We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Shop Assistants (Conditions of Employment) (No. 2) Bill, 1937—Committee (resumed).

Contributions 147–292 of 292. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

That is so. The specific point we had in mind was not the man who was ill, but the building trade worker who does a job, is laid off for a couple of weeks, goes to another job, is laid off for a couple of weeks, and then goes to another job. We wanted to make his employment continuous despite the period he is laid off. That type of interruption rarely occurs in the retail distribution trade, but it might occur, and we are putting the same provision in here. If you are dealing with the case of illness, it is necessary to bear in mind the point I made that it is only where an employee returns to the employment of his employer that this arises at all, and I think the wisdom of extending the period beyond a month is very doubtful from any point of view, and I urge that on Deputies opposite.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 84:—

In paragraph (c), lines 57 and 58, to delete the words "one month" and substitute the words "a continuous period of not less than five weeks".

The amendment is to ensure that the break in the employment must be continuous. I think the Minister has already mentioned that.

Comment on this

There might be more than one interruption. I think the Deputy's amendment is not necessary if that is the intention. There could be more than one interruption in the year and still the employment would be continuous, provided no interruption is for more than a month.

Comment on this

On the section I should like to ask the Minister, does he not think that in the case of illness of an employee, the employer should be advised? The Minister has said that, of course, the employer can make the point that he does not require his services. I think in certain cases it might be very difficult for the employer to find out whether the employee is sick or has gone away. The employee might return and contend that he had been sick and that he was willing to resume work. In that case, I think where illness is going to be claimed, the employer should be given notice.

Comment on this

There is nothing in the Bill to compel the employer to take such an employee back into the service. I imagine that an employee who absented himself from employment without explanation has very little chance of employment on presenting himself again for work of this kind.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 85:—

In sub-section (3), line 14, to delete the figure "3" and substitute the figures "1.30."

The purpose of this amendment is to ensure that employees of shops which are refreshment houses will get a half-holiday commencing at 1.30 instead of at 3 o'clock as provided by the Bill. The generally established view of a half-holiday is that it should permit one to take the whole afternoon free from work, and a half-holiday commencing at 3 o'clock could hardly be regarded as a half-holiday at all. I might mention in this connection that it is the practice at present in many places to give the half-holiday at 1 o'clock or at 1.30. It is, I think, actually the practice in the licensed trade in Dublin, for instance, at the present time. I feel that a half-holiday commencing at a later hour than 1.30 for employees who had started to work in the forenoon does not conform to what is generally understood to be a half-holiday. The Minister might meet the point by agreeing to insert 1.30 instead of 3 o'clock in this sub-section.

Comment on this

I do not think I could agree to this amendment, nor do I think that the illustration of the licensed house meets the case.

Comment on this

They are refreshment houses.

Comment on this

Oh, no. These are restaurants and hotels where the busiest hours are probably the hours between 12 and 3. I think it is necessary to preserve 3 o'clock there. The Deputy should remember that it is 3 o'clock or five hours after the work commences, whichever is the earlier. If he starts at 9 o'clock the half-holiday must be given at 2 o'clock, and if he starts at 8 o'clock it must be given at 1 o'clock. I think it would be unreasonable to require that waiters and similar employees in hotels should get their half-holiday at 1.30. I think 3 o'clock is a reasonable provision in their case.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

There is one provision in this section which strikes me as rather peculiar in its wording, namely, "but only if such proprietor does not permit such member to do on that day any work for him." I would suggest to the Minister that he should insert some such words as "any substantial work," because even if the employee deals with a till, or with something which he forgot to do the night before—if he lodges, for instance, a little money—he has done some work. It might give rise to some considerable difficulty. An employer may come down to his shop and suddenly see that an employee has done some very trifling service for the day on which the employee is to have his whole holiday. I should like if some such word as "substantial" were inserted. I have not put down an amendment but the Minister might look into the matter.

Comment on this

I have a natural reluctance to inserting such words in legislation, if it can be avoided, because they lead to contention and litigation. I think it is necessary to provide fairly clearly that if the employee does any work on a particular day for an employer, that is not a holiday. I am not sure, but I think that is the corresponding provision in the existing law. I do not think it will cause any substantial difficulty in interpretation.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

It might. If he does something trifling everybody may ignore it, but a "pernickety" chap may say: "I was off yesterday, but I did such-and-such a thing. I unrolled a bale of cloth yesterday and you looked on at my doing it. I must have another holiday to-day."

Comment on this

Of course there is another way of dealing with that. The proprietor may say: "This is your half-day from the shop, but you can milk the cows this evening."

Comment on this

On this section, I should like to know from the Minister whether it is held that the words in line 41, "salary or wages," are regarded as referring only to the ordinary remuneration or whether it may be necessary to insert the words "excluding overtime." I think this point cropped up on the Conditions of Employment Act, but possibly that was dealing with piece-work. I know that the words were added in some section of that Act.

Comment on this

I take it the Deputy has in mind the same point which Deputy Dockrell raised in relation to Section 22, that it is the normal rate of wages that shall apply.

Comment on this

Yes, that overtime shall not be taken into account.

Comment on this

It may be necessary to make that clear, that wages should be paid at the normal rate and that that should not include any extra remuneration paid for overtime to the employee.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Norton I move amendment No. 89:

In sub-section (1), lines 5 and 6, to delete the words "which is either a non-special-trade shop or a Sunday trading shop.

Section 29 imposes on the proprietors of certain shops the obligation to grant a weekly half-holiday to their employees. This obligation, however, does not extend to the proprietor of special-trade shops, such as refreshment houses, licensed premises, and so forth. This amendment simply seeks to remove the limiting words in sub-section (1). Its adoption would ensure a half-holiday for all these workers. It is simply bringing these employees on a par with other employees.

Comment on this

I do not see that this amendment is necessary. I do not know if Deputy Norton fully appreciated that where certain classes of employees receive no half-holiday, they are given the right to two whole holidays in the month, two whole holidays which may be given in half-holidays if it suits the convenience of the employer. In those classes of shops it is considered more convenient to provide for the giving of those holidays to those employees in that way, rather than to give them one half-holiday in each week. That is the practice at present. It is the existing law. I have had no representations from anybody that it is desirable to change it, and consequently we are providing for its continuation here. An employee is entitled to two whole holidays in the month in lieu of the half-holidays—two whole holidays which may, at the discretion of the employer, be given in half-holidays. I think it is desirable to leave that provision. It has worked fairly well. I have no recollection of anybody making any representations in favour of the changing of it. Consequently I think it is desirable to leave it as it stands.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 90:

In sub-section (1), line 7, after the word "shop," to insert the words "except during the annual leave of such member."

The idea is that it should be made quite clear that an employee cannot contend that he was entitled to holidays during the periods of his annual leave.

Comment on this

He could not have two holidays on the same day. I see the point that the Deputy is getting at, but I do not think the amendment is necessary. I think it is quite clear that a person cannot be given a half-holiday on a day on which he has a whole holiday.

Comment on this

Would it consist of going to work?

Comment on this

On the principle of "a change is as good as a rest"!

Comment on this

It would be like the magistrates: "Sentences to run concurrently."

Comment on this

The point is that he may claim he is entitled to the half-day which he should have got when he was taking a whole day.

Comment on this

I do not think the section is open to that interpretation, but I will have it examined if Deputies have any doubt about it. It is provided here that he must be allowed a half-holiday on one day in each week. If he does not take it during that week it cannot be taken over to another week. Obviously he cannot get it in the week during which he is on annual leave.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 91:—

In sub-section (1), line 8, to delete the words "if such shop is a non-special-trade shop".

The purpose of this amendment is to ensure that a Sunday-trading shop, like a non-special-trade shop, will be compelled to give a half-holiday on a day which is not a public holiday. The Sunday-trading shop, as the Bill stands, has an advantage in that respect over the non-special-trade shop.

Comment on this

I did not quite get the Deputy's point.

Comment on this

The amendment seeks to ensure that the Sunday-trading shop will be compelled to give a half-holiday on a day which is not a public holiday. As the Bill stands they can give the half-holiday on a public holiday.

Comment on this

I do not see what the objection is. Those Sunday-trading shops are shops which presumably also open on public holidays. This succession of negatives makes it very difficult to follow precisely what the Deputy is getting at. There are two classes of shops concerned here. One is described as a non-special-trade shop and the other as a Sunday-trading shop. The words in brackets are designed to secure that in the case of the non-special-trade shop the half-holiday shall not be on a public holiday. In the case of a Sunday-trading shop the position is somewhat difficult. The Sunday-trading shop can also trade on a public holiday, and if that be so I do not see why it is necessary to provide that the proprietor of that shop cannot give his assistants a half-holiday on a public holiday, because the shop will be open on that public holiday.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 96:—

In sub-section (1) (b), line 45, to delete the words "twenty-six" and substitute the words "twenty-five".

This is the same idea in another form. This is holidays during holiday period again.

Comment on this

I think amendment No. 98 in my name deals with the point which the Deputy has in mind.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 97:—

At the end of sub-section (1) to add the following proviso:—

"Provided that if the proprietor of a shop to which this section applies allows to each member of the staff of such shop a half-holiday not later than 1.30 p.m. on one weekday in each week, the foregoing provisions of this sub-section shall not apply in any such case."

This, again, is on the question of the half-holiday commencing at 1.30 p.m.

Comment on this

I think that is similar to the Deputy's previous amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 98:—

Before sub-section (3) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

(3) Where annual leave is allowed to a member of the staff of a shop, which is either a refreshment house or licensed premises, the following provisions shall have effect, that is to say:—

(a) the proprietor of such shop shall be deemed for the purposes of this section to have allowed such member one whole holiday in the month in which such annual leave commences;

(b) no part of a day falling within such annual leave shall be deemed to be a half-holiday for the purposes of sub-section (2) of this section.

The purpose of this amendment is obvious. It is to provide that the proprietor of any class of shop mentioned will be deemed to have allowed an assistant a whole holiday in the month in which that assistant's annual leave commences, and that no part of a day falling within such annual leave shall be deemed to be a half-holiday for the purposes of the section. I think that is a reasonable provision. It is designed to meet the points which Deputy Dockrell also had in mind in framing his amendment.

Comment on this

On the section, I should like to ask the Minister what number of hours an employee is supposed to work in the remaining days of a week in which the proprietor allows him a whole holiday?

Comment on this

I think we will have to make clear what is precisely in mind. What is intended, of course, is that the holidays shall count for the purpose of calculating the number of hours worked in the week. Otherwise, there would be no point in having a provision with regard to a holiday at all. I am not sure that it is necessary to have such a provision, but I think it is better to have it in order to prevent any doubt on the matter. If a person gets a whole holiday or a half-holiday in the week, then the maximum number of hours that person should work must be regulated accordingly.

Comment on this

If that is so, why put in the provision for 48 hours in the Bill at all, since everybody must get a half-holiday? If a half-holiday is provided for, then it is only in connection with a whole holiday that such a provision should be made.

Comment on this

Yes, that is a fair presentation, I think. It is not clear, however, and I should like the matter to be left over for the present because it is a bit complicated.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 100, standing in the name of Deputy Norton:—

Before sub-section (1), to insert the following new sub-section:—

(1) Except as regards shops in which all, or any, of the businesses mentioned in the Fourth Schedule to this Act are carried on, it shall not be lawful for the proprietor of a shop to permit a member of the staff of that shop to work on Sunday.

The sub-section, as it stands, does not prohibit Sunday work, but it allows what one might call compensatory holidays to members of staffs of shops working on Sundays and so on. The purpose of the amendment submitted by Deputy Norton is to prohibit Sunday work except in certain cases as set out in this Fourth Schedule. I do not propose to read out the list of cases set out in that Schedule, as it is a very long list, but it includes shops the business of which is the sale by retail of intoxicating liquors, the sale of meals or refreshments for consumption on the premises, the sale of table waters, sweets, and so on, the sale of newspapers, periodicals or magazines, the sale of milk, cream, bread and so on, and the sale of motor, cycle or aircraft supplies.

Comment on this

I think that this amendment would be more appropriate to the Hours of Trading Bill. The Shops (Hours of Trading) Bill will prohibit the opening of certain classes of shops on a Sunday, and once that is done the question of employment in that case in such shops is automatically fixed. I think that what Deputy Norton was trying to achieve by an amendment to this Bill would more properly arise on the Shops (Hours of Trading) Bill.

Comment on this

I think the same applies to the Schedule.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That covers amendment No. 128, of course.

Comment on this

Yes, that covers the Schedule.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 101:—

In sub-section (1), line 5, after the word "shop" to insert the words "not being a refreshment house".

Comment on this

I am afraid I could not accept this amendment, because it would be contrary to the whole intention of the Bill. The effect of it would be to deprive shop assistants of that which the Bill intended to provide.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 103, standing in Deputy Norton's name:—

In sub-section (1), line 10, to delete the word "four" and substitute the word "three".

This arises out of the same thing about compensatory days, and the idea is to change the number of hours mentioned from four hours to three hours and to entitle an employee, who works for three hours on a Sunday, to a compensatory holiday. In certain towns in Ireland, such as Dublin, Cork and Limerick, certain assistants in licensed premises work from two to five o'clock and, according to the present wording of the section, they would not fulfil the conditions of the Bill so as to entitle them to a compensatory holiday. The idea of this amendment is to bring them in and grant them a compensatory day in lieu of the hours worked on Sunday.

Comment on this

The amendment looks very innocent, but I am afraid it would effect a very great change in what is intended by the Bill. As the Bill stands, an assistant who works three hours on a Sunday is entitled to a half-holiday, and if he works for more than four hours on a Sunday he is entitled to a whole holiday. I am afraid I could not accept the amendment because it would effect changes which would be too much to contemplate, and, in fact, it is more than has been asked for.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 105, standing in Deputy Norton's name:

Before sub-section (2), to insert the following new sub-section:—

(2) The proprietor of a shop shall not permit any person not a member of the staff of that shop, who by virtue of this section may not be employed on a whole day or on a half-holiday (as the case may be) in a shop if he is a member of the staff of such last mentioned shop to do shop work for him on such day or half-holiday (as the case may be).

The purpose of the amendment is to ensure that the provisions of the Bill will not be availed of by an employee working in a shop other than the shop in which he is normally employed. Its purpose is to ensure that that would be made impossible. It may be said that there is already a provision dealing with that situation in the case of the annual holidays, but the purpose of the amendment is simply to provide that, in respect of hours of work, the same protection will be given as is given in the case of annual holidays, and that a person cannot be on duty in a shop other than the shop in which he is normally employed and thus evade the hours provisions.

Comment on this

I am not sure that that is necessary, and in any event I am not quite sure that it is the best way to do it. I think that what the Deputy has in mind is that a person who is entitled to a holiday from one employer must not be permitted to spend that holiday in working for another employer. The way to deal with that situation would be to deal with it as we dealt with similar cases in the Conditions of Employment Act, and that is to make it illegal for the employee to take such employment. Instead of making it illegal for the employer to employ the person concerned, I think the best thing would be to make it illegal for such a person to take that employment. If you deal with it in the other way, it might prove to be unfair to the employer, who might not be aware of the circumstances. The employee, however, knows what he is doing and, if he commits the offence, he should be punished. The employer would always have the defence that he employed this person as an extra hand for a day or a half-day, not knowing that in doing so he was committing an offence, but the person who takes the employment does so knowing full well what he is doing. That is the way we dealt with it under the Conditions of Employment Act—not merely making it illegal for the employer, but also making it illegal for the employee to take the work. It was the only effective way to do it. Of course, there is not so much danger of that kind of thing arising in this connection. It might arise in some cases, but it is not very likely that, in any particular district, a shop assistant will get a holiday on a day when trade will be so considerable that other shop proprietors will be considering the employment of additional staff. I think that the danger of that type of practice developing is remote. Apparently, however, there is some danger—the danger I mention is confined to the licensed trade—and because of that danger I am prepared to consider a provision of that kind, but it would be a provision designed against the employee himself and would be designed to see that he took a holiday when he got it.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

I should like to know from the Minister whether he would also deal with the question of the voluntary worker as distinct from the person who takes employment. I am referring to the person who gets, say, a half-day off, and who is a brother or a cousin and comes in and works in the other man's place for him. I was told some years ago, at a time when, in fact, every public-house in Dublin, even though the law allowed them to keep open until 11 o'clock, had to shut at 9 o'clock because the employees would not work after 9 o'clock. As the law then stood, every public-house could remain open till 11. The law did not compel them to shut, but they had to shut at 9 o'clock because the employees all went home, or at least left the shop. I was told that there were many houses, however, which were owned by individuals who kept open until 11 o'clock because they were working themselves. Shop assistants from other shops, having left the place in which they were employed, used to come down and help their friends, not for money, but simply because they wanted to do a good turn to a friend. That condition of affairs may never occur again, but at the same time I think the Minister ought to deal with voluntary as well as paid labour.

Comment on this

I think the provision of the 1936 Act is that any person on holiday is precluded from doing any form of industrial work. The provision in this Bill may have to be that any person on holiday will be prevented from doing shop work or industrial work.

Comment on this

I take it that it will cover annual holidays, too.

Comment on this

It will have to.

Comment on this

I am not concerned about how this practice is prevented. I understand the Minister is to look into the matter and do something to obviate the practice. I am quite satisfied with that and I shall withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I desire to move amendment No. 105a:—

Before sub-section (2) to insert the following sub-section:—

The provisions of this section shall not apply to the proprietor of a shop legally engaged in keeping open shop under the Pharmacy Act (Ireland), 1875, and the Pharmacy Act, (Ireland), 1875, Amendment Act, 1890.

Comment on this

If I might interrupt the Deputy, is not this the case where the Minister promised to look into the matter?

Comment on this

Not quite. I promised to look into the proposal of Deputy Dockrell that, instead of working 48 hours in the week, chemists' assistants might be limited to 96 hours in the fortnight. That was probably designed to meet somewhat the point Deputy Keogh is now making. I take it that Deputy Keogh has in mind the case that, where a chemist's assistant works on a Sunday, the chemist will be excluded from the obligation of giving the extra half-day in the week in lieu of the Sunday work.

Comment on this

It is tantamount to that. Speaking generally, this Bill is welcomed by me as a definite advance in the social legislation of this country. The public understand that the services of pharmaceutical chemists on Sundays and bank holidays are as important for the welfare of the sick as are the services of the medical profession. Many cases are found to be sufficiently serious to warrant the calling in of medical aid on Sundays and this is invariably accompanied by the need for obtaining medicines suitable for the particular malady. It is essential, therefore, that facilities for the dispensing of such medicines should be made available. The agreement between the association and the Irish Union of Distributive Workers and Clerks is considered very satisfactory. It provides that the assistants may be worked on alternate Sundays without receiving any special time off in lieu.

Pharmaceutical chemists are distinguished from chemists and druggists; they can only compound under the Pharmacy Act. There are many in Dublin and throughout the country. There is usually the master man and his qualified assistant, his legally qualified assistant as distinct from the fully qualified man. Let us assume that he does 120 hours' duty in the city or the country and he gets the alternate Sunday. The master will say to him, "You will be on duty this Sunday and I will be on duty next Sunday." If that man is to be let away for the whole day the master will have to get in another person. It would be necessary for him to have someone qualified behind the counter. If he needs a man he cannot ring up the labour exchange to get such a man. There is no such thing here as a Pharmaceutical Assistants' Bureau, where a man can be obtained for the day at 10/- or 15/-, or whatever the rate may be. If he has to pay that man it may not be a case of the cost of living going up, but of the cost of dying going up, because it may mean more for your prescriptions.

Comment on this

That is a terrible reflection on the chemists.

Comment on this

In this matter I hold a brief something similar to that of Deputy Cole, inasmuch as he and I, out of the 138 Deputies here, find ourselves the only registered pharmaceutical chemists, though, fortunately or unfortunately, we are not engaged in the shop business. It is the public we have in mind in connection with this thing. It is possible that a man might want a little digitalis or some of the other things that are essential in the medical profession. The shops engaged in this business are mostly lock-up shops and it is possible that a man would sooner close up the shop, as it might be more convenient from a business point of view or as an economic proposition. For instance, the chemist might prefer to shut up the shop and give his man the day off. I am not now touching the side of the business dealing with the sale of hairbrushes, lipstick or port wine; I am not entering into that portion of the business. I have more in mind prescriptions and things of that sort.

It should be remembered that there are certain privileges given to students who desire to become pharmaceutical chemists. If they put in a certain number of years in the chemists' shops they are let off for lectures. The work is different to that of the man who has to tot up figures or cut linen behind a counter. Perhaps the Minister could see his way to accept the amendment I have tabled. The Minister knows all about this, and so do the Labour Party. I am perfectly satisfied that the combination of both makes one too many for me. I think they ought to admit that the chemist should get a look in.

Comment on this

I think that Deputy Keogh has gone somewhat outside the terms of his amendment. We think that if the Bill becomes law in its present form it will seriously impair the essential public service which the Pharmaceutical Society renders. Pharmacy is part of the medical and health service and if you restrict its practice you might as well restrict the medical profession altogether. It would be impossible, notwithstanding the facilities of the tabloid concerns with which we are so much acquainted now—it would be impossible, even with the assistance of those combinations, for a medical man to carry on. I have known cases in the country when we were called up in the middle of the night to telephone for serum, which it would be impossible for the medical man to carry, because these things must be kept fresh. If we restrict altogether the members of the Pharmaceutical Society or restrict interference with them it would be better. If this Bill is passed as it stands it will be a very serious matter not only for pharmaceutical chemists but for the general public. I think it will be a relief to many pharmaceutical chemists who are called to act on various emergencies. It would be a serious inconvenience and loss to the public at large for people will not be able to get their requirements. They cannot get medicines in unexpected cases. I think this Bill should not interfere at all with the qualified pharmaceutical chemists who should be exempted from it altogether irrespective of the sort of work they do.

As Deputy Keogh has said, the pharmaceutical assistants are different altogether from the ordinary shop assistants. To begin with, the pharmaceutical chemist must keep a qualified assistant. If he leaves his place of business he must leave a qualified man behind him. Now, if these restrictions are put on, what will happen? The qualified man will not be employed. It would be very difficult for such men then to get employment and there will be a big addition of a new class of man on your unemployed list. Deputy Keogh said that although the pharmaceutical chemist has certain grievances he has not nearly as much now as in the old days when he had to work from 8 in the morning until 11 at night. Even after leaving the shop he had to make up his books and then perhaps read up for an examination that was coming off. These days are now past. The pharmaceutical assistant agrees that the services now required of him are moderate and agreeable. A young man going in for that business has a long course. Sometimes he has to board and lodge away from home; he has lectures to take out. He has to get a certain amount of time in which to do that and that is not allowed for in the Bill. He has to attend those lectures during the day and sometimes during the evening.

Comment on this

Do they ever get any sleep at all?

Comment on this

Not much sleep. We are often called up three or four times during the night. There is now a certain amount of latitude in the association. The union have agreed to terms that are quite reasonable. If the Bill is to remain as it is, it will mean that the services performed by members of the Pharmaceutical Society will be very seriously impaired. I would ask the Minister to reconsider this matter. At the time when the Juries Bill was going through the House we had some negotiations with the late Kevin O'Higgins. We wanted the Pharmaceutical Society exempted, and eventually the Minister for Justice reconsidered the matter and exempted them. If the Minister now realises the responsibility he is taking on, he will, after consideration, see that pharmaceutical chemists are exempted from this Bill.

Comment on this

We have no objection to pharmaceutical chemists opening on Sunday to carry on business purely and simply as pharmaceutical chemists. We are quite aware of what it costs to become a qualified chemist. We know the chemist has to attend lectures, and we know the amount of money that has to be spent on his education. We do not know that the chemist or his assistant has to go to the university and pass examinations in order that he may be qualified to sell white-wash brushes, face powder, sheep dip, or things of that sort. That is our difficulty. If a chemist would open on Sunday and confine his activities purely and simply to selling the things within his own line, there would be no objection. But there is a very strong objection to their doing what we all know they have been doing in the past ten years—transgressing into selling other things, and opening their premises on Sundays to sell them. Their sales activities extend now to cameras, face powders, sheep dip, and in fact it is difficult to say what particular article of merchandise is immune from the activities of the chemist. We would have no objection if they confined themselves to selling medicines and drugs. Everybody with a sick head on a Sunday morning should be entitled to go into a chemist's shop to get something to cure it; but nobody wants to buy white-wash brushes, sheep dip, or face powders on a Sunday. I do not know why they should be permitted any exemption for selling these things.

Comment on this

The question of Sunday opening is not the only question that arises here. I think Deputy Cole has made a very good case for the inclusion of the chemists' assistants under the terms of the Bill. We are not now dealing with the Shops (Hours of Trading) Bill. We are dealing with the Bill that is limiting the hours of work for shop assistants, and if shop assistants in the drug trade are working 14 hours a day, and half the night as well, it seems to me that that is the best possible case for bringing them under the provisions of this Bill.

Comment on this

I did not say they were working 14 hours a day now. I said that was so in the old days. There is a 48 hours week arranged now with the union.

Comment on this

Then if they are working only 48 hours a week now, where is the objection? It is not necessary that they should be exempted. Is it not a 48-hour week now?

Comment on this

Well, if there is such an arrangement this Bill is in no way interfering with it. What, then, is the trouble about?

Comment on this

The trouble is that the chemist cannot, by ringing up the exchange, get another man. The rule that generally obtains is that the chemist has one assistant. The chemist himself manages to put in some hours one Sunday and his assistant does it the following Sunday. The Bill will work in such a way that the chemist, because of an hour or two on Sunday, must have a third man. If that is so, then the cost of dying will go up.

Comment on this

I think the chemists have some sort of a case to argue, but in the present instance both Deputies Cole and Keogh have pressed the case so unduly that they would prejudice anyone against their proposal. The only question here is whether the existing agreement between the chemist and his assistants, which provides for the assistant working two hours on alternative Sundays, should be allowed unchanged or whether the previous Bill should operate which necessitated giving half a day during the week to the assistant employed on Sunday. That is all. What it has to do with the cost of dying or this sudden demand for serum for which special trains have to be chartered and dispatched is a thing I cannot understand.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Keogh was speaking of the cost of dyeing, not in the sense of the usual spelling of the word.

Comment on this

If a person gets sick at 10 o'clock on a Sunday morning after this Bill is passed, he would be in the same position as at present. The voluntary arrangement made by the chemists and their assistants has nothing to do with the Bill. There is no provision in the Bill requiring the chemist to close at any time. All the Bill does require is that the 48-hour week should operate, and that certain provisions as to half-holidays, restrictions upon Sunday work and leave should apply. The point made by Deputies Cole and Keogh is that the present arrangement with pharmaceutical chemists who work on Sundays for two hours and then only on alternate Sundays, subject to the preservation of a 48-hour week, should be sufficient without imposing upon the chemist this further liability of giving a half-day as compensation for the two hours on the Sunday. The amendment is to exempt them from this provision entirely, irrespective of what changes may take place in the practice or what the practice may be in particular parts of the country. There is no legal validity behind the agreement between chemists and their assistants in Dublin, and I do not know that that agreement applies nationally.

Comment on this

It does not.

Comment on this

If the intention is to ensure that a chemist's assistant who works 2 hours on Sunday need not get a half-day in lieu of those two hours, then I am prepared to provide for that, subject to the maximum of 48 hours in the week. That, however, is different from what the Deputy's amendment proposes, and it is, I think, in fact, the practice. If that will meet the point of the chemists, then their point is met, but I got the impression that, upon a slender basis, they have been trying to build a case for exemption from the Bill as a whole. They cannot get that, nor have they made any case for it.

Comment on this

The idea would be 96 hours over two weeks—50 hours in one week and 46 hours in the next.

Comment on this

There would have to be a special provision in respect of Sunday in any event.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 106:—

At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—

This section shall not apply to the proprietor of a shop which is licensed premises.

I put the case for this amendment before the Minister already. The Minister would not accept my argument on a similar amendment, and I shall not argue this one.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to agree to the amendment. In respect of all classes of workers, we are providing that if they work on Sundays they must get time off during the week in lieu of the time so worked.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

On the section, I ask the Minister to consider the question of allowing one whole holiday in the case of Sunday workers instead of two half-holidays. If a person works less than 4 hours on Sunday he is entitled to a compensatory half-holiday. He is also entitled to a half-holiday during the week under the ordinary provisions of the Act. I ask the Minister to make it permissible to amalgamate these two half-holidays into one whole holiday. Of course, if an employee works for more than 4 hours on Sunday, he must get 1½ days' holiday. I do not ask the Minister for an immediate answer, but I ask him to consider the matter and, when the Bill is recommitted, to put in an amendment to give effect to my suggestion.

Comment on this

I shall consider that.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 107 (a):—

Before Section 33 to insert a new section as follows:—

The provisions of the two preceding sections shall not apply to any shop where the following businesses shall be carried on, that is to say:—

(a) the business of selling newspapers, periodicals, stationery, cheap books, novels and magazines;

(b) the business of selling tobacco or smokers' requisites;

(c) the business of confectioners.

Comment on this

I could not agree to this amendment. The object of the amendment is to exempt the businesses named from the provisions concerning compensatory holidays for Sundays and public holidays. That would be contrary to the intention of the Bill and the amendment, as worded, goes much further than that, because the Deputy seeks to exempt from the scope of this section any shop where these businesses might be carried on even if other businesses are carried on as well. I do not know if that was what he intended. In any event, I should not be prepared to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Not even in its narrower sense?

Comment on this

No. I think that the same provisions in respect of holidays should apply to workers in these shops as well as to workers in other shops which open on Sundays.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 109 and 113 may, I think, be considered in connection with amendment No. 108.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 108 on behalf of Deputy Lawlor:—

In sub-section (1), line 50, to delete the word "six" and substitute the word "fourteen."

Under Section 33, employees in special-trade shops are entitled to 14 days' annual leave, but employees in non-special-trade shops, such as hardware shops, are entitled only to 6 days' leave. The purpose of this amendment is to secure that there will be no distinction between special-trade shops and non-special-trade shops as regards annual leave—in other words, that the employee in hardware premises should get the same leave as an employee in licensed premises. I do not think that any case can be made against that proposal. In recent times, arrangements have been arrived at between employers and trade unions with the result that, in a great many trades in Dublin and other cities and towns, employees are granted 12 days' leave per annum, plus Sundays and bank holidays when they occur within that period. The purpose of this amendment is simply to give legislative sanction to what has already been agreed upon by trade unions with decent employers in Dublin and elsewhere. It is rather unfair to penalise decent employers who have agreed with trade unions to grant their employees 14 days' leave per annum by allowing other employers who are not quite as decent to get away with a leave allowance of six days per annum. This amendment will be pressed by the Labour Party.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to accept the proposal for 14 days' leave in these cases. The reason for the difference between special-trade shops and non-special-trade shops is that employees in special-trade shops are not given the right to six holidays on public holidays during the year.

The employees in the non-special-trade shops get six public holidays with pay, and, in addition, six consecutive days' holiday with pay. The employees in special-trade shops do not get the six public holidays, but, as compensation, their annual holiday period is fixed at 14 consecutive days. They are, therefore, similarly situated and there is no necessity to amend the section to secure for one section terms as good as those given to another. The intention is to ensure that, and it is believed that the arrangement here does in fact provide that the employees in both classes of shops have, in essence, the same provision made for them. We are, however, here providing for a minimum statutory provision in respect of annual holidays for shop workers. We set out that the minimum holidays, other than the annual holidays, shall be six consecutive days. That is the same provision as was made for industrial workers under the Act of 1936. It is, of course, not so framed as to preclude the possibility of an employer giving more holidays, or entering into an agreement with an organisation of workers to provide a longer period of holidays. We are setting out here what the legal minimum will be and I do not think it is desirable at this stage to fix the legal minimum beyond six consecutive days.

Deputy McGowan mentioned trade union agreements providing for longer holidays. There may be such, but there are not very many of them. I have no distinct recollection of ever having seen an agreement of that kind providing for longer than six days. Except in special cases, such as the special-trade shops which I mentioned here, the great majority of the trade union agreements provide for six days. In any event, I think we should be satisfied at this stage with raising the legal requirement to that level. It will ensure for a very large number of workers in the distributive trades an annual holiday this year for the first time, and I do not think we should try to push that too far. I know, of course, that if I had brought in a proposal to give workers 14 days' holidays, the Labour Party would have proposed 21 days or 28 days. They had to raise my ante in any event, but in this particular case, I am quite serious in my belief that it would be unwise to push this legislation too far or too rapidly. If we can succeed in having this idea of annual paid holidays generally applied and enforced on the basis of six consecutive days, we shall have done as much as we should attempt to do at this stage. There is, of course, no limit being fixed in respect of the future, no barrier being placed against giving longer holidays, or against trade unions seeking agreements for longer holidays, but we are not proposing to make the statutory provision more than that at this time.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister is quite justified in saying that if the Bill provided 14 days, the Labour Party would have suggested 21 and so on. The fact of the matter is that in putting down this amendment we had in mind that the prevailing practice for shop and office employment is a fortnight's holiday each year. I think the Minister will recognise that that is a very common practice.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy means when he speaks of the prevailing practice, but if he determines that in relation to the numbers of persons employed, I should say that the prevailing practice is to give no holidays at all. In certain of the larger shops, they do give more than a fortnight's holidays, but only in certain shops.

Comment on this

I suggest that the purpose of legislation of this kind is to bring bad employments up to the level of reasonably good employments, and while there are people engaged in shop work who get more than a fortnight's holidays in the year, it is a very common practice, and certainly the prevailing practice in the decent employments in the towns and cities, for assistants to get a fortnight's holiday with pay, and I think the Minister might very well accept that principle and ensure that every shop employee will get a fortnight's holiday. A fortnight is not a long period and it is a very common thing in shops and offices for workers to get a fortnight's holiday each year.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say whether six days' holiday per annum is enough for a shop assistant?

Comment on this

It is sufficient to make the legal minimum requirement. I am not going to express an opinion as to what holidays a shop assistant requires. What we are doing here, and I emphasise it again, is fixing the legal minimum, and not determining what the practice will be in any particular trade or part of the country, and I am satisfied that we should not at present attempt to fix the legal minimum higher than six consecutive days, plus, of course, the six annual holidays.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 112.

In sub-section (9), page 18, line 25, to insert before the words "this Act" the words "this Part of".

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

Section 2 says:

Where the proprietor of both a special-trade shop and a non-special-trade shop employs any person as a member of the staff of one of such shops during any part of an employment year of such person, and as a member of the staff of the other of such shops during any other part of such employment year, such person shall be deemed for the purpose of this section to be a member of the staff of such special-trade shop during such employment year...

That is all right in the larger businesses where he is transferred from one type of business to another; but take the case of, say, a confectioner in the suburbs or country town, who puts out a table with a few bottles of lemonade on it on a bank holiday. Will that bring a person into the special class? I think the Minister might very well look into some of the ramifications of this section in respect of some of the smaller general shops. Would a confectioner have to keep time-sheets for his assistants in order to say what people might be engaged on this type of special trade? I should like the Minister to look into that aspect of the matter.

Comment on this

Obviously there must be some provision to deal with the case of mixed employment. What we suggest here is that if a person is employed by one proprietor partly in connection with a special trade and partly in connection with a non-special trade, he will get the holidays provided for that special trade.

Comment on this

I think "partly" is too general a term.

Comment on this

His employment must be continuous for a year, in any event. If it is very casual, or intermittent, or of a very short duration, I think it is in the interests of the proprietor to ensure that the mixture of employment does not take place at all. I think that could be easily arranged. It is necessary to make some provision, and I think the best provision to make is to ensure that if a person can come in under one head or the other, he gets the best conditions of either. If you do not provide that, you must provide something else, and the only alternative is that he shall get the worst.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 114:—

At the end of sub-section (1) to add the following proviso:—

Provided that the time so selected in any year shall not be earlier than the first day of June or later than the thirtieth day of September.

The purpose of this amendment, in the name of Deputy Norton, is to provide that the leave period will be during the summer. As the Bill stands the employer will select the period at which the annual leave will be given. It may be argued, if this amendment was inserted in the Bill, and even if there was an agreement between the employer and the employee for a period outside the summer period, that the summer period would still have to be adhered to. That objection might be overcome by a slight alteration. There is a great deal to be said for not leaving it entirely to the employer to choose the leave period. Annual holidays are normally taken in the summer, and if they are not taken then they lose a good deal of the advantage to be derived from them. I suggest that the Minister should either accept this amendment, or indicate that he will be prepared to insert some such amendment at another stage, something that would provide that the normal leave period would be in the summer, and that the employer would not be permitted to give leave at a time when it would not be beneficial.

Comment on this

I have a certain amount of sympathy with the amendment but, in practice, it would be difficult to provide for it. The proprietors of large shops, in which a number of workers are engaged, will, in fact, have to spread the holidays over a longer period than that contemplated in the amendment, just as in the public service at the present time civil servants are, in many cases, required to take their period of leave late in the winter or early in the year. I think that is unavoidable. In the great majority of cases the proprietors of shops will endeavour to meet the wishes of assistants. It is very rarely that cases will arise where assistants will be compelled to take their holidays at utterly unsuitable times, but, having regard to the circumstances of cases that may arise, it is necessary to ensure that holidays should be taken at the discretion of the employers. I do not think that it would be wise to provide for the exclusion of any period of the year whether with or without the consent of employers. We had discussions about this on the Act of 1936, and the question was raised on a number of occasions since by different organisations of workers and other persons and, in every case, when I looked into the matter I came to the conclusion that it was not possible to intervene. I know of many cases where agreements were made with employers for the drawing up and the carrying out of a scheme of holidays designed to meet the convenience both of employers and workers. In fact, I think that was the normal practice. In trades of a special kind or of a seasonal character it was found impracticable to give the employees holidays in the summer months, and they had to be satisfied to get them at other periods of the year. Quite possibly the same question will arise now, and that the one period of the year when the services of employees would be fully occupied would be the period that the rest of us ordinarily regard as the holiday period. In such cases, presumably, the giving of holidays would take place at other periods. I have sympathy with the idea behind the amendment, but I think it is impossible to give practical effect to it.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider introducing the principle of extending the period from May to October instead of June to September?

Comment on this

That brings the Department into the picture to supervise the fulfilment of the operation.

Comment on this

Would that present any greater difficulty than the difficulty of supervision that will be there?

Comment on this

Of course, we give workers the right to recover in lieu of holidays.

Comment on this

Restricting the period within which they must get holidays will not make it more difficult for the Department.

Comment on this

One aspect of this question has not been dealt with. If this amendment were passed, would its provisions be mandatory? I think employers try to give their employees holidays at a period that suits them, spread over a certain period. Of course the months of June, July, August and September may be the busiest months of the year and accordingly that period is altogether too short. An English poet wrote: "Oh to be in England now that April is here," but apparently the Labour Party do not think that the ideal time for a holiday. In any event, I do not think the holidays could be squeezed into that period.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider the acceptance of a longer period?

Comment on this

I would be very reluctant to do so. I think it has to be left to negotiation in each case. That might be the only period of the year when the services of employees would be fully occupied. I do not know if any great difficulty arose in that regard under the 1936 Act. In some cases there was adjustment. I think you must leave the period of holidays to the employers.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 115:—

Before sub-section (3) to insert the following sub-section:—

It shall be a proper defence, for the proprietor of a refreshment house, to a breach of the regulations in this section to show that an emergency had arisen, by reason of death, illness, breakdown of plant, unusually heavy bookings or reservations. or any other happening which could not be reasonably anticipated.

This amendment deals with a case where an emergency arises, and I understand the Minister is going to look into it.

Comment on this

I do not think the provision is necessary at all in this Bill.

Comment on this

I should be glad if the Minister would consider adding the words "to affirm or to declare" to paragraph (b) of this section. I am aware that in the Interpretation Act which was passed before Christmas the definition of an oath is taken to include "to affirm or to declare". I noticed, however, in the evening papers of Wednesday last that some difficulty arose in the District Court and that the justice apparently was not prepared to accept the position as it stands. I should be glad if the Minister would include the usual words "to affirm or to declare" in the section.

Comment on this

I will look into the point.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 117:—

Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

Where as a result of the operation of Section 22 of this Act—

(a) the proprietor of a shop claims that the wages paid to a member of his staff or to a class of members of his staff are unduly high, and

(b) no rules under this Part of this Act fixing minimum wages and applicable to such member or class of members are in force, such proprietor or a person who claims to be representative of proprietors of the class of shops to which the shop of such proprietor belongs may send to the Minister an application (in this Part of this Act referred to as a minimum wages application) to have a minimum rate of wages fixed for that class of shops situate in the area specified in such application.

The purpose of the amendment is to give the Minister power to vary wages up or down.

Comment on this

I can contemplate the possibility of fixing minimum rates of wages, but if the Deputy wants to have maximum rates fixed and enforced, in my opinion it would be completely impracticable in relation to shop assistants where the wages paid to individuals have to vary considerably in accordance with their individual skill and capabilities.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister understands my point. He is taking power to fix certain minimum rates of wages for certain classes of individuals. Something might occur as a result of which you would have greatly changed conditions and, in consequence, employers might feel that the maximum or the minimum, as the case may be, was too high, and that the rate should be fixed at another level. What I want is to have that rate fixed as soon as it has been ratified by the parties concerned.

Comment on this

That is provided for in Section 42, where it is provided "any person may apply to the Minister to have any rules fixing minimum rates of wages which are enforced amended in specified respects or revoked".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 118:—

In sub-section (3), page 22, line 49, to delete the words "is in force" and substitute the words "which are in force, is referred to the Board".

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 119:—

Before Section 46 to insert a new section as follows:—

Where, at the passing of this Act, there is in force between members of the staffs of shops and proprietors of shops or between the representatives of the staffs of shops and the representatives of the proprietors of shops an agreement as to wages, such agreement, when a copy thereof has been sent to the Minister, shall until amended or revoked by the board have effect as if it were a rule of the board fixing a minimum rate of wage fixed and in force in accordance with the provisions of this Part of this Act.

The effect of the amendment is that when there is an agreement in force between the staffs of shops and proprietors they can by sending it to the Minister have it registered, and that it will then have the same effect as if it were a decision of the board.

Comment on this

I would ask the Deputy to leave the amendment over. I think it will be necessary to have a provision of the kind in certain cases, but at the moment I am not quite clear as to how best to do it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 119a:—

In sub-section (1), page 23, line 40, to delete the words "clear of all deductions".

These words, "clear of all deductions," seem to me to be too sweeping, because there are certain cases where employees have acceded to deductions being made for certain benefits received, as well, of course, as other matters such as national health payments, which are exempted. I do not know whether the idea is not to allow certain deductions which are being made at present in certain cases.

Comment on this

It would be a dangerous principle to provide for the possibility of deductions being made from the minimum wage provided for by order of the board. Under sub-section (6) the word "deduction" is defined. From that definition it is clear that deductions for statutory purposes are permitted, but all other deductions are excluded. I agree that it might be desirable to permit of deductions being made by agreement for some such purpose as a benefit fund or a holiday fund or for some other fund to which the employees agree to contribute.

Comment on this

Or an advance in cash.

Comment on this

The Deputy is now bringing us to a point where one can conceive of the possibility of abuses arising, and of the principle of the minimum wage, contemplated in this part of the Bill, being defeated by deductions of one kind or another, or the imposition of fines or penalties, all of which would operate to reduce the minimum wage. I will look into the point, but it would be with very considerable reluctance that I would contemplate making any change. We must adhere to the principle of the wage being paid clear of all deductions, but we may exempt certain clearly specified forms of deductions.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Norton, I move amendment No. 120:—

In pages 25 and 26, to delete sub-sections (6), (7), (8) and (9) and substitute the following sub-section:—

(6) Notwithstanding anything contained in Section 13 of the Shops Act, 1912, as modified by Section 21 of that Act, it shall be the duty of the sanitary authority for every district, as part of their duties under the Public Health Acts, to enforce the provisions of this Part of this Act.

This is the section that makes provision with regard to sanitary or other arrangements in shops. Sub-section (1) requires that suitable and sufficient means of ventilation shall be provided and maintained. There is another provision which gives the local sanitary authority the right to make certain exemptions and sets out the conditions which must be complied with before they can do that. The object of the amendment is to secure that the local sanitary authority shall not have this power, as it is considered that in a good many instances the local board exercising the authority would be composed of shopkeepers, and, therefore, the giving of this power to local sanitary authorities is not to be commended. In Section 49 "the expression ‘suitable and sufficient' means in relation to any shop or part of a shop suitable and sufficient having regard to the circumstances and conditions affecting that shop or part". I submit that that definition sufficiently protects the proprietor of a shop. I think it will be agreed that in a good many parts of the country, probably not intentionally but perhaps through neglect, the requirements contemplated in this section have been allowed to get into a deplorable state, with the result that shop assistants in many places are living under intolerable conditions. If you leave this power of exemption with the local bodies they will be subject to local influences and so on, and as members of boards are human the result will be that the intention of the Bill will not be carried out.

Comment on this

Of course, the sanitary authorities may grant an exemption from the provisions regarding sanitary arrangements only where they are satisfied that alternative accommodation and suitable and sufficient washing facilities are otherwise conveniently available. That is on the face of it a reasonable provision. I think what the Deputy has in mind is that sanitary authorities are not fulfilling their duties properly. That, however, is a somewhat different matter. So far as this part of the Bill is concerned, we must set out reasonable requirements, set out what the law is, see that the law is reasonable, and then subsequently there arises the question of seeing that the law is enforced. It is reasonable, in my opinion, to ensure that these requirements as to the sanitary arrangements in the Bill may be met in certain cases where the sanitary authority is prepared to grant exemption when satisfied that alternative arrangements and suitable and adequate facilities exist, and I would not be prepared to change the law in that respect.

I am disposed to agree that it may be necessary to consider the general question of enforcement, and I am quite prepared to bring that matter to the notice of the Department of Local Government, which is the Department directly concerned, and ensure that they will impress upon local sanitary authorities the desirability of carrying out properly their duties in respect of these Acts. I do not think, however, that we should go further than to set out in the Acts themselves what we regard as a reasonable provision, and not allow ourselves to be provoked, by the failure of certain authorities to do their duty, to make the law appear on the face of it unreasonable.

Comment on this

Would you not take the enforcement out of the hands of the local authorities?

Comment on this

It is all a matter of enforcement. The law is all right if it is enforced.

Comment on this

A lot of the sanitary authorities do not enforce it, particularly outside the cities.

Comment on this

I would not say that. Some of them could do more than they are doing.

Comment on this

Under sub-section (9) of this section, if an order is made and they then proceed to cancel it, there is provision for appealing to the Minister against the sanitary authority's wish to cancel the order. I suggest to the Minister that in sub-sections (6) and (7) provision should be made for appeal against the refusal of a sanitary authority to make the original order. It seems to be a logical conclusion from the other provision. If you can appeal against the cancellation of an order, you should be able to appeal against refusal to make the original order.

Comment on this

I am not so sure that there is much in that point, but I shall look into it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Might I suggest, in order to get the Bill out of Committee to-night, that the remaining amendments be postponed for the Report Stage?

Comment on this

It has been agreed to dispose of all the amendments to-night by withdrawing them if time does not permit of their consideration so that the Committee Stage can be concluded now.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When will the next stage be taken?

Comment on this

I think you had better order it for 2nd February, but I am not sure that we will be ready to take it on that day.

Comment on this

The Minister will take some time to get the new draft out, and I think there ought to be a fortnight's interval between the circulation of the Bill, as amended, and the next stage.

Comment on this

I think it is no harm to order it for the 2nd February. It is, however, most unlikely that we will be able to take it on that date. We have, of course, the Shops (Hours of Trading) Bill, which will come before it in any event. I think it is advisable to complete the Committee Stage of that Bill before we take the Recommittal Stage of this Bill. It is not improbable that the Committee Stage of that Bill will take some time, because there are a number of points which are likely to be discussed at length on it. If we take the Committee Stage of that Bill on the 2nd February, it is most unlikely that we will get any further with this Bill during that week, whatever we may do in the following week.

Comment on this

The only point I want to make is that there should be a substantial period between the issue of the Bill, as amended, and the Recommittal Stage.

Comment on this

The draft of the Bill, as amended now will, I take it, be issued from the Dáil office in the course of a day or two.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

I think Deputy Dockrell means that we should have some time to consider the Minister's further amendments to it.

Comment on this

They will hardly be ready for at least a couple of weeks.

Comment on this

There has been a number of amendments withdrawn which will be put down again.

Comment on this

Yes, all amendments not dealt with can be put down again.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Ordered provisionally for 2nd February.

Next stage ordered for 2nd February.

Comment on this