We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Agricultural Wages Bill, 1936—Second Stage.

Contributions 1–148 of 277. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Agricultural Wages Bill, 1936
Enacted

No. 37 of 1936 ›

James Ryan Minister for Agriculture (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

I move that the Bill be now read a Second Time. This Bill to deal with agricultural wages is, as far as the document itself is concerned, a very simple measure. But behind it there lies a rather difficult and complicated question which deserves to be treated at length so that the House may have an opportunity of knowing what were the reasons for bringing the legislation forward. In order to get a perspective of the whole background of this question, I am afraid I shall have to go rather deeply into figures of the economics of farming and so on, so that I may make a case, first of all, as to the necessity for this measure, and, secondly, prove that it is not going to do any undue injury to any part of the agricultural population.

We must go back to the census of the rural population to get an idea of how the numbers stand as between farmers and farmers' relatives and agricultural labourers. The latest that we have at the moment are the 1926 figures. At that time, there were 268,930 farmers; 206,382 sons and daughters; 57,713 other relatives; and others 12,695; which gives roughly 546,000 on that side—that is on the side of owners of property. On the side of the agricultural labourers we had living out—"not living in" is the census heading—89,963; and "living in" 36,446; which gives 126,000. Therefore, the holders of land, with their relatives, totalled 546,000, as compared with 126,000 agricultural labourers, as returned by the census of 1926.

The next thing that I should like to do is to get some idea of the remuneration of agriculturists. If we take the same time, there was an output of agriculture taken and a very full analysis of the figures made at that time. We find that the remuneration of all people engaged in agriculture, in the year 1926-27, was £59,250,000. It was calculated by the statisticians at the time that paid agricultural workers were in receipt, on an average, of £66 each, and the others, that is, farmers and farmers' relatives, if the remainder was divided amongst them, would be in receipt of £93 each.

The next matter that I should like to bring before the House is the distribution of agricultural labourers. The big majority of agricultural labourers are found in Leinster and Munster; the numbers in Connaught and Ulster are very much smaller. Out of the 136,000 I have spoken of, there are 102,000 in the two provinces of Leinster and Munster, and they are about equally divided between the two provinces. There are only 24,000 in Connaught and the three Ulster counties, and they are also equally divided between the two provinces. If again we look at the distribution of the agricultural labourers according to the size of farms, we find from the same Census of 1926, which enumerated the number of agricultural workers at work, there were only 32,000 on farms under 50 acres, and that compared with 391,000 farmers and relatives gives only 7.5 per cent. of the agricultural population as agricultural labourers on these farms under 50 acres. If we take farms over 50 acres, there were 75,000 labourers working on them, as against 137,000 farmers and relatives, so that they formed 35 per cent. of the population. Again, when we come to the larger-sized farms—over 100 acres—the labourers amount to about 50 per cent. of the agricultural population.

We have often been asked why this question was not dealt with sooner, and the example of England and Wales was quoted to us as having such a system of regulation of agricultural wages. The facts with regard to population and distribution of labourers are, at any rate, quite different. While the agricultural labourers form only 20 per cent. of our total agricultural population, in England and Wales they form 63 per cent. It is obvious from these figures that in England and Wales they were dealing with a situation where you have much larger farms than we have here and a much bigger proportion of hired labour. That may make our problem easier perhaps in some respects, but it may make it more difficult in others. At any rate, that is the fact.

The most striking thing about agricultural wages is the great disparity in the rates. We all know that there is a certain average given each year of wages paid. This year, 1936, the figure given is 21/9. But when we come to examine the wages paid in some detail we find that in 1935 —I have not got the detailed figures for 1936—13.2 per cent. of agricultural labourers were paid less than 17/-; 15.9 per cent. were paid 17/- and under 20/-; 46.4 per cent. were paid 20/- and under 25/-; 15 per cent. were paid 25/- and under 30/-; 7 per cent. were paid 30/- and under 35/-; and 2.5 per cent. were paid 35/- and over.

Comment on this

Do these figures apply to those living out?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Altogether.

Comment on this

How many were taken into consideration in working out the figures?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

As far as I remember, the number of farms taken—I do not know the number of labourers—was somewhere about 3,000.

Comment on this

Do these figures take into account any payment in kind?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No. These are the figures of labourers living out.

Comment on this

Getting nothing at all except remuneration?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Getting no allowances of any kind.

Comment on this

What proportion of the total agricultural labourers in the country work under these conditions?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

About 90,000 were given as not living in, and 36,000 as living in.

Comment on this

Does that entirely cover my question? Is there not a class of labourers who are living out and yet get certain perquisites, apart from remuneration?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, they get certain perquisites. If they get perquisites, such as milk, vegetables, or things of that kind when living out, these are taken into account.

Comment on this

They are taken into account?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes. To get some idea next of the trend of agricultural wages, taking the mean wage, in July 1931, the mean wage was given as 24/3; in July, 1934, it was given as 21/-; and in July, 1936, as 21/9. I am rather anxious to go further into this question to see how during that time, that is from 1931 to 1935, the drop in agricultural wages affected the groups I have already given—that is the 17/-, 20/-, 25/-groups and so on. A detailed examination was made in the County Cork, and it showed that 3.2 per cent. of the labourers in 1931 were in the category under 17/- and that, in 1935, 9.8 were in that category. In the category from 17/- to 20/-, there were 5.6 per cent. in 1931 and 16.9 per cent. in 1935; in the category 20/- to 25/-, 40.6 per cent. in 1931 and 41.1 per cent. in 1935; from 25/- to 30/-, 32 per cent. in 1931 and 18.2 per cent. in 1935; from 30/- to 35/-, 14 per cent. in 1931 and 9.1 per cent. in 1935; over 35/- 4.6 per cent. in 1931 and 4.9 per cent. in 1935. If these figures are examined closely, it will be found that a comparatively large number of labourers came from over 20/- to below 20/- and an equally large number from over 17/- to below 17/-. Those in the middle category—20/- to 25/—appear to have remained stationary, though they would not be the same labourers. We had the same number on the medium wage—20/- to 25/—in 1935 as we had in 1931.

Another calculation was made in 1935 to find out, if possible, what were the average wages paid on different sizes of farm. Five counties were taken—Meath, Wexford, Cork, Tipperary and Galway. On farms under 50 acres, 22/- was the average wage in 1935. On farms over 50 acres, the average wage was the same on farms between 50 to 100 acres and from 100 acres to 200 acres—20/-. On farms under 50 acres, a somewhat higher wage was paid than on farms over 50 acres. Another question we may have to consider in discussing this Bill is that of allowances. There has been no legislation here in regard to allowances but, in England and Wales, there has been. They have settled the value of allowances at from 14/- to 18/6 a week. They fixed a minimum wage and allowed a deduction in the case of a labourer who lived in, according to the district in which he lived. The deduction varied from 14/- to 18/6. Here we have had no opportunity of discussing allowances but we may ascertain what the accepted allowance is by ascertaining the difference between the average wage paid to labourers living in and the average wage paid to labourers living out. As I have already said, in 1935 the labourer who was not living in was getting an average wage of 21/3. For the same year, the labourer living in was getting an average wage of 9/6— a difference of 11/9 which might be regarded as the value of the allowance, worked out in this natural way. I give these figures as a background to the Bill so that Deputies may be able to follow the discussion and realise the difficulties we are up against in dealing with a fixed wage.

Comment on this

The Minister said that the average wage on farms under 50 acres was 22/- and that on farms over 50 acres it was pretty stable at 20/-. In dealing with farms over 50 acres, did the Minister take into consideration temporary labourers or did he confine himself all the time to permanently employed labourers?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The figures are based on permanent employment. The first thing that strikes anybody in connection with these figures, and the strongest argument I can advance in favour of regulation of the wages, is their great disparity. Deputies will notice that in 1935 29 per cent. of labourers were receiving a wage under 20/-, while 24½ per cent. were receiving a wage over 25/-. We actually had some agricultural labourers being paid twice as much as others. It cannot be denied that certain classes of agricultural labourers are much more valuable than others, but I think nobody will admit that there is any justification for the great disparity shown. The ploughman and the stock man are much more valuable to a farmer than the agricultural labourer who cannot use his brains and who can only use his hands in a very imperfect way. With that great disparity, however, there would appear to be, at least, ground for discontent, if not for a sense of injustice amongst certain of the labourers.

I think everybody will admit that some of the scales I have quoted are too low and should be improved if we intend to do justice to that particular class of labourers and give them an opportunity of providing for their families in a decent way. It will be noticed from the table for County Cork from which I quoted that there was a tendency to reduce all wages between 1931 and 1935. Those who were paying between 17/- and 20/- were just as anxious to reduce as those who were paying from 25/- to 30/- or from 30/- to 35/-. In the highest grades— over 35/—there was no tendency to reduce. If these reductions were due to economic necessity, one would imagine that the big reductions would be at the top and that the wages of from 17/- to 20/- would have remained as they were. That is not the case. One can only come to the conclusion that once the opportunity offered to reduce wages, it was taken.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give us any indication as to where in County Cork labour was available at 15/-?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That obtained to some extent anyway—under 17/-.

Comment on this

I have not met any of these labourers and I come from the County Cork.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Statistics Department asked the Gárda Síochána to give them as representative figures as possible. If the Gárda carried out their instructions properly, they would take the medium wage in their district so that the position may be much worse than these figures show. If they are giving representative figures they are giving medium figures. If they gave the highest and lowest figures they might be worse.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give us an indication of any particular place in which these low wages are paid?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I could not give that at the moment and I am not sure whether the Statistics Department could give it.

Comment on this

Some of us could give that information very easily.

Comment on this

I should like to get it.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Has the Deputy heard of the number of people asked by the labour exchange to go to work for 3/-a week?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I was drawing the deduction from the figures I quoted from Cork that we do not find that farmers were able to pay any particular wage. Some of them continued to pay 35/-and some 30/- and over; but we do find there was a general tendency to reduce wages. Even in 1935, when all the reductions had been made, we find there were still one-third of the labourers in County Cork, when these examples were taken, being paid over 25/-, although many of them had gone below 17/-. I would again like to go into the case of the five counties that I have already quoted, where we took different-sized farms, and you will find from that that the smaller farmers were paying, as far as the investigations disclosed, a larger average wage than those with the larger farms. If it can be claimed—and I suppose it can be argued—that the more efficient farmer is paying a higher wage, that is only an argument that the smaller farmer is more efficient than the larger. Another explanation could be given, and it is that the smaller farmer usually employs only one man, a good man, a man who is able to look after machinery and other things, whereas the larger farmer, in addition to employing a ploughman and stock man, may employ three or four others who are not as highly qualified or trained.

I do not think I need dwell too long on the necessity of doing better for these men. I think all Parties will combine in an endeavour to do better for the agricultural labourers, if it can be done, and I do not want to delay the House any further in putting up arguments as to why that should be done. The next thing we must examine is whether, from the point of view of the farmer, that is advisable or not. I think it is certainly advisable, if the farmer can do it. In all industries, farming and other industries, it is agreed that if men are well paid they are more contented and more efficient. There is an additional argument in the case of agricultural labourers, and that is that there is a drift from rural to urban areas. If you have an ambitious worker in the country he is inclined to go to the town in order to get a better wage. In order to keep these ambitious and, perhaps, more efficient men in the country, it would be well for the farmer to pay them a good wage, if he can afford to do so. If the lower wages continue, we possibly may have to face the situation of seeing the country stripped of its best men, who will make for the towns, and we may be left with a less efficient, a worse type of worker, who will be content with the lower wage.

There is another very obvious cause of discontent amongst labourers and that is that they find, between district and district, there is a great difference in wages. Indeed, that often applies between farm and farm. I think every Deputy has the same experience—that you will get two farmers living side by side, one paying a much better wage than the other. That, naturally, leaves the worse paid labourer very discontented and, possibly, anxious to leave his employer as soon as he gets the opportunity. I think, finding, as we have found, that there are farmers who are paying less than half what others are paying, and also that there are many farmers who appear to be able to pay a much better wage, there is a case to be made for regulating the industry, for fixing some wage. The question that is naturally going to agitate our minds is whether the farmers can afford to do it. I may be told that if we increase the agricultural wage to any great extent the labourer will be better off than the farmer. I would like to find out whether that is true. I have already given some figures for 1926. I would like to refer to them again, so that we can get on to existing conditions and find out how we stand. I have stated that in 1926 hired labourers got £66 per annum of an average and the farmer and his relatives each got about £93 per annum. As regards the position to-day, we may be able to get at it by taking the output figures published for 1934.

Comment on this

Does the figure of £93 mean the farmer's entire income from his land?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I should have mentioned income in cash and kind.

Comment on this

Net profit?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No; income in cash and kind. The total remuneration I have mentioned represents the cash received by the agricultural population and also all food consumed by the agricultural population on their own farms at retail prices. On that basis it was calculated that each labourer was in receipt of £66 per annum and each farmer and the relatives he employed on the land was in receipt of £93.

Comment on this

That is, those employed on the land, not the total members of their families?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No; only those employed on the land. The agricultural output for 1934-35 is given as £40,500,000. If we want to get the remuneration that is available for all workers in agriculture and if we follow the lines adopted in 1926-27, we would have to deduct from that figure £6,000,000 to cover rent, rates, tradesmen's bills and so on. In 1926 the figure was, I think, £8,500,000. That figure would now be reduced by £2,500,000, when we compare the amount paid by farmers in rent and rates with the amount they paid at that time. We will therefore deduct £6,000,000. We will take the number of labourers at 126,000. We do not know, of course, what the number actually was, but we will take it that the number was the same as in 1926. If we assume an average wage of 21/-, that will be an additional £6,880,000. That would leave something like £27,620,000 for distribution amongst the farmers and their relatives. If this had been done in 1934, it would give each farmer and relative working on the land £51 for the year. That is on the assumption that the number employed in agriculture, whether farmers themselves or relatives of farmers or agricultural labourers, was the same as in 1926. That is how the figures would have worked out if we had applied this scheme in 1934, but we must make certain adjustments.

Comment on this

Does the labourer stick at £66?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No, 21/- a week.

Comment on this

You gave him £66 per annum in 1926, and that would be 24/-.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Fifty-five pounds, I think it is. The total is £6,880,000.

Comment on this

According to the Minister's figures, the labourer is getting more than the farmer.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I would say he would have in 1934.

Comment on this

Will Deputy Mulcahy say what he was getting in 1931?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The figures are £51 to the farmer and £54 12s., so far as I can calculate it, to the labourer at 21/-a week. There is a difference, however. In the first place, the index of agricultural prices has risen by 12½ per cent.

Comment on this

Since when?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Between May-August, 1935, and May-August, 1936, and that output was taken from June, 1934, to June, 1935. Therefore, if the output were being calculated now, there would be £5,000,000 more on account of the rise in agricultural prices. There is also a large increase in quantity of output in certain directions since 1934. I am taking only two items—cattle and wheat. And taking the number of cattle exported this year, as compared with the number exported in 1934, and taking the wheat crop this year as compared with 1934, these two items alone would account for an increase of £3,000,000 in output. I am not mentioning smaller items in respect of which there is an increased output, such as bacon and butter, because they would not account for more than a few hundred thousand pounds; but taking those two substantial items—£5,000,000 due to the increase in agricultural prices over the whole lot, and £3,000,000 due to the increase in quantity of output—we would have £8,000,000 to add on to the output in 1934, and it would bring the sum available for distribution up to £35,620,000. There is one other correction we should make and it is that, taking this year as compared with 1934, there is £250,000 more paid to agricultural labourers because the average wage is 9d. higher.

Comment on this

Has the cost of living not increased?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The cost of living has nothing to do with the question I am discussing. Where you are taking the farmer's income in cash and kind, it does make a difference, because we are calculating that some of the things he buys for himself, such as farmers' butter, for instance, which is about a penny higher than it was this time two years, would raise his income to that extent. I think it is, however, negligible whether the cost of living has gone up or not for this particular calculation. At any rate, we get a final figure of £37,370,000.

Comment on this

The Minister said £35,000,000.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am sorry; I should have said £35,370,000. That must be divided, as I have mentioned already, between 546,000 farmers and relatives, and it gives us £65 each. So far I have been sticking to the figures supplied by statisticians, and whether they are any more reliable than ordinary conjecture or not, I do not know. Some people think they are not, but, at any rate, we must depart from these figures now and go on to talk about other matters which influence the situation. When I say that we had £35,000,000 odd for distribution amongst the agricultural population, other than labourers, I am sure nobody believes that that was distributed evenly. For instance, we know that more than half our agricultural population are living on holdings under £10 valuation. They have at least as big families as the people on the big farms and it is impossible to see how they could have the same income as the men on the big farms, and, therefore, they are certainly not getting their share of this £35,000,000 odd. I know that nobody in this House who comes from a congested district, or mountain area, will claim that the farmer and his two sons working on the farm, a small farm, are in receipt of £65 each per year. We all know they are getting less.

Another point is that there are many of these relatives of farmers on unemployment assistance which they do not receive until they have proved that they are not in receipt of anything. The last figure I got in respect of this was got rather a long time ago. I think it is a couple of years old. It appears to be a rather difficult figure to get, but at that time there were 22,750 farmers' relatives on unemployment assistance. It may be more or it may be less now. We also know that there are many of these small farmers and their sons working on the roads and in the fishing industry. Many of the old people have old age pensions and many of the widows have widows' and orphans' pensions. Whether they are in receipt of unemployment assistance, getting work under a local authority, getting the old age pension or a widows' and orphans' pension, all these things would go to show that they are not in receipt of £65 per year, and if they are not in receipt of £65 per year, and if the statistics I have quoted, showing that there is a sum of over £35,000,000 in a pool for those people are correct, the people in the bigger farms must be getting more than £65 a year out of the pool. The recent census figures show also that there is some reduction in the rural population. In fact, Deputies have claimed that there is a big exodus from the country to the cities, to Great Britain and to other places. If that is the case, there is still more in the pool for those who remain, so that whatever arguments may be used about poverty in the congested districts, the number of people on unemployment assistance or the number of people going off the land, it would all go to show that the people on the bigger farms and their relatives are getting more out of the pool than their share of £65 per year, if it is distributed equally. I think we may assume, therefore, that it cannot be said that the labourers are better off than the farmers. Surely the farmers are somewhat better off. I would recommend Deputies who want to study this matter for themselves to get the 1936 output, to get the Trade Journal with the recent 1934 output and also the index of farm prices, exports of cattle, the amount of wheat grown and so on. All these figures can be built up by any Deputy as I have done, and he will find out for himself what is the total amount of money available for agriculturists to divide between them.

Comment on this

In order to avoid possible confusion, because I am sure that other people will try to create it, is the figure for 1933 the figure for the head of the household or the average figure for the whole family?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

For everybody engaged in agriculture—the farmer, his sons and relatives.

Comment on this

It does not include the average income of the son who may be going to school or to college?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No, he is not employed on the land.

Comment on this

Does it deal with males only?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No, sons and daughters.

Comment on this

The Dublin Deputy does not know the country at all.

Comment on this

The Deputy is doing a lot of agricultural work where he is at present.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We must also, all the time, keep in mind that the smaller farmer, that is, the farmer holding under 50 acres, was in fact paying a better wage than the farmer with over 50 acres. I think it is an accepted fact, although I cannot prove it by figures I think every Deputy will agree with me, that in the case of the very small farm there is a bigger output per acre than on the big farm, but there is certainly a bigger output per person on the big farm than on the small farm. If that is the case, it is almost certain that the big farmers and the ranchers get more out of the remuneration pool than the smaller ones. Again I would say that they are getting a considerably bigger amount than £65 per year. I think we should be optimistic as to the future of agriculture. Prices are improving. They have gone up by 12½ per cent. in the last 12 months. In the last four months—for the last six months, I should say, as August is the last month for which we have figures—each month was better than that which preceded it. There is no reason to think that prices are going to go back for any commodity. I think we might, perhaps, profit to a great extent by being a little more optimistic for the future and by hoping that prices will continue to improve. Even wages have been improving. As I have said already, in 1934 the average wage was 21/-; in 1935, 21/3; and in 1936, 21/9, so that if we regulate wages and fix some minimum wage, we are only helping the farmer to do in a regular, legal way what he was going to do in any case.

If we are agreed, and I hope we shall agree, that something should be done, what is the best way to do it? If we agree that labourers do deserve better treatment and that the farmer is at least in a position to do better— that is, those farmers who are paying very low wages—the next question is how it should be done. Some Deputies may be out against this Bill, but I know that if they think that it is going to be enacted by a majority, they will be anxious to see the best scheme possible for the purpose. The scheme of the Bill is to set up an arbitration board. On that board there will be four members to represent farmer employers and four to represent agricultural labourers. Unfortunately there is no organisation that can claim to represent fully these classes and these members must, therefore, be nominated. As they must be nominated, they are going to be nominated by me. There will be an independent chairman, also nominated. He will have very full powers. It is felt that there may be disagreement between representatives of farmers and the representatives of the labourers, and the chairman will have the deciding voice after he has heard their views. I looked up the 1917 Act before deciding on the scheme that we are going to adopt this time. There was one thing with which I was particularly impressed, and that was with what were called "neutral members," because I think neutral members on the board would be very helpful to the chairman. If there were no neutral members the chairman would listen to a very exaggerated case put forward on each side and he might frequently find it difficult to make up his mind. If we have three neutral members on the board, as we intend to have, they will act as a sort of jury. They will listen to the arguments from the representatives of the labourers and the farmers. They will make up their minds independently and the chairman will have the benefit of their wisdom. They will be very helpful to the chairman in deciding what will be a difficult question.

Comment on this

Where will you get these saints?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not know, but we shall get them.

Comment on this

It will be very hard for you to find them.

Comment on this

Can you suggest any?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I could hardly take a suggestion on that matter from Deputy Davin or Deputy Curran, but perhaps we shall ask some of the neutral Deputies to suggest them. Both sides, labourers' representatives and farmers' representatives, of that board will put forward their case. The neutral members will be there to listen.

Comment on this

And the chairman will be there to decide.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I was going to say that eventually, having heard both sides express their opinions, the chairman will be in the position to have at least the advice of his jury before he comes to his own decision. Eventually he comes to a decision and decides the matter on his own responsibility. He cannot say afterwards that the neutral members said so-and-so. He will decide absolutely on his own responsibility, unless there is unanimity and then he must decide with the whole board. If there is not unanimity, he must decide on his own responsibility. As far as I understand these terms, he should be termed a compulsory arbitrator.

Comment on this

Why not a dictator?

Comment on this

He would not be an unique dictator.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Oh, no. Areas are to be set up under the Bill. There are probably different conditions in different areas although when we come to examine the average rate of wages paid in different counties, we find that there is no great difference except in County Dublin, in which the rate is considerably higher than in the other counties. Really, as far as the rate of wages is concerned, we could put the whole Saorstát, with the exception of County Dublin, into one area. That, however, might not be advisable because we want to get as far as possible into contact with the people concerned. For that purpose, certain areas will be defined by the Minister and committees will be appointed for them. These committees will be representative of farmers and labourers and will be merely advisory committees. The chairman of the board will be also chairman of each committee. When the Act comes into force we shall set up these committees and define the areas.

Comment on this

Are there to be any neutral members on the committee?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

There may be, but not necessarily.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say how many areas are contemplated?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I could not say exactly but I think there will be probably six. When the Act comes into force the areas are defined by Order and the committees are appointed. The first active step to be taken is that the board makes an order which it serves on the committee saying that it is going to fix a wage. The committee then gets two months within which to make its observations to the board. The committee can suggest, if it likes, that no wage should be fixed, that such and such a wage can be fixed or can say that it has no observations to make. At the meeting of each committee the chairman of the board shall preside and after two months period the board is free to meet and make an order. The chairman will come back having been present at all these committee meetings. He will have gathered a great deal of information which will be very helpful to him, I hope. He will come back to the meeting of the board and the board will consider the various suggestions from the committees all over the country. The board can then make an order fixing a minimum wage which may apply to all the areas or it may fix a different wage for each area. They may, in fact, make a different wage for different districts within an area, if they like. They may make a difference for the different classes of workers, or they may very the wage according to the conditions of work. They have very full powers with regard to the variations, and I think that they should be able to meet any case that might arise in that way. They will also, of course, fix allowances. They will have to do that. If they fix a minimum wage, they will have to fix so much for full board, so much for lodging, so much for perquisites that men are in the habit of getting, such as milk, vegetables and things like that; and also, on application, they are empowered to exempt certain people who, through physical or mental disability——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

——are not fit to receive this minimum wage.

Comment on this

I mentioned youths.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That would come under the question of different classes.

Comment on this

On the application of whom would the exemption apply?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Of the employer—on the application of either, as a matter of fact. It is not stated, but anybody can make application—either the employer or the employee. Now, I want it to be clearly understood that the committees are purely advisory. I do not know whether Deputies agree that is useful or not, but it must be remembered that in the old scheme and in the English and Welsh schemes the committees actually fix the wage and the board is there only to confirm what they have fixed. The board, of course, can refuse to confirm, but its only purpose there is to confirm.

Comment on this

Are there not neutral members on the committees in Great Britain?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am not sure of that, but I shall try to answer the Deputy later on. However, I want to have that clearly borne in mind, because there is a departure here from the system we had here before and from the English and Welsh systems. In fact, the board is the executive body and the committees are only advisory. The board does all the executive acts. The board will make an order saying: "We are going to fix a wage," and the board then gives two months for the consideration of that order. The board is then free to fix the wage. Let us suppose they do fix the wage. It is, of course, legal and binding and there are penalties provided for all those who do not observe the fixed wage; but let us take it that the wage is fixed and that everything goes on all right, for a while, and then that somebody begins to agitate for a change—whether the farmers in a district want it lowered or the labourers in the district want it raised—the body to whom they will make the application in that case is the board, and not the committee, because the board is the executive authority; and the board will then take the initiative and, if they think necessary, they will make an amending order. If they make an amending order, either raising or lowering the wage, they must serve notice of this order on the committees concerned. That is, in the case of any committee through whose territory they are going, they must serve notice of the intended order on that committee and give the committee two months to consider the position and make recommendations either approving or protesting against the amended order, as the case may be. At the end of the two months, the board is free to meet and either to make the order or perhaps amend the order to meet the wishes of the committees concerned.

I am only giving that very general outline of the working of the Bill because I think that, as far as we are concerned, on this particular discussion of the Second Reading, we only want to know the big general principles on which the Bill works, and I think that really the only thing that concerns us in this debate—that is, if we are going to discuss the Bill and its workings apart from the general principle of it—is whether the board is properly constituted and whether the powers given to the board are right and proper, and whether the House agrees that it is better to make the committees advisory rather than executive. Now, personally, I believe that the Bill will do at least a great social good to labourers who are paid a wage that is much too low. I do not think it will impose an impossible burden on employers. In fact, my own experience at any rate, knowing farmers here and there through the country, is that the farmers who pay the better wage get better value for their money than those who pay low wages, and I do not think that farmers need have any great fear or apprehension under this Bill. I think the members of the board will have a sense of reality, and they are not going to recommend a wage, or perhaps I should say to argue for a wage, that would be absolutely impossible or out of the question for the farmers to pay. The board should be able to give the greatest help to the chairman, both representatives of the interests concerned and the neutral members, and, in addition to that, the advice he gets from the committees, during his tour of the country before making the final order, should enable him to give a decision that I hope will always be marked by prudence and justice.

Comment on this

Sir, the principle of securing for the agricultural labourer in this country a fair wage is a principle which, I think, would be accepted by every side of the House. The machinery which has been outlined by the Minister to achieve that end seems to me to call for one criticism before we proceed to a discussion of the general principles at stake. The Minister has described to us the functions of the district committees and the wages board, but on perusal of the Bill it becomes perfectly clear that both the wages board and the district committees are merely blinds to conceal from the public eye the fact that this Bill is designed to create in the country a wages dictator. In fact, the individual who is going to be chairman of the wages board and of the district committees is going to fix the wages in every area in the country, because it is highly unlikely that we will find in any given case that the wages board, as distinguished from the wages committee, will be unanimous in its recommendation and, unless it is unanimous, the chairman has a right to fix the wages and from his fixation there is no appeal. It seems perfectly clear to me that it would be a very much better thing to carry into the machinery of these boards the same system that obtains in the trade boards in industrial relations, which provides that, in effect, the neutral members, by their votes, make the decision as to what the wage will be and what the conditions should be. If there is an even cleavage between the representatives of the workers and those of the employers, whichever side can carry the majority of the neutral members with them secures the verdict of the board. I believe that that is an infinitely preferable system to the proposal that a wage dictator should be set up, who would fix wages all over the country. I think it is an illusion to imagine that a civil servant is capable of doing everything better than those who are in intimate daily touch with the particular problem that has to be solved. I believe that it will be very much better to allow a majority of the district committee to make the recommendation to the board, and a majority of the board to fix the wage which would obtain in the particular district. The difference between the British system—under which the district committee fixes the wages and the board confirms it—and the proposed system here under which the district committee would recommend and the board fix, is not very material; it is merely a matter of words.

On this general question I am prepared to say that the principle of fixing wages for agricultural workers is a good one. Believing, as I think most Deputies of this House do, that the agricultural labourer is as skilled, or more skilled, than the worker in any other craft, I hold that he is entitled to a fair wage. But it is one thing to say that we all want to see the agricultural labourer getting a fair wage; it is quite another thing to say that under the circumstances which obtain in this country at the present time we see our way to getting that wage for him. It has been truly said of the British Constitution that the only thing which Parliament cannot do is to turn a man into a woman or a woman into a man. The person responsible for that dictum forgot one other thing which even the British Parliament cannot do, and that is to take blood from a turnip or water from a stone. No amount of legislation by this House is going to make it possible for the farmer to pay to the agricultural labourer money which the farmer himself has not got.

If agriculture were being carried on in this country on a profitable basis, the experience of most Deputies in this House, I believe, is that farmers would pay their labourers a fair wage, with very few exceptions. Under those circumstances the function of those wages boards would be not to raise the general level of wages— because the farmers of the country would be already paying a fair wage —but to bring those recalcitrant few who are failing to pay a fair wage up to the level which their more conscientious neighbours had fixed for the general run of agricultural workers in the country. That ought to be the purpose of a wages board. A wages board should primarily be established for the purpose of eliminating sweating from any particular industry, and, with the exception of very few industries, when the wages boards come to examine them they will find that the majority of employers in industry are giving a fair wage, but there are individuals who are sweating their employees. The trade board intervenes and forces the sweater to come up to the decent level of wages that ought to obtain in the industry. Under ordinary conditions that should be the function of a trade board with regard to the agricultural labourer—to make every farmer pay the wage which, in fact, the vast majority of farmers were paying. But, on the facts brought before us here, either of two things must be true: either the farmers of this country are an unscrupulous body of sweaters, or else the farmers of this country have been reduced by the present Government to a level of poverty which makes it impossible for them to pay the wages they would wish to pay. I have lived all my life amongst farmers, and the vast majority of the Deputies of this House have done likewise. I think the experience of us all is that the farmer has always been willing to pay his working man a decent wage, so long as he had the money to do so. When 90 per cent. of the farm labourers of this country are getting less than 30/-a week, and over 25 per cent. are getting less than £1 per week—without any addition or without any perquisite—on which they are supposed not only to feed themselves but to rear their families, we have got to face the fact that either the entire agricultural community of this country is unscrupulous, or else they have been reduced to very dire straits by the Government which is at present in office.

I submit to Deputies that the fact is that the farmers are paying as much as they can afford to pay, and the reason why 13.2 per cent. of the labourers of this country are getting less than 17/- and 15.9 per cent. are getting less than 20/- is because the farmers who employ those men cannot afford to pay them more. I regard such wages as a horrible scandal, but I think it would be a cruel injustice on the part of this House or of responsible Deputies in it to use their position for the purpose of suggesting that those wages are being paid by farmers who desire to put the profits in their own pockets. They are not. They are being paid by farmers who are ashamed of their lives to pay such wages but who cannot find the money to pay any more. What I seriously apprehend in the existing situation is that if we set up those wages committees and wages boards while the present state of affairs continues in agriculture we will be faced with two possible alternatives. One is that those boards will fix wages so low as to make the name of this country a byword before the whole world. I ask Deputies to realise what the situation is. I have here, in the July number of the Journal of the British Ministry of Agriculture, the farm workers' minimum rates of wages, which were fixed on June 23rd by the Agricultural Wages Board in London. In Hertfordshire the minimum wage was 11d. an hour; in Warwick the minimum wage was 31/- for a 50-hour week and 8½d. and 9d. an hour overtime. From 30/- to 32/- a week, with a sum varying between 8d. and 9d. an hour for overtime, is the average agricultural wage all over England. There may be one or two districts in Norfolk in which it is lower, but that is substantially the rate of wages being paid to agricultural workers in England at the present time. The average rate of wages being paid in this country at the present time is 21/9. Are we to anticipate that the first agricultural wages board to function in this country is going to fix the general wage for the agricultural labourers of this country at least 10/- a week—and more probably in practice 15/- a week—lower than the amount paid to men doing the same work in Great Britain? Are we going to hold ourselves out to the world as a country which treats the agricultural labourer as if he were a coolie?

You have either got to do that or else you have got to do the other thing, and that is fix what may reasonably be taken to be a fair living wage for the agricultural labourer. That will more closely approximate to 35/-than to 21/-. Suppose we do that— what is going to be the result of it? The farmers who want to employ labourers, and who would be glad to pay them 35/- if they had it, will not be able to employ them, and they will have to put them out on the road.

Comment on this

Is that advice to them?

Comment on this

It is not, and the Deputy knows perfectly well it is not. It is foolish, in discussing this matter where we are all ad idem in regard to principle, to make cheap debating points of that kind.

Comment on this

It is not a cheap debating point.

Comment on this

I am putting this case to Deputies. We have here an average wage of 21/9 all over the country. Let us suppose that if ideal wages were paid at the present time, if everyone were paying the last penny he could, you would raise that average to 23/- or 24/-. If we want to fix a fair wage where are the farmers going to get the money to pay it? Let the Deputy remember, when he interrupts me, that his leader, Deputy Norton, said in this House in the debate on the Agricultural Estimate that the Government have reduced the farmers of this country to a position in which no farmer can pay a fair wage. I agree with Deputy Norton. I think that is true. What I am afraid of——

Comment on this

Is Deputy Dillon purporting to quote Deputy Norton?

Comment on this

I am purporting to repeat, in substance, what Deputy Norton said.

Comment on this

To repeat in substance! Yes, the Deputy's version of the substance, of course.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin will have ample opportunity to speak after me and then he can contradict anything I said. I apprehend that dilemma when I say if we are forced by circumstances into fixing a wage which is grotesquely low, and which is not a living wage for the labourer, or if, on the other hand, we are forced into fixing a wage above the capacity of the farmer to pay on the ground that it is a fair living wage, we are going to do the agricultural workers of this country an immense injury instead of conferring a boon upon them. My view and the view of our Party is that there is a sensible and practicable way out of this dilemma and that is to recognise the supreme importance of the agricultural industry and to take such steps in the sphere of our international relations as may be necessary to secure for that industry a market in which its products can be profitably disposed of. If we can do that, and if we get for the industry as a whole a fair measure of prosperity, this dilemma to which I have referred will disappear and abundant resources will be there in the hands of those who own the land to pay a fair wage to those who work for them.

No one can then complain of the most trenchant measures being taken to ensure that the farmers who are enjoying a modest prosperity will share that prosperity justly with those who work for them. But if this Government is not prepared to adopt that course and designs to continue a policy which reduces the agricultural industry from £61,000,000 to £40,000,000, then there is no alternative to resorting to what in my opinion is economically and politically a thoroughly unsound expedient. It is the only expedient which is available in the appalling condition in which we find the country. That expedient is to instruct those boards, when they go to fix a wage, to have regard to two matters: (1) to fix what in their opinion is a living wage for the agricultural labourer, having regard to the cost of living and the general circumstances surrounding his case and then in the next case to fix an economic wage which—in the judgement of that board, having examined the circumstances of the farmers who will have to pay this wage themselves—will be a wage that they will be in a position to pay. It will then be for the Exchequer to intervene and make up the difference between what is essentially an economic wage and what is the living wage fixed by the board. I freely admit that that proposal is open to the greatest possible objection because it places in the hands of these committees, or of the chairman himself, the power of charging to the Exchequer various sums of money according to the disparity between the living wage and the economic wage. But in a desperate situation you have to devise desperate remedies. I would resort to a proposal as unsound as that rather than drive a large percentage of the agricultural labourers of this country on to the dole or in the alternative fix for any time, or set the seal of approval upon, a rate of wages which I would consider to be a disgrace to any civilised country which put its hand to the business of fixing the rates of wages which ought to apply in the agricultural industry.

It is to be borne in mind that whatever machinery may be ultimately devised for fixing a proper and fair wage for the labourer will serve one useful purpose. It will bring together committees in a wide number of districts throughout the country. At these committees the farmers and their labourers will sit down together and there discuss, to their own personal knowledge, the circumstances of the industry which provides a living for both. They will come face to face, perhaps for the first time, with a true appreciation of the facts of the situation in which they find themselves. I imagine a good deal of vapour about our patriotic duty in the desperate fight against the base, bloody and brutal Saxon will go up in smoke when the practical question is being discussed as to what share the farmer is entitled to get out of the total agricultural industry and what share the agricultural labourer may legitimately expect to get out of that industry. I would be glad to know from the Minister whether he proposes to amend this Bill with a view to bringing it into operation at an earlier date than 1938?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Oh, yes; it will be in operation before 1938.

Comment on this

The Minister is obliged to give notice in September that he is going to bring the Bill into operation in the following January.

Comment on this

That is in the Bill in any case.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

In what section is that?

Comment on this

In Section 4, sub-section (2).

Comment on this

The sub-section reads:

"After the commencement of this Act the Minister may, in any calendar year, by order made not later than the 30th September in such calendar year..."

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is after the commencement of the Act, but sub-section (1) provides for the thing to be done before the commencement of this Act. It says: "(a) group the several wage districts in Saorstát Eireann into such and so many areas..." as he thinks proper. Sub-section (3) says that every order made ... shall come into force on the 1st January next following the date of such order. But sub-section (1) deals with it immediately.

Comment on this

In face of sub-section (3) of Section 4 how can the Minister put the machinery into operation before 1938 in view of the fact that September, 1936, has already gone by?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

As I have already pointed out, under sub-section (1) of Section 4 the Act is put into operation immediately. Sub-section (2) is where you have to make changes afterwards.

Comment on this

In fact the Minister can bring the Act into operation.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want the Bill?

Comment on this

That is good.

Comment on this

Provided the Minister will do something on these lines, and in order to avoid the dilemma into which I feel the country will be led unless steps of the kind suggested are taken. I would be interested to hear from Deputy Davin, when he comes to review the position, what his estimate of a fair wage for an agricultural labourer is at the present time, and how he hopes to get it. Will he get up and seriously suggest that labourers can reasonably expect to get a wage of 30/- per week out of the agricultural industry as at present circumstanced? I do not think, if he is a responsible man, that he can maintain that that is so. If he is not going to maintain that he must tell the House what he proposes these committees should do and suggest how they can escape from the dilemma I submit. I do not think any Christian man would approve of fixing a fair wage which it would be physically impossible for farmers to pay. Out of that dilemma some way must be found. I have honestly faced it. Will the Deputy do as much?

Comment on this

What do you mean by "physically impossible" to pay?

Comment on this

If they have not got the money they cannot pay it. Suppose a man has three employees and the minimum wage is fixed at 30/- a week; if the farmer is actually making less than £4 10s. 0d. a week, how can he pay these three employees that wage? He must do one of two things. He must pay a lesser wage or dispense with one of the employees. That is the dilemma to be faced, and it is not one to be baulked by the Labour Party. It is not good enough to get up and say to those who have the courage to face that kind of difficulty that they are suggesting that farmers should dismiss their employees. That is cheap propaganda. We are all agreed on the fundamental principles of this Bill, and we are charged with the responsibility of seeing that it works effectively. Let us face it and make the only suggestion which can meet the situation if the economic war is to continue. I do not believe any difficulty will arise if accommodation is arrived at with Great Britain whereby the normal trading facilities between these two countries can continue.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy advocate a wage of 35/- a week for labourers if the economic war was over?

Comment on this

That is a most pertinent question in view of what the Deputy said.

Comment on this

Surely Deputy Corish and Deputy Davin will agree with me that the wages which may be fixed from time to time will fluctuate with the prosperity of the industry?

Comment on this

Answer the question.

Comment on this

The Deputy said all along that if the economic war was settled the farm labourers would get what they wanted. Now there is a straight question.

Comment on this

The Deputy has experience of controversy and he certainly does not suggest that any responsible man at this juncture should proceed to supersede both the wages committees and the wages board.

Comment on this

I suggest that that is the inference we are entitled to draw from what you have been saying.

Comment on this

Let us consider what is the minimum wage a labourer ought to get in the light of the existing cost of living. I am not one of those who believes that the minimum living wage a man should get ought to be ascertained and then nail him down to that.

Comment on this

Answer my question.

Comment on this

If subsequently the industry becomes more prosperous I would be glad to see every agricultural labourer getting not only a living wage, but something substantially in excess thereof. The question does not arise now of something more than a living wage. It is the difficulty we are going to be in, and we should examine the facts of the situation as we now find them. If we fix a bare living wage we will find that the industry will not be able to pay it. That is the dilemma I find myself in. It is not what we are going to give labourers over and above that, but the grave apprehension that if we fix a minimum that we think is reasonable for a Christian man to live on, if we find the industry cannot pay it, then there is nothing for the Exchequer to do but to fill the gap or else to make an end to the preposterous foreign policy which reduces the industry to the position in which it cannot pay the workers a living wage. That is the dilemma Deputies in the Labour Party have to face, and to tell the Government what is the suggested remedy for that difficulty. Unless they do that they avoid their responsibility.

Comment on this

You will not tell them what they ought to do.

Comment on this

Do not let us have any feelings on a matter of this sort. I suggest to Deputies that they have a very grave responsibility in the matter, and that it behoves them to make some practical suggestion to the Government. There is no use in saying to the Government: "We must have blood from a turnip, we must have water from a stone. It is not our business to say how you are to get it, but get it we must." They know that blood cannot be got from a turnip, water from a stone, or a quart out of a pint pot.

Comment on this

What about a mug?

Comment on this

We made a suggestion to remedy the existing situation. There should be an end to that policy. The results of it do not seem to have sunk into the minds of many of the Deputies. Let me recapitulate shortly the effects of that policy on the agricultural output of this country during the last five years. In order that Deputies may be aware of the situation which confronts us at present, let me point out that in 1929-30 the output of horses was 21,000, the value of which was £1,594,000. In 1934-35 the numbers dropped by one-third and the value was £494,000; cattle and calves numbered 830,000 in 1929, the value being £14,960,000, or say £15,000,000, but in 1934-35 the numbers were reduced to 710,000 and the value was reduced from £15,000,000 to £5,653,000. In the case of sheep there was a reduction between these years from 1,122,000 to 1,038,000, and in value from £3,207,000 to £1,600,000, or a reduction of half.

In the case of pigs the numbers increased by 80,000 between 1929 and 1935 but the value of the increased numbers is down from £8,990,000 to £5,273,000. In the output of pigs, the number of which was increased, there is a reduction in value of £3,700,000, and Deputies will remember that the cost of feeding stuffs has gone up over the same period. When we come to eggs, the output dropped from 11,700,000 to 9,915,000 and the value from £7,000,000 to £4,273,000, a fall of nearly £3,000,000. As against that, the Minister will say that we have increased the output of wheat, beet, peat and tobacco. On the amount of prosperity that the tobacco industry has brought to farmers I shall invite Deputy O'Reilly to address the House. He will tell us what a rosy prospect that industry offered when first embarked upon, and he will tell us what a gloomy realisation there has been. The Deputy knows that the farmers of Meath, Wexford and the Midlands can describe the miserable dribble they got from tobacco. The Minister will tell us what has been spent on the crop by the State, Tobacco, remarkably enough, does not appear in the estimated output of agricultural products for 1934. It is not now regarded as of sufficient consequence to be included. It was to be, in the words of the President, one of the largest branches of the agricultural industry.

Now, wheat is another mainstay which is being provided to compensate for the loss of the cattle and the live-stock industry. The output of wheat in this country has been increased, and increased substantially. In monetary value there has been an increase from £111,000 in 1929, to £703,000 in 1935, and, according to the Minister, there will be a still further increase in this year. That, however, is a matter which I think will have to be investigated and more accurately computed when the yield of the wheat crop is known with greater certainty. But, let us take the known figures. There has been an increase, as I have said, from £111,000 to £703,000. That sounds considerable, but when we come to realise that the State has spent £1,500,000 in an increase in the cost of the price of flour, to say nothing of the administrative costs, the advertising costs and the costs of the county committees of agriculture, I venture to say that it raises the total figures of expenditure to not less than £2,000,000. We discover, therefore, that, in order to increase the income of the farmer by £600,000 in respect of his wheat crop, the State has spent £2,000,000, and that we could have increased the income of those farmers by three times as much if we had given them the money instead of frittering it away in promoting the growth of wheat that nobody wants. On these figures, that means an absolute waste of the land on which the wheat has been grown. The money that we have spent to get them to grow wheat would have given them three times the compensation they have got, and would have left them with the land to grow some other crop on it. They could have given the crop away for nothing, and still have got twice as much out of the Government as they have, in fact, got for growing wheat.

That is one of the props that have been provided by the Government as a substitute for the live-stock industry. The other is beet. Admittedly, the income of the farmers growing beet has been increased from £360,000 to £820,000. The quantity grown has been nearly quadrupled. We would have expected, therefore, that the return to the farmer would also have been quadrupled. Instead, the price of beet has been substantially reduced. We have achieved an increase in the farmer's income from beet by £460,000, but it has cost the State £1,000,000 per annum to give the farmer an extra £460,000. At the same time, it has reduced the farmer who has been growing beet from the position of a moderately comfortable man, getting 37/6 a ton for his beet with a 15½ per cent. sugar content, to something approaching that of a coolie, producing beet for a price which he is glad to get in the absence of anything else, because he has got to get money somewhere and is glad to take whatever he can get.

Comment on this
Denis Allen Mr. Allen

What price are the farmers in Great Britain getting for their beet? Will the Deputy answer that?

Comment on this

Deputy Allen is welcome back to the House, but he has got to remember that he is not at a street corner now and, if he wants to, he can get up after I have concluded and make his speech. But he is not to interrupt while I am speaking.

Comment on this
Denis Allen Mr. Allen

Will the Deputy answer the question?

Comment on this

The Deputy can make his speech when I have finished. He is quite eloquent enough.

Comment on this
Denis Allen Mr. Allen

Like yourself.

Comment on this

The Deputy, by his interruptions, is not going to put me off now. As I was saying, it has cost the State £1,000,000 to provide the farmers of this country with £460,000 extra for beet, and at that figure we set them a standard of work which, in my opinion, reduces them to a condition to which no Irish farmer ought to be reduced.

Then we come to peat. In this connection we have to bear in mind the statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who has put this industry second only in importance to the entire agricultural industry of the country. The Minister did not speak of it as a branch of the agricultural industry, but said that it was second only in importance to the agricultural industry. With that pious purpose in mind we have embarked on an expenditure of hundreds of thousands of pounds to facilitate the development of the industry, to advertise its advantages and to encourage the public to assist in its development. The result of the expenditure of these hundreds of thousands of pounds was, in fact, to reduce the output of turf from 3,567,000 tons in 1929 to 3,310,000 tons in 1935. Did we offer during the same period a dramatic increase in the price of turf? Did we see the farmers getting as much money for the smaller output in 1935 as they had got for the larger output in 1929? Not at all. By the expenditure of these hundreds of thousands of pounds we succeeded in reducing the farmers' income from turf from £3,317,000 in 1929 down to £2,814,000 in 1935. That is a distinguished record.

When we come to contemplate the difficulties with which these committees and boards are going to be confronted when they seek to do substantial justice to the agricultural labourers, we ought to bear in mind that the principal difficulty against which they are going to find themselves is one that has been created by the policy that has reduced the wages pool for farmers and labourers from £64,000,000 in 1929 to £40,000,000 in 1935. Would we have any difficulty in giving the 126,000 labourers of this country a fair wage if we had £24,000,000 sterling wherewith to do it? Is it not because this sum of £24,000,000 is gone that we are faced with the deplorable fact that 10 per cent. of the agricultural labourers of this country are getting less than £1 per week, and that not only is that true, but that, so far as we can see, the numbers that are getting less than 17/- per week and the numbers that are getting less than 20/- per week are increasing rather than decreasing. Now we are up against hard, concrete facts in regard to this business. I say it will be a public scandal and a grave injury to the good name of this country if wages boards fix, and publicly set the seal of Government approval on, a scale of wages anything like that which generally obtains through the State at the present time. I want to see a higher rate of wages fixed, and I want to see, as a consequence of that, widespread prosperity for the labourers in whose interests it is proposed to fix wages. I do not want to see the fixing of that higher rate of wages resulting in a larger number of young men being driven on to the dole or out of the country, as they are going at the present time. In existing circumstances, there can be only one thoroughly unsound expedient to which we can have resort, and that is to ask the Exchequer to make up the difference between an economic and a living wage.

Let us change the circumstances without pulling down any flags and without surrendering any principle by making some more of the trade agreements that are being made every day in the week with Great Britain; by extending just a little every day the relations that are going on between the Minister's own Department and the Department presided over until recently by Major Elliot in England. Let us recognise the fact that Great Britain has material interests in fostering good relations with this country, and that we have got material interests in fostering good relations with her. Let us realise that if labouring men in this country, and every section in it, are to have a fair and decent livelihood, agriculture has got to be prosperous.

If we are going to get agriculture to prosper, we have to provide it with a market in which it can sell its surplus produce. Let us face that fact. If this Bill achieves nothing else than bringing the Deputies on all sides of the House to a realisation of the urgent necessity from the point of view of everybody, from the poorest person in the State to the most prosperous, for an end of the idiotic situation obtaining between this country and Great Britain, the Bill will not have been introduced in vain.

Comment on this

I regret that the Deputy should see fit to sit down without giving any definite indication to the House as to what his Party propose to do with regard to the Second Reading of this measure. He made a speech facing both ways. I listened to it very carefully and I do not think that any impartially-minded Deputy, after having listened to the full speech made by Deputy Dillon, can say what he or his Party propose to do—whether they are going to divide on this measure or not. However, I suppose it is not a matter of very serious moment what Deputy Dillon is going to do. I hope that my colleague, Deputy Finlay, and those who sit with him in the centre seats of this House, and who know more about the agricultural conditions of Munster and Leinster, will give us a little more valuable information before this discussion concludes. Deputy Dillon, as the Minister pointed out by the figures which he gave to the House, represents an area, the whole of Connaught and the three Ulster counties, which only gives employment to 24,000 agricultural labourers.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy allow me to get up and bow for saying that I represent the whole of Connaught and the three Ulster counties? I appreciate that tribute.

Comment on this

Everybody who has any interest in the Bill is delighted to know that that viewpoint would not be the viewpoint of the representatives of Connaught and the three other counties represented in this House that provide employment for only 24,000 agricultural labourers. The figures given by the Minister show that out of a total of 126,000 agricultural labourers, either living in or living out, in the whole of the State, 102,000 are in Minister and Leinster, and the other 24,000 are in Connaught and the other three counties represented in this House.

I think the Bill is only a belated attempt on the part of the Minister and his colleagues to carry out a public promise made over two years ago. I welcome the Bill, although, as I say, it is a belated attempt to carry out a promise given such a considerable time ago. The members of this Party who have been in this House since 1922 have always given encouragement to the last Government and to this Government, since they came into office, to provide guaranteed markets and guaranteed prices for the farmers. They have given this Government encouragement, so far as they have gone in that direction already, to go still further and provide these guaranteed prices and markets in such a way as will enable the farmer-producers of this State to get a reasonable return for their labour on the land. In doing that we have always had in mind that the honest, Christian, decent-minded farmers would, when they come to such a stage, or in return for the support, at any rate realise that the agricultural labourers had a right to receive a living wage.

I am not quite sure from the Minister's speech whether the Minister intends the Bill to lay down for the agricultural labourers in the future a decent, living, minimum wage. The Minister has been very cautious and careful in anything he has said about the Bill and has, in my opinion, given very little encouragement to the chairman, who will be the dictator under the terms of the Bill, to go any further in regard to the wages for agricultural labourers than these people enjoy at present. In his concluding remarks he said the farmers need not have any apprehension as to the working of this Bill. I should like him in his reply to elaborate a little more upon the meaning of these words, because I think it is in the interests of the administration of the Bill that he should give some advice here in public to the chairman, who will be the wages dictator set up under the terms of the Bill.

I have always endeavoured in my speeches in this House and outside the House, whether I represented the Party point of view on the matter or not, to look forward to the time when the working farmers, who are the real producers in this State, would cooperate with the agricultural labourers for the purpose of getting a bigger share out of the profits of production than the farmer-producer and the agricultural labourer get to-day. I hope that, instead of the farmers as producers getting further apart from the agricultural labourers, they will see the sense of joining with them for that very desirable purpose. I do not want to share the point of view of the person who encourages agitation and division between the agricultural producers and the agricultural labourers or other workers in this country. We had an unfortunate experience recently—I hope it will never happen again—of a dispute which might have led to serious consequences, where certain well-paid gentlemen, who sit upon a State-subsidised board in this country, made it quite clear to their friends that they were anxious to provoke a quarrel and cause disunity between the beet-growing farmers and the workers in the beet factories and the agricultural labourers, who help to produce the beet for these farmers. I am glad to say that, through the intervention of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, these well-paid gentlemen were prevented from getting their point of view home in regard to that matter. The gentlemen to whom I refer are paid salaries as high as £4,150 a year.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We ought to get away from that.

Comment on this

I never heard Deputy Dillon or anybody else getting up in this House to protest against high salaries of that kind being paid to these gentlemen. We have heard him to-day, as on previous occasions, raising a sort of fog barrier when the rights of agricultural labourers were to be considered. I am prepared to admit that the principal sacrifices which had to be borne up to the present as a result of the economic war have been shared in the main, if not altogether, by the working farmers and their agricultural labourers. I want to see them getting an equal share in the more prosperous future that the Minister visualised in his speech this evening. The farmers and the agricultural labourers have borne the brunt of the battle up to the present.

What have the bankers and the businessmen lost, if they have lost anything, compared with the losses incurred by the working farmers and agricultural labourers? The bankers and the big businessmen have lost nothing. Not alone have they lost nothing, but many have increased their profits, as compared with the pre-economic war period. Some people may laugh at that, but everybody knows that the flour millers have been making fortunes and the bacon curers have been making increased profits as compared with what were made by these particular sections during the pre-economic war period. Who are producing the raw material that supplies the flour mills and the bacon factories? Is it not the working farmers and the agricultural labourers? I say that these people, instead of taking the bad advice tendered to them by people who get big salaries from State-subsidised institutions, should instead of getting further apart come nearer to each other and help to get a bigger share out of the profits of production. That is the point of view I have always held and will continue to advocate as long as I am privileged by the people of my constituency to represent them in this House. The Minister said that we had arrived at a more prosperous period. May I join with him in expressing the hope that a still greater measure of prosperity lies before us in the future? But are we to wait for that prosperous period in order that some of the mean-minded farmers may recognise their obligations and pay their labourers a decent, minimum rate of wages? If we are to wait for that period, how are we to give any protection to these labourers? The producer is, undoubtedly, getting a big share of the subsidies and bounties which come out of the £2,250,000 voted by this House. What share of that sum is finding its way to the pockets of the agricultural labourers?

Comment on this

What are the poor farmers from the mountainy districts getting?

Comment on this

The proof of my statement is to be found in the official statistics circulated by the Department of Industry and Commerce. These are available to every Deputy and to every citizen who wants to read them. According to these official statistics, there has been an average reduction in the wages paid to agricultural labourers of 3/- per week between 1931 and 1935. Something must be done, therefore, to bring the standard of wages paid to agricultural labourers up to a figure which will enable them to live and which will enable them to share, to some extent, the subsidies and bounties which are still being paid and the grant of which will have the support of this Party so long as they are necessary to the working farmers of the State. I am the son of a farmer and I come in contact, from time to time, with working farmers. I realise that they have been suffering both before and since the economic war. Even if the economic war were over to-morrow, there is a class of farmer who would still say, whether true or not, that he was not receiving the cost of the production of his crops. When farmers were getting 52/- for their barley, some of them complained in my constituency that they could not pay a reasonable wage to their labourers, and some of them contended at the meeting of local authorities that there was no justification for paying a fair rate of wages to the road workers.

Comment on this

That was Leix-Offaly.

Comment on this

I am sure you would have a small number of the same type to say the same thing in Cork.

Comment on this

They are too honest there.

Comment on this

I am sure Deputy Finlay will not deny——

Comment on this

What wages should they get at present?

Comment on this

I am sure Deputy Finlay, when he comes to speak, will tell us whether he proposes to vote for or against this Bill and will give us good reasons for his action.

Comment on this

I will do so.

Comment on this

I am sure you will do it in a more "understandable" way than Deputy Dillon did. I will pay you that tribute. The policy which has led to reduction of the wages of agricultural workers has had a serious effect on the wages and conditions of other sections of workers. My colleagues on these benches have had occasion to draw attention to attempts by different Government Departments to reduce the wages paid on relief schemes, peat development schemes and afforestation schemes. In every case where we did that, the Minister responsible for these Departments told us that the wages had to bear a relation to the reduced wages payable to the agricultural workers in these areas. The Minister will not deny that. I drew the attention of the Minister responsible for afforestation to the new rate of wages paid in my constituency for that work. A new rate of 24/- was being paid as against the previous standard rate of 28/-. He stated that a wages committee advised the Government in respect of schemes of that kind, and that the rate of wages was supposed to have some relation to the wages paid by representative farmers in the same localities. One hopes that the passing of this Bill and the impartial administration of the Act will prevent anything of that kind in the future.

The Minister admitted that this measure did not make any provision for fixing the rates of wages payable to living-in agricultural labourers. He gave figures to show that, of the total of 126,000 agricultural labourers, 89,000 were living-out labourers and 36,000 living-in labourers, or what are commonly called in my part of the country "servant boys". It is a serious matter if a measure of this kind excludes provision for fixing rates of wages for 36,000 people out of a total of 126,000. I hope an amendment will be brought in which will empower the Minister, or the board to be set up under the Bill, to fix the wages and working conditions of these 36,000 living-in labourers.

Comment on this

The Minister did not say that they were excluded.

Comment on this

He admitted they were.

Comment on this

In my opinion, they are excluded by the wording of the Bill.

Comment on this

What the Minister said was that account would have to be taken of the perquisites these people were receiving.

Comment on this

I contend that the Bill, as drafted, precludes the board from fixing a weekly wage for such labourers. If I am wrong, I shall be glad to be corrected by the Minister. I have no intention of travelling after the Minister into the foggy figures he gave the House in his attempt to justify the passing of this milk-and-water measure. I do not think there is anything in the Bill to get excited about. There is nothing in the Bill that one can thoroughly understand, because its effect will only be appreciated when it comes to be administered by the dictator, or the chairman of the board, who will have the last word in regard to the fixing of rates of wages under the Bill. The agricultural labourer will only know what the Bill will bring him when he discovers the mentality of the chairman of the board, who is to be the dictator. I hope the Minister will look around very carefully before he decides on that dictator, because the decisions of the dictator will have a great deal to do with the relations that will exist between the working farmer and the agricultural labourer in the future. I am sorry to say the Minister did not give any clear indication to the chairman of this board as to what he intended to be a reasonable rate of wages for agricultural labourers, whether they live in Leinster or Munster or any other area covered by the Bill. I hope that he will make his point of view much clearer than he did when speaking on the Second Reading.

I think everybody who has read the Bill gathers that the area committees are only meant to be purely advisory bodies. I am not making any objection to that, and I am not taking any exception to that particular section, but I would like to know how the Minister proposes to select the different representatives to comprise the area committee, and what bodies, if any, he proposes to consult before he makes the selection of the representatives of the agricultural workers and the farmers. The Minister seems to think there are no organised bodies representing the farmers. I do not agree with him. I do not know if Deputies on the centre benches, representing the Fine Gael Party, will disagree with me when I say that I think the Beet Growers' Association is thoroughly representative of the tillage farmers.

Comment on this

I would not agree with that at all.

Comment on this

I am not sure whether the Deputy tills a high percentage of his land.

Comment on this

I do, but I am talking now of the people who cannot grow beet, wheat or anything else.

Comment on this