Bunreacht na hEireann (Dréacht)—Coiste (d'ath-thógaint).
Contributions 126–259 of 259. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
If that is the position on the one hand, as far as labour is concerned, does it not also apply at the other end as far as business and industry are concerned?
Comment on this
Deputy Norton has an amendment on the Order Paper— amendment No. 126—in which he proposes that "in the interest of the community restrictions may be imposed by law on the formation and conduct of profit-making enterprises or associations". The way we propose to deal with that amendment is to say that it is covered by this clause. There may be dangers in certain directions, and is the Legislature to be prevented from making laws in the interests of the community? In the present social conditions are we to be told that the Legislature must not have that power: that every form of organisation and association, no matter whether it is in the public interest or not, must be allowed to operate?
Comment on this
No. There is a question of wide public interest, and the Legislature may have to regulate, in the general public interest, the formation of associations of that kind. I think it would be unwise, in the present condition of things, to say that the Legislature must not be able to regulate the formation of associations when those associations conflict with the general public interest. I think that we would be simply blinding ourselves to obvious facts if we did that. Deputy Norton calls out for it in one case, but there may be other cases where the regulation of the formation of associations may have to be looked after in the public interest. Consequently, this is giving a power to the Legislature, a power which I believe is necessary in the present condition of things. It would be ridiculous for us to say that we should shackle ourselves just at the time when the greatest freedom of action by the Legislature is necessary on behalf of the public. We have very serious problems of a social character to deal with. You cannot foresee completely the most effective way of dealing with them, but surely you should, in the interest of the community, allow the Legislature to be free to deal with them and not have it tied up with Constitutional restrictions. The purpose of the Article is to make the way open so that the Legislature can do that in the way best calculated to serve the public interest.
Comment on this
I think the President has unwittingly let his real mind be known to the House on this matter. I think the mentality in the Government regarding this particular part of the Article, referred to by Deputy Norton, may be traced back to the transport strike here in Dublin. We know what the Government's mind was on that strike. I think that the Government, through one of its Ministers, let the trade union movement in this country know what its mind was. I do not think I am going too far in saying that, subsequent to that strike, the Government delivered what was almost an ultimatum to the trade unions as to setting their house in order, and that it was intimated to the trade unions that if they themselves did not take certain action, then the Government would be forced to do so. In my opinion, this is the most serious part of this Article. From a practical point of view, it is even more serious than the first part which was under discussion yesterday and for the greater part of to-day.
The President talks about the Government or the Legislature taking action in the public interest. As we know in this country, and particularly so to-day, the Government is the Legislature when it comes to taking action. It is the Government that will decide what is, and what is not, in the public interest. It can decide to ban an association, trade union or group if it decides that it is in the public interest to do so, although it may be far from the public interest to take the action that the Government determines to take. I think it ought to be quite clear now, if it has not been long before this, that all the talk we have heard both inside and outside of this House from the occupants of the Government Front Bench as to their sympathy with trade unions, with working men, and their desire to see associations formed for the protection of the workers, was all nonsense.
Comment on this
It never went out on a strike-breaking campaign like the Deputy's Party did when in office.
Comment on this
The Deputy ought to remember what happened in his own constituency and ought not to rush in here. He is on very thin ice now.
Comment on this
It would be more to the point if the Deputy would read the Constitution. If he would do that and listen to the President he would learn that there is more danger to trade unions in this country in this Article than there is in any file in any Government office.
Comment on this
Deputy Tom Kelly's absolute blind faith in the President and the Government is something to be admired.
Comment on this
I certainly admire the loyalty of the Deputy. He cannot conceive of the President doing anything wrong.
Comment on this
And I am quite sure that if Deputy Kelly thought the President was doing anything wrong he would address a few words to the President on the matter and try to put him back on the right path. That, however, is what is wrong. The President is never wrong, in his own opinion, and he is probably never wrong in Deputy Kelly's opinion also. However, I want Deputy Cooney, who has, I know, a keen interest in the trade unions and in trade union conditions, to address himself to this particular Article of the Constitution, to read it carefully, to listen——
Comment on this
Let the Deputy give us his interpretation now and again. Let us hear Deputy Cooney on it.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey is entitled to make his speech without interruption, just as other Deputies are entitled to do so.
Comment on this
Well, Sir, this is the nearest that Deputy Cooney came to speaking, and perhaps he should not be discouraged.
Comment on this
Well, I was hoping to elicit and encourage the support of old trade unionists like Deputy Cooney. Many years ago I remember hearing him thumping the table and holding forth very eloquently against the oppression the trade unions were suffering under. At the Trades Union Congress there was no more eloquent member of that Congress than Deputy Cooney.
Comment on this
Well, I do not know if that Party is still in existence. However, I want to make the point, and I want to repeat it, that I believe —and the President blurted it out——
Comment on this
Interpreted by the President, mind you. Just imagine this thing being left in the Constitution to be interpreted by the President in the next Parliament, say.
Comment on this
We know what the President told us last night. He wants those powers for himself, just as he wants certain other powers in the Constitution for himself.
Comment on this
Well, I hope that it will be only a political grave, but he is not going to remain here. He is either going up a step or he is going down, but he is not going to remain as Leader of this House.
Comment on this
Oh, it is the people who will do it, not we; and they are waiting the chance to do it. The only thing is that the people are absolutely impatient at the amount of time that is being taken to deal with this Constitution, Sir, and, therefore, as I do not desire to take up any further time in standing between the people and their verdict, I shall sit down.
Comment on this
Of course, it must be obvious to people who are talking about this thing being directed against trade unions and the right of the citizens to form associations and unions that, if you want to have a power such as Deputy Norton is seeking, you must have the powers to legislate in these matters. It is ridiculous to say that the powers are being directed against one group rather than against another group. These are general powers, and we do not know in what direction it may be necessary to use them.
Comment on this
The big point is still that it is a general power to be adjudicated upon by an Executive. It is a power which can be operated by an Executive which wants to do something and which can get laws passed inside the term "public order and morality". In that connection, I am assuming all the time that the word "public" carries forward from "order" to "morality" in the Preamble to this. I notice that in the Irish text the adjective is attached to the other words, but I think that is because the adjective always comes last. The only way to reconcile the two is on the ground that the word "public" applies both to the word "morality" and the word "order". That being so, what does "morality" cover? Would it cover such things as the abuse of the power of forming associations? Would it come anywhere near the phrase "in the public interest"? I think it would come very close. Is it intended to be something near that? If it is, and if it does approach to something near, then the only point of distinction and the only reason for bringing this in is that, when you get a judgment on "order and morality," it will not be an Executive operating from a Legislature that will be the judges; it will be somebody outside. But when you get this other phrase, it means that, even though it is contrary to public order and morality, laws may be passed with regard to the restriction of the exercise of the right.
The whole purpose of this parenthesis is to get away from the courts— not to have people sitting outside in an impartial spirit interpreting whether some law is governed by the phrase "public order or morality," but to have it here so that the Executive of a Party, working through a majority in the House, can get laws passed which will enable some member of the Executive Council to declare that, according to his view of what is the public interest, various things may be done. The only change really that we get in these three lines from the Preamble phrase—public order and morality—is that change of whether to have some outside body decide or to have a Minister decide what is in the public interest. Do you want to have the courts decide on whether the right to form associations is being abused, or do you want a Minister to be given power to say, "My view is that that particular kind of thing should be stopped"? Once that law is passed, you cannot go to the courts on the ground that that law is unconstitutional because once it goes into the Constitution, then, even though it is not contrary to public order and morality the Minister gets powers to do something in the public interest.
Comment on this
I should certainly vote against any law giving a Minister power to determine what was a proper association or not. I do not believe that such a law would have the faintest chance of being passed.
Comment on this
But if the law be passed, these words being there, the courts are excluded. I am all the time arguing with Deputies and asking them do they think it right that in the matter of these fundamental liberties— the part we are dealing with is headed "Fundamental Rights"—do they desire that these fundamental rights should eventually, in the last resort, be subject to the test of the courts, or do they want it to be left to what some Minister thinks is in the public interest? I only allude to it as a possibility, because it is a possibility.
Comment on this
It is not so much between the courts and the Minister as between the courts and the Legislature, and where it is a matter between the courts and the Legislature I would be in favour of the latter each time.
Comment on this
Well, then, the Deputy will go for the courts, because this is certainly a diminution of the rights of the Legislature.
Comment on this
No. If you have a written Constitution at all, you must have the courts to interpret it. I think it is not necessary to have a written Constitution, but if you are going to have one I should like to put as little in it as possible. I do not believe at all in trying to tie future legislators as much as you can, and as much as Deputy McGilligan, apparently, wants to tie them.
Comment on this
Is it tying them to say that these fundamental rights are subject to public order and morality? Is it a very big restriction to put on them to say that that is the governing phrase and that we will get an independent body to interpret? Evidently the Deputy would like to oust the courts from the guardianship of the fundamental rights in the Constitution.
Comment on this
I understood Deputy MacDermot to be one of the people who was enamoured of this phrase of checks and balances. At least, he used to be when he was on the other benches. He may now have shed his faith in that as he shed his membership of the Party.
Comment on this
For the past week it was very necessary to remind people of it, but I do not happen to be one of the people who used to talk about it. I am not saying that it is a bad phrase.
Comment on this
Now everybody has a choice in knowing where the Deputy stands. As has been pointed out to the President when the previous sections of this Article were being discussed, the overriding condition, in the guaranteeing of certain liberties to citizens, is that they must exercise these liberties all the time subject to public order and morality. It seems to me that in that overriding condition set out in the opening sentence of the section, the Executive Council has all the powers that might reasonably be required. The President, however, is not satisfied with that. He wants in addition to give the Executive Council powers within the confines of the Party meeting room——
Comment on this
We can discuss the relevancy of it when we come to it. The President wants in this sub-section to enable powers to be conferred on the Executive Council to enact legislation providing for the regulation and control in the public interest of the right to form associations and trade unions. Of course, what that means is that the Executive Council of the day, having an obedient majority behind it, will be able to secure an endorsement of its proposals from the Party machine and to steamroll them through this Assembly, even though a fraction of the members probably will not know what the legislation is about, and will pay as little attention to it as many of them are paying to the provisions of this Constitution. That is the situation with which we may be confronted if this Article is passed in its present form. I, therefore, object to the inclusion of this limiting sentence because it gives power to an Executive Council with a bare majority behind it in this Assembly, to pass legislation which may be a serious invasion of long-recognised rights held by trade unions. Some of the provisions of that legislation may enable the Minister to come in to exercise further functions, without his action in that respect being restrainable by the courts.
In the United States it used to be possible, when an industrial dispute took place, for employers' organisations to get the court to sequestrate union funds. In that way the employers were able, because of the peculiar legislation that existed, to render the use of organised power by the trades unions entirely ineffective. It may be possible under the legislation contemplated here to give power to the Minister, in any circumstances in which he may think fit, to apply to the court to sequestrate union funds which are being used to finance an industrial dispute. It may be possible in that legislation to give the Minister power to proscribe a strike in any particular industry, in any particular service, or in any group of particular services. Of course, many of the utterances of members of the Government give grounds for considerable fears in that respect. The Department of Industry and Commerce or the Minister did not come out of the tramway strike in this city with any great credit from the trade unions' standpoint. We had in the course of the strike what was tantamount to an ultimatum by the Minister, telling the union that he would not exercise his normal functions as mediator unless the workers on strike went back to work.
Comment on this
That is one of the dangers of this section, and it is the same Executive Council that is asking us to pass this Draft Constitution.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce did say at a public lecture that there were too many trade unions in this country in his opinion. If this section is allowed to stand in its present form, what is to prevent the Minister passing a law to restrict the number of trade unions in the country? Surely we can allude to that?
Comment on this
I have allowed the Deputy to allude to the probable genesis of this idea, but to extend it to the extent to which Deputy Norton has sought to extend it is a thing the Chair could not allow.
Comment on this
I think you will agree, Sir, that I spent scarcely a minute in referring to this matter, and the Minister's attitude towards the trade unions, I think, necessitated my recalling it. As Deputy McGilligan has pointed out, we had a subsequent declaration by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, at a meeting to which he was invited in his capacity as Minister, foreshadowing legislation affecting trade unions. The Minister's speech on that occasion occasioned grave disquiet amongst the trade union movement, which had every reason to fear that the manner and the matter of the speech indicated the imposition of restrictions on trade unions. Now we have the President coming along some time after that action and that statement by the Minister, indicating that it is desirable to give the Legislature power to enact laws regulating and controlling the exercise of the rights of citizens to form trade unions. One of the reasons given in favour of putting this sentence into this Draft Constitution is that somebody might desire to restrict trade. That is the case for giving the Legislature this power.
Comment on this
The President's mind is revealed in instalments. Probably if we managed to spend until next December on this Constitution, we would then know clearly what the President has in mind.
Comment on this
I have read the text very carefully, but I am afraid I cannot follow the President even yet. The President says that the phrase "public order and morality" is not wide enough, that he is not satisfied to allow organisations to be formed subject to the overriding consideration that they must conform to public order and morality——
Comment on this
——and that he wants, in addition, to get some further powers and restrictions over the right to form associations and trade unions.
Comment on this
Let the President defend his own Constitution. Little as the President knows about the dangers of some portions of it, he at least knows ten times as much as Deputy MacDermot. The President is not satisfied with having inserted in this Article a provision that the formation of associations and unions shall be subject to public order and morality. He says that is not wide enough, and he wants some wider powers for regulating the formation of associations and unions. He, therefore, proposes that he should have power to regulate the formation of associations and unions, and control them in the public interest. Of course, "the public interest" is so wide a term that it might well mean, when translated into legislative action, that the unions had practically no rights and no powers whatever. The President says, of course, like the just man, "trust me." The President's whole attitude on this is "trust me."
Comment on this
It is a repeating seven in this case. What assurance have the unions that this particular phrase will not be used in such a manner as to enable legislation to be introduced proscribing the right of unions to withdraw their labour; proscribing them alternately from withdrawing their labour in the case of public services, or in the case of transport, or the variety of other industries in which the Government are shareholders? That is the danger which trade unions see in this particular section. The President wants a wider power than that set out at the commencement of this section. Not satisfied with ensuring that the unions must conform to public order and public morality, he wants in addition to ensure that they will be controlled in the public interest. That may mean the withdrawal from the unions of many of the rights which they have got.
The President's statement about its being desirable to interfere in order to avoid restriction of trade, the attitude of the Minister for Industry and Commerce during the transport dispute in Dublin, and the Minister's subsequent intimation that he intended to introduce legislation dealing with the position of unions, because there were too many unions, and that certain other matters required to be adjusted, legislatively, convince the unions that the Government has under contemplation proposals which, if they are to take the form of the utterances to which I have just referred, must inevitably mean the restriction of the rights which trade unions have enjoyed for generations.
Comment on this
I do not know exactly whether Deputy Norton is letting loose a hare or a number of hares.
Comment on this
But I am referring to Deputy Norton's speech. It is a very able speech indeed, and a very clever one.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy and Deputy Norton have been quarrelling lately; they may have been shadowboxing. What is the position to be, from the public interest point of view, for instance, if an association or associations have a general strike? I can see that there are needs of definite safeguards for the public interest. At the same time I can see that there may be, from the trade unions' point of view, an anxiety intermingled in it that there may be a restriction of the trade unions' rights. Obviously the public interest must be protected. One has only to go back to 1926 and see what happened in Great Britain, when the whole community was held up by a general strike. If the Government had the power at that time the trouble would never have occurred. If the trade union leaders—one has read a good deal of their statements on it, and some of the biographies afterwards—had realised that Sir John Simon was going to come along and declare it illegal, that general strike would not have taken place. The public would have been saved, and the trade union members themselves would have been saved. Deputy MacDermot says it is better to have a written Constitution, but if you have a written Constitution you must have something in it guaranteeing the public interest in certain eventualities that may arise, as, for instance, a general strike.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Norton must be trying to put off the general election until next December, because even from him I have never heard such unblushing repetition as there was in his speeches on this particular amendment. A system of checks and balances does not mean you are to tie yourself up so tightly with red tape that you cannot move hand or foot, and that is the danger which Deputy Norton seems to have lost sight of. On almost every Article of the Constitution on which he speaks he is advocating that we should tie ourselves up tightly with red tape and bind the Legislature——
Comment on this
Nobody is proposing to muzzle the citizen or to handcuff him. Nobody is introducing a law at the present moment for the restriction of the liberty of an association. What is being done is to say that when we are laying down the fundamental principle of the liberty of association, it is desirable to take note of the fact that the liberties of certain associations may sometimes have to be restricted by law, by the Legislature in its wisdom, with the full democratic consent of a democratic House. Deputy Norton must know that in America, where very important democratic measures had to be carried through by the actual President of the United States, the interests of the people were very gravely endangered by the fact that he found himself tied up with red tape in just the same way that Deputy Norton is trying to tie us up with red tape here.
Comment on this
Maybe, but also by the Supreme Court interpreting an unduly rigid and detailed Constitution, and it is exactly an unduly rigid Constitution that Deputy Norton is trying to impose upon us here. It was only the merest prudence on the part of those who drafted this Constitution to leave room for such contingencies as may arise in the life of every nation. We must not suppose that every Legislature which is to follow us is to be a Legislature that cannot be trusted. We have no right to adopt that superior attitude to posterity. The Irish people will have just as much right to legislate for themselves when we have gone as they have when we are here. In any case, Deputy Norton has ruined every particle of plausibility that there might be in his argument by the fact that he himself has put down an amendment restricting a certain kind of association.
Comment on this
It would be just like Deputy MacDermot not to see the difference between a profit-making undertaking and a trade union movement.
Comment on this
I see that a profit-making association is an association. I am perfectly well aware that Deputy Norton thinks all members of profit-making associations, if not actually depraved, are well on the road to being depraved; whereas members of every trade union, if not angels, are the next thing to angels. That is not the point of view of everybody, and I for one would prefer to take the view that the possibilities of depravity are about equal in the two cases. What we have to do is to hold the balance fairly between all classes of the community. I do think it is thoroughly possible that associations might arise which did not offend against public morality, and yet which might in the interests of the people have to be restricted. I suggest that Deputy Norton thinks so, too, unless he goes so far as to say that a profit-making association is ipso facto one that offends against public morality.
Comment on this
At the beginning I wish to say that if in Deputy MacDermot's opinion Deputy Norton is going to keep this thing going until December, I think Deputy MacDermot is already obviously anticipating a seven years' Parliament, as referred to in the Constitution, and is taking up as much time of the House as if we had seven years to consider it.
Comment on this
I know that the Deputy assumes he is never wrong and I will not waste my time contradicting him. My simple view of a Constitution is that it is a document which lays down clearly the rights of citizens. It is a document which declares beyond yea or nea what rights they are to have, and it should not be utilised in order to lay down for all time a mass of restrictions on the liberty of the people. If it is the President's intention, as it is obviously, that it might be necessary by law at some time, either in the near future or in the distant future, to restrict the right of citizens to form unions and associations, then, why have anything in the Constitution giving the citizens the right to form associations and unions when, in fact, the next clause asserts the right of the Government to take that right from the people? Is not the honest way and the decent way to do it to cut out the reference to the people having any right in that direction, and to leave them dependent on whatever rights the law may or may not give them in the future? That is what we are doing here. One step forward, three steps back. That is characteristic of every Article in this Constitution that gives any right to anybody. In big print on the top of the Article you proclaim the rights you are giving, but in little print, in sub-sections you take back every one of these rights, with the characteristic exception of the rights given to the President. When dealing with the rights and powers to be given to the President, then all the sub-sections are devoted to making it impossible ever to curb those rights; making it impossible even for the courts to judge that individual and making it impossible, even for the Parliament of the people to do so. But when dealing with trade unions or with the individual citizen, or the property of individual citizens, then a right is declared, but underneath that is laid down a whole lot of powers that are being given to an Executive either to limit, to restrict or to filch those rights from the individual or from the union.
If there is one thing which should not be in a Constitution it is meaningless paragraphs that are so much frothy humbug. The beginning of this Article and the subsequent sub-sections merely enshrine in a Constitution, which should live for a considerable number of years, a piece of Parliamentary humbug and chaff. Apparently, the whole test of the possibility of abuse or misuse or otherwise of powers that are being given over the people's rights is to be purely the President's personal opinion. It is "I,""I,""I" since we started to consider this document. The Executive Council or the Parliament were never mentioned. It is "I will consider this" or "I will consider that." It has been the first person singular all the time.
The President may be and, certainly in his own opinion, is the most just and reasonable man that ever pulled on trousers, but this Constitution is a document that is meant to live and to last, and it will be worked under other Presidents and under other Executives of all types, politically venomous, politically vindictive, anti-the individual right, and anti-the right of unions. Are you when you start out in the Constitution to assert the right of people to form associations and unions, in the same Constitution to make it not only possible but to invite any bigoted and narrow-minded Executive in the future to formulate laws to restrict and to rob individuals of the right you proposed to give in the earlier part? Is not that obvious, when you start off by setting out in big print that citizens have the right to form unions and associations, but as an afterthought consider that is a dangerous right to give and put in, in small print, these words: "subject however to whatever laws may be passed from time to time."
If the President has that suspicion, that lack of trust and lack of confidence in Irish associations, in Irish trade unions, and in Irish democracy, then cut out the whole lot and define no right in one breath which you take away in the next breath. It is this double shuffle, the advertisement in the shop window "good," and the article as it crosses the counter "rotten" that is the characteristic feature of the Constitution from beginning to end. The first portion of it, referred to as "the just and reasonable portion," which will be quoted from Fianna Fáil platforms, is that in which you have enshrined the right of citizens to form associations and unions. There will be no reference to the next features. There was not a colleague of the Deputies who spoke during the last two weeks who did not refer to this document as the charter of liberty. I do not know any piece of legislation that ever passed through this House—and there were times, past and present, when harsh and restrictive measures had to be passed—that contained more restrictions; that so limited the powers and filched the rights of individual and organisations as this great charter of liberty.
Comment on this
I want to say a last word on this. A statement has been made that public order and public interest are not the same thing. We ought to have some exposition given by people who assert that there is a difference. I want to hear how one differs from the other. If there is any difference, it is for those who are bringing forward this document to explain where the difference lies. We have the declaration that the State guarantees the right to form unions and associations, and if the only limitation on that right is that it should be "subject to public order and morality," it will be the courts will determine whether any limitation was put upon the right as caught by the phrase "public order and morality." There are two changes: the extent of the possible limitation of the right has been extended, and more onerous still, the person to determine the meaning of the phrase "in the public interest" will no longer be a judge but will be a member of the Executive of the day.
Comment on this
I do not know that there is any use in going over the same ground. It is quite clear that if I speak 50 times, we will have 50 Deputies going over the same ground. We had Deputy Norton talking as if all these terrible things, which he apprehends could be done in future, could not be done to-day. Why are they not being done? In future the Legislature will have to look after the public interest, as it is doing to-day. Are we going to shackle the Legislature in the future in a way in which it is not shackled to-day, and in which it would be most unwise to shackle it? We are providing for that freedom of action to work in the public interest and to safeguard the public interest in the future which the Legislature has to-day—that and no more. As to "public morality," the lawyers on the opposite benches, I understand, are accurate enough—it has been pretty well defined. "Public interest" is a wider term, as I understand it. Public interest would enable the Legislature to regard the good of the community in any direction. Whether the narrower interpretation, as I understand it, of "public morality" would enable them to do that or not I do not know. I think the Legislature ought to be enabled in its own judgment to decide and not the courts. The courts have to interpret the laws. The courts have not placed upon them the responsibility that the Legislature has. The Legislature has the responsibility of working in the public interest and of seeing, in the passing of its laws, that the rights of the individual, as an individual, and the rights of the community, as a community, do not conflict and are properly co-ordinated. That is the duty of the Legislature; and what we want to see is that in future the Legislature will not be so restricted that it will not be able to function properly.
Comment on this
Why not take the phrase "public order and morality" out of the Preamble and put it in this? That can be completely ousted by this narrower phrase. Why not be decent about it and take out "public order and morality"?
Comment on this
Question—"That the lines proposed to be deleted stand"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 125:—
At the end of Section 6, sub-section 1º, iii, line 5, after the word "right" to insert the words "provided that nothing contained in such laws may limit or restrict the rights and liberties enjoyed by the citizens previous to the enactment of this Constitution".
The object of this amendment is to enshrine in the Constitution a provision that whatever type of laws may be introduced to provide for the regulation and control of the public interest and of the right of citizens to form associations and unions, nothing contained in such laws may limit or restrict the rights and liberties enjoyed by the citizens previous to the enactment of this Constitution. I take it, for instance, that the President would agree that the existing system of society in respect of legislative provision for regulating the establishment and control of associations and unions gives no grounds for concern so far as the State is concerned. The legislation which is in existence at the moment has been on the Statute Book for quite a long time, and, so far as the public is concerned, there has been no demand for a revision of that legislation in a restrictive sense. The President endeavours to justify this section of Article 40, and says that it may be desirable in the public interest to enact legislation to provide for the regulation and control of associations and unions. The object of this amendment is to ensure that such legislation as may be enacted will not limit or restrict the rights and liberties enjoyed by the citizens previous to the enactment of this Constitution. That amendment would ensure to the citizens that whatever rights they have got will be continued to them, even after the proposed laws are passed, and citizens will be assured that their rights cannot be invaded by any legislation that may be subsequently enacted.
Comment on this
I am sure Deputy Norton is not serious in asking that we should stabilise the present situation without knowing what the future may hold. We cannot do that. It is absolutely ridiculous that the Legislature of the nation should be tied up in such a way that it could not in the future act in the public interest. According to the Draft Constitution the citizens have preserved to them the right to form associations and unions.
Comment on this
That has nothing to do with the amendment. I want to prevent any restrictions of the citizens rights.
Comment on this
To take any action that may be necessary in certain directions. In regard to this amendment I do not think Deputy Norton himself would for a moment say that he was going to deal with the future and tie up the Legislature. I do not think he would be prepared to say: "We cannot take any steps for the future no matter how the future may change; we have got to do as we are doing to-day." That is a ridiculous proposal.
Comment on this
It seems to me that almost every effort to preserve any right or liberty is a ridiculous effort according to the President. The mentality of the President is "trust the President, the one just man."
Comment on this
We have the interesting declaration of the President now that it is ridiculous to ask for the preservation of rights and liberties such as citizens enjoy to-day, that in future we must be content with all the restrictions contained in this Constitution and, if we are still uneasy, then we must trust the Executive of the day.
Comment on this
The President is splitting hairs on the difference between the Executive of the day and the Legislature. What does the Legislature mean? Does not the President know that he can simply sit in his seat while any particular amendment is being discussed; does he not know that he need not offer the slightest shred of opposition to any amendment and that all he need say is that he is standing by the Draft Constitution? Then, if a division is called, his loyal legionaries will walk into the Lobby and make sure that the President's viewpoint is upheld in the manner prescribed by the Standing Orders of the House. What is the use of trying to split hairs on the difference between the Legislature and the Executive of the day? Do we not all know that the Executive of the day, commanding a majority, is capable of putting through any type of legislation? When you talk about the Legislature, what you really mean is the majority Party in the Legislature, because it is the all-powerful Party so far as the Legislature is concerned.
A minority Opposition, no matter how virtuous their viewpoint may be, or how laudable their objective, could never hope to pass any legislation protecting the rights or liberties of the people unless they had the approval of the Government. So when you come to examine the Legislature and ascertain what exactly it means, you are driven to the conclusion that for the purpose of the enactment of legislation, while the Legislature may either approve or criticise, the fact remains that in the last resort the decision rests with the Executive Council, which in turn means the Party caucus. In future a body of that kind, acting in that way, may be able to come before the House with proposals for legislation which may seriously affect the rights and liberties that trade unions enjoy to-day under existing statutes.
The President says that my amendment would stereotype the existing position and prevent the introduction of legislation dealing with the position of associations and unions in future. Of course, the President knows perfectly well that it could do no such thing. There would be nothing to prevent the President introducing new laws dealing with the position of associations and unions; but my amendment would prevent him enacting in any of these laws a provision which would give the citizens less rights or less liberties than they have to-day. The President could, in his new legislation, maintain their existing rights and liberties and give them more rights and liberties and more responsibility or less responsibility; but my amendment would ensure that he could not give the citizens less rights or less liberties than they have to-day. Is there anything unreasonable in asking that? This Draft Constitution is taking us into uncharted seas. It is taking the trade unions into uncharted seas where they do not know what is in store for them.
Comment on this
Let me take this whole Article which deals with public order and morality, plus control in the public interest. Let me take these three points together with the speech made by the President on the last section and the speech made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I say that there is grave ground for fear that the position in the future may not be so satisfactory as it is to-day. I want, therefore, to ensure, when the position is thrown into the melting-pot, that at least we will be able to say that whatever changes are to be made they will not give the unions less rights and less liberties than they enjoy to-day. That, whatever rights they have to-day, they will be anchored to them and no Executive Council anxious to restrict their powers will be able to invade such rights and liberties.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and, 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
The Deputy was talking about an invasion of rights. The whole body of laws as it exists is being taken over by this Constitution. The passage of this Constitution does not make any change in that respect. What the Deputy wants us to do is to tie our hands now and go blindfolded and tied into the future. Does the Deputy want the same sort of position with regard to other associations? It is the duty of the Legislature to look after the interests of all sections of the community and it would be ridiculous for any responsible body of people to agree to a suggestion such as is made by Deputy Norton, that they should now tie their hands and go blindfolded into the future. There is no invasion in this Constitution. If the Deputy says I want to make something out of this Constitution so as to give a special position to certain organisations at the present time, then he is on quite a different footing, but we are not touching that. That is a matter that can be dealt with quite as freely after this Constitution is passed as it can now and, consequently, no one in his senses, with any sense of responsibility whatever, would accept that proposal.
Comment on this
Question put:—"That those words be there added."
Do you agree with this result?