We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Agreements Between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom—Motion of Approval—(Resumed).

Contributions 182–371 of 371. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

If it does not come then it does not matter. Take another item —potatoes. These marketing schemes, I should say, are all different. Under the bacon regulations certificates for importing into Great Britain are issued to the Government here and then we give them out to the bacon factories. Under the potato regulations, there is a different procedure. The import certificates are issued to the importers in Great Britain, and these importers are free to deal with anybody they like. They can deal with us or with any country that is not prohibited, on account of certain diseases, from sending potatoes into Britain. The British Government cannot help us there. They may say to us that we have our chance with other people, and that the importers are free to deal with anybody they like.

Comment on this

Can English dealers buy from the Continent and export the stuff here?

Comment on this

No, I am talking about supplies for England — about the amount of potatoes imported into Great Britain. Instead of dividing that quantity amongst the countries, as they do in the case of bacon, they issue import licences to British merchants. These merchants are free to bring in potatoes from any country that is permitted to send potatoes to England.

Comment on this

They are not taking them into England at present.

Comment on this

When they have good crops themselves there is no need for them to import. With regard to seed potatoes we have what will practically amount to free access to the British market because seed potatoes will not come under this Article. We are much more interested in seed potatoes than we are in ware potatoes. No potatoes can come in here from Great Britain or Northern Ireland because we have more than we want. Therefore, we do not get them in.

I come now to cattle in which many Deputies are interested. I am confident that, in the case of store cattle, the quota that we get will be quite sufficient. The figure of 500,000 was mentioned. Probably that is as much as we will require. If we require a bigger quota I should say that we will not have any great difficulty in getting it. Fat cattle, cows and calves are outside that quota. In the case of cattle, I think that our biggest exports were in the year 1929. Going on the figures for that year, I think a quota for 500,000 would be sufficient. Our exports for last year were very good. According to the census we have as many cattle in the country as ever we had, but according to the eyes of some of the Deputies opposite we have not.

As regards fat cattle, the question with regard to them must come before the Beef Conference. Again, in that case I do not think that we need have any worries about the quota. I think that we will get a sufficient quota for fat cattle as soon as the question comes before the Beef Conference, and that we will be put in the same position for fat cattle as we were in last year with regard to stores—that is to say, that we will not need to have licences. The cattle will be counted and enumerated entering Great Britain so that if we exceed the quota we will be likely to hear about it, but what I want to bring out is that the individual farmer or shipper will not be bothered with licences.

Comment on this

Will the cattle be graded on the other side?

Comment on this

No; we will do the grading. The question of markings on cattle is a fine point. I hope to be able to give the House some information on that when the Bill comes up for consideration. The quotas for milk products such as cream, condensed milk and so on are enlarged. I think they will be sufficient to keep the factory that we have at Limerick going full speed. Deputies will notice that there is a special Article—Article 4—for poultry and eggs. If they look at the corresponding Article 9, they will find that we have the same right to regulate imports of agricultural produce here as the British claim in their country under Article 3.

Comment on this

The Articles are not worded the same.

Comment on this

Under Article 9 we claim that. At least it is put in that if the two Governments agree we may put on a tariff instead of a quota. They have made a separate Article for eggs and poultry. If the two Governments agree we may agree on a tariff rather than have quantitative regulation. If we do not agree on the tariff, we can proceed to have quantitative regulation. Our Article 9 can be taken as being the same as if Articles 3 and 4 were put in one. I think that would be the position.

Comment on this

I cannot see it, Sir.

Comment on this

I admit the wording is somewhat different, but I think the net result is what I say. Article 5 deals with commodities on the free list. The First Schedule refers to horses and other live quadrupeds, and to preserved fish. They are already on the free list coming into this country, and they remain on the free list; that is under this Agreement we cannot put a tariff against Great Britain on those particular items. The next Schedule gives a list of items where we take off tariffs that are there at the moment, and guarantee not to put on tariffs against Great Britain. They are: Live cattle; live sheep and lambs; live poultry, which are domestic fowls, turkeys and guinea fowls; ducks, geese, game and other live birds; poultry, dead; rabbits and hares, dead; milk, whole, fresh; eggs in shell; wheat offals; pears, raw; and rose stocks. There is one item there in regard to which perhaps some Deputies will be curious to know why it was put in, and that is wheat offals. The British Government were anxious to get wheat offals in there although they were assured by our side that they would not be sold here because they are too dear. I think it will be found that that is the position, because for the last three years during the spring months we have issued licences for the imports of bran, and we never could get British bran that would at all compete with the price here. We always had to import it from the Continent or from South America. However, if at any time in the future British wheat offals come down in price to our own level they can come in freely and be purchased by our own farmers. Now I come to Article 9, which I say is more or less the opposite to Articles 3 and 4. It gives us the power to regulate the imports of agricultural products here. Under that Article, we have the right to put tariffs on a certain number of articles. They will appear in a Bill which is being circulated, I think, tonight or to-morrow night, and there is no necessity to go into them now, but they are principally fruits, because we found it very difficult to have quantitative control over certain fruits, like strawberries, plums and grapes. Therefore we agreed to have a small tariff on those fruits, instead of regulating them quantitatively. Other items in regard to which we will have quantitative control here will be bacon and live fat pigs—we can of course regulate all pigs if we like—fish, seed oats, seed wheat, and certain feeding stuffs; possibly tomatoes and apples. Those will be regulated quantitatively.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister a question about apples and plums. That applies to English grown apples and plums?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It does not apply to Canada, Nova Scotia, or South Africa?

Comment on this

No. We are referring all the time to United Kingdom products. There is, however, a difficulty about apples which we must try to get over, and that is that under this Agreement I am not sure that we can do it absolutely by quantitative control. We may have to keep our present tariff policy at least to some extent, but whether they go on the tariff list or the quantitative control side I cannot say at the moment. They are one of the most difficult things to control.

Comment on this

I am concerned only with the outside stuff, and not with United Kingdom stuff.

Comment on this

The items under Article 9 may be discussed in greater detail when the Bills come along. Article 15 provides for the removal of subsidies, but it is worded in such a way that we will be entitled to maintain subsidies either for a marketing scheme of our own or if we thought the producer here was not getting sufficient for his product. As I said already, we do mean at any rate to continue to give subsidies on dairy products, and very probably on eggs, and I should say possibly also on seed potatoes, that is exports of seed potatoes to any country outside the United Kingdom. We have been building up a very good market for our seed potatoes. They have been getting a remarkably good reputation in many countries, but I am afraid the price we would get if we dropped the bounty would hardly be sufficient to keep our farmers in production. Therefore, it may be necessary for us to continue some bounty on seed potatoes exported to markets outside the United Kingdom for the next year or two.

Comment on this

Before leaving Article 15 perhaps the Minister would be good enough to explain the final portion, which says:—

"In particular they undertake to withdraw export bounties and subsidies in so far as the intention of such payments has been to counteract the effect of duties of customs on such goods on importation into the United Kingdom, in all cases where such duties have been abolished."

Comment on this

I think the only subsidy to which that would apply is the subsidy on bacon and pigs, because we would consider in any case that at the present price for pigs here, and pigs for export, too, there would be no necessity to give an export bounty. The bounty was given for the last three or four years as against the duty going into Great Britain. In the other cases, like dairy produce, eggs and so on, we may have to continue the bounties, because they are given to try to raise the price even above the world price.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us whether the Pigs Marketing Board are to continue operating in the same way?

Comment on this

Oh, yes. They will have to continue. Before leaving the subject of this particular Agreement, I should like to say that I think I will be in a better position to give more detail with regard to the imports, especially of agricultural products into this country, when the Bills come up for discussion. As a matter of fact, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce said already, we have during the negotiations settled a good many of those quotas or duties, as the case may be. Some of them have not yet been settled, and perhaps may not be regulated at all. There are then certain duties on agricultural products coming in here which have been left on, and where protection will continue, principally, I should say, on things like potatoes, vegetables, and so on, where we have more than we want for our own needs, and where it would be absolutely foolish to try to give the British a market here for things of which we have too much already.

Naturally, I have great sympathy with Deputies opposite who ask why we did not make this Agreement sooner, but I think the Deputies should remember that we had a very difficult situation to deal with, because it was being pointed out by Deputies opposite —and by newspapers which support them—that in the first place all those sums of money were due to Great Britain. In fact, I think that Deputies opposite and their Party went to a considerable amount of expense in getting lawyers to prove that they were due, and in printing pamphlets to prove that they were due. Naturally, some of those pamphlets got into the hands of the British Government. The Party opposite went to a great deal of trouble to prove that those moneys were due to Great Britain. We never had a debate on agriculture here in this House that we were not told the country was on the verge of bankruptcy. I kept a diary of it for a time——

Comment on this

The Minister would have done well to close up at the last few sentences.

Comment on this

If everybody else had closed up, I would have done so too. My diary was too long, because Deputies opposite in, say June, 1932, told us that we would be bankrupt about Christmas, and when Christmas came we were told we would be bankrupt in May.

Comment on this

Is the Minister referring to himself or to the agricultural community? We knew he was not going to be bankrupt.

Comment on this

It was the country that Deputies always referred to as being on the verge of bankruptcy. We were always told that in about three months' time the country was going to be bankrupt, and not only that, but that the moneys were legally due. Deputy Gorey, in one speech—I do not know whether he was correctly reported or not—said it would be breaking the seventh commandment if we did not pay them over.

Comment on this

I never mentioned the seventh commandment. I am not keen about commandments. Perhaps it is blasphemy to use the word "commandment" in this connection.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister know that he said we were robbing John Bull?

Comment on this

Is that against the eleventh commandment?

Comment on this

I should just like to ask the Minister whether he was convinced by the arguments from this side of the House that the moneys were due?

Comment on this

I was never convinced by anything——

Comment on this

Is that the reason the President admitted they were due?

Comment on this

The Deputy must think I am a great fool if he thinks I am going to be convinced by anything from that side of the House. Here, however, is the point. The British Government wanted to win the economic war just as we wanted to win it; and the British Government read the papers in order to find out how things were going on here, just as we read the papers in order to find out how the British were taking it. Whenever we read that somebody got up in the British Parliament and told the members of the British Government that they ought to settle the economic war, we naturally said to ourselves "That is good"; but they were also reading the papers in order to find out the effects of the economic war here, and when, according to the newspapers, it appeared that a big section of the community here thought and said that these moneys were legally and morally due, that this country was almost broken and bankrupt as a result of the economic war, and that a Party in this State that said it was going to come into power held that it could settle the whole matter in three days, what attitude could one expect from the British Government in such circumstances? The Party opposite said that if they were in power—and they believed that they were coming into power—they could settle this thing in three days; and these were the men who said not alone that the moneys were due, but that this country was bankrupt. Could you imagine the British Government seeing a better position for themselves when they were being told day after day in speeches from public platforms all over this country that the country was bankrupt, that the money was due, and that the people opposite, as soon as they got into power, were coming across to settle the whole matter and that they could settle it in two or three days? Yet we are now asked: "Why did not you settle it six years ago?" As a matter of fact, I met Mr. J.H. Thomas in Ottawa, and we were asked at that time by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney why we did not settle it then. As a matter of fact, I was very anxious to settle it, and I told Mr. Thomas that we wanted to settle it. Well, I will not use his exact words on the occasion, but I shall paraphrase what he said, which was to this effect: "Do not bother me about the economic war; did you not see where a White Army has been started in Ireland?" A White Army—the predecessors of the Blueshirts—the White Army that was started to throw this Government out and, I suppose, to settle the economic war in three days. After all that, we have these people having the cheek to come along now and say: "Why did you not settle it six years ago?" I think they ought to forget it.

Comment on this

Did Mr. Thomas tell you anything else?

Comment on this

Not only that, but they ask us why we did not settle the question of Partition—and this from the men who consented to the giving away of the Six Counties in 1922 and confirmed it in 1925, and said, in effect, "We resign all rights in the Six Counties for ever more." These are the people who say "Why do you not settle Partition"? Well, all I say is that if we had the cheek of that Party over there, with all our own ability, we could go anywhere.

Comment on this

You mean, if you had the ability of this Party with all your own cheek.

Comment on this

We are told that the country lost £50,000,000 on the economic war. That, of course, was issued by the Irish Independent for the benefit of the people opposite, and there were several sums put into it on the wrong side, just as Deputy Cosgrave did in Carlow when he turned a sum upside down and got the result he wanted. In the same way, the Irish Independent added figures that should have been subtracted. In any case, what did the economic war cost, as such? We had been sending out £5,000,000 a year and, instead of us sending out that voluntarily, they collected it on the other side; but I do not see how we lost anything. However we arranged our affairs internally, the country lost nothing by the economic war.

Comment on this

What about the 500,000 calves?

Comment on this

Yes, what about the calves? I was very anxious, at the time, to get our people here to consume veal, because I was told by Deputy O'Leary and other Deputies that they were selling calves for 2/6 apiece in Cork. I asked him what would we do with those calves, and he said that there were people buying calves down there for 2/6 apiece and giving the flesh to the dogs. When I heard this pitiful story, I said "Is it not a pity that we do not get our butchers to purchase these calves and kill them and sell the veal to the people?" And in order to encourage them, I gave a bounty on calf skins. In any case, however, our policy with regard to veal did not succeed. With regard to the slaughter of these 500,000 calves— and it may have to be done again—at any rate, the bounty was provided on them, but now we are told that if these 500,000 calves were now cattle, they would be worth a lot of money. Well, they would be worth a lot of money, if they had lived. Whether they died or whether they were slaughtered is another matter. At any rate, we paid the bounty on 120,000 calf skins in 1937 and, as far as I or my inspectors are concerned, we cannot trace the slaughter of 1,000 calves. We all know, of course, that a big number of calves died——

Comment on this

You killed them to prevent them dying.

Comment on this

——and the farmers who had dead calves skinned them and brought the skins in and got their 11/6 for them, and I think they were doing very well in the circumstances. In spite of it all, however, I say that we have as many cattle in the country now as we had under the prosperous days of Fine Gael. They were able to pay £5,000,000 a year and they said that that sum was morally due. Now, some Deputy says that we will have to derate because he wants to put the farmers here on an equal footing with the farmers in the North of Ireland and in England. Well, one thing that has been settled by us for all time is that the farmer here has got off half his annuities. I know that the Deputies opposite agree with that policy also. As a matter of fact, I understand that Deputy Cosgrave was on his way to Naas when he heard about it and that he turned back and said that he would halve the annuities.

Comment on this

Are they due?

Comment on this

Of course they are due. Now we are having the old argument over again. Of course they are due, but they were not due to England.

Comment on this

Why did you pay the £10,000,000?

Comment on this

The farmer here is paying a certain amount of rates and he is paying half his annuities, and if there is an honest man on the other side— which, perhaps, is too much to assume —let him find out what the farmers in the North of Ireland are paying in rates and annuities together and compare that with what our farmers are paying, and then see which is the worse off. Let him compare what the English farmer is paying in rates and rents as compared with what our farmers are paying, and I think it will be found that our farmers are better off.

Comment on this

What is his freight to his market—the market that you have to go to? What is the use in doing the clown in that way?

Comment on this

Well, I suppose that the next time that we go over to England, we will have to get this island shoved over a bit.

Comment on this

The farmers in the North of Ireland are getting a subsidy of 5/- on beef.

Comment on this

What about the price of greyhounds?

Comment on this

There is no economic war there.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon said that we were now in a position to get back to sensible farming and to use the land to the best advantage, in other words, I suppose, to get back to a sort of Fine Gael policy and using the land as it should be used. He said we are going to drop schemes like tobacco growing. I suppose that even his friends will agree that Deputy Dillon talked quite a lot over the last five years and talked a lot about agriculture. He never made a suggestion on agriculture beyond "Get us back our markets" except on one occasion. He usually took an hour and a half to put "Get us back our markets" into a speech and he used to make that speech very regularly. Only once in the five years did he make another suggestion and that was to grow French beans on a big scale. Surely tobacco growing is as good a policy as growing French beans. We are not going to drop tobacco growing and adopt the growing of French beans —we will not grow them for export. Deputies will find that farmers are at least sensible enough and educated enough to know that the mixed farming which we have tried to get them into by growing wheat, barley, and oats is better than getting back to the bullock.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Reilly does not agree with you.

Comment on this

You would not say that if you saw the heaps of dirt at the back of the ditches which were dragged off the wheat fields.

Comment on this

What will they talk about when the economic war is over?

Comment on this

Another suggestion made by Opposition Deputies, as well as derating, was that we should bring in a scheme of loans for the re-stocking of land. I am not making a political point in this, but I put it to Deputies on the other side to consider well before advocating that too strongly. I have always thought that the giving out of loans too liberally for re-stocking is a terrible danger to farmers because you will have them competing against one another and they will inevitably put up the price of stock higher than its value and, when they come to sell that stock, they will not get their money back. I think if we had money for any purpose like that it is not for re-stocking that we should use it, but for some other purpose. I think Deputies ought not to advocate too strongly the giving of large loans for re-stocking land without considering the matter very carefully.

Comment on this

I should like to know what the Minister's attitude is now in regard to derating.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise on this motion.

Comment on this

Somebody said, "Put the farmer on the same level as the farmer in Northern Ireland and Great Britain," and I say that he is on the same level with regard to rents and rates put together.

Comment on this

Will the Minister take a case in point—the case of a person now as compared with 1932?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might deal with that matter on the Vote for Agriculture.

Comment on this

We are having a very friendly discussion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Which the Chair would like to be in order.

Comment on this

If I were offered £1,000,000 by the Government for the purpose of derating, I would say, "No, I would prefer not to use it for derating, but for some other purpose."

Comment on this

When did you change your mind?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

It is written up on the wall not far from my house since 1930.

Comment on this

One other point I want to make is this. Deputy Keating asked about alternative markets. We have got alternative markets and the Deputy will be surprised to hear that we will be able to carry on in these markets even though this Agreement is come to.

Comment on this

Does that mean you will carry on with the Germans?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The Minister referred to bran from the Continent. Is that good business now that the Continent is raging with foot and mouth disease?

Comment on this

But sending cattle to the Continent does not matter.

Comment on this

But you imported bran.

Comment on this

We certainly will not allow bran in from any country where there is foot and mouth disease.

Comment on this

You said you imported bran from the Continent.

Comment on this

The point anyway is this. I was asked if we got alternative markets. We did our best to get them and, what is more, we did our best to get the British market all the time.

Comment on this

I thought the Taoiseach said it was gone for ever.

Comment on this

A person may make a remark here which, as I said before, is a figure of speech. Somebody said the British market was gone.

Comment on this

Ex-Senator Connolly said it was gone for ever, thank God.

Comment on this

If I went down the country I might say that Fine Gael was gone. I would not mean by that that it had gone altogether, but that they are never going to come back. In that way the British market is gone. Look at the British market now. The British market was a free and open market up to seven or eight years ago. Now it is a free market to us so far as duties are concerned, but it is not an open market to anybody with regard to quantity. In that way I say that the British market is gone. I was told here by speakers on the opposite side that we now begin to agree with them because we are now getting back the British market. I say we tried all the time to get the British market. Why did we make the coal-cattle pact which had nothing but sneers from the other side? Every time I appeared here with the Estimate—if you look it up—I do not advise you at all to read my speeches on the Estimate—but if you are interested and if you look them up I indicated in every speech I made on the Estimate how we were trying to get back the British market.

Comment on this

Did you describe how you lost it?

Comment on this

I described how you lost it. That is all I have got to say. I say that because I do not want to be accused of going over to Fine Gael because we are trying to get the British market back. We do not want to be going over there, or accused of going over there, because we are giving them £10,000,000 in settlement of the financial dispute, seeing that they stated that £104,000,000, I think, was legally and morally due.

Comment on this

What do we think they owed us?

Comment on this

I am only mentioning these points—Deputy Gorey said I was not taking them seriously— because I do not want to be accused of changing the agricultural policy in any way and I say we made the coal-cattle pact and renewed the coal-cattle pact because we were anxious to get the British market, and we did other things in the way of bacon quotas and so on in order to try and get the British market, and at the same time we tried to get the alternative markets—we succeeded in getting alternative markets—I admit in a very small way—but they are not such bad markets at all, and I believe we could continue in those alternative markets even if we settle with Great Britain.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister for Agriculture is to be commended upon his speech. His colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and Deputy Dillon on this side, set, I think, a very fine example and very high standard of debate. After all, we are discussing a subject that is of considerable import to the people of this country, and I do think that at least one of the Ministers who participated in these negotiations should have taken and dealt with that subject seriously. Now, we wanted to hear from the Minister particularly something about this Agreement, and instead of that we have been compelled to listen at considerable length to a number of cheap jokes about a number of things that were said and that happened in this country in the past. Now, I think the Minister, if he were wise, would have refrained from making any reference at all to some of the things that he gave so much prominence to in the course of his speech. I would imagine the Minister and some of his colleagues ought to be very anxious to forget about a number of statements they made in the past, and I imagine that if I were in the Minister's position I would feel rather in a state of repentance when I would review a number of the statements made in the past and which they have been compelled to swallow according to the terms of the Agreement we are discussing now. It is true the members on this side did say that these moneys were legally and morally due and the proof that we were right is contained in the terms of this Agreement. The Minister, his leader, and his colleagues said "not a penny," and this Agreement provides for a payment of £10,000,000.

I would advise the Minister for Agriculture to try and forget the slaughter of the calves. Surely, if ever there was a crime committed against the farmers of this country, that is a crime that will require a lot of explanation, and the sooner the Minister forgets about it the better. The Minister started his speech—I propose now to deal with the serious part of the Minister's speech—by ridiculing Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney when he said it was difficult to understand the language contained in some of the Articles of this Agreement. The language contained in these Articles in many cases is archaic and, for the ordinary Deputy, without some legal assistance, it certainly is very difficult to understand what some of the phrases contained in these Articles do really mean, and that is why I was so anxious to hear the Minister explaining clearly to this House the meaning of these Articles, and especially those Articles dealing with the agricultural exports to Great Britain. Instead of that the Minister indulged in a lot of cheap jibes in replying to interruptions from members on this side of the House. Now, the Minister started off his speech by referring to certain statements that were made by members of the Opposition on the butter bounties, but surely the Minister is not prepared to claim credit for the butter bounties. Is it not a fact that the Minister's predecessor had prepared a scheme for giving bounties to exporters of butter?

Comment on this

Why did your Party vote against it then?

Comment on this

Is it not a fact also that the Minister adopted that scheme almost in its entirety and that that is the scheme that is in operation?

Comment on this

In spite of that your Party voted against it.

Comment on this

Because of the peculiar nature of the butter industry it was necessary to subsidise it. It was necessary to subsidise it in New Zealand and Australia and other countries as well. We were the authors of the subsidy and it comes very poorly from the Minister to be making cheap jibes about the attitude of the Party——

Comment on this

Why did your Party vote against it?

Comment on this

Now, another thing the Minister said is that feeding stuffs were cheaper in this country than they are in other countries. I want to know is he quite serious.

Comment on this

Perfectly.

Comment on this

Take the principal feeding stuff. What is the price of maize meal in Northern Ireland and Great Britain? You can buy it in Northern Ireland for £8 10s. a ton and you have to pay £10 for the mixture—a very inferior commadity—on this side of the Border. I could mention a number of other items as well but I do not choose to waste the time of the House over matter of that kind. The one item that I mentioned shows clearly that the Minister's statement is not to be relied on to any great extent.

Comment on this

Look up Bulfast and Cork.

Comment on this

Take Great Britain leave out Northern Ireland.

Comment on this

I say, compare Belfast and Cork.

Comment on this

I am comparing prices in the Free State with prices in the Six Counties and Great Britain. The price of maize meal, the principal feeding stuff and the most valuable feeding stuff there is for live stock, costs the farmer in Northern Ireland from £8 to £10s. a ton. The price of the meal mixture here is £10 a ton.

Comment on this

It may be in some parts of the Free State, but compare belfast and Cork.

Comment on this

But in any event, I think the farmers on this side of the House as well as on the Minister's side of the House are very glad indeed that this economic war has been ended, but this Agreement now, this new charter of liberty, that so much capital is being made about, simply brings us back to the position we were in in 1931. In fact, it does not bring us back to the identical position we were in in 1931 because in 1931 we could export all the commodities we produced from the land of this country quite freely to the British market without restrictions or quotas of any description whatsoever. In these Articles we are discussing now power is taken to impose restrictions on a certain limited number of agricultural exports from this country and in addition to that our other agricultural exports are regulated by quotas of one kind or another. I accept the Minister's statement that these quotas will be operated sympathetically and that we will certainly get the maximum benefit which it will be possible for the British Government to extend to us. Nevertheless, the fact is there that our agricultural exports are regulated and will continue to be regulated so long as this Agreement remains in operation, so that l do say, quite deliberately, that this Agreement does not bring us back altogether to the satisfactory position we enjoyed in 1931 so far as the export of agricultural commodities is concerned.

There is also this difference, and mind you, after all this means a tremendous lot to many members of the farming community in this country, that owing to the policy operated by the Fianna Fáil Government during the last six years the farmers in this country are not in a position to take advantage, and will not be in a position for a number of years to take advantage of the terms of this Agreement. As a result of the various nostrums, expedients and experiments resorted to by the Minister for Agriculture, the agricultural economic policy operated up to 1931 has becn completely disorganised and disarranged and the result is that, in order that the farmers of this country will have an opportunity of working this Agreement satisfactorily it is necessary, in the first instance, to readjust their agricultural economy so that they will be in a position to reap the full advantage from the terms of this Agreement. That will take time and it will probably take a number of years.

Another point, notwithstanding what the Minister for Agriculture says, the number of cattle in this country is declining and has been for some years. He advised the members on this side of the House to pause and to think carefully before advocating a grant to the farmers to restock their land. I say that if the farmers of this country are to reap the full advantages of this Agreement it is absolutely essential that there should be some form of State assistance to enable them fully to restock their lands. What is the position at present? Cattle prices have been soaring for a number of months past, due to a variety of reasons. Probably the fact that these discussions were going on in London was a contributory reason. But the fact remains that cattle prices have been soaring. The man whose lands to-day are only one half, three quarters or one quarter stocked is not in a position to buy cattle in the market, and even assuming that he could borrow money from the bank for the purpose of buying cattle, he would buy at a big price. He would, I admit, sell at a big price, but the buying price would neutralise the selling price, and it would be a considerable number of years before that man was really in a position to reap any profit worth speaking about from his livestock.

Comment on this

Is that not a reason for not encouraging borrowing?

Comment on this

It depends on the interest.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding the Minister's attitude towards a grant or loan for the purpose of restocking land, which seems to me at least to be sceptical, can the Minister suggest any alternative to the granting of a long-term loan for this purpose? In what other way is the farmer who has suffered serious losses in consequence of the economic war to get his lands fully stocked and reap the advantages undoubtedly derivable from this Agreement? The banks will not lend the money. From what source will he get it? Surely there is no other way of getting it except by the State coming to his assistance, and I do not know how the State can assist him unless it is prepared to float a loan for the purpose of assisting him towards that end.

I do not propose to discuss the Trade Agreement, or the Third Agreement, because, as I said at the outset, I do not understand clearly the language in a number of the Articles and I have not had the opportunity of relating these Articles to agreements made in the past, either with the other Dominions or with the British Government. I will defer whatever I have to say on that subject until the Bill is introduced next week. In conclusion, I wish merely to say that I am very glad the economic war has been ended. I am glad also that the members of the Government have realised the folly of the policy they were pursuing up to the date of the opening of negotiations, and no matter what the Minister for Agriculture or any other Minister, whether he participated in these negotiations or not, may say, it is, after all, a victory for the members on this side of the House——

Comment on this

You cheered us on.

Comment on this

because the Government have been forced, by virtue of circumstances, to adopt the policy they have been preaching for the last six years—a policy of negotiation—and now they have learned, and I hope they will profit by their experience, that it was the only wise policy for them to have pursued right from the beginning.

Comment on this

I think the Agreement in respect of the cancellation of Articles 6 and 7 of the Treaty of December 6th, 1921, and the subsequent Financial Agreement is quite good. I did not intend to speak on this matter were it not for the fact that I was unable to see the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Secretary of his Department. I could have got the information I require from either of these gentlemen had I been able to see them, and it would have prevented my going into a number of matters on which I had not intended to speak. I think it was Deputy Cosgrave who said that we got fiscal autonomy at the time of the Treaty. We did, but what did we get it for? In order that we might be able to put on tariffs, if we wanted to, with a view to encouraging industry. It was not intended that we should use our fiscal powers to the full extent because, of course, that would mean that the people against whom we were using those powers would immediately retaliate. All the countries in the world are practically in agreement on this and no one country uses its full fiscal autonomy. It would not be permitted to do so. America, as I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce stated, is at present negotiating with Great Britain; England is negotiating with Germany and other countries, trade treaties that last for certain periods, at the end of which they both agree to take off or put on or reduce or increase tariffs. We are in exactly the same position. Had we at any time put on big tariffs against England's goods, England would have imposed what were the penal tariffs which we have had to pay owing to this economic dispute.

However, what I am interested in is this Agreement and so far as the trade section of it is concerned, I want to know what is the position of the Prices Commission. So far as I can gather from what I hear here and outside, the Prices Commission is a government of its own and not at all responsible to the House. That may not be so, but if it is so, I think power should be taken out of the hands of the Prices Commission and a new Prices Commission, with lesser powers, set up. One would like to know if the Prices Commission is the Commission which was operating at the back end of last year, or whether it has been brought into being since the negotiations started, because if the latter be the case, it would look as if it were brought into being in order to enable British manufacturers or importers to use it as an instrument to promote their own trade and industry, and that, of course, I would not like at all. If they have undue powers, I think they should be taken from them and I think a Bill should be brought in immediately for that purpose.

There is no question but that this Agreement, whether rightly or wrongly, has caused quite a lot of uneasiness amongst manufacturers. They feel that there is a sword of Damocles hanging over their heads. They do not know what the Agreement really means. The Minister for Industry and Commerce spoke at quite considerable length to-day, but he did not clarify the situation in such a way as to enable manufacturers and industrialists to know exactly what the position is. If any Minister can make the matter clearer, I think everybody engaged in industry would be very much interested. The chief point on which I seek information is with regard to boots and hosiery. No Minister, no official and no member of the House can have a knowledge of all trades and a Minister has to hear from the people interested in the different trades what they fear and what their grievances are. In regard to boots, the tariff has been reduced to 20 per cent. I am speaking purely from memory, but I think that the Cumann na nGaedheal Government put a 15 per cent. tariff on boots. That was purely a revenue tax. It was not a protective tariff and 20 per cent. is very little, especially in view of the fact that whereas, formerly, they had a free market for the purchase of leather, they now have to buy from a firm in some part of the country which has quite a big tariff and which is not giving the best value. A 20 per cent. tariff is of no value whatever to the boot trade and if there is any possibility of having it revised, it should be done.

There is a tariff of 33 per cent. on hosiery. With that, the hosiery people are, I understand, quite satisfied so far as the higher-priced articles are concerned. In connection with the lower-priced articles, a gentleman was speaking to me about ladies' stockings, which are sold at 1/- per pair. These are sold by the trade at from 8/11 to 9/6 per dozen pairs and they are sold retail at 1/- That gives the retailers about 20 per cent. gross profit. In respect of that particular article, a tariff of 33? per cent. is not sufficient to enable home manufacturers to compete. Some of them have had to lay off hands and others of them will have to lay off hands if that tariff cannot be revised. English manufacturers, by reason of the fact that they have an increased output of 30 per cent. per machine or per person, and by reason of some other consideration which I have quite forgotten, are able to produce these stockings at 8/- per dozen pairs and sell them at 8/- The Irish manufacturers are being absolutely wiped out. They cannot get any orders for the cheap stockings, which represent quite a big proportion of the trade in that article in this country.

When do the Agreements come into force? I do not refer to the two main Agreements, but I think that the Trade Agreement should, if possible, be subjected to revision. The Agreement itself states that the matters referred to will be subject to revision from time to time. Why cannot that be done before the Agreement is finally signed?

Comment on this

It is signed.

Comment on this

I am not objecting to the signing at all. I simply think that those things should be done now instead of doing them later when they may have done a lot of damage. This is the time to do it.

Comment on this

Ní hé lá na gaoithe lá na scolb.

Comment on this

From the first paragraph in Article 6, I deduce that the British Minister or his officials were in touch with many people in the trade before they came to a decision. I do not think that any of our Ministers or officials were in touch with anybody here before they came to agreement. I think that they ignored them altogether and that the behaviour of the English Ministers and their officials could be very admirably followed, with good results, in this country. There is no doubt whatever about that. I do not think that the English exporters, notwithstanding what the Minister for Industry and Commerce said to-day, should have admission to the Prices Commission. I think that we should confine it to ourselves. They have quite sufficient means of wiping out our industries without getting the aid of our Prices Commission, which commission, by the way, is a free-trade commission.

During the discussion that took place this evening, Deputy Roddy called attention to what he described as the gibes of the Minister for Agriculture. The Minister was interrupted in a most disgraceful manner and even the Ceann Comhairle could not prevent that interruption. If you are treated in that fashion, you are not too careful about what you say. However, I think the Minister was right. We are going to get in a lot of cattle and other animals under Schedule 2, Part 2. I notice that, included in that Schedule, are poultry (live), ducks, poultry (dead), rabbits and hares (dead). I do not know anything about hares.

Comment on this

What about greyhounds?

Comment on this

Poultry can be bought very cheaply from China and Russia and the English may send us in some of these Russian and Chinese poultry and Australian rabbits. We have any amount of rabbits here. They constitute a sort of plague in the country and they do a lot of damage. If these dead rabbits are allowed in, they will take the place of rabbits here which people would otherwise kill and they will allow the home rabbits to do a lot of damage to the land. Clause 2 of Article 9 states:

"The Government of the United Kingdom recognise that it may be necessary for the Government of Eire, in pursuance of their agricultural policy, to regulate the imports of certain agricultural products, including those enumerated in Schedule IV."

If a clause like that were inserted on the industrial side, everything would be in order.

Comment on this

Is maith leis an cat an cronán.

Comment on this

If the fears that some of the industrialists have with regard to this Agreement are correct, the business of many manufacturers will be torpedoed. What is the Government going to do if that happens? People have put money into these businesses in support of Government policy. If they are going to lose that money and if these businesses are to be forced out of existence, what is the Government going to do about it? I should say that if businesses are closed down by reason of this Agreement, the companies should be compensated fully so that they can pay back their shareholders the money they got from them.

Comment on this

Give them the same treatment that was given to Roscrea.

Comment on this

What about compensating the farmers, who lost a greater amount of money?

Comment on this

This is what I objected to in the case of the Minister for Agriculture. I am dealing with this subject and I do not want any interruptions. Notwithstanding that the Minister for Agriculture had already explained the matter fully, Deputy Roddy persisted in talking about getting back to the position in 1931 with regard to our agricultural exports. England long before that started regulating her imports, and she is continuing to regulate them. She is not alone putting quotas on them but this gentleman that the Taoiscach yesterday praised so highly, Mr. Neville chamberlain, when he was Minister for Agriculture or something else at one time or another, told the Danes, who had no economic war, "You have to sell 70,000 tons of bacon less next year." NOW, 70,000 tons would, I assume, mean over 2,000,000 pigs. That is far more than we export in the year. He told the Danes that they would have to stop it. Look at the disorganisation that the cancellation of a trade of 70,000 tons of bacon, or 2,250,000 pigs, would cause, not alone to the people actually engaged in the trade, but to many other people such as those who provide food for the animals. The position is that England is acting in her own interests. Every nation does the same. England is not going to take any food or anything else from anybody that she does not want, and it would be just as well that all Deputies should get that into their heads. People in England will take everything they get at a price, and in our case it is to be hoped it will be at such a price that we will not have to subsidise the farmers. It would he helpful if Ministers could give some information that would make the people less anxious about their position. If there is any possibility of it, I think that Government officials should get in touch with the various industries and see if there is not some chance of giving them some explanation that will satisfy them as to what can he done.

Comment on this

I do not intend to go outside the rules of order by introducing a matter on this motion that could be more fittingly introduced on a Vote such as that for the Department of the Taoiseach. I might say that I have already handed in a notice of motion in connection with that matter, and I intend to raise the whole subject of the amount of the costs of the economic war to this State, the particular sections of the people who had to bear it, the causes that led up to the position that has existed here for some years, and the remedies that might be considered by the Executive Council. I do not think that any of these things would be proper to the motion before the House. The Minister for Agriculture, in the latter portion of his speech, in my opinion, spoiled a good and a reasonable speech by the introduction of what was nothing less than silly burlesque. It was the introduction of what he thought fit to introduce that was responsible for all the interruptions from this side, and indeed from all over the House. Nobody believed a word of what he said, and nobody will be deceived in the country by the burlesque the Minister indulged in. That sort of thing is more or less peculiar to the Minister now and again. Of course, nobody minds the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, who always seems to remember the revue stage when he addresses this House, and more or less plays the clown on the programme on almost every occasion that he stands up.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A Deputy may not be said to play the clown.

Comment on this

That is the kind of thing that he always plays.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must withdraw.

Comment on this

I said he plays the clown. If you say it is disorderly, I withdraw it. I think this is rather a solemn occasion, solemn in more ways than one. It is a solemn occasion in the relation of the Parties here with each other and the effect of this Agreement, and solemn in regard to the relations of this nation with another nation, and I think that anything introduced to make it unseemly at this moment ought not to be introduced. Nobody is more grateful than I am that this war is over. Nobody is more grateful that the position is being restored to normal. Deputies will remember that in 1932 I was keen that this war should never have been started and, when it was started, I was anxious that it should be settled then. Nobody was more emphatic than myself in warning the President then about the silly idea that seemed to be in his head looking for alternative markets all over the world. I remember telling the President then that it was little short of criminal for a man in his position to be dangling the bait of an alternative market before the people. At that time the President said: "Well, we are going to have good try." Anybody who remembers the history of that time and all that happened since will realise how silly the President was to send out ambassadors all over the Continent looking for markets that never were there for us or for anybody else. I am really glad that it is ended, and with it ends the occupations of the hosts of buzzards and birds of prey who were brought into existence because of the economic war. I refer to buzzards in business, and especially the buzzards that came out of the North of Ireland into the cattle trade; the huge gangs that came through the country, some of them from this side of the Border, some of them connected with politicians in this House, some connected with private members in this House. They feasted for four or five years, especially in the first three or four years of the economic war, on the money, the life blood of the people. I am glad their occupations are ended and that they are gone out of business.

Comment on this

It is obviously a solemn moment for the buzzards, Sir.

Comment on this

I do not see the point. We are prepared to do anything, even to come here on Monday or Tuesday, or any day, to facilitate the Taoiseach or the Ministry here in order to push this question of an Agreement, to have it settled at the earliest possible moment, because we know its value to the country, and especially do we know its value to the fat cattle trade. The cattle trade of this country is on two different planes. With regard to store cattle, people have been gambling on a settlement for the last three or four months, since it was first mentioned. In my opinion the whole extent of the benefit has already been paid in the matter of store cattle. It is quite a different proposition with regard to fat cattle. There could be no gamble there. In their case the full extent of£4 5s. can be realised the moment this Agreement has been signed. That will not be so with regard to stores. With regard to fat cattle, heavy cows or springers that have to be shipped across, the full extent of this Agreement will operate from the first day. The sooner then that it is put into operation the better. The earliest day on which it can be put into operation is the proper day.

Great play has been made here about the opportune moment in which to have this settlement made. The Taoiseach went out of his way to prove that it could not have been made earlier than it has been. He has been followed by the Minister for Agriculture. I might tell them that we are not all fools in this country. We have some sources of information and some sense of observation. Everybody knows what brought back the Minister for Agriculture from Ottawa before the rest of his colleagues returned. The Taoiseach is smiling denial. But the Taoiseach went down to his own constituents in the country to deal with that matter and——

Comment on this

What?

Comment on this

When I am finished the Taoiseach can reply. The Minister for Agriculture came home here from Ottawa. What was the cause of the threatened split in the Government Party between 1932 and the election in 1933? Why did the Taoiseach go down the country to his supporters and tell them that the election had to be forced because the Deputies of his own Party were in revolt?

Comment on this

That was not the reason.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach cannot hide all the things he did at that time. All these things cannot be a closed book. Everybody knows that the offer that came from Ottawa a was an offer of £20,000,000 or £25,000,000 in cash——

Comment on this

Oh, dear, dear!

Comment on this

The Taoiseach can "dear, dear" away now, but this offer he will have to admit.

Comment on this

It must have been Wicklow gold——

Comment on this

Found in Roscrea.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture talked about the difference in price now, as compared with some years ago, as if he or his Government did anything to remedy the price or to bring the price up to the figure at which it stands. Did they do anything to bring that about? This is, perhaps, not a matter for discussion on this particular motion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There I am in agreement with the Deputy.

Comment on this

Thank you. The Government had nothing at all to do with raising the price. It is only throwing dust in the eyes of the people to suggest that they had. This Government did nothing and could do nothing in the last six years, since this economic war started, to raise the price of cattle in England. They did nothing and could do nothing, and I leave it at that. If we make a comparison between the price six months ago and the price to-day, that is not a proper comparison. The comparison should be made between the price to-day and the price in 1932, 1933, 1934 and 1935. When the Government did nothing to remedy the position, that position was remedied over their heads by the hand of God.

I would like to know from the Minister for Agriculture if there is any hope as to the revival of the dead meat trade that was in operation in the first year or year and a-half of the economic war? At that time we were able to kill cattle, sheep and pigs, and ship them to Great Britain. Will that position be restored? I have seen no reference to it so far. I dare say that will depend on British policy, as to whether they think it better to kill their own animals, or they might think that this may interfere with their own fresh meat trade. I would like if the Minister would give an indication of what the prospect is in that direction. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said "we won this war." He paid a great tribute to the people of the country who won it. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance talked about the morale that was bred in the country, the new outlook and the new capacity for resistance displayed by the people. The Parliamentary Secretary did not suffer much from the economic war.

Comment on this

He got an increase in his salary.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary was not put into the front line trenches. He did not lose a bob over this war. On the contrary he secured quite an increase in his salary. That applies to the politicians who had nothing to lose, who represented nothing and who in my opinion knew nothing.

Comment on this

Like Deputy Gorey in 1927 to 1932.

Comment on this

They lost nothing. But it was a different story with the people who were in the front line trenches all the time. The only thing these people got from the Government was the knife in the back and treachery from behind. I will deal with that matter another time. As regards the settlement we on this side have nothing but a blessing for it. We are glad that the economic war is ended-We are glad that normalcy has been restored. We are glad that the occupation of the buzzards, the suckers and the sharks, men bred out of this economic war, is ended. Their trade has gone out of existence. With it I hope will pass away the occupation of some industrialists, owners of some factories, people who have been guaranteed by this Government. One of these places was called a meat factory. They had the cheek to get down a high prelate of the Church to bless the opening. All they did there was to convert cattle into meat meal and they designated that place a factory. But that Roscrea factory was only a knacker's factory. These are the people who have been fattening on the misfortune of this country. These are the people who own this State and own Dublin to-day. Anything that will take away the growth of that host of buzzards, suckers and sharks, is something to be welcomed.

Comment on this

I do not intend or propose to "damn the Government with faint praise" as so many previous speakers have done, beginning with complimenting the Taoiseach and his co-negotiators on bringing about what we were told was an amicable arrangement with Great Britain. Having damned them with faint praise everything in the Agreement was then subjected to severe criticism. Deputies harked back to history which I had always thought was the prerogative of the Government Party. I was sorry to see that the Fine Gael Party this afternoon fell into that bad habit which has so marked the Fianna Fáil Party, when they engage in resurrecting Brian Boru and sticking a bit closely to Caithlin Ní Houlihán. Owing perhaps to the bad example of the Fianna Fáil Party, I am sorry to say that the Fine Gael Party have fallen into the same evil habit. I do not propose to indulge in any recrimination although I might possibly go a bit farther back, if I so wished, into history than the Fine Gael Deputies who have spoken. I welcome this Agreement. I hope it will mark the beginning of a number of other agreements towards a fuller and more complete understanding between the peoples of Ireland and Great Britain. I feel that while a great deal has been said about the pressure exerted by the second largest Party in the House, a greater pressure has been exerted from within the Government Party. It must be common knowledge that many members of the Fianna Fáil Party suffered as much from the economic war as did the members of the Fine Gael Party.

Every farmer here, many farmer Deputies on the Fianna Fail Benches, and Fianna Fáil farmers outside this House, have suffered very seriously and severely as a result of the economic war, and I believe it was because of the impatience of these people that they were able to exercise through their clubs or cumainn to bring a mass pressure to bear on the leaders of the Party from the Prime Minister down. I welcome their return to political sanity in this very important matter. I join with Deputy Roddy and others in asking that farmers who have suffered most by this economic war should be helped by way of loans at a very low rate of interest to take advantage of the position that is created by the ending of the economic war and by the free entry which is now given our agricultural products to the British markets.

With regard to the annulment of Articles 6 and 7 of thc Articles of Agreement of the 6th December, 1921, and the transfer to the Government of Eire of the Admiralty property and rights at Berehaven and the harbour defences at Berehaven, Cobh, and Lough Swilly, I do not attach quite as much importance to that particular agreement as I do to the agreements that follow, that is to say, the financial agreements and the trade agreements. I consider that that part of the Agreement—and it may be considered unpatriotic on my part to say so—has been entered into by our negotiators in order to satisfy a certain number of irresponsibles in the, country who were possibly demanding that these ports should be acquired, and who consider it more important that we should get some concession of that kind rather than something of more tangible advantage. It was probably considered that the acquisition of these ports will satisfy certain ambitions about an Ireland "free from centre to the sea," but it will cost this country a considerable sum of money to maintain them. I strongly hold the view that in the event of war it does not matter whether we own these ports or not. If these ports are wanted by any Power that is sufficiently strong to seize them, it will seize them, and it will regard this Treaty merely as a scrap of paper. Whilst our negotiators were about it, they might also have asked for occasional visits from the Fleet. The British Fleet in former years occasionally came into Bantry Bay, to Berehaven, to Cobh and some of these other places mentioned in the Articles of Agreement, and the landing of 8,000 or 10,000 officers and men was responsible for circulating a considerable sum of money in these places. I do not think that we would lose any of our patriotism if we asked for similar visits in future.

The Prime Minister has been chided because of his failure to end Partition, although every Deputy in this House knows that this generation will not see Partition ended or the Border removed. Somebody in the course of the debate expressed the hope that he would live to see it. I have read of Scriptural figures like Methusclah and others but I have doubts, although I should like the Prime Minister live to see the realisation of his ambitions in that regard, that if he lived to the age of these venerable figures he would see the end of Partition. I do not believe that we shall realise it in this generation or possibly in the next. We will only realise the abolition of the Border and the ending of Partition when we shall have sufficient common sense here to face realities and when some members of the Dáil and some of our public men cease making provocative and bellicose speeches against "the one and only enemy," the enemy with whom, by the way, we are now entering into an arrangement after friendly negotiation and with whom we have arrived at these remarkably fine series of agreements. I feel that the Prime Minister and his co-negotiators are to be congratulated on that achievement. Mind you, I am not saying that by way of irony, because I do not care to indulge in irony on an occasion of this kind; but it must have been a severe wrench for the Prime Minister himself and many of his fellow negotiators to sit down at table with a number of British Ministers and arrive at this Agreement. I pay them a tribute for their manliness, because any fool can float down with the flood but it takes a strong man to swim against it. For that reason, this is the one outstanding thing that this Government has done, and I do hope that they and the country will reap the benefit of it. I say that with all sincerity.

As I have mentioned the Border, whilst we all know it was and still remains an unnatural division of our country, and whilst we all believe it should be abolished and hope that it will be abolished, at the same time if we are perfectly honest with ourselves we must remember—I do not know anything, about the buzzards to whom Deputy Gorey referred—that there is a section, in fact two sections of the community, who do not want to see Partition abolished. These are the persons, probstbly, to whom Deputy Gorey referred as buzzards or parasites. They are the people who made a good living by taking cattle across the Border They do not want to see that Border abolished. There is, too, that enterprising industrialist who established some small industry and perhaps gave some employment. I personally cannot conceive, and I do not know of anybody on this side of the House who could conceive, of an industrialist on this side of the Border sending out a cordial invitation to a number of industrialists on the other side asking them to join with him in a petition to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to allow these industrialists of the North to come down here and enjoy all the advantages of high tariffs that our industrialists enjoy here. I have put the question of the Border to several persons and the answer I got in nearly every case was to the effect that they were not troubling about the Border. If we want to be honest with ourselves and ask any industrialist in Dublin does he want the Border abolished, we may get a rather surprising answer. I asked an industrialist that question and the answer I got was rather illuminating. He said: "Look here, Mr. Anthony, I would like the Border down as far as Mallow." That was his idea of the Border. There are very few altruists in industry. I have yet to find an altruist in industry and I have not met anyone, and I do not know of anyone, who has lost one night's sleep over the Border. Listening to all the talk and all the platitudes that we hear in this House on this question, one would think that there was weeping and gnashing of teeth all the time in connection with the Border.

The Financial Agreement I consider to be a very satisfactory one. In that I believe the Government made a very good bargain, too, but the Trade Agreement, which has been alluded to by Deputy Dowdall, has been suhjected to an amount of criticism. I know that Deputy Dowdall knows what he is speaking about, and I ask that the Minister should give as full an explanation as possible to satisfy Deputy Dowdall and those whom he represents, that the case is not quite so bad as it appears. Article 8 states that the Government of Eire undertakes to do certain things "in accordance with the principle that existing protective duties and restrictions upon goods produced and manufactured in the United kingdom shall be replaced by duties which shall not exceed such a level as will give to United Kingdom producers and manufacturers full opportunity of reasonable competition." This is the part to which I wish to draw Deputy Dowdall's attention:

"while affording to Eire industries adequate protection having regard to the relative cost of economical and efficient production, provided that in the application of this principle special consideration may be given to the case of industries not fully established. The tariff on goods produced or manufactured in the United Kingdom will be adjusted, where necessary, to give effect to the recommendations of the Prices commission."

I listened attentively to the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce and, unlike some people, I say without egotism that I do not require a trained lawyer to construe or understand these Articles. I think it is a reflection on the standard of education of Deputies if they cannot understand Articles which to me appear to be as plain as A.B.C. Quantitative restrictions are mentioned in many cases, and I take it that they take the place of the present quota system. I think that covers the objections raised by Deputy Dowdall. However, as my deductions may require correction or amplification, I hope the Minister will deal with the matter. It must be remembered, too, that during the operation of a tariff system—and it certainly should obtain in this country in the case of selective or highly protective tariffs—these tariffs should be subjected to examination from time to time. It is only fair and right, as the Minister stated in his speech to-day, that when certain industries founded and financed by Irish industrialists or capitalists are in operation for a time, under the protection of almost prohibitive tariffs in many cases, that they should, at the end of a period, be able to do without that kind of artificial assistance. I have always likened the position of a new industry to that of a child requiring help before being able to walk, but when the child is able to toddle around for itself it should be allowed to exercise its limbs. In that connection I feel that it is absolutely essential to the economic life of our country that the operation of these tariffs should be examined and all the facts concerning them taken into consideration from time to time. Assuming that a very high tariff is in operation and that wages in certain industries are higher here than across the water, that should be taken into consideration, and adequate steps taken to protect the wages and the conditions of the working-class, and also to see that those who invested their money got a fair return. When I say "fair return" I think they should be satisfied with 5 or 6 per cent., and not 25 per cent., as happened in the case of a protected industry.

There is one aspect of this agreement between the Governments of Eire and Britain which has so far not been referred to, and that is the enormous advantage that will arise when they become operative in relation to the tourist traffic. We know that a good deal of propaganda was used against this country in the past, and particularly during the operation of the economic war, that tended to keep away travellers, seekers of health, and sportsmen of various kinds. That represented a very big joss of revenue to this country. These agreements will have a wonderfully stimulating effect upon that industry, and will help in many other ways to dissipate old antagonisms and misunderstandings, and, let us hope, pave the way to a more prosperous and ultimately a more united Ireland.

Comment on this

As a matter of explanation, may I say that I have received information on certain points that I raised about some industries, and I am quite satisfied that they are fully protected.

Comment on this

Was I right then?

Comment on this

It would he more or less churlish for anyone on this side of the House to urge acceptance of this particular pact without, in the first place, welcoming to the ranks of Fine, Gael the Taoiseach and his colleagues, because we have incorporated in this document the particulir things that we have been advocating for six long years, although in our advocacy we were repeatedly shouted down and called "cowards,""renegades" and "traitors." I am not reminding Government Deputies of this in any spirit of pique. I am rather mentioning it in order to call attention to the fact that any of us may be wrong, and that the man who is capable of admitting he is wrong and turns in his tracks and goes the proper road should be welcomed when he turns in his tracks and goes the proper road. We accept this particular pact not so much as a very advantageous arrangement between this country and Great Britain, but rather as an instrument to end a period which was tragic in the history of this country, and to end a state of economic lunacy that could only rapidly lead to bankruptcy. We had this country brought to such a state that any way out, even though that way was rough and humiliating, even though it might mean in certain aspects a dipping of the flag and national surrender—even that way out was preferable to remaining in the position in which we were. This is a way out that has certain advantages and certain disadvantages.

It would be as, wrong to their people to exaggerate the advantages and to minimise the disadvantages as it would be to exaggerate the disadvantages and minimise the advantages. I am prepared to say from this side of the House that there are immense advantages contained in this document, and not the least is the new atmosphere of friendship between this country and Great Britain. I believe that is something which cannot be assessed in value: that it is only as one year follows another that the value of friendship between two contiguous islands, two islands to an extent mutually dehendent, will be realised. We realised the value of that atmosphere many years ago. perhaps we were a little bit in advance of the times in doing so, but the pioneer always has a hard road to travel. We had to go the hard road because we first appreciated the value of friendship between this country and Great Britain, and because we first appreciated the extent to which this country is dependent on Great Britain for trade and the extent to which Great Britain is dependent on this country for trade. Because we were in advance of the times and expressed our minds openly, we went through all the hard experiences of the pioneer: the first to clear the bush, the first to blaze the trail, the first to make the path easy for others to follow. We do not begrudge the use of the road that we have steam-rolled to others, but we do at least claim that we should get a certain amount of credit for having blazed the trail, cleared the bush and made the path easier for those who came after.

There are contained in this document many advantages and many good elements, so good that, I think, it may be criticised mainly on the grounds that only a three-years life is given to the terms contained therein. There may have been sound reasons for giving this Agreement only a life of three years. I am not aware of them. I think that in patching up trade arrangements between this country and Great Britain, by leaving them, as you do here properly subject to revision by consultations at any time between the Governments, that the mere fact of giving it a three years life can only result in creating a certain amount of insecurity and instability. Whether we are engaged in commercial life, in agriculture or in anything else that is intimately concerned with the Agreement before us, a man will hesitate to sink big capital behind an arrangement that may be completely upset after three years. I would urge that one of the first matters in this Agreement that should be the subject of reconsideration is the life that is given to the document, always allowing to meet the person with the fears expressed by Deputy Dowdall—that the clause remains as it is inside the document, and that any point which may arise can be rcexamined, rearranged and altered between the Governments at auy time following consultation. I think that one of the bad points in the document is that reference to the three-years life.

Now, I can see from the point of view of certain Ministers sitting opposite that this particular document can be viewed with pleasure, and that by others it must be viewed with a certain amount of relief, not unmixed with a certain amount of dismay. I can see every reason why the Minister for Finance should feel particularly elated at a document such as this, viewed purely from the financial angle. He now finds himself, presumably, in the position of a man having an unexpected sum of about £2,000,000 to play with on the eve of a Budget. Presumably, provision must have been made for the payment of bounties and subsidies in the coming year, because as we are not prophets we could not foresee an arrangement such as this. That sum will be available next week for the relief of taxation, or to give a new start to agriculture under the new conditions. I can see that from the Minister's point of view also a big debt, with a capital value of about £70,000,000, has been cleared out of the way, and the shadow of it taken out of his track for a lump sum payment of £10,000,000, so that from the angle of the Minister for Finance everything in the garden is rosy.

From the point of view of the Minister for Agriculture, this document must bring nothing but joy, no matter what empty phrases we had from himself and his colleagues in the years gone by with regard to the valueless British market and to the fact that we were rapidly getting out of it. We knew that such phrases were the hollow phrases of humbugs, and that, in fact, those men had sufficient common sense and intelligence to treat with contempt the phrases which were falling from their own lips. We knew that every one of them, in fact, appreciated, as we did, the value of the English market to the Irish farmer. In spite of all those phrases, cant and hollow sentences poured forth by Ministers from Fianna Fáil platforms over the last six years, we know that the Minister for Agriculture must view this document with feelings of pleasure because it restores, once again, to the Irish farmer free entry to the greatest market in the world. It saves the Minister from the experiences he had in the last six years of having to engage in all kinds of foolish, futile political stunts, from the slaughter of calves to the promotion of crops and other phases of agriculture that were costing the neighbour dear. This document has brought him back once more into the position of having free entry into the greatest market in the world. Even the greatest nations in the world vie with one another to get an entry, such as we are now to have, to that market.

From the point of view of either the Taoiseach or the Minister for Industry and Commerce I think the document must be viewed with mixed feelings. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, perhaps more than any Minister sitting opposite, was the man who made his name known as the one who advocated whole-hog high tariffs on everything; the man who repeatedly and eloquently urged the advisability and desirability of national self-sufficiency; the man who claimed that the only path which this country could follow with dignity and hope was the path that meant esclusion from the home market of any and every element which competed with the goods of this country. We all remember the time when the Labour Party did not support him very fully in his advocacy of whole-hog tariffs, and he referred to that Party as being "whole-hog nothing"; in fact, "the bonham Party". I wonder is he himself proud of that title to-day. If other parties in this House deserve the label of "bonham Party" because they were standing only for moderate tariffs——

Comment on this

"Bonhameens" we call them in the country.

Comment on this

——at least they stood for moderate tariffs by their own choice, and not by direction from outside. Those are matters that must not be overlooked. We have got to remember that whereas it may cost a certain amount to educate Ministers, that money should not be regarded as wasted, and it is necessary wlso to educate the followers of Ministers. If one side of an Article such as this is unduly stressed without calling attention to the other side, we may be shirking our educational responsibility towards those behind us. As far as this document reopens to the farmers of this country free entry into the British market, with the preferences and advantageous terms that are given to every member of the Commonwealth as against outside competitors, it is particularly welcome. With regard to the clearing off of a big debt, whether in the past it was regarded as a debt or not—a big claim, at all events, by Great Britain to an immense amount—by a lump sum of £10,000,000, that again is highly welcome and acceptable. But let us remember in dealing with one another that once before Britain had a great claim, a huge claim, against this country, a claim for £130,000,000, I think. Irish delegates met British Ministers, just as they did in the last three months. They went over there with hopes of driving the best bargain they could with regard to the huge claim of the British, and with hopes of driving the best bargain they could with regard to the unfortunate partition of this country. They wiped out the debt of £130,000,000-not one red penny was left—and they failed to wipe out Partition. When they came back they were accused of having sold Ulster for the sum of £130,000,000. There was no truth in that charge, any more than there would be any truth in anyone who would charge the Taoiseach to-day with having sold Ulster for this pact. But let us understand that there has got to be give and take in those matters. If Ulster was sold on that previous occasion, if the chare was true then we are brothers in crime to-day, and the only difference between us is that we got twice as much for the sale of Ulster as the people opposite got. It was not true then, and it is not true now. You are burying the hatchet, and, thank God, you are doing it with your traditional enemy. You are beginning to realise that they have qualities which you never bothered yourselves to discover in the past. let the same be applied to the people at home. While there is recantation of certain attitudes with regard to your outside neighbour, let there also be recantation of certain attitudes and certain charges with regard to your neighbour and brother here at home.

That huge British claim was wiped out by a lump sum payment of £10,000,000, but there was also wiped out a claim to £400,000,000 by the Irish Government against the British Government. Do not let us forget that, except the Minister and his colleagues were behaving as humbugs with their tongues in their cheeks on 15th October, 1932, when, acting us the Executive Council of this State, they formally lodged an itemised claim to £400,000,000 against the British Government. Do not let us forget that for that lump sum payment of £10;000,000 by this little State there is a claim of £80,000,000 by Great Britain withdrawn, but there is also a claim to £100,000,000 by Eire withdrawn. Now, I am not one of those who hold, or ever did hold, that compromise was surrender. I believe that compromise is, and always was, good business, and that if you only buy a handkerchief across the counter it amounts to compromise. One man wants the money, the other man wants ihe handkerchief, and the purchaser would like to get the handkerchief cheaper. I am glad we have reached a phase in the business of this Dail when compromise is no longer regarded as surrender, because this particular document expresses in every line of it a compromise on every important section and every important point. We give and we take. Britain waives a claim; we waive a bigger claim; we wipe them out, one against tha other. Britain gives us free entry into her market, but if she gives free entry into her market she says: "I am not going to give that for nothing. You have cattle and agricultural goods for sale in that country; we have industrial goods for Sale in ours"; and she claims, in spite of all the twaddle and nonsense that deluged this country for six years back, that there has got to be co-operation in trade as well as everything else: that if we are to get free entry for our cattle and so on, she is going to get. reasonable entry here for the products of her industrial concerns.

There you have compromise, compromise of a, type which it would have been suicidal to reject. I would not refer to that compromise or any of the compromises contained therein as being surrender. I hope we have all got away from the mentality and the atmosphere that we are going to say to one another with regard to agreements, national and international, that compromise is surrender, that compromise means surrender, and that we will never be associated with surrender.

Remember, it is much easier to raise a cheer than to do sound business. There was too much cheer-raising and too little business in this country for the last six years. Perhaps the first evidence of a courageous attempt to do business in a businesslike way and ignore the flag-wagging, the cheapgags and the cheer-raising stunts, is before us here to-day. Because of that, I welcome it far more than because of the clauses of the Agreement. There is, however, one thing running right, through this Agreement that is worthy of consideration. To an extent, throughout this Trade Agreement, we have gone perilously near to the complete surrender of our fiscal independence. It may be that we are living in a hard, material, businesslike world; it may be that such concessions were necessary; but I think it is essential to stress the point that this country is an exporting country, and that even concessions of that kind, which may even approach the point of pawning our purchasing trade and conceding absolutely into the custody of others our tariff powers and our taxing powers over commodities, were necessary and desirable in this country on account of the importance of the export trade and the conditions under which we were getting that particular market made available. I think it would be a mistake not to let people know in a loud manner that, in spite of the writings and the yearnings and the teachings of patriots in tho past when they were expressing through that voices or through their pens the mental aspiration for complete and full independence — and independence when mentioned in those times was nearly synonymous with separation—it is well to let the followers of such doctrines know that we are living in a world made up of many nations, that we are living in a world where there is a community of nations, that inter-trade is the lifeblood of a country, and that no country—even a big country—can progress and develop by living in splendid isolation behind high walls of artificial creation; that the smaller a country is, and the more it is an agricultural country, the more there is necessity for a clear export and a free export of the goods they produce; and that that export market is so vital to this country that we are justified even in jeopardising, if not completely surrendering, our fiscal autonomy in order to secure an export for our goods.

There are, as I say, clauses and sentiments and expressions running through this Trade Agreement which any of us would delete if we could have our own way; which any of us would delete, and cheerfully delete, if we could redraft that document and if we had not to get agreement with anybody else. I am not going to criticise members of the Government because there are certain things in that document to which they agreed in order to get greater benefits for this country. I am not going to act as a man who could take up his pen and draft that document according to his own liking, and had not to meet others representing another people with other points of view and arrive at compromise and agreement. Let us all take a lesson from that, too. Any of us could do things better if we had not to consult anybody else. Any of us could do things better to-day, or 18 years ago, if we were not confronted with the necessity and the desirability of reaching agreement in the interests of our own people. When we welcome this pact to-day, and when we welcome even the courage and the risk that was taken in making such Agreement, let us remember this: that you are not the first generation of Irish Ministers that boldly and bravely risked much in making agreements with people beyond the sea, and let us extend to people who did likewise in the past the same generosity as the Opposition is extending to you to-day.

Comment on this

Sir, in intervening in this debate I do not propose to deal with any of the details contained in these three Agreements which we are discussing. I prefer to deal with the general character and the atmosphere of the document which the Prime Minister has asked the House to agree to. I listened very carefully to the Prime Minister's speech and I realised that, with him, it was a difficult moment in his political career to recommend such a document as this to the House for acceptance. Deputy O'Higgins, who has just concluded his remarks, referred to the fact that he welcomed into the ranks of those who can see a certain way towards the inhabitants and the Government of Great Britain the members of our Government and their supporters. May I be permitted, as a person who belonged to a particular brand of nationalism in this country, to say that I also welcome into the ranks of those who believe in good feelings and good friendship with England to-day the members of our Government as I did, in spirit at all events, in 1922, when members belonging to the Party to which I now belong realised at that time that the future of this country was linked up with friendship and co-operation with Great Britain.

There is a very important part of this document which has not been referred to yet and which, I think, is something that should be referred to. I mean the remarks that are contained on the inside of the first page, and contained in the first sentence of those remarks. They are as follows:—

"The Government of Eire and the Government of the United Kingdom, being desirous of promoting relations of friendship and good understanding between the two countries..."

That is the first effective sentence of the document which the Prime Minister recommends to the House. The Prime Minister has asked us to study the map of Europe. Unfortunately, in the past, political opinion sometimes has been moulded too much by studying the pages of history books and not paying sufficient attention to the pages of the geography book and the matter contained therein. Therefore, for one reason, and for one reason alone, I welcome the fact that our Government has seen fit to recognise in a document of this kind that it is possible to be a good and a patriotic Irishman arid at the same time meet our neighbour with whom our destiny is linked up and tied up in order to make a sensible, a reasonable, and a proper bargain.

I am not going to deal with the question of whether now is the time it should have been made or whether it should have been made at any previous date. I prefer to deal with this matter as a realist. I do not care what the origins of the squabble were, who was responsible for it, or what happened during the last six years or the last fifteen years. It is our duty as representing the people who sent us here, no matter what Party we belong to, to take this Agreement and to work it as best we can for the benefit of the people of the country. Therefore, because we recognise that our destiny in future is linked up, in the terms of this document, by relations of friendship and good understanding between the two countries, for the first reason I welcome it. For the second reason I welcome it because the document in its various clauses Tecognises what we in this Party have stated time and again to be true, that the real, substantial and workable industry of this country is the agricultural industry with its market in Great Britain. That is the second reason I welcome this document and propose to vote for it.

There is one other thing I should like to say, and it is this. The Prime Minister, in speaking of the people associated with the bringing about of this Agreement, referred in very proper terms to the officials of the Government who assisted him. He was quite right in doing so. Many of these officials are personally known to us, and we realise that they are very competent people and that they must have had a difficult task in working out the various matters connected with the Agreement. But I think the Prime Minister might have gone a little further. There was an omission in his speech. I do not believe for one moment that it was a deliberate omission. I think when I bring it to his notice he will probably recognise it was an omission. A little over three months ago he announced that he and three of his Ministers proposed to cross to the other side for the purpose of commencing negotiations in connection with the outstanding differences. From that day until this we of this Panty and members of other Opposition Parties can claim that by no word, act or deed did we put anything whatsoever in the way of the Prime Minister and his colleagues in bringing the best agreement they could back. I really think that in praising his colleagues and his assistants from the Civil Service, the Prime Minister did overlook the fact that the Opposition had played a wise, a noble, and a patriotic part during the past three months.

Comment on this

As a farmer and as a Deputy representing a number of farmers in Meath and Westmeath, I wish to congratulate the Government on bringing back this Agreement. Since I became a Deputy I have always advocated inside and outside this House a settlement of the economic war, and lately I did not think it would come so soon. I therefore wish to congratulate the Government because of the relief which the settlement will bring to farmers, especially in my constituency, because everyone knows that the economic war hit the cattle industr5more than any other industry, and Meath and Westmeath are the two leading counties in the cattle industry. There is one thing that should be remembered now that the economic war is over and that is that there were a number of casualties during that war In my county a large number of farmers will not derive any benefit whatever from this settlement. At the beginning of the economic war they had a certain number of cattle. Some of the Fianna Fáil Party maintained that they had also certain debts. Even if they owed a couple of hundred pounds, they always had ten or 20 cattle that would pay that debt. When the economic war had been going on for two or three years, if they owed £200 they found that 20 cattle would not pay more than a quarter of that debt, and when they sold them they were still left with a debt in the bank. The result is that the debt is still there and, in fact, has been accumulating by the addition of interest. In fact there are numbers of farmers in my county at present who have not a beast on the land. Owing to the rumours of a settlement for the last three months we have had English and other cattle dealers coming down there and taking land from the farmers so that they could buy up a lot of cattle for sale when the settlement came. I know that a lot of them are disappointed because the settlement did not come as quickly as they expected. But the farmers who are in that position should be thought of.

I know of a farmer with 150 acres who at the commencement of the economic war had all his land stocked. He had a certain amount of debt, but it was not a lot. At the present time that farmer has only two cows and eight yearlings on his land. The rest of his land is stocked by a cattle dealer from Dublin. When I was in that man's house the day before yesterday, that cattle dealer came down in a large motor car and went around that poor farmer's land and congratulated himself on the fine cattle he had now that the economic war was settled. Honestly, I pitied the poor farmer looking at that man examining his cattle. There are large numbers like him in the country and something will have to be done for them, both for the good of the country and of the State. Whether by loans oy some other means the problem will have to be tackled. It could be dealt with by some of the money saved by this settlement. There is another question which I do not want to go into now—it can be brought up afterwards—and that is the right of the Government to the land annuities now that they are wiped out. These things will have to be thought of. These people are down and out now aud should get the benefit of that. There should be pity for that poor farmer, who was formerly well off and could make a living before the economic war started, when we think of him looking at a stranger coming to his home, where his people had been for generations, and of that stranger deriving all the benefit of this settlement. I ask the Government in all seriousness to think of that aspect of the matter, and I am sure they will do it.

I am delighted that the economic war is settled. Farming will derive a great benefit, more benefit even than the newspapers say. I, as a practical farmer, can tell you we were in the hands of cattle dealers and in the hands of people coming over here. During the economic war a, farmer might send 20 cattle over to York, and what would it cost to land them in York market? £1 12s. 6d. a head, and he had to pay his fare over. I know what I am talking about, because I do it. We have store sales here every Thursday, and we have Welsh farmers coming over. What can they land our cattle in Wales for at the present time? From 14/- to 16/- a head. This is the benefit we are going to derive and I am glad that the Government have sense at last to settle this up. I am delighted, and all our people will take advantage of it. I could have taken more advantage of it a few years ago, but I will pull along now, and I have a hope of rearing my family. I may say that I am in debt. I got into debt during the economic war, and I have hopes now of getting out of it. I could show the Government bills that length. I could show where I got £350 for a certain number of cattle and that there was £196 of that tariff. I have bills to show and to look at when I am old. I will keep them.

Comment on this

When Deputy Fagan has a few winners he will feel better about it.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance has a big salary, and I think it would be a great, thing for the country it he would spend some of it on the training of a few horses, I breed my horses and try to sell them, and I support a lot by doing it, and I am not ashamed of it. I know the Minister for Finance was offered a horse, and his better-half advised him not to take it as it would be too expensive. I know those things.

There is another matter—derating— which, if it could be put into force now, would help the farmers. The Government Party advocated it at one time, and our Party advocate it now. I think it would be a good time to put it into force. It is awful to see the bailiffs and sheriffs going around the country seizing the few cows the farmer has for rates. I think something should be done about that. I do not want to take up the time of the House. I think it would be a good thing if Deputies would cut their speeches short and let this Agreement come into force immediately, because I know the cattle trade, and I know that it will upset business, especially in the first week of May. A week's delay at this time means a loss of thousands of pounds to the people. If you had two days' rain at the present time it would greatly. benefit the people of the country. I would advocate that the speeches should be cut short, and that this Agreement should be got through so that we can have a free market next Thursday.

Comment on this

A Chinn Chomhairle, I, like other speakers, agree with the Government in making a settlement of this question. At the same time there are certain points that I wish to bring to the notice of the Government and certain other points on which I would like information. The Taoiseach said that the Agreement fell under three heads. Now, under the financial head, £10,000,000 is to be paid. I also notice that Section 3 shows:—

"The provisions of Article 2 of this Agreement shall not affect—

(i) payments made or liabilities incurred by one Government to the other in respect of agency services,"

and so on. I should like to know what our total payments would be under that section of the Agreement. I should also like to know at whose expense the Irish Lights will now be conducted.

There is another point that some Deputies asked the Taoiseach about and I noticed he was a little bit diffident about mentioning figures for it. What will the approximate liability be in taking over the services of the ports and harbours and the new military fortifications adumbaated under this treaty?

There is another matter to which I wish to refer. Article 8 can be read in a variety of ways. The review is to be made of existing tariffs on representations from the English Government as to the precedence that they are to have and, I take it, on applications from English manufacturers. The clause contained in this Article to which I call the attention of the House is that:

"such duties and restrictions upon goods produced or manufactured in the United kingdom shall be replaced by duties which shall not exceed such a level as will give to the United kingdom producers and manufacturers full opportunity of reasonable competition while affording to Eire industries adequate protection having regard to the relative cost of economical and efficient production, provided that in the application of this principle greater consideration may be given to the case of industries not fully established."

I wish the body joy that has to interpret that clause. I would like to give the Taoiseach a hypothetical case and to ask him what circumstances the Prices Commission ought to take into account in the following instance:— Say, an English manufacturer applies to have the tariff on certain goods reviewed. The English manufacturer would make the case that the lrish manufacturer was protected by a 100 per cent. to 500 per cent. tariff and that the price at which the goods were sold in Ireland was 100 per cent. over the price in England. I suppose there would be counter recriminations and the English manufacturer, in support of his application for a reduction of the tariff, would say that the Irishman is selling in English territory at one-third of the price at which he is selling in Ireland, and that the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when putting on the tariff, had said that tho increase over the world price would be only 5 per cent., but that it was now 100 per cent. The Irish manufacturer would probably say: "Look at my books; they are open to the Prices Commission. My costs are very much higher than in England, and I cannot sell the goods any cheaper." I should like the Taoiseach to give us some line as to the matters that would guide the Prices Commission in reviewing such a case. I am quite sure they would not get over a case like that in an afternoon. The Prices Commission is apparently going to be a very important body. I do not know how fast they are going to move, but I have an idea that they have been considering prices in the building trade for the last two years and have not come to any decision in the matter yet.

Comment on this

The building bosses are too astute for them.

Comment on this

The building bosses have nothing on the English manufacturers, and you are making a great mistake if you think they have. I do not know how long the Prices Commission will take to go through that list, not to mention other lists. I should like to point out that apparently it is to be a sovereign assembly which is going to impose or take off tariffs. It seems to me that the logical outcome of that is that they ought also to prepare the Budget, because I think that millions of pounds of a difference could be made in a year as between putting on and taking off tariffs.

Another matter which occurs to one is why the Prices Commission, which is at present overburdened with work, and which has a job to do, is given this job at all. I think there are three Tariff Commissioners who are doing nothing. I should like the Taoiseach to correct me if I am wrong, but I think they ought to be associated with this job, and if not, they ought to be done away with. Another matter which I want to bring to the notice of the Government is, what right of entry to the Prices Commission will consumers or the distributing trade have? If they appear, will they be told: "Read the terms of reference. You have no right of entry into this assembly." I suppose many people would not be pleased with an arrangement by which the British, who had been put out of the ports, should be installed in the Prices Commission to which they had no right to go in and make their case.

I felt rather carious to-day—and I think Deputy Dowdall dealt with the same point—when the Minister for Industry and Commerce was talking about the Canadian Agreement, because I thought that, in that case, the consumers had the right to go in, and, if consumers here have not got the right to appear before the Commission I should like the Taoiseach to make that clear, because it ought to be safeguarded. For instance, could points be made before the Prices Commission to the effect that one manufacturer has a better system for distributing his goods and that, therefore, as between certain rival manufacturers, the distributors would favour one manufacturer as against another, or could the point be made that a manufacturer refuses to meet his customers to hear their complaints? I think that over the last few years far too little attention has been paid to the legitimate needs and grievances of the consuming public. In many cases, tariffs have been put on and revenues collected, tariffs being described as protective duties in cases where the goods were not manufactured in this country at all. If representation is made, will the Prices Commission have any right to intervene and can a case be made from the Irish side?

In making these few remarks, I have endeavoured not to range over past history or to deal with who started the economic war or who won. I have tried to make the case that the Government, as I recognise, had to come to an agreement, but having come to an agreement, I want to say that there is quite a lot of red tape and nonsense going on in connection with tariffs, and I only hope the Government will seize this opportunity to regularise and straighten out the present position, and that the situation in regard to tariffs, quotas, quantitative reductions, emergency duties and protective duties will be straightened out. I am quite sure, if that is so, that the Prices Commission will have a whole-time job for years to come. Another point which I wish to bring to the attention of the Government is the position of the importer in this country who has brought in goods and paid duty on them. Under one of he provisions in this Agreement, the Customs duty, the stamp duty and the package tax are reduced. I do not say anything about that. I wish to make the point clear to the Government that that facilitates trading by post with the other side. I suppose that is quite right. At the same time, the people who hold stocks over here are at present in a very unfortunate and invidious position. They do not know, if they order stocks to-morrow, that the duty may not be off the following day. That is not good for trade. It is not assisting the display of goods in this country. The distributing trade has a very difficult position to face. They have got very heavy costs. They are trying in some cases to display goods for the benefit of a very scattered population. The alternative is to have no distributing trade over here—to have the goods sold by post. I think that the Taoiseach said at the start of the negotiations that he realised how bad for trade uncertainty was. The position will be infinitely worse if this uncertainty is to go on for years to come. It will really be an intolerable position so far as anybody who is trying to hold stocks of goods in this country is concerned. I suggest to the Government that they, at least, issue a time-table which would show that certain commodities would not be reviewed within a certain time. That would give an opportunity for adjusting the position which, in many respects, is a dangerous one owing to the possibility of very high tariffs coming off. I appeal to the Taoiseach to take into account the difficulties of the Irish section who are dealing with this Agreement. I am not in any sense indulging in reproaches. I merely suggest that, taking the document as it is, he should inflict only the minimum of hardship on his own nationals. That can best be effected by telling them, as far as possible, when the tariffs are to be reviewed. I put that matter very seriously to the Government.

Comment on this

Before the Taoiseach concludes, there are one or two little points in connection with the Trade Agreement which t should like to get clarified. In the first place, I should like to know whether the Trade Agreement provides for the removal of quantitative restrictions. So far as I can discover, it does not definitely say so anywhere, but it seems to be implied in paragraph 3 of Article 8, which says: "It is understood that quantitative restrictions may be imposed..." Furthermore, the first paragraph of Article 10 says: "...Provided that, on the abolition of control by quantitative regulation, higher rates of duty may be charged..." The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that under Article 10, no change would be made and that the duties laid down in Schedule 5 would not come into operation until the matter would have been referred to the Prices Commission. I cannot read that meaning into that paragraph. The Prices Commission only comes in when you allow these higher rates on the abolition of quantitative restriction. As I understood, the Minister for Industry and Commerce said that neither the relaxation of quantitative control nor the imposition of the reduced duties mentioned in Schedule 5 became operative until the matter had been inquired into by the Prices Commission. In addition to Deputy Dockrell's point as regards uncertainty, there is the further point that, under Article 10, certain articles mentioned in the schedules have the duties reduced to 15 per cent. At present, in some of these cases, the difference in price between this country and the United kingdom is in the region of 50 per cent. If that provision becomes operative, it will obviously be economical for anybody to purchase these goods in the United Kingdom, but in paragraph 2 of Article 10, we are practically told that if they do so in any quantity, the quantitative restrictions will be reimposed. Will these quantitative restrictions only be reimposed after reference to the Prices Commission? In other words, will they have an opportunity of inquiring into the question of the 15 per cent. duty and the 50 per cent. difference in price, or will the quantitative restrictions be automatically reimposed if considerable quantities are imported under the reduced duties?

Comment on this

I should like to welcome this Agreement. I am one of those who maintained in this House, from time to time, that there was no hope for the agricultural community until the economic war was settled— and settled on a basis that could not be described as surrender. I, and other Deputies, advocated a settlement even at the risk of being called "imperialists." After all, it is a blessing that that cry is now gone, and gone for ever, so far as those on the Government Benches are concerned. There is as much patriotism on these benches as there is on the opposite benches. We were told from time to time that the economic war should not be settled. I do not want to say anything that would create bitterness. I do not want anybody on the Government Benches to think that what I say has that purpose. Nobody in the country is more anxious than I am to see the bitterness of the past removed. After all, there is no good in thinking of the past. I was glad to hear the Minister for Industry and Commerce ask members on these benches to support them in building up this unfortnnate country. There is no use in jeering or trying to convey to people in the cities and towns, who have no knowledge of the manner of livelihood of people in the country, that only small hardships were imposed on farmers by this unfortunate economic war.

I do not want to go into the motives behind the starting of the economic war, but there is one thing that we on these benches have made a point of since the negotiations started, and that is that. we were not going to do or to say anything that would embarrass the Government in the carrying out of the negotiations. Since the Treaty was passed I never suffered from any inferiority complex so far this country is concerned. On one occasion the late Deputy Hogan, formerly Minister for Agriculture, made a statement to the effect that when they went across to bargain with the British they stood on equal terms with them as members of the British Commonwealth of Nations. I need scarcely tell you that from time to time it was a bit sore on some of us to have to put up with taunts from the Government Benches, such as when we were described as Imperialists and other things. Perhaps it is a good thing that that cry can on longer come from Deputies on the Government Benches. I am glad to see that at last they have realised the necessity of fixing up the economic war and that they realise the real importance of the British market for the agricultural community in this country. The Government realise now how important it is to have our agricultural community in such a position that they can pay their way. The people in the towns and cities know full well now how serious the conditions have been as a result of the farmers being unable to buy various commodities.

With regard to tariffs, I do not want to misrepresent Deputy Dowdall, but I think he rather tried to convey to-night that the Fianna Fáil Government were the first to start putting on tariffs, in order to encourage employment. I would not agree with that statement, that is, if Deputy Dowdall wished to convey that meaning. The Cumann na nGaedheal Government set up a Tariff Commission, and when any factory or any other concern applied for a tariff, they put that application before the Tariff Commission, and if anybody wished to object he could go before the commission and make his objection. The Tariff Commission investigated the claim for the tariff and considered any objections, and then they reported to the Government as to the desirability or otherwise of putting on a tariff. They reported as to the cost it would mean to the country and the amount of employment it would give. Then the Government decided as to whether it would be wise to impose a tariff. The leader of our Party stated on more than one occasion that if they did impose a tariff they always made it a point, when they saw that it was going to impose a little burden on the community, to reduce the cost of living in some way, to reduce the tax on tea or sugar, or some commodity commonly used by the people. I believe that was a sensible policy. I am not in agreement with the policy of shoving on tariffs indiscriminately. I am sure this Government now realise that it was not a wise thing. When they were in opposition, the Fianna Fáil Party always argued that tariffs were not going to increase the cost of living. Is there anybody on the Government Benches now bold enough to say that tariffs did not increase the cost of living? I am as patriotic as anybody on the Government Benches. I was associated with the Gaelic League since its inception, and I have always given preference to Irish-manufactured stuff, even if there was a little extra expense. But there are people in this country who cannot afford to do that, and these are the people who should be considered. There are many men by no means well off by reason of this Government's policy through the last few years. It is all very well to tell them to be patriotic, but they cannot afford to do very much in the way of purchasing Irish-manufactured goods. I hold that it is the business of the Government to see that the unfortunate people are not fleeced by industrialists who come into the country just in order to take what they can out of it.

The Minister for Agriculture to-night tried to argue with regard to the increase in the price of cattle here. He charged us that we did not give him more credit for increasing the price of cattle when they went up in the British market. If he has any doubt about it, I want to reiterate the statement that he does not deserve any credit for the price of cattle in the British market. I will quote the words of the late Minister for Agriculture—Go ndeanaidh Dia trocaire ar a anam! —when he said here on one occasion that the export price of our agricultural produce ruled the price in the home market. I can get the qaotation of the present Minister for Agriculture, where, perhaps on more than one occasion, he admitted that that statement was correct.

The Budget is being introduced on Wednesday next, and my principal reason for rising now is to support the claim put forward by Deputy Davin and other Deputies on these benches, the claim of the agriculturists, the claim of those who have been in the front line trenches for the last five or six years. The Minister for Agriculture argued to-night that we were in a better position than the people of the North with regard to derating and annuities. I will instance my own position, and I wish this to go to the Press, because there are people in the cities who know very little about the burden that has been imposed on farmers. My annuity in 1932 was £218 10s. Od. Now, it might appear very high to the ordinary person in the country, but, mind you, I am not a rancher, and I have invited the Minister for Agriculture on more than one occasion to come to my place and work there for a week. Probably he would then realise what the farmers have to go through in order to meet their commitments.

Comment on this

Would you pay him 24/-a week?

Comment on this

I never paid men as low as 24/- a week. I am nearer to paying them 24/- a week with their board and lodging. I may tell you that as s result of the Government's policy you will not get many men to work on the land even at £1 a week, all found. I am prepared to pay a good ploughman £1 a week, all found. Unfortunately, our people have been turned away from the land, and I told the Fianna Fáil Party that. As I was saying, my annuity was £218 10s. Od.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might be good enough to relate the position to the Agreement to which the House is asked to give assent.

Comment on this

It has been conveyed by the Minister that this is going to be a great boon to the agriculturists. If this Agreement has been signed, what was the economic war fought for? Was it to improve the position of the agriculturist? I believe I have the right to say that, so far as we are concerned, we are in the dumps as a result of the economic war. I want to make an appeal to the Minister for Finance now that the Budget will be introduced in a few days——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy cannot deal with the Budget now.

Comment on this

I am only referring to it in passing. I want to point out now that this is how it affects the farmers. In 1932 my annuity was £218 10s. That was reduced by £98 4s. 6d., and at present the annuity I am paying is £120 5s. 6d. On the other hand, my rates have gone up considerably since 1932. In 1938 the rate I was called on to pay was £95 1s. 1d. That rate included 2/2 in the £1 for the Blessington tram. This item came to £33, so that my net rate after deducting that figure would be £62. The Blessington tram rate is done away with now. My present rate has gone up by over £100 as compared with 1932.

Comment on this

Why do you not pay your annuities?

Comment on this

What?

Comment on this

Your rates have gone up because some people are not paying their annuities.

Comment on this

And the Minister wants to penalise those who pay them. It is an awful pity that some of your Supporters in the country who are so strong in advocating the payment of land annuities for others cannot and will not pay their own Shop debts.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must get back to the motion.

Comment on this

I do not want to be at all personal, but if the Minister for Finance is looking for trouble he is going to get all he wants. If I have gone outside the motion, it is because I was trying to bring home to the people in this House the conditions at present existing in the country. The fact is, that we are now only in the same position as we were in 1932. As a result of the increase in the rates we are paying now as much in rates and annuities as we were paying before the annuities were reduced. I do not wish to take up the time of the House any further, but I do wish to appeal to the Minister for Finance to go and investigate for himself up aud down the country the existing conditions in which the farmers are living, and I ask him to have some consideration for the unfortunate people who have been deprived of their means of existence.

Comment on this

On this motion I wish——

Comment on this

Now we have the farmers' champion.

Comment on this

in the first place, to welcome this Agreement. I do so on the one hand as a farmer and, secondly, as one who believes in the absolute freedom and independence of this country. I have been listening all day to the Opposition Deputies asking why was not this matter settled five years ago. I have heard it asserted from the Opposition side of the House that this problem could have been settled more easily five years ago than now. Deputy Esmonde went so far as to ask why his Party was not thanked by the President for having kept quiet for three months. As to that, I must say that on very many occasions in the past six years I stood up here and asked them for God's sake to keep quiet for a few months——

Comment on this

They could not understand the Deputy.

Comment on this

We have no graveyards on this side, anyway.

Comment on this

There is always room for an extra one in it. I have sat here patiently all day listening to their talk and to their questions as to why this matter was not settled five years ago. If this matter was not settled five years ago it was because it took the British people all those six years to realise that the Opposition were not going to get back into office in this country. The British were not able to realise until now that the people on the Opposition side, who gave away the position before were not getting back into office here. That is the sole reason why this question was not settled during the past six years. During all that time the British were led to believe that the people who were going to hand over these annuities to them were going to get back into office again.

Comment on this

I hoar applause in the gallery. I wonder if these fellows in the gallery have got pensions.

Comment on this

They will surely get a pension after that clap.

Comment on this

I also wish to welcome the departure from our ports of the British forces——

Comment on this

You will have to man them for them now.

Comment on this

We will man them for ourselves. If I know Deputy Giles or any other Deputy in this House who was in the war for independence from 1916 to 1922 I believe they are going to be manly enough to say that as they fought to get the foreigner out of this country they will be prepared to man these ports in the future.

Comment on this

But not for England.

Comment on this

Not for England.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry had better not be blowing about 1916. We know where he was then.

Comment on this

Anybody living in the district in which I live and anybody who witnessed the state of affairs there from 1922 onwards could not help feeling a thrill of delight when we were told at last that the British were cleared out bag arid baggage from that port. We saw the British there in those years bolder than ever. I am glad they are gone and gone peacefully. There is only one regret I have in connection with this Agreement and that is that it has not completely finished the job, and that included in this Agreement we have not the Six Counties that were handed over by those who agreed to the Feetham Commission. But we have got Twenty-Six Counties, and I hope there is patriotism enough and enough Deputies with determination on both sides of the House to finish the job of getting the British forces out of this country.

Comment on this
A Deputy

That is not what Deputy Corry has been saying all along.

Comment on this

We have been told all about the position of affairs now. We have, on the one hand, some members of the Labour Party, with Deputy Dowdall and Deputy Dockrell, talking about the effect of the Agreement on the industrial position and telling us about the industries that are going to be closed down. I am indeed rather surprised to hear any Deputy on the Labour Benches talking about these industries at all considering that during the last six months here any time I opened my mouth to speak I was asked whether I was backing the millers and whether I was aware of all the profiteering that was going on. Well, if there was profiteering going on, let it be stopped now. I am rather surprised, on the one hand, to hear Deputies shouting about the high cost of living and about profiteering in the matter of the new industries, and, on the other hand, these people objecting now and shouting because there is an attempt being made to have a check on these people—even by English people coming over here.

Comment on this

Then Deputy Corry admits that English people are coming over here to interfere in this matter?

Comment on this

I thought it was the high rate of wages paid here that Deputy Corry was objecting to.

Comment on this

Yes, the wages paid here are higher than the wages paid in similar industries across the water.

Comment on this

No credit is due to you for that.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry wanted workers paid 24/- a week.

Comment on this

He stood over that.

Comment on this

I paid more wages than Deputy O'Brien or Deputy Norton ever paid in their lives.

Comment on this

You had got to do it.

Comment on this

I now move the adjournment of the debate.

Comment on this