We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote 57—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).

Contributions 1–219 of 424. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

Yesterday I stated it was my intention to give on this Estimate a general review of the work done by the Department of Industry and Commerce in the past year, and also of the work which it is now doing and hopes to do in the coming year. The Department of Industry and Commerce has many activities and covers many phases of the national life, but its most important work at the present time consists in the development of industries and it is in relation to that aspect that I would like, first of all, to inform the Dáil of the progress made and of the additional progress which we hope to make.

Deputies are aware that the development of industry has been proceeding here with considerable rapidity during the past couple of years. Previous to the change of Government, various measures designed to promote industrial development were adopted which, however, did not produce material results and, in fact, in some directions there was considerable retrogression. During the decade prior to the change of Government certain industries disappeared and other industries fell away considerably. I am glad to say that most of the arrears of development have been made good and a number, if not all, of the industries which disappeared in the previous decade have been revived and are now flourishing in the Saorstát.

Deputies on occasions take as the index of the progress of our industrial policy the number of new factories established, but that index is a misleading one because, of course, the greater part of the development that has taken place has been in the form of extended production of existing concerns. It is true that a number of new industries have been established, but the greater part of the progress made to date has taken the form of an extension of previously existing industries. For example, the flour milling industry is a very old one in this country, but, during the period prior to 1932, that industry got into considerable difficulties. A number of the flour mills were closed down and others of them found their production considerably decreasing. The position was reached in 1931 that, of the mills then in existence, most of them were working only to half their capacity, and roughly half of the country's requirements in flour was being imported.

The development of the flour milling industry was one of the first tasks to which we put our hand and I am glad to say that it has been very successful indeed. Not merely are all the mills that were working to half their capacity in 1931 now engaged to full capacity, but the capacity of a number of them has been extended by the installation of additional equipment. In addition, three of the mills that were closed down during the previous decade have been re-opened and are now working to full capacity and two new mills have been established. There is at the present time a sufficient flour milling capacity in the Saorstát to supply all the requirements in flour of the people of this State. From the 1st April in this year the importation of flour, other than for biscuit manufacture, ceased and, I hope, ceased finally. There are two new mills about to come into production, licences for an additional three have been promised and plans for their erection are, I understand, proceeding. When these new mills are in production, the flour milling capacity of the Saorstát concerns will be substantially in excess of the country's requirements and that is the situation that we aimed to achieve when, in July of 1932, this programme was embarked upon.

Another industry which received early attention, and the development of which has been remarkably rapid, has been the apparel industry, the industry concerned in the production of men's and women's outer garments, of under garments, shirts, hats, gloves and of children's garments. There were, of course, a number of concerns engaged in the production of these goods prior to 1932. All of them have increased their production considerably. In addition, according to the Factories and Workshops Register, there have been 72 additional manufacturing concerns established for the production of women's clothing; 29 new factories established for the production of men's outer clothing; ten new factories established for the manufacture of waterproof and leather clothing, and ten new factories producing shirts and collars. Associated with those industries there is the hosiery industry, an industry which has long been established in the Saorstát and which, in fact, has given a Saorstát place-name to a particular class of hosiery goods. The industry, however, was not very productive when we acquired the responsibility for dealing with industrial matters and by far the greater proportion of the hosiery goods used in this country was imported. Since then, however, substantial strides have been made. The production of hosiery goods of all kinds, manufactured from cotton, wool, and artificial silk, has increased very considerably and 25 new hosiery factories have been established since 1932.

The manufacture of sacks and bags of paper and of cloth is becoming an important industry in this country and, because of changes in trading habits generally, it is becoming an important industry in all countries. There have been seven new factories established for the manufacture of articles of that kind. The manufacture of yeast was protected in 1932 and, although there has been no new factory established, the production from the existing concerns has increased very considerably, with the result that they are now in a position to supply all the requirements of the country in bakers' yeast.

Another industry of considerable importance which existed for a long time in the Saorstát was the manufacture of furniture of various descriptions, household and industrial, of wood and metal. The development of that industry was also taken in hand in 1932 and the progress made has been quite considerable to date. A number of new concerns have been established and all the requirements of the country in furniture of all descriptions, whether of wood or metal, can now be supplied from these concerns.

In the year 1931 there was a very substantial importation of paints and varnish. With the contemplated development of the Government's housing programme and, consequently, a substantially increased demand for housing materials of all kinds, including paints and varnish, it was decided to endeavour to develop that industry at the beginning, so that the increased demand would be translated to employment in Irish factories. We were, I think, very successful in the development of that industry. The previously existing concerns, which were few in number, have all developed considerably and, in addition, nine new factories have been established in various parts of the Saorstát.

Another industry which is becoming of rapidly increasing importance in all countries, because of the changed methods of trading, is the production of cardboard boxes, containers and cartons, and the development of that industry in the Saorstát has been remarkably rapid. During the last couple of years ten new factories have been established and all classes of cartons, containers and cardboard boxes can now be supplied from these factories. I might draw particular attention to the cigarette cartons which, previous to last year, were imported. The establishment last year of three new factories for the production of cigarette cartons represented the final stage in the development of that industry, apart from containers such as cylindrical boxes and waxed-container factories for the production of which are being established but have not yet come into production.

Equally important is the production of boxes and containers of tin. At an early date an import duty on such containers was imposed, with the result that that industry has developed considerably, and tin boxes of all descriptions are now available from Saorstát factories. The same can be said of boxes in wood. The duty imposed on cases for the packing of eggs, which was a very substantial item in our import statistics in the past, has resulted in a widespread development and the establishment of a number of concerns all over the Saorstát for the production of these cases, and also for the production of other articles made from wood. The number of new saw-mills brought into production has been very considerable. There has also been a remarkable increase in the production of factory-made joinery. There is still a certain importation of joinery work, but I hope that that will disappear when the additional large-scale commercial joinery works which are now planned are constructed and come into operation.

We have frequently discussed here in the past the position with regard to boot and shoe development. The development of the boot and shoe industry was one of the most difficult tasks that fell to us. It is an industry that requires a high degree of skill on behalf of the operators. Skilled operatives were not available in the country. The practice in Great Britain and other countries is to require a five-years' apprenticeship from people proposing to engage in that industry. We were faced with the necessity of securing rapid development here, and, at the same time, training workers to the same degree of efficiency as in Great Britain in a much shorter period. In the year 1931, the Saorstát shoe and boot factories were supplying from 10 to 12 per cent. of the total requirements in boots and shoes in the Saorstát. This year the Saorstát factories will supply 75 per cent. of the boots and shoes required, and next year they will supply 100 per cent. There has been a considerable development in the equipment and production capacity of the firms that were in existence in 1931, and in addition eight new factories have been established. Added to those, four others are now being equipped and will commence operations in the near future. When they are in full production there will be no need to import any of the boots and shoes required here.

The production of bricks and tiles was also undertaken. Having regard to the housing programme, a substantial number of new brickworks have been opened in various places throughout the country. The number of concerns for the production of tiles of concrete is very considerable now. Fourteen new concerns were established for the production of chemicals, disinfectants, cosmetics and articles of that description, and the country's requirements of these goods can now be supplied from these concerns. The development of the brush and broom industry has been also considerable.

It is perhaps not generally appreciated that one of the most important industries in the country is the printing industry. At a very early stage we endeavoured to secure its development because of its importance, having regard to the nature of the employment it gives and to the value of the printed goods of all descriptions which had previously been imported. The development of that industry has been, I think, sufficient to eliminate completely unemployment from the skilled printing trade. A number of new concerns have been established, so that printing of all descriptions is being undertaken here, some of it of a very high class indeed, particularly the new colour printing which is being done in some of the newer factories and which experts have told me is far superior to work of the same description procurable in other countries.

A couple of new factories were established for the manufacture of buttons. In 1931, despite the tariffs in operation from 1925, there was still a substantial importation of soaps and candles. That importation has not been entirely eliminated, but it has fallen to insignificant proportions through the development of the existing soap and candle works here. There have been a number of new firms established for the production of canned fruits, canned meats, soups and articles of that description.

At a very early stage we were determined that the development of the hosiery industry would not take the form it had taken in other countries and which it was threatening to take here. That was the form of a mere making-up industry, taking knitted fabrics from other countries and fabricating them into hosiery goods here. Consequently, though there was no sign at the time of any considerable production of knitted fabrics taking place in this country, we imposed, in the first Budget in 1932, duties upon these fabrics. Licences to import were issued to a number of firms, but they were given due notice which extended from 18 to 24 months that in each case we would expect them to be in a position to produce their own knitted fabrics or else procure their requirements from firms in the country. In the last year, the issue of licences was terminated because we are satisfied that the new concerns established in that industry were sufficient to supply the immediate requirements of the country. The requirements of the country will, of course, increase as the hosiery industry itself develops, but there is no reason to anticipate that the development in the production of knitted fabrics will not keep pace with the requirements of the hosiery industry.

The production of woven fabrics is, of course, an old industry in this country, but that, like all others of the older industries, has also developed considerably. There is at the present time a very complete production sufficient to meet the requirements in linen fabrics, in certain classes of cotton fabrics and in most classes of woollen fabrics. In due course we hope to secure the establishment of the silk fabric industry, and the Executive Council has given notice of its intention to make a Reserved Commodity Order in respect of knitted art-silk fabrics, the purpose being to secure that the development of that industry will be directed towards the Western counties, but no such Order has yet been made.

The development of the confectionery industry is well known to Deputies. There was, in the year 1931, a substantial importation of confectionery goods, amounting to half a million pounds' worth. The development of the confectionery business by concerns here, for the production of confectionery, of flour, chocolate, and so on, have been sufficient to ensure that our full requirements are being met with from within the country.

There has also arisen out of our housing programme an increased necessity for foundry products, and it was decided to make a special effort within the country for the production of grates and ranges and other foundry goods in connection with housing, such as rain-pipe gutters and so on. There is still a not inconsiderable import of grates and ranges. The imports last year showed a small tendency to increase, but as the production of these goods here is rapidly developing, and with the new concerns that will arise in the course of the coming year and the increased production, these articles should disappear from our imports statistics. The fabrication of steel work for constructional purposes is also being established as an industry here. It is not possible for us, having regard to the size of our market, to produce the rolled steel required for constructional purposes, but there is no reason why the fabrication of that steel should not be done here. It was necessary occasionally to issue licences for the importation of fabricated steel where the type of work was not of a kind capable of being done in such Saorstát concerns as exist, or in special cases of urgency. The development, nevertheless, has been considerable, and some of the new buildings constructed with steel work entirely fabricated within the country, are a credit to the firms engaged in that industry.

In 1932 the old and formerly famous marble industry in the Saorstát had disappeared. None of the marble quarries in the Saorstát was in production then and we made a special effort to revive the industry. Up to date two marble quarries in Connemara have been re-opened and are in a position to take orders. With the changes we have effected in the duty this year, we hope to commence production in some of the other quarries, and I hope, in due course, the industry will recover some of its former importance.

The production of polishes of all kind is now sufficient to supply the demands of the country. A commencement was made in the manufacture of metal polish, which was not liable to duty formerly, but was made liable to duty by the Budget this year.

The manufacture of spades, forks and shovels and other agricultural implements has been undertaken, and a number of industries established in various parts of the country. The full requirements of the country for implements of that kind are met by those concerns.

The development of the boot and shoe industry made it possible to establish a number of other industries supplying that trade. The first of these tackled was the establishment of tanneries for sole and insole leather. And Although we are not yet in the position to supply all the requirements of the boot and shoe industry with leather of that description, nevertheless we are getting near to that position. With the establishment of the new tannery that is to be opened in the south-east corner of the country, and with the development of the tanneries in Limerick and elsewhere, and the new tannery established at Portlaw, I think we are well advanced and will shortly be to a position when we can close down all imports of sole and insole leather. I shall deal with other classes of leather later on. I am now dealing with industries that existed in the Saorstát prior to 1932, the development of which had not received the attention it should.

With regard to woollen and worsted tissues, its development creates the possibility of increasing the production of woollen and worsted yarns. Production of fingering yarns has been commenced by two firms. But because of the development of the weaving industry concerned, there has been an increase in the importation of woollen and worsted yarns, and although a number of the industries are now using their own, there is a lot to be done before Irish woollens and worsteds can be said to be 100 per cent. Irish.

Further, arising out of the housing programme, the production of slates for roofing purposes has received attention. Various exceptional measures were adopted to develop new quarries in various parts of the country. Grants for quarrying purposes were made, and these were expended for the purpose of clearing quarries by the removal of over-burden, or removing debris from quarries formerly worked, but since closed down, so that their new development could be proceeded with. We are not yet in a position to supply promptly all the slates required by house builders. There is still scope for development despite the fact that new quarries are being opened. Even when we get to the stage that we will be able to supply all our own demands, there is no reason why the industry should stop there, because there is unlimited demand for Irish slates in other countries where sometimes they command a higher price than those of other countries.

The development of the rope and cord industry is also proceeding, and a number of new concerns have been established in various parts of the country. The only substantial item in respect of these goods not produced is binder twine. But a commencement has been made this year. The full requirements will not be provided this year, but we are expecting that they will be next year.

I need not refer to the development of the sugar industry, for all Deputies are aware of that. The establishment of three new sugar factories has brought the production of sugar to a point very nearly up to all our requirements in this country.

So much for the development that has taken place in respect to industries which, to some extent, existed here previous to 1932. Apart, however, from the development indicated by the facts and figures I have given, a number of new industries, which never previously existed, have been created, and a number of industries which previously existed here but which disappeared before 1932, have been revived. The list of these industries is, I think, quite impressive. We commence with the production of aluminium hollow ware in Tipperary; vegetable oils and oil cake manufacture in Drogheda, and a large commercial pottery established at Arklow. There was a pottery in the South of Ireland engaged in the production of certain classes of pottery but that pottery was on a comparatively small scale. It has increased its production considerably, but the full requirements of the country in all classes of pottery goods will, it is hoped, be provided from the new concern at Arklow. The manufacture of suit cases, handbags and attache cases from fibre, and also similar goods of other descriptions, has been undertaken by a number of concerns. A new factory at Portarlington is producing fibre cases and handbags. The manufacture of dry electric batteries has been undertaken by a couple of concerns and the full requirements of the country are now being supplied by these firms.

At an early stage we decided that there was no good reason why bicycles which were imported into this country should be imported completely assembled. We did not at that time contemplate the development of a bicycle manufacturing industry, but by imposing a duty on assembled bicycles, a duty which did not apply to the unassembled parts, a number of firms were induced to go into the business of assembling bicycles. Quite a substantial little industry has been built up in consequence. We have now reached the stage at which we can give more detailed attention to the possibility of manufacturing parts of bicycles in the country. That is having attention at the present time. Two concerns were established for the manufacture of razor blades.

One of the most controversial matters upon which the Government entered was the development of the motor assembling industry. It is within the recollection of Deputies that none of the industrial plans of the Government met with fiercer opposition here in the Dáil than those designed to secure the development of the motor vehicle assembling industry. There were a number of prophets of disaster, a number of people who told us here that we were attempting the impossible and that there were physical, commercial, economic and financial reasons why that industry could never be established in the Saorstát. In fact, I recollect that when in the early part of 1933, before the general election of that year, a certain deputation went to the head office of Cumann na nGaedheal—it was Cumann na nGaedheal then—they were assured by the representatives whom they saw there—Deputy McGilligan and others— that all the tariffs which the Fianna Fáil Government had imposed would be kept on by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government that they expected was coming into office that year, except one and the one tariff they barred was that designed to secure the establishment of the motor assembling industry. Well, the industry is established. It is quite an important industry and it is giving employment to several hundred skilled adult workers. The products of the industry are equal in appearance and in quality to anything that was previously imported. The prices have not been increased and certain classes of cars are available here at prices lower than similar models may be procured in Britain. I do not think there is anybody in this House or outside it to-day who would seriously urge that our plans should be reversed so as to allow completely assembled cars in at the lower rates which obtained before this Government came into office.

Comment on this

What models are cheaper here than in Great Britain?

Comment on this

Most of the American models. A number of concerns were established for the production of bolts and nuts. Various descriptions of bolts and nuts are being produced in Dublin and in other factories situated in different parts of the country. The glass bottle industry had a rather varied history in this country. It is not necessary for me to recount it in detail. Suffice it to say that in 1931 there appeared to be a final collapse of the efforts which had been made to keep that industry going and the industry was, in fact, non-existent in 1932 when the change of Government took place. I am glad to say that that industry has now been revived. It has been revived on a very extended scale. All classes of bottles are now being produced at the concern in Ringsend and, in fact, a not unsubstantial export trade has been created by the company.

The manufacture of printing ink has been undertaken for the first time. The manufacture of shotgun cartridges has commenced in Galway. At the present time I understand that there is an international claybird shooting competition taking place, or about to take place, in the Saorstát. I have been informed by the organisers that the only cartridges used in connection with that competition will be made in Ireland. A number of new factories have been established in Dublin, Cork and elsewhere for the manufacture of metal windows, the popularity of which seems to be growing with house designers generally. The manufacture of electric cables has been undertaken for the first time at New Ross. Deputies are all aware of the fact that the manufacture of rubber tyres and tubes for motor cars, motor bicycles and bicycles has been undertaken in Cork. The manufacture of linen thread has commenced in Dublin. Two factories have been established for the production of galvanised buckets, pails and similar goods. The manufacture of leather handbags and similar leather commodities has also been commenced. There is still a considerable importation of these goods but we hope to overtake it during the present year. The manufacture of paper book matches was commenced for the first time in 1933, also the manufacture of splints from which wooden matches are made. The manufacture of oxygen, as is apparent from some of the debates in the Dáil, has also commenced in the Saorstát. I might also refer to the assembly and partial manufacture of refrigerators.

I am not putting forward this list as being necessarily complete. The Department of Industry and Commerce is publishing an official Directory of industries, and Deputies will be able to get full particulars in that publication of the classes of goods now made in the Saorstát and the names and addresses of the firms making them. I am merely drawing attention to some of the more obvious developments which have occurred quite recently. Dealing with the developments anticipated during the coming year, Deputies will appreciate that I am in a certain difficulty. There are certain developments anticipated to which it is not possible to refer without risking the possibility of action being taken by get-rich-quick individuals to forestall possible Customs changes, or other action in their own interests. The various developments to which I intend to refer are all fairly well known, or the position has been safeguarded by action taken already in respect to the imposition of duties or the making of Quota Orders. A large scale factory for the production of wire nails, wood screws and tools of various descriptions is being established at Limerick. The company has been registered and an issue of shares is due to take place in the near future. A factory for the manufacture of cutlery of all descriptions is being erected at Droichead Nua, in County Kildare.

We anticipate that the construction of cement factories will commence in this year. Deputies are aware that plans which were made in 1932 and developed during 1933 for the development of the cement industry were wrecked in consequence of the financial crisis that occurred on the Continent when a well-known financier got himself into difficulties. The reaction of that affair in relation to this country was to upset the plans which we were then making in conjunction with a Belgian company for the establishment of factories here to produce cement. We had to regard as undone all the work that had been put into that project, and to start again from the beginning. We have now got to the stage when, I think, it is possible to say that within two or three months at the outside the foundation stones of the factories will be laid and their construction commenced. It will, of course, be 12 or 18 months later before they will have been completed and the production of cement begun. The factories will be quite considerable in size. The building and equipping of them, it is anticipated, may take 18 months.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned a couple of weeks ago that at least two years would elapse before they would be producing cement.

Comment on this

That is right—two years from to-day. The manufacture of paper of all classes is also being planned, and I think that all the difficulties which we encountered in relation to that industry have now been overcome. A group is being formed, experts have been consulted, plans have been approved and the construction of the factories will commence in this year. A factory for the production of fire-clay goods is being established in the County of Leix. An industry which we hope to develop in the course of this year is the assembly and partial manufacture of clocks and watches. Certain progress, in respect of clocks, has already been made and developments in respect to watches are expected quite soon. A factory for the manufacture of copper tubing is being erected at Galway and a factory for the manufacture of electric lamps is being constructed at Bray in the County Wicklow. A factory for the manufacture of bakelite products will also be established in this country this year. A factory for the manufacture of men's and women's hats, felt and straw, will also be established.

I now come to the question of the production of leathers of all classes, other than sole and insole leather. The production of chrome-tanned leather, linings and other classes of leather used for the upper parts of boots and shoes and for similar purposes, is a highly skilled industry. In fact, it is an industry which, at the present time, is practically confined to certain countries. I do not think that even in Great Britain there is any considerable chrome-tanning of leather. Most of the chrome-tanned leather used by British manufacturers is imported from the Continent. A factory for the production of chrome-tanned leather is at present being constructed at Carrick-on-Suir, and factories for the production of upper leathers have been planned, and I think most of them will come into production this year. If not this year, then certainly next year. These factories—a number of them are contemplated—will cover the full range of the leathers which we require here: upper leathers of all kinds and linings as well as leathers used for other than boot manufacturing purposes. The manufacture of rubber footwear. Wellington boots and plimsoles, will be undertaken at Cork in about six months' time—certainly in sufficient time to supply the requirements for next year. The manufacture of waterproof fabrics has also commenced in Cork. A factory for the production of enamel hollow ware is being constructed at Tralee, County Kerry. Three factories for the production of washing soda are being established: one at Galway, one at Dublin and one at Cork. A factory for the manufacture of cotton thread is being constructed at Westport, County Mayo, and will shortly come into production.

I now propose to refer to a very interesting development that is taking place in the County Kildare for the establishment of a peat briquetting factory. As Deputies know, the manufacture of peat into briquets has occupied the attention of more than this Government for a long time. Various Governments have spent large sums of money upon experimental work in that connection. During the course of the war, the British Government alone expended well over £5,000,000 upon experimental work in relation to the briquetting of peat. The Canadian Government has also been interested in the matter. Quite recently a delegation was sent to this country by the Canadian Government to inquire into the work that is being done here. The Danish Government are establishing a State factory in their country for the purpose of experimenting with the process that is now being brought to efficiency here. Similarly, in Germany and in Russia and in other countries where there are large supplies of peat, very large sums of money have been devoted by the Governments of those countries to experimental work in relation to this matter. So far as we have been able to discover, the net result of all that expenditure and of that experimental work pointed towards a development along a particular line, and the line pointed to is that which is now being adopted here in the County Kildare on an experimental scale. A company has been formed with a capital of £150,000, about half of which has been secured on State guarantee, and with certain foreign interests associated with it for the purpose of trying out that briquetting process. In this country a large amount of experimental work has already been done. The factory has not yet been constructed—only a part of it has been built. The laying out of the bog for the mechanical winning of the turf, as a preliminary to the briquetting of the peat, has been very largely completed.

If that industry should prove to be the success which those associated with it believe it will be, then it is going to be of tremendous importance to this country. The fuel which they hope to produce will have a calorific value very nearly equal to that of coal, with a number of advantages over coal, particularly as regards its cleanliness, while its convenience for storage purposes will also be of very considerable value. It is believed that it will be possible to under-sell coal. The company establishing the factory at Kildare are of opinion that they may even be able to find an export market for some of their products. It is clear, therefore, that if the experiment should prove to be the success anticipated the factory can be duplicated not once or twice but 20 times within the country, and that a very substantial and important new industry will have come into being.

A factory is being established at Roscrea for the manufacture of meat meal and similar products. A factory in Kildare will undertake this year the manufacture of boot and shoe lasts which are required in considerable number by boot and shoe manufacturers. A factory at Mullingar will commence the manufacture of lead pencils and similar classes of goods. We hope also to have commenced before the end of this year manufacture of sheet glass. There are other developments that it is not possible to refer to. Frequently, I receive deputations of people from the different towns in the country and of members of different Parties in the Dáil who seek advice as to the nature of the industries that might be established in the localities in which they are interested. It is very difficult to give that advice. The Department of Industry and Commerce is not in a position to give technical information concerning any industry, or to say that the establishment here of it, having regard to the peculiarities of this country and the size of the market available, is an economic proposition. Ordinarily, we advise Deputies and others interested in the establishment of industries, such as local industrial development committees, to seek their information from the Trade and Shipping Statistics where they can get particulars of the classes of goods that are still being imported. I would like, however, to get in the near future proposals for the production of an art silk yarn industry which is one of major importance in other countries, and the market for which here is, I think, sufficient to support an economic unit. The same thing applies to art silk woven fabrics. We have, of course, various proposals in connection with art silk knitted fabrics, but the other is also an important industry and one which I would like to see established here. There is a very substantial importation of goods manufactured from asbestos, such as corrugated sheets, slates and even asbestos pipes. All these are now being used here to a very great degree in connection with housing schemes, and there appears no reason whatever why their manufacture should not be undertaken here. There is also a considerable importation of linoleum and oil cloths, the manufacture of which here might, perhaps, be economic.

I would also direct attention to the possibility of manufacturing plywood, which is being used very extensively here at the present time. There is still, of course, considerable scope for development in respect of some of the existing industries. The artificial silk hosiery industry is, as I mentioned last week, only supplying 900,000 pairs per year out of a total requirement of 3,500,000 pairs. In relation to other industries which are in existence here, there is considerable scope for development. Information as to these industries is generally available from the Quota Orders which are made. Wherever it is necessary, under a Quota Order, to permit importation to continue, it is clear that there is room for additional development.

The main question that arises from this review of industrial development which I am giving is whether it has, in fact, improved the employment position in the country. That is a matter which we have debated here frequently. Deputy McGilligan and I have slung statistics at each other and other Deputies have got tied up in these statistics, so that it was never very clear what they proved. I think that it is necessary to try to clarify the position so that Deputies will understand clearly, so far as the information available can make it clear, what has happened, and will not be led in the future into misreading the statistics in the same way as they have been induced to do in the past. Obviously, the first figures we require if we are to consider the question of whether or not there has been increased employment in the country, is the number of people who have been insured under the Unemployment Insurance Act. Every person who engages in any occupation for wages other than agriculture or domestic service must be insured under the Unemployment Insurance Acts, and the number of employment insurance books current in any period of 12 months is an indication of the number of people who, during that period, have got employment of a class which is insurable under these Acts. In 1930, the number of persons who were insured under the Unemployment Insurance Act, measured, as I have said, by the number of unemployment insurance books current, was 284,380. In the following year—the last year in which Cumann na nGaedheal was in office—the number fell to 282,622, indicating that, in that period of 12 months, the number of persons who got insurable employment was slightly less than in the previous year. Then the change of Government took place and, in 1932, the number rose again to 294,847. In 1933, it continued to rise and reached 314,368. In 1934, it kept going up and reached 359,516. In the present year— 1935—it reached 379,694. That is 97,072 in excess of the figure for 1931. That figure represents the number of additional persons who have got insurable employment in the 12 months previous to this, as compared with the corresponding 12 months in 1931. It does not follow, nor am I asserting, that that number of persons got whole-time employment for the whole of the 12 months.

Comment on this

It might be only for a fortnight.

Comment on this

It has, in fact, been sometimes asserted that the increase in insurable employment is due to a larger number of persons getting shorter spells of employment than was the case previously. In order to test that, I had an investigation carried out and I found that, on the contrary, the average duration of employment is tending to increase, and that the average duration of unemployment is tending to decrease. In fact, in this country, the average duration of unemployment is considerably lower than it is in Great Britain.

There are, of course, other methods of testing whether employment has increased or not. There is the test of the contribution income of the Unemployment Insurance Fund. By comparing the contribution income of the Fund in any one year as against another, we can get a figure which represents, not the actual number of persons who got employment in the period of 12 months, but the average weekly employment throughout the whole of the period. The figures I am going to give are slightly different from the figures given previously. That is due to the fact that, since the earlier figures were given, more reliable datum has become available for the calculation of the average contribution per person. The average contribution per person has now been estimated at 17.6 pence per week. That is the first time that that figure has been produced, and it involved fairly elaborate examination of the figures, and a number of calculations. Having regard to the fact that there are varying rates of contribution for adult men, adult women, and juveniles, the figure on which we have to work for this purpose cannot be the actual rate for any one class. The average contribution per person over a period has been estimated at 17.6 pence. Working upon the basis of 17.6 pence as the average weekly contribution per person and adjusting the revenue of the Fund as if the variation in the rates of contribution had not taken place, we find that in the financial year 1931-32—the last 12 months during which the Cumann na nGaedheal Party were in office—the average number of persons employed weekly in insurable occupations was 188,000. By 1933-34 that number had risen to 207,000, and in 1934-35 it reached 215,000.

Comment on this

What does the Minister mean by the year 1933-34?

Comment on this

The year ended 31st March, 1934.

Comment on this

The Minister is not dealing with calendar years?

Comment on this

No. I am taking the financial year, which is the proper year.

Comment on this

Was the Minister dealing with calendar years when referring to books current?

Comment on this

No. The number of books current can be ascertained at any time in relation to the previous 12 months.

Comment on this

When referring to books current, was the Minister referring to the financial year or the insurance year?

Comment on this

Practically to the financial year, because you cannot always take the 31st March. You have to take the nearest Thursday to the date on which you want the information.

Comment on this

The Minister is not dealing with the insurance year?

Comment on this

Will the Minister give the calendar year, which he gave before?

Comment on this

No. Figures based on the calendar year would be misleading. The proper year is the financial year, when the accounts are balanced and audited. The figures represent an increase in the average number of persons employed weekly in insurable occupations in 1934-35 over 1931-32 of 27,000.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would give the figures.

Comment on this

Certainly. In 1933-34 the average weekly number was 207,000, and in 1934-35 the average weekly number was 215,000.

Comment on this

Has the Minister got the figures for 1932-33?

Comment on this

I have not. They show an increase. I gave these figures before and they are available in the records. An increase in insurable occupations did take place while Cumann na nGaedheal was in office. I make that concession to the vanity of Deputies opposite. Over the whole period they were in office that increase in employment represented an average of 5,000 per year in the weekly average figures. In the three years that this Government has been responsible for the conduct of affairs the increase has averaged 9,000 per year on the average weekly figures. There is also the evidence of the national health insurance contributions. All persons employed for wages, even persons employed in agriculture and domestic service, come under the National Health Insurance Act, and for every week's work done a stamp must be purchased and affixed to the card. Consequently, by a calculation, taking on the one hand the average contribution per person and on the other hand the total revenue of the fund, it is possible to get from them sources of information as to the employment position. In the calendar year 1931 the average weekly number of persons employed in all occupations insurable under the National Health Insurance Act was 342,000. In 1933 it had risen to 355,000, and in 1934 to 370,000, representing a total increase of 28,000.

Comment on this

Is the Minister dealing with the calendar year now?

Comment on this

Yes. For national health purposes they are the only figures I could get. Deputy McGilligan did a very ingenious thing when discussing the unemployment insurance figures. He took that calculation in respect of the Unemployment Insurance Fund and said the Minister had produced a figure of 27,000, representing increased employment in insurable occupations. But he said in May, 1934, there were 21,500 employed on house-building. Therefore, he deducted that 21,500 from the 27,000 and said that the balance represented the actual increased employment in industry. That is the type of statistical calculation we have to expect from the Party opposite. It is quite clear that these figures cannot be related one to the other: one representing the average number of persons employed weekly, and the other representing the actual number employed any one day. They cannot be related, particularly when the figures relating to house-building are examined, because, as is well known, that is a seasonal occupation, and the actual number of persons employed in May may differ from the number that would be employed in November or December.

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government stated to the contrary.

Comment on this

Absolutely.

Comment on this

Deputies can ask Deputy Dockrell or Deputy Good or any person associated with the industry.

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government took building through the whole country, rural and urban, and made a positive statement.

Comment on this

It fluctuates.

Comment on this

Apparently; so does Ministerial opinion.

Comment on this

The line of attack with Deputies opposite is not to deny that there is increased employment in industry, but to assert that the increased employment has been gained because of decreased employment in other spheres.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey says "Hear, hear!" He spoke too soon. Obviously, there is one source from which we can find whether there has been decreased employment in agriculture and domestic service taken together.

Comment on this

Take agriculture.

Comment on this

I intend to, but I am going to deal with this first. Comparing the weekly average increase, the number of persons employed under the Unemployment Insurance Act rose from 188,000 in 1931 to 342,000. The difference, 154,000, may be taken to represent persons employed in agriculture and domestic service. In 1934 the figures were 215,000 and 370,000, representing a difference of 155,000. The increase is not considerable, but there is an increase of 1,000 in the average number of persons employed weekly in agriculture and domestic service. The reason why the increase is not large is because there has been a decline in employment in domestic service, as I am going to convince Deputy Morrissey.

Comment on this

Is the Minister overlooking the fact that in certain industries large numbers of men are exempt?

Comment on this

Yes, transport, employment on railways and other concerns of that kind.

Comment on this

That is important.

Comment on this

Of course, it is important. If the Deputy wants to know if there has been an increase in employment there, he can find that out in a more direct way.

Comment on this

Has the Minister taken that into account?

Comment on this

I have not. But I have given the benefit of it to Deputies opposite. If I wanted I could swell the figures considerably.

Comment on this

The Minister said that he is able to ascertain the average number of persons employed weekly for every week of the year.

Comment on this

Would it not be simpler, instead of utilising the number of books current, to give a calculation based on every week of the year for the number employed under the National Health and Unemployment Insurance Acts?

Comment on this

I have given that. There has been an increase in the average number of persons employed of 27,000 in 1934-35, as compared with 1931-32 and under the National Health Insurance Act the average increase is 28,000. There is another source of information which I will quote. It is the Census of Production. Unfortunately, the last figures that we have relate to 1933 when Fianna Fáil was only getting into its stride. There has been a considerable amount of additional work done since.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give the figures dealing with agriculture?

Comment on this

I intend to.

Comment on this

The Minister might forget.

Comment on this

I am keeping to the last mentioned because it is particularly important.

Comment on this

I am sure it is.

Comment on this

The Census of Production figures for 1932 and subsequent years are on a much more limited scale than in earlier years, but it is important to know that amongst the industries excluded from the census in 1932-33, were the following:—building and construction—that wipes out Deputy McGilligan's argument at one stroke—timber trades, creameries, butter and margarine factories, bread, flour, confectionery, gas, water, electricity, local authorities and Government Departments. Leaving all these, and certain other occupations out of account we find the following figures for the total employment in industries reported in the Census of Production for October in each of the years: in 1929, 47,092. Cumann na nGaedheal was only beginning to get to work at that time. They were in full swing in 1931 and the figures had gone down to 44,343. Then the country was saved by the advent of the Fianna Fáil Government and the figures started to go up, in 1933, to 52,043. It is that figure which relates to October, 1933. It is not of very much immediate importance in June, 1935, except to indicate the trend of the development during the last years of Cumann na nGaedheal and the first years of Fianna Fáil. At the present time, according to the estimates prepared by the Department of Industry and Commerce, the additional number of persons employed in tariffed industries, as compared with March, 1932, or the date upon which the particular tariff was first imposed, is 25,000, and that figure is continuously increasing.

Comment on this

Where did the Minister get that figure?

Comment on this

It is an estimate compiled in the Department of Industry and Commerce from figures supplied voluntarily by the manufacturers themselves. Employment in agriculture now comes to be considered, and I hope that Deputy Morrissey has his pad in front of him and is taking notes. The peculiar thing about agriculture is that we can say, precisely, for each year, the actual number of persons employed in it, because there is an enumeration taken in respect of the number of persons employed in agriculture on the 1st June in each year. That has been done for the last ten or 12 years. In 1929, the basis of calculation was slightly changed, but it has not been changed since then. In 1928, —the figure has been adjusted so as to prevent any discrepancy arising because of the change made in the method of calculation that took place in 1929—showed that the number of males engaged in farm work on the 1st June, 1928, was 577,764. By 1929, that had gone down to 566,021. By 1930 it had gone down still further and reached such a low point as 561,700. In 1931, there was a slight revival and the figure went up to 562,573. That is the Cumann na nGaedheal record so far as employment in agriculture is concerned. Between 1928 and 1931 there was a decrease in the number of male persons employed in agriculture from 574,000 to 563,000—a decrease of 11,000. By 1934, that figure had gone up to 579,409, an increase of 16,836 as compared with 1931.

We can analyse that figure a little further, and it will be of interest to Deputies who are continuously asserting that there is less labour employed for wages in agriculture. It is true that the greater proportion of that increase is represented by members of families owning land. That accounts for 15,724.

Comment on this

Does that mean that there are more people living on the land?

Comment on this

The additional number of persons in permanent agricultural employment for wages in 1934 as compared with 1931 was 1,630, and the number of persons temporarily employed in 1934 was 3,375 more than in 1931. Deputy Morrissey will see that there is an apparent increase there in excess of the total. The explanation for that excess is due to the fact that, since 1931, there has been a decrease of 3,893 in the number of males under 18 years of age engaged in agriculture. The other figures that I mentioned, by the way, relate to males over 18 years of age—adult males, in other words— but there has been a decrease in the number of persons under 18 years of age employed on agriculture, whether as labourers or as members of a family owning the land.

It is quite possible—and I concede this point to Deputies opposite—to have, at the same time, an increase in employment and an increase in unemployment. That is particularly possible in this country where the population has increased by 56,000, according to the Registrar-General, since 1931. Therefore, it is clear that we could have an increase in employment, and, at the same time, have an increase in unemployment. From that point of view, it is necessary to examine our statistics further in order to see if, in fact, there has been an increase in unemployment. The figures will show that, instead of that, there has been a decrease in unemployment.

I admit that, in view of the changed circumstances, we have not the information which will enable a safe comparison to be made. There is only one set of figures available now which can be related to any of the figures that were available in any of the ten years during which Cumann na nGaedheal were in office, and that is the number of persons claiming unemployment insurance benefit. That figure is not of much advantage for the purpose of determining the actual number of persons unemployed, but it is of advantage in ascertaining the trend of employment conditions. Let us be clear on the fact that an increase in the actual number of persons claiming unemployment insurance benefit could take place even if there was a substantial increase in the actual amount of employment available. In fact, if there were an increase in the amount of employment available, there could be an increase in the number of persons claiming unemployment insurance benefit, because a larger number of persons would become entitled to make claims. The important factor is the proportion which the number of persons claiming benefit bears to the total number of persons in employment. I shall give the figures for the month of March in each year. I select the month of March chiefly because the figures are most unfavourable to my contention. I shall give the figures for July and December of each year later. Deputies are quite well aware of the seasonal fluctuations that occur in employment conditions in certain industries, and unemployment is usually higher in March than at other periods. In March, 1931, the number of persons claiming unemployment insurance benefit was 6.9 per cent. of the total insured population. That was the last year of the Cumann na nGaedheal Administration. By March, 1932, that figure had risen to 7.3 per cent. That was when the change of Government took place. By March, 1933, the figure had risen to 7.8 per cent. I admit that that is a point against Fianna Fáil; but by 1934, the figure had gone down to 6.3 per cent.—substantially below the percentage for 1931—and by March, 1935, it had gone down to 6.2 per cent., the lowest point recorded.

Now, let us take the figures for July of each year. In 1930 the number of persons claiming benefit was 5.3 per cent. of the insured population. By 1931 it had gone up to 6.9 per cent. By 1932, when Fianna Fáil had been in office about four months, it had gone down to 5.9 per cent. By 1933 it had gone down to 5.2 per cent., and by 1934, to 5.1 per cent. Now, let us take the figures for December of each year. In December of 1930 the figure was 6.6 per cent., and it had risen in December of 1931 to 7.4 per cent. That figure had fallen in 1932 to 7.2 per cent.; in 1933 to 5.6 per cent., and in 1934 to 5.3 per cent. These figures, as I have said, do not give us any indication of the actual number of persons unemployed, but they do show what the trend was, and it is undoubted that unemployment has been tending to decrease in recent years.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give us the percentages of payments out of the fund as compared with contributions to the fund?

Comment on this

It would be the same.

Comment on this

Surely not?

Comment on this

Surely yes. Surely the actual payments made out of the fund are related to the number of persons paid.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give us the actual figures?

Comment on this

I have not got them here, but they are published, and I am sure that the Deputy has them there before him. We have got to face the fact that the only statistical figures we have in relation to unemployment are, first of all, the census enumeration that was compiled in April, 1926; and, secondly, the live register, whatever it may mean, in any particular year. It must be remembered, however, that all methods of enumeration, whether by census compilation or registration or any such methods, all have this common weakness, that they depend entirely on what the people want to tell about themselves in the particular circumstances at the moment. Obviously, if you make an announcement that every person who is proved to be unemployed on 1st July next is going to get £10, you will get a much different figure for unemployment in respect of that date than if you made an announcement that everybody proved to be unemployed on that date is going to be sent to a labour camp or in some other way penalised. Nobody is legally compelled to place his name upon the register nor can he be made to disclose in any way his condition in respect of unemployment. Even at best, therefore, any enumeration of the unemployed in this country, or in any other country, taken in the most favourable circumstances, must be expected to yield only approximate figures, and some methods of enumeration might not even yield approximate figures.

It is, however, possible to make some comparison between the census enumeration and the live register at the corresponding date of 1934. The census was taken on 18th April, 1926, and we can take the live register for the corresponding date in 1934. The figure arrived at by the census was 78,071 persons out of work. That figure does not include ex-soldiers not otherwise occupationally described and they amounted to 5,869. It was estimated, on the other hand, that the figures included a number of persons who described themselves as unemployed, but who should not properly be placed in the category of persons normally dependent on wage earnings who are genuinely seeking and unable to obtain work. Farmers and their sons, whose principal occupation was assisting in the home farms, were not included as unemployed, but it was estimated that of the total returned as unemployed, 7,836 were small farmers and their sons living at home who incorrectly described themselves as agricultural labourers or road labourers out of work. The figure was also estimated to include certain classes who, it was thought, should have been excluded, but who could not be segregated from the 78,071 persons.

Comparing the census figure and the live register for 1934 in respect to different parts of the country, we find that in the four county boroughs, on census night, there were 24,871 persons unemployed. The live register figure on the same date in April, 1934, was 20,879. For the rest of Leinster, the figures were 25,513 and 23,988; for the rest of Munster, 19,707 and 22,596; and for Connacht—and mark these figures—the census figure was 4,255 and the live register figure 16,080; and for the three counties of Ulster, the census figure was 3,725 and the live register figure 13,441. Let us examine them. For the four county boroughs, the live register figure was, undoubtedly, below the census figure, and for the rest of Leinster and the rest of Munster, although, as I have said, the statistics are somewhat different in scope, there is a remarkable similarity between the census and live register figures. The difference in the totals—78,000 on the one hand and 97,000 on the other—is almost entirely due to differences in Connacht and Ulster.

The extent to which the agricultural class is included in the live register figures for April, 1934, may be roughly calculated in this way: the number of persons on the register in April, 1934, in the county boroughs and urban districts constituted the following percentages of the total occupied, including unemployed, populations of these urban areas in April of 1926: Leinster, 8.6; Munster, 10.7; Connacht, 6.2; and Ulster, 6.3; assuming that these percentages apply to the total non-agriculturally occupied populations of the respective Provinces, it may be estimated that the number of non-agriculturists unemployed in the Saorstát in April of 1934 was 57,000, made up of 29,000 in Leinster, 22,000 in Munster, 3,500 in Connacht and 2,500 in Ulster, so that the remaining 40,000 on the live register may be regarded as being normally engaged in agriculture. In April, 1926, the total number described as out of work by the census was 78,000, which included 15,000 in agricultural occupations, so that the number in non-agricultural occupations was 63,000 and that does not include ex-soldiers. While, for reasons which I have already given, these totals of 63,000 in 1926 and 57,000 in 1934 cannot safely be compared, the analysis does suggest that, comparing these two years, it is unlikely that there was any increase in non-agricultural unemployment and apart from these calculations, there is other evidence, some of which I have given and more of which is available to our senses, that unemployment has not increased but that on the contrary it has decreased.

I have spoken for a considerable length. I have spoken in this protracted way in anticipation that Deputy McGilligan would have responded to my challenge yesterday to be here when I was dealing with certain stupid allegations made by him in respect of a mining lease given in the County Wicklow. I will speak on another matter for ten or 12 minutes, but if the Deputy does not turn up then, I shall have to deal with that particular matter in his absence.

Comment on this

You will find the gold for us.

Comment on this

Perhaps he is down there looking for it.

Comment on this

I am sure you will agree, Sir, that the Minister could postpone his reference to that until about 7.30 or some other convenient time?

Comment on this

He said he was going to be here, and I am giving him the opportunity of being here. I will spend about ten minutes in relation to the Government's policy on transport, shipping and air. The reorganisation of internal transport effected by the Act of 1933 is now in full swing. Occasionally Deputies are inclined to be critical of what is being done in the Department in that connection. At present, of course, attention is being directed to certain hardships and inconveniences which are being caused by the process of reorganisation, and to such an extent we are inclined to lose sight of the situation with which the Acts were intended to deal. Previous to 1933, transport conditions here were properly described as chaotic. Not merely was there no regulation or control of transport services, but the main transport operators, the railway companies, were in a precarious position. The Great Southern Railways Company had passed its guaranteed dividend and was barely able, by the most drastic economies, to meet its debenture charges in that year. The Great Northern Railway Company was in no better plight. The other couple of smaller railways operating in the Saorstát were definitely losing money and, in fact, one of them was only kept going by getting repeated Government subsidies.

It was to remedy that situation and to preserve the railways, which were regarded as essential to the economic development of the country, that it was decided to create a new situation in which the cut-throat competition would be eliminated and in which a central direction of transport services would become possible. There were two ways of doing that. One was by nationalisation, and the other the method adopted in the Act of 1933. Already, I suggest, that Act is producing results. The cut-throat competition has been largely eliminated. It is true that that meant an increase in fares. Transport was being sold at a figure less than the cost of production, and the obvious first step to be taken in putting it on an economic basis was to secure economic rates for the services it was providing. The railway traffic receipts have been going up since that year for the first time since 1925.

I mentioned last year the intention of the Government to take steps to procure the development of air services in and from the Saorstát. No development has taken place yet, and I am taking full responsibility for that fact, because I am convinced that it would be unwise for us to facilitate or promote any development of air services here until we are satisfied that they are going to be organised upon sound lines, with proper equipment. and upon a reasonably large scale. The development of air services with inadequate or unsuitable equipment, and inadequately financed, would only result in failures, and might well retard for a long time proper air development here. We are concerned to secure that the development of air services in Ireland, and from Ireland to Great Britain and other countries, will take place under Irish control; that those services, when they come, will be as good as any in the world, and that they will be so organised and equipped as to be able to avail of any opportunity of development that may offer.

Various proposals have been submitted by parties in this country and outside it, but until recently we did not consider that any of those proposals came up to the standard we had set for ourselves. As I have said, we had made up our minds that it was better to delay starting those services than to start them on wrong lines. We have, now, I think, got to the point where we can see development going ahead. In fact, it is very probable that an experimental service — experimental but nevertheless regular — between Great Britain and the Saorstát will be commenced probably next month, and will be continued right through the winter, for the purpose of getting the technical information that is required before a permanent and regular service can be planned. It is necessary to decide the type of aircraft that is best suited for those services, the landing and other facilities which must be provided, and so forth. Next year, as a result of the experimental service that will be operated this year, we hope to have a permanent and adequate service established — with suitable machines, as good as those in use in any part of the world—to and from Great Britain, internally in Ireland, and ultimately from the trans-Atlantic ports to continental countries. The Department has been keeping in close touch with the possibilities of trans-Atlantic air service development. There are people who consider that the technical development of air craft has reached the stage at which trans-Atlantic services are feasible, certainly in the summer, if not during the whole year round, and we are concerned to secure that, if and when those services commence, the geographical position of the Saorstát and the advantages it offers to persons engaging in those services will be availed of.

I mentioned last year also that we were planning the development of an Irish mercantile marine. We have experienced certain delays in bringing our plans to fruition in regard to that matter. Our aim is to secure that 50 per cent. of the traffic which passes from the Saorstát to Great Britain, and from the Saorstát to the Continent, will be carried in Irish boats. We are making progress, but progress which is much slower than I had hoped, towards that end. However, there are methods by which it can be done and to which we can resort if the lines we have followed up to the present prove to be unavailing. We regard it not merely as a matter of national prestige, but also as of vital economic importance, that a Saorstát mercantile marine should be established. I do not know if there is any other matter to which I need refer.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us what is the policy of the Government in regard to transport in Dublin?

Comment on this

It is not proposed to effect an immediate change in the situation.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say whether the policy indicated by him in this House in December, 1931, has been abandoned? He said he stood for municipal ownership of the services.

Comment on this

The Deputy can ask that question in his speech, and, if I think it wise, he will get a reply.

Comment on this

The Minister is getting wise now after having enunciated the policy.

Comment on this

During the course of last year certain trade negotiations entered into with other countries——

Comment on this

Before the Minister passes away, perhaps he would give us some indication as to what steps have been taken by his Department regarding working conditions and wages in the different industries he has mentioned? I think that is a rather important matter.

Comment on this

My answer to the Deputy's preliminary observation is that I have no immediate intention of passing away. As to the second part, I refer him to the Conditions of Employment Bill.

Comment on this

But can the Minister give us any indication, from the reports of his inspectors, as to conditions of employment and rates of wages paid?

Comment on this

I have no responsibility for fixing the rates of wages in any industry not subject to the Trade Boards Acts.

Comment on this

The Minister is not in a position to give us any information regarding the working conditions in those factories?

Comment on this

We can deal with that matter under the Conditions of Employment Bill. The principal trade agreements made last year, apart from the coal-cattle pact with Great Britain, which was fully discussed last week and to which there is no necessity to refer again, were with Germany, Belgium and Spain. The pact with Belgium was, in fact, a continuation of a pact which had been made in the previous year. So far as the pact with Germany is concerned, Deputies will have noted that its result in the first five months of this year is an increase in the value of our exports to Germany from £50,000 to £205,000. So far as the pact with Spain is concerned, the increase in our exports has been from £3,000 to £27,000. I think we can regard those results as satisfactory.

Comment on this

What class of goods went to Germany?

Comment on this

Various classes of goods, cattle, butter, eggs and other products. The export trade of the Saorstát has been declining for some time past; in fact, it has been declining since 1929. Between 1932 and 1934 the value of our exports fell by £7,600,000. In case Deputies opposite are thinking of taking any consolation, or making any propaganda out of that, I will give them the figure for the two previous years. Between 1929 and 1931 the value of our exports fell by £10,600,000.

Comment on this

But that is not a gold figure. For the subsequent year it was in gold money.

Comment on this

I hope to hear the Deputy developing that argument.

Comment on this

I am only stating a fact which the Minister ought to know.

Comment on this

The decline, however, appears to have been arrested. In 1931 the decline was £8,300,000; in 1932, £10,400,000; in 1933, £6,800,000; and in last year only £800,000; whereas, for the first five months of this year the indications are that the value of our exports is rising, and that the total value of the Saorstát export trade this year is likely to be above the value last year. On the other hand, our imports, which were declining in 1932 and 1933, tended to rise in 1934, a development which was unexpected in some quarters because of the Saorstát protectionist policy, but an examination of the position will show that it is inevitable. We are at present engaged in considerable capital expenditure. Large sums of money are being paid out for new machinery, new equipment of all kinds, cement and other building products, and so forth, in consequence of the industrial revival and of the housing programme. In fact, the whole of the increase in imports, when one examines the details, is explained by those items —imports of iron and steel manufactures, and machinery—apart from one item which was an abnormal one, an increase of nearly £1,000,000 in the value of tobacco imported. This was due to the action of certain tobacco firms in forestalling the change in the procedure in respect of weighing and sampling tobacco, adopted by the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

Will the Minister state what was paid out for machinery in any one year, instead of merely making a general statement?

Comment on this

I am not going to say anything else now, except what I intended to say if Deputy McGilligan were present. I am sorry he is not here. Some of his colleagues can tell him what I said about him afterwards, and then, if he can pluck up enough courage, he may come in and deal with the matter later. Deputy McGilligan made a statement concerning a mining lease in County Wicklow which some of the papers thought fit to describe as a serious charge against the Government. I read the statement in the newspapers and in the Official Report to-day, and I am not quite clear as to what the charge is. As the matter refers to a particular mining lease issued by me, I propose to give all the information that I have concerning that lease, so that Deputies can decide for themselves whether there is any charge or not lying against the Department.

I do not know how to deal with Deputy McGilligan. One could deal with him as an impish schoolboy, sitting in a pool of mud, squirting slime at his more respectable companions, or possibly as an unfortunate person whose mind has become so warped by hatred and rancour that he is incapable of seeing anything except the rottenness and corruption—of seeing everything but decency; or probably he might be more correctly regarded as an unfortunate investigator all of whose mares' nests have turned out to be booby traps for himself.

The Constitution of this State contains a provision concerning mines and minerals. Article 11 of the Constitution states:—

All the ... mines and minerals, within the territory of the Irish Free State ... hitherto vested in the State or any Department thereof, or held for the public use or benefit ... shall, from and after the date of the coming into operation of this Constitution, belong to the Irish Free State ...

And the Article goes on as follows:—

and shall be controlled and administered by the Oireachtas, in accordance with such regulations and provisions as shall be from time to time approved by legislation, but the same shall not, nor shall any part thereof, be alienated, but may in the public interest be from time to time granted by way of lease or licence to be worked or enjoyed under the authority and subject to the control of the Oireachtas: Provided that no such lease or licence may be made for a term exceeding ninety-nine years, beginning from the date thereof, and no such lease or licence may be renewable by the terms thereof.

Now, the legislation which was contemplated by that Article was enacted in 1931, enacted by Deputy McGilligan. He seems to have forgotten all about it, judging by his remarks in the Dáil last week. That was the Mines and Minerals Act. That Act gives power to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to demise such mines and minerals or exclusive State mining rights for periods not exceeding 99 years. There is also a provision that the Minister may make some leases by way of a take note or prospecting lease for such term not exceeding two years as the Minister shall think proper, and such lease may contain an option to the lessee to take a reversionary lease of such State mines and minerals or exclusive State mining right for such term as will, together with the term created by the take note or prospecting lease, not exceed 99 years.

Leases under the Act are subject to the payment to the Minister "of such moneys, whether by way of fine or other preliminary payment or by way of rent (including a royalty rent variable according to the price or value of the minerals gotten) or by both such ways, as the Minister and the Minister for Finance shall jointly think proper and shall agree upon with the person to whom such lease is made." All such moneys when received by the Minister are paid into or disposed of for the benefit of the Exchequer in such manner as the Minister for Finance shall direct. The section of the Act giving the Minister power to make these mining leases provides that "every such lease shall be made subject to and shall contain such covenants, conditions and agreements as the Minister shall consider proper or desirable in the public interest," and it is also provided that in exercising their respective powers the Minister and the Minister for Finance may take into consideration the general advantages that are likely to accrue to the State from the development of the mines and minerals to which the demise relates.

It is quite clear that the intention of the Act was to enable the development of the mineral rights which are the property of the State to be undertaken and to put the State in a position in which it could authorise private parties to prospect for minerals and, if they found them, to work them commercially. Until 1931 the State-owned minerals could not be worked, because the Minister for Industry and Commerce had no authority to issue a lease of such minerals or a licence to work them. The object of the Act was to put the Minister in that position. In fact, since that Act was passed some 50 applications for a mining lease have been received by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Of these, 18 leases have actually been granted, of which seven were take notes or prospecting leases and the remaining 11 leases for periods ranging from 99 to 21 years. The usual period is 99 years. None of the seven prospecting leases has yet reached the stage where the applicants have put forward an application for the reversionary lease which is provided for in the prospecting lease. In cases where no prospecting lease has been asked for, the position was that the existence of the deposit was well known and the necessity for a prospecting lease really did not exist.

All these leases contain very similar provisions. They contain conditions requiring the payment of a half yearly dead rent and of yearly royalties based on the amount of minerals produced. The dead rent merges in the royalty when the latter amounts to or exceeds the amount of the dead rent. There are also conditions as to the proper working of the minerals and the employment of a minimum number of able-bodied men and there is the provision that if work ceases the Minister may determine the lease and resume possession. That power has, in fact, been exercised in two cases. The lessees shall not assign, under-let or part with the demise without the consent of the Minister. It is also provided that in the event of the lessees granting a sub-lease, the lessees shall pay half the amount payable to them under the sub-lease with the minimum of the amounts for rents and royalties reserved in the original lease. There is also provision for the determination of the lease by the Minister in case of default of the payments of royalties and rents or in the event of bankruptcy on the part of the lessees.

I am not quite clear what Deputy McGilligan was getting at in his allegation, or charge, or insinuation, and so I have to deal with every possible contingency. I would like to point out that there is nothing in the Act which says that it shall not be lawful to give to a supporter or a member of Fianna Fáil whatever rights and privileges other members of the community are entitled to; neither is there anything there which says that members of the Oireachtas shall not be entitled to receive a lease and, in fact, in respect of three of the leases issued to various groups and companies, members of the Oireachtas were interested.

The history, however, of the particular lease which we are now examining can be quite simply stated and, because of the attention which has been drawn to the matter, I propose to give the whole of that history, which goes back beyond the time this Government came into office. An application dated 28th March, 1933, was made by Senator Michael Comyn, K.C., Deputy Briscoe and another, whose name I need not mention, because he is not now interested in the matter. That application was for a mining lease in respect of nine townlands in the County Wicklow. Ultimately, a prospecting lease was granted on 1st November, 1934, to Senator Comyn and Deputy Briscoe, and that lease covered an area of three townlands. It was issued for a period of two years at a dead rent of £5 per annum with a royalty of 1/25th out of what minerals might be obtained during the term of the lease. The lease provides for the payment of rent and royalties, the employment of labour, and the furnishing of a true and fair account of the particulars of all minerals. There is provision made against under-letting or assigning over or parting with, except with the consent of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, first obtained in writing, and for the payment to the Minister in the case of sub-letting of half the rent and royalties payable to the lessees. There is the usual provision for the determination of the lease in the event of default. I observe Deputy McGilligan has arrived. How did they spur him up? Congratulations, Deputy!

Comment on this

I will not be saying "congratulations" to you in a minute.

Comment on this

As I have indicated, there is the usual provision for the determination of the lease in the event of default of payment of rent or royalties or in the event of failure to carry out a search for the minerals concerned. The prospecting lease also makes provision for the granting of another lease. This lease is to be granted at the request of the lessees at any time prior to the determination, and, on the Minister being satisfied that the lessees possess the necessary technical and financial qualifications to carry out the full development of the undertaking.

That is the whole story. I am not going to stop there, but that is the whole story. I have informed Deputies of the background, namely, the effect of Article 11 of the Constitution and the purport of the Mines and Minerals Act of 1931. Under the Mines and Minerals Act of 1931 application was made for a lease by the persons I have mentioned in respect of certain townlands in the County Wicklow. They got that lease subject to conditions. In view, however, of the nature of the insinuation made by Deputy McGilligan, it is necessary to go further than that. I pointed out that the existing lease was issued for three townlands, though nine townlands had been applied for. That was due to the fact that the Land Commission examination of the ownership would have occupied considerable time if extended to the nine townlands. The applicants were prepared to accept three townlands, so that they might start operations at once. It is possible, however, if the original application in respect of the nine townlands were pressed we would have had to consider whether the area was too large. An application for the six townlands has since been received from the same parties; a decision has not yet been taken on that application. Deputy McGilligan, as reported in column 350, Volume 57, No. 1, of the Official Debates, said—I give you his words in order to make sure I am not misrepresenting him:

"I have one example of a concession that was given to certain people in the country who have no industrial history in the matter, and what did they do? They jumped across to London and sold it."

The Minister for Finance intervened and said:

"The statements which the Deputy is making cannot be answered by me in this debate and should be reserved for the Minister for Industry and Commerce. This is not a case of a financial slant; it is a case of an Opposition squint."

Deputy McGilligan then said:

"This is a licence signed by the Minister for Finance"—that was the first thing wrong—"and it included this point—that sub-leasings could not be granted without the Minister's approval."

That is the second thing wrong.

"The people who were granted that go and hawk it around London, and in the end sell the concession on the terms that the new concessionaire will pay the Minister a one-twenty-fifth royalty."

Then the Minister for Finance said:

"Surely the Deputy is aware that the Minister who is primarily responsible in this case is the Minister for Industry and Commerce."

And Deputy McGilligan said:

"No, Sir, ... this matter comes under the State Lands Act, and the Minister for Finance is the operating authority there."

I would intervene to say that Deputy McGilligan is entirely wrong. It does not come under the State Lands Act. It comes under the Mines and Minerals Act, 1931, which Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, introduced here. The Deputy, apparently, forgot all about that. The Minister responsible is the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

Read the next paragraph.

Comment on this

"The Minister for Finance is the man who controls the letting of mines and minerals under the State Lands Act, in so far as they are grouped by Article 11."

Comment on this

"Gripped" is the word, not "grouped."

Comment on this

Then the Minister for Finance said that the matter should be raised on his Vote, and Deputy McGilligan replied "Rubbish!" and that in order to comply with Article 11 there could not be sub-leasing except with his authority. In fact, it is with the authority of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The Deputy then went on to say:

"This lease was made to certain Deputies of his own Party, and to one Senator of his own Party, and they sell it in England to a group of concessionaires, on the terms that that group will pay the Minister a one-twenty-fifth royalty; that they will pay this group 2¼ per cent. extra, and give them 48,000 five shilling shares in an £80,000 company. Why did three Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party and the Vice-Chairman of the Seanad get that concession merely to hawk it around London? Surely that is a matter which, if it is going to be dealt with, should be dealt with in the House."

Right; we will deal with it in the House. I have pointed out that the Deputy was obviously misinformed as to the nature of the situation under which the lease was issued and as to the functions of the Minister for Finance in relation to that lease and the nature of the lease itself. Deputies who have read the Official Debates will notice there is no charge under it except whatever charge can be levelled against the lessees, arising out of these words:—

"Why did the three Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party and the Vice-Chairman of the Seanad get that concession merely to hawk it around London?"

I will deal with that first of all. I want to make it clear that the prospecting lease which was issued can hardly be described as a concession. It is a lease of the mining rights for a period of not more than two years, and it imposes on the lessees the obligation to carry out a search and trial for minerals and to report the result of their investigations to the Department. But it contains also this provision, that if the minerals for which the search is made are proved to exist, and if they satisfy the Minister that they possess financial and technical resources for the full development of the undertaking, then a further mining lease for 97 years shall be granted.

With regard to the allegation that a prospecting lease was hawked around London, I want to say now that that is entirely contrary to the fact. There is no information as to that in my Department, and we would know it was not true when it was stated by Deputy McGilligan. It is untrue. The Deputy also stated none of the lessees had any previous industrial history in these matters. The statement is entirely without foundation. At least one of the lessees has considerable experience of mining and minerals in this country. He has been engaged in mining investigations for years, as the Deputy must have known if he had any information as to what his Department was doing when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce. It is quite clear that Deputy McGilligan did not intend to make a charge. He never makes a charge. He will never be specific. He throws out a number of sentences which are intended to convey an insinuation not to make a charge, something he can run away from, if necessary. It is the type of charge that is hardest to meet, but it is the type of thing that Deputy McGilligan has made peculiarly his own. Let us get his allegation here in all its ugliness. I think I can put it in this way— Deputy McGilligan wanted the House to believe that the Government gave to certain persons who were its supporters in the Oireachtas a concession of valuable State property; that they gave that concession because these people were their supporters, and that they gave the concession for the purpose of enabling them to sell it for the purpose of profit, although the Government could have disposed of that property to greater advantage otherwise. That is the allegation and the insinuation that Deputy McGilligan tried to get across. It is not stated in so many words there; but the Deputy was practically making that insinuation on Friday morning when he knew that it would not be possible for any member of the Government to reply to it so that his mean insinuation would have got a week-end's start before it could be caught up. Incidentally also there were the by-elections in Dublin and in Galway, and no doubt the allegation was intended to influence votes in these by-elections, Let us examine what the allegation says. I have already indicated the extent to which a prospecting lease can be described as a concession. But let that go. Assume that this is a valuable property. I wonder when Deputy McGilligan first began to realise that it was a valuable property. Perhaps I shall have a little more to say about that before I finish. On the general question, as far as I am concerned, I have no information that it is valuable property. Certain statements are made that there are many million pounds of gold in these townlands. I hope they are true, but so far as I am aware there has been no adequate investigation of the mineral deposits in that area yet, and no one with any certainty can say what there is in that place.

The allegation that a lease was given to the lessees because they were political supporters of the Government is entirely without foundation. At the time they applied, and were granted the lease, there was no other application before the Department. It was a case of granting them a prospecting lease or not giving the grant to anybody. The whole purpose of the Mines and Minerals Act was to enable such leases to be granted, and the investigation work which was neglected for ten years when Deputy McGilligan was Minister, was made possible by it. The allegation that the lease was made to those parties for the purpose of enabling them to dispose of it at a profit is also without foundation. The actual terms of the lease provided that no assignment, or subletting, of the lease could be made without the permission in writing of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. In fact, no application for such consent has yet been made by the lessees, although if such an application were made it probably would be granted provided we were satisfied that the giving of the consent was going to lead to the commercial development of whatever mineral resources there are in that neighbourhood. It is suggested, also, that the Government could have disposed of that mining right elsewhere at greater advantage. I have mentioned the fact that, at the time the application was made, there was no other application before us. Furthermore the lease is subjected to the same dead rent and the same royalty charges which would be enforced no matter to whom the lease was made.

I said that the history of this matter goes back earlier than the date of the lease. Early in 1930, Deputy McGilligan, who was then Minister for Industry and Commerce, was approached by representatives of a company calling itself Crusade Prospectors, Limited. Mr. Heiser was the principal and his name will arise again. I have nothing to say against him, and I may say that he bore credentials from the representative of the Queensland Government. So far as I know the Crusade Prospectors, Limited, were a company formed in London and included Sir H. Brittain, Sir Basil Clarke, Sir Basil MacFarlane, the Right Honourable Harry Samuels, and others. That company applied to Mr. McGilligan for authority to prospect for gold and other minerals in the County Wicklow, and, subsequently, generally throughout Ireland.

Deputy McGilligan rightly pointed out to them that the Mines and Minerals Act, not having been passed, there was no authority or legal power to issue such lease or grant such licences. But he did indicate to them that if they proceeded with their prospecting, and made whatever arrangements they desired with the surface owners and the other Government Departments concerned he promised favourable consideration subject to their proposals being in every way satisfactory in the matter of recording of priority for any application subsequently made, after the passing of the Mines and Minerals Act.

At some time Crusade Prospectors, Limited, had been acquired by the people known as Risberget Syndicate, Limited. An Irish group was also organised under the name of Irish Prospectors, Limited, the members of which were at that time Mr. F.M. Summerfield, Mr. Joseph McGrath and others and at the present time, Mr. Summerfield, Mr. Manus Noonan, B.L., Mr. Heiser and Mr. E.J. Smith, a former civil servant.

I do not quite know what Deputy McGilligan's interest in this matter is, but the question in respect of these minerals remained in that position while the Mines and Minerals Act was going through. This London interest, with their Irish associates, had intimated their interest in the mines and minerals. Mr. Heiser expressed the opinion that valuable mineral deposits existed, and they proposed that they should be granted some sort of a monopoly concession for the purpose of carrying out prospecting work, but the proposal was not accepted. They were informed that while they could not be given absolute priority in respect of any application before the Act came into operation, nevertheless, that if they proceeded with their work they could anticipate favourable consideration in respect of any lease or licence application for which they made when the Minister had acquired power to grant such lease or licence.

The Mines and Minerals Act was passed and, shortly afterwards, there was a change of Government. This particular group then appear to have lost interest in the matter. Some of its members were in America and others, on their own statement, were temporarily involved in financial difficulties and generally indicated that they were unable to proceed. Early in 1932 they were informed that the Act was now passed and were invited to send in their application. They were told the form the application should take, and from the nature of their reply to us it was clear that no application was likely to be forthcoming for some time. We gave the members of that original group a full 12 months' notice that the Act was passed, and that they were free to make an application for this licence. In May, 1933, we wrote and said, having regard to the fact that we received no application in response to our letter of 12 months ago, and no indication from them of their intention we must regard their application as having lapsed. Similar letters were sent to a number of persons interested in mineral deposits at that time and, as they did not proceed, we regarded their applications as lapsed. Then the application that was submitted by Senator Comyn and Deputy Briscoe was taken up. It was discussed at considerable length. The application was very carefully examined. Eight months after the application was made, in November, 1933, I think, the prospecting lease was granted. There is obviously no charge lying against the Government or anybody else because certain people interested in mineral development in this country applied for certain rights in respect of certain townlands in the County of Wicklow and got them and with them the obligation to carry out searches for minerals in that area.

The allegation is, however, as I understand it, that the Government gave that lease knowing or believing that the lessees were going immediately to sell it to somebody else at a profit. So far as I am aware no such allegation can be sustained. The only application in fact which was received for the giving of the Minister's consent to a sub-lease, was made very shortly after the lease was granted. It was for the purpose of permitting the Risberget Syndicate, which was associated with the investigation of these minerals to set up a gold-mining unit in the three townlands covered by the lease. As the documents did not reveal any definite parting with the interest in the minerals, but something in the nature of an experimental working of these mining units in the area, by arrangement between the company mentioned and the lessees, they were informed that the Minister's consent did not appear to be required.

Subsequently, Irish Prospectors, Limited, came into the picture. Apparently this group was associated with the proposed establishment of the experimental mining unit on the leasehold of Senator Comyn and Deputy Briscoe because they communicated with the Department representing themselves as perturbed lest there should be difficulty, when they had proved their pilot plant, about the Minister's sanction to the proposed sub-lease, under the main lease, to Risberget. They asked me for an assurance that if Deputy Briscoe and Senator Comyn applied for a sub-lease to be granted to Risberget, my consent would not be withheld. I replied to that application to say that I could not give my assurance at that stage as the precise terms of the sub-lease were not known to me. The letter went on to add that "it was the definite desire of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that the mineral resources of this country should be developed to the largest practicable extent and it may be taken that proposals in that direction by reputable firms with the necessary technical and financial backing would have his sympathetic consideration at all times." That is where the matter stands. It is true that the lessees have supplied us with the copy of an agreement which they have made with Risberget, Limited, for the formation of a company to carry out the commercial working of the minerals in the area when prospecting had been satisfactorily completed but no application for my consent to the making of a sub-lease or to the assignment in any way of the lessees' interest in the lease has yet been made. That fact disposes wholly of Deputy McGilligan's allegations.

To sum up, the position is as follows: A two years' prospecting lease, dated 1st November, 1934, has been granted to the two gentlemen I have named. The lease provides for the grant of another lease of 97 years at the request of the lessees and on the Minister for Industry and Commerce being satisfied that they possess the technical and financial resources necessary for the full development of the undertaking. No application has been put before me for a formal agreement to such a sub-lease but a copy of an agreement between the lessees and other parties for a sub-lease has been put before the Department. An application in respect of a mining unit in the area was submitted to the Minister but it was not considered to require his approval under the original lease.

It is quite obvious that Deputy McGilligan's insinuation is entirely without foundation. I think he knows that himself. I think he has been surprised at the fact that his insinuation was taken seriously and regarded as a serious charge. Of course it would be a serious charge if it could be contended that the Minister for Industry and Commerce had given to certain political friends, for the purpose of enabling them to re-sell it, State property that could be disposed of more advantageously elsewhere to anybody else. Nor did Deputy McGilligan say that in so many words. He left it to be inferred. I think it is about time that Deputies got out of the habit of abusing their privileged position in this Dáil for the purpose of making mean insinuations against persons who are engaged in commercial enterprises in this State, whether these persons happen to be their political opponents or not. I am not assuming anything against Deputy McGilligan because he entered into discussions with the parties who were interested in these matters in 1930 even though members of that group were political supporters of his. I think he did quite right in endeavouring to get prospecting carried out and in promoting legislation which would enable him to give a lease, if the parties had remained interested in the matter and if he had remained Minister for Industry and Commerce. I hope that these parties who are still interested in the matter and who have obviously entered into an agreement with the present lessees of the property will be able in cooperation with them to find some valuable minerals in that area and arrange for their actual excavation.

It is a rotten thing that any Deputy should come in here and make mean insinuations of that kind and then expect to get away with it by pointing to the vague nature of his remarks and by pretending, perhaps, that he meant something else altogether. I hope that we have had the last of this. So far as I am personally concerned, my administration as Minister for Industry and Commerce is open to examination by anybody in this House. I do not think it desirable that papers and documents which the Department has, relating to matters of this kind and which contain letters written by a number of private interests who are dealing in various ways with the Department on a number of matters, should be seen other than by the Minister or officers of the Department. but if there is any Deputy in the House who seriously believes that there is an iota of justification for the insinuation contained in Deputy McGilligan's remarks, there is the file relating to the mining leases in County Wicklow since early in 1930, and I invite him to road it, to read every document in it, every minute that was written by every official as well as by Deputy McGilligan, when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce, and by myself. I ask, for the sake of the decency of this House and for the purpose of ensuring that its time will not be wasted with matters of this kind when we could be dealing with important public business, that the more responsible members of the Fine Gael Party should try to restrain Deputy McGilligan from unloosing these misguided and entirely malicious allegations. It is easy enough for anybody to defend the political weakness of his Party, their absence of policy and his own personal incapacity, by throwing out allegations of the kind that we are accustomed to get from Deputy McGilligan. That is an easy thing to do. Any schoolboy could do it, but a Party which claims to be a responsible Party and that thinks it has a future in the political life of the country, should surely be able to produce some justification for its existence other than Deputy McGilligan and those like him.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Mulcahy, I move that the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration. On this Vote of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, there are quite a number of interesting topics such as employment and unemployment, the wages given in the so-called successful tariffed industries, say, the handling of the Dublin tram strike, and the last item, the elucidation of the details of which the public are anxiously awaiting at this moment—this Wicklow gold mine. I would like to deal with all these matters, but I propose postponing what I have to say on the tramways strike, and the Minister's handling of it, until the Transport Vote comes on.

Comment on this

This is the time to deal with it. It has nothing to do with the Transport Vote.

Comment on this

I suggest that this Vote is too heavily loaded with the misdeeds of the Minister to deal with it on this Vote. The Transport Vote will afford a suitable opportunity for discussing the tramway strike.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the labour disputes section of the Department of Industry and Commerce is not dealt with on the Transport Vote, and if the Deputy wants to deal with that question, then he must do so on this Vote.

Comment on this

There is a special transport section which deals with the giving of licences, and there are certain moneys allocated for transport. I believe—at any rate I am prepared to risk my belief—that the tramway strike can be raised on the Transport Vote. Therefore, I propose postponing what I have to say on that until that Vote comes up, and also in order not to cloud the best discussion that we could possibly have in this House on this concession on the main Vote. I move to refer back the Vote, mainly because of the scandal that is associated with the granting of this concession. We have heard of "Teapot Dome" scandals elsewhere. Now we have our own. The Minister said that he did not know whether I made a charge at all or not. He changed that by saying that this was a charge against himself and his Department, the conjunction being effected by innuendos.

I suggest to the Minister that, when privilege was attached to what Deputies say here, it was given for the purpose of enabling Deputies to raise matters like this. That is the special reason why the privilege grew up; that Deputies in the deliberative Assembly of the nation could discuss freely any matter that seemed to them to warrant open discussion, and to warrant the letting out of a lot of disordered matter from a wound or an abscess that had grown up in the administration. There is a great abscess and a great deal of matter to be let out of this particular thing. If the Minister wants me to formulate charges I shall do so immediately. I say that the Minister did handle State property in this way: that he gave what the concessionaires believe to be a valuable State property—worth, as they say, £17,000,000—that he gave that definitely, clearly and admittedly to two political friends of his, and that he gave it under conditions of secrecy. Under the Mines and Minerals Act there was a way of having it so done that it would have to be laid on the Table of the House, but he did it under conditions which ensured secrecy for two years.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

Let me deal with that. Under the Mines and Minerals Act, if a lease is given for more than two years, a report has to be laid on the Table of the House. If given for less than two years, it need not be laid on the Table of the House.

Comment on this

A prospecting lease?

Comment on this

That is the law. By making it two years and a day, the Dáil had to know about it. By making it a day less than two years, the Dáil need not know about it until the two years had passed.

Comment on this

The Deputy is completely misinformed. A prospecting lease could not be for longer than two years.

Comment on this

Was there a necessity to make it into a prospecting lease?

Comment on this

That is what we will have to get explained. At any rate, the lease could have been given for two years and a day.

Comment on this

It could have been. What happened then? A Deputy has become so annoyed about this that he has had to leave the House at the moment. If it had been made for two years and a day, what would have happened? The fact that the lease had been made would have become known immediately. I suggest that this is an important matter that we should discuss here openly and freely: the handing over of certain State property, which the concessionaires believed to have great value, to two members of the same political group as that to which the Government belong, and the handing of it over under conditions of secrecy. I suggest a far more scandalous matter is that when the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who had handed over that lease, discovered that these people were likely to make a big sum of money on it, that he did not act under the powers given him in the lease and void the whole thing. Let me again restate the principle. I am afraid it will have to be restated several times before this discussion ends. If there is valuable State property, and it is going to be worked, there should be the quickest possible conjunction between the property and the people who are going to work it.

Much as I dislike Labour philosophy on certain things, I think that in this matter the Labour view of middlemen's profits, and lazy middlemen's profits at that, is quite sound. Can anyone really believe that this House would have stood for the open proposition, made here, that two members of any Party should get a concession in relation to a good part of the County Wicklow: that they should not work that themselves but should convey it over to certain other people who would have worked it under Government control, and that for merely bringing the workers and the property together these two members of a political Party should get shares to the amount of £12,000 in a company with a capital of £80,000, with 2¼ per cent. over and above anything that they would have to pay to the State? That is what has happened. Does the Minister for Industry and Commerce believe that he could, brazen and all as he is, have come into the House and stood over a proposition of that kind? To hand over to two people—let me call them X and Y, and let their names be hidden even—and that these two people, instead of working the particular property themselves, were simply going to get in people who had previously made an application in connection with the same property: that for bringing in people to work this valuable State property, valuable in the eyes of those who wanted to work it, these two lazy middlemen should get £12,000 in a company with a capital of £80,000 and, in addition, 2¼ per cent. over and above anything that they would have to pay the State? That is what is before the House. I say it is a fact that the two men who have got this are members of the Fianna Fáil Party. I say it is a big scandal that one is a Deputy, and one the Vice-Chairman of the Seanad. I say it is an extra big scandal that the contract document was drawn up on Seanad Eireann notepaper to give an official stamp, as it were, to the whole matter.

What were the public to get out of this? The best apparently that could be demanded in the lease was that for two years four able-bodied and experienced miners would be employed, and that for the remaining term employment would be given to four other able-bodied and experienced miners. The best that the two people who had got this £12,000 concession in an £80,000 company, with 2¼ per cent. over anything that they had to pay to the State, could offer in return was to keep constantly employed four able-bodied miners for the first two years, and four others for the remaining term. There used to be an old music-hall ditty: "Don't go down the mine, Daddy; let the mine come up to you." There never was such an example of a mine coming up to people—a gold mine—as in this particular instance.

As regards the concession that has been granted to these people, I have only dealt with it so far as it relates to 982 acres in the Co. Wicklow. Remember that there were more considerations than merely passing on that bit of a concession to these people who were going to work those particular minerals. There was a second and a third item of consideration also gained from the Government. These two gentlemen immediately guaranteed and agreed to pass over whatever rights they had obtained in 982 acres in certain named townlands in the County Wicklow, but they also guaranteed that they would do everything in their power necessary to obtain further leases, and when they got them to hand these over too. What do they cover? 2,000 extra acres in the Co. Wicklow and the whole of the foreshore of Arklow.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

And he knows it is not true.

Comment on this

Read the agreement to the House.

Comment on this

I will.

"You are also, at the request and expense of Risberget, Ltd., or their nominee, to do all acts which on your part may be necessary for completing the lease to you of the mines and minerals in six other townlands in the County of Wicklow included in your application, viz., Kilcarragh West, Rostygah, Monologh, Mongan, Knockmiller, Ballinvalley Lower, approximately 2,000 acres, and the foreshore of Arklow."

Is that right? I was challenged on it, and there it is.

Comment on this

That is not what the Deputy said before. The Deputy definitely stated that part of the consideration was that further applications for agreements from the State were to have passed to this company.

Comment on this

We have not got to the end of it yet. There was a third clause. The first clause dealt with the granting to Risberget, Ltd., of 39a Maddox Street, Hanover Square, London, or its nominee, a sub-lease of licence to work the mineral substances of the lands demised. That refers to the 982 acres, part of the mineral rights in the townlands of Ballintemple, Coolgarrow and Clon-william. That is what the Deputy was putting into the hotch-pot—what he got from the Government. In the second place, the concessionaires were to do everything in their power to get the lease of the mines and minerals in six other townlands, covering 2,000 acres, and the foreshore of Arklow. As if that was not big enough to get the Deputy the £12,000 in shares and 2¼ per cent., there is a third clause providing that— again, at the expense of Risberget; the careful Deputy does not allow himself in for any expense—they will

"do all acts which on your part may be necessary for obtaining a lease or leases of the mines and minerals in any other townlands in the County of Wicklow in respect of which you or either of you may have made application for a lease or licence."

This transaction involved 2,982 acres in the County Wicklow, the foreshore of Arklow and something in addition. That is what is brought into the bargain by the Deputy and his colleagues, and they have got that from the Government.

Comment on this

They have got what?

Comment on this

They have made application for this to the Government.

Comment on this

They made application in March, 1933, for these six additional townlands.

Comment on this

I do not care when they made it. What consideration did these two gentlemen bring into the bargain? They brought in what they got from the Government. What were they bound to do? To pay a rent of £5 or £10, according to the period, and to pay a royalty of one-twenty-fifth. They pass on those obligations to Risberget. They got originally a concession in respect of 982 acres, and there is to be a lease of 2,000 acres more, the foreshore of Arklow and something in addition. They pass that over, with their obligations, to the new company, and the new company guarantee that they will occupy and work the mines, that they will pay the Deputy and his colleague one-twenty-fifth, with this 2¼ per cent., and give them 48,000 5/- shares out of 80,000 shares, the company to be known by the grandiose title "The Consolidated Gold Fields of Ireland, Limited."

Comment on this

You invented the title yourself in 1930.

Comment on this

Possibly, but see how it has been taken up and sold for 48,000 5/- shares and 2¼ per cent. as long as the lease lasts. The Deputy and his colleague believe—they have put it on paper—that there is £17,000,000 worth of gold in that mine.

Comment on this

We did not say that. Your friend, whom we would not allow to dispose of it, said that.

Comment on this

Except to himself——

Comment on this

To dispose of it at all.

Comment on this

That is what I call a scandal. Am I supposed to dot the "i's" and cross the "t's" of what I have said? A lease has been given covering 982 acres. Leases are under consideration in regard to 2,000 acres more. Applications are under consideration in regard to some other property, and these people cross the seas to London. They go to Hanover Square and get Risberget to take over this property.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

To take over the obligations in connection with it and to pay the Deputy 48,000 5/- shares. I hope that is not denied.

Comment on this

That is your version. It is all lies.

Comment on this

If necessary, I shall read every word in the document.

Comment on this

Read them all. You said that we crossed to London. That is not true.

Comment on this

I say that two people representing the Deputy crossed to London.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

You have never been in London on this business?

Comment on this

These people came over here and approached us. It is their proposal, not ours.

Comment on this

The Deputy was hanging around anxious to do business, and, suddenly, these adventurers from abroad came to him and they fell for this offer.

Comment on this

I did not say "adventurers." They are your friends.

Comment on this

These peculiar friends of mine come across and make the peculiar proposition, as friends of mine, that they will give the Deputy £12,000. There are other matters in this sub-lease about a bond for £500 which has been handed over. The receipt of it has been recorded, and there are guarantees about employing people. Let us not have much more verbiage in connection with this matter. Does this House consider that it is a proper thing, in relation to the sale of State property, that certain people should be given a concession and that these people should, to the knowledge of the Ministry, at a later stage at all events, have sold that property for valuable consideration to others, with no increased consideration to the State? If ever there was a case in which middlemen's profits should be decried and scouted, surely that is the case.

Let me go back a bit. I am told that these people had already made application. That would show that they were anxious to work this property. They had, apparently, paraded themselves as having certain skill, finance and mechanical equipment. The Minister told us that some of them had met with financial difficulties. Whether they had or not, they are the group on which Deputy Briscoe and his friend finally descend. Very early, these people made application for a mining licence in Wicklow. The only thing that could be done then was to register the application. It is registered. An invitation is sent to them later to make further application and they do not respond. Whether their financial position be sound or unsound, they are somewhere in the background and they are easily found by Deputy Briscoe. That adds to the scandal. These people were known to be at the game, were known to be making application for this lease, apparently having some thought themselves that they had some skill, finance and equipment behind them. The Minister mentioned that they had suffered a lapse in their finances but they were in a sufficiently healthy position to promise the Deputy shares worth £12,000 in a company. Let us leave out the fact that there were a Deputy and a Senator involved in this transaction. The Minister asked me what better bargain the State could have made. Suppose the State had gone to Risberget and said: "You are a foreigner and we shall put an extra tax on you. You shall pay us 6¼ per cent. and give us shares in the company." Would the State be better off? Does the Minister consider it a proper thing that men should be allowed to traffic in property that is not their own, the value of which they have not enhanced to any degree by their activities and that they should be enabled, if the transaction works out rightly, to get their 2¼ per cent. over and above the money they have to pay, as long as the stream of gold lasts and that they should get shares worth £12,000 in a company, with whatever these shares will yield to the shareholders after this 6¼ per cent. has been paid.

I suggest that those simple facts indicate a scandal. As to this matter of the State Lands Act and the Mines and Minerals Act the Minister for Finance spent a considerable time here yesterday, and a short time on Friday, denying that he had anything to do with this. He was put a very precise question yesterday by Deputy McGuire. Deputy McGuire said: "You were a party to it," and the Minister answered, "No." Deputy McGuire is reported a few sentences later to have said: "You had to sanction this," and the Minister said, "No." The original lease is made out in the name of the Minister for Industry and Commerce of the first part, and the Minister for Finance of Saorstát Eireann of the second part.

Comment on this

He said he signed it.

Comment on this

I have to analyse this. The Minister for Industry and Commerce is a party of the first part and the Minister for Finance is a party of the second part and when Deputy McGuire said yesterday in almost legal language: "You are a party to it" the Minister answered "No." Talk of misleading the House. I do not think there are words that the Chair would care to allow to pass to deal with it if the Minister still denies full knowledge of what took place. I find these words, "In witness whereof the parties of the first and the second part have caused their respective seals to be affixed hereto." The Minister for Finance is in this up to the hilt. Whatever the mess, it is not right to submerge the Minister for Industry and Commerce in it leaving the others to climb out on his bedraggled shoulders. The Minister for Finance is in the mess up to the neck, and possibly higher. That Minister evolved a peculiar theory with regard to the lease. It is quite common in regard to legislative business in this House to have a Minister named, and if there is any finance matter in a particular lease, in the way of a licence or concession of any type, the Minister for Finance is necessarily named. The Minister for Finance told us yesterday that he could only be regarded as rather formal, that he would not interfere with a colleague, unless, so to speak, there was a very bad scandal in the proposal. We will remember that when we come to other pieces of legislation. Up to this this House has put Ministers' names into Acts of Parliament. I suggest that this is almost in entirety a financial matter. "We want mines developed in this country," says the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Apparently, he was quite indifferent as to how it was to be done, whether by Deputy Briscoe, Senator Comyn, or some nominees of theirs. The Minister for Finance was concerned to get the best rent. He did not get the best rent. It only required a couple of months possibly to find that there was a better rent to be got. There was the 4 per cent. or the one twenty-fifth that the Ministry demanded, and there was the 2¼ per cent. and the £12,000 that the lessees were to get. Had the Minister not an interest in getting an extra £12,000 for the Government? We had a discussion recently on employment, and the statistical figures showed that wages in two or three years, with all the tariffs, only increased by £25,000. Think of all the labour, according to Deputy Norton, sweated labour, it took to get £25,000 additional to a wages bill of £4,000,000, when Deputy Briscoe and Senator Comyn could get half of that for doing nothing? They could get more than half that. They can get £12,000 stone cold in the company.

Comment on this

We were digging for four years in Wicklow.

Comment on this

I hope you were digging your political graves. They were to enjoy £12,000, half the increased wages secured in two years. I wonder would Deputy Norton fancy himself when speaking to a trade union assembly, having to say that he did in any way sanction an agreement whereby a Deputy and a member of the other House, acting, as I say as the most lazy type of middlemen, were able to get, apart from the dividends, such a location as brought them in an increase equal to the wages bill of two years. That is what we have here.

Comment on this

May I point out that there is no sub-lease.

Comment on this

I know.

Comment on this

Then what is the Deputy talking about?

Comment on this

I saw in the Press on Saturday after I had raised this question, that an application was at present under consideration. It did not shock the Minister into refusing it straight away.

Comment on this

That was not correct.

Comment on this

I am sorry.

Comment on this

No application has been made.

Comment on this

But an application for a sub-lease has been made to the Minister, and he has power to void this on certain grounds. Is he thinking of doing it?

Comment on this

I have no power to void except on application.

Comment on this

One of the obligations was that work should be started in three months on a particular scale, and continued afterwards. Is there not ground for voiding it?

Comment on this

I have no reason to believe it will not be carried out.

Comment on this

We were told that an application was under consideration. Am I to take it that the Minister accepts responsibility for the statement that was made?

Comment on this

Yes; it was a mistake.

Comment on this

It read:—

"The lessees in this case have made arrangements for the exploration of the mineral resources of the property covered by the lease, and have applied for the consent of the Minister to a sub-letting in accordance with the terms of the lease."

Is that not right?

Comment on this

I said that there was an application for consent, for the purpose of having exploration work done, and that as the proposal did not involve any alienation of the terms of the lease, I replied that my consent was not required.

Comment on this

At any rate, the statement that was published, that they applied for a sub-lease, is not correct?

Comment on this

There has been no application.

Comment on this

Therefore, it is not under consideration. Was there something under consideration on Friday? The statement went on:—

"This application is at present under consideration."

I do not imagine that a Minister would stray so far from the truth that he would make a statement like this when, in fact, these two gentlemen's prospecting was of an experimental nature and did not require consent. Did the Minister rush into print on Saturday about something that was under consideration when, in fact, there was nothing under consideration? I hope I am not pressing the point too much, but it is very important.

Comment on this

It was incorrectly stated on Saturday that an application had been made. No application, in fact, has been made.

Comment on this

Not merely did the Minister make a wrong statement but he went on to found a little theory:

"At this stage the Minister wishes to take the opportunity of saying that while he would not give his consent to any arrangement which would be likely to militate against the fullest commercial development of the mineral deposits of the Saorstát, his primary object is to secure such development, and it is not necessarily reprehensible for a lessee to dispose on satisfactory terms of his interest in a lease."

I hope the Deputy will mark the word "necessarily." Can the Minister tell us straight-forward now? This lease that he made contains a clause that there shall be no sub-letting without his consent. The Minister is in the agreement. Has he indicated to these two gentlemen that when their period for experimental digging has concluded he will not favour the sub-lease? Has he told them that?

Comment on this

I will put it in another way. Then the Minister is prepared to consider an arrangement under which these two gentlemen can get over this.

Comment on this

I did not say that. On the contrary, I was asked by the firm concerned, Messrs. Summerfield, Smith and Noonan, if I was prepared to agree. I replied I would give no assurance until I saw the sub-lease.

Comment on this

I am merely drawing this conclusion that by this procedure these two people, members of the Oireachtas, members of his own Party, might get £12,000 in a company and 2¼ per cent. dividend for nothing. Does not that shock him? I would like an answer.

Comment on this

I am not called upon to give any answer.

Comment on this

Now we have it. Surely, I suggest that a Minister in charge of the mineral wealth of this country should be immediately alert in answering if such a proposition was put to him. What value is the Minister getting by these two people being enabled to get £12,000 in a certain company and 2¼ per cent. dividend, over and above anything the State was going to get? What value is accruing to the State? Does the Minister think that these two people have put sufficient work into this business to warrant them getting £12,000 and 2¼ per cent.? I suggest that there is no other person in this House, except the Minister, but should be shocked into an immediate answer by way of a repudiation of such a sub-lease.

Comment on this

Of course, the Deputy's statement is ridiculous.

Comment on this

What statement is ridiculous?

Comment on this

The statement that they are getting £12,000 or that there has been any proposal that they would get £12,000.

Comment on this

Let me get that. Here is the wording of the document:—

"I undertake to form a Company, to be called ‘The Consolidated Gold Fields of Ireland, Ltd.,' or some other name to be substituted therefor, with paid up capital of not less than £80,000, with the object of working the mineral substance of the said lands compriséd in the said lease and all other lands in the County Wicklow which may hereafter be acquired by you under paragraphs 2 and 3 hereof."

Paragraph 2 refers to certain portions of the foreshore of Co. Wicklow, and paragraph 3 says:

"You are to be allotted 48,000, 5/- fully paid-up shares in such Company in consideration for the granting of the sub-lease and of your obligations under paragraphs 2 and 3 hereof."

Is the Minister satisfied with that?

Comment on this

If the Deputy does not appreciate the difference between £12,000 and what he has just read out, he should not be dealing with this matter at all.

Comment on this

Let me understand that. Does the Minister mean that I cannot call 48,000 fully paid-up 5/- shares £12,000? Is the Minister accusing Deputy Briscoe of being a share-pusher, or is he accusing Deputy Briscoe of being "codded" by a share-pusher?

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan knows that Deputy Briscoe has refused cash in that connection. Deputy McGilligan knows that there is a provision there precluding sale.

Comment on this

Is there any prohibition against sale? Supposing that it was even sold for, say, 50 per cent. of the nominal value?

Comment on this

Supposing the shares were sold for a penny?

Comment on this

Supposing certain people floated a company and asked people to subscribe £80,000 to this company and talked of the leases that had been granted and what a valuable property it was, and so on, and supposing that the public were fooled into subscribing for it?

Comment on this

That did not arise in this case. Read the whole thing.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy refer me to the paragraph he has in mind?

Comment on this

Read the whole document.

Comment on this

I say that I cannot find anything here precluding sale.

Comment on this

Oh, I see!

Comment on this

I ask to have the paragraph pointed out to me in which sale is precluded. What paragraph is it? I ask the question again.

Comment on this

Read the whole document.

Comment on this

That is the clearest evasion.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy deny that sale is precluded there?

Comment on this

Yes. I say that I cannot find it anywhere here.

Comment on this

That is a different thing from saying that it is not there.

Comment on this

A Chinn Comhairle, I want to raise the question of the relevancy of this discussion.

Comment on this

At the present time I am answerable for matters of administration in connection with the Mines and Minerals Act, but the particular document which Deputy McGilligan is reading is one with which I have nothing to do. In regard to the matter about which Deputy McGilligan is speaking, there has been no sub-letting by me, and I have not even been asked to approve of any such sub-letting.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister must be aware of all the circumstances connected with the document from which I am quoting?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Industry and Commerce has stated that no sub-letting of the concession has been sanctioned. His word must be taken by the Chair on that matter. With regard to the document which Deputy McGilligan is quoting, the Chair has no knowledge of whether or not it is a document signed or sanctioned by the Minister.

Comment on this

I have stated, Sir, that not alone has there been no sub-letting by me, but that I have had no application for such sub-letting.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Accordingly, the question of sub-letting does not arise, since no application for such has been made to the Department concerned.

Comment on this

So that there is no question of £12,000 for sub-letting what Deputy Briscoe has got? On a point of order, Sir, Clause 9 of this agreement, which the Minister has signed and sealed with the Minister for Finance, has this prohibition: that Deputy Briscoe and his colleague are not "to give, underlet, or assign over, or part with the possession, by way of licence, or otherwise, of these presents of the several premises hereby demised," etc., etc., "without the consent of the lessor in writing first had and obtained." The lessor is the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Without his consent they cannot sub-let, according to that, but the Minister has in his possession an agreement signed and sealed by the Deputy and Senator agreeing to sub-let.

Comment on this

That is not true. If the Deputy is really honest I have no objection to his raising this question, but the Deputy himself knows that he is absolutely dishonest in his contention. There is a clause there which specifically says that anything done under this agreement has first to have the sanction of the Minister.

Comment on this

That is the whole crux of the matter.

Comment on this

I submit, Sir, that this is the Vote for my Department and that nobody else is concerned.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair would like to know whether Deputy McGilligan purports to discuss the conduct of the Leas-Chathaoirleach of the Seanad and a Deputy of this House or the Minister's administration in regard to the alleged sub-lease. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has assured the House that there is no such sub-lease, and that being so, he cannot be held responsible for any proposals made.

Comment on this

We know he has got it, and we know that the Minister's consent must be looked for.

Comment on this

I have had no application for it.

Comment on this

The Minister wanted this exposed in the House, did he not?

Comment on this

I am prepared to put this to the House: that, with the consent of the House, we will appoint a Special Committee of the House to consider this whole matter and report on it.

Comment on this

I would be prepared to accept that, with one addition. I suggest that, if a committee of the House is to be appointed to inquire into this particular matter, it should also inquire into the granting of licences in relation to cattle, flour, and thread—just these three things.

Comment on this

Oh, no! We are dealing with the particular allegation the Deputy has made.

Comment on this

The Minister is running away, as usual. I thought that, when the Minister said that the administration of his Department was open to examination by anyone in this House he would be willing to have an investigation into all these branches of his Department. The Minister welcomed examination. My object is to expose these scandals in regard to the granting of licences and permits.

Comment on this

The Deputy made a number of groundless allegations with regard to my Department. Is he prepared to back them before a select committee of this House?

Comment on this

I am prepared to discuss this matter before the House.

Comment on this

I knew the Deputy would run away.

Comment on this

I have not said that I would refuse that offer. I want to make the case that, once one scandal of this type is exposed, there is a prima facie case for investigating the Minister's Department thoroughly, and also the Department of his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture. It must be remembered that this is only the beginning of it. May I take it that the Minister is not prepared to discuss this matter of the sub-lease?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Minister states that a sub-lease has neither been granted nor applied for, the question does not arise for debate.

Comment on this

The Minister knows that there is a sub-lease.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair must accept what the Minister has stated as the position.

Comment on this

If the Minister says, in flat defiance of the document he has in his possession, that there is no sub-lease——

Comment on this

A sub-lease?

Comment on this

No sub-lease can be made without my consent, and I have not been asked for my consent to that sub-lease at any time.

Comment on this

An agreement has been entered into about this, and part of the agreement is that the Minister's consent shall be had.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister has not given his consent to any sub-lease. He has stated so, and his word must be accepted.

Comment on this

The Minister wants this discussion squashed.

Comment on this