Public Business. - Finance Bill, 1935—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 122–250 of 250. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 15 of 1935 ›
Such an interjection on the Minister's part only serves to illustrate the condition in which he finds himself. It is quite possible that this tax may have the opposite effect. It is possible its imposition may have this effect, that we may reach saturation point in this matter. While we may regard tobacco as important from a soothing point of view, it is, nevertheless, the type of thing that people can go without, and the Minister may find that his revenue will not increase as a result of this tax. As Deputy Anthony pointed out, and as we have endeavoured to point out, this is one more indication of the tragic position in which we find ourselves. It is a very sad state of affairs to find that the Government must tax all foodstuffs and must even tax tobacco in order to accumulate revenue. I am very sorry indeed that a Government of this country should have sunk to such a depth.
Comment on this
Listening to what Deputy Anthony said, I recalled a statement made by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance during the Budget discussions which were the prelude to the present Bill, and I was wondering if Deputy Anthony had not really put his finger on the purpose of the tax. Is this tax really brought in for the purpose stated by the Parliamentary Secretary during the Budget discussions? He said that what he liked about the Budget was that it brought everybody up against the facts. In answer to Deputy Anthony, who protested against taxes on working men, the Parliamentary Secretary said: "Why should not the working man be taxed?" He said also that the Budget brought everybody, including the working man, up against the facts. Perhaps Deputy Anthony has really discovered the true purpose of this tobacco tax—that it is not for the purpose of revenue or even taxing the luxuries or the necessities of the working man, the poor man, but it is really for the purpose of bringing home to everybody the facts of the present situation.
Comment on this
If there was any substance in that supposition, then somebody should be looking for relief, but no one is being promised relief.
Comment on this
Question put:—"That Section 20 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I want to give notice that on Report Stage, I will move an amendment to delete para graphs (b) and (c) of sub-section (5), and I will move a further amendment to delete sub-section (15).
Comment on this
Will the Minister say what is the importance of these sub-sections on which he proceeds to break silence, the Minister having been so silent on important matters during the debate?
Comment on this
I am merely giving notice that this will be done. I will explain to the House fully on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
As the Minister has again broken silence on this important section, will he tell us why this tax which we oppose is being imposed? Having ransacked every corner of the home to see on what he can put taxes, and in the case of the rural homes having sent in the tax gatherer himself to collect the revenue on butter, he now puts a tax gatherer very prominently outside every single house of entertainment to which people may be tempted to go to try to get away from the smell of the tax gatherer around the house. The only chance these people have of forgetting the shape of the tax gatherer's fist is to get away from the linoleum in the home, from the wallpaper in the home, from the window glass in the home, and from everything else in the place——
Comment on this
——and when they do mean to make an attempt to get away from these things—and these things can have a very upsetting effect on the nerves of the ordinary housekeeper—they are to be followed to the house of entertainment. The housekeeper has sufficient troubles to meet at home without seeing that kind of new broad arrow stamped all over the place. But when the householders do go to a house of entertainment the same old fist and the same old head is stuck out there to remind them not that social services are being built up or that the Free State is being built up but that there is a war leading them into further miseries, further wrecking of hope and further unemployment. Is the Minister going to take these taxes off by the amendment which he hopes to bring in on Report Stage, so that there will be somewhere without the broad arrow of the new Christian State to which the people would be able to go for an hour or two?
Comment on this
Would I be in order in moving that progress be reported with a view to asking that the President would come here and tell the House what the attitude of the Government is to the House?
Comment on this
There is no authority in the Chair to force the Minister to reply, if he does not wish to.
Comment on this
Are we to understand that the subsequent sections are to be discussed without the Minister intervening in any way to face up to the criticism of the House?
Comment on this
This Bill was fully discussed in all its aspects on the Second Stage for four days. It is not necessary now to say anything on a Bill that has been discussed so exhaustively by the House.
Comment on this
Is it the policy of the Minister to cut out the Committee Stage and to mark out against each section of the Bill, "majority of one,""majority of two," or "majority of three." Are we coming to that?
Comment on this
Question put: "That Section 24 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
On behalf of Deputy Mulcahy I beg to move amendment No. 12:
Before Section 25 to insert a new section as follows:—
The duty of five shillings per ton imposed on coal, culm, shale, slack and coke and also solid fuel which in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners is composed wholly or mainly of coal or coal dust under the Emergency (Imposition of Duties) (No. 5) Order, 1932, and confirmed by the Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Orders) Act, 1933 (No. 21 of 1933) shall cease to be charged, levied or paid as on and from the passing of this Act.
We have had examples already of what I may call the topsy-turvy policy of the Government in certain matters. But anything more irrational than their conduct in connection with this tax on coal it is difficult to imagine. We are asking for the removal of this particular tax on coal. Everybody will remember the excuse that was put forward at the time of the imposition of this tax. Even at that time it was a mad idea to strike the Government to adopt this tax, at least if it was their purpose to use it as an economic weapon in the economic war. Anything more foolish or ill-conceived than that particular tax on coal it would be difficult to imagine. It was, as the House will remember, a tax imposed on British coal which was meant to hit back against the British in the economic war. It was pointed out at the time that it could have no such effect. The only result of such action on the part of the Government would be that our cattle would be heavily taxed going into England, and we would pay that tax owing to the fact that we were only supplying a portion of the English market and that most, or practically all, of our cattle had to go into that market. It was pointed out, in these circumstances, and would be plain to anybody except the Executive Council, that the people of this country would have to pay that tariff—every penny of it. That is what happened. Of course, it was denied at the time; now it is acknowledged by everybody.
Then a brilliant idea struck the Government. They said: "What about taxing English coal?" With that simplicity of mind that characterises them on certain occasions, they assumed that because a tax was put on cattle by the British Government and paid by Irish farmers, if a tax was put on British coal by us it would have to be paid by English producers and not by Irish consumers. Again it was quite clear to anybody who gave the conditions of the country a moment's consideration that what would happen would be this: There might be interference with the amount of coal that came into this country, but the tax would be paid not by the British producer but by the Irish consumer. That, of course, was what happened. The only excuse offered for the putting on of this tax—we heard no other justification for it and I wonder will we hear one from the silent Minister to-night—was that it was a weapon in the Irish war. It was a weapon with the unfortunate characteristic of the boomerang when used by unskilled hands. It had the effect merely of increasing the cost of British coal to the Free State, yet it was hailed at the time as the first of the great big strokes that were to be delivered against the British Government to bring them to a sense of the seriousness of entering into an economic war with this country. Anything more foolishly conceived than such a plan it would be difficult to imagine. But foolish as was that plan, the whole thing became nonsensical when the embargo on British coal was declared off and not merely was the divorce between ourselves and the British declared off, but there was to be close union between the two countries, and, in the future, not merely were we to be allowed to take British coal but were to be compelled to do it and, incidentally, to pay an extra 5/- per ton by way of tax.
That 5/- per ton we could escape at first by taking Continental coal instead of British. Now, as a result of the friendly relations established in the war which still continues, we are compelled to take British coal, and that economic weapon which was one of the methods of attacking the British now stands forth clearly, for what it really is, merely a dodge to raise revenue by a tax which is pressing upon everybody. It presses upon people who buy one or two tons of coal, but it presses still more upon people who only buy a bag of coal at a time. That tax is left, and not merely is it left, but now it is imposed on everybody as he has to buy English coal. What was to be a great counter offensive, in the economic war, has now become a weapon for drawing the last penny out of the pockets of the people of this country.
I do not know whether it is £600,000 or not—I forget the actual figure—that the Minister expects to get from this particular tax, but the House will notice that whatever excuse was ever put forward for this particular tax has vanished—I was going to say has more than vanished. However, if it was possible for the Ministry to do anything absurd they would, of course, do it. Not merely has the excuse vanished for this tax, but now we are compelled, whether we like it or not, to buy coal that we were warned not to buy at the time when the tax was first imposed, and we are compelled to do that in the new atmosphere of friendship between the two Governments who are at war.
The war goes gaily on; the fight still goes on, but the burden remains to the people of this country. The people find that the knife they were using against the other side has an unhappy knack of closing and cutting off their fingers. There has been reference to taxes put on in war conditions. Here was an actual war tax meant to hit others and not to tax the people of this country. It was never meant as a tax at all and in fact we were told, when this tax was put on, by many Government spokesmen that it was not the people of this country who would pay this tax but the producer in Great Britain. Unfortunately, even when we had the Continental coal market open to us, that particular statement was not true. How much less is it true now when the Continental coal market is closed to the people of this country and when the people are compelled, by the recent pact, to take British coal and to take only British coal? What is the justification? A war tax, a war measure meant to hit the enemy, kept on in the dire straits of the Government so that they can scrape every penny from the unfortunate taxpayer to meet bloated expenses, because it is absurd to say that this tax cannot be got rid of, as the Minister used to say when he made even the pretence of putting forward a case in this House in favour of the policy he is meant to sponsor.
What is the excuse now? None whatsoever. Expenses are mounting up year after year and mounting up by the million. It is inevitable, if the Government goes in for the policy of gross extravagance, on the one hand, because that is what they are doing, that they have to grind the last 1d. out of the unfortunate taxpayer, on the other hand, and they have to utilise discreditable methods of this kind and turn what is meant, as I say, to be a great war weapon into a weapon against our own people. For that reason, I ask the House to support the amendment.
Comment on this
This is a part of the Government's policy which I find very hard to understand. I find it very hard to understand the mentality that conceived it. Prior to the Coal-Cattle Pact, one would be looked upon as unpatriotic if one supported British coal, and, in some quarters, one would be called a traitor for doing so. Public bodies in various parts of the country were almost compelled by the Local Government Department to use Continental coal. This Continental coal could only be brought in in large complements by large steamers, and these steamers were unable to enter the smaller ports, with the result that during the 12 months prior to the Coal-Cattle Pact, a great number of harbour authorities suffered very seriously. Now, since the Coal-Cattle Pact, we are asked to be unpatriotic and, in being unpatriotic, to pay 5/- of a fee. I cannot for the life of me understand why this tariff is put on English coal. We are compelled to take it; we have no option. It is hitting the poor very hard and I am sure it costs the ordinary working man's household at least 6d. per week and that, along with the other taxes imposed by the Government in this Budget, is something which I am not going to support. I think that even now the Minister should see his way to remove the tax altogether. It is an unjustifiable tax. It is certainly not understandable and, to say the least of it, it is absolutely Gilbertian.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish is, I think, putting it at a very low figure indeed, when he puts the increase at a minimum of 6d. per week in the average household. If Deputy Corish was thinking solely of the 5/- tax, he would probably be in or about right, but the Deputy must remember that it means more than that. This tax becomes particularly harsh because the giving to Great Britain of a monopoly of the coal supplies of this country means not only 5/- per ton tax, but 5/- per ton increase on the coal in addition to the tax, so that the consumer of coal in this country to-day is paying, between the tax and the increase in the price of British coal, that is, the difference in the price over and above the price at which good Continental coal could have been purchased prior to 1st February, at least 10/- per ton. I think Deputy Corish or anybody else in the House will agree that that means a minimum of 1/- per week extra in respect of coal alone in the average household in this country.
Taking three items alone in the Finance Bill—tea, sugar and coal— there is the huge sum of £2,000,000 in taxation imposed on the people. The Minister will get roughly £700,000 from this coal tax. Under the first quota order, the amount of coal to be imported from Britain was roughly 1,100,000 tons. That quota order was due to expire this month. A new quota order has been made for the remainder of this year and, under it, 1,705,000 tons of coal are to be imported, of which 1,704,000 tons must be imported from Britain. It will, therefore, be seen that the quota allows, over a space of about 11 months, an importation of roughly 2,800,000 tons of British coal at 5/- per ton. The people of this country are, however, compelled to pay more than £700,000. I want to submit here that it would be nearer £1,400,000.
Comment on this
The Minister can rebut my figures, if he is in a position to do so, when he is replying. I am putting forward this point and I challenge the Minister to contradict it, that, quality for quality, British coal to-day, including this 5/- tax, is 10/- per ton dearer than it was prior to the coal-cattle pact.
When one has regard to the attitude of the Government on this Finance Bill, one is driven to the conclusion that the coal-cattle pact was negotiated not so much for the sake of getting rid of 150,000 head of cattle, as to enable the Government to collect £700,000 by way of the coal tax. I think that is what is emerging now. The coal-cattle pact surprised everybody in this country. Nobody could understand for a moment how the Government could have concluded such a silly bargain. We can only come to the conclusion that it was arranged and that this monopoly was given to Britain in order to enable the Government to collect, as I say, roughly £700,000 in taxation from the people of this country. We must remember that this is not the only saving the Government has made in this matter. I do not remember the details but when the Government decided to impose a duty on British coal, I seem to remember that there was a question of a half-crown a ton of a bounty or a subsidy or whatever it was called for small boats supposed to be affected. That, I am sure, amounted to a fairly tidy sum which had to be paid by the Government. When the coal-cattle pact was concluded, that subsidy was withdrawn, from the smaller boats. It was supposed to be no longer necessary to pay it and, therefore, there was that saving also. I should like the Minister, if he is going to reply on this, to give us some idea of the sum involved in that subsidy to the smaller boats.
It was first blurted out in the House here that the tax was being retained for the purpose of collecting revenue. Then, as a sort of afterthought, in order I suppose to try to recover a little of the patriotic touch, it was said: "People can burn home fuel; if they burn turf they may not pay the tax on coal." I daresay if they decided to do so, they would very soon find that there was a tax on turf also. The fact remains that there are many reasons why people do not burn turf exclusively. Some people cannot burn turf at all because they have not the means to do so and for many other reasons. One reason that it is not as economic as coal. I think it is admitted by everybody, who knows anything about the matter, that it takes three tons of turf to give the same results as one ton of coal. There is also the question of the inconvenience of storing it in certain private houses because of the bulk of it. If the Minister would take the price of three tons of turf against one ton of coal, even at the increased price, he will find that there is a substantial difference. Here is a tax which was originally imposed for the purpose of keeping British coal out of the country as far as possible. That tax is now being retained although Britain has been given a monopoly of the coal supplies of the country. The people are denied an opportunity of getting coal from the Continent or any other country in the world because of the coal-cattle pact. A fact which I want Deputies to realise is that the people of this country are being compelled to pay not only the 5/- tax for revenue purposes but another 5/- over and above what they were paying formerly, an increase of 10/- per ton in all. That is what the people of this country get on the coal side and we know what they are getting on the cattle side of the pact.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish told the House that he cannot understand why the Government have imposed this tax. I think it is rather unkind for Deputy Corish or any member of the Labour Party to criticise the Government for this, because the Government have had the support of the Labour Party for the last three years in wasting the resources of this country, and they must find money from somewhere. Deputy Morrissey has mentioned the fact that in addition to a tax of 5/-, there is an increase in price which the British coal exporters imposed on coal since the coal-cattle pact was entered into. There is another aspect of the matter that strikes me very forcibly as representing a constituency with perhaps more poor people than any other constituency in this country. What is the increase in the price of coal for the poor people of the city of Dublin who buy it in small quantities of a stone at a time? When you come to distribute the increased price of 10/- per ton, over the price of stones of coal, the increase to these people probably works out at £1 per ton.
Deputy Kelly who represents a constituency that I think is almost equally as poor as mine, namely, the South City, told us this evening that he would be confined to barracks if he were to speak on the question of the tea tax. I wonder would Deputy Kelly be confined to barracks by his Party or by his Whips if he were to speak on the coal tax and the effect it has on the poor people of the City of Dublin. This tax is an extraordinary instance of the peculiar orientation of this Government since they came into office. When they first put a tax on British coal as a sort of so-called war measure, they were following the advice which Swift gave this country nearly two centuries ago when he said that we should burn everything English except her coal. The Minister started off with that policy a couple of years ago but now the policy of the Government is that we must not be permitted to burn any coal except British. That is in return for this extraordinary so-called concession, this bargain by which we are entitled to send 150,000 head of cattle more in the year to Great Britain with the duty that we pay the British Treasury on every one of these cattle. This coal-cattle pact is the most astonishing bargain that was ever made by any Government in any country. Such is the condition of desperation to which the country has been reduced by the policy of the Government that even that wretched bargain was accepted by the people. It was accepted by them on the grounds that even a very bad bargain is better than no bargain, having regard to the condition to which the country has been reduced.
Comment on this
I think this tax is on a par with the tax on tea. It is a grinding imposition on the poorest people in this country. I hope that Deputy Kelly will refuse to be confined to barracks and will express his views about it as affecting his constituency.
Comment on this
This is a matter in which the Government has taken a step that they will regret. They have given away the greatest power that any Government could possess, namely the sale of coal in this country. It may look to some of us a very small matter when we see the bellman going around, but it is the one control that Britain has over us here, the selling of that lump of coal. We may produce gold in Wicklow, or coal in some other place, but we certainly cannot produce coal at a price as economical as England can produce it and sell it here. The country was told twice, in 1932 and 1933, that we would fight Britain and beat Britain in this economic war. The greatest weapon we had in that war was the purchase of coal by the Irish people. That weapon—"weapon," perhaps, is the best word to use—in the economic war has been handed over and surrendered. It has been surrendered by a Government who come to the Irish people to-day and say: "we are fighting for the Irish people against England." They began the fight by handing over the best weapon that could possibly be used in a fight, economic or otherwise.
I think that the people of this country have not realised the repercussions of this Coal-Cattle Pact and of this tax with which we are now dealing. They are led, improperly or otherwise, and they follow that lead. In a speech which I saw reported in the papers recently it was stated that the Irish people always stood by their leaders. The President of the Executive Council speaking, I think, in Limerick, said that the fight in the Land War was greater than in the Black and Tan War and that the Irish people backed their leaders on that occasion. In connection with the Land War we have such names as Parnell, Davitt and O'Brien. I wonder do the Irish people realise to-day that they are called upon to fight behind a Party under the leadership——
Comment on this
It strikes me that the Deputy is talking about the Land War and the Black and Tan War.
Comment on this
Having regard to that I wonder do the Irish people realise that they are called upon to follow leaders——
Comment on this
I am talking about quasi-leaders, people who pretend to be leaders. Do the Irish people realise that their leaders of to-day have surrendered?
Comment on this
Let us be clear. We are not discussing leaders or what they have done. What we have to discuss are the merits of this 5/- tax on imported coal.
Comment on this
We are told that we are fighting a war with Great Britain. Surely we may discuss the question of handing over the greatest weapon we have, whether it is a gun or a piece of paper or a secret pact. Surely, I am in order in discussing that?
Comment on this
The Government which presumes to give leadership to the people and which calls upon the people to support it, as the people of Ireland supported their leaders in the Land War and Black and Tan times, tell us that we are in a similar fight to-day. Surely I am in order in saying that the leaders of that Party have given over the greatest weapon they had—the purchase of coal by Ireland from England. They did it before the war began. Then they come back and they appeal to the patriotism, the courage and the decency of the Irish people, saying "back us now: we are fighting England." They do that, having handed over the guns. I think the Greeks did that in the Great War, and I remember that something similar happened in Cork in 1916, but I do not think that anything equal to this happened in Irish history before—before the fight begins to hand over the only good weapon we have. What do we hand over? Is it a gentleman's agreement? No. Is it a bit of paper, secret or otherwise, or signed by anybody? Not at all. The poorest people of the country must pay for this. There is no outcry. There is no cry of traitor.
Comment on this
I am discussing the 5/- tax. I do not see why the Minister should want to run away from it. Surely it is a thing of which he is proud. Here we have an Irish Government crying out to the people "stand behind us now. Remember we won the land war, we beat the Black and Tans, and we are fighting the British now." That is the Government that get up and surrender at first opportunity the best weapon they had.
Comment on this
They put a tax on British coal and said they would allow no other coal to be taken in.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would explain why coal has increased in price by from 5/- to 10/-. There was a market here open to English, German and Polish coal. At that time, there was a 5/- tax on British coal only. In case the competition amongst these countries for the Irish market would continue, the Minister comes along and says: "We will restrict the amount of coal imported." I know that I may be reminded that I am discussing the quota. I am. Why is it that out of 1,705,000 tons of coal only 1,000 tons may be imported from outside Britain? That is the open market. And this is a country which had the coal supplies of the world at its service. I do not think that the House should support this tax of 5/-.
Comment on this
I am just wondering if the Minister has yet discovered how ridiculous he has made not alone himself and his immediate supporters in the Government appear but how ridiculous he has made most of his supporters in the country appear by this tax. Deputy Corish referred a moment ago to the action of a number of Government supporters in the country who were successful in having resolutions passed at public boards precluding these boards from using British coal. That was the case with one board in Cork. Supplies of coal were to originate outside Great Britain. We could not purchase British coal and we were compelled to use coal from Westphalia, Silesia and other foreign centres. I remember at one time working in a little bit of badinage which had a useful effect, with the efforts of other persons, who thought on the same lines as I did, in bringing the Government to realise that their policy was ridiculous. And it is still ridiculous in this respect. I stated publicly on that occasion that I would run all the risks of which Deputy Corish spoke about a moment ago. I was prepared to run the risk of being called an Imperialist, a traitor and everything anti-Irish because I said in public I would continue to use British coal. Now, I find that I must have been a patriot then because I am now compelled to buy British coal. I pointed out on that occasion that we had a lot of our kith and kin working in Westphalia where the Murphys and the McCarthys come from. I am sure the Minister had that in mind, that we had working in the mines of Westphalia people with such Irish names as I have mentioned.
Comment on this
I regard this as a further impost on the ordinary family budget. I do not want to overemphasise the statements already made, but perhaps the Minister will in his rather peculiar career come to realise that he is not dealing with a nation of school-children; that the majority of our people are a thinking people though, by the way, they did not prove that at the last election.
Comment on this
I hope that a little commonsense will dawn on the Minister because I am certain that the public are not such fools as the Minister must think them to be. His supporters told us at one time to boycott British coal, but now we are being compelled to buy British coal, whether we like it or not, at a prohibitive price to the community. Is the Minister prepared to give us some indication, beyond that given to the public by the Government Press Bureau, as to what are the other conditions surrounding this Coal-Cattle Pact?
Comment on this
The effect of it at any rate is that the ordinary consumers are being called upon to pay at least 10/- per ton more for their coal. It is the duty of the Minister, I think, to give some explanation of the figures quoted by Deputy Morrissey and others, and to let the country know where exactly we stand. It is all very fine for the Minister to say that it is a good bargain, but he has been reminded by some Deputies that it is a very bad bargain, and that, in the final analysis, it is the consumer who will have to pay. There would be no use in again enumerating all the necessaries of life that have been taxed by the present Government. Our people are certainly a patient people to put up with the Government and the Minister so long. If the Minister set out to do some very unpopular thing, he has gone the right way about it. There is such a thing as doing an unpopular thing when there is a public duty to be performed, but this is not to be taken in that light. There are certain unpopular things which the Minister might attempt to do, but which I am precluded from referring to on this amendment. But certainly the Minister has set out to make the lot of the poor harder, and to make the rich richer. I hope that even at this stage the Minister will show a little commonsense instead of making himself and those associated with him ridiculous.
Comment on this
I think there must be other Deputies besides Deputy Kelly on the Government side of the House who are confined to barracks.
Comment on this
There is a peculiar reluctance amongst Deputies on the Government side of the House to get up and speak in favour of this tax. One Deputy did evade the guards and addressed the House in defence of the Government's proposal, but he was, apparently, effectively silenced. No other Government Deputy has since dared to repeat the process except the Minister by way of interruptions.
Comment on this
Apparently there is no defence possible for the Government's proposals in this Finance Bill. We were treated to the spectacle of an hour's debate on the question of an additional 2/- tax on the bag of flour. We had a discussion in connection with the additional tax of 6d. on the bag of coal. Previously we had discussions on a tax on the bag of sugar and on the bag of tea. A Deputy reminds me that our next discussion will be on a tax on a bag of cement. Well, we have not yet been driven to the stage of eating cement though I think we are coming near it. One Deputy said that this was a 5/- tax on coal, and another said it was a tax of 10/-. I do not know what the amount of the tax will be eventually when the coal reaches the poor consumer through the bellman. When the tax of 5/- a ton comes to be paid by the poor person who purchases a stone or two of coal at a time, I do not know what the actual increase will be. When that 5/- comes to be expressed in vulgar fractions over so many stone of coal, I am afraid it will amount to a considerable sum and particularly after the profiteer has added his little fraction. If I were to refer to the Coal-Cattle Pact, I know that I would be ruled out of order by the Chair. All that I will say on that is that when we export cattle to England Paddy pays the tax on them, and when we import coal from England Patrick pays the tax. Paddy or Patrick has to bear the burden in either case. Yet, there is no Deputy on the Government Benches venturesome enough to get up and attempt to defend this coal tax.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear that Deputy Jordan is preparing for the defence. Apparently, the Deputy believes in the principle that to be prepared for attack is sometimes the best method of defence. I am anxiously waiting to see what Deputy Jordan's line of attack will be for defending the poor against this tax. If he does not get nearer to making an adequate defence for it than Deputy Corry did——
Comment on this
The amendment, Sir. I have been talking on this burning, or non-burning, question, if you like, for ten minutes. I have been trying to confine myself to the tax on coal. I am quite satisfied that the coal will cost a good deal more than the 5/- a ton by the time it reaches the stores. I am waiting for the Minister to prove that the tax will only amount to 5/- a ton. I hope, when the Minister makes another bargain, that we will not have to pay on all sides, and that some distinction will be made in the terms of the bargain. We protest in the strongest terms against the imposition of a bag tax on coal, a bag tax on flour, a bag tax on sugar, and a bag tax on every other necessity of the poor. It is really the very poor will suffer from these taxes. I suppose it is no harm to be humorous occasionally, but this is not a question of humour. There will be many fireless grates because of this imposition on coal. If the Minister could defend this tax, possibly he would do so in the way he defended the other taxes, by saying that if people do not want to use coal they need not be taxed; that if they do not want to use flour they need not be taxed; and that if they do not want to use sugar they need not be taxed. That was his solitary line of defence of these impositions on the food of the people. The people were told that they need not buy any of these things, that they could fall back on some other foods. Perhaps if they use raw beet, or raw wheat or even potatoes they would be exempt. There is very little left for them to use if they are going to defy the taxation that the Minister says they need not pay. If we do not wear boots, I suppose we need not bear the taxes, because we can go in our bare feet. The only way of evading the Minister's tax gatherers is by not wearing boots, clothes or other necessaries. So far we have not tempted Deputies on the Government Benches to defend these taxes. They dare not do so. Deputy Corry ventured to speak for a few minutes, but the gag was put on and the rest of the Party was confined to barracks. They are still there. None of them has the courage to get up to defend a tax of 2/- on a sack of flour and a tax on coal. I suppose to-morrow or after we will be told that we are traitors because we are defending the poor against these taxes. I have not been interrupted while speaking. Usually there is a volley of interruptions from the opposite benches. For once, there is silence.
Comment on this
I welcome this amendment because it will clear away the misunderstanding that was abroad in connection with this Party voting some time ago in favour of the Coal-Cattle Pact. It was represented by those who desired to misrepresented the United Ireland Party that this Party voted in favour of the 5/- tax on imports of British coal, when, as a matter of fact, we voted for the Coal-Cattle Pact so that farmers might be able to get rid of their cattle. By this amendment, we are using all the pressure we can to keep the Minister from exploiting that pact against the interests of the community. The question has been ably dealt with by Deputy Corish, Deputy Morrissey and other Deputies in which they referred to the iniquity of the tax. Some time ago it was patriotic for public bodies to burn nothing but turf, and it was patriotic of members of these bodies to have the odour of turf on their clothes when they travelled in the trams or in the trains. It was considered patriotic to do that, in order to show that we were doing everything possible to keep up our end in the economic war. Now, we see that that was all flapdoodle and nonsense, that it was all sham. Tonight's proceedings prove that it was never meant. All this country has got to do now is to let the Die-hards in the Carlton Club in London see that our financial position is so bad that we can do nothing but order all the coal this country requires from Great Britain and pay an extra fine of 5/- on every ton. Surely, that must be looked upon by other countries as a form of imbecility. That attitude cannot be understood except in the peculiar atmosphere of this House. I wonder what the Germans, the French, the Belgians, or other Continental peoples, from whom we could get coal, think of us, seeing that Great Britain has got everything from this bargain, and that we have to pay an extra 5/- per ton for coal, while, at the same time we are supposed to be fighting for our economic existence. The Minister may have reasons for increasing the imports of coal from Great Britain, but no camouflage or smoke-screen can hide the fact that this tax is to get money to carry on the affairs of the country.
Comment on this
I cannot understand why the Minister and the Government will not accept this amendment. I cannot understand the eloquent silence of my friend, Deputy T. Kelly, who has spent his life in the service of the poor. The very poor are vitally concerned about the price of coal. The only apologia I heard from the Government Benches was from Deputy Moore last week on another phase of the Budget, when he issued a solemn note of warning that there was profiteering in coal, that bellmen were extorting fancy prices for this coal. That shows the mentality behind the support for this tax on coal. If a man buys a ton of coal at £1, he goes out and trades it among the community. In order to make a living profit out of it he has to put on the price on the basis of £1 outlay. If he has to pay 25/-, he must make his profit on the basis of 25/- outlay. If a man is going to buy coal at £1 and sell it at, say, 5/- a ton profit, is he going to pay 25/- a ton and still sell it at 5/- profit? Of course not. He must have his profit on his initial outlay. I am sorry Deputy Moore is not here. I hope that some Deputy of his Party will take up the running for him in his absence. Do not blame others for your own iniquities. The Coal-Cattle Pact has been mentioned. Personally, I am proud of having voted against it.
Comment on this
Well, at any rate, I will stop the Minister from bragging. If the Minister has to put 5/- a ton on the coal used by the poor of this City and County of Dublin, why does he not use that £50,000 that he promised the citizens of County Dublin, and told them that he had rusting, for a water supply at Finglas? Why does he want to put on this tax when he says that he has this money rusting there?
Comment on this
Except for the mis-statement that I ever made the statement that there was £50,000 available for any water scheme anywhere.
Comment on this
Very well, I accept the Minister's contradiction and I hope the Pressmen put it in leaded type on the front page to-morrow, and nobody will be more pleased than I and nobody will be more displeased than the Minister's friends in County Dublin. I am grateful to the Minister for his remark.
Comment on this
First of all, the Deputy made a mis-statement and then he proceeded to contradict it. It is not the unusual with the Deputy.
Comment on this
I accept the Minister's correction. What more can I do? I am proud that it was corrected.
Comment on this
I cannot see what case can be made for this tax except want of money, and we all do queer things when we are hard up.
Comment on this
We do, and the Minister has had a queer job now, and the silence on his benches bears eloquent testimony to the queer things the Minister has to do. Deputy Kelly— honest Tom Kelly—nods assent to that. It has been stated here that the price of coal has gone up 10/- or 12/-. That is true. What is, perhaps, more significant and more important is that the coal we are getting now is much inferior to what we would get if we had freedom to buy in an open market. However, perhaps that is travelling away a little bit from the 5/- tax. This 5/- tax, however, was imposed and defended in the first instance as a hit back at the British. Now that we have made peace on the coal front with the British, there is no longer any high explosive on that front. Why, therefore, is not this big gun of a 5/- tax, that was used when the fight was fiercest on that front, silenced? Now the Minister and his colleagues have to admit the truth: that it is a naked tax for revenue, and all the arguments used heretofore, to the effect that the tariff on coal was a weapon of retaliation against the British cattle tax, have broken down. The bottom has fallen out of that argument. I should be delighted to give way to the Minister in order to hear him prove that we are taxing British coal by this. Instead of that, we are making the public pay for it. I am not going to make a special appeal and say that it only affects the poorest of the poor. I do not take any special credit for defending the poor. I think there is more hypocritical talk about the defence of the poor than anything else and I think there is no sincerity in most of it, but it is an economic trading fact that 5/- is put on, and I should like some attempt made to defend the imposition of that 5/-. It cannot keep out an article that you have agreed to let in to the exclusion of that article from any other source than Great Britain.
This is purely a naked tax for revenue. As I said in connection with the wheat tax, it is a fearful admission of the straits to which this country has been brought when we have to tax this coal that we have to buy for our own use. We do not produce it. In other aspects of the Budget debate it was mentioned here—I think by the Minister for Industry and Commerce —that there was a rebate or remission of the duty where coal is used for power purposes, but we could not find from the Minister where a remission was given. I asked him specifically whether a remission was given to the Electricity Supply Board for the production of electricity in the Pigeon House, and I was told no. Now, if there is, theoretically or in practice, a remission given anywhere, I should be curious to know, and I am sure more than I would be curious to know, where a remission of this 5/- is given in cases where coal is used for power or in industry.
Comment on this
Who got it? That was allowed in without tax, and there was no remission of the tax on coal used in the Pigeon House to produce some millions of units of electricity, and which used up at a time when we were short of water in North City and had to cut off the water—Deputy Kelly, I hope, will not be deaf to this—600,000 gallons of water that was required for human consumption. The City of Dublin had to stand that racket, but the Exchequer could not stand the racket of a remission of 5/- per ton on the coal used in the Pigeon House. I am not surprised that Deputy Kelly yawns when he hears that.
Comment on this
It is the information I am giving you that you are yawning at. If we are taxing—as the Minister interjected—British coal, and if we are going to let it in here to the exclusion of other coal, has the Minister considered that on the 150,000 extra cattle we are making England a present of anything up to £900,000. After all that we have suffered in the last three years this is the type of bargain that is made.
Comment on this
There is nothing in the Finance Bill that I know of which refers to the type of bargain made.
Comment on this
If I am grossly out of order in the opinion of the silent leader of the Labour Party, and of the eloquently silent Deputy for South City, one of my colleagues representing the Corporation, I will not say any more for fear I might confuse the issue.
Comment on this
Where were you when the Conditions of Employment Bill was being discussed? You let down all the workers you represent in North Dublin by being absent.
Comment on this
The amendment put up by the Deputy were amendments that he had to put up against his colleagues over there.
Comment on this
You made as bad a bargain with the Government as the Government made with the British over the Coal-Cattle Pact.
Comment on this
The Deputy says: "You made ... a bargain." As it is always presumed that a Deputy addresses the Chair, the inference is that the Chair must have made a bargain of some sort.
Comment on this
That is a form of address which I must withdraw. I never thought for a moment that the Ceann Comhairle made a bad bargain, or made any bargain in this matter.
Comment on this
I do—very seriously. Through you, Sir, I would ask the Minister to take it seriously, and to give the House some information as to why he will not accept this amendment by Deputy Mulcahy, or why he insists on collecting this tax off coal— not off British coal, but Irish coal. It is Irish coal when we have agreed to buy it. It is here for our use, and not for British use. It is coal which was necessary for the Irish people to get. If it was not necessary for us to get it we should not have allowed it in. We have agreed to take it in, and we are taking it in. When the matter is in that position the Minister for Finance comes along and says "Now, for every ton of that coal you use you must pay me 5/-." That is increasing the price to the consumer. Why does the Minister insist on doing that? Is it because, as has been suggested here earlier, he wants to make the consumers of coal get into the front line trenches in the economic war? If it is, when the people who are in the front line trenches are taken out of those trenches they should get some relief, but no relief has been offered. They are still going to be in the front line trenches. Has the Minister, like King Louis, called up his last reserves? Are these his last reserves? Is it the last throw of the dice? If it is, tell us. Is this the financial condition to which the country has been brought? If it is, well then the sooner the whole present situation is reviewed the better. If it is not, then the Minister ought to give us some reason why he proposes to continue this tax and rejects this amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish, when speaking, said he could not understand the mentality of the Government with regard to the Coal-Cattle Pact. I am afraid that Deputy Corish, in making that statement, admitted his incompetence and the incompetency of his Party, because they supported the Government in arriving at that position.
Comment on this
I did not vote for the tax. If the Deputy looks up the records he will find that out. Every thinking person knew that the policy of the Government was leading to a lower standard of living for everybody in this country, and especially for the people that the Labour Party represent. You have the effects now. You have a tax on tea, sugar, tobacco, flour, coal, and in fact on every article that goes into the houses of the unfortunate people of this country. Deputy Victory —I am sorry that he has left the House —speaking at a Feis last Sunday, said that we had our own fuel in this country. I should like if Deputy Victory would come into the House and tell us the cost of that fuel. In Dublin at the present time turf is being sold from door to door at 1d. for three sods. From time to time I have been thinking of buying three sods of turf and bringing them in here, to give the House the estimated cost per ton for——
Comment on this
For turf. Well, Sir, it has been argued here that we had fuel of our own, and that there was no necessity to use British coal or any other type of coal. I myself believe that turf is the dearest article that could go into any house, and I may almost say that I was reared in the bog myself. I ran away from it long ago. There used to be great talk of midnight agreement at one time in this House, and I should like to find out from the Minister, when he is replying, when this agreement was signed. The Minister for Finance, the President——
Comment on this
I am not discussing the cattle pact. I am discussing coal, because the matter is before the House, and I certainly believe I am entitled to do so.
Comment on this
I will not discuss cattle. There will be a further opportunity of doing so. The point is that because of the Coal-Cattle Pact——