We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Insurance Bill, 1935—Recommittal (Resumed).

Contributions 1–167 of 326. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Insurance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 35 of 1935 ›

I would like to hear the case that the Minister has to make against this amendment.

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

I have nothing to add to what I said on Friday last.

Comment on this

In resisting this amendment on the last day, the Minister said that he thought it was unnecessary. He said that if the House wanted any information Deputies could look at the balance sheets of the amalgamated company, and might also get a copy of the statement of transactions issued by the Minister for Finance as part of the arrangement for recording financial transactions by him. I suggest to the Minister for Industry and Commerce that that is not giving the House the adequate information which I desire in this amendment. We have had the experience that in recent years State moneys have been put into certain industries with calamitous effects so far as the State's investments were concerned. We have had examples of that under the Trade Loan (Guarantee) Act under which money was put into private companies, and we know what has happened both to the companies and to the State moneys. We had another example some years ago when the Industrial Trust Company was established into which the State put a substantial sum of money. Almost the first thing that the House heard of that company was that its shares were quoted at less than a shilling. I think if the House could get information of the kind that I desire in this amendment——

Comment on this

Section 38 provides that it will.

Comment on this

——It does not provide for the kind of information that I want in this amendment. Section 38 deals with the obligation on the amalgamted company to furnish balance sheets, etc. That does not satisfy the purposes of this amendment. The object of my amendment is "that the Minister for Finance shall submit to both Houses of the Oireachtas a report setting out particulars of the transactions which have taken place under this section and the next succeeding six sections of this Act." That is much more than the balance sheet of the amalgamated company. I think we are entitled, when State moneys are being used for the purpose indicated in Section 31 and the immediately following sections, to have much more information from the Minister merely than the balance sheet of the amalgamated company.

Comment on this

Section 38 provides for more information than the balance sheet.

Comment on this

It does not provide for what I want, namely, a full report setting out particulars of the transactions which have taken place under Sections 31 to 36, inclusive; that is, particulars of the moneys that went out of the central fund, what dividends the Minister received on these moneys, if any, and what way the Minister exercised his power as a shareholder, what shares he got, what shares he sold, and, generally, how his transactions stand under these sections.

Comment on this

All that information must be given to the Dáil under the existing law.

Comment on this

I do not think it will be given to the Dáil under the existing law in the manner I suggest. The Minister has not told us in what way it will be given.

Comment on this

All particulars of the issues from the Exchequer, all particulars of the receipts into the Exchequer, and similar information must be furnished under the Finance Acts to the Dáil, and will be so furnished.

Comment on this
Mr. Bourke

Where did the Minister get the figure of £500,000? Is there any particular reason for inserting it?

Comment on this

That is put in as the overriding maximum obligation which the State may undertake. It is probable that that figure may not be reached. The reason it appears in the Bill, is that if it should at any stage become desirable to increase it, fresh legislation will be required, and the Dáil will be consulted in that connection.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Dillon I move amendment No. 92:—

In sub-section (4), line 39, to delete the words "and other officer."

The object is to provide that only responsible officials of the company, who are handling matters like balance sheets and the other documents mentioned, should be made criminally liable. The only point I understand is to fix liability upon the responsible officials, and not to bring ordinary employees into the net of the criminal law.

Comment on this

I think the insertion of words in another amendment makes this unnecessary. The effect of the amendment is that an officer must knowingly and wilfully have authorised and permitted the default in order to be liable, and it must be capable of demonstration against him that the default was committed by him knowingly and wilfully.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Dillon I move amendment No. 93:—

In line 5, page 24, after the words "present or past" to insert the words "being a date after the commencement of this Part of this Act."

This amendment is merely a drafting amendment to make the section clearer, as far as I understand it.

Comment on this

It is necessary that the section should remain as drafted. The section enables the Minister to deal with a state of insolvency arising before the commencement of the Act, but only disclosed in the accounts relating to the period received after the commencement of the Act. If the amendment were inserted it would prevent the Minister acting on information disclosed by such accounts. If the change proposed were effected, the Minister would, presumably, have to wait until the accounts relating to a period subsequent to the passage of the Act were received, whereas we may get at an early stage, under the Act, accounts relating to a period prior to the passage of the Act revealing, in relation to the company submitting the accounts, a state of insolvency upon which action would have to be taken.

Comment on this

I think the section as it stands might be open to the construction that a company which, at the moment of investigation, was, in fact, solvent, could be declared insolvent in respect of a period when it might have been insolvent before the passing of the Act, but which company had recovered itself in the intervening time.

Comment on this

I shall look into the section and see if there is any possibility of that interpretation being put upon it. The intention is to provide that we can act upon accounts furnished, even though the accounts furnished in the first instance may relate, and probably will relate, to a period preceding the passage of the Act.

Comment on this

It is not intended to go back and look for insolvency, in other words?

Comment on this

No. The accounts for a particular period might not come in for nine months after the year concluded. These accounts might show insolvency existing and on these we would have to act, but the actual period during which the insolvency arose may be the period immediately preceding the passage of the Act. I think the only point that arises is that which Deputy Costello raised, to make it clear that we are not taking power to go back over some period past and gone for the purpose of taking action against a company by reason of some insolvency then existing which has since disappeared. It is not so intended. The intention is only to take action when and as soon as a state of insolvency is disclosed in the accounts.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Dillon I move amendment No. 94:—

In page 24, at the end of line 14, to insert the following proviso:—

"provided that the Minister shall not during the first five years after the commencement of this Part of this Act present any such petition if he is satisfied that substantial measures are being taken to improve the financial condition of the company."

I think the object of the amendment is to provide a period during which the Minister could, if he thought fit, nurse a company that is not perhaps in as healthy condition as the Minister might like it to be; that if he thought, by gentle handling of the situation, it could be brought around, he would have a chance of giving the company an opportunity of getting on its legs during the period mentioned in the amendment.

Comment on this

This is a matter that we discussed to some extent on an earlier amendment. It raises again the question of the proper attitude for the Government to adopt. If there is a company which is insolvent there is surely on the Department of State concerned the responsibility to see that the company does not enter into new liabilities to the public. Although I am naturally anxious to ensure that Irish companies which are say on the border-line at the moment should be given a reasonable opportunity of making good, if they have within them the elements which will enable them to do so, at the same time, we should, on the face of the statute, have power to deal with an insolvent company under this part of the Act if we cannot deal with it under the earlier provisions. The intention would be to ensure that measures had been taken to rectify the position of a company known to be insolvent, or of doubtful solvency, before the Act had come into operation at all. If we do not succeed in doing that, if, for reasons which we cannot see at the moment, it became impossible to rectify the position of a company of doubtful solvency, then when the Act came into operation I think we would have to have power to say that this insolvent company must not enter into new liabilities. It is unfair to the public to allow it to do so.

Comment on this
Mr. Bourke

There is no limitation on the number of inspectors to be appointed under sub-section (4), and, under sub-section (6), the companies are called upon to pay for the expenses of inspection. I think that is rather rough. In the English Act, I think the companies are called upon to pay only a proportion of the expenses, and I think that to make them pay for something in which they are not interested and which they do not invite themselves is rather hard. I should like an undertaking that there will be some limitation put on the number of inspectors and that we will not have three or four different men going around the country and running up a huge bill against a company which that company will have to meet.

Comment on this

I think this section is in the usual form. It is not intended to have more than the minimum number of inspectors necessary to enable the provisions of the Act to be carried out. I think the Deputy may be assured that there will be no attempt to appoint unnecessary inspectors under the sub-section, but, in sub-section (6) it is not specifically stated that the company must pay. It gives the Minister power to apply to the High Court for an order, which the High Court, if it thinks fit, can make, requiring the company to pay.

Comment on this

I should like to direct the Minister's attention to a point which I raised on an earlier section in connection with the use of the words "apply in the summary manner." It is not a matter I am interested in at all, but it would be better if the matter were cleared up.

Comment on this

I undertook to have that point looked into in connection with an earlier section.

Comment on this

It arises two or three times on this section.

Comment on this

The question of fees would not arise on this.

Comment on this

No, but the question of who you would make a party to the thing would arise.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It seems to me that amendments Nos. 95 and 96 are covered by amendment No. 14, which dealt with agents.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I am not terribly interested in it, but it did not strike me that amendment No. 95 was covered by any previous amendment. There is no question here of a licence. The proposal here is that the word "collector" be done away with and the word "agent" substituted.

Comment on this

With the same definition of the person?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy has any point to make, he may, of course, move the amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I move amendment No. 95:—

In line 16 to delete the word "collector" and substitute therefor the word "agent" and in line 23 to delete the words "a collector" and substitute the words "an agent."

It did not occur to me that this involved the question of a licence. The word "agent" is used occasionally through the Bill.

Comment on this

This part of the Bill relates entirely to industrial insurance, and it is obviously important in relation to industrial insurance that the collection should be carried out by means of a collector calling at the house of the insured person to collect weekly contributions.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Yes, but whether you call him agent or collector makes no difference. I do not know why the word "collector" is retained. I put this amendment down more or less on my own. I do not know that the collectors themselves are terribly keen on it, but, to my mind, the word "collector" conveys the idea of somebody who is going around looking for something for nothing.

Comment on this

The meaning of the word for the purposes of this Bill is as set out in the second sentence of the section, that "collector" means a person, however remunerated, who makes house to house visits for the purpose of receiving premiums payable on policies of industrial insurance, and includes a deputy of, or substitute for, any such person, and so forth. No matter what you call him, so long as you maintain the definition, you get the same result.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Why is there such keenness on keeping that particular name?

Comment on this

It is the one that is in common use.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I do not think that improves it.

Comment on this

Look at all the consequential amendments we should have to make if we made the change now.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I move amendment No. 97.

To delete line 19.

I do not know whether this deletion would secure exactly what I am after. It has been suggested that the practice has grown up in some offices of persons in the managerial end getting hold of vacant books as books fall in to the company, and putting themselves down as the collectors or agents, and then employing another person to make the collections at a much lesser commission than the ordinary commission allowed, and pocketing the difference. I am not quite satisfied that my amendment would succeed in bringing about the abolition of that practice, but it is certainly objectionable that persons, who could in no way be considered collectors, should get hold of books, put themselves down as the nominal collectors, and employ persons at a much smaller wage to collect premiums and pocket the differences. It is very unfair to the ordinary collecting staff.

Comment on this

I want to support Deputy Lynch in that matter, because I understand the practice to which he refers of farming out books does operate pretty extensively, and it is a highly undesirable practice. In that connection I want to direct the attention of the Minister to Section 70 (1), by which the appointment of a deputy to the collector is not allowed. There, neither an industrial assurance company nor any person employed by any such company shall employ any person who is not in the regular employment of such company to procure or endeavour to procure any person to enter into a contract of industrial insurance.

Comment on this

I think there is some misunderstanding, and it is just as well to clear it up. My recollection is that this line did not appear in the Bill as originally drafted. The change was effected at the request of the insurance companies who represented that otherwise the definition of "collector" would be too tight, and that it might sometimes happen that a collector, through illness or other temporary cause, would be unable to carry out his duties, and that the actual work of making the collection over a period might be carried out for him by his wife or some other member of his family, and consequently it was necessary to have a certain loosening of the definition to permit of that being done. That is the sole reason for the insertion of the amendment—to enable in such circumstances the work of the collector to be done by a temporary substitute for him during a period of illness or absence for any period through any cause for which he was unable to do the work himself.

Comment on this

The trouble seems to be to get something between what the Minister is aiming at and what Deputy Lynch is aiming at. I quite agree that if Deputy Lynch's amendment were accepted as it stands, it would probably rule out what the Minister had in mind. I was going to make that point myself, because it fairly frequently happens that an agent, through illness or some other valid reason, may have to get a member of his family or a friend to collect the book for a week, two weeks or three weeks, but while that is so, there is certainly good ground for the statements by Deputy Lynch and Deputy Dillon as to abuses under which books are farmed out, and, where the remuneration is 20 per cent., the person who actually does the work gets 12½ per cent. or 15 per cent., while the person who nominally holds the agency or collectorship pockets the remainder. That is very unfair. Perhaps the Minister would say whether he considers the definition in the section sufficiently wide. I am not satisfied that the definition of "collector" is sufficiently wide. Of course, the person collecting does a good deal more than receiving premiums. If he were to do only that, his remuneration at the end of the week would probably be very small.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Better raise that on the section.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister if he can meet that point, while safeguarding the person who would have to employ a substitute during illness. I realise that it is very difficult.

Comment on this

That is precisely my point. I do not want to toss the ball back to the Deputy. I think it would be very difficult to frame an amendment which would permit the carrying on of a collector's duties by his wife or some member of his family during his illness, while nevertheless ruling out the evil of farming out to which the Deputy has referred. I invite the Deputy and his friends to consider what amendment they would suggest. I am prepared to consider such an amendment if it can be devised so as to serve the two purposes. I think, however, that considerable difficulty will be found in that.

Comment on this

Might I suggest a line of thought which the Minister might consider? If words were inserted to say "without cause stated with the Minister's approval", I could then imagine the collector giving a note to his deputy asking him to act; the deputy bringing it down to the Department of Industry and Commerce at Lord Edward Street and getting a rubber stamp put on it.

Comment on this

If every time a collector got sick in the country, a note had to be stamped by the Department, the number of officials would have to be increased.

Comment on this

We have to consider the question of an agent working in rural Ireland. I do see very great difficulty and evil to be overcome, and I do imagine that some restriction of that kind might meet the situation even if prior approval was not required. Some kind of inspection will become inevitable if the class of persons acting as collectors is to be in any way restricted. If "a farmer"—as we will call the persons farming out books—habitually employs unauthorised persons, those persons could not have a certificate from him that they were collecting within the meaning of the amended sub-section. I suggest that if a collector wanted to appoint a deputy he should be obliged to give him a note or certificate that he was acting as his deputy for cause stated. In the event of somebody being found with a fraudulent note of that character steps might be taken to bring the person who issued it—and it would in fact be the farmer out of those books—to account for having issued a false certificate of the kind suggested.

Comment on this

I shall be only too glad to consider any suggestion.

Comment on this

On the section, I should just like to hear from the Minister if this definition covers a collector in canvassing for and obtaining business? It is not mentioned at all in this particular section.

Comment on this

It covers a collector, I think, for the purposes in connection with which the term "collector" is used in the part of the Bill. It may be that the person who acts as collector also carries on other duties on behalf of the company. "Collector" anywhere in connection with this part of the Bill is the definition of the term which relates to the duties of collector as set out in the Bill.

Comment on this

This section restricts the collector merely to the collecting of premiums.

Comment on this

No. The section does nothing except to define the word. The Deputy has got to relate that definition to some provision of the Bill where a difficulty might arise.

Comment on this

It seems to me that this section defines the work of collector as merely collecting premiums. The collector has far more important duties than merely collecting premiums.

Comment on this

Quite so, but wherever that arises you will find that the phrase used is "every collector and every person employed by an insurance company." There is some such amplification of the phrase used in any sub-section where it was necessary.

Comment on this

In this section it says:

The word "collector" means a person, howsoever remunerated, who makes house-to-house visits for the purpose of receiving premiums payable on policies of industrial assurance and includes a deputy or substitute for any such person, and also includes a person who holds any interest in a collecting-book.

It defines his duties.

Comment on this

It defines the term for the purposes of the Bill only. In other words, we set out there the sense in which that word is used throughout the Bill. Wherever in the course of the various sections we wish to refer to an agent of an insurance company who has other duties to perform, some other phrase is used.

Comment on this

Is it not, to say the least of it, very confusing, because whether you use the word "agent" or "collector" so far as industrial assurance is concerned it means the same thing? Every collector is an agent, and every agent is a collector, so far as I know, where industrial assurance is concerned. It is rather confusing, to say the least of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I should like to refer to the definition of "premium receipt book.""Collecting book" means any book or document issued by an industrial assurance company, and so on. The expression "premium receipt book" means any book or document in which acknowledgment of premiums payable in respect of a policy of industrial assurance is entered. I think it would be well to have the words "issued by an industrial assurance company" inserted there after the word "document" in line 26.

Comment on this

I will look into that point, but I think there may be some argument against it. If it is in fact a receipt book, no matter who issues it, it comes within that definition.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I do not think amendment No. 98 is necessary, because I think those persons have an insurable interest already.

Comment on this

That is true. The amendment is not necessary.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say what the position is in regard to amendment No. 99?

Comment on this

If the Deputy desires to effect that change the amendment is necessary. I am rather opposed to extending the degree of relationship.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 99:

In sub-section (1) (a) (i), line 53, before the word "step-parent" to insert the words "children-in-law."

I think there is a good case for the insertion of the amendment. I grant that, generally speaking, this is not a case which would arise very frequently, but one can easily visualise a position in which it would arise. I think very little more need be said in support of the amendment. It affects perhaps a small number of cases, but certainly there would be certain types of cases where it would be necessary.

Comment on this

Would Deputy Murphy tell us what are "children-in-law"? Can the Minister tell us what "children-in-law" are?

Comment on this

I am afraid I will not attempt to define Deputy Murphy's phrase. In any event, I think it would be undesirable to extend the degree of relationship. We might, perhaps, discuss this amendment with Deputy Lynch's amendment No. 100 in which the same principle arises. Deputy Lynch seeks to extend the definition to cover step-brother, step-sister, half-brother, half-sister, son-in-law or daughter-in-law. Under the existing law, policies to insure money to be paid for the funeral expenses of a parent, grand-parent, grand-child, brother or sister, may be issued by an insurance company, and we are proposing in the Bill to extend the permitted range of relationships to stepparents and step-children. In the first place, in relation to Deputy Lynch's amendment, it is unnecessary to give power to assure or validate an existing assurance in the case of half-brothers and half-sisters, since at present the whole blood is taken to include the half blood. They are already within the permitted degree of relationship. I am not quite clear what is meant by "step-brother." If by "step-brother" is meant anything other than "half-brother" then it can only mean children who have no common parent and who are related only because of the marriage of the father of one to the mother of the other, there being no blood relationship at all. I think it would be better not to permit these to insure the lives of one another.

The section, as it stands, provides, in our opinion, a sufficiently wide range of relationship, and there are many reasons why it might be undesirable to permit insurance on the lives of other relatives. Certainly, I think that if we got into the category which Deputy Murphy has in mind when he talks about children-in-law, we would be extending the range of relationship too widely altogether. That also applies to the two classes of "in-laws" to which Deputy Lynch refers in his amendment. Therefore, in relation to the three classes, firstly, it is not necessary to amend the Bill in order to cover half-brothers and half-sisters. Secondly, it is probably not necessary to extend the range to meet his point in relation to step-brothers and step-sisters where there is actual blood relationship between the people concerned, but if he means those who have no blood relationship, then I think the range should not be extended. On the general grounds on which it is desirable to restrict the degree of relationship within which people can insure the lives of one another, I should be disposed to resist any amendment to extend that degree further than we are doing in the Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Of course, I know that it is rather difficult, in the circumstances, to understand what is meant by step-brother and step-sister, and in the ordinary sense in which it is used in my part of the country it is probably more correctly now described as half-brother and half-sister. On this question of having no blood relationship, however, it might be different. I think that such classes would seem to be rather wide apart for insurable interest, but I think that is the same for every son-in-law or daughter-in-law and it might be objectionable if it were the other way around and the son-in-law should have an insurable interest in the mother-in-law. However, I think the amendment should be accepted. There is a case to be made, especially for these poor people who go in for this industrial insurance, who are very often young people living in the house with the old people, and I think a case could be made for their inclusion.

Comment on this

I would suggest to the Minister that it is rather restricted in (a) (ii) of Section 45, where it says: "Of an uncle or aunt of the person effecting the policy, where such uncle or aunt occupies the position of parent or guardian towards the said person effecting the policy." I suggest to the Minister that that might be a little wider because you have up and down the country a position where an uncle or an aunt is probably fairly advanced in years and, perhaps, an invalid, and where the uncle or aunt remains in the house and is maintained by a nephew or niece although they would not be in the position of a guardian to either the nephew or niece. That is quite a common occurrence. The uncle or aunt, as I say, is kept in the house and the responsibility for burying the uncle or aunt, when they die, eventually falls on the nephew or niece as the case may be. I think that is a sort of case which the Minister might attempt to meet.

Comment on this

I think we ought to clear our minds on this point. Deputy Murphy makes a reference to children-in-law. I do not know what that means, but now it seems that a distinction is being drawn between half-brothers and step-brothers or between half-sisters and step-sisters. That is a distinction I never heard drawn before, and I should like to know if the Minister has been advised that there is such a distinction.

Comment on this

I am not drawing the distinction. In fact the phrase in the Bill is "step-brother" or "step-sister," but it is intended to cover only the case of a blood relationship.

Comment on this

Well, suppose a man with a son and a woman with a daughter married. The girl and the boy then become step-brother and step-sister, do they not?

Comment on this

That is the phrase usually used to describe them but, in fact, they would not come within that definition.

Comment on this

They would not? Therefore the daughter would not be entitled to insure her mother's husband?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

Nor the son his father's wife?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

But the child of that marriage would have an insurable relationship with the son of the father and the daughter of the mother?

Comment on this

Well, as a matter of fact, I think I would have to work that out on paper before I could answer the Deputy. However, I can say that the general principle is that there should be no insurable interest except where there is blood relationship. That is the limitation in all statutes in connection with this, and I think it would be undesirable to extend the range within which people may insure the lives of one another to cover relationships other than blood relationships of one kind or another.

Comment on this

So that the child of that marriage would be able to insure either of the children of the two parents, and either of the children of the two parents would be able to insure the child of the marriage, but not one another.

Comment on this

Only if the other person occupied the position of parent or guardian. I take it that the child would be a nephew or niece of the elder children.

Comment on this

Well, perhaps the best rule is that, where there is a blood relationship, there will be insurable interest, and where there is no blood relationship there will be no insurable interest.

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Is the Minister prepared to accept the amendment?

Comment on this

I should be very reluctant to extend the classes of relationships to cover persons who are not blood relations. I think there is a fundamental objection to that and, therefore, I should prefer not to accept it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 101:—

In sub-section (1) (a), to delete the word "or" where it first occurs in line 54, and after the word "sister" to insert the words "legally adopted child, illegitimate son or daughter or ward".

I do not know whether the Minister in this Bill has dealt with the question of giving illegitimate children an insurable interest in their mothers, or mothers an insurable interest in illegitimate children.

Comment on this

At present the insurance of illegitimate children by mothers is permissible, and it is not necessary to amend the Bill in that respect. That is provided for even under the existing law.

Comment on this

There is a decision dealing with the insurable interest of illegitimate children in their mothers and by mothers in illegitimate children. I believe it was in a case of Morris v. Britannic Insurance Company. That is possible under existing law in Great Britain and, unless I am misled, that decision was based on the fact that in Great Britain the Adoption of Children Act, 1926, was passed, and in 1930 a similar Act was passed in respect to Scotland. No such Act has been passed in this country.

Comment on this

No; and I would be very reluctant to consider an amendment covering legally adopted children.

Comment on this

Am I to take it that after he has investigated the matter, if the Minister finds, in so far as the insurance of illegitimate children by mothers, or the insurance by illegitimate children of mothers is concerned, this provision is necessary he will take steps to deal with it?

Comment on this

I have looked into the matter and I am advised that the amendment is not necessary. An amendment of the Bill would be necessary to enable people to insure the lives of legally adopted children, but I do not think that change should be effected. Certainly I would be very reluctant to do it without having examined the question in greater detail.

Comment on this

I did not dwell on that, but I direct the Minister's attention to this: That if it is the established law in this country that illegitimate children can insure their mothers, or that the mothers can insure illegitimate children, that is founded on no more solid foundation than that such is the fact in Great Britain. In Great Britain that state of affairs is founded on the decision in Morris v. the Britannic Insurance Company, on which the Cohen Committee of 1932, adverting to that judgment, recommended that explicit legislation should be introduced to legalise that contract, inasmuch as they thought, apparently, that the judgment of the court might not stand the letter of the existing law if carried further. In any case there was a substantial doubt, and they recommended that the substance of that verdict should be incorporated in the law. I suggest, in view of that advice by the Cohen Committee to the British Legislature, it would be wise for us to incorporate the substance of that judgment in this Bill.

Comment on this

I will look into the point. I am advised that the amendment is not necessary to effect the Deputy's purpose, but if, on looking into it, I find amendment is required, it can be taken on the next stage. I think it is quite right that the mother should have the right to insure.

Comment on this

And the Minister will have regard to the reference made in the Cohen Committee's report?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 102:—

In sub-section (1) (a) (ii), line 57, after the word "guardian" to insert the words "for the time being".

In paragraph 3 an insurable interest is created in:

a nephew or niece of the person effecting the policy, where such person occupies the position of parent or guardian towards such nephew or niece.

I propose to add the words "for the time being". The suggestion apparently is that the insurable interest should exist only for the period during which the person stood in loco parentis to the niece or nephew, and when that relationship ceased, which I suppose would be when the niece or nephew attained their majority, the insurable interest would cease, and that any contract entered into subsequent to the relationship ceasing would be invalid.

Comment on this

The Deputy will appreciate that it would be impossible for a company to know whether such guardianship existed at the relevant time. I think the amendment would put a company in an impossible position.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider a case where an uncle or an aunt acted as guardian, and at a later period are maintained by the niece or nephew when they might have been a burden on the rates in a county home or be getting home assistance? That is quite a common case in the country, particularly with unmarried persons of advanced years. These people are very often kept at home by a niece or a nephew who accept responsibility for their burial. That is a type of case that the Minister might consider, because it is quite common.

Comment on this

I would be very slow to extend the provisions of the Bill. What we propose to do is to require relationship. The Bill provides that where an uncle or aunt occupies the position of parent or guardian of the persons effecting the insurance, that is legitimate, but if that relationship does not exist, it is not.

Comment on this

How is it to be determined whether there is the relationship of a guardian or not? How is an agent of a company to know that? Surely what will happen is that where a policy is sought to be taken out the agent will be informed by the niece or nephew that the uncle or aunt stands in the relationship of a guardian.

Comment on this

That could not happen where the parents are alive.

Comment on this

The case I have in mind is one where very often the parents would not be alive, and where the niece or the nephew would be maintaining an uncle or an aunt who might not be in the best of health. The uncle or aunt might be unmarried and would be taken into and maintained in the house. How is the relationship of guardian to be established there? Surely documentary proof would not have to be furnished by the person proposing to take out the policy?

Comment on this

There is an obligation on the company to satisfy itself that the case falls under the Act.

Comment on this

It must be remembered that we are dealing with industrial insurance and that the number of persons taking out policies on the lives of uncles or aunts standing in the relationship of a guardian would be very few. As a matter of fact, the majority of the people taking out industrial policies would not know the meaning of the word "guardian." We ought to get down to realities, because the case I mention is quite common. Industrial insurance is engaged in mainly by working-class people and by small farmers. If a niece or a nephew is a minor these people act as guardians, but when a niece or a nephew is of age and take control of their own households the insurable interest ceases, just at the time that it should be effective. I would like the Minister to undertake to look into this matter.

Comment on this

I will undertake to do that, but the Deputy understands my objection to extending the scope of the section.

Comment on this

It is not a question of extending it, because it is not going outside the blood relationship.

Comment on this

If the uncle or aunt is a guardian, then the insurable interest exists.

Comment on this

If they are not guardians?

Comment on this

Then I do not think it should exist.

Comment on this

I think the point I made is much more valuable.

Comment on this

It is quite true that the company illegally might issue a policy under the provisions of this part of the Bill, but in a later section provision is made for dealing with that situation if it arises.

Comment on this

My point is: how are you going to prove under this sub-section whether a person is in that relationship or not? You are dealing with ordinary working-class people and small farmers who go in for industrial insurance.

Comment on this

Am I to understand that I can on one Monday propose to take out a policy on, say, Aunt Matilda, who stands in the relationship of guardian, and that I can on the following Monday propose to take out a policy on Aunt Martha, who stands in the same relationship? Is there to be any standard of proof to establish that these people genuinely occupy the position of guardian towards me? As far as the insurance company is concerned it may be perfectly true that there should be a change of guardianship as between one Monday and another. What standard of guardianship is required?

Comment on this

I could not answer that question straight away. You mean what legal proof must a person produce?

Comment on this

To satisfy the company that they have not issued a policy ultra vires beyond saying that a policy was taken out on Aunt Matilda, who stood in the position of guardian, and that on the following Monday another one was taken out on another aunt, who stands in the same relationship.

Comment on this

There is another objection to this sub-section. This is opening up a new avenue of repudiation of policies by certain insurance companies, if they wish to do so. We know what has been happening with regard to ages. A person may take on an uncle or an aunt under this sub-section, if the person effecting the insurance says in reply to the agent, or if the agent puts on the proposal form, that the uncle or aunt stands in the relation of a guardian, and when the policy matures or comes to be paid, the company may repudiate it on the grounds that the insured person was not a guardian.

Comment on this

There are provisions in the Bill which will prevent that.

Comment on this

I want to suggest to the Minister that there are things done in industrial assurance which you could not possibly provide for in his Bill.

Comment on this

The amendment is really for the purpose of clearing up the position which would arise in the following circumstances:—A person comes into an insurance office and says on a given date "my Aunt Matilda is my guardian." The insurance company then is free to issue a policy of assurance. If three days later she ceases to be guardian and Aunt Martha takes up the running an insurance policy can be taken out in respect to Aunt Martha. Are the two policies legal?

Comment on this

If either aunt is in the position of guardian at the time the policy is taken out, it is a legal policy.

Comment on this

If that is so, the amendment is unnecessary.

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

By what process will it be established that they are guardians? Is it merely by word of mouth?

Comment on this

They will have to produce proof if the matter is questioned.

Comment on this

I have the best advice that the words "for the time being" are required, but if the Minister is satisfied with the section as it stands, I shall withdraw it.

Comment on this

The company must satisfy itself that the state of guardianship exists at the moment of the issuance of the policy.

Comment on this

And question it when a claim arises.

Comment on this

No. I think other provisions of the Bill will deal with that possibility.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I move amendment No. 104:

After sub-section (1) (a) (iii), page 27, line 3, to add a new sub-paragraph as follows:—

(iv) of a legal guardian effecting a policy on the life of a child who is maintained solely by the said guardian without fee or reward."

We inserted something like the converse of this amendment in the case of the Workmen's Compensation Act 1934, I think there is a good case for it. The type of person I have in mind is the person who takes in a youngster who has become an orphan. He may not be actually a blood relation, who would come within the other provisions of the Act, but on grounds of charity or because of friendship with the deceased parents, he takes in the child and rears it without fee or reward of any kind. That is not uncommon, as the Minister is fully aware. It is amongst people like that you will find the greatest charity. I think there is a case for the extension of the principle enshrined in the Workmen's Compensation Act covering such a case.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 109:—

In sub-section (2) line 13, after the word "shall" to insert the word "knowingly."

This raises a point that has arisen already in connection with other parts of the Bill. The sub-section provides that no industrial insurance company shall insure, or pay on a policy issued under paragraph (b) of the next preceding sub-section, etc. I desire to insert the word "knowingly" in order to afford to the company the defence that they did it unwittingly and that they had no intention of breaking the law. I do not want to elaborate at any great length the underlying argument because it has already been brought to the attention of the House on several occasions on other amendments. I should be glad to know if the Minister would be prepared to accept the word "knowingly" in this case.

Comment on this

I am afraid not. It would be extremely difficult, if not impossible, to prove that the action was done knowingly. If the insurance company issues an insurance or pays on a policy issued under paragraph (b), then I think the provisions of the sub-section ought to apply in any event.

Comment on this

The difficulty is this. This is a restriction on the insurance company insuring, or paying on a policy on the death of a person, any sum exceeding a reasonable amount for the expenses in connection with the death and funeral of such a person. The restriction is against paying a sum in excess of what would be reasonable to discharge the funeral expenses. Suppose that the deceased person has five children, each one of whom takes out a policy on the deceased person's life, each policy being for a reasonable sum, the difficulty immediately arises that the company is paying something in excess of what is reasonable on each of the policies that are paid out upon, after the first policy has been discharged. That is one difficulty where conscious willingness to break the law should be present before the company is penalised. The second difficulty is that an ostentatiously attired person may present himself or herself to effect an insurance, to insure the life of his or her parents for a sum out of all proportion to what is reasonable for the funeral requirements of a person in the station in life of such person.

One can imagine a person whose funeral expenses would be ordinarily discharged by £25 or £30 insuring for funeral expenses of £100—a sum which, for another person living in different circumstances, might be quite reasonable, within the terms of the Bill. When the company has taken all reasonable precautions to ascertain what the requirements for funeral expenses are likely to be, then, I do not think it should be penalised for having, in fact, accepted a proposal or paid out on a policy in excess of the expenses contemplated by the Bill. It is for that reason that I want to insert the word "knowingly," which would imply that the insurance company, recklessly or without making reasonable inquiry, issued what was obviously a fraudulent policy to cover funeral expenses. Unless the word "knowingly" is inserted, the insurance company, no matter what precautions they may have taken in fact, if misled into issuing an illegal policy under this section, would be liable to penalties.

Comment on this

The difficulty in that case would be to prove that the insurance company had acted "knowingly." It would be almost impossible to do that.

Comment on this

Then I suggest the word "wilfully," or "negligently," or some similar word should be inserted. The Minister would then be in a position to make the case in court that, if the most ordinary inquiries had been made, the company would have found out the circumstances of the person who insured.

Comment on this

The question that would arise would be as to whether the sum was reasonable or not, and not whether the company acted "knowingly,""wilfully," or without inquiry.

Comment on this

The difficulty would be to determine what would be a reasonable sum. What would be an adequate sum in a village or in a rural district where the relatives of the deceased had, as the phrase is in the country, "a grave of their own," would be completely inadequate in the City of Dublin, where interment would have to take place in Glasnevin. How is that question to be determined, and by whom?

Comment on this

It will be determined by practice in due course and it is, in fact, determined by practice at the present time.

Comment on this

While I admire the Minister's attempt to get after this question, I do not think that his attempt will succeed. There is nothing to prevent a person insuring either of his parents in four or five different companies for the same amount in each case. A person who might take out a substantial policy with one company might, in order to evade the provisions of the Bill, take out four or five policies with different companies.

Comment on this

The Minister is surely mistaken in saying that this provision is merely designed to prevent an insurance company paying out. It also prohibits the issue of a policy.

Comment on this

Which is an answer to Deputy Morrissey's point.

Comment on this

I am dealing with one point and Deputy Morrissey is dealing with a completely different point.

Comment on this

I am prepared to consider any proposal for tightening up the section in the manner suggested by Deputy Morrissey; but nothing would be achieved by adopting this amendment. The only question that arises is whether evasion of the intention of the section could be effected in the manner in which Deputy Morrissey suggests. It may be desirable that similar provisions to those in Section 46 (1) should be incorporated here, but I hardly think so. However, I shall look into that aspect of the question.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider the insertion of the words "wilfully" or "negligently" instead of "knowingly"?

Comment on this

Not until I am clear as to what the Deputy thinks such words would mean in that connection.

Comment on this

They would imply that where an insurance company had issued a policy in excess of a reasonable amount for funeral expenses, it would be immediately put upon its proof to show that sufficient inquiries had been made before it fell into that misfeasance.

Comment on this

The company does not commit an offence by merely issuing a policy.

Comment on this

The only question that arises is whether the amount was reasonable or not, and I think the section gives all the elasticity the Deputy desires. The question as to the issuing of the policy does not arise.

Comment on this

£25 might be regarded as the outside limit in a case in which a policy for £100 had been taken out. The company may admit, in the knowledge of the facts later revealed, that £100 is an unreasonable sum. All that would fall for the court to decide would be whether, when the policy was issued, the company took proper precautions as regards inquiry into the circumstances of the person concerned. The company must be in a position to show that they did that.

Comment on this

In the court, the only question would be as to whether the amount was reasonable or not.

Comment on this

That is as the section stands.

Comment on this

And as it should stand.

Comment on this

The company may say that they got this proposal and sent their representative to the residence of the person from whom it emanated. They found that person living in inexpensive surroundings, but they learned that she intended taking the remains of one of her parents to County Kerry and burying them there. The expense would, therefore, be out of the ordinary. Their case might be that they took every prudent precaution to satisfy themselves that this lady was entitled to insure for this sum. It later transpired that the parent was buried in Glasnevin, where the parties had been living, and that the whole expense did not come to £15, so that the insurer had £85 over and above the expense. The insurance company would say: "We admit in the light of the facts that this was an unreasonable sum, but we could not have known that when we issued the policy." I want the court to be able to say that the insurance company committed no fault——

Comment on this

In paying out on the policy?

Comment on this

——that when they issued a policy they felt they were justified in doing so and that the error could not be avoided.

Comment on this

Who is to decide in particular cases what is or what is not a reasonable amount for funeral expenses?

Comment on this

I suppose the court or the Minister.

Comment on this

There is nothing in the section about the court. It is a general prohibition and the whole thing is left at large.

Comment on this

I have been looking for the sanction for the last couple of minutes and I cannot find it, but I am sure it is somewhere in the Bill.

Comment on this

The insurance company is simply left to make up its mind, when issuing the policy, whether the amount is reasonable or not. At the end of the period, when the time comes to pay, somebody else may say that the amount is unreasonable and the company may not have to pay.

Comment on this

Let us assume that a person in the City of Dublin wants to insure his father, who is 65 years of age, for 1/- per week. The sum assured is £35. A person down in the County Kildare wants to insure, say, his father who is such an age at a premium of 1/- a week and the sum to be assured is £35. I suggest it would be held under this section that £35 in Kildare was an unreasonable sum as compared with the same sum in Dublin City. In law it would be held to be very unreasonable. What the insurance company would have to do under this section would be to say: "Very well, take 1/- for a premium in Dublin but the premium in Kildare will have to be 10d. in order to bring in the reduced amount that would be considered reasonable," and the figure would have to be something else in Cork and something else in Limerick and so on. It seems to me that the section deciding what is a reasonable or an unreasonable sum will be a difficult section to work.

Comment on this

The Minister has spoken about cases where the sum might be considered unreasonable. Very well, then let me suppose I insure a nautical uncle for £25. He takes to sea, the vessel sinks in mid-Atlantic and he is never heard of again. Am I not entitled to draw the amount of my policy? Surely if my uncle had sunk in mid-ocean there would be no funeral. Then am I entitled to draw anything for my policy?

Comment on this

"Reasonableness" must depend upon the circumstances at the time the policy was issued. But the policy is not an indemnity policy, and the question of the actual cost of the funeral does not arise.

Comment on this

Is there any similar provision to this in any of the English Acts?

Comment on this