In Committee on Finance. - Slaugher of Cattle and Sheep (Amendment) Bill, 1935—Financial Motion.
Contributions 1–141 of 263. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 24 of 1935 ›
I move:—
(1) Go n-éileofar agus go ngearrfar dleacht ar na beithigh agus na caoire uile do marbhuíodh no narbhófar (roimh an Rún so do rith no dá éis sin) mar bhia do dhaoine i Saorstát Eireann in áitreabhacha nách áitreabhacha cláruithe do réir bhrí an Achta um Beithígh agus Caoire do Mharbhadh, 1934 (Uimh. 42 de 1934).
(2) Go ndéanfaidh an duine do mhairbh no mharbhóidh aon bheithígh no caoire an dleacht san alos na mbeithíoch no na gcaorach san d'íoc leis an Aire Talmhaíochta.
(3) Go n-éiléofar, go ngearrfar agus go n-íocfar an dleacht san alos aon bheithíoch no caorach do réir an ráta gur dá réir a bhí no bheidh an dleacht fé alt 19 den Acht um Beitígh agus Caoire do Mharbhadh, 1934, adubhradh, iníoctha le linn na mbeithíoch no na gcaorach san do mharbhadh.
(4) Go ndeanfar socrú le reacht chun an dleachta san do bhailiú agus chun a íoca d'fhoirfheidhmiú.
(1) That a levy shall be charged and levied on all cattle and sheep slaughtered (whether before or after the passing of this Resolution) for human consumption in Saorstát Eireann in premises which are not registered premises within the meaning of the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act, 1934 (No. 42 of 1934).
(2) That the said levy in respect of any cattle or sheep shall be paid to the Minister for Agriculture by the person by whom such cattle or sheep were or are slaughtered.
(3) That such levy shall be charged, levied, and paid in respect of any cattle or sheep at the rate at which the levy under Section 19 of the said Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act, 1934, was or is payable at the time of the slaughter of such cattle or sheep.
(4) That provision shall be made by statute for the collection and enforcing payment of the said levy.
I should like to know if there is any objection to having the Financial Motion and the Second Reading debated together? I think it was arranged here when the main Act was going through that it should be debated in that way and that, if necessary, a vote could be taken on the Financial Motion and on the Second Reading separately at the end of the discussion. It would probably save time if that were done.
Comment on this
There is this point about it. The Financial Motion seeks to impose a levy in respect of cattle slaughtered in unregistered premises. The Act, which is being amended, as far as I understand it, made it unlawful to slaughter in unregistered premises. The whole question as to slaughtering in unregistered premises and the imposition of a levy on it, are very special and different things. Under the previous Act, the levy related to the actual Bill. This levy seems to be outside the whole scheme of things and seems to have some special significance whereas the Bill itself is to amend an Act one of the principles of which is that it is unlawful to slaughter in unregistered premises. I think we cannot get the matter clear unless we deal with the two items separately.
Comment on this
There is a special section dealing with that question. That is Section 14 which deals with the levy in respect of cattle slaughtered on unregistered premises. It would therefore come into the general scheme of the Bill. However, it is a matter for the House to decide. I do not want to press my point. If you want to have two discussions, it is all right.
Comment on this
If the Minister says that it would help to a clearer discussion, I do not mind. Is there any relation between extending this Bill to unlicensed premises and putting a levy on unlicensed premises?
Comment on this
It is only connected with Section 14. It is quite true that there are four or five main questions being dealt with in this Bill and that is one of them. The Financial Motion deals with that section alone, Section 14. I think it would save a considerable amount of time if both were debated together and I do not think that the House would be deprived of an opportunity of coming to a decision separately on both questions at the end.
Comment on this
This Financial Motion is necessary, as a levy is being imposed under Section 14 of the Bill. As the House is aware, wherever levies are being imposed, the Second Reading of the Bill must be preceded by a Financial Motion of this kind. It is true, as Deputy Mulcahy has stated, that under the main Act, a person is not legally entitled to carry on the business of slaughtering cattle or sheep for human consumption in Saorstát Eireann unless the slaughter is being done in a registered premises. The main Act only, however, provided for a penalty on conviction of carrying on slaughter in such premises, and did not provide for a levy at the same time. It is one of the amendments of the main Act that is being made in this amending Bill that in future—and it is also made retrospective—where cattle or sheep are slaughtered on unregistered premises, that in addition to the penalties whether inflicted or which might have been inflicted, the levies would be collected at the rate applicable to cattle and sheep slaughtered under registered conditions. It is a simple question: whether there is agreement or not I do not know, but it does not require any long explanation.
Comment on this
The Minister should be in a position to give us more information as to what he expects to receive in this matter.
Comment on this
The amount is small. To date it would not be more than a few hundred pounds.
Comment on this
That is an important point. The basis of last year's Bill was to improve the price of cattle, and for that purpose the Minister proceeded to put a levy upon the butchers. The levy having been put upon the butchers, it was expected that they would collect it from the consuming people. This was imposed with a view to collecting money which evidently was not done. Another question arises, over whether the House should accept this levy proposal now, and it is this: A few hundred pounds are involved in connection with this particular matter, but no one has any idea of what it will cost the State to collect that few hundred pounds. It may cost the State 50 per cent. of the whole levy. Officials must be appointed, or officials doing certain work at the moment may have to take up this extra task, and search out those people slaughtering cattle, so that they will pay these levies. Although not an extensive one, a levy tax ought to be measured by the ultimate cost it is going to entail. Everyone knows that the easiest tax to collect, although it is regarded as very hard, is the income tax, and the cost of collection is relatively smaller than the collection of 4d. a lb. on tea which may ultimately mean 6d. to the consumer.
In this particular case, if the sum is only a few hundred pounds, we would like to hear a case made for the previous Act. As we understood from the previous Act, cattle could only be slaughtered in registered premises. Now the Minister has learned that it is not possible under that Act to deal with the problem of having cattle slaughtered in premises not licensed. The easiest way for the Government would be to allow cattle to be slaughtered in premises not registered. During recent years, farmers in a small way slaughtered cattle and sheep, sold them and realised better prices than they would get by selling the animals at the fair. I expect that it is that type of person that the Minister is trying to get after. If the sum be negligible we are entitled to know what the cost of collection would be. The Bill last year was a very extensive one, consisting of nine parts, but there were only two operative items. One of these was the levy on butchers and the other the distribution of beef. So far as the remainder were concerned very few inspectors from the Department came along to see that the animal was marked before being sold. There were very few visits from the Minister's inspectors to ensure that the right price was paid. Here now we have a further imposition. Surely the House is entitled to know what its ramifications are, apart from what revenue it is going to bring in. We should be informed what is the actual cost and what are the Minister's reasons for getting after the small number of persons concerned.
Comment on this
In regard to the question of non-registered premises I would point out to the Minister that so far as rural districts in Kerry and elsewhere are concerned, this system was found to be complicated and people found it difficult to take advantage of it. I put it to the Minister that there should be some reduction in the levy to these people. So far as Kerry is concerned, we realise that this levy of 5/- per head in regard to sheep was very detrimental to the producer. I suggest to the Minister that the matter again be gone into so that the taking off of this 5/- levy should be a first consideration. It not only affects the County Kerry but it acts in regard to other counties in this way: once people know that the levy is there they do not offer remunerative prices simply because the levy is out of all proportion to the value of the animal in comparison with the grown animal and the better type of sheep. That is one vital question that affects Kerry. I believe the Minister should go into the matter and thereby assist agriculturists and unfortunate farmers on the mountainside in Kerry who find it impossible to dispose of their animals.
Comment on this
This does not arise at all; that is to say, the question of the general levy does not arise at all.
Comment on this
I am simply remarking that the general levy does not arise on this motion. I am not concluding. I wanted to answer some points put by the Leader of the Opposition. There will be no cost of collection, because these are cases that the inspectors have come across in the ordinary course of their duties. They are waiting to collect.
Comment on this
They will pay. There will be no costs. It is not a case of the individual farmer who slaughters a beast. I do not think there are any such. It is cases that afterwards became registered. Under the law at present we cannot collect for the few animals slaughtered before. These people acted in good faith and are not trying to evade the law, and we want to be able to collect from those people who are now registered.
Comment on this
Will this legalise the slaughter of animals in any kind of place, registered or unregistered?
Comment on this
There is no veterinary inspection under this Bill at all.
Comment on this
I can see nothing in this Bill, except the payment to the Government of 25/-, to prevent them slaughtering anywhere, no matter how the place is put up.
Comment on this
Under the Principal Act they still must be registered.
Comment on this
Might I ask whether this amending Bill will affect the killing of an animal by a farmer for his own use?
Comment on this
The Principal Act is not changed in any way. In the Principal Act it is set out that he must kill cattle or sheep for sale for consumption in Saorstát Eireann.
Comment on this
The first portion of the resolution sets out:
That a levy shall be charged and levied on all cattle and sheep slaughtered (whether before or after the passing of this resolution) for human consumption in Saorstát Eireann in premises which are not registered premises....
Comment on this
But it is still illegal to do that under the Principal Act.
Comment on this
I am not quite clear in regard to what the Minister said in answer to Deputy Cosgrave, that there will be no extra expense because it is only a matter of the cases which the inspectors happen to come across and which you cannot at present legally get at. I understand that is the point of the Minister?
Comment on this
If you make a thing illegal, the inspectors will have to do a great deal more work in looking for cases.
Comment on this
That is true, but, after all, they are full-time men.
Comment on this
But you will have to double their number, if they are full-time at present and if you are going to increase their work.
Comment on this
The Minister replied to Deputy Broderick or Deputy Hogan. Perhaps this is more relevant to the Second Reading than to this resolution, but what about Section 14? It seems to me that everybody is liable to the levy if he slaughters any animal.
Comment on this
Yes, he will be, but it does not make the slaughter legal.
Comment on this
I want to get this quite clearly, because I think there is confusion. The question which Deputy Holohan asked, and which I was going to ask, was whether cattle or sheep slaughtered for private use were now subject to the levy, and the answer of the Minister was "no," because under the Principal Act he was not liable to the levy. If the Minister will read Section 14 of this Bill, he will see that the words "for sale" do not occur. Sub-section (1) of Section 14 says:
(1) Every person who, whether before or after the passing of this Act, slaughters in any premises other than registered premises any cattle or sheep for human consumption in Saorstát Eireann.
........
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. I will have to look into that point. The principal Act has the words "for sale" and I agree they are not here.
Comment on this
I should like to ask if, under the principal Act, a man had registered premises for slaughtering animals, he is debarred from selling the meat in the neighbouring village unless he has premises registered in that village also. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Not exactly. I will explain the position if the Deputy wishes.
Comment on this
I do not know if it arises but perhaps the Ceann Comhairle would allow me to explain the point. He can take orders at his own premises and deliver the meat any distance. What would be illegal would be to canvass people to buy meat from a cart at their doors, but if they give orders at his own premises, either personally or by post, he could deliver the meat to them.
Comment on this
If the object of the Bill is to secure to the farmer a better and more remunerative price for his cattle and sheep, there is a good deal to be said for it, but the price fixed in this Bill, which is not quite an innovation, is 22/- a cwt. What caused the Minister to depart from the original figure of 25/-? There is another point to which I would like to draw the Minister's attention. Under Section 10 the Minister proposes to appear in a new rôle—the rôle of cattle dealer—and it is under that Section 10 that the 22/- a cwt. is paid. Has the Minister made quite sure that the price of 22/- per cwt. will be insisted upon and will in all cases be got? I do not want to make any suggestions against the persons who may be appointed as inspectors under this section, but is there anything to prevent certain corrupt influences being at work and a person, being only human, going only to his friends? Under Section 12 very great powers are given to those inspectors to search various premises.
Comment on this
Might I point out to the Deputy that it was decided that the Financial Motion would be taken before the Second Stage of the Bill? It appears to me that these points might more appropriately be raised on the Second Stage.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister what caused him to depart from the old figure of 25/- a cwt.?
Comment on this
I do not think it is relevant here, but I did say on the Second Reading of the Principal Act that we have to try to keep the minimum price as closely related as possible to the maximum export price.
Comment on this
Could the Minister give us any information as to the exact financial change this Bill brings about? He is no longer going to give free beef. He is substituting for free beef a cheaper beef, helped by an increase in the levy or, putting it another way, an expanded levy. The levy will be collected from more people than before, and people who formerly escaped are not now going to escape. Could he tell us, first of all—and I think it is quite relevant to the whole business—what the free beef has cost up to the present and what he calculates to save in this manner?
Comment on this
I am nearly certain that the estimate this year is £325,000.
Comment on this
For the present financial year. That estimate was arrived at in the belief that we would have this Bill operating from about 1st September, and operating on the basis that the recipient would be paying half the cost. If we continued paying the whole cost, I could not give the Deputy the figure at the moment, but I will have it in a few minutes, perhaps.
Comment on this
For the financial year 1934-35, the levies collected were £54,000. The figure up to 12th July of this financial year is £52,000.
Comment on this
For the whole year. The amount is £52,000 from 1st April to 12th July of this financial year. That is a little over the quarter.
Comment on this
Some time in November. At the moment I am talking about this financial year, and the amount is £52,000 to the 12th July. It is a little over the quarter. The payments on free beef for the last financial year were £173,000.
Comment on this
Something like four and a-half months. In this financial year the amount paid out for free beef was £122,000 to the 17th July.
Comment on this
The levies paid from November to March came to £54,000, and the amount of free beef——
Comment on this
Under the principal Act a farmer could slaughter for his own consumption, but under this Financial Resolution will he be able to do so, or will he have to pay a levy?
Comment on this
Under the principal Act a farmer could slaughter for his own consumption without paying a levy. Deputy O'Sullivan has drawn my attention to the fact that Section 14 does not contain the words "for sale," and I have undertaken to look into that matter.
Comment on this
The Minister will later on give us the financial information we have asked for—some estimate as to the real change this involves?
Comment on this
Yes. I have mentioned that the amount is £122,000 to the 17th July. If we continue at that rate for the whole year, it is fairly obvious it would be four times that amount.
Comment on this
We are estimating, by making this change and getting the recipients to pay something for the beef, that our expenditure will be £325,000.
Comment on this
The Leader of the Opposition has suggested that they might prefer not to take a decision on this now. The decision can be taken later. The Minister's Second Reading speech may affect the decision on this motion.
Comment on this
There are three or four rather major matters dealt with in this amending Bill. The first is to change from the system of free beef to what might be termed cheap beef. That change, as a matter of fact, was contemplated from the beginning. I remember saying on the Second Reading last year that we intended after a few months working of the principal Act to change the system to a contributory basis as soon as we could find out exactly the number of people who would be in receipt of beef and that we would get the Act working smoothly before we asked people to contribute. We felt, if we asked people to contribute at the start, they would be inclined to think they would be entitled to get the beef at that price; but when we were giving it to them on an ex gratia basis, if we were not able to meet the requirements they could not have the same complaint against us. That was the principal reason we brought in the free beef first for a trial. As a matter of fact, it was a scheme that, administratively, worked rather smoothly and there were not very many complaints.
I think we are in a position now to work on a contributory basis. Many people have complained, both amongst the Opposition and elsewhere, that it would be better if there was some small payment made for this beef. First of all, we were told people would appreciate it more and they would feel they were paying perhaps part of the value and that they had a better right to it and would not be regarded as being altogether on relief.
Comment on this
If you like to put it that way, but I do not like saying that. I am outlining the main principles of the Bill first. The second big feature in this Bill is the amendments which are brought in to try to enforce the minimum price more rigidly than has been done for the last year. Section 10 will be used in extreme cases. If it is found that it is impossible to get any particular victualler to pay the minimum price, that he is out to get round the law—and it is very difficult indeed to frame a law to catch people in some of these cases—the only remedy left is to say that he must buy from an inspector appointed by the Minister in future at a fixed price. Another point is that canned beef can be substituted for free beef in certain cases. There are some districts where it is extremely difficult to get the free beef supply and the reason is that, at the price we are paying for it, it would not be a paying proposition for any butcher to sell the whole beast on this basis. The victuallers in Dublin who get good prices for the choice cuts can well afford to sell the forequarters and the other parts with the exception of those that are excluded. We believe they can make the business pay all right. But it is quite a different matter when we go to an outlying district where there is not very much beef consumed and where the greater part of the beast must be given to recipients. It is difficult in such cases to make the business pay and it may be necessary to give out the tinned beef instead.
These are the big points and, as the Bill is not very long in the hands of Deputies, it would be better if we had a look at it section by section. The first four sections do not require any definition because they are just merely introductory sections. Section 5 seeks to amend Section 12 of the principal Act and it looks rather a formidable amendment at first sight, but it is not really so serious as it might appear. The position there is that the Department of Agriculture have to make an appearance at some District Court in the country and produce evidence from the register. What is produced is only prima facie evidence and that means that somebody must go from headquarters to prove a document. The change sought here is to make it conclusive evidence, which means that the officer need not necessarily go from headquarters to prove that this document is the document it purports to be. It is taken to be that document unless it is proved to the contrary. Our local inspector would appear in court to prove his case. It is rather expensive to have to send some officer from headquarters to appear in these cases, and it is also, indeed, very inconvenient, because it is difficult to spare officers going on such cases.
Comment on this
No. As a matter of fact in the principal Act sub-section (3) says "that ... under the hand of the officer mentioned ... shall be conclusive evidence." We are not going any further than making sub-section (2) the same as sub-section (3). At any rate, it cannot be described as a departure from precedent, because the precedent is already in the same section. Section 6 of the Bill is an amendment of Section 14 of the principal Act. As the principal Act stands, Section 14 of it deals with the inspection of registered premises and it gives the inspector power to inspect registered premises, the appliances, equipment, etc., and also to inspect all cattle, beef, veal, mutton and lamb in these premises. It is sought now to include also offals, skin and hides. The object of that is to give the inspector a better opportunity of investigating the number of cattle and sheep that have been slaughtered by the victuallers. Some of the victuallers know this legislation thoroughly, and if the inspector comes along, not having called in there for two or three weeks previously, and asks the victualler how many animals he has slaughtered he is given the number, but if he tries to verify that number the victualler, as the legislation stands, is entitled to refuse. This amendment gives the inspector power to see the number of skins, the amount of offals and the number of hides that may be on the premises, and in this way the inspector can verify the figures given to him by the victualler.
Section 7 seeks to amend Section 18 of the principal Act. It gives the inspector power to examine and inspect the skins, hides and offals. He is given power to find out any other information that he needs. It also adds two paragraphs (c) and (d) to the sub-section. These are all in the same direction, giving the inspector power with regard to the inspection of the premises in order to verify the information that the victualler may have given him.
Comment on this
To give the inspector power to verify the figures he may get from the registered person.
Comment on this
Because we feel that the registered person may not always tell the truth. The registered person may tell the inspector he slaughtered six beasts, and the inspector might like to verify that by examining the skins.
Comment on this
In view of the nature of the Bill, would it not be well if the Minister gave some of his experiences under the principal Act?
Comment on this
I have said already that some of the victuallers are quite good legal experts on the principal Act. When the inspector comes along and asks how many sheep they have slaughtered during the week and they answer six or eight, if the inspector has any suspicions about that, they know quite well that they are entitled under the Act to refuse him any further information.
Comment on this
Some of them are too mean to do that. Section 8 of this Bill deals with the weighing facilities in registered premises. Where our inspectors have called in to some premises the registered person gives the number of beasts killed. He shows his books with the amount of meat sold, and the inspector tots up the two and says that the quantity of meat hanging up is more or less than should be there. The registered person disputes that, and when he is asked to weigh the meat that is hanging up he says: "I have no scales." This section is to compel the victualler to have scales. Every victualler in the country had scales until this Act came into operation, but they got rid of the scales in order to evade that question. We want the victuallers to look up those scales and get them back to their places again. Section 9 gives the inspector power to weigh the meat.
Section 10 requires the registered proprietor to purchase cattle only from the Minister. That is perhaps one of the principal sections in the Bill. It is giving the Minister power to serve an order on any registered person that that person must buy his cattle or his sheep in future only from a particular inspector named by the Minister at a minimum price. The regulations in connection with the minimum prices have been evaded in many ways. The chief way has been by the third party method. Before the Principal Act came into operation, butchers were accustomed to go around and buy their cattle off adjoining farmers. They stopped that, and the majority adopted the practice of buying their cattle from one farmer or dealer, and they paid that one man for the cattle. This man bought the cattle at any price he was able to get them because he was not compelled to buy at a minimum price as he was not a dealer. The victualler's books showed our inspector that he had paid a minimum price to a dealer or a farmer who was buying for him. Whether he paid that price or not was another question, but it is rather suspicious, to say the least of it, that he should have changed his whole method of business since the Principal Act came into force. He may be acting illegally but as far as our inspectors were concerned they could not make a case against him because the dealer or farmer who sold to these victuallers was always prepared to assert he got the minimum price. We, however, have our suspicions, and some way must be found to deal with that particular evasion of the Act. This particular section was suggested by the Consultative Council. That Consultative Council is composed of victuallers and producers of various kinds of sheep and fat cattle, and at a meeting of that Council it was suggested that this was the best way of dealing with it.
Comment on this
No, the suggestion was made to the Minister. It was suggested by the producers, and every producer present agreed with it. I do not think that victuallers agreed with it wholeheartedly. The producers agreed with the suggestion, and I promised to give the matter consideration. I think it is the most effective method of dealing with that abuse. It is not proposed, in fact I think it would be impossible, to work this generally all over the country. We are fairly certain that a large number of victuallers are working the Act honestly. Some of them, as a matter of fact, have complained to the Department that they tried to pay the minimum price as long as they possibly could, but that their competitors were not paying it, and they could not continue to pay it unless everybody did so. I think that would be true of a large number. If we could deal with the worst offender in each district, probably we would get them all paying the minimum price without any great trouble, and it would be possible, I take it, for an inspector in an area to deal with two or three or four victuallers on this basis.
Deputy Anthony raised a question there as to whether or not it would be operated fairly. I am afraid we have to assume, at any rate, that the inspectors will operate it on a fair basis. We will have to give the inspector, I think, fairly full powers as to the person from whom he will buy a beast for the victualler, while this particular section is operative in reference to any particular victualler. It would be absolutely impossible to have him directed from headquarters, as to where he should go to buy. Therefore, I think the inspector will have to have a good deal of discretion as to whom he will buy cattle or sheep from, as the case may be. Of course, there is no great difficulty in regard to sheep, because no minimum price is fixed, but he will have to have discretion in regard to cattle. Then, having bought the cattle from the farmer, he would pass them over to the victualler at a fixed price. He would probably have to pay something higher than the ordinary fixed price. The fixed price will have to be paid to the farmer, and, if there is any expense, of course, the victualler will have to pay that in addition.
Comment on this
Where it is quite obvious that the victualler was not paying the minimum price, although his books show that he is buying from a certain dealer, or a certain farmer, since this Act came into operation, and that he is paying the minimum price to that one man, but before the Act came into operation he was buying from every farmer——
Comment on this
Who is to be the judge of the suitability of the beast for the man's requirements?
Comment on this
That is being taken rather lightly, and it is a very serious matter.
Comment on this
I admit that it is, but I think the Deputy will also admit that in any of those schemes which are worked by the Department they are only too glad to get out of what I might call penal measures if they can possibly do so. If they feel that the victualler is going to go back and buy from the farmers again this will immediately be dropped.
Comment on this
I think the butcher ought to be consulted before the animal is bought, in order to see whether it is suitable for his requirements.
Comment on this
That would spoil the whole case. What would happen in that case is that a dishonest butcher would certainly be capable of saying to the man whose beast he was inspecting: "I am prepared to say this beast is suitable if I get good luck. If I do not get good luck I will not say it is suitable," so he must not know whom the beast is being bought from.
Comment on this
The whole Bill is framed on the supposition that your ideas are not being carried out. It is possible, and even probable, that an honest man may, through the action of the inspector, be compelled to handle and offer to his customers in business meat of a very unsuitable quality. I think he is entitled to some safeguard, I do not think he ought to be treated as an outlaw before he is found guilty.
Comment on this
I do not say that either. In fact, I think the enactment of a section like this will have a good effect without being enforced at all.
Comment on this
There was never a section enacted that was not used against somebody.
Comment on this
There was very strong objection to my having power to take over maize mills. I never took over one yet.
Comment on this
Section 11 and Section 15 are somewhat related. They deal with restriction of the time of slaughter. We know from experience that our inspectors find it very difficult to call at a victualler's premises in or about the time he might be slaughtering. They have a very good intelligence system in the provincial towns, and as soon as the inspector comes into the town the victuallers get to know of his presence. If there are, say, four sheep hanging up in a shop, the inspector will invariably find that there were four sheep slaughtered the day before, but not more, as a rule. Some of them are so very difficult to deal with that it will be necessary that the inspector should be notified of the days and the hours of slaughter. Section 11 only goes that far—that is, that they should give 48 hours' notice of the time at which they are going to slaughter. Naturally, if a victualler says that he will slaughter on, say, every Monday and Thursday at 10 o'clock, he need not give any further 48 hours' notice, because that will be held to be his time until further notice is given. I do not think there will be any great hardship on the victuallers in that way, because as a rule they slaughter on a certain day and at a certain hour. If they find that they have to slaughter outside that time, I do not think they will have any great difficulty in getting in touch with the inspector and telling him that it is rather urgent that they should slaughter outside that time. Section 15 makes it illegal to slaughter at certain times. For instance, they must not slaughter on a Sunday. We will all agree on that. Also the Minister may make an order prohibiting slaughtering at any specified time, or during any specified hours.
Comment on this
Yes. It is not necessarily general. Some victuallers have made a very strong case that they have to slaughter in the middle of the night, owing to hot weather and other causes. Others, for instance, have to slaughter on Saturday evenings, at most inconvenient times for the inspector.
Comment on this
That is a different thing. If an Order is served on a particular victualler he is free to slaughter at any time he likes so long as he gives 48 hours' notice. On the other hand, Section 15 leaves the initiative with the Minister, rather than with the victualler. The Minister serves notice on him that he must not slaughter at certain times.
Comment on this
I would say that that is a great hardship on the victualler. If he wants to kill four or five sheep at six o'clock or seven o'clock on a Saturday, I take it the inspector would consider that an inconvenient time for him to call at the place. I think some regard should be had for the convenience of the victualler.
Comment on this
When I was answering Professor O'Sullivan I said the order was not general. It does not apply to an individual. It would apply to an area. It is not going to be made impossible to slaughter outside working hours or anything like that. That particular section is not going to be used to penalise anybody.
Section 12 deals with the powers of search for cattle, sheep and so on. It is a long section, but I do not think there will be any difficulty in understanding it. It gives power to an inspector to inspect the animals and premises and ask questions and get all the information he may require to satisfy himself as to returns and so on. Section 13 is on a par with a section we dealt with already. It provides that if the Minister gives a certificate that a certain amount is due, it shall be accepted as sufficient evidence until the contrary is proved. At present we have to send an officer down from headquarters who has actually seen the entry in the register, or account book, or whatever it may be, in order to prove to the court that the document produced is a genuine one. We are changing that and providing that if a document is sent down under the signature of an authorised officer it must be taken for what it purports to be until the contrary is proved.
Comment on this
How can a man prove a negative? If you said that I owed you £10 and you take me to court, how can I prove that I did not owe you £10?
Comment on this
Suppose I took you to court at present, how could you prove it?
Comment on this
It is for you to prove that I owed you the money. It is a recognised principle that no one can prove a negative.
Comment on this
If I were to bring Deputy Belton to court at present and said he owed me £10, I would have to prove it.
Comment on this
The only change we are making is that I can do it in writing. If I brought Deputy Belton to court now and he said that he did not owe the money——
Comment on this
There are precedents in other Acts for this. It is done under the Minister's seal. There are several Acts under which a document produced under the Minister's seal is taken as evidence without an officer having to attend and say that it is the seal of the Minister. That is all it means.