We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 52—Agriculture.

Contributions 1–227 of 434. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

James Ryan Minister for Agriculture (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

I move:

Go ndeontar suim ná raghaidh thar £424,900 chun slánuithe na suime is gá chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1938, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Oifig an Aire Talmhaíochta agus seirbhísí áirithe atá fé riaradh na hOifige sin, maraon le hIldeontaisí-i-gCabhair.

That a sum not exceeding £424,900 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1938, for the salaries and expenses of the Office of the Minister for Agriculture and of certain services administered by that Office, including sundry grants-in-aid.

The Estimate provides for a net increase in payments of £157,209, as compared with the year 1936-37. There is an increase under Appropriations-in-Aid of £185,469, as compared with 1936-37, making a net decrease in this year's Estimate as compared with that of the previous year of £28,260. There are certain increases under some sub-heads on which I would like to say a few words. Under sub-head F (1), Agricultural Schools and Farms, there is an increase of £1,178. This increase is mostly due to normal increments of salaries. That refers to the staffing of the schools under the Department. Under sub-head F (3), Veterinary College, there is an increase of £3,215. Here again there was reorganisation of the veterinary staff last October. The full details of the salaries paid in the last financial year and the salaries that are due to be paid in this financial year will be found in the Estimates. The college is very much better staffed now. There is also an increase in sub-head G (1), Improvement of Milk Production, of £1,536. The increase is due to an increased number of cows, the property of members of the Cow Testing Associations. There is a slight increase in the number of cows coming under the tests of these associations. The big increase was from April and September in 1933, to April and September in 1936. We found that there was an increase from April, 1933, to April, 1936, of over 3,000 cows, and from September, 1933, to September, 1936, of something like 1,000 cows. Under sub-head G (2), Improvement of Live Stock, there is an increase of £39,005. That increased Estimate is to provide for putting into operation certain recommendations of the Commission of Inquiry into the Horse Breeding Industry. I shall deal with that matter more fully at a later stage.

Under sub-head H, Grants to County Committees of Agriculture, there is an increase of £7,419. The normal grant which is payable to committees of agriculture is the equivalent of the agricultural rate raised on the rateable valuation of all the counties in the Saorstát, exclusive of urban districts. The minimum rate the county committees strike is 2d. in the £1. If all committees were to remain on the minimum, the amount which the Department would be called upon to contribute would be £72,918. But some committees have signified their intention of striking a higher rate than the minimum. It is estimated that the normal grants this year will be £84,855. In the 1936-1937 Estimates there was a provision in the sub-head for a special grant to meet the expenses incurred by county committees in connection with the distribution of cattle export licences. The corresponding provision in this Estimate has been transferred to a new sub-head OO (11), and under that sub-head OO (11) there is also included the salaries and expenses of the Department's temporary supervisors and assistant supervisors who are employed on this work.

The special grant to provide lime for agricultural purposes has been reduced from £9,500 to £8,000. That has been reduced from the experience of the administration of the scheme for three years. In the first year, 1934-35, the amount actually spent was £7,229; the following year it was £7,709, and last year it was £8,016. Sub-head K (4) is a new sub-head and it provides £2,520 for the development of the manufacture of milk powder in the Saorstát. This is for the purpose of providing a subsidy to a creamery society in respect of milk powder manufactured by them. This is one of the articles of dairy products that remains on the import list. Considerable difficulty is presented in dealing with the building up of the native industry. The troubles are more psychological than economic. I would not like to take the responsibility of compelling mothers to use an Irish product in this case for their children because they may possibly afterwards say that if they had been permitted to import the old food, whatever it may have been, their child's life would have been saved. Instead, therefore, of taking drastic measures, such as excluding foods which are coming in, in favour of what we expect to be a superior food produced at home, we think the better method is to subsidise the home-produced food and enable the manufacturer to put it on the market at a cheaper rate and in that way to get a considerable share of the market in the course of a few years.

Sub-head M (4) deals with loans and grants for agricultural purposes. There is an increase of £4,000. In one instance there has been an increase of £750 in respect of loans for the purchase of stallions. This will be necessary as a result of the recommendations made by the Commission on the Horse Breeding Industry. A sum of £2,000 is provided for loans for the equipment and repair of existing flax scutch mills. A number of these mills had fallen into disrepair and, as there was some revival of flax-growing, difficulties arose in some districts with regard to mills. This provision is put in here so as to enable the Department to give loans at the rate of five per cent. per annum for the repair and equipment of these mills.

There is an increase of £1,000 in respect of loans and grants for the erection, equipment and repair of corn mills. This scheme has been revised over the last few years. The owner of a small mill willing to grind wheat or oats for farmers for their own use —that is, on commission—could get a loan either for the repair of that mill or, alternatively, to build a new mill, limited of course to a certain maximum sum. Our scheme now is that where the needs of farmers can be met by minor repairs to existing buildings and the installation of a small type of grinding machine and perhaps a power plant, estimated to cost not more than £150, a free grant not exceeding one-third of the cost will be given and a loan will be advanced to cover the remainder. The loan will be repayable over a period of ten years at 5 per cent. In the case of existing mills a free grant not to exceed one-half of the cost of repairs and equipment will be given, together with a loan for the other half. The maximum amount of the grant will be £25.

Sub-head O (7) deals with the Pigs and Bacon Act, 1935. There is an increase on that sub-head of £9,784. Part II of that Act did not come into operation until 1st April, 1937, and that necessitated the appointment of veterinary and lay staffs in the various factories. Sub-head O (9) refers to the Agricultural Products (Regulation of Export) Acts and there is an increase of £73,768. With respect to the purchase, storage and export of butter, there is an increase of £81,000. The increase is due to the fact that in 1937 a greater proportion of the foreign exchange made available in Germany for the importation of Saorstát products will be allocated for the importation of butter. Sub-head O (11) has reference to the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Acts and there is an increase of £43,894. New trade agreements with Germany and Belgium provide for an appreciably larger number of cattle in 1937-38.

Sub-head OO (11) deals with the distribution of cattle and export licences, and there is an increase of £6,479. The increase is in respect of the salaries and expenses of temporary supervisors and assistant supervisors, which the Department find it necessary to employ in order to ensure the best possible results. Sub-head O (14) refers to the Agricultural Wages Act, and there is an increase of £4,700. There is a provision of £5,000 here, but that is only an approximate sum. The Department are not in a position to make a detailed estimate.

There is a decrease under certain other sub-heads. In the case of salaries, wages and allowances, for instance, there is a decrease of £6,942. There is a summary set out in the Estimate of the staff provided for, and on page 205 of the Book of Estimates it will be found that the administrative staff will be reduced from 606 in 1936-37 to 496 in 1937-38. The reduction is mainly due to the discontinuance in part of the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Acts. In the case of sub-head M (5), relating to the improvement of the creamery industry, there is a decrease of £30,800. There are no big schemes for the erection of creameries in contemplation during the year, and the Estimate is consequently smaller this year.

Sub-head O (8) refers to the Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Acts. Under that sub-head there is a decrease of £1,300, due to the discontinuance of the advances to seed merchants. In the case of sub-head O (10)—Acquisition of Land (Allotments) (Amendment) Act— there is a decrease of £1,341, principally due to an decrease in the amount provided for implements, as many plotholders have already been supplied with implements. Under the oats and barley purchase scheme there is only a token Vote of £5 for this year. Under sub-head O (15) there is a sum of £250 provided for the purposes of the Noxious Weeds Act. This indicates a reduction also, as under the new Act the administration is carried out to a great extent through the Gárda Síochána.

Coming to the Appropriations-in-Aid, there is indicated there an estimated increase of £185,469. The more important increases are receipts from service fees of stallions, sale of colts, sale and leasing of bulls, etc., and the amount is £3,350. The recoupment from the Dairy Produce Fund in respect of salaries and expenses of inspectors under the Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Act came to £4,990. As regards the Agricultural Products (Regulation of Export) Acts, there will be an estimated increased income of £101,716. In connection with the administration of the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Acts, it is estimated that the income will be increased by £73,640.

Comment on this

The Minister refers to an increase in the Appropriations-in-Aid in respect of the Agricultural Products (Regulation of Export) Acts. Will he say where are we going to sell the eggs?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I said the principal increase would be in butter, not in eggs. There is, of course, an amount provided for eggs, but there is no appreciable change from last year.

Comment on this

The Government are selling eggs on the Continent?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, in Germany. Arising out of the report of the Horse Breeding Commission, it has been decided to proceed with the following developments of the horse-breeding industry. In the first place, it was recommended that this country should have at least one first-class stallion of classic standard. It is impossible, of course, to give any estimate of what the cost of that horse would be but, at any rate, if such a horse should come upon the market, we shall make every attempt to secure it for the breeders in this country. There is also the matter of the purchase of two or three thoroughbred stallions, not quite up to the classic standard, perhaps, but which nevertheless might become first-class horses, or, perhaps, even superior horses, because nobody can foretell in those cases. We intend also to purchase such stallions and, in all probability, to lease them out to approved breeders. Then there is the matter of stallions for hunter-breeding. It has become very much more difficult, at the sales both here and in England, to get these stallions and, in fact, it is practically impossible to get them at the prices we have been in the habit of paying for the last few years. Many foreign Governments are now coming in to bid for these horses, and that has contributed to their scarcity and has caused those that are available to become very much dearer. Accordingly, we must make up our minds to increase the price we are prepared to pay, and in that way there will be a bigger cost on the State because, when they are leased out or placed with breeders, I am afraid we cannot pass on the whole of the increased cost. We will have to reduce the selling price when the animals are being placed out.

There is also a subsidy for yearling thoroughbred colts with the object of inducing the owners to retain them entire, keep them well, and offer them for sale to the Department at the fair market price as two-year-olds. However, these will not become payable till 1938-39 and therefore they are not provided here. It is also proposed to purchase a limited number of thoroughbred colts, when presented, or to purchase others, if presented, with a view to having them brought up as stallions. It is not intended to race them, but to keep them as stallions. Then, with regard to the Irish draught stallions, it has been decided to develop the breeding of horses of the Irish draught type, as far as we possibly can, by increasing the number of subsidies from 25 to 30 for the yearling Irish draughts offered for inspection, with a view to inducing owners to keep them entire and keep them well. The subsidies are valued at about £20 each. That is also for the purpose of increasing the price for suitable two-year-old colts which are likely to make Irish draught stallions.

That, at any rate, is an outline of the measures, which are going to cost money, which have been adopted as a result of the recommendations of the Horse Breeding Commission. Now, I want to give some short review—as short a review as possible—of the production and marketing provisions of agriculture in general during the year 1936. First of all, to take the tillage crops, there has been, as everybody is aware, a very big increase in the acreage under wheat in the year 1936 as compared with previous years. In 1932 we had only 21,000 acres under wheat, and that was increased to 254,000 acres in 1936; or, in tonnage, the amount of wheat produced by this country increased in 1936 from 22,000 tons to 210,000 tons. One thing that may be taken from that, and which would be a wrong deduction to make, is that the yield has gone down in 1936 as compared with 1932, and the deduction might be made by certain Deputies that the old argument, which was used against the growing of wheat four or five years ago, is quite true. That argument was to the effect that the more land there was under wheat, the less would be the yield. I do not know if that can be taken in regard to the 1936 figures, but in 1935 there were 163,000 acres under wheat, and yet the tonnage was 179,000 tons. Of course the truth is that 1935 was an extremely good year for wheat, whereas 1936 was an extremely bad year for wheat, and, therefore, neither year should be taken as a basis for argument or comparison.

Our full requirements in regard to flour for human consumption would be about 535,000 tons of wheat. That would give us our full flour requirements at 70 per cent. extraction. This is foreign wheat, which comes in here with about 12 per cent. moisture, and which is conditioned up to about 16 per cent. for milling. If we were to calculate it on the basis of all Irish wheat being used, with moisture at from 18 per cent. to 20 per cent., we should require up to about 555,000 tons, and that would require some 635,000 acres under wheat. I must point out that I am only speaking here of the amount we would require for human consumption. That does not include the acreage required for seed, and it also excludes the acreage required if wheat should be used for any other purposes, such as poultry feeding and so on.

Now, with regard to prices, on the amount purchased, the price was 27/6 per barrel here before Christmas, and those who kept their wheat got 28/6— some of them, perhaps, a little more— as compared with the English farmer, who got 25/- per barrel for his wheat before Christmas and who recently was getting 26/- per barrel. There, again, in dealing with the comparison of the prices got by the Irish farmer, as against the prices received by the English farmer, I should like to draw attention to another point which is very interesting, and that is that while we in this country have 2.2 per cent. of our total pasture land—that is, of our total land which is land—under wheat, the British farmer has 6.1 per cent. of his land under wheat. The argument has been used, fairly frequently and fairly vigorously, by certain Deputies on the opposite side, that if the Irish farmer were allowed to farm in the way they would allow him to farm—that is, so that he could get a good price for his cattle, sheep, pigs, and so on—he would not grow wheat. Now, nobody on the opposite side can ever hope—at least nobody on the opposite side has ever said—with the big surplus of cattle in this country, that we can get a better price for Irish cattle in England than the English farmer can get for his cattle. Yet, even though the English farmer is getting a much better price for his cattle and other stock, he is still, in spite of that, increasing his acreage under wheat, and he is using 6.1 per cent. of his land for the production of wheat as against our 2.2 per cent. I think it will be realised by everybody that, if the English farmer, not through any motive of patriotism so much as of good farming, has increased his acreage under wheat to that extent, it must be a good proposition to the English farmer, apart from any other consideration. If we had reached the same standard here—that is, 6.1 per cent.—we would be more than self-sufficient, as a matter of fact. Taking the price of foreign wheat——

Comment on this

Might I interrupt the Minister for a moment? Has he got the figures showing the tendency during the last few years in Britain with regard to wheat? Are they increasing year by year?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I have only got odd years. There is a slight tendency, a very slight tendency, to increase, but the percentage of increase is nothing as much as in our case. The price of foreign wheat, during this cereal year, landed here in Dublin was, in September, 22/6 per barrel. That is Manitoba wheat. In October and November it was 24/-, and it went on increasing from November up to the present time, when it is 31/6 per barrel. At the present time, Australian wheat is 29/- per barrel. So that at the moment our Irish wheat, at 27/6, or 28/6 even, would be about as valuable to the Irish miller as foreign wheat. As far as consumers in this country are concerned, they are not suffering any disadvantage by having wheat grown at home at the moment. There is only one other thing which might be noticed about wheat, and that is the value of wheat to the farmers last year was about £2,300,000. It is true that to grow wheat the farmer must buy seed.

Comment on this

How much does the Minister say was the value to the farmer?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

£2,300,000 was the value of the wheat crop. It is true, as I say, that the farmer must buy seed, and we should possibly deduct the price of seed from that sum, although in any production, whether it be cattle, sheep, pigs or poultry, there are expenses to be deducted from the ultimate price realised. Even so, taking the price of seed from that figure, the farmers would be in receipt of almost £2,000,000 per year from wheat.

Now, I come to the maize-meal mixture, which has created quite an amount of public discussion. We want if possible to get at the real cost of this maize-meal mixture as compared with the price of pure maize meal. The price of the maize-meal mixture f.o.r. in Dublin district in January was £8 5s. 0d. per ton; in February, £8 10s. 0d.; in March, £8 15s. 0d., and in April, £9 0s. 0d. per ton. If no mixing scheme had been in operation, and pure maize meal were being sold, the corresponding price would have been £7 7s. 6d. in January and £8 5s. 0d. per ton in April. That would be with the 25 per cent. mixture, but now that the mixture has been reduced to 16? per cent.—that is, to one-sixth instead of one-fourth—the extra cost of the maize-meal mixture over pure maize would be 6/8 per ton at the moment. I am quoting the price for Dublin, but every Deputy, I think, is supplied with these official quotations for feeding-stuffs in various towns in the Free State, and if the prices were taken for any other town, probably the result would be somewhat the same. We must take some particular town, taking the price of pure maize landed, and taking the cost of milling, and so on, to get a comparison between the present cost of the maize-meal mixture and the cost of pure maize meal.

Comment on this

Do I understand the Minister to say that the cost of pure maize meal is £9 per ton?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I say that the price of pure maize meal sold ex-mill would be about £8 13s. 4d. It is almost £8 per ton at the port.

Comment on this

According to the Irish Press yesterday the price in Londou was £7 10s. 0d.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not know, but if you question any miller of maize here, you will find that it is almost £8 per ton landed at the port.

Comment on this

I can get you the quotation in the Irish Press for yesterday of £7 7s. 6d. and £7 10s. in London.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy may be right. I am not disputing that, but London is a different place. Comparing the price of other feeding-stuffs here and in Northern Ireland—there are official publications which give the price of these various feeding-stuffs—we find that, in the Saorstát, the farmer is getting at present 8/7 per cwt. for his oats and the Northern Ireland farmer is getting 7/9½. On the other hand, the Saorstát farmer is buying red bran here in Dublin at 7/6, while in Northern Ireland it is 9/4½.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister where he can get red bran at the moment? I tried every mill in Ireland and I could not get an ounce of bran at any price.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I cannot tell the Deputy where he might get bran, but they are turning out bran obviously.

Comment on this

Well, I cannot get it. I can get German bran, but none other.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

White bran is 8/9 here as against 10/3½ in Northern Ireland. Pollards run from 8/- to 8/9 here as against 9/4 to 10/3½ in Northern Ireland. On the other hand, imported cakes are somewhat dearer here than in Northern Ireland—linseed, 12/- as compared with 11/9½, cotton seed cake 11/3 as compared with 10/4½, and palmnut cake 9/- as against 8/8½. There is one very important feeding-stuff which is becoming more important to farmers who want to use a balanced ration and that is meat meal. I have not succeeded in getting a quotation for Great Britain or Northern Ireland, but I can say that meat meal is very much dearer in Great Britain and Northern Ireland than it is here.

Comment on this

And it represents only 5 per cent. of the ration.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Ten per cent. if the Deputy knew how to feed pigs.

Comment on this

I should not care to give them 10 per cent.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is why the Deputy does not make pig-feeding pay. Taking the price of beet, our price is 37/6 per ton with offals free.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

This is beet delivered by the farmer.

Comment on this

Delivered where?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Delivered to the factory. This is the basic price, 37/- to 37/6 for beet with a 15½ per cent. sugar content. The average price paid in Great Britain last year was 3/6 over the basic price, that is from 40/- to 41/-. Here our farmers are paid 37/6, plus offals free. The growers in England are charged for the offals. The lowest price charged by any factory is £4 5s., and the highest is £4 10s. Our growers get back free threequarters of a cwt. per ton. Of course they pay carriage. On that basis it would be worth something over 3/-, so that our price works out exactly the same as the British farmers for beet.

Comment on this

Before the Minister leaves that, would he be good enough to say if the British farmer gets paid on the basis of free on rail, or does he have to deliver the beet to the factory?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The British farmer pays carriage on his beet up to 7/-; the Beet Corporation pays in excess of 7/- a ton. It is true that there is no such concession here, but the number of farmers who are paying higher freight than 7/- here is a comparatively small percentage of the whole. On the whole, the price is practically the same in the two countries. Our farmers here are very anxious to grow beet; there are many applications. It is said by Deputies opposite that when they introduce their programme of good prices for cattle, good prices for sheep, and so on, there will be no more beet grown, but it is grown in Great Britain at the same price by the British farmer who has got all those prices we hear about. I am now going on to dairy produce. The number of milch cows on 1st June, 1936, was approximately 1,350,000. This was an increase of 16,000 over 1935, and it is I believe the highest on record. The statistics go back ten or 12 years, and it is probably the highest on record. The production of creamery butter was also the highest reached—838,000 cwts. The average value of this butter to the creameries was 114/10 per cwt., which was about 7/- better than in 1935. The price paid by the creameries rose from 4.3 pence in 1935 to 4.6 pence in 1936. That is the average price per gallon, of course, separated milk being returned. The total exports of our dairy produce in 1936 amounted in value to £2,243,000 as against £1,922,000 in 1935. The quantity of creamery butter exported was less than in 1935, although our production was greater, which goes to prove an argument which was put up from this side a few days ago that our people —in spite of all that is said about high prices—are consuming more food than they have been consuming.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister the quantity exported?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

460,000 cwts.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

In 1936, as compared with 473,000 cwts. in 1935. That is the calendar year. The total value of that export was £1,706,000. I am now talking about creamery butter alone. I already gave the figure for dairy produce. That can be compared with a lower figure for 1935, but—more interesting still—it can be compared with a lower figure for 1931, in the good old times, when we realised £1,496,000 for our creamery butter export. In that same year 1931 we imported £176,000 worth of butter, so that if we take that import from what was realised for export in 1931 it will be found that, apart from what creamery suppliers got, the real value of our exports as the English consumer values it, was higher in 1936 than in 1931. In addition to that, when we come to add £720,000 in subsidies and £412,000 in bounties, we have an enormously increased receipt for our dairy produce in 1936 as compared with 1931.

Comment on this

Would the Minister mind telling us what did we get per cwt. for butter exported in 1931 as opposed to what we exported in 1936?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I will give the Deputy the total. He will work it out for himself.

Comment on this

Is it not as 110/6 is to 74/- per cwt.?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

In 1931 we exported 264,000 odd cwts. of creamery butter and we received £1,496,000.

Comment on this

Taking all butter?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is creamery butter.

Comment on this

Was it not 376,000 cwts. taking the total?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We exported 377,000 cwts. and received £2,086,000.

Comment on this

That is 110/6 per cwt. What is the figure for 1936?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

For all butter? We exported 518,000 cwts. and received £1,917,000.

Comment on this

That is 74/- per cwt.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I was talking about creamery butter. Even so, as I pointed out to the Deputy, to that figure of receipts for all butter would be added £1,132,000, which is paid out in subsidies and bounties, and which would bring our total receipts for all dairy produce considerably above what they were in 1931. We are not taking the imports into account, because we had to pay out a certain amount of money for imports in that year 1931, for butter, condensed milk, cheese and other things, which was not paid out in 1936. The net price realised is about 74/-, but our creameries were actually paid 114/10. Prior to the year 1932 there was annually a substantial import of butter, and for the five years 1928 to 1932 the average import was 35,000 cwts. per year, whereas for the four years from 1933 to 1936 the average fell to 3,500 cwts. The greater part of this import took place this year, due to the fact that the very unfavourable weather in the winter and early spring reacted seriously on butter production, which fell 25 per cent. below normal. We had to import butter to meet the normal demand. During the five years 1928 to 1932, there was an average import of cheese of 27,000 cwts. per annum, while the exports averaged about 1,100 cwts. During the four years from 1933 to 1936, the average import fell from 27,000 cwts. to 1,200 cwts. per annum, while the average exports had gone up from 1,100 cwts. to 7,600 cwts. The production of cheese in 1932 was only 2,500 cwts.; the production in 1936 reached almost 36,000 cwts. We had available for export in that year 15,500 cwts., as well as availing of our own market. I now have the figure which the Deputy asked for. The average export value of Saorstát creamery butter in 1936 was 105/- per cwt., that is at the British price. After deducting freight commission and duty, the price realised was 71/6, but by means of payments out of the Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Fund and the Vote for Export Bounties and Subsidies, the value of exports increased to the extent that the average value of all creamery butter produced reached 114/10 per cwt. We, therefore, paid to creamery producers in excess of world prices as taken from the English market——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If we take that as the world value.

Comment on this

We were realising 15/- per cwt. less than the world value. The world price was 89/-, and you were getting only 74/-.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

What period is the Deputy talking about?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If the Deputy would pay some attention to what are called weighted averages, he might be able to follow me. In the first few months the price was very low. The price got good about August or September, but our exports were small. But, taking it week by week, as our butter was going out, we on the whole realised the New Zealand price for it.

Comment on this

Except that you started to cold store in June when you should have been exporting it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We took the experience of the four years previous, when butter always went up in September. Therefore, we cold stored it at the cheapest period. It turned out, however, that last year the previous four years experience was against us. Of course, if I were now in the Deputy's place, I would say that in doing that we made a mistake.

Comment on this

The Minister would not, because he would not get the chance of saying it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Well, I think I am safe in saying that the Deputy will never get a chance of saying it over here. Anyway, it is very easy for the Deputy to be wise after the event. I do not think he was ever wise any other way. We were going on the experience of the previous four years. We paid the creamery producers £750,000 more than they would have realised on the open market, without any duties or subsidies or anything else. The Fine Gael Party, under their plan, will give them 5d. a gallon for their milk. That will cost another £1,000,000 in addition to what we are paying, and they tell us that by doing that they are not going to increase taxation.

Comment on this

Is the £750,000 the total sum?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It is the amount which producers got over the world price. The total amount paid was over £1,100,000.

Comment on this

Then £350,000 is the amount of the tariff?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not know what was collected by way of tariff, but when the world price was about 105/- they were getting about 114/10. By bringing the price of all butter production at home and abroad up by 9/-, it was worth £750,000 to the creamery producers here. I should say the winter prices were also higher.

The quantity of eggs exported in 1936 was 2,966,000 great hundreds. It was somewhat less than the quantity exported in 1935, and in value was a few thousand pounds under the value realised in 1935. The British duty collected on eggs exported in 1936 was approximately £397,000, and towards this a subsidy or bounty was paid of £357,000. That subsidy on the export of eggs is being increased this year, and will probably equate, if it does not exceed, the duty collected by Great Britain on eggs going in there. The rate of the bounty has been increased this month, and is now 3/2 per great hundred for selected and extra selected, as compared with 2/9 on these grades last year. The price paid at fairs and markets for our eggs during the year averaged 8/7 per great hundred, as against 8/5 in 1935. It is true that the Northern Ireland producers of eggs get somewhere between 1/6 and 2/- per great hundred more than we get for our eggs sent to the United Kingdom, but that is due to the regulation with regard to stamping, and it is the price of our separation from the United Kingdom, politically. The price paid for eggs during the month of March—it is the latest return I have got—was 8.32/- per great hundred.

Comment on this

That is not so. The average price paid last month was about 6/-.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy wants us to believe that he knows more than the people who collect the prices. I am not inclined to accept the figure which he gives. The price paid last March was higher than in March of 1935 or, indeed, during the month of March in any of the last four or five years. In the case of poultry, on the census taken last June there was an increase in the number during the year of almost 1,000,000. The increase was amongst all classes of poultry. The number of live poultry exported increased by 71 per cent. In the case of dead poultry, the quantity exported last year was 104,242 cwts. It was slightly below that of 1935, but the value at £377,000 was higher by over £3,000 than the value of our exports in 1935. The bounty paid on dead poultry, in 1936, was £160,000 which was practically the same as the amount of the British duty.

I now come to pigs and bacon. These are the prices paid for pigs on a deadweight basis delivered at the factories. The top price for the Irish Free State was 73/-. The top price for Northern Ireland was 68/7, and for contracted pigs 72/7. Taking the production of bacon, as compared with 1931, in 1931 we actually imported more bacon to this country than we exported. In that year our net import of bacon and hams was 87,428 cwts. In 1936 we imported none, but we exported 541,000 cwts., so that our balance of trade, our net exports, from being a minus quantity of £74,000 in 1931—I am speaking now of bacon and hams alone—came to be a plus quantity of £1,683,000 in 1936.

Comment on this

What were the gross exports of pigs and bacon in that period?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I will give the value. The value of net exports of live pigs, in 1931, was £2,187,000 and in 1936, £492,000.

Comment on this

Or a difference of roughly £1,700,000.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

On the other hand, the total value of exports of pig products, that is bacon, hams, pork, sausage casings, and everything else, after deducting the amount paid for imports in 1931, was £1,169,000, and in 1936, £2,111,000. Again, when we add to these figures something over £600,000 paid by way of bounties on exports, we have a figure that almost equates that for 1931. But it is not so much that, because no matter how things go here in future with regard to pigs, the price must be regulated. The present system of contracted pigs in Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the present system of restriction of imports owing to their pig production scheme, will always necessitate, if there is no other reason for it, at any rate the regulation of pig production and the regulation of price here. Whether the factories exporting bacon get their price by way of subsidy or otherwise, it makes no great difference to the pig producer who is trying to find out whether it pays him to produce pigs here as compared with the producer in Northern Ireland or Great Britain. As we see, he is paid a higher price for his pigs than the Northern Ireland producer at present, and I think at times during the year that was the case; at other times, perhaps, the case was the other way round. On the whole, prices were as good here as in Northern Ireland, and, therefore, the pig producer here has done as well as what is referred to here sometimes as the world market.

Comment on this

Could we check these figures: £2,178,000, £1,169,000, £429,000, £2,111,000 and £600,000, a difference of £200,000?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, a difference of about £200,000 lower than that realised in 1931. The number of sheep has been increasing for the last few years. There was a cycle in regard to the number of sheep in this country. It was down fairly low in 1927; it began getting higher up to about 1930 or 1931; then it began going down, until it reached the lowest level in 1934; it is now on the up-grade again, and is somewhere about the 1927 figure. The numbers and value of the exports have been increasing during the last few years, and also the consumption of sheep here at home, as far as that figure can be got, has been increasing. According to the Irish Trade Journal, the average price of fat sheep realised in 1933 was 33/-; 1934, 39/3; 1935, 40/-; 1936, 42/-, and for the three months to date of 1937, from 45/- to 48/-. There is a per-head tariff on sheep going into Great Britain, and there is no bounty or subsidy. It might be claimed, therefore, that farmers exporting sheep— and the price would be reflected here at home—are losing 5/- per head as a result of the penal tariffs put on by Great Britain. That would amount to about £225,000 in the year.

With regard to cattle, the number in 1936 was almost the same as in 1935. The number of milch cows increased considerably, and, as I have already said, it is the highest figure for many years. Deputies are aware that there has been an improvement in the price realised by farmers for cattle. In the last week of March—I have not got any report since then—the average price for fat cattle in Dublin market was 29/6 per cwt. That has been very much exceeded, as a matter of fact, during the last few markets. Taking the price at 29/6 in the last week in March, I want to see what effect the penal tariffs are having on the price of cattle here. In March, 1932, the average price was 40/6, and the average in Great Britain—that is, England and Wales—during the same month was 42/6, so that there was a difference of 2/- per cwt., which would, I take it, be the cost of having them exported to Great Britain, with an allowance for a reduction in weight, and so on. Applying that same test to the last week in March here, our farmers were getting 29/6, and for the same week in England the price was 37/4. Taking off the 2/-, which would be the normal difference, there is almost 6/- of a difference, due to the penal tariffs. There is, of course, a tariff of £4 5s. 0d. per head on cattle over two years old. Another way of estimating it is to take the amount of the tariffs collected on our cattle going into Great Britain, which was within £100,000 of £2,000,000 in 1936. Four-fifths of our cattle are exported, and one-fifth, or perhaps nearer one-fourth now, are consumed at home. So that, if we add on one-fourth to the £2,000,000, we get £2,500,000 as being the probable loss sustained by the farmers owing to the penal tariffs on our cattle.

I want to come back and make a summary of the various gains and losses of the farmers as against world prices in this country. I said in the beginning that the farmers had realised about £2,000,000 for wheat in 1936 which, I may take it from the utterances of Deputies on the other side, would never have been realised were it not that a Fianna Fáil Government was in power. As a matter of fact, the Leader of the Opposition made a very fine distinction between our policy and his with regard to wheat growing. As far as I can understand, he means to do exactly what we are doing, to give guaranteed prices for wheat and other things, while he says that he will not encourage them. We have given these fixed prices in order to encourage the growing of wheat. How Deputies on the opposite benches can give these prices without encouraging the growing of such crops I do not know. Perhaps Deputy Cosgrave can explain.

Comment on this

To compensate for the losses.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is all right, to compensate for the losses, but there is evidently a certain amount of disapproval of wheat growing on the opposite benches yet, while they disapprove of it, they say they are going to continue it. That is a very fine distinction. Then there is beet growing which is looked upon as——

Comment on this

A white elephant.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

About 40,000 extra acres were under beet, and taking ten tons to the acre at £2 a ton, that would represent £800,000 as compensation, as the Deputy says, for beet growing.

Comment on this

What is the total acreage under beet?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Fifty-four thousand acres.

Comment on this

And 60,000 acres would supply all that is required?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

There are 54,000 acres now. Under dairy produce £750,000 was given to the producers to produce over and above what the world prices were, so that in these three items, as a result of Fianna Fáil policy, which had not any great support on the opposite side, the farmers were in receipt of £3,550,000, in addition to what they would have got if they had the misfortune to keep Fine Gael in power.

Comment on this

In addition?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, so far. I will do the whole sum before I am finished.

Comment on this

In addition?

Comment on this

The Minister has not started on subtraction yet.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

When I have the whole sum done the Deputies will be mortified.

Comment on this

We will be astonished.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am glad the Deputy said that. I do not want any Deputy on the other side to say that I said the farmers are well off. I say definitely they are not well off.

Comment on this

They must be well off.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I never said they were well off, but I am telling the farmers how well off they would be if Fine Gael was here! They would not be there at all.

Comment on this

Whose fault is it if the farmers are not well off?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It is the fault of the world. It is not our fault. I have told you what we are doing for them, as against world conditions. In the case of eggs we got about £40,000 less on the world price, but we made that good by way of subsidy, so that there would be no loss as regards eggs. I am talking of the free world markets that we are to get when Fine Gael comes back. The producer of eggs here has as good prices as in the world market. The same applies to poultry, because the subsidies were equal to the tariffs collected on them. The same applies to pigs and bacon because that is not a case where we can talk about the world market and limited production. We are paying producers here as good a price for pigs as countries where prices are good. Taking England and Northern Ireland as my guide, I say that we are paying as good a price for pigs as they are paying. There is no duty on horses, so that there is no difference as far as horses go. The only two items of agricultural produce where our prices are not as good as if we had the free world market spoken of are sheep and cattle. Sheep are down by 5/- a head as a result of tariffs. The total number of sheep exported and consumed here is 900,000 or a loss of about £225,000. The loss on cattle is £2,500,000. Say that the losses are £2,725,000 against £3,550,000, which gives a balance for Fianna Fáil policy on agriculture as against Fine Gael policy.

Comment on this

So that the farmers are better off?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am saying that they are not well off, but I say that they are better off than if Fine Gael was in power. The farmers know that. If I went to farmers and got 20 per cent. or 30 per cent. or whatever percentage of votes Fine Gael is able to get, these farmers know this, that they are better off than if Fine Gael were here.

Comment on this

Are they better off than when Fine Gael was in power?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It shows the opinion they have of the Opposition Party when they would not trust them at any price. When the duty was put on against cattle, one of the benefits which we as a Government sought to give the farmers against that loss on cattle, was to halve the land annuities. At that time, in 1933, we took off half the annuities and gave the farmers the benefit of £2,000,000.

Comment on this

I thought that was against derating.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I was going to say, if the Deputy had not interrupted me, that I recognise that that is part of the programme of the Party on the opposite benches now. It became part of their programme rather suddenly and unexpectedly, after Deputy Cosgrave had to call a meeting of the shadow Cabinet in Naas about a week before the 1933 election, to get his Party to do one better than we could do, by halving the annuities, as he put it. It does not matter to the farmers whether Deputy Cosgrave did that in Naas or in Dublin, because the farmers have got the advantage of that £2,000,000 yearly. That is the position. I do not want to say that the farmers are well-off. I do not think they are. They are very badly off, as we know, all over the world, but I should like to ask farmers—I hardly think it is necessary to do so—whatever complaints they may have about their conditions now, what would their condition have been if Fine Gael had been in power; if Fine Gael had not allowed them to grow wheat or beet, or given that encouragement to the dairying industry that we gave it, and thereby tried to alleviate the great suffering there would have been if these things had not been done?

Comment on this

I move that the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration. It took the Minister one and a half hours to explain his balance sheet, and the purpose of his explanation was to show that the depression that is keeping farmers depressed is due to world depression. So astute an observer as Deputy O'Reilly will remember that the Minister began his observations by telling us that the price of wheat and the price of maize is rising so high on the world market at the present time, that if we were not growing wheat we would be all bankrupt, and that the rise in the maize-meal mixture was owing to the immense rise in the price of agricultural produce in countries that produce wheat and maize. That was the introduction to the Minister's speech. He wanted to warn us that prices of primary agricultural produce all over the world were going sky high, and he wound up by saying that the reason farmers are badly off was because world prices are unsatisfactory, the truth being that the world is booming, and that this country, alone amongst the nations, is still trailing along at the bottom of the depression. That depression was created by Fianna Fáil, and we are having the pleasure and the privilege of selling at depression prices and buying at boom prices.

The sad part of this situation is that if we had a rational administration we could approach Great Britain and make a bargain as hard as we are in a position to drive—a fairly hard bargain— at the present time. We have never closed our eyes to the fact that if Great Britain attempted to dominate the economic life of this country, it would be the duty of whatever political Party was responsible for Government here, to come back and tell our people that they had to reorient their lives and, if needs be, go back to the present standard rather than submit to the control of our economic life by any outside power. I believe there are weapons in the hands of an Irish Government, rationally controlled, which would make it worth England's while to make a very satisfactory trade agreement with this country, because, by deliberately turning our backs upon the British market, while our people would have to face very material hardships, we could seriously dislocate, and, indeed, gravely injure, the entire agricultural industry of Great Britain, and substantially jeopardise certain essential food supplies of that country. I do not believe it would be ever necessary to do that, but it is wise to bear that fact in mind, if, and when, negotiations have to be entered into with the British Government for a comprehensive trade agreement.

The tragedy of it is that we have not in this country at present, nor have we had during the last three years, a Government with the competence, moral courage and common-sense to go and make an agreement with Great Britain on that basis. Our Government, throughout these four disastrous years, instead of facing issues squarely, calling whatever bluff Great Britain might properly make in the course of negotiation, and getting, as I am quite satisfied they could have got, and could now get, a sound business arrangement with that country, have wobbled like jellies, protesting in Galway that we are marching towards the Republic and trembling at Westminster as shamefaced members of the Commonwealth of Nations, having none of the advantages of membership and all the disadvantages. It is a very sad thing that our trade relations, which are so vital to the welfare of our people, should be so complicated by political folly of that kind, but we ought to face the fact that they are, and we ought to realise that a great deal of the misery in this country at present exists because the Government of this country is mixing politics with economics with disastrous results for 80 per cent. of our people.

Before I go into the general question of agricultural policy in this country, I want to say a word about pigs and bacon because I want to throw into relief the shameless ramp going on in connection with pigs and bacon at present. The export of live pigs from this country has, in the last five years, been reduced from £2,178,000 to £429,000. In fact, it has been practically wiped out. The exports of bacon have increased from £1,169,000 to £2,111,000, and at the present time, we have a situation in which our people are being charged, wholesale, 132/- per cwt. for green middles, 142/- per cwt. for smoked middles, 118/- per cwt. for lean long sides, and 120/- for lean long clears. The farmers of the country were being paid a maximum price of 69/- per cwt., dead weight, for pigs delivered to the factory of class A.1. They are now getting 73/- per cwt. for the same quality pig delivered to the factory. In fact, the farmers are getting an average price for all pigs delivered to the factory now of about 69/- per cwt., and the consumer in this country is being charged as high as 142/- per cwt.— 142/- for smoked middles, and 69/- per cwt. for pork delivered at the factory. Many Deputies are almost incredulous when these figures are brought under their notice. I am now quoting from invoices on the foot of which bacon has been delivered in the course of the last week.

What is the explanation of it? Everybody is looking for somebody who is to be the whipping boy of this scandalous ramp. You need not look far. The person entirely responsible for this whole ramp is the Minister for Agriculture in Saorstát Eireann, and I will challenge him to deny the exposé which I now propose to make of his activities in connection with bacon. The facts are that, under the British quota regulations, the British Government allocates to this country a quota for bacon, and at present are prepared to give us any quota we want. Having accepted the quota from Great Britain, the Minister apportions it out under the Pigs and Bacon Act between the various curers, and he fixes them with notice that if each curer accepts liability for a certain portion of the British quota, he must fill that amount, and that if he does not, when the next quota period comes along, he will reduce his export quota by so much as he fell short of the quota which he at present enjoys. The duty levied by the British Government for the purpose of collecting the land annuities on bacon is substantial. The Minister wants to maintain exports of bacon to the British market because he must have those exports in order to maintain the demand for pigs in this country. The curers who are sending bacon to the British market would lose very substantially if they had to pay the entire duty themselves. Ordinarily, they would pass that loss on to the pig producer and if that happened, the pig producer would give up producing altogether, because he could not produce pigs at the price the curers would be able to pay if they had to pay all the duty themselves, seeing the price which the producer has to pay for feeding stuffs. So the Minister gives a bounty on exports, but he will not give a bounty sufficient to compensate the curers for their loss on the exports.

The curers say to the Minister: "We are losing an immense amount of money on this English trade because you will not pay us a bounty sufficient to meet the full amount of the duty." The bacon curers, however, have to pay for pigs the price fixed by the Pigs Marketing Board and, as a result of an amendment put in by the Opposition on the Committee Stage of the Pigs and Bacon Act, the Pigs Board must have regard to the cost of production when fixing a price for pigs. Therefore, the bacon curers have to pay at present 73/- per cwt. for grade 1 pigs. They have to sell the bacon in England, pay the tariff on it, and get back from the Department of Finance whatever bounty the Exchequer is prepared to pay. That bounty does not bridge the gap between the cost of the pork to the curer and the price he receives for bacon in England, and he goes to the Minister and asks him what will he do in face of that situation. The Minister first says: "I will go to the hypothetical price fund and I will permit the Pigs Marketing Board to give you back, out of the hypothetical price fund, a large sum of money to compensate you for whatever loss you suffered on the British market." The hypothetical price fund was made up under the Pigs Marketing Act in this way: The curers were authorised to pay to pig producers in the autumn a price less than the economic price. When they were paying the producers less than a fair price in the autumn, they paid the difference between what they actually paid the producer and what would be a fair price into the hypothetical price fund. The plan was that, in the spring, when it is desired to encourage people to produce more pigs, the curers were to pay the producers more than an economic price for their pigs and compensate themselves for that extra payment by refunds out of the hypothetical price fund. In short, the money was to be taken from the producers in the autumn and given back to the producers in the spring. In fact, what has happened is that the money was taken from the producers in the autumn and, when the spring came round, the money was taken out of that fund and given to the curers to compensate them for part of the loss which the Minister ought to have made up by payment of bounties out of the Exchequer. When they got that, the curers were still at a loss on their sales of bacon in Great Britain, and I now allege that they went to the Minister and said: "We are still at a loss," and that the Minister caused it to be known to the bacon curers—I cannot prove and I do not know that he sent any personal message to them, but he caused it to be known—that if they would form a ring to force up the price of bacon in Saorstát Eireann, they could knock out of the Irish consumer a price sufficiently high to yield them not only a profit on what they sold here, but a very large additional sum which would more than compensate them for any loss they had made on their sales on the British market even after they received the Minister's bounty and the special grant from the hypothetical price fund.

Accordingly, the curers have put on to the bacon consumed by the people here from 2d. to 3½d. per lb. over and above the profit they might reasonably take. Each curer has put that 2d. to 3½d. into a fund to compensate himself for his loss on the British market. So, instead of having an item appearing in the revenue accounts in the Budget showing bounties for bacon £500,000 greater than they now are and, on the other side of the Budget account, an item of revenue or an item of deficit corresponding to that £500,000, the whole of that sum is taken out of the Budget and passed on to the consumers of bacon in this country without any authority by statute, without the knowledge of this House, without the consent of this House and, in my opinion, by a fraudulent and scandalous understanding between the curers and the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

There was no understanding between me and the bacon curers, and certainly, the word "fraudulent" does not arise.

Comment on this

I say that this is a very undesirable state of affairs. If it is the intention of any Government in this country to levy taxes on the food of the people, it is the duty of that Government to come to this House, declare their purpose, and submit their decision for the approval of Oireachtas Eireann. This devious method of clandestine negotiation between the Minister or his representatives and certain trade interests, whereby revenue is raised without any statutory authority, is a menace not only to the people's welfare, but to Government institutions. We have, at last, succeeded in forcing this issue to the Prices Commission. That is a futile and helpless body. They will probably flounder about on this question for the next six months. I have no doubt the curers will succeed in pulling the wool over their eyes, as the millers succeeded in pulling the wool over their eyes. In the meantime, I have no doubt the bacon curers will plunder the people of this country just as the millers have plundered them during the last four years. I have no doubt that the bacon curers will be able to say, if they are allowed to continue as they are at present doing, at the end of four years what the millers are in a position to say now—that they have knocked out of the Irish people sufficient in surplus profits to make each miller indifferent as to whether the Government takes over his mill, confiscates his mill, or exiles him; that he has succeeded in knocking out of the people in superfluous profits, over and above a legitimate return on capital, such a sum in the last four years as gives him reserves equal to the entire capital value of his premises and goodwill. I say that if the present scandal is allowed to continue, every bacon curer will be able to say the same thing, and when these two bodies have plundered and sacrificed the consuming public, it will be the policy of the intelligentsia on the Government Front Bench to take over their business, in the belief that they will be able to do the same thing. Of course, they will not be able to do the same thing, because just about the time that the intelligentsia will be thinking of doing that, the people will rise against them, and, if they do not burn the mills and blow up the curing stations, they will, at least, secure that food will be supplied to them at a price which they are in a position to pay. There is a far graver issue involved in this matter than the question of imposing on the people an extra tax. It is a damnable principle that Ministers are conniving at the imposition of taxation without the consent of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has raised matters which had been already discussed in the Budget debate. He has also introduced matters which would properly arise on the Vote for the Department of Industry and Commerce. Obviously, these matters cannot be relevantly debated on three different Estimates. The Deputy used the word "fraudulent" in reference to certain Ministerial action. The use of that word is not Parliamentary. The word of a Minister or other member as to his personal actions must be accepted. The Minister has made a statement——

Comment on this

What statement?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy heard the statement as did the House generally.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Minister said and I do not believe the Minister is in a position to deny that he caused it to be known to the curers that a certain course of action would meet with his approval.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I was waiting to deny everything the Deputy said.

Comment on this

It would not be the first time that the Minister denied what I said, and that it subsequently emerged that the Minister was mistaken and that I was correct.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I should be surprised if you were ever correct on anything.

Comment on this

If this thing continues, it is going to give rise to a position in which a legitimate Irish industry is going to be aspersed by conduct which is not characteristic of the Free State as a whole and which would never become manifest except as a result of the wholly abnormal situation which is being created by the Executive's political interference in the normal trend of trade. The Minister spoke of comparative prices. I want to refer in a few details to his observations. He spoke of the prices of pollard and bran and said that they were available in this country. The Minister knows that that is not so.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I want to say the Deputy is entirely wrong.

Comment on this

The Minister spoke for one and a half hours and he will have the chance of winding up.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy is making statements that are all wrong. I will deal with them when I wind up.

Comment on this

Does the Minister want to intervene now?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No, go ahead.

Comment on this

What I was pointing out is the fact that there is no bran or pollard available in this country. It is very nice to quote prices for bran but there is not any bran to be got by the shopkeeper. It is very nice to quote prices for pollard but there is not any pollard to be got. The Minister knows that himself. He has been issuing permits for the importation of German pollard and bran.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Because there is not enough here. There is a whole lot of bran and pollard turned out every day here.

Comment on this

All I can say is that representations have been made to the Minister by merchants asking for permits to import German bran and pollard.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, about 1 per cent. of their requirements.

Comment on this

The Minister knows nothing about the business. I take it that all these interests are deliberately trying to deceive him. You go to your miller at present and you find that the miller has considerable difficulty in selling his output of flour because the demand for flour has fallen off considerably. Ask the millers for bran or pollard and they ask you immediately what amount of flour you require. You say you want no flour but that you want bran and they tell you that they cannot sell you the bran or pollard unless you take an equivalent quantity of flour. The yield from wheat is 70 per cent. flour and 30 per cent. bran and offals. Many millers will tell you that if you take seven tons of flour they will give you a mixed lot of three tons of bran and pollard. The average country merchant would sell 40 tons of bran and pollard while he would sell seven tons of flour. If the average merchant had to buy flour equivalent to the amount of offals he needed for his customers he would have to build a large warehouse to store his flour but he would never be able to sell it. The miller will tell the merchant that he will supply any order for bran and pollard provided that order carries with it an order for an equivalent quantity of flour—that is to say seven tons of flour for every three tons of bran and pollard. Deputies will see from that that the real fact is that the country merchant cannot get bran and pollard. I know this, that there is not a single mill in the country that is not prepared to say to the Department's inspectors: "Here is the bran; we are prepared to accept orders for bran and pollard." But when you get down to it you cannot get the bran unless you take a comparable quantity of flour. This is true of pollard but not in such a large measure as it is of bran.

Now, in the matter of linseed cake it takes three weeks or a month to get delivery of oil-cake or linseed cake meal. If you ask the reason why, you are told that licences have to be got and that without a licence you cannot import that particular type of linseed cake which cannot be supplied from Saorstát sources. You will be told, or you will find out that Saorstát sources cannot supply linseed cake because they have been disappointed in shipments of linseed. Some of the Irish firms will say that the same situation obtains in Great Britain. That is not so. You can get all the linseed cake meal you want there. The fact is that not only is oil-cake dearer here than in Great Britain but it cannot be got. The Minister spoke of allowing millers to sell Manitoba No. 1 wheat for seed. In the name of common sense, this is the 21st of April and we know what sort of a season it has been. Is it sane or sound on the part of the Minister to suggest to farmers that they can get Manitoba No. 1 wheat for seed?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not think I said anything about that.

Comment on this

The Minister said to-day that he had asked the millers to sell Manitoba wheat as seed.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It was not to-day I asked them.

Comment on this

To be urging small men to invest their labour and their land in Manitoba No. 1 wheat at this season of the year is reckless and almost insane. The chances are seven to one against wheat planted now coming to maturity. There may be one or two varieties of wheat which have a remote chance of reaching maturity, but I do not think there is any seed of either of those varieties in the country at the present time. One of these varieties is the Diamond and the other is April something. Outside of these two varieties which may come to maturity, the Minister ought to make it clear before he winds up to-day that he does not encourage anyone to whom it represents a considerable investment to start planting spring wheat now.

The net result of five years' Fianna Fáil agricultural policy has been that the agricultural output of this country is down from £64,000,000 in 1931 to £40,000,000 now. There is no doubt whatever that part of that fall is due to the fall in world prices. But the greater part is due to the fall in prices in this country. We might as well face up to that. The figures are much more readily available to the Minister for Agriculture than they are to me. Any Deputy who refers to them will find that the output per 100 acres of land in this country has fallen from £528 in 1931 to £346 in 1935-36. I take the prices ruling in Great Britain as approximating world prices. If one takes up the agricultural statistics, one finds that the agricultural price index for Ireland as a whole between 1931 and 1935 fell from 110 to 83. The movement in agricultural prices in Great Britain over the same period has been not a fall but a rise of three points. If you include wheat and beet subsidy payments—and for the purpose of comparison here you have got to do that because a large part of our production now is subsidised production—you will see what these figures mean to the country. Beet and wheat and other items are now receiving subsidies from the Government here, and one realises the fact that while agricultural prices in Great Britain have risen by three points, agricultural prices in this country have fallen by 27 points. That would be bad enough if the whole of that fall resulted directly in the payments of tariffs to Great Britain, but it does not.

I asked the Minister recently to give me figures about the shipments of cattle to Germany and Belgium, and the Minister had the amazing audacity to say that he thought that when those figures came to be published the people would realise that it was a very profitable business. The fact is that the Minister received in respect of the shipment of bullocks and heifers to Germany 27/9 a cwt., and in respect of his shipments of bullocks and heifers to Belgium 22/7 per cwt. Admittedly, the stuff going to Belgium was not of as high a quality as that going to Germany. The corresponding prices for cattle of a similar quality in the British market at the same time were about 37/3 for the cattle he was selling for 27/9 and 34/3 for the second quality fat cattle, which would correspond with the cattle for which he was getting 22/7 in Belgium. It is to be borne in mind that the two British prices I have quoted do not include the British fat stock subsidy. They would be substantially higher if they did.

If the Minister imagines that exports of that kind are going to help this country, I do not know what he is thinking of. The fact of it is that this country has got to make up its mind as to what attitude it shall adopt, and the Minister has to make up his mind whether he wants to be in the Commonwealth or out of it. If he wants to be in the Commonwealth, he has got to use the advantages available to him in the Commonwealth for the benefit of our people; he has got to remember that tariffs on our live-stock industry do not only constitute a direct burden on the people of a monetary character, but they have a dislocating effect on trade in general out of all proportion to the monetary burden they constitute. That is notable in regard to the horse business. The monetary relief derived from the removal of the tariff on horses may be comparatively small, but the benefit on the trade as a whole by the removal of barriers will be immense.

We have to face the fact that the alternative markets of Belgium, Germany and Spain are a complete farce, and a disastrous farce. The Minister has told us that he has made agreements whereunder he is going to send to Spain and Belgium increased quantities of fat cattle for which he has been getting 27/9 and 22/7 at a time when he has not enough fat cattle to give to the poor of this country or to fill the quota allocated to our farmers in the British market, where we are able to get about 35/- a cwt. That seems to me to be extravagant insanity. The Minister has said that the price of live stock is rising. That is quite true. The boom is on all over the world. If we were not engaged in this imbecile wrangle with Great Britain, this country would be enjoying a greater boom than has been experienced in Ireland since 1921. Even at this moment when, despite the tariffs, the prices are rising for live stock, what is the position? The vast majority of our farmers have not got the cattle to sell, because the cattle we ought to be putting out now as two- or three-years-old animals are rotting in the graves dug for them as calves two and a half years ago by the Minister for Agriculture. It was then supposed to be the acme of economic foresight to slaughter the young animals and bury them. Had they been allowed to live, these animals would now be selling to an eager buyer at 34/- to 35/- a cwt. and pay the tariff; and if the tariff were off these cattle would now be selling to an eager buyer at 42/- a cwt.

We are all going round congratulating ourselves that we slaughtered and buried them two and a half years ago, and we have now entered into an unalterable engagement with Belgium and Germany to send them butter and beef in increasing quantities at 27/9 and 22/7 per cwt. for beef. It is extremely difficult to confine oneself to Parliamentary language in the presence of a situation of that kind. Nowhere outside of Grangegorman could a policy of that kind be found. If you took any inmate out of Grangegorman lunatic asylum and planted him in Upper Merrion Street, he would evolve a more comprehensive and a more sane policy than the policy which is at present being sponsored by the Minister for Agriculture. The Minister surely must know that he is allowing himself to be used as the whipping boy and the footstool of every political crank in the Party to which he belongs and that he is being used as an instrument to clap down on the backs of our people the political insanity of the man who is leading them.

We were told that wheat and beet are going to revive the falling fortunes of our people. The entire capacity of the Irish people to consume sugar and wheat would account for 760,000 acres of arable land. That is what it would mean if we were to produce all the wheat and beet that our people could consume. We have got to provide for the produce of 12,000,000 acres of arable land. Suppose we do grow all the wheat and beet we need and suppose we grow everything else that the Irish people are in a position to consume, if you pack every Irish stomach as full as a bed tick, you could only employ 5,000,000 acres of arable land and you would have to find a profitable market for the remaining 7,000,000 acres. There is no use bleating about beet and wheat and peat and tobacco. It does not matter a thraneen whether you grow them or not. You may waste money every year, but it can make no permanent difference to the economic welfare of our people unless you can provide a profitable occupation for the 12,000,000 acres of arable land which constitute the only natural resource of this country. It does not matter what subsidies you pay, because the agricultural industry will not be working to the limit of its capacity and will not be fit to maintain the population which has to live upon the land and will not yield the income which it must yield if the economic life of this country is to be maintained.

The Minister expresses some surprise that we are determined to let these two schemes work themselves out, to continue paying the guaranteed price for wheat and beet. There has been a sum of £250,000 spent by way of high-power propaganda—posters, leaflets, grants and encouragements of every kind-to persuade the people that they owe the country some lofty patriotic duty and that they should grow wheat, and they are bewildered into the belief that it is in their own interests to do so. We do not believe in having a revolution every time you change a government in this country. Our point is that we should let the wheat and beet schemes be worked out side by side with the mixed farming, which constitutes the only economic hope of our agricultural industry, and then let the people choose between them. It is vitally necessary that this kind of codology should not be manifesting itself every ten or 20 years. Every time someone escapes from Grangegorman we are likely to have the whole gamut of the wheat and beet policy started off again. It should be allowed to work itself out for good and all. Tell the people that they can grow wheat and beet at the guaranteed price; tell them that they are to keep on doing it until they are as old as Methuselah, but at the same time afford them an opportunity of being able to use their land in an economic way, and I have not the slightest doubt that 95 per cent. of our farmers will avail of the markets provided for them and will use their land to the best advantage, and will extract from it a very much better living than any of them can hope to get out of wheat and beet at present prices, without costing the Exchequer or the consumer one penny by way of subsidy or contribution of any kind.

Some Deputies may say: "Why do you pay for what you do not believe in?" The answer is simple. We pay it because we believe it is worth any money to try out wheat and beet to the bitter end: to let them be tried out on their merits now, once and for all, so that the most obscurantist and insignificant member of the Fianna Fáil Party may see for himself in practice, under his own eyes, the measure of the folly of the policy he has been deluded into promoting for the past five years in this country. I think, Sir, I have come almost within your stricture with regard to repetition in reference to the reasons I have given as to why we have deemed it expedient to allow these grotesque experiments to be worked out to their logical end. The reason, Sir, that I have reiterated these reasons is that, although I have pointed the facts out to the Minister for Agriculture, not once or twice, but many times, I have completely failed to penetrate to his attention. I have, therefore, deliberately chosen words of one of two syllables to make it clear, and I cannot imagine that there now remains a single member of the Fianna Fáil Party that does not really understand the position in regard to those two grotesque undertakings.

I have here some figures, Sir, to which I think the attention of the House should be drawn. Members of the House are as well aware as I am that prices have fallen in the agricultural industry; they know, as well as I do, that output has fallen in the agricultural industry; they are aware that agricultural wages have fallen in the agricultural industry since the Minister came into office. They may not be aware that employment on the land has fallen as substantially as it has since Fianna Fáil came into office.

I remember that, at one time, Deputy Victory fondly believed that planting wheat and beet would result in an immense increase in employment on the land. That used to be one of the reasons that was advanced for those two policies. I want now to direct the attention of the House to the facts. Recently, some provisional figures were published with regard to the number of male workers employed on farm work up to 1st June, 1936. In 1935, the number of persons employed in agricultural labour was 573,351— that is, the total number of male persons. In 1936, that figure had fallen by 13,000 persons, to 560,371. Now, we may leave out of our reckoning persons between 14 and 18 years of age, because I do not think it is a matter of very great economic consequence to this country whether they are employed or not. The people who matter are the males over 18 years of age who are employed, temporarily or permanently, in agriculture. The figures are: Members of families, over 18 years, employed, 377,143; males permanently employed, 85,875; males temporarily employed, 57,642.

I ask the House to remember that over the last few years there has been a special concession made in regard to rates in respect of every male whom you had permanently employed on your land in agricultural labour, and that has resulted, in many cases, in the father of the family giving his son 2/6 or 3/- a week, and his keep, as wages as a permanent agricultural employee on his land, and claiming in respect of that son the rates rebate to which he is entitled in respect of an agricultural labourer employed on the land. That has resulted in a reduction in the numbers of the members of a family employed on the land and in a proportionate increase in the number of persons returned as being permanently employed on the land, but over the five years in which Fianna Fáil has been in office, the number of members of a family employed on the land has increased by about 2,000; the number of permanents has increased by about 1,000, and the number of temporaries has increased, according to this return, by 2,000. However, the total number of persons employed on the land has decreased, over these five years, by about 2,000 persons. The net result is that for the five years no increase in employment is apparent at all, but during the last 12 months there has developed a very marked tendency towards decrease in employment on the land, which suggests, as we have already submitted, that intensive cereal growing, in fact, makes no contribution to increased employment on the land at all, but that mixed farming, such as dairy farming, or any kind of mixed farming such as is carried on in Limerick, South Tipperary and places of that kind, probably gives more employment than any other form of agriculture that has ever been carried on in this country.

Now, I direct the attention of the House to this. The price realised for fat cattle in 1931 was £12,500,000, whereas the price realised for fat cattle in 1936 was £6,500,000—a reduction of £6,000,000. The price realised for sheep in 1931 was £1,900,000, and in 1936 the price was £1,200,000—a reduction of £700,000. The price realised for eggs in 1931 was £2,227,000, and the price for eggs in 1936 was £992,000. We had reduced our export of eggs by £1,200,000. The numbers of eggs exported were 4,609,000 great hundreds in 1931, and in 1936 the numbers were 2,966,000 great hundreds. We had reduced our export of eggs by 1,700,000 great hundreds. In 1931, the value of our exports of butter was £2,086,000. In 1936, it had fallen to £1,917,000 in value. This interesting fact emerges, however, that in 1931, for every cwt. of butter we exported we got 110/6, or £5 10s. 6d., where as in 1936 we got 74/-. Now, in 1931, we were getting, approximately, the world price, I suppose, for butter, because we were then exporting to the British market almost entirely, where the world price was ruling. It had fallen in 1936 to 74/-, and many of the more gullible Fianna Fáil T.D.s believed that that was as a result of a fall in world prices; but the facts are that, when you look to the statistics, you find that the basic price for butter in 1931 was 111/—the world price—and it had fallen to 89/- in 1936.

Now, if we assume—and I think we may—that the price of butter in 1931 was, in fact, 110/6, the interesting fact emerges that about one point in the Statistical Abstract corresponds to 1/- per cwt. in the price of butter, and therefore, while the world price fell from about 111/- in 1931 to 89/- in 1936, the Irish price, or the price Ireland was getting for her exports of butter, fell from 111/- to 74/-. We had dropped 15/- below the world price, and in 1935, two years ago, we were getting 62/5 for our exports of butter while the world was getting 87/- a cwt.—that is, we were getting 23/- less than the world price. I do not not know how the Minister will commend his trade agreements to us in the light of those facts. Remember those prices were partially got as a result of the tariffs levied by Great Britain on our butter going in there and partially as a result of the prices realised on our butter sold on the Continent, but the net result of it was that our butter was getting it in the neck, when this country was using immense sums of money and when our people were paying 1/5 per lb. for butter in order to have the privilege of selling it for 7d. per lb. to people in Great Britain, in Germany and in Belgium. Again I appeal to Deputy Victory; does he agree with me that an agricultural policy which can produce that kind of situation is more reminiscent of Grangegorman——

Comment on this

When you are able to see conditions in this country from the point of view of self-sufficiency, I shall discuss it with you, but not otherwise.

Comment on this

I do not know if Deputy Victory has become a convert to the fallacy of economic self-sufficiency, but if he has I would not advise him to criticise any occupant of Grangegorman, because if he follows that line of thought far enough he may attain to a place in Grangegorman before long.

Comment on this

We will not have to do without sugar for our tea as we had during the Great War, at any rate.

Comment on this

If the Deputy believes in economic self-sufficiency, it is not without sugar only that he will have to do. Even his resources will scarcely grow tea in this country, and though he may drink light beer, as was suggested by the President on one occasion, I do not know whether he will be able to convert his constituents in Longford to that course. The Deputy may return to a wooden plough. He will look very well behind it.

Comment on this

I did more of it than you did, at any rate.

Comment on this

With the wooden plough, I am sure you did. The Deputy may return to a bicycle with wooden wheels, unless he can grow rubber in this country. These are the little things the Deputy forgets. These are the things the Deputy is never asked to think about by his own colleagues or by his own leader. I would suggest that he should ask himself if the policy of economic self-sufficiency, into which he has allowed the Minister to lead him by the nose, is not the greatest nonsense. If he applies his mind impartially to that investigation he will come to the amazing discovery that what he really wants to be doing is supporting Fine Gael and the United Ireland Party, and that it is through the merest misapprehension on his part that he is in the ranks of Fianna Fáil. If he would only think this matter out for himself he would discover the incredible folly into which the country has been driven.

Comment on this

I asked you one question before and you refused to answer it.

Comment on this

What was that?

Comment on this

Do you agree with the policy of John Redmond and your late father regarding the financial relations between this country and Britain? That is the root cause of the economic war.

Comment on this

I would say to the Deputy that I am a great believer in concentrating on the future and in not brooding on the past.

Comment on this

There you are.

Comment on this

As I understand the gospel of the Fianna Fáil Party, with regard to the past, it is that our taxable capacity as compared with that of the British is 66 to 1. If the Deputy wants to start multiplying all the figures I have read out by 66, I should be glad to know of it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Better not.

Comment on this

If I could do anything in that way to illuminate the mind of Deputy Victory, I should be glad to do so, but I doubt if even that would do it. I do not believe that any useful purpose can at this stage be served by criticising the Minister for Agriculture without making a few suggestions to the House as to how the immense damage that he has done to the country during the last few years may be repaired. Fortunately it is not too late to undo the immense damage he has done. The first thing we have got to do is to make a trade agreement with Great Britain. A number of people in this House do not realise what our failure to do that at Ottawa involved us in. It must be said to the credit of the present Minister that he did make a trade agreement at Ottawa.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I denied that here before. I say it is absolutely wrong.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Not a slander.

Comment on this

I say that the Minister entered into some kind of understanding——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No.

Comment on this

——about something——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Not even that.

Comment on this

——which may or may not have been relevant to the trade relations of this country but which certainly left the other party under the impression that it was.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No.

Comment on this

When he came back to this country and submitted its terms to the head of the Government——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I submitted no terms.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Does this not refer to something that happened four or five years ago? We are concerned here with this year's Estimate.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

He has not the decency to withdraw it.

Comment on this

These terms were turned down, and the result of the turning down of these terms has been the disaster into which we have been led and which I propose shortly to describe.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If he had any decency he would not say that.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

You have said it three times. I made no agreement, not even any sort of understanding, with British Ministers. I brought no agreement or understanding home with me.

Comment on this

The Minister came home then.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I did.

Comment on this

The Minister came home and the Minister was accompanied by another Minister there.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Where?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, by two others.

Comment on this

One of them, in any case, had something in the shape of an agreement or a quasi-agreement or an imaginary agreement or a hoped-for agreement which was submitted to the Executive Council, or at least to the President thereof.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is a hope!

Comment on this

That something was brought home and it was turned down.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

There was nothing turned down.

Comment on this

It may have been turned up, but in any case it was not accepted.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy has not the decency to withdraw. He is just trying to wriggle away from it.

Comment on this

In 1931 the trade of the other members of the Commonwealth of Nations with Great Britain had been declining. In 1932 the Ottawa Conference was held and the result was dramatic. In 1931-32 exports from Canada to Great Britain had fallen to £30,000,000. The Ottawa Conference took place, and since then the exports from Canada to Great Britain have risen to £75,000,000.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

In what year?

Comment on this

In 1936. That is the figure taken from the Economist. The last official figure from the British Trade Statistics was about £54,000,000 for 1935. The Economist figure is £75,000,000 for 1936. The Australian trade in 1931 had fallen to £40,000,000. In 1936 it had gone up to £62,000,000. New Zealand trade in 1931 had fallen to about £33,000,000. In 1936 it had gone up to about £43,000,000. The Trade of the Irish Free State with Great Britain had fallen to about £36,000,000 in 1931. It was then higher than the trade of New Zealand or Canada. By 1934 the trade of the Irish Free State had fallen to £17,000,000, and from that up to end of 1936 it had increased to about £20,000,000. But another nation, a member of the Commonwealth, which was doing less trade with Great Britain than we were doing in 1931, is now selling about £75,000,000 worth of stuff to Great Britain every year, while we are selling £20,000,000 worth. Still another country which was doing less trade than we were doing with Great Britain in 1931 is now selling Great Britain about £62,000,000 worth, while we are selling her £20,000,000 worth.

This interesting fact emerges, that if you take the countries outside the Commonwealth of Nations you find that as from the date of the Ottawa Conference our trade dropped in the same proportion as did the trade of France and Holland, two countries which not only did not enjoy the advantage of being members of the Commonwealth, but had both elected to remain on the gold standard and pursue a vigorous deflationary policy, while England had gone off the gold standard and was pursuing an inflationary policy, so the economic war has proved to us as disastrous, as shattering in our foreign trade as the gold policy has proved to France. Since then France, having pledged herself in every conceivable way to remain on gold, has discovered that it is quite impossible to do so without sacrificing her people in such a way as no sane Government would attempt. Holland has learned the same lesson and has abandoned gold. This is the only country which has been hoisted with its petard to the gold of the President's conceit. You can go off the gold standard but you cannot go off the standard of President de Valera's conceit. He wants to show the world that he is right, and was always right, and that everybody else is wrong. Because the world has got to learn that lesson, every unfortunate person down the country has to lower his standard of living and sink lower than he ever has been before. The only purpose being served is the pious one of demonstrating that President de Valera was right and that everybody else was wrong.

If we get that trade agreement, we have an unprecedented opportunity of capturing for this country a wealthier market than has ever been offered us before, and for two reasons; one, because the British Government is now committeed to a policy in conformity with the recommendations of the Commission on nutrition, presided over by Sir John Orr, and that Commission recommends that if the health of the British people is to be maintained, and their physique developed, greatly increased quantities of butter, eggs, milk products, and proteins in the form of fresh meat or bacon must be made available to the masses of the people. Before I pass from that, let me remind Deputies that those are the four commodities which we are most concerned to sell. Secondly, at the same time as the Government has adopted that policy, the Government is spending £1,500,000,000 on armaments, which is going to increase enormously the purchasing capacity of the working people of Great Britain. We can get our share of that market. We can get our share of that immense expenditure for the benefit of our people. I warn the Deputies of this House that if you do not get it by making a trade agreement with the British, producing foodstuffs here and selling them in England, the people will go over to England and will get it for themselves. You will force them into emigration. You are not going to get people to live like paupers in this country, when, by crossing to Liverpool, they can live in comparative prosperity. If the President thinks that he can consecrate the whole populace of this country to the important task of holding up his personal pride and conceit——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The President is not responsible for the administration of this Vote.

Comment on this

Indeed he is, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The President?

Comment on this

Certainly. That poor man there has no responsibility for this.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister for Agriculture is responsible for the administration of this Vote. If the Deputy wants to make any charges or any statements in regard to the President, there is an appropriate Vote on which they can be made; this is not it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

He cannot help being personal and scurrilous.

Comment on this

I say that the whole agricultural policy in this country is being pursued at the dictation of the Executive Council for the purpose of carrying on a political vendetta.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That may be the Deputy's view, but the person responsible to this House for the administration of this money is the Minister for Agriculture. He is the only person whom this House can hold responsible.

Comment on this

In any case, Sir, it is very easy to make the case that the Minister is subordinating the interests of the people to those of the political purposes which I have just mentioned, but the matter is not worth pursuing. It is essential, however, for our people to realise that they have got to make their choice. It is essential to realise that we have either got to get that market for our people or our people will fly out of the country and get it for themselves. I want to see this country prosperous. I want to see this country made a success of, and I am perfectly certain that if we pursue our present course we will become a bankrupt and contemptible appendix of Great Britain; our people, before the whole world, will emigrate in hundreds of thousands to Great Britain; we will be left clamouring before the world that England is in a conspiracy to undo us, and the world will simply laugh at us in the knowledge that the vast majority of our people are going to England, getting work in England and sending the money that they earn there home to their people in this country. If any Deputy in this House considers that is a dignified international position for this country to take up, I shall be glad to hear him. To me, it is a grotesque and horrible humiliation. There is only one sane way out, and that is to restore the prosperity that can be got for our people in this country. The most effective way to do that is to recover that market for our people, and let the people exploit it themselves.

Assuming that that is done, there are some detailed matters about which I wish to ask the Minister a few categorical questions. He spoke of horse-breeding and of an extra expenditure under that head. He spoke of purchasing certain stallions to be put in a classic category. What type of stallions are they to be? Surely it is not suggested that stallions of the racehorse type should be hired out to the farmers of the country. I cannot believe that that is going to do the horse-breeding industry any real service at all. I would like to know is it the intention of the Department definitely to condemn as a sire any horse with faulty breeding—with broken wind. There are people who take the view that if a man has a licensed horse it will be condemned if it has broken wind, but that if there is a Department sire in a farmer's possession that he will be allowed to go on using that sire even though it is broken-winded.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No.

Comment on this

Now, it would be well if the Minister would definitely say whether he accepts as certainly right the view that broken-windedness is a hereditary taint, and that therefore the Department has made up its mind to prohibit the use of such sires altogether. I understand that there is a bona fide difference of opinion on that question, and that it has never been definitely ascertained whether broken-windedness is a hereditary taint or not. But, whatever the objective truth in that question may be, it would be well if the Department would let it be known very explicitly what their view is, the view on which they propose to act in the future. The Minister spoke of a special bounty of £50 which was to be paid to farmers to induce them to keep as whole horses colts bred under certain circumstances. I would like to know will the colts eligible for that bounty be exclusively the progeny of Department sires, or can any farmer submitting a colt for examination to the Department claim that bounty?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, provided he is qualified.

Comment on this

I am glad to see in the Estimate this year that increased money is being provided for the Veterinary College. I would very strongly urge on the Minister the desirability of considering a very much more comprehensive departure in respect of veterinary medicine in this country. Ten or 11 years ago we lost the opportunity of having established in this country a Roman bureau of agricultural statistics. I think it would have been a matter of great consequence in this country if we had succeeded in getting it established here. I believe it would be of material advantage to the country if Ireland came to be known as an international centre of veterinary research. I believe that our farmers would benefit directly from that by having the peculiar problems of this country considered and examined by a very highly competent body of international scientists. I would, therefore, suggest to the Minister that we should have in this country as fine a veterinary teaching and research college as money can provide. I suggest the Government should provide for that college endowments adequate to attract to it the most distinguished veterinarians in the world, and that we should regard it not only as a school for our own farmers and veterinary students, but as an advertisement and a source of information to assist the Department of Agriculture in combating certain problems that beset the live-stock industry in this country at the present time.

There are three such difficulties. One is contagious abortion. I do not want to dwell on that because I know that the Minister is as much concerned about the solution of that problem as anybody else can be. I know the immense difficulties in the way. A great deal of work remains to be done before it is satisfactorily disposed of. But I do want to sound this note of warning. There has been brought under my attention recently a circular that has been sent around by some kind of chemical firm in London alleging that it has discovered specific cures for contagious abortion and endeavouring, by implication, to connect them with certain work that has been done in London on streptococci infections there. It is an extremely specious document and steps ought to be taken to prevent its being widely circulated in this country, or else follow it up and expose its wholly fraudulent character because, as far as I can find out, the so-called specific cure has no merit and no scientific foundation whatever.

Cartarrhal vaginitis in cattle is becoming an immense plague in the West of Ireland. It is resulting in not less than 50 per cent. of the cattle failing to become pregnant in the Province of Connacht. Now, the loss that that situation involves in the case of a small farmer who depends for his income on three or four cows is immense. The problem is formidable. I believe that one cure, which is almost specific, has been discovered, but unfortunately it requires the intervention of a veterinary surgeon to administer it. I urge on the Minister the necessity of research in regard to this matter, because the losses in which people are being involved by a continuation of this trouble amongst cattle must be immense.

I would like the Minister to requisition information from our Veterinary College as to whether any practical use can be made of recent discoveries in connection with drugs in Great Britain which have been found there to be a specific for strepticoccus haemolyticus. I am informed that strepticoccus, which is usually responsible for mammitis in cows, results very frequently in material injury to good cows and, as the Minister knows, it is the best milker that is most likely to get a sore udder. Not only does it result in very grave injury to cows, but I should not be at all surprised if many of the infections arising from unsatisfactory milk come from cows who are in the initial stages of this streptococci mammitis. If it were discovered that this drug which has been used for streptococci infections in human beings and rats with immense success in the last 12 months could be adapted for use with cattle, its value could not be exaggerated. The remarkable thing about this preparation, so far as the literature issued in connection with it goes, is that its administration seems to be very easy to standardise, and is quite possible of application by an ordinary farmer without calling in a veterinary surgeon on every occasion when it is necessary to treat a beast.

I suggest to the Minister that the development of plant breeding is very backward in the country at the present time and that we ought to press forward in that matter with a view to adapting certain crops to the climate of this country which are at present ungrowable here. When we do that I want to ask him if he would not consider the desirability of trying out the conclusions come to as a result of experiments under practical working conditions on demonstration farms. It is a terrible pity that so much of the work done in Glasnevin and in the scientific laboratories of the Department of Agriculture is never reported to the farmers at all. There is plenty of information to be had in the Department of Agriculture that the average farmer never hears about. The only way you can get the information out to the average farmer is by having demonstration farms in rural Ireland, carried on and operated under conditions to which the small farmer is himself accustomed.

There is no use telling the small farmer that it is profitable to grow onions commercially in Glasnevin, because he believes that it may be profitable in Glasnevin but it is not going to pay a profit in Lanesboro' or Strokestown. If you, however, establish a farm in or about Elphin and show farmers there that you can grow onions and sell them profitably to the neighbouring shopkeepers, you will have farmers coming from all parts of Roscommon to see that being done and to copy it themselves, if they are once convinced it can be successfully done in conditions under which they themselves have to work. I know that, because I have seen it. I have experienced myself the reluctance to venture on plans or schemes suggested in the Department of Agriculture's circulars. I had the additional difficulty of persuading men working for me on the land to believe a single word in these leaflets. It is almost enough in some cases that a certain course of conduct should be recommended in a Department leaflet to get a countryman to say: "That must be wrong," and to do the other thing. That is a difficulty against which the Department cannot labour except through the instrumentality of the demonstration farm.

For instance, I should like the potentialities of the soya bean to be investigated. At present, so far as I know, no variety of the soya bean tried out in Glasnevin or elsewhere will come to maturity here. In the State of Vermont in the United States the whole population are going in for the cultivation of the soya bean and the uses to which that product can be turned are perfectly astonishing. They are too many to recite here, but the soya bean, if it could be made to grow in this country, would be an immense source of wealth to our people. I should be glad to know from the Minister whether any recent developments have taken place in connection with that matter.

I am sorry the cheese business has been developed so far almost entirely along the line of the factory production. I do not believe we will ever get anywhere with factory cheese. The kind of stuff produced in factories is not the best for Ireland—it never can be. No person who likes cheese will ever eat it. I do not by any means say that the factories ought to be discouraged, but they are not the most important end of the business. I should like to see cheese produced in this country on the same lines as farmers' butter. Then you will get characteristic cheeses; you will get cheeses that will stand on their own merits anywhere, and which will build up for themselves the same kind of a trading reputation as the special cheeses of England, Italy, France and Holland in the world over at the present time.

I suggest to the Minister that the journal of the Department of Agriculture should be published monthly instead of annually. I doubt if many people see it. The journal of the British Department of Agriculture is published every month and is a most useful and interesting periodical. The journal of our Department is an extremely interesting document, too, but, to tell the honest truth, until recently I did not know it existed. I suggest to the Minister that at least he ought to secure that it should be circulated to Deputies, which it is not at present. A great many less interesting and less valuable documents are so circulated.

The last matter to which I want to refer is to make a further reference to the demonstration farms which I have already mentioned. I believe that they could be made invaluable, (1) for communicating to farmers the knowledge that the Department has; (2) that they should be used as centres to which farmers could send their children as apprentices. At present, if a farmer wants his child trained and cannot afford to send him to the university or to the technical school, he binds him as an apprentice to some tradesman or shopkeeper or something of that sort. When the boy has finished his apprenticeship, he has to look for a job. If he has been in a good house he may find little difficulty in getting a job, but if he has not, he may find it very hard, indeed. Why should not we, if we had demonstration farms of this kind, allow farmers to bind their children to the agricultural instructor or the man in charge of the farm? If a boy serves three years on such a farm under a practical farmer, learning under the conditions obtaining on his own father's place the art of husbandry and farming, would he not be a very valuable man? I think he would. I think that as he grows older, having been accustomed to the Department of Agriculture's ways and made familiar with the Department of Agriculture's sources of information, he will be a very much better farmer than you can hope to make him at the present time.

He would learn the practical methods of abating the nuisances that manifested themselves on the holding where he was brought up and would, in addition to learning a great deal himself from his apprenticeship, serve to teach the Department of Agriculture a good deal by communicating to the instructors, under whom he would be working on these farms, the kind of difficulties he often heard his father complain of on the holding where he was born and bred. You have to remember that one of the greatest difficulties of agricultural instructors is that the farmer will not believe the instructor, and the instructors, very frequently, do not know what the farmer's troubles are. I believe strongly in bringing the farmers and the Department closer together. I believe that both have a great deal to give to one another; and I think the demonstration farms, to which I have referred, might play no small part in producing that very desirable alliance.

Comment on this

As Deputy Dillon made a very complete survey of the position of agriculture, what remains can be said very briefly. Farmers will read with amazement the speech made by the Minister for Agriculture this evening. If the Minister is able to convince them, even his own followers, that they are prosperous, I will be amazed. The Minister did not exactly say that they were prosperous. He said the farmers were badly off.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I knew you would say that.

Comment on this

The Minister said that they were better off than they would be under Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Than they would be.

Comment on this

That is a prophecy. I am sure they will be amazed when they read it. The farmers are not all as thick as the Minister thinks. There are farmers, even amongst the Minister's Party, who are amazed at the way he has neglected them. They thought that, at least, the Minister for Agriculture would interest himself in some settlements which would be favourable to them, so that they would not be kept always in the front line trenches. Even those who were amongst the Minister's supporters— and some of them may be supporters of his yet—thought when the Coal-Cattle Pact and the horse-sugar pact was being arranged that the Minister should have appeared in person, to see that these pacts were properly made in the interests of the people. Farmers will be amazed when they read the Minister's speech pointing out how well off they are. Of course, he qualified his remarks by saying that he knew they were not well off. According to the figures the Minister gave, they must be well off. When he gives figures, the Minister always takes care to add the bounties and the subsidies. Is not that a rather sad state of affairs? I do not think many people believe that the full benefit of subsidies and bounties is given to the producers. The Minister has to add these figures to balance what has already been taken from the people in some shape or form. They believe in the country that what he gives by way of subsidies and bounties has been already extracted from them by way of taxation, customs duties and other things.

Every single item people have to buy is taxed, so that the Minister may have the money to recoup the losses sustained because of the so-called economic war. I do not generally read the Irish Press, but a supporter of the Minister called my attention to a speech that he delivered recently at Wynn's Hotel, in which he dealt with agriculture. This man told me it was evident the Minister was making a speech on agriculture to non-agricultural people, in other words, to city people. That man was quite right. He was a supporter of the Minister, but I am afraid he is not a supporter of his to-day. To my mind that speech was the most damning indictment of the Fianna Fáil policy that could possibly be made. Speaking to a Dublin audience, he told them of the things that Fianna Fáil had done for agriculture. He told them about wheat growing. It is evident he was not speaking to people who are engaged in agriculture, because he said:

"He did not believe there was any single industry that could be nearly as good, and he doubted if there was any industry that could employ even 25 per cent. of the number, as in the growing of their own wheat."

That speech was made to a city audience. The Minister would not go to the country and make it, because the growing of wheat does not give employment except to a limited extent. Any other crop, even turnips or mangolds, provided for fattening live stock, or grain ground up for live stock, gives five times as much employment as wheat-growing. The Minister knows that.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Indeed I do not.

Comment on this

The Minister thinks that putting in a crop of wheat, taking it out, and having it threshed, gives as much employment as crops grown for fattening live stock. Of course it does not. But this is part of the Fianna Fáil political humbug, and the farce must be kept up.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It gives more employment than is provided by a bag of flour from Canada.

Comment on this

I agree. The Minister did not say that it gave more employment, but that he did not believe there was any single industry that could employ even 25 per cent. of the number engaged in the growing of wheat.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Over £6,000,000.

Comment on this

The Minister said that no other Irish industry could employ even 25 per cent. of the number engaged in the growing of wheat.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is true.

Comment on this

Nonsense! Here is the real condemnation of the Fianna Fáil policy, where the Minister, when referring to wheat growing, said:

"England, in pursuance of her policy of free trade and of building up her industrial exports, abolished the corn laws, thereby withdrawing the protection from corn growers afforded within the United Kingdom as it then was. In face of open competition from resources abroad, it was absolutely uneconomic for the Irish farmer to produce grain, and he had to turn to the production of cattle and live-stock products as items that could be produced in competition."

It is a pity the Minister would not let it go on.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy quoted that during another debate the other day, and I asked him to give the whole history.

Comment on this

The whole history of what?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The whole history.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

In reality we can only discuss at present what the Minister said in the House.

Comment on this

The Minister was referring to the year 1847, the year of the famine.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is a long time ago.

Comment on this

At that time, in the Minister's own words, the people found that it was absolutely uneconomic to grow wheat. Transport communications have been brought up to date since then. In 1840 it took months to bring a cargo of grain from other countries. Notwithstanding the undeveloped resources of the world at that time, the people found it uneconomic to produce grain. As the Minister said, they found that it was live stock, and live-stock products, they could produce in competition. I say "Hear, hear" to that.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Can they do it now?

Comment on this

The Minister was quite right there.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Can they do it to-day?

Comment on this

They can. They can produce live stock and live-stock products better than any other part.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Is butter economic?

Comment on this

I am talking of live stock and live-stock products. The Minister can single out any item and say that on the whole it does not pay. The Minister knows that this is an agricultural country.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Every country is.

Comment on this

This is the live stock country. We are favoured by God and by nature for the production of live stock. No live stock in the world can compare with the Irish live stock, and the Minister knows that. Other items in the Minister's speech show that when he goes to a city audience he tells them what suits them regarding agriculture. He would not go down the country and make that speech.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Why not?

Comment on this

Not at all. He gets his own supporters and tells them all this humbug.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is a good word.

Comment on this

He told them the same with regard to bacon. It is interesting to see the figures that were given regarding pigs and bacon. It was interesting to see the manner in which the Minister gave the figures, and how hard it was to get the real figures from him. Although he represented that we were getting a much better export trade for bacon, he did not tell us, until it was dragged out of him, that we were £200,000 down compared with 1931, on bacon production.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We are not losing on it.

Comment on this

We are not making on it compared with 1931. The last figures from the statistical abstract for 1936 show that we have 100,000 less pigs than we had in 1931. At this meeting at which he spoke the Minister boasted of the fact that he had stopped the importation of bacon.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Is not that right?

Comment on this

Yes. There is only one test as to whether the recent export of Irish bacon has been a success, and that test is the live pigs that are being reared. If we were importing bacon, and if at the same time we reared a larger number of pigs than was represented by the imported bacon, then it was better to let the imported bacon come in. There is only one good result to be gained from stopping the imports of bacon, and that is to increase pig production. We have not done that. We have decreased production. It is an extraordinary situation. Bacon value for over £1,000,000 was formerly imported, and one would imagine that in order to fill that gap, and seeing that we have increased our exports, we would be rearing more pigs. We are not. What has happened, I wonder?

Comment on this

If you allow a free market for imported bacon here, how are you going to guarantee the farmers a fixed price for their bacon?

Comment on this

I am not advocating any such thing. I am putting it to the test of success, to the test of criticism—that is all. If we reared in this country 1,227,000 pigs in 1931 and if, at the same time, we imported over £1,000,000 worth of bacon, and if to-day, between what we are using in this country without any importation, plus our increased export, we have only 1,087,000 pigs, there is only one conclusion to be drawn and that is that the people of this country cannot afford bacon.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Will the Deputy take the years 1929 and 1930?

Comment on this

I cannot.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy has taken the peak year of pig production in this country.

Comment on this

I took 1931, when Fianna Fáil came into power.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is the highest year of pig production.

Comment on this

Perhaps, but I took that year and the figure for the last year I got in the statistical abstract.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It is the peak year.

Comment on this

Let it be anything it likes. I should like the Minister to make the case I am trying to make now and to explain to the House how it is that, although we have increased our export of bacon and cut out the importation of bacon, we have not increased our pigs.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We have, though, except for that peak year.

Comment on this

Not to any extent. If we take our increased exports of bacon out of it, it will be found that we have not increased our pigs to that extent.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Our consumption.

Comment on this

And our consumption has apparently gone down, and gone down considerably.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is true.

Comment on this