Private Business. - Central Fund Bill, 1937—Second Stage.
Contributions 214–451 of 451. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1937 ›
I know they are, and I have quoted two industries in which a half-million extra has been given.
Comment on this
They may have gone up, but there is £2,500,000 in net production, and the proportion is less than £80,000 to the workers and the rest to the manufacturers.
Comment on this
£2,500,000 is the net production out of the £20,000,000 gross production. The Minister, the other day, thought he would meet that by saying that the £20,000,000 was spent on raw materials. I take first of all the question: who pays the £20,000,000? The consumer. There is no questioning that. The consumer pays £20,000,000 more than he used to pay.
Comment on this
Is that the Deputy's argument, that the cost of materials has gone up by £20,000,000?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy's point that consumers are paying £20,000,000 more to the Irish manufacturers than they formerly paid to the foreigner?
Comment on this
In my own way and in my own time you will get it. £20,000,000, I say, is the cost borne by the consumer, and that cannot be denied.
Comment on this
Again I want to fix the Minister's attention on the fact that £20,000,000 more is paid by the consumer. Part of the cost is in raw materials. The Minister the other day, in arguing this, said that he would take bacon and he gave me certain figures on that. Then he took sugar. Then he took grain milling—three good examples.
Comment on this
They are not in an alphabetical list. I find it hard to get bacon and sugar running together.
Comment on this
Take bacon, sugar and grain milling. The Minister's point is that part of the £20,000,000 is the cost of the raw materials and, with a great flourish of trumpets, he said that that means £20,000,000 to Irish producers, producing grain, sugar and bacon. Let us turn to the agricultural statistics for that.
Comment on this
Whatever the figure is. There was a Trade Journal produced in September, 1936, which showed us the output of agricultural production, and it is based on the prices paid. I find there that between the year 1929-30 and the year 1934-35 the value of agricultural production had dropped from £64,000,000 to £40,000,000. Apparently, in that drop is the £20,000,000 more which the consumer is paying for a variety of these industrial goods, the raw material of which is the agricultural product.
Comment on this
The Minister will save his opportunity to deal with it. I suggest the gross production is the price charged at the factory for the finished goods. In these finished goods there are essential raw materials. I have got the value of the raw materials and for them somebody is paying. The consumer does. The consumer is being mulcted to the tune of £20,000,000 for certain industrial goods, and in the end the manufacturer and the worker are dividing about £2,500,000 between them in very unfair proportions. Deputy Belton on the last occasion asked a very apposite question as to how the prices were to be compared, whether it was with the world price or with the Irish Free State price. The Minister professed to be ignorant of what Deputy Belton meant, but I think he understood it well. If the prices of raw materials are based on the prices of raw materials coming into the country at world prices, we have, at any rate, some standard. If you have an enclosed area and you shoot up your prices to an absurdly high level, who pays? The consumer, in this country. Who gets the advantage if the consumers pay? Will the Minister take it from me that the agricultural table published in the Trade Journal of 1936 gives the increased cost of the raw materials accruing to Irish products.?
Comment on this
I want to follow it out. There is an increase in what the consumer pays. Does anybody get the benefit? If I take the Minister's argument, there were three specific points he gave me as being a general answer, and they all boil down to this—it is the agriculturist. It must be, because the productions of nature are the raw materials of industry. Whenever we are talking of the benefits accruing to the community when there is a twenty million extra expenditure, we have to look at our agricultural production. It has gone down by £24,000,000.
Comment on this
I will, if the Minister gets us the figures. We are simply jumping for them, asking for them time and again. Give them to us; we want them. At the moment we have to go on the best the Government can supply. Here it is indicated that agricultural production fell in a period of five years from £64,000,000 to £40,000,000. Gross production, which is one part of the cost to the consumer, goes up by £20,000,000. The worker and the industrialist divide £2,500,000 between them. There is something wrong. That is the general conclusion arrived at. There, in any event, is the picture. The end of it all is what I started off with, that 11,000 people more have been put into occupation. That is the result after all this immense load of tariffs, this raising of the cost to the consumer and this distributing of money unequally between manufacturer and labourer. At the end of it all you have 11,000 more put into occupation following the five years experiment. That is what you parade to the country as a successful industrial revolution.
The Minister professed to believe the other day that the emigration that has been so definitely deplored amongst all sections of the community is mainly that of women. The Minister cannot have anybody travelling the roads this weather. He must know well that there is a decided change with regard to emigration. He again tried to confuse the arguments with regard to this matter by bulking numbers over a period of years. I suggest that this is the proper picture. When government in the Irish Free State started, there was not merely emigration, a continuance of emigration, but there was a tradition with regard to emigration. That has been commented upon by one of the most expert commentators in matters of population that this country has produced. In a paper read before the Statistical Society, he pointed to what he called this tradition in regard to emigration to America. He said that behind that tradition there was a thing operating in this country that operated in no other European country. He used the phrase the attraction, the pull, towards America, and he said that pull was the strongest thing known affecting changes of population anywhere, because it amounted to this, that there was money sent home to Ireland from people in good positions in America, letters sent home from persons in good positions inviting the young people here to go out. Further, there was a promise by people in good employment in America that they would secure good posts for the young people who would leave here. What he called the attraction, the pull, of money was there pulling people across right out of their homes and even out of employment here.
That tendency, that pull, was there and that tendency, at any rate, was countered to some degree between 1922 and 1931. The tendency with regard to emigration during that period was downward. In the later years that was helped by the fact that America was not as prosperous as it had been, although there was money still coming from the other side and although there were invitations to go across. There were places in a quota that were not filled, there was a definite decline and no attempt to confuse the issue by talking of the mass numbers who emigrated can get away from this point, that right along, but more particularly in the last years, the tendency with regard to emigration was diminishing until it got to the point that there were more people returning than left this country. That figure is going up again. The tendency is again reversed in the wrong direction. There is an increased tendency towards emigration and I would like the Minister to persist in saying that they are only female emigrants. The Minister professed here that it was, in the main, women who were going. That is not a fact and if the Minister persists in saying that he will soon find that the commonsense of the people who see what is happening around them will quickly readjust his outlook.
Comment on this
Possibly, maybe so. I merely hope the Minister will continue to say that only women are going. I would like him to say in the West of Ireland that the emigration from that area is mainly female. There was, at any rate, that very definite pull across to America, through money and the hope of good posts, the almost certain security of good posts. Now, the new tendency has to have its characteristics marked. The people are not now going to America where their friends are; they are going to England. There never was the same tradition about emigration to England, there never was the same pull in the way in which that scientific observer described it. There was never the money sent over from England here or the promises of secured posts as in the case of America. Instead, the people who go, go out in the old adventurous spirit, carrying about them, in their pockets, all that belongs to them, with no hope of work but just to see what they can get. And this is happening in relation to a country about which the Minister tried to demonstrate the other day that there was worse unemployment. He tried to convey that there was worse unemployment in Great Britain than here. That is something that requires explanation.
On the Minister's thesis, there is a much worse situation in regard to unemployment in England than here, and yet there are people leaving this country for England. And they are leaving no longer, as in the American days, with money and the promise of work to entice them; they are going apparently to see what they can do for themselves in a country worse off, more ripe and more rotten in the matter of unemployment, than this country is.
Why should people flee from this country, which the Minister says has more prosperity than England? Deputy Moore tried to say to-day that it was due to restlessness, the love of a change, the desire for a change of life. At the same time he told us the heart-rending story of the man who left a job here worth 30/- a week and who is now working in England and receiving scarcely enough to sustain him. There must be some answer to the question as to why these people of ours are going to this country, in connection with which there is not even a tradition of emigration. The fact is, if the Minister will only care to admit it, that while we here are still rolling round in a depression that could be fairly easily cured, most of the journals in other countries in which we are interested are full of articles on how to avoid the next slump. All the observers and economists believe they are moving into a boom period and they are full of anxiety as to the cycle, the phase of development, which means that there will be a slump sometime ahead following on the present boom. But there are certainly boom conditions in all these countries and they are attempting to make provision for, to have something to do in, the next slump when it comes along. They are taking long-range measures to prevent a slump following, as it naturally will and as it has done in economic history to date, a boom period. But they do believe they are in a boom.
The Minister or anybody can point very easily—it is a phenomenon in English life—to the fact that, while they do assert there is a boom in certain parts, there are also the distressed areas. With regard to them there are varying view-points accepted. They range from the lowest type of pessimism to a slight flutter of optimism. In the main, the attitude taken up with regard to the distressed areas is that they were founded upon certain types of industry, mainly coal mining, that these areas could not produce coal at an economic rate, and that the miners, if they do not adapt themselves to something else, would stay on the dole all the rest of their lives. It is possible to have that condition, together with the boom with regard to new manufactures and industries, and they in England believe that they are in such a period.
We are here with our losses in agricultural production, with our industrial production not very highly developed, with a number of people running out of the country, for apparently no explicable reason, according to the Government. There are things which require some attention. Of course, the other side of it is that, if taxes press too heavily on any community, they are going to be aimed, first of all, at the wealthy members of the community. They will rest lightly enough on the shoulders of the wealthy members of the community, because most taxes can be off-shouldered, and they go, at a slightly accelerated rate, on to the more indigent portion of the community. There has been in this country for five years past a scale of taxation unequalled, except possibly in Germany during her bad period, in any country. We did get to the point here in which it was distinctly and clearly stated by the Government that they were moving on to the taxation of necessities because the taxation of luxuries had given out. It was boasted by two members of the Government that they were going to make the working man pay, and to make him pay because he had to drink his cup of tea, because he had to have sugar in it, because he had to have bread, and butter on it, and there was a tax put on all four of these items.
Take those in the middle classes of this community. Income tax is pressing on them very hardly, and there was an attack upon what was regarded as a good social plan. Anyone who thought along lines of good social development thought one thing that ought to be done was to make as many people in this country the possessors of their own houses as possible. Plans are made on that. People are more or less hustled into becoming the owners of their own houses. Immediately that is done there is the equivalent of an extra tax of 50 per cent. put on house property in two years. There is not a thing that man needs ordinarily, needs in the way of equipment of a house, needs in the way of sustenance for himself and his family, that does not bear some taxation at present. It is on an unexampled scale and has been going on for five years.
That type of thing can go on for a bit. It would be possible in any country in a period of grave necessity, for some hard-pressed Finance Minister simply to announce one day that all taxes were doubled. There would be revenue, but not double the revenue, brought in. Supposing that spectacular thing were done, that would immediately reveal to people just what the impact of taxation was. Supposing in any year a man was so mulcted, both in direct and indirect taxation, that he had to pay double what he paid the year before. Does that mean that he can live on the same standard, or that, in order to meet the extra taxation, he can economise on something he can avoid buying? Of course it means economising. The money may be extracted in one year, but if that doubling-up process is continued for a third year, there will be a serious falling-off. So it was here with regard to income tax and a variety of other things. In the end, the Government were driven to taxation that was always avoided, the taxation of necessities, and to a point that has definitely broken in on the old standards and principles of taxation.
I said before that, no matter what schemes of taxation have been thought about, there has been always one point of exception made in it—the recognition that a man if he is unmarried, for himself, if he is married, for himself and his family, must live, must spend a certain amount on sustenance. There has always been the exception from income tax of the subsistence allowance. You can break in on that allowance by taxing one necessity, but you surely break the whole principle of taxation into smithereens when you tax not one necessity, but such four things as bread, butter, sugar and tea.
Comment on this
I am talking about some of the effects of the continuance of the Fianna Fáil policy. I suggest that heavy taxation and an attempt to carry out foolish schemes are part of it. I suggest that one of the events casting its shadows before them now is emigration. I am suggesting that part of the reason for that is the heavy taxation in the country. If there is a principle of taxation, to leave what a man subsists upon free, must it not be admitted, whatever excuse may be made, that the principle is broken once you tax four such necessities as those I have named? Why not face up to that boldly and say incomes of even £1 per week will be taxed, because you are taxing the £1 a week man? Not merely that, but the man getting unemployment insurance, the man getting unemployment assistance money, is being taxed.
Comment on this
I am finished with it. There is the situation as I see it. We have that publication of the Government which shows agricultural production down in this period by £24,000,000. Let us get the other statistical returns to see the improvement. We have the Minister for Agriculture telling us, on the Agricultural Wages Bill, that where the farmer used to get £93 for himself and each of his relatives out of the land, he had been reduced to getting £51 as between the years 1926 and 1934; that the labourer, who used to get £66, had been reduced, but only reduced to £55. And the labourers and the farmers between them are 51 per cent. of the gainfully occupied in this country. That reduction would be equivalent to confining half the population of Dublin to the rôle of unemployed, forbidding them to work, and insisting that they would be maintained, and leaving the rest no other income to maintain themselves but from the half that would be put out of work.
We have increased prices charged for the goods that are supposed to be bringing employment money both to manufacturers and workers. We see that, on the calculation I have made, 11,000 people, at the end of a five years' experiment, have been put into work at a very, very heavy cost to the consumer. If there are any results from the cost to the consumer showing in the statistics of agriculture, they have not done anything seriously towards stopping the drop in agricultural production in face of this fierce emigration. The numbers may not be so very heavy at the present moment, but the thing that has to be regarded is, that while the old tendency is downward, the present tendency is upward. I know the answer that will be given to that will be the one that was given before, that it is due to world depression. The Government have published the Trade and Shipping Statistics for 1935, and they show world depression in sterling values. If you take 1929 as the basic year, the year in which the depression started to have an effect economically, between that and 1931, the repercussion in this country was severe. The repercussion in the rest of the world had reduced wealth by 38 points, and in the Free State by 20 points. Between 1931 and 1935 the impact on the world reduced it by another four points, and in the Free State by another 17 points. Between 1929 and 1931 it appears that the impact of world depression was not so severe here as it was on the average in other countries, but since 1931 it has been four times as severe. There must be some answer to that. Add to that the figure reached in 1935. Most of these countries believe that there is an upward sweep at the moment, and that they are approaching a boom period. The most we can say in this country is that if people are emigrating it is because they want excitement or amusement; that it is not economic deprivation that drives them out.
Deputy MacDermot talked about education. Mind you, there has been education. I remember when the Minister for Defence went to Dundalk and told an audience there that the British would get every shilling of the annuities out of this country, as long as we had to export any cattle. He put before them his policy, that they should get this country so self-centred that there would be no necessity to send an animal out of it. His definite doctrine to the people of Dundalk was that as long as they sent cattle to the British market, so long would Britain be able to take £5,000,000 from them, and he proposed to them that a policy should be adopted, and we should so work our economy here as not to be compelled to send our live stock to Great Britain. In a debate on agricultural wages that took place in this House in November last, Deputy Corry asked if that policy could be put into effect, and he was told that it could. The Minister for Agriculture told him: "You must recognise what it will mean. It will mean that we will have to close down one third of our agricultural production; we will have to put one third of our agricultural employees out of work." There are about 750,000 people engaged in agriculture, and the policy which the Minister for Defence thought was a good one would mean adding to the unemployed list another 250,000 people. Even the brazenness of the Minister for Industry and Commerce would not like the prospect which would result in an extra 250,000 people being dislodged from agriculture. It is at any rate worth while having that lesson learned. Remember that Deputy Corry still believes in the Minister for Defence, as when he asked the Minister for Agriculture if that policy could be carried out, he was told it could, but that there was a price. The answer has been given in this debate, and it was given when the question was previously raised, that England cannot buy our goods. I do not think that policy is seriously put forward by anyone except by a back-bencher now.
Supposing it were put forward. The British, at the moment, are proposing to expend £1,500,000,000 over a period of years on armaments, but a lot of it will be paid to people who are working on them. A lot of the money will go on material and a lot on wages. The money that goes on wages will have to be spent by the people on foodstuffs, and we are in an extraordinarily good position to supply foodstuffs to England. Is there likely to be a limited boom with regard to the purchase of our goods in England in the next five years? You have only to think of the expenditure of the immense figure of £1,500,000,000 to realise what a benefit and what a change it could make in the whole economy of the country. If all that was put into armaments was eventually blown up in smoke and destruction, and if Britain was hereafter reduced, as it was reduced after the last war, to a powerless condition, we will suffer as at that time. But if we must look forward to a period, after another war, in which England will not be able to buy as much from us as we would hope, at any rate any farseeing person would say: "We will take advantage of the situation now, while it is good. If there is going to be vast expenditure on armaments, we should get our goods across to England when the demand is there for them." The difficulty is that there was one opportunity presented to the people of this country which may not occur again. In 1932 there was an Ottawa Conference, but the chance there was lost. This year there is a conference to be held about the period of the Coronation. We are keeping an attitude of detachment and protest to that Coronation. We lost the Ottawa chance. Other people are making good and have cashed in on that chance. If there are other chances going to offer, are we going to take them? We have apparently lodged ourselves in the Commonwealth, and we get what Deputy O'Higgins described as "Not Imperial preference but Imperial penalties." Can that opportunity be taken?
Remember the situation left over at Ottawa is one that has never yet been properly realised. In the early months of 1932 there came the notification that the British Government was going to do what the people of this country yearned for for years. They were going to tax foodstuffs. Up to that date the difficulty with the British market was that our goods had to go there at world prices because the whole idea of English policy was that as there had to be a free breakfast table there could be no tax on foodstuffs. For the first time in history the relations between these two countries changed when there came the cheerful news that Britain was going to tax foodstuffs. On representations made from this country, and only from this country, it was agreed that the 10 per cent. going to be put on all foodstuffs would not apply to foodstuffs from this country. That was the first gain for this country. It was afterwards extended to the rest of the Dominions on their appeal. The situation was stereotyped in the beginning of 1932 to include all foodstuffs except those from this country and members of the Commonwealth.
There would be 10 per cent. against Denmark and against the Argentine while there was a suggestion of preference by reason of the distance in the case of New Zealand and Australia. That position was kept for better handling in Ottawa in the autumn, but when our delegates went to Ottawa what they got was penal duties. The penal duties have since lasted with three attempts to get them modified. These three attempts to get them modified were made in pacts, in which we abandon the right to tariff certain goods, and gave them a monopoly in one article. Though we have done that, not merely have we not got back our 10 per cent., but we have not got equality with the rest of the Dominions and the rest of the world.
Canada has recently rearranged the Ottawa agreement more to her own benefit. Australia proposes to do it after the Coronation. We do not know whether our people are to face it with an air of detachment or whether the Government, having lodged itself in the Commonwealth, proposes to take advantage of the situation and to claim the preference that ought to be given to our people under it. If we do not get this preference it is not that there will be less emigration but there will be more. We have heard of the phenomenon that where there is a higher standard of living than in the country adjoining there is always an emptying out of proportion from the one with the lower standard to the one with the higher standard. That is what is causing emigration, and not the old pull from America, or the sentiment, or the money, or the home or security from there.
Comment on this
Another theory which might explain the animosity between Deputy McGilligan and Deputy MacDermot is that Deputy MacDermot once proposed that speeches should be limited to 30 minutes. I do not propose to follow Deputy McGilligan over the whole field he has covered, but I am glad of this opportunity of putting him right on a few points. If Deputy McGilligan's figures are correct his calculations about the increase of employment here would also be correct, on the assumption first, that everybody employed here was employed for 52 weeks in the year; secondly, that nobody was ever employed in house building here before 1931; thirdly, that those who got relief work got 52 weeks relief work, and fourthly, that Deputy McGilligan can carry out sums in arithmetic. Unfortunately, all those assumptions are incorrect, and therefore Deputy McGilligan's calculations are vitiated. I will agree that there was not much house building done here before 1931, but there was some. I will agree that the average spell of employment which workers insurable under the Employment Insurance Acts are now getting is somewhat longer than it was before 1931. I will agree that the provision made by the Government for relief works, and consequently the number employed on relief works, is greater now than in 1931. But even allowing for all those factors, one cannot merely talk away an increase in employment which the figures show is at least 54,000 and is probably much higher than that.
That increase is there; the people can be counted. Industry by industry, every year the number of persons employed are recorded. Those figures are published to the Dáil, and those figures show an increase which cannot be explained away by those extraordinarily fallacious calculations with which Deputy McGilligan proceeds. Even if the Deputy's figures were correct, surely he, who was Minister for Industry and Commerce for eight years, appreciates that you cannot take from one figure which represents a yearly average another figure which represents the number of persons employed on another date, and contend that the answer means anything at all? It means nothing. The number of persons employed on house building on a particular day, or in a particular week, in a particular month, or the number of persons employed on relief works at a particular time of the year, has no relation whatever to a figure which if it means anything means the average weekly number employed, and the average weekly number employed in 1936 as compared with 1931 was increased by 54,000. That is the figure. Certain persons did not get work for the whole year. Certain persons came into employment in the middle of the year, or towards the end of the year. The actual number of persons who got new employment must be greater than that, but on the average in each week of 1936, there were 54,000 more people employed than on the average in each week of 1931, and all the calculations that Deputy McGilligan makes cannot take away that fact. There is no sense in deducting from that figure the number of persons employed in house building on 1st August, 1936. The number of persons employed on house building on a particular day has no relation to that figure. The number of persons employed on relief works in February was about four or five times what it was in November, and probably at least ten times more than it was in July. The number varies from week to week, from month to month and from season to season. To take the maximum number employed in February and the maximum number employed in house building in August, and deduct those two from the average figure, and produce the result as representing the actual increase in employment in industry, is a method of argument which one would not expect from a person who was head of the statistics branch of the Department of Industry and Commerce for a number of years.
Even all those arguments and all those calculations, ridiculous and erroneous as they are, fade into insignificance beside the calculations which the Deputy made or pretended to make concerning the increase in the value of the gross output of industry. I am quite certain of this—that Deputy McGilligan was merely trying to hoodwink members of his own Party into believing they had some case to make at the coming elections, and that he did not convince himself that there was any significance in the figures which he gave. The value of the gross output of 23 industries covered by the limited census of production taken annually increased from 1931 to 1935 by a sum of £13,500,000. Incidentally, it had decreased in the previous two years— between 1929 and 1931— by £5,500,000.
Deputy McGilligan proceeds to add to that £13,500,000 certain sums which, he said, represented the profits of wholesalers, as if wholesalers took no profit before 1931, and certain other sums which he contended represented the profit of retailers, as if retailers worked for nothing before 1931; and he represented the result as the additional amount which the people of this country paid for a net value which the figures show to be £3,500,000. The figures show this: that between 1931 and 1935 a very considerable volume of goods which previously were imported and paid for by the Irish people, and on which Irish wholesalers and retailers took profits, ceased to be imported and were produced instead in Irish factories, employing 25,000 additional Irish workers and resulting in the distribution of £1,604,000 additional wages in this country. That is what the figures show, and the net value in relation to that gross value has the same relation in 1935 as it had in 1931.
Comment on this
The extra amount paid was due to the increased production. We paid £13,500,000 for a much greater quantity of goods. That is the point which Deputy McGilligan was trying to conceal.
Comment on this
No; we are consuming about the same quantity but we are importing less. We are employing our own people to make them now, instead of employing foreigners to make them as in 1931.
Comment on this
There is nothing wrong with the statistics. The only thing which is wrong is the conclusion which the Deputy has drawn.
Comment on this
I am going to put the Deputy right on another point. Either we are consuming the same quantity of goods now as we were in 1931, or we are not. Deputy Mulcahy would say we are not, in which case those figures are more striking still. I will say that I think we are, although it is a debatable point. Assuming, for the sake of argument, that the amount of bacon, sugar, boots, shoes, and so forth which we used in 1935 was the same as in 1931, the difference is due to the fact that a much greater proportion of our total requirements was met by the production of Irish factories in 1935 than in 1931. The increased production of Irish factories has been represented by the increase in the gross value of the output from £32,000,000 to £46,000,000, an increase over five years which succeeded a period of three years during which the gross value of industrial output was decreasing, during which the number of persons in industry was decreasing, and during which the wages paid to workers in industry was decreasing. If there is any contention that those figures which I have given, and which are published in the statistical abstract, do not really represent the actual increase in the volume of production here, then I am prepared to drop those figures and rely on others, namely, the figures for employment, the figures for wages distribution, and the figures for the increase in the net output. The difference in increase between net and gross output represents the amount paid for raw materials.
Comment on this
Ninety per cent. at least, and probably more. If we are now using native raw materials in our own factories and producing the industrial products required by our own people, instead of importing the completely manufactured products from abroad, surely it is to the benefit of the producers of the raw materials here. We stopped importing some half a million pounds worth of foreign bacon. The pig producers here have benefited by that fact. The value of the gross output of the bacon curing industry increased, but so also did the amount distributed to the producers of the raw material of that industry, namely, pigs. The same applies in respect of sugar, boots and shoes, or any other commodity. Deputy McGilligan comes to that point and says: "But between 1929 and 1935 there was a decrease in the value of all agricultural output, including cattle and other live stock, of £24,000,000." I asked Deputy McGilligan why he went back to 1929. He was comparing, in relation to industry, the figures for 1931 with the figures for 1935, but, in relation to agriculture, he compared the figures for 1929 with the figures for 1935. He pretended he had not got the figures. He might not have the precise figure, but he has the information which would enable him to conclude what precisely happened between 1929 and 1931 in relation to the value of agricultural output. This happened: Between 1929 and 1931, a period of two years, the value of our agricultural output fell by more, and substantially more, than it has fallen since.
Comment on this
Did not prices naturally go up when Britain went off the gold standard? Was that not their object in going off the gold standard?
Comment on this
Between 1929 and 1931 the agricultural price index number for the Saorstát decreased from 139 to 110, a fall of 29 points.
Comment on this
Between 1931 and 1935 the fall was less than that. It was 27 points. That fall has taken place but when Deputy McGilligan quotes the total decline over the whole period as £24,000,000, it is, I think, desirable that I should point out that the greater part of that reduction had taken place before the industrial production for 1931, upon which he makes his calculation, had been in fact achieved. Now what did happen? Between 1929 and 1931, the last three years during which Deputy McGilligan was Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Party opposite were in power, industrial production fell in value by £5,000,000. Industrial employment fell. The amount paid in wages through the industry fell by about £500,000.
Comment on this
It fell here, certainly. During the same period the value of agricultural output fell by about £12,000,000 and the number of persons employed in agriculture decreased by 23,000. We had, therefore, a decline in industrial output, a decline in industrial employment, a decline in agricultural output and in agricultural employment. Over the whole industrial field, the average weekly number of persons employed decreased by about 8,000. It was to deal with that situation that this Government came in. We had to stop that decline, a decline which had taken place during the period of friendly relations with Great Britain and before the economic war started, while all the conditions existed which Fine Gael tell us would now produce prosperity if they existed. These conditions in that period were producing that simultaneous decline all over our economic organisation. We arrested the decline and we have got since an increase over the whole field—an increase in industrial and agricultural production and an increase in industrial and agricultural employment. The facts are there. They cannot be denied and the conclusion which the people will draw from these facts is the same conclusion as I give the House now, namely, that the policy we followed since 1932 was a much better policy for this country than that which operated previous to that year.
Of course, there is emigration, and emigration is due to economic causes in the main. I am not saying that other factors do not operate, but behind all these other factors there are economic considerations, and the existence of emigration, as I said last week, is proof of the existence in our economic organisation of defects which it is our purpose, and which it should be our purpose, to eradicate. To contend that emigration started last year and that it is due to the policy of the Government, or to the economic war or to any immediate and temporary cause, is merely to attempt to mislead the members of the House and the people of this country and an attempt which cannot succeed. Total emigration in all the five years 1932, 1933, 1934, 1935 and 1936, added together, was approximately 40,000. Over these five years added together, approximately 40,000 people emigrated from this country. Go back ten years to 1925; 40,000 people went out in that year alone, and yet we are told that the existence of emigration is to be brought forward as an indication of the failure of the Government's policy. I do not think we will succeed in stopping emigration entirely in the course of a year or two. Emigration did stop in 1932, and it was not very considerable in 1933, but since that year the trend has set in again, and in support of my contention here that the majority of those going are females and that the majority of those who have gone since 1926 have been females, there is the recorded fact that, between 1926 and 1936, for the first time since 1841, the male population of the Free State increased by about 11,000.
There is also the fact that during that period the employment per 1,000 of the population was the lowest recorded since 1841. These facts are all set out in the foreword to the preliminary report on the census of last year, and Deputies can find them for themselves. If we are going to stop emigration, I know of no way by which it can be done except by increasing the opportunities of employment here, and whatever policy is going to increase the opportunities of employment is the policy against emigration. I contend that the policy we followed has tended to increase employment, and to increase it considerably, as against the fact that the policy in operation from 1929 to 1931 decreased employment, and, therefore, we are much more likely to arrest, or, at any rate, to reduce, the tendency to emigrate by continuing as we are going, even though we have to intensify our activities and speed up the pace of progress, than by any other method.
Taxation, of course, has been increased. Deputy McGilligan talked about the possibility of the Minister for Finance coming in here and announcing that all taxes were to be doubled. Fortunately, we were able last year to reduce taxation, to remove a number of taxes, and as proof of the soundness of the economic organisation of the State, there is the fact that, despite the removal of certain taxes and the reduction of others, the revenue this year is greater than it was last year. Taxation was increased for stated purposes. The Dáil was asked to approve of those purposes before the various taxes were imposed and the Dáil did approve of them. The establishment of the unemployment assistance scheme, the provision of widows' and orphans' pensions, the provision of housing for the working classes, the increase in the provision for old age pensions, and certain other social services—it was for these purposes the additional revenue was required. Is there a single Deputy opposite prepared to state that it is the policy of his Party to abolish these services? There is not. They profess to stand in favour of maintaining them and, if so, the same revenue will be required, if they come into office to finance these services as is required at present. But, of course, their policy goes much further than that. They stand, I believe, for old age pensions at 65, which will involve another £3,000,000 a year; they stand for the complete derating of agricultural land—another £2,000,000; and there are certain other provisions which I saw in a most interesting document which they are circulating to prospective subscribers to their Party funds at present. If they are going to maintain existing services and, in addition, provide these new services involving an increased annual cost of £5,000,000, the amount of taxation under their régime will be so completely out of relation to what it is at present that people will think they are paying nothing now compared with what they will be paying then. They will certainly wish to get back to the conditions of low taxation now existing.
Comment on this
When I arrived in the House Deputy McGilligan was dealing with the question of foreign policy. He was telling the House that because the policy of the Saorstát in relation to non-intervention in the Spanish war was the same as the policy of the British Government, therefore we had surrendered our independence in foreign affairs and we were accepting dictation in such matters from Great Britain. That argument seemed to impress his colleagues, though it appeared to me to be particularly silly.
Comment on this
The policy of non-intervention has been accepted by every nation in Europe. France, Germany, Italy, Denmark, CzechoSlovakia, Belgium, Holland, as well as Great Britain, have all accepted the policy of non-intervention. Is it not as logical to argue that we are accepting dictation from Albania and Czecho-Slovakia because we happen to agree with them on this policy of non-intervention as that we are accepting dictation from Great Britain because we happen to be in agreement with them on this policy? What is the policy of Great Britain in connection with this matter?
Comment on this
Will the Minister allow me to say what I did say? I talked about withdrawing our Ambassador from the Caballero Government. That was quite clearly what I said. That is non-intervention.
Comment on this
And because our Ambassador to Spain has not been formally withdrawn the Deputy thinks we are accepting dictation from Great Britain. The Deputy talked about the atheistic beliefs of the Minister for Education in Spain and of the Communistic aims of the Madrid Government; he talked of the burning of churches and of the murdering of priests.
Comment on this
He said that we, because of our not breaking off relations with the Spanish Government, were approving of their actions. That is what he intended to convey. Well, in any event, if our action is to be regarded in any way as giving approval to the actions of the Spanish Government and the attitude of the Spanish Government, we are erring in good company.
Comment on this
If there is to be any presumption of approval of the Spanish Government by the Irish Government —and Deputy McGilligan intended to convey that impression—if there is to be any such presumption of our approval, then the same presumption stands in relation to our case as to that of the Vatican, because we have taken exactly the same course. Deputy McGilligan is more Catholic than the Pope.
Comment on this
The Party opposite want to make this the main point in their platform this year, because they are more concerned about the Civil War in Spain than about the coming general election. Deputy MacDermot talked about the Government being now in touch with reality. The Party opposite have established touch with reality in one respect. They have grasped the central fact that there is an election coming on this year, and they know that they have no chance unless they can parade their Catholicity and get themselves votes because of their claim that they are defenders of the Faith, and they want to convey in some way to the Irish people that the Government here are standing behind the action and the attitude of the Caballero Government in Spain. That is what the Opposition are trying to do, and that is what is behind their attitude here, and not sympathy for the Spanish Catholics.
Comment on this
It is a disgrace to the Opposition, and when speaking of the Opposition I will include Deputy Belton with them.
Comment on this
The Minister will do no such thing. He is sending provisions and food-stuffs by the "Clonlara" to the Spanish Reds.
Comment on this
The people of this country are with Catholic Spain and the Irish Government is against it.
Comment on this
And the Irish people will vote in the election this year and that is the central fact before the Deputy's mind.
Comment on this
If Deputy Belton cannot cease from interrupting, the Chair will be forced to take action.
Comment on this
The second idea that Deputy McGilligan tried to develop was that we had abandoned our independence——
Comment on this
On a point of order, I was suspended from this House for doing precisely what the Minister for Industry and Commerce is doing now.
Comment on this
The point that was tried to be made by Deputy McGilligan is that we surrendered our independence. The only way then in which we can express our independence is by disagreeing with the British on every question whether right or wrong. We came to our decision on that matter and we found ourselves in agreement with Great Britain. But we decided the matter having regard to one consideration only and that was the best interest of the Irish people. I submit it is in the best interest of the Irish people that we should take every possible step to avoid the possibility of a general war in Europe. Why did the nations of Europe come together to implement the policy of non-intervention in Spain? They did so because they realised that the alternative was war, and nothing would lead anyone to think that a general war in Europe is in any way going to help the Irish people. If we in a small way can contribute to the maintenance of European peace it is in the interests of the Irish people that we should do so. If the Party opposite were in power they would take precisely the same line and it is because they are in opposition and because they expect to remain in opposition for the next ten years that they are adopting this policy in the faint hope that it might secure them a few more votes at the coming general election than they would otherwise secure. I do not think that in this matter the Government has very much to worry about concerning the attack made on it to-day. Nobody on these benches, or at least no member of the Executive Council is going to assert that everything is as it should be in the present state of affairs or that we have reached the maximum that we hope to achieve. It is quite the reverse. The factors which operated during the past five years reduced the results which we hoped to achieve and made them less than our anticipations. In every direction we might have done more. But generally speaking we do feel that we are pursuing a much sounder economic policy.
Industrial and agricultural activities are being carried on on a much surer basis and with much greater prospect of being able to secure prosperity in the future, and there is no alternative either in the sphere of industrial or agricultural policy to the programme now in operation. Certainly, no alternative has been offered to the Irish people. I do not say that there is no aspect of the Governments policy in relation to either matter which could not be improved and which is not subject to criticism. Possibly, there is. Possibly, if we got constructive criticism of these aspects, the whole policy in each direction could be improved. We have never got that criticism. We have got stupid misrepresentation, wild assertions, periodic parades of scare stories without foundation and consistent, persistent and blind refusal by the Opposition to produce any alternative policy they may have. If you want to get a complete example of political ineffectiveness, turn to the published election programme of Fine Gael in the matter of unemployment: "It is the policy of Fine Gael to deal effectively with unemployment."
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce has gone even beyond the blasphemous remark made by the Minister for Finance here last week——
Comment on this
The term is in itself quite unparliamentary and should not be used. It is not capable of explanation in reference to any Deputy.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy withdraw, without any reservation, the term he used in regard to the Minister for Finance?
Comment on this
Yes. The Minister for Finance said here last week, when I was referring to alien immigration permitted by the Government and encouraged by Government policy, that "the village of Nazareth is quite as famous as the birthplace of Deputy Belton."
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants to make any point about that, he might, at least, quote me correctly.
Comment on this
I did not hear the remark at the time or I should have replied. I was then referring to the undesirable Jewish immigration permitted and encouraged by this Government.
Comment on this
The reference of the Minister for Finance suggested, as I take it, that the first Christian—Christ Himself—was the Son of a Jew. My education taught me He was the Son of God and not the Son of a Jew.
Comment on this
I am not going to model my line of argument or conduct according to the directions of Deputy MacDermot.
Comment on this
I am asking the Deputy to pass from this matter, which ought not to be referred to at all. Now that it has been referred to, it ought to be passed over as quickly as possible. I am asking the Deputy to conclude his remarks as quickly as possible on that particular subject.
Comment on this
The remark by the Minister for Finance, which Deputy Belton has quoted, is on record. Is that also to be passed over?
Comment on this
I am asking Deputy Belton to pass over his particular reference to the Founder of Christianity. That is a matter which, we all feel, should be referred to as little as possible in this House.
Comment on this
Would that ruling apply in reference to the remark about the village of Nazareth as well?
Comment on this
The meaning will be understood. I wish also—I think I have some right and some authority for doing so—to repudiate the remarks of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who suggested that people in this country were trading on Catholicity and that the sympathy they had expressed with Spain was prompted more by political necessity than by love for Christianity or Catholicity. That is a disgraceful remark to have made in this House. The reports of the debates in this House are watched on the Continent, and that remark from the Minister for Industry and Commerce will be read on the Continent with mixed feelings, and will be read with mixed feelings by Catholics—and particularly by Irish Catholics and Irish Christians —the world over.
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot, in his opening remarks, stated, by way of apologia for the remark he made about the President three years ago, that the education of Fianna Fáil had improved. The education of Deputy MacDermot must have improved and he must now be seeking anchorage somewhere in the Fianna Fáil ranks or seeking Fianna Fáil patronage.
Comment on this
I certainly resent and repudiate the remarks of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I have good grounds for doing so. The people of this country met in tens of thousands and hundreds of thousands——
Comment on this
They were not sneering, as the Minister for Finance is at the present time. They came there solemnly and raised their hands in support of the resolutions sending sympathy to the Catholics of Spain in their struggle against Communism. There was no talk of politics there. There was no sign of a general election. It was honest sympathy springing from the hearts of the Irish people for the suffering Catholics of Spain. Now, that expression of sympathy must go out diluted to the Spanish people. Catholics and Christians all over the world will read, after this performance by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that nothing prompted those thousands of Irishmen who met in Dublin and throughout the country to express sympathy with the Catholics of Spain but a desire to score over political opponents. That is a disgraceful observation which should not be made by a representative person. After all, a Minister is a far more important person than an ordinary Deputy. Even a Deputy, in making a public statement like that, should not consider his own feelings on the matter but should realise that he is speaking for and on behalf of from 7,000 to 9,000 adult voters.
If the Minister in a public statement, confined to himself, makes a slip, then he brands with a similar guilt the 7,000 to 9,000 adult voters that he is speaking for at that moment. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that if the Government of this country refused to recognise the national Government of Spain that it had done so in good company; that it had done so with the Vatican. Anybody who has made any investigations into the matter knows that there are very solid reasons why the Vatican should not formally break off relations. On the evening of the 24th November that question was put in my presence to the Cardinal Primate of Spain, the question why the Vatican had not broken off relations, and the Primate's answer was that he dare not, because the Cathedral of Barcelona that was still standing would go up if he broke off relations, and that the lives of many people who were suffered to exist in Red territory would not be safe if formal relations were broken off. But there was no representative, in fact, there. There was no representative to the Red Government from the Vatican. There is a representative in Burgos accredited from the Vatican.
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy a question? Has the Deputy the permission of the authority which he has quoted for the statement which he has just made to make that statement public, or is that another breach of confidence?
Comment on this
What is the Minister's point? If the Deputy has not permission to make that statement, well, it is the Deputy's funeral.
Comment on this
I will look after my own character and honour in the matter. Will the Minister deny that the Vatican has, in fact, no representative at the Court of Caballero? Will he deny that the Vatican has a representative at the Court of Franco? The voice to my left is silent. It was articulate a moment ago, punctuating my remarks by saying "Neither have we." I am making the positive statement now that the Vatican has a representative at the Court of Franco, and Deputy MacDermot is silent.
Comment on this
Then the Deputy does not know much about the situation. The Deputy knows the statement has been published in the daily papers of this country, that Cardinal Gomaz is the accredited representative of the Vatican to the Burgos Government. Deputy MacDermot made the positive statement here a week ago that Portugal had not recognised the Franco Government. I said it had. The Deputy contradicted me, but apologised a day or two afterwards in the newspapers. I dare say we will see another apology from Deputy MacDermot in the next day or two. When he gets another whiff of the Roscommon air he will be brought into line.
Comment on this
Wait and see. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that the Vatican recognised the Caballero Government. Neither the Vatican nor anybody from it did, but we did, and if we want to march in step with the Vatican we will have no special agreements with the Caballero Government. The Vatican has none, but it has a duty there, a moral and a spiritual duty, that we have not. I should say that the Spanish Caballero Government has a consulate office that is functioning in this city at the present time. There is no office of the Vatican functioning in Madrid or in Valencia. Will any Minister get up and contradict my statement that the Spanish Red Government has still a consulate office functioning here in this city? We have continued to have special trade relations with the Red Government in Spain. We had been sending out food supplies to the Valencia Government, but it may be that we are not doing so now—that we have got the wind up because of certain happenings in the last few days. But such supplies went out no later than the 13th January. The boat, the "Clonlara," that the Minister for Industry and Commerce solemnly declared went with cattle and nothing else but cattle to the British Navy in Gibraltar——
Comment on this
The responsibility of the Government in that matter is the outcome of their foreign policy with regard to Spain, which they continue to pursue.
Comment on this
It has concluded a special trade agreement with the Spanish Government. It did so in 1935. It has recognised the successor to the Government in office in 1935— the administration of Caballero.
Comment on this
Did not the Dáil ratify that trade agreement at the time? Was it not submitted to the House for ratification?
Comment on this
It is not for me to say what is the right Government in Spain, and I am not going to be put in the position of doing so. This Dáil ratified a trade agreement made by the Executive, and as such it is not open for discussion.
Comment on this
The point made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce was to equate the policy of our Government with regard to the Caballero Government with the policy of the Vatican to the same Government.
Comment on this
I do not know what trade agreements the Vatican may have with any government, but what I do know is that we concluded a trade agreement with the Government of Spain. That trade agreement was ratified by this Dáil, and as such it cannot now be reopened for discussion.
Comment on this
I am simply drawing attention to the statement made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce which is misleading. That statement was an attempt to equate the policy of our Government with that of the Vatican with regard to the Caballero Government, and that if we were erring we were erring in good company. The point I want to make is that we are erring in the matter of sending foodstuffs to the Caballero Government, which the Vatican is not doing. I am not questioning at the moment the policy, nor am I criticising that agreement that was concluded. I am just dealing with the bald statement made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and pointing out that it is misleading.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that a ship named "Clonlara" went with foodstuffs to what is generally described as the Valencia Government. He proceeded then to discuss the Government's attitude towards Spain as shown by trade agreements. That trade agreement was ratified by this House long before there was a war in Spain, and so, therefore, we cannot discuss trade relations with Spain.
Comment on this
For certain reasons, Sir, I did not intend to intervene in this debate at all, but as it has proceeded here to-day there has been the widest possible discussion on grounds of policy. It is not questioning the conclusion of any particular instrument that I am concerned with; it is dealing with general policy of the Government, and, as I followed the debate prior to my intervention in it, there seemed to me to be no limit to the references——
Comment on this
——and I submit that, when we are asked to vote £10,000,000 of public money, allocated to the various services on account, my understanding of those Votes in this House, in my reading of the Constitution and Standing Orders, has been that, when it is a question of money for any Department or for any public service, we, as representing the outside public, have full freedom to discuss the policy for which that money is used. I submit further that I am not going outside those terms of reference. No doubt an agreement has been come to, and I am not questioning that agreement, but in the circumstances that have arisen I am criticising the general foreign policy of our Government in continuing that agreement, because circumstances are now there that were not there, and that were not anticipated, at the time that agreement was concluded. If those circumstances had not arisen, the matter would not have been mentioned at all. There would be no point in raising it.
Comment on this
I am not anxious to limit the Deputy at all but, clearly, if this House ratifies an agreement, it requires legislation to undo that agreement.
Comment on this
Agreed, Sir, but if an agreement is ratified in this House in certain circumstances, and if then very exceptional circumstances arise and the Government still continues that agreement, I submit that when a vote of money for that particular Department comes before this House, members of the House have not only a right, but a duty to agree or disagree with or criticise that policy of continuance, because a new situation has arisen.
Comment on this
The Deputy has agreed that it would require new legislation to abrogate that agreement. Clearly, the Deputy is advocating new legislation, which cannot be done on this Bill.
Comment on this
I am rather dealing with the matter, Sir, in a negative way. The policy of the Government is to continue that agreement, and my attitude is negative to that policy of the Government and I am criticising the Government for perpetuating that policy. Now, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, while very anxious for a fight with Britain on certain matters, here in this House to-day first repudiated the suggestion that our Government accepted foreign dictation from the British Government in the matter of its policy towards Spain. Quite obviously, it is sticking out that dictation was accepted. We were not told that this country put up any case, any policy, any principle, with regard to this non-intervention. Non-intervention, standing by itself, with the special information that Governments have, is a thing against which perhaps there is not so much to be said. I am not going to discuss it now. It has been discussed here. The House has taken a decision on it. The only aspect of it that I want to touch on at all is that referred to by the Minister here to-day when he repudiated the suggestion that there was any dictation accepted by our Government from the British Government—that we acted quite freely. It is an appalling admission. It was bad enough to accept dictation from the British Government, but to say that the Government of this country accepted freely, and without any dictation, and of its own free will agreed to recognise the Caballero Government, agreed to continue its special trading relations with that Government, agreed to recognise that so-called Government that is admitted all over the world as being a Government that stands for the rule and the reign of anti-Christ in Spain, and that has been so branded by the Cardinal Primate of Spain, is a humiliating position for the Government of this overwhelmingly Catholic country to have taken up.
There could be some excuse for it, had it said that it was influenced by the threat of its big brother. We have the authority of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that they have done nothing in the matter, that whatever they did, they did in the best interests of this country and that they did it freely. So, therefore, it must be in the best interest of this country that we recognise the Government of anti-Christ in Spain and refuse to recognise the Government of Christ in Spain. That is what it comes down to. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that nobody raised any voice here on behalf of the Christian side in Spain except those who were prompted to do so for political reasons. That was the statement of one Minister speaking here to-day. He was afraid of the "Clonlara" looming up here again and he ran out the moment his speech was delivered. We had the Minister for Finance referring, in a speech that can only be described as contemptible, at Cavan a couple of weeks ago, to the men who have gone out to fight for what they believe to be the cause of Christianity in Spain, and who are at this moment in the trenches before Madrid. I have the honour to have a communication in my pocket direct from Madrid. The Minister in his speech at Cavan said these men went out there so that they might be able on coming home to set up a Fascist State in this country.
Comment on this
How can the Deputy relate that to expenditure by the present Government under this Bill?
Comment on this
It is not the foreign policy of the Government to send volunteers to Spain. They are not incurring any expenditure in that way.
Comment on this
I should like if the Deputy would confine himself somewhere reasonably near to the matters in the Central Fund Bill. Whether there are volunteers in Spain or not, the Government are not responsible for any expenditure in connection with them. This Bill is concerned with expenditure for which the Government has some responsibility.
Comment on this
In order that the Deputy may have an opportunity of collecting his thoughts on that matter, may I call attention to the fact that there is not a quorum?
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
The statements of both those Ministers, in addition to the statement made by the President here, are a clear indication of the mentality of the Government as regards the foreign policy they pursue. I submit, with some show of proof, that that is not the foreign policy that the people of this country would wish our Government to pursue. It is not the foreign policy for which they wish the money, which they pay in taxation, to be utilised. If they were consulted and asked what should be the foreign policy of our Government, not 1 per cent. of the people would hesitate to say that the foreign policy of our Government with regard to Spain should be completely reversed, in other words, that instead of the Government of Caballero in Valencia being recognised by this Government, and our having an accredited representative there, and that Government having an accredited representative here, we should withdraw our representative from the Caballero Government and advise them to withdraw their representative here. The people would, furthermore, say that we ought to send a duly accredited representative to the Franco Government in Burgos and invite them to send a representative here to Dublin. Those, I submit, are unquestionably the wishes of the Irish people, and those wishes, unquestionably, are not being carried out by the Government. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has just informed us that they were perfectly free to make a choice and that they did in fact make a free choice. Their free choice was to do precisely the opposite to what the people of this country wished them to do.
A year ago this House voted £2,500,000 for unemployment. It was revealed, I believe, last year in the debate on the Finance Act, that of that money £1,675,000 would be provided by the Central Fund and that the balance of £825,000 should be put up by the local authorities. I should like to know from the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Local Government, what rule was followed in apportioning that money to the various local authorities? There has been, as far as I have been able to ascertain, great inequality in the allocation of that money.
Comment on this
Is that not administration purely? Would that not arise on the Vote of the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Vote for the Minister for Local Government?
Comment on this
Yes, but there is this point which deals with policy, I submit. When the local authorities considered this matter, and I think when this House considered the matter last year, they considered it from the point of view of the practicability of the local authorities borrowing their share over the usual period of 15 years. Local authorities that I know agreed to put up this money, having a general idea that the policy relating to it, the terms of borrowing, would be the same as in the case of other large sums; but the Government have limited the period over which this money must be repaid to three years.
Comment on this
The result, anyway, is the imposition of an intolerable burden. I submit that the general policy of making the local authority shoulder one-third of the cost of the relief of unemployment is entirely wrong. The local authority has no concern, no responsibility, for the national policy. It is the national authority that is responsible for national economic policy and it should find the money to relieve the product of the defects of that national economic policy. However, that is a point that will develop further on the Departmental Votes.
We are constructing alcohol factories here, and we have constructed beet factories. If we require to bring in technicians to help some industry that is new to this country, I suggest that they should be brought in under contract only for a period which would give Irishmen or women an opportunity to learn the technique of those industries.
Comment on this
I am discussing the general policy of the Government in bringing those people in and placing them—we do not know their qualifications, and I will not put it any stronger than that—in important positions in this country without any limit to their period of office. We are gathering up the scattered Jews of Europe and dumping them into these positions. I would like to know from the Minister when the steel construction was finished in Cooley.
Comment on this
That is purely a matter of administration. The Deputy ought to be able to distinguish between general Government policy and the administration of a particular Department. When the Minister's Vote comes on the Deputy can raise that matter. Whatever Minister is responsible for the steel construction in the particular place to which the Deputy refers, when his Vote comes under discussion, that subject can be raised and dealt with in detail, and the Deputy can ask the Minister whatever questions he wishes to ask.
Comment on this
Is it in order for a Deputy to engage in Jew baiting, which is all Deputy Belton is doing in this discussion?
Comment on this
Deputy Norton has gone to great pains—and we were all glad to see it—to show that the Party he belongs to has no association with Communism. Everybody in this country was delighted to read Deputy Norton's declaration on that. As far as I am aware, I do not think there ever was any doubt of Deputy Norton's attitude in that regard. But Communism can only be kept out of this country by clearing the breeding grounds of Communism, and those breeding grounds are poverty, bad conditions and propagandists. I suggest that Jews have been the propagandists of Communism the world over, and we should not let them into sheltered trades and positions in this country to carry on their propaganda. Is there anything wrong in a reference of that kind? I would be surprised if Deputy Norton objects to that, after all his protestations here and outside this country that he and the Party he belongs to are not Communists. I am sure they are not. There is no Jew baiting about that.
Comment on this
I did not think the Jews would be able to pull the wool over Deputy Norton's eyes so easily as that.
Comment on this
I find myself in rather strange company when I come to discuss another point, that is, the suggestion of an increase in Ministers' salaries. The Government, whose main plank in getting into office was that no man is worth more than £1,000 a year or should get more than £1,000 a year in this country, are now adopting a different attitude. It ill-becomes such people, when they get into office and find the largest section of the people—whom they deluded sufficiently to put them into office— poorer than they have ever been in the history of this country, to turn round and say: "Now, we are going to increase our salaries." This Government got into office largely by declaring that if they got in they would reduce the salaries. They now say that they must increase them. While I have a vote here I will vote against that Government increasing salaries.
I was waiting to hear some solid comparisons made here about conditions as the result of Government policy in the last few years. Deputy McGilligan made a long statement. I will say that he made a perfectly reasoned statement. The Minister for Industry and Commerce got up after him and, instead of going over the ground after Deputy McGilligan, he indulged in a lot of rhetoric and shibboleths in order to confuse the issue. He talked about the fall in the prices of produce from 1929 to 1931. The fall then in world prices, particularly in British prices, was catastrophic, so catastrophic that Great Britain could not remain on the gold standard after December, 1931. She went off the gold standard and from that time until now we have not had gold prices—we have had only paper prices.
I am not sure, at the moment, what is the gold value of sterling—it might be about 12/-. So that if we are going to compare prices for 1929 to 1931 with present prices, we must take into account the value of the unit of money.
The £1 unit that we reckoned up to, I think, 19th December, 1931, was 20/-. That unit to-day is, I think, in the neighbourhood of from 11/- to 13/- or 14/-. It is obvious that the first reaction to going off the gold standard, even if the values fundamentally remain the same, would be that prices would go up, not because of any increase in real price, but because the unit of currency was cheapened from 20/- to 13/- or 14/-. That brought a boom and was intended to bring a boom and always brings a boom in trade. Great Britain went off the gold standard in order to bring about a boom in British trade and she succeeded. If the depreciation of her currency to the first point was not sufficient—and it was not sufficient—she kept on depreciating it until she had it down to a level that she could trade with profit and sell to other nations which had a currency equal to or of more value than her own. That was deliberately done by Great Britain to depreciate the value of her money, so that she could sell in countries on the gold standard or which had a more appreciated currency than the British currency. These matters are not taken into account. How did the Minister for Industry and Commerce get out of his jam? What will people say? How will people vote? Ministers are expected to do what is right and to consider fundamentals, regardless of what the mass will do when things are misrepresented, as generally they are misrepresented by politicians.
Prices have risen since 1931. Deputy McGilligan quoted statistics to show that, while world prices fell from 1929 to 1931, they fell less in the Free State than in any other sterling country, and that from 1931 to 1935 they rose more in other countries than they did in the Free State. He said that wanted an explanation. The Minister for Industry and Commerce did not explain that, because it cannot be explained away. I challenge the Minister for Finance to explain it away. These are the matters that count. If, by false misrepresentation to the electorate, the Government got 100 per cent. of the electorate to vote for them, it would not make wrong right. I ask the Minister for Finance to explain why general prices fell less in the Free State from 1929 to 1931 than in any other sterling country, and why they rose less from 1931 to 1935 in the Free State than in any other sterling country. Then we will get down to bedrock.
We have been told, in effect, that we may take it as a normal condition of affairs here that the tariffs on our cattle and on our produce generally going into Great Britain will remain. We have been told that we have got either to fight or to surrender. We have surrendered. We have agreed to pay, and we are paying. It has become a hardy annual now to reiterate in writing, in an instrument called the Coal-Cattle Pact, that we will pay the annuities and all the other sums to Great Britain. It is not now a question of whether we will pay or not; it is a question of the form in which we will pay. The form in which the present Government agreed to pay is so much per head on every beast going into Great Britain. That is the agreement, and that has dislocated the trade of the country.
I want to direct Deputy Norton's attention to this. It has been stated here to-day that the indebtedness of local authorities in the last few years has gone up from £14,000,000 or £15,000,000 to £24,000,000. I am not going to say that all that indebtedness is non-productive; a great lot of it is productive. But with some knowledge of what I am saying, I suggest there is hardly a local authority in this country to-day which has not a large overdraft. There is no county council that has not a difficulty in getting in the rates, and has perforce to work on an overdraft. The defaulters in the payment of rates are the farmers, and the reason the farmers are defaulters is because of the general policy of the Government.
I am not one of those who object to the growing of wheat or beet, because I have been a pioneer in the growing of those two crops. I am as strongly in favour of their cultivation to-day as ever I was, provided it is done with commonsense and in a rotation of good farming. I think, when I speak of good farming, I speak on a subject which I know at least a little about. In the county in which I have the honour to be chairman of the county council, and which the Minister for Finance has the honour to represent in this House, the arrears of rates amount to £70,000 or £80,000, substantially all accumulated in the last four or five years. There is no possible chance of getting in those rates. We have investigated case after case. The Minister's colleague, Deputy Brady, is a member of the Dublin County Council and he knows what I am saying is true. We have tried means that were distasteful to some of us, yet I see great difficulty in carrying on. I want to relate that condition of things to something that will be interesting to Deputy Norton and his Party. We hear a lot about the wages that should be paid, yet within four miles of where I am standing, men have to work 60 hours a week for 25/-, and the men who are getting 25/- a week working on a farm have more out of it than the farmers have. I challenge contradiction of that statement. It is all very well to come here and talk about social conditions and about what has been done for agriculture. I grant that the Minister for Finance thinks that the overwhelming majority of the farmers voted No. 1 for him at the last election. I will not say what they will do next time, because nobody knows what they will do. I know that the farmers are quite satisfied that their position is now much worse than it was four years ago. I know that it is worse, and so does Deputy Brady.
What is the cause? The cause is that our Government in a so-called fight, but which is really a surrender, agreed to pay the British Government £5,000,000 by way of a tax on cattle going to Great Britain and at the same time they are making the farmers pay here. That cannot be done. When farmers grumbled at that state of affairs the Minister for Finance went amongst the people and said: "These farmers are trying to sabotage the State and to prevent the Government giving you the social services that it intended to give." I wonder if any Deputy thinks 25/- for a 60 hours' week a fair wage. Yet the people who have these men employed have nothing for themselves and are going deeper into debt every day. I can bring any Deputy to 100 farmers in County Dublin who are in that position. They are men who always paid their way in the past. I speak with some feeling on this question, because I know the impossible condition under which the farmers are working owing to the fact that the British Government is collecting the annuities on one hand and another £2,000,000 is being collected here, so that the farmers have to pay both sides.
I am convinced that farmers should not be asked to pay rates or annuities while they have to pay £5,000,000 to the British Government, a payment that was agreed to by President de Valera. While that is the condition of farmers, as chairman of Dublin County Council, I should point out that we have been urged by the Minister for Local Government to get in the rates, and a short time ago we had a communication from that Department stating that if two rate collectors, whose names were mentioned, did not show a better collection within a certain date they should be suspended. Farming conditions at present mean 25/- a week for a labouring man. Deputies get up in this House and pay lip service to the cause of labour. Nobody is doing any service to the cause of labour who helps in the remotest way to produce conditions in any industry which make it impossible to pay decent wages. I would be very glad if anybody with experience of agricultural conditions, who knows what it is to handle a plough, would tell me where more than 25/- a week is being paid in agricultural wages, and what return farmers are getting at the present time for the slavery that they have to put into cash crops.
There was never such slavery in agriculture as there is in the growing of beet. While I hold that beet should be grown, and that a percentage of our sugar requirements should be met in this country, I say that we cannot afford to lose on every crop. We must make a profit on some crop. The artificial price given for beet is only given because of excessive excise duties and import duties. In other circumstances, many of us would be enthusiastic about the Government's industrial policy which has been so severely criticised. I am 70 or 80 per cent. in favour of that industrial policy, but the producers of manufactured goods here which require protection must look for a market in this country and must look for a market for agriculture where every country is looking for it. If agriculture is bankrupt, and not able to pay more than 25/- a week to its workers, it is not a good potential market for our industry. Although £2 and £3 per week is insisted on for industrial workers while profits are guaranteed to industries, those can only be guaranteed by the slave conditions in agriculture.
I should like to say a word in conclusion about another matter that is piling on costs to local authorities and causing difficulties to county councils. The Land Commission is dividing farms. I presume that every county council has by-laws—our county council has anyway—governing road maintenance and road construction. We take over new roads on condition that those roads are made on a certain standard. The policy of the Land Commission has been to ignore local standards of road-making and only leave tracks.
Comment on this
He will not deal with the Minister lightly when it comes to the Vote for the Minister's Department; and he will not deal lightly with the Land Commission when it comes to the Vote for the Land Commission, because then he will produce specific cases where the Land Commission has failed.
Comment on this
We can breathe lightly now that we have heard that, because probably when those Estimates come to be dealt with the Deputy will not be here.
Comment on this
Has the Minister any idea where he might be? When the Minister tried conclusions with the Deputy before I know how it came off. None of us know whether he will be here or not. It is sufficient for us, when we are here, to do our job here. If the people I represent think I have not done or am not fitted to do their work here, the sooner I know that the better I like it. If that is their opinion I shall be glad to have their decision. I will have nothing to regret when that decision is taken. I am going to save money instead of losing it by absenting myself from here. I am here at great loss. I am not a professional politician, coming in here for a livelihood. I have my livelihood outside, and I am neglecting it in order to come in here and help my country according to my lights. The sneers of the Minister for Finance come very ill from a Minister. We shall meet, perhaps, on the battle ground of County Dublin in the coming election, and—well, we shall wait and see.
Comment on this
The Minister's deputy, the Parliamentary Secretary, knows the condition of affairs in the County Dublin; knows the condition of unemployment in the county; knows that the county council has put up nearly pound for pound with the Minister. And the Minister has imposed conditions which work out at, I think, two guineas a week for a 47-hour week.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the condition of unemployment in the part of Ireland that I know, and that the Minister ought to know and ought to serve. Those people will not work for that wage. I am not saying they are right or wrong, but they will not work for it. Yet all those benches there have pursued a policy, and are still pursuing a policy, that alongside where those men will not work for two guineas a week, agricultural labourers have to work for 25/-. Those are the benches responsible for that.
Comment on this
And the leader of the Labour Party cannot contradict or substantiate that? He asks me to talk sense when I state what I know to be a fact. The leader of the Labour Party cannot shirk responsibility for being a party to producing the conditions which have brought agriculture to that position.
Comment on this
Throughout the County Dublin conditions of unemployment are the same. The people are on the verge of starvation. The reaction of that comes to the local authorities in arrears of rent on labourers' cottages. Deputy McGilligan dealt with the reactions and repercussions of Government policy. He dealt with the matter in a scientific or academic way by taking certain figures and hypotheses and working from them. I am dealing with it from practical observation. I hope that the Deputies who represent County Dublin will be able to get up and contradict my statement as regards the conditions of employment in the county, the rates or remuneration in the county, the conditions of local finances and the general instability of conditions in County Dublin. I am quite sure they know every tick of the clock as regards political moves in the county; now let them show what they know about the economic needs of the people.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton, in the course of his contribution to this debate, again felt it necessary to pose as the one person not merely in this House but indeed in all Ireland who was concerned with the needs of the Catholic population in Spain. We had from Deputy Belton this evening another speech after the pattern of the previous speeches which he delivered in this House on the subject of Spain. I was not, owing to a ruling of the Chair, permitted to participate in that debate, because I felt it necessary to refute a very vile slander on the Labour Party which was uttered in this House.
Comment on this
Oh, no—by Deputy Anthony. Normally, I would not intervene in this debate were it not for the line which Deputy Belton has taken here this evening. It is quite clear from Deputy Belton's speeches inside and outside this House that Deputy Belton's dearest wish is that we should not pursue a non-intervention policy in Spain, but rather that we should pursue an active intervention policy there, with all the appalling consequences that an active intervention policy means for our people and for the peoples of Europe.
Comment on this
The Chair did not hear any remarks passed by the Deputy while Deputy Norton was speaking.
Comment on this
Surely Deputy Briscoe will not be allowed to describe a member of this House as an ignoramus?
Comment on this
Notwithstanding the obviously active intervention attitude which Deputy Belton has displayed in his speeches in this House and outside on the subject of Spain and her problems, in my opinion, non-intervention is the only safe and practical policy for this country to pursue in respect of the events which are at present torturing that unhappy country.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton made a speech on this matter this evening in which he deplored the attitude of those who did not accept his point of view. I do not accept his point of view on this matter, and surely I am entitled to make a short statement in reply. An effort has been made by Deputy Belton and by the Opposition Party to pretend that they, and they only, have the interests of the Catholics of Spain at heart. Speeches were made from the Opposition Benches during the debate on the Non-Intervention Bill, and speeches have since been repeated by Opposition Deputies throughout the country on the question. All these speeches are based on the brazen and impudent contention by them that they, and they only, are concerned with the interests of the Catholic population of Spain. Deputy MacDermot said one thing here last week which Deputy Dillon strongly resented, namely, that the Fine Gael Party was endeavouring to cash in on Christianity, and those who heard the speeches of the Deputies in the Party opposite and those who have read the speeches subsequently delivered throughout the country will have no hesitation in appreciating the appropriateness of that remark in respect of the attitude of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
It is easy to understand the attitude of the Party in this respect. Your economic policy is one that has not commended itself to the people. Your political policy has not commended itself to the people. Various devices of changing your name have not deceived the people and the only policy now left for you to adopt in order to endeavour to woo the people into giving you a new lease of political life is to pretend, and, in my opinion, it is an insolent and brazen contention, that you are the only Party in this country concerned with the interests of the Catholic population of Spain. Every member on these benches is a Catholic. I should imagine that 99 per cent, if not 100 per cent., of the Deputies on the Government Benches are Catholics, and I say that those who occupy both these benches are as much concerned with defending the interests of the Catholic Church in Spain and in Ireland as any Deputy on the Fine Gael Benches or on the Independent Benches, and probably some of them a good deal more genuinely concerned in that respect.
I move the adjournment of the debate.