We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Insurance Bill, 1935—Recommittal (Resumed).

Contributions 191–385 of 385. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Insurance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 35 of 1935 ›

What does the Deputy mean by a tariff company?

Comment on this

In the existing circumstances, it means a company engaged in the tariff ring in Great Britain, which is admitted to tariff treaties of reinsurance, and admitted to them on the basis of some agreement as to the premiums charged and the nature of the risks taken. Outside that, there is a considerable body of companies who negotiate their reinsurance with Lloyds or Continental reinsurance companies of one kind or another. If the Bill is passed, there is going to be compulsory reinsurance with the Reinsurance Corporation of Ireland, in so far as that corporation wants to take the risk. Is not that so?

Comment on this

Perhaps.

Comment on this

If Part VI of the Bill is put into force. The remainder of risks must be provided for as heretofore in one way or another. The British companies can, I assume, reinsure any balance which the Irish Reinsurance Corporation will not take with the tariff ring in England. Those Irish companies and other foreign companies who are not in the British tariff ring will reinsure part of their general business with the Irish Reinsurance Corporation.

Comment on this

I think all, or practically all, the Saorstát companies are tariff companies.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the new Irish Reinsurance Corporation is in the ring or not. The Hibernian is, of course, because it was a British company, and it has only recently been bought over by an Irish group of financiers within the last two or three years.

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with it. I think that, with the exception of one, they all are.

Comment on this

It was owned by a big British company, and the Minister knows that.

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

Yes, it has. It is brought into the tariff ring by the company which bought it.

Comment on this

It was a tariff company before it was bought.

Comment on this

What is the relevancy of that? It is merely a red herring which is being thrown in by the Minister to distract public attention from the fact that he is seeking powers which cannot be justified on any grounds, and seeking the right to fix premiums under the section we are discussing. He argued that this is necessary, because there will not be sufficient competition against the tariff bloc, and he says that the tariff bloc consists of 50 companies. I say that there will be seven companies outside of that, and to that proposition the Minister assents.

Comment on this

No; the figures are the Deputy's.

Comment on this

How many companies will there be outside the tariff ring when licences are issued under this Act?

Comment on this

I have no idea.

Comment on this

Nevertheless, the Minister is prepared to found his whole case for the powers in this section on the ground that there will not be sufficient competition against the tariff companies, but he has not got the faintest notion of how many tariff companies and how many non-tariff companies there are. That is the basis on which this section is being discussed, and the Minister himself says he has not the vaguest notion what the nature of the competition will be. Is it beginning to dawn on Deputy Moore that he is being led up the alley?

Comment on this

I did not think it would. However, my submission is and my figures stand until the Minister contradicts them, that out of the 57 companies eligible to do business under this Bill of a general and fire character, 50 will be in the tariff ring and seven outside. I say that these seven will provide adequate competition to keep premiums at a reasonable level from the point of view of the policy-holder. Therefore, the Minister ought not to have statutory power to fix premiums when no danger threatens the policy-holding public of this country. I allege that he wants that power simply for the purpose of facilitating him in a gradual regimentation of the insurance business, with a view to nationalising it, at the same time as he nationalises, or attempts to nationalise, a good many other commercial enterprises at present operating in this country, in order to go as far on the road to State socialism as he thinks it safe at any given moment to go. In my opinion, he will not get to first base, because he will be kicked out before he gets half way, but I believe this section is part of a general scheme to facilitate nationalisation of the insurance business, and that that itself is only one small part of a larger scheme to nationalise a wide scope of commercial activity in this country, which I look forward to seeing fail, and which I think the Minister is foolish enough to hope will succeed.

Comment on this

In my opinion, a minority of non-tariff companies would not in itself be sufficient security against impossible rates. It would depend entirely on the quality of those companies.

Comment on this

They are all guaranteed by the Government under this Bill.

Comment on this

It has always been the case that a non-tariff company is prepared to undercut, but that affects very little the business of the average tariff company. May I submit that whatever defect the section may have, the amendment would have many more defects? The amendment proposes to give the Minister power to fix rates with regard to two classes of insurance, insurance in respect of mechanically propelled vehicles and another class. With regard to insurance affecting mechanically propelled vehicles, it has very often been held, and, in fact, I think is generally held, by the companies doing that insurance, that it is not a paying proposition at all.

Comment on this

I have heard that gag, too, but they still go on doing it.

Comment on this

They do, and that is the point. If it is associated with other classes of insurance and if the Minister were to take power to fix premiums with regard to that class of insurance only, it would create a totally new situation for the companies. He would be creating a situation which would affect the general policy of the companies to a considerable extent, because it is the case, at present, that companies doing that class of business are prepared to lose on insurance affecting mechanically-propelled vehicles so long as they gain by insurance closely associated with it. If they are subject now to a fixed premium in respect of motor insurance it means that the Minister's interference must be directed towards making such insurance a paying proposition in itself. That is not a proposal that would be consistent with the Deputy's general criticism of the Bill. His general criticism of the Bill is that it may make insurance expensive. He has been pleading for the insurer, but the effect of his amendment would be probably to increase the rates of one particular class of insurance which affects a great number of people and an increasing number of people all over the country. I submit that, whatever defects the section may have, the amendment has much more serious defects.

Comment on this
Cecil Lavery Mr. Lavery

It occurs to me that possibly Deputy Moore has mistaken the meaning of the amendment. As I understand it, it is put forward, not as being advisable or desirable that the Minister should have power to fix rates for any class of insurance, but as being a lesser evil than the giving of comprehensive powers that the Minister should be authorised to fix rates for particular classes of insurance where a special case can be made. If that be right, Deputy Moore's argument falls to the ground.

Comment on this
Cecil Lavery Mr. Lavery

In the case of the two classes mentioned in the amendment, insurance in regard to mechanically-propelled vehicles and employers' liability insurance, there is in one case the absolute compulsion in law upon persons to cover themselves in respect of those risks, and, in the other, there is, if not an actual compulsion, a practical compulsion. By law, any person driving a mechanically-propelled vehicle is bound to cover himself with an insurance policy. An employer is practically bound, having regard to the Workmen's Compensation Act and the liabilities he has to his workmen, to cover himself with an insurance company against those risks. That being so, it might be urged, and, no doubt, would be if the section as a whole were to go, that a special case could be made for these two classes, but the object of the amendment is not to suggest that that is necessary. The object is to narrow the evil which a wide power embracing all classes of insurance would make for. I suggest it is a better principle to go upon to indicate the particular subjects to be covered rather than to give the Minister the widest power of fixing rates for all classes.

The undesirability of giving to the Minister, or to any Minister or Department, the power to fix matters which ordinarily ought to be regulated by free competition among companies and other bodies looking for business of a particular kind has been urged in other matters, and certainly I think it will be admitted that the ideal is to allow business to be conducted without State restriction and without State obligations being imposed upon the parties. I understand that the Minister is afraid that the competition in this case between insurance companies offering to cover risks will not be sufficient to bring rates to the level at which they ought to stand having regard to the risk involved. Does the Minister think that, by taking power to fix rates—presuming that a rates order would fix a maximum rate—he is going to remedy that state of affairs? After all, it is not proposed that fire insurance should be made compulsory on the individual, and it is certainly not proposed that insurance companies should be laid under a compulsion to cover any fire risk that is offered to them. I do not know how the situation should be met —how a particular person would feel he would be affected by a rates order if a rates order were fixed and if, as a result of that order, any insurance company refused to cover him at that risk. The position of that person then would be that he would have to go uninsured, I suggest.

I suppose there is no class of insurance in which more risks are involved, from the companies' point of view, than fire insurance. Some classes of property, possibly, go without fire insurance because they are not so much exposed to the danger of fire, but all classes of property or premises which are peculiarly vulnerable to fire risks are described by insurance companies as poor risks, and I do not know how the Minister is able to say that he believes demands should be met if he is going to say that a rate should be fixed and if the insurance company concerned is not to be free to say to a particular person: "We cannot cover you at such-and-such a rate, and if that rate exceeds the maximum then we cannot cover you at all." Apart from the merits or demerits of exercising State control in a matter of this kind, I really think that this is going to be a disservice to people who might be able to get cover, and that it is really going to leave them without the possibility of getting cover at all.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is amendment No. 182 withdrawn?

Comment on this

Has the Minister anything to say with regard to Deputy Lavery's point?

Comment on this

I think I dealt with that point already, and I do not like to speak about the same matter twice, if I can avoid it. However, I realise that there may be some difficulty in differentiating between cases, as Deputy Lavery has pointed out. At the same time, I think the power should be there — recognising, of course, that that power should only be used in very exceptional circumstances, and only where the actions of the insurance companies concerned would be such as would demand that drastic action should be taken to prevent the exploitation of policy-holders. I admit that I am not very definite about this power, but I think we should have it in regard to all classes of insurance except life business. I admit, however, that the application of these powers, if it should be necessary to use them, would be a difficult matter.

Comment on this
Cecil Lavery Mr. Lavery

Can the Minister give us an instance of this power in any other country?

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

I do not think there is any such power in any part of the world. However, with regard to what Deputy Lavery has suggested, would the Minister consider, between this and the next stage of the Bill, fixing a limitation of this power and confining it to a certain class of risk so that insurance companies would know where they stand? I think, from what the Minister has said, that he recognises the difficulties of fixing rates generally, and I think it would probably be very much to the advantage of the proposed policy-holders, and also of the companies concerned, that the power should be limited to certain specified classes of insurance policies.

Comment on this

But it is at the moment. The power is limited at the moment.

Comment on this

Yes, it is limited in the sense that the word "Iceland" is limited. However, there is a vast class of insurance to which this may apply, and there are other classes of insurance to which, I think, it could not in practice apply. For instance, if the Minister started to fix a rate for the insurance to be fixed for a saw-mill, I think he would find some difficulty in doing so, and I suggest that if he would address his mind to fixing the rate of insurance for a saw-mill he might realise his difficulties and be able to limit still further than at the moment the classes of insurance that would be included in this power.

Comment on this

I am inclined to agree, to the extent that, if profiteering in insurance—or, for that matter, in any other kind of business—were being carried on, where there is difficulty in price fixation, there are other methods that can be applied and can be more effectively used for that purpose.

Comment on this

I do not think Deputy Dillon would agree with the methods I have in mind, despite his rather rash approbation. However, as I was going to say, I am prepared to think this over. At the same time, I think this particular method of control should be retained in case there is need for it, and I think it will be admitted that that need might exist where, in the new circumstances, a limited number of companies will be licensed to do certain classes of business. There might be only one company in a particular class of business. However, as I have said, I shall consider the matter.

Comment on this
Mr. Bourke

I move amendment No. 183:—

In sub-section (4), line 33, after the word "greater" to insert the words "or less than".

This section is really one of the most obnoxious sections of the whole Bill. It represents, so to speak, the high-water mark of the tendency that has been so obvious nowadays towards bureaucracy—the tendency to interfere with everything and to insist on having control over everything and everybody, while, at the same time, shirking responsibility—the tendency to adjudge and control while, at the same time keeping Pontius Pilate's finger-bowl alongside. I think the effect of the Minister's statement is that everybody realises the difficulty of enforcing regulations of this kind. The fire business varies in every case. Even in the case of a company getting a particular business, say, in one street, the fire business may vary. There might be four or five houses of a different kind in the same area and that makes it necessary for the companies concerned to change their attitude and get different premiums from the occupiers of the different houses. The Minister, I am sure, realises what a difficult problem that presents, and I suggest that, in such circumstances, such drastic powers as are here proposed should not be given to a Minister. Deputy Costello made a case for varying the Minister's attitude towards fire insurance as against motor insurance and employers' liability insurance. However, I really do not think there is very much force in that. Certainly, the fact that it is obligatory on these people to insure is something in their favour but, at the same time, two wrongs do not make a right, and it does not get over the difficulty of getting motorists to insure by asking insurance companies to take them at a rate that will not make it a paying proposition. In this and every other business competition will look after the question of maximum premiums. In the cut-throat competition that there is in this particular line of business in the Saorstát there is not the slightest danger that the companies will go in for profiteering. As a matter of fact, one of the reasons given as a justification for an Insurance Bill being brought before this House is the fact that the companies have been inclined to undercut. I know that in connection with motor insurance business certain companies have taken business at half the tariff rates, and even at these rates most of it is not paying business, owing to the fact that there is exceptionally high damage. It is not a paying business and the companies only undertake it to increase their incomes. Very few companies are inclined to go mad about motor insurance. If the Minister insists on maximum premiums, as a counterbalance he should insist also on having minimum premiums, and should see that companies trying to do business in a straightforward way, and with funds adequate to meet their liabilities, are not going to be penalised by those that are less conscientious.

Comment on this

Deputy Bourke, having said what he has said on this matter, is, I expect, satisfied and does not expect me to accept the amendment. I do not think we should take power to fix minimum premiums for any class of insurance business. This section is intended merely to prevent exploitation of the public, and any extension of the section in the manner suggested would be undesirable.

Comment on this
Mr. Bourke

Does not the Minister agree that what I said has taken place in the past?

Comment on this

I am not quite sure. I agree that there is substantial evidence to show that numbers of companies have found third party motor vehicle insurance business unprofitable. It does not apply to all companies.

Comment on this

I should like to hear the Minister on this section.

Comment on this

The Deputy will not have that pleasure.

Comment on this

I think I had better read the section:—

Whenever a form of proposal for a policy of assurance is filled in wholly in the Irish language every policy of assurance issued in pursuance or as a consequence of such proposal and any other document issued in connection with such policy by the assurance company to which such proposal was made shall, if the proposer so requires, be issued by such assurance company in the Irish language.

In the history of codology was there ever greater codology than that? If so I have yet to hear it. What fool is responsible for putting that in? There is a statutory obligation on insurance companies to issue policies in Irish on request. Is not that codology? Does it not bring the language movement into contempt? Does it not bring a blush of shame to the cheek of anyone who ever advocated the promotion of the Irish language movement? God knows, when you spend years encouraging the promotion of the use of the Irish language in this country you find yourself being brought out to be made a fool of by an imbecile section of this kind being put into an Insurance Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not alleging that we made a fool of him.

Comment on this

When I see the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who does not know the word for cat, pig or goat in Irish, it makes me feel a fool after having spent 15 years of my life learning the Irish language. It makes it ridiculous.

Comment on this

I did not do it.

Comment on this

You put that section into the Bill. The implication outside is that the Irish language movement is codology. No one wants that position except the pious warriors who are going around hoping that they will get jobs by the pretence that they are more enthusiastic Gaels than their neighbours. No one who has any regard or respect for the language desires to be associated with codology of that kind. The people responsible for introducing this section into a Bill of this character do the Irish language nothing but harm. They bring it into disrepute and ridicule, and as far as I am concerned I think the section is greatly to be deplored. It brings something to which I attach great value, and a movement for which I have deep respect, into disrepute. It is a humiliation for anyone associated with it.

Comment on this

I would like to associate myself with the remarks made by Mr. Dillon. I asked the Minister when this section was considered on the Committee Stage if it was a joke. I hardly believed that it was seriously intended. Apparently it is going in as a joke and a futile joke. The Government that is responsible for putting this futile section into the Bill and into legislation passed in this House is going to make the House and the country a laughing stock.

Comment on this

I rise at once to refute everything that Deputy Costello has said. The Deputy's position for the past two weeks has been that insurance law should be framed to meet the desires of the insurance companies. They do not want a provision of this kind. In fact, a very large number of them are in the position in which they will issue insurance policies in the Irish language to those who request them to do so. I think this is a very desirable provision, and that they should be required to do so when persons doing business with them so desire. Any company not prepared to conform to that condition is not required to do business here.

Comment on this

Why should there be a statutory obligation? It would always be open to persons taking out policies to give their custom only to companies providing policies in Irish.

Comment on this

It is not enough. We are making it a condition for any company which takes out a licence.

Comment on this

It is codology masquerading as patriotism.

Comment on this

We have had enough codology from the Deputy for the last fortnight.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 184:—

In sub-section (2), line 54, after the word "secretary" to delete the words "or other" and in line 55 after the word "officer" to insert the words "or employee".

I do not propose to say much about this amendment. I know that there is no legal difference between "officer" and "employee."

Comment on this

I accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 185:—

In sub-section (1), lines 11 and 12, to delete the words "whichever period is the longer" and substitute the words "but not in any case after more than three years from the commission of the offence."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This amendment governs the next one.

Comment on this

Not necessarily; they are closely analogous.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy has a different point he may raise it.

Comment on this

I do not wish to condone any insurance company which has committed an offence, but I think there ought to be some statutory limitation. I do not know whether the three years would commend itself to the Minister, but certainly some period ought to be fixed by which some possibly vexatious prosecutions might be prevented.

Comment on this

I think it is perhaps not unreasonable that there should be some limit, but I think three years is much too short a period. Certainly I could not agree to accept Deputy Dillon's amendment, which would have the effect of confining it to one year. I might be prepared to consider the insertion of an amendment providing for an overriding period of six years. I think it might be quite possible to conceal offences for more than three years. It might even be possible to conceal offences for six years, but I agree that there should be some limit. I would be prepared to accept six years, but I would be very slow to consider any shorter period.

Comment on this
Cecil Lavery Mr. Lavery

Does the Minister realise that the usual period within which summary proceedings must be brought is six months, and that this section is provided in order to take those cases out of that particular limitation? Surely, if a six months' period is ordinarily sufficient, three years is not too short a period to allow?

Comment on this

Of course the circumstances here are different. The proposal here is similar to that which has been embodied in unemployment insurance law since its inception.

Comment on this

The proposal, in my experience of the working of unemployment insurance, is very bad. Stale claims are resurrected by the officials in defence of the fund for which they have a tremendous admiration in the Minister's Department.

Comment on this

It can frequently happen that knowledge of the fact that an offence has taken place may not come to light for years afterwards, when a repeat claim is made, or something of that kind.

Comment on this

The amendment proposes that the Minister should have a reasonable period within which to gain that knowledge. I think Deputy Dockrell's period of three years is rather long, having regard to the fact which has been pointed out by Deputy Lavery—that six months is the ordinary period. Certainly I would think that the period of six years suggested by the Minister is entirely too long. The facts may come to the knowledge of the Minister after a lapse of five or six years, and the evidence to refute those particular facts which come to the knowledge of the Minister may have long since passed away. Evidence that might have been available to the person who is going to be prosecuted will probably, after a lapse of five or six years, have completely vanished or be unprocurable, and the only result might be that the person prosecuted after the lapse of such a considerable period would be quite unable to know what it was all about or to defend himself adequately. The Minister should remember that what is being created here is a summary offence. Therefore, it would be what is called in the Constitution a minor offence—not of a very serious character —and consequently I do not think it is desirable as a matter of principle that after such a long period as the Minister has suggested a person should be prosecuted in reference to minor offences.

Comment on this

My personal feeling is that it is proper not to have any limitation at all, but I am prepared to say that I cannot find strong arguments against the proposal that there should be an overriding maximum period. I think six years would be not at all unreasonable, because having regard to the nature of this business, the long-term contracts that are made, and so forth, it may well happen that a considerable period may elapse before the knowledge that an offence has been committed will come to light.

Comment on this

As between the suggested periods of three and six years, would the Minister consider between this and Report Stage whether six years is not too long? I think it is a little bit too long. If the Minister will look at the various offences which are created by this Bill I think he will find that a six years' period is a little bit unreasonable, having regard to the type of offence.

Comment on this
Cecil Lavery Mr. Lavery

I think that in regard to prosecutions for customs and revenue offences of that type a period of three years is already provided. I am not positive, but that is my idea.

Comment on this

That may be so. I am concerned only with the nature of the offences which are specified here. I will just give the example that the valuation which each company is required to undertake operates only once every five years, and I think the period must therefore be some time longer than that, if, as a result, information that an offence was committed is brought to light.

Comment on this

Surely that would be ascertained before five years?

Comment on this

It is six months after the knowledge has come to the Minister but not more than six years altogether.

Comment on this

After the date of the offence?

Comment on this

I would suggest that a six years' period is far too long. It is a very bad precedent.

Comment on this

I will accept the principle of an overriding maximum period, but I will consider the period.

Comment on this

The First Schedule is the Schedule which implements the amalgamation scheme under this Bill. This Bill has been one of very great complexity, and its full significance did not I believe present itself to most Deputies of this House until after a somewhat protracted debate, but from this Committee Stage it now clearly emerges that it will not be possible for any Irish solvent insurance company to carry on its business in this country. It is an astonishing thing that the effect of this Bill is going to be that an Irish company which has become insolvent is going to be carried on in perpetuity, or an English company which has been operating in this country is going to be carried on in perpetuity.

Comment on this

I fail to see what this has to do with the Schedule.

Comment on this

The only company which this Schedule is going to make it impossible to carry on is a solvent Irish company.

Comment on this

This Schedule has nothing whatever to do with that.

Comment on this

I submit that this Schedule refers to a particular section of the Bill. It defines the conditions affecting the amalgamation of companies, but we have already discussed the sections which provide for the amalgamation.

Comment on this

The conditions provided in this amalgamation Schedule result in the facts as I have just stated them. In my opinion it is unjust on the part of this House to adopt any Schedule which operates to destroy a business which has been legitimately built up——

Comment on this

This Schedule does not affect any business.

Comment on this

——and kept within the law. I believe that this Schedule forms part of a general scheme which the Minister for Industry and Commerce has in his mind for the unification of the life and industrial life insurance business of this country under one large British combine. I believe that when he has it assembled under that British combine he proposes to nationalise it as a body in insurance analogous to the Electricity Supply Board in the distribution of electricity. I think it has become clear from an interjection made by the Minister in a debate on another measure which he was presenting to this House that he is now prepared to accept the philosophy of State Socialism; that he now takes the view that businesses of most kind can best be carried on by the Government, and should be carried on by the Government so long as he is entitled to run them. He very wisely has made up his mind that the rank and file of his own Party either do not take the interest or have not got the intelligence to see whither he is going.

Comment on this

Complimentary, no doubt.

Comment on this

He believes that by whipping them up every now and then he can persuade them, in the sacred name of patriotism, to help him in socialising the entire life of this country.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

"The socialisation of the entire life" of the country is not relevant to this Schedule.

Comment on this

I am entitled to suggest that the intention behind the amalgamation scheme contained in the First Schedule to this Bill is Socialism.

Comment on this

Which paragraph does the Deputy refer to?

Comment on this

The Minister will get plenty of information before I am finished. He will get all he wants. I believe the Minister is deliberately leading the innocents of the Fianna Fáil Party along that line. So far as they are concerned they will follow. They do not switch off, because they are told by the President that they must go along a certain line. But I believe the people will not continue to go along that line. I believe the people will kick the Minister out of office before he is able to consummate the job. But, in the course of carrying this into operation, I apprehend that he will destroy the livelihood of certain individuals who depend upon their business operations for a living. I put it to the House that that is the general trend. But this Schedule is entirely inadequate to the form outlined in the Bill. We will have British companies with all their great wealth consolidated. We are going to have insolvent companies, in one way or another consolidated, and taken over, to enable them to carry on and to protect their policy-holders from loss. When they come under this scheme, every policy they issue will carry an implied Government guarantee.

The only persons left independent will be the solvent Irish companies, and they will be in this position: On the one hand, they will have as competitors the great British companies with their enormous reserves accumulated, offering far more advantageous terms than the Irish companies can offer. On the other hand, there will be the amalgamated Irish insolvent companies, issuing policies each of which is endorsed with an implied Government guarantee. Between these two competitors the independent Irish solvent firms will have nothing to offer. They cannot plead for business on the ground that they are Irish companies because the amalgamated companies will also be Irish companies.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not permissible at this stage to make a Second Reading speech. The Deputy has not yet related his remarks to any part of the Schedule.

Comment on this

I want to submit a form of Schedule for the one I am discussing. I was indicating the views to the Minister by which he might devise a scheme under which every company could claim admission as a right, instead of, as under this scheme, making every company submit to him a scheme. My contention is that the general trend of the Bill is that it forces every company either into bankruptcy or to amalgamate and, therefore, I contend that the duty devolves upon the Minister to devise an amalgamation scheme in which Irish companies could seek refuge. I am offering the Minister, in lieu of the proposals in the First Schedule, a standard amalgamation scheme into which no one would be forced to come except insolvent companies, and into which each one could come if it claimed to do so as a right. I, therefore, for the purpose of illustration, suggest that there may be in this country—I have no reason to believe that that is so—I am giving a pure illustration without any information on the facts— companies hopelessly insolvent, doing Irish insurance; and now I am submitting to the House the framework of an amalgamation scheme which I suggest should be adopted. I suggest company A which has, actuarially, a deficiency of £250,000; company B which has an actuarial deficiency of £100,000. I am suggesting a third company C as solvent and a fourth company D as solvent with a surplus, and a fifth company E with a greater surplus. I want the Minister to notify the company A that has an actuarial deficiency of £250,000 that he would take in exchange for the money he puts in ordinary shares to the value of £250,000. Let me assume that the actual subscribed capital is £20,000. That would give the Minister the vast majority of the shares and would make the company solvent. In regard to company B which has £100,000 deficiency I want the Minister to put in £100,000 in exchange for ordinary shares. That would make the company solvent and the Minister secure because the subscribed capital would then be in the neighbourhood of £100,000. Having done that, there would be five solvent companies, two owned by the Minister, and three by their own shareholders. The two owned by the Minister would be just solvent. One other would be solvent, and two others would be solvent and have surpluses. I then would have the Minister value these five companies actuarially and my submission is that a fair basis of valuation would be to show that the goodwill of a solvent company is commensurate with one year's premium income.

Comment on this

I submit, A Chinn Comhairle, that this is entirely out of order.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of the scheme of amalgamation was dealt with on Section 24, Part III of the Bill. The matter before the House is the Schedule of conditions affecting such amalgamation, but the Deputy is speaking of the general trend of the Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's own words were "the general trend of the Minister's policy" and "the general trend of this Bill." I assure him he will find, on referring to the Official Report, that I am quoting him correctly. He is proposing an alternative scheme of amalgamation, giving the basis of valuation and the value of the goodwill. Such matters are not relevant.

Comment on this

Sub-section (1) of the First Schedule says:

The memorandum and articles of association of every amalgamated company shall be subject to the approval of the Minister for Finance after consultation by him with the Minister.

(2) The memorandum of association of every amalgamated company shall provide:

And it goes on and provides certain things. I desire now to submit that the memorandum of every associated company shall provide certain things, and I want to go on and set out the certain things that the memorandum should provide.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy would possibly have been in order if he had submitted an amendment.

Comment on this

I do not want to. I want to submit a schedule and to provide for certain matters.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

But the matters that the Deputy wants to submit must be relevant to this schedule.

Comment on this

I submit that these are matters that might be aimed at in connection with the amalgamation scheme and, therefore, would have come in under the general provisions of Section 24. The Schedule is associated only with paragraph (f), sub-section (2) of Section 24.

Comment on this

I desire to submit that the memorandum of association of the amalgamated companies shall provide for the basis of amalgamation and that the goodwill of the amalgamating companies shall be assessed on the basis of one year's premium income plus the amount of the actuarial surplus. The memorandum of every associated company, I suggest, should further provide that the ordinary shares will be issued to the joint value of the goodwill of the five companies plus the combined surplus.

Comment on this

Including shares for the goodwill of a company with a deficiency.

Comment on this

The Minister was not listening.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that two of the five companies would have deficiencies.

Comment on this

Not after the Minister had contributed money in exchange for shares.

Comment on this

We would have created the goodwill.

Comment on this

The Minister knows as much about the goodwill of an insurance company as I know about the Pharaohs of Egypt. I am putting forward a scheme now, and let his advisers tell him what it means. After I have finished he can go to his advisers and get them to explain it to him.

Comment on this

Nevertheless we are to issue shares for the goodwill of a company with a deficiency.

Comment on this

The Minister does not know what I am talking about. The memorandum of association having set out the value of the goodwill of the five companies, some of which are solvent, and some of which he would have been compelled to amalgamate, plus the value of the surplus, share capital to their joint value would be issued, and the five companies would be purchased from their present proprietors by the issue of shares to these proprietors in an amount equal to their several holdings in the five companies. That is to say that in respect of a company to which the Minister would have contributed £250,000 in order to make it solvent, taking 250,000 shares for the money contributed, whereas the capital is £25,000, the Minister would receive 1,000 shares in the amalgamated company for every one share the original proprietors of the insolvent company would receive. I think, Sir, the memorandum of association of the amalgamated company should provide that the directors of a solvent company would be entitled to compensation in the event of its being deemed expedient to dispense with their services as supernumerary in order to facilitate the amalgamation. I do not think that the memorandum of association of the amalgamated company should provide that a director of an insolvent company should be entitled to compensation inasmuch as by the failure of the company to maintain solvency he has disqualified himself.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not wish to interrupt the Deputy's argument unnecessarily. I do not remember clearly what should be in a company's memorandum or articles of association. It strikes me, however, that Deputy Dillon is including many extraneous and unusual items in order to discuss on the Schedule matters quite irrelevant thereto.

Comment on this

One of the most usual clauses in the memorandum of a company is a clause providing that the company shall have the right and obligation to confirm certain agreements that have been come to, which were necessary for the proper formation of the company. These are the matters to which Deputy Dillon has adverted.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Relevant to this schedule?

Comment on this

Yes. Matters that would appear either directly in the articles of association or would be contained in the scheme to be so confirmed.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello is quite right in stating that before the articles of association for the amalgamated company are prepared there must be a scheme, and the provisions of the scheme were discussed and settled on Section 24 of the Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of amalgamation was fully discussed on Section 24 of Part III of the Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And may not now be reopened.

Comment on this

No, Sir. I have said that I regard the principle of amalgamation as having been decided, and I am now outlining a method—hateful as it is to me, I regard the principle of amalgamation as having been decided—by which there shall be incorporated in the articles of association or memorandum of association, whatever scheme of amalgamation is least objectionable.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The scheme of amalgamation should have been discussed on the relevant section.

Comment on this

At that juncture we were discussing the principle as to whether there should be amalgamation or not.

Comment on this

We discussed the scheme of amalgamation and assented to it.

Comment on this

On the original section we discussed whether there should be amalgamation or not and we disposed of that. It was decided against us, and for the Minister, that there should be amalgamation. We now come to the First Schedule and I am suggesting the contents of the articles of association of the amalgamated company. However, I do not wish to detain the House any longer than is necessary to state the details of the scheme which should be incorporated in the First Schedule. I trust the Minister will examine the suggestion I make. I trust he will realise my desire to have outlined appropriate contents for this memoranadum and these articles so as to prevent a memorandum being drawn, the effect of which would be to destroy an independent solvent company which is at present in existence. I believe there are at least three such companies threatened with extinction, if the memorandum of association of any amalgamated company is improperly or undesirably drawn. I should be glad to know if the Minister would consider having his Department draw a memorandum of association and articles of association into which he will invite all the companies to come on the terms outlined by me as highly desirable, in view, and only in view, of the success with which the Minister has secured the assent of this House to the principles which were raised at earlier stages in our discussion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

May I put the First Schedule?

Comment on this

Will the Minister give us any indication of his intentions?

Comment on this

I do not want to discuss the matter of amalgamation further than we have already done so on Section 24.

Comment on this

Is the Minister prepared to give us any indication whether he would consider providing an amalgamation scheme himself into which it would be open to any company that desired to enter without reference to whether it was solvent or not?

Comment on this

It is my hope that any amalgamation scheme that may result from this Bill will include within its scope companies which are unquestionably solvent.

Comment on this

But the Minister sees the point I am making. There are two schemes of amalgamation, one a voluntary scheme on the lines of the proposal which I have put before him. There are certain companies which he will have to order to amalgamate as insolvent. There may be one or two such companies; we do not know the number, but there are some. I want to know whether he will consider drafting a scheme, under which he would feel, within the powers already contained in the Bill, competent to order insolvent companies to enter on terms and into which he would feel himself free to invite solvent companies to come on stated terms to be fixed in each particular case by arbitration, actuarial arbitration.

Comment on this

The Bill provides for that at present.

Comment on this

The Bill provides for the Minister putting up a scheme himself?

Comment on this

Oh no.

Comment on this

That is the case I am putting to him.

Comment on this

Of course the Minister does not need a Bill to enable him to do that.

Comment on this

Surely it is desirable for the Minister to settle the public mind. Does the Minister feel free to say at this stage that he recognises he has a duty to discharge—as we all know he has—in respect to insolvent companies? Does he think it is practicable to put up a scheme which would attract not only the insolvent companies—he could force them in—but the solvent companies?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

Possibly something on the lines I have outlined might commend itself to the Minister's Department.

Comment on this

I should not like to say that.

First and Second Schedules agreed to.

THIRD SCHEDULE.

Comment on this

I should like if the Minister would give us some explanation of sub-section (1), Section 1, of Part II of this Schedule.

Comment on this

On what point does the Deputy require information?

Comment on this

I should like to know what it means.

Comment on this

These are rules for ascertaining the amount of a free paid-up policy and the cash surrender value of any policy of industrial assurance.

Comment on this

I know that.

Comment on this

I do not know if the Deputy is merely trying to trap me. If he wants information, he will have to tell me what information he wants. The meaning of that paragraph is, I think, clear in relation to all the other paragraphs of that part of the Schedule.

Comment on this

I do not want to trap the Minister at all. I am asking for information on this particular sub-section and I think I am entitled to receive it. It is customary for Ministers, when dealing with a Bill in Committee, to explain each section. The Minister has not done that and has not been asked to do it. I am asking the Minister to explain sub-section (1) of Section 1 of Part II.

Comment on this

It means nothing except in relation to all the other paragraphs.

Comment on this

Does the Minister consider that that is an answer to my question?

Comment on this

It is. It means nothing except in relation to all the other paragraphs.

Comment on this

Am I to assume that the Minister does not know what it means or that he does not desire to give the information?

Comment on this

All these paragraphs constitute a set of rules for determining a certain thing and one paragraph, by itself, means nothing.

Comment on this

That is an answer?

Comment on this

The Minister must have in his papers a brief explaining this portion of Part II of the Third Schedule. Would he mind reading out that brief?

Comment on this

I have no intention of doing so. As a matter of fact, I have no brief. The meaning of Part II is quite clear. There are four paragraphs there which, between them, lay down rules for determining certain things. If Deputies desire to suggest alterations of these rules, I am prepared to consider them, but to say that they should be——

Comment on this

Explained. That is monstrous.

Comment on this

It is preposterous, because the explanation appears on the face of them. We say that certain things will have to be taken into account and certain calculations will have to be made in order to get a reasonable basis for determining the amount of a free paid-up policy or the cash surrender value of a policy, as the case may be. I am prepared to consider any alteration of these rules which Deputies suggest.

Comment on this

It appears to me that the Minister himself does not understand what the sub-section means. But the Minister is in a position of advantage as compared with other members of the House. He has experts at his disposal and we have not. I want to know what exactly is the meaning of the sub-section, which says: "... the date of the policy may be assumed for the purposes of this paragraph to be one year after the actual date thereof, and, if it is so assumed, duration of the policy may be assumed to be one year less than the actual duration". What does that convey to any ordinary layman without the assistance of experts? We are supposed to understand the legislation we are asked to pass, whether we do or not. We are entitled to ask for information. I am simply asking for information, and there is no use in the Minister getting angry or suggesting that anybody is trying to trap him. There is no use in his telling me that it means nothing.

Comment on this

It means nothing except in relation to the other sections.

Comment on this

Taken by itself, it means something definite.

Comment on this

The four paragraphs, between them, determine the rules for ascertaining the amount of a free paid-up policy or the cash surrender value of a policy.

Comment on this

Why is it thought necessary to put in the words "the policy may be assumed to be one year less than the actual duration"?

Comment on this

It is not thought necessary except that these combined rules determine the matter.

Comment on this

Why is that in this sub-section? It would not be there unless it were necessary.

Comment on this

We can discuss Part II of the Schedule as a whole and not portions of it.

Comment on this

We are discussing the Third Schedule to the Bill in Committee, and if I do not ask the question now the Ceann Comhairle will put the Schedule as a whole and there will be no opportunity for relevantly discussing this provision.

Comment on this

I have explained that the four rules in Part II of the Schedule provide a basis upon which the value of a free paid-up policy or the cash surrender value of a policy can be determined. Various modifications of each rule can be made, provided that the result represents a fair determination of the value of these policies. In this particular case we provide that the first year may not be taken into account, so as to allow a set-off against initial expenses, but some other device might have been adopted and the same result secured. The rules which we have taken and embodied in this Schedule are similar to those recommended by the Cohen Committee, the report of which Deputies opposite have frequently quoted in the course of this debate. The Cohen Committee dealt with conditions in Great Britain and made recommendations in relation to the conduct of insurance in Great Britain. In a matter of this kind it is merely a question of getting some fair basis, and this is as fair a basis as any other. Precisely the same result might be obtained by a completely different set of rules, and Deputies, if they so desired, could have moved to alter the rules which are set out.

Comment on this

I am not opposing this section. I merely want to understand it. I am not going to suggest any alteration until I know what the section means. The Minister has gone some distance by way of explanation.

Comment on this

This matter merely underlines the point I made to the Minister, not once, but 20 times—that if you are going to introduce complicated legislation of this kind you ought to circulate a White Paper in connection with it.

Comment on this

Enough White Papers and briefs were circulated to Deputies in connection with this Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister came in with a considerable bundle of papers under his arm, which it took two years to hatch out under the comfortable wing of every British insurance company which has invaded this country. What I am suggesting is that when complex legislation of a highly technical kind is brought before the House it would greatly expedite the discussion if the Minister's expert advisers would prepare a simple commentary on the more highly technical schedules and sections of the Bill, a commentary which would explain the general trend and purpose of the sections. That is the universal practice in the House of Commons, in the United States House of Representatives and in the United States Senate, and in my opinion it is a practice that would be a very desirable one in this country, particularly now when we have here a mono-cameral Government.

Comment on this

Is this Schedule going to be reviewed in connection with the intending review of Section 84 of the Bill?

Comment on this

Well, the Minister himself, so far as Section 84 of the Bill is concerned, felt that that section did not clearly express the purpose the Government had in mind.

Comment on this

On the contrary, I think it does clearly express what the Government had in mind, but so that it shall be still further clarified I have agreed to accept certain amendments which appeared on the paper from Deputy Costello and to embody them in the section, not because I consider that these amendments are necessary or that a change in the section will be effected, but because it is desirable to have clarification. That, however, has nothing to do with this Schedule.

Comment on this

All I want to ensure is that the Minister will do what he expressed his intention of doing when speaking on this Bill on the 10th June, 1936, as reported in column 2275 of Vol. 63, No. 5, when he accepted Deputy Costello's amendments in principle.

Comment on this

I would be surprised if I said that.

Comment on this

What happened was that on that occasion Deputy Costello said:

"I accept, of course, his statement that his idea is that this reinsurance company should operate on the same business lines as ordinary reinsurance companies do at the present moment."

To that my reply was:—

"That is intended, but a reinsurance treaty at the present time between one company and another is a voluntary arrangement. To a certain extent that voluntary arrangement is being removed from the relations between companies licensed to do business here and the reinsurance company of Ireland, because it says that there shall be an agreement. In these circumstances I think it is necessary to have the qualification to which the Deputy refers which is designed to prevent a company, having a reinsurance agreement with the reinsurance company, writing all sorts of bad risks, passing the whole of these risks on to the reinsurance company and retaining none itself. The object of this provision is to ensure that this cannot happen ..."

Comment on this

I think the quotation the Deputy wants is in column 2273.

Comment on this

Yes, in column 2273 the Minister said:—

"I am quite prepared to agree to ... Deputy Costello's amendment which, I think, is intended to clarify the intention of the section and which would clarify it in my opinion if inserted."

Comment on this

That does not affect the Fifth Schedule at all.

Fifth Schedule agreed to.

SIXTH SCHEDULE.

Comment on this
Cecil Lavery Mr. Lavery

On behalf of Deputy Costello I move amendment No. 187:—

In pages 55 and 56 to delete the words—"(i) Third Party Claims, (ii) All other Claims"—wherever they appear.

The object of this amendment is to simplify the form of the Schedule. Presumably the object of returning the fund in that form is to be found in Section 94 of the Bill, sub-section (1) of which sets out the nature of the returns to be made and sub-section (2) of which describes the form of this Schedule. Under the first sub-section the assurance company carrying on the business of insuring mechanically propelled vehicles is required in addition to the statement made under Section 76 of the Road Traffic Act to prepare a statement of the estimated liability of such assurance company in respect of outstanding and unsettled claims relating to such business. The object of the section is to ensure that the company are making proper provision in respect of outstanding and unsettled liabilities. There is nothing to suggest that anything can be gained by dividing the return into two classes of claims, first, third party claims and, second, all other claims. The amendment is that that division should be eliminated and that the returns asked for should merely be sufficient to satisfy the requirements of the section. It is obvious that the division asked for in the Schedule cannot be made with any sense of reality. No doubt it is possible for the company to say how much it has paid in respect of third party claims within the year, and how much in connection with mechanically propelled vehicles. But by requiring a severance of the particulars between the third party claims and the other claims, the Bill is asking for something that can be done. The object of the section will be fully satisfied by requiring a return to be made in respect of claims in connection with mechanically propelled vehicles. There is no real purpose to be served by requiring this severance of the different claims. Insisting on this severance will mean that costs must be incurred in regard to the claims as a whole. Ordinarily the claim in respect of this insurance would include the third party claims and the material damage claim in respect of the car.

Comment on this

In support of what Deputy Lavery has said I think the Minister will realise that in a number of cases the settlement really does not give the assurance companies the information that is asked for under this. It is a lump sum settlement. Really asking for the breaking up of this third party and other claims would be at the best only an estimate. I think what the Minister wants to know is the total liabilities of the insurance company.

Comment on this

I am disposed to agree with Deputy Lavery, but Deputy Costello's amendment goes much further than what he said. I am prepared to bring forward an amendment on the Report Stage making it clear that the amounts need not be segregated in respect of costs and expenses as between the third party and the other claims, and also proposing that all the claims arising out of one policy may be treated as one claim.

Comment on this

That the third party claim and all the other claims arising out of one policy will be treated under one head. If I knock down a man and injure him that is a third party claim. Then there is a claim for the injury to my car. Will all be treated together as one?

Comment on this
Cecil Lavery Mr. Lavery

What is the purpose of requiring this division?

Comment on this

I propose to insert an amendment not to require a division in respect of costs and expenses. I doubt that there will be any difficulty in regard to giving information except where claims under various heads arise out of one policy. In that case we will not require a separation.

Comment on this
Cecil Lavery Mr. Lavery

What are you proposing to do?

Comment on this

I will bring forward an amendment at the next stage to clarify these matters.

Comment on this
Cecil Lavery Mr. Lavery

Does the Minister suggest that at present there is no difficulty in separating these claims?

Comment on this

If the Minister is prepared to accept the suggestion about bracketing third party and all other claims together, I understand that is all Deputy Costello wants to achieve.

Comment on this

I propose to put a note into the Schedule making it clear that the segregation of costs and expenses as between these two groups need not be effected.

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell us, in reply to Deputy Lavery's query, what purpose is to be served by making this segregation? If you have an accident of a mixed character in which a third party is injured, and your vehicle is at the same time destroyed and the two risks are covered by the one policy, how will such a claim be segregated?

Comment on this

I propose to introduce an amendment requiring them not to be segregated.

Comment on this

Where will you put them, under third party or under the other?

Comment on this

I suggest the Deputy might wait until he sees the amendment.

Comment on this