We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Conditions of Employment Bill, 1935—Report Stage.

Contributions 121–246 of 246. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Conditions of Employment Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 13 of 1935 ›

Would the Deputy have any difficulty in finding an employer who gives no holidays at present?

Comment on this

To anybody?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I think I would. I cannot recall anybody.

Comment on this

I will send the Deputy a long list before the Fifth Stage.

Comment on this

Very well. I will check up on it afterwards. As far as the average employers are concerned there will always be a certain amount of give and take. I think the Minister has fairly met the average case by saying: "Well, the worker must get one week's notice." Most of the workers who are going away for holidays will make their plans a good way ahead, and they will then try to find out how far the employer can accommodate them. I think that in most cases that will be the spirit in which the problem will be approached. But absolutely to say that everybody must get a fortnight's notice is, I think, going too far. After all, the average worker does not hire a pantechnicon for going away.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows why.

Comment on this

Yes. He has not to take a seat in an aeroplane when he is departing for his holidays. Many of them could make their arrangements in a few hours.

Comment on this

What about the accommodation they must get?

Comment on this

At the present time a considerable number of holiday-makers can get accommodated in the rural districts. Perhaps I would supply the Deputy with a list. I would like to say that I think a fair average has been struck and I am sorry to see the Deputy wanting to make a fortnight's notice mandatory in the Bill.

Comment on this

This point was also discussed already on another amendment. I agree that as a general rule it is desirable that the employees should get a longer notice than a week as to the date of the commencement of their holidays. But the question we are considering now is not what is a reasonable arrangement between employer and employees in that respect but what is the statutory minimum obligation we are going to impose having regard to the circumstances of some industries and the advisability of conveniencing the employer to the extent that he will be able to fulfil his obligation to give his employees a week's annual holidays during the slack season of his trade and other considerations. It is desirable I think that the minimum statutory obligation in respect of the holidays should not be for longer than a week's notice. I think I am quite certain that the majority of employers will find it not merely advisable but also desirable to give a longer notice. I do not think the giving of more than a week's notice should be made a punishable offence under this Bill. There is an obligation to give at least a week's notice. I think the Bill is better in its present form. In certain cases it might prove detrimental not merely to the interests of the employer but also to the interests of the workers if a longer period were prescribed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:—

In page 14, line 57, at end of Section 28, to add the following sub-section:—

Exclusion regulations made under this section shall be expressed to provide that conditions of employment not less favourable to the workers concerned than the provisions of the enactments mentioned in the Schedule to this Act shall be observed in every undertaking engaged in the form of industrial work to which such exclusion regulations relate.

This amendment is somewhat similar to amendment No. 2, except that amendment No. 2 applies to a certain type of industrial worker. This amendment, however, deals with a somewhat wider issue, because it provides for the issue by the Minister of exclusion regulations, and these exclusion regulations can, of course, be made applicable to industrial undertakings in such a way as to exclude industrial undertakings from the obligation which is provided for the workers in that undertaking by this Bill. As the Minister knows, large sections of the Factory and Workshop Acts are repealed, and the whole of the Employment of Women, Young Persons and Children Act, 1920, is repealed in respect of any form of industrial work. The amendment which I have proposed is designed to ensure, in respect of forms of undertaking in which exclusion regulations are made, that the protection afforded by the Acts repealed by this measure will continue to apply to the workers who are working under the exclusion regulations. I think the Minister ought to grant to the workers that protection in the case of excluded undertakings.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy can have given this matter very careful consideration. Obviously, the only case in which an exclusion order will be made is where it is not possible to observe, in respect of some form of industrial work, the provisions of this Bill. I do not contemplate that the exclusion regulations will be made except where it is not possible—I use the term with its ordinary meaning—to observe the provisions of the Bill. It is the intention to make suitable provision in cases where, having regard to the circumstances of the industry, it is impracticable to observe the strict conditions of this Bill. The only circumstances, therefore, in which exclusion orders will be made will be where it is necessary to enable a particular industry to carry on, but it is not proposed to permit particular workers to work under conditions less favourable than those prescribed in the Bill. One provision is that a man must not be employed after 8 p.m. In some industry which one can conceive the regular practice might be such as to require that workers will be employed after that hour, not on overtime, but on ordinary work. If a case were made to show that the circumstances of the industry were such that that was necessary, then an exclusion order would be made. Obviously, if the amendment were inserted, no such exclusion order could be made, and therefore, in my opinion, the Deputy's amendment cuts right across the intentions of the section as to permit of exclusion orders being made in certain exceptional cases in respect of which the provisions of the Bill cannot be carried out.

Comment on this

The Minister knows that the provisions of the Factory and Workshop Acts and the Employment of Women, Young Persons and Children Act at present apply, if the industry is excluded by exclusion regulations, but they will not if certain provisions set out in this Bill are enacted, because these Acts will be repealed.

Comment on this

No exclusion order can be made except after consultation with the workers and employers. I contemplate such exclusion orders will be associated with agreements or other regulations making special provision for the peculiar circumstances of the trade covered by the exclusion order.

Comment on this

May I take it that, in making the exclusion regulations, the Minister will at least afford the protection now afforded but which will not be afforded when the Factory Acts and the other Act are repealed by this measure?

Comment on this

That would be my intention.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not think it desirable to arm himself with powers in a specific way?

Comment on this

The amendment does not do that. Saturday will be a short day, but an employer may substitute another day for Saturday on giving notice. In certain industries in respect of some class of workers another day cannot be regularly substituted. There may be industries where the short day of the week might change from week to week and the number of workers affected would not be very many, and the number of industries affected would not be very many, but we have to meet that case by an exclusion order. It might be contended that that was a disimprovement of the conditions, but, even if it were, it is necessary to enable the industry to be carried on.

Comment on this

I take it the Minister is going to meet that in fact by his actions in issuing the regulation?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

In page 17, before Section 37 (2), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

This section shall not apply to any industrial work done in or about—

(a) the printing of newspapers, or

(b) the construction, maintenance, alteration, or repair of any telegraphic or telephonic installation, or

(c) the maintenance or working of a broadcasting station maintained and worked under Part II of the Wireless Telegraphy Act, 1926 (No. 45 of 1926).

This amendment, in so far as it affects the printing of newspapers, was discussed already on amendment No. 1. The purpose of this amendment is to exclude from the scope of Section 37, which regulates working hours, persons employed in the printing of newspapers, in the construction, maintenance, alteration or repair of any telegraphic or telephonic installation and in the maintenance or working of a broadcasting station. These classes of persons would necessarily have to be excluded from the scope of the section or else these services could not be carried on. We originally intended that they should be excluded by regulation under Section 28, but on reconsideration it was considered more desirable that the exclusion should be effected in the Bill, because there can be no question as to the need for it.

The effect of the exclusion is to impose no regulation in respect of hours upon these classes of workers, but I do not think that need cause any apprehension, because the conditions under which such persons will be employed will be such that no abuse need be feared. Exclusion from the section involves and implies exclusion from Section 30 and the sections dealing with overtime. The three classes of work which I have mentioned are necessarily done at night. I do not say that all work upon telegraphic or telephonic installation must be done at night, but obviously the work could not be allowed to be left undone, otherwise we would not have any telegraph or telephone services after 8 p.m. and we would have no broadcasting service after 8 p.m. and no newspapers in the morning unless this amendment were inserted. The only question that arises is whether it is more desirable to have the exclusion effected in this way. In so far as the exclusion when made must be permanent, it is more desirable to have it by way of provision in the Bill.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister's statement and I am also pleased to know this amendment brings in an exclusion from Section 30. There is one point the Minister has not dealt with, namely, how far it could be argued that the newspapers were employing shifts. I will ask the Minister if it would be possible to exclude them from Section 31. I need not go over what I said on a previous amendment. The Minister stated that newspapers were not a continual process and I think it is doubtful whether, under the provisions of this Bill, they are actually employing continuous shifts, or shifts at all. At the same time they do employ separate gangs of men and from that point of view it might be argued that they were employing shifts. I would like him in that connection to exclude them from Section 31.

Comment on this

I do not think that is necessary. The industry is clearly not one of those contemplated under Sections 32 or 33. Under Section 32 the industry must be a continuous process industry; that is, an industry the process of which must be carried on continuously and newspaper production is obviously not of that kind. In Section 33 the industries concerned are those which need not necessarily be carried on by a continuous process but are permitted to be carried on in that way. Newspapers are not carried on as a continuous process. As the Bill stands, the regulation of newspaper employment would obviously come in under Section 37. They are to be excluded by this amendment. The result would leave them uncontrolled in respect of hours.

Comment on this

While the Minister may find it necessary to meet some practical difficulty by this amendment, I think, by the manner in which he has attempted to do so, he has gone to quite unnecessary extremes. For instance, in sub-section (b) of the amendment he deals with "the construction, maintenance, alteration, or repair of any telegraphic or telephonic installation" and places that completely outside the section of this Bill dealing with working hours. Let me remind the Minister, as one who knows something about the matter, that it is not necessary to exclude the whole of the staff engaged in that kind of work in order to ensure that a limited number of people working outside the hours 8 p.m. and 8 a.m. may continue to work, in order that telephonic and telegraphic services should not be interrupted. Everyone wants these services to be maintained as one of the necessary things of modern life. Lots of people could make a case for the continuance of broadcasting after 8 p.m. but it would not be necessary to exclude the whole of the broadcasting staff from the scope of the Bill.

Comment on this

They are not excluded from the scope of the Bill.

Comment on this

From the scope of the section. It would have been better to have such exclusion effected under Section 28, because then it would be limited and it could be secured that the exclusion was only in respect of the people that it was proposed to employ from 8 p.m. to 8 a.m.

Comment on this

It would be in respect of a class.

Comment on this

It could be a well-defined class. I think the Minister has been stampeded with regard to excluding these people. If he had proposed it under Section 28 such people could be excluded under Section 37.

Comment on this

There are no such people employed by private employers.

Comment on this

The State is committed to observe the maximum 48 hours.

Comment on this

That section provides the 48 hours.

Comment on this

That is the legal maximum. The State employs people for 48 hours.

Comment on this

If they employ them longer they have to pay overtime.

Comment on this

It may be that the Minister is excluding them from the beneficial portions of this Act. I think he could go back to the exclusion Section 28 and get over the difficulty in that way. In order to provide for the work of 2 per cent. of the telephone and telegraph staff workers who work between 8 p.m. and 8 a.m. the Minister by this new section is excluding the other 98 per cent.

Comment on this

We are not doing any harm. We are not worsening their conditions of employment.

Comment on this

The Bill as it stood was very much better than it is as amended. Forty-eight hours were given as the maximum plus the guarantee that when the Bill was got through we would try to keep the hours below 48.

Comment on this

The particular circumstance here is that the persons engaged are employed by the State. Whatever the State forces upon private employers it can adopt for its own employees. There is no legal difficulty.

Comment on this

It does not seem too much to say that the Government does not want to do it. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has been pressed for the last two years, and I think that is a fairly long period, to reduce the working hours of the group affected by this amendment. The Department of the Minister's colleague takes all that time, and even then we cannot get a decision. I suggest this amendment is unfair. In order to provide a skeleton service between 8 p.m. and 8 a.m. the Minister is by this section taking out 98 per cent. of the workers already in. I think their inclusion is valuable. The Minister ought to be glad to get as many industrial workers as possible within the scope of this section of the Bill. Similarly in the case of the Post Office factory at St. John's Road where telephone parts and instruments are manufactured. These people would also appear to be excluded from the scope of this section. They are clearly industrial workers, yet they are to be excluded by this amendment because the work they do can be described as that particular type of work. Here again if the Minister had relied upon the powers he has under Section 28 he would do the minimum amount of harm instead of tearing through this section in such a brusque way. I hope the Minister will reconsider this matter.

Comment on this

I think this is a desirable way to do it. There are always means open to ensure that the conditions of employment of State employees will not be less favourable than those generally observed.

Comment on this

You are really dealing with the difficulty of 2 per cent. of the service and not 98 per cent.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 71
·
Níl 9
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 11:—

In page 18, line 23, Section 40 (1) (a) after the word "year" to insert the words "or thirty-six hours in any period of four consecutive weeks."

This amendment arises out of a discussion which we had here on the Committee Stage. The Bill permits of certain uncontrolled overtime being worked—not more than two hours in any day, 12 hours in any week, or 240 hours in any year. It was pointed out that the yearly maximum might be concentrated in a short period, and that that would be undesirable. This amendment provides that the overtime worked shall not be more than 36 hours in any period of four weeks; in other words, if the maximum overtime is being worked it cannot be worked continuously for more than three weeks. The next amendment works a similar change in the sub-section which regulates juvenile employment.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Minister's attention has been drawn to one item, not in the amendment, which I would support, but in the section itself. I think the case of the person who has to work overtime has been very fairly met, but I should like to point out to the Minister that two hours on any day is too short, because the employer is allowed to employ the worker on overtime for twelve hours in a week. He would have to be employed on six days, therefore. I suggest to the Minister that he might allow four hours overtime on any day, because that would mean that in three days the overtime for the week could be worked. I am sure the Minister can very easily imagine cases, especially where the job is some distance, or divorced in some way from the work they were doing during the ordinary day, in which it might be desirable for a worker to work four hours overtime on any one day. I think the practice at present, where there is a case such as I have cited, is to work in longer periods than two hours and not to work them on consecutive evenings. I suggest to the Minister that if he would double the overtime for the day and leave the rest stand he would make this section more flexible.

Comment on this

My objection to that is that the purpose of the whole scheme is to discourage the working of overtime as a regular policy. But, if special circumstances should arise necessitating the working of a considerable amount of overtime, if a special job arises which has to be completed within a period involving long hours of work, then it should properly come under Section 41, the following section, under which, on application, a permit to employ workers in excess of the uncontrolled overtime can be given. In other words, work of that kind, involving a considerable amount of overtime, should be foreseeable, whereas the uncontrolled overtime under Section 40 is designed to facilitate the employer who may have work in excess of the normal, the aggregate of which he has been unable to foresee, and which must be done as it arises. But where foreseeable overtime is involved, then Section 41 should be applied and a permit should be sought, and such permit when obtained, would permit of the working of employees in excess of the uncontrolled overtime.

Comment on this

I should like to point out to the Minister that I am not increasing the amount of overtime work in a week, a month, or a year. I am merely allowing what I think is the usual practice. I will not say that it is in any way a universal practice, but, at the same time, it is the practice. I think the workers would themselves prefer to work longer periods on fewer evenings. I should like to point out that Section 41 involves an application to the Minister and a certain amount of foresight, etc. I am not seeking to increase the amount of uncontrolled overtime work. I am merely trying to make the provision more flexible and bring it more into line with the present practice.

Comment on this

I have not any very strong views on the matter, and I should like an opportunity of looking into it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:—

In page 18, line 41, Section 40 (2), to delete the word "particular" and substitute the word "specified."

I have not any strong views on the amendment and simply put it down to see whether the Minister was satisfied that the word "particular" did not restrict the powers which I think he ought to have in the matter.

Comment on this

The particular form of work must be specified in the Order. It is better.

Comment on this

So long as it is not narrowing down the interpretation.

Comment on this

It does not.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14:—

In page 21, line 20, Section 47 (5), after the word "employed" to add the words "provided that nothing in this sub-section shall be deemed to entitle a worker to payment for wages who is present on the premises of his employer and who is there for the purpose of performing outside work which it has been impossible to do owing to the inclemency of the weather."

I was asked to put the amendment down so that the Minister will get an opportunity of clearing up the point as to whether this clause had any effect as regards payment of wages. I do not think it has. It is an interval clause, and, I take it, only refers to the question of that interval and does not include the question of wages.

Comment on this

Quite. There is nothing in the Bill dealing with wages except the section dealing with agreements. In other words, there is nothing in this Bill which compels an employer to pay wages whether for work done or work not done, and this particular provision, which deems a worker to be employed, is only inserted for the purposes of the section, and the section deals solely with intervals of work.

Comment on this

That is what I understood.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 16:—

In page 21, line 35, to add at the end of Section 48 (1), two new paragraphs as follows:—

(f) done in or about the construction, maintenance, alteration, or repair of any telegraphic or telephonic installation.

(g) done in or about the maintenance or working of a broadcasting station maintained and worked under Part II of the Wireless Telegraphy Act, 1926 (No. 45 of 1926).

The purpose of the amendment is to permit of work in connection with telegraphic and telephonic installation and broadcasting to be done on Sundays or public holidays. The same effect could be secured by regulations made under the section, but as such regulations will have to be made and, when made, will have to be permanent, it is better to have provision made in the section itself.

Comment on this

I do not think it is, for the same reason that I have already expressed. If the Minister is to make regulations under the section he can limit the effect of the exclusion. But if he is going to insert an amendment of this kind the effect is to exclude them completely from the benefits of the section.

Comment on this

It does not mean that they will have to work on Sundays, only that they may be employed on Sundays.

Comment on this

That means that it is permissible to employ them on Sundays.

Comment on this

I want to ensure that they cannot be capriciously employed and must only be employed when the need is shown and that the need should be the kind of need that the Minister would permit to be satisfied. It is much better for the Minister to make specific regulations to permit it to be done, rather than to exclude it in this general way.

Comment on this

The Deputy has a weaker case on this than he had earlier. The purpose merely is to make it clear that a worker may be employed, if required, upon the telephone or broadcasting service on Sunday. I do not think we can go without the Sunday telephone or broadcasting.

Comment on this

We can do without the broadcasting. I am not agreeing with the amendment, but I do not mind if you record it as being carried.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 17:—

In page 21, before Section 48 (4), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

The Minister may, if he so thinks proper, by order make regulations permitting, in respect of any particular form of industrial work, the period of twenty-four consecutive hours' rest mentioned in the next preceding sub-section of this section to be given to any worker within seven days after the Sunday on which such worker was so employed as to be entitled under the said next preceding sub-section to such period of rest, and whenever any such regulations are so made the said next preceding sub-section shall have effect subject to the provisions of such regulations.

This amendment is inserted to deal with a special case that may arise. The only illustration I can give is in connection with newspapers again. As the Bill stands, if a worker is employed on Sundays for a period in excess of three hours, he must get a period of twenty-four hours before the following Sunday. Now, workers employed on the printing of morning newspapers start work on Sunday evening, generally, I understand, before 9 o'clock, and consequently are regarded as being employed upon Sunday for the purposes of the section and would be entitled to a period of 24 hours' rest before the following Sunday unless an order were made under this proposed amendment. In fact, they do not work on Saturday and get a period of rest extending from early on Saturday morning until the ordinary starting hour upon Sunday evening—in other words, the full normal period of rest—but it happens to be spread over Saturday and Sunday. It is proposed here to take power in such a case to allow the period of rest to be given within seven days after the Sunday on which the worker was employed. If the section were not changed it would involve considerable dislocation in the matter of morning newspapers.

Comment on this

Having regard to the nature of a certain type of industrial work to which I have referred previously—that is, railway work—I find now that it would be possible for men to be called out on relaying work or bridge work on Sundays. If they could get their rest between that Sunday and the following Sunday, it would be all right, but it is a common occurrence in that type of work that it may entail two, three, and sometimes four Sundays for the completion of the particular bridge or the relaying of the section of line concerned. The men are drawn from the various lengths of line adjacent to that district and it would cause considerable dislocation to have them laid off on the following week because they are specialists in that class of work and it would be impossible to get outside men to do it. Of course, it might only happen once in twelve months, but has the Minister provided for such cases?

Comment on this

To meet that case there would have to be a regulation excluding such workers from this section, but this amendment deals with a different type of case. As I say, the amendment is designed to give us power to vary the provision in regard to the period of rest in certain forms of industrial work.

Comment on this

Any particular form of industrial work?

Comment on this

As an illustration, I gave the case of the printing of daily newspapers, and I think the case that Deputy Keyes mentions can best be met by exclusion from the section.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18:—

In page 21, lines 51-53, Section 48 (4) to delete all words from and including the words "one day's pay", line 51, to and including the word and bracket "leave)" and substitute the words "such sum as would be paid normally for the full number of hours ordinarily worked by a worker on a week-day.

The object of this amendment is that, where a holiday is granted, the payment for that holiday should be that of the normal number of hours that would have been worked on that day. There is a rather complicated arrangement made for the payment of holidays, which would come to a fractional amount. That, I think, will not appeal to the working-men or to the employers. If a man gets a holiday on, say, Monday, he should be paid, in my opinion, for the number of hours he would work if he had been working on a Monday. Similarly, for the other days of the week: if he gets a holiday on a Saturday—and that is normally a short day—he should get paid the short day's salary. I think that anything else is unworkable.

Comment on this

Deputy Beckett is thinking entirely of the case of the man paid by the hour, and obviously his amendment would be entirely inapplicable to the person employed at piece rates. In his case the other system of calculation would have to be applied.

Comment on this

I take it that they will be dealt with on their own. My amendment refers to the normal working day, and the effect of it is that the worker should be paid for that day at the same rate that he would have been paid if he had been working.

Comment on this

But the Deputy is proposing to take out what is in the Bill and insert another set of words which would deal only with one type of worker. The provisions in Section 23, which are transferred up to this section, provide for the calculation of the pay that is to be given, and while I agree that they are perhaps a little elaborate in relation to one public holiday as distinct from the annual holidays, nevertheless I think they are necessary in order to cover all the various types of case that will have to be dealt with.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister see the point of Deputy Beckett's amendment: that, if the holiday is on a Saturday, the worker should not get an ordinary day's pay for the Saturday, which is a short day?

Comment on this

I do not think that is the point Deputy Beckett is raising. That is the point we discussed on the last day, and my answer was that it cancelled out in seven years, whatever the position might be in regard to one year. The section says: "One day's pay, calculated at the rate which would be applicable if such day were a day of annual leave." Section 24 says that, in the case of a worker whose ordinary remuneration is wholly calculated by reference to time—and these are the workers in whom Deputy Beckett is interested—he shall be paid at the rate at which such remuneration was payable immediately before the commencement of such annual leave. I think that meets Deputy Beckett's case quite well and will occasion no difficulty in the case of the class of workers he has referred to. The only case in respect of which an elaborate calculation is required is the case of workers employed at piece rates.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 19:—

In page 22, line 7, Section 48 (4) (d), to delete the words "and fifty" and substitute the words "and twentyfive".

The intention of this amendment is to provide that, where workers are working on short time, there should be an average of hours which will bring them in to qualify. I think Deputy Keyes mentioned last week or the week before last, in discussing this matter, that a large number of employees were working on short hours —I think 35 hours a week—and that they would be disqualified under this clause unless they got a reasonable amount of hours. I suggest that 125 hours would bring them in reasonably.

Comment on this

The amendment is one which the Labour Party would accept enthusiastically, because it is in the interest of the workers. The 150 hours relates to a 48-hour week. I have an amendment down—the next amendment—which is designed to give the Minister power to vary that figure of 150 downwards in the event of the normal working week in any industry being less than 48 hours. If the normal working week is less than 48 hours, then I agree that that figure should be reduced, but where there is a 48-hour week ordinarily worked, then the requirement that the worker shall have worked 150 hours out of the 192 is not unreasonable. The only circumstances under which that figure would have to be reduced would be where the normal week was less than 48 hours, and I am taking power to deal with that position in the next amendment, which, I think, is the most satisfactory way of doing it.

Comment on this

Seeing that the Minister already has experience of industries working less than the 48-hour week and having regard to the fact that a considerable number have been shown to be working on short time, I think the Minister ought to accept Deputy Beckett's amendment. The 125 hours seems to be a very fair proportion. The other works out at 118, I grant you.

Comment on this

It is the same pro portion. This section must be related to the working hours provision which provides for a 48-hour week. So long as the 48-hour week is involved, that figure is not unreasonable.

Comment on this

I suggest, apart from that, that in this particular section, without prejudice to the general alteration made, that you could accept 125 hours during the period of four weeks as being very reasonable. You are only dealing in this section with a four-weeks period, but you have 1,800 hours in the entire year.

Comment on this

That figure 125 is only two-thirds. A man need only work two weeks in three.

Comment on this

That would bring in these people who have a perfectly good claim. I do not know what the Minister has in mind to meet existing circumstances, but I suggest it would be a good thing to take cognisance of that point now.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister if it is his intention to issue a licence in this connection after the Bill becomes law or whether it would be necessary to make application?

Comment on this

To make application is not legally necessary. I do not say that application should not be made because it is always in the interests of the party concerned to bring particular cases to the notice of the officers of the Department who would be dealing with them. The intention is where the normal working week is less than 48 hours that then a reduction in this period will be effected under the proposed amendment. But the maximum must relate to the maximum working week. The number does not mathematically exclude it, but this figure and a similar figure have been fixed, and there must have been 75 per cent. of the full time worked in order to qualify the worker to be considered as "continuously employed."

Comment on this

Until the Minister makes regulations there will be no provision.

Comment on this

Deputy Beckett's amendment is incomparably better than anything the Minister has any notion of. The worker who was employed normally for 48 hours in the week may have been working at only three-quarters time for the last seven years. In that particular case the worker would have to work the full three-quarters time every day, every week, every month in the year in order to get any benefit under this section. The only way in which he could possibly get any benefit is by reducing the number of hours from 150 to 125.

Comment on this

Deputy Beckett is now getting suspicious about his amendment.

Comment on this

He is sufficiently clear about his amendment. He prefaced his remarks by saying that he was struck by the case made the last day, and he expressed agreement with it. The Minister, in fixing these hours at 150 in a period of four weeks, arrived at that by saying: "Take a normal working week at 48 hours; we require a person under this section to work 75 per cent. of that before he can qualify under this section." He is offering in his amendment No. 20 that if the working week is reduced to 44 hours, you are going to get 75 per cent. of 44, but he has no notion of going down to the limits that Deputy Beckett suggests. If it were a 36-hour week, the Minister may draw on his imagination to say that a person may work 75 per cent. of that in order to get the benefit of the section. The amendment is much better than what the Minister proposes in his amendment No. 20. It is incomparably better than anything that the Minister has any notion of doing under that amendment and he should accept it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 48
·
Níl 27
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 20:—

In page 22, before Section 48 (5), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

The Minister may, whenever and so often as he so thinks proper, by order make regulations varying, in respect of all or any particular classes or class of workers, both or either of the periods of 150 hours and 20 hours mentioned in the next preceding sub-section of this section by substituting for such periods or period such other periods or period as the Minister shall think proper, and whenever any such regulations are in force the said next preceding sub-section shall have effect, in respect of the workers or the classes or class of workers to which such regulations apply, as if the said periods or period affected by such regulations were varied in the manner stated in such regulations.

This is the amendment I referred to in the discussion on the previous amendment. In view of the vote on the previous amendment, I take it there will be unanimity in connection with this one.

Comment on this

It is a different amendment, of course.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 22, before Section 48 (5), to insert the following sub-section:—

Where a day mentioned in sub-section (3) of Section 6 has been substituted as a public holiday for a day mentioned in sub-section (1) of that section every worker who by virtue of the provisions of this section would be prohibited from doing any form of industrial work on one of the days mentioned in the said sub-section (1) is entitled to recover from the employer one day's pay (calculated at the rate which would be applicable to overtime work) if he ceases to be employed by such employer at the date of the public holiday substituted as aforesaid.

Is there likely to be the same unanimity on this amendment?

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

Under this Bill it is provided that an employer, on his own initiative, without consulting the workers or the Minister, may substitute a Church holiday for a bank holiday. The Bill is drawn in such an unsatisfactory way from the point of view of the workers that an employer may offer to a worker a Church holiday in December in lieu of, let us say, St. Patrick's Day. In the meantime, he may dismiss the worker. If the worker were employed on St. Patrick's Day and if the employer were required to give him St. Patrick's Day and pay him wages for that day, and if he were required to consult the worker before he made any change such as substituting a Church holiday in December for St. Patrick's Day, then the worker would have got the benefit of receiving wages for St. Patrick's Day. But if he did not get the benefit of wages on St. Patrick's Day, he might lose his employment between that day and the date of the Church holiday in December.

This Bill in its present form could conceivably be used by employers to deprive workers of the six bank holidays to which they are entitled. The Minister must admit that under the Bill the employer can say to a worker that he proposes to substitute the 1st November, a Church holiday, for, let us say, Easter Monday. In other words, he postpones the day due to the worker for a period of seven months. In the meantime he may dismiss the worker and then the worker will be in the position that he will not get paid for Easter Monday or 1st November. That would be obviously unfair. This amendment seeks to provide that if the employer, on his own initiative, substitutes a Church holiday subsequent to the normal bank holiday for that bank holiday, and if the worker is dismissed in the meantime, the employer should be required to pay him wages in respect of the substituted bank holiday. The Minister, I think, should accept the amendment.

Comment on this

The notice which the employer gives is a notice not to an individual worker but to all persons in his employment. He cannot act in that way in respect of an individual worker. He must fix by notice the day on which all the workers in his employment will get a Church holiday in lieu of the public holiday. There is nothing in the Bill to prevent that Church holiday being a day previous to the public holiday.

Comment on this

Except that it is unlikely.

Comment on this

It is just as likely, particularly having regard to the fact that the two public holidays which cannot be substituted both occur in the same period of the year, Christmas Day and St. Patrick's Day. They cannot be substituted; they must be observed in any event. I have had regard to that fact and it is not at all improbable that a Church holiday before a bank holiday may be fixed. The notice of substitution is one that applies to the workers.

Comment on this

Surely that does not cover the point. If notice is given jointly in respect to the holidays will not that cover the individual?

Comment on this

The employer must still observe the six public holidays in the year and must give holidays to workers employed upon these days by him. Deputy Norton is talking about an employer who maliciously defrauds an individual worker. That cannot be done by an employer who shuts down his factory altogether. He cannot gain anything by the tactics which Deputy Norton says he might adopt.

Comment on this

Will the Minister admit that it is possible for an employer to say to his worker: "I am not going to give you any pay for Easter Monday?"

Comment on this

He might say: "We are going to work on Easter Monday."

Comment on this

That is a day the worker would normally be paid for. If the employer is going to say to the worker, "I am not going to pay you for being absent on Easter Monday——

Comment on this

If he says that to all his workers.

Comment on this

And if he says "but I will pay you instead on the 8th December," the employer may have a certain number of workers on Easter Monday, but between Easter Monday and the 8th December some may have left his employment and who is to pay those who had left before the 8th December comes round? These people were clearly entitled to payment for the bank holiday when it arrived. The substitution portion is a secondary consideration. The prior consideration is the recognition of the six days as bank holidays. Now, this worker that I have been mentioning is entitled to pay for Easter Monday, but he is told that he will not be paid for that day, and that he will have to wait until the 8th December. Meantime, the employer pays off some of his men including this man because there is no work for them. If it gets to that stage the man is not paid for the six days' holidays, so that what is being done has deprived the worker when he was in employment of his Easter Monday holiday with pay.

Comment on this

Some other worker gets the benefit on the 8th December.

Comment on this

Does the Minister really mean that? Is that said definitely or is it another try on?

Comment on this

Provided the employer substitutes the 8th December or any other date there will be employees employed by him on that day who will get the benefit.

Comment on this

That is a most fantastic argument. Clearly these people will get the holidays they are entitled to. It is possible under the Minister's amendment for a man, by dodging in and out of employment to get 12 public holidays. I suggest the Minister should reflect a bit before he tries to get that argument that he has used into his service. He really ought to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister might clear up one point. Supposing an employer employs fewer men on the 8th December than on Easter Monday what is his position?

Comment on this

That may happen. The provisions of this Bill in relation to holidays are only of very special interest to the workers who are, more or less, in continuous employment. The workers not in continuous employment may complain that they are getting too many holidays. It is workers who are continually employed who benefit by these holidays.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 23
·
Níl 53
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendments Nos. 22 and 23:—

22. In page 23, line 10, Section 49 (4) (b), after the word "worker" to insert the words "or for any such worker to accept any employment or payment with or from any such employer".

23. In page 23, line 16, Section 49 (4) (c), after the word "section" to add the words "and if any such worker accepts any employment or payment in contravention of the said next preceding paragraph, such worker shall also be guilty of an offence under this section".

On the last day I indicated my intention of introducing those amendments, which are necessary in order to make the enforcement of the agreed rate of wages effective. The purpose of the amendments is to make it an offence for the worker to accept—as it is an offence for the employer to pay—less than the agreed rate.

Comment on this

In Section 49, sub-section (8)——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot speak on the section on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I only want to point out to the Minister a certain redundancy of words for the purpose of correcting them at this stage. I do not propose to discuss the section.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Very well.

Comment on this

In Section 49 (8) the words "the High Court may" are repeated, and should be deleted.

Comment on this

Yes. That correction is necessary.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 24:—

In page 26, before Section 53 (2), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

No proceedings shall be taken against any person for a breach of any of the provisions of this Part of this Act if immediate notification (together with such particulars as will enable the Minister to identify the particular piece of work in which such emergency arose) is sent to the Minister of an occurrence of any such emergency as comes within the provisions of sub-section (1) of this section, and if the Minister is satisfied that such an emergency as aforesaid did in fact exist.

I understood the Minister to agree with me on the Second Reading that work of an emergency character, say in regard to burst water mains and so on, would be provided for. At the time, I made a suggestion that the work should be undertaken immediately, and that immediate notice should be given to his Department. Under the Bill as it stands at present, if a contractor undertakes work of national importance—say it is in regard to some dangerous structure, or the stopping of a serious water wastage—he may possibly have to defend an action in court for having successfully done that necessary work, and that is an unfair position in which to put any contractor or workman. I suggest that the clause embodied in the amendment would meet the whole case, and that the Minister should adopt it. It would mean that the Minister would get immediate notice, and that the contractor would not be put to the annoyance of having an inspector stepping in and summoning him to court. He would have a good case to defend, but having done probably very unpleasant work he should not be put in the position of having to defend himself.

Comment on this

I can tell the Deputy that what he sets out in this amendment will undoubtedly be the practice so far as the Minister is concerned, but the Bill does not provide that the proceedings must be taken at the suit of the Minister only. It provides that proceedings may be instituted by the Minister, but proceedings may be instituted otherwise than by the Minister, in which case the Deputy's amendment would appear to be inoperative. In any event it is perhaps undesirable to put the Minister in the position of judging the facts. What we are providing in the Bill is that it shall be a good defence for an employer, if proceedings are taken against him, to show that the circumstances which gave rise to the working contrary to the provisions of the Act were due to an emergency, but the proceedings might be instituted by a party other than the Minister, and, in those circumstances, the mere fact that a notification had been sent to the Minister would not be sufficient to prevent the proceedings taking place. So far as the Minister is concerned, it is certain that he would not institute proceedings against an employer unless the circumstances were different from those described in the amendment. If he had received notification of the fact that such nonobservance of the Act had taken place, due to an emergency, and if he satisfied himself that there was an emergency, he would not institute proceedings, but, as the Bill stands, it is open to any person, in the guise of a common informer, to start proceedings.

Comment on this

Is it a Guard who will start proceedings or an official of the Minister? What does the Act provide for?

Comment on this

What we are providing is that if proceedings are taken against an employer for a breach of the Act, it will be a perfectly good defence for him to show that the circumstances which gave rise to the breach were circumstances of emergency. That is as far, I think, as we can go in the legislation; otherwise, we are taking the function of deciding the facts from the court and giving it to the Minister, or to an official of the Minister, which would be undesirable in the circumstances.

Comment on this

Does the Minister realise that he is putting a difficulty in the way of getting that work done at all?

Comment on this

I think that in actual practice very few prosecutions will be taken otherwise than at the suit of the Minister, and obviously the Minister will not prosecute unless he is satisfied that there has been a breach of the Act in spirit as well as in fact.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:—

In page 28, Section 60, to delete all words from the word "on" in line 46 to the word "grounds", line 48.

The amendment is a verbal one. Deputy Norton drew attention to the fact that the words in Section 60 which it is proposed to delete really did not add to the meaning and might confuse its interpretation. I have no objection to the deletion of the words for which Deputy Norton pressed. The effect of the deletion is to leave the sense of the section unchanged.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

When will the next stage be taken?

Comment on this

To-morrow.

Comment on this

Is it necessary to take it to-morrow?

Comment on this

I think it desirable to get rid of it, now that we have gone through it, and have it sent forward to the Seanad.

Comment on this

Are we to take all the stages to-morrow?

Comment on this

There is only one more stage. There can be no more amendments.

Final Stage ordered for to-morrow.

Comment on this