We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill, 1935—Fifth Stage.

Contributions 1–236 of 450. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 39 of 1935 ›

Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

Scarcely once has the discussion on this Bill been directed to the merits of the measure or the alternatives in regard to it which were put before the House by the Government and the Opposition, respectively. I make an honourable exception of Deputy MacDermot, who, in his two speeches, has addressed himself to the fundamental question at issue. The alternatives are either to do what the Bill seeks to do, to clear up at once the doubts which are alleged to exist as to the intentions of the Oireachtas in regard to the Guarantee Fund and the purchase annuities or to do as the Opposition suggest, to await the result of an action in the courts before dealing with the problem which these alleged doubts have created. There might be some merit in adopting the latter alternative if the intention of the Oireachtas in regard to this matter had been for one instant other than clear and certain or if, in equity and justice, any other course were open to the Government than that which we now propose. But when inevitably the result would be the same, when inevitably the Dáil would make the Guarantee Fund liable for any deficiency in the Purchase Annuities Fund, what good purpose would be served by allowing the moneys of the ratepayers and taxpayers to be spent in purposeless litigation?

It may be argued that the intention of the Dáil in regard to the Guarantee Fund could only be carried out by retrospective legislation if we waited until the courts had decided. But that is a mistaken view. It would not be necessary to legislate retrospectively in order to rectify the effects of a decision by the courts, adverse to the Exchequer, in this matter. A Bill could be introduced dealing only with the immediate and future liability of the Guarantee Fund, and for the rest, it has to be remembered, that the greater part of the grants which constitute the Guarantee Fund are annual grants voted by the Dáil, from year to year, upon that condition. Not only are these grants variable amounts but the conditions that attach to them, and the regulations which govern their distribution, can be varied from year to year, and in fact have been varied on numerous occasions since the Dáil came into existence. What, therefore, can be gained by litigation except this: that lawyers would be feed upon both sides, that the time of the courts would be occupied in the consideration of the legal arguments that would have little practical effect upon the ultimate issue, and that private individuals, who have claims upon the time of the courts, would be prejudiced, as I said, so that this purposeless action would be argued out. The ultimate result would be no different, but the taxpayers' and the ratepayers' money would be spent and the time of the court would be occupied.

Yet it is argued that we should allow public money to be wasted in such litigation, and the time of the courts to be occupied. That is the only practical alternative in the pro posals that the Opposition have advanced. As I said, the Guarantee Fund is constituted of public moneys provided from year to year by the Dáil. And the Dáil is at liberty at any time to regulate the distribution of these grants and to attach to them any conditions it wishes to attach. I think the consideration of these fundamental facts will dispose effectively of the Deputy, who without sense or sensibility and who, out of oafish pride and asinine prejudice, interfered in this debate to bellow or bray the word embezzlement in this matter. No such epithet can be applied to the Government's action and such an interjection in this debate is merely indicative of the legal illiteracy of the Deputy who used it.

Now let us come once more to the merits of the course which the Dáil is adopting in regard to the Guarantee Fund, to the action which the Government is taking in carrying out what were the avowed intentions of the Dáil in regard to it. Let us see what the position might have been on the 31st of July last if we had done other than we have done in regard to this fund and carried out what appears to be the desires of those who launched these legal proceedings against the Government in regard to it. Yesterday I gave some striking figures to the Dáil. I pointed out that poor counties like Monaghan, Cavan, Donegal and Mayo had practically paid the full amount of the annuities, collectible from them, since the 1st of November, 1933; and that other counties like Cork, Tipperary, Tipperary South, Westmeath and Waterford had failed to do what the poorer farmers in those other counties had succeeded in doing.

Comment on this

For what cause?

Comment on this

The Deputy asks me what the cause was. Nobody knows better than the Deputy what is the cause of the state of affairs that existed in Cork on the 31st of July last. I pointed out in the course of the debate that the effect of the attitude which the Opposition desires us to adopt in regard to the Guarantee Fund would be that the poorer section of the community who have discharged their obligations in relation to the land purchase agreements would be mulcted in order that the more fortunate, who are buying the more fertile lands in this country, might be free of their purchase obligations. I know that sometimes values in that relation, when expressed as percentages, do not bring home in very concrete form what in reality they are. I have, therefore, gone to the trouble to work out what the position might have been in July, 1935, if the Guarantee Fund had not been liable for the deficiencies in the Purchase Annuities Fund and if, in fact, the Central Fund of the Exchequer had been liable instead to make good these deficiencies. The amount in arrears on the 31st July was, approximately, £1,350,000. If that deficiency were to be made good by the Central Fund it would entail an increase of 9/- per head in the taxation of every man, woman and child in the Free State.

Comment on this

What gales were included in that?

Comment on this

All gales from the 1st November, 1933, to the 31st of July, 1935. They are the last figures we have available. The position would be that every man, woman and child would have to accept an increased imposition of 9/- per head in order to make good that deficiency. Then consider what the position would have been in relation to some of these counties. In Louth, which is a party to these proceedings, on the 31st of July last under the existing condition of affairs Louth as a county might only be called upon to make good a deficiency of £15,181, but under the new dispensation which the Louth Council is now seeking to bring about the contingent liability of the inhabitants of Louth County as a whole would have jumped up to £29,000. In Cavan— for which Deputy McGovern sits and, I think, Deputy O'Reilly—on the 31st July, 1935, the total amount of the annuity arrears was £16,079. To-day Deputy McGovern or—I do not want to prejudge him; he is not here—yesterday and last week voted to bring about a condition of affairs in which his constituents in County Cavan, instead of being responsible for only £16,000 arrears, would have had, or rather might have had, to find £38,000. In Donegal the amount of the arrears on 31st July, 1935, was—as, no doubt, Deputy McMenamin will recollect, because I hope he took a note of my figures yesterday—£10,188—but yesterday and last week Deputy McMenamin voted to inflate the contingent liability of the poor farmers of County Donegal to £71,000.

Comment on this

And I am going to repeat it to-day, and tell them what you are.

Comment on this

He wants to multiply seven-fold the burden of the poverty-stricken areas of Donegal.

Comment on this

How does the Minister arrive at the £71,000?

Comment on this

I have already explained. Every man, woman and child in Donegal would have to find an extra 9/- a year.

Comment on this

You have put £15 a head on them already.

Comment on this

The position in Leitrim—there are some Deputies here, even on the Opposition Benches, I think, from Leitrim—on the 31st July was that the amount of arrears was £8,681. Under the new dispensation, by which we are told the burden upon the taxpayer and the honest farmer is going to be lightened, they would have to find £26,000 in County Leitrim.

Comment on this

All this stuff is hypothetical.

Comment on this

It is idiotic.

Comment on this

Must that be multiplied by 66?

Comment on this

In Monaghan, where the amount of arrears on 31st July last was £7,906, if the Dáil had not intended that the Guarantee Fund should be liable for the deficiencies in the Purchase Annuities Fund, the amount of the contingent liability of the County Monaghan taxpayers and ratepayers would be not less than £30,000.

Comment on this

Why do you not collect it?

Comment on this

In County Dublin——

Comment on this

You had better attend to that or you might have to go back to Monaghan.

Comment on this

In County Dublin, where the amount of the contingent liability was about £31,000, if Deputy Belton had his way the ratepayers and taxpayers might have to find £88,000.

Comment on this

Can you give us an explanation of that?

Comment on this

There is a representative of the City of Dublin here; a representative of the City of Dublin who never makes a public pronouncement at a social function in which he is not at pains to refer to the cost of living in Dublin, and to declare that it is higher than it is in other places. That Deputy yesterday and on previous occasions voted to increase the annual burden on the ratepayers of County Dublin by a possible £326,000.

Comment on this

Multiplied by 66?

Comment on this

I should have said £147,000.

Comment on this

It does not matter!

Comment on this

A few extra thousands do not matter.

Comment on this

It does matter. Nevertheless he voted. His vote was a vote to impose an additional £147,000 on the rates of County Dublin, where most of his constituents —the people who vote for him; the people whose hand he is ready to shake—had not even enough land, as Deputy Belton has often said, to sod a lark. All those people in Marlborough Street, in Gloucester Street, in the slums of our City, would have had to find, if the Lord Mayor's intentions were carried out, an additional £147,000.

Comment on this

If everybody would lose, who would win? Somebody must win.

Comment on this

This is a joke.

Comment on this

It might be a joke for a representative of County Roscommon——

Comment on this

The Minister's reasoning is all bad.

Comment on this

——because on 31st July this year Roscommon was liable for £43,000 odd. If the Deputy had his way—he is not quite so bad as Deputy McMenamin or Deputy McGovern or even Deputy Roddy—he was going to secure a slight reduction; Roscommon may have been liable for only £39,000. But what of the position of Mayo? The Deputy has a colleague on the front bench representing Mayo. In the case of Mayo, whereas it was liable for only £18,000 last July, if Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and Deputy Brennan had their way it would have been liable for about £33,000. As I say, Deputy Brennan may regard it as a joke, but what about Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and the voters who sent him here? Will they regard it as a joke?

Comment on this

The Minister's reasoning is all a joke.

Comment on this

Oh, I see. Well, will the Deputy tell us how we are going to get those moneys? If this action is going to be effective at all, and if the Government says: "We are going to disregard what was the plain and clear intention of the Dáil when it passed the Land Act of 1933; we are not going to enforce the Guarantee Fund procedure," will the Deputy tell us where we are going to get those moneys that are impounded in the Guarantee Fund?

Comment on this

Keep your promise about the £2,000,000.

Comment on this

The Deputy relies on a newspaper advertisement to get him out of this dilemma.

Comment on this

I am not as fond of that as you are.

Comment on this

That surely is a case of inordinate belief in the value of paper money——

Comment on this

Put him on the Banking Commission.

Comment on this

——but unfortunately I do not happen to be a paper Minister. In considering those matters I have to consider the financial effect of them. It is quite easy for Deputy McMenamin and others, who are completely and wholly irresponsible, to come here and say: "Oh, we are going to vote that the central Exchequer should find this money." And, in case there might be any doubt as to what the attitude of the Opposition in regard to this Bill really is, I think it was stated, by implication, when Deputy Cosgrave said:

"No matter who goes short, no matter what privations are caused throughout the length and breadth of the country, in no circumstances is the Central Fund to be short one penny. Is that justice or does it show consideration for the maintenance of local services?"

What conclusion are we to draw from that statement of the leader of the Opposition except this, that the Central Fund must provide this deficiency? Which horse are Deputies going to ride? Either the Central Fund finds this money with the effect which I have related upon the constituencies of Donegal, Mayo, Sligo, Leitrim, Monaghan, and Cavan—of all the constituencies where an honest attempt is being made to meet their obligations under the Land Purchase Act, or else the Guarantee Fund must be held liable for the deficiencies in the collection of the annuities. Deputies cannot have it both ways. Their leader has pointed out what is the plain consequence of the attitude which they have taken up here, that if they succeed in preventing us from making clear what has always been the intention of the Oireachtas in regard to the Guarantee Fund, the only alternative is that the Central Fund must make good the deficiency, and the Central Fund, as I have said, can only make it good in one or other of two ways, either by increasing taxation or by reducing expenditure.

Comment on this

That is what the county councils have to do—to increase the rates when you reduce the grants.

Comment on this

And to avoid frivolous and vexatious legislation, particularly by county councils such as the County Council of Dublin——

Comment on this

They showed you how to do business.

Comment on this

Let us see one of the reasons why the Central Fund should not be made liable for this deficiency. I have pointed out that one of the reasons why it should not be is that the people among the community as a whole, who are not reaping any immediate or direct benefit from these land purchase transactions, should not be called upon to make good the default of people who have entered into agreements to buy land and who are failing to discharge their obligations under those agreements.

Comment on this

They are not failing to pay £6 per head on their cattle. Will the Minister apply himself to that?

Comment on this

It has nothing to do with the case.

Comment on this

Of course not, but the people have to pay it and the Minister will not deal with it.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to ride his hobby-horse he ought to take it out to Leinster Lawn and prank on it.

Comment on this

The Minister is riding his hobby-ass.

Comment on this

I was saying that it would not be just and it would not be equitable to ask the general body of the community to make good the default of those who, through the good offices and with the assistance of the community, are now purchasing land which they once held as tenants at will. It would not be equitable to do that nor would it be just. Moreover, in view of the extraordinary efforts which the community as a whole is making to complete the distribution of land in this country, and to enable working farmers to become owners of their holdings, it would be unreasonable, even on the part of Deputies like Deputy Belton and others, to ask that they should. The actual expenditure on the work of the Land Commission for the year 1934-5 was £995,000, and of that £995,000 no less than £547,000 went to meet the deficiencies in the Land Bond Fund arising from the revision of the annuities under the Land Act of 1933.

Comment on this

May I point out that the Land Bond Fund is not concerned with this measure, good, bad or indifferent. Is the Minister in order in introducing it?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On the Fifth Stage of a Bill the debate is confined to what is contained in the Bill. The Land Bond Fund is not in this Bill.

Comment on this

I was merely giving details of this expenditure. I submit that it is relevant to defend what is in the Bill on the ground that the community is already doing enough for those who have liabilities towards the Purchase Annuities Fund. The total amount was £995,000 actual expenditure——

Comment on this

Is it in order to discuss the land bond arrangement? This Bill has no reference to it good, bad or indifferent.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not in order to discuss the Land Bond Fund now.

Comment on this

I am not discussing the Land Bond Fund.

Comment on this
Deputies

Accept the ruling.

Comment on this

Certainly I am accepting the ruling. I was not discussing the Land Bond Bill. I merely referred to it in passing and I was not discussing its merits or otherwise. The estimated expenditure for the present year is £1,230,000 and the Opposition are going to vote against the Bill on the ground that the £1,230,000 which we are providing and are spending for the purchase and distribution of land is insufficient.

Comment on this

I again raise the point that the Minister's statement is connected with land bonds. Land bonds are not involved in connection with this Bill.

Comment on this

I could show the Deputy, if I chose to pursue the matter, that the land bonds are——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair holds that land bonds are not connected with this Bill. The Minister must cease discussing them.

Comment on this

Because the Guarantee Fund applies to land bonds and this Bill relates to the Guarantee Fund, and these annuities are a charge on the Guarantee Fund——

Comment on this

Where is that?

Comment on this

Has the Deputy read the Bill?

Comment on this

Very carefully.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy remember the Long Title of the Bill:

An Act to remove doubts as to the liability of the Guarantee Fund under the Land Purchase Acts of 1933, 1923, 1909 and 1903——

Comment on this
Deputies

Chair, Chair!

Comment on this

——for the recoupment of deficiencies in the Purchase Annuities Fund and to define such liability?

When I mentioned land bonds, I was dealing with the point mentioned in the Long Title of the Bill. However, I am not going to argue that. I merely make the point that we are spending already £1,230,000.

Comment on this
A Deputy

There is nothing about that in the Bill.

Comment on this

If the Oireachtas were to reverse what was its clear intention in 1933, we would have in addition to the £1,230,000 to find £750,000 at least.

Comment on this

Not a single penny of it.

Comment on this

If I were permitted to traverse all the misleading statements which the Deputy has made himself responsible for, I am afraid it would occupy more than an hour or two. On another occasion I shall take the opportunity to tell the Deputy what is the Copyright Bill of 1929.

Comment on this
A Deputy

The Minister does not know what is in the Land Bill he passed.

Comment on this

He has enough to do correcting his own errors.

Comment on this

This Bill has been attacked because it is alleged to be without precedent. I do not propose and did not propose to base any substantial part of my case for this Bill upon precedent. The matter arose out of a statement made by Deputy Dillon on the First Reading of the Bill, when he said that legislation of this sort was without precedent in the State. I think I showed that there were many precedents for a Bill with retrospective effect. I do not propose to argue the merits or demerits of any of the measures to which I referred. I do not think that it would serve any useful purpose. Each measure must stand or fall on its own merits. But, Deputy McGilligan, speaking on the Committee Stage last night, said there never had been a Bill brought in here to reverse a decision of the Supreme Court of this country. I think the Deputy's recollection in that connection is grievously at fault. I am looking at the Copyright Act to which I referred a moment ago. The Deputy said that, as the result of an action which had been taken by, I think, the Performing Rights Society, the Supreme Court found that over a certain period copyright did not exist in this country in regard to certain publications and certain works of art. Here is the first section of the Copyright (Preservation) Act, 1929:

Every copyright which was subsisting in the late United Kingdom on the 5th day of December, 1921, shall subsist and be deemed always to have subsisted in Saorstát Eireann as fully in all respects, whether as to duration, force, effect, limitation, obligation, or otherwise as the same would have so subsisted if the Copyright Act 1911 had always been, now were, and hereafter continued to be in full force and effect in Saorstát Eireann.

Comment on this

Tell us what that means.

Comment on this

If that means anything it means this, that whereas the Supreme Court found that, in a certain interim period, copyright in certain publications and musical compositions did not exist in this country, that the Supreme Court found them to have been nonexistent, Section 1 of this Act nullifies the finding of the Supreme Court and declares in express terms that they always existed here, even during the interim period.

Comment on this

What has this got to do with the Fifth Stage of this Bill?

Comment on this

This is directed to the retrospective effect of the Bill.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister will allow the Chair to say.

Comment on this

You ought not to press that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On the Committee Stage of this Bill yesterday the matters now referred to were argued. They are at least as relevant on the Fifth Stage. If, however, all the alleged parallels to and precedents for this measure are to be discussed on the Fifth Stage I fear that discussion will be prolonged.

Comment on this

I do not propose to discuss the merits or demerits of this measure.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Minister were allowed to discuss one precedent other Deputies would be entitled to cite and compare others.

Comment on this

I would be quite prepared, if it were universally accepted by the House, not to address myself to this point.

Comment on this

The Minister cannot get away with it like that.

Comment on this

This Bill has not been discussed here upon any other basis than that it is a measure with retrospective effect. The merits of the measure have not been discussed.

Comment on this

They have.

Comment on this

I do not intend to dilate at any great length on this, but I am merely bringing to the touchstone of truth that statement of Deputy McGilligan's, that never did an Act of the Oireachtas nullify the effect of a decision of the Supreme Court of this country. I think I have shown that that statement, like most of Deputy McGilligan's statements, is the nearest approximation he can ever get to the truth.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say in respect of what case it nullifies a Supreme Court decision?

Comment on this

I do not want to enter into that. If the Deputy is incapable of reading and understanding the words of the statute I cannot help him any further.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that that section set aside a decision of the Supreme Court between the parties thereto?

Comment on this

Another point that has been made in the course of a discussion is that the Oireachtas is not entitled to apply the Guarantee Fund to these annuities because we are no longer, they say, collecting land annuities, we are collecting revenue from land—a land tax. Deputy Dillon used that argument. The land annuities are not a land tax; they are not paid as revenue. If the land annuities are a land tax then Deputy Belton, Deputy Holohan, Deputy Finlay, Deputy Fagan, Deputy O'Donovan, and other farmer Deputies have no right or title in their land. That is the ground upon which the Opposition are basing their case in this matter.

Comment on this

We will argue it any day.

Comment on this

They are arguing by implication that they are merely paying a tax and that they have got no title in their lands.

Comment on this

We are paying the annuities as well.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The elected representatives of the people should be able to exercise self-restraint in debate.

Comment on this

These annuities are not collected as a tax. They are collected in fulfilment of a purchase agreement which Deputies entered into with the Land Commission.

Comment on this

What do you call what is collected by England?

Comment on this

The Deputy can leave that out of his mind.

Comment on this

It has gone out of his pocket.

Comment on this

If England is collecting anything from us by way of these taxes, and I say "if she is," every individual in this State is contributing to it, and it is not being paid solely, and I say it is not even being paid mainly, by some farmers in this country.

Comment on this

How does the Minister explain that?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is another story.

Comment on this

Yes, that is another story, and I do not want to digress. But I am saying that the Land Commission collects these annuities from Deputy Holohan on the presentation of a receivable order relating to the holding which he has purchased from the Land Commission, and every payment which he has made to the Land Commission is part of that purchase price. Every payment he makes decreases the number of payments which he will have to make until the day when the land is his without having to make any further payments in regard to it. It is his, then, in fee simple without any prior charge or equity. If this were a land tax the Deputy would not be in that happy position. He would have to go on paying it indefinitely. These annuities are part of the purchase price of the holding and if the people from whom these annuities are due fail to pay them, the time will come when their title to that land will lapse and the State or any other authority can claim——

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister if there is any Sinking Fund now accumulating to the farmer's credit?

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that a person whose title is registered is not the fee simple owner of his land?

Comment on this

Not until he has completed the purchase.

Comment on this

Then may I tell the Minister that whoever told him that, does not know the first thing about law?

Comment on this

There is a prior charge on the land, and when that is paid——

Comment on this

The Minister does not know anything about fee simple ownership.

Comment on this

We have exhibited on the other side here all the Northern rudeness.

Comment on this

That is good from Belfast.

Comment on this

I say on the other side.

Comment on this

The Minister went beyond his depth that time.

Comment on this

No, I made it quite clear——

Comment on this

By retrospective legislation.

Comment on this

——that in so far as the tenant has a title to the fee simple it is subject to prior charges and prior interest to the Land Commission until the day when the tenant purchaser discharges his debt to the Land Commission. That is the position and these annuities are not, therefore, a land tax. They are simply purchase instalments paid upon the holding of the tenant and Deputies cannot get over that fact. If people wish to upset their title to the land by refusing to pay the annuities, they may be perfectly certain that this community as a whole will not stand for that. There are too many people in our towns and cities without land. There are too many agricultural labourers without land for such a position of affairs as that to be allowed to exist for a moment. What the Deputies on the other side behind this agitation are doing in a short-sighted way is to create an agrarian problem, which they will be sorry they ever initiated. We were told in this House yesterday by a Deputy that this was an abuse of democracy. Deputy MacDermot referred to it. He referred to the statement made by a Deputy that what we were doing here was an abuse of democracy. It was alleged that I have said that we were acting for the majority in this matter and that we were enforcing our will. I said on the Second Reading of this Bill and made it clear that the people who were competent to speak for the Oireachtas as a whole are the people who are the responsible Ministers, who have the support of the majority of the Oireachtas. It has been said that, because I said that, we were heading for a dictatorship. We have had sneers here from Deputies opposite. An attempt was made, I think, on the part of the Leader of the Opposition, to represent the action of the Oireachtas as the action of the majority of a caucus. He said that it was possible for people to meet, and, by a mere majority, that meeting could decide upon a certain course of action there and then, and afterwards come in here and carry that through. The Deputy endeavoured to hold up to opprobrium the institutions of this State. I think this is a great disservice. I think that the Deputy who does that forgets his own past. This country has gone through great sacrifices to establish the right of majority rule here.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Yes, I am quite prepared to say that Deputy Cosgrave and his Party established that principle and we are here to preserve it.

Comment on this

If I bore an honourable name as Deputy O'Higgins bears an honourable name; if I professed to uphold the principles which another holder of that name professed, I certainly would not make the speech which Deputy O'Higgins made in the Dáil yesterday, because I feel that if I did a person could get up and level at me the epithet "hypocrite." I am just as concerned and have always been as concerned as the Opposition are on this question of majority rule. I am concerned, now that we have come out of the revolutionary stage, to say that it is accepted by the people of this country as the rule of conduct and the determinant in national affairs. Deputies on the opposite benches ought to be very chary before they bring that principle into contempt. There are people and sections in this country that we know are against majority rule.

Comment on this

People who were told by the Minister's Party in this House that they were right.

Comment on this

Whatever they were told, anyway, the principle is that we are all here accepting it. Majority rule is what exists here at the present moment, and it is what we desire to see existing in the future and that is what counts. However this vote may go and whatever disabilities or disadvantages the rule of the majority may impose on the minority, we are all now accepting the voice of the majority as the voice of the Oireachtas—the voice of the people.

Comment on this

Within the last few minutes we went very near launching off into another type of discussion which would be quite useful and quite interesting, but which I think would obscure the whole position with regard to what this Bill proposes to do. I think that this House would regret very much if it did not make an attempt to see what this Bill proposes to do. It would regret very much if it did not discuss that and take its decision with some plain facts before it as to what was proposed to be done under the Bill. This Bill proposes to put on the backs of the paying farmer and ratepayers of this country the debts of those people who do not pay their land annuities. The Minister insists that these debts will go on the backs of the paying farming ratepayers. The position of the taxpayer at present is such that he cannot bear another penny. It was suggested by the Minister, in his speech last night, that the burden was not going to be too heavy in the future. It is essential that we should know whether or not the burden that is going to fall on the paying ratepayers of this country, in respect of deficiencies in the collection of the land annuities, is going to be a big burden or not. The Minister suggested last night that it was going to be small, but he rather drifted into a position to-day which gave us much more information than the information he was prepared to give us last night.

He fired a terrible shot into the hearts of the Opposition in the eyes of the people when he pointed out, as a result of all the arithmetical calculations that were made between last night and this morning, what kind of a burden the Opposition were going to put on the country. But it was a trailer bullet; it had a little tail after it that gave us a lot more information than the Minister was prepared to give us last night. Last night this thing was getting small, but the Minister's figures to-day show that not only will the local authorities lose the £716,000 that was taken out of their pockets last year, but that they are going to lose more this year, because the Minister has indicated that if the balances were struck, not on the 31st January this year, but on the 31st July this year, instead of £1,089,000, which was the gross total withheld from local authorities on 1st February this year, there is going to be an additional £270,400 withdrawn. The contingent liability on the Guarantee Fund on 31st July was £1,350,000. The total liability on the Guarantee Fund on 1st February, five months before that, was only £1,089,600. It was fully subtracted from the local authorities when the Minister took the £716,000 at the beginning of this year. Not only on that reckoning are the local authorities going to be stuck for the £716,000, but in the gross there is another bill for £270,400 prepared for them.

The Minister told us the number of counties in which a heavy burden would be imposed at the rate of 9/- a head, even though that were not multiplied by 66, the magic figure. He told us the amount that would have to be raised from these counties. He has only given us those counties in which there is a small further deficit in the payment of land annuities. From the figures he gives us, not only need Donegal—if the amounts were struck on the 31st July—not expect a return of any moneys withheld from it on the 1st February, but it would get a further bill for £3,917. The Leitrim people not only would not get their money back, but they would get a further bill for £1,808.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us how he gets those figures?

Comment on this

The Minister can tell us if these figures are wrong.

Comment on this

I am afraid they are.

Comment on this

I will tell the Minister how I got them. The Minister says that the total contingent liability on the Guarantee Fund in respect of Donegal on the 31st July of this year was £10,018. Does he deny that?

Comment on this

That is quite correct.

Comment on this

Does he deny that the total amount withheld from Donegal up to February, 1935, was £6,101, £3,552 of which was withdrawn in the beginning of this year and the remainder had already been withdrawn? I figure it out by my arithmetic that if the Minister had withdrawn a total of £6,101 from the local authority in Donegal in February this year if, when squaring accounts with them on the 31st July he would have to withdraw a total of £10,018, he would have on that date a further bill of £3,917.

Comment on this

May we get agreement on this point, that the total amount of the Agricultural Grant which might have gone to Donegal over the period covered from 1st November, 1933, to 31st July, 1935, was decreased by £10,000, due to the operation of the Guarantee Fund? That is the exact position.

Comment on this

If that is the exact position, the thing, for all I know, may be worse. At any rate, there was £6,000 odd taken from Donegal in February. If the Minister was squaring accounts in July last he would have to take £10,000.

Comment on this

The total amount.

Comment on this

I want to say that none of the counties I mention need expect anything back in respect of the amount taken from them up to the 1st April this year. But the following bills are in pickle for them, together with whatever deficiency may follow between 1st August and the end of the land annuity year:—Donegal, £3,917; Leitrim, £1,808; Monaghan, £1,340; Dublin, £9,944; Roscommon, £7,956; Louth, £7,342; Cavan, £2,115; and the whole lot of the county councils put together £270,400. That being the position, with the situation in respect of the Land Commission annuities not getting better, with the taxpayer, according to the Minister, unable to support the burden of any of these deficiencies, this House should examine the condition of the various bodies and the condition of the people whom they are asking to support the burden of these non-paid annuities, and the general conditions that bring about the non-payment of the annuities.

The Land Commission annuitants are supposed to have very dishonest sections at the present time; but Land Commission annuitants met difficulties in the past and there are a couple of figures worth looking at to see what their character in the past was. When the Provisional Government was set up the total amount that had been withdrawn from the Guarantee Fund up to date was only £889,553. Then we had some of the circumstances that the Minister for Finance now suggests he regrets. We then had an order from people who did not accept the Parliamentary institutions of this country that Land Commission annuities should not be paid. Then we had a period of distress and a political repudiation of Parliamentary institutions by some people. After one year of that, the total amount that was withdrawn from the Guarantee Fund was £642,939. That was in February, 1923. When we come to February, 1931, we find that not only had every penny of the eight years' annuities that intervened been paid up, but that £89,562 of the arrears had been paid.

That is the record, as far as the honesty and character of the people paying the land annuities are concerned. It was only when we ran into a period of the repudiation of the land annuities campaign that the deficiency arose from what it was in 1932, £793,000 and showed an increase of about £132,000. Is it not worth examining what are the circumstances that prevent land annuities from being paid now? I suggest to Ministers that they should, in the quiet of their council, examine into what are the circumstances that prevent the land annuities being paid. This Bill proposes to put the responsibility upon bodies carrying out local administration in the country to collect money in rates from people, and this money is to be paid by people who cannot pay their land annuities, however willing they may be to pay them. This calls attention to the particular type of people upon whom this responsibility is to be put. They are people carrying out the administration of our rural districts and the people who support them are the farmers of the country.

But the farmers are suffering from general agricultural depression, in the first place, and, in the second place, from the economic war which has lasted from May or June, 1932. We have had voluminous statements from persons who are now Ministers, setting out the conditions of the farmers in the year 1931. They then admitted that the farmer was a struggling person, suffering under difficulties, so much so that the rates at that time were greater than he should be asked to pay. Not only did they consider that the farmer should be relieved of rates but they held that he should be subsidised in various ways to help him during the period of depression which they said was existing at the time.

Take one or two county councils and consider the position they stand in to-day, financially, when laws are being passed by this House putting upon them burdens that are not proper to be borne by them now. The Cork County Council has been mentioned. In March, 1932, the total bill that went to the ratepayers of County Cork was £287,747. What is the nature of the bill that went to them four years afterwards, when our present Ministers, who said so much about the farmers' difficulties in 1931, and had so many ideas of what could be done for the farmers, said they should be relieved of their rates. These farmers are now getting a bill, without any credit notes, for £385,365. Not only were the Cork farmers not derated, but they got an additional bill, increased by £97,846 as compared with the year when the Fianna Fáil Ministers were making such a cry about the farmers' conditions. And that does not take into consideration one penny of the £118,000 taken from the Cork County Council at the beginning of this year. That money must be found if the Cork County Council pays its way. That money must be found if the Cork County Council is to pay its debts, and, if it is to pay its workers, by the 31st of March next.

Kildare County Council got a bill in 1932 for £74,925. It got a bill this year for £108,723, hard cash, ignoring credit notes. That does not include one penny in respect of land annuities, nevertheless Kildare's bill is increased by £33,798. One wonders what thought has been given to this matter by Deputies, like Deputy Harris, by Deputy Corry, and by men in the position of the President himself, when they introduce a Bill like this and ask us to pass it. They ask us in these circumstances for the ratepayers in the county council to pass this Bill, not imposing the figures of March, 1932, but the figures of to-day, which have been very largely increased.

I would like to hear Deputy Harris on this question. On the 3rd of March, 1932, Deputy Harris is reported as having put before the Kildare County Council a motion which drew attention to the utter impossibility of the ratepayers meeting any demand for rates in the coming year. That was in March, 1932, when the bill that had been given to the Kildare ratepayers was £33,798 less than this year's bill. Deputy Harris, now a member of the Fianna Fáil Party, with others is pushing this Bill through the Dáil, although he spoke of the utter impossibility of the ratepayers of Kildare meeting their demands for rates at the time when that demand was less, and when the ratepayers were better off than they are this year, with increased demands to meet. He pointed out that, instead of taxation, agriculture needed assistance in the form of increased grants and subsidies for production, and complete derating was demanded also. Complete derating was promised by Deputy Corry, who said that Fianna Fáil would certainly give them complete derating, and he added: "Every pledge we gave is to be kept." The President, addressing himself to this matter, in an interview with an English Press representative, was reported in the Irish Press, 1932, to have said: “The overhead charges on the farmers are too heavy and must be lightened. One of the heaviest of these is rates, and we propose to derate agricultural holdings. They derated in Great Britain and in the Six Counties, and the £2,000,000 or £3,000,000 taken from us in land annuities will suffice to finance derating.” The President thought that the farmer ratepayers of the country ought to be relieved of their rates. Now first of all the whole bill given to the farmers generally, irrespective of land annuities, is of a cash value of £310,040. It has gone up by £240,688 arrears carried forward. They have squeezed out of them in arrers of rates, in all £600,000, that is, £568,000 already squeezed out of them and £54,000 squeezed out of them after the 1st September. It may have been squeezed out of them already. In a year like that, when, without counting the land annuities, the farmers have had to support that burden of rates, the President—when an opportunity is given him and his colleagues to review the condition of things and to see whether this burden can be borne by the ratepayers, apart altogether from the desirability of using the ratepayers to support this burden, or the desirability of taking retrospective legislative action such as they are taking—sends his Minister for Finance into the House here to go brutally through the work of pushing this Bill through the House as brutally as they ever tackled any work they have ever done, whether inside or outside this House. The local bodies have very delicate and very difficult responsibility. They have to deal with the home assistance side of things; they have to deal with the poor law relief side of things; they have quite a number of other important and costly duties which require a very considerable amount of tact on their part, and very close and harmonious relations with the people with whom they work, and from whom they collect money. The past Acts of the Government, and now this one, will put them into the position where they will not be able to carry out their duties. They will not have money enough to do the work which requires to be carried out. They will not be able to continue between themselves and the ratepaying community the type of harmonious relations that it is essential should be kept up if local administration is going to go through effectively, and if the results of local administration are to be brought home to the people.

Local bodies' difficulties on the financial side have been growing, as I have indicated. Their difficulties in respect of carrying out their work have also increased. The Ministry proposes that they are going to relieve local authorities of a very large part of the cost of home assistance, but the remarkable thing is that in spite of the fact that an extra £32,000 was paid out in unemployment assistance in October of this year as compared with October of last year the burden of home assistance on local authorities has gone up this year by something over £1,000 in the month, over last year. There was £32,000 more paid out to support the unemployed under the Unemployment Assistance Bill, but nevertheless the condition in the country is such that a heavier burden falls upon the local authorities in the month of October this year than fell upon them last year for the maintenance of the destitute poor. In spite of the fact that the Unemployment Assistance Bill has been running for two years, the burden borne by local authorities during the current year in respect of home assistance is bigger than the burden they bore for home assistance in the year ended March, 1932. The burden of local authorities in respect of the poor law system in the country is increasing. In respect of roads the Government are leaving the local authorities completely in the lurch. It is most remarkable to see the way in which the Government has treated local authorities in respect of road improvement. In the year 1933, through special improvement grants from the Road Fund, the local authorities throughout the country got £1,082,114 paid to them—not money allotted but money actually paid out in respect of improvement work on the roads. What has that been reduced to in the current year? In the year ended March, 1935, they got only £386,011. The local authorities got £696,103 less paid into their hands during the year ended March, 1935, for work on the roads than they got in the year that Fianna Fáil were going for their second election. What is the position this year? They are getting less. The amount allocated this year is £778,069 less than the amount allocated to them for the year ended March, 1933. The Minister, no doubt, has his difficulties on the revenue side; the taxpayer has difficulties, and everything the Minister says points to it, but here you have a fund which is specially paid for the maintenance of the roads, and instead of handling that money over to the road authorities to carry out the work of maintaining and improving the roads the Minister is withholding from the Road Fund substantial sums to help him in the difficulties that his general policy has created for him as between himself and the taxpayers. Last year the Minister actually paid out to the local authorities £145,000 less than he got in during the year to the Road Fund.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

On a point of order, is this relevant to this discussion? The Road Fund is not part of the Guarantee Fund.

Comment on this

Before you give a decision on the matter, might I say that I pointed out that this Bill throws considerable burdens on the local authorities which, by law, do not exist for them already, and I am pointing out the condition of the local authorities upon whom these burdens are being thrown.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question as to whether this Bill does or does not impose unlawful burdens upon county councils is not for the Chair to decide. That point, apparently, is in dispute. The Chair does not see the relation of the Deputy's figures to this Bill. It would be possible on the line now being pursued to go into all the burdens and all the circumstances, economical and social, of the rural community, and to argue that, seriatim, those burdens should not be put upon them. It would not, however, be relevant.

Comment on this

I would put this to you, Sir. If this Bill is not passed, it is much more than likely that local authorities will not be asked to bear the deficiencies from the Guarantee Fund: that the £714,000 withheld last year and the year before will not be withheld from them; and that they may face, say, the next financial year, knowing what amounts of money they will have on hands, and knowing that they will not be used to send bills to the ratepayers to make up the deficiencies in the revenue. I take it that you admit that, Sir. The passing of this Bill is definitely going to throw those enormous burdens on them, and is going to cause the machinery of the county councils to be used to collect money for passing on to the revenue. They have to collect moneys for their own practical purposes and for their own statutory works; I want to point out that they will not be able to do it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's argument is not quite in order. If he were to state briefly—it is not for the Chair to suggest to any Deputy how he might make a case—that certain commitments are on the county councils, and that they will have to bear those further burdens to which the Deputy alludes, he would be quite in order. I do submit that a detailed discussion on the Road Fund, on the National Health and all the other obligations that fall to be borne by local councils, would make this debate interminable.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

That is what is intended.

Comment on this

It is very difficult to be content—when dealing either with the finance of local authorities or with the finance of the State—with the general statement that there is a big sum to be spent on roads. It is much more satisfactory to deal with an explicit amount.

What I am saying is that local county councils have a statutory duty to maintain the roads, that there is a fund which is used for the maintenance and the improvement of roads passing through the hands of the Government, that this House holds county councils to-day, and will hold county councils next year, responsible for the maintenance of roads whilst the Government paid nearly £700,000 less from State Grants last year, and is paying £700,000 less this year than was thought desirable to pay them in respect of the maintenance of roads in the year ending March, 1933.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Are not these deductions made for the purpose of meeting obligations which fall on the Road Fund?

Comment on this

This House is leaving responsibility for maintaining the roads with the county councils.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy could find a sounder argument than the Road Fund? We, like the Deputy's Party, have obligations for the Road Fund and we are discharging our full commitments.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with what the Minister is doing. I am concerned with the position in which local bodies find themselves in regard to their statutory duties and their ability to collect the necessary finances to support them in the carrying out of these duties. The Minister is throwing on the people who have been robbed right, left and centre, responsibility for maintaining their ordinary statutory work of carrying on local government. They have been robbed to such an extent that many of them are barely able to subsist at the moment. The whole agricultural community have been despoiled of much of the capital on which they carried on. They have been despoiled of any hope for their children for many years to come; they have been thrown into the condition of the most terrible poverty.

This is a matter in which I agree, Sir, it may not be desirable to go into the full details, but this House cannot leave it without giving some consideration to these details, when we consider that the Government is transferring to those people burdens which at the beginning of this year amounted to £714,000.

From the way in which Deputies like Deputy Harris and Deputy Corry, who were interested in the position of the farmers some time ago, have kept their silence, and the way in which the President, from whom I quoted a short time ago, has kept out of the House during this debate —a debate which is not only vital to the financial credit of the country but vital also to our institutions of Government—it is clear that Deputies on the Government side are not prepared to discuss these matters, even if they have given some consideration to them outside the House. The main thing that stands out in my mind in all this discussion is that in petty spite and petty pride Government Deputies are unwilling to review the results of their policy for the last three years. The Executive Council have put down their heads and they say: "We are going to push this burden on local authorities without giving any consideration to what the result of our action is going to be. We are showing the courts how simple it is to destroy them. We are showing the Seanad how simple it is to destroy it."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On this Bill?

Comment on this

It is very nearly on this Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, it is the next item on the Order Paper.

Comment on this

I question whether the Seanad Bill would have been introduced so quickly if it were not that they wish to get the Seanad out of the way so that Senators could not tinker with this Bill. Then if there is no delay in dealing with this Bill the Ministry is quite safe and sound.

Comment on this

That is a new argument.

Comment on this

If Deputy Donnelly wants to mouth democratic opinions or democratic feelings, I would ask him to remember what will be the position of democratic government in this country when, as a result of the line of action which the Executive Council is taking now and as a result of the type of support that is being given them by Deputy Donnelly, local authorities are crushed out of existence. Then we shall come to the position in this country about which Deputy Cosgrave spoke, that the Government in this country will be a bare majority of the Fianna Fáil Party sitting in the Fianna Fáil rooms.

Comment on this

Or any other Party who can get there.

Comment on this

Deputy MacDermot believes that we think too much of the possibilities in that direction, and that we talk too much about them. I do not think the Deputies could possibly talk too much about dictatorship or about tyranny. An advice that might be given on one particular matter is very often generally applicable. I do not think that Punch's advice about marriage was originally given about marriage. We would not have been waiting until comparatively recently for an advice like that if it were. I think it was given about politics. There is an advice given about marriage that might be freely taken to heart by some politicians and by people who have not been too long associated with the Fianna Fáil Party, people like Deputy Dowdall, Deputy Gibbons, and even Deputy Hugo Flinn. Deputy MacDermot might also think about it. There is an advice given in Gaelic that I think would suit them very well:

"Do thabharfinn comhairle do mhnáibh óga,

Agus déanfad fós nach ar an dtuathal,

Gan fear do phósa, as a n-eolas,

Ach d'reir mar gheobhaid siad a thuairisc."

Comment on this

Translate it.

Comment on this

It gives advice to a young maiden who is thinking about taking advantage of the things that matrimony brings, not to choose her wooer because of what she knows about him, but rather because of what she hears about him. The Irish are a bit subtle, and when they say "what she knows about him" it means "what she thinks she knows about him." We could tell the country a lot about the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

The Deputy has spent 12 years in telling them, but the difficulty is that they do not appear to believe him.

Comment on this

Is it not an astounding thing that it is necessary to keep telling the people about them?

Comment on this

It is a more astounding thing that they do not believe you.

Comment on this

Is it not an astounding thing that people are of the type that you have to leave a lot of things unsaid? I know that when some people make up their minds to get married, it is as well to let them do it, but I would suggest to people who have had 12 years to look back to consider whether they would be better advised to take the Fianna Fáil Party for what they think they know about them, or take the Fianna Fáil Party for what some of us can tell them about them.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Or to take this Bill.

Comment on this

Tell us something about the Bill.

Comment on this

There are some people prepared to take this Bill on the ground that the Minister for Finance in the Dáil to-day recanted lots of unexpressed and inexpressible things—at any rate inexpressible at this stage of the Bill. It is quite unwise to accept the Bill on, say, one day's notice by the Minister for Finance. It is equally unwise to accept the Bill on four years' notice by the Minister for Finance. It is almost equally unwise to accept the Bill on 12 years' knowledge of the Minister, if the Deputies concerned confine themselves to what they think they know about the Minister and his colleagues.

The Minister cannot object to its being stated that they attempted to destroy this Parliament—it is an historical fact. They cannot object to having it said that they are prepared to trample on the courts; they cannot object to having it said that they are wiping out the Seanad, and that, when the Seanad is wiped out, a majority of this House, meaning, as the Minister knows, a majority of the Fianna Fáil Party, can decide anything they like here, and it is the will of the people in gold letters paid for by the people to print and paid for by the people to expound it. They cannot object to its being argued, when they are driven by circumstances to consider whether they would impose this burden on the paying farmer ratepayers of this country, that they ought to sit down and examine the conditions of the people on whom they are putting the burden and ask themselves, if the taxpayers cannot bear the cost of these losses, how can the ratepayers bear the cost of these losses, particularly when the ratepayers are the very men that they whined about and wept so much over in 1932 and who to-day are bearing a burden of taxation in the way of rates infinitely greater than they were bearing then.

To refuse to do that, as the Ministers are doing, is simply to bring themselves up against the situation that they know must come, and that is the breakdown of the democratic machinery of local government. Then what are you going to have? Knowing the people on the opposite benches as I do from the President down to the Minister for Finance, and knowing the blind, helpless way in which their followers have to follow them, I believe that they know they are going to destroy local government by this measure, but that they do not care: that they are going to drift blindly along, and then, if they have courage enough, they will act the dictator, and, if they have not courage enough, they will simply slither out of the picture and let the unfortunate people throw up again whatever institutions they can, with whatever leaders they can, to help them out of the mess and destruction to which they have been brought.

Comment on this

That will be the Deputy's chance.

Comment on this

This debate has drawn from the Minister for Finance what appears to me to be one of the most striking statements made in this House since I came into it. The Minister for Finance is by way of being an orator, and, carried away to-day, not by the intoxication of wine, but the intoxication of his own oratory, he spoke the truth and said that he now admitted that Deputy Cosgrave had established the rule of the majority in this country, that he and his supporters had accepted it, and that he was now concerned to preserve what he himself had resisted in the times gone by. I think I speak for all my colleagues when I say that, if that statement is sincere, we welcome it. If that statement is a desire to bury the past and to acknowledge that mistakes have been made, no one on this side of the House has a desire to jeer or jibe. We welcome the change of heart, and are glad to find in that matter common ground.

The more fundamental matters—I say fundamental matters—on which we can find common ground in this country the better. I am not one of those sentimentalists who believe that we ought all be working together for Cathleen Ni Houlihan. I like the cut and thrust of debate and vigorous and healthy difference in the every-day polities of the State; but there are certain fundamental matters on which it is very desirable to achieve substantial accord between all public men in the public business of this country. That majority rule should prevail is one such fundamental matter, and it is a source of unmitigated satisfaction to me that President de Valera and his supporters have, for the first time, publicly proclaimed that they now recognise that there was a time in this country when men sitting on these benches were obliged to defend the principle of majority rule, that the members of the Fianna Fáil Party are now glad that it was successfully defended and now publicly proclaim their intention to co-operate with all-comers in preserving it in this country for all time. If that is sincere, we are all united in that determination. Now we come to the every-day matter of this Bill. I want to ask the Minister for Finance why was the Westmeath County Council dissolved?

Comment on this

That question will have to be addressed to the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

He would choke if he had to answer it, just as the Minister for Finance chokes when I ask him to answer it, and as Deputy Kennedy takes good care not to put his nose inside the House when there is a danger of that being asked. The Westmeath County Council was dissolved because the Council would not do in Westmeath what the Minister is trying to do to-day in this House. The Westmeath County Council was dissolved because Deputy Kennedy and his colleagues on the Westmeath County Council, where there is a Fianna Fáil majority, refused to strike a rate to make up the deficiency created by the deduction in the Agricultural Grant on the foot of unpaid annuities. They refused to do it because they said it was not within the capacity of the ratepayers of the County Westmeath to pay these moneys.

The Westmeath County Council sent a deputation to the Minister for Local Government to make that case, and the case they made was, not that the ratepayers would not pay, but that the ratepayers could not pay. They said: "We ask for time, and we assure you that if you give us time these people are anxious and willing to pay and will pay as soon as they are able; in the meantime, do not ask the impossible." The answer was that the Westmeath County Council was dissolved, Deputy Kennedy vigorously protesting, and Deputy Kennedy, after protesting in Westmeath, in Dáil Eireann walks meekly into the Division Lobby like any sheep being led to slaughter. In this case the sheep are not led by any goat into the slaughterhouse, but they are flogged by President de Valera into the right Lobby, and a dignified picture they present.

Perhaps some of the Deputies on the other side will tell me, when they get up to speak, why the Westmeath County Council was dissolved. I will be especially grateful to my friend Deputy Donnelly if he will ask Deputy Kennedy to come in and give us an exordium on the life and times of the Westmeath County Council under Deputy Kennedy. I want to ask another member of the Fianna Fáil Party the reason for the metamorphosis that is taking place at present in his mind. Deputy O'Dowd, the member for Roscommon, was waxing very eloquent up and down Roscommon a few years ago. Deputy O'Dowd, addressing a large convention in Boyle, on the 22nd April, 1928, said: "You may see the report that £10,000 is due by the defaulting annuitants in this county. The rates are liable for that burden of 8d. in the £ on the present rate. I say," went on Deputy O'Dowd, "that you cannot knock blood out of a turnip. Some farmers are defaulters through no fault of their own. It is common knowledge," added the Deputy, "that the farming community have passed through the most critical period in the lives of most of them. Agriculture is now in a more depressed condition than in any period in the history of this country. Some farmers cannot pay, and that is all." That was on the 22nd April, 1928. But that did not finish Deputy O'Dowd. He delivered another speech on the same day. In that speech he referred to how the County Council stopped the water supply scheme for Elphin. He said this "would involve only ½d. in the £ on the rates, and whilst the county councillors are fiddling about ½d. in the £, they have at the same time no remedy for the arrears of the land annuities, including almost an 8d. rate in the £. They are putting this rate on the unfortunate people who are unable to pay, and these are the people who are to be hit at."

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

What date is that?

Comment on this

That is the 22nd April, 1928.

Comment on this

And the people of Roscommon were paying £25,000 less in rates that year than they are paying to-day.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

You compelled them to pay them.

Comment on this

We have not finished with Deputy O'Dowd yet. He was getting better and better as he went along. On the 12th May, 1928, he delivered another speech. That was the year of his eloquence. That was the vintage year for Deputy O'Dowd. Speaking at Elphin on the 12th May, 1928, he said: "Fianna Fáil will collect the annuities but, unlike Cumann na nGaedheal who paid them into the English Exchequer, Fianna Fáil will pay them into the Irish Exchequer, and give relief to the farmers by way of long-term loans at low rates of interest, unlike the Agricultural Credit Corporation, or by way of relief in the agricultural rates. Fianna Fáil do not believe in turning out on the roadside those who, through no fault of their own, are unable at the moment to pay. They believe in helping, not in harassing those poor people who through the sheer incompetence of their present rulers have got into the sorry plight in which they are to-day." Now having come through the sorry plight in which they were in 1928, what in the name of God is the plight in which they are to-day?

Comment on this

Sucking calves were dearer at that time than yearlings now.

Comment on this

I want to agree with Deputy O'Dowd in one particular; it really goes to the root foundation of this whole Bill and it is this: that you cannot take blood from a turnip nor water from a stone. The people have not got it and you cannot get it out of them. The astonishing part of this business is this: that there is not a single Deputy on the Fianna Fáil benches living in rural Ireland who does not know that as well as we know it and who will not admit it anywhere outside this particular Chamber. If you meet them outside they will admit it and if they are speaking to their constituents they freely admit it. Deputy Corkery, in an indiscreet moment, forgot he was speaking where somebody other than his own friends heard him. He made no disguise as to what the position was. He said: "You have got to do something and do it quickly; most of these people have reached the breaking point." There is not a Deputy on the Fianna Fáil benches who will not endorse that statement. But the terrifying part of it is that there is not a man or woman amongst them who would have the courage to get up here and say so. I admit their physical courage, because how they can have the effrontery to come up here and speak as they do and then go down to the street corners in the country and say the very reverse without the apprehension that the people will tear them to pieces, is a matter of astonishment to me. It would be difficult to estimate the exact amount of the money that the passage of this Bill will impose on the local authorities of this country. Deputies have got to realise in the event of this judgment in the courts being favourable to the litigants, the amount of relief the local authorities will gain in the matter of these deductions from the Agricultural Grant. These grants are being retained in respect of such annuities as are unpaid under the Land Acts prior to the Land Act of 1923 and such as accrued since the passage of the Land Act of 1933. That is a very large sum of money. The effect of this Bill if passed will be to impose large burdens on the local authorities who will be compelled to pay. I would not be surprised if this Bill makes a difference of £1,000,000 to the local authorities. The figure up to last July was £1,350,000.

A vast number of Deputies in this House hold themselves out as representatives of the small farmers in this country. The figure of £1,350,000 might be taken, but I will put it at the conservative figure of £1,000,000 so as to avoid the charge of exaggeration. This Bill is going to impose on the small farmer at least a charge that would be equivalent to a charge of 1/- in the £ on the income-tax payers. More likely it would be the equivalent of a charge of 1/6 in the £ on the income-tax payers because in past years 6d. in the income-tax produced a sum of £500,000. I am deliberately understating my case in that particular. At all events this imposition corresponds to an increase of 1/- in the £ in the income-tax. Now supposing the Government introduced a Bill here increasing the income-tax by 1/- in the £, what an outcry there would be.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has got to be very careful.

Comment on this

I put it to the Minister what an outcry there would be. We would hear Deputy Dowdall making the welkin ring with denunciations of such a tax.

Comment on this

And Deputy John Good would be silent.

Comment on this

Let the Minister face this fact—that every Deputy who has the industrial interest of this country at heart would strenuously and legitimately raise his voice and point out the disastrous effects of laying a burden of that weight upon industry in this country. If such a thing were done we would have that denunciation from all taxpayers and their representatives. But is there a word from the representatives of the small farmers on those benches opposite when exactly the same burden is going to be placed on the shoulders of these small farmers who are infinitely less able to bear it?

Comment on this

And the agricultural labourers will have to bear their share as well.

Comment on this

I will come to the agricultural labourers. There is not a word from the opposite benches, from the gentlemen who are supposed to represent the small farmer. The Labour Party have placed themselves on record. They recognise what the implications of this legislation are going to be. You will hear, in the more eloquent moments of the Fianna Fáil Party, protests that they are more representative of labour than the Labour Party itself, but they have nothing to say now on behalf of the labouring men upon whose backs a large portion of this burden is going to fall. The Minister for Finance says that Deputy Good would raise his voice; the representatives of capital or property would raise their voices; the representatives of industry would raise their voices. Is not that what they are here for, to raise their voices and in this House defend the legitimate interests that they are called upon to support? Why do not the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, who hold themselves out as being here to defend the legitimate interests of the small farmers and the agricultural labourers, take example by Deputy John Good and raise their voices in defence of those people? They do not, because they have not got the courage to do it, because they all know if they dared to do it they would be chased out of public life by President de Valera. And they are right. There is not a single one of the Fianna Fáil Deputies who could hope to hold his seat if President de Valera set his mind to chase him out, and that is the danger that threatens this country. If you have Parliamentary institutions, let them be Parliamentary institutions; but if you have Parliamentary institutions reduced to a phonographic reproduction of one individual's particular cranks and criticisms, then there is very grave danger and the only remedy is that there should be a certain modicum of moral courage and independence in every Deputy, no matter to what Party he belongs.

Comment on this

Come now to the Bill.

Comment on this

I did not think the members of the Fianna Fáil Party would like that. The Deputy will get his opportunity of going into the Division Lobby soon. As soon as President de Valera's whip cracks, the Deputy would go anywhere; he would go to the gates of Hell rather than face him. He need not be one bit ashamed, because all his colleagues will do the same thing. As I said before, you cannot take blood from a turnip or water from a stone. Deputy Mulcahy has elaborated, and very rightly, the view that the burdens at present borne by the ratepayers render them incapable of submitting to any further imposition. I very well remember, when the Unemployment Assistance Bill was going through, one of the most potent arguments used for it on all sides of the House was that while at first glance the Bill might appear to lay a very heavy extra charge on the public purse, in fact it would not, because one of the first consequences would be to take off the local authorities the bulk of outdoor assistance charges. The very reverse has happened. In addition to all the money that is being paid in unemployment assistance, and it is a very substantial sum, outdoor assistance has increased and we are paying more outdoor assistance now than we ever paid before. We are paying more this year than last year and we have no guarantee in the years to come that the burden will not continue to grow.

Before I finish I am going to submit that it is as certain as we are sitting here that the burden will continue to grow if the present situation continues and for this reason. The landowners, the tenant purchasers are getting progressively poorer. Their standard of living is being beaten down because everything they have to sell is being made cheaper by Government policy and everything they have to buy is being made dearer by Government policy. I know of at least two cases. Let me tell the House of two specific cases of tenant purchasers with whom I am personally acquainted. One of them is a man with a wife and eight children. He has about 21 Irish acres of land and he keeps three cows. Deputies will get from that information an idea of the kind of measure of prosperity he has. I met that man at a pig fair recently. He was selling a breeding pig and he sold it and got £4 10s. He then told me that the money he got for that pig was not sufficient to pay his rates, not to speak of the shop debts outstanding against him. I said to him it had occured to me that a man in his position must be having a rather hard time of it. He said he was having a hard time of it, and a much harder time than I knew. He said he had no butter in his house for the last two months, and no meat. He had looked forward to being able to buy a pig and cure it in his own home in order to give his children meat and fats this Christmas; but he was now obliged to face the fact that he could not afford it because he had not any ready cash to buy anything. That man went home to face the Christmas, and he has nothing to give his children but dry bread, potatoes; he has one cow giving milk, and eggs. That is, to me, a very shocking and horrible thing to happen in this country. The man is not actually hungry; he has enough food to keep going; but he is at a standard of living as low as obtains amongst the peasantry of the poorest country in Europe.

I know another man, a neighbour of my own, a man who was a very strong supporter of President de Valera. He is a personal friend of mine. He came to me recently and told me there had not been sugar or tea in his house for six months. To anyone who is living amongst the people, who knows their everyday life and meets them and is their guest from time to time in their houses, the significance of that is perfectly shocking. That a farmer in this country with a wife and family should admit to me that he actually had not a grain of tea or sugar in the house for six months, bespeaks a degree of poverty which is perfectly shocking to anybody who at the same time is enjoying any degree of the comforts of this life. And shocking as that is to me, I consider it to be much more appalling that Deputies, like Deputy Donnelly and Deputy Jordan, who are intimately in touch with the conditions of the people in rural Ireland, should sit silently when they know that is going on and lend their voices and countenance to the fraud that everything is lovely in the garden. Everything is not lovely in the garden. I do not deny, I freely admit, that anybody in Dublin does get an altogether false picture of what the situation in the country is. I do not deny that in certain aspects there is a degree of prosperity in the City of Dublin in the way of business passing, but the unanswerable fact is that it is not reproduced in any part of Ireland except in the city. Anybody living in the country, as I am, can see that every day of the week, and they can see neighbours who were comfortable, not rich but confortable, whose children were well nourished and properly clad, they can see those people steadily going down; they can see them with that pride which is their credit and which is something desirable and admirable in them, concealing their poverty, but they can see the children's clothes becoming poorer and more ragged, they can see the children needing the want of the essential nourishment they ought to be getting and are not getting, because their people are getting poorer every day.

Deputies sitting on the Government side of the House know that as well as I do. But they have not the courage to say it. One last word. I have on more than one occasion said in this House that the present policy of the Government is running the country into national bankruptcy. To that there have been two replies. One is the cry of "wolf" and the other is "what do you mean by national bankruptcy?" I answer: "This Bill is national bankruptcy." Here we have the signs of the beginning of national bankruptcy, in that the Exchequer is no longer able to collect revenue, but has to go to the local authorities to do it, and when the local authorities reply: "We cannot collect it because the people have not got the money to give."

The first consequence of that is—and the Labour Party know this—any Government will preserve the services of the army and the police to the last ditch. They are essential to government, and the first thing to suffer, and to be impinged upon, as a sign of national bankruptcy, is the social services of the country. Let any Labour Deputy ask himself the question: if the local authorities have to find this money to recoup the Central Fund, and if that money is to be forcibly extracted from the local authorities, and if they are physically unable to extract that money from the ratepayers, what is there to suffer from the non-collection of those rates but the social services? Does not every Deputy who is a member of a council know that at meetings of his own board of health it is a constant struggle to keep outdoor relief for the people maintained at a proper standard? Is there not a constant struggle to reduce the standard of outdoor relief on the grounds that the rates will not stand more? Does he not know that if there are one or two or three thousand pounds wanted under this Bill, the first fount it will be taken from is the board of health? It takes time for all that to sink in. Deputies generally do not feel the impact because they are not members of boards of health. But the unfortunate individual who got 5/- and now only gets 4/- does not realise that he is only getting 4/- because this Bill was passed.

That is the way this Bill is being financed. You cannot get another penny out of the people by rates or taxes, and the only way you can get it is by taking it from the boards of health. You are going to collect every penny out of them. There is nowhere else you can get the money. After you get all that, and look for more, you will find it is not to be had. All that could be remedied and stopped the moment the Government comes to their senses. Every penny of the annuities would be promptly paid. Every penny of rates would be paid, and even paid in advance if the people were only given a chance of paying. To avoid the inevitable consequences of what the Government are doing, and doing with their eyes open, they are going to finance this Bill out of the resources of the local authorities, and if that fails they will try to finance it out of national social services. If that fails then you are going to have anarchy or else change their tune.

We had a passionate appeal from the President for peace conferences before war. Bad as war is, anarchy is worse, and I say let us have the peace of commonsense before anarchy. Deputies on the Government Benches opposite think they can carry on for ever. But when the smash comes they will run to Deputies on this side and call to them to lend a hand to save the ship. They know, if they ask for help from this side of the House, they will get it, and they bank upon that. They demanded our help when floating the National Loan. They declared they wanted stability and made application to us and to the country, and they got it. If they run this country into bankruptcy they will then run to us, and to other Deputies in this House, for help, and they know they will get it. We will get the country out of its predicament, but we will only be able to get it out after terrible suffering, and we will find ourselves faced by an exasperated people driven to anarchy by the kind of government administered here. All that can be avoided if you refrain from taking the steps you are taking now.

The Minister for Finance, very eloquently, said, when addressing the meeting of the Ard-Fheis recently, that it was the extreme folly of the kind that was talked in the Ard-Fheis that made his job so difficult. It is the extreme folly of the kind of thing that the Government stands for, in national affairs, that makes it so very difficult, and almost impossible, for the farmers to carry on. I make the same appeal to the Minister that he made to the Ard-Fheis in regard to the step he has taken here. Notwithstanding all the balderdash that is talked here, the fundamental fact remains that you cannot get blood from a turnip, nor water from a stone, and neither can you collect, from the people of this country, money which they have not got to give you.

Comment on this

I did not intend to speak on this measure at all, but on Second Reading yesterday, and again to-day, the Minister dealt particularly with my contituency. That was done for the purpose apparently of a threat. I do not think, in the past, that I have been subjected to threats, or that I have reacted to them. What is the threat? That in voting for this amendment I will be putting an increased tax on every person in my constituency to the extent of 9/- per head. But what about a paltry 9/-? At the last election the Minister promised to relieve taxation in this country by £2,000,000 a year; that would be practically £3 10s. a head. What about a paltry 9/- in these circumstances? That threat was made in order to secure votes in this House. Let me tell the Minister that the farmers of Donegal will take their places with the farmers of Cork. They did that in the past and they will do it again now.

The number of heresies we had from the Minister was astonishing. He told the House that they stand for majority rule. So far as I am concerned, though perhaps I only speak for myself, I have the utmost contempt for majority rule. To me it is a pagan doctrine. I know what Deputy Cosgrave stood for when in office. He stood for the law as enacted by majority rule.

That is what I want to stand for in regard to this Bill. I want the County Council of Louth and the County Council of Cork to get the law as enacted by this House. The Minister comes in and tells us what is in the Copyright Act, and what is the meaning of it. The Minister, on the Second Reading yesterday, emphasised in this House that in 1923, when the Land Act was passed, it was intended to, and actually did, make provision for the independence of the Guarantee Fund. He quoted what Deputy Cosgrave, when he was President, said about retrospective legislation. If there were no other reason for voting against this Bill except that it is retrospective I would vote against it. I would vote against it even if my constituents dismissed me to-morrow, for the simple reason that there is no security for anybody, particularly for the poor, except the supremacy of the law. The Oireachtas can protect themselves, in the State and in the House, but the minorities they represent cannot do so; hence their one and only security in the last analysis is the supremacy of the law. For that reason I would ask the House to reject this measure. In spite of all the discussion by the Minister and by Deputies on his side, we are not told why this Guarantee Fund section was included in the Land Act of 1891, or what it was to do. Whom was it to impose a tax upon? This section was inserted in the Act of 1891, at the behest of the landowners in England, in order to make it clear, definite, and final that no loss would fall upon the English taxpayer. That section was fought by three distinguished Irishmen—Tim Healy, Tom Sexton and Maurice Healy. Here we have the Irish Parliament, representing the plain people of this country, enacting in this House what was done in the interests of British landlords and British taxpayers.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy answer one question? Would he tell us why it was insisted upon in the Act of 1923 by Deputy Cosgrave?

Comment on this

I will tell you. It is quite simple. Deputy Cosgrave was discharging the liabilities imposed on the Guarantee Fund. He was paying the interest and sinking fund on the land stock. You are not.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy allow me to intervene for a moment? Deputy Corry has not read the Bill. The Guarantee Fund operated from 1891 up to 1923 and up to 1931 for one purpose—to make good any shortage that there was in paying interest on land stock and sinking fund.

Comment on this

To make good anything that was due to John Bull.

Comment on this

We are again having all this claptrap about John Bull. I should like to know what percentage of the land stock included in the Land Act is in the hands of the poor Irish people. Deputy Corry interrupts in this House. What was he doing when the farmers of this country were fighting for the Land Acts? They undertook to pay their contracts, and did discharge them until his Party came into power. They are still prepared to pay the last penny if they get an opportunity of doing so. It is a remarkable thing that when the Guarantee Fund section was enacted in the House of Commons in 1891 the then Chief Secretary, Mr. Balfour, did admit that there was only 2d. in the £ unpaid annuities by the Irish farmers. When the British Government was crushing this country, when it was grinding the life out of us, there was only 2d. in the £ unpaid annuities in this State. When the British Government was imposing on this country the taxation which was to drive them out of this country, only 2d. per £ of the land annuities remained in default. What is the position to-day when £700,000 out of £2,000,000 remains outstanding? When people in this House talk about democracy and freedom I should like them to reflect on that. The Minister says, "Oh, this will fall on the poor." Has the House not yet learned that in the last analysis all taxation falls upon the poor? It has been said in this House repeatedly that when the economic crash comes— and it must come as a result of the policy of the present administration— the poor will be the worst sufferers, because those who are reasonably well off will get something even when there is nothing for the poor. I am not going to cite any cases; it would look like playing on the poverty of those poor people. The House can pass this Bill, this retrospective legislation to take away from the citizen the right to go to the courts and get the benefit of the law. I do not mind whether the law is good or bad; I do not mind whether this Bill is for or against the County Councils of Louth and Cork, but whatever the law is, let the courts interpret it. Majority rule, to my mind, is just the same in a savage State as in a civilised State. What I want is the law passed by the majority. That is what I want, and I will obey it. Every word and letter of that law I will obey, but I am not to be taken as going to obey anywhere, either in this House or outside it, a majority of any kind. I will obey the law they enact, both in the spirit and in the letter, but not the majority. I will obey the law and the letter of the law, and nothing but the law. That is what I ask for.

Comment on this

The Magna Charta.

Comment on this

In the law there is security; outside it there is no security for anybody, particularly for minorities. What is the reason of majority rule? Two county councils instituted legal proceedings, and immediately a Bill is introduced in this House to prevent their getting justice. The Seanad rejects a measure introduced by the Government, and the Seanad is abolished. Then we hear talk about majority rule! There is talk from the Minister that he is submitting to majority rule. Did anybody ever hear such hypocrisy as that? When I came into the House he was speaking about a remark interjected yesterday by Deputy McGilligan, charging the Government with embezzling this money. What is the position of the law upon that question? The money in the Guarantee Fund is for the purpose of paying interest and sinking fund on the land stock. Is that being done? It is not. If money is not applied for the purposes for which it is got, is that embezzlement or is it not?

The Attorney-General, I presume, will be elevated to the Bench when the Courts of Justice Bill is passed. How does he expect, when he goes on the Bench, to get respect for the law when he sits in this House at present and advises the Government, if a citizen goes into the courts and seeks to get redress against the Government, to take steps to frustrate that action of the citizen and to deny him justice? It is a nice position for a man occupying the highest office in this country that, when a citizen whom he is supposed to protect goes into the court to seek justice, he will advise the Government to deny him that justice. In other words, when he sits on the Bench he will get a salary but he will have no rights or no power. This Bill is bad from the point of view that it is retrospective. It is wrong from every aspect and, as I have said in the House at different times, I do not care if there were a thousand precedents for introducing retrospective legislation, I am opposed to it and I shall vote against it. I do not care if there was not another person in the country to vote against it, I shall vote against it. These two county councils went into the courts to get the benefit of the law. Are they not entitled to it? Is any Deputy in this House going to support a proposition that county councils are not entitled to get the benefit of the law? Will Deputy Corry say that the County Councils of Cork and Louth ought not to get the benefit of the law?

Comment on this

It is better to be a good farmer than a bad lawyer.

Comment on this

Apparently there is a good deal of bad law in this country. There is plenty of bad law on the Front Bench opposite. A lot has been said about the Guarantee Fund in this connection. I should not be at all surprised if we had another Guarantee Fund Bill in this House before very long. This is not the end, and I shall not be surprised if there is another Guarantee Fund Bill introduced in this House to take away the rights of somebody else. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance spoke for about three-quarters of an hour here lecturing Deputy Davin because he opposed this Bill. I do not know what course was open to Deputy Davin except to vote against the Bill. I have known him as an Irish Nationalist and an Irish democrat for a good many years, and in either capacity he could do nothing but vote against this measure. The Parliamentary Secretary taunted him with the question of where the money was to be got if the Bill were not passed. That is not Deputy Davin's responsibility. He is not a member of the Government; it is only when he has some part in the government of the country that he should be asked that question. Opposition Deputies have been asked the same question but that is not our business. We have repeatedly told the Minister that if he could bring about economy to the amount of £2,000,000, as he promised before he got into office, he could get the money which would make a Bill such as this unnecessary.

You can pass this Bill, but in my opinion it is mere waste paper because it is endeavouring to compel county councils to do an impossible thing. Deputy Dillon described it as trying to take blood out of a turnip or water out of a stone. You cannot do it. This House may vote for it but it is mere waste paper. The Government have reduced the farmers of the country to such a condition that they cannot find this money. When the Guarantee Fund was first instituted it was intended only to supply a nominal amount, a mere drop in the ocean, something like 2d. in the £. That was what was envisaged when this Act was originally enacted. Now for all practical purposes the entire land annuities remain unpaid. That is the position to-day. What will be the position next year or the year afterwards? Every Deputy knows as well as I know the incapacity of the people to pay, as they have been reduced to such a condition of poverty. How long is that situation going to last? In face of that position we are asked to pass a useless and futile Bill. I ask the House to reject the measure.

Comment on this

I am one of those who believe that we have had nearly enough talk on this measure up to the present—too much, in fact. At any rate my remarks will be very brief. I propose to say something pleasant, something other than all those fiery speeches and orations such as Deputy McMenamin has delivered. If we could approach this matter from the point of view of sense rather than of sentiment and passion and eliminate from our arguments that recriminatory spirit that sometimes takes possession of the House, I think it would be all to the good. Deputy McMenamin, when he does make a speech, generally makes a good one. It is an epoch-making speech always that Deputy McMenamin makes. I remember one time, when Deputy Cosgrave was responsible for a very delicate document, an international document, Deputy McMenamin went out the following day and said: "This man has signed a document which is called a White Paper but it is the blackest document that ever was signed since the Union." Yet to-day he is following as leader the man who, he said at that time, had signed the blackest document that was ever signed since the days of the Union. Every speaker who got up to attack this Bill told us about poverty and about ruin, about what the Government has done and how impossible it is for anybody to carry on anything profitably in this country. We must congratulate and compliment Deputy MacDermot on the admirable tone of his observations last night.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I believe that Deputy MacDermot meant what he said. I believe that he was sincere in the sentiments which he expressed and I think it would be a good thing if more of us took the same standpoint.

Comment on this

Might I interrupt the Deputy?

Comment on this

Oh, do not.

Comment on this

I should be very much interested to know what remarks he is referring to, because on the particular topic on which he is now speaking I expressed views similar to what Deputy Dillon has been saying here to-day.

Comment on this

The remarks which the Deputy used, and on which I wish to congratulate him, were remarks in which he deprecated any recrimination and the use of epithets or offensive expressions in this House. I think I am right in that. Deputy MacDermot has a bee in his bonnet——

Comment on this
Deputies

Oh!

Comment on this

I beg your pardon. Deputy McMenamin has a bee in his bonnet because of the Government's attitude towards the County Councils of Louth and Cork. He wants the County Councils of Louth and Cork to get the law, the whole law, and nothing but the law. He wants them to get fair play, as he says. I do not know so much about the County Council in Cork—probably Deputy Corry will deal with that.

Comment on this

They will deal with him, anyway.

Comment on this

I do know a good deal about County Louth, as I lived in an adjoining county. I listened last night to Deputy Coburn making a big oration and resenting the statement of the Minister that this action of the County Council was vexatious. I wish I had thought of bringing the local paper with me, but I should like to ask was that a unanimous decision of the Louth County Council? They are a very wise and astute people in County Louth, and they are in a very unique position. I should like Deputy Belton to follow this for a moment. Eliminating the City of Dublin from the County of Dublin, the County Louth is the one county in Ireland where the urban population is bigger than the rural. I would be delighted to see them getting grant after grant there, but, comparatively speaking, there is no county that has done better during the last three years than County Louth. Grants have flown into that county for all purposes, and they are still going there. Take the towns of Dundalk, Drogheda and Ardee. There was a big grant, I understand, to the Dundalk Harbour Board, a big trade loan given to a firm in Drogheda, and an alcohol factory is going to be erected in Cooley.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is travelling far from the Fifth Stage of the Bill.

Comment on this

I want to relate this to the action of the County Council. I think I have given my reasons for the unique position of County Louth. While grants were going in there from the Government from an urban standpoint for relief schemes, we had these little piping voices and the County Council coming along and, from the rural standpoint, taking action against the Government and carrying it by a majority. That was done, in my opinion, purely from a vexatious standpoint, and no other.

Comment on this

Were these grants or loans by which the future is mortgaged?

Comment on this

Let the man speak. Deputies on your side were not interrupted.

Comment on this

Whatever they are, they are useful to the people. What is the difference? They got a big grant for a certain institution up there. I am making the point that while these grants were going to Louth from the Government for one particular purpose, the Government is landed into court by a clique or section of the County Council for the purely vexatious purpose of doing harm and trying to annoy the Government.

Comment on this

The Cork County Council was unanimous.

Comment on this

I do not blame them for carrying the resolution, if they thought it was right, but they were not content to stop there. Deputy Coburn took advantage of his membership of the County Councils' General Council the other day to parade his views and condemn this Bill and ask that it should be withdrawn. You would think it was a speech from the dock. That is the kind of vexatious litigation we were going to have, and this Bill, in my opinion, will stop that sort of thing, and I, for one, am glad that that step has been taken for that purpose.

Comment on this

It is a pity you had not a revolver to stop me. If you had a revolver behind a ditch you could stop me from speaking.

Comment on this

I am not accustomed to firearms, and I do not think we ought to introduce them here. Another reason was given by Deputy Mulcahy for the opposition to this Bill. I am rather surprised at Deputy Mulcahy going back to this old thing again. He made the analogy that the courts would be trampled upon and put out of action. Then, of course, the old threadbare argument was brought in about the abolition of the Seanad. The Seanad is going, if it has not already gone. There is no doubt about that; everybody knows that. As regards the strangulation of the courts. I want to make my position clear in relation to this Bill. I would be the last Deputy to say or do anything, or vote in any Division Lobby for anything that would take away from the courts all the power and all the authority the courts ought to have.

I agree with Deputy McGilligan when he said last night that the courts are the last protection for the ordinary citizen, and the weaker the man and the weaker the case, the greater is the need for the courts to protect the citizen and the purpose for which the citizen wants to use the courts. For that reason, if I thought this Bill was going to do damage to the courts or any harm in any way, or militate against the rights of any citizen in getting justice from the courts, I would go into the Division Lobby against it. But I do not believe it is going to do anything of the kind. It is a good debating point. It is a good thing in a debate here for the Opposition to say that to a Minister and tell him that he is going to destroy the authority of the courts. It is a good debating point, but that is all it is. I question very much if Deputy Belton or Deputy Coburn, or any other Deputy, believes for a moment that when the Bill becomes law the courts will be one whit less powerful than they are, or have one whit less authority.

Deputy MacEoin yesterday, and I think Deputy Mulcahy to-day, said that we put men on the public boards at the last local elections by virtue of the promises which we made. We did nothing of the sort. The point was made in this House yesterday that we succeeded in getting a number of creatures of our Party on the various public boards so that when an Act such as this would come along we would simply have a number of puppets on the boards of the country. I know something about the last local elections, and there never was a Party that did less to secure a majority on the public boards than we did. We made no intensive canvass and had no intensive campaign throughout the country. The people themselves did it, and for this reason. At that time there was a kind of wave of insanity over this country and a number of bosthoons, through the weakness of the Opposition leader, Deputy Cosgrave, in standing out of their way, paraded this country telling the people not to pay anything, throwing contempt on, and spurning the President, throwing every obstacle in the way of the Government. But the sensible men and women of the country, on a restricted franchise, gave us control practically of every county council in the Twenty-Six Counties. That is how we won the local elections. Anybody who says that we simply put these people there to carry on as a number of puppets certainly did not understand the position at that time.

Comment on this

How long are we going on with this? Is it in order, on the Fifth Stage of the Bill, to reply to everything said on the earlier Stages? Surely, what Deputy Donnelly has been saying for the last five minutes has no bearing on what is in the Bill?

Comment on this

I have made my point and I will leave it. Deputy Dillon, in the course of his speech, remarked that if we continued our tactics in two or three years there will be ruin and then we will have to go across to the Opposition and we would be welcome there and that they would help us to bring the country out of the mess. I remember when the organisation which was responsible for putting the Ministers on the Front Bench was established, predictions of a similar kind were made all over the country. Immediately before the Minister for Finance came into this House it was said that if he, and men like him, got Ministerial positions, the country would be ruined. That was seven or eight years ago.

Comment on this

It is coming true.

Comment on this

It was said that every bully would be taking out arms——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must not traverse and discuss every statement made by the Opposition at any time. The Deputy must tell us why the Bill should be passed by this House, or why it should not be passed.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir, I was relating that so as to make an analogy between the predictions that were made here this evening and similar predictions that were made seven years ago.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Are we to hear all those predictions on this Bill?

Comment on this

Very well. My impression is that the entire opposition to this Bill is merely a political move to attack the Government. There is not a solitary Deputy amongst the Opposition Deputies who believes that this Bill is going to do the thing so many of them have alleged it will do. After all, there must be some finality somewhere or other. If actions are to be taken every day against the Government similar to those taken by the County Louth and County Cork County Councils what will the end of government be? I was glad to hear Opposition Deputies saying last evening that they were all telling their constituents to pay their rates and annuities. But there are some Deputies who did not do that as yet. There are on the records of this House statements showing that members of this House told their constituents not to pay their rates or annuities.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

There is no such thing on the records of this House.

Comment on this

Deputy Minch made a speech which I quoted to this House already. He made that speech in Monasterevan and it was reported in the Leinster Advertiser advising the people not to pay rates. We have had from Deputies opposite statements as to the provision and what would happen if the councils could not collect their rates. But that attitude is now gone.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I want to say that I listened to Deputy Minch in this House denying that he made that statement in Monasterevan with which Deputy Donnelly is again charging him.

Comment on this

In the town of Monasterevan Deputy Minch said to the people that they should not pay rates or annuities. I will bring Deputy McGovern to the Library and show him the speech, in which he said, "Pay no rates or annuities while the Economic War is on." That is a quotation from the speech and he tried to explain it away afterwards. That speech was quoted also here by the Minister for Justice. At that time there was no anxiety as to what was to become of the finances of the county councils. There was no anxiety then about social services. These are now brought in here in order to make political capital and for no other reason.

Comment on this

If I might interrupt Deputy Donnelly for a minute, I want to put it to him as to a man who in general shows himself fair-minded that the most he is establishing here is that one Deputy made a speech in the sense to which he has referred. Is it fair, on the strength of that, to say that the whole Party was taking that line, when, with a little research, I could produce not one quotation but a hundred in the contrary sense?

Comment on this

What about Deputy Fagan and the others?

Comment on this

At the time that Deputy Minch made that speech, the Opposition Deputies were following a leader certainly not as responsible as the Deputy who is leading them to-day. There was a certain wave over the country at that particular time, and perhaps it was because of the extreme honesty of Deputy Minch that he made that speech. Perhaps also that speech was the outcome of certain deliberations that were taking place in other places at the time. The Party that makes up the Opposition to-day is as different from the Opposition Party of two years ago as——

Comment on this

So are you from what you were ten years ago.

Comment on this

I am delighted at last to hear Deputy Burke recognising us.

Comment on this

We are delighted to see you here.

Comment on this

I am delighted at last to hear Deputy Burke recognising us for once. It was the first time he recognised us except to say—I do not quite know the word to use. Now that he has spoken and said something to us, I hope he will give us a little more of his historical position and what his attitude was to us then——

Comment on this

My record is clean and unstained by blood.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

On the Bill.

Comment on this

We will all be delighted if he will tell us here what his political attitude was at that time. We thought we were doing good for the country. I am supporting this Bill because I believe it is going to tighten up things legally and otherwise.

Comment on this

It will tighten us up all right. It will tighten up all our belts.

Comment on this