We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 41—Local Government and Public Health.

Contributions 83–178 of 178. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

We are consulted, but they can go ahead without any reference to the Minister.

Comment on this

Without any reference?

Comment on this

It is not usual; it is not the practice.

Comment on this

We were not aware of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

I should like to know what are the duties of the Housing Board. That board has been in existence for something like four years and, up to the present, I have not seen or heard what its duties are. I have heard nothing of the board, except when I see the Estimate for the salaries. I have not seen where the board recommended any particular class of house, fittings or grates for any district. I am not aware that the members of the board went to the country and recommended particular houses to suit local conditions in the different counties. I thought that would be part of their duties. About two years ago I had a contract to build houses and I made every endeavour to get Irish slates. I tried four firms, and the answer was that they could not supply Irish slates for, at least, six months. When the man that I was building the houses for went to get the £40 grant, he found that £6 per house was deducted because Irish slates were not used. As Irish slates could not be got, I think it should be the duty of the Housing Board to make some recommendation in a case like that.

Comment on this

The Housing Board does.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

So far, I have not seen any recommendation, but I know that £6 a house was deducted because Irish slates could not be got.

Comment on this

I did that. I am the person responsible there. He was lucky that I did not take £10 a house.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

I suppose he was lucky that the whole amount was not kept. I want to draw the Minister's attention to another matter. It has been brought to my notice that contractors for bacon to institutions like county homes and mental hospitals took contracts at a time—if my memory serves me right—when bacon was something like 70/- a cwt. dead weight. Since then the price of pigs, live weight, advanced about 3/- per cwt. and dead weight something like 23/- a cwt. The contractors appealed to the different institutions for consideration of their claims for increased payments, but the only answer was that a contract was a contract. There would be some reason in that answer if the price of pigs live weight had gone up in the same proportion as the price of bacon. There are many contractors to different institutions concerned, not alone in my constituency but, I suppose, in other counties, and I would like to know if the Minister would again consider the matter, having regard to the fact that there has been such a difference in the price of bacon, while the price the farmer gets for pigs has not increased in the same proportion.

There is one other matter to which I have called attention for a number of years—as to whether the Government is about to give any consideration to the question of erecting mental hospitals for harmless people. You have a number of harmless people, both male and female, in county homes and mental hospitals.

Comment on this

We have them in other buildings as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

Even here.

Comment on this

Politicians.

Comment on this

You will have some more of them after the general election.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

This matter might be worth consideration by the Government because it might be a help to these poor people. The county homes are crowded out and they are not people who can be sent to the county hospitals.

Comment on this

Send them here.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

Some provision should be made for them and I think the Government should give consideration to having homes for two or three counties. It would relieve congestion in many of these institutions and these people might be helped when they are taken away from their present surroundings.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Some weeks ago I was reproved rather sharply by the Minister for making certain suggestions from these benches. He told me that these suggestions should not come from the Labour Party Benches—I suppose because he thought they were of a rather undemocratic nature. I am afraid I am a rather bold, unbiddable child. I am going to return to the assault. I want to refer to the lack of labourers' cottages in the administrative County of Clare. At the outset of the scheme some four years ago, applications were made for a large number of cottages to the County Clare Board of Health, and some 1,000 houses were granted, that is, were declared by the Clare Board of Health to be necessary, and a scheme was initiated. Now, after four years, we find that there are between 150 and 200 houses erected by the Clare Board of Health to fill the need for the 1,000 houses which the Board of Health declared four years ago were necessary. There are less than 200 houses, and even if there were 200 houses, and supposing that the demand would remain stationary, it would take 20 years at this rate of progress to satisfy the housing needs of those who are entitled to labourers' cottages in the administrative County of Clare. It was for referring to that the Minister reproved me. I want to assure him that any criticism I make of the Minister's Department is as benevolent as I can make it.

Comment on this

The Minister does not mind much whether it is benevolent or otherwise, and I think you know that very well. Make it whatever you please.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Minister need not be sharp. I am referring to the Minister's officers and to the heads of the various sections. I have found them efficient and courteous, and if the Minister chooses to be discourteous to me I am just as well pleased.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! That is right.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

So now we are on equal terms. I am going to revert to the statement the Minister made that statements should not be made from these benches, or by me, that the Minister should make representations to the County Clare Board of Health that they should speed up——

Comment on this

That the Deputy should, not the Minister.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Deputy has made representations repeatedly in all the ways open to him to the County Clare Board of Health, that they should build the necessary number of cottages, and the Deputy thinks that the best way to make effective representations to the County Clare Board of Health is to ask the Minister to exercise the power vested in him by legislation in regard to the labourers' cottages that are needed for the county. That, I hope, is clear. There are not sufficient houses being built for the labourers of the county. I hope the Minister realises that and I hope he realises also that the present rate of progress is not sufficient to fill the housing demands of the county for the next 20 years.

Regarding the actual erection of the houses themselves, complaint has been made with regard to the type of material being used and the type of contractor building the houses. It is quite true to say that people regard themselves as contractors who have no technical knowledge and no experience of any kind in the erection of houses before taking on contracts under the various boards of health, and that has been exemplified in County Clare where some cottages had to be knocked down after erection, and where various extensive alterations had to be made in the walls and other portions of the cottages. Complaints have been made, and these complaints have been conveyed to the Minister's Department, regarding the rate of wages paid by the contractors. These complaints are that the provisions of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act are not being put into force and that wages are being paid which are not at all near the standard rate of wages paid in the district where the cottages are being erected. Thirty-five shillings a week is the standard rate of wages paid by the Clare County Council and that operates throughout the length and breadth of the county. In a great many cases, 24/-, 25/-, 26/- and, in some advanced cases, 30/- a week is being paid in respect of houses erected in the county. In scarcely any case is 35/- being paid in the rural areas and in no case, to my knowledge, has the Minister interfered, although representations have been made to him to see that the provisions of that Act are put into operation.

There are other cottages in which I am interested. Cottages were erected in Gort and I was asked to go through them and examine them. I went through some of them and I found that the conditions described here by Deputy Norton in respect of certain cottages in County Kildare operated there as well. In some of these houses, the door frames had ceased to be rectangular, and, in one very bad case, the family had to take their dinner into the next house to have it cooked. The house would be filled with smoke if they were to put on sufficient fire to cook a dinner for the family. These cottages were erected upon what is almost a quaking bog. The portion between the front of the house and the roadway had never been levelled off and was a danger to the children and to the people themselves at night. The back door was three feet and, in some cases, four feet from the field at the back, and in practically all the cases the people had to erect a kind of platform or causeway from their door sloping down to the field. The field was acquired by the Galway Board of Health because it was got cheaply. It was absolutely sodden at the back and was almost quaking with water. During all this winter it was sodden and these people had to live in these houses and, although representations were made to the Minister, I do not know what steps he took to bring the matter to the notice of the Galway Board of Health, but as late as a week ago, I was informed that no alteration had been made in the circumstances surrounding these houses.

There are some other cottages in that village which were erected some four or five years ago, and no walls have yet been erected around the plots of these cottages. I have seen the plots which some of the cottiers are endeavouring to till and where they are growing cabbage, potatoes and vegetables, and the only fencing they have around their plots is composed of branches of trees nailed together in a kind of rustic railing. These would not withstand a charge by cattle going along the road and their crops are likely to be destroyed. I earned the reproof of the Minister by asking that he should bring the pressure, vested in him by legislation, to bear upon the two boards of health concerned so that justice should be done in these cases. I shall repeat these representations in this House as often as I get the opportunity until justice is done to these people.

I agree with Deputy Kissane and Deputy Kennedy that there should be some alteration in the allocation of the road grants. The complaint was made in the time of the previous Government that counties with a large road area and counties which depend to a great extent upon the structure and quality of their roads do not get a fair share of the road grants. That complaint still holds. The allocation of the road grants should be re-examined with a view to seeing what change could be made which would give those counties which depend a great deal for their prosperity on the roads an increased proportion of the grants, according to their deserts.

I should like to reinforce what has been said by Deputy Rowlette with reference to immunisation schemes in connection with diphtheria. There is a growing fear amongst a great many people regarding outbreaks of that fell disease. In some cases, where county medical officers of health have recently been appointed, these schemes have been put into operation almost immediately. If only to indicate to the people, who have been rather slack in appointing county medical officers of health, that there is a value in these appointments, I suggest that the Minister should take whatever steps he is empowered to take to see that these immunisation schemes are introduced as early as possible.

Comment on this

There are a few matters to which I should like to refer on this estimate. The first matter is in connection with the tarring of roads. A good deal has been said on this Estimate from year to year regarding the tarring of roads. Still, we find that, in most counties, there is an inclination to tar the roads from side to side. My opinion is that that is due to a recommendation by county surveyors or by people who are users of motor cars and motor lorries. I should like to put the case for the farmers. The farmers of the constituency I represent are very much opposed to the tarring of any road in the county—even if it be within a mile or two of a town—from side to side. We have our own experience from time to time of the accidents that occur on tarred roads. These occur even where there is a margin. Where there is no margin, the position is very much worse. We are suffering a great deal of inconvenience by the tarring of roads, even though only the centre of the road is tarred. A great deal of loss has been suffered and a great deal of damage done owing to tarred roads. We are prepared to suffer that inconvenience and loss provided a margin of three or four feet is left on each side of the road. County surveyors and others interested in this matter know, as a rule, more about motor cars than they do about the driving of horses or cattle, and so the whole road is very often tarred from side to side. I have been asked by a number of farmers in Kilkenny to go on a deputation to the Commissioner in connection with this matter. It is my intention to do so, but, before going to the Commissioner, I should like to put the position to the Minister, who is the head of the Department. Where an allocation is made, it would be only fair to the farmers that these margins should be left, and the recommendations of the county surveyors should not be allowed to override the views of the farmers.

The second matter to which I wish to direct attention is that of the cottage fences which are being built in the rural areas. I think I mentioned this matter before, but I am not sure. For the last couple of years we have had a number of these clay fences built. All around me in my constituency I can see gaps in these fences, which are falling already. No matter how they are packed or built to please the eye, I do not think that these fences will last. In addition, a quantity of the good sod required by the man who has to grow his crop is taken from the plot and put into the fence. I think that about three yards of sod is taken off the land for the purpose of the fence. That is the best part of the land. I would recommend —I think it would be cheaper—that a small concrete wall be put around these plots, because these clay fences will fall and trouble will be caused between the man in the cottage and the owner of the adjoining land. I notice that where there are two or three plots together, a concrete post with wire has been put up. That is a fairly lasting fence, but what protection will there be against trespass by fowl where you have one cottage 10 or 15 yards from another, and only a wire fence? I do not see how any division can be made by that fence. As time goes on, there may not be any trouble. The fowl of the cottagers may mix but I am afraid that there will be a little trouble from time in time. If anything could be done to erect a better fence which would prevent the trespass of fowl, it would be a good thing. A couple of little pigs might easily find their way into another man's plot and cause trouble. I think that a concrete wall, six inches or eight inches wide, would be the best form of fence. It would last much longer than the other fences and, perhaps, it would not cost much more. I do not know what the clay fences are costing, but I think the cost of the concrete wall would not be very much more.

Another matter to which I should like to refer is the rent of the cottages. I am glad to see cottages going up for the labourers and workers of the country. I know these houses are needed. But we have a lot of farm labourers whose wages are only 10/- a week and their board and the rents of these cottages that are now being erected go up to 2/4 a week. I do not know how farm labourers can, out of their small wages, afford to pay that rent. At the present rate of wages I think it would be almost impossible for farm labourers to do so. Of course, the labourer will take the house and do his utmost to pay for it, but I do not think he can succeed in doing so. I would recommend to the Minister that perhaps some arrangements might be made whereby the agricultural labourer could get his house at 50 per cent. of this rent of 2/4. That would be of great assistance to the agricultural worker, and it would give him some sort of encouragement. The wages we farmers are able to pay are bad wages. That is all we can afford to pay. If the Department could do anything to help to reduce these rents, say, to ½ a week, it would be of material advantage and a great boon to the labourers who are going to occupy these cottages. There is not much more I have to say in connection with this matter. On the whole, I think the question of the fencing of these plots is of extreme importance. If the fences are not made right the first day, a great deal of annoyance would be caused through the cattle grazing on the neighbouring lands getting in and destroying the labourer's crop. I suggest if possible that a concrete wall be built around the plots. It would be much the cheapest fence in the end.

Comment on this

As this discussion has ranged over the whole gamut of local government services, I am not inclined to speak at any great length on it or to go in detail over the points put forward by speakers on the Government side or by speakers on the Opposition side. I would like to draw the Minister's attention to one matter especially. I do not wish to criticise the work of the Minister in any way. It would be very unreasonable on my part to criticise the work of him whom I might call the Minister for Housing, for that is his accurate appellation. But I would like to draw his attention specifically to a scheme for the town of Enniscorthy.

In that area there have been several building schemes of late years, all under the ægis of the Minister's Department. Other housing schemes have been carried out there, and a good deal of buildings have been erected. Enniscorthy, however, is in the peculiar position of being built on two sides of a river—as perhaps a great many other towns. The people on one side of the river appear to think they have a grievance in the matter of housing, as the bulk of houses under these housing schemes appear to have been built on the other side. These things generate local acrimony, and it would be very unpleasant if anything were done that would help to foster that spirit. I know the Minister is not primarily responsible for this thing. As I said, on one side of the river the people appear to have a grievance. You have on one side, the Barrow side, a site that is unrivalled in Ireland from the point of view of health, and possibly of sanitation, and there is in addition a very good water supply. The houses that are proposed to be built on this site would stand on the grounds on which the Battle of Vinegar Hill was fought, a place of great repute in Irish history. Houses built there would have an historic interest. From the point of sanitary possibilities the site is unique. It is high and dry and possibly it is the cheapest site in Ireland. But for some reason or other the Department of Local Government and Public Health appear to look askance on that site. I am not saying the Department are wrong, but I have a shrewd suspicion that they are viewing the scheme from the wrong angle. I would ask the Minister who is already conversant with the details to see that this scheme will not be shelved because of some nebulous reason on the part of officials. One side of the town has been exceedingly well catered for in every way in the matter of housing, so that this other side to which I am now referring has a grievance. The fact that I am advocating this site of Vinegar Hill does not mean that other schemes need or should be dropped, but there is no reason why the Vinegar Hill site should not be gone on with. Sites are desperately needed for the relief of congestion. In this particular part of the town of Enniscorthy there are no less than 27 houses each of which house three large families. Knocking down old houses and replacing them by new ones will not in the slightest degree relieve the congestion that is prevalent and endemic there. Indeed, that congestion is too apparent to need any comment on my part. I trust the Minister will look into the matter, and if the officials of his Department may happen to think the scheme not feasible, I am sure he would be able to get around them somehow.

I would like to congratulate the Minister on the work he has done for housing and for the health of the people in general. I think the rather acidulous criticism with which the Minister has been met here this evening has not been deserved. The very great success of the Minister's housing programme has, to a certain extent, militated against it. Our Government came into existence and found the working people very badly housed and in a state of appalling poverty. The work of housing those who needed houses has been rushed, and very naturally the houses may have been hastily put together and handy man labour may have, in some cases, been used. It is no doubt regrettable that anything like this should happen, but desperate diseases require desperate remedies. I would like if all housing had been done by trade union labour and not by handy man labour, but there were occasions when houses had to be built at any cost, even though everything had not been perfect.

As I have already said, the very success of the Minister's programme militated against the thorough working out of his housing policy. I do not think that Deputy Hogan need take offence, as I presume he did, at the Minister's remark. I think the Minister simply meant, when he disavowed his intention of being moved by Deputy Hogan's criticism, that he would not be hurt by criticism. The Minister has shown his anxiety to meet the needs of the housing people in every possible way. We must all be convinced that on the question of housing the Government is guiltless of any neglect. Such little complaints as houses being flung together hastily is, perhaps, inseparable from the great schemes which were found necessary when the Minister took up office. Perhaps I should not say that the Minister's schemes were hastily conceived, but I know that there had to be some bit of a rush in carrying them through. In conclusion, I would ask the Minister to look carefully into this particular item of the housing scheme in Enniscorthy to which I have referred. It is a matter of much concern to the town of Enniscorthy. It is a matter of importance that the question be ignored or shelved in no way because therein lie possibilities of disturbance between two local sections of the town who have hitherto lived on terms of amity.

Comment on this

So much has been said on this Vote in connection with house-building that I will confine myself primarily to the question of labourers' cottages. So far as that part of the programme has come under my notice, I must say I have very little criticism to offer in connection with either the work or the sites. The only criticism I could offer in connection with it —and I do not blame either the Minister or the Party—is that sometimes there is a discrepancy, so to speak, with regard to the tenants who were put into possession of these houses. At the initiation of this scheme in rural Ireland I was appointed a member of a sites committee, whose business it was to go around selecting suitable sites on which to build cottages. I was interested in the scheme of labourers' cottages and many cases came under my notice. I came across one case where a man with five children, who was living in a single room, was not allocated a cottage, while I saw a cottage occupied by a single man. I do not think it was the Department that selected the tenant for this particular cottage; indeed, I am sure it was not. But there was a certain amount of partiality in connection with the selection of applicants for these cottages in the first instance.

References have been made to the fences around cottage plots, and in that connection I would like to endorse the remarks of Deputy Holohan. I too, have seen fences falling. One thing upon which I can congratulate myself is that I made it one of the conditions in granting a cottage site that I would not be satisfied with a clay fence. I was not satisfied and I am getting another class of fence; I believe it is to be concrete or stone —I do not care which. It was the one stipulation I made in the granting of a site. I believe it much better to have a concrete wall put there. It would be everlasting and the difference in cost would not be a lot. I have seen some fences as well built as they can be; I have seen others badly built. I suppose that sort of thing will happen. It was not a very good idea, in the first instance, to allow clay fences to be put up. They take a lot off the plot; they take up land which ought to be of use to an agricultural labourer. The sods are taken to a depth of six feet in order to build the fence and there is a big trench dug there. I do not know the difference between the cost of a little concrete wall and a sod fence, but I know that the concrete wall would be preferable and I do not think it would cost so much more.

There is one matter in connection with road grants that I would like to deal with. I am in the position that if I go about half a mile from my place I enter into the area of administration of four different authorities in the matter of road-making and maintenance. I can see evidence where the work is well done, where it is moderately done and where it is done in a disgraceful manner. I think that condition of things should not be. There should be some central authority to supervise the expenditure of money on the roads. So far as I know the situation, it appears to me that the same care is not taken because of the distribution of responsibility. The Minister knows very well that for years I have been seeking a grant for a certain road. I may tell the Minister that the road will soon be just as it was before ever it was done; unless it is tarred in the very near future, it will be as bad as it was originally.

My idea in calling attention to this matter is to make it evident that some other steps should be taken in the matter of dealing with road-making and road maintenance. Indeed, the whole road administration should be brought under one central authority. I am not now discussing the question of wages or hours. I think it is very regrettable, when money is still available, that there is not a decent job done. I am sure the Minister will agree with that. I know very well that conditions vary on particular jobs and it is not so very easy for those in charge to have the job done in the same manner as it would be done under other conditions. As things exist, those engaged on the work of road supervision and construction get one set of men for one or two days and another set of men for another one or two days and the result is that the job is not done in the satisfactory way in which it would be done under normal conditions.

Reference has been made to the tarring of roads. So far as I can see, if some of the roads were not tarred they would not be there in two months. I believe engineers are rising to the occasion and they realise that the day of the high camber on the road is gone. That is where the real danger exists. I am aware that some roads are very dangerous. I am not an expert and I do not want to dictate to engineers and others, but I am well aware that the roads that are being constructed now are much safer, even for horse traffic, than the roads that were constructed some years ago; they are safer because of the absence of camber. I have travelled over roads that were a positive danger. They deteriorated very quickly and once you got off the centre of the road you were quickly in the dyke. Deputy Holohan lives on a very important road, the road from Waterford to Kilkenny. It has a very fine surface. Except roads are tarred they would not hold any length of time. When a job is done it ought to be done reasonably well.

As regards the fences, nothing can be done about them now, I presume. Most of them are built. I was an advocate of a different class of fence before and, as other Deputies have referred to the matter, I thought it well to give my view. There is no doubt, as Deputy Hogan said, that the only fly in the ointment in regard to labourers' cottages is the smoke problem. That is probably an engineer's job, and the Department or the Minister cannot be blamed for it. I hope, however, that some steps will be taken to remedy it. As regards the cottages built in my vicinity, I have nothing but praise for the way they are built. I am sorry to say that some of the plots are nothing better than a small ranch; not a sod has been tilled. It is to be hoped that they will be made a little more productive.

So far as the roads are concerned, I should like to see them put under one central authority. It is too bad to have one local authority making a good job and another local authority doing bad work. If I take a mile radius from my place, I come under the jurisdiction of four different authorities, and while I have nothing but praise for some work, there is other work done very badly indeed. I hope the Minister and the Department will see in future that where public money is being expended a reasonably good job will be done.

Comment on this

The debate was instructive to me, inasmuch as I learned how indifferent is local administration throughout the country. I was wondering was it the same Local Government Department in the Custom House that was supervising administration in the country and that was supervising the local administration in Dublin City and County. It is a revelation to us in Dublin to hear that one engineer works part of the time for a mental hospital, another part of the time for a board of health, and yet another part of the time for a county council. Another matter that was not brought out before, of which we had knowledge, was the travesty of health administration in the country. I have been told here that, in criticising a certain Act, or rather the reluctance of the Minister in putting a certain Act into operation —an Act that is now nearly two years old and that was passed on the plea of urgency here for the sake of the public health of the people, and the vital clauses of which have not yet been put into operation—I have been told that, in criticising that policy of the Government on a former occasion— the policy of the Department of Local Government and Public Health—that the Dairies and Cowsheds Order and the Bovine Tuberculosis Order were being administered in other counties. Surely the Minister and his officials know that they are not being administered in other counties. They know that they are only played with, and that there is not a single whole-time officer, under any county council outside the Dublin County Council, engaged in administering those orders. We have the position that because, naturally and of necessity, when legislation is passed into law in this House, it is generally passed with a majority of votes from other counties and a minority of votes from County Dublin, County Dublin is the only county council carrying this out, though a majority of its representatives in this House voted against it.

Why is that so? Why is the Milk and Dairies Act of 1935 not in operation, and why is an Act passed here a few months ago in operation for some time? We have to pay the price in County Dublin. We have to pay it in the rates, because to carry out an Act efficiently is far more expensive than to carry it out in a slipshod fashion. We have increases on rates over our four districts this year varying from 9¾d. to ?½ in the £. We have large arrears, and we have an order of the Minister that, if those arrears are not reduced forthwith, that council should consider the suspension and dismissal of certain rate collectors. While the Act that he got passed in this House is being administered by the Dublin County Council to produce a good article for human consumption as a food, namely, milk, that Act is not enforced in any other county, and the provisions of this particular Act that would make the Act enforceable in other counties have been suspended and are not yet in operation.

Of course, we are gradually approaching the climax, or the anticlimax, when it will be realised that the burden on local authorities has become unbearable; that is, when the social legislation passed by this House is carried out, in the county in which it is carried out, and a county for which I can speak, that county—speaking now from a council point of view— is on the verge of bankruptcy. It has to face the collection of £300,000 in rates in the present financial year. It has to face an arrears bill of £100,000, and it has to face an overdraft of £100,000, and the Minister, while knowing that that council does its job well in administering the legislation passed in this House, will not make other counties do their job. I have heard representatives of other counties standing up here and claiming an increase in the road grants—an increase in road grants for counties on the Atlantic coast—while the roads we are maintaining in County Dublin are the highways and the pass-ways for the rest of the country.

A year ago the welkin was made to ring here, particularly by the Minister for Finance, in connection with the £2,500,000 that the Government was giving for unemployment in the last financial year. An analysis of that revealed that £1,675,000 was being given by the Government and £825,000 was to be put up by the local authorities. When it came to the allocation of these grants, I am afraid there was great discrimination in the amounts allocated to the various counties, and, while we in Dublin had to put up with £15,000 or £16,000, and had to put up nearly pound for pound, places like Donegal and Galway could get about £70,000. I wonder how did that come about? This is not a leap year, although it may be a political year. That was agreed to by our council, but it was agreed to on the understanding that the conditions attaching to our putting up the money were similar to those that we have been accustomed to. Two things, however, revealed themselves, and I think I am right in stating that, notwithstanding the fact that our council consists of 11 of each Party and two Independents—a total of 24—the council was unanimous in opposing those two conditions when the conditions became clearly known. One condition was that, though we could borrow the money we would put up for those unemployment works, we should repay it over a period of three years. The repayment of a loan over three years is moonshine. It is much better finance to put up the money out of revenue. It comes practically to the same thing, and it probably would be easier in the long run on the ratepayers to put it up out of revenue. It is obvious that by this manæuvre the Government intends to start by throwing about 40 per cent. of the burden of unemployment, created by Government policy, on to the shoulders of local authorities and of local ratepayers. Gradually, I presume, the portion put up by the Government will be reduced and the portion put up by the local authority will have to be increased, so that the Government will get rid of the baby.

Another fantastic scheme was one for which, I think, the Board of Works was responsible, but it came before local authorities, and I think the Minister for Local Government was involved in some way. It was a scheme by which a man got two days' or three days' work a week according to the number of dependents he had.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That matter would more properly arise on the last Vote on the Order Paper.

Comment on this

I shall pass away from it, then, after making the comment that it found no favour anywhere amongst local bodies. I hope the Department of Local Government will use its influence to try to amend that scheme so that a man may be given at least a week's work.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The scheme to which the Deputy refers does enter into this Vote, but I think it could be much more fully and relevantly discussed on Vote 69.

Comment on this

The only comment I have to make on it is to appeal to the Government generally to ensure that the least that should be offered a man, by way of employment, is one complete week's work. It would be much better if he could be given at least two weeks' work.

There is another matter in which, I think, the Department should interest itself. The local authorities with which I am connected have certain by-laws governing new roads. These local authorities will take over and maintain new roads, provided these roads are constructed to a certain specification standard and to satisfy the roads engineer or the county surveyor, as the case may be. In County Dublin the Land Commission has divided a few farms, some of them many years ago, even, I think, before the present Administration came into office. The one I have really in mind was divided before the advent of the present Administration, some years ago anyway. The people whose houses are built on the interior of the farm which was divided up, were left with what only can be described as car-tracks through a field, to serve as roads since. They asked the Land Commission to make the roads. I do not know if the Land Commission definitely refused, but I know the roads were not made. They have appealed to the county council to make the roads for them, but our by-laws stand in the way of that arrangement, and rightly stand in the way, because if a private individual has to construct a road to a certain specification standard before the county council takes it over, why should the Land Commission not have to do the same? It is a matter which I intend to raise on the Vote for the Land Commission, because it is not really the responsibility of the Local Government Department, but remembering that the Local Government Department is the local authorities' voice in the councils of the Cabinet, I appeal to the Minister to interest himself in the matter and to ask the Land Commission why, when they took on the job, they did not complete it as a private individual would have to complete it under similar circumstances.

There is another matter which is not directly the responsibility of the Local Government Department but is nevertheless a matter in which the Department must be interested. That is the question of public lighting.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is it not a matter for the local councils?

Comment on this

I submit that to refuse public lighting——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair does not see that the Minister for Local Government has any responsibility.

Comment on this

I prefaced what I was going to say with the remark that it was a matter in which he would, and should, interest himself, though he has not direct responsibility for it. I just want to make this passing comment on it. When the local authority, the board of health, decides on a public lighting scheme, it is put forward to the Minister to get his approval. The particular scheme in which we are interested in County Dublin was so dealt with. I am now referring to the public lighting of Skerries. We, in County Dublin, struck, I think, 1d., or almost 1d., in the £ to subsidise the tourist organisation here. One of the best seaside resorts in the county is Skerries. The Shannon current is in Skerries, and when the Dublin Board of Health asked for it, the E.S.B. refused to give it. Why? I should like the Minister for Local Government to inquire into it. I am not blaming him for it. He had nothing to do with the refusal. As far as our scheme went, and as far as he had anything to do with it by approving of it, he did it. I see the difficulty of getting at the E.S.B. here. I wish there was some Vote, even a token Vote, brought forward in this House so that we could have a straight talk about the E.S.B. Here is an extraordinary thing. We have to pay in Skerries for 3,520 kilowatts a rent of £260 to a private supplier, whereas in Malahide we get 13,000 kilowatts for £195 a year.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy professed to be giving the Minister a gentle reminder on extraneous matters.

Comment on this

I think if there is any ungentleness in it, it will not hurt the Minister. It is given in the interest——

Comment on this

Of shedding the light.

Comment on this

Shedding the light is an appropriate remark. I believe, from what I could gather from a subsequent speaker, that some Deputy appealed to the Minister to do something in the matter of reducing the rents of labourers' cottages. We have in County Dublin about 90 cottages that were built at a time when money was difficult to get and when it was very dear. Loans repayable over a longer period than 15 years could not be got. I think the rate of interest went up to 5 or 6 per cent. I was a bit amused when I heard Deputies here contending that 2/4 a week for labourers' cottages was a rent that could not be paid in their counties. I wonder how would labourers in those counties like to face a bill of 5/9 a week for labourers' cottages.

Comment on this

Does that include the rates?

Comment on this

I think it does. Well, even with or without rates it is something, I think, that will make most Deputies in this House think how happy they are with cottages at a rent of 2/4, which I presume includes rates also.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

Well, the rates would not mean a small Player's per week.

Comment on this

In those times that is rather an extravagance.

Comment on this

Well, the working man wants a smoke as well as we do.

Comment on this

I quite agree.

Comment on this

A suggestion has been made to the Department of Local Government, and I do not think it has been received as well as it should be. Those cottages which I have in mind were built by a district council just before 1930, or perhaps a little bit previous to that. It was only then that the board of health was set up in County Dublin, and consequently it is only from that time that I have any knowledge of this kind of work. This proposal was made to the Department of Local Government, to lend to the board of health from the Local Loans Fund sufficient money to redeem the outstanding loans on those cottages, and then either to lend for a 35-year period from that date or a 35-year period from the original renting of those cottages. One or other would considerably reduce the rents. There would be no loss of money to anybody —no loss of rates and no loss to the Government—and it would enable the occupiers of those cottages, who rented them when wages and conditions were better, to pull down some of the burden corresponding to the drop in their incomes. At any rate, having regard to the class of people occupying those cottages, a rent of 5/9 is too much, and I would appeal to the Minister for Local Government to reconsider that matter. I do not see why it could not be done.

I was rather interested to hear from Deputy Broderick that in the Urban Council of Galway an inquiry was held into the administration of the Small Dwellings Act. I would be equally interested to know why, in regard to a far worse case of maladministration or of peculiar administration—I will not put it stronger than that—in County Dublin, when there was an unanimous application from the Dublin County Council to have a public sworn inquiry held by the Department of Local Government, that inquiry was not held. The case was very clearly and exhaustively stated. It was shown by documentary evidence that through misrepresentation and other things the full selling price of the house was lent by the Dublin County Council. When this was discovered it gave rise to many things, and we sent a new valuer to value the houses. The money that had been lent was £400 a house, which was supposed to be 80 per cent. of the market value. When we found that the actual selling price was £400 we thought there was something wrong and we sent a new valuer. His highest valuation was £350. There are a lot of other filling-up facts which need not be gone into here—it would be waste of time— but they were all put in a lengthy document before the Minister, and the Minister refused an inquiry. That was very peculiar. If it was not necessary to hold an inquiry in this particular instance, I should be very interested to hear what terrible thing happened in Galway that made an inquiry necessary.

There is another matter which I should like the Department of Local Government to consider. It is very difficult for them to depart from the policy which they adopt, but I submit for their consideration that it is hardly the best policy. I refer to contracts, particularly for the building of labourers' cottages. The Ministry insists on the lowest tenderer getting the contract. It is difficult to oppose that principle, because, by departing from it, avenues for a lot of abuses would be opened up, but I think that the Department of Local Government should at least insist on a list of tenderers who are fit to do various classes of work. Do not bother about anybody except a man who is on that list. If a new man wants the work let him make application. If he makes any sort of a fair case that he is fit to do the work he should be put on the list. A lot would be saved in advertising if there was such a list, and invitations to submit a tender were sent out to all on that list. We have had sad experience because we had to accept the lowest tender. A case arose only a couple of weeks ago where we refused to accept the lowest tender and decided to accept the second lowest. The Department of Local Government said, "No; you must accept the lowest." Correspondence passed to and fro, and, when the Department came down with the sledge-hammer last word that we were to accept the lowest tender, the lowest tenderer could not be found; he was bankrupt. While I agree that the Department of Local Government should not depart from the principle of accepting the lowest tender, they should be always reasonably ready to consider a case put up by the local authorities. I am afraid they have not been as reasonable in that respect as they should have been. A lot of loss has occurred, which far exceeded the little margin that might be saved even if things were done satisfactorily by the lowest tenderer. There is a good deal of over-holding. What I mean is that contracts are not being executed up to date. Penalties are provided against that, but it is very difficult to enforce them. I have known houses to be over-held for a year and more, although part of the money in respect of them had been paid out. In such cases, I believe, a penalty of £10 a day is provided. That is an exorbitant sum, and is rarely enforced. In some cases money will have been paid out by the board of health for more than two years before houses are handed up by a contractor, and before there is any return in the way of rent from them. While that is so, the board of health will have been making repayments to the Local Loans Fund at 4¾ per cent. during all that time. In my opinion it is not always good business to insist rigidly on the lowest tender being accepted. What should be done is to have a closer examination made of the character of those applying to do work of that kind. I would appeal to the Local Government Department to reconsider their attitude on the matter.

There is a suggestion I have to make which, if accepted, would have particular application to Dublin and its neighbourhood, and probably to Cork, Limerick, Galway and Waterford and other towns. I am sure that while the Department recognises we have direct housing schemes and the poorest people being housed by the aid of loans under the Small Dwellings Act, there is in between these two a class of people who would be able to put down a reasonable deposit to buy a house, but at the same time might find the instalment they had to pay afterwards a bit too heavy for their income. In the case of people who are housed under direct schemes promoted by the Dublin Corporation there is an initial loan by the corporation. There is also a subvention given by the Exchequer to meet part of the service of the loan. In many cases the people who are being housed under direct schemes of housing are as well able and, in some cases, better able to buy their houses than the people who are actually doing so by the aid of loans under the Small Dwellings Act. Perhaps the Department would consider a combination of the help given under the two Acts—to help the applicant for a loan under the Small Dwellings Act to repay it to the same extent as the tenant of a corporation house is helped. If that were done, I think it would go a long way to solve the housing problem. It would encourage thrift amongst tradesmen to save sufficient to enable them to make the necessary deposit to purchase their houses.

I understood Deputy Curran to suggest that there was partiality in the selection of tenants for labourers' cottages. If that is so, I wonder if we in Dublin are having our eyes wiped in being made to provide machinery here that is more near to perfection than that to be found in any other county. As regards the new cottages that are being allocated, in practice pretty well the last word resides with the medical officer of health. I understand that in some counties they have not a medical officer of health yet.

Comment on this

I think in some counties they only got a county medical officer of health within the last couple of months. A county medical officer of health in a county counts for nothing if the machinery of his department has not been built up. I hope the Minister will see that in the various counties the department of the county medical officer of health will be brought up to the standard required from us here in the County Dublin. The Minister has now returned to the House after regaling himself. I feel sure that he is in good humour, and I hope that my suggestion will sink in and be sympathetically considered by him.

Comment on this

In view of the importance of the Vote for the Department of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, there are one or two matters of vital interest to my county that I want to deal with. The first question that I propose to deal with is the number of housing schemes that are held up, due to the fact that large sums of money in the shape of arrears of cottage rents have accrued in parts of the county. In view of that the Department has withheld its consent to certain proposals put forward with regard to housing schemes by the Kerry Board of Health. I would like to point out to the Minister that those arrears of rent have accumulated over a period of ten or 15 years, and that the position at present facing the board of health and the people whose houses have been condemned is not, so to speak, of their making at all. Another important factor to be borne in mind is this: that the portion of the county in which it is proposed to carry out housing schemes to replace the unsanitary houses that exist there, is not the portion of the county where the arrears of cottage rents have accrued over a long period of years.

In order to make my point clear and to show that Kerry is trying to meet its liabilities in regard to rates and current cottage rents, and also in answer to the comment made by Deputy Brennan to try to show that the question of rates in Kerry was a serious one, I should like to quote from the Irish Press of April 5th, in which it is stated that at a sub-committee of the Kerry County Council the County Secretary stated that out of a rate warrant of £163,863 to the 31st March, 1937, £126,361, or 77 per cent., had been collected, and the corresponding percentage for last year was 68 per cent. That will show conclusively that so far as Kerry is concerned the people are doing their utmost to meet their liabilities and that the arrears are being met by the people concerned in as good a way as they can meet them. The real difficulty is because of the fact that these arrears have been allowed to accumulate over a period of about 15 years.

Further, in order to show that in these congested areas the people have availed of these schemes, I should like to remind the Minister that in Killorglin, where we have had a very successful housing scheme, the tenants of the houses have paid their rents promptly, and there is no question of arrears in that area. The matter is a vital one because of the fact that the people reside in congested areas, and their present houses have been condemned for the past two and a-half years. I again appeal to the Minister at least to allow the schemes in Cahirciveen, Sneem and Castleisland, which are in the congested parts of the county, to be got under way by the board of health.

Another important matter concerning us in Kerry is in connection with the remission of rates given when agricultural labourers are employed by the farmers. The matter has been brought before the Kerry County Council on several occasions and we have been asked to make representations in regard to it to the Minister. The question of continuity of service is the principle involved. In our county men are generally employed for a ten months' period. Therefore great hardship has been caused to the farmers who cannot qualify for this remission of rates because the system does not lend itself to continuity of service. Under the system operating there farmers cannot get men to stay longer than nine or ten months. We realise, of course, that amending legislation may be required to remedy that. I simply mention it because it affects the rating authority and the farmers concerned.

I fully endorse the points raised by Deputy Kissane with regard to the road grants. I think the whole system should be revised. I think it is mainly on the basis of valuation that the allocations are made and, needless to say, that reacts very much against our county. I understand that the proportion works out in the ratio of £1,000 to Kerry and £2,500 to Kildare or counties like it. We have repeatedly referred to this matter and, in view of the fact that our county is a tourist county, I think that a special concession should be given to it; that rather than having a ratio operating against us, it should work the other way, and that instead of being on a valuation basis it should be on the basis of traffic. In Kerry, where thousands of tourists visit the various centres every year, the traffic is considerable. I hold that the amount allocated to Kerry is totally inadequate to assist the local authority in maintaining these roads to enable them to stand up to modern requirements. In conclusion, I should like to say that as far as our county is concerned, we realise the great work which is being done. I have referred to the housing schemes which are in operation and to the scheme which has been completed in Killorglin. There is also the hospitalisation of our county. As I say, the people realise the great work which has been done there.

Comment on this

I first want to congratulate the Minister on the very elaborate and informative statement which he gave to the House in connection with every phase of local government. It certainly reflects great credit on his Department and on himself. A great deal of attention has been given to the question of housing and a great many complaints have been made as to the type of houses being built in the country. A great many complaints have been made as to the unsuitability of certain materials and as to houses being badly built. A certain amount of blame is attributed to the Local Government Department for permitting that particular type of building. As far as I am concerned, I have no complaint to make in that direction and I am as much in touch with housing as anybody in the country. There are certainly some houses in various parts of the county which have not been built as they should be built. Certain defects have appeared and certain bad materials have been allowed to go into the houses. As a member of two local authorities in touch with building, my experience has been that the Department gives a good deal of attention, considering the magnitude of the problem, to the various housing schemes scattered all over the country. In my opinion, the supervision exercised by the housing department has been marvellous, and the defects have been in a very small proportion of the total number of houses built, having regard to the way in which the housing problem was tackled on such a large scale by this Government. There are bound to be defects here and there, but, on the whole, I say emphatically that the housing schemes embarked upon by local authorities under the supervision of the Department have been successful. A great many of the complaints that are made concern leaking walls and chimneys. The responsibility for these complaints is that, in many rural areas, when a house is being built the contract is handed over to a carpenter and a mason. The mason is given the plastering and the slating work. No matter how good a mason is, I submit that he cannot properly do all the plastering work on the house, and it is because that work has not been properly attended to that so many walls leak and so many cracks appear in the plaster. Plastering is highly skilled work. I know that there is a shortage of plasterers at present, but I suggest to the Minister that, where possible, plasterers should be secured to finish houses in rural districts.

On two or three occasions I put questions to the Minister in connection with the subsidies paid on houses built in urban and rural areas by the local authorities. The Minister will remember that a few months ago a deputation from the Council of Municipal Councils waited on him, and requested him to ask the Minister for Finance to increase the subsidy on houses costing more than £300 to build. I thought that the Minister was impressed by the case that was made, and I was under the impression that he undertook to see the Minister for Finance with a view to having the subsidy increased. It will be admitted by the Department and by the officials that the cost of building has gone up, if not considerably, it has gone up to some extent during the past twelve months. It is correct to say that the cost has increased by between 15 and 20 per cent. On a £300 house an increase of 15 per cent. in the cost of building would mean a good deal. If subsidy was paid on £350, the house with the advantage of that subsidy could be let at 5/8½, whereas if subsidy was paid only on £300 the rent of the same house would be 6/5½ per week. The Minister and the officials know that even that rent is too high to charge in many urban districts. In provincial towns the rents average 4/- or 4/6 weekly. If a house of that kind could still be let at 4/6 weekly, keeping in mind the cost of building increasing, it is going to cost the local authorities a considerable amount of money to do so. The Minister will admit, even though the cost of building has gone up, that it would be very undesirable that rents of houses similar to those built recently and let at a certain figure should be now increased. He knows that the tenants put into these new houses have been taken from rooms and from slums and that they are very hard set to pay 4/- or 4/6 weekly. If they are to be charged an increased rent owing to the increase in the cost of building, a state of chaos will be reached as far as rent collection is concerned.

It is well known that people who have been taken from the slums and put into the new houses were in the habit of paying an average of from ? to 2/6 weekly. It would be unreasonable to expect that the new houses could be let at that rent at the present time but I suggest to the Minister that when houses cost over 4/- weekly, it is very difficult for local authorities to collect the rents. A problem is being created for these local authorities by reason of the fact that numbers of people transferred from the slums have fallen into arrears in their payments, and the local authorities are at their wits' end to know what to do in that connection. The Department may say: "Serve notice to quit; you have the law at your back," but it has to be remembered that numbers of these people did not go into these new houses of their own volition; that the local authorities, in the interests of public health generally, sought demolition orders and had the people removed in many cases against their will. I ask the Minister to do his best to help the local authorities in this matter, because I know there is a growing hesitancy on their part to proceed with further housing schemes owing to the fact that building prices are increasing.

At this stage I should like to say something about the Housing Board which has been referred to by different Deputies. A great many people wonder what the Housing Board is doing. As far as I am concerned, I may say that I have been in touch with the board on various occasions and I got a good deal of information so far as the provision of materials and things of that kind is concerned. Representing the Corporation of Wexford, I found difficulty on various occasions in getting certain materials, and I must say that I got every help from the Housing Board in Dublin. I know that certain local authorities were rather lax in the promotion of housing schemes in some parts of this State, and I know that it is because of the advice and help extended to them by the Housing Board that they proceeded with housing schemes.

The Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act has been referred to. I think I am right in saying that when that legislation was initiated some years ago, the object was to try to encourage tenants to buy the houses in which they lived. The policy of the Department at the present time is that it will not recommend a loan from the Local Loans Fund unless it is for the purpose of buying or erecting a new house. I suggest that that is a mistaken policy. Of course, they agreed on some occasions with a recommendation made by a local authority that people could buy a house in which they had been living for years, but suggested that the money should be secured from the banks. The Minister and the Department know that the bank will not give a loan for a longer period than 15 years. It will be admitted, I think, that the cost of borrowing for 15 years is prohibitive so far as the ordinary working man is concerned. I suggest to the Minister that he ought to recommend to the Local Loans Fund the claims of any person in favour of buying a house in which he has lived for a few years, provided always that the house is in a decent state of repair and so certified by an architect.

Some Deputies referred to the roads grant, or grants from the Road Fund. I agree that it is a defect that some of that grant cannot be applied to the reconstruction of second-class roads and by-roads, because a great deal, if not most, of the traffic of the county proper is sent over these roads. In this matter of traffic it is absolutely necessary that these roads should get attention.

In the course of his criticism, Deputy Belton complained that the Dublin County Council were making roads that are being used by people all over the country, and that they were not getting sufficient money for doing that. So far as I am concerned, and so far as a good number of the country Deputies are concerned, they would prefer that the people in the country would not use the roads in the vicinity of Dublin as much as they do, and that they would leave their money at home in their own towns and around their own country districts. If these people use the roads in County Dublin, they leave their money there. There are special attractions in Dublin for those people, and if we had those attractions, we would be very glad to build roads to bring the people into the towns. Another matter that was put before the Minister by the Council of Municipal Councils was the matter of municipal councils being permitted to offer prizes for well-kept gardens. So far as I remember, I do not thnk the Minister held out any hope in this respect. Might I again ask the Minister to reconsider his action? In the various towns to-day, we have people living in houses with gardens, front and back, who have hitherto not had a garden at all. Urban councils are endeavouring to get these people to keep their gardens in a proper manner and to encourage them by giving them prizes. I daresay that anything from £10 to £20 would cover the amount each year. Schemes of this kind have been carried out in a few areas and with good results. I would, therefore, ask the Minister to reconsider his attitude in that connection.

Although I know that the employment schemes will be discussed on Vote 69, there is one particular aspect I want to refer to. Quite recently the Minister has sent a notice to urban councils that they are to receive a certain amount of money this year towards the relief of unemployment, but that it is necessary for them to include in the current rate a certain amount of money in order to qualify for the grant. While I agree that it is better finance that the amount of money should be raised in revenue during the current year, I submit that in a comparatively small urban area it is going to be very heavy on the ratepayers, and I am wondering what the position is going to be in some areas, in view of the fact that that notification has been received only within the past fortnight and the rates have already been struck. I do not know of any authority an urban area has to strike a supplementary rate after the ordinary rate has been struck, unless by a plebiscite of the ratepayers, or a meeting of the ratepayers, and that is a rather tall order. I think we would hear a good deal about rates at that particular meeting and I should like the Minister to give us some guidance as to what the position is in view of the fact that the rate has been struck.

There is one other small matter I want to refer to. During the period when boards of guardians and district councils were operating in the different counties, it was the custom to have tailors and shoemakers placed on the staff in the same position as officers. I do not know whether it is since the amalgamation of unions was carried out, but certainly within recent years, the Minister's Department has refused absolutely to place shoemakers, tailors or any other tradesmen on the permanent staff. I should like to know why, in view of the fact that unanimous requests have been sent from county health boards that this should be done, the Minister still persists in refusing. Surely tailors and shoemakers are entitled to as much consideration as any official, especially when the representatives of the local ratepayers are satisfied that they should be placed in such a position?

I have no other criticism to offer, but I want again to congratulate the Minister on the splendid statement he laid before the House and on the wonderful work that has been done by his Department so far as housing is concerned. Progress made certainly reflects all that we heard from the Minister before he became Minister for Local Government. We have always known him to be a great advocate of the housing of the working classes and he has taken this the first opportunity presented to him to push that work ahead.

Comment on this

I should like to add my voice to the remarks made by other Deputies with regard to the better distribution of the Road Fund through the remote districts. I have in mind some places where we have failed to get 'bus services because the roads were certified by the county surveyor as not being fit to bear 'buses, and particularly in a district where the railway has been closed down and where there has been a redistribution of road services, it is important that the roads in districts where the population is heaviest should be put into such a condition that the people there might benefit by the road services which can now be placed at their disposal.

I do not know whether the Minister has any jurisdiction in the matter, but I want to draw his attention to the building of the hospital in Galway. I have heard a good deal of criticism lately, and the most recent criticism I have heard was at a meeting of the Galway Industrial Development Association on Monday night, with regard to this project. It is proposed, I understand, that this hospital should be built of concrete and iron. In view of the fact that there is plenty of very fine stones quite convenient to the proposed site, the opinion generally in the district is that local materials ought to be used in preference to spending money on materials which must be imported. The matter may be one for the authority administering the hospital funds, but I would earnestly call the attention of the Minister to it. The difference would be very important to a variety of people in Galway area.

There is another matter, and it is one of great importance in urban areas, and I refer particularly to the Galway area, to which I wish to draw the Minister's attention. It is the very high valuation on agricultural land within the urban boundary. There has been considerable complaint in Galway area in this respect, and it is a very real grievance. In the case of farmers living on either side of the urban boundary the difference in rating is very marked, and the farmer who happens to be just inside the urban boundary is paying possibly twice what his neighbour on the other side of the urban boundary is paying. It is not, I believe, in order to suggest legislation on a Vote, and I do not know whether legislation would be necessary in this connection or not, but I ask the Minister to give the matter his attention.

Comment on this

Sub-head U provides for the payment of gratuities to certain former officers of local authorities and persons in the Civil Service of Saorstát Eireann. In that connection I want to raise the question of the moneys which are to be made payable to the ex-Secretary of the Department of Local Government and Public Health, because I consider that, in the present strained financial circumstances of this country, to charge the public purse with the maximum pension for a distinguished public officer, who is peculiarly competent to carry on the work which he did carry on so successfully, so disinterestedly and with such conspicuous devotion to duty over a long official life, is something that cannot be justified. We are now required to find money to pay the salary of a new Secretary of the Department of Local Government and Public Health. We are required to do that because Mr. McCarron has been driven out of his position for no assigned reason. You will remember that we did afford the Minister for Local Government and Public Health an opportunity of stating what were the reasons he advanced to justify this double charge on the public purse.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is aware that this matter was the subject of a motion in the Dáil. That motion was fully discussed, and there is a ruling, carried down for many years, that matters raised within a short time before the discussion of an Estimate to which they refer cannot be reopened on that Estimate. The reasons for the removal of Mr. McCarron from office cannot, therefore, be discussed on this Estimate. The amount of money being paid him by way of superannuation is the amount fixed by law and cannot be questioned. The appointment of a secretary of the Department is also a legal act, and his salary is paid under the authority of a statute. Therefore, that matter cannot be raised on this Estimate either.

Comment on this

I desire to make a submission on that ruling. A sum appears under sub-head U of this Estimate which is stated to be compensation for persons who were in the service of a local authority or in the Civil Service of Saorstát Eireann. It does not appear from the explanatory note on page 149 of the Book of Estimates whether any part of that money will be paid to Mr. McCarron.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

So far as I know, that item does not refer to superannuation at all.

Comment on this

It refers to gratuities.

Comment on this

It may be gratuities, but it does refer to moneys paid to the officers. My second submission is that the precedent which you have quoted, and which I do not for a moment challenge, does provide that the same Minister shall not be questioned twice within a short period on the same issue.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not a question of the Minister. The matter cannot be reopened, no matter what Minister is held responsible.

Comment on this

So that the Minister may, on the motion, run away out of the House and, on the first occasion on which he is bound to attend and answer, he can closure the debate and refuse to discuss the matter. That is what happens.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair has no control over the actions of Ministers.

Comment on this

The Chair has an absolute discretion in deciding whether precedents will be enforced, because the Chair has to determine whether the circumstances are identical with those which existed when the precedent was made. In my respectful submission, the circumstances are not identical.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair does not see any reason for departing from the precedent established. The matter which the Deputy is endeavouring to raise was fully discussed and was decided by the House. It cannot be reopened on this Estimate.

Comment on this

We never heard the Minister on that particular matter, of which he only has knowledge.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is not responsible for that.

Comment on this

The discretion is in your hands. I want to refer to another sub-head in connection with the distribution of free beef. I understand that the appropriation for that purpose has been very substantially reduced under sub-head V—from £40,000 to £5,000. Is that reduction being made in the cause of economy or is it, as I suspect it is, being made because there is no beef in the country? If it be true, as I suspect it is, that there is not enough fat stock in the country to fill the British quota and provide free beef for the poor, perhaps the Minister would be good enough to ask his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, to expound to us the benefits of an agricultural policy which, in five years, results in this country being without beef and without butter. I do not believe the Bashi Bazouks could have achieved that if they had taken over the government of this country. That is a most amazing commentary on the Government's ineptitude and inefficiency. The Minister must be proud of his colleague in the Executive Council——

Comment on this
Denis Allen Mr. Allen

Is the Deputy in order in discussing the Minister for Agriculture on this Vote?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not quite sure that the Deputy is discussing the Department of Agriculture. If the Deputy transgresses, I shall call him to order.

Comment on this

I can quite understand the difficulty of Deputy Allen in associating the name of the Minister for Agriculture with public health or health of any other kind—even physical health. Astonishing as it may be, his name may be associated with the public health of this country in one connection only—that he is the first man in the history of Ireland to succeed in precipitating a famine of beef.

Comment on this
Denis Allen Mr. Allen

You are not suffering from it yet.

Comment on this

To depart from the distasteful subject of the Minister for Agriculture, I should like to inquire about another strange body which has been created by this Government—the Housing Board. What has become of the Housing Board? We were told by the Minister on a previous occasion, as reported in volume 61, column 1611 of the Official Reports, that "there is a type of work which I might call a sort of propaganda work—going around and talking to local authorities and encouraging them—that the officials could not be expected to do, and that kind of work which I could not do with individual local authorities has been most successfully done by the members of the Housing Board."

I have seen very little trace of the activities of the Housing Board. I am a member of a local authority in County Roscommon and, since I became a member four years ago, I never heard the name of the Housing Board mentioned there. I have never seen any trace of the board in our work, and I see no evidence in the housing schemes of any beneficent influence by that body. The only member who ever showed any activity sought to expose what looked very like a scandal in connection with a series of houses somewhere near Castlebar which fell as soon as erected. He was promptly "sacked." From that hour forward the Housing Board sunk into silence and there has not been a word out of it ever since. I would have expected the Housing Board to be constantly visiting housing schemes, to be satisfying themselves that the houses were of the kind that ought to be erected and that these schemes provided comfortable homesteads for those people for whom they were intended. I would have expected the board to be making suggestions for newer and better types of houses.

I am glad that Deputy Tom Kelly is here. In that connection, I want to ask who fixed the standard for the accommodation available in the flat buildings that have been erected by the Dublin Corporation in Dublin? I went down recently to the Anchor Brewery site and I saw there a number of flat buildings the exteriors of which were admittedly prepossessing; the lay-out seems admirable and the whole has the appearance of an ambitious scheme. By the courtesy of some of the tenants of those flats I went in to inspect some of the flats as they are at present occupied. I was appalled to find that the tenants of these flats—who had been taken out of admittedly bad tenement houses, but out of tenement houses that at least had large, spacious rooms—had been put into flats in these pretentious buildings which consisted of three or four miserable little cubby-holes. They were dark, they were very small, and I am sorry to say that, in my judgment, they bore all the evidences of getting into a rapid decline to a far worse slum than the slum out of which these tenants had been taken. Those of us, and there are some of us in this House who were born in the slums— I was brought up in the slums in North Great George's Street—at least know that those large houses, unsuitable as they unquestionably are for the families living in them in the individual rooms, have large rooms with plenty of window space and air. On the other hand, these little flats are made up of deplorably small rooms; they are very dark, and the general finish of the interior of the rooms seems to me to leave a great deal to be desired.

Now that you are going to move people who, through no fault of their own, have lived in very squalid surroundings into better houses, you ought to design these in such a way as to make it easy for the tenants to keep their rooms clean.

You ought not to build these flats that allow the rooms to be dark, you ought at least to have one spacious room and you ought to see that the walls of the rooms have a reasonable kind of surface that can be kept clean by the housewife of the family. Go into one of the kitchens of these flats and you will find that the range occupies half the room. Imagine an unfortunate woman with three or four little children moving about a kitchen trying to cook in the atmosphere that will arise in a very small space with a range occupying so much of that room. It is true that there is a fine asphalt space in front of these buildings where the children can play in fine weather. That is much better than having them playing in the street. I think, however, that the Housing Board is wrong or remiss in permitting the class of accommodation provided in the Anchor Brewery site. They should insist that families going into these flats would have at least one large room where the family can live, where there will be plenty of air and proper ventilation. I have no hesitation in saying that the interior of these flats in the Anchor Brewery site does not provide this accommodation. I do not know whether the Minister has been through these houses or whether he thinks the accommodation is adequate. I saw one flat on the ground floor and I saw one flat on the first floor. I was favourably impressed with neither. The flat on the ground floor struck me particularly with its darkness and its gloomy appearance. The flat on the second floor struck me particularly with the ridiculous inadequacy of the size of the rooms.

We have got to face this problem. There are two schools of thought. One school is that you ought to have a multiplicity of rooms. The other school of thought is that you ought to have one decent room in which the family can live and the two or three bedrooms in which the different sexes may be segregated at night. I have not the slightest hesitation in saying that with whatever sacrifice of luxury, the first essential to reasonable comfort for a married man with his wife and family is a decent living-room. I would like housing accommodation provided for the working people of this country broadly to be designed on the well-established design of the Irish country house where the kitchen is a large, airy, comfortable room, where the people cook, eat and live. It is kept warm by the kitchen fire. It is large enough not to become too warm in the summer nor oppressively cold at any time. It is a room into which visitors can be welcomed. It is a room which can be used for one occasion or another; it is the whole centre of these people's lives. It is a room of such a character that the woman of the house can take a pride in it and spend her time beautifying it with the resources at her disposal. I say that no one can beautify the rooms of the flats in the Anchor Brewery site. I say it is a bad mistake to treat the poor of this city as if they were some kind of pathological specimens and not human beings. The poor of this city are just as able as we are to adapt themselves to the circumstances in which they find themselves, and they will look to the morals and proprieties of family life in their own way where they have got anything like reasonable accommodation. I do not think it would be excessive to provide one decent room and three bedrooms. If that is impossible then let there be one decent room and two bedrooms, and let each family make its own arrangements for the propriety and the segregations that are to be made in any properly conducted Christian family.

While the Minister for Local Government and Public Health prides himself that he has achieved prodigies in the field of housing, I charge him again that he has allowed a situation to develop in which he has admittedly attacked the easy half of the housing problem, but he is not doing half enough to attack the difficult end. There is no difficulty whatsoever in providing for rural housing at present. It is merely a question of shovelling out the money. The land is there, the materials are there, and there is no problem except that of finance. There is little trouble beyond making the county surveyors work a little harder than before in order to build all the houses you want in rural Ireland. But when you come to the question of the relief of slum congestions in the cities, then you are up against a real problem. That is the housing problem. Only a fool will rush in where wise men fear to tread. I know enough about the housing problem in the City of Dublin to realise the complexities of that problem. Deputy Tom Kelly, who knows a great deal about housing in the city, has said that the great obstacle confronting him is the want of money. He said that if he could get the money, the problem of re-housing the poor of this city could be dealt with very quickly. I think I am correctly quoting him. Why is not the Minister giving the co-operation that he ought to give in that regard? Does the Minister think that the progress being made in re-housing the poor of this city is satisfactory? If he does not, what does he think is lacking to make that progress satisfactory? Does he think he is doing his job if he sits calmly by and contents himself with clapping his hands and saying the progress is not satisfactory? Is it not his business to see that it is satisfactory?

I remember being sharply upbraided for saying on one occasion that I did not believe the tenement population of this city had been substantially reduced in the last five years. I now repeat that. I believe there are just as many people living in accommodation in this city that ought to be condemned, living in accommodation which is not fit, in my opinion, to accommodate animals, much less human beings, as there were five years ago. I say that that state of affairs gravely reflects on the Minister. I fully recognise that revolutionary steps might be necessary in order to abate this evil. It is his job to take them. It has been clearly indicated to him ever since he took office that any steps that he could satisfy this House were necessary to make an end of the slums would be approved by all Parties. Why have not those steps been taken?

I understand he has all the relevant facts. He has Deputy Tom Kelly as chairman of the Housing Board of this city, and he cannot pretend he is not getting all the co-operation he wants. Why is he failing in that particular part of his job? It is the most important element in the housing problem of this country at the present time. So far, his record in regard to it reflects little credit upon him, and it is time now, as he lays down the reins of office and goes into the wilderness of a general election, to let us know how it is that during his five years he has been quite unable to find any effective instrument for making an end of the slums of this city.

I should like to ask the Minister a categorical question about local loans. I was recently told by a man who knows conditions in Northern Ireland that local loans are available there for 3½ per cent. Can that be true and, if it is, how comes it that local loans here cost nearly 2 per cent more? Perhaps the Minister would look into that question and let me have an answer. Now we come to the National Health Insurance. I think that comes under this Vote.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I dare say the position is that all the Minister's Votes will be discussed together?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

In that event the Deputy will have an opportunity of raising the matter on another Vote.

Comment on this

Under sub-head Q the Minister provides a grant for the training of Gaeltacht girls as nurses. I would like to know what success attends that scheme. Year after year on the Committee of Public Accounts we found that the money which was taken under this Vote for that purpose was never spent, and it seemed to me, from my experience of that committee, that the matter was not being enthusiastically pursued. Some suggestion was made that suitable girls could not be got. I cannot believe that. It may astonish Deputy Mrs. Concannon to know that in practically no financial year was the money spent. It was surrendered at the end of the year, and we were told it was impossible to get anything done.

I think it is very desirable that all public officials, whether they be district nurses or maternity nurses, or civic guards or rate collectors, or anybody else of the kind operating in the Fíor-Ghaeltacht, should be able to use the Irish language, exclusively if needs be. Certainly there are not at present sufficient district and maternity nurses available to provide attention in the Gaeltacht and be able to speak nothing but Irish if the situation should arise. At the same time there are immense numbers of girls fleeing from these areas to England as emigrants, as untrained domestic servants, and it occurs to me they might be much better employed if they were trained as nurses and sent to their own districts to look after their own people. In those circumstances I ask the Minister to extend that system.

I think the Minister at present has power to help in the financing of district nursing. I would ask him to take counsel with the local authorities and, if needs be, with the Department of Finance, with a view to devising a scheme whereby whatever assistance he at present gives for district nurses might be greatly extended. In my experience in rural Ireland the dispensary doctor finds his work immensely hampered by his inability to get proper nursing care for patients whom he is attending in country houses. I know amongst my own neighbours that the sufferings of illness are immensely aggravated by the inability of invalids' relatives to look after them properly. It is not for the want of the will; it is for the want of knowledge and means that their relatives cannot look after them as they ought to be looked after.

I would like to see attached to every dispensary doctor in this country a district nurse, so that in any case where you had a patient unable to move in bed, or who required special dressings or in the very many circumstances which we all know where it is obvious simple country people are quite unable to give the proper attention necessary if the patient is to be spared great suffering, the doctor would be able to pass the name of that patient to a district nurse and require her to call on the patient once or, if needs be, twice a day. I think in that way we could kill two birds with the one stone. First of all, we could provide very useful employment for an immense number of Irish country girls and, in the second place, we could remove from the everyday life of the people living in rural Ireland a very constant anxiety and distress.

Nobody understands the misery that can be carried into an Irish home by sickness of the kind to which I refer unless and until he has come in touch with it. If you have a sick person lying, perhaps, in the kitchen with none of the modern conveniences that are available in a house in Dublin or in a house in any town, and you have nobody skilled in moving them in the bed or doing the various little offices that the patient requires, the amount of added anxiety and misery that can be caused to the relatives is immense. However one might attempt to describe intimate personal details of these people's domestic circles, I do not think any useful purpose would be served by so doing, because any Deputy coming from the country understands the matter just as clearly as I do.

I desire to emphasise that this is a reform that is long overdue. It would confer immense benefits on the people at large and would provide very desirable employment for numbers of girls at present fleeing the country to a very undesirable type of employment in Great Britain. It would also—and mind you this is important—provide very suitable occupation for nurses who feel themselves unequal to continuing as hospital nurses in the ordinary sense of the word, nurses who are no longer equal to night duty and the rigours of a full hospital day. Many such women find it very difficult to secure employment that they are able for and, if this system of district nursing was very much extended, abundant opportunities might be provided for them. Out of that eventually I would like to see a system grow whereunder the State and the hospitals would combine to make the nursing profession a pensionable profession. At present, the fate of a nurse, who has grown old in spinsterhood at her profession, may be very distressing indeed.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Would not that require legislation?

Comment on this

I do not know that it would, Sir. Would it? Latitude certainly has been allowed to-day to give the benefit of the doubt to Deputies where there is any doubt.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Chair is not informed whether it would require legislation or not, the Chair cannot give the benefit.

Comment on this

Well, I see that there are grants-in-aid for hospitals and grants-in-aid of the local authorities for child welfare, or the care of mothers and the medical treatment of school children.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have said that, in the absence of information, I cannot say.

Comment on this

Well, I have no doubt that it would come under one of those various headings. I am not now rebuking the Minister or suggesting that he has been remiss in not putting up a pension scheme for nurses. I quite see that such schemes would take time to work them out and that it would not be easy to envisage them in a permanent form, but I am throwing the suggestion out that eventually a wider scheme could be worked out between the hospitals and the Minister whereunder the nursing profession might be made a pensionable one. I do not want to exhaust language or to paint depressing pictures, but we do know that there are circumstances in which nurses find themselves at the end of their days poorly provided for.

The very essence of successful nursing is that it should be looked upon as a vocation rather than as a moneymaking occupation. It is a very great mistake for the public to trade on people who are prepared to deal with them in that spirit and, if the nursing profession is what it is in Ireland at the present time, we should be solicitous to keep it so rather than to put such difficulties in its way under its present form as would make it likely that it might be converted into something else. Deputies in this House, particularly those who have been abroad, know that Irish nursing stands higher, probably, than any nursing in the world. You will find that, in the most expensive and luxurious nursing homes in London, there is a very marked preference for Irish-trained nurses. Anyone who has lived in America will be struck by the comparison between the standard of nursing in that country and the standard of nursing here. I attribute that largely to the fact that nurses in this country look upon their occupation as a vocation as much as a profession, and I think we ought to do all that is reasonable to make it possible for them to continue in that spirit.

Now, nursing reminds me of a problem which has come under my attention in connection with the county homes. Some of our county homes provide very inadequate accommodation, and it is not easy to enforce the segregation that one would wish for. There is one urgent problem, however, that I think requires immediate attention. We often find in the county home children of tender years. A little boy of, perhaps, ten years of age is brought in there suffering, perhaps, from a broken arm or, more frequently, from chronic heart trouble, or something of that kind which would not ordinarily bring him to the surgical hospital. He is probably going to be there for quite a while, and that little boy, not infrequently, is put into the men's ward. We all know what the county home is. So far as the Roscommon County Home is concerned, it is an advertisement for public administration and for the nuns who superintend it. It is, in my judgment, one of the best kept county homes in Ireland. Everything that the resources will permit is being done for the patients there. It has always struck me, however, as improper that small children should be put in the same ward with adults, particularly when you are not in a position to distinguish at all between the class of adults who go in there. When I speak of the class of adults, I do not desire to differentiate between rich and poor; but we all know that the county homes receive, and are bound to receive, numbers of poor old persons who are of defective intellect and who are breaking up from one reason or another. To put small children, night and day, into close association with these unhappy wrecks of humanity is, I think, very wrong. Therefore, I make a concrete suggestion to the Minister. I would ask him to make a recommendation to the local authorities that, where they have not accommodation for children's wards, children going either into the surgical hospital or the county home must be removed at the earliest possible moment to a children's hospital.

Now, that is not an unduly extravagant or unreasonable proposal. Either there should be a children's ward established, or else the children should be removed to a children's hospital at the earliest possible moment. Unless that is done, in my opinion, very undesirable results may accrue. Now, when we come to consider removing children to children's hospitals, I want to ask the Minister if, in his judgment, there is sufficient accommodation in this country at present for the orthopædic treatment of children. I do not suppose there is any more ghastly tragedy than the appearance of a youth or of a young man or young woman who has grown up deformed or crippled for want of proper orthopædic treatment in youth. Now, no kind of surgery has made more progress in the last 20 years than orthopædic surgery. I doubt if I would overstate my case if I say that seven cripples out of ten could be restored to the full use of their limbs if adequate orthopædic treatment were available for them in infancy or early youth. At present I do not think adequate treatment of that kind is available, because the accommodation is not there, and we have got to remember in connection with this problem that adequate orthopædic treatment of young children takes from six months to two and three years in each case. That is going to be expensive, but if any of us had a child who had the alternative of being strong and well and able to earn its living, or going through life a cripple, I venture to say that we would spend all we had to get it proper health and fitness to get through life. I do not believe a single Deputy in this House would desire to economise at the expense of the children of our neighbours who are unable to afford the protracted treatment which their children may stand in need of. I say, advisedly, that I do not believe a single Deputy in the House would make any difficulties about any expenditure they were satisfied was necessary. In that connection, you have got to remember that there are millions of money in the hands of the Hospitals Trust. I would be quite prepared to support voting money from this House if it were necessary, but I think the Minister should first satisfy himself that the funds of the Hospitals Trust will be used to supply this need adequately, and that he will not dissipate that money building hospitals where they are not wanted, while so glaring and urgent a necessity continues in the State.

Mind you, I am getting very much alarmed at the way in which the Hospitals Trust money is being spent. I understand that there are a number of hospitals in this city who want to get a straight answer from that body as to what their intentions are with regard to amalgamation. I understand that Sir Patrick Dun's, the City of Dublin, and Mercer's Hospitals—these three, I believe—want to amalgamate if the Hospitals Trust approve. Pending the determination of that question, they are afraid to spend money on improving their present premises or in getting the equipment they should have. They are quite prepared, if the Hospitals Trust definitely turn down their proposals, to try to equip their several hospitals as best they can. What they are not prepared to do is to spend money that should be spent now if they were not going to amalgamate, if the improvements are going to be scrapped in six months' time and one central hospital established instead of the three. I think it reflects very gravely on the Hospitals Trust that they have not been able to make up their minds on this question.

There is another matter that alarms me. Every local authority is hospital-building, and nobody seems to have any general conception of what the policy ultimately is going to be. We are going to spend £90,000 on the building of a hospital in Roscommon. We are going to spend another five-figure sum—I forget the exact amount —on the building of a hospital in Boyle. We are going, therefore, to have two large hospitals in County Roscommon. People seem to forget that when you have built these hospitals, it is only then the expense begins. You have got to equip them before they are going to be in a position to do the work which, in my opinion, should be done by central hospitals. If they are going to do all that work you will have to pay very large salaries indeed to surgeons who are competent to do the work, if you are to induce them to live in rural parts. In addition, you will have to purchase very expensive equipment if they are to be put in a position to afford people the treatment that is at present given in Dublin hospitals. Thirdly, you will have to have immense staffs because the day is long gone when you could get a country surgeon who was prepared to act as pathologist, bacteriologist and radiologist—to discharge the functions, in fact, of the seven or eight specialists to whom a patient might have recourse in Dublin or Cork.

What we shall do with this immense hospital in Roscommon and another in Boyle, I cannot imagine. I seriously believe that these hospitals will be the death of a great many people because people who want highly skilled attention will be detained down the country in order to justify the maintenance of these immense hospitals and they will not be able to get the kind of treatment they should have or the rapid diagnosis they should have. I have not heard this question adequately discussed or properly looked into by anybody. I should be glad if the Minister would give us the benefit of his cogitations on these questions. I confess myself that I am extremely uneasy for two reasons: firstly, that if the cost of maintaining these hospitals is to be prohibitive, I am terrified that the local authority, faced with these heavy charges, will start economising at the expense of the sick poor. Secondly, I cannot see how you can get the personnel adequate to man the hospitals and with the requisite skill to deal with serious cases. I am afraid that patients will die for want of the treatment they would have got in Dublin if these local hospitals were not erected. Do not imagine that I am not in favour of improving the existing facilities, but the scheme which I should have imagined as the proper one was that you would have cottage hospitals in various parts of rural Ireland where emergency cases could be dealt with, where a case of acute appendicitis or an acute condition would be dealt with, when there was no time to get the patient to Dublin, or where some condition that did not require Dublin attention, like a fractured arm, might be attended to. For the grave cases I had hoped that the cottage hospital would merely act as a clearing house where the county surgeon would say to a patient: "You must go to Dublin when I have got you into trim to face the journey." I should like to know what is the purpose for which these immense hospitals are being built and what is the intention in regard to them. A facetious friend suggests that one of their principal functions will be to be opened by the Minister. I do not suggest for a moment that he has favoured this extensive expenditure for the purpose of adding to his collection of keys.

I see a sub-head here for expenses in connection with school meals. I wish to see that scheme very widely extended. Instead of jacking up the price of milk by a halfpenny a pint or a quart in the City of Dublin, because there was a surplus of milk, so-called, coming in here, I should have liked the Minister to use his powers to absorb that surplus of milk by providing it for little children in this country who have not got enough milk at present. There is a scheme of this kind, a free meals scheme, functioning at present in Achill and the papers are filled every week with long descriptions of strikes, demonstrations and counter-demonstrations. I want to ask the Minister what is at the back of that business in Achill. Is that a bona fide dispute between the people and the teachers, arising out of a misunderstanding, or is it a carefully fomented agitation by certain individuals in Achill who want to give this country a demonstration of the benefits that could be conferred on the people by establishing Soviets in certain parts of the country? If there is an ulterior motive being served by some gentlemen in Achill, who want to kick up a row there for the purpose of causing general discontent and upheaval, it is the Minister's duty to expose it now. If the teachers are at fault, let the Minister apportion the blame but the House and the public are entitled to know the truth about that business.

If my information is correct, the teachers have been prepared to do all that is reasonable; but one or two warriors in Achill have been deliberately stirring up the people, to create a riot so that if their demands are in any sense met they can say to these people: "You would get nothing if you had not kicked up a row. If you had not frightened the Government you would have got nothing." If the people are right, let their rights be acknowledged before there is an outbreak. If the people are wrong, let the rights of the teachers be vindicated. Let substantial justice be done between both parties and then let the Government stand firm. If they do not, this business will develop until you have a proper riot, and it will then take a great deal more trouble than is at present necessary to make an end of the whole business.

I think I have covered all the points to which I desire to refer under this Vote, in view of the fact that we must take another occasion to refer to national health insurance. I want to emphasise before sitting down that, in my judgment, the most vital question is that of the tenement houses in the city and their abolition. Other Deputies and I have said on previous occasions that any co-operation the Minister stands in need of would be forthcoming if he would only tell us what he wanted. I think he should take this occasion to tell us perfectly frankly what is necessary, no matter how great it may be, to make an end once and for all of the slums of this city. I am not suggesting that any reasonable body of men could expect him to expound a scheme for the abolition of slums overnight. They could not; but if he would say: "By embarking on this course, by spending this amount of money in five years, we could abolish the slums in the following areas and the following cities," I am perfectly certain he would carry conviction to this House of his ability to achieve that. I am perfectly certain that any money, any power, any discretion that he chose to ask of us would be gladly forthcoming. He is peculiarly free to speak now. If he speaks now, it is his last speech as Minister for Local Government before the general election. Deputy Tom Kelly seems to see coming events casting their shadows before. It would, at this stage, be indelicate for me to suggest that the Minister had come to the end of his tether. I shall postpone that line of country for the hustings, where I intend to use it extensively. Here the Minister goes on for ever—in himself or in his successors. He is now free to outline a comprehensive scheme for dealing with this matter. If he fails, he has, in my opinion, failed in the most important work which the duties of his office impose upon him.

Comment on this

I am afraid Deputy Dillon, like others, has got a rather severe attack of what we in Cork call "Dublinitis." Deputy Dillon has told us about the dark and gloomy houses that are being built in Dublin. I suggest that it is Deputy Dillon's mind which is dark and gloomy. The Deputy cannot spend four or five years moaning and groaning from morning till night, day in and day out, without its having some effect on his nature and his mind, and having a dark and gloomy effect from his point of view on anything that was built or carried out under the schemes of the present Government. He also told us that we should not bother with rural houses; there was no need for us, he said. I remember he also told us that there was no trouble at all about rural houses. If not, why were they not built? Down the country, ever since 1913, we had lands taken over for housing schemes; we had lands taken over for the building of labourers' cottages, and from 1913 until 1933 those acres of land were lying there without any houses being built on them.

Comment on this

They were not built because you destroyed the rights of property.

Comment on this

They had no notion of building anything.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

We built houses and you destroyed houses. That is all.

Comment on this

I submit that that position has been completely changed; the labourers who were waiting for their houses from 1913 to 1933 have now got them.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

What is the amount of the destruction which you have done in this country?

Comment on this

I submit that the Minister, in extending his plans a little beyond the purlieus of Dublin City, has done the country a great service; in seeing that the agricultural labourers of this country got at least a decent house to live in, he has done an untold service to the people of this country, whatever Deputy Dillon's viewpoint on that may be. I did not expect any praise from Deputy Dillon for the work of the Minister for Local Government. I do not think there is any other Deputy there on those benches opposite who would get up and find fault with the work which the Minister for Local Government has done, but of course if it was St. Peter who was sitting here Deputy Dillon should find fault with him. Deputy Dillon was wondering about the Housing Board. I wonder how many meetings of the famous Board of Health of County Roscommon did Deputy Dillon attend?

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I want to register a protest at this stage. The Department of Local Government has done tremendous work in this country, in spite of the fact that Deputy Corry was in the Opposition camp.

Comment on this

I wonder how many meetings of the Roscommon Board of Health did Deputy Dillon attend and how many of those meetings did he miss? If Deputy Dillon had been here when Deputy Corish was speaking he would have got some small idea of the work that the Housing Department has done. I wish to pay a personal tribute to them for the manner in which they have helped us out in Cork County by their advice and assistance. I also wish to congratulate the Minister on another phase in the housing question which has supplied a long-felt want, namely, the grant to the small farmers for the reconstruction of their houses.

These farmhouses throughout the country were in many cases in a very dilapidated condition. Now that the first need has been met, I wonder whether we could induce the Minister to extend his work in that direction by giving the reconstruction grant on an increased valuation. Up to the present the grant has been on a valuation of £25. Unfortunately, in my constituency, a valuation of £25 in many cases covers only from 11 to 15 statute acres of land.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Deputy should take another opportunity of bringing up that matter. His proposal would involve legislation.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will keep the matter in mind. I also wish to call his attention to the holding up of the building of 57 houses at Dublin Hill and Ballyvolane, Cork, by the Cork Corporation, failing the supply of water and sewerage facilities. The Minister, as far as I am aware, has got several requests from the people living in those houses, and the condition of affairs there is such that the county medical officer of health stated definitely that he would not let his dog live in them. I consider that that state of affairs has lasted too long. It was enough for those unfortunate people to have to live under those conditions when the other gentlemen, who did not give a hand about them, were in office, but now that we have a Government which is providing for the needs of the ordinary people of this country, I think that the condition of the families living in those 57 houses should not be allowed to continue any longer. Whatever steps are necessary on the part of the Minister to see that this scheme is got under way immediately should be carried out. I should also like to call his attention to the position in regard to the Blarney sewerage scheme. I understand that the Local Government inspector reported on that scheme some time ago. There are sinister rumours around the district that this scheme is being held up owing to the influence of a local landlord.

Comment on this

It is a wonder it is not the Freemasons. It used to be, you know.

Comment on this

I go to see my constituents sometimes. Deputy Dillon is only going back to his constituency in a few months time to get kicked out of it. The Deputy has made his last speech in the Dáil on this Estimate, and much as we shall miss him after the election, we will have to try and do without him. I urge on the Minister to give special attention to the Blarney sewerage scheme, and to see that steps are immediately taken to carry out whatever instructions the inspectors of his Department have given in connection with it.

I also want to call his attention to the delay that has arisen in going ahead with a cottage purchase scheme. Proposals have been brought in over a long period, and we would like now to see some results. After all, those people are just as much entitled as the farmers to become the owners of their houses and of their acre plots. We have now between 500 and 700 cottagers living happily in their own homes and paying their few shillings a week as rent. What a contrast that is to the position when they had to pay 4/- and 6/- a week to rack-renting landlords for tumbled-down stables and wrecks! I wonder whether Deputy Dillon in his travels through the country ever worried himself to look into those hovels and see the conditions under which those unfortunate people were compelled to live previously, and whether the improvement in housing conditions that has taken place under this Government for that class of people will not coax some joy or some measure of praise out of his dark and gloomy nature. Apparently not. The work done by the Minister for the housing of the poor is worthy of all praise, as well as the work which he has done in that respect for the small working farmers of the country. When we sat on the opposite side of the House, I made many an appeal, as the official records of the House will show, to the then Minister for Local Government to give some small grant towards the reconstruction of farmers' dwellings. But the then Minister for Local Government, although I renewed my appeal year after year, could not see his way to look beyond the borough boundaries of the City of Dublin. He did nothing to relieve the condition of those unfortunate men in the country who have to work in the open, many a day getting drenched with the rain and then having to return to a cheerless fireside.

The ordinary working people of this country owe a debt of gratitude to the present Minister for Local Government that will never be forgotten. All I say is, "God speed the good work!" I hope the Minister's activities in that direction will continue until we have all our people, throughout the length and breadth of the land, enabled to get decent houses to live in. I would appeal to the Minister, no matter what pressure may be brought to bear on him to do so, not to slacken his activities in that respect. At present a sum of over £250,000 is being spent in the County Cork on a labourers' cottage scheme alone. Another £500,000 has been voted by the Blueshirt County Council of Cork towards those housing schemes. We have also gone into the condition of affairs in the local villages in the county, as a result of which over 200 village schemes relating to housing have been passed through. So far as the housing needs of the rural population are concerned, I think that so far as our county is concerned these will be completed within the next two years. As I stated before, there were plots of land acquired and paid for by the then local authorities in the year 1913. The cottages that were to be built on those plots at that time were not built. Many of the applicants were, I am sure, young married men, but we have now got a Minister who has provided cottages for the children of the original applicants for the cottages on those plots. The young men of 21 and 22 years of age who would have been reared in those houses, if we had a proper Government here at the time, have those cottages to go into to-day. We have reason to thank God for that change, and for having a Minister for Local Government who has put an end to that scandal.

On behalf of the people of my constituency, I wish to thank the Minister sincerely for his work in that respect. I do not think there is any Department of State that merits the thanks of the ordinary people of this country as much as the Department of Local Government. I do not wish to make any allusion to Deputy Dillon's opening remarks beyond saying this: that if there is any individual who stands in the way of the proper working of any Department of this State, he must go.

Comment on this

Does the Minister subscribe to that observation? That is the kind of dirty slander that is being circulated at the present time, and the Minister is responsible for it.

Comment on this

I desire, at the outset, to congratulate the Minister very heartily on his references to nurses in this country. I endorse everything that he has said, and if he can see his way to introduce a measure to provide pensions for nurses in this country, I feel certain that it will receive the approval and sympathy of every member of the Dáil. A good deal has been said on this Estimate about housing conditions in the country. Not long since I had to speak here on the housing conditions in my constituency, which I regret are not what they should be. I am glad the Minister himself is here to-night to hear what I have to say on this, because I know that he must be just as much concerned about those housing conditions as I am myself. To remind the Minister of what is taking place, I now propose to read a letter that I wrote to him on the 4th February of this year.

"Dear Mr. O'Kelly—Last night, on the motion No. 13 on the Order Paper, I referred to the condition of the Wolfe Tone houses in Bray which I had myself seen last Tuesday evening. I was horrified at the condition of some of the houses, and to my mind it is imperative that all houses that require repair should be attended to immediately. The matter is most urgent, and I would respectfully suggest that an inspector from your Department be sent down at once to investigate the conditions that people are living in, due to the cause that many of these houses are not weatherproof. I feel sure if you had seen what I saw on Tuesday evening, you would be equally horrified and perturbed. The inclement weather prevailing at the present time makes the whole matter still more serious."

To that letter I received the following reply on February 7th this year:

"The Minister for Local Government and Public Health desires me to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 4th instant and to state that over a year ago he drew the attention of the Bray Urban District Council to certain defects in the houses at Wolfe Tone Square and pointed out the steps which the technical advisers of the Department considered necessary to remedy these defects.

"On that occasion the inspection was made by a senior engineering inspector of the Department and a copy of his report was sent to the council for their guidance on the 29th February, 1936.

"Nothing further was heard of the matter until the 27th January, 1937, when the Town Clerk of Bray sent a telephone request that an inspector should visit Bray for the purpose of inspecting the houses in question in respect of which the tenants were complaining. In reply to that request a letter was sent, copy of which I attach for your information and the Minister feels that there is no further action open to him. It is clearly a matter for the council to take steps to have the defects remedied."

The letter referred to in that communication is addressed to the Town Clerk, Bray, dated 28th January, 1937, and is as follows:

"With reference to your request over the telephone on the 27th instant for the attendance of an inspector of this Department for the purpose of inspecting certain houses at Oldcourt, recently provided by the Bray Urban District Council, in respect of which complaints have been made and of attending a meeting of a committee of the council in regard thereto, I am directed by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health to state that owing to pressure of other duties and prior engagements it is not possible to send the inspector. In this connection, however, I am to state that this matter was fully considered about twelve months ago in conjunction with the Department's and council's technical advisers, and on the 29th February last a detailed report (copy of which is enclosed) was sent to the council setting out the steps which were considered necessary to deal with the defects found to exist. The senior inspector who examined the position at that time has advised that even if he inspected the houses now he could add nothing to the recommendations made in the report already furnished to the council. The council would do well to act on the advice of their surveyor, upon whom ultimately rests the responsibility of indicating the appropriate steps to be taken."

I regret to have to take up the time of the House in reading these letters, but I want to be quite fair to the Department of Local Government and to be quite clear in showing to the public what the action so far has been of the Department of Local Government. On receipt of that correspondence I felt the only thing I could do was to bring the whole matter before the Bray Urban Council. I therefore wrote on the 18th February to the Chairman of the Bray Urban District Council and I also sent him a copy of that letter. My letter was as follows:—

"For your information I enclose you copy of correspondence which I have had with the Minister for Local Government and Public Health regarding the Wolfe Tone houses in Bray. You will note from his letter to me, dated the 7th instant, that he holds that it is clearly a matter for the Bray Urban Council to take steps to have the defects in these houses remedied as recommended by the technical advisers of the Department of Local Government in their report of the 29th February, 1936.

"I note in the letter to your council from the Minister, dated 28th January, 1937, he stated that it was not possible to send an inspector owing to the pressure of other duties and prior engagements, and that the inspector who examined the position over a year ago would be able to add nothing to the recommendations made in the report already furnished to your council.

"My main concern in the whole matter, and which I feel also is the chief concern of the Bray Urban Council, is to find out who is responsible for the present state of affairs. Everyone must be in agreement that the present position cannot be allowed to remain as it is and that the Wolfe Tone Square houses should be made weatherproof and all damage done repaired. These houses were built to improve the housing conditions of people in the Bray area at considerable expense to the ratepayers of Bray, and it appears to me lamentable that the conditions as at present prevailing should ever have been allowed to occur, as it is imposing cruel hardships on the people who are living in some of these houses, and a heavy liability on the ratepayers at Bray who already were carrying a heavy burden.

"I feel sure that you will agree with all I have written, and my one interest in the whole matter is to see justice done to the people occupying these houses and to the ratepayers who subscribed through their increased rates towards the building of these houses.

"It is evident that the responsibility must lie somewhere. Evidently the Minister for Local Government and Public Health considers his Department is not responsible, as in his letter to me of the 7th instant he states that ‘the Minister feels there is no further action open to him.' But unless I am mistaken I feel that his Department must have given sanction to the original plans and specifications before any work was allowed to start, and also that these houses must have been finally passed by his Department. However, this is a matter that you will know all about.

"Finally I would like to add that anything that I can do in the matter I am only too willing to do. All I want to see is justice done to the people living in the Wolfe Tone Square houses and justice done to the ratepayers of Bray."

Regarding this whole question I tried to make as many inquiries as I possibly could, and discovered that on 5th September, 1936, a letter was sent to the Town Clerk of Bray by the Bray Ratepayers' Association. In this letter certain questions were asked, and in the margin replies were made by the Town Clerk.

I move to report progress.

Comment on this