We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolutions (Resumed).

Contributions 137–308 of 308. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The difference is only a paltry £200,000.

Comment on this

The Deputy merely wished to undertake a little inflation.

Comment on this

I would never like to follow the Minister's bad example. The actual figure is £838,000. That money, apparently, is to be provided by the local authorities. Many local authorities have embarked on big development schemes which will mean a heavy cost to the ratepayers. They have borrowed enormous sums already, and it appears to me that if the local authorities are to be encouraged, the Minister will need to facilitate them more than he has done already in the borrowing of additional moneys for the purpose of carrying out wholeheartedly his schemes for the relief of unemployment. I have no doubt local authorities will be anxious to co-operate with the Minister, but many of them are hampered by restrictions imposed by the Minister's Department, and however willing they may be to assist him in carrying out these relief schemes, they cannot do so at present. Again, many local authorities may be somewhat hesitant to embark on further schemes of expenditure without some suitable guarantees that the ratepayers as a body will not have to bear whatever losses may occur—I sincerely hope that there will not be any losses—in the carrying out of these schemes. The outline given by the Minister is rather vague, and I would be anxious to hear a good deal more from him about the financial framework of his scheme. I would like to be assured that it will be water-tight and that no undue burdens will be imposed upon local authorities.

The Minister made a most extraordinary statement yesterday. He got so enthusiastic about social services and the wonderful work done by his Government in extending and developing social services in this country that I think he was carried away much further than he intended. He said he regarded the work of the Land Commission as a social service. I suppose in next year's Budget we will hear from the Minister that he is arranging for the local authorities to take responsibility for portion of the Land Commission work. His actual words were: "Within my experience no vote has been cast in the Dáil for the curtailment of its activities, and no one has ventured to deny the social value of its work. Accordingly, we may regard it as a social service, and add the expenditure thereon to the figures which I have given, bringing them up to £8,652,000 for 1931-32, and to £13,028,000 for 1935-36." There the Minister regards it as a social service —the Land Commission.

Comment on this

Certainly. If the Deputy is of opinion that it is not a social service, will he define a social service to the House?

Comment on this

Here we are dealing with the greatest and the most fundamental asset in the State—land. It is the duty of the Land Commission to deal with the purchase and the resale of land, and does the Minister regard the value of landed property in this country so lightly that he is prepared to consider the work of purchasing and reselling land as merely a social service? Is he prepared to place that in the same category as the carrying out of drainage work, the construction of wells, and the carrying out of other schemes which normally come under local authorities? Does the Minister mean to suggest that the buying and reselling of land in this country is on exactly the same plane as the work normally carried out in the way of social services by local authorities?

Comment on this

Which does the Deputy rate the higher? Which would be of more importance—the work of the Land Commission or the social services which, apparently, the Deputy is inclined to rate so lowly?

Comment on this

There is no relation whatsoever between the two. They are both on quite different planes.

Comment on this

Which is on the higher plane?

Comment on this

Ah now. The Minister apparently was carried beyond himself. He got so enthusiastic about the money he was spending on the social service development taking place during his time of office that he——

Comment on this

But which does the Deputy regard as the higher?

Comment on this

The Minister is very disorderly.

Comment on this

This is surely a most amazing development. It is a most extraordinary statement coming from a Minister of the Government running this country that the greatest asset in this State, the land, is to be treated as a social service, that it is to be regarded on the same footing as such things as drainage, water, sewerage and so on. The Minister has actually in his Estimate taken credit for the particular money spent by the Land Commission as part of the social services of the country. Surely the Minister was not serious when he wrote down this beautiful passage in his Budget. As I am on the subject of the social services I wish to say this, that whilst undoubtedly these social services are necessary, I do think that the expenditure on them should be proportioned to the ability of the people to bear it. The Government are embarking or at least they are forcing the local authorities to embark on certain schemes of social services that could very well wait until the financial structure of this State might become sounder than it is at the present moment.

There is a limit to the amount of money which the local authorities should be asked to expend on social services. The general feeling throughout the country at the moment is that the local authorities are spending rather too much money on social services. These social services are, I believe, quite necessary in due time and in the normal course, but, after all, this Government cannot hope to make this country perfect during its lifetime in this respect. I do not see why the present generation should be asked to bear the whole cost of the development of all these services. The Budget in my opinion is a bad Budget because it has not withdrawn any of the huge taxes which the Budget of last year imposed on the people of this country. There is no doubt about it that the large taxpayer in this country may feel relieved because he has not been asked to carry any additional burdens on his already overburdened shoulders. But the unfortunate consumer who is sorely pressed to make ends meet will certainly be disappointed and gravely disappointed when his worries have not been lessened in the slightest. In that sense I think the Budget is a bad one, and I do not think the Government is deserving of any congratulation whatsoever for having produced a Budget of this kind.

Comment on this

After the speech of Deputy Roddy and the figures he has given the House my work will be very light. I do not propose to cover the same ground. I propose to refer only to a few points. The Minister will recollect that it is not so very long since I pulled him out of the hole in which he had been placed by Deputy Brennan. It is true that I always have been endeavouring to help the Minister and his colleagues so far as I could by giving them sound advice. It is also true that they never acted on my advice. It is only quite lately that they acknowledged I gave them sound advice, and some of my friends in the Press gallery exalted me on a pinnacle high above the arena of Party manoeuvring. Now, in order to live up to that reputation, I will try to help the Minister again. I have examined the Minister's Budget with great care to see if I could congratulate him on anything in it. I think there is only one thing in connection with the Budget on which I can congratulate the Minister and that was the speech in which he introduced it to the House. I think it was a very eloquent speech. But it was worthy of a better Budget. The Budget itself, if I might use the expression, was rather a poor bird arrayed in a wonderful plumage. I think I could not better describe it than by calling it a peacock Budget. I think, however, that by the time it has done the circuit of the House it will come back to the Minister a very bare and ragged Budget. In my criticisms and in anything that I have to say on the Budget I am afraid that I am rather late; so many other Deputies have got in before me that the position of the Budget now is that there is scarcely a feather left. The question that is generally asked is, "what do you think of the Budget?"

Comment on this

Tell us that.

Comment on this

Yes, I propose to tell the House what I think of it. It depends on the standard by which we are to judge it. If the Budget is judged on the standard of last year's Budget then it is not a very bad one at all. But, judged on the standard of what a Budget ought to be, I say it is a very bad Budget. How are we to get a standard as to what a good Budget ought to be? I think we could not select a better authority than the Minister himself and what he told this House before he was given the responsibility of Ministerial rank himself. He told us then his ideal of what a good Budget ought to be. His description of what it ought to be was something like £2,000,000 less than what the Cumann na nGaedheal Budget of 1931-32 was. That Budget was somewhere about £22,000,000. On that basis the Minister's Budget would be about £20,000,000. That was then the Minister's ideal standard as to what a Budget ought to be. If we are to judge this Budget by that standard we will find that it is an extraordinary Budget for it imposes £12,000,000 in excess of what a good Budget ought to be.

If we examine the Budget at close quarters we find that there is one section of the community that fares very badly under it; that is the producers. What do the producers get from this Budget? The Minister has boasted about distributing his surplus. But there is one section of this community that is getting nothing out of this surplus. That is the section of the population that is hardest hit, the section that is responsible for the raising of the money paid in taxation—the producers of this country—the agricultural section of the community. The agricultural community, instead of getting anything out of the surplus that the Minister is distributing, has lost something near to £1,000,000. The amount provided for bounties last year was £3,180,000. That has been reduced this year to £2,273,000 or something like £900,000 of a decrease. That money is being taken off the most deserving section of the whole community. There is very little relief there, and the relief given in sugar taxes—in order to sweeten this Budget—leaves a very bod taste in the mouths of the producers of this country who are losing £900,000.

Another matter which the Minister boasted very much about was that there was an increase of £340,000 in the amount received from income-tax, which he said showed the increased prosperity of the country. I wonder does it. Deputy McGilligan said it had reference to prosperity on the other side of the Channel and increased dividends from there, and I agree with that point of view. But there is another point of view. What about the profiteering that is in operation under the present Government? A good deal of this is a profiteering tax; in fact, I would say that the whole of the £340,000 would represent a profiteering tax. Profiteering has been brought to the notice of the Minister and his colleagues time and time again in this House but nothing has been done to check it—profiteering in flour, in transport services, and in many other directions. A good deal of this increase in income-tax is in reality a profiteering tax. So far as this £340,000 represents a profiteering tax, it means a tax of more than four times that amount on the producers. That is an aspect of the tax that the Minister has nothing to boast about. I ask him to use his influence with the Ministers responsible to see that this profiteering is stopped, because it is a very serious burden, added to all the other burdens, on the producers of the country.

The Minister also boasts about how the money is spent, and so do some of his colleagues. He boasts that it is spent on social services, and that therefore, it is all to the good. I question that. The Minister claimed that the Land Commission is a social service. I wonder does he claim that the Army and the Gárda Síochána are social services? Fianna Fáil were very explicit in their promises before they came into power that they would cut down the expenditure upon these two services, and, as a result, cut down the taxation necessary to keep these services at the high standard, as they called it, at which they were at that time. Since then, what has happened? We need only go back three years to the year 1933-34. In that year the Estimate for the Gárda Síochána was £1,698,137. This year it is £1,865,129, an increase of £166,992. Then, as to the Army, which we were told was not necessary at all in the country. I quite agreed with the Minister and his colleagues when they told us that there was no Army necessary in this country. I do not know whom we are going to fight or what we want an Army for. We were told that under a good Government, a Government with the consent of the people, and which gave the people the sort of government they wanted, we would need no Army and that the whole of the money spent on the Army could be saved. Yet we find that in the year 1933-34, the Estimate for the Army was £1,160,000, while the Estimate for this year is £1,529,987, an increase of £370,000. That is what we have got from the Government which was to give the country the sort of government it wanted. How can the Minister claim that these are social services? Then when the Estimates are examined one by one, and we go into the details of the Estimates——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Estimates may not be examined in detail on a discussion of the Financial Resolutions.

Comment on this

It is the Budget I am dealing with. I am dealing with the Estimates which are being provided for in this Budget. In the President's Department the expenditure in 1933-34 was £10,610, and this year there is an increase of £1,057 to £11,667. Then the Estimate for the Department of Finance, the Minister's own Department, in 1933-34 was £61,058; this year it is £67,622.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is precisely a matter that should not be debated on the Budget. The Army Vote was before the House, and the increase or decrease in expenditure on the Army should have been raised on that Vote. Matters proper to the Estimates should not be raised now.

Comment on this

This is not exactly the Estimate. These are details taken from the Estimates which deal with salaries and allowances and the expenditure on administration.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Administration does not enter into this discussion.

Comment on this

The Minister and other speakers on the other side of the House claimed that the increased expenditure is due to, and is going to the benefit of social services. I want to ask if these are social services. I should like to have a reply from the Minister as to whether the money spent upon an increased number of officials and an increase in travelling expenses and that sort of thing, is for social services. Deputy Roddy asked whether the expenditure on the Land Commission is a social service. I want to know from the Minister if he claims that this increase of £6,537 on the administration on his own Department is a social service. I do not want to stray from the main track. I am never afraid of going astray, as I have confidence that you, Sir, will keep me on the right track.

There are some other very important items and I should like to have an explanation from the Minister or some of his colleagues as to whether they are social services or not. For instance, the expenditure on salaries, wages and allowances in 1933-34 for the Revenue Commissioners' Department was £709,365. This year, it is £793,121, an increase of £83,756. Does that go to a social service? For commissions and special inquiries there is an increase of over £5,000 in salaries, wages and allowances. In the Public Works Department there is an increase of £17,000. Civil Service Commission is increased by £8,000; secret service is increased by £10,000; law charges increased by £7,754. I do not think that could be described as a social service. The Department of Local Government and Public Health, in wages and salaries and allowances and travelling expenses for inspectors, is increased by £31,000 odd, and there is an increase in the number of officials from 243 to 342. I want to know is that social service? There is also an increase in the salaries and allowances of the National Health Insurance Department of £17,137. The Department of Education shows an increase of £6,000. In the Department of Agriculture, in salaries and other allowances, there is an increase from £117,000 in 1933-34 to £180,666 in 1936-37, or an increase of £63,000. There is an increase of officials in the Department of Agriculture from 332 to 712. Then let us turn to old age pensions, which is really a social service. Here we find an increase in that Vote from £3,316,738 in the year 1933-34 to £3,466,850 for 1936-37 showing an increase of £150,112, less than half the increase on the Army and much less than the increase on the Gárda Síochána. That is what has been done for the social services. The Minister told the House that this money was all being expended on social services. There is a progressive increase in services other than social services, and the increase in old age pensions, in the three years is no more than £150,112.

Then, of course, if we turn to another aspect we find that the farmers have paid in tariffs on their produce, not to speak at all of what they pay in tariffs in connection with industries started by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, £5,500,000 last year. That was reduced this year, because of the excess over and above what ought to have been paid, and the Minister for Finance comes along and coolly adds that to his Budget in order to balance it. I am afraid that while the Minister is balancing his Budget he is at the same time breaking the backs of the taxpayers. That £5,500,000 which the farmers paid in taxation on their cattle was reduced by £500,000 this year. The Minister appropriated that to the Exchequer, just as if the Exchequer was entitled to that relief which was so badly needed by the farmers. The Minister admits, at any rate, that the improved position in the price of agricultural produce has helped him out with his Budget. Some speakers from the benches opposite, including the Minister himself, took no small credit for the improvement which has taken place in prices. What is that due to? It is due to the improved conditions across the water, and to the fact that a bounty of 5/- per cwt. has been put upon fat cattle in England. Since the farmers in Great Britain have been getting that increased price in the shape of bounty, they are buying more and more store cattle in this country in order to secure their bounty. Accordingly, the benefit, which these farmers in Britain are receiving, is being passed on to farmers in this country, and the Minister is not entitled to any credit for that increase in the price of cattle.

The Minister, last year, told us that he was borrowing for the bounty because he looked upon the bounty as something arising out of circumstances that were not likely to be continued; that the circumstances were abnormal, and only of a temporary character. He does not say so this year. Are we coming any nearer to the end of these temporary circumstances? He did not tell us that. He looks into that matter, withdraws the bounty and gradually passes it on to the producer, and will make the producer bear the whole burden. If prices still improve across the water and go up further, he will simply appropriate more and more of what the farmers are entitled to. Not only is he appropriating this bounty which he gave last year, and which has been remitted this year, because of the excess collected last year by the British Government but he is also arranging that £1,700,000 odd which he proposes to grant in relief of unemployment, is to be made conditional on the local bodies putting up the balance of £800,000 odd. That is simply another trick of the Minister's to shift the responsibility of the Exchequer on to the local bodies and to impose on the ratepayers a burden that should be the responsibility of the Treasury.

A great deal of unemployment resulting from the economic war is due to the condition of agriculture. In the rural districts the whole of it is due to the policy that has brought the farmer to his present position. Therefore it is the responsibility of the Minister to relieve unemployment, and not the responsibility of the local bodies. They had no responsibility at all for bringing about this unemployment in the country, and they should not be asked to contribute. The Minister should know, or at least the Minister for Local Government and Public Health should know, that the farmers are not able to pay their present rates apart from increased responsibility being put upon them. They cannot take responsibility for the relief of unemployment by having to pay additional rates. I hold that that is the responsibility of the Minister, and his Government, and that they should face up to that responsibility until they are prepared to end the economic war. Instead of putting more burdens upon the farmers they should try to relieve them of the burdens they are bearing, and shift the cost of this fruitless war to the whole community.

Comment on this

I think the Minister for Finance may congratulate himself on the fact that he has produced a good Budget. There has been a tremendous lot of criticism of it, and there has been a certain amount of approval of it. Deputy McGovern has said that the producers have the whole burden of the taxation in the Budget upon their shoulders. He says the farmer is deprived of a certain amount in bounties, which he got last year. It is a lesser amount but he is taxed to the extent of the lesser amount of the decreased bounty. He cannot object very much to that. Deputy Roddy referred to an estimate of the national income made by the Minister for Finance when he was in Opposition. He said he fixed the national income at about £90,000,000. Deputy Roddy contended that we were taking about £30,000,000 out of productive employment. But is not the £30,000,000 going back in expenditure? It must go into employment of some sort—productive or otherwise. Nobody can spend money without giving some employment. This sum of £30,000,000 is going back to the people—it may not go back to the particular people from whom it was extracted—and it gives employment. I do not think it can be shown that we are living beyond our means, so far as taxation is concerned, when that money goes back into employment. Deputy McGovern spoke about tariffs and the burden of prices on producers and on the farming community. Last year, Deputy Dillon, and, this year, Deputy McGilligan, speaking on the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce, referred to some statements of mine with regard to tariffs. If I would be in order, I should like to make my views on tariffs perfectly clear.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am afraid it would not be in order.

Comment on this

Then I had better not deal with it. Deputy MacDermot spoke of the policy of self-sufficiency as a foolish policy and one that should be abandoned. I do not think that any member of the Executive Council has ever advocated absolute self-sufficiency. They have advocated self-sufficiency so far as possible, and I think that that is a very good aim. I do not agree at all with what Deputy MacDermot said with regard to self-sufficiency. I understand that, during his absence to-day, the Minister for Finance was alleged to have made some reference in his Budget statement to people being too lazy to go a certain distance to get work—that when a certain number of people were required for particular work only nine out of 73 attended.

Comment on this

The word "lazy" did not occur in my statement.

Comment on this

I am speaking only of what was said in the House to-day. It is quite possible that it would be inconvenient for men to walk a considerable distance to work. I do not, however, think that the Minister intended to convey that there was any such thing as a deliberate refusal to work on the part of the unemployed or the people on the dole. That implication appears to have been taken by some of the Deputies on the opposite benches. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney appeared to resent this alleged statement very much and he paid tribute to the workmen of his own district. I have had considerable experience of employment here and across the water and all the Irish people I had to do with worked very well indeed.

Deputy Roddy referred at least twice to the speech made to-day by Deputy Dillon. I listened to the whole of the speech of Deputy Dillon and I was rather impressed. In fact, I would have been convinced, or nearly convinced, if Deputy Dillon had not, in the earlier part of his discourse, called attention to the question of unemployment during the period of the administration of the last Government and during the period of the administration of the present Government. If I remember aright, he measured the unemployment during the period of the late administration at 29,000. Of course, it is considerably more now. Deputy Dillon did not explain that the number of unemployed then was calculated on a very different basis from that on which it is calculated now. If he had explained that matter I am sure that people would not take a wrong view as to the position being very much worse now than it was then. So far as I can gather, it is a lot better. When one considers all the people who are eligible to register now, as a result of Acts passed by the Oireachtas, I am sure the position is better now, more particularly when one takes into account the increase of population.

Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney referred to some committee which the Minister for Finance intended to set up with regard to employment schemes as an incompetent committee. I took him to refer to the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance as rather incompetent. I may be wrong in that but, if he did so refer to him, I am sure he is altogether wrong. I do not think that there is any more competent member of the Oireachtas in carrying out the work he has got to do than Mr. Hugo Flinn. Reference was made to agreements with other countries for trading purposes and they were rather approved of. Two agreements were made by the Government with Great Britain—one last year and another this year—and we have not yet heard the end of them, so dissatisfied are the Opposition with them. If they approve of the agreements made with other countries for trading purposes, why should they kick up such a row with regard to the coal-cattle pact and the extension of that pact this year? I think it was Deputy Roddy who spoke of our contributing in three or four years about £16,000,000 to the British Exchequer. They are blaming Fianna Fáil for that. But the real cause of our having to contribute £16,000,000 to the British Exchequer is the suppressed agreement they made with Great Britain after the Boundary Commission. I commend the Budget and I hope this Resolution will be passed without a division.

Comment on this

When the Minister rose to speak yesterday afternoon he very properly referred to the Book of Lamentations and in the words of that very sacred book I say to him Convertere, Convertere ad Dominum Deum nostrum. I listened to my friend Deputy Dowdall speaking on this subject. We all know and we are glad, that he is fattening and battening on the tariffs. He is the richest and wealthiest merchant in Cork City. I hope he will be still richer. I am not a bit surprised that he approves of the policy of the Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The business affairs of a Deputy should not be brought into discussion in this House.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I know that.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke is only thinking of the time when he held the record himself.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

What did the Minister say?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not relevant to the discussion.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

Anything I say is not relevant. A very great financier said that figures are more misleading and more mystifying than facts. I think that statement is not justified by the Budget which the Minister introduced. I always like to be fair to everybody in this House, or outside it. There are very many good points in the Budget. I know that there is great reserve power in this country, but a State cannot subsist all the time on capital or on credit. If its cash is exhausted its credit ceases. It seems to me we are coming nearer the day when our reserve funds will be gone and our credit will then fail. I am not going into the big figures. I am not able to do so, but let me point out a few simple facts. Will anybody deny that the cost of living has gone up or the standard of living has gone down? I challenge the Minister to deny that. Will anybody tell me that agriculture is as thriving and as productive as it was five years ago? I challenge the Minister again on that point. Will anybody have the audacity to proclaim that every merchant, like my friend, Deputy Dowdall, is rolling in wealth, or that plain citizens, to whom so many promises were made during the election times, are better off than they were five years ago? These are simple questions to which, I hope, the Minister will give satisfactory answers. The national bill, instead of being reduced, is growing, and the promised reduction of £2,000,000 has vanished into thin air. Why is that so? Why has the Government not carried out the promises they made on the eve of the General Election in 1931? The Minister is resorting to every expedient to pull the legs and put his fingers in the eyes of the electors, and if he succeeds, well and good. However, the day of reckoning will come, when he will have many questions to answer and many misdeeds to atone for.

I am sorry there is so much unemployment in the country. I agree that any man who is willing and able to work ought to get sufficient to provide him with proper shelter and clothing, and to enable him to live in decent comfort amid Christian and sanitary surroundings. At the same time a work-shy people, who, when offered employment refuse it, deserve very little consideration, either from the Government or from any charitable society. Men, able to work, who are offered employment, but will not work, ought to be consigned to a Tophet or Gehenna, which, I am sure, the Minister knows all about but in which I hope he will never find himself. The way the State stands in the matter of expenditure indicates that we cannot afford to spend any more than is being spent. I appeal to the Minister in all sincerity to come to the aid of the farmers by finishing the economic war. As he admits, and as everybody else admits, agriculture is the backbone of the country. I believe that can be done without sacrifice of honour, principle or national dignity. By doing that he and the members of the Executive Council will earn the eternal gratitude of the Irish people. There is no necessity to prolong a war which has been disastrous not only to this country but to Great Britain. After all, we are next-door neighbours. As everyone knows, it is a foolish thing for neighbours to quarrel with one another. In a necessity everybody realises that a neighbour will come to another neighbour's assistance. I say again in all solemnity, that it would be a good thing for this country, as well as for Great Britain, to make a peaceful and honourable settlement of the unfortunate dispute that exists between them. I do not know if my words will have any weight with the Government but I feel that I am bound to give expression to them, in the assurance that in doing so it would be a very good thing for both neighbours to come to a friendly, amicable and lasting settlement.

Comment on this

If this debate has been remarkable for anything apart from being the dullest Budget speeches we have had since this House was established, it is because the leaders of the Opposition Party have decided to emulate the famous Duke and lead their forces from behind. Back benchers have been put up to speak, while they maintain their discreet silence. I am curious to find out why that should be so. Of course we had Deputy Dillon. Perhaps it was the fact that Deputy Dillon led off that persuaded his colleagues on the front benches to remain silent.

Comment on this

What about the other front benchers?

Comment on this

Are they front benchers? I am sorry I did not know that. I prefer to deal with the more intelligent speeches we heard from the back benchers. Deputy Burke's speech, for example. It was a remarkable example of how an otherwise intelligent mind can be doped by propaganda. I think Deputy Burke has some claim to be regarded as intelligent, but apparently he reads nothing except the official organ of his Party and the propaganda material which the Party organisation distributes from time to time, with the result that he has got a very lopsided view of conditions in the country and of the problems with which this House has got to deal. If that is not the explanation, how otherwise can I account for the fact that Deputy Burke asked a number of foolish questions? These questions were foolish because the answers to the questions are obvious and the answers are not those which Deputy Burke expects to get. He asked could anyone deny that the cost of living here has increased. Of course it can be denied.

Comment on this

Without any trouble.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

It can be denied, all right.

Comment on this

I got sent to me yesterday, and I think every Deputy got sent to him, the quarterly return of the Currency Commission. The Currency Commission of the Saorstát publishes every quarter a statistical bulletin, and the issue for April, 1936, was issued on yesterday. On page 9 of that bulletin is set out the Cost-of-living index, not merely for the months of last year but for the months of the previous year, and for each year back to 1924. There is given the index figure for the cost of living in respect of all items, and another figure for the cost of living in respect of food items alone. In the year 1931—that was the last year during which the Cumann na nGaedheal Party was in office and, in respect to this matter, it was their best year — the Cost-of-living index stood at 160. That was the lowest point reached by the Cost-of-living index during the whole period during which they were in office. In 1930 the index was 177, in the previous year 176, and so on. The lowest point that the Cost-of-living index reached during the ten years that our predecessors were in office was in 1931, and the figure then was 160. The figure for last year was 156. The cost of living, according to the statistical returns prepared by the Department of Industry and Commerce and published by the Currency Commission, was four points lower in 1935 than in 1931. If we leave out the items that are not food items—rents, rates, the cost of clothing, the cost of fuel, and other materials that come into the calculation of the cost of living of the average family—and take the food items alone, we find that the fall was greater still. The Cost-of-living index for 1931 for food items only was 147, and in 1935 it had fallen to 140, a drop of seven points during that period. The Deputy went on to ask would anybody deny that the standard of living has gone down. I deny that it has gone down. I say that not merely has the standard of living been maintained, but that it has gone up, and that the real wages that are being earned at the present time in this country are higher by about 13 per cent. than in 1931.

Comment on this

Good man!

Comment on this

That figure is not mine; it was prepared by the statisticians in the service of my Department. An index for real wages can be easily obtained by a simple calculation based on the cost of living index and the actual wage index. That index shows that the value of real wages has been increased by about 13 per cent. since 1931, a fact which has got to be compared with the British real wage index which shows only an increase of 10 per cent. in the same period. I am not giving these figures merely for the purpose of demonstrating to Deputies opposite that they have been wrong in the attitude they have adopted for the last four or five years. That needs no demonstration. I am giving these figures because Deputy Burke asked for them. I am surprised that he asked for them. On the assumption that he is an intelligent man, I can only surmise that he was misled by Cumann na nGaedheal propaganda through not having taken the precaution—the elementary precaution which would suggest itself to any politician—to find out the answers to his questions before he asked them. He said that, while agriculture was thriving five years ago—I want Deputies to mark that—it has since gone down. I say that the volume of agricultural production has gone up, and that there are 10,000 more employed now than in 1931. These figures are published periodically, and they are available to Deputies. Any sensible politician would have examined them; certainly anybody who wished to maintain the reputation for intelligence which Deputy Burke had previously, would have examined them before asking questions about them.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I am sure that the Minister remembers the old saying—"Positive, lie; comparative, damn lie; superlative, statistics."

Comment on this

Very well, we shall drop statistics. I am no more anxious than Deputy Burke to quote statistics. In fact, I am rather afraid to quote statistics in the presence of Deputy Mulcahy, because they go to his head. However, I am prepared to avoid statistics and to deal with the general situation. I want to congratulate the Party opposite on the skill with which they have tried to get out of a difficult position. I do not for a moment pretend to remember all the speeches made by Opposition Deputies on previous Budgets, but I think it cannot be denied that the general tone of their speeches has been the same on almost every Budget since the Government came into office. No Deputy needs a very brilliant memory to recollect the general tone of the speeches we had from the benches opposite on each of these occasions. As prophets of disaster they outrival Job. The Minister for Finance referred to the Book of Lamentations in his statement yesterday, but I would say that the Book of Lamentations was a comic song compared to the speeches we have heard from the benches opposite on every occasion as to the evils that were going to befall this country in consequence of Fianna Fáil policy.

I remember particularly that the former Minister for Agriculture came into the House and gave the actual date on which disaster was to befall us—eight months after 1932. Nothing happened at the end of that period. They indicated then that they might have made a slight error in the reading of the stars, that those who frame their policy by examining the position of the various planets cannot be expected to be so accurate in fixing the actual date of a catastrophe of the nature they foretold. So they prolonged the period for a few months more. The disaster did not happen in 1933, but they came back undismayed in the next year and renewed their dire prophecies. In 1934 they repeated them. It was a question of days in 1934: at any time the general crash was going to take place. Civilisation, as we know it, was going to cease to exist in this country because of the policy of Fianna Fáil. They had to extricate themselves from that position on this occasion. The crash has not happened; on the contrary, every index which economists study for the purpose of ascertaining the condition of any country point to progress in this country. I defy Deputies opposite to find one single index of any general significance which points in the opposite direction.

Comment on this

147,000.

Comment on this

147,000 what? When were 147,000 unemployed?

Comment on this

Before the Minister's Employment Period Order came into effect.

Comment on this

I invite the Deputy to show me, from the published returns of my Department for any single week in this year, the figure of 147,000. I will deal with the 147,000 later, but it is about time that the Deputies opposite began to get the facts straight, because they cannot possibly function as a political Party—they certainly cannot frame a policy—without having the facts right.

Comment on this

On the figures supplied by the Minister's Department.

Comment on this

Without having the facts right. It comes to the same thing. On this occasion the Deputies tried to explain away the failure of their forebodings to come true. They had to take note of the fact that the revenue was buoyant—that the various taxes which were in operation were producing more than they were estimated to produce; that people were spending more upon necessaries and upon luxuries—that they were saving more; that production was increasing and that in every respect the country was making progress; that the national wealth was increasing; that the national income was improving, and that the general standard of living of our people was rising. Every index which is open to us to study points to those conclusions, and so we get the very ingenious explanation that the entire improvement is due to improved conditions in Great Britain. It was an ingenious thought. Deputy McGilligan saved the Party yesterday by stepping into the breach at once with an answer to the question, and with that solution of their problem. The whole explanation of the improved conditions here—the increase in revenue, the rise in the standard of living, and so forth —is because of the improved conditions in Great Britain. But Deputy McGilligan must think that our memory is very bad.

Do the Deputies opposite remember the speeches that were made only last year by Deputy McGilligan in the House, and he did not confine himself to the House because he went outside and made speeches. He even got one speech broadcast by the Athlone radio station. The sole purport of his speeches was to prove that there had been a decline in the yield of income-tax, a decline due, as he said, entirely to the operation of Government policy, and to the fact that that policy was producing results which his Party had foretold in previous years. Every speech that he made on the Budget last year was re-echoed by those sitting on the Front Opposition bench. Every speech that he made outside the House contained a reference to his central theory that the yield of income-tax was declining: that is, that the yield for each unit of taxation was going down, and that a higher tax in 1935 was producing less than a lower tax had produced in previous years. I am not going to contend now that his statement was wrong. It was obviously wrong, but, accepting his argument at its face value, he convinced his Party, if he convinced nobody else, that Government policy was responsible for the situation that he was describing—that the decline in the yield of income tax was due entirely to the ill-effects of that policy. But, if he was right in his argument in 1935, he cannot possibly be right in his argument in 1936. He cannot have it both ways. If, in 1936 it is now obvious that not merely has the yield of income-tax been maintained but that it has improved, there must be an explanation for that. It cannot be entirely attributed to causes outside the control of the Government. The policy of the Government must have had something to do with it.

I know Deputies opposite will not admit that. When things go wrong the Government is to be blamed, and when things go right it is purely an accidental result to which the Government did not contribute. That is their attitude. It is their policy. I have often explained to them before that they have no other policy, and this Budget debate has been as remarkable as all previous discussions of this kind for the absence of any indication of a general policy amongst the Deputies opposite except in one direction. In one respect, we got a tentative indication of their policy yesterday. A number of resolutions were submitted to the Dáil. They were only brought in and circulated to Deputies after the conclusion of the Budget speech. The Deputies opposite had no opportunity of examining them, and, as is usual on such occasions, the discussion on them was purely formal. In fact, all these resolutions, except one, were allowed to go through without a division, and that one was Resolution No. 4 which provides for the imposition of protective duties on a number of industrial commodities which we are making, or propose to make, in this country. Now I ask the House to mark that fact, that the Deputies opposite had no opportunity of reading that Resolution. They did not know what was contained in it; they had not had time to study it, and they could not say of their own knowledge what it contained, nor could they arrive at any conclusion as to whether the proposals in it were good or bad, or likely to assist the development of industry in this country or the reverse. But they voted against it, and that vote must be taken as an indication of their opposition in principle to any atempt to foster industrial development here.

That was the obvious significance of their action and it is capable of no other explanation. If there is any other explanation I will be glad to hear it, but I am quite certain that we will not hear it because, although they publish in their Party's programme—I mean the latest edition of their Party's programme—their intention to continue the industrial policy of the present Government should they ever become a Government—to assist the development of industry by tariffs, quotas and similar measures—nevertheless, they have no intention whatever of ever giving effect to that policy. That particular item was shoved into their Party programme to humbug the electorate. It had no other motive, because on every occasion on which the question of industrial development came forward in this House they indicated an unreasoning opposition to it, an unreasoning opposition such as we had yesterday when, out of all the Budget Resolutions submitted to the House, only one was selected for attack, a long Resolution covering 18 closely-printed pages. As I have said, that Resolution was not circulated until the conclusion of the Budget speech. The Deputies opposite could not have read it. They did not read it, but they decided, in fulfilment of their Party's policy, to oppose every attempt to foster industrial development here, and to vote against it.

That I suppose, is to be expected from the Party opposite because the only thing that we know about their policy is negative. We know there are certain things that they are opposed to. We do not know what they stand for, and we are never likely to find out because they stand for nothing. If any single member of the Party musters sufficient moral courage to enunciate a policy for himself and takes a definite line on any question, then he follows Deputy Belton and Deputy MacDermot over to the benches in which these Deputies now sit. Apparently, an indeterminate attitude on every question of public importance is an essential condition of membership of the conglomeration that sits on the benches opposite.

I also congratulate the Party opposite upon their skill in dealing with figures. When I make that remark, I do not mean that they get the figures right as a rule. In fact, I am congratulating them on the skill with which they avoid getting the figures right. Possibly, some of them have taken the trouble to ascertain the correct position before attempting to deal with those matters in a public debate, but if so, they carefully avoid giving any figure which has even a remote resemblance to that which is correct or to that which is available in any official publication. We have this question of increased taxation. Deputy McGilligan started yesterday by bidding £26,500,000. According to him, since we came into office we have increased taxation by £26,500,000. Deputy O'Higgins thought that was a bit too mild. He thought that he could go one better than that, so he increased it to-day to £10,000,000 a year, making it £50,000,000 altogether. That is not a bad effort. I wonder if any Deputy opposite will beat that? I wonder where they got those figures? I wonder where Deputy McGilligan got his figure? I have searched all the official publications; I have studied the Budget statement in each year since we came into office; I have studied the revenue returns at the end of each year; I have tried every possible device that I could think of. I got all those figures, added them up, subtracted them, divided them, tossed them about on different slips of paper and took them up by chance——

Comment on this

That is what you usually do.

Comment on this

——but by no possible method could I get the figure which Deputy McGilligan referred to.

Comment on this

We set the Minister working anyhow.

Comment on this

I knew that no sensible method of approach could possibly have given me that figure. I was trying to find out how Deputy McGilligan got it. If any Deputy opposite can tell me how he arrived at that figure, I will stop. Can any Deputy opposite tell me how he arrived at it?

Comment on this

By chance!

Comment on this

He thought of a number, he doubled it, he subtracted his first thought, he multiplied by three and divided by two, and there was the figure.

Comment on this

That is your system.

Comment on this

Why do Deputies opposite think that exaggeration of such a figure is going to help their case? I want them to remember that the Budget of this year, despite the amount that is being taken in taxation, whatever it may be, shows that our people are spending more on necessaries, that they are spending more on luxuries, and that they are saving more. There can be no question on any of those matters. There is increased consumption of all the articles that are considered necessary for life. There has been increased consumption of luxuries — tobacco, drink, sugar, motor cars, wireless sets, all the things that you can think of as luxuries upon which people are likely to spend money in any quantity. In addition, they have saved more. The total amount upon deposit in the Post Office Savings Bank and in the Trustee Savings Banks to the credit of depositors is the highest on record. At no time since this State was established was the total amount to the credit of depositors in those institutions as high as it is now.

All that is in spite of the taxation to which Deputies are referring. That means that if their exaggerated figure of increased taxation is correct, then the effect of Fianna Fáil policy in increasing the prosperity of the country has been even greater than we claimed. It can mean nothing else. Obviously, there has been an increase in the national income. Obviously, the various measures which have been adopted to increase production, to increase the wealth of the country and to improve the standard of living of the people have been successful. There can be no other conclusion arrived at from the figures that are available to Deputies. That has been done not merely in spite of but in consequence of the various increases in Governmental expenditure which necessitated an increase of taxation. But the increase in taxation was considerably less for all the years during which we have been in office than one-third of the lowest figure quoted by any Deputy on the benches opposite. Those of them who can do arithmetic can work that out for themselves. We had Deputy McGilligan making his usual case against social services. Now what are social services? There is the provision for aged persons—those who are over 70 years of age, and who are beyond their labours. That service is not a new one. New provisions relating to it were enacted by this Government and involved a considerable increase in the cost of the service. Not merely did we restore what the previous Government, in its zeal for a reduction of taxation, had taken from them with Deputy Morrissey's approval——

Comment on this

I was not in the Party then.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept the Deputy's word, but I must assume that he approved of it because he subsequently identified himself with the Party which carried out the reduction.

Comment on this

That was very clever, but the Minister should not make an inaccurate statement.

Comment on this

If I have caused another split in the Party opposite I am deeply sorry. I appeal to Deputy Morrissey to remain in that Party. It will be better for him, and better for everybody else. However, there was a reduction in the old age pensions——

Comment on this

And £100,000 last year.

Comment on this

There was no reduction last year.

Comment on this

There was.

Comment on this

The Deputy is misinformed.

Comment on this

It was in the Budget.

Comment on this

It was not.

Comment on this

It was like the reduction in the unemployment assistance which was not able to come off.

Comment on this

There was no reduction in it intended.

Comment on this

There was £300,000.

Comment on this

That misrepresentation is played out. The amounts provided in the Statute to be paid to aged persons was reduced by our predecessors and was restored by us.

Comment on this

Not all of it.

Comment on this

Certain additional provisions were also made in relation to old age pensions, and they cost a considerable sum. That is the first of the social services to which I wanted to refer. There is also the provision for housing, which is a necessary social service. It is also a costly one, because with housing costs at their present figure it is necessary to subsidise each house that is built, in order to enable it to be let at a rent which the average working-class family can afford to pay. That service has been enlarged three-fold by this Government, and the cost of it has been increased correspondingly. There is the new service of unemployment assistance, to which the Party opposite are opposed. Does Deputy Morrissey deny that?

Comment on this

Tell us more about it.

Comment on this

I will admit this; I stated once before that the Party opposite were opposed to unemployment assistance, and I was contradicted. I am not being contradicted to-day. I am not being contradicted to-day because the Party opposite cannot contradict me. We have just had a most vehement declaration from Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney — whom I have just been assured is a Front Bench member of that Party —that they are opposed to the unemployment assistance scheme and will be glad to see it abolished.

Comment on this

Why is it necessary?

Comment on this

He asked to have the necessity for it disappear.

Comment on this

That is not what Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney said. I do not think Deputy Mulcahy could have been here when he was speaking.

Comment on this

I was here when he stated the case for unemployment assistance on the Bill.

Comment on this

All these social services are, in our opinion, essential in any civilised State. Any Government that regarded its duty to its people seriously, and that wanted to make adequate provision against unnecessary hardship or destitution, would provide these services on the scale on which we are providing them.

Comment on this

You are boasting of your failure to find work.

Comment on this

But, apparently, the Government's point of view on such matters is different from that of the Party opposite. It was made quite clear by Deputy McGilligan that he regarded these social services as an evil, and he contended that the volume of production within the country was not sufficient to maintain them. Deputies will remember his argument of yesterday. Personally, I could not follow it. I cannot quite see what the volume of production has to do with the level of our social services. When we take money from the taxpayers for the purpose of financing social services, we do not destroy that money. It goes back to the people. It may be that it goes back to different people than those from whom it was taken. I am not denying that. That is the purpose of taxation. There is, in fact, shall I say, a redistribution of the national income, a transfer of purchasing power from one section to another, the taking of something from those who have more than they need in order to assist those who have less than they need, but there is no wastage in the process. I am unable to follow the argument that there must be an increase in the volume of production to enable increased social services to be made possible.

Comment on this

You cannot follow that?

Comment on this

I cannot follow that. As Deputy Dowdall very rightly pointed out, only a short while ago, the money that is distributed or, should I say, redistributed, by the institution of these social services is expended upon the purchase of consumers' goods in this country. It goes back into circulation; it goes back to stimulate production; it goes back to provide employment in production. It possibly is more useful in the matter of stimulating production and employment when spent by the people who are receiving it in consequence of these social services than if it were spent by those from whom it is taken, because, to some extent, at any rate, those from whom it is taken in taxation would be unable to spend it all, and some portion of it would be saved for investment. I do not think any Deputy can deny that. Those who are contributing in income-tax the cost of our social services, if that tax were abolished, would put some part of the total amount remitted to them into their deposit accounts in the banks or into long-term investments of one kind or another. It certainly would not be all expended upon consumers' goods in the year as it is now expended when redistributed through social services to the classes of the community that must spend it on consumers' goods and spend it at once. In any event, there is no wastage, and it is a completely false conception of the financial consequence of that taxation and expenditure to regard the total amount taken from the public as not being available for expenditure in the ordinary way on consumers' goods during the course of the year in which it is, in fact, collected.

Comment on this

Why not take more, then?

Comment on this

Double the unemployment assistance—more and more, and more money.

Comment on this

I am prepared to deal with that argument any time. There is a point at which you must stop.

Comment on this

I am not making that argument.

Comment on this

If they got double the amount, they might save.

Comment on this

There is no wastage, so why not double or treble it?

Comment on this

Because if you take too much from those who contribute the taxation, for the purpose of redistributing that purchasing power to the other sections of the community, you might, in fact, increase unemployment.

Comment on this

More and more money—why should it ever stop? Is that not the theory?

Comment on this

I am going to deal with that argument in a minute also. I am glad the Deputy reminded me, because it is about time that we got down to brass tacks as to what is in fact happening. I want to deal, however, with one other matter that was raised to-day. Quite a number of Deputies opposite misinterpreted certain phrases in the financial statement of the Minister for Finance, for the purpose of representing him as saying that the unemployed were too lazy to work. The Minister for Finance said nothing of the kind. I was rather astonished, however, that certain Deputies opposite should pretend to get indignant about that, and particularly Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, in view of the statement he proceeded to make. The Minister for Finance, said Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, libelled the unemployed. In the tone of voice and with all the eloquence we have come to associate with Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, he shouted at us his indignation that this libel on the unemployed should have been perpetrated and then he proceeded to say that the explanation for the increased yield of the drink duties was that the unemployed, when they drew the meagre amount of unemployment assistance which is being given to them, spent it on drink.

Comment on this

Is that an exact quotation?

Comment on this

I ask any Deputy in the House?

Comment on this

Yes, he said it.

Comment on this

It is an exact quotation. He condemned the Unemployment Assistance Act because it had that effect, and he gave that as explanation for the increased yield of the drink duties. That is a libel on the unemployed, far worse than anything that might be read into the speech of the Minister for Finance by the most malicious mind. In fact, the Minister for Finance said nothing of the kind that Deputies have been attributing to him. It is not true to say that the unemployed are too lazy to work.

Comment on this

Why did he say it?

Comment on this

He did not say it. In fact, it is probable that nobody in an official position is in a better position to form a judgment upon that matter than I am, because it is the function of my Department to administer the Unemployment Assistance Act and to see that nobody gets unemployment assistance who is not qualified in accordance with the terms of that Act. I am quite satisfied that, although there may be people here and there throughout the country getting unemployment assistance who are not entitled to it, in respect of the great body of the unemployed, they are unemployed because they are unable, in present circumstances, to find work suitable for them in the localities in which they reside, or of a nature which their physique enables them to perform. The justification for the various measures which the Government has adopted, and particularly the justification for the Unemployment Assistance Act, is the Government's belief that, to whatever extent unemployment exists, it is a social evil that must be remedied and for which the unemployed themselves are in no way responsible. We regard them as the innocent victims of 10 years of mis-government before 1932 directed from this House, and 100 years of mis-government by an alien Parliament, which left us deficient in economic organisation, with our resources unexplored, and certainly undeveloped, and with our ability to deal with complex modern economic problems definitely impaired.

The existence of unemployment in this country can be attributed to these causes and certainly, the number of persons upon our live register, who are, in the main, genuinely seeking work, are, in our opinion, entitled to look to the State for assistance in finding employment, which private enterprise in industry or agriculture is not at the moment able to make available to them, or, alternatively, to get some assistance, to the limit of the resources we can make available for that purpose, to guard them against destitution; and we are doing that. The whole purpose of this Government and of every member of this Government, and of every member of the Party that brought this Government into existence, is so to reorganise economic conditions here, so to develop the resources of this island and equip it with the means to exploit these resources, that unemployment and all the evils that follow from it may in due course be abolished.

We have had a lot of talk here from time to time about statements we are supposed to have made before we became a Government as to what could be done to abolish unemployment. We had Deputy McGilligan reading advertisements from time to time and we had Deputy Morrissey following suit on a number of occasions. We published one advertisement in which we stated that if we produced all our own requirements in certain specified classes of industrial and agricultural goods, we would increase employment by 82,000——

Comment on this

84,601.

Comment on this

Very good—84,601.

Comment on this

Do not forget the one, anyway.

Comment on this

That is what we said. Let us see, now, how far we are getting in that direction. In my opinion, we are about half-way through our industrial programme. I do not know whether Deputies opposite will agree with me about that, but, in my opinion, in carrying out that programme, we have progressed at least as far as half-way. Half the industries, the establishing of which was consequential upon that policy, have been created, and some progress has been made in the reorganisation of agriculture which we contemplated also. We have progressed about half-way—perhaps a little further—but how far has our anticipation as to the consequences of that policy in increasing employment been borne out? I would say that our anticipations have been more than justified and that, to date, we have in fact created increased employment in excess of what we might have reasonably anticipated from the progress of industrial development already accomplished.

Comment on this

That is what the Minister called "avoiding statistics."

Comment on this

I shall come to statistics in a moment. We never intended, and no Deputy can produce a single quotation to suggest that we did intend, that the work of replacing all the goods set out in that list, which, in 1931, were imported from abroad, by home produced commodities, could be done in a twelve-month.

Comment on this

You said that you could absorb the unemployed in 12 months.

Comment on this

Nobody ever suggested that Fianna Fáil could produce sugar factories, cement factories, hosiery factories and all the other industries that were necessary, over-night by a wave of the hand.

Comment on this

At least, we could have reduced taxation.

Comment on this

As I have said, these things cannot be done over-night. However, we proceeded with our policy, and, as I have said, I think we have got at least half-way. At least half of the industries we planned to establish are now functioning, and the other half will be functioning in a much shorter period than it has taken us to get this far. What is the result? Let us take the number of persons in employment insurable under the Unemployment Insurance Acts. The actual number of these persons might be misleading. In actual numbers, the increase in the number of insurance cards current has been 35,000 as compared between 1931 and 1935. In other words, 85,000 additional people had issued to them cards insuring them under the Unemployment Insurance Acts. I am not contending that all these people are in constant employment. I have said, in fact, that that number is misleading. The actual true index of increased employment would give a figure somewhat below that— how far below, we can judge in a minute.

Comment on this

You said 36,000 last week.

Comment on this

The increase in the number of persons insured under the Acts is 85,000. However, let us take another basis. Let us assume that everybody employed in occupations insurable under these Acts is employed for 52 weeks in the year; that there is no casual employment, no broken time for any class of work, and that all of them are employed for a year. On that basis the increase in employment is 36,000. I shall put it another way. If we take the average number employed in each week in 1931, and compare it with the average number employed in each week in 1935, there has been an increase of 36,000 in that figure. Add to that 36,000, the 10,000 increase in agriculture.

Comment on this

36,000 over three years?

Comment on this

As between 1935 and 1931.

Comment on this

Last week, the Minister gave that figure in relation to three years.

Comment on this

Oh, no. Add to that an increase of 13,000—I am correcting my 10,000 figure — in the number of persons employed in occupations which are not insurable under the Unemployment Insurance Acts but which are insurable under the National Health Insurance Act—in the main, those engaged in agriculture, and I am taking 10,000 as the increase in agriculture because the sale of stamps under the National Health Insurance Act can be checked

Comment on this

Is the Minister sure that these were not employed in agriculture before?

Comment on this

There was an increase of 10,000 in the total number employed in agriculture.

Comment on this

And paid in agriculture?

Comment on this

They were employed either for wages or as small land-holders or the sons of land-holders working on their own land, and it must be remembered that the numbers of the latter class must increase in the future. The activities of the Land Commission, which have been greatly extended, are all directed towards the breaking up of large ranches and splitting them up into small farms to be worked by the owners of these small farms and their families with little or no whole-time hired labour. Therefore, unless the activities of the Land Commission are arrested or reversed, there must be an increase in the number of persons working in agriculture on their own land and a decrease in the number working permanently for wages. There will probably be an increase in the number of persons employed seasonally, but the number employed permanently in agriculture is decreasing, naturally, because of the increase in the number of holdings worked by their own owners and their families.

Comment on this

And because of emigration.

Comment on this

We can point with certainty to a minimum employment of 46,000 in excess of those in employment in 1931.

Comment on this

46,000 in four years.

Comment on this

I will give the Deputy whatever point he wants to make as to how long it has taken to do it. I will admit that we met with difficulties since 1932 that we did not anticipate. The difficulties created by the economic war are obvious, and equally obvious are the difficulties created by the unreasoned opposition of the Party opposite. We assumed that in our plans for increasing employment they would give us, if not all their active support, at least their passive support. We did not anticipate their hostility, and if it were merely passive hostility, it might not have been so bad, but we have got their active and virulent hostility. They have done their best in every way open to them to retard industrial development for no other reason except that they believed that the success of the Government's industrial policy would be detrimental to their political Party interests. That was a very narrow viewpoint, in my opinion, and one that they will find it hard to justify before the people who have been observing it.

Comment on this

A bad workman always quarrels with his tools.

Comment on this

I am not quarreling with the Party opposite on that account. I am not even quarreling with Deputy Belton. I never regarded Deputy Belton as one of my tools.

Comment on this

I am sure you did not.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Opposition did?

Comment on this

These difficulties, plus the larger difficulties created by general world conditions throughout that period, may have retarded the fulfilment of our plans, but they have not arrested their fulfilment. In all the circumstances, I think we can claim credit for having got at least half-way through our programme by this date, and being able to demonstrate to the people that the completion of the programme will have the results that we foretold, the results in employment that we foretold, because the results to date indicate that our calculations were, if anything, on the conservative side. In fact, Deputy Morrissey can take this as certain that whenever there is an election, and there is an advertisement published on behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party, any statement contained therein is an understatement. We always err on the side of conservatism.

Comment on this

You are noted for that.

Comment on this

When you get the whole way through your programme, will you be able to put only another 36,000 into employment? You have put only 36,000 into employment so far.

Comment on this

The Deputy is about 25 per cent. out in his calculation; the number is 46,000.

Comment on this

The Deputy is surely making a mistake; when the Minister gets through with his programme he will have to send to America, because they will not have enough workers here.

Comment on this

Quite so. On the other hand, the population has been increasing, and, under modern conditions, it is necessary to do more than merely replace the imports of 1931. I think it is possible for us to do more. I think we can proceed to improve upon the standard of living of 1931, to increase the requirements of our people, and their ability to satisfy these requirements, and that will involve still further production over and above that necessary to replace the 1931 imports. Deputy Morrissey will remember that the calculation in regard to employment was based on the 1931 position. We hope to improve the standard of living of our people, and make it possible for people to——

Comment on this

To drive motor cars.

Comment on this

——demand and satisfy their demands for goods which, in 1931, they would have regarded as luxuries outside their reach. I think we are succeeding in that direction. We have a very substantial increase in the number of wireless sets in the country; in fact, the number of wireless sets more than doubled in the course of a very short period. There are more motor cars in the country than ever before; there were more bicycles purchased. All the classes of things that people in 1931 regarded as altogether outside their reach, are now being brought within their reach——

Comment on this

By the hire-purchase system?

Comment on this

——because their incomes are increasing, and their conditions generally are improving.

Comment on this

Hire purchase—everything on the Kathleen Mavourneen system.

Comment on this

Was Kathleen Mavourneen never heard of in 1931?

Comment on this

Perhaps it was not so common as now.

Comment on this

I think it was much more common—very definitely so. This attempt to paint the conditions of 1931, as Deputy Burke described them, as representing the most that we can hope for in this country in the way of prosperity and production, is based upon a very foolish conception of political tactics by the Party opposite. We had Deputy Burke talking about agriculture thriving in 1931, and every speech made by Deputies opposite is designed to show that if we could only get back to the conditions of 1931 how much better off we would be. But the people have not forgotten the conditions of 1931. They disliked these conditions so definitely that they put the Government then in office out of office at the first opportunity they got. Despite the nature of the campaign which the then Government tried to organise for the purpose of snatching an electoral victory, the people, in indignation at the conditions which had been created for them by mis-government during a decade, rejected that Government and put us into office early in 1932. I give them this advice as a politician: if they want to get back into office, they have to convince the people that they can do better than in 1931.

Comment on this

That they can bluff better than you did.

Comment on this

Do better than in 1931, whether it is bluff or not; but so long as you make 1931 your standard, the most you can rise to and the people can hope for, so long are you going to sit in diminishing numbers on the benches opposite. The Budget which has been introduced is an indication of the strength of the national position, an indication of the country's ability to weather the storms to which it has been subjected during the past few years, both the storm of depression which brought down much stronger countries than ours, as well as the artificial hurricane which the British Government created on the advice of certain Deputies now sitting on the benches opposite. We have weathered these storms and come out with a stronger economic system than we had before. We have come out with the resources of the nation investigated, with its capital equipment enlarged, with its ability to deal with its resources improved, with its people being trained in the technical processes of new industries, with our national production of wealth annually increasing, with our national economy gradually attaining the balanced position that we had contemplated originally and which we regard as most conducive to preserve the well-being of our people, irrespective of the changes which might take place from time to time in world conditions.

Comment on this

Prove that.

Comment on this

I spent the last one and a half hours trying to prove it, and I refuse to start on it again.

Comment on this

The Minister has claimed a lot of things. Why not prove them now?

Comment on this

I despair of making the Deputy understand anything.

Comment on this

I understand quite well what you have done and I will tell you to-morrow what you have done. You say that the national position is strengthened?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Then get at it and prove it.

Comment on this

Every figure given by the Minister for Finance yesterday, and every figure available, published by any organisation, an official organisation or a banking or trading organisation, proves it.

Comment on this

Go over the national balance sheet.

Comment on this

The figures all point in the same direction. I will go over any set of figures that can be suggested to me. We have, for instance, the Dublin banks' clearances of bills, notes and cheques and, I am sure, Deputy Belton will agree that that is a fair index of commercial activity. I find there that the weekly average for the first 12 weeks of this year was considerably in excess of the weekly average for a similar period in previous years. I find, for the first time since 1925, that the volume of traffic passing over the railways has increased, and the receipts of the railways company from that traffic have increased. I find that the volume of production both in agriculture and industry is higher. I find that employment is increasing rapidly. I will give as an example of increased employment the position in the boot and shoe industry. In the discussion on my Estimate three weeks ago, I said the number of persons employed in that industry was 4,500. That was the figure for a date in March. I now give the figure as 4,900; that is the return received for April. That shows an increase of 400 in one industry in the space of one month. What is happening there is typical of what is happening in other industries. Taxation at standard rates is yielding an increased revenue. I give you the fact that the volume of savings in our savings banks is increasing. Is there any other index that the Deputy would ask for?

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to explain the figures in pages 15 and 16 of the Minister's speech yesterday, and show how he proves his argument by them or proves them to be correct?

Comment on this

The Deputy can take them certainly as correct. There is no possible source of information to which any economist or any Deputy —and I make no distinction between the two — could go for knowledge concerning our national position that does not point to the conclusion that our national economy has been strengthened and that we are progressing towards greater prosperity every day. We have not yet got to the position we set out to reach and to which we hope to get. We have a number of problems to solve and there are a number of difficulties to be surmounted, but the progress we have made up to now, by pursuing the policy of the Government, the policy which the people of this country have repeatedly endorsed, has been so considerable as to justify us in being optimistic that we will overcome those difficulties and get to the position at which we aimed when we took over the government of this country. In this perhaps we may yet satisfy Deputy Belton.

Comment on this

Would the Minister explain the position in regard to the Local Loans Fund? Would he explain further how he takes credit for the £12,841,195 mentioned yesterday by the Minister for Finance?

Comment on this

Is not Deputy Belton going to speak for three hours to-morrow on that matter? He might spend half an hour now in reading the Budget speech and digesting it. He would there get all the information he is looking for.

Comment on this

How does the Minister take credit for that item?

Comment on this

What conclusion does Deputy Belton draw from that?

Comment on this

That the local authorities have to pay for the services which the National Exchequer is not paying for.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

These interruptions will have to stop.

Comment on this

For the second time our friend, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, has taken the advice of the future ex-Minister for Lands, Senator Connolly, and has determined to adopt the attitude of the bold buccaneer in this House. I think the phrase is a phrase of his colleague and fits him. But he does that merely by shouting and reiterating the many statements he has made so frequently in this House and from the method which he himself described, we now see how he gets his figures—by juggling about with pieces of paper. He thinks he will be able to prove that the position of this country at the moment is satisfactory. But if he will not have great difficulty in proving it to the satisfaction of his own Party or the Labour Party, he will have great difficulty in proving to the satisfaction of the people of this country. There is one purely minor matter I must deal with, and I do not see why the Minister went out of his way trying to draw attention to it. I am compelled by him to deal with that matter. It is in connection with the statement made by his colleague in page 41 of his typescript on the Budget speech. This was not a speech but a most carefully prepared statement. I take it that those couple of sentences were deliberately put in and with full advertence to their being put in. What do they mean? Is it suggested that this was an isolated instance? Is that the contention? It is surprising that from the two Ministers who are so much in the habit of interrupting there is now such a great silence.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy make his speech without any spoon feeding from us.

Comment on this

This is the first time I have made a speech without interruption from the two Ministers present. I am glad to secure from the Minister the statement that he is not going to interrupt me. This incident to which I want to refer was put into the Budget speech because it was regarded by the Minister as a typical state of affairs. If that was not the Minister's purpose there was no justification for his making the statement. The statement was in reference to difficulties that some people possibly did not imagine had existed—and that was to provide labour of a suitable kind. He spoke of a relief scheme and conveyed the impression that labour of a suitable kind was not available. Then he went on:

"This latter desideratum, contrary to the prevailing belief, is not going to be the easiest element to provide. I have had before me recently one instance in which an essential and useful public work has been held up because of the fact that of 73 recipients of unemployment assistance who were detailed by the employment exchange for the work, only nine turned up on the job. Some of the remainder thought the walk was too far for them."

Now, why was that statement put in if it was merely one instance? If that was merely one instance and if it was the only evidence he had, he had no justification whatever in wasting the half page of this particular typescript in putting in a statement of that kind.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy on an economy campaign now?

Comment on this

No, I am not. But I want to know what the Minister meant by putting it in?

Comment on this

It is there.

Comment on this

It is, but the Minister wishes it were not. Then he adds:

"The incident would indicate that there are some people on the unemployment register who are not so badly in need of work or so desirous of obtaining work as to be entitled to be paid unemployment assistance."

It was not, apparently, an isolated instance in the mind of the Minister because he begins to draw a general conclusion from it. I cannot understand the heat shown by his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in objecting to the use that is being made of that statement in this House. The Minister for Industry and Commerce certainly gave an advertisement to it that otherwise possibly that statement would not have got. It will be for the Minister to explain why the statement is there and what it means. There were a number of other statements made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that must have come as a surprise, even to Members of this House. What are we to think of a Minister for Industry and Commerce who commits himself to the statement that he could not see any connection between the volume of productive work and the size of the social services? Is there not an obvious connection? One of the social services mentioned is the provision made for unemployment benefit. Various money is paid out in different ways to people who are out of employment. Is it not obvious that if you have employment enough to absorb all the people who are looking for work a number of social services can be got rid of? That the Minister for Industry and Commerce should stand up here and tell us he sees no connection between the volume of productive work and the size of the social services surprises me. It surprises people who are not easily surprised at any statement coming from that particular Minister. The charge is that despite the promises made by the Fianna Fáil Party and despite the boasts of the Minister, we have the fact brought out that their only method, up to the present, of dealing with the main bulk of unemployment is either the dole on the one hand, which I think they call a social service and the connection between which and employment or unemployment the Minister cannot see, and on the other hand work on the roads, not work of a productive character.

Comment on this

Nor on the bogs either?

Comment on this

I am referring to the Minister's statement and not dealing with Deputy Victory. Surely there is a connection and it is very relevant to draw attention to the fact that social services have to be provided on the scale at which they are provided because of the lamentable failure of the Government to carry out their policy. We have mock indignation on the part of the Minister for Industry and Commerce when his attention was drawn to that fact from these Benches. Is not that the outstanding feature in the provisions made by previous Budgets and by this Budget when they are up against the problem of unemployment? The Minister went on, strange to say, to the other side of the problem, pointing out that the provision of maintenance for the unemployed is necessary. That was not the point raised. The point raised is that there should be employment. If the Government's boasts were true, and if they had any return to show for the extra millions of money which they have spent, it would not be necessary to provide these social services on the scale provided in this and previous Budgets.

The Minister went on to argue that at least these social services meant no national loss, that they meant taking the money out of the pocket of Peter and putting it into the pocket of Paul. He argued that, in reality, that meant that there was more money spent in the country in this way: "Peter is a man who has a large amount of money and who cannot spend all of it; we take a certain amount from him and give it to Paul, who has not much, and who will spend it; the result is more money spent." I am not questioning the value of that argument. Remember, that was stressed as being one of the principal tasks of the Government —the policy of the redistribution of wealth, a redistribution carried out irrespective of whether there is an increase or a decrease in the national wealth of the country.

What follows from the argument of the Minister that we have just listened to? That you can have more spending capacity in this country without any increase in wealth! The Minister's whole argument for at least a quarter of an hour was to prove that point, and that is the explanation of the Budget figures being high—not an increase in the national wealth as a whole, but a different distribution of wealth, so that there is more money spent because more people are spending it. There is no increase of national wealth, but a redistribution; as the Minister himself says, taking it from the man who cannot spend all he has and giving it to the man who has nothing and who, therefore, will spend and must spend whatever he will get. That is the explanation of the fact to which the Minister has pointed with so much pride and to which the Minister for Finance drew attention several times in the course of his Budget statement, namely, that merely as a result of the policy of redistribution, not, be it noted, of increasing the national wealth, not of greater productivity in the country as a whole, there is more spent—for the moment. No wonder the tobacco duties, the beer duties, and other duties are in the ascendent because, as the Minister pointed out, without any increase in national wealth there will be more money spent. That is precisely what both Ministers overlook. It was all right as an argument for the Minister to use against the Deputies on this side but it must be turned against the boosting of the results of their industrial and strange to say their agricultural policy—it nullifies the argument that their agricultural policy is so successful the people have more money to spend. It is difficult to believe that a Minister, even one living in Dublin, can speak like the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Can they be so ignorant of the conditions of the country to suggest that the result of their agricultural policy is that the farmers have more money to spend? I will take that very sentence in the first page of the Minister's statement yesterday as quite typical of the recklessness with which statements are made in this Budget and the value of the arguments used:

"But when every allowance is made for that and other circumstances there still remains the fact that the buoyancy of the revenue has been so remarkable and so general that some part of the economic recovery which it indicates must be ascribed to the new agricultural and industrial policies which under the leadership of the present Government our people have adopted."

Leaving aside altogether for the moment all the claims made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce let us take the first of the two industries mentioned by the Minister for Finance. What is the claim? The claim is that the Budget returns are higher because agriculture is in a better condition as a result of the policy of the Government. Is there a single Deputy, even on the opposite side of the House, representing a country constituency—most of the country constituencies anyhow—who holds that the farmers have more money to spend as the result of the improvement of the agricultural industry? Yet it is on arguments of that kind that the Minister bases not merely the rosy account he gave of the Government's finance but of the general condition of the country which he says was reflected in these finances. Anybody who knows the condition of the farmer at present could not possibly think that the Minister was serious in suggesting that it was as a result of the increased prosperity of the agricultural industry that more money was paid in taxes—that the farmers were better able to provide money in taxes direct and indirect. Yet we have that statement in the very front page of the Minister's pronouncement yesterday; that some part of that must be attributed to the increased prosperity of the agricultural industry.

Comment on this

A very modest claim.

Comment on this

Yes, for the Minister, most modest, but most untrue and unfounded. I am quite satisfied that the country will judge the other claims made by the Minister and his colleagues on the value of that particular claim. If the Minister is ready to put all his other claims, which are quite as unfounded, on that particular basis and if he is satisfied we are satisfied with him. We were all given to understand that the Minister had a policy. I myself heard, in this house, a period of eight months mentioned by the Minister's colleague as the period in which the success of his policy would be demonstrated beyond yea or nay. Eight months after the first Budget was introduced by the present Minister for Finance and was co-operated in by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. What is the result? Figures of which the Minister himself can give no accurate interpretation. He mentioned 36,000 extra in employment. He did not suggest what was continually suggested by those Ministers when in opposition, and in the opening period of their office at least 36,000 were in what I might call reproductive industries. I have explained before in this House that housing is a very necessary provision, whether it is undertaken or helped by the central Government or by the people who get very little credit for what they do, namely, the local authorities.

I move to report progress.

Comment on this