situation like that, not only has the President power, in terms of the man power of this country, but of the Truceliers of 1921, and he has even the people who threw their influence against us when we were arguing for constitutional co-equality with Britain in 1921. He has people then on the British side to help in negotiations with Britain, people who were against us in 1921 and he has with him all the people who were with us—the representatives of the rising nations of Canada, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa.

Consider how progress was made in the past. Standish O'Grady in one of his essays used to liken the position of the Irish in the struggle with Britain under the old régime to that of a chessplayer playing chess with a veiled player, and every time when the veiled player's king was in danger of being mated, his hand swept all the pieces off the board so that there could be no successful conclusion to his adversary's game. The man whom the President repudiated in 1922 has provided a board that no hand can sweep the pieces off, and with sound argument, logical position and moral strength can find their true places there untouched by force. Are we to have it that, with that provided, the President is not going to sit down to list our difficulties and to argue them out? As I say, some of the British themselves who were against us when we were arguing towards constitutional co-equality are with the President and his colleagues now and tell them how the argument was carried on in the old days. I think that the President and his associates had something to do with the recent publication of a certain pamphlet dealing with the Anglo-Irish dispute, with an introduction by Henry Harrison and some letters by Mr. Berriedale Keith. On page 14 of the pamphlet Mr. Keith says in one of his letters:—

"In the Free State, Mr. Cosgrave, with the co-operation of successive British Governments, and most notably of Mr. Thomas, deprived the King of every vestige of legal influence and all legal power. There is not an act of external or internal affairs on which His Majesty can do otherwise than as bidden by the Executive Council of the State. He cannot refuse advice, he cannot dismiss a Ministry with a majority in the Dáil. All his functions, now of the most limited kind in internal matters under the Constitution, are performed by a servant of the Ministry, who could not legally receive or obey an instruction from the King."

On page 16 of the same pamphlet Mr. Keith again writes:—

"Despite these facts, Mr. Thomas in his dispatch, of December 5, wrote: ‘The period which elapsed between 1921 and 1932 was marked by the progressive development of friendly relations and co-operation between the two countries'."

Mr. Keith on page 15 is of opinion that:—

"What is urgently needed is an effort by all parties in the country, with the aid of the Dominions, to work out a position which may preserve unity in essentials with the gratification of Irish aspirations, however needless we here may think them."

We want to know from the President: does he accept the position that this State stands a co-equal in status with Great Britain, that we are in no way subordinate to Great Britain in any aspect of our affairs, and has he Irish manliness enough, with that ground under his feet, to go and argue out the position, or is he going to sulk behind the old wall of glass and leave the people to go down in the degradation of spirit and the material misery that they are going down in day by day? The head of this State has to disseminate throughout the country a cloud of the most appalling falsehoods that it is possible to have uttered in order to cover up the situation that is here, to distract the attention of our people, and to serve out that kind of excuse for his inability not only to carry out the things he promised but to prevent the economic condition of the people worsening.

You have an example of what the President's line is when he deals with the question of partition. In August of last year, when speaking to a British journalist on the question of partition, he said that

"Any proposition must come from Britain or from Northern Ireland, but that we cannot take any practical steps ourselves."

Apparently in no matter can the President take any practical steps himself. He must sit down in the quiet and security of his own position and let the people outside suffer. This country wants to have its economic condition improved. With our own Legislature which Davis, whom the President now begins to quote, characterised as "the foundation of all freedom and the foundation of all power," we want to use it to improve both the industrial and the agricultural condition of our people. To discuss only the material side, the President knows that we found this country in this position: that the market we had of necessity in Great Britain for our agricultural produce was three times the market that our farmers had here. The Minister for Finance rather corrects Deputy Fitzgerald for his exaggerating the importance of the agricultural position in this country. He took him to task over certain figures of his the other night. The Minister for Finance can find out for himself if he refers to the Official Reports, page 786 of volume 29, for April 24, 1929. He will find that Fianna Fáil then held a different opinion with regard to the importance of the agricultural position of the country, because the President on that occasion said, when speaking in a debate on a Financial Resolution:—

"We know, of course, that agriculture is our principal industry and that seven out of every nine engaged on productive industries are engaged on the land; also that two-thirds of the wealth of the country is produced from agriculture, and, moreover, that the greater part of the remaining one-third is produced from industries ancillary to farming, such as baconcuring, butter-making, brewing, distilling, and so forth."

That is to say, that seven out of nine were engaged on agriculture with an external market three times the market that we had here arising out of the historical circumstances affecting the country in which it was governed from Great Britain. It was in circumstances like those that the President, again speaking to an English journalist, said:—

"We do not ask for any special advantages. We do not expect them any more than any other country, France or Denmark for example, would."

We do demand more from Great Britain than Denmark or France or any other country in the world is entitled to demand, and we believe that the way that demand can be made effective is to talk straight into the faces of British Ministers and British representatives. It is utterly impossible to assume in any way the conception of his responsibilities that the President has when he would make a statement like that.

The President, by his general action, has been driven to take up the attitude that there is not any longer a British market, while a very big publicity campaign is being developed by his Press around the position between New Zealand and Great Britain. An attempt is being made to persuade the people of this country that even countries as dear to the heart of Great Britain as New Zealand cannot get their goods on to the British market to-day. There is not a single country in the British Commonwealth that, as a result of the Ottawa Conference, has not increased the benefits it previously derived from the British market. New Zealand, that the President is using as a subject for propaganda to show that there is no British market, increased the value of its exports in the first four months of 1934, as compared with the first four months of 1932, between the Ottawa Conference year, from £11,530,000 to £12,536,000; increased the total amount of its exports to Great Britain by £1,000,000, and increased its favourable balance of trade when dealing with Great Britain by £1,866,000. Canada increased its exports to the British market from £8,359,000 to £10,673,000 in the same four months. The total increase of trade was £2,312,000 and the total increase in its favourable trade balance was £1,820,000. Australia increased its exports to Great Britain for the same period of four months from £13,775,000 to £15,822,000. Its total exports to Great Britain were increased in value by £1,647,000, and the increase in its favourable trade balance with Great Britain was £1,075,000. In the case of South Africa that country increased its exports to Great Britain from £4,047,000 to £4,157,000. Its trade in the reverse direction increased from £4,142,000 to £6,833,000. As between the two the total trade was increased from £8,500,000 to £11,000,000.

As far as one of the principal items in which this country is interested in the British market, is concerned, so far from the British market being gone, the imports of meat to that market for the first four months of 1932 were valued at £26,783,000; in 1933, £25,375,000; and in 1934, £26,846,000. That was what the meat imports to Great Britain—into a vanishing market—represented in the first four months of this year—the market that has vanished for us.

Comment on this

Where did these imports come from?

Comment on this

The Deputy can look up the British figures and he will find a whole series of countries from which they came.

Comment on this

The Argentine.

Comment on this

The Argentine and nearly every country in the world. The imports into that market amounted to £26,846,000.

Comment on this

Could the Deputy say what it was retailed at?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

I know the Deputy would like me to tell him a lot now which would take me off this important subject. If the Deputy has any question to ask me I will be very glad to meet him. I will have a few little things to tell him about the land annuities. This vanishing British market, in the first four months of this year, took meat value for £26,000,000. What did the imports from this great agricultural country, the Irish Free State, represent? £620,000. Why? Because the market had vanished! It was not there!

Comment on this

Fresh meat?

Comment on this

The tastes of the people had changed and there was no market! And because we are told a market for meat, value £26,000,000, is no market at all, we have to change our economy. The change in economy that we want here is a change of understanding between ourselves and the British; a change to secure that we will send meat value for more than £620,000 to a market worth £26,000,000. Where a fall has taken place has been in live animals. If Deputy Donnelly has taken an interest in the British market, he will understand that, as far as meat is concerned, the fight which is going on in Great Britain is a fight to safeguard the fresh meat trade against the other meat trade. Just as our fight for nationality and sovereign status was a fight for Canada, for Australia and for South Africa, the fight of British farmers for a decent market for their fresh meat is a fight that is our fight. There was no necessity in the world, if the Vice-President and the Ministers at Ottawa in a reasonable spirit had tucked their feet in under the same table with British Ministers, why the word "quota" should be mentioned either in connection with our live animal trade or our fresh meat trade. I do not believe there was any necessity why it should be mentioned in trade between our people and Great Britain.

If there is a falling off in our trade with Great Britain it is in our fresh meat trade. Whereas the exports in 1932 were value for £4,286,000, in 1934 they were only value for £1,672,000. There is not a Fianna Fáil Deputy who could argue before any intelligent group of people that there was any necessity for that fall, or that there would be that fall if Irish Ministers had discussed their affairs with British Ministers in the proper way, and had fought the fight of the Irish farmers for their fresh meat trade, in the same way as we fought for our sovereign status; fighting thereby for Canada, Australia and South Africa, making them people to whom we owe a mutual debt. At the end of this month the meat agreements made at Ottawa cease. Will the President tell us what he is doing to restore the position by which we may get even £4,286,000 for our live animal trade or for our fresh meat trade with Great Britain, in the first four months of the year, as we got for the first four months of 1932? Is it the position that he can do nothing practical? Is it the position that he is not free? He has all the freedom that any leader of his people could have, or could want, to discuss that question. It is because he accepts an inferior position, in his own mind, because he will not step on the ground prepared for him by us, and by the people who went before us, the ground of absolute equality with Ministers in Great Britain, that he runs away from that position as the Vice-President and the Ministers ran away from Ottawa. Meantime, our farmers must suffer loss of their capital, must suffer a loss of income with which to pay agricultural labourers, from which our towns also got their income, and from which Irish industries would get capital in the free and favourable circumstances that we now have, when a native Government could build up industry. We want to know from the President what he is going to do about the meat agreements with Great Britain at the end of this month?

He tells us there is a threat of war over us, that Britain may declare war on us if we develop our constitutional position, and that we may be dragged into war because the British hold certain maintenance parties in certain of our ports. The President can do practically nothing about it. He can sit down in his pleasant isolation behind his wall of glass and wait for the war to come. What kind of attempt to prevent war, either with the British or to prevent our being dragged into war with other nations because Britain goes to war with them, is the preparation the President is making now? The threat of war is the biggest bogey that the President has in his whole stock but if there is any threat of war, in other circumstances, arising out of our constitutional position or arising out of anything connected with the unity of our country—any threat of war on the part of Britain against us—is there any safer place to argue that than at a table where Ministers have representatives of Canada, South Africa, Australia and New Zealand all around them, a place where the position of absolute constitutional equality of status is definitely settled and agreed? If the President believed that there was the slightest threat of war, arising from our relations with Great Britain, he could have the matter discussed at such an assembly. If circumstances compel him to leave that council chamber, is he not in a better position then to appeal to the world, if he wants to appeal to the world, when the other nations have seen that he has done his best to secure a settlement inside that council chamber?

In the same way, if there is any danger of this country getting involved in an outside war by reason of Great Britain being involved in that war, has he any better method to fight that threat or, at any rate, to get more clear about it, than to sit in with the representatives of the other members of the Commonwealth and argue that under the Constitution that has been given him here, this country can only be brought into a war by the vote of its own Parliament? If by any misfortune, absurd to think about, we were in danger of being entangled with any other country would the President's voice be stronger or would the voice of any leader here be stronger, sitting here alone, than if he spoke at the council chamber of all the nations of the British Commonwealth saying: "I am not with you in this"? If he thinks there is a single bit of danger in his bogey of war, the President is deserting and betraying the interests of his people in present circumstances by the attitude he has taken up with regard to Great Britain and the other members of the Commonwealth.

We want to be freed from our financial burdens too and the President has adopted a line of his own. He took that line against the advice of hundreds of thousands of his countrymen. He embarked on that line in the dark and, because he finds himself in circumstances in which he would persuade us he never expected himself to be, and in which he says he never would have been but for the action of the Opposition, he endeavours to persuade his own followers, and people throughout the country, that Britain would never have minded at all his withholding the land annuities if they had not been encouraged by the Opposition to take an aggressive line. At any rate, he has taken a certain line and that line is such that the British are getting every halfpenny out of our people that the President says he does not want to pay to them. He is withholding the land annuities and he has entered the world arena and, as it were, championed the cause of the United States against Great Britain in connection with the war debts. Instead of sitting in as a member of the Commonwealth, instead of sitting in his place in Geneva when he was President of the Assembly there or even as a member there arguing— because this is accepted throughout the world practically, that some radical change must be made in respect of international debts—instead of sitting in and arguing that in general world interests and ultimately in the interests of his own country, his Press and his voice have been thrown into the arena to argue that all nations must pay their debts and that Great Britain particularly must pay every halfpenny of the debt she owes to the United States. The President has played a most unworthy part, as a member of the League of Nations, in the attitude he has taken up in this matter. He has taken up a particular attitude as between Great Britain and the United States entirely in a party spirit.

Our country again is a member of the Commonwealth of Nations. Australia owes Great Britain about £79,000,000 war debts, and she has not paid a halfpenny in respect of it in the last few years. New Zealand owes the British Government £26,000,000. I do not think it matters to the British Government whether the money which Australia owes it is war debts or any other kind of debts, but if I were arguing that the amount which this country is asked to pay to Great Britain is too much, I would like to argue that round the kind of table that our Ministers found in Ottawa, with an Australian representative on my right and a New Zealand representative on my left. I think it would be a more profitable way to argue the case than to argue it in the way in which the President is now arguing it—losing every halfpenny of the money that Britain is seeking to recover, and at the same time inflicting an appalling loss not only on our agriculturists but on the people of the country as a whole.

Deputy Donnelly intervened, rather unnecessarily, I think, on the question of the land annuities, and I shall just digress for a moment to answer the point that the Deputy made. The Deputy put forward the charge that Deputy Cosgrave was the first person to get the Dáil to agree to withholding the land annuities, and Deputy Cosgrave denied that. On the 16th May last, the Deputy and Deputy Cosgrave had a certain amount of discussion, as reported in column 1003 of the Debates. The Deputy argued that clause 5 of these proposals, dealing with local government, was passed by the Dáil. "The entire report," said Deputy Donnelly, "went through the Dáil nem. con. proposed by you.” Deputy Cosgrave then stated:

"I have here the Official Report of the minutes, and on page 223, as I have said, clause 5 was referred to the Finance Department for consideration. The proposals were in clause 5. That was the clause for the collection of revenue, and they were referred to the Finance Department for consideration. They were not adopted."

And the Deputy still held to his statement that they were adopted nem. con., on the proposition of Deputy Cosgrave, and that Deputy Cosgrave now found himself in a tight corner. Well, whatever has to be said about the land annuities ought to be said on the merits of the case. To attempt, however, to go back to 1921 or 1920 in the matter is simply running away from the discussion of the Land Commission annuities question in 1934, but if we do go back to 1920 we ought not to make false statements.

Comment on this

I think I gave the quotations.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not give the quotation he was asked for. He was asked to give the quotation which would show that clause 5 was adopted——

Comment on this

And I gave it.

Comment on this

——and the Deputy did not give a single quotation or a single word about it.

Comment on this

I gave the quotation.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will refer to page 220 of the Dáil debates of the September 1920 Session, he will find that:

"It was here decided to take up the clauses of the memorandum separately, and the Secretary for Local Government proposed, and M. Staines (St. Michan's, Dublin), seconded the adoption of clause 4 of the memorandum down to and including sub-clause (h)."

Then there was a certain discussion on the matter, and, coming down to page 221, we read:

"The adoption of clause 4 of the memorandum, amended to read as follows, was then put and carried."

Comment on this

Just before that the discussion of the financial proposals first was suggested.

Comment on this

Clause 4 was discussed first, and Clause 4 was put and carried. The terms of Clause 4 are on page 221.

Comment on this

But on page 220—you are looking at it now—what did Deputy Dolan propose?

Comment on this

I am trying to help the Deputy. Clause 4 was discussed first, put and carried, and the terms are given on page 221. Then the Secretary for Local Government moved the adoption of Clauses 1, 2 and 3, and there was some discussion on that; and, at the end of page 222, on an amendment by Deputy MacEntee—now the Minister for Finance—being lost, the original motion was then put and carried—that is, Clauses 1, 2 and 3.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Then, on page 223, at the suggestion of the Secretary for Local Government: "the proposals in Clause 5 for collection of revenue were referred to the Finance Department for consideration."

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Now, the Deputy was asked by Deputy Cosgrave to show any way in which these proposals were adopted.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

They were referred to the Finance Department for consideration.

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

We next hear of the land annuities on the 10th May, 1922, on page 396 of the Dáil Records.

Comment on this

Oh, no. You are skipping. I want to intervene for one moment.

Comment on this

I am going to give the Deputy the benefit of my perusal of these books.

Comment on this

You have skipped one important speech.

Comment on this

The Deputy can go back and fill in anything he likes in the picture, but I want to give him the picture and to take him to page 396.

Comment on this

On a point of correction——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not entitled to rise on a point of correction. The Deputy in possession may quote what he likes, if it is relevant.

Comment on this

I quite understand, Sir, but if, during his quotations, he is omitting an important speech by Deputy Cosgrave——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a matter for the Deputy in possession.

Comment on this

I offered the Deputy every facility in this House in his own time, and I am refusing to give way to him now for the simple reason that when faced here with Deputy Cosgrave on a second occasion, he completely misconstrued and refused to understand Deputy Cosgrave's remarks, and he came back again on Friday——

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

——into a discussion on this matter without having referred in any way to the point made by Deputy Cosgrave.

Comment on this

I certainly did not.

Comment on this

Therefore, I pass to page 396, on the 10th May, 1922, when Mr. Art O'Connor, described as the Minister for Agriculture of Dáil Eireann since a particular date, says:—

"While the British were in occupation of this country and fighting against us very bitterly, a proposition was put up to me many times that we should retort by not paying land annuities. I declined to agree to that policy on the plea that it was killing the credit of the nation, that even though the English were our enemies, the Irish people had contracted to borrow a certain sum of money on certain terms, and that they should fulfil the terms of that contract."

That was in May, 1922.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That is, about five months after the Heads of the Working Arrangements for Implementing the Treaty had been signed by the representatives of the Provisional Government. They were published afterwards in 1923, and on page 9, as part of the Agreement, it is stated:

"That, pending a definite arrangement for capitalisation, the Irish Government be responsible for the recovery of payments due in respect of local loans and the collection of Land Purchase Annuities, and for paying over the proceeds to the British Exchequer, together with an amount equal to certain expenditure still borne on the British Votes or charged on the Consolidated Fund of the United Kingdom (e.g., pensions of civil servants, payments for any agency services and salaries of judges)."

Five months after that, we had the man who was Minister for Agriculture in the old Dáil Cabinet, and who was, no doubt, at that particular time, shadow Minister of the Opposition Cabinet, making the statement that I have quoted in respect of the old attitude of the Minister for Agriculture in the Dáil to the question of the land annuities.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy, but I wish to intervene for one moment——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Unless the Deputy in possession gives way, he may not be interrupted.

Comment on this

But the Deputy has the speech there before him.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must resume his seat. He is entitled to interrupt only on a point of order.

Comment on this

The Deputy already has dealt with this matter on three occasions in the House, and it is for the purpose of trying to get the Deputy to do things more consistently that I am refusing to give way to him at the present time. I say that the thing of shreds and patches which the President held up here on Friday last is a thing which saved this country from what he considered was a debt that would cost this country £19,000,000 a year——

Comment on this

Will the Deputy read——

Comment on this

——and if there is any document that ought to be preserved it is that Agreement, in whatever form it is put together, however shreddy and however patchy it may be; because it is, as I say, a document that has saved this country from a debt that the President considered would take £19,000,000 a year out of this country.

Comment on this

You will not quote it even yet.

Comment on this

Again, the President has no practical proposals for settling our difficulties financially with Great Britain. We tell him that we have built up the machinery for him and that he can sit down at a particular table, undisturbed by force or threats of any kind, and can have there the assistance of the representatives of Australia, who owe a similar debt, however contracted, to that which we owe ourselves, and of the representatives of New Zealand, who owe a debt of approximately one-third of the debt we owe at the present time. If the integrity and the unity of the nation have to be re-established, how does the Minister think he is going to bring that about except by sitting down around the same council table? As I said, the policy of the President with regard to the unity of our country is indicated in a statement made to the representative of a cross-Channel paper and reported on 3rd August, 1932. In that statement the President said: "We cannot take any practical steps ourselves." No practical steps can be taken to achieve unity. No practical steps can be taken to settle our financial difficulties. No practical steps can be taken to deal with our trade difficulties with Great Britain. Why? Because we have leaders in Ireland to-day who will not lead. They are not cast in the traditional mould of Irish leadership. They are not cast in the mould to which I referred before as being the traditional mould, the mould indicated in Collins's statement on 19th December, 1921, when, dealing with his journey to England, he said:

"I knew, when I was going over there, that I was being placed in a position that I could not reconcile and that could not, in the public mind, be reconciled with what they thought I stood for, no matter what we brought back—and if we brought back the recognition of the Republic —but I knew that the English would make a greater effort if I were there than they would if I were not there, and I didn't care if my popularity was sacrificed or not. I should have been unfair to my own country if I did not go there. Members of the Dáil remember that I protested against being selected."

Collins led. Being an Irish leader, he accepted the responsibility and incurred the danger of Irish leadership. So did O'Connell. He left it open to any type of small boy to disparage his name as an Irish nationalist in his day. Redmond did the same in his time. He pursued a line of policy that he thought was right and led, with his political reputation gone as far as a very considerable amount of propaganda and public opinion at that time went. Pearse gave his life. An Irish leader, with a particular line of thought, he was able to stand on a platform with John Redmond in 1912 and tell the people who did not want to accept the proposals Redmond was dealing with then, that it would be magnificent to refuse them but it would not be war. Four years later, when Pearse saw that he was not achieving what he wanted to achieve in the way he was working, he gave his life. He pursued the line of policy that he thought was right and the line of policy that he thought would, ultimately, bring freedom and material and spiritual betterment to his people. He did not stick his heels in an office and say: "I am a statesman and statesmanship can only bear fruit in freedom." What would be our present political position if leaders in the past had taken up that attitude? Griffith gave his life, working laboriously to the last moment. He did not complain that he had not freedom to work. Collins gave his life. Cosgrave was satisfied to pursue the line of policy he pursued and to suffer any shattering of his political reputation which it might involve. He acted the part of the traditional Irish leader, entered into danger and was prepared to sacrifice his life, his liberty or his political reputation doing what he thought was the right thing to do as an Irish leader. That is why we have the President and his Ministers in the position in which they are. That work was done in the past in the traditional spirit of Irish leadership.

Our country is being destroyed to-day, both in spirit and materially, because it is looking to leaders to lead and the leaders are not leading. Then we have the stirring up of every mob element in the country and the setting of every unintelligent element in the country against the political Opposition because they dare stand on platforms made free by the efforts of the Irish people, because they dare discuss Irish political matters and dare point out the dangers and disasters into which the country is running. Surely, there is not a Deputy on the opposite side who expects the people to sit down quietly and watch their trade being ruined and their money robbed under the leadership that obtains to-day. Their country was given sovereign power over all its resources. It has a Parliament here which is sovereign in respect of everything in which the people have a practical or spiritual interest. Are the people expected to sit down and watch these resources being frittered away in the way in which the present Government are frittering them? Deputies on the opposite side will have to make up their mind on this matter. The responsibility is on top of every one of them. If they are being led into chaos and disaster, both materially and spiritually, it is their own futility, their own blindness, their own cowardice that is responsible for it. The President may carry their political cross for a few more months, but the time will come when they themselves will have to carry their political cross. The cross they will have to carry will be a heavy one. The sooner they get more closely into touch with conditions in their constituencies and the sooner they tell the President they do not see that man on the horizon who is going to change our whole economic structure, the sooner the President will be driven to turn round and use the machinery, resources and opportunities which he has for doing good, materially and spiritually, for the people of this country.

Comment on this

I am venturing to intervene for a few moments in this debate because, so far as I can observe, it is open to Deputies in this debate to discuss anything from China to Peru or from Greenland's icy mountains to India's coral strands. Therefore, I hope I may be able to say a few words without undergoing my ordinary experience of being pulled up for saying something out of order. A supercilious, a cynical and an ultra-patriotic Parliamentary Secretary—I refer, in all humility, to Deputy Hugo Flinn—in the course of his remarks the other day suggested that anybody who did not see eye to eye with his supreme highness was cursed with an inferiority complex. At the risk of being charged with this great deficiency, I beg to express my disagreement with a great many of the things which he said in the course of his argument. There are two things that seem to me to emerge from this debate and which indicate, to my untutored mind, the views of the Government. One is that anybody who, no matter how honestly or sincerely, disagrees with or attempts to criticise the President or any of his works, pomps or miracles is a traitor who deserves to be sent to Siberia or consigned to a felon's grave. The second view of the Government reminds me of Cromwell's famous, or infamous, if you wish, letter to the people of New Ross in the course of which he said:—

"As for liberty of conscience, I meddle with no man's conscience but if by liberty of conscience you mean the right to exercise the Mass, be assured that where the Parliament of England has power that will not be allowed."

The attitude of the Government is similar. They declare that they do not interfere with freedom of speech or liberty of action within the law, but if anybody has the temerity, in any district in which they have power, to tell some home truths about the Government, we know what happens. We know how meetings have been interfered with; we know how they have been broken up; and we know how disorder and disturbance have been allowed to stalk the land unchallenged and unchecked. I do not say that the policy of the present Government has been barren of some good results. I do not even aver that it is the first Government that secured or stole into office by false promises, but I do assert that its policy has been marked and marred by foolish and fatuous experiments and by wild and uneconomic expedients and I further assert that it has shamelessly and signally failed to carry out its unambiguous promises to the people, not only at the last election but at the election previously. I am not going to discuss the various matters which already have been debated at full length and in all their phases by several members of the House—the annuities question, the bounties, the tariff policy, unemployment, doles, and other questions which are, undoubtedly, of supreme importance to the people, but which, as I have said, have been already threshed out fully in this House.

With regard to the establishment of a republic, which seems to be the dream of some idealists in this House, let me say that, personally, on a number of logical grounds, I am in favour of the republican form of government if anybody will tell me how it is going to be established in the country. I think it has been pointed out again and again by Deputy MacDermot that there is nothing to prevent the present Government from declaring a republic at the present moment if they wish to do so and if they honestly believe in their own professions, but there is no good in anybody in this House appealing to Gaelic history for any sanction for a republic, because it is an ideal totally foreign to the Gael and entirely alien from their thoughts and from their aspirations. Any republicanism there is has filtered or been imported from external sources into this country and it is just as much of foreign growth as the very presence of the English here hundreds of years ago. What I am really interested in and which is the subject about which I got up to say a few words, is the administration of justice in this country. Will anybody tell me that for the past two years there has been an impartial and even-handed administration of justice in the Free State? I see by the paper this morning that Deputy Hugo Flinn, in the course of his speech in Bantry, on Sunday, said that never within the memory of living man has there been so much respect for law and order in the Free State as for the past two years.

I put it seriously to anybody in the House, is that true? Is it evidenced, for instance, by the murder of O'Reilly in West Cork, whose assassin has not yet been traced? Is it evidenced by the slaying on Christmas morning of Con Daly of Dunmanway, whose assailants are still untraced and undetected? Is it evidenced by the hurling of missiles at passing trains and omnibuses, by the felling of trees and the placing of obstructions across public roads? Is it evidenced by the burning of platforms and the firing of shots in the public streets? Is it evidenced by the unlawful interference which is going on, Sunday after Sunday, with legitimate public meetings? I do not for one moment wish to lay all the blame on the Minister for Justice and I do not lay all the blame on the Attorney-General. I certainly attribute no blame to the Civic Guards, or the Gárda Síochána, if you wish to call them so, who have been placed in a position of great delicacy and great difficulty, but I do charge the Executive Council who are in solidum responsible for this shocking and lamentable state of affairs which brings no credit to and reflects no glory on the Free State. In the course of his speech last Friday the President complained of the want of loyalty to and the lack of co-operation with the Government from the Opposition. Does he remember that some months ago Coroner Rice of Fermoy, who is and has been a professed and a prominent supporter of the Fianna Fáil Party, suggested the holding of a conference between the representatives of the various Parties in this House? Does he remember that his Eminence Cardinal MacRory was prepared to preside over that conference? By whom was the conference turned down? By the President himself, who publicly stated that probably no good would come of such a conference. Why, in those circumstances, he should complain of wilful opposition to the Government and the malicious withholding of co-operation with it, is a thing that, to me at all events, is a mystery.

On the relations between Ireland and England I will only say one word. The Creator, and as a famous Englishman once said, the ground-plan of the would, have made England and Ireland neighbours. They are next-door neighbours. They carry on extensive dealings with each other. It is to their mutual advantage that they should be on friendly terms, and that they should continue to carry on those dealings. Anybody who attempts to put asunder those whom God has joined together is certain to meet with failure and disaster.

Comment on this
A Deputy

And the divorce court.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

Is Deputy Donnelly again interrupting? Before I sit down, let me say I see one ray of hope in the present situation. I am keenly looking forward to the day when I shall see Deputy Donnelly as Commodore of the Mercantile Marine, sailing out of Dublin Harbour in charge of a brigantine flying the Jolly Roger at the foremast.

Comment on this

I had no intention of intervening in this debate, and as I am not at all prepared with any data to do so, I will not occupy the time of the House except for a few moments. I came into the House when Deputy Mulcahy was talking about the increasing trade that was being done with England by Australia, Canada and New Zealand. He seemed to take a great deal of consolation from the fact that the market was still there for those countries for meat and other agricultural products. Deputy Mulcahy quoted figures of increasing trade, but you can have a very large trade run at a loss. As I said, I am not going to occupy your time very long, but I should like to call attention to the one matter on which, perhaps, I can speak with some little knowledge, and that is butter. In January of this present year, 1934, we bought Australian creamery butter for 60/- a cwt. I have already repeated this in the House, but it does not seem to matter how many times facts are put before the Deputies. They are like water running off a duck's back. They come in here and repeat the same old slanders and misrepresentations as if they had never heard them refuted. As I said, this butter was bought at 60/- a cwt. I said that it took 10/- to bring it from Australia to England. I further added that the cost of bringing that butter from the creamery to the boat in Australia, loading it on the steamer, paying bankers' charges and brokers' charges was approximately 6/- a cwt. I further added—giving Australia a great deal of credit for the advantage over this country in turning milk into butter; it costs 22/- a cwt. here—10/- a cwt. as the cost of turning milk into butter. I brought the price down to 33/6 as the net price which the Australian farmer got. I suppose there are some farmers on the opposite side of the House. They can see what price for milk that would mean to the Australian farmers. The present price of Australian butter in England is 8d. per lb. or 74/8 per cwt.; that would allow a price of 3d. a gallon to be paid for milk. The farmers here say they cannot do anything on 3d. per gallon. They are being paid over 4d. per gallon for milk at the present moment, and they say that is not sufficient. If they were only getting 3d., what would the position be? We will take that 60/- a cwt., which allows two and two-fifth pence per gallon for their milk, and they cannot afford to produce milk at that figure. I am only just instanceing the price of butter for the simple reason that I want to come to the question of meat.

As regards the question of meat, I know nothing at all about it, but I am absolutely certain that if the price is taken in 1931, and the price in 1933 and 1934, the average price of meat will have gone down to a figure that will not pay. The Australians and the others have no opportunity of sending their goods to other markets. The markets are not there. We were assured by Deputy Mulcahy that if this Government, when they were in Ottawa, took advantage of the proposals put before them we could have this market. Perhaps I am not quoting him correctly, but at all events he indicated that the market was there for us. The market is not going to be there for us, or for anybody else if the English people want it for themselves. Charity commences at home, and it is at home that the English are going to look after it. We were told we would have no quotas, and that would not apply to the others. As a matter of fact it is going to apply to them, for the simple reason that the English are already engaged in strenuously endeavouring to supply their requirements by home products as far as they possibly can. The outlook for Australia, Canada, Argentine, and the other countries which have been supplying England with food is going to be a very dark one indeed, if they do not get on to something else; if they do not get on to exactly what the President here is attempting to do, making this a self-contained country so far as it can be self-contained. I want to emphasise this, because so far as I can see, no matter how often it is repeated, and no matter where it is repeated, in this House or outside, the same old story is told here over and over again about the English market. I am not disputing that there is an English market, and that it is going to continue for a certain time, but that time is gradually drawing to a close, and there will be no market there for either this country or any other country. The sooner Deputies of the Opposition get the cobwebs out of their brains and do some hard thinking the sooner they will realise that.

We were told by Deputy Mulcahy that they prepared the way for this Government to carry on and build up a state of prosperity in this country. The exact opposite is what has been the case. It is the case that when they were the Government they refused to prepare the ground, as they could have done, in such a way that when this economic war came on this Government and the people of the Free State could practically snap their fingers at it. They neglected to do everything that Arthur Griffith stood for—that Arthur Griffith preached. They tell us that they put on tariffs. They put on tariffs for revenue purposes.

Comment on this

That is what you did.

Comment on this

No, it is not. We put on tariffs to support the people. You put on tariffs for revenue purposes, not for protecting or building up industries. There is no use making statements of that kind. You could not prevent the importation of boots or shoes by a 10 per cent. or 15 per cent. tariff. The English could jump over that tariff wall easily.

Comment on this

That is what they did last year.

Comment on this

They are doing it still. We do not want these interruptions, as they do not lead to anything. The late Government neglected everything that any responsible, thoughtful man would have done in view of the world position and what was coming on. Deputy Burke talked about what takes place at the meetings every Sunday. He said that they cannot hold perfectly legitimate meetings without interruptions. People say, and I know it is absolutely true, that for the first 12 months this Government was in office there was practically no trouble of any sort or kind in the country. There may have been some trifling matters, and even some serious matters, but they were few and far between. But when this Government came back a second time, the people opposite realised definitely that their day was gone, and they came back to make things as difficult as possible for the present Government. They have been at it all the time, both inside and outside the House. They have never ceased to do it. They do not care what sort of statements they make and what misrepresentations they put forward as to the policy of the Government so long as they think that these will get out to the public and convince the public that this Government are doing things in a wrong way.

I hope that some of the honest, honourable Deputies on that side will begin to examine their consciences and see whether they are not contributing to a condition of things which is going to make it so difficult that the people are going to suffer. The fact is that Deputies on that side, whether they be farmers or Deputies of other kinds, cannot get it out of their heads that they and the classes they represent have been in more or less privileged positions in this country, not for generations, but for centuries. They and their supporters, and some of our supporters, have got into such bad habits by reason of our contact and association with, and the rather easy transport to the other side, that they have ideas of living far beyond the means of production as they are at present in this country. I do not care what it costs to run a country so long as you get it out of the land—the only place you can get it out of——

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Deputies can say "Hear, hear," but it is the same all over the world. Though England, Germany and many other countries may have prospered industrially, they never could have done it had it not first come out of the land. As to the uproar which is talked about, read the papers any day, and go from China to Peru, as Deputy Burke said, and what do you find? Just consult those papers and see what is happening in Spain, what is happening in Austria, what is happening in Germany, what is happening in America, and even what is happening in England. Can we show anything half so bad, notwithstanding all the efforts of the gentlemen on that side of the House to create a position in which it would be worse or as bad?

The only other point I wish to refer to is Deputy Mulcahy's statement about the statesman that sits in his office. I read the President's speech in the papers on Saturday. I never heard the President make any claim to be a statesman. He spoke about the Opposition talking about statesmanship as something that occurred often here in the debates. The President never made any claim to be a statesman. So far as the Opposition are concerned, they have shown very little statesmanship in anything they have done. They have done a horrible amount of bungling in connection with several matters committed to their care, even at the conference tables that they talk about.

Comment on this

I should like to make a few remarks on the economic war. While we have had a number of speeches on that question it seems to me that there is a definite progress being made along a certain course. Nobody, however, seems exactly to see where we are getting and we have not had much light, I am sorry to say, from the Government. We were told at the start of the economic war that the English would not retaliate. If they did not retaliate, I suppose it would be the first war in which some show was not made by both parties. The next argument that we heard was that our goods could not be done without in the English market. Unfortutunately, other goods seem to have crept in, and things seem to be going on very much the same in that market. The next argument we hear is that the English wanted the market for their own farmers. I think that if we made a present of all the arable land in this country to English farmers and planted it down in England they could not raise sufficient foodstuffs to feed the people of England. That seems to dispose of that argument. In fact, I think somebody stated here that the combined efforts of English and Irish farmers to supply that market only resulted in a very small percentage of what was being consumed being provided. The next argument that we hear is that the prices were not worth anything. Deputy Dowdall's remarks were directed along these lines. But, bad as the prices were, they seem to have been reduced to a still lower level as a result of the economic war.

The next milestone that we seem to pass is represented by the remark that the market is gone for ever. I hope it is not gone for ever from this country, but somebody else seems to have got it meanwhile. If you compare the first quarter of 1931 with the first quarter of 1934, you will find that Ireland has lost practically £5,000,000 in trade, and Canada, Australia, New Zealand and South Africa have gained over £10,000,000. They have gained twice what we have lost. Our total trade has fallen from £87,000,000 in 1931 to £55,000,000 in 1933. Our live stock trade has fallen from £18,000,000 in 1931 to £7,000,000 in 1933. What had caused that fall? People on the opposite benches say: "Oh, it is brought about by world conditions." Other people have benefited while we have lost ground. Why was that condition of things brought about? Because we are engaged in an economic war which the Government think it necessary to pursue. The next argument that has been used in this struggle is what I might describe as the hush-hush argument. In other words, if you make any criticism at all somebody across the water may hear it and make use of it, and it will show that the whole country is not solidly behind the Government as to the way in which this war is being waged. We are even told that the people who criticise are knaves and traitors. There is no doubt that posterity will describe as knaves and traitors people who kept silent even though they could see the end towards which we are drifting.

The speeches of Deputies on this side of the House amount to this. The Government have started to wage an economic war, and they certainly mentioned to the electors at the last election that they were going to raise the question of paying annuities to the British. From that they have argued that they received a mandate to raise this question with the British. I suggest the Government have not got a mandate to cease paying £5,000,000, thereby costing the country over £10,000,000. That is the position, broadly speaking. We have heard remarks from Deputies opposite to the effect that of course the English are suffering too. Undoubtedly they are. During the course of Friday's debate coal was referred to. Let us examine what is happening in the case of some commodities upon which we put an emergency duty. We put such a duty on coal, and undoubtedly English coal imports have decreased. Coal is sold in the international market at a very keen price. A few pence a ton make a very big difference. In the case of large boats that come here from the continent laden with foreign coal, what happens is they deposit their large cargoes of coal here, then leave for Cardiff and load English coal there for the Baltic. That means that we are paying an artificial price for coal purchased in the world market. We bring a ship over here at a paying freight, and, in order to get a return freight, that ship is prepared to cut the price to the very minimum. In effect, while we are keeping out English coal, we are really providing a bounty for the export of English coal in another direction.

I would like to examine in detail the circumstances connected with the importation of cement. In 1932 there were 88,000 tons of British cement imported here, together with 10,000 tons of Danish cement. We put an emergency duty on British cement and reduced the imports of that commodity in 1933 to 52,000 tons. The net result is that we have reduced the import of British cement by 36,000 tons as between 1932 and 1933. Danish cement imports, which came to 10,000 tons in 1932, were 48,000 in 1933. We reduced British cement imports by 36,000 tons and increased Danish cement imports by 38,000 tons. I would like to suggest to the Government that the Danes made a very good commercial bargain. What we are, in effect, doing is taking in Danish cement instead of British and the Danes are taking back British coal for their State railways instead of foreign coal. I do not know whether the Government are quite satisfied with that position. I would not like to suggest to them that they have any extraordinary affection for the Danes. They are our chief competitors in the market, which is described as one we could not have done without. They want now to get prices for their own farmers, we are told; and that that market has gone forever. It seems to me an extraordinary position that we are merely swapping British cement for Danish cement. I do not propose to go over any of the other commodities that we are importing.

I was very much struck, on Friday, by some of the President's remarks. It seemed to me that the case put forward, from this side of the House, that the economic war was costing us more than twice the original sum in dispute, was not answered. What did the President say in reply to that? By inference he accepted the position and told us that it did not matter, and could not be helped. He told us we were going in for a republic, that he believed that that was the ultimate goal to which we were tending and that we were preparing our economy along lines that would suit that position, that our cattle trade, whether it was paying or not, would have to be done away with because it was not suited to the economic position of this country. He went on to make some further remarks; I hope I took a right meaning from them. They certainly were news to me, namely, that the economic war which, as I have said, we pointed out we were losing, every day we were waging it, was dependent upon a whole lot of other items which would have to be settled with England, namely, the presence of English soldiers down in Cork and the presence of English troops in Lough Swilly and the question of partition.

Now, apparently, the question of partition is bound up with the economic war and will have to be settled with the economic war. I inferred that from the President's remarks, and I would like to be corrected, if I am wrong, I would have liked the President to go a little further and state whether, when the question of partition is to be settled with England, it is to be settled in the presence of the Northern Government or not. The President made some further remarks about our not being free. He said we were not free like Belgium and Holland and Switzerland. Supposing we did set up a Republic would that Republic and its status be guaranteed by anybody? Would it be an insult to say to the President that the status of the Republic should be guaranteed by England? I would like him to think about that. You could not set up a Republic within a few miles of England, and if they tried to buy off the other nations of the earth so as to command their neutrality, unless you have some one to guarantee the status of the Republic. Belgium is concerned, according to the extent of her neutrality as guaranteed by England, and I think Deputies on the other side will remember a row about the neutrality of Belgium. In fact, we all remember the talk about the scrap of paper. I do not think we have really heard enough from the President as to where this economic war is going to end. He appears to have acknowledged the case made from this side of the House, namely, that we are losing far more each year than the original sum at issue and he appears to await offers from England and possibly from the North of Ireland—I do not know whether they are probably included, probably they are when the question of partition has been raised—he appears to await offers from them as to how the question will be settled. I suppose some of us have had experience of negotiations. I do not think I ever saw any delicate question of negotiations settled along these lines. I would certainly hope that the President when closing the debate would give us some further light as to where we stand at present in the economic war. Apparently, the pure economic war of the £5,000,000 has now become entangled in a number of other issues which must be settled at the same time and, presumably in the same circumstances, as the question of the annuities.

A great deal of play has been made from the Government Benches as to the want of co-operation from this side of the House. Certainly, we never had been told what the Government's case was or what it was they were relying on. Possibly in negotiations it might be just as well not to disclose all the situation. But at least the Opposition are entitled to know what is the general trend of the position and when the Government hope to bring its struggle to a happy ending. I can only ask that the President, when he is summing up this debate, will give us some further information along the lines that he did on Friday last, information that would enable us to see how far this economic war has proceeded and what hope there is of its termination.

Comment on this

Deputy Dowdall, speaking here on the Government side, has made as remarkable a speech as has been delivered in this House since I came into it. The Deputy has stated that it has been the policy of the Government to remove the farmer from the privileged position he occupied. I would like the President to declare clearly that that is really the policy, and if Deputy Dowdall has been stating with authority the Fianna Fáil policy. It is the first time that what Deputy Dowdall has given us this evening has been stated publicly in the House, or indeed in the country to my knowledge. Instead, the Fianna Fáil Party in seeking for the votes of the farmers, stated they regarded them as a downtrodden class, and they would relieve them. They promised them that they would be relieved of overhead charges. They were going to derate them and make them prosperous in many other ways. But now the truth is out, at any rate, and it is up to the President to state whether Deputy Dowdall has not given the Government policy correctly—that is, that the Government were going to make a change from the privileged position that the farmers occupied.

Deputy Dowdall referred to other matters which were hardly worth discussing as they have been already discussed very fully. One is the question with regard to the British market. We were told by the President it was gone for ever. A few days ago the Minister for Agriculture denied that it was. The Minister for Finance since denied that it is gone. He added that this economic war must inevitably be settled, for the agricultural industry is being crippled and the cattle industry is being destroyed. These are the words of the Minister for Finance, and now Deputy Dowdall comes along and repeats here to-day what the President stated on several occasions. The Minister for Agriculture went to some pains last week to explain that the President did not mean what he said when he stated the British market was gone. He stated that what the President meant was that it was not what it used to be. Of course, everybody knows that the British market is not what it used to be. That is what we have been told now. But we all know that since the Fianna Fáil Government came into office and power the British market is not what it used to be. We, on these benches, have been criticised because we have said that very thing, but now the Minister for Agriculture agrees that what we have been saying to the people is the truth.

We have been told over and over again that there is a mandate for this agricultural policy of the present Government. They tell us they are now doing a thing that they got a mandate for at the General Election. What is their justification for the things they have been arguing about here? I have been endeavouring to study carefully and impartially the President's speeches in this House and in the country, as well as the speeches of other members of the Executive Council. I have been at great trouble to ascertain what really is their policy. I say that because it never was stated clearly and definitely by them, and I do not believe that the average citizen knows what the policy of the present Government is. However, I have not myself the slightest doubt as to what their policy is now. I have got a clear conception of it. The policy, as the President has explained on many occasions, is to go forward towards something that he admits is unattainable. He is sacrificing those things that are attainable and that are actually in our possession, for what he admits is unattainable. There is no need to sacrifice those rights that we have. The President is out for a Thirty-Two County Republic. He says it is the right of the people to have a Thirty-Two County Republic if they want it.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Yes, I agree with him. If they want it it is their right. The Vice-President, speaking last Sunday week, I think it was in Mayo, stated that in a generation, or perhaps two generations, we may get a Republic. The Minister for Agriculture, on the same day, speaking in Sligo, said that he and his Party stood for a Republic for the Thirty-Two Counties if that were possible. But if it is not possible what does he stand for? Of course, it is quite possible. What trouble can there be about it? There is nothing between them and a Thirty-Two County Republic only a Power sixty-six times as great as their own. If they are able to destroy forces sixty-six times as great as their own, they can have a Thirty-Two County Republic. All the attainable advantages that our country has secured under the Treaty are being thrown away. This country has been deprived of all these advantages without any reference at all to the Treaty of 1921 and without any reference at all to the will of the people as expressed in 1922, 1923, 1925— that is every time that this Treaty was made an issue at an election in this country.

And this is the Government who say that they are speaking in the name of the will of the people. Can anybody say that the policy of the present Government is other than in opposition to the will of the people as expressed in these three elections? The will of the people as expressed at the two last elections was not the issue of a Republic, and it was not an issue as to the smashing of the Treaty. Therefore, the President and his Government have no authority from the people to interfere with the Treaty. Yet his speech the other day and every speech he is making in the country at the present time makes it absolutely clear that his policy is to march step by step to a Republic and to destroy the Treaty step by step. It may be that he could give us a Republic if he possibly can. It is the right of the people as he conceives it to have a Republic. But then it seems he is not able to do that. The only thing he is able to do is to destroy what we have got in order that in a generation, or two generations or three generations, we may achieve his ideal.

It is easy to imagine what would be thought of a man who, let us suppose, was looking at an estate of which his father or grandfather or forefathers had been deprived many generations ago, say in Cromwell's time. Let us suppose that in those far-off days his ancestors had been deprived of this fine place. You might imagine that man living in a place of his own in the neighbourhood saying: "That fine place belongs to me all right. I hope to have it. The first thing I propose to do is to burn this place that I have. I will destroy it first and go out in the wilderness. I will stay there until I get that place." What do you think would happen that man? Of course, the police would be sent for. They would send for a doctor to examine the man to see if he was all right. The doctor would give a certificate to send him off to some institution, if not to jail then to a mental hospital. What difference is there, I wonder, in the attitude of that man and that of the President? The President is quite correct, of course, if he says that this country is absolutely entitled to its rights. But why should he destroy the rights that the people enjoy under the Treaty for rights which he himself admits he cannot achieve, which, according to the Vice-President, cannot be achieved in this generation, and which, according to the Minister for Agriculture, are in all probability impossible?

That is the position. Now it would be quite natural to imagine that the Vice-President might adopt an attitude like that: that the Vice-President would decide to take his gun on his shoulder in the martial spirit of the Republicans. I believe that he did state some time ago in Dublin that he was prepared to fight and to lead them against the enemy. It would be quite natural to expect a man of his spirit to adopt that attitude: that he would order his rearguard to blow up all the bridges so that there could be no retreat. But, I think that the President, who is so cautious, is not justified in adopting the policy of burning his nets before he sees any hope of getting anything better. The President says that he stands for a Republic, but he has not the courage of the Vice-President to go and take it. His method of getting a Republic is to appeal to Mr. Thomas, asking aim what he will do: whether he should declare a Republic or make it an issue at the next or some other general election. He wants Mr. Thomas, in playing this game, to play the first card. Mr. Thomas says, "No, it is your play.""Well, then, show me your hand," the President says. Of course, Mr. Thomas would not show his hand. He only shakes his head, and so the President will not play the game. The President has not the courage to go forward, and yet he destroys the position that the people of this country won in 1921 and have since held under the Treaty, while he has no hope of getting towards the object he has in view, an object which he is entitled to win. But I hold that he should go right about it.

We are told that the President has got a mandate for this policy. I question very much whether he has or not. We know how that mandate was secured. It was secured by promises, and when the Government were challenged about those promises one of their supporters, Deputy Dowdall, said that those promises were only statements. It is on the strength of those statements that the mandate for this step-by-step policy, a policy that is destroying the security and the independence that the people had, is being pursued. If the promises are only statements, what do the statements amount to? The President has made the statement on many occasions that the British market is gone, but the Minister for Agriculture has said that this statement means nothing: that it only means that the British market was not as good as it used to be, so that we find this position: that the promises are only statements and the statements are nothing at all. They filter through and they amount to nothing. Yet it is on the strength of a mandate secured by promises of that kind that this country is being ruined and that the farmers who are the backbone of the country are being ruined.

Deputy Dowdall said that the farmers were regarded as holding a privileged position, and that it was the policy of the Government to change that: to destroy their privileged position. Well, if that is the Government's policy they are certainly carrying it out, but when the President was seeking the votes of the people he did not tell them it was his intention to destroy the farmers and to deprive them of their privileged position. I hope that, when the President comes to reply, he will deal with that question. It is a good job at any rate that the truth is out. We will see whether the President will deny what Deputy Dowdall has stated.

The Minister for Finance, at the last general election, said that the economic war was won. That was one of the statements on which the Government were returned to power. Yet, last week we had the Minister for Finance stating in this House that the economic war must be settled. According to him, in January 1933 the economic war was won by this country, but in May, 1934, we find him saying that it must inevitably be settled. Can any mandate, secured on such promises or statements as those, justify a Government in going forward with such a reckless policy as they are pursuing at the present time: a policy that is inflicting such terrible hardships upon the main body of the people, the people who are the backbone of the nation and who are engaged in its principal industry, a policy, too, that will affect every individual in the State sooner or later? Such a mandate as that is not one that would justify a Government in taking the strong measures that have been taken by the present Government.

We were told, too, by the Government Party at the last two general elections that the Army and the Police force were to be reduced, and that taxation was to be reduced by £2,000,000 a year. How have those promises been kept? Does the manner in which they are being kept justify a continuance of the Government in office? I do not think so. Another of their promises was that unemployment was to be wiped out. We were told that we were to be provided with alternative markets. Would the President, when he is replying, tell us the value of these alternative markets? He also told the people that the economic war was to be settled: that if they were returned to power again and could say that the majority of the people were behind them the economic war was to be settled almost immediately.

Comment on this

When did I say that?

Comment on this

It was placarded all over the country.

Comment on this

I would like very much to see it.

Comment on this

I have not got it about me, but I will undertake to provide it. I am very glad to hear that statement. Was it not stated on every Fianna Fáil platform that the Government was not in a position to settle the economic war, or to procure a good settlement, unless they could show that the people were behind them?

Comment on this

Is there no difference in that? That is precisely what I did say.

Comment on this

Perhaps the President said a little more, or that some other speaker said it on his behalf?

Comment on this

That is very different.

Comment on this

The people were led to believe—and I do not think the President can deny it—that if we were to get a good settlement of the economic war there was one way, and one way only, and that was to return the President to power. He never told the country that the war was to be fought for all time; he never told it that it was his policy to destroy the cattle trade; he never told it that it was his policy to deprive farmers of the privileged position that they had so long occupied. No. I never heard that until Deputy Dowdall told us to-day. The country was told by the President that he would bring peace; that coercion was to be abolished for all time. Did he abolish coercion? If he did not, had he any mandate for it? He asked for a mandate to secure that coercion would be abolished and that peace and good will would be restored. It is idle for the President, or anyone else, to charge the Opposition with being the cause of creating trouble. He told us that the Blueshirts were doing something to bring about trouble. The fact is that things are a little quieter since the Blueshirts were started. People had to submit to things until the Blueshirts were started and stood out for the rights of the people. Before the Blueshirts were started people were afraid to go to public meetings. Unless they were going to meetings of one Party they were afraid they would be molested and their speakers shouted down. At the last general election speakers at a meeting in the town I live near could not be heard.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

You were not there.

Comment on this

I was there. The Deputy's statement is not true.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy deny that a drum was beaten while the meeting was going on?

Comment on this

I deny that you were prevented from being heard. The trouble was that no one was interested in your speech.

Comment on this

I tell the Deputy that is a lie and——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Wait a minute.

Comment on this

——he knows it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy did not know it, it would not be a lie. The Deputy must withdraw that remark.

Comment on this

I do not know if the Deputy was present that day.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There can be no qualification whatever. The Deputy's remark, "that is a lie," must be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I withdraw it. Notwithstanding what the Deputy said, it is true that a drum was beaten. It is also true that neither Dr. O'Reilly nor the candidates standing for the Centre Party, could be heard at the Cavan meeting.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is entitled to make a speech without interruption.

Comment on this

A crowd of 40 or 50 people got in front of the platform, and because of the shouting, not a single word said by the speakers could be heard. I referred to the matter before in this House. I do not want to stress it now. I only want to tell what is true. What I said cannot be denied. The Attorney-General was there. I would not mention it only for that. He was looking on.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General will deny your statement.

Comment on this

I listened to some statements made by Deputy Flinn the other day with regard to the economic war. He said that we were not in a position to settle the economic war unless we came down to the same moral standard as Great Britain. The Deputy persisted in asking if the Party on this side of the House wanted this State to descend to the same moral standard. We do not want Deputy Flinn to descend to a lower moral standard than God or nature intended, and neither do we ask him to ascend to any other standard. I suggest that Deputy Flinn should cultivate his own moral sense, and try to develop rather than to descend to any moral standard lower than the one he has naturally. In his speech Deputy MacDermot referred to the bargaining possibilities the President had at his hand. The failure of Britain to pay her debts might be used as a further bargaining asset if properly handled. I doubt if the method adopted by Deputy Flinn is the way to make most of bargaining possibilities. We are all anxious for the welfare of this country, for its honour, for the best and most honourable settlement of the economic war, and for the largest measure of freedom, whatever brand or label may be attached to it. The Opposition will be only too glad to co-operate with the President if he makes an honest effort to bring the present trouble to an end. I appeal strongly to the President not to destroy such rights as the people have, for rights that he and his colleagues admit are not possible of achievement in this generation, or perhaps in the next generation, or maybe never. I ask the President to consider the position carefully and to make an honest effort to get this country out of its difficulties. I am quite sure, if he does, he will have the whole-hearted support and sympathy of everyone on this side of the House.

Comment on this

One would imagine that as the economic war drags along slowly, at least the issues involved in the dispute would become more clear. The opposite seems to be the case. Instead of the issues becoming more clear, we find, as we go along, that there are at least three different points of view expressed from the Government Benches with regard to the economic war. There are people who would give a lot to be able to read the mind of the President on the question of the economic war. The President must not take it as coming from a mere back-bencher when I say that a number of people regard the President, rightly or wrongly, as a man who is absolutely incapable of arriving at a settlement of this dispute. He must not blame these people for having that point of view, because the history of the President is one which suggests that for him to settle this dispute with England is practically impossible. There is no need to cite instances. We are aware of the part played by the President at the time of the Treaty with England. Since he came into office we are aware of his attempts to negotiate with England. We are aware of the type of case he put up when he went to England. All these things lead us inevitably to believe that the President of the Executive Council is a man who, at least, will never settle this dispute whatever chance there is for whoever he may send to negotiate. That is the history of the President—a man absolutely incapable of making any bargain with the English people, a man who seems, to me at least, to be incapable of understanding the word "negotiation" or "settlement" as it is understood in ordinary lay and legal circles.

"Get all and give nothing" is the President's point of view. That is a great mentality to have from the point of view of the Irish people if it could be achieved in practice. If we could get everything from England and give nothing, so much the better, but who ever heard of a settlement being arrived at on those lines? Who ever heard of litigants in a dispute coming to a settlement on the basis that one party takes all and the other gets nothing? I heard the Minister for Agriculture, who apparently models himself on the President, state here in the Dáil one day, or rather ask the rhetorical question: "What are we to do? How is this thing to be settled? If we give anything to England we have lost." That is a mentality which I, at least, find it almost impossible to understand because while this hard-headed attitude is being persevered in, the trade of this country, both import and export, is being ruined. I had sincerely believed, when the Fianna Fáil Party first came into office and when they started this economic war, that no more than about a year could pass without its proving disastrous to the country and I must confess that I was absolutely wrong, in company with many others, in that belief. But I would like the President, as I see him laughing——

Comment on this

You had hoped that?

Comment on this

——to give me and other ignorant people like me some enlightenment as to when this economic war is likely to finish or, if it is not likely to finish, what its results are likely to be, because, as I have said a moment ago, we do not seem to be able to judge for ourselves what it is leading to. Does the President want to settle this, or is the economic war or the continuance of it, the instrument whereby the President is going to create self-sufficiency for this country? Is that really the position? We want to know one way or another. We want to know what to look forward to because, at the moment, this position of unrest, of doubt, of anxiety is not doing the country any good. It is difficult for business people in this country to make plans at the present moment. It is difficult to know what you can do, what outlay you can involve yourself in, if you do not know what the attitude of the Government is in regard to the economic war.

Is it the President's deliberate policy to reduce the standard of living in this country? That seems to be what is happening. The standard is, undoubtedly, going to come down. There is less money circulating in this country now by far than there was a couple of years ago, certainly far less than there was three years ago. If there is less money circulating in the country it is absolutely certain the standard of living must go down, because, as I understand, it is a principle of economics that the more money circulating in the country the higher the standard of living. I know for an absolute certainty that in this country at least £10,000,000 less money is now in circulation than was in circulation three years ago. I should like if the President would give us some clear indication of what he thinks the future of the country is going to be, say, within the next three years. He must know, as we all believe, that the idea of getting a court to settle this dispute with England, or to settle the issues in this dispute with England, is absolutely impossible. People on this side of the House—I, at any rate—are not altogether lacking in sympathy with the President in his attitude on the question of a tribunal. It seems obvious to me, for one, that it would be difficult for the people of this country to accept a tribunal the composition of which is such that its members are drawn from people whose motherland is England.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Come over here, man.

Comment on this

That, I think, has always been the view of people on this side of the House.

Comment on this

It is a pity it was not.

Comment on this

I think, without going into that question, that the day of the tribunal is dead. What we want is a business-like attitude on the part of the Government, an attitude of men who will make up their minds that they are going to compromise, that compromise is not weakness, that in order to settle this question with England compromise will have to be entered into and that some offer will have to be made to them. I understand that when he President last went across, instead of offering them something, he claimed some sum like £200,000,000 from England, based his whole case on that, and would not give way one pound in his claim. We know that if you start off with that sort of mentality you are never going to settle this dispute. We here in this country by our representatives, our Government, agreed to give a payment of £5,000,000 per annum to England. Then a new Government came into office and they put up the proposition that they are not alone going to stop the payment of that £5,000,000 but they are also claiming £200,000,000 or some such fantastic sum as a counter-claim.

I should like the President to say just a few words, if I am in order in raising this point on his Vote, with regard to the prospects of reviving, or rather creating, industrial activity in this country. So far as I understand it, last year's Budget proves one thing, if it proves nothing else, and that is that protective tariffs as protective tariffs were an entire failure. The Minister for Finance, as I understand the position, got £1,200,000 from these tariffs more than he estimated for. That is, roughly, the figure. Now, that clearly demonstrates that protection, at least for last year, has been a failure, and if I read the accounts of the Minister for Finance correctly, this year I think he is counting again on the same thing occurring. Otherwise, how could he possibly give sixpence off the income tax and the other remittances he gave in his Budget? I should like the President to tell us something on that point —as to what he thinks are the chances of a real industrial revival in this country.

Above all, however, and before concluding, I would ask the President not to throw away too hurriedly that which has proved to be a good financial success in this country. I refer to agriculture—the agricultural industry as it has been worked in this country for a great number of years. I do not profess to be a farmer or to know anything much about farming, but I know this: that the agricultural industry has proved itself to be a success in this country for a number of years. I have always thought it wrong that politicians—men who know nothing whatever about the inner workings of farming—should try to teach farmers what they should do and what sort of products they should produce in order to make a living for themselves. I think that the farming community should be left to themselves. They are the best judges of what the land produces best for them, and it seems to me to be the height of absurdity for a medical doctor to come along and tell farmers how they are to run their farms.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy apply that to the British Minister for Agriculture?

Comment on this

I am not going to hold the British Minister of Agriculture up as a model for us. Everybody knows that the British farmer is the worst farmer on the face of the earth. We have competed most successfully with the British farmer for centuries, and we are certainly not going to take the British Minister of Agriculture as our model. I think we should take—and these are my last words—Deputy Patrick Hogan, of Galway, as our model of how agriculture should be run.

Comment on this

And yet you ousted him and put Deputy Belton in his place in the Shadow Cabinet after all Deputy Hogan did for you. That was a nice way to treat him!

Comment on this

The Estimate which we have before us is, to my mind, relatively the most important Estimate of all. It is the Estimate for the Department of the President, and, after all is said and done, the whole policy carried out by other Departments really starts, I take it, from the President himself. The present economic condition of the country and the economic policy of the present Government are really two matters of vital importance. The other night, when I was speaking on the Agricultural Estimate, I alluded to the necessity, in my mind, that no matter whether speeches were made from the Front Bench of the Opposition or the Front Bench of the Government, those who made those speeches should be particularly careful as to what they said. After all is said and done, the country, anyhow, has a right to expect, from leaders and from the Front Bench of the Opposition and of the Government, statements which they would stand over; that there would be no misleading of the people in any way. Personally, I attach very great importance to any speeches made, whether in the Dáil or in the country. Statements that are absolutely true should be made, and there should be nothing misleading about them.

In volume 29 of the Official Debates, column 2, page 786, Deputy de Valera, as he then was, spoke as follows—he was alluding to the then Minister for Finance, Mr. Blythe:—

"The Minister spoke of derating, and stated that if adopted here it would be at a cost which would practically make it prohibitive, but he has closed his ears to those who pointed out that a sum which would far more than cover the cost of derating is unwarrantably exported every year. We believe that the sum paid to England is not due, and that if the greater portion of it were retained here in the Exchequer there would be no need to put on extra taxation to relieve the present burden on agriculture. We know, of course, that agriculture is our principal industry, and that seven out of every nine engaged on productive industries are engaged on the land; also that two-thirds of the wealth of the country is produced from agriculture, and, moreover, that the greater part of the remaining one-third is produced from industries ancillary to farming, such as bacon-curing, butter-making, brewing, distilling, and so forth.

"The pressure of rates is particularly severe on our farming community. If we take into account the fact that they have to compete with rivals in Great Britain itself and in Northern Ireland, who are relieved of that burden of rates, we realise what a severe handicap there exists and will remain on the farming community. As we say, we agree with the Minister that it is very difficult to say how that can be done by imposing alternative forms of taxation, but we say that there is a way which was open to a determined Minister. If the present Ministry is not prepared to take it, then we say it is the duty of members of the House who see expenditure steadily fixed at the figure given in the Estimates, about £24,000,000 — members who are interested in finding some relief where taxation is too burdensome and in providing means of employment for those who are unemployed —to get a Ministry who will see that that money is not exported."

Those are the President's words on 24th April, 1929, when he was Leader of the Opposition. Now, what has happened? Those land annuities have been held and that money has not been exported, but the equivalent amount of money has been collected by England. Then, take the rates. In that speech the President stated definitely and clearly that agriculture in this country could not compete with England unless we had full derating. That was the meaning of his speech. But what does he do? He cuts down the agricultural grant. As everybody knows, the rates in every county, at the present time, have gone up enormously. I know that there is a tremendous amount of talk about conspiracies not to pay rates. All I can say is that, going around my own county, I have never come across a single instance of any man refusing to pay his rates. My own feeling, from mixing amongst the people, is that they would gladly pay their rates if they could only make the money with which to do so. That is the trouble. We have the declaration from the President that certain things should be done. All would be well as long as the land annuities were retained. He has retained them and the result is that an equivalent sum is collected by Great Britain. The President does not apply the money he kept back to derating, as he said ought to be done.

In the latter portion of his speech, the President seemed to think that £24,000,000 was beyond the limit in the way of the burden which this country should have to bear. What does the burden amount to now? It is nearer to £38,000,000 than £24,000,000. I have said in the country and in this House that the greatest necessity at present is that people who get up to speak should face facts. That is what we want public men to do. I do not think that it is asking too much to request the President to face facts. Reading reports of speeches made by the President and other Ministers and listening to their speeches here, it is almost impossible for anybody to understand what they really mean. They all contradict one another. One Minister says that the British market is gone. Another Minister says it is not gone. A third Minister says "Thank God it is gone." One does not know what the position is owing to the speeches of Ministers. It is very plain, however, that until that market is restored in full to the people there is no earthly hope for agriculture.

We have heard the argument used regarding the quotas put up against other members of the British Commonwealth. As I said here the other night, we can do what no other member of the Commonwealth can do—we can send across fresh food to England. The other colonies cannot do that. Their produce has to be frozen before it can be sent to England. All the British Minister of Agriculture is doing is trying to preserve that particular market for the English farmer. Nobody can deny that if no food of that nature were allowed into England, England could not exist on the produce of her own farms. To go a step farther, if the only food of that nature allowed into England were the surplus we have to send, England could not exist on her own production plus our surplus. We have a better chance of reaping the full benefit of that market than any other country in the world. It is our just right because we are so situated that we can deliver the goods fresh. Ottawa, which should have been the crowning of all our hopes with regard to the agricultural community of this country, became the tomb of the farmers' hopes. Why? Simply because those who went over there had not the courage to face up to facts and thresh the whole matter out in a manly, straightforward way. If we had to-morrow as leader of the Government a man with sufficient courage to go over and thresh this matter out in England, the whole difficulty could be settled. There is no question about that. We have got the brains in this country. We have got the materials which England requires and it is only a question of making a decent, straightforward bargain. As I have said before, there is a table on the other side of the Channel with empty seats waiting for men of courage to go and thresh this matter out. Until that is done, I can see no earthly hope for the farming community here.

The President cannot get away from the statement he made that the agricultural community is the most important community in this country. I do not say that because I happen to be a farmer myself. It is simply a question of looking facts in the face. Go into any town in the Free State and you will soon realise how the very existence of the people is dependent on the prosperity of the farming community around them. There is hardly a person outside the big cities who has not got some interest in some way in agriculture. When that industry is hit, everyone is hit and the injury works its way down into the towns and even into the cities. One man is responsible for the present deplorable position—the President. I lay the full responsibility at his door. One man— the President himself—could, if he wished, settle the whole matter tomorrow. No other member of his Government could do it. However, he could do it. I ask him to sacrifice some of his pride and some of the statements he made, to throw his chest out and do the right thing even though people say he is going back on other statements. I ask him to go over there and discuss this matter as man to man. He can make a good bargain. If he does that, he will never regret it and this country will never regret it. If he does not, this country will pay for the omission and some day he will pay for it in bitter remorse.

Comment on this

Another tonic for Mr. Thomas.

Comment on this

There are really two methods by which one can judge a Government. One can judge its success or its failure by considering how the methods it adopts make for the wealth of the State, and one can judge it, also, by the way in which its actions show themselves in the preservation of the peace of the State. As a Government, looking after the material prosperity of this State, it is, in my judgment, at any rate, unquestionable that this administration must be put amongst the greatest failures of all administrations that have failed in any country in modern times. When I turn in another direction and see how justice is being administered in this State, I am driven to the conclusion that seldom, indeed, if ever, has justice been administered in a more partial— and I will go further and say a more disgraceful—manner than the manner in which this present Executive is dealing with the matter of the administration of justice in this country. Let me take that latter because, after all, it is the more important. You can have no material prosperity, you can have no wealth in this country if you have no sense of security, and you can have no sense of security unless every single person in this State is satisfied that there is a Government in office which is going to administer the law, which is going to administer it impartially, which is going to administer it without fear, favour or affection, and which is going to see that every citizen of the State is able to live his own life in his own way, free from let or hindrance by any evil-doer.

Within the last few weeks I had occasion to make many remarks of a grave nature about the administration of the Guards by the Minister for Justice, and certainly I do not believe that, even with Fianna Fáil, the attempted defence of the Minister for Justice carried the slightest bit of conviction. I am not going over the same ground again; I have left it there, but I am coming right down to what the Executive Council themselves do to prevent the fair and impartial administration of the law. I am coming down to where the Executive Council itself is deliberately leaning itself against the fair and impartial administration of justice, and where the Executive Council itself is giving examples, and the greatest of examples, of injustice done to citizens of this State. Let me take one great example. The Executive Council, under its own hand, placed its name to a shocking lie, when the Executive Council declared that an association—in its own nature, in every single one of its aims and in every single one of its objects, a perfectly lawful association; an organisation which, as a matter of fact, does credit to the young men and girls of this country who belong to it—was unlawful. You find men who have not broken the law; you find men who have lived within the law; you find men who are splendid examples to the young men of Ireland in the observation of the law, sent to prison because they are members of a lawful association which, in the teeth of all truth, in the teeth of all justice, and in the teeth of all morality, has been condemned by an unjust—and I will not hesitate to use the words—an immoral Executive Council.

Are you going to have anywhere in this country a respect for law? How can you ever expect justice to thrive in this country if you are going to have, at the very top, false declarations made against law-abiding citizens of this State because they happen to be political opponents of the Government in office? Let me pass on. Under the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, certain duties are imposed on the Executive Council. Under Section 12 of that statute, the Executive Council is, in fact, made a Court of Appeal over the Military Tribunal and it is the duty of the Executive Council carefully to see that no miscarriage of justice takes place before the Military Tribunal. If a plainly wrong verdict has been arrived at, it is the duty of the Executive Council to investigate and to quash the finding.

Comment on this

I thought that was a matter for the courts at present.

Comment on this

It is not; I am going to deal with two matters which are not before the court. I am going to deal now with two specific cases, neither of which has been made the subject matter of habeas corpus. One case came from County Tipperary. Two revolvers were found in an open shed in a man's yard, to which any single person who liked could have access. There was not one scintilla of evidence to connect the owner of that shed with possession of those revolvers. Anybody might have gone through the shed which, as a matter of fact, had three openings, two of which were not even covered by a door. That case came before the Military Tribunal and there was a conviction, in the teeth of a long series of decisions as to what constitutes “possession,” according to the criminal law. That matter was brought to the attention of the Attorney-General and, I presume, by the Attorney-General to the Executive Council, but that sentence has not been quashed by the Executive Council. A case which no judge in this country would have left to a jury has been——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Military Tribunal gave a decision. Is the Deputy not proceeding to discuss it when he says what a judge would do under similar circumstances?

Comment on this

It is the duty of the Executive Council to exercise certain powers, and I say that here is a case in which a judge would not have left the matter to a jury——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow that to go any further. A decision has been reached by the Military Tribunal. It may or not be the duty of the Executive Council to review that decision but, clearly, it is not the privilege of the Deputy to discuss what a judge would do under similar circumstances if the case came before him as against coming before the Military Tribunal.

Comment on this

I will bow to your ruling, Sir, as I always do, but I should like to impress upon you that I am not now discussing the Military Tribunal. I am discussing the non-performance of its statutory duty by the Executive Council and showing——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not at all anxious to interfere with the Deputy's line of argument, but I am anxious to prevent the decision of any court being discussed here, and it seems to me that when the Deputy says that a case which came before the Military Tribunal and was treated in a certain fashion would not be dealt with by a judge in the same fashion, under the same circumstances, there is discussion and consideration of the Military Tribunal's decision in that particular case.

Comment on this

What I am discussing, just as has been discussed in this Dáil on many occasions, is the ordinary prerogative of justice in respect of which the decisions have been discussed.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Oh, no.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon. I could actually quote instances, because when I was Minister for Justice, I know that on certain occasions the exercise of the prerogative of justice was questioned again and again in this House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy, but I do not think there is any precedent for the discussion of a decision of a court of justice in this House.

Comment on this

There is.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Even if there is, I think the Deputy will agree that the decisions of courts should not be made a subject of discussion in this House.

Comment on this

With great respect, what I want to do is this. There is a certain section—Section 12— which is the only method of appeal from decisions of the Military Tribunal, and that method of appeal is to the Executive Council. I submit that every action of the Executive Council is subject to discussion in this House. When the Executive Council have acted in an improper fashion it is necessary for me to point out the facts of the cases in which they have acted in that improper fashion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not object to the facts of the case being discussed. I do not object to arraigning the Executive Council for what the Deputy considers is failure to do its duty in certain circumstances, but I think the House will be with me when I say that the decision of any court should not be discussed here. To do so clearly does not make for the ideal administration of justice.

Comment on this

On the point you have raised from the Chair, might I bring to your memory that on one occasion I raised here the matter of a county court case in which a man was charged and convicted of an indecent assault. Despite that fact, he was released by the then Minister for Justice, now Deputy Geoghegan. I raised that matter in Parliamentary questions, and afterwards on the adjournment. In the course of his reply the Minister said, and was allowed to say, referring to certain expressions used by the judge, that they were shocking, that they should not have been used by him and were contrary to the office he held. I do not know whether or not you desire to continue that precedent, but at any rate there is the precedent. On the second point there is, in the Constitution Amendment (No. 17) Act, power given to the Executive Council to review decisions. If it is ever allowed to ask the Executive Council are they going to review decisions, where does the opportunity better arise than on the Vote of the head of the Government, to discuss by what method the Government in this matter should review the decisions and discharge the findings of the Military Tribunal? When that point has to be raised, it is not necessary that the facts and circumstances of the case should be disclosed to the House?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

But not the decision.

Comment on this

The decision is simply stated, but the facts and circumstances may be commented upon. If one is disposed to argue that the facts and circumstances warrant the Executive Council in changing the sentence, by implication if not explicitly, the statement has got to be made or the insinuation has got to be passed that the Tribunal in this case should not have acted as it did. How else can the case be argued?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not for me to discover that for the Deputy. The facts of the case may be discussed and the Executive Council's action may also be discussed, but when Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney proceeded to say that a judge would not, in similar circumstances, do so and so, he clearly was indicating that the Tribunal had not dealt with the case in a proper fashion.

Comment on this

With great respect, no. There is no court which will not occasionally make mistakes; it is in human nature to err. Surely to goodness, I am not in the slightest way attacking the honesty of the Tribunal when I say that they did in fact make a mistake, and that it was the duty of the Executive Council to rectify that mistake.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not the honesty of the Tribunal that is in question, nor is it the honesty of a judge or of a court. The point is that we cannot allow this House to interfere with the judiciary in doing their work, or with the courts in doing their work.

Comment on this

But surely there is a distinction between the judiciary——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I said the courts.

Comment on this

——between the courts and the Military Tribunal. I make a distinction, because we have specifically precluded members of the House from dealing with the courts in the ordinary way. Judges' salaries are not on an annual Vote. There is nobody answerable for their conduct. They are free and independent. The Military Tribunal is tied up with the Government. Their actions are reviewable only by the Government. The salaries of its members are paid by the Government, and borne here on an annual Vote. Surely there is a plain distinction?

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was not allowed to continue his argument, so I do not quite know what line he was going on. You will remember that this court is not bound by the ordinary rules or laws of evidence which govern other courts. It did seem to me that what the Deputy was going to point out was that a judge, controlled by laws of evidence, would perforce have found in a certain way; that the Military Tribunal, not being tied by laws of evidence, there is still protection for the prisoner brought before it in that the Executive Council —which should be the fountain head of justice—can review his sentence. Although the Deputy was not allowed to continue his argument, I understand that he was going to point out that this, pre-eminently, was a case for the Executive Council to take cognisance of, because it arose from the circumstance that the Military Tribunal was created to act in a different way from an ordinary court, and that arising out of that fact there was a miscarriage of justice which should have been rectified by the Executive Council.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot say off-hand what precedents have been established here. Deputy McGilligan has quoted something which has happened, and which I daresay is on record. The practice, as far as I remember, and every member of the House remembers, is that decisions of courts are not reviewable here. If we allow decisions of one court to be reviewed it will be very difficult to keep decisions of other courts from being reviewed also, and that would certainly be highly injurious to the administration of justice.

Comment on this

The matter of the special powers conferred on the Executive Council is the only matter I am dealing with, and I submit that this is the only place, and this the only Vote on which it can be dealt with. If persons are unjustly imprisoned, and it is the duty of the Executive Council to release those persons, surely it is the duty of a Deputy in the Dáil—and in consequence of its being his duty it ought to be within the rights of a Deputy in the Dáil—to bring those facts to the public notice, and to the notice of every member of this House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am only precluding the Deputy from discussing the decision of the Military Tribunal.

Comment on this