We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Financial Resolutions—Report Stage. - Financial Resolution No. 9—Customs.

Contributions 1–137 of 262. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

I move: "That the Dáil agree with the Committee in Resolution No. 9."

Comment on this

I should like to get some information from the Minister for Industry and Commerce regarding several items set out in the Schedule to this Resolution. We have been discussing the effect of an income tax imposition on housing. In this Schedule, a great number of articles used in the building of houses are subjected to duties of varying amounts. I should like to know from the Minister, how many of these articles are made in the country and to what extent they are available. I should like to know whether the impositions in this Schedule are in the nature of protective duties or are intended for revenue purposes. I should like to know whether the duties proposed to be levied under this Resolution will increase the cost of house building, and, if so, to what extent. In this Resolution and in Resolutions which are to follow, we find that nearly every commodity used in the building of houses, with the exception of timber, is subjected to tax. Many of the articles set out in the Resolution are not made here and, so far as we know, are not likely to be available in this country in the near future. The Ministry are very anxious to promote the building of houses by local authorities and by private builders but if, through practices such as this, the cost of building these houses and — a point I shall come to later — the cost of occupying houses built by local authorities for people living in the slum areas is going to be made more expensive, the Ministry will retard the building of houses rather than assist their building. Before we are asked to vote on a Resolution which covers a large group of articles which are subjected to duties ranging up to 50 per cent., we are entitled to get from the Minister information as to what extent these articles are being made in the country; if they are not being made here now, we are entitled to ask when they are likely to be made and whether these impositions are going to increase the cost of building.

The Schedule covers school bags and other satchels used by children going to school. Are these made in this country and are they available? Having regard to the very expensive books which have to be bought by these children, I should like to know whether these bags are available at reasonable prices. I rose, however, principally to deal with the question of housing materials, which constitute so important a part of this Schedule and I should like to get from the Minister some information regarding them.

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy name the items which are not made here and the duties on which he alleges will affect the cost of building?

Comment on this

I am asking the Minister to do that. Does the Minister think it is possible for any private member to tell him that?

Comment on this

I may have misunderstood the Deputy but I thought he said that there were articles being subjected to duty which he knew were not made in the country. I should like him to indicate the references he has in mind.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I said that it seemed to me, reading down through the Schedule, that practically all the materials used in the building of houses, with the exception of timber, were being taxed. I said that I should like to know from the Minister whether all these materials were being made in the country and were available, or how many were being made and to what extent they were available. Is the supply of the articles made in the country sufficient to meet the demand? I am really asking the Minister to indicate to what extent these duties are protective and to what extent they are being imposed merely for the purpose of collecting revenue.

Comment on this

There seems to be terrible opposition to the sweeping nature of the proposals in this Resolution. "Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, so thinks proper, the Revenue Commissioners may authorise any particular person... to import any articles without payment of duty." That betrays the whole object. While there are some things in the Schedule that I know a little about, like Deputy Morrissey, I would like some information. It is outrageous to put a big percentage tariff on any article for use here if it is not produced in sufficient quantities to meet our requirements. That is not industrial protection. That is for the purpose of producing revenue. It is collecting revenue and taxing the people and in that way it is going to destroy any chance of a revival of Irish industry. There can be no case made for a big tariff to help any industrial activity unless that industrial activity has reached a stage above 80 per cent. of our total requirements, so that, by an extra effort, working day and night, we will be able to produce all that is required. Then let outsiders compete with the home producer over the tariff barrier. This is not giving the producer at home any chance. It is creating a big barrier over which goods must not pass because we want them. If the House took time intelligently to examine all these Resolutions, by the time they are all passed we will find industrial activity being hamstrung, particularly in the building trade.

Reference No. 1 in the Schedule deals with rear reflectors. I do not think there is such an article made here or that we have any exports. If we are turning out our total requirements to 70 or 80 per cent., I am wholeheartedly in favour of a 75 per cent. tariff. Otherwise, I am against it, and I take second place to no one in supporting a tariff policy. But I am not a fool. If this is for revenue let it be for revenue, but let the House and the country know that. I do not believe we are producing rear reflectors. I give the information for what it is worth. If the total production of this article here amounts to 80 per cent., I agree with the Minister. If not, I disagree with his proposal. If the total production of our requirements represents 20 per cent. we should have no tariff at all, but should give a subsidy to anybody prepared to put down money and guarantee protection when there was 70 or 80 per cent. production. I would give a national guarantee in that case, and I am sure the Opposition, if they became a Government, would see that such a policy was continuous. I am quite sure that if we get down to rationalisation no one is going to support a 75 per cent. tariff if we are not making about that figure of the total requirement.

The next reference is to polishing preparations of all kinds, on which there is a duty of 33? per cent. I do not know what we are doing in that respect. Then there is cotton bandages and bandaging material imported in rolls on which there is a duty of 33? per cent. Again, "whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, so thinks proper, the Revenue Commissioners may, by licence, authorise any particular person, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of the duty...." So we are going to hand the powers of this House over to a Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and whatever they say in a chat will be done. I do not suggest that either the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Minister for Finance, separately or collectively, would be parties to any abuse of the power they get. But it is this House got the power — and not even the whole Ministry. This House has no authority, and should not act ultra vires by giving the authority vested in it by the people to any one Minister or to any group of people, by excluding members of this House from imposing tariffs. If there is to be exemption, let this House, which is vested with authority, have the right of exemption. I do not see any need for the Dáil meeting at all now. There might be a general muster once a year.

Even then it would be of very little use. It would be only a kind of show. It is not legislation, and certainly the people are not represented.

The next item in the Schedule is satchels, on which there is a duty of 20 per cent. No comment is needed. If we are not able to make sufficient satchels for the children going to school, well we are not able to do it. I hope we will before we put on 20 per cent. If we are not, it is monstrous. Reference No. 6 refers to:

surrounds, hearths and curbs which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are of a kind normally used for fireplaces and are made or consist partly of tiles, bricks or slabs made wholly or partly of clay, stone (including reconstructed stone) or cement; (b) sections of any such surrounds, hearths or curbs as are mentioned in the foregoing paragraphs.

There is no comment by the Minister for Industry and Commerce about that. These are house fittings for building purposes. Are we making our total requirement of these fittings? Are supplies not in arrear? Have not builders got to wait for the execution of orders? I should like to hear from the Minister for Industry and Commerce that all these things are made here. He promulgated an order some time ago imposing a high tariff on syphon cisterns used for lavatories. That was followed up by his colleague, the Minister for Local Government, intimating that Irish syphon cisterns could be used; otherwise there would be no grants. Of course, it is open to doubt whether a house would otherwise be certified as habitable. However, the grant was good. Is the Minister aware that many builders are waiting — myself included — for syphons of a modern pattern? The syphons that are flung at us are syphon cisterns that we must put on an overflow pipe, with a hole through the wall, instead of a syphon with internal control. No one wants to pass the Irish articles if they can be had of a good pattern. In fact, people are prepared to pay a little more for them. I want the Minister for Industry and Commerce to understand that a finished article used as raw material concerns a builder who has to sell a house and to please the public. When a person sees a hole through a wall from the cistern for the overflow, it may make a difference between buying and not buying the house. Besides, there is no need to have it there.

Comment on this

Apart from that, they are not being made subject to duty by this Resolution.

Comment on this

Not exactly, that is right; but I hope the Minister does not want to slip out of his order by that technicality. I should like to know from the Minister if boiler grates are made here. I do not want to take the Minister at a disadvantage. A boiler grate is a grate used now in nearly every house. It has a boiler at the back of it and it is installed in the diningroom or living room of the house.

Comment on this

I should like to answer the Deputy, but I fear I would be out of order in doing so, as they are not subject to duty by this Resolution.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that tiles and slabs for the facing of fireplaces are made here?

Comment on this

The duty is imposed by this reference upon surrounds made from tiles.

Comment on this

Are they made here?

Comment on this

Surrounds, yes.

Comment on this

And tiles for the surrounds?

Comment on this

No; the reference imposes a duty upon surrounds made from the tiles.

Comment on this

It does not refer to the tiles that may be used in the surrounds. The Minister is satisfied that the output of surrounds is substantial?

Comment on this

There are several firms engaged in it.

Comment on this

I know, but the Minister, I am sure, is aware, and if he is not, I can tell him for a fact, that there are orders in arrear. One cannot have much complaint if that happens now and again, but if it is a regular thing, it is serious, and a matter of which the Minister should take notice. Is the Minister satisfied that steel windows can be delivered here in a sufficiency for our requirements?

Comment on this

Well, I am not, and I am quite sure they cannot. If you order a window in the morning, you will not be guaranteed it for three months, not that it matters much in view of the state house-building has been brought to. There is difficulty in getting gutters, and they are going to be taxed to the extent of 33? per cent.

Comment on this

Hooks, brackets, bands and similar fittings for those things.

Comment on this

That is right. In regard to all these matters, I should like the Minister who, I am sure, is familiar with all this, as it is his work, to give the House a figure against each reference as to our production at the present time. Then, there is a reference to ridge tiles, hip tiles and roofing tiles.

Comment on this

It is in Brooks Thomas' you ought to be and not here.

Comment on this

I am afraid it is in the museum the Deputy ought to be and not here.

Comment on this

He looks upon you, Deputy, as a wild and turbulent spirit.

Comment on this

You are interested in farming and he is not.

Comment on this

If there was any turbulence about he could not sleep so soundly or so consistently. He woke up that time when he heard the racket about tiles. It must have been the Minister for Industry and Commerce who woke him up when he spoke. Are iron wheelbarrows made here? Moulds for making concrete blocks are made here. I could make one myself, but would it be a good machine? If the Minister wants to be serious about this, he should not be satisfied to put on a tariff when a man puts up a plate stating that such and such a machine is made here. I have a few of those machines. I have an English machine which has been working continuously for five years, and it can make a block as good as it could on the day it started. None of the others can.

Recently, in the Dublin County Council, we wanted a new machine. There was a builder who is a Fianna Fáil Councillor, at the Committee, and both of us agreed that it would be better for us to pay £25 — including or excluding the tariff, I do not know which — to import one machine than to get two native machine for the same price. We both would have agreed to do it and it would be the better bargain, but the Minister for Local Government would not permit it. It was not a case of politics, as the Minister can understand — I am sure he does not doubt my word, but, if he does, I can give him the name of the Councillor. He had had practical experience of the different machines for making blocks, and so had I. If high tariffs are going to be put on like this, give the people a fair chance, especially when it is a question of machinery and especially machinery for making these blocks. Those blocks are to be used in house building and a faulty machine may produce bad blocks. If it does, no builder in the world can produce a good house. It is important. There is a duty of 40 per cent. imposed on binder twine. I think there is a little joke about that of which I could inform the Minister. I hope we will have all our requirements even with the rapid extension of our agricultural economy. I wonder if this little factory is rapidly extending to meet our requirements?

There are other things here about which I know a little but I will leave them to people who know more. I will leave Reference No. 25 particularly — prayer books and hymn books — to Deputy Kelly.

Comment on this

I do not need them as badly as you do.

Comment on this

You have spent longer repenting than I have, I agree. Reference No. 26 deals with copper tubing and pipes having a wall thickness not exceeding one-eighth of an inch. I take it that that is the tube used for water supplies now. The duty is 75 per cent. and tacked on to that is a note to the effect that the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, can remit the whole thing. That at once, to my mind, admits that we are not producing anywhere near our requirements, and that the Ministers will have a chat and will allow them in under licence free of duty. I should like to know two things, which are very important. Are we near producing our requirements, and have those things been sufficiently tested? It is terribly important that they should be good, and should be guaranteed to be up to standard. It is not good enough to dump an inferior article on a person who is not going to use it outright, but is going to use it in the construction of something else. The Minister will admit there is a difference between an article which will be used up in a year or so and one which is used as a constructional part of something else which should last for a life-time. In any case, I am not satisfied that they are produced here in sufficient quantities.

Comment on this

I cannot say that the factory is in production yet, but it will be very soon.

Comment on this

That is a bit of a joke. Are we grown-up babies, to be talking about a 75 per cent. tariff on those articles? Deputy Good would be a better authority than I am——

Comment on this

Nobody will pay the duty until the Irish goods are available.

Comment on this

Then why are we putting it on?

Comment on this

To regulate imports.

Comment on this

Is it to regiment us? Is it to put us all into a militia?

Comment on this

It is to prevent forestalling.

Comment on this

The Minister need not worry about forestalling, as if anybody is going to start now to get in all that would be necessary to meet their requirements. I suppose there would be 100 feet used in a comparatively small house, and you cannot go on without it. There is going to be a 75 per cent. tariff put on, before you make one foot of it. I heard a story about a popular gentleman in the City of Dublin who went into Grangegorman. One of the inmates said to him "What do you think the wall is there for?" The gentleman replied "I do not know" and the inmate went on to say "You fools think that is to keep us in here, but it is not; it is to keep you out." I think there are worse people outside than there are in Grangegorman.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

Deputy Kelly and myself agree on one thing and we will vote together on this.

Comment on this

It is open to you to prove it.

Comment on this

Here is a written document——

Comment on this

And there is the author.

Comment on this

——to help Irish industry and to help us to use the products of Irish industry. We cannot build houses in the City of Dublin without perhaps 100 or 200 feet of this tubing. It is all the same whether it is 100 feet or a mile or one inch; you must see it to build a house. There is none of it made here, but the enterprising Minister for Finance, after, I presume, consultation with the equally enterprising Minister for Industry and Commerce, said: "Now, to help Irish industry and make the people support Irish industry we will put a tariff of 75 per cent. on this copper tubing, even though none of it is made here yet. That is the way to help housing. Then, if anybody wants to import it, let him ask us and we will allow him to import it duty free." If the Minister for Industry and Commerce is really serious about industry he should start the industry before he talks about protecting it. This is a joke and a very serious joke.

Comment on this

That is what our predecessors tried, and they did not get the industries.

Comment on this

What did they try?

Comment on this

To start the industry before protection. They did not start many.

Comment on this

The industries which they started throve and prospered.

Comment on this

I bet you will not vote against that one.

Comment on this

What one?

Comment on this

The copper tubes.

Comment on this

Wait until I have finished and you will find out.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton might.

Comment on this

Sure, and I was a protectionist before the Minister.

Comment on this

And for the next five weeks they will try to persuade the people down in Galway that they did not.

Comment on this

I see. It is an election stunt then.

Comment on this

I would not vote against it if it were produced here.

Comment on this

Now you have thought about it you will not vote against it.

Comment on this

I see the Minister's position. It is an election stunt.

Comment on this

You had better be careful or you will be found guilty of sabotage.

Comment on this

I have been found guilty of a lot of things. I do not mind what their drumhead courtsmartial find me guilty of. Then we are to have a duty on refrigerating or cold storage apparatus. We are putting everything into cold storage in this country, but now if we want to get in a cold storage apparatus we are to pay 25 per cent. on it.

Comment on this

You need not bring it in. There is better stuff made in Ireland.

Comment on this

If we need not bring it in, why have this special provision?

"Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, so thinks proper, the Revenue Commissioners may, by licence, authorise any particular person, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of the duty mentioned, at this reference number any articles chargeable with such duty..."

What is the need for that if we need not import them? That is a confession that we have not got them here. They will be let in under licence. I do not know whether we make pencils here, and those other articles mentioned, but I should like to know. If there was any advocate of constructive economic nationality in this country, that man was the late Arthur Griffith. He would turn in his grave if he saw that.

Comment on this

On those Financial Resolutions I first wish to direct the attention of the House to sub-section (3) of the preamble:

"That the provisions (if any) set forth in the fourth column of the Schedule to this Resolution at any reference number in that Schedule shall have effect in respect of the duty mentioned at that reference number."

That amounts to a licensing provision authorising the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to admit free of duty certain commodities to certain selected applicants. I have directed the attention of the House to the abuses which have grown up under that practice in the past, and I ask the House to refuse those powers to the Minister in connection with this Customs Resolution. I do so particularly in view of two specific cases which I am in a position to bring under the attention of the House. I need hardly explain to Deputies that it is extremely difficult to get information of those abuses from the people who are benefiting by them, and that, therefore, it is a matter of some surprise to me that I have been able to run down two cases which the Minister is not in a position to deny. One relates to licences to import elastic and bootlaces, which were granted to a firm that was at one time, I think, in Suffolk Street or Wicklow Street in the City of Dublin, and which now has its headquarters in the town of Ennis. That firm entered, I believe, into some negotiations with the Minister, and held themselves out as persons who were prepared to engage in the manufacture of bootlaces, elastic, and certain other minor items of haberdashery. On that representation, steps were taken through the medium of a tariff to restrict the import of bootlaces and elastic. I think an Emergency (Imposition of Duties) Order was made. Shortly after that time a merchant applied to the Minister for Industry and Commerce for a direction to the Revenue Commissioners that a licence should issue, so that he might import these commodities free of duty. He was informed that the Minister for Industry and Commerce would not grant the licence, and he was referred to a firm in Wicklow Street or Suffolk Street — I do not know which — for the commodities he required. The merchant applied there for elastic and bootlaces of Saorstát manufacture, and he was told by the people in Suffolk Street that they had no supplies of Irish manufacture but they could supply him with foreign elastic and foreign bootlaces. He was obliged to get the articles there. He immediately drew the attention of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to this anomaly, and after the lapse of some time he was notified that the Minister was now prepared to issue a licence to import the goods.

Comment on this

Is this the case that was discussed at length here a year ago?

Comment on this

This is a case that I have brought to the attention of the House once before.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to refresh his memory, he can get all the facts in the Official Report.

Comment on this

So much for that particular transaction. It emerges since that while this firm in Wicklow Street was seeking the privilege which it got, the privilege of the exclusive right to import elastic and boot laces free of duty, another individual of this State, who had spent the greater part of his life as a traveller in boot laces, applied for a licence to import the braid wherefrom boot laces are made, free of duty, and he was refused. His proposal was that he would get in the braid, put the tags on after cutting the braid into boot lace lengths, and then dispose of the laces to his customers. He was refused. I want to know why he was refused, while the people now in Ennis were granted a licence.

Comment on this

That is obvious — I could not make it any more obvious.

Comment on this

How is it obvious? Why should he be refused while the others were granted the licence? Does the Minister admit that was the case?

Comment on this

Certainly. Everybody else was refused the licence.

Comment on this

Except the firm in Ennis?

Comment on this

Yes, the firm who were building a factory to carry on the manuture.

Comment on this

Now we have the admission made which has never been made before.

Comment on this

Of course it has been.

Comment on this

About four months prior to these incidents a Bill connected with cereals was passing through the House and on the industrial provisions of the Bill the general question of licences arose. The Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance were sitting side by side on the Benches opposite. I asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce would he accept an amendment to the industrial provisions of that Bill requiring that if he gave a licence to any Saorstát citizen to import certain goods over a certain period, any other Saorstát citizen could claim as of right a similar licence. The Minister for Finance interrupted to say: "That is the law." I replied: "It is not the law. Will the Minister for Industry and Commerce undertake to make it so?" and the Minister for Industry and Commerce shook his head. When he came to wind up the debate I reminded him that the Minister for Finance believed that it was the law that any citizen was entitled as of right to demand the same licence as his neighbour got, but the Minister for Industry and Commerce replied: "You know that is what is always done." I replied: "It is not always done, but will you place on yourself a legal obligation to do it?" The Minister sat down, a division was challenged and he brought the boys into the Lobby and, as usual, not one of them knew what he was voting for and the result was that I was voted down.

Now, the same Minister, whose colleague said there was no statutory obligation on them to issue a licence and who himself said that such was the universal practice even if there was no statutory obligation, states, he freely admits, that he was granting a licence to a firm in Ennis to import this merchandise while he was refusing other citizens and he makes no bones about it. That is a long progress from the first position taken up in the House. Any fair-minded Deputy will recognise that the Minister has at last admitted what he has never admitted heretofore, and that is that he was prepared to discriminate between one citizen and another if one was prepared to give him certain undertakings as to future action that the other citizen was not prepared to give. This House had never any intention of conferring on the Minister a discretion of that character, which amounts to a powerful penal weapon, and he is so using it.

Comment on this

The intention of using the licensing power in that way was announced in the Dáil.

Comment on this

Anyone not prepared to climb on the band-wagon and boom up the industrial fraud which the Minister set out to put over on the country, and which Deputy Belton so ably indicted to-day, would not be considered. Unless you are prepared to go out and say that the industries which are thriving and prospering, the industries which were founded under the late Government these are quite useless, that they are no good, and that no one got industrial employment until Seán Lemass became the Minister for Industry and Commerce, you will get no licence and you will get no permissions under this section so long as there is some one who is prepared to boost the Minister up, applying for a similar thing. I declare that that is a grave injustice. If one citizen gets a licence, every other citizen is entitled to get a similar licence for a similar period of time. If a provision to that effect is not inserted, then grave injustice will be done.

I cited one case of a merchant who applied for a licence to import bootlaces and elastic, and I cited the case of a man who applied for a licence to import braid to make boot laces and who was refused, while another citizen got such a licence. Now, I charge the Minister with another specific case. A merchant in Inishowen applied for a licence to import a Crossley engine for industrial purposes and he was refused.

Comment on this

Is this the case the Deputy asked a Parliamentary question about?

Comment on this

The Minister will hear the facts in due course. I will give him all the information.

Comment on this

May I suggest to the Deputy that he might have informed the Minister of his intention to raise these matters? Perhaps the Deputy was afraid.

Comment on this

The Minister must sit down.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Neither of these matters arise on this Resolution. This Resolution imposes a duty on specific articles and the matters the Deputy is introducing do not, I submit, arise.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

By what power does the Minister impose a licence?

Comment on this

A specific power in relation to each duty.

Comment on this

Surely Deputy Dillon was entitled to advance reasons and proofs as to why these powers, in their present form, to grant licences should not be granted to the Minister?

Comment on this

I submit that the Deputy might have had the decency to inform the Minister that he would raise these matters, but apparently decency is not a recognised characteristic of some of the Deputies opposite.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dillon was quoting reasons why the existing powers in regard to licences should not be permitted, and I allowed him to proceed on that line.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister rose to make a point of order and he has now said that practically his only reason for rising was to make a point and that he had got in what he wanted to say. I suggest that is a gross abuse of the privilege of the House and disrespect for the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I did not catch what the Minister said. I understood he rose to make a point of order and I ruled against the Minister.

Comment on this

And then he said: "I got in what I wanted to say."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair did not hear that.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny it?

Comment on this

I have quoted two cases which the Minister, with that brazen-faced audacity with which he faces the House habitually, admits.

Comment on this

Is that in order?

Comment on this

The third case is as follows. A merchant in Inishowen applied to the Minister for a licence to import a Crossley engine for industrial purposes. The Minister refused the licence. The merchant went to the source of supply to purchase the engine and then discovered that an individual who was virtually his next door neighbour was importing an identical engine on a licence supplied by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

The Deputy's statement is entirely untrue. There was an interval of two years between the two cases. The Deputy is stating an untruth, which he knows to be an untruth, because he got a reply to a Parliamentary question which he addressed to me on the matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister cannot be allowed to say that the Deputy is with knowledge stating an untruth, or making a statement which he knows is untrue.

Comment on this

I want to point out that the Deputy asked a Parliamentary question——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister will have to withdraw the remark with regard to Deputy Dillon. There can be no qualification. The House must have a withdrawal simpliciter in this matter. The Minister said that the Deputy made a statement which he knows is untrue.

Comment on this

I would like to withdraw at your request, but he has made a statement which he was informed by me in reply to a Parliamentary question, was untrue.

Comment on this

Simpliciter!

Comment on this

The Minister now brings into this question a letter which I received from his Department, marked "Private and Confidential." I am not going to follow the Minister into a discussion on the contents of that letter unless he will allow me to deal with it freely.

Comment on this

Certainly. It was marked "Private and Confidential" at the Deputy's request.

Comment on this

The circumstances are as follows: I put down a Parliamentary question to the Minister in relation to this transaction, and the Minister made an evasive reply. I made further and fuller inquiries in order to be able to nail the Minister's ear to the post which I proceeded to do. When his ear was inextricably nailed to the post, I got a long letter from the Department setting out all the facts which in his first Parliamentary answer he had sought to deny. He then sent a letter——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have allowed the Deputy to proceed to give the details of a certain case very fully. I allowed him to do so on the assumption that his contention was that the Minister should not be allowed to give licences in these cases. We cannot however, discuss or go into the merits and demerits of every application for a licence that the Minister granted or refused, as the Deputy is attempting to do.

Comment on this

I alleged certain things which the Minister admitted promptly, and I passed on. Then I alleged certain other things, and the Minister, in a disorderly fashion, arose and said that I was stating an untruth. Now, he has put me on my proof.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister withdrew that part of the statement — at least that part in which he said that the Deputy had made a certain statement knowing that it was untrue. I cannot allow every question arising in connection with every licence to be discussed on this reference. I allowed the Deputy to refer to this licence to prove his contention that the Minister should not be allowed power under this reference to give a licence.

Comment on this

Under sub-section (3) of the preamble, power is conferred on the Minister to grant licences to certain individuals. I want to build up the case that there had been repeated abuses under this power, a case which will convince the House that it is not safe to give the Minister this power. That is my respectful submission to you, Sir. If I had only one case perhaps the Minister would say: "Well, mistakes will happen in the best regulated families; possibly there has been a mistake." Surely, I am entitled to quote other cases in which abuses have occurred to uphold my contention? If you do not let me do so the Minister can say: "Well, there may have been a few mistakes but that will happen in the best regulated families."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely the Deputy cannot be allowed to go into every case in which a licence was granted or refused?

Comment on this

Surely I am entitled to direct the attention of the House to the relevant facts of every case which, I say, proves my contention?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

To go into the merits of every case?

Comment on this

I can set out the facts. I am not discussing the merits.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy was proceeding to discuss the merits and the demerits.

Comment on this

All I want to do is to lay the facts before the House and to say to the House: "I think that it is an abuse and if you agree with me that it is an abuse, is it not time to say to the Minister: ‘We refuse to give you these powers any longer'"?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow the Deputy discuss the merits and demerits of each case.

Comment on this

I merely want to state the facts. Two merchants applied for a licence under a power similar to that conferred by sub-section (3) of the preamble of the Resolution. One merchant was refused a licence, but he bought his engine and brought it in. The second merchant bought his engine, brought it in under licence, and paid no duty. Both engines came into Saorstát Eireann about the same time, but it emerged, when the Minister was pressed, that the first application for a licence had been granted to a man about eight months before the second application had been made. The licence lay fallow, for want of a better word, in this man's hands for a considerable time but he elected to use it at the same time as the other merchant was bringing in his engine. While it is true that there was a time lag between the two applications——

Comment on this

Two years, to be exact.

Comment on this

Does the Minister allege that there was an interval of two years between the issue of the licence and the engine being brought in?

Comment on this

Does the Minister allege that there were two years between the engine being brought in and the other licence being asked for?

Comment on this

And the other licence being refused.

Comment on this

I shall have to look up the correspondence with the Minister on the matter. Furthermore, I now allege in addition to the facts which I laid before the House on the occasion of the Parliamentary question, that there was another application made to the Minister for a licence to import an engine within two months of the first successful application and that was refused. Why, in the exact terms of my allegation, can one man get a licence, say in February, 1933, when another man unsuccessfully applied for a licence before 1st August, 1933, and when a third man unsuccessfully applied for a licence in January of 1934? These are not the exact dates, but they bear the relation to one another that the actual dates in fact do. I allege that the licencee under the first licence in February, 1933, brought in his engine in February, 1934, and that that engine was in transit at the time the controversy was going on between the third applicant and the Department for the licence under which he sought to bring in a similar conveyance. On these grounds I urge the House to withhold from the Minister the powers which he seeks under sub-section (3) of the preamble to the Resolution.

I desire to direct the attention of the Minister to the terms of Paragraph No. 3 under which it is sought to impose a Customs duty of 33? per cent. on cotton bandages and bandaging material imported in rolls. I take it these are largely used by the hospitals of the country. Quite apart from anything else, I do want to submit that it is highly undersirable to make these things subject to a Customs duty, unless we are able to supply them here, for the simple reason that the delay, which Customs supervision inevitably entails, may cause the very greatest inconvenience.

I have no doubt that we could make ordinary cotton bandages of one kind or another in this country. But this is a case I think in which the Government should indicate their willingness to give a subsidy to cotton bandage-makers until they are able to supply sufficient of them of the right kind for hospitals and other institutions. I ask the Minister to consider whether he ought really to put a duty on crêpe bandages; they are indispensable to invalid persons. It is vital they should be of a special quality and have the necessary tensive strength; otherwise they may be worse than useless. I know no one who has any experience of making surgical bandages of that kind, and I think it is imprudent to impose a tariff upon them unless the Minister is satisfied on the assurance of surgeons in this country that facilities for the turning out of such bandages are available and are of the very best quality in Saorstát Eireann.

From curiosity I would inquire why the Minister is putting on a duty on ice. Does he apprehend that there will be forestalling at the North Wall while we are awaiting the setting up of that industry? Does he contemplate going down to open a new industry close to a turf manufactury, for the manufacture of ice?

Comment on this

They have been opened already.

Comment on this

I think it is well to note that the terms of sub-section (3) will be available in regard to a tariff on ice. If a Deputy shows an urgent desire to import a block of ice from Peru he can do so.

Comment on this

No; that is intended entirely for Donegal.

Comment on this

Paragraph 25 deals with prayer books, missals, breviaries, hymnals and so on, used for the purpose of religious worship. I do not know whether Deputies are aware that, contrary to the well-established practice of the Fianna Fáil Party, the Minister referred the question of a duty on these things to the Tariff Commission and they reported against them.

Comment on this

Nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not read the report.

Comment on this

If the Deputy can produce a unanimous finding of the Commission against I shall give him £5.

Comment on this

I am very thankful indeed for this evidence of generosity on the Minister's part. Will he agree that the evidence was against tariffs on breviaries and hymnals, on the ground that the sale of these books in Saorstát Eireann made it unthinkable that they could be produced here and, that that would mean that the tariff would have to be paid by the persons who used them, and that they were persons least able to bear the expenditure. So far as I am aware every Franciscan monastery and similar institution in the country will have to pay this tariff on breviaries and hymnals. Every Protestant community will have to pay the tariff on hymnals they import because they will not be used in sufficient quantities to justify their production by Saorstát firms. Many of the regular Orders of the Catholic Church who have such ritual will find it impossible to get supplies of their particular missals in Saorstát Eireann, and will, therefore, have to pay the tariff on the imported ones. The Minister must find himself put to the pin of his collar when he has to come out and collect tariffs from the parsonages of the Protestant Church and the friaries and monastic institutions of the Catholic Church. The Minister waxes very eloquent over our roofless monasteries and ruined churches but he ought to refrain from making his contribution to the injury of the monasteries and the friaries by his tariff on breviaries and hymnals and other books used in these institutions. I suggest that if he would do so we might rest quietly with regard to the imminence of the Protestant Succession in this country.

In regard to the question of advertising on pencils the Minister may have observed that in recent years a desirable practice has grown up of advertising one's wares or place of business on highly enamelled pencils. This is an advantage to the poor and that is something that one ought to think of in a case of this kind. These pencils are of a superior quality. They are made in Czecho Slovakia by the same people who used to make the Koh-i-noor pencil which was for many years a standard of excellence. It is well worth a merchant's while to buy these turned out with an advertisement of his business on them and sell them to the national schools at a price which the cheapest black lead pencil could be sold at. Because they are a good advertisement for his trade or business he is compensated for any loss in the transaction so that these pencils which cost him 16/- a gross are supplied to the children at one penny apiece, and to school teachers at 9d. per dozen so that they can sell them to the children. I am certain that the production of that style of pencil cannot be contemplated in this country and that no serious difficulty can arise where the pencil was admitted with the name of the person who distributes such on the pencils. In that way a number of persons derive considerable benefit that would otherwise be denied to them if the Resolution is passed in its present form. Subject to these observations, and with special reference to sub-section (3) of the preamble I propose to oppose this Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

I wonder why is it that when we are discussing import licences in this House we are always treated to several scenes by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I hardly remember an occasion on which we were discussing import licences that the Minister has not lost his temper and treated the House to the most amazing display.

Comment on this

Dear, dear.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance was not here and I do not think I ever heard the Minister for Finance so lose his head as the Minister for Industry and Commerce does. The Minister for Industry and Commerce displays great anger on every occasion this particular subject is mentioned. But if the Minister would only consider the matter seriously he would realise that his system is bad. It can only lead to abuse; it cannot avoid leading to abuse if kept up for any long time. I think the House ought to take every opportunity of resisting every attempt to extend this system. Yet instead of some curb being put upon this system of licences we find that month after month it is being extended, though it can only lead to corruption in the long run. But there is no good in the Minister losing his temper. I wonder whether there any Deputies in this House who have not heard serious complaints about the abuses of this system or of any kind of licensing system that is at present in vogue and that is being extended. If a Deputy tries to probe into that and asks for the full evidence he is told that he cannot get it.

Comment on this

Who told him?

Comment on this