We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Bill, 1936—Money Resolution. - Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Orders) Bill, 1937—Second Stage.

Contributions 140–302 of 302. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Bill, 1936
Enacted

No. 47 of 1936 ›

Denis Allen Mr. Allen

I know all about it.

Comment on this

Therefore, he knows that Great Britain collected £5,420,000. The Deputy knows also, I presume, that in the same period this Government here collected under the various Land Acts £2,500,000. The Deputy is perfectly aware of that?

Comment on this
Denis Allen Mr. Allen

I saw it in the book.

Comment on this

That is approximately £8,000,000 and that has had no effect on the farmers; not only has it had no adverse effect, but it has had a beneficial effect. There is no farmer in this country, even the most enthusiastic supporter, if there are any enthusiastic supporters left, of the present Government that will subscribe to that statement. When we get, not a relief, mind you, but a transfer of approximately £40,000 off horses on to cattle, sheep, and other things, the relief is supposed to be so tremendous that the Irish Press features it as a wonderful gain for the people of the country. We cannot have it both ways. There was no reduction of the £40,000.

Comment on this
Denis Allen Mr. Allen

The horse-breeders profited.

Comment on this

Yes, but what about the duties on cattle, sheep and pigs? The Deputy cannot get away from this fact, that the British Government are collecting every penny of the money that they allege is due to them, and the Government here is collecting about £2,500,000 a year as well.

Comment on this
Denis Allen Mr. Allen

Who paid the coal tax?

Comment on this

The people of this country. I would not advise the Deputy to say much about the Coal-Cattle Pact, or about the coal tax, as the Minister might not be at all grateful to him. They cannot talk about the Coal-Cattle Pact, or the new addition of it that we have got, while at the same time the President talks about no compromise and no surrender. Deputy Kehoe spoke about the uncompromising attitude of the Government. Have they not given a complete monopoly of the coal trade to the enemy and put people here in this position that they cannot buy one pound of coal from any country other than Great Britain?

Comment on this

Has the Deputy never heard of coals of fire?

Comment on this

It is almost futile to go any further when we have Deputies telling us that the farmers are better off to-day than they were before the present Government came into office.

Comment on this

They say so themselves.

Comment on this

Why? We have heard a great deal of boasting from the Minister, Deputy Kehoe, Deputy Victory and Deputy Allen about having won two general elections. We did not hear them boasting of the fact that they were beaten at four other elections. There have been six general elections in 15 years.

Comment on this

The Deputy was beaten.

Comment on this

The Deputy won every election in spite of the efforts of the Fianna Fáil Party, including the Minister.

Comment on this

And will again.

Comment on this

At six general elections the Party opposite were beaten badly and decisively. I have not broken my continuous service in this House like Deputy Allen.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

When the Deputy severed his connection with this House it was not any loss to him.

Comment on this
Denis Allen Mr. Allen

I did not refer to the Deputy personally. I referred to his Party.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The private business or avocations of Deputies should not be discussed in the House.

Comment on this

With all respect, I submit that I am not responsible, but if these matters are introduced I am entitled to defend myself. If I misunderstood what the Deputy said I apologise to him. I am concerned about another side to this pact, because there are rumours across the Channel that there will be difficulty in obtaining supplies owing to a greater demand for coal in Great Britain at present than for a number of years. Prices are rising on the home market and on the Continent, and I want to know from the Minister when this pact was being negotiated if any steps were taken to safeguard the coal supplies of this country, so that adequate supplies will be available under the monopoly; and if any steps were taken to see that there will be no increase in prices.

Comment on this

I have a good deal of sympathy with what I heard of Deputy Kehoe's speech. I concede that to him and to the Government without equivocation, so that the country will wake up to the exact position and that those responsible will know that the responsibility is theirs. I concede that in 1932 the Party to which Deputy Kehoe belongs won the general election. It put forward the policy of retaining the annuities and, of course, was lavish in its promises about what could be done with the money. The outstanding promise was that there would be complete de-rating of agricultural land. That was not carried out. It was also stated that England would not retaliate. It is an historical fact that in 1932 £2,250,000 was voted by this Government for the relief of rates on agricultural land.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of de-rating does not arise.

Comment on this

That was only a passing reference by way of reply to the remarks of Deputy Kehoe.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Surely Deputy Kehoe did not discuss de-rating.

Comment on this

No, but he boasted, and made it the bedrock of his argument, that the Government had gone to the people twice in the last five years and were returned to power. I mentioned de-rating when conceding the net claim made by Deputy Kehoe. I may say in passing, as an opponent of the Government, that if there is one section of the people more than another that the Government may thank for their return to power, it is the farmers. I say that without fear of contradiction. If the farmers are in the bad condition that I know them to be in, let them take that home and ponder over it. They have nobody to blame but themselves. I say that as a farmer and as a supporter of the farmers' cause. The Deputy will concede that after the 1933 election there was not the same measure of relief given to the rating of agricultural land. He has this in favour of his argument, that the farming community knew in 1933 what they did not know in 1932, that the economic war was on, that the £5,000,000 was being withheld from Great Britain, and that Great Britain had retaliated and was collecting that money by duties on our produce. The Deputy should remember that this fight had only started, being only six or seven months in existence.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question before the House is the confirmation of certain orders. The debate has strayed somewhat. It is not clear to me that any programme put before the people in 1932 or 1933 is relevant to this Bill.

Comment on this

Item 12 in the Schedule deals with the remission of duties arising out of the Coal-Cattle Pact. Listening to the debate as it developed here, it was on the Coal-Cattle Pact; it was on the position created by the withholding of those payments to Britain. I am sorry if I am lacking in understanding, but I submit, with all deference to the Chair, that in my opinion I am not going outside the bounds marked by previous speakers. I do not want to do so, because there is plenty of scope within those confines to put up all the relevant arguments that there are. However, if, in your opinion, Sir, I am transgressing, I will narrow my bounds. In passing, I should like to submit that I do not think it is an argument in favour of a certain course, of the rights or wrongs of a particular line, simply to say that an election has been won on that point, with others, because the presentation of a case very often wins a case rather than the intrinsic value of it. The whole thing has arisen out of a policy rather than a conviction, because I know quite well that there was no conviction in the Government Party that those moneys were not due; it was only taken as a political stunt.

However, they were withheld. Britain said, "Well, we will collect them," and Britain is collecting them. I submit that this Coal-Cattle Pact and its predecessors were a surrender to Britain's policy of collecting those annuities; they were an agreement that Britain should collect them in this particular way. The only difference between the present state of affairs and the old state of affairs is a difference in the method of collecting the annuities and the other payments. There is also this difference, that instead of the whole community bearing its share —as those debts were incurred in years gone by before the advent of the Treaty —the agricultural community now has to bear its own share, plus half its own share, plus what the whole community had to bear. The figures were given roughly by Deputy Morrissey when he was speaking. Let us leave politics and the winning or losing of general elections out of it, and deal with the equity of the case before the House. I would challenge any farmer or any man in this House who knows anything about agriculture to give the names of a dozen farmers in this country who are better off than they were five or six years ago. Let us be candid about this matter when we come in here. I know farmers who voted for the Government at the last election and will vote for them again. To-day, I drove into town with one of them. He came to me to ask whether I could get the county council to accept from him arrears of rates that were due on 31st March last, without any of the rates of the current year. That farmer will vote for the Government again, although he will tell you that conditions are appalling and he cannot carry on. I cannot understand his mentality. That will be a No. 1 vote from this neighbour of mine for the Government candidate at the next general election, and the man cannot pay his rates and will tell you that that is because of this economic war. He is a friend of mine—in other respects a very decent man. I see the meaning that draws the laughter. I will make you a present of it, because it has cheered up the sad faces I was looking at.

Comment on this

It shows your sense of humour anyway.

Comment on this

It would be a pity to spoil your sense of humour, especially when Deputy Jordan is about; he has a sense of humour which I very much appreciate. What is the difference in principle between our paying the annuities into the Land Commission to be transferred to Britain, and agreeing to pay them £4 5s. a head on a certain kind of cattle, £2 10s. a head on another kind of cattle, and I think 25/- or £1 a head on another class? What is the difference. Our Government have made a commercial agreement on the principle of allowing Britain to collect this tax on our cattle going over. What is that tax for? It is deliberately to collect those moneys. Is not that agreeing to pay them? What is the use of perpetuating the farce and saying, "We will not pay them; we will not surrender?" Each Coal-Cattle Pact has been a surrender.

Deputy Allen interjected a remark about the relief of the tax on horses. But is it a relief? Is there going to be remitted to us the £ x which Britain was collecting off our horses? Is it any part of the disputed moneys? Is Britain going to reduce her collection in the current year by the amount she takes off the tax on horses? Of course she is not. Deputy Allen laughed when he got the reply to his interjection from Deputy Morrissey. Deputy Allen had asked: “Who paid the coal tax?” Deputy Morrissey, of course, said that the consumer here paid it, and Deputy Allen laughed. If that laugh was genuine, and if that represents the mentality of the farmers of this country then we can understand how the farmers' eyes are being wiped; we can understand it if their mentality is not above that. Coal landed here on the Dublin quays came in at a commercial price. When 5/- per ton was put on it, that had to be paid by the consumer. The price to the consumer was increased by that 5/-. If Deputy Allen sends a bullock to Birkenhead there is no tax collected on that bullock when he lands. He is sold in the Birkenhead market or in some other British market at the commercial price there. Instead of adding a tariff to that price, the British tariff is taken off that price. The Minister for Industry and Commerce shakes his head?

Comment on this

The tax is collected at the port in both cases.

Comment on this

The tax is collected by the salesman.

Comment on this

And paid for by the people of this country in both cases.

Comment on this

Of course it is.

Comment on this

Of course it always works out against us!

Comment on this

That is the fact in any case.

Comment on this

That is the one mistake the Deputy makes; he tries to get the best of every argument.

Comment on this

And your one mistake is always denying the truth.

Comment on this

If, when he says "the Deputy," the Minister is referring to me and the argument I am putting up, I should like to say that I have been putting up this argument until I am tired putting it up. No Minister on the Government Benches has ever taken up that argument, or attempted to refute it, because it is irrefutable. It is not my argument; it is the country's argument. It is not increasing the price of cattle to the British consumer by one penny because our cattle are sold in the British market at the British market price and handed out to the consumer at that price, without any additions. When the Irish exporter, however, comes to be paid out of that market price, in addition to the other deductions for commission, etc., there is the deduction of the tax, and I have produced here documents, returns of sales in the Birkenhead market, showing that that is how the transaction takes place. I challenge the Minister for Industry and Commerce to deny that. The reverse happens here. This is not a tariff the British are putting on our stuff going over—it is a tax taken off the market value of our stuff. Consequently, the person who suffers the deduction has to bear the loss, whereas, if it were in addition to the market price, it is the consumer would have to pay it. In the case of our stuff going over, it comes off the market price, and, therefore, we who send it over have to bear that tax. The opposite was the case when coal was tariffed here at the ports. It came in here at the world price, the market price.

Comment on this

British coal came in at the world price? Why did they increase the price when the tax was taken off?

Comment on this

That is what we should like to hear from the Minister.

Comment on this

Because they were paying the tax before that.

Comment on this

If the Minister gives me a monopoly in respect of supplying, in the season, 500 tons of potatoes to him, will I be working at a loss?

Comment on this

You gave a monopoly to the British coal merchant. He was trying to get coal in here when there was a tax on and he was competing with the European countries.

Comment on this

And he was cutting his price to meet the tax.

Comment on this

Then the consumer here did not pay it.

Comment on this

But were we not getting cheaper coal from the Continent?

Comment on this

The British coal prices were reduced to meet the tax and, therefore, the British exporter paid the tax.

Comment on this

We were getting coal from the Continent. The Coal-Cattle Pact was made, and was defended here by the Minister, giving Britain the monopoly of the coal, and Britain did what every monopolist would do. She sent in coal of a lesser value at a higher price.

Comment on this

And the tax was continued.

Comment on this

The Minister has just admitted that now. That is the transaction he defended last year and that is the transaction he is here to-night to defend—a perpetuation of that monopoly for Britain to send what quality coal she likes and to charge whatever prices she likes for it. We have given her that market and we are agreeing in the same document to pay Britain her £5,000,000 which we are codding the country is not being paid and will never be paid to Britain again. We are appealing to the people not to surrender and we know why the people are cajoled into it. We know the Government is trading on the patriotism of the people. We know that they are trading on what they call "the centuries-old conflict with England," instead of this being a new conflict of a few years ago. They are trading on that, appealing to the patriotism of the people and asking them not to lower the flag now, when they know that they themselves have lowered it and that they only have pulled it down.

We do not want to go into the background of this matter. We have seen ragged documents alleged to be secret agreements and alleged to be 12 or 13 years old produced here last year, or the year before, when we were discussing this pact, and everybody who followed public affairs at that time knew that a deal like that had taken place, and that the very people who are resurrecting those documents were conspicuous by their absence in looking after the interests of this country during those years. Now, they refuse to admit that they are responsible for precipitating this. Of course, they are. Who else is responsible? If they genuinely believe that we do not owe these moneys and if they are prepared to fight to the last ditch in their determination not to pay them, why agree to the Coal-Cattle Pact? The official Opposition Party here, when in office, accepted the position that these moneys were due, and I could understand the Opposition making a Coal-Cattle Agreement with the British for the payment of the annuities if some dislocation in the method of collecting the annuities arose; but I cannot for the life of me appreciate the mentality of the Government who say that these payments are not due to Britain, and that they will not pay them, and who then sign a document agreeing to pay them by agreeing to a tax on cattle going into England.

I have observed your ruling, Sir, on the development of the argument about emigration, but I just want to say that, in the reference I make to that subject, I do not propose to develop the question of emigration. It has been pretty well argued in the last couple of days and whether it could be worked in on this occasion is immaterial. But the very serious part and the very serious consequence of this economic war, this economic peace if you like, this economic surrender if you like, or this economic swindle is a tragic affair for the Irish people.

Agriculture is the basic industry of this country and if it is not flourishing, if it is not showing a profit no other industry can be sustained here. For it is out of the profits of agriculture that industry can be built up. There are no profits in agriculture now. One Wexford Deputy spoke here to-day. I heard some of his speech; he did not go deeply into the question of agriculture. I was told that Deputy Victory spoke and I am sorry I was not here at the time because the Deputy happens to represent my own native county in this House. I know the condition of farmers in the County Longford—very well I know them. I know even the condition of farmers in the County Wexford. Only this morning I had a long letter from a Wexford farmer depicting the conditions of agriculture there. I am sure that farmer will read with interest the speech Deputy Kehoe made here to-day. I hope he will see the whole of that speech and read it and I hope also that he will get the interjection made by Deputy Allen.

It would be very hard to reconcile the cases put up here by Deputies Kehoe and Allen with the information that I got this morning from a County Wexford farmer. I am sure they and every country Deputy here knew the usual course of life in a farmer's house prior to this economic war. As the family grew up, according to the size of the farm and according to the size of the income, the parents were able to place the sons and daughters in some kind of a position in life. If the farm were a substantial one they were able to educate their children for the professions. Some of the children developed a taste for agriculture and out of the profits they were able to make during their young years of manhood and womanhood they and their fathers were able to buy other farms and go into occupation of these farms. Is there any farmer doing that to-day? Are not the farmers' houses throughout the country getting filled up with young men and young women from 15 to 25 years of age whose parents are unable to put any of them into any profession or any calling in life and unable to save any money to buy farms for them so that they could start out on their own?

Is not the position really that these farmhouses are filled with young men and young women who have no prospect in life? And how is farming being carried on? By the slavery of these young men and young women working on their parents' farms for the bit they eat. That is the story all over the country, in Wexford, Galway, Roscommon, Donegal, Cork, Dublin and the Midland and Southern Counties. That is the precise position. Were those young peope to get the lowest wage that is paid to farm labourers in this country, their parents could not carry on. It is only on the slavery of the farming community of this country that this economic war is possible. That is the answer. If anybody wants to investigate the position he will find that that is precisely what is happening and that is the answer to the jibe thrown from the Government Benches about people in this House who prophesied two or three years ago that we were heading for bankruptcy. That prophecy was true. But we are told we are not bankrupt. This country is not bankrupt because of the slavery of the farming community. I would ask any Deputy here who would like to contradict that statement to get any farmer or any group of farmers anywhere, no matter what their politics are, to contradict it.

Comment on this

We did get them. We got them in Galway and Wexford.

Comment on this

Deputy Donnelly was not here when I told the House about a neighbour of mine who is very hard up and who blames the economic war for his financial position. That man voted for Fianna Fáil at the last election and he will vote again for them. But he blames the economic war for his impoverished condition and the impossibility of his carrying on. I can concede this to Deputies on the Government Benches—you won the bye-election in Galway and in Wexford. You need not ask me to concede that. I concede all that——

Comment on this

Is there any moral?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy or any of his colleagues refute the case that I am making that the farmers of this country are not able to carry on and provide for their families in the way the people reared in similar homesteads and actually in these same homesteads were provided for in an humble way prior to the economic war?

Comment on this

Surely they did not vote for their own destruction.

Comment on this

Evidently they did. I do not want to repeat what I said in the beginning of my speech in which I dealt with the matter from this angle. I am not making an anti-Government speech. I am not making a partisan speech. I am putting the case, as I see it and as I understand it and as I know the conditions obtaining in farming at the present time. I would be glad if any Deputy on the Government Benches would attempt to refute the case I am making. What is the wage being paid in agriculture under the conditions arising out of the economic war and continued under the Coal-Cattle Pact? What are the overheads in agriculture? Five millions instead of four millions, and one and a half millions for half the annuities. Five millions are collected off our export produce to England. That lowers the wholesale price for the produce that is sold by the farmers in the home market. We are losing five millions on our export produce and we are losing as much more on the home market. No wonder agriculture is impoverished. Those homesteads heretofore provided for the previous generations of young men and young women who were raised in those houses; now owing to the economic war or the economic peace they are not able to provide for them. It is from these houses that the stream of emigration is now flowing to Great Britain and that is one of the direct results of the economic war. It is because of this economic war that the rates are not being paid and that the overdrafts from the banks to the local bodies have gone up. The policy of the Minister for Industry and Commerce has just a passing success, simply through the exploitation of agriculture and simply through the impoverishment of the farmers' families. Will any Deputy here who knows agricultural conditions in his constituency tell us that wages are being paid to farm workers? Do they pay farm workers 25/- a week in Laoighise, Wexford, Galway, Meath, Westmeath or Donegal? Of course they do not. Can any man live and rear a family on 25/- a week? Is there any industry that is being created by the Minister's policy and that depends for its existence on the exploitation of agriculture paying a wage of 25/- a week to adult men? Of course there is not; so that the whole economic policy of the Minister is being carried out on one condition only, and that is the slavery and exploitation of agriculture.

The economic war relieves the Exchequer of payments but it does not relieve the taxpayer. Were there no economic war, were those payments not withheld, the Exchequer would find three millions from the farmers in the way of annuities. But there would be two millions more to be found by the Exchequer. Now there has been no remission of taxation to balance that two million pounds, so that if the economic war were ended two million pounds extra would have to be found by the Minister for Finance out of taxation.

The £2,500,000 that come in as annuities to the Exchequer would not be coming in if the farmers had to pay their annuities to only one Government. The Government have a gift of between £4,000,000 and £5,000,000 which agriculture has to pay above and beyond what it had to pay before the economic war. It is this money, scattered in grants for public works throughout the country at election times, that is giving this Government its grip rather than the policy it is putting over. Perhaps the only solution is to let the thing wear itself out. There is a terrible responsibility on this House and particularly on the Government, who understand the position as well as, and perhaps better than, ony other body of men in the country. Yet they keep the thing going. This has euphemistically been called a war. It has lasted for five years. The President stated in effect only a few days ago that there was no hope of a settlement and that we must carry on. When a dispute has gone on for five years with no serious attempt at settlement, something must be wrong somewhere. A settlement of the Great War came after four years. Why is not some attempt at settlement of the economic war made now? The President saw Mr. McDonald. What happened between them? I have not read an account of it in any paper. Surely if the President makes a pact with the British Government to continue the collection of these moneys off our goods and if nothing better can be done, he ought to come to this House and tell us what obstacles are in the way. He has not done so. In effect, he says: "Carry on; pay the annuities by way of tariffs on the goods going into the British market."

Comment on this

What is your own idea of a settlement?

Comment on this

If no better arrangement can be made than that which the President has made, it would be much better for this country to revert to the old arrangement and have the annuities paid directly by the Land Commission. We would win on it. No sinking fund is being provided. The Land Commission is keeping its accounts as if the land annuities had not been halved. Remember, all these things are on record, to come before us for settlement in the future. I challenge the Minister to contradict that. The halving of the annuities is only eyewash, because it is there recorded that they are still due, and the accounting system is carried on accordingly. Why should not we revert to the old arrangement if the President cannot produce anything better than this pact? The farmers, as a whole, had £3,000,000 as annuities to pay to Britain, and that finished the job. Now they have to pay £5,000,000 to Britain and £2,000,000 to our Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not repeat his figures.

Comment on this

Deputy Donnelly put me a question.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should ignore interruptions.

Comment on this

The Deputy is now making his speech for the third time.

Comment on this

It is about the twentieth time I have made a similar speech and the Minister has never been able to refute it.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy intend to finish to-night?

Comment on this

I am not working against time. So long as I conform to the rules of order, I am entitled to go on.

Comment on this

For ever?

Comment on this

Until I make my case.

Comment on this

Once.

Comment on this

Only once. I realise that it is almost superfluous to discuss this matter here at all because the motion will be carried. No argument is put up in its favour and it is superfluous to put up an argument against it. The whole country knows the position quite well and I am now taking the philosophic view that the only remedy is to let it work itself out and, when the farmers get a sufficient squelching, they will realise they have been wrongly led. Perhaps they will, before it is too late, realise their mistake and rectify it. The Government know the position better than the ordinary farmer, who is troubled about the weather and other matters, who does not, perhaps, read a daily or a weekly paper and who does not know the "ins" and "outs" of this matter. In these circumstances, our Government should be fairer to the farmer and when, after five years, they cannot see any hope of winning in this dispute, they ought to try to make an honourable settlement of some kind and not a dishonourable settlement such as this Coal-Cattle Pact, which is a complete surrender of the whole position, a loss to the country and a loss to the farmer. It is driving the country directly to bankruptcy. One manifestation of the condition of the country is when a certain class of the community, who were able heretofore to provide for their families at home, have now to send them to be domestic servants in Great Britain.

Comment on this

This Bill is a formal measure of no great importance. It is necessary it should be passed in order to confirm certain orders, none of which is of very great significance, made under the Imposition of Duties Acts. The orders effected a number of minor changes in the tariff schedule of the country, all of which are being confirmed by this Bill. I must say I did not anticipate anything more than a formal discussion on the measure. Instead, we have had a field-day in connection with the economic war and the condition of the agricultural community. Apparently there is a big flood of election oratory dammed up in the breasts of the back benchers of the Opposition, some of which is bound to spit out every time they shake themselves. We have had a fair amount of it to-day and I think it was bad tactics on their part. Because not merely have they revealed that their election arguments are not very strong but they have brought prematurely into the House arguments that will be a bit fly-blown by the time the election takes place. It is a bad thing to shoot off all your guns before battle. These speeches would sound very well from a platform at the crossroads. They might even convince people who had never heard a speech before or who were particularly misinformed about conditions in the country, but it is merely wasting the time of the Dáil to produce them here, although, apparently, we are going to have them on the slightest provocation upon any Bill to which they can be regarded as even remotely relevant from this until the election takes place.

That is an argument in favour of an early election, but unfortunately there is a considerable amount of business to be disposed of. If we are going to have a general dress rehearsal of the election battle on every one of these Bills, then I feel that a statutory time limit is likely to be necessary before the required measures can be enacted and the election take place. It will mean campaigning next January, and I appeal to Deputies not to force us into that because January, in weather such as we are experiencing just now, would be most unpleasant for electioneering.

Deputy Fagan appealed to the Government to face realities, to come down out of the air and to get their feet on the ground. The Deputy spoke in most moving tones. The only mistake he made was that he addressed his appeal to the wrong side of the House. It is to the other side of the House that the appeal should be made to get into grips with realities and to face facts: to come down out of the clouds and on to the earth. We have been trying to get them to face up to facts for the last four years without success. We have heard in the last couple of days a lot of talk about educating the Government and educating the people. We had a reiteration of that talk to-day. The Party opposite may have succeeded in teaching the Government something during the past five years. It may even have succeeded in teaching the people something in that period, but one thing certain is that we have succeeded in teaching them nothing. We have done our best.

We have brought the facts before them with great patience and explained the facts to them. We have shown, in every sphere of national activity, how a particular policy could produce beneficial results, but they will not see it. They refuse to see it. They are still purblind about national interests as they were in 1932. We may not be very effective teachers, and despite all our efforts it is necessary, here at the end of our term of office, to confess that we have failed to teach them anything. I think it would be the merest waste of time to try again to get any sense of realities into them.

What are the facts about the economic war? All the speeches which we heard to-day from Deputy Dillon', down to Deputy Belton's, if they were condensed and the rhetoric left out, and flights of oratory abandoned, would mean this: that the economic war is not beneficial to the farmers of this country, it has done the country harm, it has done the farmers harm, and it is desirable that it should be ended, if possible. That is the sum total of their speeches, and so far as that is what they intended to say, they were right. The economic war was not started by Great Britain for the benefit of this country. They intended to do as much harm as they could to the economic system here, to depress the country as deeply as they could, to lower the standard of living of our people, to undermine the prosperity of this nation, and, particularly, the prosperity of our farmers. That is what they intended to do, and they had been assured by people in this country, whom they regarded as well-informed, and particularly by front-bench members of the Opposition Party, that if they started the economic war and imposed tariffs generally on our agricultural exports, they would get those results.

Comment on this

Now who is at the crossroads?

Comment on this

I am merely dealing with historical facts.

Comment on this

And the Minister is now asking the House to pass a Bill to facilitate Great Britain in further depressing the country.

Comment on this

Some of the speakers went back as far as the Flood and others as far as the Famine. I am only going back as far as 1932. That is how the economic war started, and it is quite a waste of time for Deputies to announce, as if they had just discovered it for the first time, that it is not doing us any good. It is not doing us all the harm that it was intended to do. This attack upon our economic organisation was intended to destroy us, to force us into a position in which we would have to accept dictation from Great Britain upon a vital matter affecting our interests.

Comment on this

You are accepting that dictation in the Coal-Cattle Pact.

Comment on this

That is what they intended. They did that because they had been assured of that result. The people who gave them that assurance were, of course, wrong in that matter just as they have since proved themselves to be wrong in most other matters. We have survived the attack which was intended to destroy us. We have reached a position in which we can contemplate a survival of our independence, a survival of our economic organisation and a gradual improvement and prosperity of our people irrespective of the outcome of the economic dispute. The various measures which have been adopted in order to lessen the hardships involved in that attack upon us have had results. These measures were drastic in their nature. They had to be operated hurriedly and not always perfectly; nevertheless, they have succeeded in enabling us to weather the storm. That being so, it is necessary to bring another fact before the Deputies opposite, a fact which they persistently ignore. A determination of this economic dispute would have had less noticeable effects upon the prosperity of our farmers and the fortunes of this country than the Deputies opposite profess to believe. It is sheer nonsense for Deputy Dillon to say, as he did to-day, that if the economic war was ended this would be the most prosperous country in the world. I am quite certain that the Deputy does not believe that. If that is true, why was not this the most prosperous country in the world in 1931?

Comment on this

Has there been no change in the circumstances?

Comment on this

If the Deputy objects to 1931 I am prepared to select any year since the State was established. If the ending of the economic war now is going to make this country overnight the most prosperous in the world, as Deputy Dillon said it would, why were we not in that position during the years before the economic war started?

Comment on this

We were in that position.

Comment on this

Australia has improved her position since this economic dispute started here.

Comment on this

During those years this country was disimproving and that is the central fact that the Deputies opposite choose to ignore. There has been a fall in agricultural prices since 1932. The value of agricultural output diminished, but that diminution in the value of agricultural output during that period of five years was less, and substantially less, than the fall in the value of agricultural output during the previous two years. I tried yesterday to get into the minds of Deputies on the opposite benches the fact that something happened to this country in 1929 long before the economic war started, long before the land annuities dispute originated and long before this Government came into office which had an appalling effect upon the whole economic system here and upon the prosperity of our people. During the three years 1929, 1930 and 1931, the year before the change of Government took place, there had been a steady and continuous decline in every sphere of economic activity: a decline in agricultural production and agricultural employment, a decline in industrial production and in industrial employment. That change took place in consequence of circumstances which had nothing whatever to do with the economic war or the special tariffs imposed on our exports or with the land annuities dispute or the election of a Fianna Fáil Government or anything else. The events that took place in 1932 merely accentuated something which had begun long before that, but we succeeded in the ensuing two years in arresting that decline and in stopping the rot. Since 1934 there has been a substantial increase in the volume and value of agricultural production, an increase in the volume and value of agricultural exports, a substantial increase in the number of persons employed in agriculture—an increase which is continuing during the present year—and, side by side with that improvement in the position of agriculture, there was a much more substantial, a much more spectacular increase in the output of industry and in employment in industry—an increase represented by the figure I gave here yesterday: £13,500,000 increase in the gross value of industrial production and £1,600,000 additional in wages paid to industry, and an increase in the average weekly number employed of 54,000 in 1936 as against 1931.

Comment on this

Had we not all that yesterday?

Comment on this

Yes, the whole of it.

Comment on this

Is it in this Bill?

Comment on this

Well, apparently, we are going to have this on every Bill from now on till the election. If it succeeds in impressing the Deputy, it is all the better. I know, of course, that he wants to impress us, but I hope we will succeed in impressing on him that our election speeches are going to be very much better than his.

Comment on this

I hope they will not be as long.

Comment on this

So far as the economic war is concerned, I want to say that nothing has happened yet which would seem to suggest that there is any prospect of securing a settlement of that dispute by negotiation on terms which would not involve concessions by us that this Government is not prepared to give.

Comment on this

What are the conces sions?

Comment on this

What about the result of the MacDonald-de Valera Conference?

Comment on this

We have no objection in principle, as was alleged here, to the negotiation of trade agreements with Great Britain. We have, in fact, availed of any opportunity that offered for the negotiation of these agreements. These agreements were not always entirely satisfactory to us. We had to take due cognisance of the economic conditions prevailing here. If we were completely masters of our destiny, if economic conditions were better, and if there had not been this dependence on the British market for the sale of a large proportion of our agricultural exports, we could afford to take a different attitude; but we had to take into full account these economic circumstances to which I have referred and to frame a policy accordingly, and we have done it. That is why this agreement was made. It was made because we took into account these circumstances and, in these circumstances, tried to do the best thing possible for the people of this country, and I submit that we have done it. It is not perfect. The situation is not one of our choosing. Certainly, it is not one we wished to see, but if Deputies opposite think that this Government, at any rate, is going to secure an improvement in that situation by surrendering upon principles which are vital to our people, then they are mistaken.

Deputy Dillon, of course, announced here this afternoon that his Party knew of a course which would settle the dispute and, at the same time, avoid payment of the moneys directly or indirectly, but he took good care not to give the slightest hint of what that course was. He was just talking humbug. That sort of "boloney" may fool the members of his own Party, but it will not fool anybody else. I am quite sure that it will not fool Deputy Belton.

Comment on this

I am quite sure it will not fool me, any more than the Minister will.

Comment on this

Well, I will say for Deputy Belton, that, judging by the average standard prevailing on the opposite benches——

Comment on this

Standard of what?

Comment on this

Of intelligence. I will say of him that, judging by the average standard prevailing on the opposite benches, Deputy Belton must be reckoned as intelligent, but, of course, the average standard there is very low.

Comment on this

That is a very useful contribution to the debate.

Comment on this

Tell us about the prosperity of the farmers.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon made that assertion here, and I am quite certain we are going to hear it again. In any event, whether other Deputies in that Party are as foolish as he was and whether they will be so foolish as to make that assertion in so many words, it will certainly be implied by many of them that there are some means by which, at the present time, it is possible to secure a settlement of the dispute without payment of these moneys, directly or indirectly, or without surrendering upon a question of vital principle. There is no such course at present. No one, of course, can tell what circumstances will arise in the future, but it is an entire illusion, and a dangerous illusion, to think that we can benefit the farmers of this country by accepting terms in settlement of this dispute which would involve the concession by us of principles to which, in our opinion, we must adhere——

Comment on this

What are they?

Comment on this

——because, if we permit the British Government to get the idea that, by applying tariffs upon our agricultural exports, they can force us to accept conditions which are otherwise intolerable to us, then it is inevitable that, time and again, that device will be resorted to whenever any other matter comes into dispute between the two countries. If once we accept that position, our independence—economic, fiscal and political—will be meaningless.

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell us the Ottawa terms?

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy is referring to.

Comment on this

The interviews given.

Comment on this

The Deputy is probably relying upon certain statements which appeared in a book published over the name of J.H. Thomas. Well, I can assure the Deputy that the members of this Party and the people of this country would believe whatever assertion was made by President de Valera in connection with that matter much sooner, and long before, they would believe anything that was said on the matter by Mr. Thomas.

Comment on this

Or by the Vice-President?

Comment on this

Yes, or by the Vice-President, or the meanest member of that Party. Well, I should not have used that adjective. I should have said the least significant.

Comment on this

The truth does come out occasionally.

Comment on this

Will that Deputy, to whom the Minister referred, stand up?

Comment on this

He has not been elected yet.

Comment on this

Well, then there is no use complaining.

Comment on this

That is class distinction, evidently.

Comment on this

It is, of course, completely misleading to talk about the tariff having been taken off horses and put on to something else. It has been put on to nothing else. There was no change with regard to anything else, and no tariff was put on anything else.

Comment on this

Of course not, because it was last season.

Comment on this

Then the Deputy admits he was wrong. Then, Deputy Morrissey spoke about the price of coal. It is not possible to forecast the tendency of prices or to be able to say what the price of coal is going to be in the future. Prices of raw materials are rising steadily all over the world. Some raw materials, such as timber, have gone up by 100 per cent. in a short time, and other raw materials, such as copper, have gone up even more than that. It is inevitable, in the circumstances now prevailing, that the tendency of coal prices will be upward, but when Deputy Morrissey talks about giving a monopoly to the British coal producers he is using a word that conveys a definite meaning which has no relation to the circumstances existing in connection with the coal trade between this country and Great Britain. If there had not been a tariff imposed upon Continental coal, no Continental coal would have been imported here in circumstances in which all coal is brought into this country duty free. It is inevitable that all our coal imports in such circumstances will come from Great Britain, not because the coal is produced more cheaply in Great Britain, but because it can be transported so much more cheaply to this country. We frequently had arguments here in the past as to whether the duty was paid by our consumers or by the British exporters. The increase in the price of coal which took place after the removal of the duty proves the contention that we then made, that the duty on coal previous to that was paid by the exporters, except for the short period during which the coal quota was in operation simultaneously with the duty. During that period, of course, the duty was paid by our people.

In the earlier years, the duty on British coal was partly offset by a reduction in the price to producers, and, secondly, by a reduction in the cost of transporting it here. As soon as the duty went off, these reductions were eliminated and the price went up. I do not think we lost by that, either. The people of this country are certainly paying no more than they would have to pay if the quota order had never been made. The coal quota order is necessary for the implementation of our agreement, and, in fact, the very removal of the duty would have produced the same result, that only British coal would have been purchased. The net result was to put the coal trade of this country into precisely the same position as it was before 1932, when all our coal supplies came from Britain. But in the interval something had happened in Great Britain. In the interval what was tantamount to a central selling organisation had been created, and, in these circumstances, I agree our importers are less able to protect their interests than they were previously. It may be necessary, if we cannot get voluntary action, to protect our interests in the matter of price and quality, to establish some counter-organisation on this side which will at least put this country as a purchasing country in the same position of strength as Great Britain is as a seller of coal at the present time. I would prefer that that necessity should not arise, but it will undoubtedly arise if the discussions which are periodically taking place, concerning the guarantees to our coal importers in respect to price and quality, do not prove to yield beneficial results from our point of view.

Comment on this

Before the Minister departs from that subject, I should like to ask him a question. May I take it from what the Minister has said, that there is nothing in the Coal-Cattle Pact which will prevent us, should there be an unreasonable increase in the price of coal in Britain from getting coal from alternative sources?

Comment on this

An organisation has been set up, similar in its nature to the organisations that were set up between Britain and certain other countries which had contracted to take stated quantities of coal from Great Britain, to negotiate and regulate the price at which coal would be supplied, to supervise the quality of the coal and the availability of supplies. That organisation is in existence, and meetings have taken place between representatives of this country and representatives of the British coal producers.

These meetings are for the purpose of negotiating and settling any question in dispute in these matters. I merely indicate that, in the event of that organisation not being 100 per cent. effective in meeting what we regard as reasonable requests, we may have to supplement it on our side by a more effective method of controlling purchases. If, in the last resort, we cannot get satisfaction, as in fact occurred last year in the case of cement, when after we made a quota order for the benefit of Great Britain in regard to cement, we found that we could not get supplies or could only get them at exorbitant prices, and that it was necessary to reopen the agreement, as we did, and secured a release from our obligations to purchase a certain quantity of cement——

Comment on this

The point I want to get clear is this. The Minister talks about other countries in connection with stated quantities. It is not a question of stated quantities in our case.

Comment on this

It comes to the same thing.

Comment on this

No. Under this particular pact we have got to take all the coal we require from Britain. Whether the purchasing organisation here and the selling organisation on the other side come to an agreement or not as to quality and price, we cannot go outside Britain for supplies without definitely breaking the pact. I want to know are we being committed for 12 months to purchase coal from Great Britain, and from nowhere else, irrespective of price or quality? Supposing the two organisations, one buying and the other selling, fail to come to an agreement, are we empowered to go outside Britain to purchase coal?

Comment on this

I gave a concrete example of what happened, in the case of cement. We made a quota order in regard to cement.

Comment on this

That is not the point I am at.

Comment on this

We found that the supplies were not available and that the prices, in our opinion, increased unduly. That created a situation in which we were not prepared to carry out the obligation to purchase a stated quantity of cement from Britain; therefore, we went back to the British Government and said that we were going to purchase that cement elsewhere in these circumstances. There was a question of whether the countervailing concession which the British Government had made would be withdrawn, but it was not withdrawn. The same thing may arise in connection with coal.

Comment on this

There is no stated quantity in that case.

Comment on this

If we, as a result of an increase in prices or a difficulty in getting supplies, found that a situation had been created in which we had to go abroad for our coal, then the question of the agreement would be reopened.

Comment on this

Before the expiry of the 12 months?

Comment on this

At any time.

Comment on this

So that this pact can be reopened and, if necessary, broken?

Comment on this

If a critical situation were created as a result of which sufficient supplies of coal could not be procured from Britain, or only procured at prices which were exorbitant, then the question would have to be reopened.

Comment on this

That is very wide.

Comment on this

We have by agreement with the British Government secured an understanding with the British Coal Miners' Association and set up machinery for the implementation of that understanding which we think will prevent this situation arising.

Comment on this

What increase has been agreed upon?

Comment on this

I could not answer that.

Comment on this

Could the Minister say beyond what limits we are not prepared to go?

Comment on this

The price at which we will purchase the coal will have to depend on the price at which it is sold in Britain or elsewhere.

Comment on this

Is there a copy of the agreement available for Deputies?

Comment on this

The nature of the understanding concerning coal prices was given on the pact last year. The same understanding operates this year.

Comment on this

This aspect was never dealt with before.

Comment on this

It was, indeed.

Comment on this

Might I have the Minister's permission to put a question to him? I want to be clear on the case he is making. The Minister drew a parallel between the cement crux of last year and a possible coal crux which may arise this year, through the possibility of a British coal-ring inflating their prices excessively. He said it occurred in the case of cement and that he went back to the British Government and said that he could not take cement at that price. It strikes me that that is not anything like a reasonable parallel, because the main agreement, as far as I understand it, is one of coal against cattle.

Comment on this

The other was cement against bacon.

Comment on this

The other agreement was a little bit of trimming.

Comment on this

It was, but it meant an increased bacon quota. It was offset by a concession in the matter of the bacon quota.

Comment on this

They agreed to take so many cattle against something over a million tons of coal. There was only a small amount of cement to be taken in comparison with the coal. The breakdown of the cement end of the pact was only a breakdown in a very small percentage.

Comment on this

The purchase by us of a specified quantity of cement was in consideration of the purchase by Great Britain of an increased quantity of bacon. One was definitely set against the other, and when the cement end of it broke down there was a possibility that the increased quota in respect of bacon would be withdrawn also. In fact it was not. In fact in the circumstances existing the British cement producers had to meet an increased demand in Great Britain and they ceased to be interested in selling cement here.

Comment on this

Is it correct to say that the main framework of the annual agreement is coal against cattle?

Comment on this

They are the big items.

Comment on this

If we break down on the coal side by refusing to take our agreed commitments in the way of coal, that would be equivalent to a repudiation of the cattle side?

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

That is a stick to hold over you with regard to the price and quality of coal.

Comment on this

The undertaking on our side is to purchase the coal if price, quality and regularity of supply are satisfactory.

Comment on this

Is there any "if" on the other side?

Comment on this

They will take the cattle whether we purchase the coal or not?

Comment on this

He did not say that.

Comment on this

They gave to this country certain quota allocations. We may reach the number in respect of each class. We did not last year. If we had more fat cattle last year we could have sold more and be still within the quota, but in fact we did not.

Comment on this

Why did you kill the calves so?

Comment on this

The Deputy knows what happened. We had an excess of stores and in respect of stores we sold more than our quota.

Comment on this

I followed the Minister through the bacon, the cement and his last statement with regard to coal and cattle. There is apparently an "if" on the coal side and no "if" on the cattle side. We are prohibited from buying coal elsewhere than from Great Britain except we reopen the agreement, but supposing the position arose that we discovered some other type of fuel here and we bought no coal from Great Britain, would the cattle side of the agreement hold?

Comment on this

It would still hold. We are under no obligation to purchase a specific quantity of coal from Great Britain. We purchase our coal requirements.

Comment on this

We purchase just whatever we require?

Comment on this

In so far as we might develop our native resources of coal or other fuel, that is a matter for ourselves, and I hope we will succeed in doing so. I understand that public business is to be interrupted at 9 o'clock and I desire to conclude now, as I hope to get another Bill through to-night.

Comment on this