Committee on Finance. - Vote 69—Employment Schemes.
Contributions 128–260 of 260. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Lest the Parliamentary Secretary, listening to Deputy Dillon, might get the impression that we in West Donegal regard him as a vade mecum, I would remind the Parliamentary Secretary that Deputy Dillon's knowledge of Donegal is not, perhaps, as good as it used to be. He is one of those who migrated some years ago, evidently anticipating a period of unemployment himself. I would like to say, speaking for that constituency, where a great proportion of this money is spent in comparison with most other constituencies, that the people there appreciate fully the work the Board of Works is doing in connection with employment schemes. In a long discourse, lasting probably an hour, Deputy Dillon pointed out a number of schemes that should be undertaken and that could be done. He pointed out to the Parliamentary Secretary that the objection to the cutting of farmers' hedges was that the Department of Finance would not sanction it. I would remind Deputy Dillon that the Board of Works are every day doing work that as intimately affects the farmer as going into his field and cutting his hedges. When the Board of Works undertake minor relief schemes, such as the making of bog roads or accommodation roads, or the carrying out of a drainage scheme, they are encroaching on the farmers' lands and at the same time they are adding to the amenities of the farmers' holdings or the amenities of tenants who require turbary and cannot, without good roads, get their turf from the bogs.
Deputy Dillon's knowledge of the work that is being carried out by the Department of Finance and the Board of Works seems to be very little. He extolled the migration of agricultural labourers and told us that, as regards the number who migrated every year, there was no other means of livelihood for them and that they would prefer to get good wages in England to remaining on the land in the West of Ireland or depending on minor relief schemes. I remember a fortnight or three weeks ago, when Deputy Maguire of Leitrim made a statement to the effect that there were portions of the country in which there were too many people on the land, Deputy Dillon held up his hands in horror at the idea of the Deputy suggesting that there was not too much of a flight from the land and that anybody who could should migrate from the land.
Comment on this
There is one suggestion I should like to make to the Parliamentary Secretary with regard to those schemes. Perhaps some scheme could be devised for extending the reclamation work at present being carried out in rural areas. Those reclamation schemes are, I understand, carried out under the auspices of the Department of Agriculture, but perhaps there could be some co-operation between that Department and the Board of Works. These schemes are not extensive enough. If there could be some scheme devised to reclaim more land in the congested areas, that would help the unemployed as well as improving the holdings of numbers of people in the congested areas. The works that are being done in our constituency are, generally speaking, works of great public utility and works the people appreciate and we hope the Board of Works will continue expending money in that direction.
Comment on this
I intervene in this debate in order to return to a subject that I brought to the notice of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. That is, the very heavy unemployment that exists amongst the workers who used to be employed in the Benduff and Madranna quarries, which were possibly the greatest factors in regard to our employment position in West Cork. I understand 250 men have been put out of employment in the quarries due to one particular cause or another, but ultimately resolving itself into a shortage of orders for slates. I do not think that is a matter I can discuss with the Parliamentary Secretary now.
Comment on this
I shall come to an aspect of the case which, I hope, will not merit any censure from the Chair. That is, to add to the troubles of the management there, a very heavy landslide took place in the quarry recently, as a result of which a very considerable portion of overhanging cliff fell in and accentuated a position that even at that time was pretty bad. If the Parliamentary Secretary will have the matter examined with a view to seeing whether he could give any assistance, I would be obliged. I do not know whether that is a practical suggestion or not.
Comment on this
I feel, however, it is a matter that will get his sympathetic consideration. He has, I think, very properly made some contribution to the improvement of many of the seaside villages out of the sums at his disposal. Many of our little seaside villages are pretty drab and derelict, and, with a comparatively modest expenditure on improvements in the way of approaches to the strands and matters of that kind, it would enhance their appearance and, I think, on the whole give a good return. At a time when big advances are expected in tourist development, and when State assistance of a very considerable amount will be forthcoming for the purpose of encouraging tourist development, I submit this suggestion to the Parliamentary Secretary, that what has been very well and very thoroughly begun in a few places might be extended.
I do not propose to discuss individual schemes or individual cases, but I make the two suggestions I have made in the hope that they will be of some value to the Parliamentary Secretary, and when he is considering certain schemes in the future perhaps he will have an opportunity of dwelling upon them. I hope that the suggestions I have made will be of some value.
Comment on this
If the Deputy has any details of schemes of that kind, perhaps he will be good enough to send them to me; I shall be glad to have them.
Comment on this
I feel personally gratified at the opinions generally expressed with regard to how money should be expended under this Estimate. I remember, as far back as 1932, putting up a suggestion for a minor drainage scheme. I put forward a rough draft scheme whereby money such as is voted under this Estimate could be utilised. I find now that that idea is supported on every side of the House. At that time, I said that the first essential was that a survey should be made of the minor drainage necessities of each particular county. Even if there were no engineers available for that work it should be possible to train in our colleges persons who would be qualified to take levels and to give a rather accurate survey of the requirements for each county. There is no denying that the dairy lands and the cattle lands of 60 or 80 years ago are for the most part practically derelict to-day and have been so for the last 25 or 30 years. The arable lands of 50 or 80 years ago are now the cattle and dairy lands while most of the land that used to be good cattle and dairy land is now practically waste. Taking my own experience, before the Fianna Fáil Government came into office in 1932, I carried out a scheme on my own. I had to go down to restore the river to its original depth of 5 feet 10 inches. The benefit that resulted to the surrounding district has only to be seen to be appreciated to-day. Where there was nothing but blue sedge, "flaggers" and rushes, to-day white clover is growing. That has happened in County Kilkenny and I am sure it would be true of every county in Ireland if similar schemes were carried out.
Exception has been taken to some of the suggestions made here on this Vote and it has been said that it would cost too much to put them into operation but in this Estimate we are providing £1,500,000. I do not quarrel with the spending of that money because the people who are absorbed on employment schemes give some return for it, but I say that there are more useful opportunities for spending this money. In addition, you have the money spent on the dole proper. I should like to know if there is an estimate available of the amount spent under this Vote and the amount spent on the dole proper. The two Votes added together must represent a very considerable amount.
Comment on this
The amount of work that could be done with an annual expenditure of £3,000,000 is immense. I do say that the money spent on the dole proper is criminal expenditure, inasmuch as it only helps to demoralise the people who are getting that money. If that £3,000,000 were spent in providing useful work, even if it were not work that would be immediately reproductive, work that would prevent the unemployed from becoming demoralised physically and mentally, it would be money well spent. If the money were only spent, as I suggested here some years ago on shovelling sand from the shores, it would help to keep red blood in their veins. If spending money on work of that kind is much more praiseworthy than paying it out in doles, how much more praiseworthy is it to spend it on the kind of work suggested by Deputies on all sides of the House to-day? I was delighted to hear Deputy Childers' frank exposition of the conditions that obtain in the country to-day. Human nature is never perfect and we have not a monopoly of perfection, or of imperfection for that matter, in this country. A portion of our people must always be driven to do their duty to the State. A lot has been said about what the State owes to the individual but I have never heard, from the Labour benches at any rate, what the individual owes to the State. In my opinion, the individual owes more to the State than the State owes to the individual. He has been sent into the world to contribute to his own support and if he falls short in that he falls short in his duty to himself and to the State.
I say that the £1,500,000 paid out under this Estimate and the £1,500,000 paid out on the dole proper, could if properly utilised effect wonders in this country. If necessary, I think scheme could be devised to hire out or to give to farmers who have work to do, a certain number of men at a nominal rate, the remainder of the wage to be made up out of the £3,000,000 provided under these two Votes. Wonders could be effected in that way and at the same time you would preserve the morale of the people so employed. I say that a survey should be taken of each county's requirements in the matter of minor drainage schemes. You could then proceed step by step with this annual expenditure of £3,000,000. That is to be greatly preferred to distributing the money in doles in a way that will demoralise the people. To distribute the money in doles is a national crime. The chief consideration in this matter should not be whether a Deputy will offend somebody in the country who has a vote. That attitude is of no value to the State or to the race. It is a matter of absolute indifference whether or not certain people are re-elected at the polls. The chief consideration is that the morale of the State and of the race should be preserved.
The schemes financed under this Vote were operated on a basis last year different from the year before. Last year the unit for schemes was the electoral division and if a sufficient number of unemployed could not be shown in any electoral division, no work could be done. The year prior to that, three or four electoral divisions were grouped and the unemployed within that area were sent from one job to another in these three or four electoral divisions.
Comment on this
There has been no change; if anything, it has been in the direction which the Deputy desires.
Comment on this
In actual fact, there has been a change. Nothing could be done last year in areas where work had been carried out the year before. When I made application for some schemes in my county, I was told that there was only one electoral division in the old district council area of Kilkenny where work could be done under the regulations now obtaining. There was nothing offered there, so that nothing could be done in that part of the county at all. I think that the grouping of electoral divisions is a reasonable proposition.
Exception has been taken to the transport system which was suggested here on the ground of the expenditure involved, but I do not think that anybody ever meant to suggest that we should hire 'buses for this purpose. Surely to goodness, some sale conveyance could be rigged up, some conveyance the property of some authority —the county council or somebody else, let it be a 'bus or a chassis with a body built on it, to take these people around. There would be no expense involved apart from petrol. It is ridiculous to tell me this could not be done. There are any amount of chassis in the country which could be rigged up with an expenditure of a few pounds, and they could be driven by some of the unemployed. Many of them are qualified to drive vehicles of that kind. The matter of expense disappears altogether.
Deputy Dillon talked a lot about making new flagged drains. There may be some drains of that description needed in the country, but they would be very few. What is needed is to restore the old waterways, because you will find a drainage scheme along the bed of every waterway. There are some of these of which no account has been kept and they have disappeared utterly. A new man on a farm does not know where the previous drainage scheme was constructed. He may be going along to one of these waterways and find water coming along, and thus discover the drains. In many places these waterways have been neglected altogether. Some maps should be kept of these drainage schemes, because a man coming into a farm does not know what has been done previously. These schemes ought to be registered, and a map of them kept somewhere locally. It is a pity that they cannot be discovered now.
The restoration work is there to be done. The whole country is demanding that it should be done. It is very necessary from the point of view of the national health. The land is waterlogged and there is water all over the place; the drains and rivers are choked and there is no way for the water to get away. Such a scheme should be put into operation and the waterways cleared. They ought to be cleared at the national expense. No individual can be held responsible for the damage done, not even the occupier of the land, because up to 50 years ago the landlords preserved the drainage schemes and the waterways and when sales began to take place under the Land Acts there was utter neglect and no supervision was exercised. If there was a bridge on a man's land which was broken down, it was left in that condition. Mud began to accumulate and bushes to collect there. If the man was taking the produce of a tillage field or a meadow across it bushes were thrown into the waterway and sods put on top of them and left there. That is all due to neglect as there was nobody to look after it. What was everybody's business was nobody's business. Under the present land tenure in England every drainage scheme is looked after every year. That does not happen here.
If you embark on a national restoration of the original minor drainage schemes, the job of seeing that the waterways are kept clear should be given to some authority, and I suggest that the Gárda should look after it in every area. There would not be so much to do. Let the occupiers dam them up in the summer time if they like for the passage of horses and cattle, produce, etc., as that does no harm. But in October, or November, there should be an absolute clearance of every waterway, no matter how small, all over the country. Anybody who refuses to do this should be prosecuted. Anybody who knows the country should know the importance of this. It is much more important that the drains and waterways should be kept clear than that the hedges on the roadside should be cut, and I would make it an offence not to have this done. I would leave it to the Gárda to look after the matter. One man in each district could do it in a week. He could point out what was to be done, and if it were not done the person should be prosecuted. Under this scheme a considerable amount of good work can be done, both from the point of view of the people in the districts concerned and the country generally. The important thing is that the morale of the people should be preserved as well as their capacity to work. I saw in the Sunday Independent last week that 19,000 young people in Dublin, between the ages of 18 and 21, have never done a day's work. That cannot continue. In five years' time the number will be 30,000 or 40,000, and the number in the country will increase in a proportionate degree, according to the population. You are faced with that problem and you must tackle it. If you do not tackle it now, you will be leaving an almost impossible heritage to those who come after you. You should tackle it like men and do it.
Comment on this
I want to draw the attention of the Parliamentary Secretary to the necessity for some marine works in my constituency, with particular reference to the repair of the sea wall on the island of Inishboffin. I have had correspondence with the Office of Public Works on the matter. I understand that the reason the work is held up is that the county council have been asked to promise to maintain it. I think the Parliamentary Secretary is aware that on these islands rates have not been paid for a long number of years and there is a disinclination on the part of the county council to undertake any liability in respect of these places. There is a good case to be made for the non-payment of rates— at least the islanders can make a good case. They say that they are not getting services comparable to those on the mainland. There is an urgent necessity for the repair of this sea wall on Inishboffin as there is a possibility that certain houses, including the post office, will have to be evacuated if the work is not done. I think the Office of Public Works ought to waive the condition that the county council should undertake the work of maintenance and do this work. As regards maintenance, the Office of Public Works are spending a certain amount of money each year for the relief of unemployment, and I put it to the Parliamentary Secretary that the maintenance of works of that kind might be regarded as a suitable proposal at some future time, if any deterioration has taken place. I should also like to refer to the small islands of Aran. A pier or a slip in such places is equivalent to a road on the mainland. These places have not got any relief works during the past season. I know that the Office of Public Works had schemes prepared, and it has been a great disappointment to the islanders that they have not been carried out. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will take these matters into consideration. There are also some marine works on the mainland in which I am interested, but I shall not refer to them now.
Comment on this
I think the Parliamentary Secretary deserves every credit for the machinery he has set up to deal with the unemployment problem. I believe that he has his finger on the problem in almost every county. Any money that is spent on works which will provide employment is money very well spent, because if we gave the money in the form of a dole there could be no return for it. Whether these schemes are economic or uneconomic, I believe the money is well spent. For hundreds of years farmers who lived long distances off the main road had to travel up bad boreens which in some cases were flooded, so that they could not bring a horse and cart up them in the winter time, and sometimes even in the summer time. Now, after an application of stones and gravel, these lanes will be in pretty good order perhaps for 20 years. The same thing applies to the bog roads. Formerly the farmers before they started their operations in the bogs in the summer time had to go around the country gathering bushes to throw on these roads to keep the carts from sinking. A good deal of work has been done on many of these bog roads, and they are now in a serviceable condition. I am sorry that these works have to be confined to certain areas where unemployment is rife, because in that way the same lane perhaps has to be done three years in succession for the want of other works in the area I do not object to any lane getting a second application, because with one application the stones find their way up, but after a second application the lane is in a very serviceable condition.
Now that we have done a fair amount of lanes, we ought to concentrate on giving the farmers outside the areas with unemployment a chance of getting their lanes repaired. There are some lanes which will never come within the scope of the schemes because the unemployment problem is not rife there. These lanes are desperately bad—I know some of them myself—and I should like the Parliamentary Secretary to extend the mileage. If he were to extend it by five miles, so as to take in some of these lanes, he would be doing a good turn for the ratepayers. He would get a fair number of men who would travel five miles to get the work for a few months.
The Parliamentary Secretary should extend the present scope and I think he should consider circularising every farmer in Ireland with a valuation of £50 and upwards asking them to submit schemes which they want carried out, but which they themselves have not got the money to carry out. If he did that, a vast amount of work would be found in the different areas for all the unemployed, and it would be a cheap scheme because most of these farmers are clever and intelligent and would do the supervising without any cost to the State. Nearly all our farmers have big problems on their land. They have drainage schemes which they cannot tackle and fencing which they cannot tackle, because their financial resources will not allow them. With an unemployed list of 107,000, I think those problems should be tackled by the Parliamentary Secretary. It would give the farmers a great deal of help and put much of our waste land into serviceable condition.
I am not at all satisfied with one part of this Department's work, that is, in connection with the drainage of bogs. My colleague, Deputy Ryan, has spoken of it and, in my county, I have found the same problem. The Parliamentary Secretary sent down a squad of men and a large number of engineers. In fact, two or three came there every week. They spent months surveying and then they tackled the problem, as they thought, in a satisfactory way, but which to the ordinary bog-man was nothing less than a laughing-stock. They put a canal through a bog in some cases and that is not a satisfactory method, as any bog-man will tell you. I believe that any bog-man is far superior to the new engineers we have dealing with this problem. A small drain in a bog will stand up for a number of years, whereas if you make a large canal through a bog, no matter how good it is, you may find that the two sides slip in and all your work goes for nothing. In my county, some of the water drained off the bogs is running into the farmer's land. For bog drainage, there should be a special type of people and I think the local bog-men should be consulted because they have spent scores of years in the temporary draining of those bogs and they know what type of drain is most suitable. Making large ditches or canals is not a satisfactory way. I know that from the local people who saw the schemes being carried out and who saw them fail. These canals in my county have fallen in and all the work has gone for nothing.
Comment on this
Cloneycavan and Hill of Down, in County Meath. With regard to the Hill of Down bog, I should like to get a definite reply from the Parliamentary Secretary as to what he is going to do there. I think it was understood that there was to be a peat works started there. A large number of men were employed for six or nine months and they did a vast amount of work, but, in the middle of the work, the financial resources fizzled out, the men were sacked and the job was not completed. A large quantity of water from the bog is now draining into the farmers' lands. The Parliamentary Secretary, I think, when notified, will rectify that situation. It is just a matter of getting the water to go in the normal course into the River Boyne. The people there have a grievance because instead of having their land drained, it is being flooded. They do not seek compensation. All they want is that the job should be completed. There is a large amount of unemployment in that area, too.
I think also that the Land Commission should work more closely with the Parliamentary Secretary's Department, because, when the Land Commission tackle a very big estate, they find a huge amount of work ready to be done there, such as drains, forestry, in some cases, and bog land, all in a swamp. The Parliamentary Secretary could put hundreds of men there and get the estates into proper order for the new tenants. At present, the Land Commission do nothing more than build a few ditches around the farm and say to the tenant: "There is your farm" although they are giving him nothing but a swamp in many cases. All the shores are stopped, the ditches knocked down and the tenant is given nothing more than a swamp to start a living on. The Parliamentary Secretary's Department should be asked to come in and put the land in proper condition before it is given to the tenant, so that the tenant may have some hope of making a start. I have very little to say against the work of this Department and I must congratulate the Parliamentary Secretary on his efficient and courteous staff. I have never heard any man in this House, or outside it, making any complaint against them. If you write a letter, you get a reply by return and if it is at all possible, it will be a satisfactory reply.
Comment on this
I wish to congratulate the Parliamentary Secretary on the excellent work his Department has carried out in the drainage of the River Robe in South Mayo. I want also to appeal to him to carry out, now that that work is nearly completed, the drainage of three or four tributaries of that river which were not included in the original scheme. The works are very small, but there are four tributaries which are not included in the scheme, the drainage of which is necessary. I will give them to the Parliamentary Secretary. They are from Bekan Lake to Cloonbulban, from Ballinphuil Lake through Cartown, Eskerlavally, Castlegar and Ballintubber to the river, and from Scardane Bridge to Galway boundary. That is about a mile, and the work in the first case would not cost very much—probably about £100. The second would cost about £300. The third is a very small work and would not cost more than £100. There was also a footbridge across the road at a point between Crimlin and Ballykinava. That was removed when the drainage of the River Robe was undertaken. It has not been restored, and there is no way for the people of the townlands of Crimlin and Ballykinava to get across except by going around three miles. The drainage of this river is nearly complete, and I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will carry out the other works in the county which were petitioned for by the county council—the drainage of the Gweston, Pollock and Yellow Rivers.
Comment on this
That does not come under this Vote. It is only fair that I should say that, because other Deputies have kept themselves within the limits.
Comment on this
During the River Robe drainage operations, about 200 men were employed for two years——
Comment on this
Other Deputies have restrained themselves from going outside the Vote. I have no objection myself, but I do not think it is fair to those other Deputies.
Comment on this
There are some very urgent works which would give considerable employment if carried out, such as the repairs of certain roads through bogs. I will not mention the roads as I am precluded from doing so, but they happen to be in certain areas where there are only a few on the unemployment register. These roads are in a frightful condition and I hope that the Parliamentary Secretary will extend the scheme in some way or another to include works of that description. It may require legislation, but I know of several roads in that area which would give employment to 300 or 400 men for almost a year. The roads are in a frightful condition and the people in some instances have to remove the turf from the bogs on their backs. When an application was made to the Board of Works, the authorities stated that there were only a few persons there on the unemployment register. I think the county council has sent forward several applications to the Department asking to have the necessary work carried out. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will bear the matter in mind and, if he does, I am sure he will do anything he can in connection with the matter.
Comment on this
This Vote and the £1,500,000 provided under it, added to the other £1,500,000 to be spent by the Department, gives some idea of the unemployment problem here in its true perspective. The Parliamentary Secretary told the House that he welcomed rotational schemes as a real solution of unemployment in rural districts, and expressed the hope that this Vote had come to stay. If that represents the real outlook of the Government on this question, it is a sorry and a hopeless position. This Party has always realised what an immense problem it is to solve unemployment. The Parliamentary Secretary told us that he has found it difficult to get the right type of scheme in certain areas, and that, to some extent, such schemes were becoming exhausted.
I welcome the suggestion made by Deputy Childers that some attempt should be made to subsidise employment on the land, so that work which is not ordinary productive work, but the type of work that has been neglected for years, could be undertaken. That work includes field drainage, the cleaning and repairing of fences and hedges, and the laying and breasting of hedges. There is an enormous amount of waste land through the country as a result of long neglect. When one sees what has been done in England, Holland and Denmark, one begins to realise what an amount of waste land there is here. Work of that kind was attended to up to 40 to 50 years ago but, in recent years, it has been completely neglected. The cost from the farmers' point of view is prohibitive, as they can only devote their attention to work that will give immediate results. The class of work I refer to might be classed as work that results in indirect production, but that is absolutely necessary. If the Parliamentary Secretary can evolve some sort of scheme that will supply labour to farmers, who would pay a nominal contribution towards what is not the ordinary work that occurs on the farm, it certainly opens up a vast field of operations, and should be productive of good results.
In dealing with some of the minor relief schemes, especially on roads, it appeared to me that some of the work is not of a useful nature. I am most anxious that any money spent under this Vote should be spent on work of a useful nature. A good deal of the work done is of a useful nature, and money should be more willingly spent there rather than in cases where money is voted as a dole, because that has a demoralising effect on our people. I would like to see the Vote increased under the first head as against the latter. In spending minor relief grants on county roads small patches are done in a half a dozen places, and these patches sometimes only extend a couple of hundred yards. A person running over them with a motor car thinks that when these patches are good a good road may be expected, but he is soon grievously disappointed. When county surveyors give an estimate of the cost of a road or of its maintenance for the coming year, they really cannot give any credit for short lengths, although the local ratepayers have made some contribution towards the cost of their maintenance under an unemployment scheme.
It has been suggested by Deputies that transport should be provided. If it was, instead of doing a hundred yards or three hundred yards, a mile of the road could be done, and in that way some benefit would be conferred on local authorities who make contributions towards these schemes. In order to deal with unemployment, there is no doubt that we will have eventually to get down to the question of transport. If there is a persistent amount of unemployment in certain areas, and if people are asked to contribute towards the benefits being provided while useful work in other areas is neglected, that is a position that can scarcely continue. It is hardly fair to the general community that it should. I do not think the question of providing transport is so difficult. I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary is capable of solving it.
This Estimate has been fairly exhaustively discussed, especially in connection with the subsidising of labour for agriculture. I do not wish to deal with it any further now. With the present stagnant position of agriculture, work of the kind suggested would undoubtedly help to retain workers on the farm. When we consider that within the last four years there has been a reduction in the number of workers employed on agriculture by 43,000, that shows a serious falling off in employment on the land. Some means must be adopted by the State to make it attractive for farmers to give employment on the land. That opens up a vast field for the Parliamentary Secretary, seeing that he has invited suggestions from Deputies towards a solution of the problem.
A good deal has been said about migratory labour to England and Scotland. I know very little about that because I come from an area in which we do not send any workers across to the other side. It has often struck me that we could do, at certain periods of the year, with labour in our district and in the tillage areas of South Kildare, Carlow and Wexford. At certain times, there is a definite want of labour in these districts. One thing that has affected beet-growing and which may make the future of beet-growing problematical is the problem of labour. That is a real problem to the big farmer. The man who grows from 25 to 40 acres of beet finds it a serious problem to obtain labour for that crop, which has to be singled in two or three weeks. During the winter season, imported labour would be very useful to the farmers for the lifting operations. It is generally agreed amongst beet growers that this is a big problem. There is only one solution. You must import labour into these areas from the areas where there is no work.
Deputy Dillon pointed out that migratory labour in England and Scotland, during the harvest and potato-picking seasons, is well paid and well treated. In the beet-growing areas, the wages paid for this work are much higher than the agricultural wage. Payment is generally on a piece-work basis and a man is able to earn, approximately, 10/- per day. In that way, there is some inducement to people to go from districts where work is not available to these districts for singling in spring time, for harvesting operations and, in the winter period, for lifting operations. Farmers, as individuals, cannot solve that problem.
It is a problem which ought to be tackled by the Government and by the Parliamentary Secretary in particular, with the co-operation of the Sugar Company. It has been so tackled in other countries. The sugar companies in other countries have organised labour for the farmers during those periods. If you are going to preserve beet-growing in this country, you must do something to provide labour. I speak as a beet grower, and that is one of the chief obstacles to the signing of contracts by farmers to grow big crops. My problem as a beet grower is to get sufficient labour for singling and lifting.
Comment on this
I was just going on to that, and I was going to suggest that, if possible, the type of men obtainable from the labour exchange should be classified. The farmer does not go to the labour exchange, because he does not get a satisfactory worker. The official in charge of the labour exchange will send men as he meets them on the list, and most of them are unsatisfactory. It would be a good thing if they could be classified. The type of man who is useful in lifting or singling beet is a man with experience of other cereal or root crops. If he has been accustomed to working with turnips or mangolds he does not want any further experience. People living in rural districts have some experience of that sort. Very often, you go to the labour exchange and you get a town worker with little or no experience—a worker who, very often, is not willing to gain the necessary experience. Some of them are willing, but they are unable to become reasonably skilled at the job.
Comment on this
I am interested in the Deputy's problem, but if we were to start to transfer men without a complete register, the same objection would apply to them. There is something in the Deputy's suggestion, but he can see the difficulty.
Comment on this
I see the difficulty. There would be no difficulty as regards the supply of the camp, because the farmer would be quite willing to supply lodging.
Comment on this
The real position is that when the farmer is short of labour he will not apply to the employment exchange to get agricultural labour.
Comment on this
He does not get a satisfactory type of man. He does apply to a limited extent, but you must not forget that, in that area, men are not available at that time. They are not on the register. You will find that, during singling operations, there will be very few men on the Carlow register—scarcely any.
Comment on this
If an agricultural labourer was applied for, an agricultural labourer would be sent.
Comment on this
He would not be available at that particular time in that particular centre. You would not, I think, have an agricultural worker on the Carlow register to-day.
Comment on this
Is not the position that, in all probability, at that particular time a really competent worker would not be available anywhere else?
Comment on this
Yes, but why not do what is being done in other countries? Why not migrate people from the western to the eastern counties instead of having them going across to Scotland or England?
Comment on this
If application is made to a labour exchange for a man of a particular trade or qualification, inquiries are made through the Department of Industry and Commerce in other exchanges, to see if such a man is available. Whether that is so in relation to agricultural labour, I do not know. The difficulty is that they do not apply.
Comment on this
What I suggest is that they should apply and specify the particular kind of labour they want and, roughly, the time they would be prepared to afford employment. It might be possible, then, for the Department of Industry and Commerce to do something in the matter. I am inclined to think they would do something.
Comment on this
If a notice were inserted in the local papers that this type of employment was available at these periods and could be obtained by application to the labour exchange, it would solve the problem.
Comment on this
There are no agricultural workers registering at the labour exchange at these periods.
Comment on this
Not in our area. You would not get an agricultural worker on the Carlow register to-day.
Comment on this
I find in connection with these employment schemes that a great deal of work is being done in certain districts, and that no work is being done in other districts. That is, I suppose, because there are no unemployed registered in those districts. I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to look into that proposal of providing transport for bringing men from districts where there is no work to districts where there is work. I know of a few cases where work is being done, and I know of three or four districts in Westmeath where the Department are looking for new works and for the last two or three years these are the only districts where a new work has been done, whereas there are a lot of other districts where nothing has been done. I should like the Parliamentary Secretary to look into that matter and try to arrange for the transport of men to those parts of the county where any work is being done.
Another matter to which I should like to refer is that there is quite a number of lakes in County Westmeath, around the neighbourhood of Castlepollard and Mullingar, and you could absorb quite a number of people in employment if you were to make a road around that district. It would mean that it would bring a lot of people to the district, apart from the employment that would be given. That applies to both sides of Mullingar, both to Lough Derravaragh as well as to Loch Owell and Loch Ennel, and the neighbourhood of the Crooked Wood, where there is some of the loveliest scenery that could be found anywhere, and where there are already old roads which, if they were remade, would add to the amenities of the district; and the remaking of these roads would give a lot of employment in the district. It would not cost a lot of money to make proper motor roads for three or four miles around that district, and it would be very useful work.
Now, as I have mentioned Mullingar, I should like to say that there is a very bad case there from the unemployment point of view. I was with a parish priest and other people who were in touch with the situation there and they told me that the position in Mullingar is desperate. Again, I would like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary to look into the suggestion of making a road around the district of Lough Owell and Loch Ennel—for about two miles from Mullingar—and I can assure him that it would absorb a lot of the unemployed. The same applies to the other side of Mullingar, around about Loch Derravaragh and the Castlepollard district.
Now, I should like to refer to the matter of footpaths in that district. The roads have been steam-rolled right to the sides, with the result that people going to, or coming from, Mass on Sunday, run the risk of being run over by motor cars, because the road is steam-rolled practically to the ditches. Long ago, these footpaths were made by the county councils, and I hold that they should be remade and footpaths provided. That would be useful work and would help to absorb the unemployed. Another suggestion I should like to make—I think I heard Deputy Hughes mention it—would be to give some help to the farmers, by way of a grant, that would enable them to absorb some of the unemployed on their farms in clearing the farms of furze, bushes and so on. It would be very useful work and I suggest that, if you gave a grant—something in the nature of the grant that was given for the improvement of houses—it would enable the farmers to give very useful employment. There are hundreds and hundreds of acres covered with furze, bushes, and so on, and if a farmer were to get a grant of two-thirds or half, and let him employ these men through the employment exchanges, that would be good and useful work for the country, would bring into use a lot of land that is not being used, and would give quite an amount of employment.
There is another matter to which I should like to refer. In the district of Dysart, in Westmeath, there are two or three lanes in a very bad way. Now, it happens that in some of these districts there are only three or four or five unemployed in a particular district for the last year or two, and the result is that these men that I have in mind cannot get employment because there is not a sufficient number of unemployed in the district. The representatives of the various Parties, the Fianna Fáil representatives and the representatives of my Party, have been trying to get something done in this matter for the last few years, but nothing has been done because there is not enough people unemployed in the district. The district to which I refer is only about three miles from Mullingar, and I suggest that if you had a lorry to transport these men, it would not cost very much. There are two or three districts where that problem arises.
With regard to the matter, to which I have already referred, of the making of roads, in the neighbourhood of the lakes near Mullingar and Castlepollard, I feel sure that that would absorb a large number of the unemployed, and it is also work that could be done in all weathers. A couple of hundred pounds would go a long way in that direction, and if that were done, not alone would it be an attraction for tourists, but it would also go a long way towards keeping people there who would otherwise go to the seaside in the summer time. There is some of the loveliest scenery there and, if some attempt were made to provide proper roads, people would go there and there could even be swimming places made. Employment would be encouraged and it would also encourage the people already there to stay in the neighbourhood. Again, I would impress on the Parliamentary Secretary that he should take into account my suggestion of giving grants to the farmers to enable them to employ labour to stub the furze, because there are hundreds and hundreds of acres of land covered with furze and bushes where good work could be done in that direction. My suggestion is that something could be done in that way, somewhat similar to what was done in connection with providing grants for the building or improvement of houses in the country, where the farmer would provide some of the money and the Government provide the rest. These are all the recommendations I have to make.
Comment on this
I should like to say a word upon this Vote, because this problem of unemployment is the most serious in the country. I think it will be admitted that there has been a complete failure with regard to trying to solve that problem here for a number of years past. The position is that a sum of about £1,500,000 was voted and spent last year on unemployment and the same was allocated this year, while for unemployment insurance and unemployment assistance a sum of about £1,250,000 was expended last year. That means that about £2,750,000 was spent on unemployment, and yet the people who are receiving this money are anything but well off. It must be admitted, therefore, that the whole scheme is a failure and I hold that something must be done to devise a better scheme—a general scheme—to relieve unemployment in this country. I have referred to this matter on previous occasions. Some kind of scheme for finding employment in rural districts should be devised—for finding employment for the people on the land. I think that if the Parliamentary Secretary were to take a trip down the country—as, I suppose, he does from time to time— he would see that the country is overflowing with water and rushes, from the lack of proper drainage, with derelict hedges, and everything else. There is plenty of work to be done, but the trouble is that no scheme has been devised by which the money could be spent to the advantage of the people that would get employment, the advantage of the country as a whole, and the advantage of the individuals that would give the employment. It should not be impossible to devise some scheme that would benefit all these three parties.
I think it must be admitted now that if the farmers are not to gain something by subsidised labour—and they are certainly in need of it—they must get relief in one direction or another. The unemployed need relief, and we are spending this sum of £2,750,000, which should go a long way towards giving relief to both, and also improving both the wealth and the look of the country. The difficulty is to devise a scheme, and I think that there is now a good opportunity to do so at a time when the Agricultural Commission is sitting. I hope that the Parliamentary Secretary will take an interest in this matter, and ask the Agricultural Commission to try to devise some sort of workable scheme that would give employment in the rural districts where there is always work to be done, and where, at the same time, there is a shortage of labour notwithstanding the numbers that are registered as unemployed. Deputy Hickey this evening disagreed with Deputy Dillon when he made that remark, but I know for a fact that there is a general shortage of labour in the rural districts, both in spring and harvest; and in some districts people are unemployed. Despite that, people do not like to become informers. The farmers will not inform on the people who are not working, but the thing is going on nevertheless. Every Deputy on these benches knows that it is so. We all know it. We know that, whether individually or in crowds, the thing is done, and it must be met; but you cannot induce the farmers to inform on these people because they are not doing their duty as citizens. The farmers will not do that, but I hold that there should be some scheme devised that would put the onus upon these people to go to work.
I do not suggest that particular scheme. I have heard schemes suggested here. They might be suitable for a particular season or district. I would not think it wise to fix upon a hard and fast scheme that might work well in one district and not in others. It might lead to a great deal of wastage from the point of view of supervision. The smallest amount of money possible should be spent on supervision. The aim should be to give, if possible, a 100 per cent. of the money allocated to the workers.
During the past couple of years they have a very good scheme operating during the winter months in the Six Counties. The farmers are directed by a Government inspector who marks out certain work that is to be done, such as cleaning hedges, clearing whins, cleaning drains and improving the land generally. The farmers are authorised to take in one, two, three or four men, the farmer acting as their employer and ganger. He pays them a minimum wage of about 23/- a week. The Government makes a refund of from 18/- to 20/- to the farmer, so that his actual outlay only amounts to a few shillings a week for each man employed. The scheme has succeeded in bringing about a great improvement in what used to be inferior land, that it would not pay a farmer to improve out of his own resources. The scheme is bringing a lot of land into benefit that would otherwise go derelict.
You have the same condition of things prevailing all over the country. At the present time, having regard to the value of agricultural produce and the cost of labour, there is a lot of land in this country going out of production altogether. It is only by the adoption of a scheme such as this that this land can be kept in production. If one looks through the country at the present time, notwithstanding all the propaganda that we have and the big expenditure on it to grow more wheat, one would imagine that the slogan that had gone forth was "to grow more rushes." Certainly we have more rushes being grown than ever before. They are the most plentiful crop we have. It is impossible for the struggling farmer to keep his land clear of them. He has not the money to improve his land as it ought to be improved. We are spending on the schemes under discussion a sum of in or about £2,750,000. If, instead of spending that money on unemployment assistance and employment schemes, a beginning were to be made by devoting a part of it to help those who are in employment at whatever wage they can get, I think the Government would be putting it to a very good purpose. It could be applied towards making up the difference between a living wage and an economic wage for those men. It is that sort of a scheme that is wanted in the country.
Comment on this
Yes, and who is providing this £2,750,000 for unemployment assistance and the other schemes?
Comment on this
Under these schemes you have men getting 6/- and 7/- a week. If, instead of giving them that and keeping them idle, the farmer was given assistance and enabled to employ them on the lines that men are being employed on the land in the Six-County scheme, would it not be much better for the country than what we have at present? This unemployment evil is growing from year to year, and the question is, where is it going to end? It is a question that will have to be faced up to sooner or later, and something will have to be done about it. The Parliamentary Secretary asked for suggestions for dealing with it some years ago. He got some, but he did not take any notice of them. I admit that it is not an easy thing to work out a scheme, but I suggest that the present time is opportune, when we have an Agricultural Commission sitting to make a fresh effort to get a workable scheme that will provide employment for the people. There is no need to have any able-bodied young man, especially unmarried men, in rural districts unemployed. There is an abundance of work for them, particularly in the poorer districts where, owing to lack of attention, much of the land is going derelict.
The whole trouble is to find a scheme that will be workable. Deputy Belton wants to know where the money is to come from to finance it. If he speaks on this Vote, I hope he will tell us who is paying the industrial producers in this country the 60, 70 or 75 per cent. extra that they are getting for their products. Is not the consumer paying it? Are not the taxpayers generally who consume their goods paying it, and are they not also paying the labour that is employed in these industries? What is wrong, therefore, with the principle of paying something to the farmers, especially when we remember that the farmers and farm workers are paying their share to the industrialists, the profiteers, and to every other class. Is it not time to recognise that there should be justice and fair play all round, and that if agriculture is paying its share to industry, that, in return, industry should pay its share to agriculture? Would it not be much better if we had some scheme such as I speak of in operation rather than be demoralising the people by maintaining them in idleness? When they are idle temptations will come in their way and many will find mischievous work to do. Surely able-bodied young people would be better off earning 25/- or 28/- a week than to be idle and trying to live on 6/- or 7/—on the dole—or on rotation schemes.
We have plenty of precedents for encouraging people to give employment, and there will be nothing wrong in encouraging the farmers to give employment by the State paying part of the workers' wages.
We have the Minister for Local Government and Public Health encouraging the county councils, as Deputy Belton knows, to spend more money in order to give employment. They do that by offering so much of a grant to local bodies on condition that these put up much more. Would it not be as well for the State to offer so much if these people find employment—to add so much to the wages—and instead of giving a few shillings a week for going idle to add a few shillings to the wages the farmers give to the labourers? I think this is the best solution of the unemployment problem. If some such scheme could be devised by the Agricultural Commission, it would, I think, be the most important work to which it could set itself. The Parliamentary Secretary should interest himself in this matter and ask the Agricultural Commission to give its most careful consideration to this suggestion.
Comment on this
I was surprised to hear advocated in this House for the relief of unemployment a policy which is really increasing unemployment at an accelerated pace. This Government was elected seven years ago with a plan to cure unemployment. Unemployment is worse now than it was then. There is no denying that. Agriculture, housing, transport and pretty well every phase of the economic life of this country is in a worse position now than then and the Government are making time through commissions to see what they will do. Every plan the Government had seems to have miscarried. It is now suggested to subsidise farm labour. I employ 20 or 30 farm labourers. If there is going to be a subsidy for them do you think I will keep them in continuous employment as at present? Of course not. I am going to work for the subsidy. Is it not a terrible commentary on the Government, after seven years in office, and supported as they are by a majority that perhaps no Government in Europe for the past seven years has commanded, to find to-day that the staple industry of this country is not a profitable concern?
I agree with Deputy McGovern that help should be given to agriculture. But I hold that agriculture, as the staple industry of this country, should be on a sound, paying, economic basis. No nation can be sound unless its agricultural life is on a sound basis. What else is to support any nation but its agricultural industry? It is greater than all the others put together and if this industry, with a majority over all the others, is not on a paying basis how can the others which can only exist and grow by the profits of the agricultural industry be on a sound basis? I am afraid this country at the present time is in a more precarious condition than is appreciated. Men are being paid miserable pittances on the dole. Are there any brains in the Government Party to devise some scheme which will give work for money instead of money for nothing? It is not so much the loss of the money to the State as the demoralisation of thousands of the young manhood and young womanhood, entering into man's estate every year, young people who have never done a day's work. If that is to continue for another seven or ten years we will have by the thousand people in this country in the prime of life who never did a day's work and never will. That is facing us if this is allowed to continue.
Go through the country, look across the hedges and you see rushes growing everywhere. Why are they allowed to grow? If this Government were alive to the agricultural and health needs of the country they would make it a penal offence to have dead water in any ditch. I do not say that their policy should be the subsidisation of labour by the cleaning up of ditches. Their policy should be—and it should be a signal for the Minister for Agriculture—that if agriculture is not able to pay for the cleaning up of ditches, then agriculture is not on a paying basis and it is time he looked to his job. I am against subsidising agricultural labour because agriculture should be able to pay labour. It is a proof of the failure of the policy of the Minister for Agriculture that he has not given agriculture a policy and put it on a paying basis so as to be able to pay a living wage to its workers.
Deputy McGovern's argument is sound at the starting-point but I do not follow his reasoning. Agriculture is taxed to maintain other industries and to build them up. Of course the Government did not take heed of the warnings that were given years ago when they set out on an economic war and made agriculture pay for it. Concurrently with that economic war we had the setting-up of an industrial revival and made agriculture pay for it. The result has been agricultural bankruptcy. What is the stability behind that industrial revival and the £10,000,000 that we gave on the surrender in the economic war?
Throughout the country there is plenty of work. There is the reclamation of land, the improvement and the clearing away of rocky land. In some cases powder, dynamite, and gelignite were used for blasting. This might be made of some use to the country in the giving of employment. The main drainage of the country should be done by the Government. Agriculture should be put on such a basis that it would be a paying proposition for the owners of the land to reclaim their wet land into the main drainage systems made by the Government. There are in the country hundreds and thousands of acres under furze. This could be stubbed out. Again, if agriculture were on a paying basis it would pay the owners of that furzy land to stub the furze out of it. Here in Dublin we have had a lot of talk about the Blue Lagoon. We have out in Dollymount and at the Bull Wall, out by Sutton, a large area that could be reclaimed. We have here thousands of acres of land that at low tide is dry land. At high tide it is flooded. Why does not our Government devise a scheme for the reclamation of that area? Why not build a wall from Dollymount to Sutton and reclaim all inside that wall? A little scheme was carried out by the Dublin Corporation along the Clontarf sea wall. They were tricking about it for a good while. Then they got a machine over from Holland. I do not know what its name is. That machine sucks the stuff out of the bed of the Liffey and dumps it in to fill up the space behind. In the County Dublin there is the village of Rush. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government and Public Health lives there now and again and he knows the place. Some land there was reclaimed from the sea in the same way. It is the best possible kind of land for market gardening. Again, we have at low tide thousands of acres uncovered by water out near Blackrock.
Why should there not be an effort made to reclaim that from the sea? It is possible in Holland and it is possible here. We have a boxing team competing in the amateur European contest this week. Why do not we as a nation compete in the European contest for the reclamation of the land? Why do we not enter the ring with Holland and show that we are as good in reclaiming land from the sea as the Dutch are? How many thousands of men would be absorbed in doing this? It would not be profitable. It would not pay anybody to do it, but it would pay and State to have men employed on that work when the principle is adopted, with which the whole House agrees, that there should be maintenance or work for the workers. Give them maintenance but give them work. It would be quite easy—not quite easy, but possible—to devise schemes of public works and keep men permanently employed on them. Any man that finds himself unemployed or disemployed should not be allowed to remain unemployed. Machinery should be available—and it is quite possible to devise such machinery—where he could go and report to the nearest post-office or the nearest Gárda barracks and there get a voucher which would take him to public works for the unemployed inhabitants of his particular area. No attempt whatever has been made to do that.
Deputy McGovern referred to £2,750,000. What about the millions that are paid out by the local authorities and boards of assistance, in many cases to able-bodied unemployed men? I do not think that the unemployment problem has been tackled at all in a serious way. People who knew nothing about agriculture shouted about wheat and peat and pigs a few years ago. I heard the other day that the peat scheme in Carbury died a natural death a few days ago. I hope I am wrong, but I am afraid I am not. Wheat, instead of being operated according to all the rules of the game of sound competent agriculture, developed into wheat ranching. No employment at all was given in it.
Comment on this
Except from the point of view of its being a medium of employment and a means by which employment could be increased. It was advocated here time and time again to rip up the land and sow wheat.
Comment on this
Yes, but the boys who made the flour got the plums, not the fellows who went to rip up the land. There was no employment created there. There was, in fact, less employment, for there is less employment in a field of wheat than in a field of grass or meadow. I wonder will the Parliamentary Secretary or his colleague, the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Hugo Flinn, contradict that? I know a little on this subject, perhaps as much as the two Parliamentary Secretaries combined. Instead of giving employment, they grew more wheat and the robbery of the land went on.
Comment on this
That is surely a matter for the Minister for Agriculture. The title of this Vote is "Employment Schemes".
Comment on this
Employment schemes to relieve unemployment, I presume. That is the purpose of all the schemes that are put up to us in the local bodies, and if there were no unemployment there would be no employment schemes or unemployment schemes, whichever you like to call them. But, with all the devices for increasing employment and absorbing the unemployed, without sending any ship across the briny to bring back the exiles, the unemployment figures are going up. I suppose most of the unemployment in the country exists around Dublin, and I would suggest the reclamation of land from the sea. That is, instead of having a wide, lazy, rambling old estuary out to Howth, we should have a narrow, navigable channel, with, perhaps, a deep-water port at Howth. That work would absorb a lot of the unemployed. If we have to continue the dole, it should be money for work done and we would have some return for the money, but the best of all returns that we would get would be that we would keep men working instead of having them loafing.
I am afraid that the present position is the greatest indictment of the Government's policy and effort since it came to power. I see no hope of improvement if nothing better can be done than is suggested by Deputy McGovern, that is, to hire the unemployed out to farmers and let the farmer pay them perhaps 5/- or 6/- a week, the State to make up the difference between that and the living wage. It is assumed that 5/- or 6/- would be an economic wage to do work that will not be reproductive perhaps in this generation. If that is the position, agriculture would not be able to pay any more for it and the State is to come along and make up the difference between the weekly allowance the farmer would be able to pay and what would be a living wage. That would be some way of doing it, but does it not suggest at once bankruptcy of economic policy? Are we not able to put our industries and our agriculture on an economic basis, so that both will pay a living wage and that both will expand and that, in the ordinary development of both agriculture and industry, we would be able to absorb the unemployed and the youth that are growing up to manhood and womanhood? That is the problem before the country and if the Government is not able to face up to that problem it is confessing failure. They have not been able to solve that problem and maintain that position since they took office. Therefore, the Government has failed and the present depression in the position of the labour market, agriculture, building, transport and every phase of the economic life of this country is the greatest possible indictment of the present Government. It marks their failure. It is time we got out of this thing of unemployment schemes, palliatives, soup kitchens, etc., and tackled agriculture and industry as the two-armed nation, to which we heard such lip service from the other side, and show that these two arms are fully developed and that they can absorb labour. If our Government is not able to do that, what is the reason for it?
Can you not produce more in agriculture and, by producing more, employ more people and pay them a living wage? Does the Government say we cannot? They must say it, because they have failed to develop agriculture. Then let them look at industry. I am as interested personally in industry as I am in agriculture, and I am not going to argue one against the other. Labour, too, makes the boast now and again that certain classes of industrial labour are better paid in this country than in other parts of these Kingdoms. Is agriculture as well paid? We hear a lot about the flight from the land and a lot of people sitting in armchairs in the cities are offering cures for it. The one cure is to provide a decent living on the land. We never found country life dull, but we left it because we were crushed out of it economically and the youth of to-day will not stay there at a miserable wage. We probably pay a higher wage in industry here than is paid across the water but that is made possible through a tax on agriculture through the medium of tariffs. The price of agricultural produce cannot go up, however, because the price is regulated and governed by the price we get on the British market. Consequently, agriculture is not able to pay a wage here higher than in Great Britain, and agriculture is taxed to pay the high industrial prices because of tariff policy here. I am not taking up that line to argue against tariffs, but to show the difficulties of the problem and to show the ill-thought policy which rushed forward to make this country an industrial country in a couple of years. It is because of that accelerated industrial policy that it is impossible to solve the problem of unemployment which the Government thought could be solved by tariffs.
The acid test is: have they absorbed the unemployed in profitable agriculture or in profitable industry? There is no other way to cure unemployment. I put this to the Parliamentary Secretary and I challenge contradiction. He will not find a county surveyor in Ireland who will not tell him that the grant for unemployment would have been better given away to the unemployed for nothing, rather than try to put the unemployed doing work which it would be cheaper for the ratepayers to do themselves with money raised by the rates. I think that was the conclusion reached at the last or second last Conference of County Surveyors held in Dublin. I can speak with authority for the County Surveyor of County Dublin when I say that a healthy development of agriculture and of industry is the only cure for unemployment. In both these two spheres the Government has failed and it is time they put up some policy for these two economic arms. The Government is failing to absorb all the workers into healthy agriculture and into healthy industry, and I think that schemes should be formulated—even for draining the Bog of Allen, digging canals through it, or for reclaiming mountain slopes or for the main drainage of land; but have public works continuously going on, so that any man who finds himself unemployed, instead of going to the board of assistance to get relief, may go to a post office or a Gárda barrack and there get a voucher that will take him to a place where he will get Government work, and let him stay there until he can be absorbed in agriculture or in industry in the ordinary way. If this is not done, a time must inevitably come when we will all be unemployed, because the person who is producing nothing must be living on the production of somebody who is working. The more you have idle the heavier the dead weight that industry and agriculture have to carry, the heavier the overhead charges, the millions that we are paying for the various forms of assistance without any return. These millions would not have to be put up for unemployment if we had unemployed producing in the ordinary way. So that there is a very serious problem and the only cure for the ills that exist at present is to keep those ills from developing.
I would be interested to hear the Parliamentary Secretary, when he is replying, tell us what is going to be done for the cure of unemployment, which is what the House should address itself to and not to mere palliatives to keep that army of unemployed going. Surely a time must come when we must find a cure. I have followed this matter from year to year in the seasonal debates, but apparently the attention of the House is devoted to considerations as to how to carry the load of unemployment instead of how to effect its cure. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will find some means to prevent our unemployed remaining in idleness.
Comment on this
Ní raibh de rún agam labhairt or an gceist seo anocht ach i mo cheanntar fhéin bhí galar imeasc na ndaoine bochta, agus tá fhios agam gur thug an Rialtas seo obair mhaith do na daoine sin faoi'n scéim seo, ach tá fhios agam nach maith leis na daoine saidhbhre go bhfuigheadh na daoine bochta an t-airgead le saothrú. Ní raibh leigheas ar bith le fáil acu ón dream eile a bhí ag stiúradh sa Teach seo ach tá fhios againn go bhfuil an obair sin do na daoine bochta le fáil anois agus airgead ina theannta sin, buidheachas le Dia. Bhí an Teachta Belton ag labhairt ar an sgéal seo agus ó thosach go deire, ní raibj as a bhéal ach ag fáil locht ar na daoine atá ag stiúradh sa Teach seo.
An dream eile a bhí ag stiuradh, dubhairt siad nach raibh orra obair do sholáthair do na daoine bochta agus go leighfí dhóibh bás fháil le ocras ach faoi'n dream atá ag stiúradh anois, buidheachas le Dia, tá sé le rá go bhfuil obair le fáil acu. Níl morán blianta ó shoin ann ó tháinic mise sa Teach seo agus annsin ní raibh morán á dhéanamh ar son na ndaoine bochta. D'imthigh an lá sin, agus tá sé imthighthe go deo sa tír seo, le congnamh Dé. Tá obair le fáil anois ag na daoine bochta, is cuma cé'n dream a leanann siad. Tá mé cinnte go bhfuil go leor airgid anois do lucht oibre agus na feilméaraí beaga sa tír seo. Níor b'iad na feilméaraí móra, ach b'iad na feilméaraí beaga, a chur an Rialtas seo faoi réim, agus déanfaidh an Rialtas seo a ndicheall ar son na bhfeilméaraí agus ar son lucht oibre na tíre seo. Chó fhad agus tá an Rialtas seo ag stiúradh annseo, beidh siad sásta níos mó airgid agus níos mó oibre do na daoine.
Comment on this
During this debate we have heard a good deal on the question of unemployment and we have heard various theories advanced as to the cause of unemployment. I think that while it is right to pay due attention to the unemployment in agricultural vocations, there is also a good deal of unemployment in the cities and towns. We were told by various Deputies of the unsuitability of the town worker for work on the land. It would be interesting to get from the Parliamentary Secretary the numbers of unemployed amongst town and rural workers. There is no doubt that work on the land is skilled work, and in many cases very skilled work. The town worker, on account of his training and experience as a town worker, is not suitable for skilled agricultural work. I remember, and everybody in the House remembers, that in 1932, when the present Government were seeking office, they proclaimed from platforms, by posters and through the Press, that they had a plan to abolish unemployment in this country. Their leading spokesmen told the people up and down the country that there was no necessity for unemployment in this country; that with its undeveloped resources and its potentialities it was quite within the capacity of any Government who really tackled the problem of unemployment to solve it. I remember during that time we were told that by setting up industries in this country to produce the things that were required here instead of importing them we could absorb many hundreds, if not thousands, of our unemployed in the cities and towns. The plan put forward was that we were importing so many thousand pairs of boots, and that by making those at home we could definitely absorb so many—I think the figure was stated— of the unemployed in that industry. The same was put forward with regard to the wollen industry, and other industries. We were told that the great solution of unemployment was to start industries here at home. Probably the people who said that believed in it, and were quite sincere in their claims, but they did not count on the reactions to their plan.
They put on tariffs; they prohibited certain goods being imported, and gave carte blanche to the industrialist to start his factory and get on with the production of the goods here at home. The industrialists, being given a free hand, without any conditions as to the number who were to be employed or the conditions on which their employment was to operate, immediately set about exercising their own sweet will. The first thing was that very modern machinery, in fact machinery that is usually styled labour-saving machinery, was installed. The installation of labour-saving machinery, of course, meant that they could do without a certain amount of human labour in producing their goods. Instead of male adult labour—which I assume was visualised in the plan of 1932— being employed, very often female labour or even juvenile labour was employed, so that when this plan of 1932, which theoretically seemed to be all right, was worked out in practice, it was found that the unemployed were not absorbed. I will give a case in point. In my constituency there was a small factory which manufactured a very special type of blanket at a place called Sally brook, about six miles from the City of Cork. That little factory has specialised in that type of manufacture over a long period of years, for generations. The proprietor of that factory was also engaged in similar production in other factories— in a woollen mill at Dripsey and, I understand, a woollen mill in Kilkenny. His interests were divided over a very large area, and he got the idea that by concentrating the manufacture of blankets at Dripsey, or attempting to do so, he could cut down his overhead charges, lessen his costs, and incidentally increase the profits. When that plan was worked out it meant that the 70 workers in that factory at Sallybrook were disemployed and the factory was closed down. It was not a question of increased costs as far as the people there were concerned. The wages which were paid in that factory were not in any way of an exorbitant character.
The factory had employed several members of a family and, although wages were not in any way high, they were sufficient when they were grouped to keep the family in decent circumstances. The business was transferred to the other factory in Dripsey, and in some fashion the production of those blankets goes on there. What I want to point out is this, that when this plan of 1932 was being evolved there should have been definite conditions laid down in the industrialist to compel him, in his manufacture, to serve the interests of the community rather than, as in many cases, to make a big rake-off for himself. If it had been a condition that that little rural industry would have to be kept going, there is no reason why it should not be kept going, except because of the greed of the industrialist who ran the factory. That is a case in point.
Comment on this
What I am afraid about with regard to what the Deputy is saying is that I cannot see what it has to do with employment schemes, and that is the matter under discussion. I may be entirely wrong, but I am afraid the Deputy has not related his statement to that.
Comment on this
If you will allow me to develop my statement, I want to point out that the whole trouble with employment schemes is that they are only being put up as a palliative, a substitute, for what was intended to be employment schemes in the sense of permanent remunerative employment. I am discussing the position that was put before us when the present Government had their plan in 1932. I am giving them credit for their sincerity and honesty of purpose in connection with that plan, but there were certain things that should have been done then that were not done and, as a result, we are now back to the position that we have to rely altogether on those employment schemes, major and minor, in order to make good the want of consideration for the problem as a whole which was put before us in 1932.
Employment schemes, to the mind of any reasoning person, would mean that they are schemes of employment to give permanent remunerative work to people able and willing to work. That is not being done under the present employment schemes. We have what is known now as rotational schemes of employment. That is the best the Government can do. I must say the Parliamentary Secretary is doing his best under the circumstances. We are told that the money is not there for big schemes of employment, and the Parliamentary Secretary told us yesterday that, even with the money, the difficulty arising now is to find schemes of employment. That is really scratching the surface of the problem, because these little schemes of £100 or £200 here and there will not in any way contribute a permanent solution to our unemployment problem.
It is the duty of the Parliamentary Secretary, who is directly interested in this matter and is, I am sure, charged by the Government to a great extent with the solution of unemployment, to turn his attention to the cities and towns, where there are in many of the factories girls and juveniles employed rather than adult labour. It is within the competence of the Government, with the powers they have, to insist on a certain proportion of adult male labour being employed. The Parliamentary Secretary admitted yesterday that, even with the best intentions, the schemes of employment with which he is now dealing are running out and that he does not conceive of any big schemes which will have a big labour content in order to carry on even this palliative. The time is coming when the resources of the Parliamentary Secretary, great and all as they are, will not be sufficient to carry on even those schemes.
During the coming year £1,500,000 will be expended on such schemes and, with the contributions from the local authorities of £300,000, almost £2,000,000 will be expended. But he tells us that the schemes will not be there and the money cannot be expended. That means that even those schemes will not continue for an indefinite period, that they cannot continue. What does the Parliamentary Secretary suggest should be done when he is bankrupt of ideas as far as this kind of work is concerned?
I suggest he should turn his attention to the industries, have them overhauled and see that a certain proportion of male adult labour be employed. I say very advisedly that where labour-saving machinery is being installed in order to do away with labour—so-called labour-saving machinery—it should be a condition that so many people disemployed would be maintained at the expense of the machine. If the question of unemployment is to be tackled seriously it must be taken in a big way. These employment schemes are mere palliatives in comparison with the big jobs that could be done in the country.
There is the other question which has been fairly well debated here, and that is the employment that can be found in agricultural vocations. There are all over the country, in rural areas, large numbers of unemployed able and willing to work and they cannot get it except on those schemes. That is particularly true around city areas. I am speaking with some knowledge of the conditions obtaining around the City of Cork. There you have the system that the city rates of wages are being paid quite convenient to the city on building schemes and other work of that kind. If one of the minor relief schemes is started nearby, the wages paid there will be 27/6 a week, immediately making a very odious comparison with the scales paid to the men on building work. These labourers have been working side by side in different parts of the country.
I drew the attention of the Parliamentary Secretary to a case that occurred in Little Island, where county council roadmen, who were paid 35/- a week, were working side by side with men on a minor relief scheme. The men working on the scheme were doing work that in ordinary times would be done by county council men, but because it is not so classified and is regarded only as a minor relief scheme they were paid 27/6 a week, and even with that they were getting only three or four days' work in the week. The men were satisfied to work at 27/6 a week if they could get a guarantee of a full week's work. That was not given to them, although when the case came before the Court of Referees, which I attended, the deputy surveyor told me he could have given these men a full week's work but he was precluded by the regulations under which they were working, the regulations of the Board of Works, to tell the men that fact, that they could get a week's work.
This question of minor and major relief schemes, especially in those areas around cities, will cause a good deal of trouble. That was only one of two or three cases we have where men working side by side were getting different rates. One section of them was getting far higher wages and better conditions and that was the cause of a great deal of trouble. As I said already, that is not the type of employment that we visualised or that the people of the country, I am sure, visualised when they were told that this Government had a plan for abolishing unemployment. Even with the position as it is, with the position of agriculture as it is, and with the resources of the country undeveloped as they are, I think that the Parliamentary Secretary could turn his attention to the question of relieving unemployment and abolishing unemployment in rural areas by big schemes of work of national importance. Many suggestions have been made, and these suggestions afford plenty of room for schemes that could be operated successfully from a national point of view.
There is reclamation, for instance, to be carried out. I am informed that in County Kerry alone there are 200,000 acres of land that could be reclaimed. That work would absorb a good many unemployed men for a long period. We shall be told, on the one hand, that the money is not there, and, on the other hand, that such work is beyond the capacity of the Department which we are discussing. I say that there is a good deal of reclamation that can be done all over the country. I am only giving one instance that has been brought to my notice, where 200,000 acres can be reclaimed in County Kerry. That work would relieve the congested districts in that area instead of its being necessary to migrate people to Meath, Kildare, and other counties.
Then the question of drainage was referred to. There are many big schemes of drainage which should be carried out. I am going to suggest, and to suggest very seriously, that the money could and should be found for those schemes of drainage. There is also the question of afforestation. The Parliamentary Secretary's colleague in the representation of Cork City is very keen on this subject. I am with him in that keenness, and I think his arguments are correct.
Comment on this
I am afraid the question of afforestation cannot be brought within this Vote. I think there is special Vote for it.
Comment on this
What I am trying to suggest is that there are ways by which employment schemes can be provided other than through the palliatives put up by the Board of Works, the Parliamentary Secretary and the Government. I am suggesting seriously that this is another big scheme to which the Government could attend and in which thousands of people could be usefully engaged. Very detailed attention has been given to these questions of afforestation, reclamation and drainage. If the Parliamentary Secretary finds himself bankrupt as regards those schemes with which he has been dealing—4,500 of them all over the country —I would suggest very seriously that he should turn his attention to this side of the picture and he would see that, along those lines, there is important national work to be done. I am putting forward these suggestions in all sincerity. I am not putting them forward for the purpose of detracting from what the Parliamentary Secretary tried to do. I know he has a very difficult job, but I will say that with all his earnestness he is not in any way solving the problem of unemployment. This system of rotational work is simply exploiting the unemployed. Simply because they are unemployed, they are to be kept on these schemes year in, year out, as a class apart from the ordinary workers of the country. That is not fair to the unemployed. It is through no fault of their own that they are unemployed, but because they are unemployed they are to be segregated and kept on this form of work instead of an effort being made to bring them back into useful employment.
I should like, as I am on this question of unemployment, to say one word with regard to what the trade union movement has contributed towards a solution of this problem.
Comment on this
Does that question really come within this discussion? I do not want to widen the discussion unduly. The subject is one that is open to a very wide interpretation, but I think the Deputy is going a little beyond the limits when he tries to go into trade unionism. I shall hear the Deputy for a minute or two.
Comment on this
What I wanted to say was that a Minister in this House quite recently charged the trade unions with neglecting this question of unemployment, ignoring it and, as a matter of fact, doing nothing to contribute towards its solution. I want to suggest and the Parliamentary Secretary is probably aware of it, that the Trade Union Congress, year after year, have put up constructive suggestions with regard to unemployment plans. They have gone to the Taoiseach with their plans and discussed them with him. They have gone to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Even after the second last Congress they wanted again to interview the Minister and the reply they got was that no useful purpose could be served by that interview. If the Government, the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary has a plan, as they said they had, for abolishing unemployment, let them put it forward. Let them tell us what it is and I am sure they will get the support of every member of the House in the implementation of that plan. The only solution they have got is these unemployment schemes.
The Parliamentary Secretary also said that while he was running short of ideas with regard to employment schemes he would be very glad to get schemes. I have another scheme from one very small portion of my constituency, that is, the portion down in Crosshaven. Discussing the position down there with the county surveyor recently, he told me of schemes he had in mind and that I think were put before the Board of Works. One was the construction of a road along by the bay in Crosshaven. Another was the taking over of the old Blackrock and Passage railway and constructing a bye-pass road on it. There is a sharp turn going into the village of Crosshaven and the suggestion was made that the road should be widened there for the benefit of traffic.
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy knows very well that money voted under this Estimate could not be applied to schemes which are ordinary road maintenance or road improvement schemes for which the county council is responsible.
Comment on this
You have misunderstood me, Sir. These are suggestions, a list of works, put up to the Board of Works by the county surveyor. I understand that the Board of Works asked the various officials connected with county councils and borough councils for schemes of work which they suggested should be done under these employment schemes. These are some of the things that the county surveyor in Cork put up to the county council. I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that if his schemes are running out there are many schemes in that part of the country which could be tackled and which have been put up already. The approximate cost of these schemes has been given by the engineers and officials concerned and they could be usefully done.
I wish, however, to emphasise the fact that, so far as we in this part of the House are concerned, we are not at all satisfied with this rotational system of employment. These minor relief schemes and other things will not make any useful contribution to the solution of the unemployment problem. The position is not in any way being improved. The unemployment figures are increasing week by week. I often wonder what would be the position of unemployment in this country but for the outlet we have in emigration. Many thousands of people have left this country in the last ten years. If these had remained here and added to the roll of unemployment, look at the position we would have then.
There is also another very serious aspect of the problem, that every year from 40,000 to 50,000 young people leave school when they reach the school-leaving age, and there is no possible way of absorbing them in employment. It has been suggested very seriously that the school-leaving age should be raised in order to keep these children off the labour market, because some of them are taken into blind alley occupations which are not in any way helpful to them in their future life. On the other hand, many of these children have never done a day's work of any kind as there is no outlet for them. That problem is growing and the country does not seem to realise the importance of it. The result is that you have cases like those reported in the papers, where in cities and towns you have regular gangs of young men being formed for the purposes of crime. That is another very serious aspect of the unemployment problem and is one that I think should come within the scope of the Parliamentary Secretary's Department.
When children reach the age of 14 they can be registered at the labour exchange for employment. Thousands of these children register year after year, but the number who get employment would not reach many hundreds. The unemployment problem is, therefore, one that will certainly have to be tackled in a much more serious fashion than it is being tackled by the Government. I wish to repeat that the rotational schemes and the other unemployment schemes are simply a palliative that will not have any far-reaching effect and will make no impression on the solution of the problem.
Comment on this
The burden of most of the speeches I have listened to from all sides of the House seems to be that "Something ought to be done about the unemployed", and I am sure everybody has at the back of his mind some grandiose scheme and important works of a permanent public nature. I do not think that under this Vote we will be permitted to go into anything big, or to discuss matters beyond the ordinary minor relief schemes administered by the Parliamentary Secretary. If we were dealing with the big question of unemployment, we could deal with such things as reclamation, coast erosion, forestry, and big things like that, but possibly these are outside the purview of the Parliamentary Secretary's Department.
Comment on this
I am afraid that within the scope of the money, at all events, the Parliamentary Secretary will find himself severely handicapped.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary said he was anxious for criticism of the whole plan, if there is a plan attached to it. I would be very glad to go into a lot of details with regard to criticising plans and schemes in operation, but I am rather handicapped by the fact that I cannot criticise the Parliamentary Secretary personally, because I think that if there is anything we could not criticise it is the whole-hearted energy he has put into this work. If these problems are still in an unsatisfactory condition, I do not think it is due to any want of goodwill or attention on his part. I travel about the country a good deal, and I must admit that it is marvellous to see the close attention which he gives to small works in remote parts of the country and the personal knowledge he has of local requirements.
I am afraid that everybody on every side of the House is disappointed that the problem is still unsolved. When we put before the Government in 1932 the principle of work or maintenance for unemployed, and when the Government accepted that principle, we all felt at that time that something would have been done by this to eat into this problem and solve it in some very material way. I am sorry to say that seven years after the acceptance of that principle we seem to be as far away as ever from a solution.
The Parliamentary Secretary tells us that he is nearly at a loss to find works of a nature on which money can be usefully spent to relieve unemployment. I think I might divide this question into two parts. These minor relief schemes affect two classes. One class is the people affected purely by a poverty problem, which is mostly in the rural districts, particularly on the seaboard in such constituencies as mine. The other is an urban problem. Dealing with the rural part of the problem, it is a matter of the poverty of small holders who cannot subsist on the little rocky patches of ground they have. These schemes are of great help to them, and very useful contributions are given by the men themselves in the way of materials and other things towards these schemes. I have, however, from time to time put forward to the Parliamentary Secretary little schemes in remote places, and the answer in many cases is that there is not sufficient unemployed registered in the area to warrant the doing of the work as an unemployed relief scheme. The reason is that these people, although they are poor, are not registered as unemployed. Their resources are very slender, but they do not go to the labour exchange to register as unemployed although they would be entitled to do so, as they are small holders of the £3 and £4 valuation type. I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary, when dealing with this question, that he could get a lot of useful work done in some of these districts by not having regard to the actual scheduled unemployed, but by taking into account rather the conditions of the people and the necessity or the practical value of the work put before him.
With regard to the unemployment question in urban areas, I am afraid I will have to admit that, as long as a man is paid for being idle, we will never get any correct solution of unemployment. I find that no matter how little a man is paid in that way there is a tendency to extract that small dole, as it is called, and to subsist on it rather than to work and get four times the amount. I am sorry to say that is the tendency, and as long as that is so, and that men are given money for living in idleness, we will never get a proper solution of the problem. What is the alternative? If we want to get useful work done, these men ought to be made work. The work should be of a permanent and useful public nature, and they should be employed at a proper rate of wages, and for a proper length of time. That brings me to the old trouble about rotational schemes. I think the Parliamentary Secretary said that there was no other way. He does not approve of rotational work himself, but he sees no other way of dealing with this question. I think we should set our faces against the rotational system. It is a very bad and demoralising system. In regard to urban relief schemes, there is not sufficient latitude given local authorities in the selection of the works on which money is to be spent. Invariably they are confined to roads, footpaths, and work of that nature. There again the Parliamentary Secretary is limited to the class of work in which there is a good labour content. Better and probably more useful and more permanent works could be got. At present we have simply to take on unskilled labour, and some of that labour is of the most unskilled character. These people have to be taken off a register that contains different types of men, and they have to be taken in rotation, as long as they are capable of working at all, and the result is that you get an unsatisfactory type of work as well as an unsatisfactory type of workman. There again you are up against the problem that is more or less a problem of charity; one of giving money to men who have no other way of living.
I think there should be a beginning by giving no money unless work of some sort is performed for it. If the Parliamentary Secretary asks me for a scheme I confess that I have not one, but I am against the very demoralising principle of giving men money without working. That is becoming more marked amongst our people. Deputy Hurley referred to the thousands of young men who are leaving school every year. It was stated that there are at present in the City of Dublin, 19,000 young men unemployed, men who never had work of any kind. That is the most serious part of our problem. These 19,000 young men never did any work and they are coming on to the very dangerous age of manhood. If there are 19,000 unemployed men in Dublin, what is the position in the whole country? The numbers must be very large indeed. That is the gravest problem we have to deal with. We have extensive demoralisation amongst young men coming on to a labour market that cannot absorb them. They get accustomed to living on the dole, and, perhaps, will not want to be taken off it. My objection to the perpetuation of the dole system is accordingly all the more marked. Another thing about urban relief schemes is the fact that sometimes urban areas are asked to contribute a certain amount from the local rates in relation to the grant that is given, and they find it very difficult to do so. I have in mind a small town where the raising of £120 by rates would mean a grant of £1,100. That sum is not to be sneezed at, but the £120 might represent a rate of 6d. or 7d. extra in the £. That is a serious matter, particularly when the rates are from 15/- to 17/- in the £.
Comment on this
I know that, but that does not fall so hard on a particularly poor locality. I need not tell the Parliamentary Secretary that all these towns are going down in population, and yet the unemployment in them is increasing. That is the most extraordinary paradox. I am living in a town with a population of 2,000. When I was born there were over 5,000 people there, yet there are more unemployed in it to-day. We have better streets, better lighting and cleaner towns, but there are less people in them. We are forced by relief grants to do what is practically useless work. If we were able to put up practical schemes which might be spread over a number of years, I think that we would be doing much better.
Comment on this
The work done would be permanent, would be useful, and would not be confined to certain classes of work which are stereotyped. I sympathise with the Parliamentary Secretary in the very difficult job he has. I have no fault to find with the way he is trying to do it. I may have sometimes said hard things about the results, but I know that it is not his fault if some of the results were not always satisfactory.
Comment on this
I am grateful to the Deputies who have taken part in the discussion which, I think, has been, from beginning to end, intended to be constructive and helpful. There has been a good deal of difference of opinion, and a good many criticisms which my own opening speech was intended to bring out, but there has been, speaking generally, a desire to use this occasion to do some benefit to the country, through the better administration of schemes of this kind. All I can say is that I very much appreciate an atmosphere of that kind, and reciprocate. If I might take the last speech first, that of Deputy O'Neill, it covers a good many of the other cases. The complaint about the form of scheme, which is now operative in small towns and urban districts, is that it is too restricted. The money that has been roughly allocated is £981,000 for road works. That is for road works all over the country, but it is not confined to roads. I am inviting those interested in schemes of this kind to give me some better schemes than road works if they can.
Comment on this
I will deal with the Deputy's case later. I am not going to take anything that anyone said to-night as being in any way controversial. It has been my privilege here for a considerable number of years to listen to speeches which were most offensive upon this Vote. It has been my privilege to ignore everything in every speech which has been made on this Vote, except it was constructive, and it has been also my privilege to be able to treat everything said, in whatever tone or spirit, as if it was intended to be a constructive suggestion. Take the great City of Cork, for instance, where there is a very serious problem. There is going into that city at the moment somewhere about £40,000 from this Vote, and there is going in about £7,000 or £8,000 from another Vote. Assuming that these schemes continue, moneys of that order are likely for some years to come.
The streets, lanes and pathways of the City of Cork are a credit to it. There are places, no doubt, which could be made super-perfect, but there is certainly no crying need to spend, over and above the money which the corporation should find itself for the maintenance of any works, anything in the nature of £46,000. I want schemes that will be alternatives but they must have certain qualities. I am only dealing with Cork as a typical case. These schemes must have a high labour content. They must be of themselves of value to the city, and they must not be in substitution for money which the local authority itself ought to spend.
Comment on this
Two schemes were put forward. There are some others which I will deal with later. There is the reservoir. That reservoir should be built by the corporation themselves, and by nobody else. So far as I am concerned, it is an offence against the purpose which this House has in making the Vote that that money should go to enabling the Corporation to avoid spending money which it ought to spend.
Comment on this
I shall deal with that point in a moment. A very big main drainage scheme, to cost about £400,000, is, certainly, not necessary, but may be desirable. It is not a matter of high necessity, but it is a thing which those who want to put the city on the standard which it holds in other ways would be very anxious to do. It can be done only over a period of years. No part of that scheme is at present ready to be done. Therefore, that scheme goes out for the moment. Of the other schemes which I have asked for from the City of Cork, the total amount put forward is not one-third of the amount that would absorb the whole year's grant of which I have spoken. I know that on various occasions the city manager has been up against this problem. I have been continuously up against it.
Year after year, I have asked "Cannot you give us something better; cannot you give me some other work"? The city manager has gone to the city council in connection with the matter. I have a record in which he says: "Yes, we can put up some more roads." What else have you got to give me? I am only giving you that as an example. By all means, put your brains to work. Roads I can do at any time. All over the country I can do roads. They are the one comfortable pool into which we can pour labour when we want to do so.
Comment on this
You are pouring a thousand pounds a week into Cork City.
Comment on this
What we are concerned with is to find work which will be better than, and which will take preference of, road work. Deputies can see the difficulty. Any work which, in the ordinary way, is obviously good is a work which the corporation or the local authority ought to do out of their own funds. As we have to confine ourselves to works which they will not normally do, we have to take second place in the sense of even the value of the work.
Comment on this
The point we made at the corporation is that we are paying 1/8 in the £, which produces over £20,000 to the unemployment fund, plus the £12,000 that supplements the grant from the unemployment relief fund. That is about £30,000 per year. If we had that £30,000 to spend without any direction from the Department, we would spend it, undoubtedly, on the main drainage scheme or the reservoir, as the case might be. In view of our contributions to that fund, we ask that we should have some discretion in connection with all these necessary schemes.
Comment on this
That is only one side of the question. You get £80,000 in unemployment assistance and £46,000 in grant. That is £126,000. In addition to that, you are getting the full value of the works. This is out of the fund of £3,000,000.
Comment on this
I shall be most happy to tell other Deputies what their constituents are getting. A Deputy on my own side of the House got up, on one occasion, and protested that in his constituency no money had been given. I turned up the list and read out the grants until he begged me, for mercy sake, to stop and not shame him any more. The easy way for us to spend money all over the country is on roads. Whether or not we shall be able to continue to find road-work in places to which the men who are unemployed will have access is difficult to say; but it is the biggest pool and the easiest pool and, for that reason, if good work can be put up against it, in substitution for it, I shall be very glad to hear about it. I think that covers that point.
Comment on this
Kilkenny is well covered. I have very old and close associations with Kilkenny and it has not been forgotten. It has been suggested that, as one of the methods of using the unemployment fund, we should subsidise labour for the farmers. That suggestion was made before and objection was taken to it on the ground that it might have a tendency to lower the rate of wages in the whole farming industry. In so far as there is now a minimum statutory wage, that objection is not so strong as it used to be. It has been suggested that, in the case of farmers prepared to employ more labour than they could be shown over a period of years to have employed on the average, the extra labour sent to them should be subsidised by the State to the amount of the unemployment assistance which these men are receiving. That is certainly one of the points which mights very well be considered by the Agricultural Commission—under what circumstances and what proportion of unemployment grant could be used for subsidising agricultural labour without doing harm to agriculture and without doing harm to labour. It is not my business to put that question before the Agricultural Commission but it is a question which, in any of its forms, any one of you are entitled to bring before the Agricultural Commission. So far as I am concerned, that suggestion will be noted.
We had an hour's speech from Deputy Dillon, who erupted with a proposal which, after he had dealt with it for a considerable time, was turned down and cursed with bell, book and candle by Deputy Colonel Ryan.
Comment on this
The next thing we moved on to was the subsidy scheme, and that was cursed with bell, book and candle by Deputy Belton. What I am putting to you is that any solution we offer is going to be attended with difficulties. Here was a scheme which was advocated on the principle that anyone who did not accept it was a heretic, a lunatic and a fool, and immediately Deputy Ryan says, "I would be boiled in oil before I would touch it; I would be much more comfortable boiled in oil than living under it if it were carried out." There is a good deal to be said for it, and we are trying to find a method which will get through the objections which are, I think, present in the mind of every thinking man when he touches that question. We are trying to find a method in which a considerable portion of that money will be turned into some use of that kind.
The State, however, must get a return for all that money. I myself regard it as the first duty I owe to the unemployed themselves—the first moral duty that I owe—to see that they earn all the money they get out of the unemployment fund.
Comment on this
I understand that we are dealing with the unemployment fund, and I am very clear and definite that that should not be for the benefit of the farmers. What I say is that we ought to have some other way of dealing with the farmers. I want to have that understood clearly. I understood that we were dealing purely and simply with the unemployed people.
Comment on this
I think that what we all want to see, in connection with this Vote, is that the money should be for the benefit of the unemployed people, and that the unemployed person is the one to whom we have a duty, and the cardinal consideration which governs all of us is to see that that money goes to the unemployed person. Now, that would also include the fact that the money should not be used upon work which, obviously, was of a character which was no use and, therefore, would not be for the benefit of the unemployed person's own self-respect. It has been suggested that one solution might be arrived at by increasing the radius to which men would be transported to a job. If any of you will look at that map, I think you will find that it is perfectly clear that it is not a question of increasing the radius from three to five miles or even to six or seven miles. If you look at that map, you will find that all these areas— green, blue, black and so on—are practically segregated—and that is where 90 per cent. of the men are. It is perfectly obvious, then, that it is not a question of a small increase such as Deputy Keyes had in mind when he talked about men having to walk further than would be reasonable. It is a question of transporting them some 30 or 40 miles. Now, as soon as you begin to touch anything of that kind you are going to face an increase in the cost which will be practically equal to the cost of labour as it is at present. We may have to face that difficulty, but I want you to understand that my whole outlook in this matter is: what proportion of the total amount of money that is spent can I get into the man's pocket and into his stomach? and if I spend a large amount on bringing a man 30 or 40 miles in transport, that has to come out of that fund. It is for that reason that, up to the present, although we have not moved our men by major transport, to the extent that we have to do so, the Dáil will have to be prepared to get a less net return for all the money they spend and, unless the Dáil is prepared to provide more money, there is going to be a less amount of money going to the men. Every consideration, such as the type of scheme, the position of the scheme, the conditions under which it is being carried out—whether through camp or through transport—all these things have to be judged by that simple standard: how many hundreds or thousands of pounds, as the case may be, are going to be turned effectively into the relief of the distress of the unemployed people?
Deputy Gorey raised a question of a national scheme of minor drainage. Now, I think that is a question which might very well go to the Agricultural Commission. There is no reason in the wide world why we should not consider that suggestion as well as the other suggestion. We must take into consideration, however, what is the general meaning when people speak of a national drainage scheme or a national road scheme, and that is that the State shall pay the whole of the cost.
Comment on this
Yes, but you can put that proposition to the Agricultural Commission, and I think it is perfectly reasonable and proper to put to the commission that, if their main drainage is being done, perhaps parallel to it a system could be set up that would ensure that all the minor drainage schemes would be undertaken.
Comment on this
You can put that as to whether all or a considerable proportion of it should not be at the cost of the farmer, who is getting the benefit of it. Two or three questions have been raised about the efficiency with which major bog drain work has been done. Major bog drain work is done through the Peat Development Company, and I am aware that they have a very competent body of engineers. I propose to put before them the criticisms which have been made, in this case, for their examination.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary gave me a promise in connection with these schemes 12 months ago, and we had some discussion on the matter, but it would appear that the schemes have not been considered. I should like if the Parliamentary Secretary or his technicians in the Board of Works would come and see the work carried out in three schemes within a few miles of where I live.
Comment on this
Two or three Deputies suggested that they would like to see twice as much spent on the unemployed relief schemes. Now, the total spent on the relief of the able-bodied unemployed, at the moment, is made up of two funds, unemployment assistance, and employment schemes. The total amount of money spent on the relief of the able-bodied unemployed for the last few years has been as follows: In 1934-35, £1,281,000; in 1935-36, £1,922,000; in 1936-37, £1,941,000; in 1937-38, £2,292,000; in 1938-39, £2,662,000, and the Estimate for 1939-40 is £2,800,000. I hope now that I will be able to assure the Minister for Finance, if he chooses to bring forward an increase of taxation of £2,800,000, that every member of the Opposition will go into the Lobby to vote for the taxes which will be necessary to raise that amount. If that is not so, then we may take it that you do not want to spend twice as much and are not willing to spend twice as much on unemployment assistance. If you are willing to spend money on anything, you have got to be willing to vote for the unpopular taxes that are necessary to raise that money, and that is the critical issue.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that he will never solve the problem by the method he is adopting. He must know that the whole difficulty with regard to it is the finding of the money. As I have often pointed out here before, we shall never solve this problem until we change our present monetary system.
Comment on this
I should be delighted at any time to discuss that problem across the floor of this House, or elsewhere, with Deputy Hickey. I am certain that he is sincere in believing something that I spent 30 years trying to believe.
Comment on this
All that I want now is the machinery by which that thing which he and I hope for can be done. If he can find that for me, I will give him every help in working it.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary's problem is to find the money. I have given him the solution.
Comment on this
That problem, whenever we come to discuss it, will have to be discussed on the basis, not of what you want to do but what you can do and how you can do it. It has been suggested that the fact that we have 107,000 people on the unemployed register, and that this happens at the particular moment to be on the upgrade, is proof of something which is very wrong in itself. That is not true.
The rise in the unemployment register at the present moment is simply due to the fact that people are coming off unemployment schemes much faster than they went off last year. I would be most happy to show to any Deputy who is really interested in the question the graphs and the curves that record these things. I can make the position of unemployment as far as figures are concerned anything we like at a particular time by the simple organisation of works: by deciding to have an enormous peak of works at, say, a critical period, which is about the 20th February.
Comment on this
No one in this House believes for a single moment that I have ever spent one single pound or done one single work, or in any way interfered with the unemployment fund for election purposes, and I do not intend to do it for anybody. What I am pointing out now is this: You get either a flat at the top of your curve carrying a low average of men over a considerable period, or you can run them, as we have tried to run them, in proportion as we thought to the actual flow into the unemployment register. Last year we carried on our unemployment curve a bit further than we did this year. The effect is that this year there is a steeper fall, and the result is that there has been that rise. As to the number of men, I refer Deputies again to the map. Deputies can see mentally what is happening in Ireland in relation to the unemployed. You know where they are. You know the black areas and the yellow areas. Practically all the unemployed are in the black areas.
When we took over, and when I prepared my first map of the unemployment position for this State, there was not a single unemployed man west of the Shannon. They simply did not exist. The whole register was one of casual industrial employment. What we have done is, we have added to those that poverty factor of which Deputy O'Neill spoke. Deputies who are familiar with the West of Ireland know that there were these thousands of poor people there all over that period. They were in West Donegal, in North and South Mayo, to a certain extent in West Clare and West Galway and in North-west and South-west Kerry, but not a single one of these existed on the previous register. What has happened now is not that 107,000 people have become unemployed, but that 107,000 people who are in distress have been recognised and every one of them has been served.
Comment on this
They are no longer being ignored. Deputy Hickey said that only £74 a year was going into their pockets in Cork, but it is £74 a year which they never saw before. Every one of these 107,000 people is a public certificate to this Government that it is really looking after them: that it is giving something to them and not turning its back on them.
Comment on this
We have the most extraordinary sort of stories told. I do not want to be unkind about it because people do say these things whether they mean them or not. We had, for instance, the statement that "we are worse than Clanrickarde". I say that with a smile, because Deputy Dillon went into Connemara and saw a lot of people being employed on relief schemes. We could become saints and angels by employing nobody on relief schemes. What kind of criminals we will become when we accept the invitation of the Deputies opposite and spend twice as much a year on unemployment schemes and have twice as many people being served out of the State, I do not know. Clanrickarde will be a saint compared to us. That is the sort of argument we had. People wander up into Western Donegal, a splendid county with splendid men, and every 100 yards you go you find a scheme, according to Deputy Dillon, in operation. That is proof according to him that we are a lot of criminals. Now, I do not really think that the common sense and the common decency of the Party opposite echoes folly of that kind from whatever member of their Front Bench it comes.
A question has been raised which is a rather difficult one, namely, that men who are employed three days a week will pay two sets of stamps. Now, there is something in that at first sight, but there is another side to it. Remember, in the first place, that the House, for the benefit of the unemployed, has created a system of law under which a man has to get stamps. That system was created for the benefit of unemployed people. There is no man in this House who is prepared to take responsibility for withdrawing those Acts. Therefore, the payment of one stamp must be taken to have been intended to be for the benefit of the man. Why is it? Because in addition to the value of his own stamp the man is credited with the value of the stamp of his employer and in this case the employer is the State. It is both the employer and the State. Where a man has two stamps in the week he has definitely deducted from him the value of his own two stamps but he has had credited to him the double value of the two stamps from the State and two stamps from his employer. On the question as to whether that is to his benefit or otherwise we came across the fact in a rather curious way. Last year we discovered at a particular period that there were somewhere about 4,000 and 5,000 more men drawing unemployment insurance than there had been in the previous year. I sent that to the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Committee concerned with that matter to have it investigated. They reported that it was wholly due to the fact that the men who worked on relief schemes during the previous winter had accumulated that amount of stamps of their own and the State—their employer—which enabled them during a period when they would have been held up by the employment orders to draw unemployment insurance. Therefore, one can see that the men are getting the benefit of this thing. It is simply a question of looking at it in the right way. If the House thinks, for instance, that the men are getting too much benefit by having too many stamps or if the House thinks something else should be done let them go out and do it. On the whole I am of opinion that this is to the benefit of the men.
Comment on this
The Deputy can put it anyway he likes. I am only anxious to get at the truth of this matter and to put it before the House. Deputy Bartley raised the question of the maintenance of the sea wall at Inishbofin or he raised, rather, the fact that we were not prepared to make a sea wall there. We were not, for the reason that the Galway County Council were not prepared to maintain it. The rule is that these works have to be maintained by the county council. The amount of maintenance is very small, and if the county council do not think the thing worth maintaining when they get it for nothing, it certainly looks a poor piece of work or, at all events, work that is not needed. It is clear that we cannot make an exception in the case of Inishbofin Island, an island I know well indeed, without making exceptions for the rest of County Galway. We cannot make exceptions for the County Galway and have Mayo, Clare, Kerry, Cork and other seaboard districts maintaining their piers and sea walls.
I now come to the non-poverty areas, the yellow areas. There is there, again, the matter that I told you about. There is no title in any man to have his boreen done at the cost of this State. Intrinsically there is no claim whatever to have such a thing done at the cost of the State. The only reason why boreens are done at the cost of the State in the West of Ireland is because we want to give employment to men on roads and boreens to the bogs which we drain. The purpose is the employment we give. Therefore, as there is no distress in those areas, there is no reason in putting the cost on the State. These things, however, can be done if we find that we have labour which we cannot employ in its own area and that can find a method of transport, and if these better-off farmers are prepared themselves to meet part of the expenses. If they are prepared to do this it is possible that some scheme of this kind may be carried through. But intrinsically you can no more put the expense or cost for having a boreen done for the benefit of a well-of farmer than you can do anything for any private person for the benefit of his business or the surroundings of his life.
If there is that co-operation—and I think that was what Deputy Childers had strongly in mind—if those who are to benefit were to come forward with a desire to help, then it might be possible to bridge the extra cost which is represented by motor transport from the areas in which the men reside to the districts in which the work is to be done. I am giving that suggestion to the yellow areas in the hope that they will find something of that kind and deal with it.
Deputy Brodrick's speech suggested that he had not much love for those small drainage schemes because he said we flooded similar areas lower down the river. Having carried out 800 of these drainage schemes we hear of every single area lower down the river, and we have been told of cases of the inevitable consequences to the areas lower down. But owing to the care with which the work was mapped out these cases of flooding lower down the river are very few. Broadly speaking, these drainage schemes have been an outstanding success and they will be continued as far as possible.
We have had certain complaints about the rotational system. Deputy Morrissey called it this "abominable, horrible thing", and I do not know what else. Now we have had no complaints from the black areas. No representative of Donegal, no representative of West Clare, no representative of West Galway or Mayo has come here to complain about the black areas. These are places where thousands of men have been employed on relief schemes. That shows that the people generally want that scheme. Now, I have got complaints, but the one thing that irritates me is that I do not get enough complaints. I say that because I know that things are going on under the system of unemployment relief which people ought to call to my attention. The general body of complaints I get is from men who cannot get on to this work.
Deputy Corish raised the question of places where men were employed on a particular scheme and when that scheme came to an end they were taken off. Then we have had complaints of unfairness to the men who do not get on those schemes. I have had thousands of these complaints and I have investigated them. But I have occasionally got complaints from people saying that the wrong work has been done or that the work has been done in a wrong place or in a wrong manner. As I have already pointed out, I never get complaints from people against the system under which they are employed. I am quite satisfied that 99.8 per cent. of the men working on relief schemes in the western sea board are anxious that this system, so fair and obviously so just, designed to meet their conditions shall continue.
I think the only other point raised is that it is being suggested that we should not confine ourselves in the allocation of schemes to the 3,000 separate electoral areas. But I only want to say that when you divide the country into 3,000 separate electoral areas you have gone very far indeed. As a matter of fact, where there seems a good case for the work itself and this case is put forward, what happens is that the officials from the Department are asked not merely to see the number of people employed in that particular area but in the surrounding electoral areas, to which it would be possible for the men to go and whether it would be reasonably possible to bring men from contiguous areas. Where that is possible it will be done.
I want to say this that with the large experience of the men working through the unemployment assistance register, working under very strenuous and difficult conditions— removed very far indeed from comfortable conditions—in which these men have to work on relief schemes during the winter, I am satisfied that the vast majority of them would undoubtedly prefer to work if they only got the amount of money which they get through unemployment assistance rather than continue to draw the dole. I am perfectly satisfied that while there is bound to be a certain proportion who would take advantage of another system the vast majority of the men want to give the State value in return. These men have self-respect and they want to feel that they earn every penny they get. The responsibility that I owe to these men and to this House—one responsibility which I will fulfil—is, to say that every penny which they get they can take with their heads up and with self-respect knowing that they have earned that money and given value in return for it to the State.