Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolutions—Resolution No. 14—(General) (Resumed)
Contributions 147–324 of 324. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The Minister used the words "no matter how much we might deplore it." I hope I am not misquoting the Minister, but I think the spirit of his remarks was that he deplored the consumption of drink in the country.
Comment on this
Well, I am sorry if I am. The Irish Press also refers to the same matter and says: “while, from the temperance point of view, the increase in the consumption of alcoholic liquors may be deplored”—am I right?
Comment on this
I just wanted to show that there has been a wonderful decrease in the convictions for drunkenness. There has been a fall in convictions for drunkenness from 6,951 in 1924 to 3,289 in 1935. So that the country is very sober and the people very self-respecting and keeping their self-control. I should like to direct the Minister's attention to another aspect of this matter, and that is in connection with the barley trade. There was a time when 40,000 acres of barley were consumed in this country in the manufacture of spirits and beer, and that acreage has fallen by one-half. I suggest that the Minister should direct the attention of his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, to that fact in connection with his tillage scheme, because I think it goes to show that all things in connection with this drink question are not the iniquitous things we are led sometimes to believe. Perhaps the Minister did not see the full significance of using the word "deplore" in this connection, but when I saw it in the Irish Press—and I read it every day; not like some of our friends—I thought it was very deliberate.
Now, in connection with this big national scheme for the relief of unemployment, I think that we on this side of the House can congratulate the Minister on his efforts in this direction, and if they are going to be successful, I think we shall be prepared to wish him all the good luck in the world. At the same time, I do not think that he can take very much credit out of his Budget with regard to the amount of money which the Government itself is putting into this scheme. That is all I have to say.
Comment on this
I do not intend to say much on this motion. It is, however, an important fact that revenue has increased and that more money is being spent on items other than the necessaries of life. Notwithstanding all this, we have to sit here and listen to the doleful lamentations of the Deputies opposite telling us of the terrible conditions that exist in the country. They still persist in proclaiming that bankruptcy is at our door. Well, nobody can deny the fact that relief, at least to some extent, is given to the taxpayer in this Budget, while at the same time provision for social services has been increased. It is rather hard, for farmer Deputies at least, to sit here and listen to the statements of the Opposition telling us about the terrible condition of affairs, as far as the agricultural community is concerned especially, when we know full well, as also do the people down the country know full well, that the only concern of the gentlemen opposite for that section of the community is to make as much political capital as they possibly can out of any difficulties that that section of the community might have to contend with.
Deputy O'Sullivan, I think, in the course of his remarks yesterday, said that in his opinion, judging from the statements of Ministers here, he thought that they must be completely out of touch with conditions in the country. I do not at all agree with him on that. Our Ministers, I believe, are closely in touch with conditions in the country. Now, we of the rank and file are surely in close touch with conditions in the country, and I, for one, claim that there is a vast improvement in conditions generally in the country —a vast improvement. That improvement should be clearly indicated to everybody by the increase in revenue, by the increase in the amount of money in circulation generally, by the improvement in the annuity payments, and by the improvement in the collection of rates up and down the country.
Deputy Morrissey, from Tipperary, in the course of his remarks yesterday, repeated the statement that agricultural workers in Tipperary were being paid at the rate of 5/- per week with board. Now I wish to take this opportunity of refuting that statement. It is not true, and I think it is very unbecoming of that Deputy to come here and cast such a reflection upon the county that sent him here. It has also been stated that there is less employment in the rural districts. Well, I do not know so much about that. I have no figures either to confirm that statement or to disprove it, but I know this much: that certain employees, in my county at least, were disemployed by the supporters of the Party opposite simply because they refused to attire themselves in blue shirts or to allow themselves to be led like sheep into the polling booths to support the Party opposite. That is the only reason I could give for the decrease in the employment of agricultural workers.
Many of the Deputies opposite, in the course of their remarks, laid stress on the conditions that obtained here in 1931, and they more or less laid down that as a standard. Well, I think that nobody on this side of the House or, I think, very few down the country, would be satisfied with the 1931 standard. Surely, it was not because the people were satisfied with the standard of living that obtained then, and the conditions that existed then, that they decided just at that time to dispense once and for ever with the Government that were responsible for that condition of affairs. Deputies opposite made great play about the unemployment problem and the attempts made by the Government to solve it. They contended that if an honest endeavour were made, they are prepared to assist the Government in every way they can. I believe it is a problem which will not and cannot be easily solved, but nobody can deny that great strides have been made during the reign of this Government to relieve that situation and very little has been done by the gentlemen opposite to assist us.
Deputy Morrissey referred to a statement which he attributed to the Minister for Industry and Commerce —that he said some years ago that workers would have to be brought home from foreign countries to cope with the amount of employment available here. While not claiming that the unemployment problem has been solved, I certainly wish to claim that a good deal has been done for the relief of unemployment, and workers are being employed who were on the unemployed list a few years ago. It is also a fact, and I wonder will Deputy Morrissey deny it, that in the county from which we both happen to come there are workers who were in the bread lines in foreign cities a few years ago back home and in employment. I do not wish to detain the House much longer. I think the situation is bad enough without trying to make it worse and, while not claiming that things are as good as we would like to have them, I believe that, in fairness, credit should be given for what has been done. It will not improve matters to paint a picture such as the Opposition have been painting for the past couple of days.
Comment on this
I do not wish to detain the House, but I cannot let this occasion pass without saying that, after four years of Fianna Fáil administration, the Minister for Finance should be in a position to give us something better than he has given in the Budget. A farthing off the price of a pound of sugar is the principal item. That will be a profound disappointment to farmers and labourers all over the country. After all, it is only just taking off what you put on last year. In Northern Ireland the price of sugar to-day is 2d. a pound; here in the Free State it is 3¾d.
Comment on this
I will give you that information later. I think the Minister should have made some effort to reduce the price of flour and give some definite relief to the poor of the country in that respect. Flour in Northern Ireland and England at present, straight-run flour, is 26/- a sack; in the Free State it is 42/-. We always heard, so far as England is concerned, that it was the wealthiest country in the world. The Free State is a poor country. How can we afford to pay almost double what the richest country in the world is paying for flour? There must be something wrong.
I listened with great attention last night to the Minister for Industry and Commerce when he was telling us about the 46,000 workers he put into employment. He almost led me to believe that there was nobody out of work in the Free State. When we look at the number of persons on the dole it is a different proposition. I have here a list of the number of men employed on relief works on roads in County Mayo. In December, 1932, there were 3,105 men; in 1933 we had 269—that is, after a year of Fianna Fáil administration; in 1934 there were 444 men employed, and in 1935 there were 467. The total number employed on relief works in 1932 in that county was 15,363; in 1935, the last year for which we have returns, there were 4,032. That indicates there were 11,000 less employed last year than in 1932.
I think the Minister should make some effort to give relief to the farmers with regard to Local Loans. The Local Loans and the R.I.C. pensions, which are withheld by this Government, have to be paid through the tariffs on cattle; it has all to come out of the pockets of the farmers. If the farmers were left as they were some years ago, all they would have to pay would be their annuities, and these would amount altogether to about £3,000,000 a year. Instead of £3,000,000, they now have to pay £7,000,000—£3,000,000 in annuities to the British Government, together with Local Loans and R.I.C. pensions, which bring the amount to £5,000,000, and then they have to pay 50 per cent. of their annuities to the present Government. In all, it brings the farmers' annuities and so forth to £7,000,000. I am afraid, from what I can see in the West, that the farmers are practically on the verge of bankruptcy. Their standard of living has been cut down almost to nil, and the position is that they cannot stand out very much longer.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce told us he had a great number of people employed, and he mentioned the wonderful factories he has established. Where they are I do not know. There may be some, but there is none in the West; there are very few in Connaught, anyway. I do not suppose there are 100 people employed in Connaught in all the new factories mentioned by the Minister, if there were any set up there. As regards County Mayo, I know there is one thread factory in Westport, which gives employment to 30 or 40 girls, I understand.
We also heard from the Government Benches about the great prosperity all over the country. I have here the statement by the Minister for Finance with regard to Savings Banks, and what he says would not indicate that we are very prosperous. The Minister said:—
"I have no doubt whatever that were we to make the yield on Certificates slightly more attractive we could considerably increase our borrowings under this head. But for reasons with which I do not wish at this stage to burden the House, I do not consider it advisable to do so."
—I can readily understand why he did not consider it advisable to do so—
"I shall merely say that of set policy I have so regulated the rate of interest upon our Savings Certificates as to keep our liabilities in regard to them within modest and reasonable limits. It is therefore not a matter of concern to me, nor need it be to others, that the amount paid out of the Exchequer last year in respect of the principal of Savings Certificates exceeds by £28,000 the amount paid in."
I do not see where the thrift comes in when £28,000 more was paid out than the actual deposits received in the Savings Banks. That is no indication of prosperity.
Comment on this
There is another matter upon which I would like the Minister to give us some light. It has reference to a sum of £360,000 for the repayment of the Dáil External Loan. There is a sum of £4,000 for something else, but I would like him to tell us about that Dáil External Loan. Why is it necessary to keep up this office with a staff in New York for the purpose of receiving money from this country for the payment of these shareholders? Would the Minister tell us how much of that money is coming back to this country and who in this country is to get it? Who are the principal shareholders or stockholders here?
Comment on this
Surely the expenses of an office in America is a matter of administration. It does not arise now.
Comment on this
I only ask the question of the Minister to give him an opportunity of giving an explanation as to this £360,000 which he is asking this House for that purpose. I understand that last year there was a Stamp Duty Act passed, or that at least the Minister for Finance was empowered to demand that stamps be affixed to various documents. Now I want to tell the House that in the County of Mayo alone this is going to cost the county council a sum of £2,800 a year. Receipts for rates have to bear a stamp. Every tender form for a road, even a tender amounting to only 30/- or £2 must bear a 10/- stamp. I submit that the Minister for Finance should do something to relieve the county councils in respect of that duty.
With regard to Housing, I know that a great deal of money has been spent all over the country. We are all glad to see that the complexion of the country is changing. That work was started during the Cosgrave régime. The present Government have done a great deal also in the matter of housing. There is one matter to which I would like to refer with regard to the amount of money which is wilfully wasted on the building of these houses——
Comment on this
Well, then I will not refer to it. On the subject of defaulting annuitants I wish to point out that the county councils have had to pay considerable amounts under this head. I think some relief should be given by the Minister to the county councils in this matter of defaulting annuitants. After four years' administration by the present Government, I think this Budget is nothing about which the Government should go into ecstasies. We expected a better Budget after the £13,000,000 or the £14,000,000 that the Government have spent in excess of what their predecessors spent. That is all I have to say.
Comment on this
It is with a certain amount of diffidence I rise to say a few words on this Budget. After the homely advice we have got from certain Deputies on the Government Benches—advice mixed with a threat —that we, the members of the Opposition, should not waste the time of the House in unduly criticising the Budget presented by the Minister for Finance, one is forced to recall what happened in other days. When I remember the attitude of the present Government when they were in Opposition, the advice now of the back-benchers reminds me of the old saying about Satan rebuking sin. When in Opposition, the Fianna Fáil Party wasted weeks and months in saying the same thing day after day. Though it may be displeasing to certain members of the Fianna Fáil Party, I think it my duty, as a member of the House, to say a few words on what is, after all, the most important discussion that can take place in this House in the course of the year. Might I say that I rise with no spirit of vindictiveness or ill-feeling against anybody? I only just want to put before the House my views.
On the first page of the Budget, according to the figures given, the Minister expressed himself as being very happy in the knowledge of the fact that revenue in the past year has exceeded income or that the estimated income has been exceeded by well over £1,000,000. That, of course, is a matter on which the Minister can congratulate himself. I think he estimated for something like £29,000,000, while the actual revenue was £30,601,000. The expenditure was £31,106,140. Subtracting one from the other, we get a deficit of £500,000, but by various devices of additions and subtractions the Minister in the long run makes out that he has got a surplus of £1,092,000. The manner in which he arrives at that figure is as follows: he takes the sum of £461,000 expended in the erection of alcohol factories, afforestation, and the repayment of the Dáil Eireann External Loan. Naturally these are items which, I believe, after all can be met by borrowing. The Minister is entitled to do that. But when it comes to the question of the £2,000,000 which he pays in subsidies and bounties, he proposes to meet half of that by borrowing. I submit that in doing that he is not on safe ground. It might very well be that these £2,000,000 could be used to give some relief which he himself when in Opposition promised to the farmers. He promised them derating, a thing of which we hear very little lately, notably from the back benchers of the Fianna Fáil Party, who are silent on this matter. When in Opposition, the Minister stated that unless they were given derating the position of the farmers would be very bad. I notice to-day that during this discussion the Government Benches are empty. There is not a word about the position of the farming community at the present time, though the members of the Government Party waxed eloquent when in Opposition about the woes and sufferings of the farmers. I remember that the Minister for Finance himself made a very deep impression upon me by advocating derating in the years when he was in Opposition.
Comment on this
Yes. He told the then Minister for Finance how savings could be effected, and how in this way relief could be given to the farmers.
Comment on this
It is this way. Somehow when I read a thing I have a fairly good memory; I can give nearly every word of what was said. Now, in one word, does the Minister deny that his Party stood for derating—that will simplify the matter?
Comment on this
I am asking a straight answer to a straight question. We need not bother about the quotation. Does the Minister deny that when in Opposition his Party was out for derating?
Comment on this
Well, the Minister more or less disbelieves my statement, and I am simply asking him a straight question—did he, when in Opposition, stand for derating?
Comment on this
The concern of the Chair is that the Deputy should relate what any Party did years ago to this discussion.
Comment on this
I am speaking about the £2,000,000 paid in bounties and subsidies which can be met by borrowing. This could meet the cost of derating which had been advocated by the Minister for Finance when in Opposition and which he is not advocating to-day when he is in a position to give effect to his advocacy of it. I just wanted to make the analogy. As regards this whole question of taxation and the capacity of the people to pay, it seems to me, from the speeches delivered by the members of the Government during the past year, the previous two or three years, and when they were in Opposition, that taxation, however high does not matter so long as it is being spent on the people. In other words, there is no difference whether the amount raised by taxation is £30,000,000, £40,000,000, £50,000,000, or £60,000,000. Accepting that theory, and arguing the thing logically, I suggest to the Minister that instead of raising £30,000,000 this year he should have raised £60,000,000, thereby increasing old age pensions to £1 per week, the weekly rate of unemployment benefit to 30/-, and so on. That seemed to be the argument propounded by the members of the Government and also by the members of the Labour Party— that taxation is all right no matter how high it is, so long as it is being used on such things as social services.
I think that idea has been somewhat dispelled from the minds of the Party, judging from the words used by the Minister for Finance on the last page of his Budget statement, words which, in my humble opinion, should be printed in letters of gold and posted at every cross-roads all over this State. They are as follows:—
"We have not resorted to the nostrums and panaceas which are held out so often as easy ways to encompass a most difficult thing: the provision of a frugal sufficiency for everyone's needs...."
I am glad he put in that word "frugal." It makes all the difference in the world. Having regard to the nice, flowery speeches that used to be made by the members of the Fianna Fáil Party and Labour Party about a good, high standard of living, the word "frugal" is a very significant one.
"...It has been done as the phrase has it, `Within the System.' We have those among us who advocate Communism, State Socialism, Totalitarianism. To me these are but aspects of the one tyrannv, and as they are all repugnant to the essence of human liberty, the freedom of the mind and of the conscience, I hate and abhor them all."
These are words with which I thoroughly agree, for the reason that experience seems to have taught the Minister a great deal since he assumed responsibility. I welcome these words for the reason that at long last the Government, through their Minister for Finance, have got away from the idea that high taxation is not inimical to the best interests of this or any other country. Really, that seemed to run through all the speeches delivered by the members of that Party, and it was backed up to the extent of 100 per cent. by the members of the Labour Party. I am glad that the Minister for Finance has given a very hard knock to the policy of State Socialism, as advocated by the Labour Party. He says of State Socialism, Communism. and all the other "isms" that he hates them all—that they are all the same, that they are all the children of the one tyranny. These are great words. I congratulate the Minister on having the moral courage to use these words, because they, give great hope for the future of this country, and disclose a change of mind and a change of policy on the part of those who at present occupy the Government benches.
Certain statements were also made here by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who by the way, might be termed the little man with the big voice. He might be termed the shock Minister of the Fianna Fáil Party who tries to frighten everybody by speak ing as loud as he can. Of course when they cannot succeed in that way, they get Deputy Kehoe to act the part of the court jester.
Comment on this
Then I will say that Deputy Kehoe would introduce the note of levity into the discussion. The Minister for Industry and Commerce tried last night to snow under the Opposition by talking as loud as he could. He made certain statements which, in my opinion, would go to show that he has given very little study to the conditions, existing in this country at present. For instance, he stated that the cost of living has not increased. He also stated that unemployment is well on the way of being settled—that were it not for the criticism and the hindrance of the Opposition, the Government would be well on the way of having all these things satisfactorily settled. Anybody who gives any study to the matter knows that at the present time there are large numbers of people unemployed. The Minister last night disputed the numbers. He stated that we were not to take the official figures as representing the number of unemployed. He gave as a reason that, owing to the facilities offered by the Government in the matter of registration, those who did not register previously now have the opportunity of doing so.
In regard to that I must say that I never could understand at the time, nor do I understand now, why the Minister introduced the question of registration when he was not in a position to stand behind it. After all, when the number registered is returned at 140,000, it is no excuse for the Minister to state "That number is not correct, because we have given an opportunity to thousands of people who were denied the opportunity before of registering themselves as unemployed." The fact is, at any rate, that there are many thousands of people at the present time unemployed. While giving credit to the Government for the employment which they have undoubtedly created, I would say that they are taking the gross result of their policy. They forget that there is such a thing as the net result. They have to subtract from the gross the number of people who have been put out of employment by their policy. In that way you will get the exact number which the Government have put into employment.
For instance, when the wheat policy was about to be put into operation, it was stated here that if we grew all the wheat we required it would provide employment for an extra 40,000 people. And the way he arrived at that was by a simple sum just as a schoolmaster would arrive at a result of a sum worked out on a blackboard. He assumed that for every 20 acres extra grown there would be an extra man employed; 2,000 acres would mean employment for 100 men, and so on, until we get to 800,000 acres, which he worked out would give employment to 40,000 men. But anyone who knows anything about the matter knows that many acres of wheat could be grown without any extra employment being given. I am not a farmer but I know sufficient about this matter to know that 99 per cent. of the farmers, with average holdings of 20 acres could, without any additional help whatever, sow a couple of extra acres of barley or wheat or oats. It does not follow that if the whole 800,000 acres were grown that it would give employment to the numbers mentioned by the Minister for Defence, some years ago, when he spoke upon this question.
One does not like, having got such homely advice from the Government, to criticise them unduly. We know their failure to solve the unemployment question. I know it is almost impossible of solution, and I am prepared to make allowances. But what I object to is that, notwithstanding the fact that many members of the Government have stated that it is a thing that cannot be solved overnight yet, when they were attending crossroad meetings of the Fianna Fáil Party in the country they declared that they would solve it. On the occasion of the last general election they declared that they would solve the unemployment question if returned to power. Should there be another general election to-morrow they would have the hardihood to get up and state again that, if they were returned to power, they would solve the unemployment question. I feel very strongly upon this because, at the first election in 1927, at which I was a candidate, I said, from every public platform, that no Government could solve the unemployment question. I went further, and said it was not the duty of the Government to solve the unemployment question, because the moment a Government tried to solve the unemployment situation the more unemployment they would create. After seven or eight years of promises of this kind what do we find to-day? We find the Minister for Finance taking £1,150,000 in his Budget for the relief of unemployment, which proves that my philosophy was correct. My statement was true in 1927, and it is true to-day, that the Government cannot solve the problem. They can by legislation help private enterprise and thrift, and they could do more, in that direction, to solve the unemployment question than all the doles and all the moneys that can be voted by this or any other Government. That has been proved in the United States of America. President Roosevelt started, with a great flourish of trumpets, to solve the unemployment question in the States. But the Minister for Finance and his Government were lured on by the Labour Party here to embark on wild-cat schemes that lowered the dignity and honour of Labour, and refused to take the advice of a man like myself who knows more about Labour than any member of the Party opposite. I am proud to state here to-night what I stated in 1927, and my words have been prophetic. We must have private enterprise and personal thrift, says the Minister.
Again, in a speech delivered by the Minister for Industry and Commerce on this question of unemployment, he said he had already succeeded in placing in employment well over 36,000 extra hands, and that we were only half through. I do not say that that is not correct, but I do say that when he is through with the other half there will be very little left of the first half in employment. According to his own figures there are 140,000 persons unemployed. When he gets to the end of the other half of that number there will be 250,000 idle. I would suggest to the Minister for Industry and Commerce—and I am sorry he is not here—to read something that answers his remarks very effectively. I think his speeches on this matter of unemployment would be more becoming if delivered at cross-roads meetings, and perhaps very stormy meetings. His speeches on this subject would be more becoming if delivered at such places rather than in an assembly such as this. I commend these words which I am about to read to him. Lecturing on "The Crisis of Intelligence" on Wednesday, Father A. Little, S.J., said:
"The world, in spite of its increase in knowledge, was finding itself more and more unable to solve its social, political, scientific and other problems, and was consequently becoming more and more disordered. That inability was attributable to the fact that philosophical knowledge had ceased to be current among experts and leaders of the various activities"—including, I presume, political activities. "Hence, they were ignorant of the absolute and necessary laws known by philosophy that must be respected if any policy was to be ultimately successful. Those ignorant of such laws were disqualified from foreseeing the ultimate consequences of their plans, and must have recourse to experimentation to find out the solution of any problem. But experimentation could only show the inadequacy of a given means to a desired end at the cost of failure often disastrous."
I think that that answers the speech delivered by the Minister for Industry and Commerce last night. I recommend him to study it, because most of his experiments, to use his own words, have been disastrous. He said that he would solve the unemployment problem within practically 12 months. He finds, after three or four years of office, that he is only half-way through. Nobody knows what the position will be when he has got through the other half. I do not want to go through the various items in the Budget. I am one of those who always believed in giving fair play and being as honest and as impartial as possible.
I should like to pay tribute to the Minister for a certain remark which he made in the Budget and which has been the subject of much criticism by other Deputies. I am not one of those who would take advantage of that remark by the Minister because it is a common-sense remark and it refers to a matter which will have to be faced up to by Deputies of all Parties The Minister mentioned that, when there was work for 70 men, only seven turned up. In my opinion, a wrong construction was put upon that statement. We need not be talking with our tongues in our cheeks. We know the state of affairs that exists in some parts of the country. We know that the workers of this country are as good as the workers of any other country. We know, too, that some of them have certain failings. I am not one who would take advantage of the Minister's statement, and I do not criticise him for it. I should like to be fair to him. This is a big matter and we are a small country and the sooner we get away from this highfalutin' talk about a high standard of living and great wages, as if this country were flowing with milk and honey, the better for all concerned— the better for this Government and the better for all future Governments.
Usually, on such an important occasion as this, a Minister occupying the responsible office which the Minister for Finance holds, would make some reference to the future trade relationships of this country with other countries, notably Great Britain. In my opinion, those relationships will have a very big effect on future Budgets and will determine whether they will be good or bad. I thought that the Minister would make, at least, some reference to the question of the settlement of the economic war, or, if he did not settle the economic war, that he would at least do the next best thing—set up the republic which we have been so long promised. Leaving all jokes aside, I do think that it was the duty of the Minister to make some reference to the settlement of the economic war. I suppose we are all Irish, although I am sometimes termed an "old British imperialist." We are all prepared to stand up for our country in a just cause. I really think it is about time that the Ministers and the members of the Fianna Fáil Party took their courage in their hands and did publicly what they have been doing and what they are prepared to do privately—that is, make a settlement with Great Britain. They have already made a part-settlement.
Comment on this
All that was discussed on another Estimate and may be discussed again on the Estimate for the Department of External Affairs. A discussion on the settlement of the economic war would not, however, be in order on this motion.
Comment on this
In the first page of the Budget, the Minister freely admits that the favourable position, so far as the finances of the country are concerned, was due in large measure to the conditions prevailing in other countries.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy propose to discuss conditions prevailing in Abyssinia on this motion?
Comment on this
If the economic conditions in Great Britain had such an advantageous effect on this country, notwithstanding that there is a slight difference of opinion between Great Britain and the Free State, how much greater would that advantage be if we had what is called free-trade with Great Britain?
Comment on this
I should like to emphasise it, because I know the Minister in his heart would like to have the economic war out of the way.
Comment on this
The Minister is not responsible, as Minister for Finance, for the settlement of the economic dispute. The Deputy has made his point. Other Deputies might be equally in earnest on the same subject, and would be equally entitled to speak. The Deputy realises what the position would be if the door were once opened.
Comment on this
I quite appreciate that and I shall leave the matter with an expression of the wish that the Minister will, in the near future, do something to bring that dispute to an end. On the whole, much could be said by way of praising the Budget and much could be said by way of criticising it. Many branches of the Government's policy have done much good for the country. I should like to emphasise, however, that that is due to a large extent—I think the Minister will admit this—to the co-operation which the Government has received from all sections of the people. That is one of the things I should like to emphasise, in view of certain speeches made by members of the Government in the country. The Government have received—I am glad that they have— great co-operation from all sections of the people.
Comment on this
They have received great co-operation in counties such as the county I myself represent, which has a very large majority against the Government. I do not think that any county gives as loyal support to the Government as that county, They are a law-abiding people, and their public representatives always advocate obedience to the law, unlike certain other counties which are strongly Fianna Fáil. I should like to bring it to the notice of the Minister that the Government received a good deal of co-operation from all classes and all sections in that county, possibly much more than the previous Government received at the time that the present Government was in Opposition. That position existed. If we are to criticise it, it is our duty to do so, as long as the criticism is of a constructive nature. I trust when the next Budget comes along that possibly in having additions to the revenue the Minister will be able to make certain remissions, or be able to reduce the taxation that has at present to be raised. I am sure he will remember this, after all the measures that have been taken by the Government to solve unemployment, the problem still remains; that the more money set apart for it, the more will have to be set apart each year, and that as far as is humanly possible the Government should leave it to private enterprise. I am sure the Minister will be wiser if that is done, as set out in his Budget statement.
Comment on this
No. A speech such as we have just listened to from Deputy Coburn is so disarming that I scarcely have the heart to reply to some of the hard things said about this Budget. At the same time, the reception which the Budget has received at the hands of the House is also rather an unusual one. In opening my Budget statement on Tuesday last, I ventured to liken the bound volume of the criticisms directed against the preceding Budget to the Book of Lamentations. This year, not even the critics could find material to criticise our proposals; but, nevertheless, they could not deny themselves the morbid delectation of at least one penitential psalm. Accordingly, yesterday afternoon we had Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, "like the pelican in the wilderness," rose-gathering he said he was, but wool-gathering we, who had to listen to him on this side of the House, believed him to be.
Later that evening we had high on the back benches of Fine Gael Deputy McGovern, "like the sparrow that sits alone on the house-top," commiserating with himself on the political misfortune which this Budget would bring to his Party. And of course in the person of Deputy McGilligan we heard "the night raven croaking in the House." Deputy McGilligan's speech was the first, but by no means the best, of the Opposition speeches in this debate. I think he was so awed by its absolute badness that he fled the House immediately afterwards and has not been seen within its precincts since. He was not here yesterday, and he has not been here to-day. Possibly he is a little exhausted after his labours in thinking out those brilliant impromptus and acid nothings with which he occasionally tries to spur the flagging spirits of the Opposition. But we must give the Deputy credit in one respect. He always does try so hard to be funny. It is easy for us on this side to be tolerant with his ill-considered jibes, for they do us no harm. Judging by their faces during his speech on Tuesday, the Front Bench of the Opposition have not the same feeling of security. They remember the hole which Deputy McGilligan dug for himself and his Party during the Budget debates of last year, and they sat carefully wondering what indiscretion he was going to commit next. Indeed, if there was amusement to be found during the course of this, the opening speech for the Opposition, it was not in what Deputy McGilligan said, but in the expression on Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan's face. There he sat the very image of Queen Victoria, every lineament saying: "We are not amused." So striking, indeed, was the image that I thought for a moment I saw Deputy Osmond Esmonde coming down to garland him with homely vegetables, and Deputy Eamonn O'Neill in a white bainin in close attendance at the ceremony.
Comment on this
One of the things which Deputy McGilligan thought funny—apparently it has incapacitated him from taking part in the debate ever since—was his statement that so close was the Minister for Finance to the rocks that every now and then during the year a tariff resolution had to be launched like a lifeboat. In debates of this sort Deputy McGilligan has chosen as his motto a facile bowdlerisation of the maxim of a great mob leader of the French Revolution. With the Deputy it has become "Audacity! Audacity! Always Audacity." The most brilliant of that principle in practice was the one I have just cited. What were the changes in regard to these Emergency Duties which Deputy McGilligan alleged we had imposed in order to make good deficiencies in the Revenue Estimates during the year? There were 16 Orders under the Emergency Imposition of Duties Act made by the Executive Council last year. Some of these nominally imposed taxation, and some of them actually remitted taxation. The total revenue brought in by those which imposed taxation represented about £25,000 per annum, and the total revenue remitted by those which remitted taxation represented about £770,000 per annum. That is the sort of lifeboat that the Minister for Finance launched when it was thought he was on the rocks.
Comment on this
That includes coal and the cattle pact. I suppose I ought to mention Deputy Mulcahy, who makes the audacious claim that he took the coal tax off.
Comment on this
The fact is, in so far as Orders were made by the Executive Council during the 12 months ended 31st March, 1936, they were made in general to remit taxation, and they did remit it to the extent of £770,000.
Comment on this
I am not dealing with what the people are paying. I am dealing with statements made by Deputy McGilligan in this House, and I am asking the House and the people who may be misled by wild and rash statements of the sort, to discount every statement made by Deputy McGilligan in the light of the travesty of the facts in regard to these Emergency Orders, which he presented here on Tuesday last in reference to this Budget.
This is not the only instance of Deputy McGilligan's incomparable audacity. I stated that the revenue collected from general taxation for the year 1935-36, as compared with the year 1931-32, shows an increase of £3,883,000. As against that we had spent on social services, including services of the Land Commission—and later in my speech I hope to be able to show that it is proper to include the work of the Land Commission amongst such services— £4,376,000. The Deputy whose sense of veracity would make him unique even in the realms of Baron Münchausen, and of which I have given one unmitigated example, thought it sufficient to reply to my statement by saying "I do not believe it." But here are the facts. On old age pensions and widows and orphans pensions last year we spent £3,695,000 as against £2,756,000 in 1931-32. Unemployment assistance, unemployment insurance and National Health Insurance took £2,164,000 as against £514,000. On free milk, cheap beef and school meals, there was spent £408,000 as against £25,000, while housing, various relief schemes and other miscellaneous services absorbed £5,371,000 as against £4,743,000.
Comment on this
Not at all. All this money was provided out of taxation, and if the Deputy questions that, there are available to him the Appropriation Accounts for 1931-32, and there will be shortly available to him the Finance Accounts for last year.
Comment on this
I beg your pardon. The Deputy did not put it in an interrogatory form when he said "including loans." I thought he was making an assertion, not asking a question.
Comment on this
The Minister has surely sufficient imagination to imagine a note of interrogation at the end of anything.
Comment on this
Again, as I pointed out, on the Land Commission in 1931-32 the expenditure was £614,159 while last year it rose to £1,390,000. The result of all this is that, although we did take £3,883,000 more in general taxation than was taken in 1931-32; nevertheless it went back to the people with interest because the additional sums spent on social services was £4,376,000 I say, as I said in the Budget statement, that when these services were before the House there was no Deputy and no Party who questioned this expenditure, who demanded that it should be reduced or suggested that it was greater than our people could bear. Not having raised their voices against it, I do think that in all fairness, in common honesty and in common sincerity, they are not entitled now to make the case that we are taking more in general taxation from the people than was taken in 1931-32. These services are tangible valuable things, and they have to be paid for.
You cannot have it both ways, though I do know that the Opposition do like to try to have it both ways. We had Deputy Bennett getting up here during the course of the debate and telling us that the farmers did not altogether approve of the fact that I proposed this year to borrow one-half of the cost of export bounties and subsidies. He said that farmers do not like that sort of thing, that they do not want to pass these burdens on to another generation, that they prefer to pay for them now. But if I had brought in my Budget and suggested that the farmers should now pay the whole cost of the export bounties and subsidies, I think we would hear Deputy Bennett talking in another vein. We would be told that these were burdens that should properly be borne by posterity. Deputy McGilligan denies the accuracy of my figures for social expenditure, and said he did not believe them. But they are all based on official returns which are presented to the House, based on the Appropriation Accounts of 1931-32, which have been passed by the Comptroller and Auditor-General and examined by the Public Accounts Committee. Accordingly they may be taken to represent the exact position for that year. I cannot say the same for 1935-36 but I do say that the figures I have given represent substantially the position for that year, and yet Deputy McGilligan says: "I do not believe it."
Comment on this
The Deputy has not committed himself in a speech to a statement of that kind. When he does speak, possibly later on in the course of discussion on the Finance Bill, I shall have an opportunity of examining his statement and of saying that I believe, even though it will be made in the utmost good faith, his statement to be as groundless as the statement to which Deputy McGilligan committed himself on Tuesday in regard to the Emergency Orders imposed under the Emergency (Imposition of Duties) Act.
I was going to say that the Deputy who made this statement, the statement that he did not believe what I said in regard to our expenditure on social services, had the same bald observation to make in reply to my statement that the increase in the national debt between 31st March, 1923, and 31st March last, after making every allowance for all the concealed commitments arising out of the State's campaign for the better housing of the people, amounted to £5,880,000. I was at great pains to show how that conclusion was arrived at. I was perfectly certain that it was a great burden on the House to try to follow the rather complicated mass of figures which, to the best of my ability, I tried to put before Deputies as clearly and as lucidly as possible. The House with the exception of Deputy McGilligan, who I think had not listened to me at all, heard me with great patience and yet this Deputy, who quite obviously had not paid any attention to what I was saying—he had not the text of the speech before him; he was working over there in the corner giving the last touch of polish to the impromptus with which he was to tickle the ears of the groundlings in the course of his speech later—got up and said: "I do not believe it." Deputy McGilligan in this matter is like the yokel who went to the zoo for the first time, and sceptical with the scepticism of the inert mind, said: "I do not believe it. There ain't no such animal."
Deputy McGilligan does not believe it. So this is the yardstick with which the Fine Gael Party through their principal spokesman in this debate, because he opened the line of the principal criticism for them, are going to ask the people of this country to judge the Budget that was put before them on Tuesday last. Deputy McGilligan does, not believe it. But where, within the whole range of human credibility, is there one good thing that Deputy McGilligan believes about those who differ from him? That is the fundamental defect in Deputy McGilligan's mentality, his inability to believe good of anyone. I do not think that he has even a very high opinion of his colleagues on the Front Bench. He scarcely ever condescends to confer on them the privilege of his company except when he comes here bursting for deliverance. Those who were in the Dáil when Deputy McGilligan was Minister for Industry and Commerce can well remember, and are never likely to forget, the bitter and unscrupulous way that he dealt with those who were friends of his student days, or had been his political associates, or even those with whom he had had official relations, when they ventured to differ from him.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan did not believe any good might be said of them, or that there was any good in anything they did. The Deputy bears the surname McGilligan. If the sceptical faculty were purely hereditary, the Deputy's proper surname would be MacThomas.
Comment on this
They know that the Government's case in regard to this Budget is in competent hands.
Comment on this
Are we to understand from the Minister's remarks that he now classes Deputy McGilligan amongst the leopards as he classed another member of the House before?
Comment on this
I suppose I am not permitted to indulge in conversation with Deputy Mulcahy. I do not see the appositeness of that remark.
Comment on this
I think it would be better if we ceased discussing Deputy McGilligan. I do not understand Deputy Mulcahy's remark.
Comment on this
The Minister previously classified a member of this House as a leopard. Do I understand that Deputy McGilligan is now being put in that class, and if not, in what class?
Comment on this
I think the Minister should not be asked to classify anyone. He ought to be allowed to discuss the Budget and nothing else.
Comment on this
The principal criticism which is being directed against several of the proposals in this Budget is that Deputy McGilligan does not believe them. I am merely suggesting that Deputy McGilligan might properly be classified with the arch-sceptic——
Comment on this
Well, Thomas. Another instance of this scepticism of which, I think, I am properly entitled to complain, because it is scepticism which is not based upon knowledge, is that in the course of my Budget statement I gave figures showing that the savings amongst the less affluent section of the community between 1931-32 and 1935-36 increased from £13,167,000 to £18,665,000, or by almost £5,500,000 in four year, and, once more, Deputy McGilligan did not believe it. Last year the Deputy did not believe that our income was expanding. One of the points that he made in the debate on last year's Budget was that the yield from income and property taxes was drying up. This year the yield from income and property taxes alone, including stamp duty on the sweepstakes, is up by £550,000.
I understand that it was suggested this evening, when I was temporarily absent from the House, that the amount which had been brought in by the alteration in the basis for assessments in regard to the ownership of property last year had been very much under-estimated by me. When that proposal was before the House last year I indicated that I thought it would bring in £30,000 this year.
Comment on this
I say that particular proposal. There were others. So far as we have been able to check the figures, the amount that it has brought in is £35,000, and if the records are wrong they are wrong in my favour because I did not deliberately underestimate the yield. The figure was put down in my Budget statement on the best advice available to me at £30,000. But in any event, so far as we have been able to calculate the yield, it is £35,000, and it is not, as Deputy McGilligan has tried to suggest, very much more than that figure.
Comment on this
It is not in connection with that figure that I suggested the Minister under-estimated, but in regard to the tax on sugar of ½d. per lb.
Comment on this
I will deal with that, but, once again, the Deputy is wrong. We under-estimated there certainly, and if the Deputy who read my speech a second time for the House this evening, had read carefully what I said in regard to sugar he would have seen that I said this: that, when you increase or impose a tax which is calculated to increase the price of an article, then in estimating the yield from that tax the normal practice is to allow for a decrease in the consumption of the article. Last year, when estimating the yield from the sugar duty, we made an allowance for a decreased consumption, but, fortunately, owing to the improved conditions which every one knows and has experienced himself, the consumption of sugar did not go down. It went up, and, accordingly, of course our revenue went up with it.
Let me get back to Deputy McGilligan and his unbelief. The Deputy did not believe that we would be able to secure last year the yield which we estimated we would get from income tax, just as he does not believe that the National Debt this year, is up by only £5,880,000, so he does not believe that the savings of the workers are up by £5,500,000. Not merely does he not believe that, but he goes on to say:—
"Let us get a calculation based on the two, and the Minister will find that although he can boast that thrift has not been completely ousted from the country the amount put by for the last four years
—he was speaking of Savings Bank Deposits and Savings Certificates—
is down by at least £350,000 on what the average figure used to be."
What are the facts in that regard? Deputy McGilligan had no facts upon which to base that statement—none whatever—but he thought that if he did a little harm to the credit of this country he might get a few headlines in the British newspapers; he thought they might state: "Deputy McGilligan says that the rate of saving in the Irish Free State has declined," and accordingly he made himself responsible for that statement. Now, what are the facts? Not merely has the total volume of savings increased but the rate of savings has increased also. The Irish Post Office Savings Bank was established on 1st January, 1923. Between that date and 1932 there were transferred to it from the British Post Office Savings Bank deposits to the value of £137,000 odd. Between 1931-2 and the present year there were no transfers between the two institutions.
Thus the net new savings represented by Post Office deposits during the first nine years of the life of the Irish Post Office Savings Bank, that is the period from 1st January, 1923, to March, 1932, amounted to £3,600,000. I gave the figures more exactly in the Budget statement yesterday. Between the 1st January, 1923, and the end of March last, the new savings have been £6,734,000. What do we find? We find that in the first nine years of the history of the Post Office Savings Bank, that is in the period covered by the previous Administration, the total amount of savings on deposit in the bank was £3,600,000, and the average rate of saving accordingly was about £390,000 per annum, but in the four years from 31st March, 1932, to 31st March, 1936, there was an increase of £3,134,000 in the savings in the Post Office Savings Bank.
Comment on this
Would the Minister state if the first period was that during which the Post Office was being robbed?
Comment on this
I have more regard for Deputy O'Sullivan than to say anything to hurt him, but if he does interrupt and annoy me I shall lose my temper.
Comment on this
Of course, Deputy O'Sullivan is an old soldier. He knew what was coming out, he wished to divert me from this point. Here are the facts; there was an average rate of saving of £390,000 per annum in the first nine years—the nine years of Mr. Cosgrave's administration—and an average rate of saving of £746,000 per annum during the four years of Mr. de Valera's bankruptcy.
Comment on this
And will not the Minister agree with me that my question was a fair one? That was the period when he was robbing the Post Office?
Comment on this
That is the real truth in regard to our rate of saving, which Deputy McGilligan wants the House to believe is £350,000 per annum less than it used to be. The Deputy does not believe it. Since Deputy McGilligan made his exhibition on the Budget of last year, when he made himself responsible in this House for statements from which he ran away when brought before a Committee of this House, the number of people who do not believe what Deputy McGilligan says outnumbers even the number of things that Deputy McGilligan does not believe.
Comment on this
It is quite obvious that Deputies do not like to hear about the things that Deputy McGilligan does not believe.
Comment on this
Here is one of the things that Deputy McGilligan does believe. "The Government," he said on Tuesday, "got their power by bribery. The day it is realised and confessed that it was bribery, that day the Government ends. As long as there is money to be spent on roads, on public health services, on getting people jobs, on getting people places through political influence, there is a chance for a Party unconscientious about the use of public money to remain in power." That is one of the things Deputy McGilligan does believe. That is an allegation of wholesale bribery and corruption—"getting people jobs, getting people places through political influence," and again, "as long as there is money to be spent on roads, on public health services..." In other countries prominent politicians are sometimes referred to as being of Presidential timber, that is to say they are generally regarded as being of the character and calibre which would befit them for the office of the Presidency. Deputy McGilligan in the bowels of African savagery might make an efficient witch doctor, a smeller out of corruption, for that is the function of a witch doctor in the African political hierarchy. That is the very function which Deputy McGilligan has arrogated to himself in the political life of this State. He is the witch doctor of Fine Gael. When the Deputy rises to speak in any debate in this House, there is one insurance that his hearers may make with absolute certainty, that it will be as profitable and secure as an insurance against, say, a rise in income-tax, and that is that Deputy McGilligan in the course of his remarks will charge his political opponents with graft and corruption. We had it on Tuesday last in that speech from which I have just recited a passage to the House.
The Unemployment Assistance Act, we were told by this Deputy the year before last was brought in by us to corrupt the people. Our increased expenditure upon social services, according to him, was likewise to corrupt the people. Now, the provision which we are making for a programme of public works, and the employment fund which we are setting up to finance it, are also to corrupt the people. The Deputy carries around with him the essence of corruption —a bad conscience and a poor opinion of human nature, based upon self knowledge, with which for his own self-torture he has been burdened. The Deputy is a good witch doctor. He is a keen smeller-out of corruption. On this matter of corruption he has delicate nostrils which must be an occasion of unceasing offence to him because of their juxtaposition with the thoughts which lie so close to them. Let us hear no more from Deputy McGilligan about bribery and corruption, because when the Deputy opens his mind on that subject in this House, it is like removing the lid from a long-buried coffin.
Comment on this
Let us have less talk about corruption. Let us not hear any more of it. It ought not to be mentioned in this State or in this House because I do not believe it exists here, and I am prepared to say this—that I do not believe it existed when our opponents were in office. I do not believe that there are Irishmen in power or in political life here to-day who would be corrupt. It is no credit to any Party that the words should be used in this House. Because certain things happened in other countries, the lie and slander have followed the Irish race wherever they have engaged in politics. Let us, at any rate, banish the words bribery and corruption out of Irish politics. The only man who habitually uses them in this House and on the platform is Deputy McGilligan, and, as I say, it would be better for everybody and for us all if we heard no more about them.
Turning from a consideration of Deputy McGilligan's speech to that of Deputy Dillion is like walking out of the atmosphere of the charnel house into that of the nursery. There is an air of boyish pomposity about those things which Deputy Dillion says which forbids us to be annoyed even at his least veracious hyperbole. It has been amusing to us on these benches to observe the stages of Deputy Dillion's maturing adolescence in Irish politics. His speech on this Budget, I think, should mark the third stage in that development. The first stage started some time after he voted for the Fianna Fáil Budget in 1932. The next stage—I think we might call it the flagellation stage—was when the Deputy, quite obviously, was applying to himself the penitential whip for having once in his whole lifetime voted for a Fianna Fáil Budget. At this very interesting stage of his political development he had not joined the main Opposition, and he used to parade himself publicly before the gaze of Deputy Cosgrave, clothed in sackcloth, beating his breast and crying out: "Mea culpa, mea culpa, I voted for the Fianna Fáil Budget of 1932. I declared it was a humane and Christian Budget, but I pray you, Deputy Cosgrave, forgive me, because I can no longer abide in the cold regions of independence with Deputy MacDermot."
It was during this period that he used to say that he had verbally and oratorically whipped the Minister for Agriculture and whipped the Minister for Industry and Commerce. That mood passed immediately, Abraham— in the person whether of Deputy Cosgrave or General O'Duffy, no one can be quite certain—took Deputy Dillion into his bosom. No longer was it necessary for him to do public penance. His crimes had been forgiven, and he was safe among the hierarchy on the Front Opposition Bench; so he threw away the whip and equipped himself with a pair of boots. He was then in what I might describe as the sadistic stage. He took an unutterable delight in kicking Ministers, and particularly the Minister for Agriculture, down the stairs. He used to come in here and make long speeches retailing his exploits with the hobnailed boot. One day it was the Minister for Industry and Commerce to whom it had been applied, and the next day it was the Minister for Agriculture. The frequent use by Deputy Dillon during this period of the verb "to kick," and the metaphors and similes based upon it, would furnish a subject of intense interest to psycho-analysts and psychotherapists. It is a most perfect example of image transference, because, of course, Deputy Dillon could not get up and disclose his real psychological condition to the House. He could not get up and tell the House what he really thought about the industrial and agricultural progress which the country was making under this Government.
Comment on this
The Opposition on the Front Bench would not permit him to do it, and he had to suppress his real thoughts on the subject. He was suffering from certain repressions, which those who know something about the subject will agree manifested themselves in the particular characteristics of Deputy Dillon's speeches and arguments during that period. He was, in fact, kicking himself for having backed the wrong horse, for being in the wrong Party, for supporting the wrong policy, but he could not tell us that. This mental whirlwind, which was going on inside him every time he got up to speak, compelled him to tell us about the ferocious way in which he had kicked the Minister for Industry and Commerce here, the Minister for Agriculture there and the Minister for Finance in both places at once.
But now we are apparently witnessing the third stage of Deputy Dillon's adolescence. The speech we listened to on this Budget is an indication of it. Apparently he has kicked him so hard that he is, as it were, in a sort of trance. Like those pugilists who become punch drunk and are still able to stand on their feet, Deputy Dillon has been intoxicated by his own kicking, and he now stands in a sort of trance in which he talks as though he were a prophet come to judgment and a mentor of political morals and conduct.
Yesterday, Deputy Dillon ventured to commend me upon the fact that in the course of this year's Budget statement I did not resort to hyperbole. His exact words were: "For the first time, his Budget contained a useful survey of many useful economic problems and saved us a great deal of the hyperbole to which we have become accustomed when he rises to speak."
Comment on this
I deserve no commendation for that. It is to Deputy Dillon himself that the House ought to be grateful.
Comment on this
For this, certainly. Early in Deputy Dillon's political career he cornered all the hyperbole available and the rest of us have been on short commons ever since. I suppose that is why, having no room in his speeches for any other quality, the Deputy, making a virtue of necessity, has been good enough to leave to the rest of us common sense and a regard for accuracy. There are, however, one or two things in Deputy Dillon's speech of which I think serious notice must be taken; first, because, as I said, Deputy Dillon professes to be a master of morals and he ought at least to practise his own precepts. The Deputy alleged that though I had said that the State debt had increased by only £5,883,000 in the four years during which we have been in office, it had, in fact, according to my Budget statement of 1934, deteriorated in the two years since then by £10,000,000 or £11,000,000. I asked the Deputy to produce his authority for that statement and he cited one passage of the Budget statement of 1934. Here is the statement upon which the Deputy relied to support a charge that in the financial statement of the year, which every Finance Minister naturally tries to make as clear and as accurate as he can, I, in some way or another, misrepresented the facts, either now in 1935-36 or when I made this earlier statement in 1934. Here is the 1934 passage on which the Deputy relied:
"Now, take the position of the 31st March last. Our direct liabilities then stood at £44,523,000, our off-setting assets at £27,495,649, and our net direct public debt, after allowing for these assets, at £17,027,000—a reduction of £5,460,000 in two years."
Basing his statement on that, the Deputy then said that if there was a reduction of £5,460,000 in two years—if the debt had been reduced by over £5,000,000 by 1934, and an increase then by £5,800,000 over what it had been in 1931-2, the position had deteriorated by £10,000,000 or £11,000,000 inside the last two years. That is what the Deputy said, and the statement upon which he based it is the one I have just read; and then he stopped. Quite suddenly, he stopped. He must have been stricken by some sort of mental paralysis. At any rate, he seemed to have lost his ability to read, although he did not lose his ability to talk—I suppose that would be impossible— because, immediately after that statement which I have read, in the Budget speech of 1934, there comes this:
"Having said that, however, I must also point out that owing to the provisions of the Land Act of 1933 the Exchequer has assumed responsibility for half the cost of all land purchase transactions carried out under the Land Act of 1923 and subsequent Acts. The effect is, of course, to saddle the Exchequer with a capital obligation amounting now to £11,546,749, but ultimately expanding, when land purchase is completed, to about £17,000,000."
Comment on this
Is the Minister surprised to hear that the Irish Press of the 10th May, 1934, stopped at the exact same spot.
Comment on this
Ah! Is that the plea? Is it the plea that a Deputy of this House got his information from the columns of a journal outside this House, when the speech in full is on the official records of this House, and is available for any Deputy who wants to ascertain the truth?
Comment on this
There is adequate accommodation in the Library for the members of the Opposition as well as for everyone else, and I have no doubt that on the book-shelves there is a green volume containing this speech in extenso, but the Deputy now wants to cover up Deputy Dillon's statement with a report from a newspaper. I am quoting from the official records of this House, and not from any outside source.
Comment on this
This debate may be for the benefit of the poor man in the street. At any rate, I know that it is not for the benefit of the Fine Gael Party, and that is why the Deputy does not want me to go on with my speech. I am telling the House, however, where Deputy Dillon stopped in 1934, and if the House turns to page 17 of my Budget statement of last Tuesday, they will see this item of £11,000,000 odd to which I called their attention in clear and definite terms in May, 1934, as a liability of which account should be taken. We did not know then whether or not the economic war would end, or what would happen. It was not necessary to bring it in, but it is brought in now.
Comment on this
On page 15 of the Budget statement of last Tuesday we have this: "Land Acts, 1923-1933—for Costs Fund and State Contribution to Price—£14,605,000." And on page 17 I drew the attention of the House specifically to the fact that the increase in the liability as to £12,000,000 of it, is due to the fact that the land annuities under the post-1923 Acts have been reduced by the Land Act of 1933. It is there in the statement, and I am not responsible if the Deputy cannot read and assimilate the facts. However, I think the Deputy's speech to-day showed that he could not read or assimilate the facts.
Comment on this
It is not the business of the Minister to be able to detail every figure and item in the whole statement of accounts.
Comment on this
The Minister challenges the correctness of a figure of £11,000,000 that has been given, and he is not able to put the correct figure against that.
Comment on this
The figure is £5,883,000 as the net increase of the debt over and above what it was in 1931-2.
Comment on this
I am merely stating the fact that Deputy Dillon suppressed the essential element in a statement on that matter, and I am pointing out that Deputy Dillon has become a past master in the art of the half-truth.
Comment on this
Mind you, I do not know if the Deputy quite realises what he is doing, but actually he is unconsciously paying a tribute to the Irish Press. Evidently he relies on it rather than on journals of the same political complexion as himself. He wants to get accurate news and he relies on the Irish Press, naturally. I am merely saying that no newspaper can be pleaded here by a Deputy as proof of what was said in the House.
Comment on this
I am saying that if a Deputy has nothing better to rely on than a newspaper report it merely means that he has been either grossly negligent or grossly indolent. However, let us hear why this increase in the State debt of £5,883,000 has been incurred. I pointed out that £4,000,000 of it—and again I made the most exhaustive presentation of the manner in which that figure had been determined—is due to money which the local authorities have borrowed at the instance of the Government, on the Government's behalf, since the Government meets the loan charges on that account, for the purpose of carrying on a campaign to provide better housing for the people. In addition to that, there is to be added £12,202,000 represented by this increased fund on the Exchequer in respect of the post-1923 land annuities arising out of the 50 per cent. reduction which was granted in the Land Act of 1933. With regard to the total sum of these two items— £16,202,000—we have succeeded in discounting or writing down that particular asset by almost 80 per cent. inside the last three years, and it is an indication of the very conservative basis that is being taken for the valuation of any of the assets that have been put before the House. Deputy Cosgrave, when he was President, used to boast about the credit-worthiness of this State. One thing I am concerned about is that I hope that when the time comes—and a welcome time it will be—for me to lay down the burdens of this office—I shall be able to pass on to my successor a sound basis for the credit and finances of this State, and that he will find the State in a more secure and stronger position than it was when I came in here. I am not saying that now by way of criticism of my predecessors.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Deputy feels grateful; I do not expect any gratitude for it; it is the essential truth. With regard to the statement made by Deputy Dillon, I said that one could forgive Deputy Dillon a lot because of his boyish pomposity, but when he started in this House to read a lecture to two Continental Powers, I must certainly question the wisdom, the propriety, of doing that on an occasion like this. If the Deputy wants to do it, let him start on some platform outside; let him not rise in the legislature of this country and start to tell other people how to manage their business. We may all have our opinions about how things elsewhere should be carried on, and we hope we may never see certain principles in operation here; but we ought not to take it upon ourselves to lecture other people on how they should manage their own households. We here were too long subject to other people trying to manage ours not to realise that the person who tries to do that sort of thing is doing nothing else but committing an intolerable impertinence.
Deputy Dillon was not concerned so very much about what was happening in Spain and Italy; he was more concerned to do a little blackening after the manner of his master, Deputy McGilligan. He wanted to construct a triptyque in the crude and violent colours of his own over-heated imagination. He wanted to be able to say that in Spain they had anarchy, in Italy highway robbery, and in the Free State futile bankruptcy. Futile bankruptcy was the head-line that Deputy Dillon wanted to see featured in every journal in the world inimical or hostile to the Irish people. That is what he wanted to see and, therefore, he merely, as it were, dragged in Italy and Spain as settings for this gem of his imagination. Of course, this country is not on the way to bankruptcy. The Deputy complimented me—and I am not ungrateful for the compliment —upon the careful survey which I had made of the State's financial position. One thing that that survey did bring out was that this State is not on its way to bankruptcy, that savings are up, that income is up, that income-tax was up by no less than £550,000 last year, although the standard rate had not changed, and so far as the masses of the people are concerned, particularly married people with families, I can say this, that with our 4/6 rate they are very much better off than they were under the 3/6 rate which prevailed when Deputy Cosgrave was in office. If these facts are challenged, I am prepared to produce figures. If there is any person on the Front Benches opposite as sceptical as Deputy McGilligan, who will have the hardihood to say: "I do not believe it," I have the figures here to substantiate that statement. Apparently the statement is accepted.
Comment on this
Even Deputy Mulcahy, who was a member of the previous Administration, knows and acknowledges now that so far as the general mass of small income-tax payers in this country, people with families, are concerned, the effective rate of tax is lower upon them to-day than it was when Deputy Mulcahy was in office as Minister for Local Government.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that £2,000,000 additional in Customs duties comes out of these homes, I do not see the relative importance of that statement.
Comment on this
The Deputy evidently regards discretion as the better part of valour and he is not challenging the statement I have made.
Comment on this
Do not try to paint the lily. The Deputy has said enough. The Deputy dare not challenge the statement of the Minister for Finance that so far as the small income-tax payers with families are concerned, the effective rate of tax on the 14th May, 1936, is less than what it was on the 31st March, 1932.
Comment on this
I am leaving to the Minister his monopoly of the paint-pots and the paint brushes—paint away.
Comment on this
That is not the only subject in connection with which I must be given a monopoly. There is no one who can challenge me in regard to the income-tax. I have disposed of Deputy McGilligan's challenge in regard to the State debt and the rate of savings. I am sure no one will deny my submissions in relation to the consumption of sugar, wine, beer and spirits. I have said there is an increasing return in regard to the consumption of tobacco, an increased return in respect of entertainments duty and there is more being obtained from petrol, and, taking into consideration every other criticism that has been advanced against the Budget, no person has ventured to say that it is not a sound, a balanced Budget. That is the position. That is all I am concerned to prove—that so far as this country is concerned, notwithstanding Deputy Dillon's triptyque, we are not on the road to futile bankruptcy.
If we could only arrive at common ground in regard to that, we might make a great deal of progress in this State, because it would give everybody hope if they did but realise that, after all, there is something in the agricultural and industrial policy of the Government. The Government have had their own difficulties over the last three or four years; it has been a tough job. No one could try to make that sort of change without meeting with difficulties. I think we are getting over the difficulties and there is a chance for us to try to do our best. Deputy Coburn talked of the sort of co-operation we were getting from people who do not agree with us, through the country. That is quite true; we are getting it from everywhere. There are people investing money in enterprises set up under the fostering care of the State, who would not give us a vote in 12 or even 100 years. I do not suppose they have a single political or cultural idea in common with us, and yet they help us.
If we only got down to this basis, that we would banish all this talk about corruption and bankruptcy, then we might see some hope of progress. Just as happens elsewhere, I quite realise that there must be political parties in the State. You cannot have a healthy, representative democracy without freedom of opinion. People must be allowed to think freely and to co-operate and coalesce with those who think like they do. There is no reason why we ought not to have very keen, very searching and very hostile criticism coming from people who differ from us. I think it would be a very bad day for this State, or for any Government of the State, if the people in opposition did not take their job seriously and did not try to say the hardest things they could about Government policy—did not try to find all the flaws they could in it, and put their views up to us: "There is what we think about it; you do your best and improve upon it."
We were getting down to that stage after the first speech was delivered, but then we had the statement made by Deputy Dillon. As I have already said, one can afford to give him a lot of sympathy. After all, he is a comparatively recent arrival in politics. He has a great deal of ability and natural aptitude for public life, and I do sincerely hope that when next he gets up to talk we will not be treated to the sort of statement we have been having from him recently. I think he is very often the victim of his own eruptive vocabulary. He mounts to the regions of hyperbole, and when he gets there he is quite unable to ride the brain-storm which he himself has created.
Comment on this
Maybe, but I am somewhat older, and although I may not be able to control my own tongue on occasion, nevertheless I would like to see a younger person doing better than I have been able to do.
I come now to the speech made by Deputy O'Higgins, which, I think, was really the first attempt to deal fairly, though critically, with the Budget. As far as my recollection goes—and I listened to the speech very attentively—this was the gravamen of his indictment, that we have to spend £2,500,000 to create work and wages. I take exception to that statement on two grounds: first, the money is not being spent merely to create work. That is altogether a wrong approach to the problem. The people who look at this public works programme as a sort of reversion to the philosophy of the treadmill, hard labour yards and those other things which used to be characteristics of the old workhouse system in our country are taking altogether a wrong view of the proposal. That is not the idea. The idea is this: that there is work there which has always been there. We have not created the work. A sum of £675,000 is to be spent on public health services in towns where there never had been public health services before, and I am perfectly convinced that Deputy Mulcahy, with his experience as an ex-Minister of the Government, is not going to say that it would not be a good thing if these public health services could be extended to every urbanised community of significant size in the country.
Comment on this
Yes, if the people in these communities were put in the position to pay for them—if they were in the position of being allowed to work to pay for them.
Comment on this
It would be a very difficult thing for any Government to put everybody in the job he would like. The one critical factor in the whole of this unemployment problem which is making it difficult everywhere is this, that more and more people, by reason of the changes in the methods of production, in technique, and because of the improvements and advances that are being made in labour-saving devices, are being thrown out of the jobs in which they are accustomed to earn their livelihood.
Comment on this
And because farmers are getting £7 10s. for what they got £16 10s. a few years ago——
Comment on this
There are a lot of things at this hour of the night that I will not deny. Even in agriculture the methods are changing the world over. Methods are being changed in Great Britain because they have to produce a different article to suit the changed tastes of the people. I was reading the other day in a scientific journal an article indicating the changes which are fast taking place in English agricultural mechanism as well as in industry. I read that they are abandoning the old practice of hay-making because Imperial Chemicals have succeeded in perfecting a very excellent machine at a cost of between £2,000 and £3,000 for drying grass. It was pointed out that that was going to enable the English farmer——
Comment on this
Well, the article I read said it was a success. I am not a practical farmer like Deputy Belton. I was not there, but I am merely showing the House that there are human minds working on these things, the human minds that have solved the problems of aviation, of television, of wireless broadcasting and the transmission of energy without any visible means of conduction. The minds that have accomplished these things are now devoting themselves to devising new and more efficient processes in agriculture, and they are going to succeed apparently.
Comment on this
The Minister would be much better occupied in reading the local Irish Press and not mind reading that stuff.
Comment on this
I am afraid that the interjection by Deputy Mulcahy explains quite a lot regarding the last Government. He has not got a receptive mind and Governments must have receptive minds. They must keep continually in touch with human progress and human development. What I was saying before the attempt to put me off the track—I am sorry I did a little bit digress—was this: that in this programme a sum of £675,000 is provided for public health works. That represents not the full amount of work to be done, but only a fraction of the work that can be done. It represents the volume of work, however, which is ready to be undertaken and carried out this year. There is a bigger reservoir behind that still. The plans are there. The Deputy knows from his own experience that the local authorities have been pressing Government after Government to do these things. They have been pressing us to sanction and to assist them to carry out a lot of these public health works. Anyway, whatever future we hope to have for this country we cannot hope to progress unless we equip ourselves at least as well as the other civilised communities in Europe.
Comment on this
That remains to be seen. The tourist industry is becoming more important in the Free State every year. We propose to spend about £600,000 on roads. The roads here are not bad. I think Deputy Mulcahy deserves a great deal of credit for the work done by the Department of Local Government and Public Health during the period he was Minister. I do not say that the roads are bad. They are very good. But, in the last three years all over Europe, there has been a considerable appreciation in the standard which has been set in this matter, and that is the standard by which our roads are to be judged.
Comment on this
That may be, but we are trying to change them. We will make mistakes but we will try to do our best. The only point I am trying to make is this, that in our public works programme we are not endeavouring merely to create work, for the work was there all the time. It is useful work which will redound to the benefit of our citizens. It is work that, I believe, over a prolonged period, would have to be carried out in any event, and it is work that will ultimately be reproductive. It will make this country an attractive place for tourists. If we are no longer shipping cattle to England and bringing in manufactured goods in exchange, still the volume of traffic in our ports is not going to diminish. Its character will change. Instead of having goods we will have people coming here. We will give them in exchange for the money they will leave with us our services and a great deal of our produce. I do not think there is any industry that is so intrinsically remunerative as the tourist industry. People come along. You entertain them and they spend money here on your agricultural products. They spend money in services and on the enjoyment of the amenities which you provide for them in the way of tourist roads and all that sort of thing. Every penny they spend in the country is ultimately a profit to the country in so far as it is spent upon things which are produced by our soil and by the labour of our people.
If we want to take advantage of this new habit of humanity we must cater more and more for tourists—for this new habit, which is becoming much more general, of wanting to see what other countries look like, how the people live, and so on, of wishing to compare the standards of other people with our own. One of the things that will result from our public works programme is that we are going to put this island in a position that the people who come to it will leave it with very different ideas from those with which they came. We have been held up to people abroad as a backward people. The more we improve our public health services the more we will be able to do away with those misconceptions. The more we induce tourists to visit this country the more benefit there will be for our people. I move to report progress.
The Dáil adjourned at 10.30 p.m. until 10.30 a.m. on Friday, 15th May.