Committee on Finance. - Vote No. 11—Public Works and Buildings.
Contributions 1–145 of 289. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
Go ndeontar suim ná raghaidh thar £593,216 chun slánuithe na suime is gá chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá Mhárta, 1936, chun caiteachais i dtaobh Foirgintí Puiblí; chun coinneáil-suas Páirceanna agus Oibreacha Puiblí áirithe; agus chun déanamh agus coinneáil-suas Oibreacha Dréineála.
That a sum not exceeding £593,216 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1936, for expenditure in respect of Public Buildings; for the maintenance of certain Parks and Public Works; and for the execution and maintenance of Drainage Works.
Comment on this
This represents an increase of £133,653. Under sub-head A—Purchase of Sites and Buildings—there is an increase of £31,000, made up principally by the purchase of the reversionary interest of the Dublin Corporation in the site of the Custom House, amounting to £14,000 odd, and the cost of sites for Volunteer Drill Halls, Gárda Síochána Barracks, and similar items. Under sub-head B—New Works, Alterations and Additions—there is an increase of £224,113, made up principally of grants for the building, enlarging and so forth of National Schools, £80,000; Galway and Ballyvourney special schools, £18,000; the reconstruction of the old Viceregal Lodge as a Folklore Museum, £10,000, and about £100,000 on drill halls. I think that that is all that really specially arises on this Vote.
Comment on this
I move that the Estimate be reduced by £100 in respect of sub-head B. Sub-head B provides for a certain amount of money for reconstruction of the General Post Office, and a Supplementary Estimate on the same sub-head, in August last, provided £1,000 for the provision of an Easter Week memorial in the General Post Office. On the last day of the Summer Session, in August last, and about half an hour before the adjournment was moved, the Minister for Finance introduced an Estimate for £1,000 and explained that it was proposed to set up a bronze memorial in the General Post Office, as a memorial to the men who fell in the Post Office during Easter Week. The matter was introduced in a most haphazard way. Deputy Cosgrave pointed out at the time that it was an unreasonable action on the part of the Government, and that it was a very inadequate action on their part. He pointed out that neither was the form of the memorial nor the time suitable, and that there should have been some understanding with the particular people who were concerned with the Rising in Easter Week. He pointed out that they should have been consulted in the matter, and that there should have been some understanding that they agreed that the action that was proposed to be taken was in some way suitable and that there would be general harmony between all parties concerned with the Government's action. There was no time to discuss the matter adequately. It was introduced without any previous notice to the House generally and was presented practically as a fait accompli.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I do not think, Sir, that this is in the Vote at all. It seems to have been in a Supplementary Estimate voted last year.
Comment on this
I am referring to page 47, item No. 82, General Post Office Reconstruction, where a certain amount of money has been provided for work in the Post Office and where reference is made to the sum of £1,000 voted for the provision of an Easter Week memorial in the last Vote.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not discussing the book of Estimates. He is discussing the Estimate before him and, as far as I understand, that £1,000 is not on this Estimate.
Comment on this
I am referring to the £300,000 provided for under item No. 82, and in connection with that I wish to refer to the following paragraph appearing in the Press yesterday.
Comment on this
I would draw attention to the fact that at present work is being carried out at the General Post Office and expenditure is being incurred——
Comment on this
There is a sub-head B here in the Vote for the Office of Works for "New Works, Alterations and Additions." Somebody is paying for the work which is at the present moment being done in the General Post Office with reference to which Deputy Mulcahy was about to read an extract from the Press. The submission is that the expenditure on that work will be defrayed under a sub-head of the Office of Works Vote, which is described as "New Works, Alterations and Additions."
Comment on this
There is no proof that this money is being expended on the work that Deputy Mulcahy is referring to. The Parliamentary Secretary says it is not.
Comment on this
He did not say that. He said the particular £1,000 referred to here belonged to last year's Estimate. That does not finish the matter. In any case, the expenditure is going on which is included in the £300,000.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not know. I submit that the only entry in this which could concern the G.P.O. is "Provision of Easter Week, 1916, Memorial" and no money is provided for that.
Comment on this
Before he proceeds to draw attention to anything, I want to know if what the Deputy is going to refer to is expenditure provided for in this Vote. The Parliamentary Secretary says it is not.
Comment on this
I assert here that £300,000 under Item 82 on page 47 of the Estimates provides money for paying for that work which is being carried out at present at the General Post Office for the purpose of making a Fianna Fáil holiday and I object to the expenditure of that money.
Comment on this
That is one thing, but the Parliamentary Secretary says that this money is not being expended for the purpose which the Deputy referred to.
Comment on this
I decline to accept the Parliamentary Secretary's statement when we see a notice in the Press that work is being carried out by the Office of Works at the General Post Office.
Comment on this
How can the Deputy relate that to the money which is being provided for here? I have no proof that that is the case—that the work is being carried out and that money is being provided for it here. I must take the word of the Parliamentary Secretary, as he is the head of the Department concerned.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary say where the money is being provided for the work which is being carried out at the General Post Office at present?
Comment on this
On a point of order, it is not my business to answer any such question. The only person who can ask me anything on a point of order is the Chair, and the Chair has not asked that question. The Deputy was asked what he raised it on, and he told us specifically that he raised it on Item 82, page 47. The only thing in Item 82 which concerns this matter is "Dublin General Post Office—Provision of Easter Week, 1916, Memorial, £1,000," which was voted last year.
Comment on this
The portion which definitely refers to the matter which the Deputy wants to raise has no money under it.
Comment on this
It is not for me to show; it is for the Deputy to show the Vote in this in which that is included.
Comment on this
I am showing the Parliamentary Secretary that there is money provided in Item 82 to pay for certain work at the General Post Office, and the work that is being carried out to-day at the General Post Office must be paid for out of that £300,000, or out of some Supplementary Estimate to be provided later. I submit that it is nonsense to think that a Supplementary Estimate can be provided later.
Comment on this
I submit, on a point of order, that the reference here to the specific matter which the Deputy has raised specifically states that there is no money under it. I am not going to object in the slightest; but there is direct evidence that this thing is mentioned, and that no money is provided for it.
Comment on this
May I submit that if, under any heading in this Estimate, money is being expended by the Office of Works at the General Post Office at present, the Deputy is entitled to raise it on the Estimate under any heading? I suggest that the point raised by the Parliamentary Secretary is not really a point of order at all, but a point of obstruction.
Comment on this
No. The position, as the Chair sees it, is that Deputy Mulcahy wishes to raise a particular matter. He referred to that matter on rising to speak. It had reference to the Easter Week Memorial in the General Post Office. In the Book of Estimates there is no money provided for that. The Parliamentary Secretary, who is head of the Department, and who knows what money is being expended on that matter.
Comment on this
I want to point out that it is publicly known that work is being carried out in the General Post Office which must be paid for out of money provided under sub-head B of this Estimate. I want to discuss the matter on sub-head B, on the motion I have put down.
Comment on this
I cannot relate the work being done at the General Post Office to-day with money provided here. The Parliamentary Secretary tells me that there is no money provided here for work being done in the General Post Office in connection with the particular matter which the Deputy wishes to raise.
Comment on this
But I am not going to be deprived of my right as a Deputy to discuss a matter, which I am entitled to discuss here, by the Parliamentary Secretary wriggling about any matter here. I propose to discuss on my motion the particular piece of work at present being carried out at the General Post Office and I am going to explain why I object to the expenditure of public money on this work.
Comment on this
I want to assure the Deputy that there is nobody anxious to help anybody to wriggle. The Chair is not anyway, and the Chair is not anxious to prevent Deputy Mulcahy from doing what he is entitled to do. As to the particular item to which the Deputy refers, there is no money on the Estimate for it.
Comment on this
There is a sum of £300,000 for general work in the General Post Office and this piece of work which is being carried out is going to be paid for out of that.
Comment on this
May I ask, Sir, for a ruling on the matter of order one way or the other? It will be quite satisfactory to me whichever way the Chair gives it.
Comment on this
I resist any invitation on the part of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Chair to shut me up on this matter. I have a right to discuss this matter here and I am going to discuss it.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary is quite entitled to raise a point of order. No attempt is being made to prevent Deputy Mulcahy from speaking. The Chair would not allow anybody to prevent any Deputy from speaking who is within his rights. But the Deputy wants to discuss a matter as to which I have no proof that there is any money provided in the Estimates. I cannot allow the Deputy to proceed along that line.
Comment on this
Under sub-head B here, to widen the matter, there is a sum of £521,013 provided for new works, alterations and additions. At the General Post Office, Dublin, alterations and additions and, to a certain extent, new works are being carried out, and I propose to discuss these works and to object to the expenditure of public money on them.
Comment on this
I prefer that opinion may be expressed in its widest interpretation, on the principle that it is on sub-head B of the Vote alone and is not supposed to relate to the 82 items.
Comment on this
I am not concerned with what the Parliamentary Secretary thinks is desirable. If Deputy Mulcahy wishes to discuss it with particular reference to a matter for which no item is specifically provided, we will find ourselves in a difficulty. If the Deputy wishes to discuss the entire expenditure of £300,000 nobody wants to prevent him.
Comment on this
Surely Deputy Mulcahy is entitled to discuss any item covered by the £300,000. It need not be specifically set out in the Estimate. Deputy Mulcahy has spoken of £300,000 that is being provided for work being carried out at the General Post Office, and I submit that he has a perfect right to discuss it.
Comment on this
Does not Deputy Morrissey agree that Deputy Mulcahy has created a good deal of his difficulty by stating that he wants to discuss a particular matter for which no money was provided?
Comment on this
Whether he did or did not is beside the point. Whatever the Deputy said, his rights remain and are not to be sidetracked by the submission of the Parliamentary Secretary. I submit that the Parliamentary Secretary is trying to create the position that when he says so certain things must be accepted, not only by the House but by the Chair. That is a new precedent.
Comment on this
The difficulty with the Chair is that Deputy Mulcahy proposes to raise a particular matter for which no money was provided. I have indicated to Deputy Mulcahy that if he wishes to discuss the expenditure of the entire amount, £300,000, I am not going to prevent him.
Comment on this
I was ruled out of order the other evening when discussing an Estimate because no money was provided. Deputy Dillon objected and I had to stop when no money was provided in the Estimate. Surely the Chair is not going to make one rule for one Deputy and a different rule for Deputy Mulcahy.
Comment on this
The rule made by the Chair the other evening was in accordance with Standing Orders.
Comment on this
The following appeared in the Irish Times of April 11th:—
"With a uniformed policeman and three detectives in plain clothes standing nearby, workmen were busy in the General Post Office, Dublin, yesterday, on what is presumably the base for the statue of Cuchulann, the official memorial to the men who were killed in 1916. It will be recalled that the statue, which had been in the public hall of the General Post Office for a long time, was removed last week by men employed by the Office of Public Works.
"President de Valera will formally unveil it during the remembrance celebrations on Easter Sunday morning."
I object to the expenditure of money on that object in the particular circumstances in which it is now being spent. I indicated that in August last when, without previous notice to the House and half an hour before the Adjournment Motion was taken closing the session for the summer, the Minister for Finance, in a most casual way, asked the House to grant £1,000 to be spent in putting up a memorial to the Easter Week men at the General Post Office. Certain criticism was made against that. There was no vote against it because it came on in an unexpected way at the end of the session. It was, however, indicated that this was going to be a national thing, a State thing, that the occasion was one to honour the men of 1916, one that was to be an honour to this State, and one to help to unify the various Parties in the State. No exception was taken since to the matter until an advertisement appeared in the Irish Press early in March indicating that a Fianna Fáil flag day was to be run on Palm Sunday, Holy Week and Easter Sunday. There was disseminated to the Press the information that the President was going to unveil the memorial on Easter Sunday, that there was to be a big procession of men who were out in 1916, that the Army was to parade, that Volunteers were to be brought from all parts of the country, and that there was to be a big military display. No invitations have yet been issued by the President or by the Government or anything done to indicate that this is being carried out out of State finances.
Comment on this
Surely this has nothing to do with the reconstruction of the General Post Office. I allowed the Deputy to discuss the expenditure of £300,000 in connection with the reconstruction of the General Post Office but he is now proceeding to tell us something about a ceremony that is to take place.
Comment on this
I propose to indicate that this money is being spent to make a Fianna Fáil Party collection, and that this is part of the way in which State money is being used under cover of having a State ceremony, to provide funds and possibly political capital for the Government Party.
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate that I cannot allow him to discuss the type of ceremony that is going to take place, who is going to be invited or in what way it will be carried out. I allowed him to discuss the proposed expenditure of £300,000 in connection with the reconstruction of the General Post Office. Surely that cannot be related to a military display or any such thing.
Comment on this
We cannot leave out mention that public money is being spent on an alleged official occasion when Ministers' replies have indicated that this is purely a Party matter, and that so far from bringing about unity in the country——
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot proceed along these lines. I want him to be perfectly clear about this. An expenditure of £300,000 on the reconstruction of the Post Office cannot be related in any way to a flag-day for any Party, to a military display, or invitations to a ceremony.
Comment on this
I protest that I am being wrongly ruled against, and that I am entitled to put before the House simple details of the position in order to show what the Government is doing with this money and why it is doing it.
Comment on this
The Deputy has not been wrongly ruled against. He can have his own opinion. I do not object to that. Connecting the reconstruction of the General Post Office with military parades, invitations to a ceremony, and who is going to send the invitations, is something that I cannot see.
Comment on this
May I submit that if representation is made in this House that out of the £521,000 provided in sub-head B, and if the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is asked if part of that money is being provided for the purpose of having a Fianna Fáil platform in O'Connell Street, we are entitled to describe the circumstances of the alterations and to protest to this House that that is not the way to spend the money.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy please allow me? I cannot allow the Deputy to proceed on any other lines than the expenditure of £300,000 on the reconstruction of the General Post Office. I will not hear him any further in reference to the ceremony or to invitations, who is going to be invited or who is going to invite.
Comment on this
And I insist on my rights to tell this House what is happening in the use of this money, and that this money is being used to provide——
Comment on this
I will not, Sir, because this House is being asked to vote money and this House is entitled to hear what this money is being spent on.
Comment on this
I have no desire to be disorderly in any way, but I think it is quite wrong that this House should be throttled in this way——
Comment on this
I want to warn the Deputy. I have sent for the Ceann Comhairle to report the Deputy's deliberate disobedience to the rules of the Chair and will ask that he be suspended.
Comment on this
And I will ask the Ceann Comhairle to adjudicate on the extent to which we can be cloaked up here in this House by the political difficulties of the Government Party. We are defending decency and order in the State against a Government that care more for Party than they do for the State and that care more for Party than they do for the nation, the spirit of which they are breaking up into pieces.
Comment on this
Are we at liberty to submit to you, Sir, the point of order which has been under discussion?
Comment on this
I understand that the Leas-Cheann Comhairle gave a ruling that a certain matter was not in order on this Vote and that a Deputy refused to accept that ruling.
Comment on this
There is provision made in this Estimate for the expenditure of £521,000 on new works, alterations and additions in sub-head B. In connection with that, Deputy Mulcahy was drawing attention to certain expenditure on certain new works, alterations and additions going on at the General Post Office and, in doing so, he was describing the surrounding circumstances which, in his opinion, made that expenditure improper. He was ruled against by the Leas-Cheann Comhairle and I think it is only right that it should be stated, while, of course, nobody challenges the good faith of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that it is the unanimous opinion of us on this bench that this ruling was unfair and oppressive.
Comment on this
There must be no comment of that nature. I call on the Leas-Cheann Comhairle to report.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy, in the first instance, indicated that he desired to raise the question of expenditure in connection with a specific item in the book of Estimates. The Parliamentary Secretary pointed out that there was no expenditure provided this year in connection with that particular item, and that it had been voted on last year. Some further discussion took place, but I ultimately indicated to Deputy Mulcahy that I was prepared to hear him on the £300,000 money which is provided there for expenditure in connection with reconstruction, etc., in the General Post Office. Deputy Mulcahy proceeded to discuss that for a little while. He proceeded then to tell us about a ceremony that was to take place in connection with the unveiling of the Easter Week memorial in the General Post Office, and proceeded to speak about the celebrations, military parades, invitations and who were to send the invitations, and who were to be invited. I indicated very definitely to Deputy Mulcahy more than once that I could not connect the ceremonial, the invitations to the ceremonial, or who were to be invited and who were to invite, with the expenditure of £300,000 for reconstruction work in the General Post Office. I definitely indicated to Deputy Mulcahy that I could not allow him to proceed on those lines. He deliberately disobeyed that ruling and continued to speak. I sent for you, Sir.
Comment on this
I indicated that there was work being carried out to-day at the General Post Office and that that work was provided for under the £300,000 in sub-head 82 on page 47, or, at any rate, under the £521,013 provided under sub-head (b) and that that work was being carried out in connection with a Supplementary Estimate passed in August last for carrying out the purchase and erection of a monument there.
Comment on this
I submit, Sir, that you are being put in the position of deciding between the veracity of my statement and the veracity of Deputy Mulcahy's statement, and I submit that you should not be put in that position, since you were not here.
Comment on this
If it is a question of my dealing with the matter in this particular way creating a conflict as between myself and the Leas-Cheann Comhairle for the Ceann Comhairle, I do not wish to approach it in that way.
Comment on this
I would approach it by putting to the Ceann Comhairle the line of argument I was pursuing on this item and the line of argument which, I think, I have the right to pursue.
Comment on this
I am not discussing Deputy Mulcahy's attitude. I am endeavouring to be the Leas-Cheann Comhairle here and not a Deputy. It is rather difficult. I am putting to the Ceann Comhairle this position: I ruled on an incident that was specified definitely and intimately before me; we are putting the Ceann Comhairle now in the position of deciding whether my version is the correct one or whether Deputy Mulcahy's is the correct one.
Comment on this
Do I understand from the Leas-Cheann Comhairle that he objects to my addressing you, Sir?
Comment on this
Do I understand from the Leas-Cheann Comhairle that he objects to my addressing you? I would like to be clear what he wishes me to do.
Comment on this
Did you not defy the Leas-Cheann Comhairle's ruling?
Comment on this
The Leas-Cheann Comhairle's ruling should have been obeyed. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle ruled definitely on a certain matter and the Deputy refused to accept that ruling.
Comment on this
Then I shall have to ask the Deputy to retire from the House for the remainder of this day's sitting.
General Mulcahy withdrew.
Comment on this
I say that Deputy Mulcahy was ruled out of order very wrongly. He is a partial Leas-Cheann Comhairle.
Comment on this
I must ask the Deputy also to withdraw from the House.(Interruptions.)
Deputy Coburn withdrew.
Comment on this
On a point of order. A very serious matter has occurred and I think that the remarks made by members of the Government Benches are most disorderly at this particular stage, particularly that one of "passing the buck."
Comment on this
May I submit now that the matter of Deputy Mulcahy's refusing to obey has been dealt with, that the point arises as to whether a Deputy is in order in objecting to the expenditure of public moneys——