We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Conditions of Employment Bill, 1935—Report Stage (Re-Committed).

Contributions 179–366 of 366. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Conditions of Employment Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 13 of 1935 ›

Various examples will occur, such as work done in warehouses in connection with railways, docks, etc., where the workers in one warehouse might be within the scope of the Bill and the workers in another warehouse outside the scope of the Bill. We do not think it is a sufficiently clear definition of the nature of the work done to say that the only workers to be covered are those employed in warehouses where mechanical means of lifting are employed. We should have all warehouses either in or out. I think it is more appropriate that they should be set out of this Bill, and in a Bill dealing with commercial work.

Comment on this

How far does this invade what are the normal intentions of the Bill? Take a person engaged, let us say, in storing flour in a mill, packing it away until such time as an order is received for it, packing any kind of industrial product manufactured by that particular firm, not packed from, let us say, a railway store, or a port, or anything else. Will not that person now be excluded from the scope of the Bill?

Comment on this

All warehouse workers will be excluded.

Comment on this

So that the mill-worker who is normally engaged in the mill, in respect of the portion of the mill in which he is engaged warehousing or storing the goods — although he has nothing to do with a port or a railway — will still be outside the scope of this Bill?

Comment on this

The Deputy is doing what he did in the case of a previous Bill connected with transport. One can get cases of such workers so closely analogous with industrial workers that it is very difficult to exclude them. On the other hand, one can find cases which clearly justify their exclusion. We think it is better to draw the line between the factory and the warehouse and to let the warehouseman be regarded from another standpoint. It is not intended that they shall be excluded from the benefits of this legislation, but that their cases should be covered by a different Bill.

Comment on this

I must call the Minister's attention to the fact that it was not we who put Section 1, sub-section (c) in this Bill. This is the Minister's Bill, and the Minister, when his mind was playing clearly on this Bill——

Comment on this

No. I explained, on Committee Stage, that that was not quite the case. When preparing this Bill, we took the definition of industrial worker which appeared in the Washington Hours Convention, but, having regard to representations made since the Bill was introduced——

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this

By various parties interested in the provisions of the Bill. Having regard to these representations, we decided that certain amendments were desirable in the circumstances prevailing here, whatever might be embodied in the Washington Hours Agreement. I informed the Dáil to-day that I hope to have a Bill introduced in this Session dealing with this particular matter.

Comment on this

When this Bill was first circulated and when it had run the gauntlet of keen scrutiny in the Minister's own Department, all the wiseacres there at that time thought it perfectly desirable to put sub-section (c) in this section. In other words, when the Department were examining this Bill in the first instance they, as a Department, felt that it was desirable that sub-section (c) should be in this Bill, and that was the Bill as it passed through the House in the Second Stage, the Minister indicating on the Committee Stage, when he got representations from somebody, that the proposal to include warehousing of goods in any warehouse was to be excluded on the Report Stage. I should like to know from the Minister, who made the representations, and were the workers, the people engaged in warehousing, consulted as to whether they consented to their exclusion from the scope of the Bill?

Comment on this

It was discussed with them.

Comment on this

With what body was it discussed?

Comment on this

With the Trades Union Congress.

Comment on this

The Trades Union Congress? Do I take it from the Minister that the Trades Union Congress agreed to the proposal?

Comment on this

I did not say that they agreed to it. I said that the matter was discussed with them.

Comment on this

And opposed by them?

Comment on this

I did not say that either.

Comment on this

Well, I am saying it.

Comment on this

In saying so, the Deputy is taking a chance.

Comment on this

Well, if so, he is only following the well-beaten track of the Minister in that respect. I suggest that no trade union body would be in favour of the exclusion of warehousemen and people engaged in warehousing from the scope of this Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy is again misrepresenting the case. It is not a question of whether persons engaged in warehousing are to be denied the benefits of this Bill, but of whether it is more convenient to give them these benefits within the scope of this measure, or in another measure shortly to be introduced.

Comment on this

Is it proposed to put this paragraph in the Commercial Bill?

Comment on this

To include them in the Bill dealing with that.

Comment on this

So that the people who would be excluded will be included in the Commercial Bill?

Comment on this

But I do not see any reason whatever to wait for that. I am not so sure that it will be as speedily introduced as the Minister indicates. If there is any difficulty in classifying warehousing as industrial work, then we ought to know what the difficulties are, but the Minister has made very feeble efforts to justify himself in this. Let us take the case of persons engaged in warehousing flour.

Comment on this

Persons engaged in a store or warehouse attached to a factory, in which the goods in that factory are handled, are not excluded by the provisions of this section. This relates to warehousing as a separate occupation.

Comment on this

Where do they come in?

Comment on this

They are included as persons doing industrial work for or in connection with——

Comment on this

Well, which activity?

Comment on this

——for or in connection with any of the activities set out there.

Comment on this

Will that apply whether they are warehousing by mechanical means or not?

Comment on this

Well, then, taking it out does not seem to matter.

Comment on this

There are certain warehouses which are warehouses only. I gave two examples of these already — those connected with the railway and those located at the ports. They are not associated with any industrial concern. They are warehouses which warehouse or store goods in connection with the transport organisations which serve them. It was intended that the workers employed in such warehouses should be included in this Bill originally, where these mechanical means of lifting were used, because that was the recommendation embodied in the Washington Hours Convention. On reconsideration, however, we came to the conclusion that it would be more expedient to deal with these workers in a separate measure as commercial workers than to deal with them in this Bill. It is merely a matter of securing effective administration, and the exclusion to be made here is not for the purpose of depriving these workers of the benefits of this measure, as I have explained already, but because we think that these benefits can be better secured to them in another manner.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give us specific examples of a warehousing operation that will be excluded?

Comment on this

All warehousing operations will be excluded.

Comment on this

I understand the distinction with regard to industrial work; but could the Minister give me an example where they will not be?

Comment on this

Well, any of the warehouses along the quays.

Comment on this

Take a warehouse for goods which are to undergo some process of repairing or reconstruction for the purpose of being sold — is that out?

Comment on this

Oh, no. If there were any work in the form of repairing or adapting the articles, that is industrial work at any rate.

Comment on this

I want to continue to make the case I stood up to make, namely, that already the Minister, by carrying amendment No. 7, has excluded the transport and cartage of goods, even from the factory in which industrial work is being undertaken. Now he proceeds, by this amendment, to suggest that the warehousing or the storage of the goods in an industrial undertaking should be also excluded, and the effect of these two amendments is definitely to worsen whatever benefits are conferred by this section of this Bill. The Minister may say it is desirable to include warehousing when they come to deal with commercial activity. That may be true, but there is no difficulty in leaving them in this Bill, any more than there is difficulty in leaving carters in the Bill. I think that they ought to be left in the Bill until such time as some other Bill is introduced which will regulate more precisely their conditions in relation to any other persons who are somewhat comparable from a vocational standpoint; but there is no case at all for the exclusion of warehousemen at the moment. There may be a case for a better grouping of them later on when you have two or three Bills dealing with the regulation of industries, but that is a case for assigning them to a more clearly definable category. But it is not a case for excluding them from the scope of this Bill, especially as the Minister already proposed when the Bill passed its Second Reading to allow them to remain in the Bill. I think amendment No. 7 is definitely worsening the Bill and so is this amendment. There is no case for removing the scope of them. Any classification can be done later when other Bills are available. In the meantime they ought to be allowed to occupy the position which was assigned to them when this Bill was circulated to the House and when it was subsequently adopted.

Comment on this

Sub-section (c) of Section 3 (1) is, if excluded, going to create a great anomaly, for men working in goods stores are classified as warehousemen. These men would at other times be turned on to shunt in the yards. It would be almost impossible to differentiate what classification they would then be in. I think that is what the Minister had in mind when he was first considering this Bill and I think it would not be of advantage to the Bill to have paragraph (c) deleted. I would ask the Minister to try if he could see his way to make clear that men partly engaged in warehouses as distinct from men entirely occupied in warehouses are included.

Comment on this

They are included. In fact the decision to delete paragraph (c) is a corollary to the decision to keep transport out of this Bill and to deal with that as a separate measure. There would be considerable confusion created if you try to deal with warehousemen and exclude transport.

Comment on this

I have been trying to understanad what the differentiation is. It is obviously impossible to construe warehousemen as being industrial workers because the mere phraseology "industrial workers" would rule out warehousemen, for warehousemen were not deemed to be industrial workers. Industrial work is done in connection with any of the following activities —"manufacturing, altering, cleaning, repairing, ornamenting, finishing, adapting for sale," and so on. Paragraph (a) of Section 3 (1) is widespread. I ask the Minister if there is a type of warehousing that is not for one of the purposes in paragraph (a). There is one that stands out — simple storage — not a hand laid on the article for the purpose of "packing, breaking up, demolishing, or transforming any article for sale." I think in that case that warehousing would be industrial work. When the Minister was dealing with a Bill intended for industrial occupations he thought fit to include simple storage as long as it was simple storage effected by mechanical power. He tells us now that he got that definition from the Washington Convention. That Convention was the result of international agreement. A variety of other minds and other Parliaments decided that simple storage as long as it was done by mechanical means was an industrial occupation. Why are we now asked to decide that it is not?

Comment on this

We are not asked to decide it.

Comment on this

We are asked not to include it is a Bill dealing with industrial occupations.

Comment on this

They also include work done in connection with a type of shop which we are not including at all. We think they should be excluded.

Comment on this

There is the intention of putting warehousing effected by mechanical means into the category of commercial work.

Comment on this

Yes, or transport.

Comment on this

Has the Minister yet even made an approach to the conditions of commercial and transport workers — are the conditions to be much the same as here? Why not then, as there is likely to be some disorganisation in this, leave it over until the thing comes along?

Comment on this

Obviously there would be more confusion caused by doing that then.

Comment on this

There is possibly some reason why these are to be taken up now. We were told this came in here because of the reliance upon the Washington Convention. I do not think this was discussed from the angle from which the Minister is now approaching it — of taking it all together. I raised the point as to the distinction in the last few phrases as to whether mechanical effect was by mechanical power. The Minister was reluctant to give us any information. I think that was the only point raised on it. Now, having to alter the thing, there must be some reason for it and there ought to be an argument for doing that. But the only argument that has been advanced is that we are to take the original proposal because the original proposal commends itself to that view. Even storage in relation to any of these things is more easily dealt with as an industrial occupation and will cause less trouble than the mixed business. How is the owner of such a warehouse going to make discrimination between his staff employed partly on this and partly on other work? We are told that that would be carried out in the Bill that is promised later. Is the owner asked to make a division of the staff and say that some are never employed except simply as storage men? I suggest the paragraph should be left in.

Comment on this

In my opinion paragraph (c) in the Bill when it was originally introduced was an error. When I decided the Bill should not apply to dock labourers, men engaged in shipping and transport, I should also have decided to take out this paragraph. It would be impossible to have those employed in connection with warehousing covered by this Bill. On the other hand, whatever resolution deals with one group should deal with the lot.

Comment on this

Why should not the Minister come to the point by saying that warehousing in connection with paragraph (a) is excluded?

Comment on this

We need not go to that extent. The exclusion of paragraph (c) makes it clear that industrial workers of any kind, and particularly in connection with the activities there covered by the Bill, are referred to. The matter would then be clarified when the whole field is covered by other measures dealing with other classes of work and with measures which will provide the same general conditions even if they were to be enforced in a different manner.

Comment on this

Has the Minister considered what is to happen as between two classes of merchants — one of them warehouse men, and the other people who do their own warehousing, firms like the Dublin Warehousing Company? If paragraph (c) is deleted from this Bill you will have a situation in which a warehousing company is excluded altogether, whereas the merchant who does his own warehousing will, under Section 47 of the Bill, find that his warehousing is deemed for the purposes of this Bill to be "industrial work." So that two merchants engaged in exactly the same trade will have to carry on their business under entirely different conditions.

Comment on this

Only so long as there may be delay in introducing the second measure.

Comment on this

Again, I put it to the Minister that while there is a desire on the part of everybody to co-operate in social legislation of any kind, it is neither prudent nor fair to add to the complexities of the necessary legislation, and to create a situation in which two merchants engaged in virtually an identical calling——

Comment on this

Merchants will not be affected at all.

Comment on this

—— are at a disadvantage as compared with one another is a highly undesirable state of affairs. The Minister says that merchants will not be affected.

Comment on this

This is warehousing in connection with industrial work.

Comment on this

The Minister says that merchants will not be concerned at all, but let them be merchants or industrialists that does not matter. One industrialist may warehouse his goods in the Dublin Warehousing Company. Another industrialist may do it on his own premises and in his own warehouse. Therefore, you have these two men engaged in exactly similar activities operating under different circumstances. The Minister says this is only for a short time until he has had an opportunity of getting round to the remaining cases. But it may be a year or two before the Minister can hope to cover all the ground of a complex scheme of legislation such as he has in mind. Why not leave paragraph (c) in until his new Bill is ready for submission to the House, and then if he wants to lift this class of workers into the other Bill and codify the regulations for them under the new Act, he can insert a section in the new Bill repealing paragraph (c) of Section 3 of this Bill when the new Bill comes into operation, thus avoiding, even for a period, an inequality between two citizens of the State.

I urge on the Minister not only in connection with this Bill but all analogous Bills that as regards the operations of his Department one of the principal dangers that beset his activities is discriminating against one citizen, sometimes involuntarily, and sometimes, as I have alleged, deliberately. That gives rise to bad feeling and creates prejudice in the minds of those who would wish to co-operate. If this kind of legislation is to be a success, my belief is that it should be put into force without causing undue inconvenience to anyone. Otherwise it is going to react in a most undesirable way against the whole trend of this legislation. If, for a year or two there are going to be administrative difficulties for every employer in the country, I urge him to withdraw the amendment and leave paragraph (c) in until the amending legislation is introduced.

Comment on this

I feel that whether the section is left in or out there is going to be apparent discrimination in the case of certain types of workers. I believe there will be grave discrimination in the case of railway workers and those working in goods stores and warehouses and that it will be practically impossible to apply this section. There is not much use in introducing legislation that is going to create a situation of that sort. I think it would be better to wait for the other measure the Minister has promised, the one that is to deal with the whole of the transport industry. A very difficult situation will be created if those engaged in warehousing in industrial concerns are to be in one category and those engaged in warehousing in transport sheds, quays, and railways are to be in another. The real danger in this was adverted to by Deputy Norton that men may be included in the category of warehousing by simply storing flour, the product of their own mills, in a room upstairs pending shipment. The Minister said that was not intended. In my opinion, it would be better to leave this whole question over to be dealt with in the Bill promised by the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

In page 4, Section 3 (1), paragraph (d), line 28, to delete the word "cleaning" and substitute the word "clearing".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:—

In page 4, Section 3 (1), before paragraph (j) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

"(j) quarrying, irrespective of the depth of the quarry."

It is not quite clear from the Bill as it stands that quarrying is included amongst the activities covered by the sub-section. It has been decided that it should be included. I, therefore, move to insert this new paragraph to remove all doubts on the matter.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:—

In page 4, Section 3 (1) (j), line 38, before the word "fitting" to insert the words "reconstructing, maintaining, repairing, altering".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:—

In page 4, Section 3 (1) (j), lines 39 and 40, to delete the words "or demolishing the foundations of any building" and substitute the words "laying or removing foundations, or laying out or clearing the site for the construction of any building."

Comment on this

Would the Minister say what the position will be in relation to paragraph (1) when paragraph (j) is amended?

Comment on this

That you could have workers engaged in the removal of stone, slate or sand, otherwise than for the purpose of quarrying. Take the removal of stone or sand from the seashore.

Comment on this

The removal of slate or stone from the seashore? Would the Minister say what really he has in mind?

Comment on this

That all forms of activity, other than mining, will come within the scope of the Bill — all forms of activity of that description.

Comment on this

Quarrying is separately dealt with, and mining is excluded. Would the Minister say what is "removing from the ground stone, slate or sand otherwise than for the purpose of a mine" that is not mining and is not quarrying?

Comment on this

The meaning of "removing from the ground stone, slate or sand otherwise than for the purpose of a mine" is so obvious that if the Deputy does not understand it himself I despair of explaining it to him.

Comment on this

Then I can only try to get some further explanation.

Comment on this

I do not know that the Deputy will succeed.

Comment on this

I probably will not. That has been a distinguishing feature of the Minister in connection with this Bill.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. Deputy Norton's eyes are at last being opened.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon's support is most embarrassing.

Comment on this

It is not support, but patronage.

Comment on this

The Deputy could have dropped that patronising manner, but he seems to exude it, and, as if people did not know it, he persists in reminding them of it. The Minister has moved an amendment here because he says he is doubtful whether quarrying is in the Bill, and he moves to insert quarrying irrespective of the depth of the quarry. Then we are asked to envisage another kind of operation which is not mining and is not quarrying, because quarrying is dealt with in the new section (j). We are asked to visualise an operation which is "removing from the ground stone, slate or sand otherwise than for the purpose of a mine." If any ill-digested phrase could be imagined in connection with the Bill, surely that is a classic example.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy's objection to it?

Comment on this

A natural aversion to a foolish phrase.

Comment on this

He must have developed that during the Recess.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact I had a note in reference to this matter of a quarry on the Committee Stage, but I overlooked the matter. Now we are told that a quarry is one thing and that "removing from the ground stone, slate or sand otherwise than for the purpose of a mine" is another thing. I suggest that the Minister does not know what he has in mind at all and that he is just endeavouring to patch up this admission about the quarry, leaving an inexplicable phrase in the Bill. Whatever kind this industrial undertaking is going to be, surely we ought to know it in some easily defined phrase. Surely there is some way of describing it.

Comment on this

They are making a sea wall down at Clontarf in which they are using stones and sand they are not quarrying.

Comment on this

This phrase ought to be buried in it, because it is of no use. I should like the Minister to tell us what is meant by the phrase.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not know what is meant by "removing from the ground stone, slate or sand"?

Comment on this

What industry is that if not quarrying?

Comment on this

It is hard work. It is the business of removing from the ground stone, slate or sand.

Comment on this

If that means anything it means a man removing stones or sand with a cart. The Minister says that carting is excluded.

Comment on this

They do not remove sand from the ground with a cart. They use a shovel as a rule.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14:—

In page 4, Section 3 (1), to delete paragraph (n).

The amendment is to exclude from the Bill the work indicated in paragraph (n). I feel that if we are going to have separate legislation dealing with the regulation of employment in mines, that legislation should also deal with work ancillary to work in the mines, such as the sorting or preparing for sale the produce of any mine. That is rather away from the scope of this measure, and I accordingly propose to delete paragraph (n).

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:—

In page 4, Section 3 (1), before paragraph (n) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

"(n) Printing and all other modes (exclusive of writing and typewriting) of representing or reproducing words, figures, pictures or designs."

There is some doubt as to whether printing is included in the scope of the section as it stands. It is definitely intended that it should be included, and I am proposing to insert a paragraph with that object.

Comment on this

Has printing been defined by statute? One difficulty presents itself to my mind immediately and therefore I apprehend others. The Minister is aware that in most modern drapery stores price tickets are printed on the premises as an ordinary activity in the business of retail distribution. Is it intended that clerks employed in retail stores printing price tickets should be deemed to be engaged in industrial work under this Bill?

Comment on this

I think they are excluded by the definition of commercial work. The Deputy may be aware, because I mentioned it before, that one of the reasons why we are introducing Section 4 is that Woolworths was held to be a factory because they had a small machine for printing visiting cards on one of their counters. We are proposing therefore in Section 4 to take power to exclude from the provisions of the Bill an undertaking where the amount of the industrial work done is small. I should imagine that the printing of tickets for the sale of goods in a drapery establishment would be covered by that provision.

Comment on this

I take it that under Section 4, the Minister intends to remove anomalies by issuing licences to carry on questionable activities of that kind. For instance stencilling might be held to be printing. The Minister would be satisfied that is not an industrial occupation?

Comment on this

In every case where an application is made under Section 4 the matter would be examined, the intention being to exclude the occupation where the amount of work done would be infinitesimal.

Comment on this

I presume the Minister intends to exclude work done by a totting machine or compiling machine. I do not know if he specifically mentioned if they would be excluded. I am afraid we could not describe them as typewriting machines.

Comment on this

I think that, obviously, they would be excluded.

Comment on this

I am informed that there is some alarm in newspaper offices over this amendment and it would be very advisable to leave the matter in abeyance for some time further. I have not been briefed on the matter but I understand that some alarm exists.

Comment on this

I had no representations whatever to that effect. I did assume originally that printing was included in the section as it stood. It was when a doubt was raised as to whether the existing phraseology was sufficiently clear on the point that I had the matter considered and I decided that in the interests of safety, it was desirable to have the new paragraph inserted. I have received no representations from the printing houses although I have had other representations on behalf of the employees in connection with the doubt I have mentioned.

Comment on this

I have been informed that there is some misgiving amongst the newspapers and they intend to approach the Minister. It would be advisable therefore to leave over consideration of the amendment.

Comment on this

I would prefer to have it inserted. If there are any special circumstances operating in newspaper offices which would justify exclusion, or the exercise of any of the provisions under which exclusion may be permitted, that would be in relation to particular parts of the industry, but not in relation to the industry as a whole. I propose therefore to insert the paragraph, whatever representations we may afterwards receive.

Comment on this

It is intended to apply it to newspapers?

Comment on this

Definitely.

Comment on this

They are subject to very definite limitations in regard to hours of work and so forth and none of the permitted exclusions will really satisfy such things as that. Take for instance the publication of a Sunday newspaper.

Comment on this

There is complete power of exclusion under Section 22.

Comment on this

To declare that newspaper work will not be industrial work?

Comment on this

No, but to exclude it from the scope of any of the provisions of Part III of the Bill.

Comment on this

Then it comes to this, that you cannot make any regulation——

Comment on this

So far as Sunday work is concerned, it is definitely excluded from Section 41 — the printing of newspapers. Section 41 deals with work on Sundays and public holidays.

Comment on this

That is not the point. Take the printing on a Saturday night for Sunday. The Minister may exclude it, or may make regulations excluding it for certain purposes, but he cannot do that with regard to the provisions which relate to the hours of work, unless after consultation. There are limitations on the exclusions that can be made. Let me put this point: I am not saying the Minister would like to do this; but if he did like to do it, it is open to him under the terms of the Bill — to prevent the printing of a newspaper for sale on a Sunday, by the same staff of compositors as have been on duty right through the week, even though they are paid at overtime rates of wages.

Comment on this

There is complete power to exclude any form of work from Part III of the Act, which deals with hours and times of work.

Comment on this

Is there not a limitation in sub-section (2) that it cannot be done without consulting representatives?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

If this had been included in the Bill originally, I might have moved an amendment to take it out. It has now been put in on what is called the Report Stage. If the House accepts it, judgment is passed and I cannot move to exclude newspapers from the ordinary regulations. The Minister has created that difficulty by this late introduction. What can I do in the circumstances? Of course I can argue against this now, but if the House takes a decision on it, do you see the position in which I am placed? If that had been in the Bill I could have moved an amendment in Committee to take it out.

Comment on this

Vote against it now.

Comment on this

In other circumstances I could have got a case prepared, and all the points with regard to this proposal considered — whether the exclusion would be justified and whether it was possible.

Comment on this

The Deputy may not be so uneasy if I assure him that I know from recent experience that the conditions of employment in newspaper offices are considerably better than the minimum conditions which we are proposing to provide in this Bill.

Comment on this

Then there is no special urgency about this. Why not hold this over until the real Report Stage, when we can prepare whatever details there are to be prepared? It only means that this is held over for a few days.

Comment on this

I do not know that it makes any great difference. The only question was whether the existing section could be interpreted to include printing. Having regard to the provisions of the section, I think it is fairly obvious that printing is included and if a special form of printing requires the making of an exclusion Order, the exclusion Order will be made. I do not think we should exclude printing altogether from the scope of the measure.

Comment on this

I am merely asking that the decision to put it in should not be taken to-day, but should be taken on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy can say that he has not had reasonable notice of the amendment.

Comment on this

I might have had, but what could I do? I could not put down an amendment against a suggestion. The position I should have been in is this, that that should have been in the text of the Bill and I could then have put an amendment against it.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy had ample notice of the intention.

Comment on this

Let me assume that I had notice by registered letter, what could I do? Under the procedure here you cannot put down an amendment to an amendment.

Comment on this

You can. There are several on the Amendment Paper to-day.

Comment on this

It may be quite accidental; but there is no such procedure in this House as putting down an amendment to a suggested amendment, unless the matter has been discussed previously and the amendments are in the form of gathering a formula to meet something already discussed. In such a position one would have knowledge of it. How am I to suggest the deletion of that? I could not put down an amendment to delete words which are not there in the Bill.

Comment on this

Vote against the amendment.

Comment on this

But that does not give time to get the matter reasonably put before the House. I put it to the Minister: Would it delay the progress of the Bill to hold over the insertion of that? It is not that he is weakening in his arguments; it is simply that the matter remains in abeyance for a few days. I would like to get an opportunity of discussing this. This Parliament is meeting here for the discussion of Bills such as this. We are supposed to argue these things, and when a Bill is finally passed it is supposed to embody the results of our discussions. I see no way in the present circumstances of putting down a reasoned amendment against this. I am merely asking the Minister, in view of the difficulty of procedure brought about by his own action, that he should hold over the amendment until the Report Stage. It is not a very big request.

Comment on this

I was questioned on the Committee Stage as to whether printing was included in the scope of the measure and I said it was; it was clear to everybody that it was included. When, on re-examination, I felt that that might not be reasonably clear, I proposed to put in an amendment and I had that circulated in the ordinary way and no case has been made against it by anybody. The mere fact that Section 22 requires consultation, is not an argument. In the particular trade we are now discussing, a trade so highly organised from the trade union point of view, it would be impossible for any body of employers to take action except in consultation with the trade unions concerned, who are probably the most powerful trade unions in the country.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister will agree that he wants discussion of a rational and constructive kind when he brings a Bill of this kind before the House?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Apparently by an unavoidable circumstance he was unable to introduce into the Bill this paragraph which he proposes to put in by way of amendment. Clearly, he would have put it in the body of the Bill but for an oversight, inasmuch as he did not think it was necessary at first. Now, all that is suggested to him is this, we want to discuss the Bill intelligently and make it a good Bill and we would like an opportunity later of discussing this particular matter. The Minister may have at his disposal all the information he requires, but we have not. We do not ask him to yield an inch of his position or leave the House under the impression that he is prepared to be swayed by argument. We are prepared to believe that he has made up his mind definitely. We merely ask him to put this one item back to the next Stage so that whatever case we have to make in relation to it may be fully made.

If you want intelligent and helpful discussion of Bills of this kind, you are bound to accede to that request. If, on the other hand, you want to steam-roll legislation of a wholly noncontroversial kind through the House, you can pursue the line you are at present travelling. The fact of it is that the Minister has got his heels in the ground now and he is blowed if he is going to give way. It is a very foolish attitude to take up, because it means that both sides of the House begin to wrangle over comparative trivialities. The matter can be disposed of in a moment if the Minister will consent to putting the thing back to the next Stage. Our case will be stated in five or six minutes, but, if the Minister remains adamant, the matter will go to a division and there will be an end of it. The other course will give the House and the country the satisfaction of knowing that, when the Minister understands that a cogent case is going to be put up, he will give time to prepare it.

Comment on this

I do not understand that, nor do I understand that Deputies have any difficulty in having whatever case they wish to put up between now and Report Stage. I am not going to let Deputy Dillon represent me as unreasonable or provide himself with an excuse for being unreasonable. This Bill has been before the House for six months. It is fully three months since we discussed it in Committee and, in Committee, this question of whether printing was or was not included was raised. I expressed the opinion then, which opinion I still hold, that even without this amendment printing is covered by sub-section (1) of this section. If there is a particular matter to be raised in relation to the printing of newspapers or the printing of particular types of newspapers, there is nothing to prevent Deputy Dillon or Deputy McGilligan putting down an amendment which will enable that matter to be raised on the Report Stage. The matter can be fully discussed then, but no reason has been advanced as to why this clarification of the definition in sub-section (1) should not be inserted now and the particular matter which it is desired to raise raised on a specific amendment directed towards that point. It is a full month since the amendment was circulated to members of the Dáil.

Comment on this

Indeed it is not, but, to start with, I want to ask for your ruling, Sir. If this amendment is passed to-night will it be permissible to put down a further amendment to this section on Report Stage to exclude newspapers?

Comment on this

Would the Minister accept a suggestion from me, as one fully conversant with the industry in all its branches? I would suggest that the Minister should get in touch with the proprietors of newspapers particularly and with representatives of the operatives in connection with this amendment of his. I would also suggest to the Minister — and I think it ought to meet the position created — that he should insert after the word "typewriting" at the end of the parenthesis in his amendment the words "and newspaper production". Would the Minister accept that if I handed in a formal amendment?

Comment on this

No, definitely not.

Comment on this

I put my point again. It has been expressed to us that the amendment was definitely intended to include newspaper printing. If that amendment is carried to-night, will it be permissible for me, as a Deputy, to put down a further amendment at Report Stage to exclude newspapers? If that is so, I am satisfied, but I want a ruling on it.

Comment on this

The Minister must surely be aware that the exigencies of newspaper production frequently require that overtime should be worked, and sometimes perhaps an inordinate amount of overtime, against which many trade unions protest and protest rightly. It would mean the employment of more men in the industry, but the exigencies of the business frequently call for overtime on certain occasions. Let us take, for instance, the publication of the Sweepstake results. That necessitated the working of extra overtime in the Dublin newspapers, and the Minister must also be aware that at the time of general elections, for instance, a very large number of hours of overtime are worked. Provision cannot be made because of limitations of space, etc., to employ extra men. If I could see my way to do away with overtime I should be only too happy to do so, but these occasions occur fairly frequently in newspaper production, and I suggest to the Minister that before pressing his amendment he would get into consultation with representatives of the printing industry, and particularly the newspaper branch of the printing industry, and with representatives of the workers in the industry with a view to hammering out some form of words that would meet the wishes both of himself and of the persons engaged in the industry.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Regarding Deputy McGilligan's point, I do not want to decide on what is somewhat academic, but Deputy McGilligan will realise that the ordinary rules governing amendments apply. I am of opinion, however, that means could be found by which Deputy McGilligan could effect by amendment at a later Stage what he seems to desire.

Comment on this

It could be done?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Yes.

Comment on this

So that amendments will not be ruled out because they seem to negative a decision taken in Committee?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not exactly negativing.

Comment on this

Well, limiting?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Limiting, yes.

Comment on this

Very well; I am satisfied.

Comment on this

Would the Minister accept my suggestion?

Comment on this

I think newspapers should be covered by the Bill. I have heard no reason why they should not.

Comment on this

Would the Minister keep an open mind on the subject?

Comment on this

Undoubtedly.

Comment on this

An open mind that they are in?

Comment on this

I think they should be covered. There may be a case for exclusion but I have not heard it.

Comment on this

I want an assurance from the Minister that in relation to the class of work to which I have referred the necessity that exists for overtime at certain periods will not be affected by this amendment.

Comment on this

The Bill permits of various classes of overtime being worked, and also permits certain classes of work to be entirely excluded from the scope of several sections.

Comment on this

But overtime such as will be necessary on the occasion of the next Sweep results? This will not operate injuriously against the industry?

Comment on this

The Deputy may be assured of that. I shall be as anxious to see the results as he will himself.

Comment on this

I should like to know in respect of what does the Minister give an assurance that he is going to keep an open mind. We believed that printing and newspaper production were within the scope of the Bill and we have Section 47 which provides — so surely are they in — facilities by which certain exemptions can be granted, in respect of newspaper production. Do I understand from the Minister that he is giving Deputy Good an assurance that he is going to keep an open mind as to whether they should or should not be in? I understood that the Minister had already decided that his interpretation of the Bill was that they were in and that he was going to keep them in.

Comment on this

I think they are in, and should be in, and I have heard no reason to the contrary, but I will say that if good reasons to the contrary are advanced, I am prepared to reconsider that decision.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 16:—

In page 5, Section 3 (2), line 5, after the word "restaurant" to add the words "or in a place where the person who carries on such hotel or restaurant caters for the supply of meals."

This amendment is intended to meet a difficulty that might arise in connection with persons engaged in hotel or restaurant work. As the definition of domestic work stands in the Bill, it includes the work of preparing food in any hotel or restaurant if the food so prepared is intended only for consumption in such hotel or restaurant. But, as Deputies are aware, it is the custom for caterers and hotel keepers occasionally to take a contract for providing food temporarily in various places where functions are held, such as the caterers who provide food at the Horse Show and Spring Show and persons who operate buffets at bazaars and fetês and so on. It is desired to extend the definition by including work done in connection with the supply of food by the proprietor of a hotel or restaurant to such a place, and, therefore we are adding the words set out in the amendment. These people are excluded from the Bill.

Comment on this

I think that is a wise provision, but I should like to ask what would be the position of a hotel proprietor who gives a luncheon basket to a party going to the races. Would that put him in a different category?

Comment on this

In any event, they are outside the scope of this Bill. The work of transporting the luncheon basket is not industrial work.

Comment on this

The work of eating the luncheon is not industrial work.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 17:—

In page 5, before Section 5, to insert a new section as follows:—

This Act applies in relation to persons employed by or under the State (other than members of the Defence Forces of Saorstát Eireann or of the Gárda Síochána) in like manner as if such persons were employed by a private person.

It was my intention that this Bill should apply to persons employed on industrial work by State departments.

On reconsideration of the position, my advisers think that it would not be clear unless stated in so many words in the Bill. Therefore, we are proposing to insert a new section to put it beyond doubt that the Act applies in relation to persons employed by or under the State other than members of the defence forces or Gárda Síochána in like manner as if such persons were employed by a private person.

Comment on this

On the section, I should like to say——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The section has not been re-committed.

Comment on this

May I not speak on the section?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Not at this Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18, which was discussed and decided on amendment No. 4.

Comment on this

I did not understand that it was discussed and decided then.

Comment on this

It was certainly discussed and I think I am correct in what I stated. Amendment No. 4 has been carried, and if amendment No. 18 were not passed, the whole provision in respect of public holidays would have to drop. As we have carried amendment No. 4, we have to put something in its place and the only thing we can put in its place, as the Bill stands, is amendment No. 18.

Comment on this

The Minister has yet to get the amendment accepted.

Comment on this

I propose the amendment. I think that it is an excellent one in every way.

Comment on this

I think that it is a very bad amendment. I prefer the Minister's original intention to this amendment.

Comment on this

I was persuaded by members of the Labour Party to depart from my original intention.

Comment on this

The Minister was not persuaded by us.

Comment on this

Deputy Murphy's eloquence was largely responsible for my decision.

Comment on this

I do not believe that, if the expression is in order. In the Bill, there was definite provision for public holidays which were defined as St. Patrick's Day, Easter Monday, Whit Monday, the first Monday in August, Christmas Day, St. Stephen's Day and any day which might at any time be substituted as a holiday for any of such days. If the Bill had been carried in that form, it would have been possible for every worker to have got the benefit of its provision in respect of exemption from work, with pay, on public holidays. The Minister is now proposing to put in, instead of that sensible section, a provision which opens the door for considerable misunderstanding, considerable friction and considerable disappointment so far as many workers are concerned. The Minister is preserving the same definition of public holidays as is in the Bill but he is giving by his amendment any employer power to disregard the public holidays and substitute certain religious holidays. I am not opposed to the substitution of religious holidays. There may be good reason for doing so, particularly in certain areas where religious holidays are more largely recognised than bank holidays. But the Minister has opened the door so widely that he permits an employer in an area where bank holidays are now generally recognised to adopt some other day in lieu of them. That may be a day at some other season of the year when the facilities available to the worker on bank holidays are not available. The Minister, in discussing another amendment, said he believed that employers would be guided by the custom of the locality. If that were done and if there were some measure of agreement between workers and employers, everything would be all right, but it is possible under this amendment for all but one of the employers in a particular locality — the City of Dublin, or of Cork or Waterford — to say that they intend to observe the first Monday in August as a public holiday and for the one employer to say: "I prefer to observe some other holiday in lieu of that." The purpose of his doing so may be to get advantage over a trade rival or to inconvenience his own employees in the event of there being friction between him and them. Why should there not be some well-defined basis of deciding under what circumstances the substitution is to take place? Let the municipality or the local authority, where there is a local authority, decide the matter, or let there be agreement between the persons affected and the employers. In the event of disagreement, there might be no substitution or the Minister might decide the matter. These are all well-known, previously tried remedies. The Minister proposes to allow the employer unilaterally to say: "I substitute a particular holiday for a well-known bank holiday. I have complied with the section by giving a month's notice and that is all there is about it."

In that case, an employer who is under an obligation to pay the worker for, say, the holiday on the first Monday in August may not pay him for that particular holiday but may pay him for some other holiday. I want to tie down the employer to liability to pay the worker for whatever day is observed as a bank holiday in the district. Under this amendment, it is not possible to do that because an individual employer is not obliged to take any notice of what anybody else is doing. He is obliged to satisfy only himself. Deputy Cosgrave said that he did not know of any case in which it would be advantageous to an employer to open a laundry on the first Monday in August. I wish Deputy Cosgrave would have a talk with some laundry proprietor as to that. It might be possible for other employers to secure an advantage in the same way. I know that the argument against the likelihood of their doing that is that the workers have a holiday on that day. But the employer will now be able to come along and say: "That was all right when we were relying on tradition in closing on a bank holiday but here is a measure which legislatively gives us a choice between that day and some other day. We are entitled to make that choice, tradition notwithstanding." The employer is entitled to say to the employee under the amendment: "If you do not attend for work on the first Monday in August, you will get no pay in respect of that day, as I have selected some other holiday for you." This seems to be a rule of thumb of dealing with what is a fairly important matter. The original provision was immensely preferable to the uncertainty which will arise under the Minister's amendment and I should like the Minister to go back to the Bill, as originally drawn, unless he is prepared to agree that the workers should be consulted on the question of what should be substituted for a well-known bank holiday. If the Minister is not prepared to agree to that, he should, in the last resort, take power to decide the matter in dispute.

Comment on this

I certainly think the workers ought to be consulted. I think no sensible employer would do what is suggested by the Deputy. What is to be the position if the employers and workers do not agree?

Comment on this

I think the Minister should decide the matter.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to make that decision in respect of every individual industrial undertaking in the country. I think that would be an impossible position for any Minister to get himself into. The obvious course is the one we are taking. Where public holidays are not taken, some very good reason will have to exist. If there are special reasons, the principal of which will be the prevailing practice in a particular area, which makes it advisable to substitute some of these holidays by Church holidays, at certain times, then we are requiring the employer to give a month's notice to his employees of the substitution. This section will only be operated, in practice, to enable the custom prevailing in different districts to be reconciled to the provisions of this measure. In Wexford, and other parts of the country, the preference will be to observe the Church holidays; in Dublin and Cork, perhaps, the preference will be to observe the statutory holidays. It will be possible by this amendment to satisfy both areas at the same time, whereas under Deputy Norton's suggestion only one area would be satisfied, while another would be dissatisfied. This is a rehash of the debate on amendment No. 4, when the matter was fully gone into. I do not think it desirable that we should not have the elements of discretion exercisable by the employers, nor do I think that it should be non-exercisable unless the employer obtains agreement with his employees — whether agreement should be unanimous or not. I do not know. I think it is extremely unlikely that this power will ever be used except to bring this portion of the Bill into conformity with local practice. I do not think the employer would be so unwise as to effect a change without securing the consent of his employees first. I believe it will only be done where general opinion available in the locality is in favour of its being done.

Comment on this

Why not provide that?

Comment on this

There is nothing in this Bill which compels any man to work or any employer to keep his factory open on any holiday. If in Wexford it is desired to close down upon the ten holidays then, because there is a statutory obligation to comply with six of these holidays, there is nothing to compel them to keep their factories open for the other four. If trade unions and the exercise of public opinion have been able to get statutory holidays observed in the past they will be able to get them observed in the future with this addition that they can demand payment.

Comment on this

Does the Minister want to see a situation arise where an employer may decide that instead of having a well-known bank holiday observed he can adopt another, and, as the result of his action, he can create a situation where the workers have reason to complain and are not satisfied with the rearrangement made by the employer. All that will produce friction and discord. It is not easy, in order to avoid that difficulty, to provide by legislation that the workers should be consulted? There is nothing wrong in that. The workers' holidays are not the employers' holidays and they ought to be entitled to know that they will get the holidays they want. One would think the employer was providing for his own holidays.

Comment on this

We are providing to give longer holidays than I ever got.

Comment on this

You are enabling the employer to do what he likes with the workers' holidays, whether Church holidays or bank holidays. The employer ought not to be able to decide when the worker should get his holidays.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 92
·
Níl 0
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?