Public Business. - Pigs and Bacon Bill, 1937—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 178–361 of 361. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1937 ›
That only applies to minor curers who become licensees. The Minister may direct the Board to allocate any quota that he wishes to specify, and I think that is quite a good deterrent for what the Deputy has in mind. The Deputy, I think, will see that this section, taken with Section 37, was put in to cover cases of more or less the same type. You have three classes. You have, first, the factories which do not even qualify to become minor curers. They can be compensated under Section 36. Then we have those who were minor curers for the past two years and who may not qualify to become licensees. We are providing that they may be compensated at that stage. Thirdly, we had the factories—there was at least one—which went out of business although licensed at the time when they had to make certain reconstructions. They had to incur a good deal of capital expenditure under the Act. It is to cover that class that Section 37 was put in. It is not intended to apply in the wholesale way that the Deputy speaks of. The Bacon Marketing Board under this might, perhaps, close down a factory where there were obviously too many factories in a particular city or town, and, having done that, issue new licences to some persons to move to another town. I am not very keen on this section having general application. If it were to apply to cases that were going out as a result of this legislation, I would not be quite satisfied. I may perhaps be able to bring in an amendment on Report Stage to deal with this.
Comment on this
If you put in an amendment restricting the application of this to the case of the small curer who is really, in fact, in the position of the minor curer—that is, one who is fit, technically to qualify, but who, in fact, is not in a position at the moment to qualify—and if you have it limited in time, and combined with the statement from the Minister himself that we are all agreed that, generally, it is desirable to keep the small factory in existence, then I think that the necessity for my amendment falls. I take it, then, that the Minister agrees, generally, with the principle of my amendment?
Comment on this
Well, yes, but I have not yet thought of the way in which it would be drafted.
Comment on this
I take it that the Deputy is referring to factories that may have to go out under this legislation?
Comment on this
The factories that are analogous to the fellow who cannot bring his factory under the required conditions.
Comment on this
I wish, Sir, to withdraw amendment No. 33, to insert a new section before Section 40. It may be introduced on the Report Stage, but I should like to hear what the Minister has to say on the general question.
Comment on this
No. I propose to raise the principle contained in the amendment on the section, because it may be that the Minister and ourselves are at one on it. I am withdrawing the amendment in Deputy McGilligan's name, reserving the right to introduce it on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
My reason for asking the question is that I consider it to be a very important amendment.
Comment on this
Well, I do not want, to precipitate a split in the Fianna Fáil Party and I think that, by a little tactful argument on the section itself, we might be able to arrive at a substantial agreement. If we do not succeed in arriving at a substantial agreement, then we can lock horns on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Well, it must be remembered that there is a very big difficulty here. I can quite understand Deputies arguing on the principle of this, but there is a very big difficulty. There is the question of departing altogether from the scheme of the Principal Act. Under the Principal Act we have a Pigs Marketing Board composed partly of producer members and partly of curer members, and a chairman. According to that Act, three curer members shall be elected in accordance with the Act by the Bacon Marketing Board, and three producer members shall be nominated in accordance with the Act. The curer members are persons who are ordinary members of the Bacon Marketing Board, and the producer members are persons who are representative of pig producers in the country.
To put a person representing the minor curers on that would be out of line with the legislation. There might be an argument for putting a person to represent them on the Bacon Marketing Board, if it is felt that the minor curers are not adequately represented on it. They are not adequately represented at present, but they will be. At present the case is that you have a certain number representing curers who produce between them about 80 per cent. of the production. There are not very many of these curers, and then there is the large number of minor curers —16 or 17 of them—although the quantity of bacon produced is very small. Accordingly, the number of people in the small category would be very large, as compared with the people in the other category— perhaps three times as large—but the smaller curers under the Principal Act would have only two representatives as against three representatives for the others. We could alter that representation in many ways, such as by amending the Principal Act by changing the limits obtaining at present with regard to those under 23,000 cwts. a year in the small curers' category and so on. That, however, would be a rather cumbersome way of amending the Act, and I think that the best way to amend this would be if we were to agree that these smaller curers should get better representation on the Bacon Marketing Board, and then they would naturally have their influence in getting representation on the Pigs Marketing Board. I think that is the best way to do it, and besides it would be more in line with the Principal Act. If I were to bring in an amendment on the Report Stage, it would be along these lines. I think that one or two small amendments would be sufficient if we were to follow along those lines, but I am afraid that, if we were to follow the lines suggested by Deputy McGilligan, a large number of consequential amendments would be necessary, and, as I say, it would be altogether out of line with the Principal Act. I would be prepared to bring in an amendment on the lines I have suggested, but it must be remembered that it could not apply until the next elective period, which would be about 1938.
Comment on this
Well, this amendment is designed principally to provide representation for the minor curers who are going to qualify as small curers.
Comment on this
Well, you can do either of two things: You can raise the smaller class from one to two, or from two to three, and so on, as the case may be, on the Bacon Marketing Board, or you can say that it shall consist hereafter of two from one class and one from the class of small curers who have been minor curers, and make them a new category. I see the Minister's difficulty. The difficulty is that, in the Principal Act, the representatives on the Bacon Marketing Board elect representatives on the Pigs Marketing Board, and if we were to put direct representatives on the Pigs Marketing Board, it would upset things. I forget how many representatives the Bacon Marketing Board can put on the Pigs Marketing Board.
Comment on this
Well, I would not be surprised if the Minister brought in an amendment designed to put these minor curers, who are to be small curers, in such a position as to have a representative for themselves on the Bacon Marketing Board. If that were done, I think that the point raised by Deputy McGilligan would be substantially met. I cannot say that with certainty, but I imagine that Deputy McGilligan's point would be met.
Comment on this
No, he has not; but as we are discussing the matter generally, I think that my suggestion is not inconsistent with what the Minister suggests.
Comment on this
Well, I would ask the Deputy to look at the Principal Act, and if he does so I am sure he will realise the enormous number of amendments that would be necessary in order to do that.
Comment on this
Yes. The other amendment, proposing an enlargement, would be different, however, and, in fact, it might be more resented by the small curers. It would be all right for the minor curers, at any rate, but I cannot guarantee as to the others.
Comment on this
Will the Minister look into the matter with a view to increasing the representation of the small curers, if it is determined to lump them all together?
Comment on this
Well, then, I think, Sir, it is wiser to withdraw Deputy McGilligan's amendment, and when Deputy McGilligan has perused the report of what has just now passed it may be unnecessary to put down an amendment on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
On the section, Sir: this deals with the elections of curer members of the Pigs Marketing Board and the nomination of producer members of the said board. Now, I am in a difficulty, because the rules of procedure in this House preclude Deputies from referring to persons who are not here to defend themselves. We have two producer members on the Pigs Marketing Board for the past two years. During that time, in my judgment, the interests of the producers have been absolutely jettisoned time after time. On one occasion at least, the producer members of the board came out and publicly admitted that they had consented to the price which had been fixed for pigs—a price which, they admitted, was wholly unsatisfactory considering the price of bacon. Deputies must remember that if one member of the Pigs Marketing Board says "No" to any proposal, then the determination of the question must be made by the chairman of the board. I quite see that the producer members might never be able to do more than to throw a decision into the hands of the chairman, but that they are always able to do, and if they found that the chairman consistently sacrificed the interests of the producers to those of the curers, they could, quite legitimately, go to the Minister and say: "We will no longer accept the responsibility which you put upon us by your nomination of us as producer members of the board. All we can do for the producer is to throw the decision into the hands of the chairman. We are of opinion that the chairman is not doing substantial justice to producers, and we shall no longer remain members of the board." They never have done that. I say they have most notoriously betrayed the interests of pig producers on divers occasions.
I ask the Minister: is he satisfied that both the gentlemen whom he nominated as producers' representatives on the Pigs Marketing Board have experience of raising pigs? One gentleman comes from the Midlands and the other comes from Cavan. I do not know anything about Cavan and I do not know whether the Cavan gentleman is a pig producer or not. As regards the gentleman who comes from the Midlands, I have no reason to believe that he has any long experience in pig-producing, but unless he is a gentleman who has some knowledge of the production costs of fattening pigs or a gentleman who has some knowledge of how the industry is carried on, he is not a fit person to sit on the board. I should be glad to hear from the Minister whether he is satisfied with the work these gentlemen have done, and if not, whether he will take steps to put on the board experienced producers who will not be afraid to voice the views of the average producer in the country and who will not be afraid, when the chairman has made a decision that, in their opinion, militates against the interests of the producers of the country, to throw up their jobs and to protest in public against the sacrifice of the interests which they were nominated to represent.
Comment on this
First of all, with regard to the three nominees who represent the producers——
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied that they were experienced pig producers who had a very definite knowledge of costings and of pig-production. As a matter of fact, one of the gentlemen referred to had actually spoken publicly over the wireless and in many other places on that very subject of the costings of pig-feeding.
Comment on this
Many a man spoke over the wireless who knew damn little of what he was talking about.
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. But it was for that reason principally that these men were chosen—that they did devote attention to that subject and had a good knowledge of the costing business.
Comment on this
I could not say that. But I think that a man who feeds even, say, 12 pigs and who takes an intelligent interest in it and who goes into the costings——
Comment on this
——would be a very good man and maybe a better man to represent producers than a man who is feeding 100 pigs.
Comment on this
The reason that the section was put down in this form and this change made is, not that I was dissatisfied with the representatives, but a three-year period makes it awkward in this way. First of all, we had three representatives and they were all there for one period. You may say that you must have some continuity and that you must leave at least some of three on the board in order to carry on the tradition whatever it may have been. I think it is not a good thing that a man should be led to think that he has a life interest in the job, as then he may not be so assiduous as he should be in representing the producers. That is why it is proposed to reduce the term of office to two years. We can take on one man at one time and two at another time. In that way you will have continuity and at the same time new blood coming in. That is the amendment of the section which is proposed, and I think the House will agree that the term should be shortened for that reason.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that these men have defended the interests of the pig producers?
Comment on this
Yes. I must say that on a few occasions I felt, as the Deputy feels now, that they had not put the producers' case as strongly as they might, but after inquiry from the chairman I did not feel that I was entitled to treat these men as schoolboys and say: "I will put you off if you do not do your business." After inquiry from the chairman, I must say that I was satisfied that they had done their best for the producers. The Deputy is working on the assumption that the curers could pay more. We are all inclined to think that, but we can only find out definitely when the Prices Tribunal reports.
Comment on this
I might direct the attention of the Minister to the fact that there was a special section put into the Principal Act requiring the Pigs Marketing Board to have regard to the current cost of feeding stuffs.
Comment on this
There was one occasion on which a producer member stated that they had not considered the cost of feeding stuffs.
Comment on this
There was a meeting of pig producers in this city, and two at least of the producer members of the board were present. One of them admitted that they had not considered the cost of feeding stuffs, and the meeting proceeded on the assumption that they had objected to the prices fixed for pigs when somebody suddenly called out: "If you did not consider the price of feeding stuffs, how could you have objected to the price fixed?" Then the member said: "I fought it as long as I could, but in the end I had to agree to it for peace sake." If the Minister is not satisfied that some of these gentlemen have no practical experience in pig production, will he take steps to change them? I entirely agree with the Minister that the man who is in the habit of producing only 12 pigs may be just as useful as a man who is able to rear 200 pigs. In fact, I would rather have a big producer, a medium producer, and a small producer on this board representing producers as a whole. Is the Minister satisfied that any one of these gentlemen has no practical experience of pig production at all?
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, I think I would be bound to take action in that case under the Act.
Comment on this
As the original Act stood the Pigs Marketing Board should have fixed a price for old sows, boars and so on, which was a very difficult thing to do. They now have the power to exclude certain classes like that and leave them a free market.
Comment on this
They will not have power under this section to exclude a type of pig? For instance, they would not have power to exclude large Ulster Whites?
Comment on this
The section refers to pigs of a kind. I do not see why they should not announce that large Ulster White pigs are "of a kind".
Comment on this
It is not the intention certainly. It may be very difficult to get wording to cover what the Deputy has in mind. What he has mentioned is certainly not the intention of the section. The only intention is with regard to old sows, boars and so on.
Comment on this
Would it not be better to put in there a saving clause that this power shall not be used to differentiate between breeds or types of pigs? Would not that be quite safe?
Comment on this
I do not know. I should like to think over that matter in order to see if the restriction would be awkward or likely to make the thing inoperative. We know what the intention is at any rate, and if I were to do anything I would much rather put in that, perhaps, the Order should receive some sort of sanction from some source—from the Minister or some other source. I think that to put in an amendment as suggested by the Deputy might destroy all the effect of the section.
Comment on this
No. Injured pigs are already covered. There is a clause covering that.
Comment on this
Then I cannot think of any other class of pigs except boars and sausage sows. Would the Minister alter the section to say that the board may exclude such types of pigs as the Minister may from time to time schedule?
Comment on this
Very well. The Minister will put in the words "with the Minister's approval," and they will have to submit any exclusion to the Minister?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:—
In page 18, line 32, to delete the words "one hour" and substitute the words "half-an-hour".
Under this Bill the pigs must be weighted immediately after slaughter, because under the Weights and Measures Act no curer is entitled to deduct the customary 3 lbs. which he has deducted up to this; that practice must stop. The weights and measures authorities will allow them to carry on, on the understanding that this Bill is coming in. When this Bill is passed they will have to pay on the full weight, and they must have the pig weighed hot. Certain curers put it to me that, if they were to avail of this section as it stands, that is, to wait for the hour, probably the producer would be deprived of the price of about 1 lb. of pork, and that any curer could weigh within half-an-hour. In that way the producer will be better safeguarded. We are, therefore, changing "one hour" to "half-an-hour."
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that in all factories grading is being properly done? There have been bitter complaints against certain factories in regard to grading pigs into a lower class than they properly belonged to.
Comment on this
And, at times like this, putting them into a higher class? Previously, we had no effective control over them, but from 1st April on we have had a representative in each factory, and the grading can be supervised.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:—
In sub-section (1) (b) (ii), page 22, line 18, to insert after the word "damage" the word "allowance."
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 36:—
Before Section 58 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) Where a pig is offered for sale at licensed premises or premises registered in the register of minor curers upon terms that the price thereof is to be determined after slaughter, it shall not be lawful for the licensee in respect of such licensed premises or the person registered in respect of such premises to purchase such pig except upon such terms.
(2) If any person being a licensee or registered minor curer purchases any pig in contravention of this section, such person shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding £10.
There has been, not exactly evasion, but some inconvenience, and even perhaps I might say illegality, practised on producers from time to time by certain factories. Where the producer sends his pigs to the factory to be purchased direct, the factory has agreed to take the pigs only on the live weight basis. This amendment would have the effect of compelling the factory to take them either on the dead weight or on the live weight basis, as the producer decides. I think Deputies will agree that that is a good provision, especially when pigs are plentiful. Of course, at the present time I need hardly say that the factories are very anxious to please, and will take them either on the dead weight or the live weight basis, as the producer may decide; but when pigs are plentiful, as they may be in the autumn, the factories will be more particular about the pigs they take. They will be more inclined not to take pigs at all if they can avoid it, but have agents out buying them lower than the fixed price. This is one amendment; there are other provisions coming along which will have the effect, in the first place, of compelling the factories to take pigs from any producer if the producer so opts, and under this amendment they are compelled also to take them by dead weight if the producer asks them to do so.
Comment on this
Does the amendment operate to prohibit a licensed curer paying a price over the fixed price?
Comment on this
It has nothing to do with that. The Principal Act does operate in that way.
Comment on this
It is an offence to pay more than the fixed price under the Principal Act. No one has been convicted for doing so, so far.
Comment on this
Is this section designed to remedy the position of a man who is being pressed to take less than the fixed price for his pigs?
Comment on this
I do not think so. It compels the factory to issue a certificate to the producer.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
In page 24, to delete line 13 and substitute the words "the words `in one or more counties, or, if authorised by the Minister, in a particular case in a particular area,' after the words."
At the moment pigs would only be purchased when there is a general surplus. This section gives power to purchase pigs where there is a surplus in a particular area or in a particular county. The amendment goes further and says that the board may purchase "in a particular case in a particular area." It may be necessary for the board at times to purchase pigs to get over a difficulty, although there is not a surplus. As some Deputies are aware there was a position in Donegal, in Monaghan and in some Border counties during last autumn, and the previous autumn which did not obtain in any parts of the South. There was not a general surplus, not even a county surplus, and if the factories in Donegal had played the game properly there would not have been any surplus. What was really happening was that agents were going around buying pigs and selling them to the factories. It was impossible to control that position under the Act as it stood.
Comment on this
This may be a rather drastic provision, but if the board goes to the Minister with a case and says that there is a position they cannot deal with unless they get an order to purchase pigs, if the Minister agrees there is a case, and gives permission, the board can go into an area and purchase pigs. God knows what they may do with them. They can either sell them direct to the factories or send them there to be cured on their account, export them as live pigs, or do all the other things mentioned in the Principal Act.
Comment on this
The only comment I have to make is that I do not see why the Minister does not avail of the machinery already there. This section is designed to achieve a very pious purpose but, at the same time, it finishes for all time the pig dealers of this country. This is giving the board permission, by its agents, to deal in pigs, whenever pigs are available for purchase, by persons other than the factories. The House has heard the Minister say that the board has power to sell to the factories, to get the pigs killed on their account or to export them. Why does the Minister not avail of the machinery of the Pig Dealers' Association? It includes a couple of hundred men, all of whom have their own connection in the British market, and can place every type of pig that is brought into a fair. They will sell a fat, heavy pig in one place, a pork pig in another place, a half-finished store pig in another district, and a forward store in another area. It does not matter what type of pig is brought to a market, the pig jobbers will be able to dispose of them in the best markets through one or other of the connections they have got in the trade. They are anxious to do it, and they can do it more efficiently and cheaper than any other machinery. We are now going to set up the Pigs Marketing Board to do that work. We all know what happens when Government Departments try to handle the extremely complex and difficult business of foreign trade. They generally make a mess of it. We know the lamentations there have been about the Government's experiments in selling eggs, in selling butter, in selling cattle abroad, and in selling fowl. Practically every commodity which they have sought to sell in foreign markets has resulted in catastrophic losses and ludicrous confusion. Some of the eggs that they sold to people in Spain are still unpaid for. A pair of chickens was exported to Belgium at one time and they did a tour of Europe before they found a refuge, I think, in Folkestone.
Comment on this
In the case of the chickens, they started off, went to Antwerp, and were eventually left at Folkestone. The Government is not equipped to carry on foreign trade. Why does the Government not use the pig jobbers? I am satisfied that if there was a temporary surplus in a district, or if a factory was dishonestly paying people less than they were entitled to, the pig dealers would be prepared to go and create a market in any centres where the Minister agreed that the pigs should be taken from the people at a fair price, or dispose of them to factories or export them, whichever way would get the best price for the producers. Why does not the Minister do that? What hatred has he for the pig dealers? I have a long experience of cattle dealers and horse dealers, and I say without hesitation that you can always trust a pig dealer, less often you can trust a cattle dealer but you can never trust a horse dealer. That would be about their standing.
Comment on this
One particular dealer that we know of you could trust with nothing. The Deputy knows who I mean.
Comment on this
Let us not name our supporters in this House because that would lead us farther astray than Claremorris and some of the embryos that Fianna Fáil gathered to their bosom there. I put it to the Minister that these pig dealers could make a material contribution to the industry, that they are an excellent body of men and that the effect of this section will be to destroy their business and to bankrupt some of them. They are there ready to do the job. They are good citizens. As the Government is always pleading the desire to create employment, why do they not leave these men their employment. They are quite prepared to earn their own living. They do not want to be helped by anyone. They are prepared to co-operate with the general policy laid down by the Oireachtas. Why attempt to destroy them, and to send comparatively inefficient people to do their job? Has the Minister considered the possibility of having what he wants done under this section being better done by seeking the co-operation of the pig dealers? I have reason to believe that if he asks the pig dealers he will get all the co-operation he wants. I am convinced that if he goes that way about his work it will be better done than it could be done under this section. Has the Minister consulted the pig dealers in this matter?
Comment on this
I told the Deputy on the Second Stage that we had tried that matter out in Donegal, that we had got the genuine pig dealers together, that we had advertised live pig markets in Donegal, issued special quotas for the export of live pigs by these dealers, and made arrangements with some of the factories in the South to take pigs from them. They tried that, but they were not very successful. They continued to go to the markets for some time, and eventually the markets fell through.
Comment on this
I could not say how long, but they went on for some time. It was not my Department that fell down in the matter, because we were prepared to continue to issue licences for the export of pigs as long as they would go to the markets. This amendment is aimed at alleged pig dealers.
Comment on this
I want to make a distinction between them, because if I were to say that this was aimed at pig buyers the Deputy would say they were not the people he had in mind. This is aimed at alleged pig buyers who formed a ring, bought pigs below the fixed price, and sold them to the factory. I had the genuine pig buyer in mind, and that is why this particular amendment appears with the words in it, "if authorised by the Minister." I do not want the board, if they had any intention of doing so, to take over the buying of pigs entirely in this country. Therefore, I agreed to put in this amendment, that in particular cases, and for a limited time, if the board could convince me that they had a good case for operating this section, I would give them that permission, but it would be limited both in area and time. I think the Deputy need have no fears, because I personally would, and I believe the Department, as long as they can prevail on any other Minister who might be there, will advise him to resist the board if they were to ask for powers to do all the buying themselves. I can assure the Deputy that this power will be only used in a limited way and that the genuine pig buyer will be permitted to carry on, as he is at present, making a living. I might also say that when I put that matter to the board the board said to me that in all probability they would put this business through the genuine pig buyer, if such is to be got in the particular instance. I think the Deputy need not have any fear about that.
Comment on this
Will the Minister go so far as to say that he will advise and encourage the employment of genuine pig dealers in so far as he can?
Comment on this
Yes. As a matter of fact, I have already discussed that matter with the board, and they said, yes, certainly they would employ pig dealers.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:—
In page 24, line 52, to delete the words "produced by him" and substitute the words "in his possession and at his own premises for at least four weeks before the date of such notice."
This again raises the question I referred to as the alleged dealers. This section enables a producer to send pigs direct to the factory, if he so wishes. If he notifies the board that he has pigs which he wishes to have consigned direct to the factory, the board may, under this section, authorise the factory to accept them. I am offering this amendment because the words "produced by him" might possibly be interpreted as meaning produced to the factory. I do not know exactly what the word "produced" in the section would mean, but it is better to make it clear that it would not be possible for an agent to go out and collect pigs, bring them in to his own premises, and then deliver them to the factory. It would destroy the whole effect of the section if that were permitted. We therefore provide that the pigs must be on the premises of the person for at least four weeks.
Comment on this
This section does not mean that you cannot tender a pig to a factory? Does it mean that—unless it has been on the premises for four weeks?
Comment on this
The factory would be compelled to take any pig which has been in the possession of the person for four weeks?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 40:—
At the end of the section to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(3) Every pig sold and delivered under an order made under this section shall be so sold and delivered upon terms that the price of such pig is to be determined after slaughter.
This also arose before. Under this, if pigs are consigned to a factory under this section, they must be sold by dead weight.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to tell us is it, or is it not, true that the hypothetical price fund is now being used largely to help the Exchequer to pay subsidies. The original purpose of the hypothetical price fund was dual: (1) to make the price of pigs to the producer artificially attractive in the spring for the purpose of inducing the producer of bacon pigs to keep small potatoes, and such-like fortuitous food supplies, over from the date on which they came to hand until the spring, when they could be advantageously used from a community point of view in the production of pigs. Is not that so?
Comment on this
In fact, it has been largely used for subsidising exports of bacon to England when the bounty provided by the Exchequer did not equal the tariff paid on bacon. I submit that that was pure robbery of the producer, as every penny of the fund was taken from the producers in the autumn, because they were paid an artificially depressed price and they never got an artificially increased price. At the present moment, they are only getting 75/- for Grade A1 pigs; that means that they are getting an average price of between 70/- and 72/- for all the pigs delivered at the factory. Bacon is being sold at present in Saorstát Eireann at 116/- to 120/-.
If the curers are getting 120/- for bacon, they ought to be paying from 95/- to 100/- for pigs—say, 95/-. If they are getting 120/- for bacon, they ought to be paying 95/- for pigs at least. If the hypothetical price fund was functioning, there should be added to that economic price of 95/- about 10/- from the price fund. So that the pig producer who should be getting 105/- a cwt. at this time for his pigs when bacon is being sold at 120/-, is, in fact, getting only 71/- a cwt. Few Deputies understand the hypothetical price. It is based entirely on the money that was taken from the pig producer last September, October and November, on the clear understanding and promise that if he kept in pig production and brought pigs out in the spring, he would get it all back. Has he got one penny of it back? I say he has not.
Comment on this
I think that perhaps the Deputy is not approaching this as another person might approach it. I do not say that he is right or that he is wrong. If there is a certain amount taken in the home market the price is regulated by supply and demand. If the curers get 120/-, taking the quantity available into account, then the Pigs Board take that into account, that the price is 120/- per cwt., and they also take into account the cost of the production of pigs at certain times of the year when the price was 10 per cent. or 15 per cent. better than it was last spring. They have fixed the price at the moment at 75/- and if at the moment bacon is 120/- then they say: "We can afford to take the levy off that"; and that is the difference between the hypothetical price and the fixed price. If we had no exports at all, if we had nothing but the home market probably that is the way it would operate. You fix a fair price the whole year round and then levy off the bacon curers when they are getting good prices and pay them back when the prices are lower; that is how it operates. However, exports come in and complicate matters. I gave the figures here on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture, and I showed as well as I could make out the figures, that the difference between the subsidies paid on the exports last year and the tariff collected was somewhere between £60,000 and £80,000.
That amount is taken out of the hypothetical fund. But we have a similar position as in the butter business, and that is that even if the curer were paying no tariff going into England, the price he is getting is a good deal lower there than here, and, therefore, he is compensated for the exports. That is because the export market is not as good as the home market; the amount that is paid equalises the tariff. The difference between the tariff and the subsidy going out is comparatively small. I was making inquiries about this matter a few days ago. I think the amount collected on this fund would be well over £500,000 a year, and the amount paid out is nearly the same. There is only £60,000 as a levy to bring the amount paid in subsidies up to the amount paid in tariffs. Up to this it has not all been paid out of the exports on bacon. This money is paid out during the short intervals during which they have appointed a price higher than the hypothetical price. In the majority of cases they paid out of that hypothetical fund on all bacon produced whether it was exported or sold at home.
Comment on this
I wonder who got it? I was informed at one time that the Bacon Marketing Board disclaimed having collected more than £200,000.
Comment on this
It is well that Deputy Donnelly should know that his rasher of bacon has a levy on it every morning to compensate producers for their losses on the British market. I do not know the Deputy knew that before.
Comment on this
What I am trying to convince the Deputy of was that if the old Irish Party had not partitioned this country, rashers, North and South, would be cheaper to-day.
Comment on this
Deputy Donnelly is neither wise nor relevant. It is well to realise that the exports are at present being subsidised out of the levy on bacon purchased by the Irish consumer. We are paying in rural Ireland to-day 1/3 a lb. for salty bacon so that the British consumers can have it for 11d. or 1/- a lb. At what level are we going to stop raising prices to the Irish consumer in order to sell bacon at cheaper prices in Great Britain? I am advised that we may expect soon to be charging in the West of Ireland 1/6 a lb. for bacon. Up to what level does the Minister think it is wise to force the price on our own people in order to subsidise the price to Great Britain?
Comment on this
I have told the Minister again and again that with or without his knowledge the curers have formed themselves into a ring, and I now publicly allege that the Bacon Marketing Board sent to the minor curers a circular saying that they were not charging their customers enough, because these minor curers were charging a price that had not been fixed by the ring. I want to remind the House that the Bacon Marketing Board has no authority to fix the price of bacon.
Comment on this
How can the Minister expect me to produce it? The Minister is in a position to get what I could not get. I cannot produce to the Minister written proof of all that is going on in the bacon industry. It is with the greatest difficulty I managed to get the information I got, and it is because I am able to use it to put the wind up these fellows that I have some hope here that we can have some control over them.
I cannot get at the secret archives of these bacon curers, who seem to think they can do what they like. I am not in their confidence. On the contrary, they do not like me at all and I see no prospect of their changing in regard to me. This much I do know—that whatever I find I will checkmate them, and if I am ever responsible for the control of Irish industry they will have to obey me and toe the line. I put it to the Minister that he ought to tell us how far he thinks it right that the hypothetical price fund should be used to pay bounties on the price of bacon. I think it ought to be used exclusively for the purpose of raising the hypothetical price over the fixed price. Remember, it is in time of plenty, when we have a great number of pigs, that the levy is collected—you collect it on, perhaps, 1,000,000 pigs in the autumn—and it is in the time of scarcity that you distribute it, so that the levy gathered off 1,000,000 pigs is distributed on, perhaps, 500,000 pigs. There ought to be double as much bounty paid out in spring to producers as there is collected from them in the autumn. They are not getting it and in that sense the producers are being robbed.
Comment on this
What is the effect of Section 66? Is it to make the minor curers liable to levies during the specified period?
Comment on this
This is merely a re-enactment; it is the same as in the main Act.
Comment on this
Is there not a case sub judice in which a minor curer is challenging the right of the Department to levy the hypothetical price on him?
Comment on this
We are not making any difference between the main Act and this.
Comment on this
Several sections have been taken from the Principal Act and put in here. The draftsman has repeated several of them.
Comment on this
I cannot imagine the draftsman bringing in a section identical with the section in the Principal Act.
Comment on this
After the appointed day, under this measure, a certain number of sections of the main Act go out and, therefore, they are put in here so as to become operative from that time.
Comment on this
This is the permanent structure which will take the place of certain parts of the other Act that lapse?
Comment on this
Up to this, the Board could only pay out of the fund when the hypothetical price was below the appointed price. Now there is no such restriction.
Comment on this
As a result of that, this section is designed to permit the board to pay out export subsidies?
Comment on this
No, they had not. Now you want to extend the opportunity of paying export bounties out of the hypothetical fund. I wonder does Deputy Smith know that the hypothetical price fund was being used to relieve the Exchequer of export bounties on bacon going to Great Britain?
Comment on this
We must do what we can to bolster up a bad market.
Comment on this
Deputy Smith did not know that, and he was one of the Deputies who was on the Committee. We are actually now levying on the producer in order to sell cheap bacon to Britain.
Comment on this
The British market is not what the Deputy thinks it is. The pig producers in Britain are getting 62/- while ours are getting 75/-.
Comment on this
The Minister, at the end of five years, has this to boast of— that he has reduced agriculture in this country to this situation that we have a shortage of pigs and butter, we have a scarcity of cattle, of store and meat cattle, and we have only one-third of our former egg supply
Comment on this
That is the sort of speech that would suit the Deputy next Sunday. If it were true it would be extraordinary.
Comment on this
It is true that you have a shortage of pigs because you are importing pigs from Ulster. It is the first time that that has happened since Saorstát Eireann was founded.
Comment on this
It is the first time in the history of this country. They are coming in now from Ulster because you have stripped this country of its pig population. There is a definite shortage of pigs here, and that is why they are being brought in from Ulster. You are bringing butter in from New Zealand. You have reduced our export of eggs. There is a scarcity of cattle unprecedented in this country. Is it not an astonishing achievement?
Comment on this
It is very hard to please some people. We are getting good prices for our cattle now.
Comment on this
In this Bill we are proposing to turn the hypothetical price, that Deputy Smith and I had a hand in devising, to another purpose altogether. We devised it for the purpose of securing for the farmers a better price in spring out of the moneys levied in the autumn. Those moneys that we intended should be given back to the producer are now being stolen away and handed to the curers in order to subsidise them in the export market. Is that fair? The hypothetical price fund was never meant for that purpose. Why should it be so used now?
Comment on this
If we were sending bacon to Germany and selling it at the price we are selling it in England, the Deputy would make a very fine speech about the rotten market we had in Germany, but because we are sending it to Great Britain and because we have to pay a subsidy on it, he has a different argument. If we did not pay the subsidy our producers could not get the prices they are getting. It is all because the English market is a bad market, if you like to have it that way.
Comment on this
You said they were paying 75/- in Northern Ireland for the pigs they were importing. The fixed maximum price in Northern Ireland is 62/-.
Comment on this
Go fish! They are shipping more to England now than they ever shipped before. They have doubled the pig population of Northern Ireland while we have reduced ours almost to vanishing point. Do you deny they are shipping more bacon now? Do you deny that their exports have gone up over 100 per cent while ours have fallen?
Comment on this
I admit it has gone up. If ours has not gone down we would have to send more cheap bacon to England.
Comment on this
I speak for a lot of consumers, and I should like to know can the Minister hold out any hope that people who used to have bacon for breakfast will be able to have it again in the near future? A lot of people find that it has gone beyond their means and they have to devise substitutes. Some are probably contenting themselves with an orange instead of having their usual morning rasher.
Comment on this
I have no idea when the price of bacon will come down. It is expected there will be a bigger supply of pigs by the end of July, and I assume the prices will then come down. I read out what the consumer in London is paying for bacon, and it is just as much as consumers in Dublin are paying, in spite of all this talk of cheap bacon.
Comment on this
The Minister is prepared, apparently, to argue that two and two make five, or that four times three make 21. A minute ago he was arguing that the British market was a rotten market for bacon, that there were bad prices, low prices, miserable prices. That is the argument he advanced to me. Then Deputy Alton gets up and says that bacon is very dear here, and the Minister says: "But not nearly as dear as it is in England." Which story is true?
Comment on this
Both. The consumer in England is paying a lot for his bacon.
Comment on this
You can tell that to the marines. I shall divide on this section, as it is the section under which it is proposed to misappropriate the hypothetical price fund.
Comment on this
Question—"That Section 68 stand part of the Bill"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
Amendment No. 41 to Section 69, in the name of Deputy McGilligan, is another of those amendments which had best be put back to Report Stage until the Minister produces his amendment, when the matter can be further considered.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42:—
Before Section 71 to insert a new section as follows:—
Section 153 of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the deletion of the words "by order" and Part IV of the Principal Act shall be construed and have effect accordingly.
This amendment has the same effect as amendment No. 24.
Comment on this
Surely the Executive Council should know whether we are going to dissolve this week or not?
Comment on this
If we finish the business this week, I presume we shall not meet next week.
Comment on this
Unless it will compel you to defer the dissolution, I should prefer to have the Report Stage on Tuesday next.
Comment on this
If it is fixed for Thursday, I shall not proceed if the Deputy then objects.
Report Stage fixed for Thursday, 10th June.