Committee on Finance. - Vote 61—Unemployment Insurance and Unemployment Assistance.
Contributions 155–320 of 320. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Might I ask Deputy Mulcahy to request Deputy Briscoe to give the reference, the volume from which he has been quoting?
Comment on this
It is Volume 9, column 562. The Deputy might also read column 563 where Deputy McGilligan explains what he means. Have a good read outside now.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan provided more work through his labour exchanges than the present Minister while he was employing the labour exchanges in the same way. In the returns the Minister provides for occupational groups, in which he shows the number of vacancies provided every quarter through the labour exchanges, he told us that in the quarter ended 6th July, 1935, he filled 3,329 vacancies. At the end of the quarter there were 119,719 persons left registered as unemployed. In the last quarter of Deputy McGilligan's period of office, before the present Minister took over, he had filled vacancies through the labour exchanges to the number of 4,786, leaving 17,663 registered unemployed.
Comment on this
The particulars I have given appealed to me as one of the reasons which make the thing necessary and I want to stuff these figures down the throat of Deputy Kennedy, who brings into this debate some old lies and exaggerations with regard to statements by Deputy McGilligan. I want to say that in his last two years of office, Deputy McGilligan was putting more men into employment through the machinery of the labour exchanges than the present Minister has done. I would be unfair to the Minister if I did not continue the particulars I was giving in order to show what the position was in the October quarter.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan's administration does not arise on this Estimate. Deputy Mulcahy ought to come to the Estimate under discussion.
Comment on this
The Deputy could not possibly do that but, of course, we understand what the Deputy is at.
Comment on this
The circumstances under which vacancies were filled at the labour exchange were exactly the same as during Deputy McGilligan's period of office.
Comment on this
The Deputy was told that the labour exchanges were not acting in that manner this year but on my instructions.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot proceed on these lines on this Estimate. The matter he is trying to discuss can be properly raised on the Vote on Account, or on the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
Very good. One other point. When unemployment assistance is taken from certain people in Dublin they are put on relief work. When dealing with the Dublin Relief Bill I drew the attention of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health to the want of co-operation that existed between those who were in charge of those works and the Board of Assistance in the City of Dublin. I should like to ask the Minister to say, when he takes unemployment assistance away from a man, drafting him on to relief work, in circumstances that bring him in less in a week while working than he would get while he was not working, what arrangement he has made to get the Board of Public Assistance in the city informed of the circumstances, so that when a man is thrown upon relief he may not have to crawl around in humiliating and distressing circumstances to find out exactly what his position is. If taken off unemployment assistance there ought to be machinery for transferring such a case immediately and directly to the board of assistance people. It ought not to be the lot of an unfortunate man to have to go around from one office to another, explaining his circumstances, and trying to find out where is the link that would put him in a position of getting the additional money that under the poor relief scheme he is entitled to get in order to keep his family.
Comment on this
It is well to remark that Deputy Mulcahy's reasoning on this subject is in striking contrast to what his reasoning was three years ago on a proposed extension of old age pensions. When that proposal was before the Dáil, Deputy Mulcahy was in terror lest even one person should get the old age pension if he had means. The Deputy died several deaths in his anxiety on that matter.
Comment on this
Now he is prepared to take unlimited chances. What does it matter, he says, about the means of people applying for unemployment assistance?
Comment on this
I do not want to delay the division on this question. I rose to ask the Minister if he has come to any decision on a particular problem that has arisen in fishing centres, and with regard to fishermen who being applicants for unemployment assistance were deprived of it apparently through a misunderstanding of the conditions that prevailed in the industry. I suppose these conditions prevail in other centres as well as Arklow. But in Arklow, at all events, you have this position. Men are offered employment in fishing boats. In order to qualify for unemployment assistance they have to accept that. They may go out and spend the night on a fishing boat but if there is no fish there is no reward. At the same time they are employed and, consequently, not entitled to unemployment assistance. That is obviously an anomaly; and what I cannot understand is why the local manager has not long ago brought the facts to the notice of the Minister. Recently the question has come to a crisis in Arklow, and the urban council passed a resolution calling the Minister's attention to it and asking him to rectify the anomaly. I should like to know whether the Minister has come to any decision thereon or whether special arrangements will be made to deal with the question. The case seems to suggest that there is often, at headquarters, insufficient appreciation of particular local conditions. That may lead to incorrect decisions in some cases. It seems to me that local officers should be required to observe peculiar facts of that kind, in their districts, and to report upon these facts; and that that should be one of the conditions of their service.
At the same time, I cannot say, from my experience, that the Unemployment Assistance Act is not being administered in a most careful and exact way. There have been unfortunate delays in particular cases. There have been a few cases of incorrect decisions but, generally speaking, and considering the immense complexity of the Act, and considering the great difficulty of getting entirely correct evidence, it seems to me a marvellous thing that the Act should be working so well. I think there is very great appreciation throughout the country, on the part of those drawing unemployment assistance, as to what is being done for them and as to the great sympathy with unemployed people which is being shown by those administering the Act. The last thing one will find amongst persons who have the advantage of the Act is any tendency to make general complaints in regard to it. It looks to me altogether unworthy to use this subject as an occasion for playing politics. It will always be a very difficult matter to administer such an Act; to get exact evidence, and to avoid delays. Considering the very great difficulties that may be expected, and the numerous interests that have to be considered in the administration of such an Act, I submit it is not at all a question on which there should be that nagging type of criticism we heard to-day, or in relation to which efforts should be made to score off the Minister.
It is very easy to make a speech of the type Deputy Norton made about the great advantage of having every man and woman in the country in employment; everybody realises that. And when he suggests that hard thinking should be engaged in, and that there should be an immense effort completely to cure unemployment, he is doing a thing that is very easy for him or anybody else to do. But no matter what may have been said in the past, I think it is evident that that hard thinking is required from every citizen who is interested in the problem. The great tribute that must be paid, I think, to the present Government in connection with the problem is that in face of such terrific depression in agriculture, in face of difficulties of a general kind that they have had to encounter, there has been a substantial increase in employment throughout the country, and that there is every indication that that increase is likely to continue in the future. Comparing the position in agriculture here with the position in England, a very gratifying fact emerges. In England last year there was a reduction of 60,000 in the number of agricultural labourers in regular employment, while here in the same year there was an increase in the number of agricultural labourers employed. It is very gratifying to find also that in the country as a whole there is an increase in employment, in face of the difficult circumstances which obtained during the last few years; it is a matter on which many countries would be glad to be in a position to pride themselves. In my opinion it shows that the Government is on the way towards reducing this unemployment problem, as we all hope, to the narrowest possible dimensions.
Comment on this
I propose, for the purpose of saving time, to suggest to Deputy Briscoe that now that I have got the relevant volume his bluff is called, and there is no use in repeating the hoary old statement about Deputy McGilligan; it will only waste time.
Comment on this
In regard to administration, Deputy Kennedy made reference to an alleged statement by Deputy McGilligan. That was met by Deputy Mulcahy, and that closes the incident.
Comment on this
Am I to take it that this acrobatic volubility expert and veracity contortionist over there can just say: "Here is the volume; I do not propose to read it; your bluff is called"?
Comment on this
I want first of all to refer to a practice which is growing in this House, and which I think ought to stop.
Comment on this
I must ask the Minister to try to behave himself. He finds it difficult, but he ought to exert himself to the limit of his capacity. A practice is growing up here of referring in either laudatory or condemnatory terms to individual civil servants. I deplore that practice. The Minister is here to answer for his actions, and I think it ill-becomes Deputies to animadvert at great length on the shortcomings or merits of individual civil servants.
Comment on this
The Chair is always very careful that civil servants are not referred to in this House in such a way that the individual civil servants could be picked out or recognised. The Chair is very careful of that.
Comment on this
I am not alleging disorder at all. When I so desire, I shall raise the matter on a point of order. I am referring to a general trend in practice here, which I have a perfect right to deplore. I do deplore it. I think Deputies in this House should adhere strictly to attacks on the Minister.
Comment on this
The Deputy is making an indirect statement that references have been allowed to pass here by which the individuals in question could be recognised. That has not been allowed by the Chair on any occasion in this House.
Comment on this
I am making a statement which contains no indirect reference whatever. It is an expressed statement that I deplore the practice of drawing civil servants into the discussions here, and I exhort members of the House to confine themselves to attacks upon the Minister if they are dissatisfied with his Department, or to praise of the Minister if they are satisfied with his Department. I pass from that practice; it is highly undesirable from every point of view. What I am particularly concerned about is a more fundamental matter than has been touched upon by any Deputy who has spoken on this Estimate. What I apprehend is that the whole principle of unemployment assistance is becoming a discredit to this country——
Comment on this
——owing to the abuses that have arisen under the inefficient administration of the Minister for Industry and Commerce; abuses which made it necessary to provide £10,000 over and above the original Estimate; abuses which betrayed him into the folly of reducing the original Estimate by £3,000 on the occasion of the Budget. This Party stands unequivocally for the principle of unemployment assistance. Persons who are willing to work and are unable to find it are entitled to receive from the State such assistance as may be necessary to keep them in a reasonable standard of comfort until such work is forthcoming, but advanced social services of that kind cannot subsist without the cordial support of the whole community. At the present time there is no use in disguising the fact that there are numbers of persons up and down the country who are in receipt of unemployment assistance and who ought not to be getting it; they have no more claim to unemployment assistance than I have. There are other men who want unemployment assistance, and who ought to have it, but who do not seem to be able to get through the forest of red tape which surrounds the issuing of their qualification certificate, and their subsequent admission to benefit under the Unemployment Assistance Acts.
I do not want to minimise for a single moment the difficulties that must have beset the Minister and his Department in the setting up of the machinery in the early stages of this new departure, but a time is coming, if it has not already arrived, when we should have reached a degree of efficiency which would ensure that an applicant for his legal benefits under this Act would have them made available to him without undue delay. That is not happening.
Comment on this
The time has also come when the machinery of investigation ought to be sufficiently effective to sort the wheat from the chaff. At present, as far as I can see, the system of investigation seems to be very much a hit and miss business.
Comment on this
When the Minister gets uneasy, and the unemployment assistance disbursements are causing alarm, he issues an ukase that steps must be taken to reduce the amount of the assistance. Then there is an examination of the means and circumstances of everyone holding a qualification certificate. That is, in my opinion, a great evil. It is a great evil not from a monetary point of view, because a few thousand pounds one way or the other are not going to make any permanent difference to the finances of the State, but from the point of view of shaking the confidence of the people of the country in the doctrine that unemployment assistance, in addition to unemployment insurance, is a desirable social service. The opinion is spreading abroad through the country that unemployment assistance is being made a slush fund for political purposes in this country, and that in every constituency where it is desired to promote the popularity of the Government money is allowed to flow very freely.
Comment on this
I am solicitous to ensure that that impression will not spread, and that it will become clear to everybody that all Parties in this House stand for unemployment assistance for those that are entitled to it, and the rigorous exclusion from the benefits of the Act of anybody who should not get it.
Comment on this
I do not criticise the investigation; I welcome it. But I want the class of investigation which is designed to arrive at the merits of the individual applicant, and not primarily designed to relieve the burden on the Exchequer. That is what is happening at present, that endeavours are being made to weed out a number of people with the primary purpose of relieving the drain on the Exchequer and not of arriving at a true estimate of the rights of the individuals whose claims are being investigated.
Comment on this
If the Minister is persuaded in the debate that the Court of Referees set up by him under the Act are not doing the work as it ought to be done, it is the Minister's duty to take such steps as may be necessary to alter that procedure.
Comment on this
I do not purport to recommend legislation to amend the Principal Act, because it would not be relevant or in order to do so. My duty is to point out the abuses, and, without asking for immediate legislation, to leave it to the Minister to take such steps as may be effective to remove them.
Comment on this
The third abuse that exists is that when a man goes off unemployment assistance, having got work, the business of getting back into benefit seems to take an interminable time, with the result that in rural Ireland now if you ask a man to take a job of work which will only last perhaps a week or ten days, the common answer is that he could not afford to take broken work of that kind because he would lose more of the unemployment assistance while trying to get back on to the register than he would earn in wages doing the broken work. That is common knowledge all over the country.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows full well that that complaint is being made and, instead of wrangling and snarling about giving instances, can he not ask Deputies of his own Party, who are familiar with rural conditions, and they will confirm what I say. There is no necessity to snarl and protest because we all feel sympathy with the Minister in the difficulties experienced in getting machinery of this kind to work effectively. What I am putting now is that he wants to look into the machinery whereby a man goes back on to unemployment assistance after enjoying a broken period of work, because if he does not two evils accrue: (1) a wholly unnecessary burden is put on the Exchequer by the man who remains on assistance when he could get work; and (2) that men are being demoralised in that they are deliberately abstaining from work which they conscientiously feel they ought to take when they get the offer, but they feel that to take it would cost them more than they would get in wages.
Comment on this
Name one case where that happened. Why does the Deputy make the allegation if he cannot name a case?
Comment on this
If the Minister investigates it, he will find it is true. Several Deputies on his own benches from rural Ireland will tell him the same story. Of course, Deputy Briscoe knows nothing of rural conditions.
Comment on this
It applies in every part of rural Ireland — in Donegal, Mayo, Limerick, Roscommon, Leix and Offaly, Waterford, Wexford, all over Ireland. It arises because the machinery is breaking down in that regard. It may be possible to remedy that — I think it probably is — but it is something that requires a remedy and to which attention should be given without delay. We are now seeking an additional Estimate for unemployment assistance. I want to put it to the Government that this increased Estimate would be unnecessary if they would adopt the policy of their predecessors in office, and that is, without undertaking directly to employ men themselves, or, in addition to doing that, that they would take steps to stimulate other employment which would absorb these men, for whom this £10,000 provision is being made, in remunerative work. So far as my own constituency is concerned, I want to make a suggestion to the Minister.
Comment on this
It would be out of order on this Estimate. That has been ruled several times already.
Comment on this
In connection with my own constituency, I want to make a suggestion to the Minister that would materially help him in reducing the number of 13,800 people in receipt of unemployment assistance in Donegal.
Comment on this
No. I shall outline my proposal lest it should appear that I want to avoid your ruling. What I am suggesting is that they should make remunerative the production of kelp. The next is that trade negotiations should be undertaken to secure a market for herrings.
Comment on this
This Estimate deals purely with the administration of the Unemployment Assistance Act.
Comment on this
The Minister asks for £10,000, and our lips are to be sealed as to any other method of relieving these people in that area.
Comment on this
The Deputy can discuss why the Minister should not get that sum because of past administration. The Deputy must relate the statement to some head of this Estimate.
Comment on this
I relate it to head J. The Minister requires £10,000 to relieve the distress of persons who cannot get work in Donegal.
Comment on this
I say these people are unemployed for certain reasons, and I want to suggest remedies in order that the £10,000 need not be voted.
Comment on this
Are we simply to say, when the Minister asks for £10,000: "Very well, you must have it"? Nobody can suggest any reasons——
Comment on this
The Deputy can suggest many reasons, but he must do so on the basis of the administration of the Act.
Comment on this
I say this £10,000 ought not to be asked for. Am I free to say that? I say it ought not to be asked for because there is abundant work for the men to do if the Minister will make——
Comment on this
The Deputy can say that the money should not be given because of the administration of the Act, but not because he is not seeking employment for them elsewhere by any other means.
Comment on this
It appears to me perfectly clear that if the Minister says: "If you do not like this Estimate, tell us how we can avoid it; if you do not like an increase, how am I to avoid it," I can reply: "There is another way; if you will allow employment to circulate out to them they will not require the assistance you propose to give them." That is what I want to do.
Comment on this
Then I do not propose to pursue it further than saying that there are methods, particularly in the Gaeltacht, which could be profitably pursued to that end. However, as the Chair takes the view that we cannot discuss alternative methods of relieving distress, I do not propose to waste time pursuing it. I do, however, urge strongly on the Minister to investigate closely the question of the rural labourer who takes temporary work and is trying to get back on to unemployment assistance and finds it impossible to do so.
Comment on this
I desire to draw the Minister's attention to the serious position of the sailors and fishermen in the Arklow area and to the inconvenience caused to them. If a man refuses to go on a boat, he is refused unemployment benefit. When he does go on a boat and fails to get any share out of the fishing, he is also refused unemployment benefit. I have knowledge of one case as to which I should like the Minister or the Court of Referees to say where they got the particulars. They should send as a souvenir to the Minister for Fisheries the estimate of allowances that they make out for a man engaged on the share system on one of these boats going out for a night's fishing.
There is then the case of a man who has been working as a builder's labourer for the last two years. Previously he was a fisherman. He was refused assistance because he would not go on a particular boat. The man had not the equipment to go as a sailor. He had not either the oilskins or the top-boots. He appealed to the Court of Referees. It decided against him, holding that he had refused to take employment as a sailor on a particular boat on which, according to the Court of Referees, he could earn £4 to £5 a week. In the case that was referred to by Deputy Moore where men took the risk of going out in boats they did not get unemployment assistance, home help, or even a share out of these £5 a week earnings that the court of referees talks about. It must have very valuable information in its possession when it decides that a sailor, if he takes employment, can earn £5 a week. I think that the Minister for Lands and Fisheries, as well as the fishermen and sailors in Arklow, would be glad to have made available to them that source of information.
There is every reason why men of the class for whom I speak should not be treated in the way that they have been by the Court of Referees. They are genuinely seeking work, and are prepared to risk their lives in doing so, and when they cannot get any return for their labours, it is a shame that they should be refused unemployment assistance. I would be glad if the Minister would look into the case of these fishermen. People who understand the conditions are puzzled by the decision of the Court of Referees some of the members of which would not be able to distinguish a herring from a mackerel. It is absurd to say that a sailor can earn £5 a week.
My next case is that of a man living in a labourer's cottage in West Wicklow. He was employed on task work breaking stones for the county council. The Court of Referees decided that his income from the cottage and plot was 10/- a week. The members of the court who came to that decision are, in my opinion, losing their time. They should be Chancellors of the Exchequer. If their decision in that case is right, what must be the income of some of the people in Galway of whom we hear so much in this House living on holdings of £4 valuation? In my opinion, it is absurd to put an income of 10/- a week on a labourer's cottage and a half-acre plot in West Wicklow. It is as ridiculous as to say that fishermen can earn £5 a week. The conclusion one is driven to is that those who constitute the Court of Referees are not actuated by any sort of human feeling in coming to a decision in these cases.
As regards the new regulation dealing with the employment figure, I would ask the Minister to give special consideration to the Wicklow area. There is no work for young men or agricultural labourers in County Wicklow. Take the Avoca district. We had mines being worked there at one time. The young men unemployed there at present are not entitled to unemployment assistance. As a result, the County Wicklow Board of Health will have to try and give them some assistance to maintain themselves. In the Avoca district you have more than 50 or 60 young men ready to take work if it can be found for them. The few farmers in the district do very little tillage, and do not require any labourers. Wicklow is so far away from Carlow that it derives practically no advantage from the Government's schemes for the growing of sugar beet. I hope the Minister will pay special attention to the fact that we have a large number of agricultural labourers idle in the County Wicklow who are quite ready to take work if they can get it. The new regulation, when it comes into operation, is likely to deprive many people there of unemployment assistance.
I hope that, by introducing amending legislation or in some other way, the Minister will do something to make special provision for the fishermen in Arklow. They are men who are genuinely seeking work. I would ask the Minister to inquire why a particular boat was selected for those men to chance their lives in, and why they should be deprived of their unemployment assistance because they refused to go on it. The Minister might also ask the Court of Referees how it came to decide that a sailor can earn £5 a week. I admit that three or four years ago fishermen did earn up to £4 and £5 a week, but in late years their earnings have not been anything like that, not even 10/- a week in some cases.
I have also to bring to the notice of the Minister a case of a man in Bray. When he inquired why he was not getting unemployment assistance, he received a reply from the labour exchange manager that the matter was receiving attention. It was discovered afterwards that the delay was due to some mistake made at headquarters. In the meantime, the man was brought before the court for the non-payment of the rent of his house, and the board of health had to come to his assistance. It is quite easy to understand, of course, how a clerical error can take place where you are dealing with 150,000 applications. What should have been done in that case was to get a report from the manager of the employment exchange. If something like that had been done, this man would not have been kept waiting for two or three months for his unemployment assistance. I have nothing to say against the Act, but in connection with its administration we get a good many serious complaints. I hope the Minister will look into the cases that I have brought to his notice, where you have the Court of Referees deciding that sailors can earn up to £4 and £5 a week, and that a man in a labourer's cottage and half-acre plot is held to have an income of 10/- a week. Following these decisions, the persons concerned were deprived of their unemployment assistance. I hope the Minister will make special inquiries and see that steps are taken to give these people unemployment assistance.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy O'Neill and Deputy Pattison rose.
Comment on this
The object of the Deputy is to prevent me from replying to the statements that have been made from that side.
Comment on this
That is a disorderly and scandalous performance on the part of the Minister. There is no such intention on this side of the House.
Comment on this
The tactics of the Deputies opposite is to break agreements as soon as they are made.
Comment on this
Will the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary indicate with whom this agreement is supposed to have been made?
Comment on this
When I had a conversation with your Whips on Thursday it was understood that this Vote would be concluded to-day. As we are taking a Vote-on-Account next week we must get on with the business.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary and the Minister have stated definitely that there was an agreement. I was speaking to Deputy Mulcahy within the last ten minutes and I am satisfied that there was no such agreement.
Comment on this
Surely before making the accusation the Minister ought to say if there was any such agreement. I say there was not. I asked the Parliamentary Secretary to say with whom he made the agreement.
Comment on this
I have no intention of impeding the business or of preventing the Minister from replying. I was certainly not sent in here to do so. I tried to get in earlier this morning and failed. I want to intervene now to draw special attention to a matter raised by Deputy Moore and by Deputy Everett with regard to persons engaged on fishing and where the Act militates against them getting benefits. Persons employed on fishing boats are immediately scheduled as "working". They may work for weeks without earning anything but in the meantime they lose the unemployment benefit. That is the position around the coast, and particularly in coastal towns like Arklow, Dungarvan, Kinsale, Bantry and other places. I am asking the Minister if he could take steps to see that no hardship will be inflicted on men who take employment fishing, but who are not earning. The easiest way to deal with the matter would be to substitute the word "earning" by the word "working". If a man gets employment on land he is looked upon as a wage earner, but a person who goes on a boat, either on change or on a share system, depending on the catch for a living, is in a very precarious position, and very often is weeks and weeks without earning a penny. Another fishing problem along the seaboard concerns persons scheduled as small farmers and cottiers. They come under the terms of the employment Order which comes into operation on next Thursday. If the terms of that Order are insisted upon they will inflict severe hardships on people in places like Hare Island, Stark Island and in the peninsula of Bere. These are all small necessitous people living along the seaboard.
Comment on this
Some of them would be over £4. Valuations of £4 are very small. In County Cork we have 10,000 farmers with valuations of £4 and under living on the seaboard. Perhaps the Minister would be able to extend the limit beyond £4, and to bring in a larger number under the benefits of the Act. I also wish to refer to another type of coastal town employment. There is a class of employment known as "hobblers," who are engaged in the discharge of ships. Most of the work is of a temporary character or piece-work. As that class of work has been seriously affected, it is very hard to get men to take on such jobs. They do not want to take up that employment because they say that it takes three or four weeks before they can get on to the Exchange books again. The machinery should be speeded up and made more efficient as regards men who get temporary work, because three weeks is a long time to have to wait for assistance. These men are specialists at hobbling work, and rarely do any other class of work. Their chances of work being few and far between, they are severely handicapped by the regulations. There should be some provision introduced into the administration of the Act whereby instead of having appeals sent away for decision the local officers should be empowered to deal with them as far as temporary work is concerned. The people affected find it difficult to live while waiting for their money. They have no credit, and in the meantime cannot claim home assistance. There is a problem to be solved there, and it is weighing very severely on poor persons. Generally speaking, I have no criticism to offer on the general administration of the Act. As far as my experience goes local officers, in most cases, have been most sympathetic and have done their best in difficult circumstances to do their duty.
Comment on this
A number of points dealing with administration have been raised in the course of the debate, some of which are important, and with which I should like to deal. We had also a few general matters raised which I propose to dispose of in the first instance. We had Deputy Morrissey opening for the Party opposite, and giving an indication of the line they were likely to take in this debate; an indication which, perhaps, it was desirable to have. I have the utmost contempt for Deputies like Deputy Morrissey, who address themselves to the question of unemployment, and make it quite evident that their only interest in the unemployed is the votes they hope to get. Deputy Morrissey went so far as to repudiate any responsibility on his part of putting forward even one constructive suggestion for the easement of the position. He does not regard himself as a member of the council of the nation, called here to assist in the solution of the nation's problems. He regards himself merely as an agent of a political Party whose only purpose is to help that Party to get votes.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Chair specifically ruled that no suggestion could be made in the course of the debate for the easement of the problem of unemployment. I asked leave to make three concrete suggestions, and the Minister promptly raised a point of order objecting, and he was sustained by the Leas-Cheann Comhairle. I then intimated my intention of departing from that and making these suggestions on another occasion, at the Minister's request.
Comment on this
I am not disputing that the Chair has ruled on that but I am pointing to the admission—and it cannot be disputed—of Deputy Morrissey and his Party that they do not regard themselves as being under any obligation to put forward proposals for the easement of unemployment. Therefore I invited him to put down a motion. I would be very much surprised to see such a motion forthcoming. I also invited him to indicate what was the policy of his Party on the question of employment period orders. We will possibly have a motion on that as we know where the Labour Party stand in relation to it. I am prepared to debate with them at any time the question of the justification of these orders. I want to know where the Party opposite stands. They are trying to maintain a position in which they can have a foot in each camp. Some Deputy like Deputy Morrissey will appear to advocate labour interests and another Deputy will advocate the contrary. We had from Deputy Dillon another display of his ability to stand up and make a pompous speech about something of which he knows nothing; a speech he could not have made if he had even read the Act, and which revealed from the beginning his ignorance of its provisions, and which was based entirely on his opening assumption, that the unemployment assistance fund was being used for political purposes. A slush fund for Fianna Fáil was how he described it. He stated that I issued orders that in some constituencies people were to be deprived of unemployment insurance benefit, and that in other constituencies the administration was not to be so strict.
If the Deputy were aware of the nature of the administration, or of the functions of the Minister in relation to the Act, he would know that these orders could not have been issued. I gave no instructions at any time concerning the manner in which the Act was to be administered, except the original instructions, the effect of which was to see that the intention of the Dáil was being carried out and that those people who, the Act prescribed, were entitled to unemployment assistance, would get it, and nobody else. It is as much the function of the Department to see that those who are not entitled to get it should not get it, as it is its function to see that those who are entitled to it do get it. The Minister has no power in connection with appeals against a refusal of unemployment assistance, nor has he any power to determine appeals concerning the granting of qualification certificates. The Act lays down a definite procedure for the determination of all those questions and leaves the Minister completely out of it. If a person is refused assistance he has an appeal to the Court of Referees. The courts of referees are not constituted on a political basis, as Deputy Dillon tried to convey. Each court consists, one half of persons nominated by organisations representative of the interests of employers, and the other half of persons nominated by organisations representative of the interests of the workers, and the chairman is usually a solicitor or barrister with a practice in the area in which the court operates. That is the body which deals with appeals. There is a further appeal from that body to the Umpire, but there is no appeal to the Minister, and Deputy Dillon's attempt to show that political considerations were in any way affecting the administration of the Act was merely typical of the statements Deputy Dillon makes, and typical of the kind of statement that is usually made from the opposite side.
We had a statement by Deputy Cosgrave to-day to the effect that Ministers over here are all dishonest, untruthful, stupid and amoral. That kind of statement is typical of the Party opposite. Their sole function seems to be to abuse Ministers and make all these stupid allegations concerning the administration of their Departments. It never seems to enter their heads that they should make any attempt to deal with the problems that Deputies are sent here to deal with, or to try to solve or overcome these problems and difficulties. They never have done so, and I suggest that their effectiveness here would be very much increased if they dropped all this personal abuse of individuals and these wild allegations of corruption and dishonesty, and tried to think of some way of dealing with the problems that the House is called upon to deal with. At any rate, they should at least attempt to find out the facts before they come here to abuse those who are trying to solve things for them. We had Deputy Mulcahy here to-day deliberately misrepresenting the information supplied to him by the House. I can come to no other conclusion, because explanations of that information were given to him within the past fortnight.
Comment on this
Well, then, I charge him with giving an interpretation of the figures which he must know is wrong.
Comment on this
Well, then, Sir, I will charge Deputy Mulcahy with inability to understand figures at any time. These employment period Orders, to which reference was made, are made for a definite reason. The Order which comes into operation next week is confined to persons owning land in excess of £4 valuation. These persons are excluded from unemployment assistance, as from next week, because of the reasonable assumption that anybody owning land to that extent cannot be unemployed at this time of the year; that upon these holdings there is work to be done, if the holdings are being worked by them, sufficient to make it impossible for them at the same time to be available for other employment if it were offered. That is a reasonable assumption, and I do not think it is seriously contended that it is not reasonable. The allegation which Deputy Mulcahy made against Deputy Corbett, that these farmers in County Galway, within that valuation, were too lazy to work, is typical of the accusations and abuse we are accustomed to from Cumann na nGaedheal speakers. Deputy Corbett said nothing of the kind. He said that there were certain farmers, who had not paid their annuities and were trying to pose as martyrs, who were within the description he gave of being too lazy to work or too interested in racehorses to attend to the work of their farms.
Comment on this
The small farmers in County Galway, who are the backbone of the Fianna Fáil Party and who constitute the main bulk of their supporters in that county, are amongst the hardest working people in this country, and because they are hard working and honest, they have shown their contempt for the people opposite.
Comment on this
I should say that Deputy Corbett also referred to the agricultural labourers of County Galway and said there was plenty of work for them.
Comment on this
Yes, there is plenty of work in this country for any man who wants to work. There is plenty of work for the ranchers if they want to work. I said that the Galway farmers were hard-working, decent people and that they had paid their annuities.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey had certain questions to ask about the unemployment register and the number of people employed. As a result of the measures taken, we have directly increased employment in this country by a substantial amount in the last year and the previous years. These measures are well known, and it is not necessary to reiterate them for Deputy Morrissey.
Comment on this
For example, when we were endeavouring to facilitate and make possible the establishment of an aluminium factory in Nenagh, Deputy Morrissey voted against it.
Comment on this
I am prepared to accept the Deputy's word, with examination. At any rate, he was in the House when his Party voted against it, and perhaps he will explain his attitude on the occasion.
Comment on this
That is always the way with the Minister. Whenever he is challenged he tries to twist and turn and get away from the point. The Minister made a charge against me which he cannot substantiate.
Comment on this
I published a short while ago a memorandum prepared by a committee of experts in my Department concerning the employment and unemployment position. I did so, not merely to provide information which would be of very definite value to persons seriously interested in these problems, but also to prevent misunderstandings of future statistics that might be made available. There are 140,000 or so persons upon the register of unemployed. To represent that number as being the total of persons unemployed in the country is entirely fallacious, and Deputies know that it is nothing of the kind.
Comment on this
That is entirely fallacious. There are less. A substantial number of those who are on the register are persons who are landholders or the sons of landholders living with their fathers, and these and other persons of that category are not and never were capable of being properly described as unemployed. The number of such persons is known now for the first time. It was never known before and there is no basis on which that register figure can be compared with the figure for any period previous to the coming into operation of the Unemployment Assistance Act. There is one method of comparison, perhaps, and that is with regard to the number of people entitled to unemployment insurance benefit; and that shows that in 1935 the number of such persons was reduced by about 15 or 16 per cent.
Comment on this
Let us take the total register and analyse it. There was a small increase at the beginning of this year as compared with the beginning of last year. The whole of that increase took place in Connaught, and is entirely due to the fact that there is a larger number of people in Connaught, consequent upon the stoppage of emigration and to the circumstances which exist there, which are well known to Deputies. There was no increase in the number upon the register for the county boroughs and urban areas. In the province of Leinster, exclusive of the county boroughs, there was a definite decrease in the number registered. There was a similar decrease in the province of Munster, exclusive of the county boroughs. Deputy Morrissey could have got these figures for himself. Instead of that, he chose to misrepresent the position by his assertion that the number of persons unemployed in these areas in Munster had considerably increased.
He went on further to say that although we had put persons into employment in industry, for every one person put into employment, we had put three persons out. I asked Deputy Morrissey to tell us the occupations from which they had been put out of employment. He did not answer the question, and he cannot answer it, because it is not true, as the total number of persons in employment has increased. We can get separate figures for each occupation and show that all over there was an increase. In last year, 1935, as compared with 1934, the average number of persons employed each week was higher by 13,000. That information is available to Deputies but they chose to ignore it. Their one anxiety is to try to belittle the country, to destroy its credit, to do all the damage they can, in the hope that, in consequence of that damage, they may get some additional political support. It is a completely reckless, unpatriotic and scandalous performance they give us on all occasions upon which the opportunity is offered to them.
There is an unemployment problem here, and it is because there is an unemployment problem here that the Unemployment Assistance Act was passed and various exceptional and extraordinary measures for dealing with that problem have been adopted by the Government. The Government is sincerely anxious to take any step possible for it to take to relieve that situation. We had perhaps at some time the vain hope that Deputies opposite would feel compelled to co-operate with us on that one matter, if on no other, but, instead of that we are getting their wrecking tactics and their continuous obstructive efforts to defeat the plans we have adopted, for purely Party ends. Deputy Dillon tells us pompously that his Party accepts the principle of the Unemployment Assistance Act, but they tried to prevent us from getting the money to enable unemployment assistance to be paid. All during last summer, they continued their obstructive campaign to prevent that money being provided and then they tell us they stand by the principle of it. Humbug and hypocrisy!
I want to deal now with matters of importance that were raised by Deputies who seriously addressed themselves to the administration of unemployment assistance. The question of the application of the Unemployment Assistance Act to fishermen is having consideration. It is a complicated matter and I cannot say yet what modifications in the existing regulations may be necessary. The only Arklow case, however, of which I am aware, is one which raised no question of principle at all. It was reported that fishermen in Arklow had refused employment in fishing. Assistance was suspended and the case went to the Court of Referees. On the first occasion the applicants themselves failed to make their case, but subsequently new evidence was brought forward by them, and, on the basis of that new evidence, their cases were allowed by the Court of Referees. It is entirely untrue to say that there is any unreasonable delay at the present time in the investigation of claims or in the determination of appeals.
There was, I admit, some time ago a very considerable accumulation of appeal cases when the existing machinery was inadequate to dispose of these cases, and on that account we changed the machinery. We brought in here an amending Act and set up a new appeals procedure. That new appeals procedure has worked as we intended it should work. We said that that machinery would be used in an endeavour to clear off the arrears at the rate of 2,000 a week. It succeeded in doing that, and there are now no appeals outstanding, except those of quite recent date. It is not true that persons who got spells of employment are compelled to wait for a long period after the conclusion of that employment before again becoming entitled to unemployment assistance, and before getting unemployment assistance.
Comment on this
If the period of employment does not exceed six weeks the person is entitled to unemployment assistance as from the date upon which the period of employment ends. In a minority of cases there may be delay of a short period while investigations are being made and inquiries conducted, but in the great majority of cases there is no delay, and if there should be such delay the amount due as from the date on which employment ended is paid retrospectively. Nor should there be any difficulty, if an investigation takes time, in dealing with these cases through the home assistance authorities. The home assistance authorities have complete discretion in the granting of home assistance, and the Act which we passed last year provides for the repayment to these authorities, if they so claim, of the amount of any assistance they have given from the accumulation of unemployment assistance payable, if and when the case is decided in the applicant's favour.
Comment on this
Anonymous letters are received and it is not possible for the Department to ignore the information in them. They are made the basis of investigation and I may say that our experience has been that in the great majority of cases the information has been shown to be accurate. But the amount of information that comes through anonymous letters is only a small part of the information that comes to the Department concerning particular cases from other sources. There are quite a number of citizens in the country who feel it their duty, unlike Deputy Cosgrave, to bring directly to the notice of the Department any cases of abuse that come to their notice, and, on the basis of these allegations or complaints, investigations are instituted, but they are carried out in a perfectly fair manner. The facts are examined by the unemployment assistance officer, in the first instance, and he makes his decision. If the applicant is not satisfied, there is an appeal to the Court of Referees, and the Court of Referees is entirely free from departmental influence.
Comment on this
Deputy Anthony referred to the circumstances prevailing in Cork where certain people were being transferred outside the borough boundary. The Act provides for different rates of assistance within and outside the borough boundary, and I have no power to pay the borough rate outside the borough boundary area. Any alteration in that position would require an amendment of the Act. An amendment of the Act, however, would not get rid of that problem, because, so long as you have different rates of assistance, there must be a boundary somewhere, and there will be one person inside the area and another outside, and the circumstances of such persons might well be the same. That situation in Cork appears to me to be best capable of being remedied by an extension of the borough boundary, which. I understand, can be accomplished through the Department of Local Government. If the boundary is extended, the Act of 1935 gives us power to pay forthwith to the persons in the added area the appropriate rates.
The matter of the temporary clerks is at present being dealt with. I agree that there is some case for providing means by which these clerks could hope to be made, in due course, permanent officers of the Department. There are, however, the Civil Service (Regulation) Acts which prescribe that any permanent officers of the Government must be recruited through the Civil Service Commissioners and by competitive examination.
Comment on this
That is more a matter for the Minister for Finance, who controls the Civil Service, than for me. Deputy Bennett referred to the cost of administration as shown in this Estimate, and related that to the amount of unemployment assistance paid. That was an entirely misleading calculation. The amount provided for administration in this Estimate covers not merely the administration of unemployment assistance, but also the administration of unemployment insurance, the administration of the labour exchanges themselves, the administration of the functions of the Department in relation to relief schemes, the distribution of beef vouchers and a number of other matters. The total amount shown there has no relation to the amount of unemployment assistance, and, in fact, having regard to the extent of the service, the administration, in my opinion, is extraordinarily cheap. Some Deputies will allege that it is too cheap.
Comment on this
There were a few other matters raised by Deputy Mulcahy, but I have not time to deal with them.
Comment on this
I think I have dealt with most of the matters of importance and have satisfied any reasonable person that the administration of the Department is as reasonably efficient as it is possible to make it in the circumstances. I explained at the beginning that the introduction of this Supplementary Estimate is purely a formality. It may or may not happen that the amount to be paid in unemployment assistance will exceed the total of the Estimate as originally introduced, but it is possible that we will not reach the total of the Estimate as originally introduced. It is necessary, however, to be sure that the money will be available to pay whatever unemployment assistance claims are acknowledged between now and the end of the financial year. That is why this money is necessary, but, in fact, the money provided already may not have to be expended.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say when he proposes to lay on the Table the employment period Order which he has made?
Comment on this
The only reason for delay between the date on which the Order was made and its being laid on the Table is the fact that it has to be translated and printed. When that is done, it will be laid on the Table. It will certainly be there before next week.
Comment on this
I think the Minister will agree that on principle it is undesirable that such an Order should be made and scheduled to come into operation, as a general rule, before the opportunity is given of raising it in the House.
Estimate agreed to and reported.
The Dáil adjourned at 2 p.m. until 3 p.m. on Wednesday, 4th March, 1936.