Committee on Finance. - Vote No. 26—Law Charges (Resumed).
Contributions 154–323 of 323. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
You should be in the dock with the others, because you were one of the instigators of the whole thing. You went around the country for a fortnight collecting the men who went there.
Comment on this
I want to raise a point of order. Deputy Murphy stated that I should be in the dock, that I was the instigator——
Comment on this
Ashamed of the men who planned it, you and your colleagues.
Comment on this
For a fortnight before that, you went round picking up men for the purpose.
Comment on this
Will the Attorney-General please resume his seat? Deputy Murphy has made a charge against Deputy O'Neill, and said that he should be in the dock with reference to certain incidents that happened in Marsh's Yard. That is a statement that should not be made with reference to any Deputy in this House, and it should be withdrawn.
Comment on this
I decline to withdraw it, because I believe it to be so. I will not withdraw it.
Comment on this
You will have to take the necessary steps to get me out of the House.
Comment on this
If the Deputy does not withdraw I shall have to send for the Ceann Comhairle and call his attention to the Deputy's conduct and ask for his suspension.
Comment on this
Very well, I will go then, but I adhere to the statement.
Deputy Murphy withdraw from the House.
Comment on this
I want to state, on my honour that I knew nothing about the incident until it happened in the yard.
Comment on this
I do not suggest the Deputy had anything to do with it.
Comment on this
Here is the description that was given in the Cork Examiner on the following day:—
"All was still quiet at 12.25."
There was an ominous silence amongst those gathered outside. It was quite different, as the Cork Examiner points out, from the scenes that were enacted three weeks or a fortnight previously when a howling mob interfered with a sheriff's sale and when they threatened the lives of those men who were there under protection. The description states:—
"All was still quiet at 12.25, but a few minutes later there came a sensational interruption. The Guards in the front cordon were in conversation when shouts were heard from the direction of Anglesea Street. This was followed by the roar of a lorry engine rapidly approaching, and then the crowd scattered in all directions as a lorry was seen making straight for the entrance gates. The Guards in the cordon attempted for a moment to stop the progress of the lorry in which there were some dozen young men. They were forced to scatter to avoid being run over, however, and some Guards who attempted to grasp the sides of the lorry were beaten off by the occupants of the vehicle. Straight at the second cordon went the lorry, and here again the police scattered in all directions to avoid the oncoming vehicle which crashed right through the gates into the yard. Taking advantage of the disorganised state of the police, the crowd behind rushed the gates and there followed a scene of wild confusion, as Guards with drawn batons fought men who used sticks in their efforts to get into the yard. In the midst of all this, shots rang out—several of them —and after a short interval more explosions were heard at the entrance of the repository. Spectators—amongst them many women —made a wild dash for cover, and doorways in the vicinity were congested by the rash for cover, whilst others of the onlookers made down Anglesea Street and up Infirmary Road. The crowd at the repository gates, however, continued the attempt to drive home an entrance behind the lorry, and it was several minutes before it broke before the charge of the Guards, scattered down and up Anglesea Street. Outside the Model Schools the crowd again stood and beset the Guards. Some of the helmets were knocked off the police and several helmets were seen soaring into the air, some of them landing on the roof of the Farmers' Union abattoir. The Guards eventually yielded before the onslaught and fell back some distance. Here they were joined by reinforcements and the order for another baton charge was given. This time the rush continued down to the new City Hall and down Albert Quay, over the new bridge. Another charge continued over Parnell Bridge and down Parnell Place, and the Guards then took up a position at the city side of Parnell Bridge. Several more charges followed."
Comment on this
All this was long after the man had been shot, and the Attorney-General knows it. He is deliberately misstating the facts to the House.
Comment on this
I am not deliberately misstating the facts.
Comment on this
What the Attorney-General has now read took place after the shooting, and he knows that all that took place after the shooting. The Attorney-General also knows that it was sworn by Superintendent McNeill that the cordon was reformed and that nobody could get into the yard within half a minute.
Comment on this
The Deputy stated that I have been misstating the facts. I am merely reading from the Cork Examiner, whatever Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney may say about the standing and authority of the Cork Examiner. The Deputy comes from my own native county, Mayo, and perhaps he may not know what the exact outlook of the owners of the Cork Examiner is. I wonder would any Cork Deputy——
Comment on this
He is entitled to be heard without interruption. That courtesy was extended to Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and he ought to extend it to the Attorney-General now.
Comment on this
If there was any misstatement, it was not made by me. I merely read the Cork Examiner account.
Comment on this
I read the account from the beginning.
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney seems to be getting extraordinarily excited. I started my quotation where the description was that all was still quiet. Then I read the account of the oncoming lorry making its way through the Guards. I read the incident of the shots, and I read what happened, exactly verbatim from what is in the paper.
Comment on this
You read nothing about what took place inside. The reporter was not inside. You read what took place outside after this murderous shooting took place inside.
Comment on this
I merely read the newspaper account. I read exactly the account given in the Cork Examiner of the following day of the incidents which occurred there. Will the Deputy take the quotation and read it for himself?
Comment on this
I will take it as perfectly correct, so far as it goes, but I am not taking it as being an account of the shooting, because it is not. It is an account of what took place after the shooting, and it was written by a man who was not inside the yard—which is perfectly obvious.
Comment on this
I have read all the accounts and that account seems to me to be a correct account.
Comment on this
I was merely drawing the attention of the House to this fact, that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney on the two occasions when he mentioned this matter in the House deliberately concealed the background of it, deliberately concealed the fact that there were 2,000 or 3,000 people outside.
Comment on this
What I stated was that there was a large number of people outside, but that inside there were only 20 people or thereabouts.
Comment on this
If Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney is continually going to interrupt, I will have provision made to ensure that he will cease interrupting the Attorney-General.
Comment on this
I am not making any mis-statements. I do not want the Deputy to think that I am attempting to score in this matter by making mis-statements. I am quite satisfied to make it clear that the account I read was the account of a writer in the Cork Examiner. It was obviously given by a man outside the yard. I do not suggest anything to the contrary. There is not a word in that statement describing the incidents that happened inside the yard, beyond mentioning the fact that shots were heard at a particular moment and then he described the effect of the shots on the crowd. It does bring out, and I want to draw attention to this, what the Deputy has never made clear in the course of his statements on this matter. What I want the House to understand is that you cannot take the incidents inside the yard in isolation. They must be related to what was going on outside, to conditions apparently deliberately organised, to the knowledge in the crowd that something was going to happen. The crowd was silent and then there was a wild cheer, a lorry dashed through the crowd and hurled itself against the gate of the yard, knocked down the police superintendent and was followed into the yard by a howling mob, armed with sticks.
Comment on this
As far as they could get into the yard. I understand the man who was shot, unfortunate Lynch, was one of the followers.
Comment on this
He was one of those who followed through the cordon formed by the Guards into the yard, one of the 2,000 or 3,000 outside.
Comment on this
Does the Attorney-General appreciate the fact that 2,000 or 3,000 people were kept in order by a condon of Guards?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Neill will please sit down. As I have already indicated, the Opposition got a comparatively long time in which to make their case. The Attorney-General is not getting any chance to reply.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not interrupt the Chair. The Chair will make provision that the Attorney-General will be allowed to continue his statement without interruption.
Comment on this
As I have stated, these are the facts as presented to me. These, I think, are undoubted facts—that there was this large mob armed with sticks outside, that the lorry which went in carried 15 to 20 men and in the lorry were a number of batons loaded with lead and iron; that the sticks which were carried by the crowd outside—some of them— were similarly treated. They were produced in court. If I am to go on making a defence which will take me through the whole of the evidence, I am quite prepared to do it if the House wants it, but I do not think it is necessary. Here is the reference which I mentioned some time back. I have just been referred to the statement upon which I have been challenged: "It was converted, as his Lordship had said, into half a tank and a battering ram."
Comment on this
I give it as the statement of the judge.
Comment on this
In those circumstances, with all their background —the immediate history before that occurrence, the objective at which that crowd were aiming, the whole surrounding circumstances—a body of armed men on duty, protecting the men who were there buying the cattle, opened fire on the people who appeared in this manner in the sale yard and they are here deliberately described by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney as murderers and I am described as standing behind murder. I do not know how anybody who has any sense of justice could say that. Deputy McGilligan, at the end of his speech, referred to indignities and abuse which were almost intolerable. This kind of thing, I think, is almost intolerable to anyone. I charged Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney to produce a precedent where, under circumstances approaching these, an Attorney-General as law officer was called upon to put the soldiers or the police on trial for murder. He came here the other day after he had months in which to look up these precedents and what has he trotted out to the House? Some case away back in the last century, the Borrisokane case which occurred apparently in or about the year 1828, over 100 years ago. I have not been able to trace that case. Over 100 years have elapsed since the time of that case, according to the dates on which I find the Attorney-General mentioned held office here. On numerous occasions in this country and in England riotous and unlawful assemblies have been dealt with by armed forces. I wonder does the Deputy know that?
Comment on this
Can the Attorney-General tell us any such cases in this country? Can he give us one example, with shooting similar to those which took place in Cork, where there was no prosecution? I grant him the exception of Mitchelstown.
Comment on this
The ordinary presumption of English law and the basis of English law and the basis of English justice, is that a person is presumed innocent until he is proved guilty. If Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney had studied the law and did not recklessly give forth bad law he would know that now it is established in England, beyond a shadow of doubt, that the mere fact of killing does not mean that a person is to be presumed guilty of murder.
Comment on this
That alteration of the law in England only took place in the last two months. It is ridiculous for the Attorney-General to say he had that in his mind in August last.
Comment on this
It is not ridiculous. The principle underlying the decision of the House of Lords has been followed in this country since the setting up of the Free State, and the Deputy should know that.
Comment on this
That is a reckless and untrue statement.
Comment on this
It is impossible to deal with some people. This case has been made a pet subject by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. He attended the inquest in Cork, and he asked for a verdict of murder from the coroner's jury. I think I could contrast the conduct of previous inquests with the way in which the State, the Minister for Justice, and the Guards acted at that inquiry in Cork. Did they hold back one tittle of evidence? Did they not put forward every tittle of evidence before that Cork jury to enable them to inquire into all the circumstances of the case?
Comment on this
The Deputy is now making a charge against the uniformed police and against the jury.
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney did not ask for an investigation. He simply asked for a verdict of murder. He did not ask the jury to investigate the facts and come to a conclusion as to whether the circumstances justified the firing. He asked for the verdict of murder and explained to the jury that this was murder.
Comment on this
Though it is not. Again I fear the Deputy is making reckless statements. I am really sorry I seem to have provoked the Deputy so much.
Comment on this
The Deputy having failed in Cork, comes here and thrusts out of sight the main facts of the case, and presents to this House his own facts. He omits the background to which I have referred, even though I drew attention to it on the last occasion; but he omits all reference to it. He omits the fact that the lorry driver was charged before a Cork jury in Cork and was convicted of unlawful assembly.
Comment on this
I think this is the first time it was admitted.
Comment on this
This is the first time the Deputy admitted that.
Comment on this
And the mob who assembled outside were guilty of a crime?
Comment on this
And the Guards are entitled to fire on a riotous assembly if they found it necessary to deal with it in that way.
Comment on this
Order, order. Will Deputy O'Neill please cease from interrupting. Even the Attorney-General is entitled to speak here. The Opposition ought to have learnt that; they were once in office themselves.
Comment on this
I am sorry for the Attorney-General. ("Order, order.") He is making the best of a very bad case; he ought to try to get away from it.
Comment on this
On the Vote for my Office in this Assembly, I was told that I was giving the power of life and death to the Guards. The charge was made that I initiated the doctrine that the Guards could fire and kill whom they liked. I never initiated any such doctrine. I said that in that particular case the Guards were entitled to fire.
Comment on this
The statement made by the judge who heard the case against Crowley that day, was that but for the action of the Guards firing when they did, several lives would have been lost that day.
Comment on this
The Attorney-General is quite right. The judge gave a most prejudiced summing up of the whole thing. His position was prejudiced altogether. ("Order, order.")
Comment on this
The statements from the bench were disgraceful on this occasion. (Cries of "Order, order.")
Comment on this
I say they were disgraceful and insulting, and I say that Judge O'Connor was a disgrace to his profession and a disgrace to the bench as well. ("Order, order," and interruptions.)
Comment on this
Does the Deputy realise that he is making a charge against the judge and alleging that he deliberately charged the jury incorrectly? Does he withdraw that statement?
Comment on this
Very well. I will leave the House, for peace sake.
Mr. O'Neill then left the House.
[An Ceann Comhairle took the Chair.]
Comment on this
I am very sorry to have to deal with matters which arouse—and I can quite understand it—such feeling. I am very sorry that this step of going into the details of this Marsh's Yard incident again should have to be taken by me, but I do it simply and solely, as I already explained, because I feel that a charge has been made against my personal honour by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, in suggesting that I had no justification whatever for not instituting a prosecution against the Guards in this case. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney made it qnite clear in the course of his speech what he is after. He followed up the line which has been adopted here, and which has caused so much exacerbated bitterness throughout the country, by attempting to develop bitterness against what he describes as Colonel Broy's new recruits. He, of course, exonerates the uniformed Guards altogether, but he wants to have a group of Colonel's Broy's new recruits put on trial——
Comment on this
—— to make a Blueshirt holiday. I hope we have heard the end of the Cork business.
Comment on this
Just as the Deputy and his colleague Deputy McGilligan for two or three years kept trotting out in this House the Gavin case, to which I referred earlier, on which he charged me with certain responsibilities without inquiry and when he was informed of my personal position. I merely informed him of it because he made an attack on my personal honour. The two Deputies kept trotting that case out here, time after time, and I suppose the same campaign of incitement is going to be followed in connection with this Marsh's Yard affair to cover up all the incidents to which I could refer which have happened during the last few months for which the Deputy and his followers have been responsible.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Attorney-General has made a statement about me. Am I not entitled to have that cleared up and to say to the Attorney-General that he did state to me that he was out of the country at the time this matter was investigated? I have never mentioned the matter in the House since. He now insinuates that for three years afterwards I did. The Attorney-General knows that that is false. I accepted his explanation that he was out of the country.
Comment on this
I say that the Deputy never tendered a single apology to me for the campaign he carried on in this House against me about that incident.
Comment on this
I said that the work of the Attorney-General was not properly done and I say it still, and I say——
Comment on this
We will pass to another item in respect of which the Deputy made a series of charges against me. He charged me with not following the laws of evidence and with producing in evidence against prisoners before the Military Tribunal statements made by them in answer to interrogation under Article 2A. Part of the statement which he made was that I was attempting to obtain convictions by fair means or foul. He said—and I quote from the Irish Times report of his speech:—
"I charge him with endeavouring to have men convicted against whom he knows there is no legal evidence, with endeavouring to secure convictions by fair means or foul. I charge him with actually succeeding in getting verdicts which he and everybody else knows cannot be sustained in law. I charge him with having men sent to prison in cases in which, if he discharged his duty properly, the State would have entered a nolle prosequi because there was no evidence against these men. The Attorney-General should not allow the Military Tribunal or any other court to convict any persons who in law had committed no crime and against whom in law there was no evidence.”
Then he drops a few tears for the I.R.A. and said that they had been victimised by me. Up to this, the charge was partiality, but now I am impartially unjust to both Blueshirts and I.R.A.
"He had not allowed the I.R.A. to get off scotfree, and heavens knew he had no brief for the members of that organisation...."
except when they come in useful to beat the Government with.
"... Yet there were members of that body in prison at the present time against whom there was no evidence which would justify a conviction."
I understand the charge to be that statements made by persons under interrogation under Article 2A are not admissible in evidence. The Deputy put that as a point of law, but he dressed it up with the charges I have just referred to which seem to flow from his lips so glibly that either he does not understand the effect they will have on the minds of the people who read them and who do not know me or him, or he is deliberately out to slander me. I could quite appreciate the Deputy raising a point of that kind although this seems to me not quite the forum in which it should be raised. Deputy Gearóid O'Sullivan raised the point in a much more sensible way the other day, if I may refer to his action in raising this point, at the Tribunal itself. I understand that the same point was made and that he is endeavouring at the moment to see if he can devise a means by which the point can be tested in the High Court. That is perfectly legitimate and perfectly fair, but Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney thinks nothing of coming into this House and launching this charge against me, that I have deliberately and consciously obtained convictions and that I have people languishing in jail at the moment on evidence which is no evidence at all. The Deputy nods his head in assent.
Comment on this
I wonder what consideration the Deputy gave to that charge before he made it? I wonder why, if that point was to be made, the Deputy should not raise it in the way in which Deputy Gearóid O'Sullivan raised it? If it is a good point——
Comment on this
I will deal with the Deputy in one moment, and, when I have done, I do not think the Deputy will be even as merry as he looks at the moment. The Deputy followed up that charge by saying that I had so abused my trust, and so conducted proceedings before the Military Tribunal that I had produced a travesty of justice, so much so that he had folded up his tents and left the Military Tribunal and that several other members of the Bar Library had announced that they would never go there again. The Deputy, I think, was only at the Military Tribunal once before he made this world-shaking decision, and I wonder if he is entitled——
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, if the Attorney-General had read my speech, he would see that I did not state that I would not go before the Military Tribunal myself. In fact, I would not, but I did not state it.
Comment on this
I know this strange fact, that, although I do not want, and am not anxious, to follow on the Deputy's lines of attack, there was a case to which the Deputy has referred and to which I will refer before I close this debate, in which the Deputy appeared in argument in the High Court. That case went back to the Tribunal, but the Deputy did not appear there, and I gathered from that peculiar conduct that the Deputy declined to go there.
Comment on this
It is a new tradition to set up in the Irish Bar that if prisoners require counsel to appear for them, counsel should object to the Tribunal before which the prisoners are sent. That is something new, and I wonder if the Deputy really feels proud of it? I understood that there was a tradition at the Irish Bar that if a prisoner wanted the services of counsel, that counsel was bound to go unless he had some overwhelming reason for not going.
Comment on this
The Deputy has the effrontery to come here and boast of the fact that, because of the manner in which I conduct prosecutions there he will not go before the Tribunal.
Comment on this
Yes, and because of the manner in which the Tribunal decides cases in which you prosecute.
Comment on this
I suspect that is what the Deputy would like to have said when he was speaking on this Vote, but instead of doing that he skirted around the rules of order by charging me with being guilty of creating an atmosphere which produced a travesty of justice. He did that in order to prevent being called to order by the Chair, as he would be, if he made the charge against the Tribunal which he has now made.
Comment on this
Another part of the campaign is this. I think the Deputy said that he was going to engender a spirit in the country that will refuse to recognise the sentences of the Tribunal when properly obtained: to discredit the Tribunal. I consider that is a campaign that ought not to be entered upon lightly. Certain adherents of the Party opposite have made those statements, but I wonder if those on the Opposition Front Bench realise the responsibility that they are taking on their shoulders by adopting a course such as that? Does Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney really think that it is proper for him to lend his professional position to a campaign against the members of the Military Tribunal who, as far as I know—I think most people will agree in this: certainly any unprejudiced person will — are doing their job extremely well and fairly, and that has been so stated by Deputies on the benches opposite. But Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney refuses to go before them and refuses to recognise them. However, that is the position in which we find ourselves: that a Deputy with that type of mind solemnly and seriously gets up here and says that the criticism which he has directed against me is really inspired by a desire to see that the law should be administered fairly and properly in this country. I ask the Deputy whether he really considered that charge before he made it.
I do not know whether the Deputy was attending to the affairs of the Department of Justice when he was in charge of that Department. I have here a file before me, but before I deal with it let me first of all say this: that I am informed and believe that, in every case in which statements were taken when Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was Minister for Justice, they were put in at the Military Tribunal in exactly the same way as they have been put in since I took office. In fact, they were put in far more regularly in his time. I have not put in statements in every case. The Deputy looks up surprised and shocked, but I have a file before me which, if he wishes, I will let him read. Under his signature there is this: "a certificate may issue" in the case of a prisoner from Kerry, and that prisoner was convicted on nothing but statements obtained from him under interrogation.
Comment on this
It was the case of the Attorney-General against Thomas O'Driscoll and Michael Shea on a series of charges, two or three of which required the Minister's certificate. On the file before me there appears to be what I take to be the initials of the Deputy: "I will sign a certificate in this case." and the Deputy did sign the certificate. I have also before me the file of my predecessor in office.
Comment on this
I would like to put this to the Attorney-General, that the aspect of the particular subject that is being debated is at the moment sub judice. I am sure that the Attorney-General would be as anxious as anyone else to see that in any particular case if something happened that should not have happened — if something happened wrongly — it should be reopened. Therefore, I think, it would be undesirable to discuss this, and I am sure that the Attorney-General would be the last person in this House to do anything that would prejudice any decision that the court may give in a case.
Comment on this
I am not discussing any case that is sub judice. I would yield to Deputy O'Sullivan if I felt that anything I would say might in any way prejudice a case in any way. I certainly would not even avail myself of the privilege which the House gives me to refer to matters even though they are sub judice. If the Chair says that I am not in order and that I should not refer to it——
Comment on this
If the Attorney-General says that the matter he refers to is not sub judice, the Chair has nothing to say.
Comment on this
Would the Attorney-General tell me what was the charge in the case in which I gave the certificate?
Comment on this
I think it would have been better if the Deputy had made some inquiries in this case before he lodged a charge against me.
Comment on this
I am not saying that, and I am not making any such charge against the Deputy. What I am charging him with is this: that on the file before me, under his signature, there is a case in respect of which the only evidence was answers to interrogations given by the prisoner: that senior counsel was sent to the Military Tribunal by the then Attorney-General, and that that statement was put in evidence against the prisoner. And that was the only evidence on the particular charges in respect of some of which the Deputy gave a certificate. Therefore, he must have known that when he gave the certificate, or does he say that he gave certificates in cases without seeing the oral evidence?
Comment on this
Is it not perfectly obvious that a certificate does not rest on the evidence? The certificate is that a crime has been committed. You do not condemn a person even though you do give a certificate. A crime, before a certificate can issue, must be a crime of its own nature, and not a crime against the administration of justice. That is what the Minister for Justice deals with and ought to deal with.
Comment on this
The Deputy, apparently, does not know the terms of his own Article 2A of the Constitution. Surely, it is the acts stated that constitute the offence, and does the Deputy say that he gave certificates in cases without knowing what the facts were which constituted the offence?
Comment on this
I know what the nature of the offence was. Will the Attorney-General read out what the offence was?
Comment on this
I will read the whole file for the Deputy to-morrow. I move to report progress.