We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1935—Committee.

Contributions 168–350 of 350. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 15 of 1935 ›

That is the Minister's reply to the point. Nobody with a grain of sense in his head would refer a complaint of that kind to the Prices Commission, and if anybody has responsibility for doing so, it is not primarily the Deputy's. The Minister for Industry and Commerce was brazen enough on one occasion to deny the assertion that there was smuggling of cattle across the Border. Will he now have the effrontery to say that the figures quoted with regard to the price of sugar on the other side of the Border are incorrect? Sugar can be got at nearly 1/6 a stone cheaper in the Six County area than it can be got here. The same holds good with regard to butter and the other things that form the context of this tax. Why is there a tax being put upon a commodity which the Minister previously described as a hard tax, which the President in 1931 described in most ferocious language, and about which the present Minister for Agriculture purported to give figures to prove that the increase in the cost of living through sugar alone was going to be doubled, so that there would be no advantage got from derating in that year. In view of all that, why is this being done? Simply because the Government are at their wits' end for taxation. The ordinary sources of revenue are drying up. The main sources of revenue are drying up. Why have the Government to go back and tax these things? Deputy Corry gave me the reason some time ago. He said the reason for these taxes was because they were on the necessaries of life which people had to buy. They might evade the payment of other taxes of the indirect type, but Deputy Corry was quite flamboyant about sugar. In the case of a tax on sugar you could nail people. People could not avoid consuming it, and that is what the Government have got to fall back upon—to tax the articles that cannot be evaded. The position to-day is, as Deputy Corry phrased it, that the Government have to tax the things that the people have got to consume in order to sustain life. All that throws a glaring searchlight on the rosy pictures painted here during the last one and a half years by the Government about the great productivity, prosperity, increased wealth, and all the rest. In the end they are driven to the confession that they have now got to get down to the things that people must eat and to put taxes on them.

Comment on this

This tax will press very heavily on people this year because of the fact that sugar was never dearer in this country than it is at the moment. In the period dealt with by Deputy McGilligan, sugar was at a comparatively low price compared to what it is now. As has been pointed out, sugar is dearer here by 1¼d. or 1½d. per lb. than it is in the Six County area. The Minister made the futile excuse that the Government are getting less out of this tax than they were getting two or three years ago. Why? Because, compared to the price at which sugar can be landed on the quays in Dublin, it is costing about £15 a ton more to manufacture sugar in the three factories here. We have been told that 50,000 acres are laid down under beet. That is the great new orientation in our agricultural development: one-eighth of an acre for every farmer in the country or one acre divided amongst eight farmers. If you line up eight farmers and give one of them a single acre of beet, the other seven are taxed for the production of that as well as the people in the cities and towns. It is all very well to have experiments in the growing of beet and the manufacture of sugar, but surely this is not the time, when the price of sugar is at its highest, to put on this extra burden. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that £6 a ton was the economic price of sugar at the quays. The position, therefore, is that the farmers are to pay an economic price for everything they have to purchase and are to receive an uneconomic price for what they have to sell. The seven farmers I have referred to, who have not got even one acre of beet, must pay not merely an economic price, but above an economic price, for sugar, and they are to sell their cattle at an uneconomic price. That is the position.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave seems to have some very peculiar ideas. I wonder what was his line of thought when he was President of this State, and when, from 1925 to 1932, he had the farmers of 25 counties sweetening the County Carlow constituency for him. He talked about eight farmers, and said that only one out of the eight was able to get one acre of beet to grow, but what about all the farmers in the 25 counties, in the period I have referred to, who were sweetening the Carlow constituency for him? The extra acreage under beet this year is something like 42,000 acres. That figure relates to the three factories. A large amount of extra employment is going to be given because of that increased acreage. It will provide, roughly, £1,000,000 extra for the farmers as well as extra employment for those on the land. The Deputy laughs at that. Frankly, I confess that I did not understand what Deputy McGilligan said a moment ago.

Comment on this

I was quoting the Deputy, but what he said was not quite clear to me.

Comment on this

I will be glad if, in future, Deputy McGilligan will tell us what he is quoting from and read the quotations. The Deputy leaves out words out of alleged statements Deputies make here, and puts in things that they do not say at all.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan was helping the Deputy. He was explaining that the 42,000 acres and the £1,000,000 will give £25 to every farmer.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan knows nothing at all about it, and I can assure him that I want no assistance from him.

Comment on this

He will give the Deputy all the assistance that he wants.

Comment on this

I do not want any assistance from him. I have indicated what the farmers are getting out of the Government's scheme for beet growing and out of the increased acreage that we have now. I noticed last week, and again to-day, that when an attempt is being made to provide an alternative market for our farmers, immediately a definite objection is raised by the Deputies opposite on the grounds of an increase in the cost of living. We, as farmers' representatives, do not complain when proposals are brought forward to raise money in order to set up new industries and to give employment, and hence, we see no reason why the Deputies opposite should get so noisy in connection with this proposal. I can assure Deputy Morrissey, who is one of the representatives of a large beet-growing constituency—I do not know whether he grows any beet himself or not—that the representatives of the beet growers in that area are well able to look after their own business and need no assistance from him.

Comment on this

As they did last year.

Comment on this

When you were forced to accept an uneconomic price for the beet.

Comment on this

The Deputy says, as we did last year.

Comment on this

When you were beaten.

Comment on this

When we found that the gentlemen who had urged the people and advised them not to grow beet were chasing around the country in motor cars and offering to grow beet for the factories at 30/- a ton.

Comment on this

That is untrue.

Comment on this

I can produce letters to show that it is not untrue. I can prove it.

Comment on this

What are they getting now?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy deny that E.J. Cussen made a public statement on it and that supporters of his Party hired motor cars to follow me around my constituency when I was arranging about the contracts?

Comment on this

They were only breeding greyhounds.

Comment on this

We have to listen to a lot of balderdash from Deputies opposite. It is like the £2 apiece they were paying for the cows.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There is nothing about cows in this section.

Comment on this

Any time they look for it over there they are going to get it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are on sugar now.

Comment on this

The red flag now. That is the particular point I wanted to make—that Deputy Cosgrave now complains because some of the farmers, apparently, yielded to that advice, did not take contracts and did not grow beet. They are now coming along and saying: "My neighbour has got a market and has got a cheque in respect of so many acres of beet. I would have got the same cheque but you advised me not to grow it." It is like all the other advice they took from that Party. Deputy Cosgrave sat idly by as a representative of a constituency for a number of years. Deputy Cosgrave, as a representative of a constituency which had been particularly sweetened, as he says, at the expense of the other 25 counties, should be the last man to make any complaint because a few more counties are getting the sweets he denied them.

Comment on this

I think there was talk at one time about a white elephant.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary has removed to Dublin.

Comment on this

I will never leave Cork until the last day. I love the county. They are very sane people down there.

Comment on this

I wish you had stopped with them a little longer. That is the reason for the complaint—that a market worth £1,000,000 a year has been found for the farmer. That is what all the noise is about here this evening. Last week, there was the same noise about the wheat question and the week before about the butter question. If anybody should have remained quietly silent to-night, it was Deputy Cosgrave.

Comment on this

One remarkable feature about Deputy Corry's speech was that he never once touched on the sugar tax, although that was the reason he rose to speak. He did not tell us why it was necessary to put it on or what its economic effect is. The Deputy introduced instead this question of sugar beet. I remember reading, with a great deal of interest, the comments made by Deputy Corry when the price for sugar beet to the producer was being fixed. I think he said in very blustering fashion something about coolie wages and wound up by saying in a spectacular way that the producers were not going to accept a price which would leave them less than the price of a pint. Notwithstanding that declaration, the Deputy came up to Government Buildings and crawled out of that declaration, and he had not the price of a pint with him when he left. His reputation has gone lower. The Deputy talks now of the immense benefit of this crop to the farmers, but when he was discussing the matter as a member of a Beet Committee he talked of starvation wages and said there would be no profit to the producer. The "loud music of the distant drum" rings in his ears but, with all the tub-thumping, he did not carry out these promises to his friends. At that time, he talked of coolie wages and said there would be starvation for the producer of beet. He did not need anybody to go around in motor cars then. I do not know what means of locomotion he used, but he was going up and down the country agitating against the price that was being fixed for the growing of this crop. Now, many months afterwards, he is probably entirely discarded and derided by the people who were foolish enough to believe in him then. He talks now of the benefit brought to the farming community through the sugar beet scheme. Let him address himself to what we are discussing—the tax on sugar. On a recent occasion, he said that the taxes put on these things were imposed because they were substances which the people must eat.

Comment on this

When the Deputy quotes me he should quote the actual words I used. He should produce the quotation. He is not going to father any kind of trash on me.

Comment on this

I shall try to get the quotation for the Deputy.

Comment on this

Go and get it.

Comment on this

I am not a member of the Government——

Comment on this

You are so notorious a twister of truth that nobody can believe you.

Comment on this

I am not a member of the Government to be barked at by a sugar-beet grower annoyed about the price. It is not fair. I shall endeavour to get this quotation for the Deputy, because he was called to order several times by the Ceann Comhairle for intervening in the debate in question—which was, I think, on the Second Stage of the Finance Bill. He did say—I am putting this in my own words and giving the sense of his remarks, if they had any——

Comment on this

You paid for the sense of remarks before.

Comment on this

I do not know if it is possible to read sense into the Deputy's remarks.

Comment on this

You got into one hole already.

Comment on this

The reason, he said, that we had got down to taxes on tea, sugar, bread and butter was that people had to eat these things and, therefore, the tax would be got off them. That was the remark he made.

Comment on this

That was not what I said. I should like to reply to Deputy McGilligan's statement and say this——

Comment on this

Talk about sugar, not sugar-beet.

Comment on this

At the very period that Deputy McGilligan and those over there were telling us that the farmers were ruined and robbed by us——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must deal with this section, which has reference to the tax on sugar.

Comment on this

I want to straighten out this point.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The point has been straightened. I allowed the Deputy to ramble from the subject and I allowed Deputy McGilligan to reply to him. That is all we are going to hear about the matter now.

Comment on this

I will be very brief. At that particular period, the farmers of Cork County whom Deputy McGilligan said we let down——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry must desist. I shall hear the Deputy on the tax on sugar imposed by this section but I shall hear him on nothing else just now.

Comment on this

Any vote on the beer question——

Comment on this

Are you in favour of taxing sugar.

Comment on this

Let the question go to a division and see.

Comment on this

The man is here to talk. That was what his constituents returned him for.

Comment on this

I said here before that anything that is necessary to provide for the people whom the Deputy said, on one famous occasion, it was not the duty of the Government to provide for, I am in favour of.

Comment on this

Including taxes?

Comment on this

Including anything necessary.

Comment on this

Even on necessaries?

Comment on this

Yes—even to slipping the breeches off Deputy McGilligan, if necessary.

Comment on this

That was what you said before and you denied it.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry has gone back on the argument that this tax should be imposed because it brings a benefit of £1,000,000 to the farmers. If Deputy Corry wants to accept that argument, will he tell us why, in spite of the fact of the money going to farmers, agricultural labourers' wages in Munster are down by 4/-, compared with what they were in 1931?

Comment on this

By the orders of your organisation.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us why?

Comment on this

There is nothing about a tax on farmers, or about the wages of agricultural labourers in this section.

Comment on this

In spite of the assistance given to farmers in Munster, in one-third of the wheat-growing districts, and 11,000 additional acres grown, there are only 903 additional labourers employed.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is going very wide of this section.

Comment on this

That was the orders of your organisation.

Comment on this

Who is getting the money?

Comment on this

I want to protest once more against Deputy Corry saying that the farmers of Cork are benefiting. Possibly certain farmers are benefiting. It is very doubtful whether they are or not. Deputy Corry admits that 40,000 additional acres of beet are grown, and that it is going to cost £1,000,000 to grow that acreage. I wonder could the Minister tell the House how many farmers are growing the 40,000 acres?

Comment on this

I do not propose to do so now.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance is "fed up" with that and everything else.

Comment on this

There are 450,000 farmers in this country, and £1,000,000 is going to be distributed amongst those with the 40,000 acreage. All the others have to contribute towards that expenditure. That is what I am always protesting against. I protest against unfortunate small farmers having to pay the bounty, and having to maintain people like Deputy Corry and others who have good land up and down the country.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 54
·
Níl 39
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

On the section, Sir, I take it that the result of this section will be to increase the price of all fruit consumed by the people, so that those who use apples, plums, pears, cherries, strawberries, raspberries, currants or gooseberries, will pay more?

Comment on this

On the section, Sir, I think it would be well if the Minister would tell the House, in the first place, what the effect of the section is and, in the second place, what is the intention. Sub-section (2) says that duty shall be imposed at the rate of any amount equal to 75 per cent. of the value of the article, but subsequent information, vouchsafed in some schedules circulated to the House, indicated that the duty, instead of being 75 per cent., is going to be 100 per cent. Now, a tax of 100 per cent. —or with some kind of preference thrown, a preferential tax of 75 per cent.—is being put on all cutlery that is being brought into the country. Would the Minister tell us clearly what exactly is the amount of the tariff that is being put on this cutlery, why it could not have been put plainly into this section, and what he has in mind when he proposes that a tariff of that particular size should be put on cutlery?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Deputy moving amendment No. 7?

Comment on this

I am sorry, Sir. I was talking on Section 16, but with these remarks I should like to move amendment No. 7. I now move amendment No. 7:

In sub-section (2), line 44, to delete the word "seventy-five" and substitute therefor the word "twenty"; and in lines 44 and 45, to delete the words "or the rate of six pence on each article."

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

There was a duty of 15 per cent. imposed in 1932 as a revenue duty. When the project of having a cutlery factory established in this country was first mooted, then, in order to discourage any tendency to undue importations that revenue duty was increased to 25 per cent. and cutlery was imported into the country subject to 25 per cent. duty which was paid. When the flotation of the company took place and the construction of the factory was begun, it was obvious that there was some danger of large quantities of cutlery being brought into the country in anticipation of an increase in the duty or of the making of a quota order under the Control of Imports Acts, and, in order to prevent that, this duty of 75 per cent., with a 50 per cent. preferential rate, is being imposed. However, the duty of 25 per cent. imposed under the Emergency (Imposition of Duties) Act has not been repealed and at the present time cutlery is being imported under licences which remit the duty imposed by the Finance Act; that is, the 75 per cent. with the 50 per cent. preferential rate, but the 25 per cent. imposed under the Emergency Act is still being collected. That emergency duty will disappear when the factory at Droichead Nua comes into production, and the permanent duty will be 75 per cent. with the 50 per cent. preferential rate.

The reason why the duty is being imposed at that height is because there is reason to anticipate that certain forms of cutlery could be imported at very low prices. In fact, it is known that Germany and other continental countries are subsidising the export of cutlery at the present time, and it was felt that a smaller rate of duty might prove ineffective and that dumping tactics might be resorted to in order to get cutlery products into this market. It must be remembered by Deputies that cutlery products are not perishable and that they could be brought in and stored here in any quantity. The industry is being established at Droichead Nua by a company which has been recently formed, and it is anticipated that there will be no difficulty experienced in producing cutlery there at practically the same prices as in Sheffield. No increase in prices is anticipated, but we could not take the risk of having a lower rate of duty which would interfere with the development of the industry even though the duty is not required because of any higher costs of production anticipated here. The industry is an important one and it is expected to give employment to about 200 persons in the town, of which the greater proportion will be men, but with some proportion of women. The market available is valued at about £60,000 per annum.

Comment on this

Will the Minister endeavour to see that there is no increase in the prices of the products as a result of this tariff?

Comment on this

Oh, quite. I agree that in respect of certain products manufactured here now there has been an increase in prices compared with the prices of the imported article, but we deliberately decided to establish these factories here knowing that that would be so because we expected that the results as a whole would be beneficial. In this case, having gone carefully into the matter with the promoters and other people interested in the project, we were satisfied that there was no reason of which we knew why prices should be higher here except, of course, in so far as there might be a higher standard of wages here than operates in Sheffield, or some factor of that kind.

Comment on this

I would not mind that.

Comment on this

Subject to the conditions being the same, there is no reason why prices should be higher.

Comment on this

But the Minister is aware of certain articles for which there is an excessive price compared with that operating in England?

Comment on this

There are certain points which are not quite clear. Do I understand that the tax in 1932 was definitely put on without any reference to protection?

Comment on this

Yes. It was for revenue purposes, and was stated to be for revenue purposes.

Comment on this

At the present moment the position, as I understand it, is that you have an effective tax of 25 per cent?

Comment on this

And there is restriction by licence?

Comment on this

That is, you fear that there might be a flooding of this country by the importation of a large amount of cutlery, partly owing to the cost of production abroad, and partly owing, possibly, to the question of subsidising, but by means of the prohibition—prohibition acting through licence—and the 25 per cent., the Minister is able to cope with that situation. Why could not the Minister cope with that situation once the factory is set up? What is the necessity for raising it to 75 per cent?

Comment on this

It is not being raised to 75 per cent.

Comment on this

Do I understand from the Minister that once the factory is in operation, in order to achieve the same purpose—that is to keep out dumped cutlery—he proposes to make permanent the 75 per cent. duty and possibly the 100 per cent. duty? Why will not the same machinery that is operating now with the 25 per cent. duty, be equally effective when the factory is in operation?

Comment on this

The Deputy does not understand. The 25 per cent. has been in operation for some time, and has been paid by importers, but it was not by itself sufficient to remove the danger of abnormal importations. Therefore, another duty of 75 per cent. was imposed. Both duties are now in operation, and a person trying to import cutlery without a licence would have to pay 100 per cent. but, in fact, on application such a person could get a licence which remits the 75 per cent. When production commences the position will be that the duty of 75 per cent., with a 50 per cent. preferential rate, will become payable, and there will be no licence. Anybody can import subject to that duty, but the emergency duty will be repealed, and the policy of issuing licences will be stopped.

Comment on this

So far as stopping the issue of licences is concerned I have no objection to that, as the Minister knows. But if you have this particular system, why is not the Minister continuing the licences? He apparently has not the same objection to the system that I have, judging from the way it is being operated. Why this licence provision, plus 25 per cent. duty, cannot operate in the future as well as it is evidently operating now is not clear to me. I cannot see why, once a factory is established, if he has an effective 25 per cent., plus a licensing system, he cannot do what he wants with that 25 per cent. without running the risk of raising it to 50 per cent. It is inevitable that he will raise it to 50 per cent. if any of the foreign articles come in.

Comment on this

This is not a quota order. It is a Customs duty which is remitted by licence. The intention would be to secure that when the factory is in production the situation will be that any person wishing to import can do so, subject to the payment of duty.

Comment on this

But the Minisster has not explained why that system is preferable to the present one.

Comment on this

It will obviously operate to discourage people from importing.

Comment on this

There seems to me to be two very grave objections to the general proposal; first, I think it absurd that people should suffer at the present moment the imposition of a tariff as high as 100 per cent. on cutlery.

Comment on this

But they are not.

Comment on this

I should like to hear the Minister get after that. The amendment suggests that the tariff should not in fact be higher than 45 per cent., but to raise the tariff to the point to which the Minister is now raising it is simply to drive people into the position that they have to pay a higher price for their cutlery now. Why it should be necessary to do that as a lead-up to a factory in connection with which we do not know when it will be established or in working order——

Comment on this

We expect it to be in production in August.

Comment on this

——and which the Minister tells us is going to produce as cheaply as a Sheffield factory, is more than I can understand. I do not understand the real intention of the licence provision in connection with this 75 per cent. As I understand the position, the 25 per cent. which has been imposed under the Emergency (Imposition of Duty) Order has been paid by everybody, and is going to continue to be paid.

Comment on this

It will continue to be paid until it is repealed.

Comment on this

I understand that, although the Minister has power to give a licence to import the articles dealt with in the Emergency (Imposition of Duty) Order without a tariff, he is not exercising that provision, and that everybody who is importing cutlery at any rate has to pay 25 per cent. I do not understand the Minister's remarks when he suggests that people are not going to pay the additional 75 per cent. or the 50 per cent. preference, and I should like him to make clear in what circumstances that is going to be set aside. I take it that it is in operation at present?

Comment on this

But licences to import free of that duty are being issued.

Comment on this

To everybody?

Comment on this

To everybody, except that in a case where there is an application to import an abnormal quantity it would be refused, but there is in fact no restriction upon anybody at the present time.

Comment on this

Then the mystery gets thicker and thicker. What is the intention of this section at all? It is actually being used as a quota arrangement, if I understand the Minister properly.

Comment on this

Temporarily.

Comment on this

Why on earth should this House be asked to put an additional 75 per cent., with a preferential rate of 50 per cent., on this particular class of cutlery, when it is a quota arrangement the Minister is looking for? The proceedings are very absurd, and I think they are very unreasonable. I do not even think they are meant to be reasonable; there is a twist in the matter, and the twist can only mean that the people are going to pay more for their cutlery, and are in fact paying more at the present time.

Comment on this

The Deputy will appreciate that when the company was formed, and the construction of the factory commenced, it was necessary to increase the duty. The Deputy will at least concede that from the Government's point of view it was necessary to increase the duty in order to prevent abnormal quantities of cutlery being imported in anticipation of a higher duty later, or of a Quota Order.

Comment on this

Is that the 25 per cent.?

Comment on this

No. The 25 per cent. was in operation from last year. The problem we were faced with at that time was that either we were to increase the 25 per cent. to 75 per cent. and then say to the importers: "You will pay 75 per cent.," or "we will give you a licence to import free of that duty." The first alternative would have been unfair to the importers. They would have to pay 75 per cent. for articles which were not available in this country. The second alternative would have meant that cutlery would come in for those three or four months cheaper than it had come in for the past year; in other words, the 25 per cent. would also have to be remitted as well as the increase in the duty. In order to avoid that situation arising, and maintain the 25 per cent. throughout the whole of the period until the factory would come into production, the emergency duty was left in operation, and this duty was imposed to discourage people from importing abnormal quantities. This duty is not now being paid by anybody, because any importer can get a licence to import free of that duty for the time being. That is, as the Deputy has properly described it, a quota arrangement. It is only a temporary arrangement, which will finish at the end of August, when this duty becomes effective and will be the only duty in operation. There will be no restriction on people importing except the duty.

It is considered preferable to have that arrangement in force rather than a quota and restriction in respect of quantity. There would be certain difficulties in operating a quota order in relation to cutlery. Up to the present, quota orders have restricted imports by quantities. A quota order permitted the importation of a certain quantity of goods, so many yards of cloth, so many tyres, or so many motor vehicles. It would be difficult to operate such a system in relation to cutlery. You might possibly have a quota in respect of the value. We have not done that, because there are difficulties in the way of doing it. We prefer to have protection of this industry, not by a quota order, but by the imposition of a Customs duty, which will still permit people desiring to import certain types of cutlery, perhaps cutlery which may have a sentimental value for them, subject to the payment of the duty.

Comment on this

This amendment has been moved by Deputy Mulcahy. I would like to point out to him the wide door which he is opening if he persists with his amendment. The Deputy seeks to delete the protection of 75 per cent., which is afforded in the section to cutlery produced here, and he desires to substitute for the 75 per cent., protection to the extent of 20 per cent. He wants to delete completely the provision which establishes a minimum rate of 6d. on each article. It has been decided to establish a cutlery factory here. It will be located at Droichead Nua. At present premises are being adapted for use as a factory and the adaptation will be completed about the end of this month. The factory is likely to be in production about the end of August. While efforts were being made to establish a factory here, it was found there was a large number of English and Continental travellers endeavouring to book orders in this country in advance of the establishment of the factory.

If that position had been allowed to develop without restrictions being imposed by the Government, obviously it would be a long time before the Newbridge factory would be required to produce cutlery for the Irish market. It was therefore not only necessary to impose a duty of this kind, to forestal dumping from the British and Continental markets, but it was particularly necessary to do so in respect of the imports from non-European sources. A kind of cutlery has been dumped here from Japan and sold at a price that it is not possible for any Irish producer to compete against. Some of the articles of cutlery imported from Japan could not be made and sold here, even if the workers here were to work for nothing. It is obviously desirable that we should have some adequate protection against imports from Japan of a cheap type of cutlery made under diabolical labour conditions. I think Deputy Mulcahy will hardly object if we protect Irish made cutlery against importations of that description.

Comment on this

Will 75 per cent. be sufficient to stop that?

Comment on this

I think it is very difficult to stop it, even by means of 75 per cent.; but I think you will get a considerable distance towards stopping it by the imposition of a minimum rate of 6d. on each article. Knives have been imported from Japan and sold here at 2/9 a dozen. It is impossible for any Irish worker, no matter what type of machinery is being used, to produce knives here at 2/9 a dozen. It is with that type of competitor that this factory will be asked to compete. It has also to be borne in mind that the German Government, in order to try to maintain their non-German markets, have been giving bounties on their exports; not only have they been giving these bounties, but they have been paying the complete import duty on German-exported goods. Again, one can hardly say that competition from Germany, having regard to the present rates of wages here, is fair competition in relation to articles produced in this country.

It is noteworthy that protection has been given in respect of commodities exported from countries where the rates of wages have been extremely low, notoriously low in the case of Japan, and where it was felt, because of these low rates, it would be impossible for an Irish factory, paying reasonable rates of wages, to compete with products from such countries. I think the intention is, as was explained by the Minister, that when the licensing provision ceases by reason of the fact that the Irish factory is in production, the normal rate will then be 75 per cent. for any cutlery imported, with the provision that there is a minimum rate of 6d. on each article. I suggest Deputy Mulcahy ought not to move for the deletion of the rate of 6d. on each article because the only country that will benefit by his action, if it is approved, will be Japan, and every Japanese cutlery worker will be very pleased with the Deputy. I do not know whether that would be any satisfaction to him. He ought not to persist with his amendment, because it would be calculated not to help Irish workers, but rather to help industries in other countries where people are compelled to work at extremely low rates of wages.

Comment on this

If Irish industry and Irish workers are being prejudiced in either their present or future positions by circumstances such as Deputy Norton speaks of, they will want to get a less wry-necked weapon to defend their interests than the section we have in this Finance Bill. It is no use to talk about Japan and the terrible conditions there and the kind of damage that can be done to this industry by the importation of quantities of knives at 2/9 a dozen—they would be nearly as cheap as the shoes about which the Minister for Industry and Commerce boasts. This section, as it stands, is going to leave a 75 per cent. tariff on goods made in Sheffield. I do not know whether the conditions in Sheffield are a disgrace to civilisation, or anything like that; I take it that they are better than the Japanese conditions and I have to take it that we would probably be fairly satisfied to have a well-established cutlery industry here giving stable employment and as good conditions to start with as the cutlery workers in Sheffield have. I do not know, but I imagine if I was offered that I would accept right away. As the section stands, the Minister has power to charge a 75 per cent. tariff on goods coming from Sheffield and 100 per cent. on goods coming from any other place. If people are anxious to import cutlery he will say to them: "If you do you will have to pay 50 per cent."; that is, that he is going to discriminate in the persons he will allow to import cutlery or parts of cutlery and is going to use the weapon of being able to say: "You will have to pay this extra tariff if you import." I object to that as a scheme. The proposal down here does not deal with that as a scheme, but it does suggest an amendment which leaves the tariff against Sheffield cutlery at 45 per cent., and if the Minister weighed the question of the tariff imposed by this, the tariff would be 25 per cent. against any place in respect of which there was not a preference. I think it is quite sufficient at the moment to leave it that the 45 per cent. tariff can obtain as a whole or in particular circumstances where the Minister is operating his licences. I should like to know whether the Minister has the intention of operating the licence purely to facilitate people who are setting up industry.

Comment on this

No, licences are being given to everybody who was engaged at any time in the business of importing cutlery.

Comment on this

With the tariff left at these figures, I think no complaint can be raised. It is absurd to have 75 per cent. and 100 per cent. tariffs in our tariff legislation for whatever purpose. It is a bad habit and it does reflect in prices outside. The costs falling on people outside in every direction are sufficiently high to make it necessary to avoid anything that would tend to increase them and, therefore, I am very definitely opposed to allowing the figures to stand.

Comment on this

It seems to me that so far as Deputy Norton's reference to the amendment is concerned, his argument deals only with one portion of the amendment. He does not at all deal with the increased cost of what I might call cutlery produced under ordinary conditions. To segregate the two portions of the section, one portion of the section is definitely aimed at the exclusion of extra cheap articles. We may argue whether cheap articles ought to be excluded because they are cheap and whether the suggestion that the consumer at the moment in this country can never have a word said for him, that he has no voice in the matter, that it is no advantage to him and to the tens of thousands of other consumers in this country, who buy knives, to get them cheap—you may object to getting them cheap, but it is an advantage and it cannot be brushed aside as if it did not exist. Suppose, however, that you have that insuperable objection. People seem to know a lot about labouring conditions in other countries, ever so much more than they know of labour conditions in their own country, but I often am doubtful when I hear pictures painted of labouring conditions in other countries, because I have heard pictures painted of labour conditions in other countries, and the people in those countries paint very much the same picture of labour conditions here. I have heard them do it, but leave that aside. That, at all events, can be covered by the sixpence per article tax. But there is what I gather from the Minister is going to be a permanent thing once the factory is set up. The 75 per cent. will be a permanent tax once the factory is set up. It is not a mere passing thing; it is to be permanent, and there is that increased price year after year and day after day of everything consumed in this country.

Comment on this

We do not anticipate that prices will be increased at all.

Comment on this

The Minister never did yet anticipate it.

Comment on this

I still press the amendment but I should like to ask the Minister, in view of his remarks, to say, in a loud voice, that there is nothing in this amendment that could in any way increase cutlery prices from what they were before 16th May.

Comment on this

There is nothing whatever in this section which should operate to increase cutlery prices over and above what they were on 1st May, 1st March or 1st January.

Comment on this

Will the Minister draw the attention of the Prices Controller to that statement?

Comment on this

I have received no complaint whatever on that score from anybody.

Comment on this

The 75 per cent. is not operating at present according to the Minister.

Comment on this

And at that stage prices are going down.

Comment on this
Division

Question put—"That the words proposed to be deleted stands."

Tá 59
·
Níl 35
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Before you put Section 16, there is one point that I gathered from the Minister in answer to some questions by Deputy Mulcahy and myself. The Minister said that there will be nothing in the section that will induce to an increase in price, and I gathered from the low remark made by the Deputy—I mean low in sound— that the prices were already going down. Is that so?

Comment on this

It was anticipated that it would be possible to have a factory producing cutlery at the same price as at Sheffield, and in so far as cutlery is sold here on a duty of 25 per cent., we may anticipate a decrease in the price of cutlery from the Irish factories.

Comment on this

Did I understand from the Minister that the prices at present are going down?

Comment on this

No. But we anticipate the prices will go down.

Comment on this

The Minister always anticipates these things.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment No. 8:—

In sub-section (1), to delete the word "seventy-five," where it occurs in each of the lines: 9, 17, 22 and 25.

I do not know whether the Minister is pursuing the same principle of this section as he was pursuing on Section 16. At any rate Section 17 purports to impose on clocks and on clock movements a tariff of 75 per cent. of the value of the article and not less than 2/-, and on clock cases 75 per cent. of the value of the article and not less than 5/-. Will the Minister tell us why our people should be required to pay 75 per cent. more than the prices they have been paying hitherto for clocks and other articles of that kind, and why, in certain cases, even that 75 per cent. is not enough? The minimum tariff of 2/- must be paid, and in certain other cases the minimum tariff of not less than 5/- must be paid. It seems an extraordinarily high tariff to impose, and it seems to be a tariff entirely for revenue purposes.

Comment on this

There has been a revenue tariff on clocks and component parts of clocks since before the Free State was established. There were the McKenna duties of 33? per cent. in operation before this State was established. So far as this State is concerned, what is being done now is that a higher rate of duty is imposed upon complete clocks and the duty is being taken off component parts for the purpose of encouraging people to assemble clocks here. In fact, one firm has already made arrangements to do that. The net result will be that clocks assembled here will be available without any duty instead of paying a duty of 33? per cent. The industry of assembling clocks which it is hoped to establish and the later assembling of watches is not unimportant. I do not say it will be a major industry, but it will give employment of a particularly useful type. The net effect of the changes will be a reduction in revenue in comparison with the position when an independent duty operated, that is in previous years before this State was established.

Comment on this

The Minister's argument is that the tariff is raised to this particular figure in order to protect an industry which is to develop here, but he can give us no information with regard to it.

Comment on this

The change is only taking place and one firm has already made arrangements to go into this business.

Comment on this

The position is that instead of paying 33? per cent. to come in as revenue, people are to pay a 75 per cent. tariff in future and there is to be no revenue.

Comment on this

No. The position in future is that the component parts of clocks will be imported free of duty and assembled here.

Comment on this

With a tariff of 75 per cent. to indicate the place line of these articles.

Comment on this

I do not think that will be the result.

Comment on this

The Minister, at any rate, cannot produce any argument to indicate that the cost of clocks is not going to be raised to the full margin of this tariff. It has already happened that the 2/- is being put on the smallest clock sold at present. So that where the Minister is charging these rates at present he cannot tell us in connection with this section that the difference does not operate as it operated in connection with No. 16, because I have come up against at least two cases in which persons purchasing small clocks have been told that there is an increased duty of 2/- on them.

Comment on this

We are at the transition period at present, and if people postpone buying clocks until they get Irish-assembled clocks they will get them a lot cheaper.

Comment on this

Get them at 75 per cent. more than the import price.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 59
·
Níl 34
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No 9:—

In sub-section (1) (a), lines 10 and 11, to delete the words "or 2/- on each article".

Sub-section (1) (a) provides that not only is here a 75 per cent. tax on the article, but that there shall be a tariff of not less than 2/- on each article. That 2/- is already operating. I would like to ask why that 2/- is operating or why it should be there at all if what the Minister for Industry and Commerce says is true: that clocks are being made here as cheaply as those imported?

Comment on this

The ad valorem duty would be of very little consequence on very cheap articles. It is, therefore, necessary to have a minimum duty as well as an ad valorem duty.

Comment on this

That means that only the persons who can buy the cheaper article will be hit.

Comment on this

People can buy them in the Free State.

Comment on this

Are these clocks being made here at the moment?

Comment on this

One manufacturer is making arrangements to assemble them and a number of other firms have indicated their intention of coming in.

Comment on this

None are made now?

Comment on this

Where does the Minister expect the firm to start?

Comment on this

In Dublin.

Comment on this

When does he expect them to start? Does he expect a start to be made by September?

Comment on this

I think so.

Comment on this

On the 1st or 30th of September?

Comment on this

In or about September.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

In sub-section (1) (c), line 23, to delete the words "or five shillings on each clock case."

Here the proposal is that there should be a tariff of 75 per cent. on the value of the article and not less than five shillings on clock cases made wholly or mainly of wood. I should like to ask what is the intention of the Minister in imposing such a heavy duty as five shillings on clock cases made of wood.

Comment on this

It is considered necessary to impose a substantial minimum duty to prevent the importation of these cases. The manufacture of clock cases would be an important part of the industry and it is estimated that minimum duty without an ad valorem duty would be very largely defeated.

Comment on this

Would it not be more decent to prohibit the import of these entirely.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy suggest it?

Comment on this

I think it would be more reasonable to prohibit the import of these things entirely than to start with a system that definitely raises the price of these articles by a very substantial sum.

Comment on this

There was a duty of 33? per cent. on clocks, and no duty, at all, on parts. The position will be that clocks will be assembled and clocks will be manufactured here at prices that will be no higher than the prices that prevailed heretofore and probably less.

Comment on this

Are the same people that are manufacturing clock cases also manufacturing clocks?

Comment on this

Does not this tax amount to prohibiting them altogether?

Comment on this

We might do that at any moment. We have had plans definitely from one firm for the establishment of the industry. But a number of other firms also interested are completing their plans to establish factories for this purpose. If there is any tendency of the nature that Deputy Mulcahy indicated it will be eliminated by competition.

Comment on this

Has the Minister in mind any firm that is competent to do the work? Does he intend when they are at work to still keep the 5/- duty on clock cases, or whether it would be better to keep them out? Has he any idea of the prices to be charged for the home made articles, and whether the firms are competent to do the work?

Comment on this

We are satisfied that they are competent to do the work. There will be no increase in prices. The scale of duties was devised in consultation with these firms and, in their opinion, is sufficient to justify them in taking on the work.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any idea of the amount of capital involved?

Comment on this

No. The market for clocks over here is worth about £30,000 a year, and the capital, I presume, would be a few thousand pounds per concern.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Minister is wise in pressing this. We may reach a point at which we may have more factories than the trade here would justify, a point which they seemed to have already reached in America. It is just as bad to have Irish money invested in factories which can never yield a return as never to have started them at all, because that will limit expansion in other directions. In this case is the Minister satisfied that the firms are competent to deal with the work? This is new work, I presume. It is work to which they have not been accustomed and I think it would have been better if a bounty had been given, or some assistance of that sort, in the first instance. In that case it would be possible to avoid the dissatisfaction that will be created by the sale of goods that are unsatisfactory. After all, it must not be very difficult to make a clock that will keep some sort of time, but to make a clock that will keep proper time and that will have a presentable appearance is a different proposition. In this case the wastage that will arise from the hasty establishment of industries and the fact that sufficient attention has not been paid to technique, will some time or other provoke public opinion against tariffs. That is one result that I fear because of the hasty measures taken by the Minister. There is also the danger that people will get into this business, make a "corner" in it and then get out of it. The fact that we had clock manufacturers in this country at one time is indisputable. We have also had hat manufacturers and others. In a matter of this kind, it is vital that the production of these factories should be of a sufficiently high standard to hold the market.

Comment on this

I am satisfied that the clocks will be excellent in every way.

Comment on this

That is what the Minister thinks.

Comment on this

If the Deputy would make inquiries from some of the people interested in the industry, he would discover that we have not been hasty in this matter.

Comment on this

Does the Minister hope to establish one of these factories in Galway, for example, or was that only for the election?

Comment on this

There was an election in Dublin, too.

Comment on this

There is an obvious mistake in this amendment. I do not propose to move it, Sir, but I shall move amendments, with the object which was intended to be achieved by this amendment, on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy could move it. It is not in his name.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is in the name of Deputy Dillon. Is the Deputy moving the amendment on behalf of Deputy Dillon?

Comment on this

I do not propose to move it, because there is an obvious error in the drafting of it, but I shall move a similar amendment on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

The intention of the amendment was to confine the duty to the lower priced teas, but I shall not go into that now. This is the section which imposes a duty of 4d. per lb. on tea. Members of the Party opposite seem to be somewhat confused about this whole question of the tea duty, even some of the Ministers. Recently we had the Minister for Local Government and Public Health announcing that when the Fianna Fáil Party assumed office they found a duty on tea. Notwithstanding the fact that that was denied at the time the Minister for Local Government and Public Health made that speech, we had it repeated afterwards by another member of the Party. The fact, of course, is that there was no duty on tea when the present Government assumed office. The Minister himself, on one occasion, described tea as a luxury. I do not know whether he still holds that view, or whether he is going to give that reason this year for imposing this duty. Of course, it is known to most people in this country, probably to everyone except the Minister himself, that tea is not a luxury and that as far as poor people are concerned it is an absolute necessity. Unfortunately, it forms part of nearly every meal which is partaken of by the poor people. For that reason it hits them in an exceptionally hard way.

There is another aspect of the matter to which I would draw the attention of the House. Up to about two years ago if a duty of 4d. or 6d. per lb. were imposed on tea, the very poor people, those on the point of destitution, could, in a way, get over that by purchasing cheaper tea. About two years ago, however, the tea planters came to an agreement restricting the output of the cheaper teas by about 25 per cent. Prior to their reaching that agreement it was possible for retailers to purchase tea at prices as low as 10d. or 1/- per lb. That tea was retailed at 1/2 or 1/4 Therefore, if a person had been buying tea at 1/6 per lb., and if a duty of 4d. were imposed on that, he could adjust his expenditure by falling back on the cheaper quality of tea. That is not the position to-day.

I do not know what the wholesale prices are at the moment, but up to quite recently I think that the wholesale price of the cheapest tea on the market was about 1/4 per lb. In other words, it is about 6d. per lb. dearer than it had been. It will, therefore, be seen that, so far as those who are compelled to purchase the very low quality of teas are concerned, they will have to meet the full burden of this 4d. per lb. A person, however, who was able to pay 3/- per lb. for tea can meet the situation by buying tea at 2/8, or a person who was in the habit of buying tea at 2/8 can now buy tea sold at 2/4, but the poor people who are compelled by circumstances to purchase only the poorest quality of tea will have to bear the full duty of 4d. per lb. That is a heavy imposition. In the case of these very poor people to whom I am referring, it will mean much more than 4d. per lb. because, unfortunately very many of these people have to buy tea in very small quantities. It is not uncommon for poor people living in slums and tenements to buy tea in such small quantities as a couple of ounces at a time. Because of that they pay proportionately more for tea than people who are able to buy a pound or a half-pound at a time. Taken by itself, this tax on tea is a very serious imposition, but when taken in conjunction with all the other increases in the necessaries of life imposed by this Finance Bill then, as I said on a former occasion, it amounts to a substantial reduction in the wages of workers.

We had Deputy Hugo Flinn, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, telling us on an earlier stage of the Bill that everyone in this country drank tea: that the drinking of tea was not confined to the poor. The Parliamentary Secretary overlooked the fact that persons in receipt of fairly decent wages or salary are able to enjoy a greater variety of food than the very poor. They do not use as much tea as the poor. It is because people are poor that they are compelled, so to speak, to drink so much tea. It is silly to suggest that an extra charge of 4d. in the lb. on tea will mean as much to a person in the position of the Parliamentary Secretary as it will to the unfortunate poor person trying to exist on home assistance or on unemployment assistance. Those who are in touch with poor people know that if they are able to have three meals a day, their principal diet at each consists of tea and bread. As people say in the country, the tea-pot is never off the hob. Therefore, they consume a great deal more tea than people more fortunately circumstanced, and this tax for that reason is going to press more heavily on them.

I hope Deputies in all parts of the House will make it clear to the Minister that they are opposed to this tax on tea. The country is opposed to it. It is an unpopular tax, and if the Minister does not already know that, he ought to know it. As I cannot move the amendment on this stage, I propose doing so on Report.

Comment on this

We all know that the Minister for Finance has a very strong objection to tea drinking. He informed us in one of his Budget speeches that a tax on tea did not matter: that tea was not a necessity at all, and that it was a thing that people could do without. Tea, he said, was simply a beverage. The Minister endeavoured in that somewhat heavy jocose style of his to brush aside the whole question of the heavy impost which a tax on tea means to the poorest members of the community. Those of us who live in the country and know the habits of life of the people are well aware that a great number of people rely on tea as a great stimulant to keep them going. We all know that ordinary working girls, especially in the cities, take tea a great number of times each day. Tea and bread are really the main sources from which they derive support for their bodies, and the cost of tea and bread is being increased. The Minister is quite regardless of all that. He seems to think that a tax on tea, combined with the other taxes in the Budget all of which must of necessity hit the very poorest classes in the community, is one that can be lightly imposed. That is the attitude he seems to take up in respect of all these food taxes. Anyone who knows the conditions in rural Ireland, especially of the small farmers of the West—the conditions to which they have been reduced by the economic policy which the Government have put in force—is well aware of the privations they are suffering at the moment, and must be satisfied that these taxes on the necessaries of life are a cruel and an unjust imposition. After all, what is a just tax and what is an unjust tax? A just tax is a tax which places a burden upon backs that are able to bear it, as far as that object can possibly be achieved. An unjust tax is a tax which places a burden upon backs which are too weak to bear that burden. The Minister and his colleagues, by these food taxes, are placing a terrible burden on backs already weakened by the policy which the Government have adopted. The Government have taken away their means of livelihood, their sole source of income, from a very large number of persons in this country—from the small farmers and agricultural labourers and from the working class people in the towns. The case for the latter has already been put forward in the House. My object is to stress the burden which these food taxes will place on people whose condition I am familiar with, people living in my own constituency. A great number of them are finding it impossible to make ends meet at the present time.

Comment on this

They are paying their rates and their annuities.

Comment on this

They are, with money which comes to them from England. Here is an argument which I hope the Minister will take to heart because I submit it is a direct answer to his interjection. It is this: that the people who are paying their rates and their annuities, who are stinting themselves in order that they may do so, are the people upon whom the Minister's taxes are going to press with extra weight. People who could afford to pay their rates and their annuities, and who are not doing so, can laugh at the Minister's taxes. They have got the money in their pockets and can afford to pay the extra taxes imposed by the Minister upon the necessaries of life, but the people who stint themselves in order that they may be able to pay their rates and their annuities, are the people upon whom the Minister's extra imposts press with a double weight. The Minister should recognise that fact. He should consider the position of the people who have lost their sole means of getting ready money for what they have to sell, whose market for the sale of their livestock has been taken away, and whose market for eggs has been reduced to such an extent that it is now of very little value to them. They have been compelled to reduce the number of hens which they usually kept, a very important thing for the small holders in my constituency. I move to report progress.

Comment on this