Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).
Contributions 218–446 of 446. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
What will you do? Are you going to get rid of live stock? That is, apparently, the policy you have put up for the two days while we have been discussing this matter. The policy has been to go back to live stock and to abandon tillage. That has been the policy of the Opposition. When you come back to tillage you will find that there are 100,000 more cows in the country to-day than when the economic war started. If they look into the matter Deputies will find that in order to maintain the present number of cows in the country, the Minister for Finance must come along and pay a subsidy on butter. Now, Deputy O'Leary is like myself. Neither he nor I have any complaint as far as the price of milk is concerned. I am knocking out 1/4 a gallon, whatever Deputy O'Leary's milk is fetching. We are doing very well and the Government is protecting us. We ought to pass a vote of thanks to the Minister for the protection he is giving us.
Comment on this
Some fellows will never be better off. They do not know when they are well off. The argument put forward hee by Deputy Dillon, at every opportunity, has been a definite argument in favour of live stock. The live stock has to be subsidised to the extent of £800,000 a year subsidy on butter. If we are to increase the number of our live stock we must increase the subsidy—unless Deputy Duillon has a new invention up his sleeve. I do not know whether the Deputy has special incubator which will produce, without any cows, two-year-old bullocks. Otherwise, in order to have the bullocks we must subsidise the cows. There is no farmer who would go on producing milk at the price which butter is fetching in the English market to-day.
If we on this side of the House wanted to get rid of our problem in 1934 and, in fact, in 1933, all we had to do was to sit tight and say to the farmer: "We will pay you the full amount of the tariff you have to pay on you butter on its entry into the English market; go on and produce." If we went and did that and paid the full amount of the tariff on the butter going into the English market, all that the farmer would have been getting for his milk at that time would have been 2d. or 2¼d. a gallon. That is all he could be paid at the price butter was fetching in Engalnd—70/- a cwt. We could have got rid of the problem altogether if we did that, because no farmer would keep cows and sell milk at 2d. a gallon. Without the cows we would not have the bullocks, and thus we would have got rid of the whole problem. Instead of that, what is the position? We find at the end of the economic war we are in the happy position of having 100,000 more cows than we had in 1931 and considerably more yearlings than we had then.
We will next be told that there are too many cattle. Senator Baxter wanted us last week to get rid of some of our cows rather than that the farmer should be paid a subsidy on his butter. I say it is better for us to continue the production of foodstuffs for which we have a ready market at home—the production of wheat and beet and the rest of it—than to go into the production of articles for the sale of which we have to depend on a market which Deputy Gorey has stated is unsafe. That is a market that is very good for the period while certain things are being done across the water. That market is all right while money is being spent in England or rearmament and things like that. While that lasts the price of cattle will go up, but the very moment people being to get poor the price of cattle will come down.
Between the years 1924 to 1929 the value of our produce in the English market fell by £13,000,000, though we sent over more agricultural produce in 1929 than we did in 1924. As a matter of fact, the position was so bad in 1929 and the condition of the farmers in my constituency was so precarious that year that the Deputy who sat on these benches then and represented my constituency had to go into the town of Midleton, stand up there at the urban council meeting and move a resolution asking the Minister for Lands not to collect any more annuities from the farmers in East Cork because the price of agricultural produce was so bad that the farmers there were able to pay no more annuities. That was in 1929, three years before any economic war had started. That was thenthe condition of affairs there. I ask Deputies on the Opposition Benches to consider these facts now. We have got to get back and to pull the country together so that the agricultural community will get the greatest possible benefit we can give them.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot get a guaranteed price now any more than he could then in the English market. Back in 1929 Deputy Carey said that the prices were so bad in the English market that the farmers could not pay their annuities. That is why I say that the proper thing to do was to keep at the tillage policy. Produce beef, produce wheat and beet, so that if there is a war our population will not die of starvation and will not be depending on foreign ships to bring in bread to them, and very black bread we got in 1918.
Comment on this
No, I got over it. That is the position and that is why I argue the proper attitude for us to adopt is that anything the agricultural community can produce for the home market should get protection; the home market should be preserved to them and the Government should see that they get a good price for their produce. By all means keep up your live stock; keep up or increase the number of cows you have. We have 100,000 more cows than we had when Deputies opposite were in office. Let us keep them going and increase them whenever we can, but be careful and do not put all your eggs into one basket. I would not be at all surprised if we would have to salughter calves again. I would not be at all surprised if that happened.
Comment on this
If that happened I am afraid we would have to start with the bulls. You would be slaughtered. In all probability we will have to start slaughtering calves again, and I do not see any reason why we should not. I would like to bring to the attention of the Minister for Finance the position in regard to the rates. I would like to impress on him that each new proposal that is being brought in, the Sweepstakes (Hospitals) Act, the Housing Acts and all other such Acts add an additional burden on the ratepayers. The worst burden is the burden of keeping up the roads in their present position not for the benefit of the farming community but for the benefit of the motorists, the tourists and the joyriders. I think that those people should be able to pay for their own roads but they do not. Some of these roads cost £1,500 to £2,000 per mile annually and those people who have the benefit of them should pay for them.
I suggest that the first job is to take the trunk and the mainroads and make them a national charge. Then go into the new social activities, the hospitals and everything else, which are undoubtedly throwing out grants, but side by side with it all there is a burden on the ratepayers. It is time those things were looked after and the farmers deserve that from this Government and from the country in general. One thing I can say is that the farmers were in the front line trenches. They fought their fight and won it. It would have been a far easier fight only for the advice from Deputies opposite. Anyway, the farmers have won it. The fruit of their labours is that for the rest of the land annuity period the farmers will be paying £2,100,000 less in their annuities than they would be paying if the Deputies on the opposite benches were the Government Party during the last six years. That will continue for the same period as that in which their annuities would terminate in the ordinary way. That is the actual position according to law. The farmers will have their annuities halved for the next 20, 30 or 40 years. They have won that as a result of their fight and I suggest seriously to the Minister that we should protect the home market for the farmers and see that their produce will be sold here. any assistance or help or inducement the farmers require to keep their land in cultivation should be given to them and I ask that the increasing burden of the rates will be looked into and relief given. I think that is the only fair way of dealing with these people.
Comment on this
I listened to the Deputy for some time and I frankly confess that I found it rather difficult to see the connection between his statement and the Budget which is under discussion. I have no doubt he gave us a very interesting lecture on many phases of agriculture, and the fact that it was a lecture with which I think very few authorities would agree does not take from the amount of interest which he put into the subject. Not the least interesting was his attempt to defend, justify and explain his own acrobatics and evolutions with regard to the derating of agricultural land. He started off by explaining to us, or rather apologising for the fact that many years ago he was in favour of derating, but that he learned from experience and that he was now opposed to derating because he found that the big man would benefit to a much greater extent than the little man. Having explained that position at one point, he finished up by advocating a very big degree of relief in rates, namely, taking off the rates the maintenance of institutions and main roads, apparently forgetful of the fact——
Comment on this
If the Deputy will allow me, not the maintenance of institutions, but the amount that the local bodies have to pay to supplement the sums given by the Sweepstakes for local hospitals.
Comment on this
I do not see the difference in the point. The point was that having been opposed to any degree of derating on the grounds that the big man benefited more than the little man, he then advocated a degree of derating and, whatever the degree of derating is, or whatever charges are taken off the rates, it is obvious the bigger ratepayer. But, in his inconsistency with regard to derating, he was consistent at least in his inconsistency, because I have never heard the Deputy make two speeches in succession in which one statement was reaffirmed or which he stood over in his second statement. He always gave me the impression of a Deputy speaking merely for the momentary effect, and without any previous consideration, or with any degree of conviction. His statements or misstatements with regard to derating were just on a par with his misstatements, his unfair, unjust charges, inaccurate charges, when applied to the members of the Opposition.
I am glad he came back to the Dáil in a somewhat chastened mood, having been reprimanded for suggesting the use of poison gas against our neighbours in the North, and he has at least decided that, not being allowed to use his poison gas in that direction, he is going to sue it in our direction. We are accustomed to it. We can say that it has ceased to have any effect on us. We are satisfied that the leaders of the Government, who have repeatedly repudiated the Deputy, have not been afraid to express appreciation of the conduct of Opposition Deputies in the Dáil during rather lengthy and rather delicate negotiations. That tribute was deserved, but it was given in a generous spirit and all Opposition Parties in this House prefer to remember that rather than to remember the unfounded abuse of an irresponsible Deputy.
I have always a certain amount of sympathy with any and every Minister for Finance who is standing over a Budget in this House, because I think there is a lot of truth in the statement made by the Minister that all the year round there is general demand for more expenditure and, when the demand is met, there is general condemnation and criticism of the man who puts up the money and foots the bill. There is undoubtedly a certain amount of truth in that. We have had Ministers one after the other coming into this Dáil and standing over their Estimates in the last few months, each one of them patting himself on the back because he was in a position to spend more money in this direction or more money in that direction. Now we have the other side of the coin. We have the Minister for Finance having to stand over the expenditure that is demanded day after day and month after month by the great Departments of the State. I feel our criticism, when it is directed against vastly increased taxation, should be directed against all State Departments rather than against the individual Department that has to stand over the Budget. It is true to say that as one Estimate after the other was brought into this House, members of this political Party have voiced their protest against the rapidly increasing rate of expenditure and the over-hurried way in which endeavours were being made to do highly commendable and desirable works in some cases. A job that is done in too much of a hurry, to much of a rush, is often over-costly and a very faulty job when the particular work is done.
We have repeatedly warned members of the Government against the rapidly increasing rate of expenditure and against the unplanned, hurried, and rushed tactics that were being adopted. We have the whole thing reflected in the Budget. We have it reflected in the huge volume of taxation which has to be extracted from the people. We have reached, in the sixth year of the present Government, a position where at least they can boast of this: that in bad times generally, and in very peculiarly bad times in this country, they have succeeded in abstracting £24,000,000 more from the pockets of the people in six years than their predecessors abstracted in the previous six years. Some may think that that is a thing to be proud of. Personally, I think it is a thing that requires a certain amount of apology and a certain amount of explanation. The Minister, in his Statement, tells us that there is an amount of confusion when people discuss customs duties; that customs duties are divisible into two big groups—revenue duties and protective duties. That is probably conrect. His classification is probably correct also; but whether they are revenue duties or protective duties, the thing to be borne in mind is, that a duty is a duty and that a duty is a tax, and the collection of that tax is taking so much from the people, whether its effect is purely to increase revenue or to increase revenue and protect some article being produced in this country. We find on the figures, again, that the amount collected in revenue duties is, roughly, about £2,000,000 per annum more than was collected under the previous Administration—revenue duties, the Minister told us, or such duties as tea, sugar, beer, spirits, newspapers, and motor cars. Now, the abstraction of £2,000,000 more than was previously taken from the pockets of the users of tea, sugar, newspapers, tobacco, beer and spirits, is something that should not be passed over lightly, with the possible exception of spirits. Beer, tobacco, tea and sugar are articles that are more commonly and more extensively used in the homes of the poor than in the homes of the wealthy—far more extensively. In the wealthier homes there are substitutes for those things; there is more variety and there is less reliance on the ordinary standard cup to tea or the ordinary beer. In the past, we were accustomed year after year to hear the present Minister for Finance and every one of his colleagues protesting at the mere suggesion of any form of imposition whatsoever on the necessaries of life. After six years on the opposite benches, they can pride themselves on the fact that they have succeeded, by taxation on the necessaries of life and on goods mainly and most extensively used by the poor, in abstracting £2,000,000 more per annum. We find that, in the last six years, s compared with the previous six, £13,000,000 more has been collected than in the previous six years, under the head of revenue duties.
Now, we hear a lot about social services, and I have never heard any opposition expressed to the development and extension of social services, but I think it is serving no useful purpose, not serving the poor or anybody else, to have social services made the political cat of this particular Parliament—and any time that any Deputy refers to increased taxation or rapidly increasing taxation, somebody gets up and bleats "social services." Taxation has gone up by some £4,000,000 or £5,000,000 a year. If we add to that the amount that has come in to Irish revenues that used to go to outside sources, we have increased our spending capacity by about £10,000,000. A portion—perhaps a third—of that has been utilised towards improving and developing the social services of this country. Is that any justification for making the social services the cat to be blamed for all the expenditure?
About £3,000,000 or so have gone in increased and better social services. About £3,000,000 have also gone in increased expenditure on the Army, on the Civic Guards and on the Civil Service—Approximately, according to the figures given to us by the Minister, and I appreciate the fact that, even though it may have been mainly intended to carry out a controversy with a particular newspaper, the figures this year have been presented in great details and in a very understandable manner. It is true, however, to say that the expense of sevices of a nonsocial kind has increased by as much as the expenditure on social services. From the Minister's figures, I take it that the cost of the Army, as compared with 1931, has gone up by £810,000; that the cost of the Civil Service has gone up by approximately £1,000,000; that the cost of the Civic Guards has gone up by £200,000; and now we propose to spend £250,000 on airports. That is £2,500,000 a year of increased taxation that is required for these special purposes.
It appears to me that this particular Budget has been received in many quarters with rather acute disaapointment, and in certain other quarters with a certain amount of relief. The relief is found in quarters that have been accustomed to Fianna Fáil Budgets for six years and always expected that the normal would happen, and that was that there would be a big increase in taxation. It has happened every year for six years, and there was a certain amount of relief that the same did not happen this year; but there was bitter disappointment in all ranks and classes that were invited by the Government to go through the mill and stand the racket for the last six years. There is not a person in the agricultural industry in this country, no matter what side they were on, who did not look forward to a satisfactory and successful termination of the economic war—for national reasons, but also for material reasons —and the inducement was held out to them all the time that the objects for which they were struggling, if attained, would mean that the benefits would pass directly to them. I am aware of the fact that there is rather a considerable amount of the Minister's statement directed towards an attempt to prove that the exact equivalent of what use to go to Great Britain has gone, or is going, directly or indirectly, into agricultural channels. Now, that is the portion of the Minister's statement which I am prepared to criticise most freely. I think it was a case of special pleading, and in that respect neither the Dáil nor the public was treated very fairly by the Minister Figures, especially when they come from an accountancy department can be made to appear to prove many peculiar and many very different things. It is a simple things to take the £5,000,000 that used to go out of the country, and to take £5,000,000 of internal expenditure and find that the two balance, and then to argue that the £5,000,000 that used to go out is now going as shown in that tot, which amounts to £5,000,000. It would be equally true, equally doubtful and, I would even say, equally doubtful and, I to take the £5,000,000 that used to go out of the country and put that on one side of a balance sheet, and then put the £1,000,000 increase in the Civil Service, the £800,000 increase in the Army, the £250,000 of an increase in the Civic Guard Estimate, the £250,000 for airports all on the other side and, finally, when I had reached the figure of an equivalent £5,000,000 to turn around and say that the responsible Minister for Finance told the public "that is what became of the money": that all the fruits of the economic war, or the settlement at the end of it, had gone towards inflating the Army, towards a swollen Civil Service, a more expensive Civic Guard, and that we had done that a time when there is less crime, less instability, and less danger in the country than ever before. It would not be a fair presentation of the case. It would not be fair to the people who would look to me for a lead in such a matter; but it would be as fair, and financially as sound, as the presentation which the Minister has given here. It is taking a given £5,000,000 and opposing it to a select group of items that happen to tot £5,000,000.
The fact of the matter is that of the £5,000,000 that used to go elsewhere the main part of it was paid directly by the farmers by way of paying off the purchase pruce of their holdings. In the past the present Government and Party questioned the legality and the morality of that payment, and we had a campaign in the country against continuing the payment of that money. The implication, whether it was clearly stated or not, was that if the Party, as a Government, succeeded in getting off those payments, then the farmer would no longer be expected to pay. The Minister may shake his head. He may challenge me to find a clear-cut expression or statement to that effect, but the implication was there in the ears of every audience that the Minister addressed. Does anyone think that, when the Minister excited thousands of farmers, big and little, with the cry of the non-payment of annuities, each ember of his audience read into that that the annuities would be no longer paid to Great Britain but would continue to be paid by him to the Irish Government? The individual paying the annuity did not care a rap whether he paid it to Lloyd George or Séan MacEntee. What he was interested in was getting off the payment of that particular heavy charge on his industry, and that is the meaning that he read into every Fianna Fáil speech and into the whole big campaign of Fianna Fáil propaganda.
But, be that as it may, the Minister may argue or disagree with me as to what the farmer read into it. The fact of the matter is that that money was collected for a certain purpose. It was collected because there was a claim made. That claim was waived in the settlement, and it is reasonable for the agricultural community to claim complete remission of the annuities. The debt is waived. The person paying the debt should get off it. I see that the main objection to the adoption of such a plan would be that it would end land division. We could not afford to divide land in a month's time or a year's time and give it for nothing. We could not find ourselves in the position of making the new receipient of land liable for an annuity while the people all round him were enjoying their land rent free. That is the big objection that I see to it. If the money is not to go back to that industry, by way of the remission of the annuities, then I suggest that the only alternative way in which the industry can be relieved is by utilising those moneys to completely relieve agricultural land of rates.
Now, there is one argument that is repeatedly put up from the Government Benches which I regard as entirely unjust and dishonest. It is the argument we had from Deputy Corry this evening. His objection to derating is that the big man would benefit more than the little man, and generally the name of some big landlord or landholder in a county is mentioned. I think it is very undesirable to mention here the name of individuals. I think that the number of very big landlords in the country is small and will be getting less as day passes day. If that is a fair argument against assisting a huge big industry, it must not be confined to farmers. I have never heard of that argument used by the political Opposition when the Minister for Industry and Commerce stood up here to move a resolution to give protection to some big secondary industry. The owner of that industry or the head of the firm might be the nearest thing we have here to millionaire, but not one of us ever got up to argue against protection for the whole industry because one or two wealthy individuals would benefit to a great extent from the protection given. That is an entirely dishonest argument to use from any side. Whether we are the Government or the Opposition, we have to regard industry as an industry, forget the personnel and the individuals who may be making a living out of a particular industry. It has been a popular ramp in this country during the last six years to give unlimited protection to any and every secondary industry: to place imposition after imposition on the backs of the ordinary consumers in order to give higher prices and bigger profits to those concerned with secondary industries. We did that as a matter of policy, irrespective of whether the owners of those industries were wealthy men or not, irrespective of whether they were big men or little men. Each industry was viewed as an industry—the woollen industry and others—and nobody was put up to say that Mr. John So and So, who was worth so much per year, would benefit to such an extent by a particular tariff. It is only when we come down to the farmer and it is only from the Government Party that we have that kind of cheap, canting, unjust and unparliamentary opposition to a proposal. Derating is either god for the whole agricultural industry or it is not. It is either sound as a national policy or it is not. If it is good for the whole industry and if it is sound as a national policy, then it would be nothing short of corruption for the Government to fail to give it because some big person here and there might benefit.
When I argue and advocate complete derating of agricultural land I am in very mixed company—whether good company or not, is a matter of opinion. I am in the company of every front bencher who occupies a seat opposite me. There is not a person now occupying a seat on the Government front bench, from the Taoiseach down, who did not make the welkin ring or more than one occasion with his advocacy of complete remission of rates on agricultural land. They were better politicians than we were. They times their stroke better than we did. It was generally on the eve of the poll that they were noisy about such things and I recall a speech which I quoted here and which is on record. I was invited to quote it by the Taoiseach himself. It was a speech made at the fair of Athy —a four-county fair at which every agriculturist listening to him was promised complete derating for every inch of his land if only he had sufficient sense to trust Fianna Fáil. There was a reasonable case during the last six years for the Minister for Finance or any other Minister saying that their word could not be honoured, that their promise could not be fulfilled, because the country was in a strangle-hold, because there was economic chaos in the country, particularly in agriculture, and because we were in a life-and-death struggle with a big neighbouring nation. There was reason in that case for the last six years but that is happily ended now and any and every person concerned with or interested in agriculture is entitled to demand the fulfilment of the promise made. If it is unwise to allocate the money that is being retained to the complete remission of annuities, then it is only reasonable to expect that that money would be utilised for the complete remission of rates on agricultural land. There is this to be said for the annuities—that they are a fixed figure. They cannot go up. Rates, like taxes, particularly for the last six years, have developed a habit of going up from year to year.
When the Minister for Finance was over here, he was most eloquent, and fairly impressive, on every occasion on which he got up to argue from these benches that the agricultural industry could not continue to stagger on under the crushing burden of rates and annuities which was annually crippling the industry and the individual farmers. He was particularly eloquent when he scoffed at a proposal to allocate £759,000 towards the relief of rates on agricultural land. I forget the exact expressions used but his general line was that that was only playing with the question, that the overhead charges on the industry were too heavy, that that would have to be remedied and that one of the best and most direct methods of reducing the overhead charges was by remission of rates. Does the Minister for Finance change his mind every time he changes his seat? Does the mere fact that the whole Party is over there, instead of being over here, mean that their views on every question must change? I am proud of the fact that their views have changed on so many questions. But is there any reason why they should change their views so completely on internal economic questions which were argued so eloquently and so frequently?
When the Minister was over here we were not, as a Party, opposed to derating, but the case was met by the establishment of a commission to inquire into it. It was proposed to carry out the findings of that commission, whatever they might be. The majority report of the commission was against complete derating but, if that was so, the reasons were stated. The reasons why the majority of the members were at that time against derating were: (1) that they examined bank deposits and found that the farming community was in a comparatively prosperous position, that the percentage of deposits held by the representatives of any other industry, and (2) that nothing had happened to pick out the agricultural industry or the farmer for special consideration, that nothing had happened to affect his industry in a peculiar degree or in any special manner. Those were the reasons why the majority were against derating. Does either of those reasons apply to-day?
It is rather unfortunate that we are discussing this Budget in the absence of the report of the Banking Commission. That commission was established long ago. Its sitting and sessions terminated long ago. It was due to the Dáil that every effort should have been made to place that report in the hands of Deputies before this year's Budget was discussed. However, I expect that when that report is published, what I am stating may be either verified or found to be unsound. My information is that neither of these factors that applied ten years ago applies to-day. My information is that, in the last six years, the savings and deposits of the agricultural community have melted, that they were used, day after day, to keep the wolf away from the door, and that whatever degree of prosperity might have been enjoyed by the farmer ten years ago, nobody would look at agriculture as a prosperous industry to-day.
That was the first reason for reporting against derating. The second was that nothing had happened to penalise the agricultural industry any more than any other. Is the Minister, or anybody opposite, going to hold the view that nothing has happened in the last six years to hit the farmer in a very special and peculiar way, when other members of the community were not hit to anything like the same extent? If that very same commission were to reassemble to-morrow, in the light of the events which have transpired since, and in view of the changes that have taken place in this industry, I firmly believe there would be a unanimous report in favour of derating. From the point of view of either the sacrifices and the suffering endured in the last six years, or of entitlement; from, at least the point of view of fair play and equity, those moneys should go back directly into agriculture to relieve the overhead charges, either by way of remission of annuities or remission of rates. Personally, I should only consider the latter.
There is another matter which has been introduced into this Budget about which I think it would be advisable to give the Dáil and the country more information than they have got so far, and to give the available information altogether and not in small doses. We have a kind of policy or plan—I do not know which it is—with regard to the ports of letting the Dáil and the public into the know on the instalment system. We get a little dose to-day, a bigger dose to-morrow, and a bigger dose again in a week's time. It seems to be following the medical practice of building up the capacity of an individual to tolerate a medicine by giving a little at first and then gradually more and more, and it makes me at least suspect that the ultimate dose is going to be a huge things. Let us examine the various stages of this. When we first discussed the Pact we had a clear-cut statement by the Taoiseach that these ports were given over absolutely unconditionally, and there was nothing else mentioned that day. Two or three days later we had a further dose. We were told that they were given unconditionally, but that we were going to modernise them, that the equipment is inadequate, and that we are going to bring them up to date. That was a step further. A few days later we had another dose when we learned that we were going to modernise them, and that we were going to die to defent Britain's back door. That was going a step still further, but even at that time we were thinking only in terms of reasonable maintenance parties. Then we got the next dose, which comes in the Budget, when we are told to plank down or put up £600,000 in this financial year. Whether that £600,000 is for the modernisation or to pay the personnel which is to die defending England's back door is not clear. So far as I understood from the Pact, it does not appear likely that we are to take over these ports until the end of December. Is the £600,000 which it is proposed to spend in this financial year only an expenditure for three months, because, presumably, we will not be spending money on the ports before we take them over, and we are taking them over only at the end of December?
Comment on this
Whatever this sum of £600,000 is, it is not very clear. It is put down here as being for national defence, and I take it that it is in connection with coastal defence plans, as the Minister outlined in his statement and as the Taoiseach indicated when speaking elsewhere. If our expenditure on defence arising directly or indirectly out of the Pact is to increase at the rate indicated so far, and is to continue increasing at that rate, I think the quicker the whole thing is considered and discussed and a cut-and-dried proposal put before the Dáil the better. I am not speaking as one who is necessarity opposed to this type of expenditure. If a fair case is put up for it, it will be supported; but I consider that the present situation, where you have all kinds of more or less disturbing and alarming rumours going about, and where we are getting information from responsible Ministers only in a very grudging manner, is nationally unhealthy.
If we are to take over the ports, I accept the fact that they were given unconditionally so far as the Pact goes, but there can often be understandings without conditions, and there can often be understandings outside what more or less is associated with any cut and dried agreement that is in black and white. I read this into the Taoiseach's statement: that the ports are going to be modernised and that they are going to be fully utilised for the purposes for which they are there. The ports on any coastline are not used for internal communications; they are not used for internal purposes. They are there for co-operation with and co-ordination of land and sea forces in the past, and land, sea and air forces to-day. If those ports are to be modernised, they are going to be modernised for that purpose—for co-ordination between land, sea and air forces—because they were useless for any other purpose. We have no sea forces at the moment. Is it proposed that we will launch out as a naval power? Are we going to establish sea forces of our own? If we are not, we are going to co-operate with other naval forces—presumably, the British. I hold that the quicker there is complete understanding of all that, the better. The British have for the last 20 years, as they did for the previous 60, defended those shores. It suited certain people in responsible positions to turn the blind eye on that for the last six years. When there were wars and rumours of wars for the last few years, they, like myself, slept happily in their beds because the British Navy was around our coasts, no matter who occupied the ports. I would rather approach quickly the point that if we are going to modernise those ports—it is financially impossible for us to have an adequate navy—we are going to modernise and equip them in order to co-ordinate our land forces with the British sea and air forces. If that is to be done and we are asked to put up the money to pay the piper, then the whole plan and the whole arrangement should be submitted to the Dáil for consideration and approval. We are living in the type of world and in the kind of times when it does not do to hesitate or be unstable with regard to the defence arrangements of any country.
Comment on this
We have emerged from the war. For the last four months the farmers and commercial people of this country have been enxiously people of this country have been anxiously awaiting this happy event. They have been pondearing what the settlement would be when it came, whether it would be a good settlement or a bad settlement, and expecting that once the settlement was made we would have the Minister for Finance coming into this House with a peace Budget. Does anybody call this a peace Budget? I call it a war Budget. Frankly, without any restrictions, I call it a pure, unadulterated war Budget. I do not want to go into the terms of the Agreement made with Britain. I believe, as far as the agricultural people are concerned, it is a good thing that the restrictions on our agricultural output are ended. We are grateful to the Ministry for at least coming to reason. They might have done it previously, but we do not want to go into that. To my mind, having finished one war, there is no reason why we should prepare for another. Evidently the House is in a war fever. All the speeches made by Deputies on the other side had a war scare in them.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry waxed eloquent in trying to prove what he himself said was wrong. He changed his mind two or three times, and then he prepared us for disaster to come when he told us it would probably be necessary to slaughter the calves again. We slaughtered them in the economic war. We are going to do it again.
Comment on this
I am as good a prophet as other Deputies. I am generally more correct in any prophecies. Four years ago I prophesied a lot of things that have happened since. I did not prophesy that the Government would so completely change their minds. I do not believe in miracles, but miracles have happened. In regard to this question of defence, I for one am certainly not satisfied—no matter what Deputy on this or the other side of the House is satisfied—to find that under the terms of the settlement that we had, and that we are asked to pay for in this Budget, Britain asks us to hold the baby. There is no other way of putting it. I may as well put it in plain language as in any other. The ports were there, manned and equipped. Everybody knew for what purpose they were there. They were there at the expense of Britain, for Britain's purposes. Britain said to our negotiators: "We will settle this little war, and you will help us to prepare for another, but, for God's sake, take this baby we are holding. Feed it; nourish it; we will need it again." Our delegates said: "Right you are; we will." They took it. We can forbear from any outcries about national purposes or any such ráméis as that. As Deputy O'Sullivan said the other day, we are either going to defend ourselves as an independent State, fully equipped in every way, or we are going to defend ourselves in co-operation with a neighbouring State, to whose interests it is that they should defend us. We had a statement from the Taoiseach himself a few days ago admiting frankly that he believed it way in Britain's interests to defend us if the necessity arose, and that they would defend us. I believe that every Deputy on every side of the House upholds that view. It is to Britain's interest to defend us. They are bound to defend us, for their own interests. In any of the fights we had with Britain, economic or otherwise, it was never until now suggested that we ourselves should embark on large expenditure in preparation for war. If the portents are right, as Deputy O'Higgins said, it looks as if we are preparing for war. We had speeches from two or three Deputies over there who said that we should conserve our food, we should conserve our wheat and beet and everything else, so that we would be ready for war, so that we would have food for our people when war comes— war which they believed was coming. We had other speeches of the same type, all tending in the same way. In regard to another matter, the Minister for Finance spoke in this House some years ago about three white elephants. Now I suggest that we ahve three red lions, three baby lions. We are going to take them over and fee them, and have other little baby lions, one at Limerick, one at Galway, and a few others scattered around.
Comment on this
Why did not the Deputy vote against that a short time ago, in the same way as he voted against the Butter Stabilisation Bill?
Comment on this
I am not as pronounced an antagonist of co-operation with Britain as the Minister perhaps thinks I am, or as the Minister was. I have no qualms at all about co-operation with Britain. Let nobody think I have.
Comment on this
But I do resent this attempt to bamboozle the Irish people that we are engaging in expense— and bringing in a Budget to provide for that expense—for a great scheme of national defence, defence of a country completely free, with no political affiliations whatever with any other country. That is what i resent. I resent the voting of money for that purpose. If we are to co-operate with South Africa and the other Dominions, well and good. I will fall in with that, but I will not fall in with the suggestion from the people opposite who have tried to hoodwink the people into the belief that we are a wholly independent country; that we should protect ourselves, and be able to protect ourselves. They come here with this Budget under these pretences. I believe that we could have got on very well without these ports—that the ports would have been manned and equipped in an up-to-date manner at somebody else's expense besides ours.
Comment on this
The Deputy opened his speech by stating that he did not propose to discuss the Agreements. These Agreements have been approved of by the Oireachtas and implemented.
Comment on this
It is the implementing of the Agreements through the Budget to which I am objecting.
Comment on this
The taking over of the ports has been agreed to by the Oireachtas and omplemented by legislation.
Comment on this
They are being taken over, and I have done with them. Then we had many references to the vitality of the country and its resisting power during those six years of the economic war. I believe that we resisted better than anybody believed we could at the time. Evidently there is no great belief amongst the Government Party that we are going to continue to be able to resist. There is no evidence that they believe we are going to have any revival. In fact, there have been definite statements from Deputies opposite that there is no possibility of a revival, for the agricultural community at least.
They have been falling over one another during the last three days of this debate trying to give people the impression that they must be prepared for the blow they are going to get; that there is going to be no revival; that there are going to be no better circumstances for the agricultural community. We have had this stated definitely by Deputies Allen and Corry to-day. One of them said that we would have to go back to the slaughter period again and the other one said something to the same effect. When we advocated derating as one of the things the Government, having settled the economic war, might have done as an inducement to the agriculturists who made the continuance of the economic was possible, as one of the things offered to help them to revive we were met by Deputies and Ministers on the other side with the question. "How can you provide the money?" It almost makes me blush for politician to have that question asked of me by Deputies opposite. They did not ask that question five years ago when the country was better off than it is now, and when they suggested that we should have complete derating as well as other things. Not only could we provide the money then, according to these Deputies, but we could provide for other things with reduced taxation at that period. Now, with a Budget of £35,000,000 we are asked how can we provide the money? One Deputy went on to enumerate the difficulties of the Government and suggested that we were advocating a distinction between the big and the small farmer when we advocated derating. When they advocated derating, there was no suggestion that they were differentiating between the big and the small farmer.
Let us consider for a moment why we suggested that the Minister should include derating in his Budget, and why there should be no differentiation. Why is the big farmer not as entitled to derating as the small farmer? Are his expenses any less? Is he so wealthy that he must provide for all the local social services while his brother farmers are to be free from it? I suggest that not only is there an agricultural necessity for derating but a national necessity, if the social services are to be administered as they should be administered. Rates are going to rise every year, as they have risen in the last six years. One can make no other prophecy. We had the admission from the Minister for Local Government in my city that rates were not high enough—that the farmers were not paying enough rates. I did state in the House recently that the Minister did not mean to say that the farmers were able to pay higher rates, but his suggestion was that the needs of the social services would make it necessary that more money should be provided out of rates and therefore there is going to be a continually rising bill for rates. Everybody knows that the present rates cannot be borne by the ratepayers and there is no prospect that an increasing bill can be met. Eventually, under this Government or some other Government, they must be made a national rather than a local liability. This differentiation between the big fellow and the small fellow is all clap-trap. There is only one relief given in this Budget so far as I can see and is it for the little fellow? No, it is for the big fellow. When we come to motor cars we find that the big man in this country who can afford to buy a Rolls Royce is going to have a reduction made in his taxation, whereas the little man who buys a common Ford——
Comment on this
It is not. The only thing in the London Agreement is that these cars will be allowed in after paying duty.
Comment on this
The Deputy ought to stick to his point. It si not a concession to allow them to pay 22½ per cent. duty, is it?
Comment on this
The same exactly as the other cars? Is the Minister sure that he is right in saying that they are paying the same duty?
Comment on this
The Chair desires the Minister and the Deputy to keep off the Agreement, which was approved of by the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
The regard of the Ministry is certainly not for the small fellow. I am not blaming them for that. But I think that they should have regard for the little fellow as well as for the big fellow, and that they should not accuse us of having no regard for the little fellow. I do not see why the man who wants a big motor car should not get it, but I do say that the man with the little car should also be thought of, and that there should be some relief given to him in connection with payment of road tax. The motorist who pays his road tax quaterly should get some concession. Why should he be compelled to pay more than the man who pays for the twelve months? Why should be be charged 20 per cent. more on his quarterly payments—an interest that a Jewish moneylender would hardly charge? The farmers did not expect miracles from the Government, but they did expect something from those who stated seven years ago that this country could be run with £2,000,000 less in taxation, and that derating, I assume, could be provided for out of £2,000,000 less in taxation. Having fought this economic war and stood by the Government—some of us willingly and some unwillingly; I, for one, was one of the conscripted soldiers although there were many voluntary troops who plunged themselves in the mud of the trenches for six years—the farmers ought to get something.
It will afford no measure of satisfaction to any of the agricultural community, reading this Budget at the end of the war, to find that there is going to be no provision made for them. One Deputy here the other day asked if I suggested that there should be pensions for those who suffered during the economic war. I said that I would if they could be provided and, if I thought there was any possible way of providing them, I would suggest that they be provided now. I do not, however, generally suggest things that cannot be done. We are in some ways more reasonable than Fianna Fáil Deputies in that respect. I do, however, suggest that it should be possible to provide derating, which is one of the things that can be done. There are several other measures that might be initiated to help farmers, such as advancing money at low rates of interest, or making provision for a reconstruction loan for farmers at a low rate of interest, portion of which the National Exchequer might bear; but the first and easiest way to help is certainly by derating and, in that regard, I add my voice to all the other appeals which have been made to the Ministry. As I have said, it is going to come sooner or later. I am willing to make that prophecy inside or outside this House and stake my reputation on it, that derating will come as sure as to-morrow's sun rises. With the amount of the bill for rates every year increasing, some Government, possibly this Government—they have changed their minds once on this question and it is not outside the bounds of possibility that they will do so again—will have to grant derating. I hope that if the Government make up their minds to change their attitude on this question they will do so soon, and why not now? As we often urged about another issue, when we said that it would have to be faced some day: "Why not now?" I said that several times in this House in regard to another matter and I say the same thing with regard to derating. If you do not do it now, some other Government will do it when they get in.
In any contribution we had in this debate from Deputies opposite, there is not one ray of hope for any section of the community. There is none, apparently, for the farmers in anything which the Minister or any Deputy on that side has stated. There is going to be no improvement one way or another. The only thing they have got to prepare for is a future war. There was no indication of support for our industrialists, rather the other way. I know for a fact that many of them are in fear and trembling as to their position at the moment. Nor does the Budget offer any satisfaction to the huge number of unemployed—the 70,000 or 80,000 who went to Britain. It offers them no hope of being able to come back at an early date. It was expected that, when the economic war had ended, there would be some remission of taxation, some indication that the overhead charges on agriculture would be reduced, that more employment would be provided, and that this country could look with a fair degree of certainty for improvement in the general situation in the not very remote future. Evidently that hope has to be abandoned. We are almost in a position of stalemate. We, apparently, have got to regard the conditions under which we are living as interminable. One can only hope that having within the last five years changed their minds so frequently, and so happily in the end, the Government will go further and make an attempt to economise the reserves of this country and, having economised them, expend them in such a manner that the different sections of the community will get an adequate and just proportion of the benefits which will accrue.
Comment on this
I shall endeavour to be as brief as I possibly can in any remarks I have to make on this Budget. The discussion which we have had so far has been of a rather diverse nature. From my short experience of politics, I think that any Finance Minister or any Department of Finance bringing a Budget before this House should get the sympathy of the House. With all respects to the Department of Finance, I think it is certainly a very peculiar Department to belong to. From my few months' experience of political life and from any connection I have had with Government Departments, I have found that whenever I endeavoured to be bellicose or obstreperous, I have on many occasions been put off. The whole reason is that we cannot do anything with these gentlemen of the Department of Finance. They aim at making the whole country responsive to their governmental functions. As a result of that small experience of mine, I think that any adverse criticism in personam against the Department is not equitable or fair. I suggest that any criticism should be against the Government in general, indirectly hitting the Department.
My submission about this Budget is that we are free no more. It is an admission that our freedom has gone and my reasons for saying that are as follows: I think there are two kinds of freedom. One is what I would call racial or national freedom and the other what I would term economic freedom or the freedom of the individual. The control of the ports, the control of the Executive, the judiciary and so forth will, and I think should be, called attributes of political freedom, but unfortunately they do not bring freedom to the individual or what I might call economic freedom. We may have political freedom under a home Government and yet an individual may suffer a great deal of economic servitude. It is quite possible that he can suffer as much economic servitude under a home Government as he can under an alien Government. I think we have got a precedent for that in that well-known free country, the United States. I think everybody knows that the negroes in the southern States of America were in servitude and in bondage, economically and otherwise, for a number of years prior to 1850 and that it eventually took a sanguinary civil war to clear matters up. I am not going to compare any individual in this country with a negro in South America. Nothing is further from my mind, but I suggest as a result of certain admissions in the Budget and in the recent Agreement —I think I have got to bring in the Agreement—we have sold our economic freedom.
Comment on this
Included in the Budget are different provisions from which we may take it that both physically and financially we are bound hand and foot to Great Britain, and that we are prepared to accept that position. On the other hand, owing to other provisions in the Budget this country has to find £600,000 for defence purposes, so I suggest that we are selling our political freedom also. The Party on the left has been accused— perhaps by this Party, but certainly by the Party that is now the Government —of having sold the Republic by private treaty.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Government that their Fianna Fáil supporters are asserting that not alone have they sold the Republic by private treaty, but that they have sold it by public auction, and that the price was a little more security of tenure for a couple of years. I am only saying what I heard supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party say.
Comment on this
I will not trespass in that respect again, but I repeat that this Budget is an admission that we have sold our freedom. It has been suggested on a good many occasions that a great portion of the money to be spent on defence will go in the provision of equipment, and in the fortification of certain ports to be taken over from the British; in other words, will be spent on machine guns and all kinds of guns to be provided, for the purpose of keeping out invaders. One of the first results has been that we have to pay 2d. per lb. extra for butter. I can visualise a conversation taking place between two well-known characters, generally depicted in a Dublin newspaper as Mrs. Byrne and Mrs. Win-the-war, when going down Moore Street on a Saturday night, and Mrs. Byrne asking Mrs. Win-the-war if she was going to buy butter, the reply being: "No, I am not going to buy any butter; I am going to subscribe 2d. more for a machine gun for Lough Swilly." That has been one result of the proposed big expenditure on defence. I should like to know what is meant by defence. Is it the intention to spend the £600,000 on the four ports to be taken over? I suggest that if any outside power is going to invade this country it will not attack what might be called third-class ports, but will attack modern ports such as Galway or Dun Laoghaire. These are the ports we should start fortifying. If we start fortifying all our defences there will not be enough money to do anything else. The Minister referred to another subject with which I wish to deal. When speaking he looked at Deputy Davin and members of the Labour Party who, he said, went around the country wanting to have money spent on social services like old age pensions and widows and orphans pensions, but when it came to paying, they were unwilling to do so. On that particular occasion the Minister looked only at the Labour Benches, and did not look towards Fine Gael.
Comment on this
The Minister's statement was what I might term "a cynical inconsistency." I was not very interested in politics a few years ago, but as I happened to be a constituent of the Minister then, I remember a statement in one speech dealing with taxation in which he said that his Party could run the country cheaper than it was being run. I think the Minister will agree that that was said.
Comment on this
Even £2,000,000 was something. The Minister may say now that his Party had been forced by the Labour Party to provide money for social services. I think I am correct in saying that concurrent with the assertion that taxation would be reduced, he and his Party were making promises to increase old age pensions, to provide widows and orphans pensions, and to do a great many other things provided for in this Budget. I am only suggesting that the Minister's suggestion is what I term "a cynical inconsistency," and that it does not affect the issue. Having analysed the Minister's statement, I can see nothing else in his attitude but one that I term "a cynical inconsistency." I hope I have convinced the Minister that the freedom of this country physically and economically has now definitely been taken over, as well as the sun, moon and stars.
Comment on this
Deputy Moore asked where the money was to come from for derating, and he sought the information from these benches. The answer is that that is the business of the Government in power. When Deputy Cosgrave is returned to power, there is no question at all but he will be able to find the money for derating. He was ready to find it in 1930 because, arising out of the Report of the Derating Commission, he provided a substantial instalment for derating in the shape of £750,000, which the present Government then declared was insufficient. They said it should be £1,000,000 so convinced were they of the necessity of derating at that period. I venture to say that no one on the opposite benches will deny the necessity of derating for the relief of the agricultural community from taxation. The basis of the poor law valuation of agricultural land is obsolete, and is an unfair method of taxation considering the enormous increase that has taken place in the volume of taxation required to supply social services, roads, mental hospitals, public assistance, and other services. The present system may have been all right when taxation was fixed on the basis of parish relief, but to-day, when it is extending more and more, the necessity of finding other means to supply local services is urgent. It is the business of the Government to find a means. We have been asked where the money was to come from. No matter what services were required, the Government never asked where the money was to come from, because it was provided.
It is to provide various other services that the Minister's increased Budget has been presented to this House. The necessity for providing for the relief of farmers to-day is overwhelming, considering the present position they find themselves in. It is an amazing thing to hear farmer Deputies on the Government Benches so lost to the principles of truth as to try to make out that the agricultural community are in a prosperous state to-day. There was a question as to why the late Government did not provide derating in toto. There was a strong reason for it. The necessity was not as great then as to-day. The levies for rates for provision for these services were not as large as they are to-day and they are ever growing. They are growing to such a degree that a few years ago the primary party in the Cork County Council decided that they would cry halt to the increasing expenditure and they refused to strike a rate which the Minister said should be struck. The Minister brought a mandamus against them to compel them to strike the rate that he felt was right and he won his victory in the courts and the farmers were mulcted in an increased form of taxation based on that. Since that day, when a very decided opinion was given as to what the position of farmers was on that day, when they were not as badly hit as they are to-day, when they had not got through the operations of the economic war, they protested. To-day what has been the result? There is an overwhelming arrear of rates. In one case I know in Cork County, up to £600 is due by one farmer. £400 is not an unusual sum for some of the larger farmers to owe, simply because they have lost so drastically. Doubt has been cast on the amount of those losses. The Minister's own statement, the Minister's own figures, the figures supplied by the Department of Industry and Commerce will give the lie to any question as to the position of the farmers to-day. In 1930, the amount of class I. exports, cattle, livestock and other forms of agricultural produce from the land, was £21.05 millions. These were taken from the Department's Statistical Statements. In 1931, the figure was £18.3 millions, but in 1932, when the economic war commenced, the exports had fallen to £11.9 millions. In 1933, they had sunk to £7.5 millions. In 1934, £6.1 millions. In 1935, £7.3 millions. In 1936, due to an increase in prosperity and a greater volume of purchases it had risen to £8.95 millions and in 1937, £9.8 millions. It will not be denied that the influence of the penal tariffs was largely resultant in that condition of affairs. When a cattle dealer was buying cattle at a market or fair he knew the price it would cost to export those cattle, but better than anything and it was particularly brought home to him, he knew the tariff he would have to pay on those cattle and that would have to be paid before they entered the British market. He knew when they were £6 a head and he knew when they were £4 5s. a head. He knew to a penny, and he made it clear in every fair he visited what he would have to pay on those cattle. Those tariffs which were deducted for a special purpose, the payment of which was not denied and which is acknowledged from the Government Front Bench on more than one occasion and which was also admitted in the British House of Commons, were taxes paid direct by the Irish farmer based on his production, every one of which was taken directly out of his pocket and deducted on the day they were purchased.
That will not be denied. An attempt has been made to deny it. The Minister for Agriculture has said that not one penny of the tariffs was paid by the Irish farmer, although the cattle traders will tell you that they deducted them. It is good politics for the Minister for Agriculture to say that, definitely good politics, because he knew very well the Irish farmer would demand restitution. No matter what agreement was come to, they were waiting until an agreement was brought about before making their demands, and to-morrow when those tariffs are taken off they are asking the Government for that restitution which is their right and proper due. That restitution will be demanded all over the country by the Irish farmers and they will insist upon getting it. It is useless for the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the speech which he made last Saturday to say that it was the cattle consumers in England who paid those tariffs. The cattle consumers in England bought Irish cattle on the English market based on the prices that were given for cattle on that market, whether they were Irish-produced or English-produced or Scotch-produced. They gave the actual market price, and they only gave that price because the tariffs were actually paid before those cattle entered that market.
Is it a very likely story that four plenipotentiaries went over to England to settle the case for the English farmer? If it was, what did they go over for? For what did the Minister for Industry and Commerce sacrifice his dearest ambition, to provide for the self-sufficiency of this country so far as their industries were concerned? He sacrificed that and he gave up your independence so far as your fiscal policy is concerned. The Minister for Industry and Commerce gave up all that, that he held dear and that he acknowledged as right to provide, for an Agreement which he knew was urgent and without which he knew it was impossible to go on in this country. Therefore, I say definitely there is a settlement due to the Irish farmer. The Minister for Agriculture has made suggestions that subsidies will be given. Subsidies do not travel always to the source. Subsidies do not travel back to the farmer. Very often they are arrested on their way, and I say that is not the form of relief which is necessary for men who have experienced during the past five or six years the most drastic punishment that could possibly be meted out to the agricultural community.
Beet and wheat are two very excellent things, for those who are able to carry them out and when climatic conditions are favourable. Wheat is an excellent thing on land that is favourable to its production. With regard to the beet crop, I have very good land and I can say that I have not grown a very big crop of beet. It has not been a success with me and I have had to give up growing it this year. It may be a success with the small farmer with a large family that can carry out all the operations that are necessary, but I submit that any man who has to pay, and pay well, for agricultural labour is not able to make a profit in the growing of beet because the operations are so extensive on it. Often in very unfavourable climatic conditions labourers will not work. You are paying an extra wage now to agricultural labourers. That will make those operations all the more expensive and will prevent the growing of beet in this country, whatever you may do with wheat.
I say there is one direct form of relief which you can give to the agriculturist, and that is to derate his land, simply because the services that the rates provide for are now utilised by a non-farming community. The community that use all these services are often wealthy men who pay very little in rates, and, whatever you may have done in the past, 50 or 60 years ago, when rating was a purely local matter, when every parish paid for its own poor, when the rates were kept within a particular, circumscribed area, rating might have been perfectly justified, but to-day it is unfair and inequitable. We ask in the name of the agricultural community that it will be removed. Deputies here are anxious about Partition in Northern Ireland. They do not want to see that continued. But will they tell the farmers in Northern Ireland to come in here under their wing, and that derating will be continued to them? Or will you tell the farmer that he is to pay rates on the land again—a very large volume of rates?
The Minister for Local Government and Public Health tells us that we in Cork County are not doing our duty because we are not levying a greatly increased amount of rates on the agricultural community. You can have all those services you want and every class of service you need provided you take it off one particular section of the community who are unable to bear the drastic method of taxation which is involved in the upkeep of the local services to-day. It is a burden which you cannot impose on the agricultural community in view of the heavy arrears which we are utterly unable to-day to collect. Many farms are absolutely unstocked and some of them are partly unstocked. Do not now by levying increased taxation denude the land further. That has happened already in many cases. In 1930 the present Government and its supporters wanted to give the farmers £1,000,000 in derating. In 1932, I remember, every Fianna Fáil candidate spoke of the blessings that derating would bring the agricultural community. The farmers were told what the Fianna Fáil candidates were going to do for them in addition to having the land annuities retained. The people naturally expected that that promise would be kept. Certainly while the economic war was in progress that promise was not kept.
I say that derating is a form of restitution that is absolutely due to the farmers of this country. I venture to say that we cannot by any means have a contented agricultural community if they are not derated. I have been asked by Deputy Corry as to my views on the beet industry in this country. Well, I would be very sorry to see that industry given up. It is all right for those who are able to grow it, whose land is suitable for it, and for those who have the necessary labour in their own families. But I say this, that when wages for agricultural labour are fixed at 27/- a week, if the farmers are at all to be encouraged they must be given derating and those taxes removed from them. The farmer cannot pay a proper wage unless he is relieved of this burden. The demand note for the rates is the heaviest burden the farmer has now to bear. It is one of the burdens from which he should be relieved. In England the farmers have the benefits of derating. They have been given its benefits in Scotland and Northern Ireland. It is due to the farmers in this country as well.
I think it was Deputy Moore who referred to the fact that only £1,000,000 had been drawn from the farmers' deposits in the banks during the economic war. Is there any greater proof of the fact that the deposits were not there, that they were non-existent or that they existed only in the imagination of non-farmers like Deputy Moore, than the statement that only £1,000,000 had been withdrawn during the most critical period through which the agricultural community has passed? Is it not the position in Ireland that whenever the farmer was in need he had to withdraw whatever little savings he had in order to meet his current obligations? We have evidence that they were not able to pay their rates or land annuities. I submit that it is absolutely urgent in order to provide adequate and immediate relief for these men who have suffered under the operation of what is known as the economic war that they be now given this relief. I do not suppose, though the embargo is going to be lifted to morrow, that there is going to be an immediate rise in the price of cattle.
I said a few weeks ago that the markets are very tricky things. The effect of the drought is practically to close the markets for cattle in England. A very prominent cattle trader told me quite recently that the effect of the drought was worse than the economic war. In the first place, owing to the drought here it was impossible to put the cattle into proper condition; the drought in England closed the markets there and left us no means of providing an opening for our cattle, whether saleable or not. I feel that Deputy Moore can hardly sustain his argument that the farmers have not suffered under the economic war. If the Government have any doubt as to the position of farmers under the economic war, then they can do what was done in the case of the Banking Commission and set up a commission to inquire into the farmer's present position and into what has been his position in the past six years. If you do that I venture to say that overwhelming evidence will be afforded as to what happened the farmer. Are you willing to set up that commission to inquire into what his position is to-day, and what is the best form of relief to give him? If that is done, I venture to say you will have an unanswerable demand for derating.
Comment on this
I am afraid it would be fairly long. Much weightier evidence would be given there than the evidence given before the Banking Commission.
Comment on this
Deputies must address the Chair. This conversation between Deputies cannot be allowed.
Comment on this
Well, I was only trying to show how such a commission would help towards reviving the prosperity of the agricultural community. Something would be forthcoming from it which would recoup the farmers for what they have suffered in the past six years. We have not as yet heard or seen the Report of the Banking Commission, but I understand it is of tremendous importance. At any rate, I urge on the Minister to consider the setting up of a commission to inquire into the farmers' position. I think it is most desirable to ascertain what really the farmers have suffered in the last six years. Personally I know something about it. I know that their position is one of dire need at present, and I know the utter inability of the farmers to bear the taxation levied by the Minister under this Budget. The agricultural community are particularly unable to bear that burden. I am in agreement with Deputy Corry in what he has stated as to relief of rates on roads. It would not be going very much further than what he has suggested in relieving the farmers of their annuities. In 1932 every Deputy on the front Government Bench as well as on the back benches advocated derating.
I am quite free to say that the Agreement with England is as good a bargain as possibly could have been got out of a powerful country. I am glad it has been made, but the first debt to be paid by the Government is due to the men in the front line trenches. Restitution is due to them for what they have gone through. The Prime Minister promised that as long as grass would grow and water would run, or as long as the annuities would have to be paid, the farmers would only have to pay half these annuities. I submit that that would be all right in relieving agricultural depression if the farmers had not suffered all they have suffered in the last six years, but Deputies must remember that since 1929 and 1930, when derating was promised by the members of the present Government, the farmers had not lost £26,000,000. That being the case, it is absolutely unthinkable that they would not now get something more than what they are getting through the having of the annuities. The farmers have an unanswerable case for derating.
The operations of the economic war fell on a certain class of farmers, those who raised live stock for export. There was many a man it did not fall on. It did not fall on the broken farmer who had no stock. It fell on a class of farmers that Deputies on the opposite benches claimed should not get any relief at all. Some of those men owe very large sums in rates. Deputy Corry is well aware who those people are, and surely to goodness it will not be denied that these men are entitled to relief.
Comment on this
The economic war did not mend their ills. If they were poor before, I do not know how you could describe it comparatively, but they are certainly damn poor to-day. You have taken over the forts, and they are a very desirable thing to have from a sentimental point of view, I suppose. I know a certain colleague of mine who in his constituency declared that he would be holding a dance over there.
Comment on this
I will not be there, anyway. I do not play the fiddle, and I certainly will not go near the place where Deputy Corry is. All I will say is this, that you have taken on a white elephant that is far greater than what the Minister for Finance described one time as a white elephant, the Carlow sugar factory. We will endeavour to provide for the keeping up of the various other white elephants, the other sugar factories, because it is not our policy to knock down anything that has been built up. I say this, that you are going to wreek the whole country if you do not provide for those men who have lost everything through the activities of the economic war; that is, the agricultural community. As a last word, I would ask the Minister to set up a commission which will inquire into the whole position of the agricultural community during the past five or six years.
Comment on this
I think Deputies will agree that there must be a considerable disadvantage in discussing the Budget of this year, because of the refusal of the Minister for Finance to circulate the Report of the Banking Commission.
Comment on this
I must protest against that statement. I have not refused to circulate the Report of the Banking Commission. I have already explained to the House that the Report is a voluminous document, that it is still in the hands of the printers, and I have not read it myself yet. If Deputy Davin were here oftener he would have heard that, too.
Comment on this
I was going to deal with that rather alarming admission on the part of the Minister. I am aware, and the Minister cannot deny it, that before the negotiations with the British Government were concluded, he had this voluminous document in his possession and, if he were doing his duty on behalf of the people of the country, he had that document with him before he went to London and when he was in London, and——
Comment on this
The Minister also made an alarming admission that, because the document was a voluminous and lengthy one, he had not time to read it. I ask the Minister's constituents, and the people of the State, to say what they think of a Minister for Finance who had the Banking Commission's Report in his possession, and he refused to read it at a time when he was authorised by the people to discuss the Ultimate Financial Settlement.
Comment on this
That is just like Deputy Davin, but when I answer him, I will answer him adequately.
Comment on this
I think that matter would arise more properly on the Vote for the Minister's Department, as to whether he was guilty of any dereliction of duty in connection with the affairs of his Department.
Comment on this
I submit that my complaint is a fair one. It is that Deputies in this House have not been supplied with the Banking Commission's Report, although the Minister has admitted he has the Report in his possession, but has not had time to read it.
Comment on this
I have said that it is in the hands of the printers. Does the Deputy want me to go down there and read it?
Comment on this
Is it not always the custom? Let the Deputy remember for once not to be nonsensical in the House.
Comment on this
If the Minister had had time to read the Report, the Deputy would probably find something else to charge him with.
Comment on this
I do not think I should be interrupted by the unpaid Parliamentary Secretary to the Admiral of Berehaven.
Comment on this
I am surprised, as a Deputy of this House with 16 years' experience, to learn that any report, and particularly such an important report as the Report of the Banking Commission, would be sent to the printers before it was read by the Minister and considered by the Cabinet. It is a most alarming admission on the part of the Minister for Finance, and I ask fairminded Deputies to think what they may about it, and if they are afraid to say it publicly from these benches, let them tell the Minister what they think about him at a Party meeting. I heard the Minister for Finance, and rightly so, when he was in opposition, criticise the Government of the day for having made a secret settlement with Great Britain without having gone into the whole financial history of the State. The Banking Commission's Report deals with the past history of this State and the present financial position of the State, and we have this jack-in-the-box Minister for Finance, who now tells us that it is with the printers although he has not read it, and we cannot be supplied with copies of it.
Comment on this
On a point of order. We are not discussing the Report of the Banking Commission, and I think Deputy Davin has been out of order for the last five minutes. I submit that to the Chair now.
Comment on this
The Minister is submitting a point of order. I am not quite sure if it is really a point of order. It may be more a point of relevancy. I think the Minister did say, in reply to Deputy Dillon, that the Banking Commission's Report was not in his hands, that it was with the printers, and Deputy Davin is commenting on that statement.
Comment on this
I submit to you that the conduct of the Minister in regard to the administration of the Department and the circulation or publication of this Report is entirely a matter for consideration when it arises, as you ruled from the Chair, on the Minister's Department.
Comment on this
May I make a statement? This Budget makes provision for the payment of everything that is required for the carrying on of State services, including provision for the payment of the Minister's increased salary. I submit I am entitled to comment on this matter.
Comment on this
The Deputy has commented on the fact that the Banking Commission's Report is not in the hands of Deputies. He has made several remarks with reference to it. I think the Minister's position with reference to giving that Report to the members of the House is really a matter that could better be discussed when considering the administration of his Department. The Deputy has the various methods he knows of in order to get the opinion of the House as to the Minister's duty in that connection, on the Estimate.
Comment on this
The only thing I said, and I said it quite deliberately, was that I feel I am at a disadvantage in discussing this Budget in the absence of that document.
Comment on this
The Deputy said this: "because of the Minister's refusal to publish that Report." The Report could not be published unless it had been printed.
Comment on this
I am very glad that remark provoked the Minister into saying other things which I was surprised to hear him say.
Comment on this
Yes. I am keenly disappointed at the contents of the Budget and I think the people are deeply disappointed, because they were undoubtedly expecting that, as a result of the settlement with the British Government, the moneys saved thereby would be made available for the relief of those who suffered most during the economic war period. Nobody is more pleased or delighted that the nightmare of the economic war has passed and gone for ever than the members of this Party, because— and I say it as one of the people on these benches who made it possible, much more so than other people here, to get whatever has been got out of this settlement—no one realises more than we do, the sufferings which a good deal of our supporters have borne during that period — much greater sufferings than the supporters of other Parties. I hope, during the lifetime of every one of us, that we will not have another civil war, an economic war, or an international war. I would prefer an economic war, bad as it is, to a civil war. An economic war, bad as it would be, would be better than a second civil war, and if we had to go through the economic war for the purpose of avoiding a second civil war, it was all to the good, and the people will benefit by it. I am glad the economic war has disappeared. That period was taken advantage of by this Government, in a way, to make excuses, plausible excuses, for not carrying out any of the promises they made with regard to the solution of our internal problems. The republic has been blown sky-high, as Deputy McGowan said.
Comment on this
And may the Lord have mercy on the people who did lay down their lives. I say that with respect, with the greatest respect, and it is not a matter to provoke a discussion upon. I should like to know what these people would say about the recent settlement, or whether they would think that it was for that they suffered and died.
Comment on this
The recent settlement, as the Minister for Finance admitted, made, or will make in the future, certain moneys available for the relief of taxation or for the provision of increased social services, but there is very little money that I can see in this Budget being made available for the relief of taxation. I read a document, which was issued last week and published and printed in the daily papers, asking for subscriptions from those who desire to subscribe towards the continuance of the Fianna Fáil Party so as to enable them to pursue their policy. One of the four points mentioned in that document was the giving of the necessary money to pursue their policy for the abolition of Partition. I want to know—and this is the occasion, I believe, when I am entitled to ask for the information, and I hope that I will be told, especially by a Minister for Finance who is a native of the City of Belfast—I want to know what is the Fianna Fáil policy for the abolition of Partition?
Comment on this
I suggest that it does. I suggest that all questions of policy can be properly discussed in connection with a Budget statement. It is a good job that the Minister is not in the Chair, as I am sure he would rule out everybody who did not agree with him.
Comment on this
Probably Deputy Davin will not be satisfied with the Deputy who is in the Chair when I indicate that it is only the financial policy of the Government that arises in the Budget.
Comment on this
I understood—and, in fact, it is my recollection that I was allowed to do so on previous occasions —that I was entitled to raise matters affecting public policy in connection with the Budget.
Comment on this
However, the abolition of Partition has a bearing on the financial policy of the Government. Is Partition going to be abolished by a stroke of the pen or by a wave of the Minister's magic wand, or is it going to be abolished by some kind of economic pressure, or by the increased army and defence forces that we are being called upon to provide for in this Budget? I would like to see it abolished by methods of peaceful persuasion, if it could be done, but I hope that the Minister, who is a native of the City of Belfast, and who, more than anybody else, I am sure, would like to have all Ireland under his wing as Minister for Finance, will say something on this important subject when he is replying and tell the members of all Parties in the House what is the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party for the abolition of Partition. We are all in favour of abolishing it, and we would like to know the means by which the Government is going to carry out that desirable object, and as soon as we learn that from the Minister for Finance we can then say, "Go ahead with the project and you will have our support." But we want to know what the policy is. The Minister for Finance is the Minister for Finance for Ireland. But he has not jurisdiction over the part of Ireland where he was born and reared, and we should like to know how he is going to get that jurisdiction.
Now, the recent settlement which everybody in this House, with one exception, gladly welcomed and voted for, as I say, cuts out of the political life of this country the one contentious issue upon which all young Republicans, so-called, and others, were able to hang their hats and wink at many of the other major internal problems which had been waiting for solution for a long period—since long before the present Government came into office. This question now confronts the Cabinet: Are they going to give serious consideration to the major issue before the people of this country as to what they propose to do in order to provide continuous work at decent Christian rates of wages for the 100,000 people who are waiting for work and willing to do it if they could get it? While they have been waiting for what they were promised six years ago, we of this Party think that they should be provided with maintenance, during the period of waiting for the promised work, at a rate that would enable these people to keep themselves and their families in decent comfort. The Minister for Finance, who, more than any member of the Government, claims to be a good, Christian Minister, says that they stand for a Christian social policy, the Christian social policy which was contained in the Pope's Encyclicals and which, I am sure, was well understood by the Minister. Six years ago we were told that they had a plan. Are they now ready to put that plan into operation, after waiting for a period of six years, to provide work for every able-bodied citizen of this State?
Comment on this
Well, that is one way of doing it, but that is a voluntary effort on the part of the people themselves, who have decided to go out of the country to seek for a livelihood rather than wait for a longer period than they have waited, in order to be provided with work in this country. If the Government have a plan, let them put it into operation, and every Party in this House, I am sure, will be willing to support the Government in a policy that will enable them to put that plan into operation as quickly as possible. Does the Minister, or do his colleagues, suggest that the present scale of unemployment assistance is sufficient to maintain the workless and their dependents in decency and comfort? In many cases, the rate is much below the miserable poverty rate which was previously given by the boards of health in relief. We contend that the time has arrived when that scale will have to be increased to a Christian standard to enable the unfortunate workless people to live decently while they are waiting for work. We have, of course, the plan provided by the Minister for Unemployment, as I think he was properly baptised from these benches some years ago—a plan for providing casual work under this objectionable rotational relief scheme, at the scab and black-leg rate of 24/- a week. I am referring, of course, to the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister. He said that the maximum number of people provided with work under that scheme last year at one period reached 36,000. Might I ask the Minister, who works in close collaboration with his Parliamentary Secretary, for how many weeks were these 36,000 people provided with work out of the 52 weeks in the year, and what was the average amount paid?
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir. There is a debate, which is adjourned for the moment, going on in connection with the Estimate of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, and these questions should be put, if Deputy Davin is in the House to put them, on that debate.
Comment on this
I have allowed Deputy Davin to discuss unemployment in so far as it impinges on taxation and expenditure. The question of the administration of the Department of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance would arise more relevantly on the Vote, the discussion of which is at present adjourned; but so far as unemployment and rates of benefit impinge on expenditure and taxation, I have allowed Deputy Davin to proceed.
Comment on this
That is what I was discussing, Sir, and I claim that I have a perfect right to object to the Government policy which propose in this Budget to provide the sum of £600,000 for the modernisation of our so-called forts and is providing that sum in a year when, as has been admitted, these forts will not be handed over to this Government until near the end of the year. There is sum of £600,000 being made available in this Budget for the modernisation of our forts by a Minister who knows perfectly well that this State has no battleships or seaplanes to protect those forts when they are modernised. In my opinion that sum of money should be devoted to other purposes, if possible to provide a scheme of work for our workless and their dependents. We are asked in a Financial Resolution associated with this Budget to agree to increase the price of butter in the home market to our people. The object of that is to raise a sum of £350,000 for revenue purposes. That sum of money is being raised at the expense of the butter consumers of this country to help defray the cost of modernising our ports which, when modernised, will not have supporting battleships or seaplanes to protect them.
Comment on this
The Deputy is entirely under a misapprehension. There is nothing in this Budget about raising the price of butter.
Comment on this
The Budget and the Financial Resolutions associated with it empower the Minister to increase the price of butter in the home market to our consumers by 2d. per lb.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that the amount provided in the Budget for export bounties and subsidies is £800,000.
Comment on this
I think that the Minister and Deputy O'Leary should retire to the Lobby and carry on their conversation there. I submit to the Chair that the Minister's point was a point of disorder. Next in importance to the question of unemployment is this: What policy are the Government going to adopt during the current year for the purpose of bringing down the cost of living? From the latest figures available we find that in 1936, as compared with 1931, the consumption of bread has gone down by 18,000,000 2-lb. loaves. The Minister tells us that there is more money than ever in circulation amongst the poorer classes of the community, but if that be so, why has there been that huge fall in the consumption of bread between 1931 and 1936? We also learn from the figures available that the consumption of Irish bacon in the home market in 1936 was a quarter less than it was in 1931. Then we have the increase in the price of butter. During the period of the economic was I saw the evidence myself of Irish citizens having the doubtful pleasure of paying a higher price for Irish butter at home than the British consumer had to pay for the same butter in Liverpool, London, Galsgow and other English cities. I hope that that part of the Government policy will disappear during the course of the present year, and that, if we have a surplus of butter to export, it will not be sold cheaper under any system that the Government may frame outside the country than inside.
Comment on this
The Minister is in very bad humour, but so long as I keep within the rules of order he will have to listen to me. I would appeal to his good sense not to be trying to take over the duties of the Chair. His important work connected with the Department of Finance and the fact that he has to carry such a heavy load on his back as the Parliamentary Secretary should be sufficient for him.
Comment on this
I was assuming that this £600,000 for the modernisation of the forts would also make provision for such positions as admirals of the battleships and seaplanes that will be necessary to support them.
Comment on this
The Minister cannot deny that there is this £600,000 to improve the defence forces and to modernise the forts. If the forts are to be modernised, then I take it it will be necessary to have commanders and admirals for the battleships that will be necessary to protect them. Otherwise, I cannot see any justification for modernising them. On this matter at any rate, I am in full agreement with my colleague, Deputy O'Higgins. Behind this whole scheme recently agreed to with our very good neighbours on the other side there appears to be something that has not been let out fully. Will the Minister say why this £600,000 is to to be spent inside three months of the financial year? Deputy O'Higgins correctly pointed out that the forts cannot be taken over until the end of the present calender year. That being so, only three months are left for the expenditure of this sum of money.
Comment on this
Surely to goodness you cannot proceed with the work of modernising the forts before you take them over. Is that not so?
Comment on this
The Deputy would not vote against it. Even the Minister's disorderly remarks would not provoke him into voting against the Agreement. The country and the House are entitled to know why this £600,000 is to be spent inside three months of the financial year. The House is entitled to get more information than has been given to it. For instance, is the personnel of the Army and the Air Force going to be increased considerably? I would like to hear something from the Minister for Finance on that, because it is freely rumoured in political circles that there is to be a considerable increase in the Air Force. If there is any understanding not contained in the Agreement to increase the Air Force and to modernise the forts at Berehaven, Lough Swilly and elsewhere, then this House and the country are entitled to be told about it.
Comment on this
I submit to the Chair that all this has nothing to do with the Financial Resolutions before the House. The defence policy of the Government will arise on the Vote for the Minister for Defence.
Comment on this
I think that Deputy Davin is quite in order in making reference to the proposed expenditure on defence, which will have to be raised out of public taxation. I think he is quite entitled to do that.
Comment on this
I submit that you have ruled that, on the Budget, only financial policy should be discussed. This matter relate to defence policy which would arise in due course on the Estimate for Defence.
Comment on this
This is a question of financial policy. It concerns the raising of money for the purpose of defence.
Comment on this
The Minister will say that it is only a question of £600,000 and that it does not matter. If the Minister would allocate that £600,000 for the purpose of increasing the miserable scale of unemployment assistance for those who cannot get work as a result of the Minister's failure to carry out his plans, it would make the homes of these unfortunate workers happier than they are to-day. But as it is only a matter of £600,000, it does not matter. So say Mr. Chamberlain and the Minister for Finance. Is this part of a proposed scheme of Imperial defence? If it is, the House and the country are entitled to know, and they are also entitled to know if it is part of the understanding arrived at in the recent negotiations carried on by the Minister for Finance and others with representatives of the British Government. I am, I submit, entitled to criticise this provision of £600,000 for modernisation of the forts. We have not, however, the full story of the future defence policy of this Government. If I had the power, I would vote this £600,00 out of the Budget and set it aside for a more useful purpose—to provide useful employment for the workless and to increase the unemployment assitance payments. Will the Minister say that that is disorderly? I am not concerned as to whether the Minister thinks it is pertinent to the Budget or not. It is pertinent to the people to have to find the £600,000. The plain people would much prefer—and I believe Deputies on the other side would also prefer—to find £600,000 to provide work or maintenance for the workless to modernising these forts in pursuance of any private understanding between representatives of this Government and representatives of the British Government.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin always judges other people by his own standards, and they are not high.
Comment on this
£600,000 is not a large amount, in the opinion of the Minister for Finance. I am sure it is a satisfaction to him to know that none of the people living in the Six Counties will have to pay any part of it this year. We should like to know that they will have to find moeny for these defence schemes in future years. We should like to know that they will share with us the expense of providing for defence of the whole of the country in future years. I contend that money should be made available by the Government for the relief of the people who suffered most during the economic war. I say without hesitation—I am sorry to have to say it, and I invite Deputy Corry or any other Deputy on the opposite benches to contradict it—that many of the farmers in my constituency who suffered in silence during the economic war lost all their savings. Is there any way by which these people can restock their lands or provide themselves with up-to-date machinery to work their lands in the future unless they are provided with cheap money either by way of long term loans at a low rate of interest or in some way other than that by which money is lent by the Agricultural Credit Corporation at a high rate of interest. We of the Labour Party want to see the farmers prosper. Apart from politics altogether, I often wish the farmers had the good sense to organise, and that the Labour Party, including the agricultural labourers, were equally well organised. As the son of a farmer I should be glad to see the Labour Party, well organised, joining with the farmers, well organised, for the purpose of improving the economic position of the farming community.
Comment on this
This country cannot be prosperous so long as you have a poverty-stricken community. Everybody associated with me is interested in farming, and I could not help knowing what they went through during the economic war. There are few farmers in my constituency whose savings during that period were not wiped out or almost wiped out. If this Government want the farms worked to the fullest advantage, so that they may give employment at a decent rate of wages, they must provide the farmers with cheap money from some source. That is the Government's job, because the Government cannot shirk responsibility for having depleted the resources of the farmers during the past six years. International matters may have helped to make the farmers poorer than they were, but the economic war was chiefly responsible for almost wiping out the savings of the farmers.
We have supported this Government through thick and thin in carrying out their policy of guaranteed markets and guaranteed prices for the farming community. I think I am speaking for my Party when I say that it is not worth while giving a subsidy to any industry unless you give a subsidy to the farmer which will enable him to get a remunerative price for what he has to sell. What is the use of granting a subsidy to the Industrial Alcohol Board for the production of industrial alcohol to be sold at a commercial price when that board will pay the farmers only £2 per ton for their potatoes? We want to see the farmers paid a remunerative price for their potatoes. The Minister for Education is present. I attended a meeting in Jury's Hotel at which the Minister for Education and some of his colleagues were present to deal with the price of beet at that time. The Minister was then on the Opposition Benches. The Minister is evidently going to take part in this discussion and I ask him what part he played at that meeting, what demand was made by the beet growers as the price for their beet and if he supported that demand. Why is the Minister standing to-day, as apparently he is, with his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, in insisting on an uneconomic price for beet?
Comment on this
The matters to be discussed on the Budget Resolutions are taxation, expenditure and financial policy. If the Deputy wants a guiding line, matters which may be debated on an Estimate should not be debated on the Budget Resolutions.
Comment on this
I submit to your ruling, but I do not think this is a case for discussion on an Estimate so much as for discussion on the Budget as it is a question of financial policy which can only be fully surveyed under cover of a general resolution of this kind. I am attacking the Government for their failure to provide a remunerative price to the farmers for agricultural produce and I would not be allowed to make the kind of speech I am making on an Estimate, which deals only with administration.
Comment on this
I am not discussing it. I am discussing general policy. If I were discussing the question of an economic price for beet on the Estimate for the office of the Minister for Finance, he would jump up more quickly and twice as often as he has been doing on this Resolution.
Comment on this
I should be prevented from doing that on these Estimate as well, although the Minister for Finance is in the habit of jumping up more often than his colleagues on matters of this kind. Would the Minister for Education tell us the price demanded by beet growers on that occasion? There was an agitation for an increase in the price of beet and the Minister for Education was one of the Deputies present. No matter from what side of the House the demand comes for payment of a remunerative price for beet, I shall support it, and the same will apply to any other article the farmer produces, because it is only when the farmers get remunerative prices that we shall be justified in asking them to treat their agricultural labourers in a decent, Christian way.
Comment on this
We have had complaints about the failure of the Government to deal with the increasing cost of living, with particular reference to the increasing cost of bread. I have stated that there has been a considerable reduction in the consumption of bread, presumably, amongst the poorer sections of the people. That must be due to the fact that the people are unable to buy bread to the extent to which they would like to buy it. They have not got the money to do so. I should like to hear whether the Prices Commission, for which provision is made in this Budget, intend to do anything in that direction this year. We are aware that at the request of the British Government, the Prices Commission will now have to give priority to the consideration of any proposal put before them by the British Governemnt arising out of the recent settlement.
Comment on this
I want to know whether the Prices Commission will have any time at their disposal, within the next five or six months or within the current year, to give any consideration to the general complaint about the excessive prices charged for bread and flour.
Comment on this
That is definitely a matter of administration which the Deputy may raise on the appropriate Estimate.
Comment on this
Provision is made in this Budget for the payment of the salaries of the members of the Prices Commission.
Comment on this
Am I allowed to advocate the establishment of a marketing organisation for the sale of our surplus produce in a foreign market under this general resolution? The recent Agreement, I am glad to note, professes to provide an improved market for our agricultural produce—for the sale of our butter, bacon, eggs and other agricultural produce in increasing quantities in the only market which, it is now admitted, we have outside this country. I contend, and I do so with some knowledge and experience, that the farmers of this country are not going to get this increased market to-morrow, or in the near future, unless they are prepared, and the Government helps them, to organise the sale of their surplus produce in the British market in a better way than is the case to-day. We have been beaten out of the British market by the methods adopted by better organised countries. Before the economic war the total quantity of our butter sold in the British market represented something like 9 per cent. of our butter production. I presume the figures have been decreased, and I suggest, with some knowledge of trading conditions and the experience I have had on a certain advisory body for a number of years, that the farmers of this country need not hope for the sale of their surplus produce in increased quantities, unless they are able to market it in an organised way.
Comment on this
There is no provision in existing circumstances for an organised marketing scheme. I am suggesting that it should be a matter for consideration, that it would be good policy, and I say that my words will be proved true in a year or two——
Comment on this
The Vote for the Department of Agriculture has yet to be discussed. There is an amendment down to refer the Vote back. This matter could arise then, but it certainly does not arise now.
Comment on this
I have some knowledge as to the reasons why the motion to refer back that Estimate is to be moved, but I am not going to refer to them now, because the Minister would object and say that I was out of order, and he would be right in saying so. The Minister is determined not to let me say anything if he can help it, but if I am talking rot why does the Minister not let me go on and make an ass of myself? The Minister has interrupted me at least a dozen times since I stood up, but I have not deliberately tried to avoid the rules of order and procedure. I rose to make my own speech in my own way and with a knowledge of the procedure previously adopted on this matter. I would not dream, under any circumstances, of disrespecting any order which you, Sir, or the Leas-Cheann Comhairle would ask me to obey, but the Minister has deliberately attempted to prevent me making my own speech in my own way.
Comment on this
The Minister should understand these things. You do not. You only understand the rules and procedure of the Dublin Corporation. As you grow a little older in a knowledge of the rules of this House, you will realise that this is fair game.
Comment on this
But there is a very high standard in the corporation, which is absent here.
Comment on this
The standard was so high on one occasion that the Minister abolished the corporation at a stroke of the pen and Deputy Kelly, I believe, was included in the number counted out.
Comment on this
He did not restore the corporation with its old powers, anyway. They have power to talk now, but not to decide very much. I suggest that it would be a matter of good policy for a Government that wants to improve the sale of our produce in the British market and that expresses its desire to get an increase in the amount of produce sold there, to decide to establish a marketing organisation. As you are aware, Sir, there is no provision in existing circumstances for the carrying on of an organised marketing scheme for the sale of butter, bacon, eggs or other items of agricultural produce.
Comment on this
I also desire to support, with certain qualifications, the repeated demand from all parts of the House over many years that the farmers should get some assistance by way of the derating of agrucultural land. This Party has argued for many years that it is good policy on the part of the Government to take over the complete control and cost of maintenance of the main and trunk roads of the country, and also the mental hospitals. I was delighted to hear Deputy Corry on the Government Benches supporting that demand here to-night, and I hope that the Government, before the end of the current financial year, will take its courage in its hands and take over complete control of the main trunk and coastal roads and their maintenance, and thereby relieve the farmers to some extent of the unfair burden they have to bear at present.
The main and trunk roads of the country are used mainly by the owners of motor cars, ‘buses and lorries, and these are the people who should pay the whole of the cost of their maintenance. The standard of maintenance under the present system is quite different in one country as compared with another, and any Deputy who travels from Dublin to Cork by road can plainly see that difference. If the Government will take over control of these main trunk roads and put the cost of their maintenance upon the taxpayers instead of upon the ratepayers, it will have the satisfaction of having a uniform standard of maintenance all over the State instead of having different standards in different counties, as is the position to-day.
Comment on this
I will look after the railways in the proper time. It would be out of order to refer to them now, but I am prepared to discuss the railways here or anywhere else with the Deputy, and I am sure he will be able to make some very interesting suggestions for their preservation. I am sure that I will get support of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance in requesting the Government to give careful consideration to the proposal to provide further moneys for the construction of coastal roads.
We hear a good deal from time to time from representatives of the Government, especially from the Minister for Industry and Commerce whenever he speaks at the annual dinner of the Tourist Association, about what the Government will do, what the Government are prepared to do, to develop the tourist industry in this country. It is an industry which provides unseen assets for many sections of the people. If we are going to develop the tourist industry in this country, as it is being developed in other competing countries, money must be made available for the construction of our coastal roads, so as to provide better natural scenery than is being provided in any other country to which tourists may go from time to time. I am sure Deputy Corry will agree that that money cannot be provided at the expense of the ratepayers of the counties concerned. I am sure he would not like to say to the ratepayers of the County Cork that they should provide all the money required for the making of the coastal roads which undoubtedly would be provided if the money was available. Some people in Clare and Galway——
Comment on this
I listened with great interest to the Deputy, and I am sure he would not stand up here and say he is opposed to that policy—the policy of providing a sum of money for the construction and improvement of our coastal roads.
Comment on this
It is a practical proposal, and I hope it will get careful consideration from the Ministers who have made those plausible promises from time to time during the last few years when attending functions of the Tourist Development Association. Of course Deputy Corry does not do much damage to the road from Cork to Dublin. I believe he travels mostly by rail.
Comment on this
I have reason to know— and the Minister for Lands and Forestry admitted here on the discussion on his own Estimate—that there has been a scheme for the reclamation of our bog lands under consideration for a lengthy period.
Comment on this
I am pressing the Government to provide the necessary money in this Budget for the carrying out of that scheme.
Comment on this
Matter which may be discussed on Estimates should not be raised now. The Deputy has admitted that the particular matter he now wishes to deal with has already been dealt with on the Vote. It is not relevant.
Comment on this
On an Estimate, I cannot make a submission to increase the amount of the Estimate, as you know, Sir. Nobody except a Minister can move a resolution to increase the expenditure.
Comment on this
A Deputy may, however, advocate certain improvements, and as a matter of fact such improvements were advocated on the Vote.
Comment on this
I have been a very attentive listener to the Budget discussions, and I understood that under the procedure of this House no Deputy would be allowed to move for an increase of expenditure except on a general Budget resolution.
Comment on this
I am submitting that I am entitled to advocate it now. I know I am not entitled to do so on the Estimate.
Comment on this
I say, Sir, that I am entitled to encourage the Government to provide the necessary large sum—I admit it is a large sum——
Comment on this
The Deputy surely does not maintain that the whole House is entitled to go over every Estimate, suggesting on the Budget all the improvements they desire to make in the various Departments, and advocating that money be provided for them? It would entail going through the whole Estimates again.
Comment on this
If the Deputy does it in regard to one or two Estimates, other Deputies would have equal rights, and the whole field of the Estimates would be covered—an impossible position.
Comment on this
I am submitting that for the £600,000 which it is proposed to spend on the modernisation of our ports this other more valuable work could be done. I think I am entitled to make that submission. I am indicating how I would spend that money on other and more useful work than the modernisation of ports which have no battleships or admirals to defend them. There is also, Sir, as far as I can see, no provision in the Budget of this year, nor in the Estimates, for correcting a very serious omission on the part of this Government in connection with the workers employed upon public works schemes. We complained here on many occasions, and so did Fianna Fáil Deputies and every other Deputy in turn, about the refusal of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance in particular, and the heads of other Departments, to stamp the unemployment insurance cards of men employed on those public works schemes.
Comment on this
I would again remind the Deputy and the House that on the Budget debate they may discuss taxation, expenditure and financial policy, but not the details of any Estimate. Matters which were discussed on Estimates should not be reopened now. Matters which may be discussed on forthcoming Estimates should not be anticipated now. So far, the Deputy has mentioned three or four matters which have been discussed or which would be perfectly relevant on Estimates not yet reached.
Comment on this
There is no money in the Estimate for this particular service. May I have an assurance from you now, Sir, that I will be allowed to discuss this matter on the Estimate?
Comment on this
On a point of order: the Deputy has made a statement which is not correct. The Deputy can ascertain whether or not money has been provided for the stamping of cards on the Vote which is at present being discussed.
Comment on this
I am not paying very much attention to what the Minister is saying. Are you ruling, Sir, that I cannot refer to this matter any further?
Comment on this
May I have an assurance that I will be allowed to discuss this matter on the Estimate?
Comment on this
The Chair gives no hypothetical assurances. When the Estimate comes up, the Deputy may debate what is relevant.
Comment on this
Therefore, I am probably going to get it in the neck both ways. This Party, Sir, has constantly advocated the policy of State control of our big industries. On several occasions of this kind in the past we have given every encouragement that we possibly could to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to take over control of such industries as the flour-milling industry and the transport industry. In this Budget discussion the other day the Minister had the nerve to get up and say that the number of persons employed in the transport industry had been increased.
I wonder, if he speaks again upon any Budget Resolution or on the further stages of the Finance Bill, will he give us detailed particulars to justify that statement. I know, Sir—I have reason to know—the number of thousands of men who have been dismissed from the railways section of the transport industry for reasons which it is not necessary for me to go into on this debate; they are thoroughly understood by every Deputy in this House. I should like to have from the Minister for Industry and Commerce detailed figures to justify that statement.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce—and nobody knows it better than the Minister for Finance— can have another "go" on the Finance Bill, which will be the method of implementing the Budget Resolutions now under discussion.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance knows well that we are not entitled to discuss policy on an Estimate. I should like to hear from the Minister for Finance, but I suppose he will not tell us, whether he and his colleagues have any policy that will save the transport industry from destruction. Those of us who know the transport industry better than the Minister for Industry and Commerce realise that it is in a disorganised state, a state of chaos. I hope the Minister, or somebody replying for him in this discussin, will say what the Government policy is in regard to the proposal for State control of industries such as the flour milling and transport industries.