In Committee on Finance. - Vote 52—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 128–293 of 293. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Deputy Dillon, of course, has not the courage to say that he will not adopt it. He does not go the whole way. Some Deputy said—and it is typical of the remarks passed during the debate—that farmers could not pay decent wages and grow beet at 37/6 a ton. The same Deputies are impressing on us in their speeches that the English farmers can pay a better wage. Deputy Holohan, perhaps, did not say that, but several Deputies on the opposite side have said that the English farmer can afford to pay a much bigger wage than the Irish farmer. The English farmer is getting the same price for his beet. He is getting 37/6 for 15½ per cent, and, if you take an average of 17½ per cent., he gets 5/- more.
Comment on this
We will come to those in a minute. He pays more than that extra 5/- for the offals, which our farmers get free, so that the English farmer is in a worse position with regard to beet than the Irish farmer. Still we have this talk about the Irish farmer not being able to pay a living wage to his agricultural labourers. Deputy Dillon condemns flatly all this arrangement of subsidies. He has again and again said that farming cannot be made to run on subsidies, but Deputy Dillon made an appeal to me during his speech. He said:—
"I suggest that the Minister should set on foot some scheme for subsidising the production of cheeses of that character."
That referred to farmers' cheese. He wanted me to encourage the production of farmers' cheese by subsidising it.
Comment on this
That is the end of the paragraph, at column 439. I have one other little quotation from the Deputy which I will give him while he is looking that up.
Comment on this
Might I interrupt the Minister to point out that he has stopped before this sentence:—
"It would not be at all expensive, because once the thing got under way it would cease to require a subsidy, and would be able to stand on its own feet."
That is why I wanted the subsidy. Why did the Minister not read on?
Comment on this
The Deputy is not against subsidies in principle, but only against subsidies when we advocate them.
Comment on this
I never before heard the Deputy say that he was not against them in principle. If he advocated them, they were all right, but, coming from this side, they were wrong. There is another very interesting statement from the Deputy here. He talks about the mistakes made by the Pigs Marketing Board and in the middle of column 442 there is this sentence:—
"I do not think there is any use dragging up the absurd mistakes into which they fell, dragging out the purchase of pork that was hawked round the country, put into cold store as pork, sold at one-quarter of its value to the curers, and then thrown out as unfit for conversion into bacon."
There are five errors, absolute untruths, in that statement, and, mind you, five errors in five lines is a bit of a record. It is a record even for Deputy Dillon to make five errors in five lines. First, the board did not drag out the purchase of pork. The board went to the fairs and markets and bought the pork as they got it. How that could be called dragging out the purchase of pork I do not know. It is the same as accusing the bacon factories of dragging out the purchase of pigs because they buy the whole year round.
Comment on this
"Dragging up" it obviously should read from the context. I referred in the previous sentence to "dragging up the absurd mistakes into which they fell." Then I referred to dragging up the other mistakes I cited.
Comment on this
"Hawked round the country"—what does the Deputy mean by that?
Comment on this
I thought so. The board had arranged, before they bought pork at any market, what factory it was to go to on every occasion. There was no such thing as their going around with a lorry to a factory, the factory saying "We will not take it," and then the lorry going on to another factory. That never occurred. It was never hawked round the country. "Put into cold store as pork"—that was right to a certain extent. "Sold at one-quarter of its value to the curers." There are two absolute misstatements in that sentence. It was not sold to the curers and, therefore, of course, was not sold at one-quarter of its value, and has not been sold since. It was never sold to the curers; it was given to the curers to cure on commission; and since has been marketed, not at one-quarter of its value, but at a small loss to which I will refer in a minute when I deal with the other misstatements. "And it is thrown out as unfit for human consumption." Here is a Dillonesque exaggeration. The total would cost £50,000. The amount thrown out was £60.
Comment on this
Yes, out of £50,000. Will Deputy Dillon show me any factory in this country which can show a smaller loss than that, £60 out of £50,000? If the Deputy is pinning his faith on that, the House can see to what depths he is sinking. I admit that there is a loss of £60 on £50,000 worth.
Comment on this
No, they told me the truth. The Deputy suggests that there was a big loss on this bacon.
Comment on this
We have a long way to go. Two years ago, the last time the bacon curers were asked to cold store bacon on their own account, they said there might be a loss on it, and they were guaranteed against that loss. The Pigs Marketing Board had not the loss that the bacon curers had. But these factories have all along been held up to us as models of the best business methods. Well, is it not clear that when the Pigs Marketing Board have not made as much of a loss, that they are a success? So far I have dealt with five lines out of Deputy Dillon's speech into which he has crammed all these misstatements of facts. Whether the Deputy is trying to mislead this House about the whole situation or not, I do not know, but he took 30 columns in which to say all that. I have just taken these five lines, and I think I have dealt with enough of his speech.
Comment on this
Is the Minister in order in the employment of the word "lies" in regard to my speech?
Comment on this
If the Minister says that he did not use the word "lies," that is enough. At all events, I did not hear him use that word.
Comment on this
I want to make one other reference to Deputy Dillon's speech. He advocates cheap butter for our people. Naturally that would be a desirable thing if it could be done. I remember that this thing is set out in the Cumann na nGaedheal policy, for I remember part of it.
Comment on this
That is why I remember it so well. The Cumann na nGaedheal policy advocates 5d. a gallon to dairy farmers for their milk and dairy farmers' butter to be sold at world prices here. That would cost £3,000,000 a year. I am not now referring to any tariffs by Great Britain. Even if that whole thing were fixed up it would cost this country £3,000,000 a year. I do not know where Cumann na nGaedheal would get that £3,000,000 because they have objected over and over again to the tax on tea and sugar and other taxes, and Deputy Bennett objected last year to the tax on footballs. Where are they going to get the £3,000,000 to give 5d. a gallon to the dairy farmers in Limerick and at the same time to sell butter here at 1/- a lb.? That is the sort of policy that is advocated by the irresponsible Opposition. They will promise the moon and the stars.
Comment on this
They will promise you the birds of the air but you will have to go and catch them yourself.
Comment on this
There was one thing about us when in Opposition and that is that everything we ever promised we at least told the people how it could be done. We pointed out to them the way in which it could be done. But we have an Opposition now that promises 5d. per gallon for milk delivered at the creamery, and cheap butter, but no extra penny of taxation.
Comment on this
The Minister is a bad financier. He promised the people of this country that he would reduce taxation by £2,000,000 a year.
Comment on this
Well this £3,000,000 must come from somewhere. I cannot see where it is to come from. That is the whole trouble.
Comment on this
I know if I suggest another £500,000 it must be raised some way. Deputy Dillon blames the economic war for the fall in egg prices. That is just ridiculous, because, if the Deputy looks at the subsidy we are paying at the present time on eggs, he will find that it equates with the tariff put on by Great Britain. The fact is that he cannot blame the economic war for the fall in price, for that is not the case. We have actually improved the price of eggs to the producer as a result of the economic war. Deputy Corry made a few suggestions a little bit more sensible than what we heard from Deputy Dillon. He says the Livestock Breeding Act should be abolished. His principal objection seems to be that members of the Dairy Shorthorn Breeders' Association are selected as inspectors. It is not true to say that the Dairy Shorthorn Breeders' Association are selected as inspectors, but they should not be disqualified for that reason. I do not think I need deal any further with that objection. Deputy Bennett talked about the price of milk. He says that we held if there was no Government help or no economic war that milk would be 2d. a gallon. This statement was made, it is true, but it was made at a time when butter in the British market was running from 66/- to 70/- a cwt., so that at the time the statement was made it was true.
Comment on this
No. Deputy McGilligan produced my statement that there was a difference of about ¾d. a gallon——
Comment on this
I do not want to be misquoted. I know the statement was made to my knowledge and to the knowledge of a lot of other Deputies through various parts of the country from 1931 to 1935.
Comment on this
It would have been true at this time last year, but since this time last year that statement was not true. As long as butter was under 70/- a cwt. the statement was true. At the present time, if there was no economic war, no tariffs and no bounties, the farmers would get about 3d., or perhaps 3¼d., a gallon for their milk, so that the statement is not true at the moment.
Comment on this
They would not be getting £3 for them in a creamery district, but I will come to that in a moment. Now I have to deal with the question of agricultural wages. Last October there was a question asked about agricultural wages. Deputy Norton quoted that question and my answer in the course of this debate. I asked him to quote the supplementary which had been put to that question and my answer to the supplementary. That answer to the Supplementary Question did not altogether convey what the Deputy conveyed to this House, or convey my attitude to the question. I know the Deputy had only a typed copy of the question and answer and that he had not the answer to the Supplementary Question. I think the word used in the Supplementary Question was "contemplated."
Deputy Norton quoted English wages and Irish wages. He might have made a good case if he stuck to the official figures, but he did not stick to them. He quoted figures that were not the official figures; he quoted figures that were higher and he rejected the official figures here and made a sort of census of his own. He made out the wages here to be much lower than the official figures indicate. Whatever the wages may be in Great Britain, there was exactly the same fall there from 1931 up to last year as there was in the Free State. The point is made by the Opposition that the labourer here has not the same value from the £ because the cost of living is higher. Let me say that the difference in the cost of living has remained constant; there is the very same gap between the cost of living here and the cost of living in England since 1931. I do not want to defend the wages here at all, but I will say that the comparison that has been made does not hold water. There is no economic war, I believe, in England; the farmers there have nothing like that to contend with. For the four years 1931 to 1935 the wages there have gone down the same as here and the difference in the cost of living in Ireland and in England has remained constant from 1931 to 1935.
Comment on this
They have exactly the same subsidies for wheat and beet.
Comment on this
The total receipts from dairying would be much better in England.
Comment on this
I believe it is higher here than in Great Britain, but whatever be the price of flour, sugar or tea, I am saying that the difference between the cost of living here and in England is just the same as in 1931.
Comment on this
He quoted abstracts from British statistical returns and from statistics issued by the International Labour Office in Geneva.
Comment on this
The price of agricultural produce here has gone down and the price of manufactured goods has gone up. There is nothing to show the real loss that has been sustained.
Comment on this
Can the Minister give us comparative figures for agricultural produce in 1931 and 1935 as between this country and Great Britain?
Comment on this
The Deputy is asking me for information which I cannot give him at the moment. Apparently he is well informed on these matters and perhaps instead of asking me he should be telling me.
Comment on this
We are dealing with an agricultural Estimate and, from the agricultural standpoint, we want the comparative prices of agricultural produce in relation to here and Great Britain.
Comment on this
The Minister is mixing up figures both in relation to England and here—figures which include manufactured goods.
Comment on this
I am endeavouring to deal with the case from the point of view of the labourer. If there were no economic war we can presume that wages would go down as much here as in England. As a matter of fact they have gone down exactly to the same extent, so that the labourer here, as a result of the economic war, has not suffered. What the Deputy apparently wants to get out is whether the farmer here can afford to pay more.
Comment on this
I could say straight off that farmers' prices have gone down more here than in England and therefore the farmers could not afford to pay as well here as there.
Comment on this
Can the Minister give the figures for 1932 in respect of British agricultural labourers' wages?
Comment on this
Deputy Moore quoted them; I have not got them now.
Comment on this
The Minister is telling us that there has been a decrease in English agricultural wages since 1932.
Comment on this
They were paid 33/- odd in 1931 and 30/- odd in 1935. They have gone down by 3/- and the same applies in the Free State.
Comment on this
The Deputy must be talking through his—no, he has not got a hat—when he speaks of a reduction from 28/- to 15/-.
Comment on this
If only from a sense of fair play, the Minister ought to be allowed speak without interruption.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton told us that in the pre-economic war days they were getting £3 a calf in the creamery districts.
Comment on this
That is a most extraordinary statement. In 1927 I bought calves six months old for less than £4. They were brought up to Dublin and they were sold to me in County Wicklow for that price. I know they have been sold in Wexford and Wicklow in the autumn for the last 30 years for between £3 10s. and £4.
Comment on this
They were not, and the Deputy knows what I am talking about. I am not talking about sucking calves, but rearers. They were sold at £3 10s. and £4 at the fair at Taghmon. Would any Deputy here from a creamery district have the cheek to say they were selling dropped calves for £3 before the economic war started?
Comment on this
Let the Minister's statement be published. It is better than anything we have yet heard.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary says he got £3 or more for dropped calves before the economic war.
Comment on this
Anyhow, it shows what certain Deputies will descend to. They are prepared to say anything and they have no regard for the truth. I must compliment Deputy Belton in this respect, that he is becoming a very astute politician. He condemned wheat growing and that at a time when he was making approaches to the Party opposite. He is an astute politician.
Comment on this
He made a speech two or three columns in length to show that wheat could not be grown here.
Comment on this
Neither of the statements made by the Minister is true. It is not true to say that I am making any overtures to anybody or that I condemned wheat growing as a national agricultural policy.
Comment on this
If the Deputy says that a statement is not true, must not the Minister withdraw? If the Deputy says it is untrue it has been your habit to ask the Minister to accept the Deputy's word.
Comment on this
If there is something said which is personally disparaging to the Deputy. I do not consider that anything disparaging to the Deputy has been said.
Comment on this
If every Deputy in this House is going to have a mascot I do not know where we will end.
Comment on this
The Minister made a statement that I was making overtures to a particular political Party. That is untrue, and I expect that the Minister will take my word for it.
Comment on this
Certainly. The Deputy did say that we were exhausting the soil?
Comment on this
I remember in 1926 there was a by-election in Dublin. I was not very much interested at the time; I was out in the wilderness, as the Deputy would say.
Comment on this
I was interested in Deputy Belton then, because I thought he was a coming man. The reason I thought he was a coming man——
Comment on this
I am beginning to realise that he will never come.
Comment on this
The reason I thought he was a coming man was that his motto was "speed the plough."
Comment on this
Exactly. And I am going to lick you in Dublin at the county council elections on that slogan of "speed the plough."
Comment on this
What is the slogan now? It is "speed the bullock."
Comment on this
The Minister is the only Deputy in this House limited to time, with the exception of Deputy McGilligan. Deputy McGilligan was allowed to speak without interruption. Surely the Minister should also be allowed to speak without interruption?
Comment on this
I do not want to wrong Deputy Belton in any way, but Deputy Belton was in the habit of making speeches in this House which were encouraging to me in advocating the growing of wheat, the growing of vegetables, and all those other things. Deputy Belton made a speech which was computed by one Deputy as occupying three hours—I think that was an exaggeration; it took something over two hours—and his whole speech was a cattle speech. He talked about cattle from beginning to end. You could not have beet unless you had cattle; you could not have wheat unless you had cattle; nothing could be done unless you had cattle.
Comment on this
I should like to hear the Minister explaining how he can grow them unless we have cattle.
Comment on this
We have had their programme already. Deputy O'Sullivan made a very vigorous speech. In fact one would imagine from listening to him that he was putting his whole heart into his subject. He almost shed tears over the people of Kerry in their sufferings. He asked me a question over and over again; he said: "Does more tillage mean more live stock?" He wanted to know what was the policy that we were adopting on this side with regard to live stock, and with regard to the development of tillage. He said that I enunciated both policies; in other words, that on one occasion I said "more cattle" and that on another occasion I said "less cattle and more tillage."
Comment on this
Did he not say at a meeting of a farmers' organisation in Dublin that anybody who said the number of cattle in the country should be reduced was either a fool or a knave, because we wanted the cattle to consume the extra grain in the country?
Comment on this
Quite right, but did I ever say that more tillage meant less live stock? Deputy O'Sullivan said I did.
Comment on this
I said here one day, when I was asked for my policy on this subject, that the policy of the Government and my Department is to find the largest possible market at home and abroad for all agricultural produce, cattle, pigs and everything else. That is our policy all the time. If Deputies would only accept that as our policy half the speeches need not have been made on the other side.
Comment on this
I said more tillage, if we can, and more live stock, if we can, than we have at the present time, but we must find a market for them.
Comment on this
On a point of order I wish to direct your attention, Sir, to the fact that we on this side of the House listened for three-quarters of an hour without a single interruption to a speech delivered from that side to-night. You all have to admit that. Why can they not concede, at least to the Minister, the courtesy of a hearing? He has a difficult job. You all assembled here to listen to your big man, Deputy McGilligan, and was there a word from this side of the House although he possibly made the best speech that could be made against the Estimate?
Comment on this
There is a big number of matters which I want to deal with, but I am afraid we will not get finished to-night unless we get through them very quickly. I think, even if we had to go on until to-morrow, it is important to make this clear. I do not care how often I am quoted on this if I am quoted correctly, but I want to be quoted correctly. I can prove that we have always done our best to get the biggest possible market for all agricultural produce. We have been sneered at for going on the Continent to try to sell cattle. We get the biggest possible quota in Great Britain. We tried to get the people here to eat more beef. We have done everything possible to use all the cattle in the country, and to have more cattle if possible. The same applies to bacon, sheep, and every line of agricultural produce. We have done our best to extend the market, both at home and abroad. What is the use of Deputies on the other side first of all postulating that we are trying to cut down cattle, and then building an argument on top of that? The argument topples down because there is no foundation for it. Have we not got more cows than we ever had in this country before? We disposed of more cattle in 1935—let any Deputy look it up—than were ever disposed of in any one year by Cumann na nGaedheal. Then they talk about our trying to kill the cattle trade. We used at home more cattle than usual; we exported more, even to Great Britain, than Cumann na nGaedheal did in any one year when they were in office. That ought to be sufficient, without going on with this argument that we are trying to kill the cattle trade. Of course, if they admitted that we are exporting more cattle now than they did, and using more cattle at home, they would have no argument to go on with. This year the quotas that we have for cattle, both to the Continent and Great Britain, and the amount that we are likely to consume at home, will be even still bigger than last year.
Deputy McGilligan, in answering an interruption by Deputy Donnelly, said that we had lost our market. He said, I think, that we had lost our entrance fee of £5,000,000, and so on. He gave us to understand that we had lost even the number of cattle that were allowed into Great Britain. We have not. We can get more cattle into Great Britain under our present quotas than Cumann na nGaedheal had cattle to send.
Comment on this
The Deputy may let me alone. On this, I do not care how often I am quoted in the country if I am quoted correctly. But I want to make this clear, and let us have no argument about it, that we are endeavouring by every means in our power to get a bigger market at home and abroad for cattle, sheep, pigs, and everything else in the agricultural line. That has been our policy from the very beginning. There is no necessity for any more argument about it.
Comment on this
It is not a new policy. There is not much use in trying to talk against the invincible ignorance of men who are afraid to make a speech in this House, but can only interrupt, like the Deputies over there, who were put in the lurch and left in the lurch by Deputy MacDermot.
Comment on this
There are other big matters that I want to deal with, but I should like, if the House has no objection, to adjourn now.
Comment on this
All I should like to say about that is that it was agreed that some speakers would curtail their speeches to-night in order to allow the Minister to take the division to-night. If the debate is to be carried over until to-morrow, then some of those Deputies whom the Minister charges with being afraid to speak to-night will ask for the privilege of speaking to-morrow. We are in Committee and can have that privilege.
Comment on this
I should like to make this point. If Deputy Mulcahy looks up the Official Report when this speech is published, I think he will find that more than half of it is interruptions.
Comment on this
The Minister was very keen—and I can understand his keenness—on having his point of view about more tillage and more cattle explicitly put forward here.
Comment on this
On a point of order, if this is to continue any longer the House will be unable to divide to-night. It was arranged for Ministerial purposes to divide to-night, and I suggest that the division be taken.
Comment on this
I object. I have several points to make, and I move to report progress.
Comment on this
Again on a point of order, we cut our remarks short in order to allow the Government to take the division to-night. We are in Committee, and speakers who were cut out to-night will claim the right to take part in the debate to-morrow.