Committee on Finance. - Vote 57—Industry and Commerce.
Contributions 198–430 of 430. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
We could not get it cheaper, quality for quality, than it is now available for farmers. It is quite true that a very cheap type was sometimes in the past imported from Belgium, where it was a by-product of the metallurgical industry, and therefore the product was poor. I know that when it was open to farmers to get these artificial manures from Belgium and other places, 80 per cent. of the manure used was Irish manufacture. They used it in preference, because of its higher quality, even though it cost them more.
Comment on this
I want to ask that proposals relating to agriculture should, at least, be considered in relation to unemployment, in the solution of which problem industrial development must play a vital part. I do not propose to deal with that at any undue length, but I have frequently contended that any substantial improvement in agricultural conditions, any big increase in agricultural production, or substantial rise in agricultural prices would not, of itself, directly increase in the same proportion, the number of persons employed in agriculture. Deputies who study the statistics of agricultural production not only in Ireland but in Denmark know that a substantial increase in total production is possible. The only direct effect upon employment of improved agricultural conditions and increased output and prices is to make those engaged in agriculture better contented with their position, by raising their economic status, raising purchasing power, and keeping them in employment that they might be otherwise induced to leave to seek their fortunes elsewhere. If we are to keep people at home, if we are to improve agricultural production, and check emigration, we may do so temporarily by various schemes of public works, but in the long run only by increased industrial production. Increased employment in productive industry will indirectly increase employment in other non-agricultural occupations, but the essential part of our plans much be to increase industrial activities.
That fact is sometimes not contested. It is quite true that Deputies opposite preface their remarks by indicating general goodwill for industries, except those started by Fianna Fáil. We know the story of the lady in Aberdeen who met a Scotchman and said she was half Scotch and he replied: "That does not prevent you from sinning but it does prevent you from enjoying it." That is the attitude of the Party opposite. Their antipathy to Fianna Fáil is such that, while claiming to support an industrial policy, they get no pleasure in the industrial successes that have been recorded. There have been successes. The fact that we have 51,000 more people employed in industrial occupations than there were before is an indication of what can be done.
Comment on this
Out of what employment? If the contention is that they were put out of other employment there must be some record of that. Out of what employment were they put? So far as our statistics show, they were not put out of employment in distribution, transport or in any of the non-productive occupations insurable under the Unemployment Acts. They were not put out of employment in agriculture, with which I will deal later, because I want to put Deputy Mulcahy right in respect of many matters to which he referred, and in respect of which he is liable to fall into serious error.
Comment on this
These people have been put into employment in the production of food and drink, in the production of other transportable goods, in building and in other services. I have a tabulated list of people engaged in these occupations.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister to relate that, together with the 61,000 of an increase indicated by the National Health Insurance Fund, to the total number of people engaged in building houses and the additional number engaged in relief schemes?
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy is trying to get at. The number of persons employed in industrial production, of the forms to which I referred, has increased between 1931 and 1937 by something over 50,000. That cannot be denied. These people are counted. The number of persons insured under the Unemployment Insurance Act has also increased. I can give the Deputy the exact figures if he wishes. I can give the number of cards issued and the number of contributions paid, showing that a substantial increase was recorded. The increase last year was not as substantial as the previous year. If we are to deal with unemployment, if we are to reduce the number of unemployed, if we are to create new work into which these persons can be put, we have to concentrate on an increase of industrial activities. That does not mean that we need diminish by one iota our efforts to expand agricultural production or to improve conditions in agriculture. We have to recognise, in the long run, that the solution of unemployment involves an increase in industrial production, and anything that tends to delay or to prevent industrial production is detrimental to the best national interests. We have been told that we can get better industrial plans by means of an economic council. I think that was the suggestion of Labour Deputies, while Deputy Mulcahy referred to a commission of experts, which would be charged with the task of picking out those industries that were wanted, the industries that should be preserved, while condemning industries which, in their opinion, should be scrapped.
Comment on this
In any event, I take it the idea of some of the members of the Labour Party was that there should be some expert committee or tribunal outside the Department of Industry and Commerce to examine the industrial sphere as a whole and arrive at a long-term plan.
Comment on this
That suggestion has been frequently made, not merely by members of Fine Gael and of the Labour Parties, but by members of the Government Party, and I always opposed it. I opposed it because I feel that its institution would delay progress, that all the time spent preparing elaborate plans would be lost, and that, in the end, we would be no wiser than before.
Comment on this
It is not a question of planning. It is a question of marking down these particular industries that we could say are as important to this country as agriculture is.
Comment on this
What the Deputy has said is meaningless. No committee of experts, no individuals in the world whom the Deputy could name, could possibly say that one industry is going to have an important future in the history of the country and that others are not going to count. No committee of experts you could have set up in the past would have said it was possible for us to develop here a firm like Jacobs, which brings in imported products, manufactures them into biscuits and then sends those biscuits throughout the world. Any expert committee would have ridiculed the idea of any such industry being set up here, and, if they had reported in favour of the establishment of such an industry, the Deputy Dillon of the day would have received it with a loud guffaw. There is no industry which cannot be established here, provided we get the technical knowledge, the business experience, and the financial resources to put it there. That is all that matters. Think of the most difficult industry that was ever established, the most intricate industry, that which involves the highest degree of technical skill. That industry can be established here, if we have the men to do it. The whole work of your committee, all the planning you can do, cannot substitute for the individuals, the men with the knowledge, the men with the competence, with the experience and with the drive that are necessary before any industrial enterprise can be created.
The problem of promoting industrial development and the problem of our agriculturists are entirely different. You can set up a commission to elaborate and prepare a general plan for agriculture. The agricultural industry consists of a very large number of small-scale producers who have a great deal in common, and it is possible to have a general plan in relation to them, even if it is only a plan for the combined marketing of their products; but industry is different altogether. It is essentially an individual affair. It does not matter who owns it, it does not matter whether it is State owned or privately owned, its success and development will depend on the existence of individuals with specialised knowledge, specialised experience, and with some advantage over others which enables them to build up an industry where others cannot succeed. Examine the industrial history of any country, and you will find that the big industrial developments that took place in England and Germany and Switzerland were not due to the possession by these countries of any exceptional raw material, any natural advantage which other countries had not got. They were due entirely to the development of a particular form of skill amongst the people, due to the efforts of individuals who had a particular idea, a particular invention, or a particular business conception which they put into operation.
In respect of the industries that were established here which put new names into the industrial vocabularies of the world—Balbriggan hosiery, Limerick hams, Limerick lace—there did not exist in Balbriggan, or in Limerick, or anywhere else, special advantages which made these towns more suitable as the centres of these industries than other towns. It was because there were associated with the development of these industries in these towns individuals of exceptional ability and of outstanding merit that they achieved the success which they finally secured and which made them renowned throughout the world. I say here that so long as you have a general atmosphere favourable to industrial development, so long as you have a governmental policy which is designed to assist and facilitate those who are prepared to embark on industrial enterprise here, you can do no more than endeavour to interest individuals in your industrial possibilities. We have succeeded in doing that. The success we have attained so far will, in fact, help us to a greater success in the future because the only real difficulty we had to overcome in initiating our industrial drive was the hesitancy of our own people, and of outsiders, in associating themselves with Irish industrial enterprise, which, in the past, had always been a source of financial loss.
It was always the idea that Irish industry was a hot-house plant, and that the first cold breath of air would kill it. There were no facilities for the investment of public money in industrial enterprise; there was no industrial tradition in any part of the country, and there was no experience of management and no experience of the adaptability, the suitability, of our people for industrial work. We have got over that. We have killed that hesitancy and we have created a means of contact between the investing public and the industrial organisers. We have shown the competence of our people to learn, to practise and to carry out, as skilfully as anyone else, the technical processes of modern industry, and, provided we can get a general atmosphere favourable to industrial development, I am satisfied that industrial development will go ahead. The one thing that will kill it is an atmosphere of hostility and, more particularly, an atmosphere of political controversy. If we can get the matter of industrial development taken out of the political arena, our progress will be more rapid. Up to the present, the fact that every new factory started was called a Fianna Fáil factory, and that one Party was able to take credit for it and that another appeared to oppose it, was the biggest hindrance we had to industrial progress. If we could end that, and get some agreement that industrial development is essential to our national well-being, if our national well-being is to be served, by a diminution, or an abolition, of our unemployment problem, if we can get rid of this highly critical atmosphere in relation to individual enterprises, I am satisfied that this time, the present year and the next year, subject to whatever may develop in the international situation, is as favourable as any in the history of Ireland for the promotion of industrial expansion.
I merely give these views as representing the attitude of the Government on these matters. It may be that events will prove that there are other difficulties that will have to be overcome and other objections that will have to be met, but I think the way is clear, provided we are prepared to follow it, to the creation here of sufficient employment to deal with our immediate unemployment problem. I would not say that we are going to create new employment capable of absorbing 100,000 or 105,000 people. I do not think we need do so. Apart from the fact that for every two additional persons employed in production, economists tell us, one additional person will be employed in distribution, or some other non-productive occupation, there is also the fact, to which I have referred, that the number of people on the live register does not represent accurately the volume of our unemployment.
Reference has been made here to the diminution in the number of persons employed in agriculture. It is correct that some of the available statistics appear to indicate a diminution in the number of persons recorded as employed in agriculture during recent years. Again, I ask, in all sincerity, in the national interest, that there should be no attempt to exaggerate that position. It is the easiest thing in the world to take the figure for 1938, and subtract it from the figure for 1934, and say that there are 42,000 fewer people employed in agriculture now than there were in 1934. The number of people employed in agriculture in 1934 was exceptionally high. If Deputy Mulcahy will take the years 1933, or 1935, he will get a much less impressive total.
Comment on this
I intend to deal with that. The figures which form the basis of the Deputy's calculation are those secured by Civic Guard enumerators who are asked to make a return in respect of each area of the number of persons employed in agriculture on 1st June. I ask Deputies to note the fact that the figures for each area refer to 1st June, and quite a number of considerations may influence that figure. A number of factors may operate to make the number higher or lower in one year than another. In fact, it is unsafe to base any conclusion concerning the average number of persons employed in agriculture throughout the year upon that figure at all, because, one year with another, there will be various factors which will operate to increase or decrease that figure. In the year between 1933 and 1934 the number of persons recorded as being employed in agriculture on the 1st June showed an increase of no less than 28,000. Now, I do not believe, and I am sure no Deputy opposite believes, that in 1934 there was in fact an increase of 28,000 persons employed in agriculture—the year in which the economic war had its worst effect upon our agricultural industry—and yet that increase was recorded. Since that, there have been decreases recorded, taking one year with another. We can, however, get a line upon that figure. We can secure some information concerning the average number of persons employed for wages in agriculture during the year—and, again, the figure that we can get is not an accurate figure, but is merely a figure secured by certain calculations made in relation to the number of National Health Insurance stamps sold, from which are deducted the number of unemployment insurance stamps sold.
As Deputies know, persons employed in industrial occupations, as defined under the Unemployment Insurance Act, are insured both under that Act and the National Health Insurance Act; but apart from these there are persons employed for wages in agriculture, as well as domestic servants, who are not insured under the Unemployment Insurance Act at all. As a consequence of an examination of the margin between these, you can get some idea of the fluctuations in employment in these occupations, agriculture and domestic servants, and the calculations based on the available figures would indicate that there was, on the average, a diminution of 3,000 in the number of persons employed in agriculture and domestic service last year. Again, however, that figure is not final, because it is impossible to segregate them into the two classes, but it is a more accurate indication of the trend of employment in agriculture than the figure given by Deputy Mulcahy.
Comment on this
Would the Minister relate the figures 43,000, which are from his own statistics, to the figures of 34,000 of the fall in population between 1934 and 1937? If he will ascertain whether that fall took place in town or rural districts, he may get a figure that will bear on the fall in agricultural employment.
Comment on this
The Deputy has got to take into account another factor than the distribution of that decline in population between urban and rural areas. I ask him to consider the fact that was brought to light in the most recent report published as a result of the Census of 1936—a fact to which I have already referred here—that despite the decrease in population recorded in 1936 as against 1926, there was an increase of 65,000 in the number of persons over 21 years of age, that is of employable age. The whole decrease in population occurred amongst children.
Comment on this
The subsequent diminution, to which the Deputy referred, may be capable of a similar explanation. I cannot say so, and neither can he.
Comment on this
If the Minister refers to the birth figures of the last four years, he will not find much to support him in that argument.
Comment on this
Nevertheless, the facts recorded by the census of 1936 are there. The total population, the details of which were given in the first report, are divided in that second report into ages, and they reveal that the number of persons of employable age increased substantially during the intercensal period, that the decline of population is attributable to a much greater decline in the number of persons under 18 years of age.
Comment on this
Of course not, but it shows that the Deputy should not rush to conclusions of another kind on the basis of these figures and assume that there has been a diminution in the numbers of employable age. However, my sole purpose here is to get the facts known. I have no desire whatever to conceal these facts. On the contrary, I believe that it is essential to get these facts made known to and widely appreciated by the public, because it is only when the public clearly understand the problem that is there, and the gravity and urgency of the problem, that they will be prepared to cooperate fully in whatever plan may be evolved to deal with it, and to bear cheerfully whatever burdens may be put on them in order to enable the resources to be provided that will permit of that plan being carried into effect. It is fruitless to be discussing here what is the meaning of particular statistics, or the accuracy of particular statistics. We always get into a dead end when we proceed on that line, because, no matter how carefully we may study the statistics themselves, and no matter what our previous convictions may be, or what conclusions we may want to arrive at, if we are honest with ourselves we will arrive at the same conclusions that the experts arrive at, and they are very tentative ones indeed; they merely purport to suggest that the figures seem to indicate that a certain development is taking place, without suggesting that there is any conclusive evidence to that effect.
However, there are one or two matters to which I want to refer particularly before a vote is taken on this Estimate. I may have left Deputies under the impression, when I referred to the national emergency wheat reserve in my opening remarks, that the 1/- per sack that is being charged on flour will be charged indefinitely, or that it is necessary to recover the cost of the storage, or that it is going to the millers. None of these things is correct. The reserve which is being built up, to date, is about 50,000 tons. I understand, however, that recently it has been further enlarged and that at the moment it might be put nearer to 60,000 tons. The cost of maintaining that reserve—that is, the interest on the capital invested in the wheat—the cost of storing and maintaining it— would be much more than recouped by a charge of 1/- per sack, spread over the whole year. It would not need even a half of the amount secured by such a charge to meet the costs involved.
Comment on this
Certainly. I say that the amount which would be secured by a levy of 1/- per sack, spread over the year, would produce a sum much more than double the amount required to finance the wheat storage scheme on the scale I have mentioned.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot be told what it is costing. The cost will depend on the amount stored, and that will depend on a number of factors. We are trying to ensure that when an emergency arises, no matter what time of year the emergency may occur, there will be a sufficient quantity of wheat within this country to ensure that, given due economy in its use, we would be able to carry over until the next season has occurred here in which we can increase the production of wheat at home. You will understand that the amount of wheat necessary for national safety varies from one season to another. For instance, at this season of the year, the margin of safety is probably at its lowest, whereas in the month of September the margin of safety would be at its highest; but we should have in this country a sufficient supply to ensure that we can see our way ahead—assuming that only minimum supplies can be brought in—to have a much larger acreage grown here and to have the harvest of that much larger acreage reaped.
Comment on this
No, but on the arrival of an emergency there will be a decreased supply and, with that decrease in supplies, there would be an increase in cost.
Comment on this
Quite, but the idea of the reserve is to ensure supplies. Of course, with regard to that reserve, we were fortunate in one sense, since the reserve was bought at a time when it was favourable to buy it. Of course, there was no emergency, but it would nevertheless permit of an economy in the cost of wheat being made. That is, however, a matter which is of no importance. The essential thing is to have available that adequate supply of wheat. Naturally, the greater the extent to which that reserve is increased the more costly it becomes. All the economic stores of the country are being utilised. The stores not so economic have also been utilised. The greater the extent to which that wheat becomes available for storage, the more costly it will become, because the less economic will be the methods of storage available to us.
What I want to make clear is this, that the levy of 1/- per sack under which that scheme is now being financed is not being made by the millers. The proceeds of that levy are not going to the profit and loss accounts of the millers, but to a special wheat reserve fund, which is controlled by a wheat reserve committee, and is being utilised for the purpose of defraying the cost of storage. The amount cannot yet be determined, but it will be substantially less than the annual revenue which will result from that charge.
Comment on this
It is the property of the Flour Millers' Association, but it is subject to our control.
Comment on this
Who constitutes the Wheat Reserve Committee the Minister talks of?
Comment on this
It is a committee set up by the Flour Millers' Association. Deputy Dillon spoke, as usual, about the price of flour, and I do not know that it is necessary once again to try to disprove his contention. I have no brief for the flour millers. If the flour millers are over-charging, then they have got to be dealt with. It is necessary that we should understand the facts. Deputy Dillon says that the flour millers are making a profit of 8/- to 10/- a sack more than they should make. The Prices Commission say that in the worst days they made a profit of 1/1 a sack more than they should.
Deputy Dillon went on to describe the whole process. His contention was that we took the matter to the Prices Commission and they gave us a formula; that the millers applied that formula to the most uneconomic mill in the country, and, on the basis of the application of that formula to the circumstances in the most uneconomic mill in the country, they fixed the price of flour, and that enabled the big mills to make enormous profits. That was all so much hooey. I asked the Deputy did he know what the formula was. The point is that anybody who knows what the formula is would know that the story told by the Deputy was just so much boloney. The formula is based on the standard price of foreign wheat quoted at recognised exchanges, and the formula which was set out in the published report of the Prices Commission permits of a variation in the price of flour only in accordance with the variation in the price of foreign wheat. The other charges are all fixed in relation to the average mill, applying to the smallest and the biggest mill.
The Prices Commission arrangement was on the basis of that formula. The formula was applied by the flour millers in the determination of the price to be charged to consumers for flour, and the millers would be getting only the ordinary profit, 7½ per cent. on invested capital. The flour millers assured us that they accepted that formula. The Prices Commission investigated the matter and they were satisfied that the formula had been applied. There was a dispute about one or two minor matters.
Comment on this
I do not know. The Deputy knows quite well. There have, however, been transactions in flour shares in recent years and the Deputy presumably knows all about them.
Comment on this
I have not lost sight of the significance of these transactions, nor have the Prices Commission, and there is being undertaken another inquiry into the flour position by the Prices Commission, in conjuction with officers of my Department. I do say that it is consciously dishonest of any Deputy to compare the quoted price of flour in London or Liverpool with the quoted price of flour in an Irish mill, because these Deputies know that flour cannot be bought in England at that price—it cannot be bought there. The Deputy who spoke about the difference of 15/ knows full well that before anybody in England can get delivery of the flour he has to pay a wheat levy, which amounts at present to 6/6 a sack.
Comment on this
The Irish price is the price of flour in sacks, free on rail to the consumer, and includes every possible charge. That is the price at which the consumer can get a sack of flour in a railway carriage in Dublin.
Comment on this
The English price is the price of the flour naked at the mill. It does not include the cost of the sacks, about 1/6 extra. It contains nothing for delivery, or the wheat levy of 6/6 payable under the British Wheat Subsidy Act. There are other factors which operate to justify a difference between the price of flour in Ireland and the price in England. It is, of course, quite true that flour can be manufactured in certain parts of England cheaper than it can be manufactured here, for reasons set out very fully in the report of the Tariff Commission in 1927. There is the fact that wheat offals are £1 a ton cheaper here than in England, and that is one explanation.
Comment on this
It is not nonsense. I will refer the Deputy to any reputable journal in which these facts are recorded.
Comment on this
No, of course we do not. Does the Deputy want the Irish flour millers to compete against a subsidised price? That is typical of the whole attitude of Deputies opposite. We had Deputy Mulcahy, Deputy Dillon and other Deputies speaking about the possibility of building up an export trade in one breath and at the next they came out with the old catchery that we were selling our bacon to John Bull cheaper than we could buy it ourselves; that we were giving cheap butter to John Bull while we were paying the full economic price ourselves. That type of catch-cry indicates the confusion of thought that exists on the opposite benches. It is quite true the only price we can get for our butter in the English market is the price prevailing there; the British are not going to pay us a subsidy. The only price we can get for our bacon is the world price, the open market price. It is true that you can buy English coal in Italy cheaper than you can buy it in England. We can buy English coal in Ireland cheaper than the consumers in England can buy it.
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that, quality for quality.
Comment on this
Certainly, quality for quality. The Deputy has only to compare the published lists to see that. It is also true that we can buy Czecho Slovakian sugar here at a fraction of the price at which the Czecho Slovakians can buy it, if there are any of them left; we can buy it cheaper than the people living in the immediate vicinity of the factories. German machinery can be bought cheaper in this country than they can buy it in Germany. Every country in the world has tried to maintain its export trade by devices of that kind, whether by direct subsidies or by manipulating the exchanges or by one means or another. They have kept themselves in the export markets of the world by the simple process of selling their goods there at lower prices than they were charging their own people. We could not have maintained our butter industry or our bacon industry or agriculture at all unless we were prepared at least to ensure that the prices prevailing here were economic, so long as the prices in the world market were uneconomic. It is completely misleading to talk about giving cheap butter to John Bull. We did not give John Bull cheap butter or cheap bacon. We gave him the butter and the bacon at no lower price than that at which they could obtain it from anywhere else.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is serious in this idea of building up industry with an export possibility, he has got to be reconciled to the fact that the export industries will mean selling our industrial products in England and elsewhere at a lower price than here.
Comment on this
Will the Minister deny that a cargo of wheat can be brought into the port of Cork as cheaply as into the port of Liverpool?
Comment on this
I am not talking about cargoes of wheat. I am not speaking of my own knowledge in these matters. Whatever information I have, I got from the Report of the Tariff Commission.
Comment on this
I am not disputing what you said. Is it a fact that a cargo of wheat to be manufactured into flour can be brought into the port of Cork as cheaply as into the Liverpool port?
Comment on this
I know the Deputy is trying to make some propaganda for Cork port. It has nothing whatever to do with the matter in this case.
Comment on this
Of course, the loaf is a lot dearer, substantially dearer, not merely because flour is dearer, but because a number of other factors operate—the fact that higher wages are paid to bakers and the different quality of the loaf. There are a number of other considerations which operate to make the price of bread dearer here. I am quite prepared to say that I think the price of bread here is too dear, but you are not going to get it reduced without a fight.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Cosgrave seriously suggest that the price of bread was as low in this country as it was in Great Britain in 1931?
Comment on this
I want to say a few words about the substitution of electric buses for the petrol buses. One of the problems we have got to deal with in preparing plans for a possible emergency is the extent to which we should go now in interfering with normal commercial affairs in view of the possibility of such an emergency. The emergency may never come and, consequently, it is difficult to decide always to what extent you are justified in interfering with the affairs of private individuals or private companies against that possibility. That question arose more or less acutely in connection with this matter to which Deputy Benson referred, namely, the substitution of electrically-driven trams by buses in Dublin. The emergency may come and that fact must be kept in mind, but there arose for the tramway company in Dublin, as I understand it, a financial problem of considerable magnitude. Not merely was the city spreading out over a much wider area and, consequently, bringing changes in the problem of providing suitable transport in the city, changes which, if trams were the principal vehicles used, would have involved the construction of new lines, new permanent ways and new overhead lines in the new areas, at considerable capital cost, but also, the existing equipment was becoming out of date, and would, I think, have to be replaced at some stage, at considerable cost. In fact, the financial problem of the company was very largely influenced by that fact. If they were to retain trams as their principal vehicles in use and at the same time, provide an adequate service in all parts of the city where new services were required, they would be involved at once in very heavy capital expenditure, both in relation to the permanent way and the overhead system. They could, of course, provide that service with petrol buses without any of that capital expenditure and I felt that, while I was obliged to draw their attention to the position that might arise in the event of an emergency and some curtailment of our supplies of motor fuel, I was not called upon to interfere unduly with the decisions they made, apart from the fact, of course, that I have no power to prevent them following any policy they consider wise if they are determined to proceed with it. That problem would arise again and again in the preparation of plans to deal with the possibility of a war situation arising.
Comment on this
I do not know that I should discuss that matter now. There is no Estimate for the Drumm battery this year and, consequently, the opportunity for making a statement concerning that will not arise, but if any Deputy is really interested I am prepared to do so. I may say, however, that we are in fact expending a considerable amount of money upon various experiments—perhaps I misled the House in saying we are doing it— but I know money is being expended on experiments concerning the possibility of utilising peat for the propulsion of public service vehicles. It has been done successfully with other fuels, as Deputies no doubt are aware, in other countries, and possibly, it can be done here. Private interests and semi-public interests of various kinds are, in fact, experimenting in that matter. We ourselves are proposing, through our industrial research organisation, to set up a special department for peat research, which will be financed by the Government and which will be charged with the responsibility of carrying out all the investigations that are necessary to enable us to utilise to the full our peat resources.
The matters that were raised here in connection with the Unemployment Assistance and Unemployment Insurance Acts can be dealt with by me in moving that Estimate. I do not think it is desirable to deal with them now because, undoubtedly, they will be discussed again when the Estimate is before us.
The other matters that were raised by different Deputies could not be very conveniently dealt with here and I do not propose to refer to them; but some of them, I think, could be very easily adjusted if the Deputies concerned would get in touch with the appropriate officers of the Department and discuss them there.
Comment on this
I want to ask one question. The note that dominated the Minister's reply to this Estimate was somewhat like this: That proposals for the reduction of unemployment must get consideration before any other objective whatever.
Comment on this
Oh yes, the Minister did, but these, at any rate, are his exact words. From the general trend of his remarks and the way in which he addressed himself, particularly to the question that I raised in making this motion, I say that this dominated the whole of his attitude: "That proposals for the reduction of unemployment must get consideration before any other objective whatever." What are the Minister's proposals in this matter? He asks us to agree on facts. We do agree. I think the Minister will find that most people here agree that it is in an industrial occupation, and in commercial occupations connected with it, that he must look for the absorption of the unemployed that are in the country at the present moment and of any increase in population here. The Minister has not indicated what exactly is in his mind, but makes this point dominate his outlook on the situation. If that be so, we do not see that any more moneys are being voted for unemployment schemes this year than were voted last year. I think the House would like the Minister to outline his proposals for dealing with the grave situation which he admits exists.
Comment on this
I am only concerned with the Department of Industry and Commerce now, and it is only in connection with the industrial aspects of the Government's policy that I have to answer to the House. Other Ministers have responsibility in connection with the Government's general policy, and perhaps will speak for themselves.
Comment on this
It seems to me that the Minister side-stepped addressing himself to the question of industrial development, particularly industrial development over an area that could be definitely taken out of, say, public controversy by indicating that a more urgent thing required attention, namely, the grave unemployment situation: that above and before any other objective that had to be pursued, and that the treatment of it was to be attended to before all else.
Comment on this
I did not intend to convey that idea. On the contrary, I think the whole purport of my remarks was to the effect that a solution of unemployment depended very largely on the success of the industrialisation policy.
Comment on this
Does the Minister understand how valuable a thing it would be if we could get clear, as between all Parties in this House, and between the general mass of the people in the country, that there was a certain range of industries that had to be maintained here even if sacrifices had to be made at the present moment in order to do that: that it was only when you got a situation like that, where a definite range of industrial life was accepted as being as necessary to our people here as agriculture, that we could really see whether the greatest technical efficiency possible was being achieved here, or that we could really achieve the greatest possible technical efficiency here?
Comment on this
The Minister seemed to imply that the attitude of the trade union movement was an impediment to him to do things that he wanted to do.
Comment on this
I said that we were not getting from the trade union movement the co-operation which, I think, we could get.
Comment on this
The things the Minister mentioned were only a little inter-trade union dispute. The Minister did not give any indication as to where he failed to get co-operation from the movement as a whole. He knows that we have plenty of food, that we have clothes in abundance, milk in abundance, and will he state what is standing between the people who need these things and the abundance that is there? I suggest to him in all seriousness that until such time as the Government become masters in their own house, and control the credit and money of the country we will never solve the unemployment problem.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration."
Do you agree with this result?
I move that the Estimate be reduced by £10 in respect of sub-head A. I do so in order to draw attention to the way in which the House was misled by the Minister and his departmental staff in presenting certain aspects of the industrial alcohol position before the House passed the Industrial Alcohol Act. The Minister indicated that the cost of the mixture of 1,000,000 gallons would mean an increased charge of £75,000 per year, which in fact he indicated was met by an increase of 1/2d. per gallon at that particular time. At the present time, with a consumption of petrol of 36,000,000 gallons, the users of motor spirit here are paying a sum of £187,500 more than they would pay for it if they got it at the Six-Counties prices.
Comment on this
Has the Deputy moved this motion in order to reply to statements made on the Second Stage of a Bill?
Comment on this
That is what I understood. There is, of course, no money in this Vote for industrial alcohol.
Comment on this
I am moving this motion in order to inquire whether the persons who contributed that information to the Minister for presentation to this House are still in his Department and whether they are still in a position to deal with important matters and mislead the House in other matters of equal importance.
Comment on this
The Deputy may not arraign civil servants in that fashion. The Minister is responsible for any information he supplies.
Comment on this
I am making the Minister responsible, and it is for the purpose of pointing out the Minister's responsibility in the matter that I am moving this motion. I want to do it very simply and very clearly. As I say, we are paying £187,500 more than we would be paying at the Six Counties prices, and that is based on this: that in the Dublin price area for No. 1 spirit the price is 1/8 and for No. 3 spirit, 1/6. In the rest of the country the price is 1/9 for No. 1 spirit and 1/7 for No. 3 spirit, all ex-pump. Three-quarters of our consumption takes place in the rest of the country.
Comment on this
The question of industrial alcohol was discussed on the main Estimate; how then does it arise in relation to salaries and allowances?
Comment on this
May I submit, Sir, that the Deputy has moved his motion to sub-head A, which includes the Minister's own salary. We are, I take it, in accordance with the usual practice on this Estimate, reviewing the administration of a particular Department for the last 12 months.
Comment on this
I take it that on the motion to refer back, which has been disposed of, the House discussed the policy of the Department for the past 12 months. Surely the Deputy does not want to duplicate debate.
Comment on this
This is a matter purely of administration under the Minister which occurred within the last 12 months.
Comment on this
According to the Deputy's statement so far it is not clear that the Minister's statement was made within the last 12 months.
Comment on this
The particular measure was introduced and piloted through the House by the Minister and the information which the Deputy has taken exception to was supplied by the Minister.
Comment on this
I do not think that a statement made on the Second Stage of a Bill is a matter for discussion on an Estimate subsequent to the passing of the Bill.
Comment on this
You indicated that this might be discussed on the motion. I addressed myself on the motion to refer back the Minister's Estimate to a matter of very definite and broad policy. There are details of the work of the Department during the past year that I wish to discuss simply, clearly and without any long-drawn-out debate. I claim to be quite in order in drawing attention to a state of affairs that has arisen and that is causing substantial expense to people here, a state of affairs that is entirely at variance with what was indicated by the Minister when he made a particular presentation of his case in May last. I have indicated what the prices of No. 1 and No. 3 petrol are in the Twenty-Six Counties and I have said that the consumption outside the Dublin price area is three-fourths of the total consumption. The price for the whole of the Six-County area is 1/7½ for No. 1 spirit and 1/5½ for No. 3 spirit, and with a consumption of 36,000,000 gallons, the expense to the people here over what they would have to pay at the Six-County price is £187,500. Therefore, they are paying now, not the £75,000 the Minister indicated they would be paying in May last, but a much more substantial figure, and they are doing that in spite of the fact that there is a penny more customs duty to be paid in the Six Counties on petrol than has to be paid here.
The Minister indicated that about 250 persons would be employed in this industry. With the money being paid over the Six-County level for this petrol, we could pay these people about £750 a year each. If we consider what we are paying as against the Six-County level, brought to our own, we could pay them £1,350 a year each. What are we getting for all this?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not see the fallacy of his own argument? A pupil of a kindergarten would see it.
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister to point out where my contemtions are wrong, if they are wrong. The Minister may say that that is not due to industrial alcohol. There is, at least, £125,000 due to industrial alcohol. If there has been mixed 1,000,000 gallons of industrial alcohol with 35,000,000 gallons of motor spirit imported here at 4.6d., the industrial alcohol costing 3/- per gallon, then the price to be paid for the mixture is 5d. and the increased cost of industrial alcohol is £175,000. What we are paying is the figure I gave and the whole thing is obscured by the idea that, in paying an additional price for petrol, we are supporting an industry that is doing some good for this country. It is not doing the good the Minister indicated it was to do and for which it was established. It is not assisting agriculture. So far as using molasses from the Sugar Company, which the Minister stated would be used if we had to depart from potatoes, it has been stated that we are importing molasses. Although the Minister indicated that if imported molasses were used, the alcohol so produced would be much cheaper than that produced from our native production of molasses, there is no indication of a cheaper rate in the price we are paying for our petrol. We are paying £187,000 more than we would be paying at the Six-County level in spite of the fact that there is a penny additional customs duty per gallon on petrol in the Six Counties. The Chair precludes me from putting the question in the way I should like to put it but I ask the Minister if that is the type of handling that important matters are going to receive in the coming year?
Comment on this
In the past, when there was a really effective Opposition in the House—that is to say, when I belonged to the Opposition—this question of differential between the price charged for petrol in the Six Counties and in the Twenty-Six Counties was raised frequently. If the Deputy wants to know all about the matter, he can read the speeches I made when his Government were over here. There was always an unexplained differential between the charge in the Six Counties and the charge here. I do not say it was entirely unexplained because you had a much more densely populated area around Belfast, with a number of towns with large populations. That permitted of lower distribution costs than was the case down here but the margin of difference was, in my opinion, always more than was justified by the circumstances. In fact, that margin of difference has been reduced as a result of representations made by me since I became Minister. The difference between the prices charged in the Six Counties and in the Twenty-Six Counties is not explainable by the additional cost of industrial alcohol here. The production of industrial alcohol is less than our estimate by reason of the supply of potatoes having been curtailed.
Comment on this
I could not say what the production will be, yet, as we are only in the middle of the season. There was, however, a partial failure of the potato crop in some areas and there is a substantial scarcity in those areas— a scarcity referred to more than once in this House when appeals were made to the Minister for Agriculture to provide seed potatoes to replace the destroyed crops. That has, naturally, affected the supply of potatoes to the industrial alcohol factories and the arrangements for utilisation of molasses have not yet been completed.
Comment on this
The Minister has evaded the whole point of the Deputy's question.
Comment on this
There is naturally an effect on the price by reduction of production. The estimate of the price that would be chargeable for the alcohol produced was based upon a certain production. If that production is not realised, the alcohol is going to cost more. I do not say that that need necessarily be reflected in the price charged to the consumers of it but the overhead charges will have to be borne on a smaller production and will, therefore, increase the cost per gallon or per unit of calculation.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that there was a differential between the price charged for petrol in the Twenty-Six Counties and the price charged in the Six Counties and there has been a reduction in the differential.
Comment on this
Well, I am speaking from recollection. That differential was modified some years ago as a result of representations.
Comment on this
The facts now are that we make allowances for the difference of customs duty and that we are paying £337,500 more for 36,000,000 gallons of petrol than we would be paying as against the Six-County rate of charges and the Minister's only answer to that is that there is always a differential between the price here and the price in the Six Counties; and the fact now is that it has been reduced and he can give no idea of what that differential was.
Comment on this
To what extent has the price of petrol been raised here as a result of that?
Comment on this
Before moving motion No. 3, I want to say that more than ten days ago, and again three or four days ago, there was a notification in the Press in reference to a series of statistics arising from the 1936 Census. Deputies have not got any copies of these census volumes. I want to ask the Minister what volumes have been issued, and what steps are being taken to circulate them to Deputies?
Comment on this
The volume about conjugal conditions and the volume about religions. These are only two of the reports made of the census. The remaining volumes will be made available as soon as possible.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would like to indicate what additional volumes will be issued in the near future. There is also another matter about which I want to put a question to the Minister. I indicated already that there are about 5,000 boys leaving the national schools in Dublin every year. As a matter of fact, there is a report from the Juvenile Advisory Board that they are able to do very little to place these boys in occupations. I would like to ask the Minister would he consider the feasibility of making a census during the coming summer of the number of boys, say up to 19 or 20 years of age in Dublin who are looking for work?
Comment on this
Yes, a census other than the register. That is the preparation of a particular type of inquiry form that would be circulated. That would be about young boys leaving school this year, or boys who have left school in the last year or two and who are in much larger numbers than the numbers that are presenting themselves at the employment exchanges. These boys are looking to where they can get a start in industrial life here. Many of them are too young to take the steps they would naturally be inclined to take if they were a little older—that is to emigrate. There is a very keen problem in this connection in the City of Dublin and an inquiry form could easily be drafted and an inquiry made about September or October this year. That could be done in rather an inexpensive way and it would bring a lot of valuable information as to the boys above the school-leaving age who have not got into employment. The inquiry could be conducted so as to bring in boys up to 20 years of age. The Minister will never understand the kernel of the problem that requires to be dealt with in the matter of industrial development in the City of Dublin without a systematic and a scientific plan.
In the discussions that have taken place here to-day there has been natural arguing on the part of provincial Deputies that the industries that are in the provinces should be protected and should be made sound and stable. Nobody will question their right to argue that. On the other hand it is a natural tendency for population to circulate to the larger accumulations of population. Apart altogether from the tendency for population to circulate towards Dublin from the rural areas there is the natural growth of population in the City of Dublin that must find an economic outlet for itself in increased commercial and industrial work in the City of Dublin. The growth of employment that there is in that city at the present time is not able to absorb any very big fraction of the young people who are leaving school and now is the time to get an inquiry into that position. It could be easily done. I think if it were done during the current year it would give us a picture of a particular part of the social and economic life of Dublin, a picture that it would be most valuable to have. I say again that it is the kernel of the problem that the Minister has in the employment or unemployment situation in the City of Dublin.
Comment on this
Before the Minister answers that, I want to say that there is one feature in connection with it that he should have in mind. That is, the danger of suggesting to the young boys in question that they are all to get jobs. In the corporation we go round and take names in connection with various matters, such as housing, and immediately we have numbers of people saying: "We are to get houses." Unless that is made plain now, you would have a remarkable demonstration here in Dublin afterwards if you do not provide those boys with jobs.
Comment on this
I was going to say at first sight that it would not be an easy matter to do what Deputy Mulcahy asks. There are a number of difficulties, but these may resolve themselves.
Comment on this
When the Minister considers the very intricate work that has been so magnificently and perfectly done by the census staff for the general census, he will find that certainly there is no real intricacy in the kind of inquiry that I am now suggesting. It can be scientifically done, and it can bring a lot of useful information to the public. I appreciate Deputy Kelly's point about the hopes that may be stirred up in these people's breasts. But the hope is there, and if an inquiry of this kind is in any way able to justify that hope, I think it will be well worth doing. The Minister will never have a real picture of the kernel of the problem in Dublin until something of the kind is done.
Comment on this
The census volumes issued are Volume I—Part I, relating to populations of the different areas, and Volume V—Part I, relating to ages and conjugal conditions. Volume II (Occupations) and Volume III (Religions and Birthplaces) will be issued in a few months time. The volume issued recently was No. V—Part I. The volumes have been numbered as on the last occasion. The volumes do not appear in the order in which they are numbered.
Comment on this
I move motion No. 3:—
That the Estimate be reduced by £10 in respect of sub-head K.
I just want to ask the Minister what is the explanation of the reduction in the amount of money being provided for mineral exploration? The Minister rather indicated at one particular time to-day that he had given a complete report recently on what had been done in the matter of mineral exploration. I would like to ask him if he would mention the circumstances under which that statement was made, and where we can refer to it; and, in the second place, what is the meaning of the reduction in the amount?
Comment on this
The amount required in any year depends entirely upon the explorational projects in contemplation in that year. If any new project should emerge during the course of the year, for which additional money would be required, then we would get it by means of a Supplementary Estimate, as we have done in the last year. The statement as to the present activities under that section of the Department, to which I referred in my opening statement, was made by me here some weeks ago on a Supplementary Estimate to provide additional funds for that service. The amount provided for here is the amount required to complete the payments to which we are already committed under the projects that have been approved of.
Comment on this
The gypsum exploration in the Carrickmacross area, and the coal exploration at The Swan, in Leix. Those are the only two works of any magnitude which are proceeding at the moment. There may be, and probably will be, others during the course of the year, but it is not possible to provide for them in those Estimates because the extent of the cost cannot be known as yet.
Comment on this
I move motion No. 4:—
"That the Estimate be reduced by £5,000 in respect of sub-head L (1)."
Really I think it should be reduced by more. I do not at all see how the Prices Commission can be worth spending £14,000 or £15,000 on under the present circumstances. They inquired into bacon last year. Their report was published I think in October. It drew attention no doubt to facts that we all knew. It drew attention to very serious profiteering on the part of the bacon curers, but it was sat on for four or five months before it saw the light of day, and the Minister had so far forgotten it that he did not know what had happened to it. The same thing happened when the report on flour was issued in 1934. That also was sat on. The Prices Commission is asked to do its work in an atmosphere that I think must completely warp its whole mind. I indicated before that in the year 1937, the last year for which we have full figures with regard to consumption, our people paid £1,039,391 more for their bacon than they did in 1931, although the amount of bacon supplied was down by 31 per cent.
Comment on this
It is the Prices Commission and not the bacon curers we are discussing at the moment.
Comment on this
Well, I am not responsible for the atmosphere; I am responsible for the Prices Commission.
Comment on this
I say that the Minister's policy is entirely responsible for the atmosphere in this country at the present time with regard to price levels.
Comment on this
I did not hear the Minister, but I want to deal with certain effects of the atmosphere in which the Prices Commission has got to work, and in which we cannot possibly expect to get £15,000 worth of value out of it. As I say, in 1937 the people paid £1,039,391 more for bacon than they did in 1931, and the quantity of bacon they got for it was down by 31 per cent.
Comment on this
It is a most relevant consideration. The Deputy should have taken the trouble to find out.
Comment on this
There are so many aspects of this that appeal to me in relation to the Prices Commission that I can only deal with a few of them. While the Irishman was consuming that amount of bacon and paying that additional price for it, this was the position: The difference between what the Englishman had to pay for the Irishman's bacon compared with what the Irishman had to pay for his bacon was as follows:—In 1931 the Irishman paid 7/- a cwt. less for his bacon than the Englishman paid the Irishman for the Irishman's bacon. That was all right until 1932, when the Irishman paid 1/6 more for his bacon than the Englishman paid the Irishman for his bacon.
The Irishman buying his own bacon in 1933 was at a disadvantage of 16/- a cwt. In 1934 he was at a disadvantage of 30/- a cwt. In 1935 he was at a disadvantage of 30/6 a cwt. In 1936 he was at a disadvantage of 38/- a cwt., and in 1937, the Irishman had to pay 76/- a cwt. more for his own bacon than the Englishman paid the Irishman for his bacon. All that what I call the Government Press had to say about it, arising out of a discussion at the Women's Industrial Federation the other day, was:—
"Bacon is becoming a political gag. It is beginning to get a laugh. The Englishman used to laugh at the Irishman's pigs. Now the Irishman laughs at the Irishman's bacon."
Comment on this
On a point of order, it seems to me that the Deputy who has moved to reduce the Vote for the Prices Commission is in fact paying a tribute to it. He is quoting information made available by the Commission, and is addressing his remarks to facts revealed by it in relation to the bacon curing industry.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, it would appear to me that the Deputy is going a bit wide of his motion. The Deputy's remarks would be more relevantly addressed, I should say, to a motion in connection with the Bacon Report.
Comment on this
I want to say that that was the position as far as bacon was concerned. We have got a report from the Prices Commission——
Comment on this
I hope the Deputy will not go into detail about any further reports. We are dealing now with a specific matter. The general policy of the Department has already been discussed and decided upon. The Deputy should confine himself strictly to what is dealt with by the motion on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
I am saying it is not worth spending £15,000 on the Prices Commission. In October last the Prices Commission reported a serious position with regard to bacon prices. It reported a serious position with regard to the profits made by the bacon curers. Not a thing in the world has been done arising out of that report.
Comment on this
It was lost in the Minister's office for four months. It was so lost that he was able to say in this House that we were so ignorant and so careless that we had not read it, although we had not an opportunity of reading it. That is the position with regard to bacon. The position with regard to flour is that the people are still paying through the nose for the flour, that huge profits are being made by the millers in spite of the fact that the Prices Commission reported four years ago that very substantal profits were being made.
There are two reports bearing on matters that are vital for the ordinary lives of the people and they have been completely ignored. The general atmosphere of prices in the country is that, as I say, the people are paying £1,000,000 a year for two-thirds of the amount of bacon they used to consume in 1931, and that they are paying £1,100,036 more for butter than in 1931. They are eating an increased quantity of butter, no doubt to make up for the lesser quantity of bacon they are consuming. In regard to wheat, the atmosphere of the Prices Commission is coloured by the fact that there is a smaller quantity of wheat and flour used—2 per cent. or 3 per cent. less— but the people are paying £2,917,000 more for the amount they are using. As I say, the net effect is that there is £4,985,000 piled on to the bill of the people of the country for bacon, butter and wheaten flour through Government policy. Yet the Prices Commission has been asked to take into consideration the condition of the people and not to allow them to be overcharged, when the whole policy of the present Government is to raise the cost of living for the people. That is one aspect of the matter. The second aspect is that new duties have been put upon the Prices Commission arising out of the Anglo-Irish Agreement made in the beginning of last year. In the first place, I do not believe that the Prices Commission could do that work.
Comment on this
It is their work, given to them by the Dáil. I did not give them that work. The Dáil did.
Comment on this
I do not believe it is worth while spending £15,000 to do that work, because they cannot do it. The terms of the Agreement with Great Britain are terms that were absolutely out of date as a practical approach towards arriving at an international trading agreement.
Comment on this
If the Minister had adopted the proposal I made, and that Deputy Childers suggested in a different form he would accept, if he were to approach a review of our industrial situation here, and our possible industrial development during the next five years, as the Australians indicated would have to be done in the agreement they signed with the British in July last, it would be possible for the Prices Commission to get some kind of a clear picture as to what were the real foundational lines on which industrial developments here were to be built up and safeguarded. They would be able, perhaps not at the moment, but in a couple of months, to do safely and satisfactorily the work which the Minister is asking them to perform. As I understand, what is being done now is that individual manufacturers are being invited into a back room in the Minister's Department——
Comment on this
At any rate, they are invited into a room where nothing very much will be known of what is going on. They are being catechised and brow-beaten, and made to understand that if they do not do their business in a particular way, if they do not scale their profits in a particular way, they are going to feel the displeasure of the Department.
Comment on this
The Prices Commission is dealing with some inquiries at the present moment, not publicly, but by taking industrialists before them, ordering them to do certain things, and suggesting that it would be better for them to do a particular thing rather than run the risk of inquiry before the Prices Commission. Instead of reasonable inquiry at which the facts could be brought out, there is a kind of Star Chamber procedure.
Comment on this
Yes, by the Prices Commission, for which we are asked to pay this £15,000. It is hard to blame them, because the facts of our industrial policy are so obsecure, and the ramifications of our industrial programme are so peculiar, that it might not be easy to conduct an inquiry of which a full report would be taken. I oppose the granting of this money, firstly, because of the Government's attitude towards a reduction of prices that really matter, an attitude that would rather induce the Prices Commission to allow prices to be kept up than to reduce them.
In the second place, the approach of the Minister towards delineating his industrial policy is such that the Prices Commission cannot carry out their work in a reasonable way. My third reason for opposing it is that under the conditions in which they find themselves the Prices Commission are conducting their business in a way in which they should not conduct it.
Comment on this
I merely rise lest a wrong impression might be created by interruption of the Minister when he said that the farmer was getting all this money. There was some mention of £1,000,000 and he said that the farmers were getting it all and that the consumer had to pay that.
Comment on this
I merely asked a question. I emphasised the fact that I was merely asking a question.
Comment on this
The facts are that the farmer was only one of the parties concerned. There are curers, millers and people in charge of the admixture scheme also concerned in this matter. Between the lot of them they have driven the farmer out of production of bacon to the extent of 10,000 sows last year. I could add another 10,000 sows for this year. There is a shortage of between 15,000 and 20,000 sows now so the Minister had better not get away with a wrong impression from the arguments used. I rise merely to state these facts.
Comment on this
So far as I can recall Deputy Mulcahy's remarks, he said the amount provided for the Prices Commission should be reduced because, he thought, the Government had not acted on its recommendations and because it was too effective in its dealings with industrialists. On the first point, I can say that the Prices Commission, in relation to flour, recommended that the price should be fixed having regard to a particular formula, and secondly, that the price of bread should be controlled. Legislation to control the price of bread has been enacted and, as regards flour, an assurance was received from the flour millers that they would conform to the Prices Commission's recommendations. The report on bacon was furnished to the Government last October, and proposals for legislation arising out of the report have already been prepared and will shortly be submitted to the Dáil. I cannot agree with the Deputy that the Prices Commission has exceeded its functions in its present dealings with industrialists. I am quite prepared to argue with the Deputy whether there should be a Prices Commission at all or not. I am prepared even to admit that the logical development of Government policy would not involve the existence of a Prices Commission, but we are not all logical in these matters, and sometimes we have to depart from the ruthless line of development that we would otherwise pursue. We have established the Prices Commission and, having done so, we are naturally anxious that it would be as effective as possible. I do not propose to interfere in any way with the activities of the commission in securing the regulation and adjustment of prices, even though their methods may be described as those of a Star Chamber, by the Deputy or anyone else.
Comment on this
The position is that the Minister completely washes his hands of the situation, but accepts the commission's recommendations.
Comment on this
I am not committing myself to accepting the recommendations of the Prices Commission in any matter bearing on the control of prices. I accept their recommendations only when I consider they are founded on wise arguments and proper appreciation of facts.
Comment on this
The Minister has not indicated what steps he proposes to take to keep the House informed on the questions that have been put to the Prices Commission, either arising out of applications from Great Britain, or out of actions of his own, or applications from other persons.
Comment on this
In view of what the Minister says, that he has, in a kind of way, put the Prices Commission entirely out on its own and does not interfere in any way, would he undertake to publish monthly a statement about the matters that have become the subject of inquiry by the Prices Commission? Would he also issue monthly a statement of the things on which the Prices Commission have reported, and undertake to put in the Library a copy of the reports of the commission as soon as they have been made to him?
Comment on this
I could not undertake that. As I stated before, a report from the Prices Commission might contain information concerning the business of individual firms that should not be made public in the ordinary way. In cases in which such did not arise, there would, ordinarily, be no objection to publication, but I think the Minister must retain his discretion in that matter. As to matters sent to the commission, the position is that all such references are published by advertisements in the daily papers. If at any time the Prices Commission is requested to undertake, or is about to undertake any investigation, whether for the purpose of a tariff review or a price investigation, the fact is published in the Press.
Comment on this
The Minister indicated that a large number of questions had gone before the Prices Commission for inquiry, and it is not easy for Deputies to carry these details from the daily newspapers. It is important that we should have, in a convenient form, an opportunity of looking at a list of the cases before the commission on the one hand, and on the other hand looking at, in a convenient form, a list of reports made by the Prices Commission, whether the Minister considers that they are of a kind that could be made public or not.
Comment on this
Any Deputy who applies to the Department for particulars of matters referred to the Commission can be supplied with them. I will undertake to do that. The majority of the reports of the Prices Commission recently received are very formal in character. The Commission is not required to give detailed reports such as were given by the old Tariff Commission. Any reports I have seen are merely reports to the effect that they have investigated that they have interviewed certain persons, and that they came to conclusions, without giving facts or the reasons that led to those conclusions. Reports of that kind would not ordinarily be published.
Comment on this
I move motion No. 5:—"That the Estimate be reduced by £10 in respect of sub-head M (1)." It is very difficult to understand what is happening with regard to the turf situation generally. In the first place, we had a Turf Act some years ago that seemed to indicate that there was going to be very elaborate use of turf, and districts were marked out in which only turf would be used as fuel. That has been completely forgotten, and the system by which the bags of turf were to be distributed in parts of the country and at a flat price in Dublin has been forgotten. Then there was the case that happened yesterday, where the Meath Board of Health rescinded a resolution passed a couple years ago deciding to use turf in future. They have now gone back to coal.
Deputies will have seen notices that appeared in Iris Oifigiúil from time to time, concerning a large number of turf co-operative societies that have been wiped out of existence. The general position there indicates that something has gone radically wrong with what was propaganda, about the big scheme for using turf throughout the country as a whole, and in particular to assist the western and poorer districts. As a contrast to that, very substantial sums of money are being spent in other directions in particular developments. The Minister indicated in the discussion that took place in the House last year, that at the end of that year, he hoped to be in a position to report on the success or otherwise of certain experiments, upon which a considerable amount of money had been spent. I asked him at that time what way he intended to report, as I intended at some time to put down a question to get particulars. I am moving this motion in order to get from the Minister a statement as to what is the position with regard to the original and widely propagandised claim for assisting the ordinary turf cutting industry. I want to know when we may expect, and in what form, a report as to the success or otherwise of the experiments to which he referred at the end of last year.
Comment on this
I should like to get some information on this subject. A very substantial sum of money is involved under this sub-head, nearly £70,000 for this year. Although there is a reduction of over £5,000 in the grant for the Turf Development Board, we are still asked to vote the very substantial sum of £16,000 as a Grant-in-Aid to that board. We should like to know how that £16,000 is expended by the board, what particular work they do for it, and what value, if any, the country is getting for the expenditure of that money.
I do not know that it would be fair to draw any particular conclusions from work in the bogs last year, because we know that it was a particularly unfavourable year for the saving of turf, but, as Deputy Mulcahy says, there seems to be a great falling off in the enthusiasm of the Government for this turf drive we had a couple of years ago, which led to the introduction of what was from the very beginning a completely absurd and unworkable measure, the Turf Act. The only sensible thing the Minister did in respect of that Act was that, having secured the maximum publicity and the full benefit of whatever propaganda could be got for it, he immediately put it on the shelf and forgot all about it. The facts, of course, are that, far from compelling anybody to burn turf for the last couple of years, those people who always burn turf were unable to get it, and great numbers of people, during the winter just past and up to the present day, had to burn coal for the first time in their lives, because they were unable to get out of the bogs the turf which had been made and saved there. But there is a very substantial sum of money of over £70,000 involved and I doubt if any member of the House has got any picture whatever of what return we are getting for that expenditure, over and above the ordinary turf cutting and saving that always went on.
There is no doubt at all that it is much more difficult to get supplies of turf for sale in the ordinary provincial town to-day than it was three, four or even ten years ago. The only attempt that I have seen to make turf what might be called a commercial commodity is the very fine attempt being made in the shape of turf-briquettes, but the difficulty with the briquettes, so far as the getting them into the ordinary provincial town is concerned, is that by the time freight is paid on them they are actually dearer than coal.
The Minister probably knows that, but the question is are we getting value for this very big sum of money, or can the Minister say that we are likely, in the near future, to get value for the amount of money going to be spent this year and which has been spent for the last three or four years.
Comment on this
Earlier this evening, I tried to get some information from the Minister——
Comment on this
——as to what is his policy. A few years ago, we heard a good deal about turf and, last year, we had an Estimate of £92,000 for turf development. This year, it is £70,000. If this is one of the natural resources of the country and its development is to be of great advantage to the country, one would imagine that the Estimate would have been increased. What I find fault with mostly is that administration costs account for £16,000 out of £54,000 for development which is roughly one third. That is exceedingly high. Practically one third of the money is being expended on administration costs. I think it is up to the Minister to let us know how that money is being expended. I travel a fair amount of the country in the West of Ireland and I do not see any great enthusiasm in the shape of increased burning of turf, and I am not aware that a number of the institutions throughout the country, of which the Government have control and to which huge grants are given, are sincere about the burning of turf.
There are two bogs mentioned in the Estimate, one in Kerry and another in some part of the Midlands. With the amount of money being expended, £73,000, £16,000 of which is for administration, there must be much more work done, and the Minister might enlighten the House as to the activities of the board. With regard to the different peat societies, he might give us some idea of what money has been realised from the money paid out for the development of bogs. He might also give the House an honest opinion as to whether he is serious about this matter. I know that the Minister for Defence was very keen on it two years ago, but since the Estimate was brought in, I have not seen him in the House. He always represented the Government at the national turf-cutting meetings, and he spoke very highly of turf. I think he told us that last year was the last year in which they would ask for a big sum, and that inside 12 months there would probably be great developments. The only developments we have seen in the Estimate is in respect of two bogs.
Comment on this
We are on motion No. 5—that the Estimate be reduced by £10 in respect of sub-head M (1).
Comment on this
I do not intend to move individually in respect of sub-heads M (2), M (3), M (4) and M (5), and perhaps the discussion could cover all the sub-heads, and the Minister could reply to all together.
Comment on this
I notice that there is a grant-in-aid of £50,000 for the development of Clonsast Bog. The figure was £60,000 last year. It seems a very big sum, and I should like the Minister to tell us if the number employed justifies this expenditure and what number of men are employed.
Comment on this
I should be interested to know what has damped the Minister's enthusiasm with regard to turf as revealed by the Estimate. I think his enthusiasm has become burned out and has disappeared in smoke, because I remember a time when the Minister was very enthusiastic about turf. I remember that we had a lot of fears when the Minister brought in a certain Bill providing for turf and coal quotas, but, as Deputy Morrissey said, the only decent thing he did was to put that measure on the shelf and not to operate it.
Comment on this
It was never operated with regard to the quotas of turf and coal. That is true, in any case.
I should like to ask the Minister if any part of this money is going to be utilised for the purpose of advertisements such as "Burn more turf." Are we providing money for that? If so, I should like to tell him what effect that has had on some of his supporters down in our county. The board of health there is building a hospital at a cost of something around £100,000, and when we had the foundations in, the contractor wanted to know, through the architect, what fuel we were going to burn in our furnaces there as it was important for him to know. Out of our patriotism we said we were going to burn turf, because we had had all these advertisements through the country three years ago: "Burn more turf" and we had the Minister and all his people preaching that up and down the country, and we had the Minister's Party's "Truth in the News" telling us, and the Minister telling us down in Ballinasloe, that the whole future of this country, at least in the West of Ireland, rested with the product of the bogs in the west. So we decided to burn turf. Now, what we find this year is that, in the county home and the two hospitals in County Roscommon—we always burn all the turf we can get in addition to coal—we could not get any turf this year at all. I raised the matter with the board of health and pointed out the position we were in with regard to our new hospital for which we had provided turf burning furnaces.
The chairman of the board of health —a great admirer of the Minister— said that it was a very important matter to raise. As a matter of fact, he said in effect: "The Turf Development Board has let down all the turf societies in the country. That is the position, and we cannot get any turf. No turf is coming in, and we have no turf for our institution here, and if we cannot have turf for our new hospital we will have to start off with providing furnaces for the use of coal." We then addressed a letter to the architect, and, very fortunately as it turned out, he told us that, notwithstanding that turf-burning furnaces had been required, the present furnances could be used for dual purposes and we could burn coal in them.
Now, with regard to this business of turf and the development of bogs, I never had any faith in it, although I am a turf burner myself, and I say, just as in the case raised by Deputy Gorey a while ago with regard to pigs in this country, that you must judge everything by results. Notwithstanding all the Minister's advertisements, we are not putting in more turf than we were using previously, and the position now, apparently, is that we are abandoning it, or at least abandoning it to a certain extent. I should like to ask the Minister what is being done with regard to the development of the two bogs, Clonsast and Lyracrompane, mentioned here under two headings. Is it going to be hand-won turf or machine-made turf, or is it for the manufacture of briquettes, or is the Minister developing these two bogs by way of experiment in order to see what he can do to produce alcohol or some other substitute? At any rate, the Minister referred a while ago to industrial alcohol or some substitute of that kind. We are entitled to know that, and the Minister ought to tell us whether he has abandoned the hand-won turf idea down the country, or whether in fact he has abandoned all the turf societies in the country.
I do admit that a lot of good has been done by the turf societies as regards the draining of bogs and the making of roads, which was a great convenience to the people benefited by the draining of the bogs and who are using these roads, but the Minister has certainly allowed his enthusiasm to get burnt out, and I think it was burned out by coal and not by turf. If we are going to have any more of these advertisements, such as "Burn more turf," I say that it is going to be bad for the Minister and for the country. I do not want to have local authorities patriotically walking into this thing—of course, patriotically, we ought to burn turf, and all the Minister's friends preached that, and we decided to do so —and then find that they cannot get turf and that nobody can get it. If the wealth of this country is shut up in the bogs, then I am afraid we cannot get it out of them.
I remember that here, some time ago —possibly it was a year ago or more— the Minister brought in a Supplementary Estimate, I think it was, by way of grant to the Turraun Peat Works. What has become of these peat works? Are they ours, or do they belong to the Government? They do not appear here in the Estimate.
Are we working them, and are the works paying for themselves? Are the briquettes produced there a commercial proposition? According to what we hear from local authorities in the immediate neighbourhood of the place that used these briquettes they are at least one-sixth dearer than coal. If we cannot do better than that, we have no business providing public money for them. The Minister, however, should tell us why he has altered his whole outlook on turf because, according to that, he has altered his outlook.
Comment on this
The Turf Development Board, when originally established, was charged with the function of bringing into existence the co-operative turf societies and of organising the central marketing of the turf produced by those societies. It carried out that work, expending in the process a considerable sum of money, a large proportion of which went in the construction of bog works of various kinds and, in fact, most of the turf societies came into existence for the purpose of getting and using grants that were available for the construction of bog roads, and so forth.
When the turf societies, however, had been in existence for some time, it was decided by the board to abandon the central marketing of hand-won turf and allow each society to dispose of its own turf through its own efforts in its own locality, assisted, where necessary, by the Turf Development Board; and the Turf Development Board proceeded to undertake another form of activity, that is the production of machine-made turf on bogs owned by it and made by workers employed by it.
The first development of that kind was at Clonsast. Deputies referred to the amount of money that is provided here for that purpose. That is capital money. The total amount of money that will be invested in Clonsast will be considerably more than the amount voted this year, but that is the amount of capital money required this year. We anticipate that the Clonsast bog will commence production during this year. I do not know what joke Deputy Brennan was trying to make when he asked what product we hoped to produce, whether it was industrial alcohol or what. We intend to produce electricity. The mechanical production of turf at the Lyracrompane bog, in County Kerry, was commenced last year. That turf is on sale. The Turraun Peat Works, to which I think Deputy Brennan made reference, was purchased by the Turf Development Board from its original owners some years ago and is now in full production, producing machine-won turf which is being sold in the vicinity of the bog.
Comment on this
Is it paying for itself? It is not mentioned in the Estimate, and that is my reason for asking. Is it paying for itself?
Comment on this
Undoubtedly so. The Turraun bog had many disadvantages. It was not as large, as well drained, or as suitably located for this type of production as the turf board would have chosen. It had been undertaken as an experimental development by the late Sir John Griffith, and we had some regard to the amount of money put in by Sir John himself and his family, and to the enterprising public spirit he showed in undertaking that development, when we acquired the bog from him at the time we did. The whole organisation of the bog, however, has been improved; new machinery has been installed, new methods of production introduced, and it is providing more successful than we anticipated when we purchased it. The Clonsast development is a much larger development altogether.
Comment on this
The £16,000 goes to meet the costs of the operations of the Board. The operations of the board are many and varied. They are not merely concerned with the operations at Turraun, Clonsast and Lyracrompane, but they are carrying out investigations all over the country and are preparing plans for the development of other bogs. They are doing an amount of research work of that of character, in addition to advising the turf development societies. The reduction in the Vote under subhead M.I is due to the fact that the amount of assistance given by way of inspectorial visits to turf societies has been reduced. The staff of the board has been lessened.
Comment on this
Turraun is apparently the property of the Government?
Comment on this
Are there any accounts kept by anybody? Are we getting any money from it? What is happening there?
Comment on this
Each of the schemes is not merely completely independent of the other, but is entirely economic. The turf is being sold at a price which covers the cost of production.
Comment on this
The position is that we do not know we have it.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would stop talking for a moment I might be able to explain the position. This is a commercial undertaking and it is being run as such. The Grant-in-Aid that appears in the Vote is due entirely to the fact that the Government considers it a wise policy to meet the total charges of the Turf Development Board as distinct from any charges incurred by reason of commercial undertakings conducted by the Board. As regards the board's commercial undertakings the production of turf at Lyracrompane, Clonsast and Turraun is on a commercial basis. The board has other functions, but it is supervising these enterprises, which will be the forerunners of a number of others of a similar character. We are proposing to undertake a similar development on a bog in Kildare during the course of this year; at least, to begin the development, because it takes some years to get a bog to the stage when production is possible. The necessary surveys and other preliminary work are being carried out in connection with similar schemes on bogs in Donegal and Galway.
The amount provided for Clonsast bog is part of the total capital to be invested in the enterprise. The enterprise will be entirely independent and will, I believe, yield a profit. When production begins, and it will begin this year, it is anticipated that the employment which will be given there will embrace about 400 men. The turf, of course, which will be produced there this year will be disposed of for sale in the ordinary way, but when the electricity generating station has been established there it is anticipated that almost the whole of the production of the bog will be utilised in that station.
It is entirely incorrect to say that I have lost any enthusiasm for turf development. I think that it will prove in time to be by far the most important development that we have undertaken in these years. The application of mechanical science to the problems of turf winning will open up a new source of wealth of great importance to this country. Deputies may scoff at that, but in other countries they have succeeded in solving the technical and engineering problem of turf winning to such an extent as to make their peat resources a real source of national wealth. We can do the same here. We are only at the beginning of what I think will prove to be a really important development in the economic life of this country.
Comment on this
We are not scoffing. We merely ask, the Minister why he introduced a Bill two or three years ago which he obviously did not want.
Comment on this
I am now dealing with the allegation that there is a falling-off in my enthusisam for peat. Far from there being any falling-off in my enthusiasm, I am confirmed in my faith in regard to the great possibilities ahead. That is all that has happened. I have every confidence that what I anticipated will be achieved, and I can view with perfect unconcern the scoffs and sneers and jeers of the unbelievers. In due course you will be all converted, and you will be denying emphatically that you ever opposed this development. Indeed, you will be claiming credit for having initiated it. Deputy Morrissey will stand in the Square at Nenagh, in front of the beautiful statue that is there, and he will be telling the citizens how he, and he alone, forced this Government to under take peat development. I can almost visualise that.
Comment on this
The Minister is getting enthusiastic now: we are whipping up his enthusiasm.
Comment on this
I am merely trying to convey an air of quiet confidence. I have explained why there has been a reduction under sub-head M (1). The reduction under sub-head M (2) is due to the fact that we will not have as much turf for sale this year as in other years, and consequently the same amount of advertising will not be necessary.
Comment on this
As regards sub-head M (1) do I take it that the factory at Kildare which is making briquettes is completely independent of the Turf Development Board?
Comment on this
It is; it is operated by a private company. The amount provided for the development of Clonsast and Lyracrompane, the amount of capital which will be required this year, is of no real significance.
Comment on this
May I raise a question about coal, not turf? I think I should have raised this under an earlier sub-head, but I was not here. I should like to know what efforts, if any, is the Minister making to secure that there should be a greater supply of anthracite in the country. The Minister is, no doubt, aware that authracite stoves are being used to a greater extent and there is a great scarcity of anthracite nuts. I know it is difficult to get them in Wexford.
Comment on this
We have operations proceeding in that connection at Slieveardagh, but commercial development must depend on an amendment of the Mines and Minerals Act which we have in contemplation.
Comment on this
There is likely to be a considerable quantity of anthracite coming into the country unless the native supply can be developed.
Comment on this
I should like to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that there was a considerable amount of disappointment among railway men and others that the Holidays Employees Act of 1938 did not come into operation in time to give them St. Patrick's Day as a holiday. I think that question was raised.
Comment on this
I propose to make an Order bringing the Act into operation about the middle of May. There have been representations that it should be done before Easter, but I think in the long run it would not be in the interests of the workers that that should be done. I explained when the Bill was before the Dáil why each of these Acts should be brought into operation some time in May. There is a period of three months during which workers in constant employment become entitled to their first annual holiday. If the Act is brought into operation in May they get that first annual holiday in June, July or August. If they do not get it in these months, it is possible that workers in continuous employment who would become entitled to holidays at some other season of the year would ordinarily get them at some other season. In the interest of these workers it is desirable, I think, that the Act should begin to operate some time in May. Even though it may mean that workers who would otherwise get paid for holidays at Easter will not get paid, it was not contemplated to bring it into operation earlier.