Committee on Finance. - Vote 32—Office of the Minister for Justice (Resumed.)
Contributions 152–308 of 308. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I think that line should not be continued by the Deputy. He has the opportunity of asking that the matter be inquired into by the Department and disciplinary action, if necessary, taken, but when he asserts that an official did certain things the outcome of the resulting investigation should not be prejudiced by a statement here.
Comment on this
Is it not in order to say what is a fact: that a policeman on the streets of Dundalk went across to a man and asked whom he was looking at, and said: "I shot for cattle before and I will shoot again"? Is it not in order to make a complain of this kind when discussing the Estimate for the Department of Justice here?
Comment on this
I am not anxious to curb Deputy Coburn at all, but if there is a charge made against a public servant and if there is the possibility, or the likelihood, of an inquiry into that charge, it is not right that that inquiry should be prejudiced by a statement here.
Comment on this
An example has been given on the matter that is symptomatic of a certain class of persons in the Guards at present, and surely it is in order to draw attention to a fact of that kind when discussing this Estimate?
Comment on this
I allowed the Deputy to proceed as far as I thought it was desirable. My attention was called to it earlier, but I allowed him to proceed because he had not made any charge at the time that the point of order was raised first, but now he is making a specific charge which probably will be inquired into by the Department.
Comment on this
I am not concerned with what the Deputy thinks. I have to consider what is the ordinary normal course that will be taken by the Department, and if an inquiry is held I do not think it would be fair to that particular Guard that the inquiry should be prejudiced by any further statements here on the matter.
Comment on this
I would be long sorry to make any charge that I could not substantiate. The only regret I have is that it was not to me that Moore came—this great fighting man, with two revolvers in his pocket and a Thompson gun in his motor car. That is the only regret I have, because he would find, in the words of the song commemorating '98, "That good men and true men are plenty here to-day." They would be there in Dundalk to meet Mr. Moore or any Fianna Fáil Deputy who cares to join with him in shooting down harmless, inoffensive men. I would not make any statement that I could not substantiate, and it is because I have such a high opinion of the general body of members of the Gárda Síochána—there is a very high opinion held of that force at the present time—that I do not want it lowered one iota by the actions of a particular member of the force. But Moore has made those statements, and I want to know is it essential that, in the discharge of his duties, he should deliberately insult and threaten a respectable citizen of the County Louth whose family and ancestors have always stood for law and order? I want to know from the Minister is it right and proper that such a man should be kept in the force?
As I said earlier, I pride myself on the fact that the County Louth at the moment is a quiet county in so far as this particular thing regarding seizures is concerned. That is due, in a great degree, to the attitude of the public men in the county. We have the courage to advise the people to do the right thing at the right moment and we do not want our efforts for the preservation of law and order thwarted by the actions of men of the type of Moore who, on his own admission, and I repeat it here, shot an innocent man in Cork and has said that he is prepared to shoot more men in Louth.
Comment on this
These statements should not be repeated. I have told the Deputy that he has gone far enough in that case.
Comment on this
There has been an inquiry into it, and not alone has this man not been convicted, but he has been praised and clapped on the back by the Minister.
Comment on this
If an inquiry has been held, has the decision been promulgated? If not, does the Deputy not see that he is prejudicing a fair trial?
Comment on this
With all respect, I am not going to argue the question; but, so far as I know, the case is finished and a decision has been arrived at.
Comment on this
The Minister says that proceedings are pending and I think the Deputy, in fairness to that particular person, should allow the matter to end here.
Comment on this
We will pass from that. I am here, as I have said, as a Deputy representing the County of Louth and I am going to do my duty in spite of what Deputy Kennedy, or any other member of that Fianna Fáil Party may say. We have always stood up against lawlessness of every description and we will stand up against the lawlessness, even of members of the Government or their forces. Again, I may state that, in my opinion, another of the main reasons for this increase in the Gárda Síochána Vote is not alone the actions but the public statements of members of the Fianna Fáil and the Labour Parties. I happened to be reading an account in the local and the daily papers of certain meetings held recently and I find that at meetings of the I.R.A. the names of Ministers appear as attending those meetings and holding official positions. Take, for instance, the case of the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Lands and Fisheries. They attended a meeting of the I.R.A. here in Dublin recently and, of course, praised the work of the I.R.A. on that occasion. I have read in another newspaper at home of the Parliamentary Secretary, Dr. Ward, attending meetings of the I.R.A. Of course, I will be told that the word "old" is before I.R.A. He was appointed President at that meeting and Deputy Rice—a decent man, I believe, from all accounts, and a man held in high esteem in County Monaghan—was, I think, appointed treasurer. The I.R.A.—of course, the reason for Fianna Fáil's laughter is that it was the old I.R.A.
Comment on this
I have deliberately left out the word "old" for an obvious reason. The reason is that there is no difference between the old I.R.A. and the I.R.A.—none whatever. This flirting with the name of I.R.A. is one of the reasons for this increased Vote. You have betrayed them and you have no right to mix with the I.R.A. You are traitors to the I.R.A. and you have no right to go to those meetings and masquerade as men who are still loyal to the policy pursued by the I.R.A. You are traitors to that policy and because you have members of the Executive Council, and members of the Fianna Fáil Party, who are so hypocritical and dishonest as to attend meetings of the I.R.A., on the plea that they are the natural successors of the Irish Republican Army, it is necessary to have an increase in this Vote for the Gárda Síochána.
Then we have the laugh of Fianna Fáil: "Oh, it is not the I.R.A. ; it is the old I.R.A." Did anybody ever hear of such deceit, such dishonesty, masquerading behind the actions of men like Pearse, whose policy you have betrayed and let down? One of the main reasons for the increase in this Vote is that these young men, enthusiastic and, possibly, misguided young men, but yet brave, think they are entitled to pursue the policy they are pursuing at the moment when they see members of the Executive Council and members of the Fianna Fáil Party joining the ranks of that organisation. We have the same thing in relation to the Labour Party. They stated at the last meeting of the Trades Union Congress that they were out for a thing called a Workers' Republic. If that be so, how can any member of the Labour Party support a Government that casts into prison the men who are out for the same type of Republic? It is another reason for the increase in the Vote.
Why not have the courage and honesty—I make this appeal to the Government in all seriousness—to admit once and for all that you have left the question of the Republic behind you; that you are here governing a State a member of the British Commonwealth of Nations, and recognise that fact, like the men of the late Government. I can assure you that in a short space of time you will have the overwhelming support of all the right-minded people of this country, but so long as the members of the Executive and members of Fianna Fáil go round the country masquerading as Republicans and claiming to be the natural successors of Pearse and the other 1916 leaders, so long will it be necessary to have a big force of Gárda Síochána in this country. Why not have the courage to admit, once and for all, that you are carrying on the same Government to-day as Cosgrave and the other men carried on? Do not think that you, the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, or the Executive, are the only patriots and the only nationalists in this country. I claim to be as good an Irishman and as good a nationalist as any member of the Executive Council or any member of the Fianna Fáil Party. There is one thing, and it is that I hope I will never see the day when I will turn my back to any man in this country. Courage is here, and I am ready to do my bit in the upholding of law and order in this country. Are the members of the Executive Council prepared to do the same? Are the members of Fianna Fáil prepared to do the same? If so, then there is no necessity for this extra £80,000 for the Gárda Síochána.
In conclusion, I wish to impress on the Minister the desirability of at once doing something to end the seizures that are taking place all over the South of Ireland. Those men are human. They are Irish, as Irish as any member of the Fianna Fáil Party. A few years ago they were always able to meet their bills. Something must have happened since that period. What is that something? The Minister and the Executive Council know it. They should make allowance for that something. They should make allowance for human nature, and they should do all they possibly can in the interests of peace and order to come to some agreement with those people, so that the actions that have been taken and that will, I am sure, be taken in the future, may be dispensed with.
Comment on this
I shall intervene in this debate for a short period, because I feel that certain statements that were made by leading members of the Opposition require some explanation from that side of the House. Since this Party came into the Dáil in 1922 the members of it have at all times definitely discouraged the making of charges here against individual members of the Guards or against the Guards as a body, or those responsible for the administration of the Force. We believe that every right-minded Deputy should convey his charges or complaints to those responsible before making them public here. Deputy Mulcahy, who is regarded and rightly regarded by his Party supporters as a leading member of the Party, made a statement here in reference to the I.R.A. to the effect that Gárda officers who reported upon I.R.A. activities, at the same time allowed information to leak out to the I.R.A. officers or followers of that organisation.
Comment on this
I believe Deputy Mulcahy knows the present Commissioner of the Guards, and he knows the Minister. Did he, as a leading representative of the Opposition, as a man who held a Ministerial post for ten years, take an opportunity, before making that serious and demoralising statement, to convey whatever information he had to either the Commissioner or the Minister?
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy, when he was a Minister here, would always rightly resent the making of an allegation against State servants unless the Deputy making the allegation had drawn the attention beforehand of whatever Minister was responsible, to the nature of the charge. I submit that a statement was made here deliberately by Deputy Mulcahy for the purpose of causing further demoralisation amongst the officers and men of the Gárda Síochána, and the Deputy did not think it necessary to acquaint the Commissioner or the Minister beforehand of the charges he was about to make. The statement made by the Deputy, if true, is likely to cause demoralisation, and it should not be made by any responsible person without some steps being taken to have the subject-matter investigated beforehand. Even if the charge concerns only one officer of the Guards, it was the duty of the Deputy to go to the Commissioner, whom he knows fairly well, and have the matter investigated. If found to be true, that officer should be dismissed from the Guards.
Comment on this
Are all the Guards to be held responsible for the activities of one officer, no matter what his rank may be? Is it to go out that that kind of activity is general on the part of officers and members of the Gárda Síochána? I feel pretty sore about this, because I am of opinion the Gárda should be kept apart from politics, and I believe the overwhelming majority of the Guards, both during the lifetime of the previous Government and of this Government, had and have no desire but to do their duty in an impartial way to whatever Government is elected by the people. If any officer in the Guards is responsible for the conduct Deputy Mulcahy has attributed to him, I say he should be removed from the Force.
Comment on this
The Deputy ought to talk it over at some of his fortnightly meetings with the Government.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy knows that the present Commissioner is not the type of man who loves to live in the limelight. He held a high position in the lifetime of the late Government and he was even promoted then. He is a police officer pure and simple. Any Deputy who has the welfare of his country at heart and the impartial administration of the Guards in mind, should make it his duty first to go to the Commissioner with any complaints he might have to make before coming here and endeavouring to demoralise the whole force by suggesting that that kind of activity is general amongst the Guards.
Deputy O'Higgins made a filibustering speech and he made more allegations on the same lines as Deputy Mulcahy. He wants the House to believe that members of the Gárda, including officers, are being continually removed from one place to another as a result of the passing of resolutions by Fianna Fáil clubs. I have no knowledge of any such resolution being passed in my constituency for the purpose of getting the Minister or the Commissioner to remove Gárda officers or men. I have received appeals—I do not know whether other Deputies are in the same position—to endeavour to get Gárda officers and ordinary members of the Force retained in places from which they were being removed. The fact was, they did not want to go away, nor did the people want them to go away. I would like the Minister to furnish a return to Deputy O'Higgins showing the number of officers and Civic Guards removed during the lifetime of this Government and compare it with such removals during any three years of the previous régime. That will prove that these charges are unfounded, so far as my area is concerned at any rate. Deputy Mulcahy laughs at that. I say such a return will either prove or disprove the kind of charge made by Deputy O'Higgins.
Comment on this
The Deputy laughs at everything except at what is said by himself, but he scarcely realises the number of people in the country who laugh at what he does say.
Comment on this
The Deputy who makes the people of this country laugh deserves to be appreciated, because there is many a district in the country where the people badly want a laugh, and have not had a laugh for quite a long time.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy has done a good deal in this House during the last three years to demoralise the people by making such charges as he has made arising out of this Estimate. There are many people who are prepared to take at a discount what the Deputy says in matters of this kind.
Comment on this
I will never try to prevent Deputy Mulcahy making the people of this country laugh. It will do them no harm. But every decent-minded and right-thinking citizen will not laugh at the allegations the Deputy made here and which he had not the courage to make in the right place. Deputy Belton, whom I regard as a good-humoured speaker, endeavoured to make it appear that the attitude of the Labour Party in supporting the Government in this matter was tantamount to refusing the farmers the right to strike on issues affecting the farming community. I hope to God the day is not far away when the farmers of this country in their own interests will have the sense to join an industrial organisation and use their power for the purpose of improving their own economic condition.
As a Labour Deputy and a Trades Unionist I regret that the farmers have not done that long ago. I hope they will do so if not under Deputy Belton, then under some other leader who will arise in this country and persuade the farmers to join an industrial organisation having the right to strike. I would be the last person who would deny the farmers the right to strike. I would not be associated with any Government or with any person who would deny the farmers of this country the right to organise in their own interests and the right to strike for their own protection. Deputy Belton knows very well that this Party does not oppose the right of any organised body to strike. But Deputy Belton is a house owner. He builds houses, lets houses and receives rents for them. Supposing the people who occupy Deputy Belton's houses in Clonturk Park, Donnycarney, or wherever these houses are, refused to pay rent, I wonder would Deputy Belton seek the protection of the courts and the protection of the sheriff and the Gárda to recover these rents?
Comment on this
I am making a comparison with the statement of Deputy Belton concerning the attitude of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I doubt if Deputy O'Leary has yet given the House and the country the benefit of his wisdom on this Vote. If he has not, I am sure he will have many an opportunity of ventilating his views when I am finished.
Comment on this
I do admire the speech of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney who paid a tribute to the discipline of the tramway strikers in the City of Dublin during the present strike.
Comment on this
Not too late. It is a thing that would not be said in the ordinary way from those benches but it is to the credit of the tramway strikers and everybody else connected with the strikers that they did not require any police force to maintain order and discipline in the city. I know a good deal of provocation has been given to the strikers. A number of people with their peculiar opinions and some organisations with peculiar views have offered advice and assistance to the strikers. I think anybody who has any association with these strikers can, in the future, look back with pride on the unity and solidarity displayed by the tramway men. The fact that they did not cause any disturbance or make any threat against life or property in the City of Dublin during the ten weeks of the strike is something to be proud of. I was delighted on hearing the tribute to the strikers, coming as it did from Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. I say that because of the position he held in the late Government. I hope every right-thinking Deputy will resent the allegation made by Deputy Mulcahy regarding the leakage of information by the officers of the Gárda Síochána. I trust that whenever there is any good reason for thinking that any such thing is taking place in the future that even Deputy Mulcahy will not look upon himself as an infallible person but that he will have the commonsense and the public spirit to go first of all to the Commissioner or Minister before he comes into this House and makes charges of this sort.
Comment on this
Like Deputy Coburn, I feel very deeply concerned about this particular incident in Dundalk on Monday last, when I understand a very respectable official of County Louth, a man who, as far as I know, has never associated himself publicly or privately with any political Party, was intimidated and insulted. This public official, it is alleged, was intimidated and insulted by a member of the police force. That County Louth officer at the time he was insulted and intimidated was discharging his duty in the market place of Dundalk. That such a thing should have happened is a matter for deep concern and I simply rise to ask the Minister if he will grant a disciplinary inquiry into that alleged incident. I ask further, when he comes to reply, that the Minister would tell the House the exact position occupied by this Mr. Moore in the police force and whether in attending sales of seized cattle as a police officer he is at liberty to purchase these cattle, and if so, whether he so acts in his official capacity or in his private capacity? The matter that most people are concerned with is that this disciplinary inquiry should be held. If it is necessary to furnish anything in the nature of official references Deputy Coburn and myself will attend to that. I tell the Minister and I tell the Attorney-General who is now in the House to remember that there is on the part of the public a very deep anxiety that this disciplinary inquiry should be set up to investigate the charges that have been made.
Comment on this
I did not intend intervening in this debate and would not do so now but that I wish to reply to a statement which Deputy Cleary put before the House on Tuesday last. On that occasion Deputy Cleary attacked the members of this Party and said they associated themselves with illegalities up and down the country. The Deputy even went so far as to accuse us of associating ourselves with bank robberies. It is certainly rather a funny thing to hear members on the Government Benches charging us with associating with bank robbers or with any other robbers. We have always stood for the will of the majority of the people of this country and that is the position in which we stand to-day. Deputy Davin talks about farmers standing up against the payment of their land annuities. Farmers are not standing against the payment of land annuities. The farmers have paid their land annuities over and over again. Deputies have only to read the speech made by Mr. James H. Thomas in the House of Commons a few days ago when he said that the British Government collected £4,700,000 in taxes from the Irish farmers. The President himself admitted that out of that sum only £2,900,000 went towards the payment of the land annuities, so that on that one item alone the farmers have been fleeced to the extent of £1,800,000. That is, they paid last year £1,800,000 more than their annuities to the British Government. Then they are being asked to pay them again to the Government here. Will Deputy Davin turn around and tell the farmers of this country, whose markets have been destroyed, that they are to pay their land annuities over again? I put that question to Deputy Davin and I ask for a reply. He, too, represents a constituency largely composed of farmers.
My policy always has been that I stand for the will of the majority of the people of this country. Deputy Cleary talks about cutting telegraph wires, destroying telegraph poles and cutting trees. I may tell Deputy Cleary that I remember the time when his followers in my part of the country cut nine miles of telegraph poles and wires and the people of the country had to pay compensation for that. What is the result of that to-day? We have people on the Government Benches preaching that the farmers are not law-abiding citizens. What has the Government done with the people who cut those wires and destroyed poles and trees some years ago? Why, they are now giving them pensions. Do the Government think that the ordinary people of the country can have confidence in an administration such as that? People are talking a good deal about these things. My advice to my friends in Cork has been on these lines: I have told them that the people now on the Government Benches tried to upset the legally established Government of this country by force. They failed. They became wise and they turned to the ballot boxes. My advice now to the people of the country is not to commit illegal acts but to turn to the ballot boxes and in the ballot box to say that the Government, which has placed the country in the position it is in, should be driven from office at the earliest possible opportunity.
Comment on this
Listening to this debate one must feel satisfied, owing to the very little criticism put forward against the Department, that the various sub-departments, including the police, have been doing their duty. The first thing emphasised, and which was referred to by several speakers, and would seem to have been the spearhead of the entire attack on the Department, was the parade on Easter Sunday. It has been stated very definitely by a number of Deputies, who may consider themselves, whatever anybody else thinks about them, as having some responsibility as public representatives, that the President proceeded by an unannounced route on that occasion. While one can allow for a certain amount of dishonest criticism, one would at least imagine that no Deputy, who has any respect for his responsibility as a Deputy, would make a statement like that knowing that it was untrue. In the first place, the route was very definitely published in all the papers circulating in Dublin.
Comment on this
The "Irish Press," the "Independent," and the "Irish Times." Does the Deputy deny that the route was announced in the papers published on the Saturday preceding the parade?
Comment on this
I deny that the route was announced in the "Irish Independent" on the Saturday preceding the parade.
Comment on this
I am denying the statement by the Minister that it was announced in the "Irish Independent" on the Saturday.
Comment on this
I may not have that particular cutting at the moment, as I did not think it would have been denied. It certainly was published in the "Irish Press."
Comment on this
This was done at any rate, and if the papers did not publish it, it is not the fault of the Government. It was issued from the Government Information Bureau on the Friday to the papers circulating in Dublin, and it certainly appeared in the "Sunday Independent" as well as appearing, I maintain and state very definitely, in all the other papers. They got it anyway. The route as announced on the Friday was followed and the statement should not have been made here, as it was made repeatedly by Deputies on the opposite side, that the President proceeded by an unannounced route. I repeat again that it was issued on the Friday from the Government Information Bureau to all the papers circulating in Dublin. I have got only the cutting from the "Irish Press" before me at the moment, but I do know it appeared in the "Sunday Independent" anyway, and if the Deputy looks it up I will be very surprised if he does not find it appeared in the "Independent" and the "Irish Times" on the Saturday.
Comment on this
If it did not appear, it is not the fault of the Government. It was issued to them on the Friday. Then the suggestion was made that the President, through fear that he would be attacked, or something like that, chose a certain unannounced route. That route was selected without any reference to the President by the military authorities in conjunction with the Gárda authorities, and the reason why the Clanbrassil Street route was selected was in order to cause the least inconvenience to the citizens of Dublin. Whatever route is selected, everybody knows that that route has to be closed to the public during a certain period. If the parade came by the Camden Street route, down by Rathmines, it would mean that at the very time people would be attending Mass from 11 to 1 o'clock, they would be held up going to and from two churches, Rathmines and Whitefriar Street. That was one consideration. Another consideration was that the route followed was a shorter one by about 1,000 yards. It was approximately a mile shorter, when you take it each way. That was some consideration for the troops, and they had to be considered also.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy admit that the consideration of the people going to and coming from Mass between 11 and 1 o'clock was a fair consideration to be taken into account? For the Deputy's consolation I may say that they did get into the fashionable streets about which he seems to be so very anxious. For his consolation I may say that they proceeded through Dame Street, College Green and Westmoreland Street, to O'Connell Street. Is it the Deputy's complaint that the parade did not pass by 3 Merrion Square to see the garlanding and festooning there in celebration of the occasion; or is the Deputy annoyed because he was not in some place like 3 Merrion Square, where he could cheer the President as he passed by? Is the Deputy suggesting that the President would be safer in the poorer streets of the city than in the fashionable thoroughfares? Is the Deputy suggesting that the poor people of this city are not as much entitled to see a parade like that and have an opportunity of viewing, from their own homes if they wished, the President of the State and the parade going through, as are the fashionable centres of the city? What is the point?
Comment on this
I never knew whether Mrs. Mulligan was poor or rich, although I often heard the song.
Comment on this
That was the spearhead of the Opposition attack which we have had here. The next thing raised in this debate was a very regrettable incident that took place when a citizen of this city was arrested in mistake. It was stated that the Guards went to a lot of trouble in getting a warrant, and I suppose the suggestion was that a district justice was got out of his bed to get the warrant before they went to this man's house. Deputies opposite provided the present Government with means by which it is not necessary on such an occasion to disturb any district justice, and that was not done in that particular case. Then it was stated that when the Guards went to this man's house a whistle was blown and they scurried off. If that were true, I would have been very glad that it happened in the circumstances, because it might have avoided the unpleasantness to this citizen of being arrested if they had scurried off and did not come back. But what happened was that when the Guards went to the house they knocked at the door and were in conversation with this citizen's wife when a whistle was blown at the back of the house and they went round to the back of the house to see what was happening. There was no such thing as going away and coming back hours afterwards. This man was arrested, his name being the same as that of another man for whom the Guards were looking and who has since been arrested. There was a mistake in the address. When the man was brought to the Bridewell it was discovered and an apology was made by the officer in charge. A motor car was provided for him and he was sent home. Subsequently, I gave that citizen an ample apology, and in his reply to me he acknowledged that, and also said that the Guards had treated him with the greatest courtesy. Since the question has been raised, I want to avail of this opportunity again to express the regret I feel, and that the Guards feel, that the mistake occurred.
Deputy Mulcahy referred to certain things that happened in Kilfinane. He talked about certain crimes occurring in that area, and that no persons had been brought to justice. As the Deputy should know, that is one of the most difficult and the most lawless districts we have at present to deal with. In 1934, 50 crimes occurred in that area in connection with malicious damage to telegraph communications. They were committed during the six months commencing 31st December last. Forty-five members of the League of Youth were convicted in respect of some 30 offences. During the six months ending 31st December seven persons were convicted for various crimes committed in pursuance of the non-payment of annuities campaign in the district. With regard to seven offences, or crimes, or whatever the Deputy wants to call them, to which he drew attention, the police reported to the following effect:
No. 2 of these outrages never took place;
No. 3 was never reported to the police;
In No. 4 a member of the complainants' family is believed to have been involved;
Nos. 5 and 6 are common burglaries, and in
No. 7 the crime was helped by failure to lock up the premises at night.
These were all the cases mentioned, as showing that the Guards were allowing crimes to be committed and taking no steps to bring the perpetrators to justice. Except for the reference made by Deputy Coburn, we have nothing but general statements about the Guards neglecting their duty; the usual statements that the Guards had been interfered with and prevented making investigations or making arrests for certain crimes. That does not impress anybody who has been listening to that sort of propaganda from the Opposition for the last three years. I submit that it is dishonest propaganda, and that the Opposition, instead of trying to facilitate or to help investigations, are only concerned with making political capital out of them. Anything that happens, no matter how terrible the crime, no matter how bad it is, or how sacrilegious, the opposite benches try to suggest that the atmosphere is that of Fianna Fail. I did not hear any apology from the Opposition for the statement Deputy McGilligan made about the Birr outrage. When Deputy Cleary referred to it here, it was suggested by Deputy O'Higgins that no such statement had been made. Deputy Cleary's interpretation of it was that the suggestion was that it was done by a political party. This is what Deputy McGilligan said:
"I shall make this allusion to it. When I opened the paper and first read of that burning I placed it myself as the work of a maniac. That was what I felt at first, but I have since had this doubt cast in my mind, that if it was a maniac who did it the Guards would have arrested the maniac, and I had the feeling that it is only because the Guards have an apprehension about arrests that, if arrests bring revelations and involve certain political disputants and agitators, then there is going to be criticism of the Guards for doing their duty. It is only that that prevents their making an arrest."
Is not that a clear suggestion, and could anyone interpret it otherwise, that that was done by the adherents of Fianna Fáil? Can anyone put any other construction upon it? When they knew that that sort of propaganda, lying as it was, could not be proved, would it not have been the decent thing for someone on the Opposition benches to get up and to apologise? There has been no retraction of the statements that were made, no matter how unfounded or how baseless. There is no apology from the opposite benches. There will not be an apology for the statement about the President proceeding by an unannounced route. That statement will not be withdrawn. That is the sort of political propaganda that we hear in this House, as well as wild statements like those of Deputy Mulcahy, about information being given to the I.R.A., without a title of evidence to support them.
Comment on this
Of course the Deputy says there is truth in them but he will not submit the proofs because he could not rely upon any one of them. It is the simplest thing in the world to get away with political propaganda, and it is easy to say: "I know that if I give that information to the proper quarter it will not be properly investigated." That is the way to do it and to try to get away with it.
Comment on this
The readers of the English newspapers are on the far side, because they take much more interest in them than we do.
Comment on this
I have been asked for the reasons for increasing the Guards. The reason for increasing the Guards is the one the Opposition have given, that is, the number of outrages that were carried on by their Party and its supporters. I agree that there are no outrages in County Roscommon. In fact there are none west of the Shannon. They are confined to a comparatively small area in the counties of Cork and Limerick, portion of Tipperary, and a little in the midlands. I think they have got sense in the midlands for a considerable time, and that very few outrages occurred recently.
Comment on this
Extra duties were imposed upon the Gárda in connection with the campaign for the destruction of road and rail communications during 1934. It was necessary to transfer two inspectors, four sergeants and 97 Guards in connection with the non-payment of annuities, and to enforce payment special units were formed in Mullingar, Kilkenny, Claremorris and Naas, and to these units were transferred two inspectors, five sergeants and 64 Guards. During the year 1,826 members of the Gárda performed 144,000 extra hours of duty. On 424 occasions obstructions in connection with the collecting of rates and land annuities, and in connection with seizures of stock, took place during the year 1934. On 133 occasions prosecutions were instituted, and 706 persons were prosecuted, of whom 492 were convicted. Twelve cases were also pending at the end of the year 1934. From July, 1934, to the 16th January, 1935, there were 604 outrages directed against railways, roads and telegraphic communications, mainly in the Counties Cork, Limerick, Louth, Meath, Longford, Westmeath, Tipperary and Wexford. Let anybody consider the amount of duty that is imposed on the Gárda as a result of that. While it is all right for Deputies to get up here and say they do not approve of those outrages, what way are they trying to stop them? We had Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney here the other day saying he did not approve of those lawless acts, but in the very next sentence he says that the Government are the real criminals. That is the sort of speech you get from the Opposition—in other words, that those people who stand up against the criminal Government are heroic people. We were told here the other day that Deputy Cosgrave condemned it. The campaign was two months going as hot as it could be in the South of Ireland, and why was it not condemned? When it was condemned it was referred to as "those deplorable breaches of the peace," and again in the very next sentence there is sympathy for what Deputy Mulcahy would call the inflamed farmers. Has there been even one definite condemnation of those people who carry on those illegal and lawless activities?
Comment on this
What is it? Every time there is a statement made, very lightly and very easily condemning them, you will find in the same speech that they are sympathising with them and more or less apologising for them.
Comment on this
If the Minister is not prepared to accept my statement about it I suppose there is nothing to be said, but over and over again we have implored our supporters to refrain from illegal acts. If the Minister expects us not to sympathise with men who are being ruined he is asking too much. We do sympathise with them, but that is not the same thing as asking them to commit illegal acts.
Comment on this
What effort has been made by the United Ireland Party organisation or by the League of Youth to deal with those members who are committing these illegalities? Can anyone suggest why they are confined to a small area? Are they not able to control their supporters in those areas?
Comment on this
I assume that the League of Youth are your supporters. I do not know anything further than that in their evidence they state that they are members of the League of Youth. Some of them glory in those activities and appear to be very proud of them. I admit that a number of them state they had to do those things under orders.
Comment on this
I am sure if you get into office you will very quickly give them pensions. I am quite sure you are going to consider them. They will probably be called heroes of the land war, or some other name of historical significance. You have not gone out to stop it and you know you could stop it.
Comment on this
I did not interrupt the Deputy. He can speak afterwards if he wants to. Why do you not put those people out of your organisation when they are found guilty of those offences? Not a single one of them has been put out of the organisation. Take another matter; there has been a good deal of condemnation about it now, but for two days the burning of a Deputy's house was not referred to by the Opposition. It was not referred to at all until Deputy Cleary referred to it.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it not better that the Minister for Justice should refrain from referring in any way to a crime in respect of which men are in custody and liable to be charged? Have you not repeatedly ruled in this House that the Chair prefers such matters to be left uncommented on until the persons charged are discharged or convicted?
Comment on this
I understand that nobody has been charged in connection with that matter, hence no one is being prejudiced. In the course of this debate, at least four Deputies have already referred to the incident.
Comment on this
I do not think it is going to prejudice anybody in any way that Deputies should join in condemning that outrage.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister is he now setting up a general standard for political Parties in this country, or a standard for the Opposition?
Comment on this
I do not expect the Opposition to decently follow any sort of standard in politics in this House.
Comment on this
I do not think, as a matter of fact, that there is anybody in custody in connection with that outrage; at least I have no information that there is. Deputy Mulcahy referred to a case in Midleton, where he says some young man was found with a revolver on New Year's Eve, and because he was a prominent supporter of Fianna Fáil there was no charge made.
Comment on this
No. I said a young fellow was found with a revolver, and because he was the son of a prominent supporter of Fianna Fáil no charge was made.
Comment on this
Very good. The facts of that case are these: a boy of 13 years of age was found at the merry-go-rounds on the fair green at Mitchelstown, with what appeared to the Guards to be a revolver. I do not know whether they examined it at the time or whether they did not.
Comment on this
The revolver was broken. It was a broken revolver with holes in the barrel, a bit of a stock, no trigger and no magazine. Where the boy got it I do not know, but when the Superintendent saw what it was he directed that the boy should be sent home.
Comment on this
Did we arrest any Blueshirts of 13 years of age? If Deputy Mulcahy wants to make a case he ought to make a truthful one.
Comment on this
Am I to be allowed to speak for one moment without interruption? We can see what disorderly people we have to deal with even inside the House. General Mulcahy said that this man was a prominent Fianna Fáil supporter. This man is a civil servant, and while he may have his views, I do not see how he can be a prominent supporter of any Party while he is in the civil service. What does the Deputy mean by a prominent Fianna Fáil supporter? Would not one imagine that a prominent supporter of Fianna Fáil would be a man who took some very prominent part? Surely the Deputy would not put in the word "prominent" unless this man was taking a very big part in Fianna Fáil. Civil servants have their views, and they have their votes, but I think they are very careful not to go out speaking on platforms, or anything like that. To come back to this campaign, we see where Deputies' cattle are still being seized. According to the Irish Independent of May 7, 12 cattle belonging to Deputy Wall were seized in County Waterford and brought to Kilmacthomas to be entrained to Dungarvan pound. Deputy Wall, however, paid the annuities, amounting to £25, and the cattle were restored to him. That is the kind of nonsense that is imposing all this duty on the Guards. What is the idea of the Deputy holding out, allowing the cattle to be seized and then paying up the amount, which was only £25?
Comment on this
The Deputy was able to pay up when he had to pay. Could he not have paid earlier? We had the same state of affairs from time to time in connection with other Deputies and that has imposed extra duty on the Guards. They have to run after these people who are in a conspiracy not to pay their annuities. Deputy Mulcahy asked some questions about statistics of crime. He got replies in the ordinary way and he had them published in United Ireland, with the heading: “How Fianna Fáil administers justice—57 outrages, one conviction.” Deputy Mulcahy asked three questions covering various kinds of crime. One of these questions was with reference to the obstruction of persons collecting rates, land annuities or other public moneys during the period from the 1st January, 1934, to the 31st December, 1934. That would show a very different position from the table he published but he did not publish that in United Ireland. He deliberately suppressed that.
Comment on this
The Irish Press did not get the reply in the ordinary way. It was issued by way of table and supplied afterwards to the Deputy. I do not know whether or not Deputy Coburn reported the matter to which he referred to the superintendent. Perhaps he suggests, like Deputy Mulcahy, that the superintendent cannot be relied upon and that if he gets a complaint there will be no investigation. Deputy Mulcahy chips in very glibly and says that this is symptomatic of the police force at the present time——
Comment on this
I say that that is a thing that everybody in this House— no matter on which side he is—knows is not true.
Comment on this
What sections are there? If Deputy Mulcahy could substantiate those charges, he would not make a vague statement but would refer to these charges in detail, as he has referred to these seven so-called outrages with which I have dealt. He is very good at procuring details and bringing them before this House. He is very good at putting down questions about every little incident that happens in the country, whether it comes to his notice through the newspapers or otherwise. If details could be got, he would have got them, and the organ of the United Ireland Party would have got them. But all he does is throw a statement around the House that it is symptomatic of certain sections of the police force that they go up to a man and boast of having shot some other man, and say they will do the same to him. I do not feel like replying in any detail to these matters. Any of them that have been mentioned here have been dealt with. Those are the only cases about which I have heard from Deputies opposite. The matter mentioned by Deputy Coburn I had not heard about until it was mentioned in the House. I do not know whether he kept that information to himself for the purpose of using it in this House, taking no steps to have it dealt with. We had play made about the old I.R.A. I do not know what Deputy Mulcahy thinks about that.
Comment on this
Deputy Coburn does not know much about it, at any rate. To say that the old I.R.A. are the same as the new I.R.A. is to say a thing which could not be put across anybody in this House. A person is driven to a very peculiar argument if he suggests that the old I.R.A. are really the new I.R.A.—that they are all the same. There are old I.R.A. men in those clubs who have records that they can be proud of and who have, certainly, no association with the new I.R.A. I have been asked by several speakers what our policy is with regard to the I.R.A. Our policy is known by the action we have taken already in this matter.
Comment on this
I should like to point out to the Deputy—I suppose he knows it already—that there is considerable difficulty in respect to the law about flag days and the question of permits. If those flag days were considered of any moment or if it was thought that money was going to be got for the purpose for which they alleged they required money, action might have been taken under some new legislation. But what can one think when one sees all through Tipperary the O'Duffy section of the League of Youth—that gentleman may not now be associated with the Party opposite—buying and wearing Easter lilies? That is the position that is spreading through the country—that you are going to have General O'Duffy's party wearing Easter lilies. I suggest that seems innocuous enough. Anything that General O'Duffy, who was Commissioner of Police, would be associated with in that way will not make for overthrowing the Government by unlawful means.
Comment on this
The Minister has not told us what his policy is in regard to the I.R.A. We should be glad to hear it.
Comment on this
When dealing with it, I was interrupted by General Mulcahy, who referred to Easter lilies.
Comment on this
Action has already been taken in the matter of the I.R.A. That action will be taken against anybody who commits an illegal action or is concerned in anything that would be a menace to this State or an attempt at overthrowing this State by unlawful means.
Comment on this
Reference was made to the number of serious crimes that have gone undetected. I do not want to quote again the speech of Deputy Cosgrave when introducing this 2 (A) Amendment to the Constitution. I have quoted it on two occasions in the House. That showed the number of unsolved crimes committed before that legislation was introduced. I challenge anybody on the opposite side to compare the number of undetected crimes under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government with the number of undetected crimes under the Fianna Fáil Government. I do not want to refer to any of those crimes which are sub judice. At any rate, I think it will be conceded that there has been no slackening whatever, with regard to any crime committed in this country, in trying to make the culprits amenable; and it is not helpful, apart from being not decent, even in politics, to have people trying to undermine confidence in the Gárda and to undermine the Gárda's own morale. That is what the Opposition are trying to do and that is the effect of all this kind of criticism and of such a suggestion as that recently made by Deputy McGilligan, which is typical of all their criticisms, that the person who burned Birr church was likely to be a Fianna Fáil supporter and that therefore he would not be arrested. That kind of suggestion is typical of the Opposition. One wonders what is the necessity to go into other matters of that kind or refer to them, because that is typical of the whole propaganda from those benches opposite. Whatever others may think about the matter, all I have to say about it is that at least it is not honest. Perhaps one should not be surprised at it, but one should at least regret it.
Some other matters have been referred to by Deputy Minch and Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney with regard to conditions in the force and so on. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney suggests now that the Gárdaí should get the franchise and that they should get back the boot allowance and some other things. I think that, at any rate, the Gárda themselves will know who would be the more sympathetic towards them. It is very easy for Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney to get up here and ask to give back what he took care to take away. It is very easy also for Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney to talk about giving the franchise to Gárdaí, but he took very good care, while he was in office, that they would have no franchise.
Comment on this
With regard to the matters raised by Deputy Minch, I can only say that the Gárda have a representative body and that representations come along through that body in the ordinary way. The Deputy can be assured that any representations made on behalf of the Gárda, to help them in the difficult times through which they are going, are being considered sympathetically, and that everything that is possible to be done is being done to help them to meet those difficult conditions. With regard to the question of the franchise, it is my own personal opinion that Guards should not have votes. I am only expressing my personal opinion in this matter. I think that you are bound to bring them into politics very definitely if they have votes. I do not think that the Guards themselves have any grievance about that matter. At least, no representations have been made to me asking that they should have votes, and my own personal view is that it would be undesirable. I am open to argument on the matter, but I personally think that the present feeling is that they should not have votes, and I believe that it is better for themselves and for the morale of the force that they should not have the franchise.
Comment on this
Before the question is put to the House, I should like to know whether or not the Minister feels inclined to answer the question I put to him with regard to affording protection for cinemas.
Comment on this
The Deputy can be assured that when those matters arise all possible precautions will be taken and every protection afforded.
Comment on this
I should like to point out to the Minister that he has not replied to the question I put to him asking whether or not he would order an inquiry to be held into the incidents in Dundalk last Monday, and to take disciplinary action, if necessary.
Comment on this
On several occasions I have dealt with similar questions. I think that it was Deputy Anthony who, in a similar case, raised the question of disciplinary action. That was a case where a man, who was protecting an individual down in Cork, threatened the man he was protecting. That man was only a few days in the force after that incident took place. He was dismissed. The case was made by Deputy Anthony at the time that the man would not be put out of the force because he happened to be recently recruited, but he was dismissed from the force only four days after that incident took place, and even that delay was due to having to get him to come up here. With regard to the particular case mentioned by Deputy Murphy, how can I give the Deputy any assurance other than to say that I will have the case investigated, and that, if we are satisfied as to the facts, the necessary disciplinary action will be taken?
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister whether, without prejudice to the Guards' status, he would investigate cases where certain Guards have become involved in the toils of moneylenders and have become subject to exorbitant rates of interest. If a Guard makes a clean breast of his difficulties, will the Minister undertake to give his sympathetic consideration to such a case?
Comment on this
I certainly would not like to encourage any Guard to get into the hands of moneylenders, but where it has been shown that they have got into such difficulties through no fault of their own, their cases have been dealt with sympathetically, and they have been given an opportunity of trying to make good. However, very few such cases have arisen.
Comment on this
I should like to know from the Minister if he has investigated the incident to which I referred, which took place in Keadue, and if he is satisfied that there is no substance in the allegation.
Comment on this
I am satisfied. The police report is that on the night this explosion took place—I think it was about 11 o'clock—all the Guards were in the barracks with the exception of one man who was a married man and living outside the barracks. Immediately the explosion took place, the sergeant and two Guards went to collect the other Guard on their way and found him at home in his own house. They were the only Guards available, and they refute the suggestion.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration."
Do you agree with this result?