We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Insurance Bill, 1935—Recommittal (Resumed).

Contributions 170–359 of 359. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Insurance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 35 of 1935 ›

If the Minister has approved of the scheme, and it is then taken to the High Court, the circumstances in which the Minister would withdraw approval and proceed to object in the court are inconceivable. The bringing of the scheme to the court is to enable the policyholders to voice any objections they may have.

Comment on this

That may be so, but still the Minister has power to come in and again object.

Comment on this

It may be the Minister who will bring the scheme to the court.

Comment on this

Let me put it to Deputy Moore——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Put it to the Minister, who is in charge of the Bill.

Comment on this

I put it to the House, Sir, of which I regard Deputy Moore as a respected member.

Comment on this

Go raibh mile maith agat.

Comment on this

A company puts up a scheme for amalgamation and amends that scheme to embody all the representations made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce; it puts in all the amendments he suggests, and then receives a notification on the following morning: "The Minister has changed his mind and disapproves of the scheme". Does Deputy Moore think that in those circumstances the company ought to have the right to go to the court and make the case that the Minister is acting unreasonably in refusing to approve the scheme which has, in fact, been amended in accordance with his suggestions? I will not further embarrass Deputy Moore by trespassing on his silence. Deputy Moore, apparently, does not care to answer that; I do not blame him.

Comment on this

He was told by the Minister not to make any further indiscreet speeches.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Costello is a very good judge of indiscretions.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy repeat that?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not relevant to the discussion.

Comment on this

Obviously, that is the express proviso which the Minister seeks to insert in the Bill—that the people are to be deprived of all right of reference to the court. It cannot be too constantly emphasised in this connection that this discretion is going to be exercised not by a representative of this House but in effect it is going to be exercised by a permanent official or a person appointed ad hoc to examine this scheme—a person who may be right or who may be wrong. That such a person should be vested by statute with the power of being the final judge, beyond whom there will be no appeal——

Comment on this

A judge upon a scheme submitted voluntarily for judgment by the companies concerned.

Comment on this

Submitted because they must submit it, if they are to take advantage of this Part of the Bill.

Comment on this

Why must they submit it?

Comment on this

They must submit it if they are to take advantage of this part of the Bill. It means that we are drifting into a position which is extremely dangerous. We are not only doing those companies a substantial injustice but we are establishing a detestable principle—a principle to defend which no attempt has been made by any Minister of the Government except the Minister for Industry and Commerce. There is in the minds of Deputies a kind of idea that, after all, as a general rule, you get substantial justice from a departmental decision. I do not deny in practice— though I am not prepared to waive the principle—that where you are dealing with a question of whether a person will thatch a roof or put slates on it you do get substantial justice from a departmental decision. Where you are discussing a question as to whether a lady living in Ballintemple is 78 years of age or 68 years of age, as a general rule you get substantial justice from a Departmental decision. But, in regard to complex matters of this kind, Department officials are no more qualified to formulate an unanswerable judgment than any other individual citizen of the State. The Minister will, I think, remember that not so very long ago a question arose in connection with insurance companies in Great Britain, and the official of the Board of Trade in Great Britain responsible for insurance matters very definitely ruled in regard to a series of insurance transactions in Great Britain that they were contrary to the law; he condemned them, and ordered the insurance companies to revise their practice in that regard. His decision was brought before the High Court, from the High Court to the Court of Appeal, and I think it went to the House of Lords. There, judgment was secured in favour of the insurance companies and against the Board of Trade. It was demonstrated beyond doubt or question that the law as it stood was correctly inter preted by the insurance companies and incorrectly interpreted by the experts of the Board of Trade.

Comment on this

What has that got to do with the section?

Comment on this

It means that the Minister will stipulate for certain requirements here——

Comment on this

He is not determining any question of law.

Comment on this

He is determining questions of far more complex character— questions of actuarial probability and insurance rectitude, which can be very much more complicated than any other question. His decision is subject to no review of any kind, good, bad or indifferent; and it is not his decision—it is the decision of a casually employed expert, supported by whatever experience he has in his Department at the present time. There is no opportunity to bring before any impartial tribunal all the rest of the expert opinion available. If the one individual expert whom he employs is on one side, and all known actuarial opinion in the world is on the other side, his expert is unanswerable and may not be answered. That is an absolutely intolerable position, and an absolutely indefensible proposal to bring before this House. May I invite Deputy Moore, when the time comes to signify his will on whether this section should remain part of the Bill, to join with us in protesting against the incorporation of such a proviso in the law?

Comment on this

The Minister has been insisting throughout this debate that the amalgamation proposals in the Bill are entirely voluntary, but at an earlier stage of the debate he stated— I think in answer to Deputy McGilligan—that the effect of this Bill and the proposals contained in this Bill would be to unloose forces which would compel amalgamation.

Comment on this

That being the case, how does he justify this absolute discretion? Does he mean, under his proposals in this Bill, to unloose those forces, in other words, to compel amalgamation indirectly when he has not had the courage to face up to compulsory amalgamations in this Bill, and then not merely to compel amalgamation but dictate to the companies the terms on which that amalgamation will take place? I was surprised to hear yesterday that the provisions in Section 12 dealing with the separation of the businesses of the companies were not the Minister's contribution to the solution of the insurance problems in this country. I then thought that the amalgamation proposals were the Minister's solutions for the difficulties that exist in regard to insurance here. I stated here earlier to-day that in my opinion those amalgamation proposals will not work. Whatever chance they had of working, irrespective of Section 26, I think there can be no doubt that it will be impossible to contemplate the working of those amalgamation proposals at all if Section 26 stands. Anybody who has had anything to do with the amalgamation of companies will know the complexities that are involved in such amalgamation proposals, the details that have to be considered and the long discussions that have to take place before anything in the nature of an agreement can be reached. There are problems of staff, problems of the future governing of the concern, any amount of personal considerations and personalities—all very difficult problems in themselves. But in connection with the amalgamation of insurance companies those problems become still more complex. They demand time, tact, and infinite wisdom on the part of the negotiating people who are trying to bring about amalgamation. When all that is done they are faced with a situation that the Minister may say, irrationally, and without stating any reason: "I will not have anything to do with your proposals"; then all the labour and tact which had to go into bringing about the scheme are gone for nothing. I think that any companies contemplating amalgamation under the proposals contained in this part of the Bill would simply be wasting their time if they were faced with the situation which arises under Section 26—that because of the whim of an official or the whim of an outsider brought in at their expense the whole of their work and the whole of their tact and diplomacy which have brought about the amalgamation scheme are rendered useless.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 84:

At the end of the section to add the words—

"provided that in any case of refusal he shall forthwith communicate the grounds of refusal to the promoting companies in a statement setting out such grounds under his hand."

This amendment now becomes even more urgent than it would have been had the Minister accepted my previous amendment. Deputy Costello has referred to the preliminaries and expenses which the drafting of any amalgamation scheme will involve. When the companies which propose to amalgamate reach the stage of coming to the Minister with their schemes they have already laid out substantial sums of money in smoothing out the difficulties which arose between the amalgamating parties. Having submitted the scheme, it may be sent back with objections, and they spend further time and money overcoming these objections and return their scheme to the Minister, who then tells them that, under Section 26, in his absolute discretion, he rejects the scheme. Now, this modest amendment asks that to that notification he should append a note: "and are rejected for the following reasons." Is it the intention of the Minister to accept that amendment?

Comment on this

No. I think, on general grounds, it is undesirable in a case of this kind that the Minister should be under statutory obligation to state the reasons for his decision.

Comment on this

It is for the companies themselves, if they want to avail of the advantages of this part of the Bill, to put up an acceptable scheme. If there are no advantages, they will not avail of them.

Comment on this

The Minister says that he sees no reason why the Minister should be put under the statutory obligation of giving reasons for what he is doing, and then, as the absurdity of that contention begins to dawn on the Minister's own mind, he is driven back to shaking his head at us.

Comment on this

I said that it was undesirable in a case of this kind that the Minister should be under statutory obligation to state the reasons for his decision.

Comment on this

And if companies want to put up a scheme, it is up to them to put up an acceptable scheme? How can they ascertain at any stage of the proceedings what is an acceptable scheme, since the Minister can reject it without telling them what element in the scheme is objectionable?

Comment on this

Under the Deputy's proposal, the Minister himself would have to prepare the scheme for them.

Comment on this

Under the Minister's proposal, as it stands at present in the Bill, the companies will bring forward a scheme; the Minister will appoint, at their expense, an assessor to advise him; he will then make objections to the scheme. That is what Deputy Moore calls writing the scheme for the companies, is it or is it not?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

Is that what Deputy Moore calls writing the scheme for the companies?

Comment on this

It could amount to that.

Comment on this

And that is what the Minister wants to do. He is to make objections. Those objections are to be met. It is not we who want the Minister to do that. It is he himself.

Comment on this

Then, what is the Deputy kicking up a fuss about?

Comment on this

Very well. Having done all that and, in the trenchant words of Deputy Moore, having himself written the scheme, the Minister can then say to the companies: "Although I wrote the scheme, I will not have it, and I will not tell you why." I say that, once the Minister himself has intervened and, in Deputy Moore's descriptive words, written the scheme himself, he should not have the right at all to reject it, and that, if he attempts to reject it, he should be haled before the High Court and made give his reasons there for rejecting it. The object of that amendment is to see that, when the Minister takes up the attitude that he will not accept his own scheme, he will be forced to give his reasons for its non-acceptance. The Minister having himself written the scheme, as Deputy Moore says, wants to be in the position of saying: "That is the scheme I want, not what you want, but I have now changed my mind and I will not have any scheme." In other words, it is a question of "jam yesterday, and jam to-morrow, but I will not have jam to-day," and the company comes back limply and says: "But it has cost is £5,000 and three months' hard work to bring our scheme into conformity with our requirements and your demands, and are we now to be informed that that money and time is to be thrown into the ash-can?" The Minister says: "Yes." The company then asks: "May we respectfully inquire why we are to throw £5,000 and three or six months' work into the ash-can?" and the Minister says: "No, you may not inquire; it is a most ill-mannered departure to make any such inquiry because, under Section 26, there is no obligation on me to give my reasons, and I will not give them, and so you can now proceed to throw your £5,000 and your six months' work into the ash-can, and if you do not like that you can lump it."

Does Deputy Moore consider that that is a reasonable attitude for any responsible Minister to take up, or is he going to allow himself to be led by the nose into endorsing a proposal which he himself must know is contrary to the most elementary principles of justice? The Minister does not make any defence of it himself. His only defence is to proceed to shake his gory locks at us and to say that it is the duty of these people to put up an acceptable amalgamation scheme. One's mind goes back to the happy days of the school-yard, when you said "Yah" and did something else and refused to play.

Comment on this

The Minister said that it is undesirable that a restriction of the kind suggested in this amendment should be placed under him—the restriction being that he should give the reasons for his refusal to approve of the scheme. Beyond stating that it was undesirable to place that restriction on the Minister, he has given the House no reasons. Can we have the reasons from the Minister why he thinks, at least, that it is undesirable that this restriction should be imposed on the Minister?

Comment on this

Because the obligation rests on the companies to put up an acceptable scheme.

Comment on this

The obligation of what?

Comment on this

Of devising the scheme.

Comment on this

How is that a logical deduction?

Comment on this

How are the companies to know what is moving in the Ministerial mind if the Minister announces that he himself will not reveal what is moving in the Ministerial mind? Is it suggested that they should employ a clairvoyant, that they should read the Minister's palm, or cast his horoscope, when they want to know his reasons for rejecting the scheme? The Minister says that he objects to this restriction because the obligation should devolve on the companies to put up a scheme. In other words, the obligation is on them to tell him why he objects. How can they tell him that? Words cease to have any meaning if they are to be employed in the way the Minister is employing them. In the name of Providence, how can it devolve on the promoting companies to tell themselves what they do not know?

Comment on this

Particularly as the Minister may employ a Norwegian or Japanese expert, according to what he said yesterday.

Comment on this

This section contains all the junk which we have been discussing for the last ten minutes or more, and it is a source of astonishment to me that the Minister could possibly stand firm on a section of this kind without expressing his readiness to consider any of the points that have been raised in connection with the section. We are asking for no substantial concessions, except such as the barest commonsense demands, and I think the Minister ought to give some indication that he is prepared to consider the recommendations we made.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 85:—

In sub-section (2) (c), line 19, to delete all words after the word "directs" down to and including the word "particulars", line 26, and substitute the words: "give public notice of the scheme by advertisement in Iris Oifigiúil and in two of the principal daily newspapers published in Saorstát Eireann, and every such advertisement shall contain the following particulars”.

Comment on this

Strange as it may appear, I am prepared to agree with the Deputy in this amendment——

Comment on this

There must be something wrong with it if the Minister agrees with it.

Comment on this

——and if the Deputy will leave it over to the next stage I may be able to produce a similar amendment.

Comment on this

The same applies to amendment No. 86.

Comment on this

On the understanding that the Minister will introduce similar amendments on the Report Stage?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

Sections 27 and 28 hang together, the general effect being to give policy-holders an opportunity of intervening. What are the expenses likely to be in a suit of this character? The promoting company must first meet all the expenses of the Ministerial investigation, no matter how long that goes on, and without limit as to what these expenses may be. The company then has to go into court.

Comment on this

Not necessarily; that may be done by the Minister.

Comment on this

As I want to be clear on this point I must trouble the House in regard to it, because it is open to grave abuse. Sections 27 and 28 construct procedure designed to give policy-holders power, the object being to seek further particulars. Ordinarily that looks like an unobjectionable right, but it leaves companies, particularly companies reputed to be well off, open to blackmail. Supposing a conspiracy is sponsored by a shyster lawyer who gets a couple of hundred policy-holders to give him a brief to raise an objection to a scheme of amalgamation. What might happen is that he could go to an insurance company and say: "Now, gentlemen, there is six months' litigation, and you are going to fight every day of it. If you do not want to fight, it will cost you £2,000. What about it?" The company may say "No." He is delighted, goes to court, and the company stays in the High Court perhaps for 2½ years, while the battle is hanging fire, going eventually to the Supreme Court. Assume the position of an Irish company. If a lawyer could get, say 150 policy holders and tell them that he could raise 150 objections to a scheme, he could tell a company that it would cost £2,500 unless it was settled. What could the company do? Supposing that challenge is put up to a small company, it may not be able to fight, and a potential blackmailer might know that. Deputies may think that that is highly improbable, but I saw it happen in the City of Chicago, only that, instead of an insurance company, it happened to be the Chicago Corporation that was concerned. I saw a fictitious suit raised by a lawyer, in which a couple of thousand people were concerned. He told them that he would get something for them. He went to the Corporation and said that 50,000 dollars would settle the matter, provided it was left to him to make the distribution amongst the claimants. In fact the claimants got 500 dollars between them and he got the balance. If the Corporation was not prepared to put up the money——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy indicate to the Chair where court proceedings will arise on this section?

Comment on this

Supposing 150 policy-holders make separate objections to the scheme.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On Section 28?

Comment on this

Sections 27 and 28 hang together and I understood that I had leave to discuss both.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy suggesting?

Comment on this

I am not in a position to make a suggestion, but what I think is probably better is that the Minister in some way should move in a scheme of this kind. The matter will have to be considered carefully. You do not want to exclude genuine objections being raised in court, but in the same way you do not want to assume that the provisions will be used for blackmail. The analogy I mentioned is sufficient warning of the abuse that might arise unless there is provision to avoid that.

Comment on this

Is it the intention that every scheme approved by the Minister should be brought to the court? I direct attention to the fact that the word "may" appears in Section 27 and not "shall." Will the Minister look into the point?

Comment on this

I will look into it. Certainly it does not carry out the intention of the Minister.

Comment on this

What is the necessity in sub-section (2) of directing that a certified copy of the scheme is to be served on the Minister? What is the point of adding further expense? Surely the Minister will have every document dealing with this scheme and the fullest information, and be represented through solicitor and counsel in the court proceedings. What is the object behind the sub-section? It creates expense.

Comment on this

The expense is not considerable. It may be modified.

Comment on this

I want to know what is the object of creating in something to which there is not very great objection a criminal offence?

Comment on this

It is desirable that, a copy of the scheme and the court order should be furnished to the Minister as well as to the registrar.

Comment on this

But why make it a criminal offence?

Comment on this

There must be some obligation and some sanctions if that is not done.

Comment on this

The Minister could get for a few shillings a certified copy of the court order. It will not be a very big obligation on the amalgamated company to do that, but why create an offence? I have no very serious objection to it, and only want to know the point behind it. I take it that there is no point in principle.

Comment on this

The section says that it is to be lodged with the Department.

Comment on this

There is no principle involved.

Comment on this

There is, of course. Surely people should be allowed to dispose of their own business with the least possible interference.

Comment on this

This is an approved scheme in which the Minister is concerned.

Comment on this

It cannot be kept from the Minister. There is no question of any secrecy. The Minister could get a copy of the order for a few shillings. Yet we get all the paraphernalia and £50 of a fine.

Comment on this

There is a continuing offence for every day.

Comment on this

I want to put the obligation on these people to do this, and we must have some sanctions in case they do not. Does the Deputy consider the fine too high?

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider £5 of a fine?

Comment on this

I am prepared to consider anything. I have no very definite opinion as to what the figure should be.

Comment on this

It would probably meet my view if you knocked out the words which make it a continuing offence and increased the penalty at the discretion of the district justice. There is a continuing offence where there may possibly be a difficulty in getting an order from the court or something of that kind.

Comment on this

Documents must be lodged with the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies, and the mere collection of a fine, if they were not lodged, would be no alternative.

Comment on this

We do not agree to the extension of the criminal code without some reason. Does the Minister apprehend that there will be any great difficulty here?

Comment on this

The obligation must be on the company. It is not on the Minister.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this

Because it is being put on the company.

Comment on this

Why should the obligation be put on the company? The matter will be sanctioned and the documents will be in a particular form, and Deputy Costello's argument on that is to get a certified copy. Why should not the obligation be the other way?

Comment on this

It is intended that a new company starting off should lodge these documents with the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies.

Comment on this

Once it does that, has not the Minister as ready an access to the Registrar as anybody else?

Comment on this

Having regard to the circumstance that the Minister is in association with the scheme in the period preceding the order of the court, I think it is desirable that the company should be required to lodge the document with the Minister also.

Comment on this

Desirable, yes, but you make it compulsory.

Comment on this

There is another point in connection with this section. It is a criminal offence under this sub-section to fail to deliver a certified copy of the scheme. The obligation under the sub-section is to deliver a certified copy of the scheme. Who is to certify it, or what is a certified copy of the scheme?

Comment on this

Certified by the court.

Comment on this

The court does not certify a copy of the scheme.

Comment on this

A certified copy of the scheme as confirmed by the court.

Comment on this

Certified by whom? This is a criminal offence and a certain amount of clarity should be insisted on.

Comment on this

Can anyone tell us by whom the copy is to be certified, in the event of there being a statutory obligation on me, involving me in a penalty of £50 and a fine of £1 for every day that I fail to furnish a certified copy? Surely the legislators of this country are entitled respectfully to ask of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that he would be gracious enough to say, when he asks for a certified copy, who he expects to issue the certificate, or does he wish everybody in the country affected by the section to incur a liability of £1 for every day the Minister takes to make up his mind on the question of who is to certify the copy of the scheme.

Comment on this

It cannot be certified by the court.

Comment on this

Certified by the company—a certified copy of the scheme as confirmed by the court.

Comment on this

You are dealing with a criminal offence, and you impose an obligation to lodge a certified copy of the scheme as confirmed by the court and also a certified copy of the order of the court. There is a distinction drawn, even in the section, between a certified copy of the scheme and the certified copy of the order of the court. It does not say by whom the scheme is to be certified.

Comment on this

The Minister would be well advised to say that he has not the faintest notion as to who is to certify the copy of this scheme, but that he will look into it between now and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Can you not deal with more important matters in the Bill?

Comment on this

This is an important matter for anybody who has to lodge a certified copy of the scheme.

Comment on this

There is a fine of £50, with an additional fine of £1 for every day that the failure continues.

Comment on this

Surely the fact is that the Minister has not the vaguest notion as to who is to certify the copy of the scheme?

Comment on this

I do not care either, so long as there is a certified copy of the scheme lodged.

Comment on this

The Minister would be wise to say: "I have not the faintest notion as to who is to certify the copy but between now and the next stage of the Bill I shall make inquiries and let you know." When he sits like a mystic oracle of Delphi and refuses to give us any information, surely we cannot agree to a section which imposes a fine of £50 for failure to furnish a certified copy of the scheme?

Comment on this

The mystic oracles of Delphi gave answers occasionally.

Comment on this

I have been speaking all the week.

Comment on this

Our Minister remains silent and you can take what you like out of it. They were not always prophetic.

Comment on this

Under this section there is a restriction in regard to the application of the Act of 1909 to certain schemes. Perhaps the Minister would explain it.

Comment on this

I explained that already when we were discussing the general question of amalgamation. We are not interfering with the right of a Saorstát company to amalgamate or to transfer to another under this section of the Act of 1909.

Comment on this

I have already explained they can amalgamate but they cannot carry on business. The section, therefore, is of no use.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 88:

In page 22, line 11, before the word "shall" to insert the words "and no reduction in the share capital of any amalgamated company."

This section provides that no issue of share capital of any amalgamated company shall be made without the consent of the Minister for Finance, given after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I am rather interested to know whether it is possible for the amalgamated company to move to reduce the share capital without securing the consent of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. It seems to me to be desirable that a company with considerable liabilities should not be allowed to reduce its share capital without the approval of the Minister. The Minister is taking power to prevent a company from increasing its share capital, but it seems to me to be much more desirable to prevent it reducing its share capital having regard to its possible liabilities. I should like if he will say what reason he has for not taking power to prevent a company reducing its share capital without his consent.

Comment on this

The amendment is not necessary. The memorandum of the company, which must be approved of by the Minister for Finance, will set out the amount of the share capital, and the memorandum cannot be altered without his consent, so long as he holds any shares in the company.

Comment on this

Without the consent of the Minister for Finance?

Comment on this

Yes, so long as he holds any shares in the company.

Comment on this

Does not the First Schedule apply whether the Minister holds shares or not?

Comment on this

There may be some doubt about that, but it is not intended that these provisions should apply unless the Minister holds shares.

Comment on this

And the Minister will give the same consideration to Section 30 as he is giving to the First Schedule?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

Surely the answer given to Deputy Norton then is only relative?

Comment on this

Once he ceases to hold shares his responsibility for the shares of the company ceases.

Comment on this

Is Section 30 to be applicable only to an amalgamated company as long as the Minister holds shares in that company?

Comment on this

That is what I undertook to consider. The intention is that the Minister should have these powers over the affairs of the company only so long as he has shares in the company.

Comment on this

So long as he has a single share?

Comment on this

Yes. We are putting him in a more favourable position than an ordinary shareholder just as has been done in the case of certain other Acts. So long as he holds any share, he is given certain rights which an ordinary shareholder would not have.

Comment on this

The Minister says that the articles of association cannot be altered without his consent?

Comment on this

They cannot be altered without the consent of the Minister so long as he has shares.

Comment on this

And the memorandum will set out the amount of the share capital. It would seem that the memorandum is likely to contain a provision that the share capital of the company will be fixed at a certain amount. If that is embodied in the articles of association, would not the Minister's consent be required before any increase in the share capital can be made?

Comment on this

This is an issue of share capital to the public. It might not involve an increase of capital. The whole of the capital of the company might not be paid up.

Comment on this

Is it not possible for the company to decide at a later stage to increase the share capital?

Comment on this

We are providing in this section for the issue of shares to the public without the consent of the Minister.

Comment on this

Share capital cannot be reduced without the court coming in, ordinarily. I understand from the Minister that Section 30, in regard to the issue of capital, is only going to apply in relation to a company in which the Minister for Finance has shares and as long as he has shares.

Comment on this

Is the Minister proposing to limit his powers under Section 30 to companies in which the Minister for the time being is interested and no others?

Comment on this

No. As soon as the Minister ceases to hold shares, he has no longer any responsibility in respect of the conduct of the company's affairs.

Comment on this

Are his powers related to the possession of a certain amount of capital or to possession of a single share?

Comment on this

He will have those powers so long as he holds any shares.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is amendment No. 88 withdrawn?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Withdrawn in relation to the amendment that is to be brought into Section 30. As Section 30 stands, there is nothing which prevents the impact of the Minister for Finance on a company. He, apparently, comes into every amalgamated company, and I think the Minister intended to prevent his coming in save during the time he holds shares.

Comment on this

A qualification of the powers to this extent may be necessary: it may be necessary to prevent the issue of share capital by an amalgamated company if the Minister is about to take shares in it. As to the general position, this section should only apply to a company amalgamated under this part of the Bill, and these powers of control should only operate so long as the Minister has shares in the company.

Comment on this

Amalgamation under this part of the Bill does not mean amalgamation under the Act of 1909?

Comment on this

It is intended that it should not.

Comment on this

I should like to refer to the First Schedule. As I had read the first part of the Schedule, I thought it referred to something about the making of deposits and not bothering about what happened to the deposits afterwards. I thought the Minister for Finance only came in on the first publication of the memorandum and articles. I gathered from the Minister's remarks that, in the case of any change, he has also to be referred to. Is there any precise phrase with regard to changes or is that provision supposed to be carried by formula (1) of the First Schedule?

Comment on this

It is supposed to be carried by (1).

Comment on this

The reference to the memorandum and articles mean these and any change?

Comment on this

Is it intended that the Minister for Finance should control the memorandum and articles of association throughout the whole period he is a shareholder of the company?

Comment on this

He will have to consent to any change.

Comment on this

Surely this is dealt with in Section 37.

Comment on this

That is precise, while Section 30 is general.

Comment on this

The intention is that the Minister will make the principle which is enshrined in Section 37 cover the whole of these interference proposals?

Comment on this

Yes, the same as in the Agricultural Credit Act and other Acts under which the Minister has power to invest in shares.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 91:

At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—

(3) Immediately after the end of every year the Minister for Finance shall submit to both Houses of the Oireachtas a report setting out particulars of the transactions which have taken place under this section and the next succeeding six sections of this Act.

The section provides for certain underwriting and subscription of shares in amalgamated companies by the Minister for Finance. The Minister is empowered under this section and subsequent sections to utilise moneys from the Central Fund for the purpose of subscribing for shares in certain companies under this part of the Bill. He is also entitled to receive dividends and bonuses. Not only is he entitled to hold shares, but he is entitled to sell shares from time to time. Generally speaking, he enters into such a relationship as makes him practically a stockbroker for the amalgamated company. If there are a number of amalgamations and the Minister is going to sell shares from time to time and buy additional shares, quite a considerable number of transactions will take place. Since the moneys of the State will be utilised for these transactions, I think the House should have from the Minister each year a report setting out particulars of the transactions which have taken place, so that the House may know the extent to which the Minister is participating actively in the shareholding affairs of the amalgamated company. The amendment will not impose any onerous task on the Minister. All that is required is that he should report to the House the extent and the precise nature of his activities under Section 31.

Comment on this

I suggest that this amendment is not necessary. There is already an obligation on the Minister for Finance to furnish to the House accounts of all payments into and out of public funds. Under another section of this Bill the accounts of the amalgamated company must be laid before the House. When that is done the House will have adequate information under this section.

Comment on this

I do not think that the House will get adequate information from the accounts of the amalgamated company.

Comment on this

And the accounts which the Minister for Finance must publish annually.

Comment on this

I think the Minister ought to go further than publication of the finance accounts.

Comment on this

That would be giving precisely the same information.

Comment on this

My view is that the report the Minister would make would be more detailed and informative than a balance sheet.

Comment on this

In addition to the reports which the Minister for Finance must publish, the balance sheet and profit and loss account of the companies must be laid on the Table under Section 38.

Comment on this

I suggest that we will not get in the balance sheet of an amalgamated company the kind of information which we would get in a report by the Minister, nor will we get sufficient particulars in the returns by the Department of Finance.

Comment on this

The Deputy will get in these reports all the particulars he asks for in his amendment.

Comment on this

I ask for a report setting out particulars of the transactions which have taken place. I have in mind a report which would give information somewhat different from that to be obtained by the perusal of a balance sheet of an amalgamated company. There is no indication that we will get in that way from the Minister information which the House would require as to the extent of his association with the company and the type of transactions he has entered into.

Comment on this

Particulars of all transactions involving payments into or out of public funds must be published by the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

Not under Section 38.

Comment on this

No, under the general statutes.

Comment on this

Have we not found that these reports are generally issued 18 months after the event.

Comment on this

Sometimes there are delays in connection with the report of the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

That is generally two years old when published.

Comment on this

The ordinary Revenue Accounts are published fairly expeditiously.

Comment on this

Well over a year afterwards. I thought Deputy Norton was seeking to get a report precisely relating to these sections—not so much a balance sheet as accounts of what the Minister has done.

Comment on this

I want more information as to what the Minister has done than is usually disclosed by a balance sheet.

Comment on this

The Deputy asks in his amendment for "particulars of the transactions" which have taken place under this section and succeeding sections.

Comment on this

I thought what the Deputy wanted was information as to changes in the articles or memo, whether these had been made with the Minister's consent and so forth.

Comment on this

And particulars of the bonuses and dividends received.

Comment on this

When we put people into a favourable position, as we are intending to do in this case, the consideration the country demands for that favour is publicity. The Minister for Finance is being given a certain association with certain companies. That is supposed to be for the benefit of these companies. The House is asked to agree to that as a matter of parliamentary regulation. Why, then, should the House not get more information than is contained in ordinary accounts?

Comment on this

There will be the same publicity as there is in connection with similar transactions under the Sugar Act, the Industrial Alcohol Acts and the Agricultural Credit Acts.

Comment on this

Take the case of the electricity undertaking.

Comment on this

That is different. The Minister has no shares in that.

Comment on this

They got a loan and State credit. They were supposed to run the undertaking and make it pay, and they were given power to charge in a particular way. They are obliged to have their accounts audited by an auditor and accountant, and the Minister appoints that auditor and accountant, while the Electricity Supply Board pay him. The Minister makes a report. That is a way of drawing attention to what has happened, and it leaves the Minister open to criticism if he does not report year after year on any things that are peculiar.

Comment on this

I do not think that the Deputy is correct in saying that the Minister reports on the Electricity Supply Board operations.

Comment on this

No, but the Minister adds his comments and, if he did not add his comments, he would be subject to criticism. The Minister for Finance is placed in a peculiar position under this Bill. Why should he not report, earlier than the time for the ordinary presentation of the finance accounts, on his activities in this connection? There will not be a lot of work about it. I do not believe that the Minister will be a shareholder in any of these amalgamations for a very long time. He will, I suppose, divert things in a particular way and then clear out. It is a good thing to keep to that principle, that when you give people certain advantages, the consideration to the country and to this House is publicity.

Comment on this

I am not anxious to avoid publicity. We are providing for publicity so far as the accounts of the company are concerned.

Comment on this

These will not be ready until six months after the event, and will not be tabled for a further period.

Comment on this

I do not know that the Department of Finance would be any more expeditious in preparing its report.

Comment on this

I move to report progress.

Comment on this