Committee on Finance. - Vote 52—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 157–324 of 324. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Not being a dodger, he does not feel happy when meeting these men because of his inability to discharge his liabilities. I was speaking to a merchant a week ago. His business is almost entirely with farmers and, although he does not do as big a business as some of his local competitors, he does a fair trade. He told me that the position was getting very serious from his point of view, as he found the utmost difficulty in collecting his debts. He said that his local competitors did a much bigger trade than he did, and he felt that if their outstanding debts bore the same ratio to their turnover as his outstanding debts bore to his turnover, he thought they would have to get out of business very soon. He quoted the case of a farmer who came to him recently. This farmer had never dealt with him before, but had always had the reputation of being very well-to-do, and he thought that he was getting a very good customer. This man asked for certain manures and seeds, and he said "Certainly" and told him his terms of credit. The farmer then said: "I have never dealt with you before, but So-and-So with whom I was dealing has now refused to give me credit, and I do not want to tie you down to the offer you have made." The merchant said that he was terribly amazed, but said that in any case he would stand by the offer he made and give him the credit.
Now, some reference was made here yesterday evening to experiments. I think it will be admitted generally that experiments are not alone useful but absolutely necessary. If, however, an experiment is going to deprive an individual of his means of livelihood, that individual cannot be expected to look kindly on that experiment, to say the least of it. After all, the experimenter, like the doctor, does not feel the pain. It is the patient who suffers. Take the case of wheat and beet. I think we can grow perhaps as good beet and wheat in this country as in any other country in the world, but I cannot see the wisdom of trying to convince people that wheat and beet can be substituted for our live-stock trade. You can work them side by side with the live-stock trade and perhaps make them a success in that way. I think it is very futile, however, to imagine that they will stand alone as a substitute for the live-stock trade. In that connection, there is one thing I should like to call attention to. I think that 23/- or 23/6 is paid for wheat in the earlier part of the year, and the farmer who is not in a position to store his wheat, or has to sell to meet urgent demands, has to accept that price. Now, I doubt if that is just, because the man who has facilities for storing his wheat, and who is perhaps in a better financial position, gains very considerably by reason of the fact that he is able to hold the wheat over until the higher price is available. Accordingly, I think that the minimum should be wiped out and that the maximum should be made the general price for wheat. I think that that would be fair to everybody.
Now, take the case of pigs and bacon. I should like to direct the Minister's attention to the system of grading. I think that system is too severe altogether and, in connection with that grading, I should like to quote from a bill of sale which I have before me now. This bill of sale refers to eight pigs. Six of these pigs fell into class 1, and two of them into class 2, but they were subdivided into four sections within these classes. One thing which strikes me as very extraordinary is that one pig, under grade A, class 1, weighing 1 cwt., 1 qr., 22 lbs. was paid for at the rate of 64/- a cwt., while in grade B, class 1, there was a pig of the same weight, and that pig was paid for at the rate of 60/- a cwt. Then a pig in grade C, class 1, weighing 1 cwt., 1 qr., and 25 lbs., was paid for at the rate of 56/- a cwt. That is a difference of 8/- per cwt., which is a serious matter for the producer, between two pigs when the weight only differs by 3 lbs. I think that if the consumers realised that position they would resent it just as much as the farmer resents it, because evidently the curer derives all the benefit in that case, whereas the farmer and the consumer lose very heavily by it. I believe that if one went into a shop and asked for portion of the pig that weighted 1 cwt., 1 qr., 25 lbs., at 56/- a cwt., he would not get it. It is all classed as grade A, class 1, in the store. Then in the case of the two pigs under class 2, one weighing 1 cwt., 2 qrs. and 12 lbs., and the other weighing 1 cwt. 2 qrs. 22 lbs., they were paid for at the rate of 52/- an extraordinary discrepancy in the price of two pigs. I think there is something radically wrong there.
Deputy O'Reilly, speaking here last night, said that there was considerable difficulty in getting agricultural labourers in County Meath. I think that that is becoming fairly general. There are, perhaps, different reasons in different counties for that. For instance, I find, in County Waterford, that a good many of the best workers —the young men—are going away to England. It is very hard to blame them because, unquestionably, agricultural wages are too low. Deputy Corish has referred to that and I am in agreement with him, but after all there must be a cause for this, and in order to remedy the difficulty, you must get at the cause, and the cause is that agriculture has become so depressed, as he says, both through world conditions as well as through the economic war, that the farmer is not in a position to pay a decent wage. I do not stand for the present wage, and I doubt if any man with an interest in the country could stand for it. I think it abominably low, but after all, at least the agricultural labourer is assured of that wage at the end of the week, whereas the farmer, who works just as hard and works alongside the labourer in many cases, has no guarantee that he will get anything at the end of the year, and, as a matter of fact, is very often worse off than the labourer. I know of plenty of farmers' sons who have had to go away. Also, Deputy Flynn said that the smaller farmers in Kerry had suffered but that they were prepared to do so from patriotic motives. I have the utmost sympathy with these men, but I do not think their patriotism should be played on to the extent that it has been played on. If it is a question of patriotism and duty, I believe that every class should step in and bear a fair share of whatever burden may be imposed, and that it should not be thrown on the small farmers of Kerry and elsewhere.
Comment on this
Unquestionably, cattle prices have been affected by world conditions. Neverthless, we should be getting better prices than we are. I do not say that we would be absolutely happy any more than we were before this Government came into power. There were grievances at that time also, because agricultural prices were tending to the low side. I think that every fairminded person will admit that, but the difficulties have become much more acute now, in consequence of the economic war. I have a bill of sale here referring to some cattle, where it shows that five cattle realised £87 5s. 0d. at Glasgow. There were quite a number of items that I do not intend to go through in detail. I will just give the tot. The duty worked out at £4 5s. 0d. per head making a total of £21 5s. 0d. The expenses, lumped together, are slightly under £10. Now if that man got that £21 5s. 0d. additional would it not make a great difference to him?
There are a good many other matters to which I would have liked to refer. There is one matter in connection with that world-wide depression that I must refer to. Assuming its effect here is the same as its effect in other countries, we still have an extraordinary disadvantage. First we had the disadvantage to the extent of the penal duties applied by Britain. We also have the disadvantage in the prices we are paying for our feeding stuffs. There is a difference of £2 10s. 0d. between what we pay for our mixture here, and what the people in Northern Ireland can buy pure maize at. Our mixture will produce a better type of pig, but it will not fatten a pig as well as maize, and the farmer here must suffer. There is another question on which we are at a disadvantage, and that is derating. The farmer in Northern Ireland has complete derating. We were promised it; and Deputy Corry says we got as good. But the farmer should have the choice. Derating was promised and should have been given. Perhaps I am now straying somewhat from the subject before us.
Comment on this
That is the Deputy's opinion; I am entitled to mine. The farmer was promised derating and did not get it.
Comment on this
I am sorry Deputy Maguire has left the House, because, in the course of his very brief speech, he made a number of rather extraordinary statements. He said that farming was never anything more than a mere existence. I am quite satisfied his colleague, Deputy Corry, would not agree with that, because I know if farming was only a mere existence Deputy Corry would not remain in the business for five minutes, and I know no other farmer member of the Fianna Fáil Party that would have continued in it. Deputy Maguire, I am sure, was not serious when he made that statement. If he had any doubt that the agricultural position here, up to 1931, was other than what he stated it to be, he need only consult the local bank manager in his own County of Leitrim, or get particulars from the Minister for Finance, of the money the farmers of this country invested in the three first issue of National Loan. But the Deputy, like the rest of his colleagues, steered clear of the Estimate and concentrated entirely upon generalities. He conveyed to me, at all events, that he thought it was my duty, and that of my colleagues, to throw bouquets at the Minister instead of dealing with the Estimate. He said the whole problem was due to the economic war which was forced upon this country by England.
I am not going to deal with the economic war, I am only going to make a brief reference to it. Admitting, for the sake of argument, that England made an attack upon the economic independence of this country, is the Deputy not satisfied that by the manner in which the Government are fighting the economic war they are straining this country? Is any Deputy opposite prepared to say that by making agreements, in the nature of the coal-cattle pact, they are strengthening the economic independence of this country in any respect whatever? Is it not a fact, if agreements of the coal-cattle pact kind continued to be made by this country, that instead of strengthening the economic independence of the country they are weakening it and giving the English a greater stranglehold upon this country than at any time since the Treaty was signed?
The Minister for Agriculture made a characteristic speech last night. This is an Estimate that should be dealt with in a serious manner, but he dealt with it in a semi-jocose fashion. In fact he did not attempt, at all, to face up to any of the main arguments put forward by the Opposition. His speech dealt with a number of side issues that had no bearing upon the policy that underlies his Department. He stated that we disposed of more cattle in 1935 than were ever disposed of, in any one year, during the Cumann na nGaedheal administration. I do not know whether the Minister used the word "disposed" advisedly or not. But thinking over it, it appears to me that he did use the word "disposed" advisedly; because presumably he had in mind, when making that statement, the 200,000 calves slaughtered during the years 1934 and 1935. But even allowing for the 200,000 odd claves slaughtered, his statement is inaccurate. As an actual fact there were two years during the Cumann na nGaedheal administration when the numbers exported — and allowing for the number of calves slaughtered, and allowing for the number of cows slaughtered in the Government institution in Roscrea, in 1935— were greater. In 1924, 9,430,000 cattle were sent out of this country, and in 1930, 8,580,000 cattle were sent out of this country. And the number of cattle sent out is not really the important issue here at all. The main point is the amount of money realised by the sale of these cattle in England.
If we contrast the figures for 1931 with 1935, we will see very clearly the difference in the amount of money realised in the sale of cattle exported to Great Britain. In 1931 approximately £13,000,000 was realised in the sale of cattle exported to Great Britain: whereas in 1935 only £5,500,000, approximately, was realised. That represents a difference of £7,000,000 in the income derived from the sale of our cattle in the British market in these years.
Comment on this
If Deputy Corry has any lingering doubts in his mind as to the accuracy or otherwise of my figures, I will give him the figure for 1930, when the amount realised on the sale of cattle exported to Great Britain was £14.67 millions or £15,000,000, approximately. In 1929 the amount realised was £13.59 millions. In 1928 the sum realised was £13.17 millions, and in 1924 it was £17.27 millions. In 1934 the sum realised from the sale of cattle exported to Great Britain was £4.26 millions. I submit that it is not the number of cattle the Minister sent to the British market, but the amount of money realised that matters, and from the figures I have quoted—which figures have been issued by his own Department, and are contained in the official returns—it will be seen that there was a drop of £7,000,000 in the sale of cattle as between the years 1931 and 1935.
There is another interesting point which is worth while examining also in connection with the Minister's statement, and that is the price realised per head for each of those cattle sold in the British market. In 1931 the average price per head was £16.2. In 1935 the price realised per head on the cattle we sold in the British market was £8.04. In 1930 the price realised per head averaged £17 and in 1929, £17.5. As between 1931 and 1935 there was a drop, approximately, of £7.75 in the price of each beast sold in the British market.
We heard a good deal in the course of this debate about the wages paid to agricultural labourers in England and the wages paid to agricultural labourers in the Irish Free State. The Minister, in the course of his speech last night, seemed to convey the impression that the fall in agricultural wages in Great Britain corresponded exactly with the fall in agricultural wages in the Free State. I do not know from what source or from what returns he obtained these figures. I cannot find any figures which would confirm the Minister's statement. His actual words were: "There was the very same fall in agricultural wages in Great Britain as in the Free State." It would be well to bear in mind that the conditions relating to the employment of agricultural labourers in England are different in many respects from the conditions relating to the employment of agricultural labourers in this country. The wages of agricultural labourers in England are fixed by a wages board. There is no such board in existence in this country. In addition to that the agricultural labourer in England has an eight-hour day, he is entitled to be paid for overtime, and I think gets double time, with special allowances for Sunday work.
There is no comparison at all between the conditions under which agricultural labourers work in England and the conditions under which they work here. The average agricultural wage paid in England at the 31st December, 1934, was 31/1, and the average agricultural wage paid in this country, which is, after all, only a calculation, because there are no reliable data to go upon, would be somewhere between 15/- and 21/- per week. I doubt very much if the average is even as high as that. At all events, contrasting that average wage with the average wage paid to agricultural labourers in England, we have this difference: the average total earnings of agricultural male workers in England amount to 32/7; for horsemen the figure is 36/7, and for stockmen 38/6. That represents a big difference between the earnings of agricultural labourers in England and the earnings of agricultural labourers in this country.
There was a frequent reference also in the course of this discussion to the Government policy of wheat growing, in relation to the production of live stock and live stock products, and especially in relation to the production of beef. In that connection also it is interesting to study certain figures prepared by the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries in England. It appears that the index figure for wheat, as published in the statistical returns of the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries in Great Britain for the year 1929, was 130; and the index figure for 1934 was 64. That represents, roughly, a drop of 50 per cent. The index figure for fat cattle for the year 1930—I have not the figure for 1929—was 133; and the index figure for the year 1935 was 92. That would roughly represent a reduction of 25 per cent. These figures, I say, are interesting in view of the fact that the farmers in this country are asked, to a certain extent at all events, to abandon the policy of cattle raising for the purpose of taking up the policy of wheat growing.
The conditions relating to the production of wheat and the conditions relating to the production of beef in the Free State are somewhat analogous to the conditions in England. There are no index figures issued by the Department of Agriculture here in relation either to wheat or beef. But, in any event, these figures may be taken as an indication at least of the difference in value between the policy represented by the production of cattle and the policy represented by the production of wheat. We see here that the farmers in this country are asked to embark upon a policy of wheat-growing which, in a period of five years, has represented a drop of 55 per cent., and to abandon the policy of cattle-raising, which only represents a drop in the same period of 25 per cent. These figures, I think, may be taken as somewhat analogous, at all events, to the conditions existing in the Free State in relation to the production of wheat and beef.
The Minister, when introducing the Estimate, made a very brief reference to the butter marketing scheme, and I am sorry that he did not dilate a little more on the working of that scheme. I hope, when he begins the second half of his reply, that he will deal in greater detail with the working of that scheme. I should like to know from him how many creameries have taken up the scheme. The impression I gleaned from conversations I had with members of creamery committees and creamery managers throughout the country was that they were not at all enthusiastic about the scheme, and, in fact, in a recent conversation I had with one of them, he seemed to convey the impression to me that they felt the scheme was not at all satisfactory, and that it would have to be revised if it was going to merit the support of all the creamery committees in the country. However, I am anxious that the Minister would deal more fully with the working of the scheme and would let us know how many creameries have undertaken to operate it and what effect centralised marketing has on the price of butter on the other side. Has it any effect whatever? To what extent has it reduced marketing costs on this side?
I see that the Minister has reduced the grants to the county committees of agriculture in the Estimate this year. I have no recollection that, in his statement introducing this Estimate, he made any reference whatever to the reason which inspired him to make that reduction, but, frankly, as one who knows a little about the work of the county committees of agriculture, I cannot understand why he should this year reduce the grants to these committees. During the last few years these county committees have been asked to undertake a number of new schemes. In fact, they have been forced to undertake some of these schemes by orders issued by the Minister himself, and it appears to me that these committees are doing exceedingly useful work in the country, and that, instead of reducing their finances, it should be the function of the Minister rather to increase their finances and give them an opportunity of embarking on other schemes which would be useful and helpful in the present conditions of agriculture.
I notice also that the Minister has recently issued an order relating to the wages and conditions of employment of secretaries to these county committees. Quite accidentally I came across that order on the file in the Oireachtas Library yesterday, and, frankly, I do not understand what reason the Minister has at this hour of the day to issue such an order, which, to a very large extent, takes the control of the work of the county committees out of the hands of the county committees. It appears to me—I know at least two or three of these secretaries—that they are doing their work remarkably well, and that, after all, if it is the intention of the Minister to whittle away whatever little authority these county committees enjoy at present, it will be very difficult to get men of any standing or any reputation to act on such committees in future. When the order is taken in conjunction with the reduction in the Estimate this year, I am somewhat puzzled to understand the Minister's attitude towards the county committees, and especially I should be anxious to understand his reason for issuing such an order relating to the employment, wages and conditions of the secretaries.
I see that there is a very big increase in the Vote for the improvement of the creamery industry. I assume from that that the Minister is continuing the policy of his predecessor in buying out redundant creameries and carrying out the policy of centralisation in many parts of the country. I should be anxious to hear the Minister dilate at some length on the success of that policy. I was under the impression at one time that it was the intention of the Minister to extend his scheme for the centralisation of creameries to all parts of the country, but, apparently, judging by the very little information we can glean from these Estimates, he is confining his attention to certain parts of the South of Ireland. Is it his intention to carry out the scheme of centralisation in every county where creameries exist, or is he satisfied now, after his experience of the policy of centralisation during the last few years, that such a policy cannot be embarked upon arbitrarily and that there are many local circumstances and local conditions to be taken into consideration? I think it would be a mistake, and a very serious mistake, to force such a scheme on any county where creameries are operating satisfactorily at present, even though there may be redundancy up to a point.
Reference was made to-day to the work of the Agricultural Credit Corporation. The Minister for Finance interjected rather heatedly during the course of Deputy McGovern's speech that last year the credit corporation issued loans on the same scale as in previous years. I understand that that report appeared in to-day's Irish Press. I have not had the privilege of reading that report yet, but I do know from my experience down the country that the credit corporation appears to be somewhat reluctant to give loans at present, even where the security, in my view, at least, and in the view of any normal man, is reasonably satisfactory. It is exceedingly difficult for small farmers at present to get loans from the Agricultural Credit Corporation, even where the security is reasonably good. I understood it was to be the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government to loosen out somewhat the machinery of the Credit Corporation, so that it would be possible for the directors to give loans to people, even where the security was not sufficiently good for, let us say, a bank, but it appears to me that no change whatever has taken place in regard to the granting of loans by the corporation since the Fianna Fáil Party came into power.
It does appear to me, from some recent experience I have had, that they still want almost the same security as a bank would want. In fact, in one particular case that came under my notice, they wanted even a greater security than the local bank asked for before they would agree to advance a loan to a hardworking industrious type of farmer. I must compliment the Agricultural Credit Corporation, however, on the degree of humanity they are exercising in regard to the collection of loans in regard to the payment of the interest and principal on loans advanced some time ago to people who are not in a position to meet them to-day. From my experience of the corporation, they have acted, at least in all the cases which I brought under their notice, in a very sympathetic way. They are apparently fully cognisant of the conditions existing in the country, and they are prepared to meet every case in a reasonable and sympathetic manner, if it is put to them in the proper way. The Estimate has been already exhaustively discussed and I do not think I have anything further to say on it.
Comment on this
I do not think there is much use in any of us telling the Government what the present position of the farmers is, because they do not seem to believe us. It seems to me that it runs off them like water off a duck. Owing to the present policy of the Government, 50 per cent. of the farmers of this country are not solvent. Deputies on the other side say that these are wild statements. I challenge the Minister, or any member of the Government, to find out the financial position of the farmers in any parish in Westmeath, and if 50 per cent. of those farmers are solvent, I will give £5 to the St. Vincent de Paul Society in Mullingar, even though I would find it hard to get money at present. Through no fault of their own, men, who were of independent means three years ago, are now unable to meet their demands. No matter what branch of farming they try, even with the help of their own families, everything they do is done at a loss.
The Minister for Agriculture was told on several occasions from this side of the House that his policy was wrong. We have asked for relief for the farmers. We have asked that the annuities would not be collected during the continuance of the economic war, and we have asked for derating. These things were turned down by the Government. The farmers of the country are anxious and willing to meet all their demands if they get a fair crack of the whip, but they are not getting a fair crack of the whip from this Government. When we came in here first as the Farmers' Party I put a motion on the Paper asking the Government to relieve the farmers of the annuities. That was turned down. If the Government had acceded to that request the farmers of the country would be at their backs and the economic war would now be won.
The farmers are in this position, that they are forced to pay £5,000,000 a year to the Government as well as to lose something over £2,000,000 a year on that part of their produce sold in the home market; in addition to that they are paying over £2,000,000 a year annuities. That is £9,000,000 altogether. How can the farmers carry all that load on their backs? If the farmers had been let off paying the annuities and had they been given derating there would be some recompense to them in the matter of the heavy losses on their live stock and farm produce. Notwithstanding what anybody may say or think, we must all admit that agriculture is the very root of the nation's prosperity; in every country in the world agriculture is fostered and cherished. What is the Government of this country doing for it? It has wrecked agriculture and it has wrecked the homes of the farmers in the country. I know several decent men who have been ruined by this economic war. I know of one honest man who has a big farm of land. He employs eight men but these men have to wait weeks for their wages until this farmer takes his cattle around from fair to fair in the endeavour to sell something to raise the money for their wages. A friend told him that he should pay off three of those men. What was his reply? He said: "These men's fathers were here in my father's time; their sons are here now and I have not the heart to sack three of them." That is the position.
The Minister for Agriculture has declared that it is his intention to reduce our live stock to the level which would be required to meet the requirements of the home market. But the Minister has not told us what is to happen our increased tillage. The home market is not able to consume our present agricultural produce. There is more than enough at the present time to meet the needs of our own population. It is hard to find an outside market for the surplus. The best way to get rid of our surplus crops is to feed them to our live stock and so walk these crops off the land in the form of live stock, for which we have an unlimited market at our doors. We are not allowed to avail of that market. I warn the Minister that increased tillage without live stock is but a dream. The present Government is dreaming. It is time they woke up. Live stock and tillage are dependent on each other. Live stock is needed for the consumption of the produce of tillage and it is needed also for the fertilisation of the land.
It is hard at the present time to get away from the tragic fact that, owing to Government policy and the way they have depressed and reduced the farming community, there is not a bank in the Free State to-day that would lend sixpence on the security of a farm, large or small. I defy contradiction of that statement. We have heard just now that the Agricultural Credit Corporation, a Governmental institution, will not lend money to farmers. That is entirely due to Government policy.
Last night I was accused here of interrupting the Minister. But if the Minister could only see the situation as I see it, he would understand why I interrupted. I started farming at the age of 16 years. I was one of a family of 11. My father died when I was 16 years of age and left us a fairly good farm with nothing on it. I was the eldest and I worked hard all my life. All the others got good positions. In 1924 I bought another farm with my hard-earned money. I had cleared off what I owed on that farm, but in the last few years, owing to Government policy, I have got into debt. I never left off work from the time I was 16 years of age. But during the last two years I am not able to pay my way, and I am not able to do for my children what I had expected to do for them. It is hard on me to listen to the Minister speaking as he did yesterday without my interrupting him. I was in the position a few years ago that I was able to work and rear my family decently in such a way as to give them good positions in life. Now I see the time approaching when my family will have to slave all their lives as I did. The Minister, because I interrupted him last night, said I was a coward. I would let no white man say I was a coward, and only for the respect I have for this Assembly I would tell the Minister and the Executive Council what in my heart I think about them.
Comment on this
I was a bit timid about speaking on this Vote until I listened to some of the part-time farmers and to some Deputies who are not even part-time farmers telling us about agriculture. Deputy O'Leary is moved to tears over the slaughter of calves. There is no Deputy in this House who should know better than Deputy O'Leary that in North Cork calves have been slaughtered every year as long as Deputy O'Leary can remember and he is older than I am. In the year before the Government gave a bounty on calf skins, one firm of calf dealers in Macroom slaughtered over 7,500 calves, and there were three or four others in the trade also. That is why I say the slaughter of calves is not by any means a new thing. People are now getting a bounty on calves that are being slaughtered. But these calves would be slaughtered anyway. There may be some extra calves slaughtered because of the bounty, but it is nothing new down in the South of Ireland to slaughter calves.
Deputy O'Leary also spoke about old cows being sent from Cork into Kerry. He said these were sent on to Roscrea. If the Deputy had been in Macroom yesterday he would have seen some of his own supporters, members of the Cow-Testing Association, with large numbers of cows that they purchased from the poorer Fianna Fáil supporters at anything from 7/6 to 12/6 each. These cows were also being sent to Roscrea. Unfortunately the people in whom Deputy O'Leary is so much interested had to sell those cows at a very small price. Somebody is getting the benefit of that as well as the people who get the benefit of the cattle sent into Kerry. Deputy O'Leary is anxious that the people should get maize meal at a cheap price. Deputy Minch is very anxious the people should get a good price for their barley. I think there is enough said about that. There is no doubt that conditions in the poorer districts are very bad.
Comment on this
And they have been bad for ten years. If Deputies on the opposite benches who are farmers let their farms grow weeds for ten years, they would not clear the weeds out in two or three years. Deputy O'Leary gave us a long list of prices he got for calves some years ago. I would like to ask him, and other Deputies, were they able to make farming pay in the years before Fianna Fáil came into office?
Comment on this
We have had a good many statements from Deputies on the Government Benches regarding the prosperity of farmers since Fianna Fáil came into office. The fact of the matter is that the farmers of this country are almost bankrupt because of the Government policy. I am a farmer and I can prove that. I was rather surprised to hear farmers on the Government Benches telling us that the farming community are prosperous. I come from a rich farming country in County Sligo and I am aware that the farmers of that county are almost bankrupt. Some years ago all these men could look their bankers straight in the face and they were in a position to pay 20/- in the £. To-day they are not able to do that. To-day they can scarcely clothe their families owing to the bad prices that they have been getting for stock for the last three years. At the 1933 election the men who now form the Government promised the Irish farmers that they would reduce tax-action, that if they got into power they would halve the land annuities and derate the land. They have halved the land annuities, but look at what the farmers are paying on cattle in order to get them into England. Are they not paying the land annuities three times over? The Government have not yet derated the land.
It is up to the Government to do something to improve the condition of the farmers and of the agricultural labourers, about whom we heard a lot of talk in the course of this debate. These are the parties who are paying the piper; these are the men who helped to build up this country and have kept it going through the years. What consideration is being given by the Government to the young farmers who are living in their parents' homes? What have the Government done for the men who shouldered guns 20 years ago and were responsible for the establishment here in the capital of our country of a native Government? Is there to be any consideration at all for these men who are trying to rear big families? In 1933 the members of the present Government told us what they were going to do for the farmers. They said that the Cosgrave Government had done nothing for the farming community. Under the Cosgrave Government we were getting a good price for our cattle, and for the last three or four years we could not say that. Animals that in 1929 and 1930 fetched £16 to £18 a head would go to-day for £6 or £7.
Reference was made here last night to the wages paid in England to farm labourers. I know a young farmer who had to let his land on the 11 months system about two months ago, travelled to England and there he got work at the rate of 29/- a week. The same man was working in this country at 12/- per week. Why does not the Government stand up for those people? The farmers and the poor agricultural labourers have been put in the frontline trenches. There are many agricultural labourers to-day on the dole, in receipt of home assistance or in receipt of free beef. Is that all this Government can do for them? The Government have done nothing but demoralise good and honest people. I come from a county where the people always lived well and were always prepared to pay their debts. Along by the Ox Mountains in County Sligo you have farmers who in other years lived well on the mountain side. They got a good price for their sheep and cattle; they were able to educate their sons for the Church or the medical profession. To-day they are able to do no such thing. For the last three or four years they got practically nothing for their sheep or cattle, and to-day they are down and out. That is some indication of what the farming community are suffering.
I am surprised at Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches, who should be honest men, telling us that the farmers are thriving. They are not. Deputy Maguire, who comes from the same constituency as I do, Leitrim-Sligo, spoke here about the farming community. He knows well that the farmers of Leitrim and Sligo are not prosperous to-day, because of the Government's policy. Give us an opportunity to get a good price for our produce and we will work. We want the opportunity to get a proper price for our stuff. We are told that the farmers have to work from dawn to dark. They slave from dawn to dark. Is it the object of a native Government to make slaves of the good, honest men and women of this country?
Comment on this
When the Minister was speaking last night he said that there was no real criticism from these benches of the working of his Department. I would like to put this aspect of the question to him. The people of the country are paying £665,600 for the working of the Minister's Department. The farmers who grow wheat found that owing to the bad weather before Christmas they were not able to put in the winter seed. That should be well known to the Department by Christmas-time, and I think it was the duty of the Department and of the Minister to see that seed wheat was procured for the farmers. We find the farmers, instead of paying something like 30/- a barrel for their seed wheat, having to pay 45/-. I think that showed great neglect on the part of the Minister and the Department. They were very careful to bring in a Bill to ensure that the seed would be right and proper, but they did not see fit to make sure that the farmers would have the seed wheat when they required it. I hope the Minister will see that in the coming year such a thing will not occur again. The Minister also stated that in all the speeches he heard from the Opposition it was the same old story about the economic war. I hold we can talk on nothing else but the economic war. The working of this and every other Department hinges on conditions resulting from the economic war, and until the economic war is settled, so far as I am concerned, I will talk about nothing else, because it is the cause of all the misfortune in this country. The economic war was brought about by the incompetent policy of the present Government.
A lot has been said about the agricultural workers and the wages they are receiving for the work they do. I hold that you cannot separate the farmers and the workers. They are all agricultural workers. The farmers are not being paid for the work they do, and when they are not being paid how can they pass on to the agricultural workers the money which they should receive? The agricultural workers and the farmers are the hardest working people in this country or in any other country. They are pure slaves from morning until night. They are the first up in the morning, and their work is the last to be finished. The industrial workers in the towns and cities finish their work in the evening, but the farmers' work is never finished.
This evening Deputy Mrs. Concannon was very anxious about the future training of the young farmers' wives of the country. I wonder does Deputy Mrs. Concannon know the conditions under which the farmers' wives in this country are living at the present time? I say, Sir, that they are pure slaves. The farmers' wives and daughters in this country at the present time are pure slaves. Never before had the farmers' wives of this country to work like they have to work at the present time. Never before had the daughters of the farmers to look forward to such a miserable future, due to the policy of the present Government. Ten years ago the farmers' daughters of the country could look forward to the time when their fathers would be able to give them a certain amount of money on their marriage. What have they to look forward to now? They see their fathers and mothers pure slaves. They see them unable to make ends meet. What have they to look forward to? They have only to look forward to taking the boat train for London, or some other place where they can get £30 or £40 a year and have some hope of coming back to this country with a couple of hundred pounds that they could never hope to put together in this country, nor can they have any hope of their parents doing so as long as the present Government and the present policy remain as they are. The agricultural workers were never in such a plight as they are in at the present moment. I know agricultural workers—decent, hard-working men—who are in receipt of 9/- or 10/- a week. They have a house surely—some kind of a house— over their heads. They have a garden, and a pint and a quarter of milk or whatever it is, but they have a wife and five or six children, and I would ask the Minister or any Deputy on those benches to say how a man with a wife and family can exist on 9/- or 10/- a week. The wages of those agricultural workers were surely small enough without burdening them with an additional 4d. per week to provide the widows of this country with pensions.
We have the Labour Party—a Party which for the past three or four years, since this Government came into office, have helped them to carry out their policy of ruin and destruction of the farmers and the agricultural workers of this country. They are very anxious about the agricultural workers now. We did not hear anything about them for the past three years. It is a bit late in the day for the Labour Party to be thinking about the agricultural workers now. But the day will come when the agricultural workers will have a chance of registering their votes again, and I am very full sure that they will remember the activities of the Labour Party during the past three years. However, I think two very helpful things have happened during this debate. This debate was to have concluded last night, and the division was to have been taken, but there was a chance of the Government being beaten. Why? Because the Government are coming to the end of their tether. They had to send out wires all over the country to bring in their Deputies. Their Deputies have a lot to do down the country those times, because the farmers and others down the country are finished with them. They are holding their district and county conventions, and I know for a fact that all over the country the numbers turning up to those conventions are so small that they cannot select officers to carry on.
Comment on this
I submit that the end is very near at hand; we have only to hope that it will come soon. We have only to hope that the day is not far off when the farmers and workers of this country will have a chance of bringing back to office a Government who will be responsible to the people and who will bring back prosperity to our country.
Comment on this
This is a very important Estimate, since it deals with our most important industry. I just want to refer to a few phases of the Minister's policy. Some time back the Minister passed what was known as the Pigs and Bacon Bill, presumably for the purpose of raising the price of the pigs produced by the farmers. If my memory serves me correctly, on the occasion of the Report Stage of that Bill I pointed out to the Minister that the position would be rather serious as far as the pig industry in the border counties was concerned. Unfortunately, that suspicion was confirmed, because some time back the farmers in County Louth, and Monaghan and Cavan found it very difficult to dispose of their pigs. What I want to know from the Minister is why it is that facilities, by way of an increased quota, have not been given to the local factory we have there at the moment, so as to enable that factory to purchase more pigs within the year. I understand we have a Pigs Marketing Board which is costing a good deal of money put up by the ratepayers of this country.
Comment on this
Well, it is part and parcel of the Minister's Department and comes within his purview.
Comment on this
We are dealing with the question of factories. I am sure the Minister has something to do with the bacon factories?
Comment on this
He has something to do with the bacon factories. The position as far as County Louth is concerned is this, that we had a bacon factory there called the Louth Bacon Curing Company. That factory did very well for some years. Then for some reason, or owing to some changes that took place in the Department, it was put out of business. The average number of pigs bought by that factory for curing was from 300 to 400 per week, and the amount of money paid annually for the purchase of pork carcases was in the region of £50,000. I am not taking into account the amount paid in wages, and the other incidentals in the running of a factory. I suppose the total amount would be from £70,000 to £80,000. As far as I can understand, that factory was put out of business for very little reason. I could never get to the bottom of the matter. The only suspicion I have is that possibly it was giving cheaper bacon to the people than the south of Ireland bacon curers, and that for that reason it had to go. I am sick, sore, and tired hearing bacon curers from the south of Ireland talking about the different qualities of pigs, of the York as against the Ulster pig. Seeing is believing. The proof of the pudding is in the eating. I do not mind theory; I want practical results. The Louth Bacon Curing Company bought from 300 to 400 pigs weekly, the majority being of the Ulster breed, and the bacon when cured was sold in the Free State. I want to hear none of this talk from south of Ireland bacon curers about fancy rashers and cuts, and about the Irish people being very particular about bacon. The Louth company did not buy 300 or 400 pigs weekly for fun, and did not spend £50,000 per annum for fun, in order to cure bacon in Dundalk. Since the company left, the farmers of Louth, especially in the northern end, are left to the mercy of whatever buyers may come to the weekly pork markets which have been held from time immemorial. One market in which an average of 150 to 200 pigs was sold every week has dwindled down to 40 or 50 carcases, and it is uncertain whether even that number will be bought.
I am referring to this matter owing to what we have been told of the improvements that have been made in the pig industry and in the cattle industry. We have the Dundalk Packing Company, successors to Messrs. Lunham. In answer to questions about self-sufficiency and the home market, and about allowing no bacon into the Free State, I remember when bacon was imported from CzechoSlovakia, Canada, the United States of America, and from other parts of the world to this country—when it was a country—there were from 30 to 40 men working in this factory. It is rather significant that in that factory to-day, notwithstanding the fact that there is not one pound of foreign bacon coming in, the number of men engaged is in the region of nine or ten. Yet we have been told about the home market and what it is going to do for the pig industry. I should like to ask members of the Fianna Fáil Party and the Minister, even though no foreign bacon is coming here, what would happen to the pig industry in the Free State if Great Britain said to-morrow that she would not take any percentage of the quota allotted to the bacon factories in the Free State? The ratio is about 60 to 40, 60 per cent. to the home market and 40 per cent. for export. What would be the effect on the pig and bacon industry if England said she would not take the 40 per cent.? Who would use it?
Comment on this
What is the use of all this swanking, pretending there is a war on, when the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, including the Minister, are tumbling over one another to get as much stuff as they possibly can into that market? It has been stated that some of the bacon curers, when they wanted to increase their quota, were told that they would be put out of business if they dared send an extra lb. of bacon to Paddy in Ireland, that they must reserve it for Mr. John Bull so that he will be sure of getting his supply. Can the Minister deny that that word was sent out?
Comment on this
Can the Minister deny that people were brought up for attempting to sell a greater quantity in the home market than was allotted to them? Had they not to ensure that the hated Saxon would have a good supply of Irish bacon while Irish Paddy would have to do with what was left?
Comment on this
If the Deputy said that outside, the Bacon Board might take a libel action against him.
Comment on this
People are told that they must keep up the quota for the British market or be put out of business. At the same time we are told by the great warriors on the Fianna Fáil Benches that we are at war with England. That makes one sick. There is as much truth in this talk of war with England as there is in the suggestion that the Fianna Fáil Party is at present a Republican Party. We have been told that in regard to cattle the farmers have nothing to grouse about. Deputy O'Reilly, who represents County Meath, made a statement which he knows in his heart was false, one at which the men who know him and the cattle dealers with whom he frequents would simply laugh if he made it in their presence, namely, that the late Government and the ex-Minister for Agriculture did nothing for the cattle industry. That is a remarkable statement. There are many people in this country who never made a success of things, yet they take it upon themselves to advise other people what to do. There are many of that type amongst the members of the Fianna Fáil Party. As far as cattle are concerned, is it not perfectly well known that we possess the best cattle in the world? Is it not well known that these cattle can go into the British market with their heads erect— in the same manner as the President once said he would go into the Peace Conference?
Comment on this
Is it not known that cattle could go to Great Britain without having a charge on them of £4 8s. Od.? Is it not known that farmers, prior to the coal-cattle pact, got £6 per head less for every bullock weighing from 10 cwt. to 11 cwt. that they sold than they would have got were it not for the policy pursued by the Minister and the Government? In all seriousness, I say to the Minister who is responsible for this Department that it is a well-recognised code amongst members of the Cabinet, whatever Government is in power, that if the majority of members do not agree with the policy which the Minister thinks it best to pursue, the Minister, for honour's sake alone, resigns. That has happened in England. There was a difference of opinion there between a Minister and the Cabinet within the last few months and the Minister resigned. It seems to me that the Minister still persists in a policy which he knows himself is imposing unnecessary hardships on a section of our people who, because of the manner in which they lived in the past and because of their traditions, do not deserve to have these hardships imposed upon them, namely, the farming community.
When we are told by Fianna Fáil Deputies, like Deputy Maguire, that this whole question of the economic war is a question of our national status, again I say that it is about time we dropped such pure tripe as that. You are not engaged in fighting with England or, if you are fighting with her, you are carrying on the engagement behind the backs of men who are receiving the blows from Britain. No member of the Fianna Fáil Party is receiving these blows; he is receiving his £1 a day. I do not see what fight any of them, from the President down, is making. The only men who are receiving the blows are those suffering from the small prices paid for their cattle. It is all very well for Deputy Maguire and others to talk about fighting Great Britain. You could not fight a tall hat at the present time. You would not even wear one. We want to live and do the best we can for this country. We want no more fighting or dying for it. We want to do the best we can for our farmers. We want the Minister for Agriculture, as the Minister primarily responsible for securing a livelihood for those men, to put an end to this sham, to this nonsensical economic war and to bring about a settlement which will allow of these men receiving a fair recompense for their trouble in raising live stock. You cannot say that you are not accustomed to make agreements. You have done it before. Ministers, it is true, had not the pluck to go over but they sent civil servants over to make these agreements. You can end the economic war if you have the will to do it. If you have not the will and if you still want to fight, I will be game for that fight on one condition, although I am the father of seven. That is: that you do not allow as much as the tail of a bullock, a pig's head, a potato, a lb. of butter, slice of bacon or any part of our agricultural produce to be exported to England. Let it be a fight to a finish and you will have many people behind you—not this sham fight, pretending that you are at war with England and sending over your very best produce at the cheapest price. If you want a fight I will be game for it, but I know from experience that you will put up the white flag very quickly, as you did before. Get down to facts, because I know too much about war.
Comment on this
As regards the question of butter, if the British Government said they would take none of our butter, we might be greasing the railway lines with it. Again this is a new way of fighting a war, compelling the working class in this country, the poor agricultural labourers who are paid miserable wages and the tens of thousands living in the slums of Dublin to pay 1/6 per lb. for butter, in order to ensure that the English working man can get the same butter at 10d. and 11d. per lb. That is another funny way of waging a war, that we compel all those people, including old age pensioners who, because of the policy of the Government, only receive 8/- worth of goods for their 10/-, to pay that price for butter so that the British working man may get his butter for 4d. to 6d per lb less. If the Minister could acquire a little of that essential quality, moral courage, and tell other Ministers and the wild men in the Fianna Fáil Party that that nonsense must stop, if he would get down to business and not be acting the fool or the hypocrite, because it is all hypocrisy, there would soon be a change in the situation. At present he is pursuing a dishonest policy. In fact, the Government is taking from thousands of poor people moneys that should not be taken from them. As one who has his ear to the ground, who is mixing constantly with the people—not in high society, but with the man in the street—I may tell you that people are thinking at the moment. I do not want to see the Government defeated too soon. After all, they are only three years in office and it might be well to give them another year or two. But there is a big change, and the people are beginning to complain of your policy, especially that part of it for which the Minister, whose Estimate is before us, is responsible.
Comment on this
That is another aspect of the situation. We shall come to that, but not on this Vote. Then we come to the question of the slaughter of calves. It is funny that a person like me, living on the Border, should be very much interested in calves, but I am interested, for this reason. I know that prior to the start of the economic war thousands of calves were bought in the South of Ireland and re-sold in Northern Ireland. The average price paid for these calves ranged from £3 to £3 10s. per head. There was a titter of laughter to-day when Deputy O'Leary read out the prices paid for calves. Deputy O'Leary was quite correct in these prices. These were the prices paid. I do not know whether Deputy Victory ever got such a price or not.
Comment on this
That was the price paid, and I suppose these men bought anything from 6,000 to 7,000 calves during the season from April to June. They bought them down in Kerry, that great Irish county where the people will not recognise anything except the system under which they get a few pounds for old cows. These great Irishmen down in Kerry who want to fight the economic war——
Comment on this
If they met a real man they would probably run away from him. These calves fetched £3 per head each, but for the past year or two, since Fianna Fáil came into power, the calves were sold for practically nothing. The clever fellows who, of course, knew what was coming off, bought the calves and got 10/- for the skins, but the farmer who reared the calves got nothing. Deputy O'Leary was quite right in saying that thousands of calves were bought in that way. There was no man more welcome in County Kerry than the man from Dundalk town giving £3 10s. for the calves and taking them up to the North. They were then taken across the Border and sold to be turned into stores, being eventually exported to make good beef for John Bull, with whom we are supposed to be at war.
I suggest to the Minister that it is near time that we showed that we are possessed of a little common sense in view of the fact that we are spending £5,000,000 a year on education. The people in a country such as this should be full of common sense. Many of the difficulties that the Minister has to contend with would vanish like snow before the sun if only he would get down to brass tacks, settle up with Great Britain and get us back to the market that we had formerly. The annuities are being paid three and four times over. There is no point in saying that, if we were to settle up with Great Britain, we would be surrendering the national position. At the present time there is no such thing as nationality in this country.
I come now to the question of the wages paid to agricultural labourers. I was glad, more or less, to hear the Labour Party refer to this question. I sympathise somewhat with the Government because I know that in present circumstances it is very difficult to pay wages. The Government cannot accuse me of being over critical, but I can say this in all sincerity, that never have I seen more young men from the rural districts come to my door looking for work than during the past three or six months. I have had conversations with them and have asked them "what wages were you being paid?" I did not do that for any political purpose because I seldom talk politics. The reply I received in nine cases out of ten was this "Do not mention wages; it is not a question of wages, but rather a question of taking what is given to us." Deputy Corish was quite correct when he said that the wages paid averaged from 6/- to 8/- a week. Can any Fianna Fáil Deputy, or even any Deputy on the Opposition Benches, bring to me any number of labourers who are getting a £1 a week for the 52 weeks of the year, or, allowing for the holidays, for 50 weeks of the year? If we could ensure continuity of employment for all our farm labourers at that wage, then I say we would be the richest country in the world, but we are not doing that.
What a nice commentary all this is on the Fianna Fáil plan. The people were told that if returned to power Fianna Fáil would end unemployment. The Minister for Defence went so far as to say that when Fianna Fáil got into power our workmen would become so stout that the doors of the houses would have to be widened to admit them; that they would have good food, the best of living and high wages. Think of the present position and what a commentary it is on the tripe we hear about our Irish culture and the uplifting of the worker. Instead of what we were promised we have doles and free beef.
As an Irishman, I am more or less ashamed of having to admit many of the things that are taking place in the country at present. I would again impress on the Minister that, before he goes out of office, he ought to make a real effort to settle the differences that exist between this Government and the Government of Great Britain, because as long as this economic war lasts there will be trouble here. Give the farmer back his free market. The Government doles and subsidies are of no use. They are simply giving with one hand and taking back with the other. They remind one very much of the nursery rhyme:
Give a thing and take it back,
God will ask you where is that,
If you say you do not know,
God will send you down below.
The Minister should dispense with all these subsidies and bounties and settle this sham economic war because it is nothing else. It is nothing more than a sham to be pretending that the people of this country are at war with Great Britain, or that any member of the Fianna Fáil Party or even of the Opposition is taking any part in this fight with Great Britain. I can say that 90 per cent. of the people of this country do not know that there is a war on at all. There is nothing in all this talk about standing up to England. There is none of that feeling in the country now because the people have got wise. They have gained a lot of experience during the last three or four years and in the five years previously when the Government Party were not in the Dáil. In view of the hardships that the Government Party inflicted on the country during all those years, they should, I suggest, try to make some little return to their fellow countrymen by settling up this economic dispute with Great Britain.
I am glad to see that the Minister will shortly be free of his troubles in connection with the black scab area in Cooley. The people there did suffer severely during the last few years but things are brightening up for them now. They are now getting a good price for their potatoes. They have been able to sell them in this foreign market that some pretend to despise at £3 10s. 0d. a ton. That has been a source of great satisfaction to these people during the past three or four months. The people are very well pleased at the fact that they are now able to sell their potatoes at an economic price. The foreign market that they are able to sell them in is of much more value to the country than a little factory here or there.
The Minister for Agriculture, in conjunction with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is establishing an alcohol factory in order to safeguard these men in the future. I am glad that is being done, because any potatoes which happen to be left over in any season will be used in this factory. During the past season potatoes sold well there, but we must have a foreign market for our surplus agricultural produce—let it be Great Britain or any other market. That will be necessary for some years to come. The British market, owing to its proximity, is the most remunerative market in which farmers can dispose of their agricultural produce. A good deal of that produce comes from County Meath—the county to which Deputy O'Reilly and Deputy Kelly belong. They do not object to sending their produce over there. It is the best market we have, and I think you should endeavour to make friends with the British. Seeing that you are doing it, if I may say so, secretly, you should come out now and do it openly, unless you prefer the shouts of the mobs at the cross-roads to the support and good wishes of all that is good in this country. The only thing I know which is keeping the Government from settling is their fear of the shouts of the mob—the small section with whom you are trying to keep in. You have one foot in the Republican camp and the other in the Fianna Fáil camp, and you are trying to keep both sides in tune. I advise you to cut the painter and think of the majority of the people. Make a settlement with Great Britain and most of the disabilities under which the Minister's Department is suffering will be swept away.
Comment on this
I want to direct the attention of the Chair and the House to a statement made by Deputy Coburn. When speaking of Deputy O'Reilly's reference to the prosperity of the farming community Deputy Coburn said that Deputy O'Reilly made that statement knowing in his heart that it was false. As Deputy Coburn's statement goes on the records of the House, I desire to direct the attention of the Chair and the House to the fact that he made such a statement and to say that I think he should be asked to withdraw it.
Comment on this
If such a statement were made, the attention of the Chair should have been drawn to it immediately it was made, because the Chair has to rely on its own observation as to what happens. It cannot take a statement from one Deputy as to what was said, because that statement would probably be contradicted by another Deputy. I was not in the Chair at the time, and I have no knowledge that such a statement was made by Deputy Coburn.
Comment on this
I thought that if I intervened at the time I might be regarded as interrupting, and I did not want to do that.
Comment on this
I take it that it would be in order for the Deputy to address the House now on the prosperity that exists in the country.
Comment on this
I said he knew in his heart that that was not so. There was nothing improper in that statement.
Comment on this
I had no intention of intervening in the debate on this Estimate, but some remarks were made by Deputy Coburn since I came into the House and I thought it might be just as well if I repeated and dealt with them and called attention to a few facts. Deputy Coburn, in referring to the bacon factory at Dundalk, said that when Messrs. Lunham were working it they had 40 hands employed and that the present firm have only nine or ten hands employed. Probably the reason that Messrs. Lunham gave up the factory was because it did not pay them. It is fairly evident that that cannot be a pig-producing district since the bacon factory employs only nine or ten hands. Deputy Coburn referred to the quantity of bacon sent to England and said that the Government were doing their best to provide the British with cheap bacon. I think he said that the export quota was about 70,000 cwts. to 80,000 cwts. a month. That would be about 4,000 tons of bacon per month. In 1931-32, the total quantity of bacon exported from this country to Great Britain was 14,800 tons—three months of the quota. The quantity of bacon exported by Denmark in that year, in which we exported 14,800 tons, was 357,000 tons. Mr. Neville Chamberlain, the present Chancellor of the Exchequer, went over to Denmark at that time and told the Danes, with whom there was no economic war, that they would have to cut down their exports of bacon by 20 per cent., which amounted to about 70,000 tons of bacon. Considering the weight of Danish pigs, that reduction would amount to about 2,000,000 pigs a year. Deputies can imagine the disturbance caused to the trade of Denmark by the cutting down of their exports of bacon by 70,000 tons a year, representing 2,000,000 pigs. Feeding stuffs, railway traffic, cartage and freights were affected by that change and yet there was no economic war between these two countries.
Comment on this
Deputy Coburn also referred to the price of butter. I think I spoke about that subject here last year. If I did not, I dealt with it elsewhere. There are about 500,000,000 people in Europe and, in these islands, there are less than 50,000,000. That is about one-tenth of the total population of Europe. Nine out of every ten of the people of Europe pay a higher price for butter than is paid in the Free State. The only place in which butter can be obtained more cheaply is Great Britain and that is simply because it is the dumping place of the world for agricultural produce.
Comment on this
It is more than ? in most European countries—very considerably more. The statement has been repeated ad nauseam that sugar and butter are dearer in the Free State than in the Six Counties. That is so. Deputy Coburn, who seems to think that this economic fight is a sham fight——
Comment on this
You cannot have a fight without somebody getting hurt. The people in the fight must suffer.
Comment on this
This fight was a fight of all the people from long before 1916. When it became a fight of all the people, Deputies on the opposite benches, as well as Deputies on this side, were in it. They seem to have forgotten all about it, and are not prepared to continue the fight. I say very definitely that there is no fight at all which we can win except an economic fight. That is the position we are in, and that is the only weapon we can use. It is obvious that we could not fight a stronger power physically. Therefore, I do say that the less we hear about settling the economic war in the way suggested by Deputies on the Opposition Benches, by surrendering our birthright, the better. Before concluding, I only wish to call attention to one particular fact and that is that, without any economic war with the Danes, they were told to cut down their exports of bacon to Great Britain by 20 per cent., involving an enormous amount, in the very same year that we were told to cut down our exports.
Comment on this
But how much additional pork did they send into the British market in place of that bacon?
Comment on this
I should like to know, Sir, if the House would agree that we should finish this debate to-night.
Comment on this
I think I can say, on behalf of my colleagues, that we should finish the debate to-night.
Comment on this
Well, if I get a fair "do" I will finish in half an hour—or at least three-quarters of an hour.
Comment on this
Of course, I do not wish to prevent anyone from speaking.
Comment on this
I do not wish to inconvenience the Minister or to take up too much of the time of the House, and I would hardly have intervened in this debate at all were it not for the statements of Deputy Dowdall, which have been re-echoed by several speakers from the Fianna Fáil side, to the effect that this so-called economic fight is being carried on for our birthright. That is some of the most terrible humbug possible. It is ridiculous to think that there is any national principle at stake with regard to the economic war. Deputy Dowdall says that we could not fight Britain with battleships and guns, but that we can fight them on a financial basis, which is tantamount to what the economic war comes to. It is a ridiculous thing to say that we, in our position, can fight John Bull with pound notes. That was also emphasised by a previous speaker, Deputy Flynn, who last night gave us an honest account of the condition of the people in Kerry and pointed out how badly hit they were and how they were suffering as a result of this war. At the same time, he went on to say that they were going to carry on, and that they were prepared to suffer because they believed that there was a national principle at stake. I myself can bear out the fact that that idea is very prevalent in Kerry. I have met people there and when I asked them about their `position they have told me that things were in a frightful state, that there was no money circulating, that they could not pay their bills, but that they were prepared to carry on. In their own words, they said: "Dev. has ruined the whole of us, but we shall have to back him up, because he is fighting England." These poor people really believe that, and I hold that that is all due to what I may call the psychological tyranny that is being exercised by some of the Fianna Fáil Party on their followers. In their ignorance and stupidity they believe they are fighting England, and this kind of hypocrisy is used to make them believe that the fight is being carried out on an economic basis.
This Estimate has for its main reason to be referred back for further consideration, the fact that it has put the farmer not upon his feet, but upon his "uppers." We have been told here by some of the speakers on the other side—principally, I think, by Deputy Maguire—that we find ourselves in the present condition owing to the attack of an outside power, and he has also told us that the arguments put up from this side of the House with regard to this economic war are based purely on imagination and that they have no foundation in reality. Well, I think that this Estimate, which takes up 30 pages of this volume, is one of the most real things with which this House has ever been confronted, and also that the figures of the trade results, which have followed from that policy, speak more eloquently of the condition of affairs to which that policy has brought this country than any horrible picture imagination could conjure up. For the last couple of years, since Fianna Fáil came into power, there has been going on a multiplication of boards, a multiplication of inspectors and a multiplication of all sorts of activities of a bureaucratic nature. There has been an enormous increase in the personnel of the Civil Service attached to this Department, and there has also been a terrible increase in the amount that has been spent on activities other than merely instructive or educational activities. While all these Estimates have been increased, the results to the country have been getting less and less valuable every year. Two or three years ago the total Estimate for the administration of this Department amounted to £441,000. Last year it went up to nearly £2,000,000. In all that time also, there has been a marvellous decrease not only in the exportable quantity of goods of agricultural origin but also a terrible fall in the cash value resulting.
Last night the Minister told us that they have been disposing of—I think he actually said they have got rid of— more cattle than were ever got rid of under a Cumann na nGaedheal Government. I was naturally curious to see the figures on which he could base such a statement and I find, that in 1931—only four years ago, and the year before the present Minister took office as Minister for Agriculture—we exported 765,952 cattle, whereas, in the year 1934—the year previous to the present administrative year—the amount had fallen to 511,000. Last year, of course, I admit there was an increase, owing to the little return of sanity that took possession of the Government and made them conclude the first coal-cattle pact, and which small degree of common sense was evidenced in the further development of that idea in the second coal-cattle pact later on. In the case of pigs there was also a very big decrease between 1931 and last year. Butter increased, but it has been increased in a manner that does not give evidence of very much sincerity or acumen on the part of the Government. It has simply increased because we have taxed ourselves at home so that John Bull, the good Englishman, may get cheap butter at the expense of the Irish consumer.
A lot has been said here also about agricultural wages, and I think that all figures will prove that they have fallen by more than 3/-, at all events in the last two or three years. In fact, not only have agricultural wages fallen, but employment on the land has decreased to an enormous extent. Deputy Cosgrave in speaking to-day gave an instance of Tipperary where there is a new beet factory, where tillage was increased for beet and wheat, still the amount of agricultural labour employment has decreased by over 400. That is a very bad state of affairs. Looking over the whole of the Twenty-Six Counties I find that 12,000 people have gone off the land in that period. And that is the result of the policy of the Government that was to increase the wealth of the country, that was to increase employment, that was to increase wages, and that was to give the agricultural labourer a better time.
The plight of the agricultural labourer is further seen in the decline of the poultry industry. It is a well known fact that the labourers' wives were the most industrious people in the production of poultry and of eggs. The production of eggs has gone down in value from £2,270,000 in 1931 to £995,000 in 1934. That shows how farm labourers are hit in both ways. The labourer is hit by not being able to get employment and the wife is hit in the decrease in the market in her poultry produce. The only thing that increased in the last four years of the Fianna Fáil administration was an increase in asses. I do not want to make any political capital out of that or to show that it means a breaking up of the Fianna Fáil Party, but there was an increase from 89 in 1932 to 401 in 1934.
We heard a lot of talk about self-sufficiency. But that idea can be carried too far. It is right that the country should develop its own resources so that in times of stress or danger it could fall back upon this for its own benefit. But as I say, that can be carried too far. If farmers took it into their heads not to send supplies to Dublin, and supposing Dublin was left without that market for milk and vegetables, it would find itself in a nasty position. Suppose that shoemakers made boots only for their own children, you would be up against a great difficulty. The wealth of any country consists in the produce it can export, and particularly is that so in the case of an agricultural country more than of any other people on the earth. If Deputies opposite would wake up to that fact and give up all their humbug about fighting for self-sufficiency, and national principle, they would realise that mere politics will not put one shilling into a man's pocket or a bite into a man's mouth, and can in reality have only a bad effect. Does any Deputy opposite think there is any value in such a policy as they are pursuing? I will not call it rainbow chasing, but I would remind Deputies opposite that there is as much nationalism and good national spirit on this side of the House as there is on theirs, but we do not want to pursue a policy which is based entirely on fighting humbug.
Deputy Harris told us that the English market was very shaky, and he went on to mention the dangers of foot and mouth disease, I think it is over 20 years since we had any disturbance of our cattle trade through foot and mouth disease. He was followed by Deputy O'Reilly, who told us that the farmer was suffering because he did not prepare his produce in a proper way for the foreign market. I do not know what he meant by that. Perhaps he has discovered foreign markets that look like the "Isles of Blest"; so far away that they could not be seen. It is a remarkable fact that these Deputies do not seem to realise, what everybody else realises, that we have in the English market one that is inexhaustible for our agricultural produce. The English market, which we are told is so shaky, absorbs about £300,000,000 worth of agricultural produce every year. That means that we could put into that market as much as £30,000,000 or £40,000,000 every year. Surely we could find room in that great market, three or four hours from our shore, for our surplus agricultural produce.
With regard to some of the other industries which are really ancillary to agriculture, we would like to know how they are getting on. Malting fell from £519,000 in 1931 to £381,000 in 1934. We have the greatest brewing industry in the world yet the value there fell from £6,340,000 in 1931 to £5,809,000 in 1934. That was a very big fall. Distilling has been practically wiped out. It has fallen from £175,000 in 1931 to £147,000 in 1934. The export of cattle has fallen in the same period from £18,000,000 to £6,000,000. That is a fall of £12,000,000 per annum in those years.
The export value of our goods per head of the population has fallen from 12.5 in 1931 to 6.1, that is more than 50 per cent. of a reduction in the whole value of the exports per head of the population. I want to criticise all these things. That is the policy we are asked to face up to in these Estimates. That is a policy which is taking all these hundreds of thousands out of the pockets of the taxpayers to maintain it, and it is a policy which is not only not bringing any profit to the people but is impoverishing them, because it is being carried out at such enormous cost. The only thing we have to take the place of all that agricultural produce is the home trade in beet and wheat. But you have to prop these up with subsidies, and the moment you take these subsidies away, wheat and beet will fall down. Trade cannot be subsidised for all time. God has given us a certain kind of economy and a climate favourable to that economy, and you cannot better take advantage of these gifts than by allowing the Irish farmer to develop them by taking advantage of the natural surroundings he possesses.
We were told, a while ago, that there was nothing real about our argument. I think some of the figures I have given are very real. If money has any value as a talking power, these figures ought to talk to some of the people opposite. I think the discussion of agriculture in this country with a Merrion Street mentality is very far from reality. They have no recognition of the real state of affairs in the country. If the Minister for Agriculture wants a little reality as to how his policy is affecting the country I ask him to take a walk with me through some of the towns in the County Cork. I have gone to considerable trouble to find out the real state of affairs in 15 towns in Cork, principally in my own constituency. I have taken 15 towns where the monthly value of cattle and pigs sold at each fair was over £10,000 and that sum has now fallen to a sum of about £500 and certainly not exceeding £1,000. That means that from £8,000 to £10,000 in circulation is lost in these towns. That means a loss of £100,000 per annum to these towns, so that in these 15 towns the loss in circulation to the traders amounts to £1,500,000. It means that the farmers bringing their stock into these towns get £1,500,000 per annum less than they did before, and the traders have lost the trade that would accrue from the circulation of that much money.
It also shows that if there is poverty amongst the working classes in the towns it is because the traders and the distributors of goods have not the wherewithal to keep these people employed. One of the reasons why there has been such an increase in unemployment is the decay of the towns owing to the depression of these fairs. Deputy Kehoe gave us some interesting Latin quotations. He said something about "West Cork locutus est, causa finita est.” If I might quote some further Latin, I would paraphrase the well-known “Delenda est Carthago” and make a present of a slogan to the Minister. There is a competition going on at present for slogans, and if the Minister wants a good slogan to put over his office or Department I would say the most appropriate thing he could have to paste upon his policy and upon its results would be “Delenda est agricultura.”
Comment on this
Deputies cannot complain that we have not got sufficient opportunity to discuss this Estimate. I think nearly every Deputy in the House said something, but unfortunately I have to admit that I got very little help from the Opposition as to how I am going to carry on for another year. If the advice to stop the economic war could be adopted, of course I have got that advice often enough from the Opposition. I made a complaint last night that they are not doing sufficient thinking. They ought to think of some other remedy but that, if that remedy is not going to be adopted.
Deputy Minch raised the question of the surplus barley and oats. In introducing the Estimate I said that a Bill is being prepared and will be introduced to deal with that problem, but I should like to say that it is not proposed to control the acreage. He also spoke of the shortage of threshing machines. It was reported to the Department some time ago from some areas that there was a shortage of threshing machines, and I have asked for a report from the different counties on the subject. If what the Deputy says is true we must try to see if a remedy can be found.
In regard to what Deputy O'Neill said, and I think some other Deputies, contradicting figures I gave last night showing that we were disposing of as many cattle or more than Cumann na nGaedheal did in their hey-day, Deputy O'Neill quoted the 1934 figures. I was speaking of the 1935 and of this year's figures, and I still say that we are disposing of as many cattle now per annum as Cumann na nGaedheal did when they were doing so much for cattle in this country.
Comment on this
I am afraid I will have to ignore interruptions to-night in order to finish my speech. Deputy O'Neill said that the wealth of a nation is its exports. If we go into the theory of political economy, and so on, that may be true or it may not—I have not the time to examine it. I think that at least it would be equally true to say that the drain on a country is its imports if it can produce these particular articles within the country. If the Fianna Fáil Government are attempting to produce things here that up to the time we came into office were imported, we are adding to the wealth of the nation. It is not true to say that there has been no foot-and-mouth disease for over 20 years. As a matter of fact, there was foot-and-mouth disease since I came into this House— in 1928, in fact—and I hope we shall not be troubled with it again.
Deputy O'Neill also said that he made inquiries in 15 towns in his constituency, and found that where a town was getting £12,000 before from a fair it is not getting £500 now. Surely he does not claim that the receipts of the farmers have been reduced by 2,400 per cent.—that is, that they are getting £1 now where they got £24 before. The Deputy must have been looking at these figures through blue glasses.
Deputy Coburn spoke about the Dundalk factory and he has been already answered by Deputy Dowdall. If Messrs. Lunham were doing such a fine business in 1912 and 1913 they obviously must have been running the factory at a loss, because they got rid of it. Deputy Coburn is wrong in saying that anybody compels a factory to export bacon, leaving the home market short of supplies. The only authority that controls the factory with regard to production is the Bacon Board, and the Bacon Board does not take any account of whether the factory exports its bacon or sells it at home. It does take into account the export quota; I mean that if they give that factory its quota, then it goes on and produces, and that is all.
The Deputy says that I am pursuing a policy which is inflicting undue hardship on the farmer. The best judges of that are the farmers and any time we have gone to that tribunal the farmers have stood by us. Of course, I know, and it has been said over and over again here, that in 1932 the Opposition were looking for an opportunity of asking the farmers what they were going to say the next time. When they got that opportunity they made various excuses and looked forward to a further opportunity, which was given to them a few years afterwards at the local elections. Now they are looking for the next opportunity, which will come in time.
Deputy Finlay gave some calculations on the cost of producing beet. His first item was 30/- per acre for rent and rates. Taking the total rent paid and the total rates paid, the average works out at between 5/- and 6/- per acre, so that we need not pursue Deputy Finlay any further in his calculations on the production of beet when he puts down rent and rates at 30/-. Deputy O'Leary said that I ought to insist on the fairs and markets being kept open for pigs. That is not my business. If farmers prefer to send their pigs direct to the factory, and they do better by sending the pigs to the factory, surely we are not going to stop them. I do not see that the traders in the towns can have any great objection to that. If the farmers get more for pigs by sending them direct to the factory, do not the traders get the benefit? We have heard from Opposition speakers that the traders get all the farmer's money and more, because the farmers have not sufficient to give them—in fact, they are going into debt.
Deputy Wall and other speakers said that my introductory speech would imply that the farmers are having a wonderful time. In my introductory speech I pointed out exactly how things stood with regard to butter, cheese, cattle, pigs, poultry, potatoes, wheat, beet—every single thing—and not one single thing I said was contradicted. I gave facts which were not contradicted in any single item. If the facts gave the picture that the farmers are having a wonderful time, then the facts cannot be contradicted. I do not say, however, that they are having a wonderful time. I say the farmers are finding it hard enough to get on. I was reared upon a farm and I know that they always found it hard to get on, very hard, and I suppose they are finding it hard still.
Deputy Roddy wants to know about the butter marketing scheme. He asked how many have joined. All the creameries have joined. He asked has it improved prices, and the answer is "Yes". I said in my opening speech that from the time the marketing scheme came into operation our butter definitely came above the New Zealand price and has held a place above the New Zealand price right through, which was unknown before. We may give them that much credit. They did bring us definitely above the New Zealand price. We have not, perhaps, got the real value of our butter, but we have got nearer to getting the real value, because we do claim that our butter is more valuable than any other butter on the British market. Of course, we must get more experience before we can boast too much about what we are going to do. I hope we will be able to maintain that position.
The Deputy also asked: Has it decreased the cost of marketing? I do not think we can claim that, because the creameries are doing their own marketing so far, except that they are doing it under the direction, as it were, of this marketing committee. It may in time, perhaps, decrease costs, because it may enable the creameries to do their selling without expensive agency fees, and so on, on the other side.
Deputy Roddy read the Estimates wrongly when he said that we had decreased the grants to the county committees. We have not decreased them; we have, as a matter of fact, increased them. The grants to the county committees are much the same as last year. There is a slight increase under the ordinary headings, but there is a big increase under the heading of the cost of distribution of licences, so that the county committees should be slightly better off than they were last year, so far as grants from the Central Fund are concerned. Deputy Roddy also asked about this provision for improvement of the creamery industry. I do not think he understood exactly what that money is being devoted to. It is being devoted to the purchase of the proprietary creameries, some of which still remain, and also to the development of new interests in places where the Dairy Disposals Board has existing creameries, or adding on auxilaries or developing an area of that kind.
The salaries of officers of the county committees were always subject to approval by the Department and by me, under regulations made under the 1931 Agriculture Act. These regulations have been used from time to time and we are not in any way encroaching on the powers of the county committees in what we have done lately. We are only doing what we have done over and over again in laying down regulations with regard to salaries. Deputy Cosgrave talked about the Agricultural Credit Corporation and gave us a little lecture on banking which was very interesting. I do not think that there was very much in it apart from that. He gave us to understand that the Credit Corporation were not doing as much as they ought to do for the agricultural community. I do not want to raise this question because it is entirely irrelevant, but if they are not doing what they ought to do, it is due to the terms on which they were financed in the beginning, because they paid far too much for their money and are, therefore, compelled to lend their money at present at 6 per cent. They have reduced it to 5 per cent. now, but it is extremely difficult to make a concern like that pay on that basis.
Deputy Cosgrave also complained of the reduction in the number of poultry in the country. I answered a question some few weeks ago which gave returns in respect of poultry from 1927 downwards. There has been a continuous reduction since 1927. I have not got the particular returns with me, but I happen to have returns which show that eggs exported in 1929 were valued at £2,970,000. In 1931 the value was £2,060,000. There was a fall at the rate of £450,000 a year from 1929 to 1931. If Cumann na nGaedheal had remained in power and had kept up that sort of progression, we would have no exports at all. We have done a little better than that because we have almost £1,000,000 exports at present, so that we have at least arrested that very strong tendency to reduction that prevailed in the time of Cumann na nGaedheal.
He also complained about the Pigs and Bacon Act as being due to the economic war. It shows what Deputy Cosgrave, who is leader of the Opposition Party and, I believe, a responsible Deputy, who does not make statements without thinking over them, is prepared to say in his prejudice on this matter, because the Pigs and Bacon Act is not at all due to the economic war. They have a Pigs and Bacon Act in Northern Ireland, and there is no economic war there. It is necessary there because of the control brought in in Great Britain, and it became necessary here, too, for many reasons. I have stated the reasons over and over again—that the prices paid here were absurd in many cases, and were changing from day to day, and from factory to factory. We have a position now in which men know at least some time beforehand what they are going to get for their pigs.
This monomania of the economic war is becoming a danger, if it has not already become a danger, in the Fine Gael Party, because it keeps them from thinking on any problem. They give a superficial look at a thing and say: "Oh, the economic war." Monomania is a very dangerous thing. I learned that when I was studying medicine. It is one of the few things I did learn. Deputy Cosgrave also says that Great Britain is getting every penny of the disputed moneys, which is not correct.
Comment on this
She is not. Let the Deputy wait until he sees the returns. Let us take this matter of pigs and bacon again. We were told by some Deputies opposite that we had killed the pig trade, amongst other things. In 1931, under this pigs Government of Fine Gael, we exported £2,273,000 worth of bacon and imported £1,406,000 worth, a net balance of £867,000. In 1935, under an anti-pigs Government, we exported £2,275,000 worth and imported none, so that we are three times better than the Cumann na nGaedheal Government as regards pigs. That is money. I was told when I spoke about cattle that I was only talking of numbers and not of values. There is value, and we did three times as well in 1935 as they did in 1931.
Comment on this
I am talking about the bacon industry. I have not got the figures, but this I will say to the Deputy—and if I am wrong I will apologise when the Dáil meets again— that we did better, and much better, in 1935, taking pigs, bacon, pork, and everything else into consideration, than was done in 1931.
Comment on this
Here is a little more about pigs. I was reading the Evening Herald for amusement last night and I came across a little paragraph which says:
"There was a marked improvement in the supply, demand and price at the fortnightly pig fair in Tralee, when 800 pigs and 800 bonhams were on offer, the largest supply for months. Bacon pigs realised up to 64/- per cwt., dead weight, the best price obtained this year. The brisk demand and improved prices are attributed to the fact that pig-buyers representing outside bacon factories required supplies to make up their quotas."
I was a pig producer under Cumann na nGaedheal for a while, and if I had continued to get 64/- I would not have gone out of pigs. I went out of pigs when I got 25/- a cwt. because I thought I could not stick it any longer. Of course I am a pig producer now again because we are getting a fair price.
Deputy Mrs. Concannon complained that we were not devoting enough money towards the training of women in such places as the Munster Institute and in rural domestic economy schools. That is probably correct, and, as a matter of fact, I have been endeavouring for some time to see if we could not get at least an extra school or two going. There are difficulties in that respect, but I think it is possible that it may be extended. It must be remembered, however, that what we give is only a little help to these schools. They pay, to a great extent, for themselves, and we give a grant which helps them to carry on. It is not an indication of the amount of work done by these schools, apart from the Munster Institute. I would also remind Deputies that the Department of Education carries a certain Vote for the purpose of training girls in cookery, laundry work and other things that girls ought to know.
I have a few notes also on other matters about which I wanted to speak. I was speaking last night when the debate adjourned on the question of cattle, and I said that I wanted it to be known, and so have no further dispute about it, that our policy was to furnish the largest possible market for agricultural produce, not only at home but abroad. After I had said that and emphasised it several times, I found even to-day that Deputies came in here with the argument that we were trying to keep tillage going and at the same time to wipe out the cattle trade completely. There is no use in our trying to get to understand one another in that way, if Deputies in order to support their own arguments set out to misrepresent us. If Deputies have their speeches made up and find they must build these speeches on the arguments that we are destroying the cattle trade, it is hard lines on them if you take that prop from underneath them. I gave proofs here in the course of the debate that we had got all the quotas we possibly could, not only in Great Britain, but in several European countries. We have in fact been sneered at by the other side for going to Germany, Belgium, Morocco, Spain and other countries looking for quotas. Surely we would not be doing that if we were setting out to destroy the cattle trade.
Comment on this
I am trying to do the best I can, and the Deputy must now listen to me. It does appear to the mind of certain Deputies to be a very illogical thing that we should slaughter calves. As a matter of fact we have always slaughtered young calves, as we have slaughtered chickens and young lambs. As Deputy Corkery said to-day, it was always done.
Comment on this
There has always been a mortality of about 60,000 calves a year. We brought in this subsidy for calf skins with our eyes open, and in fact we said: "Well, here is at all events an assurance to the farmer against his calves dying. We are giving him this subsidy of 10/-" That was really an insurance to the ordinary farmer against mortality in his calves. To-day Deputy Corkery pointed out that there was a trade in his county for what was called "bobby veal." Dropped calves were killed, the veal sent to England, and some of it sold in Cork City. These calves were purchased at from 5/- to 10/- apiece. Is it not a great wonder that these calves were bought at 5/- and slaughtered in 1929, 1930 and 1931, when they could have been sent to Deputy O'Leary who would get £3 15s. for them? There had always been an export of veal to Great Britain, but the export of calves as veal to Great Britain has been stopped. That market has been shut out. It is a rather strange phenomenon that you have countries in Europe that supply all their own wants in dairy produce, in wheat, barley and all those other things, and yet they have no cattle exports. Why is that? If we were to supply our own wants in dairy produce we would require only 900,000 cows. Everybody knows we could not consume all our bullocks ourselves. In other countries they consume a great amount of veal. I think it would be a good thing if in this country we were to get veal consumed to the same extent. This would enable the farmers to have a veal market for badly coloured calves and calves that are not worth rearing. That was one of the ideas we had in mind when giving this bounty on calf skins.
We are now told that this slaughter of calves is a crime. One Deputy said it was unlucky. I do not mind so much being accused of its being a crime but it is a different thing when we find Deputies going into this thing on the lines of pishogues. One would expect better from an intelligent person. I thought that sort of thing was dead in the country—hanging up a calf's heel as a protection against blackleg.
The slaughter of an old cow is not a crime but we are told that the slaughter of a calf is a crime. I have asked Cumann na nGaedheal, when next considering this moral question, to get their theologian to let me know at what particular age it is a crime to slaughter a calf and at what particular age it is not a crime. I know that Cumann na nGaedheal does not consider it a crime to slaughter a six weeks old calf, or even a three weeks old calf. Some of these calves that are being slaughtered under the bounty are 14 days old. The crime then is somewhere in between 14 days and 21 days. In the case of old cows it is not a crime. The export of those old cows to Great Britain has, for public health reasons, been stopped. It was for that reason that we were obliged to do something about them. We are converting them into meat meal. There is no objection to that and so we can go ahead.
Comment on this
Oh, no. It is not a question of a tax. As a matter of fact, I am not exaggerating when I say that the order has been tightened up in England and the regulations have been made more strict against the imports of old cows, for public health reasons. It is becoming more difficult every year.
I was asked about these moneys for land reclamation in the Gaeltacht. There is only a token Vote for £10 in this Estimate but that does not mean that we are not going ahead with this scheme. As a matter of fact, the figures under this sub-head for the last three or four years are very interesting. The figure for land reclamation in 1931-1932 was £750. That money was spent in the congested districts, or I should say it was paid to the farmers for reclaiming their own land. We were told that land that time under the Cumann na nGaedheal regime was very valuable. But the farmers in 1931-32 got only £750 for reclamation purposes. In the next year the amount spent was £8,277 and in 1933-34, £12,223. In 1934-1935 the amount was £11,277 and in 1935-36 it was £10,808. That shows that the farmers in those districts are evidently of the opinion that they can make better use of their land now than at the time when the Cumann na nGaedheal was in office. We intend to spend the same amount, if not more, in the reclamation of land in the congested districts this year.
There has been another point raised in this debate. I was asked would the figures of our trading with Germany, Spain and so on be published. Yes, these figures must be published. They will be audited first and then published. I will say this: that Deputies on the other side will be somewhat disappointed over these figures. They will find that there has not been any loss. We have done well. I said the other day that I wished that I had been doing this on my own account because, if I were, I would be almost as well off as Deputy Belton.
Comment on this
Here is one thing I want to know—who speaks for the farmers in this House? We are told that the farmers are the big majority of the people of this country. We are told that they constitute 68 to 70 per cent. of the electorate. But we represent the big majority of the people and, therefore, we represent a big majority of the farmers, and as long as we represent that big majority, is it not obvious that they are satisfied? At least, I will say this: they are satisfied they cannot do better. They are not satisfied, I know, but they are satisfied, at least, that the alternative is worse.
I was asked what do the cattle for Waterford cost. It is estimated that they will cost £47,000. They are the cattle going to the Waterford factory for conversion into tinned meat— canned meat—and into meat extract. Some Deputy mixed up the two factories. We do not do any canning in Roscrea for consumption in this country. The canning for consumption in this country is done in Waterford and the animals used are young cattle— principally mountainy cattle are used for that purpose. It is estimated that they will cost £47,000 and that we will get in receipts from that factory £25,000.
Comment on this
Last year 2,000 were bought, but for the coming year it is expected there will be 10,000 bought.
Comment on this
I could not say at the moment what was paid for them per cwt., but I will try to get that information. Perhaps the Deputy will put a question down.
Comment on this
This factory is run on a subsidy. Let us hope, as Deputy Dillon wishes, that it is a temporary subsidy. We are accused by Deputies on the other side of being responsible for a lot of people leaving the country. I think it is a most extraordinary thing that we should be accused by ex-Ministers like Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney of causing people to leave the country. I think it was one of the big planks of our platform against Deputies on the opposite side that they had driven 300,000 people out of the country in ten years. Deputy Cosgrave said that they went over to see their friends in America, but they are over there still with their friends, and some of them must not be doing very well, because they are anxious to come back.
Comment on this
We were told also that we were growing wheat two years in succession, and the Deputy who said that added that we had not increased tillage at all, that we had only carried out a substitution of crops. If we have not increased tillage, is it not strange that people should be changing their rotation? There is something illogical about it, but that is nothing new. I want to say something about the Flax Bill. I admit it is rather late to apply this Bill, but nevertheless I think we can apply it partially in the present year. It is intended to apply this Bill to Donegal, Cavan and Monaghan. It would require some further consideration to see what other areas it should be applied to. It is not intended to apply the Bill to the whole country. This year we can apply it to the three counties that I have named. We can at least undertake for this year to guarantee an amount not exceeding the average amount produced by any grower there during the past ten years. When the Bill goes through we can make the necessary order and we can give that guarantee, but we cannot give the guarantee until the crop is sown. The standard price will be 8/-. I do not want Deputies to assume that 8/- is a huge price for flax. This Bill is a guarantee against loss. We say to the growers: "Go ahead and grow flax. You may get a good price, but at least we will guarantee that you will get 8/- under this Bill."
Comment on this
No. In any case, the Bill could not apply to the Deputy's constituency, unless we were to sow flax in Mountjoy Square or Linenhall Street.
Comment on this
The Minister would be more in his element farming there than where he attempts farming, and he might be as successful.
Comment on this
At least a farming constituency had sufficient faith in me to elect me. I am not driven to the city yet.
Comment on this
A lot has been said about agricultural wages. I thought this particular matter would not be so much discussed until we came to the Motion that is on the Order Paper. It is unfair to accuse the Government of doing nothing for the agricultural labourer. We brought in a scheme of derating which at least induced the farmers to employ to some extent, perhaps not to the extent of increasing labourers' wages. We gave benefit to the men employing labour as against the men who do not.
Comment on this
I must say that that is the first I heard of it. Then the Unemployment Assistance Act was introduced and I think that Act has had some influence on maintaining the rate of wages in this country.
Comment on this
I do mean it. The Unemployment Assistance Act has had an influence in keeping wages up. I do not want to deny it at all, there was pressure from all quarters to do something on this question. The last Ard-Fheis of Fianna Fáil and the one before it passed resolutions; then my own Party and the Labour Party have been pressing me strongly to do something on this question. What some Deputies said is also true. There was a great deal of provocation after the 1932 and the 1933 election when certain employers, anti-Government in sympathy, purposely reduced men's wages because they considered these men had supported the Government Party.
Comment on this
They gave it as the reason—plainly stated that was the reason.
Comment on this
Will you find a former supporter of your own Party who pays good wages? I cannot find one in County Dublin. They followed your Party because they thought they would get out of their obligations.
Comment on this
A lot of them did not follow us because of that. The Dublin County Council, for instance, did not get out of its obligations. Some farmers are paying as good a wage as they can pay under present circumstances—we all know that—and some are not paying as good a wage as they could pay.
Comment on this
No. I am just going to tell the Deputy the difficulty about that. There are difficulties about that question here just as they have difficulties in England. First of all there are regional difficulties. A man in County Longford, for instance, might say that for some reason or other he was not able to pay the same wage as a man in County Dublin. I do not say that is true; I am just giving it as an example. You have, therefore, those regional difficulties to be considered in the first instance. Then the question arises whether a ploughman—who would be considered a skilled man— should not get a better wage than an ordinary person who comes in and would not know the front of a plough from the handles. Those things give rise to certain difficulties. Then of course you have also in this country, even more than in England, a big difficulty about this question of perquisites. Some people are boarded, and get a free house, and so on. Others get partial board, and get perhaps vegetables and milk. There are all sorts of different ways in which a man may get perquisites. It is a very difficult subject; that cannot be denied.
I was accused by Deputy Norton of not keeping faith because I had delayed this question so long. I promised to have it considered many months ago, and I did have it considered as well as I possibly could. I say that when the obvious difficulties are taken into account it must be recognised that it takes some time to get a question like this considered, but I did get it before the Executive Council. They had it before them at a number of meetings, and I can say definitely that the Executive Council are sympathetic with the idea that something should be done in the way of setting up an arbitration board. There may be farmers here who would perhaps oppose that. I do not see that any good employing farmer has anything to fear from arbitration machinery being set up, because if he is paying a fair wage according to his circumstances then his representatives on the board should be able to make that case, and therefore he will not be asked to pay more. If, on the other hand, he is not paying a fair wage in the present circumstances he will be made to pay more, because the labourer has a right to get at least as much as can be paid to him in existing circumstances. I say that my Department now, having got the approval of the Executive Council on the principle of this thing, are working on the proposals to have a Bill drafted which will come before this House in due time.
Comment on this
I might introduce it, but certainly not any more than that; I cannot promise that it will be discussed before the Summer Recess.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say if the principal thing that prevents its being introduced now is the type of economic discussion that would arise at those councils on the present state of the country?
Comment on this
Not at all. If we get decent farmers and labourers on that, they will mind their own business; they will not have this Blueshirt outlook of making political capital out of it. The Deputy has a mind that is naturally inclined to making political capital out of everything.
Comment on this
Those farmers will look at the matter from a business point of view.
Comment on this
At least three weeks. I cannot say definitely but it has been before them longer than that, anyhow.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan made a very nice speech here last night. I am sorry he is not here, because I should like to compliment him and to say he is really a pleasant speaker when he leaves out personalities. What is more, he is a clever speaker, because he puts a case in such a way that you can hardly see the flaw in it. He said, for instance, that we had spent one and a third million pounds in subsidies for beet without giving any extra employment in agriculture. Of course, the figures were against him, and the only way he could get over the figures of employment in agriculture was to say that there was a big inducement to men to register as being working on the farms in order to get some relief through the rates. Surely, there is a bigger inducement to them to say they are not working on the farms in order to get unemployment assistance? He might have taken the figures as they were, because he might have made a fairly good case even then. But surely there are other things to be taken into account besides the distribution of wages between farmers and agricultural workers? Those factories are a benefit to the country, and if the Deputy objects to that sort of scheme I think he should really have got one of his colleagues to make the case— Deputy Brennan, for instance—who was not committed, say, to the Shannon scheme; because is it not the same as the Shannon scheme, uneconomical if you like, in the accepted narrow sense of the word "uneconomical" from the political economist point of view? But it is keeping the money in the country instead of sending it out. This idea of building our own beet factories is the very same as the Shannon scheme. The same applies to wheat.
The Deputy talked about self-sufficiency and said that I prated about self-sufficiency down the country. So did Deputy McGilligan. Did he not prate about self-sufficiency? He took it for granted, because I lectured on self-sufficiency, that I agreed with self-sufficiency to the last iota. I often talk about the Fine Gael policy, but that does not mean that I agree with it; God forbid. Surely we can talk about a thing even if we do not agree with it? I said a lot of things in my lecture on self-sufficiency that would absolutely coincide with Deputy McGilligan's ideas. I think I said that self-sufficiency would not be the best thing if we had a friendly world and friendly people all over the world, but as we are situated here in this country it is quite a different thing. Taking things as they are, what can we do except defend ourselves against dumping and imports of various commodities which would put our own people out of production both in industry and agriculture? If that is self-sufficiency, then as far as it goes I agree with it, and I have advocated it as strongly as I can.
In answer to an interruption, Deputy McGilligan said he was told that the farmers had approved of our policy. Deputy McGilligan said that they approved of our policy in 1933 because they were told we were going back to settle the economic war. I do not think all the Deputies on the other side claim that that is really why we went back. If they do, I should like to state that we said if we got a strong mandate we could get a good settlement of this economic war. But what did Deputy Cosgrave say? He said he would settle in three days. What is more, he threw in the statement that he would take off the annuities as well. The people did not think that. If we are to be accused of getting back in 1933 because we promised to settle the economic war, surely the people would have voted for Deputy Cosgrave if they thought he was only going to take three days to do it. Of course the people saw through that. They have a certain amount of intelligence. They asked themselves the question which we have asked the Opposition over and over again, "Settle on what terms?" I have asked, and I heard other Ministers asking the Party on the benches opposite to state on what terms they would settle the economic war. We have never got an answer. We would like to know whether they were prepared to give £20,000,000, £10,000,000, or £5,000,000.
Comment on this
After all, when they do not want the Deputy, why defend them? I would like to know at what price the Opposition is prepared to settle. We have had four days' discussion about settling the economic war. I would like to know if they would settle for £20,000,000, £30,000,000 or £10,000,000. I should like to hear what Deputy Bennett has to say.
Comment on this
I will tell you that. We said that we did not owe this money, and that we were not prepared to pay it. That is as far as we went. Are not these simple terms?
Comment on this
Whatever it cost, it was pointed out to the Opposition for the last four days what the economic war is costing. The people know what it is costing, and surely they would like to know on what terms other people would settle. As on every other question, they have not the courage to say what they will do. It was like Deputy Bennett's action in connection with the creameries. I put it to him, when there was opposition to the Dairy Prices (Stabilisation) Bill, if he was prepared to say, if his Party got into power, that they would turn down that Bill. Of course, he would not say so. He was prepared to oppose it, but he was not prepared to say to the farmers of Limerick, that if his Party got back they would rescind the Act. It is the same in this case; they want to have it both ways. They will not tell the people on what terms they would settle.
Comment on this
Referring to the position of agricultural labourers, the Minister indicated that the Executive Council would accept the principle of fixing minimum rates of wages for agricultural workers, and that it was intended to introduce legislation on the subject. Am I to understand that it is intended to introduce legislation this year, before the Summer Recess?
Comment on this
I said there was no hope that the Bill would appear before the Summer Recess. It might be possible however to introduce the Bill, on the understanding that it would be dealt with in the autumn.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say if it was under pressure from the Official Labour Party that he is to introduce the Bill?
Comment on this
Question—"That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration"— put.
Do you agree with this result?