Appropriation Bill, 1936—Second Stage.
Contributions 113–241 of 241. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 29 of 1936 ›
Everybody would accept the statement, except those who do not wish to accept it. The Minister knows that that promise was made in his constituency and that it was made at a time when the Minister was doing his best to woo all the civil servants in the County Dublin constituency to vote for him as the new saviour and deliverer of civil servants from the land of bondage. That was the role the Minister was appearing in in 1932, and the only thing it was necessary to do then, in order to give the Minister the requisite certificate in that capacity, was to promise an arbitration board to inquire into the grievances of the civil servants.
That was in 1932. In 1936 nobody can be accused of any impetuosity in asking the Minister what he has done in the meantime to redeem the promise which, I suggest, was made with his approbation. As a matter of fact, although I have no proof of it, I rather imagine that the stroke of promising an arbitration board originated in the fertile brain of the Minister for Finance. We were told then that an arbitration board was to be established to deal with the grievances of the civil servants. There was to be no question of a commission at all. The Minister and the Fianna Fáil Party had in mind a certain type of arbitration board which was going to be established. There was no question of a commission to be set up for the purpose of devising an arbitration board or for the purpose of seeing whether or not arbitration could be applied. A very specific promise was made on that occasion that an arbitration board would be established, but, having induced the civil servants to vote for him, and feeling assured of a term of office, the Minister was not so microscopic in implementing the promise as he was in framing the precise terms of the promise. Thus, he found an excuse for setting up a commission of inquiry. The commission of inquiry was asked how best the principle of arbitration could be applied to the settlement of Civil Service disputes. That commission of inquiry sat for 2½ years. I am sure the Minister was sorry that it did not sit for 10½ years. However, the commission took as long as it could, and as long as it sat it gave the Minister the excuse of saying, whenever any question arose, "That is a matter for the commission of inquiry"—although many times during the period the commission was deliberating on this matter, the Civil Service organisations, who thought the Minister would have no hesitation in implementing such a specific promise as had been made, wondered whether the setting up of such a commission was not just a dodge to evade the promise.
After 2½ years of fooling with this question of arbitration, the commission ultimately produced a report which indicated clearly that it had exceeded the terms of reference which had been sent to it by the Minister. After spending 2½ years, the commission produced ultimately a report, but not a report of the kind they were asked to produce, because the Minister had promised arbitration. There is only one meaning to arbitration, and that is the settlement of a dispute in an impartial way and by an impartial body. The commission of inquiry, which the Minister set up without any consultation with the staff organisations, produced a report suggesting that there were certain difficulties in the way of the establishment of arbitration, and suggesting a spurious form of arbitration which none of the Civil Service organisations would accept. However, the Minister's promise and the President's promise still stood. The President's promise in 1932 was to establish an arbitration board, and the Service organisations and the staff are entitled to expect that the President will honour that promise which was so specifically made by him. Instead, however, of taking steps to implement the promise which was made in 1932, the Minister for Finance last year produced the scheme of arbitration—and there is more scheme about it than there is arbitration—the object of which was not to grant arbitration to the Service but to offer it a type of machinery which is foreign to any ordinary conception of the principles of arbitration.
The Minister asked the staff organisations to accept a scheme, one of the provisions of which gave the Minister for Finance an absolute veto over the type of case which could be referred to arbitration. In other words, while pretending to establish an arbitration board the Minister was taking care that he could refuse to submit any particular case, or every case, to the judgment of the arbitration board. The Minister's scheme provided also that there should be a restriction on the kind of persons whom the Service organisations could send to the arbitration board as advocates. The Minister was free to select any representatives to appear as advocates before the board, but he would restrict the choice of the Service organisations, by prohibiting them from selecting as advocates persons of their own choice. The crowing piece of ingenuity on the part of the Minister was the provision in the scheme whereby he took power to say that he would not be bound by the award of the arbitration tribunal, but would consider it as a recommendation, if he saw fit to put the recommendation into operation. The Minister wanted to establish a piece of machinery which he was to label an arbitration tribunal, but under this machinery he would have power to prevent any particular case going to arbitration. He had an absolute veto over the kind of case that went to arbitration. He was handicapping the other side in pleading its case before the arbitration tribunal by restricting the choice of its representatives. Even if the Minister lost the case before the arbitration tribunal, having imposed these two handicaps on his opponents, he then refused to be bound by its award. He constituted this arbitration tribunal, as he called it, and was to have a say as to who the staff representatives would be, and a say in whom the official representatives would be. The chairman of the tribunal was to be appointed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and, as if all these safeguards were not sufficient, he wanted other restrictions as well, including the restriction that if he lost a case he was not bound to accept the award of the tribunal. A staff organisation might desire to take a claim for increased wages to the tribunal, but the Minister had a veto in his scheme which would enable him to refuse to allow it to go to arbitration. However, if he consented to do so, he stipulated that even if the chairman of the tribunal, who was to be appointed by a Minister, decided against him, he was not going to be bound by the award. That is the scheme of arbitration which the Minister now imagines is an implementation of the promise made by the President in Rathmines Town Hall in 1932.
I put it to the Minister that a scheme of that kind is not an arbitration tribunal; that it has none of the features of arbitration, as popularly and industrially known, that it is not in any sense, a court or tribunal which would decide genuine disputes between the Executive Council on the one hand, and staff organisations on the other; that it is by no stretch of the imagination anything approaching an honest attempt to honour the promise which was made in 1932. The Minister pleaded previously in this House that he had not the views of the staff organisations on this draft scheme of organisations which he submitted to them. He said that, of course, at a time when he knew perfectly well that, with the exception of one tiny organisation—all the members of which would probably fit in a city tramcar—none of the organisations would accept the draft scheme of arbitration. In any case, the Minister has had for the past month a very definite memorandum, written in simple and implicit language, and signed by all the staff organisations, indicating that the scheme of arbitration which he has suggested is utterly unsuitable to the needs of the Civil Service; that it is not arbitration; that it is in no sense an implementation of the President's promise; and he has been asked to convene a conference of representatives of his Department with representatives of staff organisations, for the purpose of establishing what will be a genuine arbitration board that will make a genuine attempt to resolve the differences between the Executive Council on the one hand, and staff organisations on the other hand. The Minister has been told that the service organisations desire a scheme of arbitration which will give no veto to one side or the other, which will enable all matters within a previously agreed category to be referred to arbitration, and which will not put any restriction on the right of either side to be represented by advocates of their own choice. He has been told that the staff organisations desire a tribunal whose verdict will be binding on both sides, subject to the over-riding authority of this House. Is there anything unreasonable in making a claim of that kind? Is there anything unreasonable in setting up an arbitration tribunal of that kind? The Minister now wants to say that he does not want to be bound by the verdict of an arbitration tribunal. But we had the extraordinary spectacle of the President coming to this House, and declaring in very specific language that he was prepared to accept the judgement of an arbitration tribunal, which presumably would not consist of Irishmen, on the land annuities dispute, and to accept it as binding, and to such an extent as to compel this country to pay an award of one, two, three, four or five million pounds yearly. While we have the President prepared to accept the verdict of an arbitration tribunal on the question of the disputed financial payments, we have the Minister for Finance not prepared to accept the award of an Irish arbitration tribunal on matters in dispute between himself as employer and the staff as employees.
I ask the Minister to say definitely where he stands or where the Government stands on this matter of arbitration. Does the Government intend to honour the promise that was made in 1932, or is the Minister endeavouring to drag out this discussion, until such time as we have another general election when the promise can be furbished up in new and perhaps more alluring language than before, in the hope that it will deceive some of the Minister's constituents a third time? Is that the object, or does the Minister recant and repudiate the promise made in 1932? Is it the position now, that the Government has no further use for the promise which was made then, and which did the political trick in that year? Is that the position, or does the Minister genuinely intend to establish an arbitration tribunal, in which the staff will have confidence and in which the legislature will have confidence? Every day in the week the Department of Industry and Commerce is engaged in endeavouring to promote the settlement of disputes through the medium of arbitration. The Minister for Industry and Commerce is constantly urging trade unions to submit their differences with employers to arbitration, yet, we have the Minister for Finance, who is in the rôle of an employer towards the staff, refusing to adopt the method for the settlement of disputes which has been recommended by his colleague the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to employers and to work people. The Minister has now had four years to think over the promise made in 1932. He has had in his possession for the last month a request from the Service organisations to convene a conference to discuss the establishment of an equitable scheme of arbitration. So far the Minister has been silent; he has not indicated what his intentions are. I should like to know from the Minister what he proposes to do in that connection. The staff organisations have waited now for four years to get some definite declaration from the Minister that he intends to establish a genuine arbitration tribunal. It is time, now that the Minister has had placed before him the views of the staff organisations that he should state what he intends to do in that particular matter.
There is another matter to which I should like to refer and that is the question of the provision made in the recent Budget for the expenditure of £2,500,000 on the relief of unemployment during the present year. I should like to inquire from the Minisster for Industry and Commerce when we are likely to see some steps taken to ensure that that provision is not merely a paper provision but that it will be genuinely utilised for the relief of unemployment. So far as I can discover, in large tracts of country which I have visited, there seems very little evidence that any of this £2,500,000 is being expended. Many of the towns and areas throughout my own constituency are suffering very seriously as a result of unemployment, notwithstanding the fact that we were told that this £2,500,000 is to be expended for the relief of unemployment this year. I should like to know from the Minister whether my experience in that connection represents the general experience of Deputies from other constituencies throughout the country. We could probably test the position more accurately if we could get from the Minister some definite statement as to how much of the money has been actually allocated for the relief of unemployment, in what areas are schemes in operation, and how many persons at present have been put into employment under the schemes envisaged by the Minister.
We were told recently, as a justification for the enactment of an Employment Period Order, that there was going to be an abundance of work in the rural areas between the 3rd of June and the 27th of October. I can see no evidence of any of that work about which the Minister for Industry and Commerce talked so volubly. This £2,500,000 has certainly not found its way into the rural areas or into the towns so far. I should like to know from the Minister what is being done to expedite the expenditure of the money, when the money will be expended, and what number of persons will be taken off unemployment assistance benefit through the medium of the work provided under these schemes. The House is probably on the eve of an adjournment and it may be some time before it meets again. We should, therefore, have from the Minister for Finance who is responsible for the Budgetary provision some indication of the general way in which it will be spent, when it will be spent, and approximately the number of persons who are likely to be employed in this way.
The last point which I desire to raise has reference to a report which appeared in the Press yesterday and which indicated that the Minister for Finance, if he does not appear in the rôle of the American uncle in relation to unemployment assistance benefit, at least does appear in that capacity in connection with totalisators on greyhound racing tracks. The Press reported yesterday that the Minister for Finance had instructed counsel to go into the courts and there offer on his behalf a sum of £10,000 in settlement of an action against him.
Comment on this
I suggest, Sir, that while it is not in the Estimates in this financial year the Minister is consenting to pay £10,000.
Comment on this
All right, Sir. Quite apart from the sum, I think I would be entitled, on the Vote for the Minister's own salary, which is provided for in this Appropriation Bill, to question the manner in which he discharges his duty as Minister for Finance and custodian of the taxpayers' money. Would I not?
Comment on this
Who knew, Sir, that the Minister was going to appear on this generous rôle until the newspapers were opened yesterday and we saw the Minister shovelling out £10,000 of the people's money in settlement of this claim?
Comment on this
The matter is not before the House at present. The Vote which must be introduced later will afford an opportunity for discussion.
Comment on this
Do you rule then, Sir, that it is not permissible for me to raise the question of the action of the Minister for Finance in instructing counsel to go into court and make an offer of £10,000 in settlement of a claim against him before even the court had given a decree against the Minister? Would I not be entitled, on this Appropriation Bill, to ask whether the Minister was justified in making any offer at all, and whether he proposes to tell the House the circumstances under which he as Minister for Finance—a Minister whose salary is provided for in this Bill—took the unusual course of spending £10,000 without even the consent of the Legislature?
Comment on this
The only knowledge which the House has of that matter is that obtained from a newspaper report. The Estimate which will come before the House later, will put the matter in order for discussion. That discussion should not be anticipated.
Comment on this
Might I put the matter this way? The Minister, on taking office, found himself faced by a promise made by his predecessor in 1931 in regard to the establishment of a tote system at this greyhound course. For that period, and particularly during the past 12 months, he has refused to fulfil the promise. Surely his conduct in neglecting to fulfil that promise, which resulted in the payment of this £10,000, is relevant on the Appropriation Bill?
Comment on this
I do not suggest that they can, but did not the conduct of the Minister in failing to fulfil the promise written down in his office in 1931 result in the payment of this £10,000? His conduct during this year in bringing that to a head is surely open to discussion on this Bill.
Comment on this
I cannot delay very long on the matter. What strikes me as extraordinary, and what I think will strike the general public as extraordinary, is that the Minister for Finance goes into court and offers a sum of £10,000 in satisfaction of a claim made against him. His counsel who appeared there declared, as portion of his defence, that the Minister had, in fact, made no compromising promise such as would justify the payment of any compensation. But after some discussion in court, counsel for the Minister and counsel for the plaintiff announced that they had made a deal and settled the matter by the payment on the part of the Minister of £10,000 to the plaintiff. Consequently, in the same year as we find people cut off from unemployment assistance benefit we are going to pay £10,000 in compensation for this totalisator machine, and all this without any indication to the House as to what the responsibility of the Executive Council was in respect of any promise made. I should think this is an appropriate occasion for the Minister for Finance to make a declaration setting out the circumstances of that case. I think there is grave public disquiet that because of a change of policy on the one hand, or because of an alleged promise on the other, which the Minister stated was not a promise that bound him, the Exchequer has to be asked to pay the substantial sum of £10,000 to the plaintiff in this case. I never knew anybody who found it so easy to get so much money out of the Minister as this body, and that, apparently, through very little responsibility on the part of the Minister. I think the Minister should use this occasion to tell the House the full circumstances surrounding that case. Was there any definite promise made to this body that they would be permitted to establish this particular type of machine? On what terms, and by whom was the promise given? Did the Executive Council think they were bound by the promise made and who generally was responsible for the change of policy that resulted in the State being compelled to pay this £10,000?
Comment on this
This matter of a promise to the Civil Service has been discussed by quite a number of people. I do not want to say much upon it, but I recall with interest hearing the Minister making his humble explanation, and trying to get away from the plain words, and plain statement not merely in the speech at Rathmines, but incorporated in the manifesto produced to the electorate before the 1932 election. The Minister's attitude to-night comes upon me with surprise. Though the Civil Service feels sore at the lack of fulfilment of the promise in the manifesto of 1932, nevertheless, in their recent communication with the Minister, they asserted that the Minister has not yet denied that there was a promise and that the promise was that an arbitration board would be set up. Lest there should be any doubt on the matter, I direct attention to the fact that in 1932 the present Government, going for election, produced their manifesto and that manifesto was couched in the following terms:—
"Fianna Fáil seeks a mandate to proceed with the fulfilment of the items in its programme. Item 7.— We are prepared to establish an arbitration board to deal with the grievances of civil servants."
Comment on this
I said I could countersign the words used by the Deputy because I had them under my eyes. The actual words were: "We are prepared to establish an arbitration board to deal with the grievances of civil servants." Has that been fulfilled? I understood that up-to-date while there may have been evasions, trying to explain the non-fulfilment, there has been no attempt on the part of any Ministers to show that the statement does not mean what everyone will read into its words: "We are prepared to establish an arbitration board to deal with the grievances of civil servants." I look forward with a certain amount of interest to hearing the Minister trying to explain—and I thought his interjection was that he was going to explain—that that does not mean a promise to the civil servants to establish an arbitration board.
The Appropriation Accounts we are dealing with have got to such a height, in regard to moneys levied on the people, that possibly they could better be called expropriation accounts. I agree with Deputy Cosgrave that extortion, of a certain type, may temporarily increase the amount of the revenue raised and the opportunity the Government may find for spending. But eventually extortion will work to the detriment of the Exchequer if it can only balance its Budget by making the majority of the citizens unbalance their domestic budgets. If the Government can only achieve the balancing of the national Budget by making people sell their stock, let their premises go into disrepair and not meet their debts, if it induces local authorities no longer to pay their way out of moneys they actually get from the rates, if it increases the indebtedness of the local authorities, as has been done, by a sum of £9,000,000 in three years, and if the national Exchequer is to be overburdened with debt in the same period, then if the Minister does achieve, nominally even, the balancing of his Budget it is at a cost that will inevitably show and show quite soon.
We are voting these huge sums of money. What are they for? We are apparently going to carry on, despite all the warnings of people at home and abroad, this scheme of economic nationalism. This scheme has been tried and found wanting by most of the nations of the world. It is a scheme which is meeting with a derision that is only a preliminary to its general abandonment. It is a scheme that has been the subject of discussion where men of all nations are called together in economic conferences in the last two or three years, and it has met with their disapproval. In fact there is quoted in most booklets that deal with the world situation evidence that shows a lightening of the clouds of depression after most of them have decided to abandon economic nationalism and to open up international trade. I have tried, on many occasions, to show, just exactly what was the situation in other countries. I have shown that people who were counted amongst the foremost leaders of international thought and society have expressed their view without any show of doubt on the whole question of economic nationalism, once a phase and popular phase, but now completely unpopular. And it is unpopular not because it has not got a chance to prove itself, but because, having got that chance, it has disproved itself. I spoke again and again about the position of the Balkan States, who are trying to get their tariff barriers lowered. I have spoken in the same connection in reference to the Danubian States, who have come to the same conclusion. I stated that Mussolini had gathered together the group of nations with which he is associated— Austria, Jugoslavia—who made a series of treaties, the pivot of them being, in Mussolini's own phrase, that they had to lower their tariffs in order to have their complementary national economies interlocked, with the view of getting a better life for their people. I have said before, and repeat it, that the foremost economic leader of any French Government in the last two-and-a-half years announced to the whole Chamber of Deputies that economic nationalism had not proved a success in any country in which it had been tried. He asked for comments upon that statement, and no one said nay to that deriding comment.
I point now to this most significant fact: that before Congress last year the President asked from Congress, and got leave, that if he reduced any tariff on imported goods coming into America by at least 50 per cent. he need not go back to Congress; and only if he decided to make a reduction of a figure over 50 per cent. was he to be forced to recall Congress to have it discussed.
Comment on this
Very much lower than ours, whatever that may be. There is no general tariff wall—possibly Spain had such a wall, but it has recently been lowered—as high as ours is at the moment. Would the Deputy like to interrupt again?
Comment on this
Certainly. The two leaders in economic nationalism were France and America. France has not merely abandoned it, but has abandoned it with the phrase that it has "nowhere proved a success." The President of the United States asked leave to make a reduction of 50 per cent. The President of the United States sent to an International Conference at Geneva Mr. Cordell Hull, his Secretary of State, and Mr. Cordell Hull inaugurated a study movement in connection with economic nationalism. The basis of that movement was, so far as I can see, accepted unanimously, but I have not read through the complete account. At all events, nobody voted against it. The basis on which he got acceptance was this—that the result of tariffs throughout the world had been not an increase in employment in any country but a decrease. In the interest of mankind generally, as well as in the interest of the unemployed in the different countries, Mr. Cordell Hull got over 54 nations to agree to inaugurate a series of studies into the effect of economic nationalism with a view to the reduction of tariff barriers. That same gentleman, in May of this year, delivered what was described universally by the newspapers as an "attack on economic nationalism." It is reported in the Press of the 15th May, and it is described as having been delivered the night before. Mr. Cordell Hull said that "the nations were all bowed down in the muck and mire of extreme economic nationalism, and the world is a net-work of discriminations." He went on to say that he hoped Britain, Japan, France, Germany and all the important countries would soon see the way clear to proceed simultaneously to support the doctrines of economic liberalism.
That same gentleman, responsible for that series of utterances, announced more recently than May that as America had led the world into the chaos in which it now finds itself, America should here and now take the lead towards the restoration of economic sanity.
Comment on this
It was carried through in nine commercial treaties within a month of the permission and in seven others afterwards. The barriers are coming down but they are not coming down fast enough and, until they are brought down faster, the world is going to find itself in its present situation, with very little appreciable change in the volume of unemployment. Despite that, we are going gaily ahead. If there is one set of papers which annoys Deputies more than another it is the sheaf of Imposition of Duties Orders which they receive regularly at the rate of about half-a-dozen per week. We go gaily ahead. If we were not to look outside the country, what is the result of economic nationalism, as we see it? Again, I have given these figures but they will bear repetition. So far as agricultural products are concerned, we have subsidised two or three crops at the rate of £3,000,000 per annum. What do we get for that? We get a decrease in the number of permanent employees on the land and an increase in the case of those temporarily employed. These about balance. There is no increase in the number of those who get wages for working on farms. There is said to be an increase in the number of farmers' families employed on the land. We do not know what the precise figure is but we shall find out one of these days. Certain agricultural grants are disposed of according to the number of persons working on the land. If a farmer can enter up his children as working on the land, he may get a bigger portion of the agricultural grant. Apart from the fact that there is no increase in the personnel employed on farms, those who used to be employed on farms find that their wages are down. The amount of purchasing power from agriculture is down by over £750,000 a year. We pay £3,000,000 in subsidising crops and the result is that those employed get more than £750,000 less wages than they used to get. In other words, we pay £3,000,000 a year to get in purchasing power £750,000 less than used to be got.
What does industry show? The biggest test on the industrial side is the Unemployment Insurance Fund. The figures are there to be checked. Every man who is in insurable occupation must have a stamp put on his card for every week he is in work. The tot of these stamps and of the moneys that pass in shows clearly—there is no question of dispute—what is the extra amount of employment given. That amounts to 25,000 persons taken in terms of whole-time employment. What we pay for that, we have yet to find out. Where do these 25,000 come from? I have dealt with this matter over and over again and my figures have not even been argued about. They may be challenged and a few thousand chopped off here and there. I do not regard the Minister for Industry and Commerce as a reliable guide but, according to the figures given by him relating to the building of houses, at the time he spoke in 1934 there must have been between 15,000 and 20,000 people extra employed in the building industry. The figure is probably nearer 15,000 than 20,000 but on the Minister's figures it might be more than 20,000. There were about 1,000 more employed in the sugar beet factories—another subsidised business. A certain number of extra people were employed because of the vast extent of the relief schemes. We have not the figures because the Ministry hides them. But we can garner the fruits of economic nationalism here and now.
We spent £3,000,000 in subsidising agriculture and there has been no permanent extra employment on the land, though certain members of the families of farmers have been thrown out to pretend to work on the land. We pay £3,000,000 for that. A sum of £750,000 less in wages goes to the agricultural community. We may get 25,000 extra people employed between industry and building but the big majority are in building. The latest claim for the whole of the tariffed industries is a tot of about 9,000 people. That makes no allowance for the people put out of other avenues of employment.
Comment on this
Dockers and tobacco people. A number of instances can be given if the Deputy wants them. The number of employees in commercial houses is down. The Deputy may say that that is a good change. It may be. He will say it is better to have people employed in productive industry than merely in exploiting goods, but from the angle of employment—and it was from that angle tariffs were looked to in this country so far as election promises went—are we any better off? What about the wages of those employed in industry? There is a reduction there. I am speaking of the wages handed out to each of these people at the end of the week. They are down by varying figures according to the industry concerned but they are down on the whole.
Comment on this
The Deputy denies that. The Deputy should read the Census of Production figures and make an ordinary calculation, dividing the number of people now in employment against the wage fund created in industry. If the Deputy tells me that that figure has to be adjusted because there is a vast number of juveniles in this employment he will then be accepting the arguments constantly put up from the Labour Benches and as constantly derided by his own Minister. The Minister tells me that the adult workers used to be about 2 per cent. and that that has not changed. If that be a fact, the Deputy can make his calculation and divide the number in employment into the fund created in industry.
Comment on this
I could go through the lists and have them tabulated with regard to the different industries, but I have not time at the moment to do that. This I tell the Deputy: that the wages on the whole are down. The Deputy knows that there is not much good in talking to a man and thinking he is going to be satisfied because he has got the same number of shillings or perhaps a little less than he got previously, when that man is thinking all the time in terms of the exchange value of his money, when that man is thinking of what he can buy with the wages he gets. Can he buy as much of the necessaries of life now as he used to buy with the same amount of money?
Comment on this
Apart from that, the Lord may be providing for the man who has not to buy across the counter. Is the Deputy talking to me about the index cost-of-living figure? No explanation has been attempted as to that figure. Does not the Deputy know that in every country in the world except ours, when the depression came on, the first drive against the depression was to try to increase the amount of money which the agriculturists got for their produce, even though that meant an uplift in the cost-of-living figure? If we have achieved even an apparent lowering of the cost-of-living figure, or if we have achieved this, that the cost-of-living figure has not shot up as much as it might, how is that being done? It has been done through free beef and things like that. Is that sound? Is that good economics? Why should we find it a proper thing to depress the farmer and hope for general good conditions in the towns, when the whole world, except a few countries that depend on export markets, have adopted a policy totally the reverse of ours? The experience of every other country in the world has been the very opposite to ours. They have tried to raise the prices of agricultural produce. We are depressing these prices, and then, though we do depress them and though the cost-of-living figure may be artificially lowered because there is a calculation made in the matter of free beef and things like that, nevertheless every man who is on the destitution or the semi-destitution line knows that he is paying more for his necessaries of life, for the things he has to use, than he was a few years ago. The Deputy cannot forget that the Government which he is supporting in this activity, and which the Labour Party is supporting, has taxed certain necessities and has pleaded as a justification for doing so the fact that the taxation of luxuries was not yielding as much as before and that the reason for the taxation of necessities is because they are necessities and that they are forced to rake in taxes from the great multitude of the people. No country set out deliberately to impose income-tax on the lower level of the community. This country did. It has achieved it by taxing the commodities used by the people. It is not income tax in the ordinary sense of the word, but it comes to the same thing. In imposing income-tax we do what is regarded as logical and humane. We calculate what is a man's subsistence allowance, his personal allowance. He is not taxed on that. The Government accepted that viewpoint, but they turn around and tax the man's necessities of life. They might just as well tax his income down to the man with £1 a week. That man is taxed at the moment. At any rate, we have there economic nationalism. We can see its results abroad and we now see them at home.
The worst folly of the Government has not been allowed to eventuate in this country. There has been a forced circulation of money in the community, money that is achieved by mortgaging the future. The people have withdrawn their bank balances, and people who had investments abroad have realised them. The local authorities are spending, but they are not meeting the service of the debt. The Government has mortgaged the future to a certain extent. It has borrowed and spent all it could, and we are having at the moment the benefits of the spending. We are not feeling yet to any great extent the disadvantages of the borrowing. That will be spread out over the next generation, which will feel the impact of the Fianna Fáil Government. The Government has compelled the local authorities to borrow and spend what they borrowed. On behalf of the nation the Government has borrowed, and it has added to the national debt and spent the money. Now we are in the position that every house built and every acre of land provided is an addition to the national debt.
Despite all these things, what can we see in the way of production? It is easy to pile up expenditure and to provide for services in the way the Government is doing, but no man in his own household would inaugurate and carry on increased expenditure for himself and his family unless he saw his income rise. But while the national income is falling the Government is increasing expenditure. There is nothing in the way of extra production which would enable the country to bear the weight of the additional services which have been thrown on the people in order to catch votes for the Fianna Fáil Government.
That is the economic side of the picture. Where are we on the national side? We are told at one time that at any rate, whatever might happen to this country externally, that if there was a good national purpose behind it the people would be prepared to tighten their belts and to suffer. The people have tightened their belts and they are suffering. But what are they suffering for, where is the national purpose? One finds a great deal of comments about the policy of the Government in these last few days. A great many people who have not been vocal about the Fianna Fáil Government up to this have suddenly found their tongues loosened. One man spoke to me to-day and said that he knew all along that the Government were wrong economically but he had been compelled by their national aims to support them. But then he said: "they are no longer republicans; they are good old stick-in-the-Commonwealth like the rest of you." What are they going to do now in the matter of the national position? What about their external and internal policies?
We were told at one time that the establishment of the Military Tribunal in order to put down crime in the country was bound to be regarded as a giving in to British propaganda. We were told that it meant that there were people in this country so vicious that they could not be ruled by ordinary means. President de Valera told us recently that if he had the making of a new Constitution, and he is supposed to be making it now, he would include the Military Tribunal as a permanent plank in that Constitution. Has the President accepted for the time that British propaganda that the people are so vicious that they could not be ruled by the ordinary means of government? He has done much worse. During the Dublin municipal elections his Minister for Finance made what was one of the most disgraceful, unfair, audacious and vicious speeches ever made by any person with any sense of responsibility in the State. He was questioned by an interrupter as to how he made a connection between the I.R.A. and murder, and his answer was explicit. He said: "We have the proofs and you will get them one of these days." And he added the monstrous words, "then these people will do no more shooting." May I analyse that? It means, I take it, that the Minister, as a member of the Executive Council, and who at that time was just fresh from imposing a ban on the I.R.A. as an illegal body, had seen a series of reports; that as a member of the Executive Council he was interested in trying to find out who committed that outrageous murder; that he had got evidence submitted to him and, as a member of the Executive Council, he had made up his mind upon it. What had he made up his mind about? That the I.R.A. was connected with it, that certain individuals belonging to that body were connected with it; that it had proof connecting these people with that crime, and he was convinced that these people were going to be hanged. If that is not prejudging an issue that is before the courts I do not know what is. The Minister said that publicly—the Minister who at one time described the members of the Military Tribunal as the bloodhounds of the Executive Council. The Minister is now in charge of the bloodhounds—it is not my phrase—and he announces in a public speech, which these bloodhounds can hear, that he who controls their commissions had made up his mind, on some of the evidence submitted to him, that certain people who were going to be produced before the Military Tribunal were guilty of that crime and should be done to death.
The President who derided the Military Tribunal, and the Minister for Finance who described them in that way, are now engaged in building up a Constitution. Probably their honour as officers will save that Tribunal from taking any lead like that, but Ministers think they can come out in public and give a lead like that to a body that was set up to be judicial in the trial of cases and impartial in its evidence; that they can go on to a public platform and say these things in the heat of the moment and then proceed to build up a Constitution containing such a body, which they will apparently lecture in that public way. They think they are going to end the internal difficulty that has arisen with regard to the so-called external point of difficulty.
I wonder is the external difficulty taken seriously? It was a good election cry, just like the 84,000 people that were to be put into production and the money that was to be forthcoming as a result of the Fianna Fáil industrial and economic policy when they got in. Where is the external difficulty now? As far as one can see, we are operating this way against our deadly enemies—trying to choke them with our best butter, as used to be said was the other way of killing a dog; selling it to them at less than the price we have to pay for it at home. We are helping them to build up their livestock industry at the expense of ours. We are hunting timidly without settling a variety of matters that were on the point of settlement when the Government came into office—such a settlement, for instance, as would prevent the conflict in Lough Foyle some weeks ago. Because we are at loggerheads with our enemies the British, whose livestock industry we carefully foster, and whose butter is provided for them cheaply, we cannot enter into negotiations about the Lough Foyle dispute because it might prejudice a still greater struggle we have with them. We are going to attend at the Meat Board. We will rub shoulders there with our ancient enemies.
When the President is called into the House on the League of Nations debate he finds himself forced of a sudden to declare that collective security has gone, and that if this country ever had faith in the League of Nations as a protector against attack by an aggressor nation it should abandon such faith. Then, when he is asked what is his policy for the defence of this island, he says, in answer to a series of questions put to him, that this country is not yet in the mood in which it can respond to an application for an alliance with Great Britain. He says that we will not ally with them, but we have this great security, that if a nation wants to attack us we know, and can rest confident in the knowledge, that Great Britain will not allow anybody to attack us. We will not ally with them, we will call them our enemies, we will not make agreements about Lough Foyle or anything else, but we will rely on them to see that no other nation will hit us. That is national policy.
What about this Meat Board? Sometimes chances do recur even in the lifetime of nations; but, chances missed once, generally go past and are never brought back. We missed Ottawa; we had a chance there for an economic settlement. We had a chance of entering into economic relations which we could enter into without loss of dignity. If we had entered into economic relations, undoubtedly the political differences would be smoothed over. We lost that chance. Some of the delegates there thought they had not lost it at the time. We were told that there was going to be a settlement within three weeks. So the Vice-President stated, and he has never denied that in this House. At any rate, Ottawa was lost.
The Ottawa agreement is now running out. The British are now facing up to a regularisation of their market for meat imports. They have announced quite openly that they are going to take one line of procedure. All meat imported from any place outside the Dominions is going to be taxed. Meat coming from the Dominions is not going to be taxed. The British farmer is going to be subsidised. The £4,000,000 which the British farmer is to get is now going to be meticulously measured out to enable the British farmer to get into the production of the best type of livestock—the livestock that we used to supply. They are now in a position to regularise that industry, because they have in recent years, under the cloak of the tariffs, got into their hands quite an appreciable number of the good herds of this country. They have not merely taxed us to the full amount that we said we would withhold from them, but they have got, as part exchange, capital goods from us in the shape of animals which they are now going to make the basis of their better-regulated livestock industry. At any rate, that market is still open to us. It is still open to us either as a foreign country, or as something inside the British Commonwealth. Circumstances have not enabled us to move outside the British Commonwealth but, apparently some circumstances, or some sort of secret pride, will not allow us to get the material advantage of being a member of the British Commonwealth while we are still in it.
The Ottawa chance now recurs. It was lost before. Is it going to be lost again? The agreements now being made are being made despite the immense amount of British money invested in the Argentine. Arrangements are going to be made against Argentine interests. They are going to be made first and foremost for the British producer, and, secondly, for the Dominion producer. Great Britain, according to the President's speech at the League of Nations, is perturbed at the thought of war. The British are taking steps to ensure a bigger production of home-produced or near-produced foodstuffs. This country is obviously the place to which they would ordinarily look. We have something to bargain with.
Comment on this
Great Britain, then, is looking for economic nationalism, and it will be their ruin?
Comment on this
Great Britain is not looking for economic nationalism. It is a country which must get markets abroad and could not possibly look for economic nationalism. One of the evils in the world, as well as economic nationalism, is war; and war is driving them to the type of insurance that everybody regards as the second worst thing to economic nationalism. Great Britain must get her insurance that way if there is going to be war. The nearer their foodstuffs are to be had in abundance, the less dissipation will there be of naval strength to guard them, and the Deputy knows that. That is the situation that we are faced with, and because Deputy Moore is still flirting with economic nationalism, because he is not yet sure that it has failed, and not yet able to read the signs of the times abroad, not yet able to learn a lesson from the experience of other countries, with that experience written down for everyone to read——
Comment on this
Would the Deputy allow me to read one quotation from a man who ought to be very interested in this matter? The speaker is Sir Harry McGowan, the Chairman of Imperial Chemical Industries which, I believe, has a capital of £95,000,000 distributed all over the world. Speaking a few weeks ago, about two days after Deputy McGilligan made the first of his statements about economic nationalism having been repudiated by practically every country in the world, Sir Harry McGowan, speaking of economic nationalism, said:—
"So far as one's vision can pierce the future there seems little likelihood of any disappearance of this feature. I.C.I. is, therefore, regrettably forced to follow its tendencies by adopting a policy of entering upon the establishment of local factories wherever the demand in a country is sufficiently large to make the establishment of an enterprise there economically sound. By this policy we combine the manufacture on the spot with some share in the remaining import trade. As the local market grows imports tend to increase."
Sir Harry McGowan says that "so far as one's vision can pierce the future there seems little likelihood of any disappearance of this feature." He ought to know a thing or two about it. He has been watching it just as closely as the Deputy.
Comment on this
I have yielded to the Deputy to give a quotation, but I do not want a speech from him. The Deputy has thrown Sir Harry McGowan into the scale against 55 nations, and he says very much the same as what is summed up in the international labour office report, namely, that the tendency away from economic nationalism was observable, and that it was only checked by those who had emerged from war conditions. With the imminence of war there is a natural strengthening of the view in favour of economic nationalism, but Sir Harry McGowan does not say that economic nationalism is the best thing for the world.
Comment on this
His statement does not indicate that the countries are running away from it. He says, "as far as the eye can pierce."
Comment on this
Because the cloud of war does not allow the eye to see straight. I would advise the Deputy to read the International Labour Office report, which is a marvellous production. The two things are there set in contrast. The report runs on two lines, that the general tendency of the world and the only healthy tendency of the world is in favour of the lowering of international barriers. It says that the healthy and sound movement towards this has been checked because of the appearance of war. It by no means says, nor does anybody who has given any thought to it say, that economic nationalism is in itself a good thing.
Comment on this
That was not what the Deputy was on at all. The Deputy was contending that the countries were abandoning it.
Comment on this
And so they were. In so far as they are not perturbed by the threat of war, they are still abandoning it. America has abandoned it. Despite Sir Harry McGowan, let us leave the world aside. Have we not seen the proofs of it here? Can anyone say that this country is progressing? If we can keep up an expenditure of about £50,000,000 over five years, extra to what we used to spend, we can carry on until the source from which we get that £50,000,000 has dried up. But what are we doing? We are spending that money uselessly, because it is useless if there is no new production. Think of all it has taken to build up the source from which much of that money is taken in the way of foreign investments, bank balances and things of that kind. Can anyone tell me, viewing what has developed in this country, and taking it away from threats of war by England or by anybody else, that our present situation is better than what it used to be? Economic nationalism has been tried here and has been found wanting, as it has been found wanting elsewhere. Let us abandon the phrase that it is a blessing in disguise. It is a disguise, but it is no blessing.
When I was interrupted I was speaking of the national objective. Will Deputies opposite tell me that the national objective is being as strongly pursued as they said it was going to be when their Party came into office? Will they tell me that they still have the confidence of the country on that matter? One does not want to single out individuals, but one does know of defections from the Party opposite. Will Fianna Fáil say that they have the support of their people generally for the programme they are carrying on at the moment and, if not, can they lay their fingers on where they have disappointed their supporters? Is it in economics or is it in nationalism, or is it in both? We no longer see those vast gatherings of people meeting and applauding Fianna Fáil speakers. We do see the same multitudes gathering at meetings heckling Fianna Fáil speakers. Their programme is somewhat in decay and their reputation is certainly in the mire. Their speakers are hiding. The meetings are not so many as they used to be, the voters are not as enthusiastic, the workers have not the same energy. Why has the Party gone so weak so suddenly? Whence the cause of the flabbiness? Why is there not the same gathering here to applaud President de Valera when he wants to make a speech on principle such as we used to see in this House before? There is no longer the same ring in the voices of Fianna Fáil speakers announcing that they were no political Party but that they were a sort of national phenomenon as, I think, they described themselves before. Why are they more uncomfortable even in this House, and certainly outside of it, than they used to be? Whom have they disappointed or, rather, whom have they pleased? If you give a licence to one man, how many dozen do you disappoint? For every one that your put into a post in the Civil Service, when at least 20 other people think that they are as well entitled to it, you find yourself left with 19 disgruntled people. If you try to run a policy on these lines of giving licences to favourites and posts to favourites and making promises which cannot be implemented, it does not take even the three or four years that the Fianna Fáil Party have been in office to get the hollowness of the whole thing exposed.
That is the position at the moment and yet the House is asked to vote this sum of money. There is only one hope that Fianna Fáil has in this Green Paper before us, and that is the point that Deputy Norton touched on at the end of his speech—whether this £2,500,000 road scheme can be got going in time sufficiently to synchronise with a possible general election and thereby help the people who will be walking the bog roads also to walk to the polling booths to vote for the people who are supplying the people's money to them. That is the only little bit of hope that there is in this mass of appropriations. Can the £2,500,000 road scheme be got going? Can we forestall the disappointment of the electorate and can we wheedle back some people to support us? If so, the £2,500,000, according to Fianna Fáil, will be well spent. What is the case for spending this £2,500,000? The Minister for Industry and Commerce told us in this House, about the month of April, that the unemployment problem dealt with a matter of 40,000 people. He had a turf scheme, he said, which was going to employ 50,000 or 10,000 more than represented that problem. That was all due to the industries that had been established as well as to house building and a few other things. But despite that the unemployment problem loomed so large in the eyes of the Minister for Finance that instead of lightening the load on the taxpayer he wants an additional £2,500,000 for a road relief scheme. Who wants relief if the Minister for Industry and Commerce is providing work for 40,000 and if by the simple procedure of making an Order certain people can be deemed to be employed during a period of the year? What is the necessity for a £2,500,000 road scheme in those circumstances? Are the roads in a bad state of disrepair? Is there any business reason for getting this sum of money spent? I need not wait for an answer. Everybody knows there is only one reason for the spending of that sum of money and that reason is, that Fianna Fáil as a Party need some little bit of sustenance for their supporters. They could not give them work. They do not like going on with all this relief of destitution. They cannot cajole them any longer with the national objective. They have decided not merely to ban the I.R.A., but the Minister actually goes and proclaims one of them a murderer—a man who will never do any shooting again. And the Minister does that, apparently, before that man has been paraded for his trial; he announces that, so far as he is concerned, he has prejudged the issue, and he gives his pointer to the men who are going to try that man.
The Minister and his Party must feel somewhat disappointed. They have failed in economics, they have failed nationally and acted outrageously when the life of a man, who is condemned by the Minister for Finance, is at stake. They are no longer getting the support that they wanted. We are now asked to pass this Appropriation Bill. Let us hope that it will be the last this Minister will ask us to pass. I submit that the tot can be lowered; it can be lowered without doing any harm to the people; it can be lowered by the disappearance of certain items only brought in in order to let the Minister wave the flag of war and endeavour to get the spirit of his people revived. I hold that there is a good economic arrangement to be made, and if, Ottawa having been lost, the Minister fails to get in on the new arrangement, then his disappearance from office will not eventually compensate for that defect. The Minister ought to realise that what is approaching him is something that will mould the fortunes of our people for many years to come and that he is gaining nothing by his appearance of belligerency. The belligerency has been derided. The people who were supposed to be belligerent do not count it as such. The Minister sulks in his corner. If I were to make an unworthy comparison, he is sulking in his tent.
Comment on this
It is more than the heel—it would apply to another part of his anatomy. The Minister has a body of experts around him. It was referred to in the course of the discussion on the Estimates that the Minister had a specialised body gathered around him. The Minister could ask those people who were sitting here while this battle was raging, while economic nationalism was being developed to the full and while the loss of markets was increasing every day, to turn their attention to that and not to such matters as deliberating about academic banking points, and get them to advise him so that he could advise us on the policy that he is carrying on at the moment. I would be content to leave it to them.
Comment on this
I think I can claim to be one of the best from the point of view of attendance in this Chamber. In all my experience, extending over years, I can say that I never heard a more dismal debate than that to which we have listened, if we except the man who has just gone out. Having regard to the jubilation that was evident over there to a very remarkable degree as a result of the municipal elections, one would have expected a much better discussion. Why has all the enthusiasm disappeared? Why was it necessary to wait for Deputy McGilligan to come along? There was a lot of strategy fixing up speakers until the Deputy entered the Chamber. Everybody likes to listen to Deputy McGilligan. Undoubtedly he is the best man on the Opposition. It is a pity that such an able man is over there. If he were here he would be appreciated. But we would not have to wait for him; we would have plenty of other men ready to speak. Something must have gone wrong after all the enthusiasm of seven days ago. Maybe it was not such a victory at all.
Deputy Morrissey is a very good-humoured man, so far as I know him, but when I happened to smile this evening at one of his observations he got rusty and asked me did I know there were 7,000 on the relief list in Dublin. I do not know the exact number, but I know there are quite a lot and I am sorry there are so many. Might I suggest to the Deputy that, after all, 7,000 people would represent about 1,000 families, and there are between 80,000 and 90,000 families in Dublin? My figures may be wrong, but I think I am near the mark. The proportion of families on relief here is not too large, having regard to the population. A lot of the people on relief include the lame, the halt, the blind and others incapable of work. Those people cannot earn their living, and, in the circumstances, I do not think that there is any reflection on the Government, who are trying to do their best to help the people.
What is the position to-day compared with the position in former years? I believe I could go back 63 years at least. When I was about five years old I began to take notice; in the community where I was born one had to take notice. At that period the British Empire was at the peak of its prosperity. The riches of the world went into London and Britain. What did they do for the people of Ireland when they were the governors? Very few here have an idea of how the poor in Dublin were then circumstanced. There was a lot of talk here to-night about nationality and the Commonwealth and all that sort of stuff. I am interested only in the people amongst whom I was born and reared. In those days the poor were not thought anything of. The poorhouses were there for them. The amount of relief given was very small. Only for the charitable organisations, especially the St. Vincent de Paul Society, I do not know what would have become of the poor. I remember when there was a death a pauper's coffin would come in. I well remember the white boards, and when the corpse was put into the coffin the lid was nailed, not screwed; we knew what was happening when we heard the hammering of the nails any time we passed the poorhouse.
In the churches at that time a notice was posted from Cardinal Cullen calling on the faithful that whenever a foundling child was discovered it should be brought to the nearest church to be baptised. What was the reason? At that time there was wrangling at the boards of guardians over the religion of a foundling, over the religion of a little child found in the streets or in the alleys. That was during the height of the British Empire's prosperity. I could relate many other things concerning it, but I do not want to do so because it would take up too much time. As the years rolled on and I became a member of the Dublin Corporation, was not unemployment rife then? Will there ever be a period in this or in any other country when unemployment will not be a problem? I said before here, and I do not think it is necessary to repeat it amongst intelligent men——
Comment on this
——and women, that the vast majority of the people are born poor, and will continue to be born poor as long as the world is a world. As a member of the Corporation I remember that every Christmas we used to hand out large sums of money years ago for the purpose of the alleviation of distress, and there was actually a permanent distress committee formed by the Corporation and in existence for years here. When your own Government was in power a few years ago, in every provision shop in Dublin there was exhibited the sign "Relief tickets taken here," and you are blaming this Government for their free beef, free milk and all the rest of it. You ought to remember that people have recollections over here. We were told a while ago that to sup with the devil one would want a long spoon, but when you talk about those things you are up against a man who has a long memory. This Government, in my honest opinion, is doing all that men could do to reduce unemployment. I do not know of any period in the history of this city when the poor were so well looked after as they are at present. I challenge contradiction on that, and I do not think anybody can contradict me. I am sorry that Deputy Morrissey made that statement to-day. I believe he is a good-hearted man, and I believe he is well-intentioned, but probably his recent incursion into Dublin municipal politics has soured him. I advise him to keep out of them for the future.
Comment on this
I am giving it to you in all good faith. The recent election will be of no solid comfort to you. Unfortunately, matters have arisen in connection with that which I deeply regret. After all, I am a parish politician. I take the rough with the smooth. I am as bad a politician as there is. I make more promises on election placards than any other man, and I forget all about the promises the next day. A man says to me: "You promised this and that," and I say to him: "Did I shake hands with you after I made the promises?" to which he replies: "No, you did not." The reason for that is that I do not shake hands with anybody. I am perfectly safe in that. Every time there is a debate here out come the Fianna Fáil promises. Fianna Fáil made those promises in good faith. They believed they could do those things. When they got up against the real facts they were up against difficulties, and they are doing their best.
I leave Deputy McGilligan's remarks to the Minister to reply to. He is well able to do it. I do not want to get into high economics or any of that sort of thing, but he referred to America and said that America was now breaking down the barriers which made her powerfully rich. She had barriers up against the world, and that is how she became so rich that her millionaires were as thick as blackberries. Then they were not even satisfied; they wanted more and more, and a lot of them became gamblers, but the gamble burst on a day, I think it was in October or November, 1929. That is what brought it about, but I do not think that America is ever going to do away with the barriers which made her wealthy, and made her people comfortable and prosperous. Deputy McGilligan speaks about the economic stone wall that is being erected around Ireland. That was Griffith's policy. He often said: "We will build a stone wall around Ireland and let nothing in," so if the Government are carrying out Griffith's policy I do not see why you should blame them.
I am not going to speak any longer. I have spoken now for ten minutes, and that is quite long enough for an ordinary man. I would not have stood up at all were it not for the remarks concerning unemployment and all the rest of it. I know what I am speaking about, and I know very well that the Government are doing good work. They are carrying out now as well as they can the democratic programme of Dáil Eireann which I read at the first Dáil meeting on 21st January, 1919. That programme set out what they were going to do for the democracy of this country—that no child would want food, clothing or sustenance, that the poor law system would be reformed, and certain other great measures brought in. None of those things was done for years. It was not until President de Valera and his men took office that a really genuine attempt was made to carry out that programme, and God speed them at their work, say I.
Comment on this
This debate has been rather like a ragman's sack, with an odd end of every sort in it. We had Deputy Dillon's eloquent disquisition on the fact that no consideration of material gain would induce the people to yield on a matter in which they thought the national honour was concerned. I am glad that Deputy Dillon at last has come to recognise that fact. The whole of his public efforts during the last four years has been devoted to inducing the people of this country to put material considerations before the national honour. I suppose that to-day we see Deputy Dillon, with his hands up, announcing the failure of the Fine Gael policy. The difficulty about Deputy Dillon is that he thinks too little and talks too much. We had an example of that policy in his speech to-day. He was talking in vacuo about the new Constitution which is not before us for discussion. What will be in that Constitution remains to be seen, and the people will have an opportunity of determining for themselves whether it does represent an advance towards the goal for which we in this movement—including some who are now on the opposite side of this House—have been working so long. When the Constitution is before us we can discuss it, but until then I think it would only be a wearisome waste of time to talk about it.
We then had Deputy Cosgrave on the subject of stallions, alluding to the fact that wealthy owners of stud farms in this country have to pay tax, in the same way as in any other business, upon the incomes which they derive from the profitable business of keeping stallions. He alleged that this was detrimental to the horse-breeding industry in this country. But when he was questioned by Dr. Ryan in regard to the matter he shifted his ground completely, and said that the disabilities which that industry labours under at the present moment arise entirely from other causes. Then we had Deputy Mulcahy, I believe, on Hans Andersen and fairy tales; and last of all we had Deputy Coburn talking on pigs and butter, and on capitalism; about the doors he crowed at and the doors he did not crow at—in short, giving us a full recital of his exploits as a farm-yard cock-a-doodle-do.
To crown all, however, we had the ex-Attorney-General, the former legal adviser of the Administration which, up until 1932, was headed by Deputy Cosgrave, who proceeded to tell us, in regard to the Appropriation Bill, that it is a Bill to take millions out of the pockets of the workers. Now, one might expect that at least an ex-Attorney-General-a one-time leader of the Irish Bar—might know what the real purpose of an Appropriation Bill was. The Finance Bill, I admit, imposes taxation, but the Appropriation Bill is the legislation which enables money to be taken out of the Exchequer and put back into the pockets of the workers. It is the Bill which gives us authority to spend money upon the public service, upon the wages of the Civil Servants, of the Gárda Síochána, of the Army—of one hundred and one other public officials—as well as upon widows' and orphans' pensions, upon old age pensions, and upon the varied services that are carried on by the Departments of Agriculture, of Industry and Commerce, and of Education. Whatever else the Appropriation Bill does, it does not take money out of the pockets of the workers. As I have said, it is the Bill which takes money out of the Exchequer and puts it into the pockets of the workers and of the community generally, and when, Sir, I have pointed out the manifest error into which the former Attorney-General has fallen in regard to the Bill under debate, I think that we can, by a consideration of that fact, evaluate fairly all the things that we have heard from the Opposition in the course of this discussion to-day.
Now, Sir, I think I could say quite truthfully that there is no limit to the audacity of ignorant men. They rush in where angels fear to tread. They make suggestions and assertions which people who are well-informed would not dare to make. I think it was yesterday that the House passed the Fifth Stage of the Finance Bill. The House agreed and decided by a solemn vote that the Finance Bill for the year would become law. I am not certain whether Deputy Costello was in his place or not on the occasion. I suppose, if he had been here, he would have voted with his Party and, with his Party, would have been defeated. The House, however, heard certain proposals which, I submit, Sir, were fully discussed—proposals designed to secure the due and proper collection of the revenue of this country, and proposals designed to curb the dishonest taxpayer in his efforts to evade payment of what is properly due by him, and to protect the honest taxpayer against the consequences of that evasion. The House must remember in that connection that if an income-tax payer succeeds in evading the payment of tax which is properly due by him, it is not the Exchequer which loses. As I have said before, we have to get the money to carry on the public services, and if we fail to collect the full amount of income-tax which is properly due—if some man by some subterfuge or trick or concealment manages to evade the payment of his income-tax—we simply have to call upon the general body of the taxpayers, the honest hard-working people of this country, to make good that man's default. Therefore, as I have said, it is not the Exchequer which suffers from the efforts of a dishonest taxpayer, but it is every other honest citizen in this country who has to suffer. I am sure that it was by a true appreciation of that fact that the House, having heard the arguments for and against the proposals which we have submitted to it in the Finance Bill of the year, has decided to give us the powers and the authority which we think necessary in order to ensure that the revenue which is due to the State, and which we require to carry on the public service, will be properly and duly collected.
Comment on this
What have we had from Deputy Costello to-day? We had a most audacious request. I think the Deputy must have spoken with his tongue in his cheek. He has asked us—asked me here, on the day after the Finance Bill has been passed by an overwhelming majority of this House, or at the least by a substantial majority—not to enforce the law. He asks me to guarantee that the Revenue Commissioners will not exercise the powers which the House has given them in order, as I said before, that they might collect what is properly due to the community as a whole. Now, I think that almost beggars description. I can only remember one thing to parallel it, and that is a statement, which also came from Deputy Costello, to the effect that if a dishonest taxpayer got away with it—well, in his view he deserved to get away with it. There is one thing about the Opposition and that is that their capacity for changing their position reminds one of a weathercock. For instance, to-day Deputy Costello, who, when the Finance Bill was before the House, was prepared to cheer the dishonest taxpayer who was getting away with the goods, now asks me to be ruthless against the dishonest taxpayer and to suspend the law against other people.
I want to say this: That, so far as the revenue laws are concerned, they are going to be enforced without fear or favour. I have come definitely to the conclusion that the fact that the State could not make assessments if an income-tax payer succeeded in evading his obligations for a period of six years—the fact that they could not make assessments after that date was merely an inducement to the taxpayer to conceal his true income, because he knows that if he can manage to conceal it for a period of six years—or at least he felt up to this that if he succeeded in concealing his true income for a period of six years—then the law and the Revenue Commissioners have no terrors for him and he could proceed to sit down and enjoy his illgotten gains. I think that it is not in the public interest that taxpayers should feel that, if they should succeed in defrauding the revenue for a period of six years, they can then live with impunity. The one thing I want to bring home to everybody is this: That it is much better in the long run for an income-tax payer to make a true and accurate return, so far as he can make it, of his income and get a clear discharge from the State for these taxes which are due.
And I believe there is good public reason for that. After all, we have to admit that those who pay income-tax are, by comparison with the people whose income is not large enough to warrant collecting direct taxation from them, in a rather fortunate position. Most of them are in fairly comfortable circumstances, and it is not an unjust imposition to ask them to pay income-tax. Income-tax, as we collect it and as it is collected in Great Britain and certain other countries, is a very just and equitable tax indeed. There is nothing which would justify evasion of that tax on a large scale by income-tax payers. But, if you take the case of people not in that rather fortunate category of income-tax payers, the working man or the working farmer, and those who are living upon small incomes, they cannot evade taxation, because, just as our predecessors did, we also are compelled to levy what is known as indirect taxation, that is, taxation upon consumable commodities. We have it on tea, on sugar, on tobacco on stout and beer, and if a person does not want to pay indirect taxation, then he can do—as Deputy Cosgrave told the House when he was President of the Executive Council— without sugar, without beer, and without stout. That is the only way he can get out of the payment of indirect taxation. The great mass of the people —almost 95 per cent. of them—cannot evade taxation in that indirect form because, of course, they have to consume these things in order to live. Since the less fortunate section of the population cannot succeed in defrauding the revenue, why should the more fortunate section be given privileges which are denied generally to the community?
I wish to make it clear, therefore, that the best way of dealing with the Revenue Commissioners is to deal with them honestly. The Revenue Commissioners, the inspectors of taxes and those enforcing the revenue laws, have no other concern except to collect the amount which is justly and properly due from any individual. If there is an income-tax payer who is in any difficulty as to what is assessable for income-tax and what is not assessable, he can go to the inspector of taxes and he may be quite certain that the inspector will not take from him one penny more than the taxpayer justly owes, and he can have all difficulties regarding income-tax law and revenue law and the complications about which Deputy Costello was talking, cleared up, and cleared up by a person who will hold the scales evenly as between the taxpayer on the one hand and the revenue on the other hand. It is not the practice and it is not the tradition of the Revenue Commissioners to try to take from the taxpayer what he does not owe.
I may go further and say this, that the Revenue Commissioners are always prepared to deal as leniently as they possibly can with a defaulting taxpayer, even with a taxpayer who has been, I will not say proved guilty of wilful fraud, but who, there is very grave and serious reason to suspect, has been guilty of wilful fraud. They are always prepared to deal leniently with that class of offender because they do not operate the income-tax law as a penal code. They collect it just the same way as they collect taxes upon any consumable commodity. All that we heard from Deputy Costello about the Revenue Commissioners having an expert staff who are ruthless and without conscience in their methods, is merely the sort of thing which a lawyer will utter who is pleading from his brief. Deputy Costello does not believe it. On the contrary, I am perfectly certain that he has good reason, within his own knowledge, to bear testimony to the reasonable way in which the Revenue Commissioners deal with cases of the sort.
Let us be quite clear about this. We heard stories here about cases being reopened where settlements had been arrived at. I say this, that no case has been reopened where the taxpayer making the settlement made a full disclosure of all the facts, all his assets to the Revenue Commissioners. I know cases where a taxpayer, after investigation by officials of the Revenue Commissioners, was ultimately discovered to be operating four accounts and a settlement was reached. What happened? The settlement was reopened because the taxpayer paid by cheque drawn on a fifth account. I heard of another case where a settlement was arrived at similarly, and then by a mistake on the part of the taxpayer, in dealing with his assets, it was discovered that he had £80,000 on deposit, which he had not disclosed when seeking a settlement. Do you think the Revenue Commissioners would be doing their duty to the State which employs them, to the people of this country who pay taxation in order to pay their salaries, and to all the other citizens who would have to make good—let me repeat— the deficiency if we failed to collect income tax and other taxes due upon that £80,000 of concealed deposit? Do you think the Revenue Commissioners would be doing their duty if they did not make the person guilty of that concealment pay up? Deputy Costello talked of a case in which a decision given by the court had been reopened. Here was a case in which the taxpayer not merely deceived the Revenue Commissioners, but went into court and deceived the bench. When the settlement was reopened he threatened to bring the Revenue Commissioners into court, but his courage failed him, and he settled outside court and paid the Revenue Commissioners what they told him was properly due from him. Why was that? Because if he had gone into court it would be proven that he had perjured himself by making a false declaration of assets, and he would have found himself, not settling with the Revenue Commissioners by a monetary payment, but possibly serving a sentence of imprisonment for being guilty of perjury and contempt of court.
If taxpayers who have succeeded by making false income-tax, returns in defrauding the revenue did not live in the Twenty-Six Counties but lived in Great Britain, if they were British income-tax payers, every time they made a false declaration of their income to the Revenue Commissioners they would leave themselves open to a charge of perjury. It is due to that fact that the Revenue Commissioners in Great Britain are able to deal with the situation which we have brought in a special provision in the Finance Act of this year to deal with. I do not know which defaulting taxpayers would like best; a salutary term of imprisonment in addition to the alternative which we are giving them of paying what they justly owe.
Before I touch upon a question raised by Deputy Norton and also by Deputy Costello I might refer to another point which Deputy Costello made in his speech. He said that there had been certain disquieting statements made in regard to promotions. In that connection, the Deputy mentioned the announcement which was made at the beginning of this year that the Chief Establishment Officer, whose services I very highly appreciate and whose retirement I very much regret, had indicated to me that for certain personal reasons he proposed to retire at the end of this year and that another officer of the Civil Service, a very competent officer, as Deputy Costello himself had to acknowledge, had been designated to take his place. The Deputy seemed to think that because an announcement of this sort had been made a long time in advance, there was something sinister about it. I should like to tell the Deputy that that announcement was made after consultation with, and on the advice of, my advisers. It is the first time we have had to announce the retirement of a high officer of the Civil Service in this way, but I understand it is customary to designate some time in advance who the successor of the retiring officer is likely to be. There is nothing unusual or sinister in the fact that we have made this announcement.
As to the person chosen, Deputy Costello admits that so far as he knows, he is a very competent official. I can bear testimony to that. I can say that he is both competent and conscientious and, in my judgment, in every way fitted to succeed the very experienced officer whose place he will, in due course, take. I make no apology for recommending the Executive Council to appoint that officer, because the duties of an Establishment officer are possibly the most difficult any civil servant could be called upon to discharge. Not everybody would have the requisite qualifications to fill such a post. In the first place, he must be a person in whom the Executive, the Minister, and the Service as a whole will have confidence. He must be firm; he must be impartial; he must be a person of unassailable rectitude in every way. I am satisfied that the officer who has been chosen as an Assistant Secretary designate of my Department, as the Chief Establishment Officer designate, has all the qualifications that are required. The Minister for Finance must necessarily work in very close co-operation with such an officer and I, at any rate, feel that I could not have chosen more wisely. I make no apology to any person for having suggested him to the Executive Council for the position and for securing the assent of my colleagues to make that appointment in my Department.
The Deputy also referred to another appointment which has recently been made. In that case, I would like to make it clear that the person appointed to the position in question had a claim to a very high office in the Civil Service, a claim dating back before the establishment of the Provisional Government of the Free State, a claim based on sacrifices which he made in order to serve this people abroad. In no way is he being treated differently to any other member of the Civil Service of Dáil Eireann. He has come back into a position comparable to that from which he retired. I say that he has retired from politics wholly and will henceforth be a civil servant subject to the limitations which membership of that Service involves.
People in glass houses ought not to throw stones. When we came into office, we came in in circumstances which, in the opinion of a great many people in this country, would have warranted our adopting a different policy to that which we did adopt towards those who were in the public service. It is no use reopening the whole position, but we all know what happened in 1922, 1923 and 1924, when there were no Civil Service Acts to regulate the admission of civil servants. We disturbed no person in his position. There even had been some appointments made just prior to our assumption of office. I make no apology for the course which we pursued. I believe it was in the best interests of the country. I believe it has justified itself in the honest and zealous service which those people who were appointed by our predecessors, in the circumstances I have mentioned, have given to us. I can certainly say, in regard to one of the Departments for which I have responsibility that, in respect to persons who were appointed to very high positions there, I could not expect any better service from other men. I am prepared to say that. I think that what we have done has been justified by the results in the Service.
The one thing which I set myself to do, when I became the Minister responsible for the Civil Service, was to keep it free from politicalisation. I looked upon every individual in it as a person upon whom I could depend, as a person in whom I could have confidence, and as a person who was prepared, like myself, to give the best he could in the interests of the Irish people. I say that policy has justified itself, and I am perfectly certain that when the time comes for us to leave office, any appointments we have made of people who might appear to have political affiliations, will be found equally to have justified themselves by results. We have made comparatively few appointments. There is a great responsibility on members of the Executive Council, and the law gives— quite properly—to the Executive Council and to Ministers certain powers in regard to these appointments. I think that, when the circumstances warrant it and justify it, it would be wrong for us not to exercise these powers. They are exercised very sparingly.
Comment on this
The Minister's claim is that the Fianna Fáil Government has lived up to our standards.
Comment on this
The Deputy will please remember that I did not open this subject in debate. It need not have been opened here, but since the Deputy's colleagues have opened it, I am entitled to say this—and I do not want to start cutting notches in sticks, one against the other—that we have made very many fewer appointments to the Civil Service in what is known as the public interest, than when the Deputy's Party was in office.
Comment on this
The Minister's statement is that we laid down an excellent staff, and that Fianna Fáil are going to follow that standard.
Comment on this
I do not want to decry what the Deputy's Party did. I did not open up this subject. It was the Deputy's colleagues, Deputy Costello and Deputy McGilligan, that opened it up. Deputy McGilligan talked about jobs and said that when one appointment was given to one person it disgruntled 20 others. If I were to pursue that line I might say in regard to Deputy McGilligan that in his case he would not expect that because all the jobs were kept within the family circle.
Comment on this
The Minister implies that the appointments made by the Cabinet previous to Fianna Fáil were appointments of a kind that served Fianna Fáil magnificently, and as well as anybody could, and he explained that any appointments they have made will do the same for any subsequent Government.
Comment on this
I have said, and I have no desire to go back of it, that those whom we found in the Civil Service appointed by my predecessors, as far as I have come in contact with them, have given me as loyal and zealous service as I could expect from any men. The Deputy's Party may have been responsible, but these people have justified themselves by the results. But the Deputy need not try to behave like a babe in a kindergarten class trying to dot the "i's."
Comment on this
It is not the first time that the Deputies opposite have raised this matter here. I hope that appointments in the Civil Service, and promotion in the Civil Service, will not be raised here again unless there is some glaring scandal to be exposed. I do not want to be a party to having any glaring scandal concealed. I would much rather come cut in the open and deal with it; but there are no glaring scandals.
Deputy Norton and Deputy Costello touched upon the question of arbitration and wanted to know what the Government's position is in regard to it. The position, in that regard, is the same to-day as it was in January, 1932, when the President, then Deputy de Valera, said: "I believe it is only right that there should be an arbitration board for the Civil Service, to deal with matters between the Service and the Executive." That is our position to-day. We are taking steps to set up such a board. Deputy Norton said that when this undertaking was given no question of setting up a commission of inquiry was mentioned. Did the Deputy think that any Government would be entitled to make such a far-reaching innovation in our Civil Service without first of all having a searching investigation into all its circumstances? The terms of reference to the Brennan Commission made it quite clear that the principle of arbitration had been accepted by the Government. The Commission drafted a report in the light of the fact that they must devise a scheme of arbitration which, of course, would be consistent with the fact that financial control is vested in the Oireachtas, that is consistent with the ordinary safeguards the constitution imposes for the protection and safeguarding of the interest of the citizens in this State in regard to matters of public expenditure. The Commission did evolve a scheme which would work.
Comment on this
Alright. I shall stick to scheme, but I am going to stick to scheme because I believe that the Report has given an arbitration scheme, in the words of the Deputy, in which the service can have confidence.
Comment on this
If we take the trouble to prepare a scheme, and embody it in a Bill, and bring it before the Oireachtas, we shall do it because it will be a workable scheme designed to give effect to the President's undertaking.
We have heard a lot of talk about the fact that the Government referred this matter to a Commission of Inquiry. But it is strange that those for whom Deputy Norton professes to speak did not say at once, when this Commission was set up, that the President did not mention anything about a commission in the course of his speech at Rathmines in which he dealt with this along with a multitude of other matters. They did not start, then, to decry the commission. Instead they prepared evidence; and the one fact that emerged in the course of the hearing by the commission, was that the evidence disclosed that there was no unanimity amongst the staffs, representatives themselves as to the form of the arbitration they desired.
Comment on this
I shall deal with that in due course. As I said, the staffs themselves were not unanimous in the proposals they submitted to the Board.
We have been blamed for delay. But it took the staffs a long time to formulate their proposals before this Commission. But what then were the facts? As I have already said a dozen times, this interim report of the Commission of Inquiry clearly demonstrates that on account of constitutional difficulties inherent in any scheme of arbitration for the Civil Service, there was the desirability and necessity for having this whole matter fully investigated. What, then, was the position? We set up a tribunal in May, I think. The Commission was formally appointed on the 22nd of June, and from the 27th of October, 1932, to the 6th of April, 1933, it heard evidence on arbitration. The delay between the 22nd of June and the 27th of October was due in some measure to the fact that the staffs were not ready to submit their proposals to the inquiry. On the 5th of February, 1934, the Commission's interim report was submitted to me. On the 14th of February, in reply to a question by Deputy Norton, I said I received the report but was not in a position to state when it would be published. On the 25th April, 1934, at a meeting of the Civil Service Representative Council, the staff-side leader said that it would be desirable and reasonable that the Executive Council should have the views of the Representative Council before reaching a decision on the Commission's interim report. He added that it would be most unfortunate if the staff side who attended the Council was not consulted. On the 16th May of that year the interim report was presented to the Dáil, and on the 17th May it was published in the Press. On the 18th May, 1934, a statement was issued by certain staff service organisations condemning the report. On the 19th May, 1934, all the staff organisations were presented with a copy of the interim report and notified that the report would be discussed at a meeting of the Civil Service Representative Council to be held on 24th May. On the 4th July the Civil Service Federation intimated on behalf of their constituent associations that they would not take part in the proposed discussion on the interim report. Naturally, if the Civil Service organisations were not prepared to discuss a report made by so weighty a commission as the Brennan Commission, prepared with a great deal of trouble and signed by the overwhelming majority of the members of that commission, representative of every shade of opinion and of every interest in the community, they had only themselves to blame for any delay which subsequently took place.
Comment on this
The Commission was representative as a whole of the overwhelming majority of the people.
Comment on this
There were people there as well entitled to call themselves labour representatives as others are.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy think that only those who happen to belong to his organisation or some other organisation are entitled to call themselves labourers?
Comment on this
I am not prepared to canvass the personnel of the Commission in that way. There were people there who earn their living by their own toil, and they signed the majority report.
Comment on this
I said they were representative of every shade of opinion and of every interest. Am I to proceed to discuss what members may fall within the definition of "shade of opinion," and what others on the other hand, would come within the categories which comprise "every interest"? Amongst those who signed the majority report are people who have to earn their bread as the Deputy and I and other workers have to do. They are not representatives of any privileged class. I was giving the history of this matter when I was interrupted.
Comment on this
We proceeded then to draft a scheme and, on the 8th June, 1935, the approved draft scheme was submitted to all the staff organisations with a request for their written observations upon it. That scheme has not received, so far as I am aware, very careful or detailed consideration from the staff associations. They simply rejected it incontinently, without any regard to the labour which had gone to its preparation and without any regard to the consequences. One thing the staff organisations must get hold of, as I said before, is that we have given nobody a blank cheque. If they do not proceed to consider these proposals in detail, if they do not take as much trouble as we did to draft their proposals in detail or submit their criticisms of the scheme which we have put before them in detail, then I think they are going to get nowhere. Certainly I am not prepared, in view of the complexity of this question, to spend valuable time discussing these matters to and fro across a table unless we get some definite skeleton upon which to work. That would be merely a waste of time and would lead us nowhere.
Comment on this
Have the fortnightly conferences between the Labour Party and the Government broken down?
Comment on this
The Deputy would not be suitable as chairman of an arbitration tribunal in that regard. I am speaking now to the Civil Service as a whole and I wish to say that, if we are to get anywhere in regard to this matter, they will have to do as much as we have done for them. We have submitted a complete scheme and, before we can get any further in regard to negotiations or anything else, we must have from them a statement similar to that which has been circulated. When we see that statement, we shall be in a position to say whether there would be any use in arranging a meeting or not.
Comment on this
Would the Minister answer two simple questions? The first question is: Is the scheme which the Minister has submitted to the staff organisations the Minister's last word on arbitration? The second question is: Will the Minister call a conference if he gets the detailed views of the staff conception of what an arbitration tribunal should be?
Comment on this
I am not going to answer those questions. I am not in the dock with regard to this matter. I am stating what the position is. The organisations ought to remember that the sands of time are running. We have a very heavy legislative programme in front of us. If the Civil Service organisations are going to take up the non-possumus attitude they have adopted up to the present, they may be in grave danger of losing their scheme altogether.
Comment on this
"Their scheme." The scheme is not a scheme of arbitration at all. The Minister called it a "draft scheme." It is really a "daft scheme."
Comment on this
If it does not reach the Statute Book in this Dáil, I am afraid some people will be "dafter" than we——
Comment on this
A very sound and practical scheme has been devised. We are prepared to implement that scheme. We are prepared to put it on the Statute Book but we are not prepared to put it there if it is not going to be worked.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been talking about organisations. The fact is that his letter was signed by 19 out of 31 organisations.
Comment on this
There are 31 organisations in the Civil Service and the Deputy's communication was signed by 19 of them. Even if signed by the 31 it would not matter. Nobody gave a blank cheque——
Comment on this
We are prepared to write our proposal on the Statute Book as the best we can do for the Civil Service while, at the same time, discharging our duty to the citizens.
Comment on this
In any event I prefer to state once more the position with regard to arbitration. I think the Brennan Commission devised a sound and practical scheme. We intended to implement that scheme but it is questionable now whether it is worth our while to go ahead if we are still to be met with the passive resistance which the staff has shown to us ever since that scheme was published.
Comment on this
Whether it is or not I think the Civil Servants would be crying out yet for arbitration and they would continue to be met in the way they were met prior to 1932 were it not for the fact that we set up that commission to the report of which we are now prepared to give effect. As I say we are prepared to give effect to the recommendations of that commission and let Deputy Norton take care if some other people come to take our places that when they appreciate the difficulties in this matter——
Comment on this
Because unlike Deputy Mulcahy when he was here, I do not think I hold this office, or that we hold the Government in perpetuity. We do not think that we shall last forever on the Government Benches. We are not going to make the mistake our predecessors made. Possibly Deputy Norton may be here on these benches some day and I warn him now if he does reach here that he will not be so ready to concede to everybody everything they ask for.
Comment on this
The manifesto stands and our scheme fulfils the pledge in the manifesto. I was going to say something about Deputy McGilligan. The Deputy talked about reputations being in the mire. Now the report of the commission on the gold mining in Wicklow has given Deputy McGilligan's reputation a perpetual mud-bath which will neither beautify nor cleanse it.
Comment on this
On the Fifth Stage I would like to refer to a matter which was raised by Deputies Dillon and MacDermot. The Deputies referred to the report of an address recently given by a member of the Civil Service before the Irish Students' Association at Trinity College. I would like to make it clear that prior to speaking on this occasion the officer in question consulted me as to whether there was any objection. He informed me that the invitation to give the address was extended to him and had been accepted by him while still Minister. A short time prior to the date fixed for the delivery of the address he had become a civil servant, and it occurred to him as the date of the engagement drew near that the delivery of his address might be questioned. In view of the fact that an undertaking to speak on the occasion had already been given and also because the officer informed me that his address would deal with the subject in an abstract way and would not touch in any event on internal or Party matters, I informed him that under the circumstances I would raise no objection to his fulfilment of his original engagement. Ordinarily, I would not have granted permission as civil servants, particularly those in the more responsible posts, speaking on occasions of this sort run the risk of trenching on matters of public policy in regard to which there may be conflicting opinions, and, in a way which would be contrary to the public interest, may subsequently find themselves involved in public controversy. I know that the officer concerned would greatly regret that any words of his might lead to such a development, and that he does not wish his statement on this occasion to be applied to subjects of current controversy. Accordingly, I think we need not discuss the matter further.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister whether on this stage of the Bill he would address himself to the most important question raised here by a number of Deputies. That is the position of our agricultural industry at the present time in relation to live stock and live-stock products and the new committees and conferences that are about to be formed immediately in Great Britain with regard to the meat market there. We have set up here a very expensive machinery of Government. There have been many references to the enormous increase in the expense of that Government since the Fianna Fáil Party came into office. The people who support that cost of Government have, as their economic foundations, the farming community in the country. Now, since the Fianna Fáil Party came into office the farmers have lost in exports of live stock and live-stock products alone up to £12,000,000 a year. This is reflected to the individual farmer by the prices of cattle. I will deal simply with the prices of cattle at Irish fairs. The departmental statistics and the prices realised by Irish farmers at Irish fairs are published in the various departmental publications including the Irish Trade Journal. In the year 1930 the price of two to three-year-old store cattle at Irish fairs averaged £15 12s. 9d. In the following year, that is 1931, the average price was £14 17s. 6d. Last year the average price was £6 17s. 9d. The price for store cattle three years and over, and fat cattle of various kinds fell in the same proportion so that there was a drop between the year before the Fianna Fáil policy was put into operation in this country and last year of £7 10s. per head in the price of store cattle two to three years and upwards. There was a drop of £8 4s. per head in the price of store cattle three years and over, and there was a drop of £8 7s. in the price of fat cattle two to three year old. There was a fall of £8 17s. in the case of fat cattle three years and upwards. That is the position of the farmer in respect to the live-stock industry. He is hit in the same way in regard to live-stock products.
We sent a deputation to Ottawa in 1932. The sending of that deputation was planned before the Fianna Fáil Party came into office. The deputation was for the purpose of making arrangements there that would improve the 1931 prices and get back to the 1930 prices as far as possible. Nothing was done by the deputation this State sent to Ottawa. As Deputy McGilligan has pointed out, an opportunity arises this year of remaking our claims and getting back as far as possible in the British market to the 1930 prices or at least to the 1931 prices. There is not a man, either in the Fianna Fáil Party or outside it, with any interest in agriculture, who would not be glad to go back to these prices. There is an opportunity this year of doing something to get back to these prices. There is, on the other hand, an opportunity to be lost. There is an opportunity that will prevent the setting up of vested interests in the British market prejudicial to our interests there.
It has been stated by the Vice-President, whatever took place at Ottawa, that negotiations took place there which promised in a very short time—"immediately" was his word— to end the economic war that had arisen between ourselves and Great Britain and bring about a situation in which the British penal tariffs against our cattle would be taken off. Four or five times that statement has been repeated in this House, and the Vice-President's exact words have been quoted. The President has denied that the Vice-President made that statement. The Minister for Agriculture has denied that the Vice-President made that statement. On the last occasion on which the President dealt with the matter, less than a fortnight ago, he said he would draw the attention of the Vice-President to the fact that it was complained in this House that the Vice-President had never denied that the statement was made. On the face of it the statement was made. On the face of it negotiations went on in Ottawa which warranted the Vice-President in making the statement, and, as the President explained, a political matter was drawn across it. So that our farmers have suffered during 1932, 1933, 1934, 1935, and up to now in 1936, the enormous losses shown in the fall in income from the British market of £12,000,000 a year in respect of live stock, and all because a political question was drawn across what was practically an economic agreement arrived at there.
Is the same political question going to be drawn across the possibility of successful negotiations in London during the coming months that will restore our position in the British market, give us a market for the produce which our farmers are capable of producing, must produce if they are going to make use of the ordinary resources of our country and must dispose of if this country is going to be prosperous or rear up any kind of an industrial fabric to give employment to our people?
That is the vital question facing both the Government and the people at present. The Government are in office because they swore to the people that the interests of the people would be the thing that they would keep in mind, that they would avoid war, that they would avoid losses to the people, and that they would build up industry. They promised to every man, woman and child over 14 years of age working at agriculture an income of £16 per head per year more than they were getting in 1931. I have shown what they are getting. Their whole future prospect of any kind of a decent livelihood out of agriculture depends upon what happens at the meetings in London within the next couple of months and on the decisions arrived at. We want to know what the Government are going to do about the matter. Are they going to leave the people of the country in the position in which they were left after Ottawa?
Comment on this
With regard to the question of the meat supplies to the British market, I can only say that the High Commissioner is keeping in touch with the British authorities in regard to that matter, and so far the arrangements have not been unsatisfactory.