We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 52—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 94–209 of 209. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

There is one other matter I want to refer to, and that is the question of land reclamation. When a comparison is made with 1914 we find that there is very little of this work being done through the country to-day. The cost is high. If it does not pay the farmer he will not do it. He is not going to do anything that will not pay. There is no use in saying that the farmer is going to continue to make sacrifices in the national interest. He is not going to do that any more. It is time that the other fellow made some sacrifices. What I suggest is that it might be wise to consider the introduction of a scheme by which those who are on the dole might be employed on land reclamation work, the amount of the dole to be added to the wages they receive from the farmer. I think that this dole system is a bad one.

Deputy Brasier referred to the difficulties that farmers had in importing seed oats. I did not hear of any farmer in the County Cork who found any difficulty in doing that. The farmer wrote to the Department, and a merchant in his nearest town got authority to import for him. With regard to Deputy Dillon's exaggerated statements, I want to say that in my opinion his references to the Minister for Agriculture cannot be described as being other than scandalous. It would be God help the country if it gave Deputy Dillon the opportunity of trying out his plan, the plan that he outlined on the Land Commission Vote last week. He talked of community farming, of small farmers coming together, pooling their resources and providing work for all. I wonder what would happen if some of them were to lie down. Would they be all lying down together? Who would work the farms? Who would divide the profits? That is Deputy Dillon's cure. That is what he is going to do when he becomes Minister for Agriculture. He is going to have community farming. All the small farmers are to come together and work a day with pay all round. Of with Mick, with pay all round. Of course, they will all work hard. I would like to see the plan tried.

If Deputy Dillon has any land I suggest that he should try it there first. We had any amount of cures of that description from Deputy Dillon, who does not want wheat, does not want beet, or anything that would help to provide a home market for farmers. That is the only market in which the price can be controlled. It is the only market in which farmers can hope to get a price. It must be admitted on all sides that whatever agricultural produce is exported has to be sold at the world price, and I respectfully suggest that we cannot hope to complete at world prices with ranching countries.

Comment on this

Give us a cure.

Comment on this

I gave a cure long ago. If the Deputy has a cure I will be glad to hear it. I do not think the cure lies in Deputy Dillon's suggestion of community farming. I wonder if Deputy Belton would try it in market gardening, and guarantee the workers so much out of the profits by all working together.

Comment on this

Will you give a guarantee for the crop when it is in?

Comment on this

That is Deputy Dillon's plan for agriculture. All I have to say, and I say it honestly, is that after General O'Duffy, Deputy Dillon is the biggest asset we have. Long may he remain so, because as long as he remains there, so long will whatever is left of his Party be on the opposite benches. That is certain. I may be giving away secrets, but he won the Galway election for us, and got us thousands of votes. He went to Wexford and got us a few votes there also.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I cannot see the relevancy of this to the Agricultural Vote.

Comment on this

Surely it is as relevant——

Comment on this

As revealing, the Deputy should say.

Comment on this

It is as revant as the statement made by Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am not interested in what Deputy Dillon was reported to have said. I was not in the Chair. I am going to conduct the debate in the manner in which I think proper, and I have to insist on the Deputy being relvant.

Comment on this

I bow to your ruling. In conclusion I only hope that Deputy Dillon will be on the opposite benches for a long time, to guide the fortunes of the Fine Gael Party and make their numbers smaller and smaller.

Comment on this

As I consider this to be the most important Vote that comes before the House, I was glad to hear some Government Deputies admitting that they are turning our way, and coming to realise that the agricultural industry is the most important one we have. They are begining to realise that the farmers are in a desperate position. Roughly 50 per cent. of our population get a living out of farming. For a number of years past the position has been desperate. Farming is in a bad way owing to the world fall in agricultural prices, and still more to domestic troubles of our own in this country for the past five or six years. The result has been a big flight from the land to the towns and cities and to Great Britain to seek industrial employment. The most serious problem to be faced is the growing hopelessness and want of confidence in the future of farming as a means of living. The farmers' children are flying from the land because they see no prospect before them. They know the hardships that their fathers and mothers are enduring. I am glad that the Government are, at last, beginning to realise the position. Deputy Childers admitted that that position was the effect of a policy that had been deliberately imposed on the farmers. The economic war had brought destruction on farmers. That was the admission of a prominent member of the Government Party, that they deliberately imposed the economic war as part of a policy to destroy the farmers. The economic war is over for the past 12 months. Why has the Government not done something since then to remedy the wrong that was done?

If you take the price of cattle in the Dublin market last week, and the price in the same week in 1914, the average was somewhat more in 1914 than it is now. Taking the average price for sheep in the Dublin market last week, and the average price in 1914, the price then was bigger. That proves that their income from cattle and sheep is less than it was in 1914. The cost of production has gone up 200 per cent. in some cases. Rates have gone up 200 per cent. in some cases, and the labour farmers employ has gone up over 100 per cent., and justly so, because the men could not live otherwise. The cost of feeding stuffs has gone up 50 per cent. The cost of everything the farmer has to buy has gone up. In 1914 a mowing machine could be bought for ten guineas, but it costs £25 to-day. The ordinary plough could be bought for £4 5s. in 1914, but it costs £8 to-day. The cost of horses, carts, harness, has gone up 100 per cent. Along with the increased cost of production the farmer has to face an increased cost of living. The cost of boots, shoes and clothing has gone up by 100 per cent.—in other words, a farmer has to sell twice as many cattle and sheep to buy a plough now as he had in 1914. Therefore I maintain that the position of farmers could not be otherwise than going down and down. That is due partly to world production and low prices, but it was aggravated here by the economic war, which a Government Deputy farmers. It is the duty of the Government, 12 months after the economic war ended, to help the farmers.

Deputy Childers admitted that in one place 50 per cent. of the farmers had nothing, but on the question of full derating he said if they had the money they would run and buy wireless sets. That is the mentality of the Government Party. They begrudge the farmers wireless sets. I remember some years ago, after a meeting had been held in Naas to protest against the payment of annuities, hearing the Minister for Finance making a laugh of farmers who were at the meeting and who had motor cars.

He never stopped until he left hardly a farmer with a motor-car. That was the policy. This Government grudges the farmers the right to live and they are showing it every day. I had some hope that the position would be righted when the economic war stopped but the Government are not showing any interest in the farmers. What good is a reduction in the cost of manure to 50 per cent. of the farmers who are not able to buy a bag of manure? What 50 per cent. of the farmers want is a grant. They must be put in a position to produce for the people and, to do that, their cost of production must be reduced. I may be asked where the money is to come from. Where is the £5,000,000 to be invested in aeroplanes and bombs to come from? Where did the £2,000,000 put into the alcohol factories that have gone brust, or are likely to do so, come from? These factories were no benefit to the farmers. Where is the £600,000 for tourist development to come from? These things are aggravating the farmers. It would break your heart to read the letters I get from the farmers. It is the duty of the Government, as it would be of any Government, to come to the aid of the 50 per cent. of farmers who are in a desperate position. Low-priced manures are no good to them. They are only of use to the farmers who have money to buy them.

This Government is supposed to be a poor man's Government. Why, then, throw money to the people who can afford to buy manures? Why not give free manures to the farmers? Manure is not worth anything to many farmers because, owing to the annuities and other charges, their lands are held up. I know people who sold their last calf to pay rates, so that Westmeath might be the best rate-paying county in Ireland. It is saddening to see how people were harassed to pay their rates. There should be parish committees set up who would administer grants by the Government to the 50 per cent. of farmers who require them and to whom loans are of no use. If they got a loan, the sheriff would come for the annuities or something and it would be all gone. They want a grant or something to put stock on the land which will put them in a position to carry on. I suggest that the heifer scheme should be put in force again but not in the way it was put in force before. You had actions in connection with these heifer schemes and smart fellows going around and making profit on broken-down farmers. These heifers, when given out to the farmers, should be marked on the ear so that no sheriff could come and remove them from the land. The farmers would have to keep them for five or six years and, in that way, calves would be produced and the wealth of the country would be increased.

This business of greater production is all "codology." If farmers were going well and if there were a need for their products, they would produce. All the farmers want is a reduction of the cost of production. The Government should give them a grant to buy mowing machines and every other implement which the farmer requires. In that way, the cost of production would be reduced without reaction on the rest of the population. If a grant were given in respect of all the machinery and all the things about the house which a farmer has to buy, the money would be well spent. The farmer should also receive full derating. It may be said that that would benefit only the large farmers but the small farmers found it very hard to find £5 or £6 for rates this year.

Rating is a grave injustice to the farming community. The charge is solely borne by the farming community who derive hardly any benefit from it. Take the money spent on roads. Can any farmer use one of these roads? They cannot go out on these roads with their donkey and cart or pony and trap, while every man with a motor car can go flying by. Neither can the farmers get the services of a doctor free. If they go into a hospital, they are charged £2 2s. 0d. or £3 3s. 0d. a week. I know several farmers who had to leave hospital because of the high charges. The farmers derive no benefit whatsever from these social services and it is unfair that they should have to bear the cost of them. I know people with from £500 to £700 a year—I do not grudge it to them—who are living in semi-detached houses in the country and who are not paying ½d. in rates. They may have their houses rented. They can drive about in their motor cars and enjoy every service provided by the rates, which shows that the rating system is not fair. The charges for these services should be taken off the farmers and put on the community as a whole.

I should also like to refer to the question of our bulls. I was struck forcibly in connection with this matter at the Show. I stayed watching them the whole day long and I came to the conclusion that if 25 or 30 per cent. of the bulls were in normal condition you would not give a £5 note for them, because they were very blown up with excessive feeding. There should be a more strict inspection of bulls because, when these animals go home to the farmers, they go back and one would not know them in three or four months or allow them to go with any cows. I should like to impress on the Minister that he should give more money for shorthorn bulls because we are gradually coming to the position in which we will not have a good type of cow in the country. To get a good type, we must encourage the farmers to keep shorthorn bulls. Everybody knows that the whitehead and the black give the biggest return to the small farmer. A lot of farmers would like to buy a good bull but they are not in a position to do so because they will not get a loan. Loans should be given to ordinary farmers so that they could go up and compete for the bulls against the men who get premiums. Numerous farmers would buy good bulls if they got a loan. The amount of premiums in the counties for shorthorn bulls should be increased and the radius should also be altered. At the present time, the radius is three miles. Encouragement should be given for the keeping of shorthorn bulls anywhere and everywhere and more money should be given for premiums.

Deputy Ryan mentioned something about the bounties not going to the farmers. That was all the fault of the Government. It was their way of administering those bounties. It looked very like as if they wanted them to go to certain people. The licences were given for a certain time, until numbers of people got rich. The bounties went in a certain way. As regards these things that Deputy Ryan mentioned, the reason was that they were not properly administered. With regard to the heifer schemes, there should be a different way of dealing with them, so that certain men will not get all the benefit. The heifers should be marked in a way that they cannot be taken by the sheriff or sold by the farmer. There should not be any such thing as a backhand there and a backhand here. We do not want the condition of affairs again applying when some poor fool of a farmer would be giving double the price for an animal. I think the Minister should bring out the heifer scheme again, and have it administered in a different way.

Comment on this

In his opening statement the Minister referred to the development of his creamery scheme and, on behalf of the people in my own area, I wish to thank the Minister and his Department for the excellent work carried out in that connection. Heretofore, great doubt existed as to whether this portable creamery scheme could be a success. Being more or less unique in that part of the country, being unknown and a somewhat doubtful quantity, so to speak, people thought it could never be of very great benefit to those areas. We who have seen it in operation are in a position to state that it has saved the small farmers in the mountainous areas. So far as we are concerned, we appreciate what has been done, and we desire to thank the Minister and his Department for their efforts in that connection. It is the first big development so far as the Gaeltacht areas are concerned. It is a definite departure from the small experimental schemes that have been tried within the Gaeltacht districts, and it has proved itself a success.

I have been asked to put forward a scheme in regard to the restocking of mountainy areas with sheep of good quality. The case that has been made, in my opinion, calls for consideration. As a result of the economic war, the small farmers in these mountainy districts have had to dispose of stock which, in previous years, were their mainstay for breeding purposes, and for the continuance of what is the only means of livelihood. As the years went on, these mountainy areas became depleted of stock suitable for breeding purposes. The people there make the case now that for that reason, and also because of the fact that some of the sheep had become inbred, the quality of the stock has depreciated. The people there make the case that the Department might advance loans to enable them to restock their mountainy lands, and it has been further suggested that the stock might be imported from Scotland and allocated in the various districts by the Department's inspectors.

I think that the Minister could usefully consider such a scheme. I understand there was a somewhat similar scheme inaugurated some years ago on behalf of the farmers in the mountainy districts of Wicklow, and it worked out very well and the people availed largely of it. We are simply making the case that, through no fault of their own, the people in my part of the country are placed in circumstances which call for some sympathetic consideration.

There is a further case in regard to the question of premium bulls and the bulls allocated by the Department to congested districts. There is a certain anomaly where the Department allocates what they call a special term bull, and, through a certain system, they arrange for recoupment. They allow the people to repay the amount advanced by four yearly instalments. In that way the people in the congested areas have availed of the scheme, but on examination we have found out that the people who obtained the bulls under the committee of agriculture scheme are entitled to about £16 or £20 more than the man in the poorer district. Assuming a special term bull costs £40 or £50, and he is allocated to a man in a congested district and is given to him at the reduced cost of £15 that £15 is repaid by four yearly instalments.

Realising that the man in that district can have no premium or no remuneration so far as fees are concerned, he has lost from £16 to £20, because the man who is allocated a bull through the committee of agriculture pays £50 or £60 for the animal, and there is a premium which is valued over a period of years at £60 or £65. Therefore, there is a net difference of £16 to £20 between the man in the poorer area and the man in the richer district. We have had this brought to our notice through the committee of agriculture, and we have submitted the facts as best we could to the Department. I would like the Minister to investigate the matter, with a view to having an adjustment which, I am sure, will work out in favour of the man in the congested district.

Comment on this

I am very much afraid that it is more or less a foolish thing for one to take any part in this debate at all. For the past six or seven years we have been appealing to the Minister for Agriculture to do something for the farming community. Nothing has been done for them. It seems the Minister is contented to go on the same old way and provide no remedy for the relief of agriculturists. We have had all sorts of suggestions as to the farmers' ills. Some said they were due to the plague of rabbits; others that our troubles were because of the invasion of the markets by Argentine sheep. My opinion is that the main cause of our trouble is that we have a Minister for Agriculture in charge who does not know his job. If he does know his job, then he allows himself to be dominated by the city mentality of the Executive Council. The real cause of our trouble is that we have men sitting on the front benches who are city men. I do agree that the Minister for Agriculture is an eminent medical man, and that his vocation in life is to ease the sufferings of the people. Instead of easing the sufferings of mankind, he is intensifying the sufferings of the whole agricultural community. The first thing the Minister should do is to take his courage in his hands, dictate to the Executive Council, or else take a back seat. This House must not allow the whole agricultural community to wither away because the Minister will not do his job.

The second item that is wrong in the country is the shortage of cash. Until we have a sufficiency of cash in our countryside, we cannot revive the agricultural industry. The first remedy in the way of resurrecting rural life is to bring money to the farmer's home. How that is to be done does not matter. It may be done either through grants, through subsidies or loans. But the Government must give the farmers cash to stock their lands. That is the initial step. At present the lands of the country are unstocked, the soil is deteriorating, much of the land is getting overgrown with rushes, the ditches and hedges uncared for, the sons and daughters of the household flying away from the land, and nothing is left. Well, if the country is to survive these things must be set right.

A few months ago the Minister for Defence stood up here and in a bold manner said he wanted £8,000,000 here and now in order to put an Army of 40,000 or 50,000 men into the field to defend this country. Defend it against what? He said nothing about that but he demanded his £8,000,000, and he got it. We do not see the Minister for Agriculture getting up and saying he wants £8,000,000 to spend on a far more important business—that is, to resurrect the whole farming industry and to aid the entire mass of the people in the producing community. If the Minister for Agriculture stood up and said he wanted £8,000,000 for that purpose he would get the full support of this House. The Minister is a man with a weak will. He does not dominate the situation. He should be able to dictate to the Executive Council for he is a man who belongs to and knows all about the land. What the men on the land now want is cash to buy a cow, a plough and a sow, and all these things which go to make for production on the land.

Another item that is wrong is the one for overhead charges. Every Deputy who spoke to-day said the overhead charges were too heavy and there were too many overhead charges. Until these charges are lowered the farmers will not be able to make the land a paying proposition. Another evil is the horde of officials we have in the country. Year by year there is an increase in this horde and everyone of these officials earns from £200 to £1,500 a year. We could do with a tenth of these officials. Not alone have we too many officials but we have too many Governments. It is unfortunate to see a little small country with 3,000,000 or 4,000,000 people having to maintain two costly Governments competing with one another and both competing with the British Government. Everything that "John Bull" does in England must be followed here by our Governments. We were told for generations how cheaply this country could be run by a native Government. But the position now is that whatever the English people try for, we have got into such an imitative way that we follow them in that cry and we must get the same thing. We must get away from that whole idea of living, the English idea, and get back to the old Irish way of living, the way that is peaceable, religious and in every way sound. Let us get away from being a little empire. We were never more than a small impoverished nation and that is what we will be until the end of time.

Deputy Childers gave us a very reasonable lecture on the whole position of agriculture. But that lecture came from a man who got his knowledge through delving in books. He put up a number of theories and tried to solve them. I want to tell the Deputy that the fact is that one must live on the land in order to be able to solve these problems. The ordinary man living on the land can tell the Deputy more about the general facts of agriculture than he can learn from books. the average man working his land knows more than Deputy Childers or anybody else about it. The Deputy argues that a man has so many cattle, that he keeps these cattle for a certain time and that he must make so much profit out of them. That is all right on paper. But the Deputy says nothing about the number of beasts that die, the cows that do not produce a calf because they have got white scour. He does not tell the House that very often at the end of the year instead of a profit it is a loss the farmer has to face.

Then there is the unfortunate situation with regard to the weather. The part of the year when rain is wanted we have a solid spell of dry weather. That was the position last year and the hard, dry spring was followed up by wet weather, the worst we had for 20 years. These are the reactions against the farmers. The wet weather of last September practically destroyed a great deal of our land. Nearly all our good land was saturated. One can see land that had been good, dry land going back into rushes; this land never before grew rushes but when the soil was saturated, cold and impoverished by the wet it went back into that condition.

The main source of wealth of the agricultural community is cattle, horses, sheep, pigs and poultry. These are the natural resources of the people and the farmer must be put on his feet so that he will have a sufficient stock of these on his land. At the present moment the Minister for Industry and Commerce can command and get any money he likes for industries. More power to his elbow. That Minister is a fighter. He gets through by determination. But there is nothing given for agriculture because our Minister does not look for anything. The Minister for Agriculture sits there. He is a happy-go-lucky smiling man and no matter what one says to him he will laugh it off. The Minister for Industry and Commerce will not laugh it off. He comes here and says: "I want so-and-so", and he gets it.

I say to the Minister for Agriculture that the people down the country are losing confidence in him. Many of these people a short time ago would travel miles to hear him. The farmers who held the demonstration through the streets of Dublin a few weeks ago were some months back 100 per cent. supporters of the Government. These men heard about the Minister for Agriculture making sneering remarks about them—that they would be better off at home than marching through the streets of Dublin. That statement will follow the Minister to the end of his life. A short time ago these men were, I should say, 80 per cent. supporters of the present Government. They came there, keen, patriotic men, to let Dublin realise that there was something wrong with their position. Some people in the City of Dublin say that "the farmers are always growling; no matter what they get, they are complaining, the devil mend them." Now the people of Dublin and other towns should realise that the farmer has to work from morning till night to produce the food they have on their tables. The Minister should stand up now and apologise for the words he said about the farmers. One of the most unfortunate things that happened in the economic war was the position that our Government found itself in so far as the farmers at least were concerned. They had to try all kinds of stunts in order to blind the people and get them to follow them. First of all, they started one of the most unfortunate schemes that this country ever heard of, a scheme which I think has brought a curse on our country, that is, the slaughtering of the calves. That was a most foolish scheme. If they only gave the calves to the unfortunate people of the country for nothing, there would be some return, because it would help to keep them working on the land.

Then there was the free meat scheme. Every idle man in the country got his junk of free meat. If there were ten in the family they got ten junks of meat, with the result that they had to go round and sell some of it, while the unfortunate men who were working hard trying to produce wealth for the nation could not get a bit of free meat. Oh, no; they were not idle, but we had to feed our idle men. They could get free meat, while the men who were producing it could get nothing. That was another curse on the country.

Then we were told we would have to grow wheat. The farmers grew it, not for love of growing wheat but because it was the only chance they had of getting a few "bob". There was a guaranteed price for it, but there was certainly no guarantee that the weather would be suitable. A good many farmers ripped up fine soil—ten or 20 acres of it—at a big cost, and put it in their wheat crop at the proper time, but when it came to the reaping it did not yield three or four barrels to the acre. When they went to the Government for assistance, stating that they had destroyed the land and had got no return, the Minister said: "Try it again next year; perhaps you will be lucky." Some of them were able to try it in the following year, and they did try it, but for the last three years of the wheat scheme they were definitely put out on the dole, because the crop was worse and worse, and even the little they could produce was not millable.

In other counties the Government brought in a great factory called the beet factory, which I think the Minister himself said was a huge white elephant, and should never have been started. Of course some stunt had to be carried out, and therefore they had to put up three or four big factories at a cost of thousands and thousands of pounds. To-day they are definitely white elephants, and the Minister cannot deny it. It is a pity that that money was not expended on the production of something else.

In my county the Fianna Fáil representatives were told to go around to the different meetings and announce a grand new industry for Ireland, the tobacco industry. They went from club to club and told the farmers to get ready for the new crop of tobacco. The clubs became as active as possible in getting the farmers to apply for licenses. Down in Randalstown a huge concern for tobacco, in the past, was cleaned up and painted. Speeches were made every week; secretaries were appointed, a staff were employed, and a certain hand picked group of men in my county got licenses. I want to say they made a huge profit on the concern. On an acre of land they made anything from £40 to £100. Of course they tried it again in the next year, and were successful in getting a huge crop. Then they thought that all was over—the war was won. Those men thought they had a permanent agricultural system which would produce £40 to £100 an acre every year. What is the result this year? The Randalstown factory has been closed down. Nobody is allowed to grow tobacco in county Meath.

Comment on this

Who told the Deputy that?

Comment on this

I know it from those men who grew it, and could not get licences.

Comment on this

They could get licences.

Comment on this

The people came to me and said they could not.

Comment on this

I have listened to a good many untruths from the Deputy, but I cannot put up with any more of them.

Comment on this

The Minister will have to put up with this.

Comment on this

It is not true.

Comment on this

Randalstown has definitely been closed down.

Comment on this

It has.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will open it up again because, remember, Meath was engaged in the tobacco industry years before the counties which the Minister is petting to-day ever heard of it. It is unfair to go around the country leading people into making fools of themselves. The Randalstown factory should be opened up. If the tobacco industry can be made successful in other counties it can be made successful in my county also, which is as much entitled to it as any other country.

Comment on this

Nobody stopped them from growing tobacco.

Comment on this

I am glad the Minister has said that, and I hope it will get publicity, because the men down there think they have been stabbed in the back.

Comment on this

I think a lot of the Deputy's statements are based on statements like that.

Comment on this

The tomfoolery of the last eight years has ruined the country. Forty million pounds has been thrown away on wild cat schemes, all for the purpose of deceiving the people and bolstering up a dying policy. It is the duty of the Minister to take off his coat and stand in front of the Executive Council and demand what he wants. The Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Defence can get whatever they want. If they want £50,000,000 they can get it. But the Minister for Agriculture cannot get anything, because he is too slow and too quiet. I say that he should get up, do his job, and try to redeem himself, because he has gone down a great deal in the estimation of every farmer, big and small, in the country.

Comment on this

My contribution to this debate will, I hope, be brief. As I see it, the tendency in this country is like that in every other country—the tendency towards the ending of the small farm and the creation of the big farm. I suppose world economic conditions make for that. In every county —whether it be the congested counties in the west and south, or counties which are not congested, like those in the Midlands—the tendency is for the small uneconomic holder to sell his holding and get out, the holding being bought by his neighbour who is a bigger holder. If we are concerned with the flight from the land, and if we want to maintain the rural population, to my mind the State will have to come to the aid of the small holder, especially the £10 valuation man, not in the form of loans but in the form of free grants of various kinds. I am not a believer in loans. I have seen the Agricultural Credit Corporation operating for a number of years, and I am convinced that the farmer was far better off on the four months' bill in the joint stock bank—when he had that accommodation—than he is under the system of loans from the Agricultural Credit Corporation, because unless he is lucky, unless his stock lives and are healthy, unless he is very hard working, he will not be able to pay back the capital and interest which become due half yearly. Should he lose a cow, should he lose a store beast, or should he lose pigs through swine fever or other things, the possibility of his paying back the loan become very small. He gets into difficulties, and becomes financially embarrassed. In the old days, before the war, when he went in and got £30 or £40 on a four months' bill, he could pay a few pounds off, or explain to the manager of the bank that he had met with losses and could only pay the interest which became due at the end of the four months. He was very much better off under that system.

I believe that the small farmer is taking too much out of the soil, and that he has not the wherewithal to put back into the soil a corresponding amount. The Government have done something this year in the form of cheaper artificial manures. I think they should do something to ensure that the very small holder—say under £10 or £15 valuation—would have artificial manure every year. In my own county the necessity for artificial manure is not as great as, say, in the adjoining counties of Cavan or Longford. I have spoken to people from these counties, and they tell me that unless they can put artificial manure or farmyard manure on the land, the milk yield from the cows is very poor. There is a remarkable contrast between the yield and the quality of milk given by cows on a farm that has been treated with artificial manures, and the yield and quality of milk which comes from cows on a farm that has received no manures.

The Government have done a lot in the matter of providing free sows, and the Minister is to be congratulated on his efforts in that regard. At the same time, I understand the pig population is falling. That is not due to the free sow scheme, and I assume that that problem will be tackled from another angle. The scheme initiated in giving free sows should be extended to other forms of livestock. It should be extended to heifers, and a direction should be given to see that every smallholder in the country has the right sort of horse. Where a farm can carry sheep, a half-a-dozen or so, the occupier should be supplied with these. Ever since I became a public representative, I have advocated that stock, where necessary, should be given free, gratis and for nothing. That is the only solution. To my mind the farming industry is under-capitalised. It should be capitalised by the Government in the form of free grants, free sows, free heifers and free horses, until each farm carries a full complement of stock.

The Minister has certainly gone a long way towards encouraging the co-operative spirit amongst farmers. I do not often agree with what Deputy Dillon says in this House, but I certainly pay the compliment to him that on a previous occasion, when speaking of land division, he advocated that when a ranch of 500 or 600 acres was being divided, the houses should be built in the form of a village and the lands should be worked co-operatively —that the profits from the land should be divided, and that there should be proper management of these lands. I have seen that system worked on the Continent, and it worked very well. I have seen such people enjoy all the amenities of town life. They have electricity, water supplies, sewerage, and every other modern comfort. They have to work very hard, no doubt, both men and women. They work from sunrise to sunset, but, at the same time, I believe that under a co-operative system like that we would get a better return from our farms and a better life for the people working on the land than is possible under the individual kind of farming carried on in this country at present.

As I have said, I advocated that various things should be supplied free for farmers under £10 to £15 valuation. In the Gaeltacht subsidies are given for Irish-speaking children. The time may have to come when the Government will have to consider subsidising families of a certain number and paying towards the maintenance of large families out of the Exchequer. Anyone conversant with rural conditions—and, mind you, you have uneconomic holdings in the Midlands just as in the West—knows that a farmer of £5 or £6 valuation, with a house full of children —say seven, eight or nine children—is in a desperate plight. He is in a far worse position than the agricultural labourer, because in the case of the agricultural labourer there is a steady income, even though it is small; it is a steady flow of cash weekly. On the other hand, the farmer is dependent on the turnover of a couple of cattle twice a year, and of a few sets of pigs. That is all his land is able to give him. If you want to prevent the drift to the towns you will have to consider seriously subsidising the farmer who has a large family. It has been done in other countries, and it can be done here. Unless that is done, the rural population will continue to drop. Economic circumstances will force them to leave the land and go into the towns where they can get a living more easily.

The last matter with which I want to deal has reference to the position of the middle-class farmer. For a number of years past I have advocated the liquidation of the debts created a quarter of a century ago— from 21 to 25 years ago—on farms on which mortgages were taken out and on which interest has been paid again and again. The payment of that interest has paralysed the middle-class farmer, and the big farmer, too. In evidence before the Banking Commission, I advocated the liquidation of these debts, as has been done in practically every continental country. The banks should bear in mind that they cannot take blood out of a turnip. The Government should indicate to them that it is time now, after a quarter of a century, to liquidate these debts and to let farming get on. It is no harm to repeat. If these debts were liquidated and a certain sum fixed in settlement of these debts, that settlement would relieve a very large portion of the community in Munster, Leinster and East Connaught.

Comment on this

To my mind, the way to make this country prosperous again is to encourage the farmers to go in for mixed farming. I remember that in the 'eighties, in the constituency which the Minister and I represent, the farmers, big and small, tilled 75 per cent. of their land. Then, because of the fact that some new countries came into corn production, the farmer got a setback. His circumstances disimproved and his condition was nearly as bad as it is to-day and, goodness knows, that is bad enough. However, about 1911 and up to 1914 the farmers in that county were fairly well-off. They had even a little money in the bank and the farmer was able to provide a fairly decent living for himself and his family on the land. After some years, we got a native Government and the first thing that happened under a native Government was that the minority forced a civil war on the majority. After ten years there was another change of Government. The Government that took up office then said that the majority must rule, a thing that, I believe, was equally true in 1922.

The Fianna Fáil Party should jog their memories and think of the promises they made to the farmers as well as others before the 1932 election. They told the people: "If you return Fianna Fáil to power your land will be derated. We believe the land annuities are not legally or morally due to England." That was very good news. A good many farmers swallowed that and voted for Fianna Fáil; but like Fianna Fáil Deputies to-day, they found out that these were false promises. I am glad to see Fianna Fáil back benchers finding out the state of the farmers. I am glad that when we speak now we do not hear such cries as "The ranchers,""Up Dev," or "Cattle must go." When the economic war was first started an ex-Senator stated that it took 100 years to build up the cattle industry but, thank God, it would not take 100 days to wreck it. Are not such statements foolish, coming from people from whom you would expect something better?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not customary in this House to refer to one who is no longer a member.

Comment on this

When he was a member——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not done.

Comment on this

I bow to your ruling. Anyway, I suppose it is hurtful to hear the truth.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is only concerned with the rules of order.

Comment on this

I am not instructing the Chair in any way. I have respect for the Chair. I am sure that if the Chair had its way things would not be as they are. There are so many city men on the Government Front Bench that I feel for the Minister for Agriculture, who is a countryman, like myself. In the Land League days his father and I stood side by side on the same platform. But, unfortunately, things which have sprung up since have divided families. I am sure there is a hope that we will all come together again to work this country for all it is worth, and the only way to do that is to make agriculture prosperous, give the farmer a living wage and encourage him and his children to remain on the land. Farmers' wives, sons and daughters are no more than slaves at the present time.

Those who leave the land to go into the towns or across the water when they come back have nothing but contempt for those who are left at home. No wonder they would. We hear a lot about the economic war and how it was fought and finished, but who bore the brunt of that war? The farmers and the agricultural labourers. In 1933, when the prices of cattle were at their lowest, for a beast which realised £12 on the British market the farmer here got £4 1s. 8d. Six pounds had to be paid as a tariff to the British Government. You can blame whom you like for that—the British Government or the Irish Government—it was immaterial to the poor unfortunate people who had to pay it. They got £4 1s. 8d. for a two-and-a-half year old bullock or heifer, as the case may be. Before the economic war, that beast was worth £4 when three days' old. After being kept for two and a half years, it had to be sold for the same amount of money. Then you will hear Fianna Fáil Deputies saying that the farmer has so much money in the bank. I know what he has in the bank. He has bills that he is not able to meet. Any farmer who has money in the bank did not make it by farming. If a farmer did make money in the good times, he has drawn it all out now.

There is another class of the community which is very badly treated— the agricultural workers. In the Land League days the agricultural workers fought side by side with the farmers. By supporting our representatives in the British Parliament they got fixity of tenure for the Irish farmers and they got Land Purchase Acts passed. The fathers and grandfathers of some Deputies here were delighted with their bargain. They said: "When we pay off the principal and interest, our holdings will be our own." What did our native Government do? They passed a Land Act depriving the farmer of fixity of tenure. It is time for that Act to be amended.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not advocate legislation on an Estimate. In any case, it is a matter for another Department.

Comment on this

As to the agricultural worker, how is he situated? Some time ago I asked a question about hundreds of labourers' cottages in the County Wexford being badly in need of repair, some of them not being fit for human habitation. The board of health attacked me for that, and said they thought that I was a decent, honest man. Some of these agricultural labourers had been reporting for years that their cottages were in a bad state, but there was nothing done for them. Yet I was attacked by the board of health. They said that I had disgraced the County Wexford. But I only did my duty, and I am doing it still. There are many of these cottages not repaired yet.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Has the Minister for Agriculture any responsibility for that?

Comment on this

No. The board of health have. I know the Minister will help me in getting homes for the labourers of Wexford which will be fit to live in. Many of them at present are not fit for human habitation. Another thing I want to impress on the Minister is to get the Pigs Marketing Board to insist on pigs being graded alive, and not dead. It is no wonder that the pig population has gone down under the present conditions. When a pig is slaughtered the producer is not going to bring it home again. If the pig is graded alive, if it is too fat or too lean, too leavy or too light, he can take it away again. But when it is dead he has to put up with the grading made in the factory. I am sure Deputies will agree that the producer of pigs is not getting a fair deal. The prices given for pigs are good, but the price of feeding stuffs is too high.

If farmers are to be able to send their produce to the British market at a competitive price, agricultural land and farm buildings will have to be derated and the price of feeding stuffs will have to be brought down to the British and Northern Ireland level.

Farmers are being handicapped in every way. Some time ago there was a new food put on the market called cooked wheat. I do not know whether it came from Russia or not, but I know that it was sold at £5 10s. per ton in England while it costs £9 per ton here. When the second cargo came the "red flag" went up and it was stated: "There is no more of that to come in here." That is how our farmers are treated. That is the reason why the people are flying from the land. There is no encouragement given to young men and young women to stay at home and work the land.

There is another thing which the Government would be wise to do and that is to offer some encouragement to agricultural labourers to marry. The State should come to the aid of married labourers by giving them some help to rear their families. It is not fair that a married labourer should only receive 14/- per week and his board. He will want 1/- or 1/6 per week for tobacco and other things, for himself and his wife cannot be expected to buy a week's food for 10/- or 11/-. The sooner the Government come to the aid of the farmers and the agricultural workers the better for the country, as the city people and the townspeople cannot be prosperous as long as agriculture is bankrupt. As long as the agricultural labourer is badly fed, and badly clad, he will not take any interest in his employer's business, and it could not be expected that he would take such interest. The towns-people and the city people should realise that this country cannot be prosperous if the farmer is not prosperous. I myself have always encouraged the use of home-produced agricultural machinery. I have always purchased and used the machinery of Messrs. Pierce, of Wexford, long before this Government came into office. They are doing very well there now, but, as a result of the tariffs that have been imposed, the farmers is being made to pay more for everthing that he wants. The result is that the farmer, just like a poor man with an old suit of clothes, who will make the suit last as long as possible, is making his machinery go as far as it can, in order to try to keep going.

In conclusion, I would ask the Minister to put his hand to his heart— he came from a good family and a good county, a tillage county—and to encourage the farmer to till and also to do everything possible to encourage those gentlemen, who speak so much about bullocks in this country, to realise that the more live stock is raised in a country the more employment you can give. The man who is going in for mixed farming caters for his live stock in the spring, summer and autumn, and he has to provide for feed for his cattle in the winter. I myself find that the most work has to be done at Christmas. There is no question of unemployment in a country where that class of farming is being carried on, because you will need to employ men both in winter and in summer, and I say that it is up to the Minister for Agriculture to impress that on his colleagues in the Cabinet.

Comment on this

I intervene in this debate with some hesitation, because I may be told that I have little right to talk on this subject. I am not a farmer and, besides, I belong to a Party the attitude of which, I think, is very often misunderstood, if not misrepresented, in relation to agriculture. There used to be an idea in this country that farmers and workers were a sort of natural enemies and that very deep antipathies prevailed between them. That is not true, I believe, and even the people whom I have met in the Party to which I belong, or in the movement with which I am associated, have never shared that idea. I think the ultimate salvation of this country must come as a result of a combination between farmers and workers, and I sincerely hope that in a very short time we shall see that hope realised in the installation of a Government of that type in this country. There are in this country 200,000 farmers whose valuation does not exceed £10. A very large proportion of holdings, of that kind are situated in the county I come from, and I should say that the great majority of the holdings, in the constituency I have the honour to represent in this House, are holdings of that type.

I think that nobody who knows anything about West Cork could deny the industry and perseverance of the farmers and workers there in their efforts to win a living for themselves on the soil under very considerable difficulties. I have had 16 years' association—and very intimate association —with these people, because I sit in this House by virtue of the support of the working farmers and the agricultural workers in West Cork, and that enables me to approach their problems with some sympathy and, at least, a desire to understand them. If there is one thing that has struck me during that time, and particularly during the recent years of that period, it is the fortitude with which such people bear their burdens, and the fortitude with which they endure their sufferings.

It has struck me, as a member of a local authority there, that to the average farming household in West Cork, faced with domestic illness that, unfortunately, sometimes has an unhappy knack of occurring in the case of two or three members of a family at the one time—that illness often means almost complete ruin, because there are hospital fees, medical charges and other costs associated with illness, to be met. To my own certain knowledge, such illness has meant the piling up of debt in households of that kind that cannot possibly be redeemed during the lifetime of the present head of the household. Very unfortunately, also, that is very often coupled with losses of another description, such as losses in capital from one cause or another. I often marvel at the resignation and fortitude with which troubles of that kind are borne.

Now, my observation on the present position of the working farmers of West Cork, as I know them, is the great poverty that exists amongst a very large number of them. I heard from the lips of a parish priest in West Cork, some time ago, the story that 300 young girls and young men had left his parish, and I heard from an eminent ecclesiastic from another country, with whom I had the opportunity of talking recently, that his impressions, after consulting a number of people who had visited his diocese across in England and who were resident there, were, according to the information of these people, that they had left this country, not because of any desire to seek the "lure of the pavement", as it was called in another House, but to get a living there because they could not get a living here at home. I think that that is the most terrible indictment of native Government that could be put forward, and I think it is a tremendous confession of failure on the part of all of us in this country—and I do not want to make any narrow, Party capital out of this matter—that, 15 years after this House was established, that should be the condition of affairs.

I intervene in this discussion at a time when the debate, presumably, is drawing to a close, and I do not want to labour the position, and neither do I wish to exaggerate it; but there seems to be a suggestion, here and there in this debate, that the present position was, to some extent, the result of an unwillingness to work on the part of the workers. I suppose it is inevitable that we should have statements of that kind. I do not want to refer to statements of that kind in any harsh terms, but I very definitely and confidently repudiate the existence of any such state of things in that part of the country that I know intimately, and I think that, in view of that fact, it would be very interesting to examine the present position with regard to employment on the land in this country. The figures that were returned in that respect are very striking, it seems to me. In the period between 1934 and 1938 there were 25,500 fewer wage-earners on the land in this country; 13,000 people who had gone out of paid employment in agriculture were permanent employees, and it is well to remember that, in view of many things we are told about the number of new workers who have got into employment. The remaining 12,500 were casual employees, but, in all 25,500 fewer people worked on the land in 1938 compared with the number similarly engaged in 1934.

A good deal has been said in this debate with regard to wheat and other crops. Here, again, the figures available are extremely interesting. In 1938, there were 10,000 additional acres under wheat compared with the acreage in 1937, but another situation also manifested itself in that period. In 1938, there were 920,000 acres under corn crops; in 1937, there were 926,000 acres, and in 1936, 946,000 acres under the same type of crops. If we turn to root crops, the figures are equally striking. In 1936, there were 662,000 acres under root crops; in 1937, 653,000 acres, and, in 1938, 635,000 acres. It seems to me that the cause of the decline, very definite, very marked and very striking, in crops and in human beings actively associated with agriculture is quite definitely due to uncertainty with regard to prices and markets, and I echo some of the very interesting suggestions made here for an improvement in that position. It is, quite frankly and definitely, a very vital and important part of the policy of the Party with which I am associated in connection with agriculture.

I was glad to hear this evening references to New Zealand, and I hope Deputies will remember that what has been achieved for the benefit of agriculture in New Zealand, the very striking improvement that has been made in that country from the agricultural, the social, and various other points of view, has been largely achieved by Irishmen. A very large percentage of the people who comprise the Government of New Zealand are Irish men or of Irish descent. May it also be said that they belong to a working class Party, and that they have been able to achieve there what unfortunately has not yet been achieved, and unfortunately looks unlikely of achievement for some time yet, in their own mother country.

Quite definitely, in my opinion, credit facilities for farmers are necessary, and necessary immediately. I speak in no spirit of appreciation or disparagement of the Agricultural Commission. Obviously because of suggestions that radical remedies are necessary, the whole problem of agriculture requires examination in that way, but I speak of what is necessary in the meantime. The Agricultural Commission will deliberate for a considerable time, and perhaps a very much longer time to consider a report, and nobody who has had experience of the tedious manner in which the investigations of a commission have necessarily to be carried out will expect any early remedy. In the meantime the position of the small farmers particularly grows steadily worse. I take no pleasure in stating that fact here. I think it would be a pleasure for all of us to be able to point to an improvement. No matter to what Party the credit for that improvement was due, and no matter what the value politically of that improvement would be, I think it would be something of which all of us could very well be proud.

I advocate credit facilities as a very urgent reform. Whether they take the form of money repayable at a nominal, very trifling rate of interest, or the form of grants to people in that position, they are certainly necessary. After all, when the Great War terminated in 1918, the first job undertaken was rebuilding in the war zone. I suggest that that might be applied at home. The agriculturists of this country have had a strenuous time, and there has been a no less strenuous time for the unfortunate workers who were engaged on the land during the past five or six years. It will serve no purpose now to go into the history of that period. Like Deputy Childers and others, I think it wise to avoid any discussion of the matter, but there is certainly the accepted principle that there ought to be compensation for losses in war-time and I suggest that an endeavour to put the farmers, harassed, in great difficulty, many of them in acute poverty at present, on their feet is very urgent, and that method might reasonably be considered under that heading.

I also think that this question of the endowment of the family is one which ought to be considered at an early date. It is of very special importance to the working farmer and to the small farmer, blessed as he very often is with a large family. His difficulties, during the years of childhood of his family, are enormous. Nobody but some person very closely in touch with such people, and not always even such people, can appreciate these difficulties. We have the pointers, wherever we look in this country, to the decline in our people. Whether we look at the schools or whether we look at the records of local authorities in one way or another, there is that clear and unmistakeable evidence of a decline in the population. This principle has been given effect to in other countries, and I think it is one which ought to be considered, with special reference to the position of the small farmer and the agricultural labourer. I say that because I believe that the cases of such people typify very specially the need for some reform of that kind at present.

I have heard references here to co-operation, and I am wondering what exactly is meant in that respect. If co-operation means continuing the policy that puts a few people into business and puts another section out of business, then, I would not be a very enthusiastic admirer of it. I have seen evidence of something described occasionally as co-operation in various parts of West Cork at the present time that I am not in agreement with. I say that with all respect and without any desire to say anything that is vitally controversial in a debate of this kind, where I think such matters ought to be avoided.

One other problem besets the small farmer and his wife and children, the working farmer and the agricultural labourer, and generally the person with small means in this country at the present time. That problem is living costs. A good deal could be done to improve the position of such people by a reduction in living costs. Take for instance, the position of the labourer who works for wages, or of a farmer whose income is rather uncertain and inclined to diminish: his living costs have soared very rapidly in recent years.

The suggestions I have made were not many, but at least I have tried to make them with the desire to be helpful and with the desire to ensure that the difficulties of the agriculturists of this country might be sympathetically remembered, not by one Party, I hope, or by two Parties, but by all sections of the representatives of the people in this House.

Comment on this

It is sad to listen to the statements made in this debate now, as compared with those made four or five years ago. Yet, those of us who criticised the policy of four or five years ago welcome the increased intelligence that is now being brought to bear on these problems of national existence. It was amusing—if not tragic—to listen to all the suggestions about giving something for nothing. Anybody who understands or studies the national position at the present time will see that the whole trouble is that you cannot get anything. You are face to face with a national financial crisis—thanks to the destruction that was, by a huge majority in this House, perpetrated on agriculture for five or six years. You cannot destroy wealth and have it. And that is what the Government did. A half million calves killed! What would they be worth to-day? Fifteen pounds to £20 a piece. Make it up: it is a simple sum in arithmetic. That is the borrowing power which has been destroyed. What did Deputy Kennedy suggest? I think he suggested the repudiation of debts on mortgages. Repudiate your debts, and who is going to get a loan then? And if a loan cannot be got—if you have not credit you will not get a loan, you will not get money to carry on— national bankruptcy is staring you in the face. The Government are responsible for the condition of agriculture at the present time, and no Deputy from their benches—or from any bench in this House—has got up to suggest that any branch of agriculture is in a flourishing condition, and I challenge anybody to get up and say that it is.

After seven years of government by the Party that had a plan for everything, now it turns out they had a plan for nothing. Agriculture has borne the whole brunt of the economic war. Periodically the English Chancellor has said he has got all he has asked for, he has squared accounts; while at the same time the cows from Munster were being seized and sold in England and in the North of Ireland, and the Government was bringing down its servants to bid under the name of Mr. O'Neill for the cattle they were taking to liquidate a debt that had already been liquidated by the farmers through the British tariffs. Agriculture is now bankrupt, thanks to the Government Party and to the Labour Party that supported them. Make up your mind that no soft talk here is going to placate or cod the people outside who are pretty nearly on the verge of bankruptcy.

We are told by Deputy Kennedy that the small farmer should get free cows, free sows, free horses, free everything. Who is going to give anything free? He told us, too—perhaps in an unguarded moment—that the farmers were better off when they could go into the joint stock banks and sign a bill that a neighbour would back, and pay back the whole of the bill with a seasonal crop. Why were they better off? Because they were honest, and the country with national honesty has national credit. The man who comes back as soon as the promissory note matures, and pays it, is always sure of being welcome to another loan when he comes again. The farmers in this country who had enormous credit in the banks—not only themselves, but their fathers and grandfathers had that credit—find now that that credit has been ruined, not by any fault of their own but by the action of the Government, who have beggared the farmers. The economic war was won, we were told last year when the surrender of our economic freedom was made to save the faces of the politicians who adorn the Government Front Bench, when the ideal and conception of freedom preached by Arthur Griffith for a generation was sacrificed to save political faces. We had peace—the peace that Deputy Childers quoted a few days ago in my native country as a mile stone in the national development of this country, the surrender of what was won by the old I.R.A. nearly half a generation ago. That freedom was sacrificed in order to face-save the politicians opposite.

Comment on this

I never said anything of the kind.

Comment on this

That the settlement of last year was one of the mile stones? If the Deputy denies that, that he ever said it, then I accept his word for it.

Comment on this

I did not say it was face-saving.

Comment on this

I did not accuse the Deputy of saying it was face-saving. I said people would say it was face-saving. Our economic freedom was surrendered in order to save political faces—that I say without fear of contradiction.

I am glad to see Deputy Corry coming to his senses. He gave quite an interesting address here this evening. We have the prices of 1914 for agricultural produce, but for anything that the agriculturist has to buy we have, not the prices of 1914, but war prices. We have to pay as much as we had to pay in the height of the Great War. It did not require superhuman intelligence to know that when an attempt was made to industrialise this country at an accelerated pace this country should have some reserves to call upon. I have often given a quotation in this House from a famous European statesman—that agriculture is the mother of the nation's wealth which industry employs. When we set out to accelerate our pace for the industrialisation of this country there should be a capital reserve in agriculture. But, what was the condition of agriculture? It was taxed by the British. The net price the farmer got was about one-third of the world price. The figure was quoted here by Deputy Keating. I hope the Minister will contradict that, if he can. I hope, at any rate, that he will allude to it. With one-third of the world price for agricultural produce, the Government, with super-intelligence, set out to accelerate the pace of industrialisation, and that industrialisation could only be carried on by an increased tax on agriculture. Was agriculture able to bear it, at one-third of the world price? Of course, it was not. It would have been unwise, even apart from the economic war and the British tariffis, at that stage, to go at such an accelerated pace with industrialisation. But it was carried on. Anybody could come from anywhere and say they would start an industry. There was a prohibitive tariff put up at once. There were prohibitive tariffs put upon goods in this country that were not being made in this country but because some fellow had promised to make them. Who had to pay for it? Agriculture. And, mind you, the Labour Party supported that and the Labour Party supported the subsidisation of industry to give a manual worker £3 or £4 a week, and subsidised it at the expense of agriculture that was only able to give 24/- a week. Those are figures fixed by the Government.

Let us all face up to our past. It is the past records of Parties in this House that I am quoting. As a farmer, I did all classes of work on a farm with my own hands, day and night. I often worked in the moonlight because I was not able to pay a man. The Minister laughs. He never had to do it, but I am sure he will accept my statement when I say I did it.

Comment on this

I would believe anything you would say.

Comment on this

I am not asking you to believe anything I would say. I am not addressing myself entirely to the Minister. But now his eyes are open, and I hope he will not be so gullible in believing everything now as he was obdurate in believing nothing a few years ago. The cobwebs are taken off his eyes now. Let him tell this House and this country where the profits arising out of his policy are.

Comment on this

I will if you give me a chance.

Comment on this

We will give you a chance. If you did not get it to-day, to-morrow is another day. We will be glad to listen to you, but we will have our chance first. The Minister set out with a scheme for mixtures, and he argued here in this House that because he mixed corn here and fixed a price that that was good for agriculture. He flouted the economic truism that the ultimate price that could be paid for corn in this country was what the product of that corn, namely, beef, mutton, pork or bacon, would fetch in the world market. He learns it now. He is going to abolish the scheme.

The economic war has brought agriculture to where it is—and it is in a deplorable condition. Agriculture bore the cost of the economic war. No compensation has been given to agriculture since the settlement. I will not go into the settlement, whether it was good or bad or what it surrendered, but the economic war was settled and no compensation has been given to agriculture.

The question of derating was put up. Why is not derating effected, and stop all this nonsense about spoon-feeding? No farmer in this country will ever be able to make a success of agriculture by spoon-feeding. If you are not able to produce a class of men to work the soil of this country who can stand on their own two legs and look everybody in the face without any sops from anybody, then your country is going down. Put agriculture on an economic basis, and let agriculturists work it, and if they fail let them fail just as the workers in any other industry migh fail. But stop spoon-feeding. It is due to agriculture to be compensated for what the industry suffered in the economic war.

A demand has gone from all over the country—for which I take a certain amount of pardonable pride, because I was the first, in 1928, to raise the banner—for derating in this country. What reason has the Minister for refusing it? He comes in with a Vote of something less than £600,000 to administer the whole agricultural machinery of the country. The Minister for industry and Commerce comes in with a higher Vote to accommodate a few holidaymakers coming into this country. Are they to come in to see agriculture bankrupt? Why did not the Minister ask for money for derating? What is his objection to it? I think I have read where the Minister stated that derating would help the big farmer, but would not help the small one. It shows the Minister's lack of appreciation of what derating is. Did the Minister ever consider that derating was advocated, not for the individual, but for the industry? Is the Minister going to argue that complete derating, which would mean a lightening of the burden on agriculture of over £2,000,000, will not be good for that industry?

Comment on this

Where did you get the £2,000,000? It does not amount to £2,000,000.

Comment on this

Then you have less reason for refusing it.

Comment on this

I was pointing out that the Deputy was wrong in saying £2,000,000.

Comment on this

I think, if farm buildings are taken into account, that it will be more.

Comment on this

No, less.

Comment on this

I accept the correction, but I think it is very little less. £2,000,000 is a round figure; take it at £1,500,000.

Comment on this

£1,000,000 would be nearer to it.

Comment on this

And that £1,000,000 to help agriculture has been refused, and the only argument that the Minister put up and that he stands over here is that it would be good for the big farmer but it would be bad for the small farmer. I know the line of argument he takes. That argument was taken ten years ago, when I addressed the members of the Leitrim County Council in Carrick-on-Shannon and when the members of the Minister's Party who were members of the Council there supported me.

Comment on this

We were all together at that time.

Comment on this

We were not together. Perhaps we were further apart then than we are now. If we were together on this point, I am sorry for the wanderings of the Minister.

Comment on this

Oh, no. I never wandered. The Deputy wandered right around and back again.

Comment on this

What about the Minister who would not come into this House?

Comment on this

Whatever wandering the Deputy did, he made good use of his time.

Comment on this

He never wandered, but the Minister, led by the nose by his leader, boxed the compass. There is no "Up the Republic!" now.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not want a compass.

Comment on this

However, the Minister is not going by any slick suggestion to turn me off my argument or my speech.

Comment on this

You have no argument.

Comment on this

The Minister says that £1,000,000 going to agriculture in the shape of derating would not help the small farmers. Live stock is one of the principal branches of agriculture. Who produces our live stock? Are the small farmers of the country not the breeders of that live stock? The Minister would devise a scheme for derating the small farmers. The small farmer who has a yearling or a year-and-a-half to sell has to sell that beast to a bigger farmer. The latter can give one price for the yearling if he can put it on derated land, but he must give a lesser price for the yearling if he has to put it on land that is highly rated. I remember the Minister saying here, when he was defending the giving of cattle licences to the dealers: "That will work its way down to the producer." Will the Minister not accept this: that by derating all agricultural land, the increased prices for live stock will be distributed over all farmers, big and small? If the Minister is not satisfied with that way of partially helping agriculture we will be glad to hear what other suggestion be has to make for helping it. I hope he has travelled some distance in that direction since the time when the people of this country were taxed, to pay the "John Browns" to buy the cattle that were seized from the farmers.

A great deal of play has been made about the growing of wheat here. I always stood for the growing of wheat. The Minister claims to be a champion of wheat-growing. I say that the growing of wheat successfully and permanently in this country will depend on the success of the laboratory. I see here in the Book of Estimates that the Faculty of Agriculture is costing to-day precisely what it cost when it was set up in the University—about £24,000 a year. The plant breeder is still a lecturer there and not a professor, so that the very key to the making of this country a successful wheat-growing country has been neglected. The growing of wheat successfully, in any country, and I challenge the Minister to contradict this, depends upon breeding a strain of wheat suitable to the soil and climate of that country. That must be done in the plant breeding section up in the laboratory.

It must be done through the Faculty of Agriculture, and it must be financed. As a member of the board that set up this faculty in the university, I endeavoured to get a professorship in plant breeding. I failed, and it is still a lectureship. There is not a penny more available for plant breeding than there was at that time, and yet the Minister and his Party go out shouting: "Grow more wheat!" I believe in growing wheat, and I think that I grow as much of it—and that I grow it as successfully—as the Minister. That, however, is not here or there.

I believe in the growing of wheat. It is wrong to say that wheat is not a profitable crop on suitable land. It is artificially profitable. I got over 30/- a barrel in my haggard, and so did others, for my wheat this year. It was carted away free in sacks at a time when good milling wheat could be bought at 14/- and 15/- a barrel. I believe in the growing of wheat on national grounds and on defence grounds, just as I believe that the best defence for this country in the face of a European war would be to have agriculture in a strong position. Yet, in spite of that, it is doubtful business to produce an article at 30/- if you can buy it at 15/-. I am as strongly in favour of tillage as any member of the House. I probably do as much tillage as anybody in the House, but there is no crop I will grow if I can buy it at half the price that it costs me to grow it. Any man who does that is inviting bankruptcy, and the nation that does it is inviting bankruptcy. I would like to hear the Minister justify the utilisation of land in this country for the growing of a particular crop if that crop can be bought at a less figure than it costs to produce here.

Comment on this

That applies to every farm product at the present time.

Comment on this

Then the sooner the present Government get out the better.

Comment on this

We cannot change that.

Comment on this

Cannot the Minister get out?

Comment on this

There will be a rout before you feel.

Comment on this

There is not an article we are producing that we could not import at a cheaper price.

Comment on this

Where is the fault? Is the land in this country no good, or are the men in it no good? How is it other countries are able to produce, according to the Minister, agricultural products more cheaply than we can, and send them into this country at a lower figure than we can produce them?

Comment on this

Argentine beef can be imported into this country at a much cheaper figure than we could produce it.

Comment on this

Can we produce the same quality of beef? We cannot produce Argentine beef, but we can produce Irish beef which is of better quality. It is all a question of quality.

Comment on this

The Deputy can get away with that sort of thing all right.

Comment on this

It is a sad reflection that the Minister for Agriculture, addressing not only this House, but the nation, has to come here and tell us that every crop we grow in this country can be more cheaply imported, and that there is no cure for that. I think that is the most defeatist policy that I have ever heard coming from the lips of a man entrusted with responsibility. I do not subscribe to that view, and I ask is it not time that some effort was made to remedy that position? Did it ever strike the Minister that if our effort must be to produce food in this country at an economic cost to the producer and at an economic price to the consumer, that we must review our land policy? Did the Minister ever consider that the breaking up of ranches and cheap food are diametrically opposed? The only way to produce cheap food and pay a decent wage in its production is by the use of modern machinery. The only alternative we have to the use of the most up-to-date machinery on the farms is low wages.

I would like to hear some of the Labour Party on this before the debate closes. There is no use in talking about a decent living standard and cheap food in agriculture, because you cannot have it both ways. If you want cheap food you must have slave conditions, according to industrial standards.

If you want to have decent conditions in agriculture, then you must have dear food and high living costs. Which are we going to have? I would like to hear the Labour Party on this. Are we going to have long hours, low wages, and cheap food or an eight-hour day? As a large employer of labour I would welcome an eight-hour day, and I would welcome high wages, if I got high economic prices for the stuff I produce. There is no use in playing to the gallery here. Members of all Parties must face up to the position that agriculture is on the verge of bankruptcy. National credit was never lower. I say that without fear of contradiction, knowing full well what I am talking about. I challenge contradiction of this statement, that national credit was never lower since we got our own Government. I challenge the Minister or any of his colleagues on that. Why? Because our income is so small. We have used up our savings, not only here but our investments abroad. We are face to face now with a national financial crisis, thanks to the incompetency and recklessness of the Government.

The biggest industry we had in this city is practically idle—the building industry. Let any Labour representative contradict that. I challenge representatives of the City or County of Dublin to contradict it. What is the reason? Scarcity of money. Why have we scarcity of money? Because our national credit is low. Why is our national credit low? Because agriculture, our principal industry, and the pillar of our economic life, is bankrupt, thanks to the Government. Where is the remedy? The only one offered was a piecemeal remedy, with a hit here and there; but not to give loans because that is adding a millstone around a man's neck. Give grants. We would all like to get grants. Who will give them? Are we to have nothing in this land but a whole lot of paupers, waiting for some dole or queueing up for one? Is that the freedom we fought for? Is that what the Sinn Féin policy of self-reliance has come to? Are we to watch like hungry dogs for crusts and run off with them? Is that what we have come to? Has there been any other suggestion made? Deputy Flynn and Deputy Kennedy made certain suggestions.

I stand for a different type of agriculture. I stand for agriculture that is able to stand on its own legs. In the past a farmer was able to go into a bank and say he wanted a loan of money, and he got it. Instead of being able to go in and do that now, not only is he not able to pay what he owes, but he is not able to pay the interest. Yet we have representatives standing up and saying, because debts were long overdue to banks, repudiate them. I wonder if we have gone mad altogether. I belong to bodies that severely criticised banks for not handing out money, but I realise that money in banks is entrusted to them and is not their own. Is any public representative prepared to get up and, in his privileged position, tell the people to repudiate debts because they are overdue?

I do not know if wheat is sound nationally. Individually it pays. I grow wheat because it pays me, but I do not believe in the extensive growing of wheat, as has been advocated, at a guaranteed price. It has robbed the land of fertility because during the economic war nothing else paid and people ranched in wheat. They put a tractor into a big field of seven or eight acres of good land. Such land would not be long going out of fertility. At the rate it could be cultivated after being sown and rolled, there would be no more labour needed until a reaper and binder was put in in the harvest. That machine would deal with eight or ten acres in a day. Next year there was wheat there again, and then wheat the following year, until the land was rendered useless. That is what we have got where wheat was grown extensively. Now the Minister wakes up and says that we must restore fertility, after bribing farmers to rob the land of fertility in the last few years. Wheat ranching on the system I have explained, with a guaranteed price, was nothing else but bribing farmers to rob the land and to rob national wealth as truly as if the Minister sent gangsters to rob money out of banks. Now we have to call in the taxpayers to subsidise the land in order to restore fertility, and the munificent sum of 10/- a ton is given on artificial manures. As a previous speaker very properly asked, what is the good of offering 10/- a ton to a farmer who has not the price of a ton of artificial manure? That is what the Minister and his colleagues in the Government have done, while the John Browns, the O'Neills, the Tom Carpenters and all the rest of that type have grown fat on the plunder of the farmers.

Deputy Corry said that we have no exports that are not subsidised. Roughly speaking, that is true. How are we to keep up our credit if we have nothing to sell in the world markets? I leave it to the Minister to explain that. Deputy Corry said there was no land reclamation now. Of course there is not. Who would be mad enough to reclaim land when the best land is not paying? Why should we reclaim land that, at its best, will be secondary land, when first-class land will not pay, and is going into rushes? Some Deputy suggested subsidising farm labour. As a practical farmer I am against any subsidies. I stand for a fair hunt for the man on the land just as I stand for a fair hunt for a man in any other occupation; but, if he is not able to keep his place in the race, he must fall out, just as a man in industrial or commercial life has to fall out. I do not blame the farmers for falling out of the race in the last few years, because they were spancilled and starved before the race and could not run.

The Minister for Defence gets £8,000,000 to defend the outpost of Western Europe here. I put it to the Minister for Agriculture that if we had this country teeming with foodstuffs, would not that be a better first line of defence than 30,000 of an army, armed with British guns, firing British ammunition at some unknown enemy, doubling our navy, or providing five bombing planes? Would it not be better if that £8,000,000 was producing foodstuffs?

Comment on this

What about subsidies?

Comment on this

Not subsidies but in making restitution for the plunder of the last six or seven years that the Deputy supported. There are ways of doing that besides subsidies. Deputy Murphy said that in some quarters farmers and labourers were looked upon as natural enemies. I never saw any attempt at cultivating that animosity except on the basis of the O.B.U. I wonder does Deputy Hurley remember when the Voice of Labour talked in military language in advocating the O.B.U. and described everything in the phraseology of “fronts”? That time is gone and I hope it will never come again. Deputy Murphy objected to co-operative farms. I think he was thinking in terms of co-operative trading. I am at one with him in regard both to co-operative trading and co-operative farms, for one reason if for no other—that the Irish people are not co-operatively inclined, that they want to work out their own salvation. They are very individualistic, and I think they are the better for that. Deputy Corry fears that he would not know what to do with the fellow who wanted to lie down on a co-operative farm. It would be very hard to know what to do.

Comment on this

If Deputy Dillon, Deputy Belton and I were co-operating, we might not know what to do with Deputy Dillon about wheat.

Comment on this

I leave that to the Deputy's fertile imagination.

Comment on this

Would we decide by majority rule?

Comment on this

The Minister should not mind what Deputy Belton would do. When up against it Deputy Belton will be able to draw on his own resources——

Comment on this

On his imagination.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Minister is short of imagination. He will have to tax his imagination in connection with this question of the depressed state of agriculture. Does he admit that it is depressed and, if so, what is his remedy? If he does not admit it, let him show where it is prosperous. If he can do that, he will do more than I can do. The Minister is Minister for Agriculture not on behalf of a Party, but on behalf of the nation. He has been in that position for the last seven years, and agriculture is admitted by his own Party to be in a more serious position to-day than it was when he took up the running seven years ago. Deputy Corry says we have more cows. But we have less milk. Efficiency has gone down. We have more cows because of the period when, except heifers were turned into cows, they were of no value. That gave us a surplus of cows. Let the Minister tell us what remedy he has for the position as regards Deputy Flynn's people on the hills of Kerry and West Cork. They want free sheep. Deputy Kennedy wants free sows and free money in Westmeath. What remedy has the Minister for all the people who want something for nothing because of the depression in agriculture?

I ask the Minister to tell the House and the country what his opinion is as to the state of agriculture and, if it is depressed, as has been stated in this House, what is his remedy. I am not going to say anything personal to the Minister. I am not going to say that he is not fit for his job. Perhaps there were circumstances over which he had no control. Perhaps he had a very difficult job to perform. I agree with Deputy Corry when he says that nobody has any difficulty in obtaining approach to the Minister for Agriculture. Whether a person belongs to the Minister's Party or any other Party, there is no difficulty in that connection. Even though he and I fire exchanges across the floor of the House, I find him the most approachable of Ministers. I hope he will not take anything I have said in a personal way. I should like that he would apply himself to the question I have put and state what is the condition of agriculture and what is the remedy. I submit that it is in a very depressed condition. One way of helping it would be to reduce overhead charges by abolishing rates on the land. That would stop the ramp going on in local expenditure over the last six years or seven years. If the Minister will not accept that remedy, let him tell us what his proposal is and why he puts up with less than £600,000 when the Minister for Industry and Commerce was able to get away with £600,000 to accommodate holiday-makers whom we are to invite to this country in a year when the ordinary law was not sufficient to maintain the peace, and we had to pass Public Safety Acts.

Comment on this

Will they not eat the produce of the land?

Comment on this

Some of them bring their food with them. As regards beet growing, Deputy Corry will agree that that is the hardest work on the land. There is no harder work than the handling of beet. The reason the industry was taken up by the people is that it was put over when there was no cash in any other crop and also because of the propaganda of men like Deputy Corry who told his own constituents, as well as other prospective beet growers, that 30/- a ton for beet was a good price. I think that was the price in the Act—30/- per ton with 15 per cent or 17½ per cent. sugar-content, with a 2/6 per ton rise for each point in excess of that percentage. The Deputy and the Government were told here at the time that it could not be grown, that beet growing was not an economic proposition in any country. The only way to make beet growing an economic proposition is to raise the sugar-content of the average crop of beet to about 25 per cent. If you had a 25 per cent. Sugar-content for the average crop, then you would be able to produce sugar at an economic price.

I think Deputy Corry will agree with me in that. The only way to arrive at a 25 per cent. sugar-content is to try the breeding of a good strain of beet. The present strain was originally bred from a 4 per cent. or 5 per cent. sugar-content and it is now up to 17 per cent. or 18 per cent. The Minister has done nothing in connection with the breeding of a special strain of beet. I do not think that the seed for our beet is raised in this country but I am open to correction on that. I believe it is all imported and, if the people over the way did not send us the beet seed, we could not grow beet at any price. I think I am right in that statement. We have a faculty of agriculture. It is about 12 years' old and nothing has been done with reference to the raising of beet seed or the breeding of a new strain of beet.

I hope the Minister will tell us the cure for agriculture, if he will not accept the suggestions that have been made. From my own point of view, I should be sorry to see agriculture propped up by any system of doles. If it is down and out, it is no harm and no shame to accept doles to put it on its feet; but for the permanent relief of agriculture, or for the putting of agriculture on a sound basis, it must be done in an economic manner and not by any doles, subsidies or anything of that kind. If the charges on agriculture are too high, take them off; if the rates are too high, take them off; if annuities are too high, take them off, but give the agriculturist a chance of producing food at an economic price. Take off the overhead charges and, if he fails in the race, let him pay the price just as the industrialist has to pay. The commercial man who does not mind his business will fail. Let us put efficient people on the land who will be able to produce food. I believe that is possible if the other condition is fulfilled —that is, if democracy works properly and puts men on the Government Front Benches who are fit for their jobs.

Comment on this

There are just a few points that I would like to make on this particular Vote. So many things have been said from all angles that there is no need for me to repeat them, but there are two points, at least, that I should like the Minister to consider very seriously. It is agreed, I think, that the agricultural community have been hard hit and that many persons engaged in agriculture have been specially hit because of the set of circumstances in which they found themselves. They were put by the Government into the front line trenches. Some of them perhaps, were not willing to go into the front lines. The result was that they did not, perhaps, grow the wheat or beet that they should have grown; they stuck to their cattle and lost very substantially. They suffered financial embarrassment. They were unable to meet the many calls that were put upon them. One farmer, perhaps, was unable to meet his bank liabilities; another farmer was unable to meet his rates; another was unable to meet his land annuities.

The Government, rightly or wrongly, felt that the farmer must live up to all his responsibilities and meet every call that came upon him and, when he was unable to do that, they decided to compel him. The result was that in regard to land annuities you had Mr. Brown and Mr. O'Neill buying the farmer's stock at an enforced sale at a fraction of their true value. I want to stress this point particularly for the Minister's benefit. Even though he is in the Government there is a moral responsibility on the Minister. When he takes a man's property at much less than its true value, there is a moral responsibility on him and, if the farmer now wants to do what he can and the Government are satisfied that he is not a deliberate law breaker, there is the moral responsibility on the Government to give the farmer reasonable value for whatever stock or property was seized.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Agriculture has no responsibility in that connection.

Comment on this

In a way he has, because the Minister for Agriculture assured the Minister for Finance that the farmer was thoroughly well able to pay were it not for the fact that he wore a shirt of some type or kind, and if he had not that shirt he would be well able to pay. Therefore that farmer must be made pay, and between the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Agriculture they broke that farmer, whoever he was. The point I make is that now we have arrived at a certain stage. The Minister is fully cognisant of all the facts, and he should take a clear view of the position of these farmers who were so broken and at least do something to restock their farms. There are some of them large farmers, some of them small, but the obligation is upon him, and I should like to know from him what steps he is taking, or if he proposes to take any steps, or if he is satisfied that everything is rosy in the garden and that he does not need to take any steps. I would like to remind him that that moral law is there for him just as it is for me, and it is the same for the Government as for the individual. I am not going to stress it any further than that. I would just like to know if the Minister is examining that particular point and if he is going to do something for the farmers who have been broken in the front line trenches into which the Government put them.

I regret I was not here when Deputy Childers was speaking. I have read reports of some speeches of his in the country. So far as my information goes —I speak subject to correction—he made a speech here this evening which would remind me of a story that I heard when I was a young fellow. A young student left college and he was talking big about farming. An old parish priest was listening to him. He listened very attentively while the young fellow talked wisely and well and criticised somebody who might be described as an average farmer. He said: "That man does not know anything about farming, because, if he did, he could do so-and-so, and it would be far better." The parish priest said: "You are right; he is a bad farmer; as a matter of fact, I was just thinking that he does not know the difference between a ewe and a wether, and, surely to goodness, you know that?""I do, well," replied the young man. "Well, just tell me what is a wether," said the priest. "Oh," was the reply, "sure everybody knows that.""I know," said the parish priest, "but I want you to tell me.""Well," said the young fellow, "it is quite easy to tell you that. It is a heifer that has had her first calf.""That is right," said the parish priest, "you should take up farming because you would make an absolute success of it." Now Deputy Childers comes in and tells the farmers of this country and the people of this country what they should do to make farming a success. When I heard Deputy Childers speaking here that story that I have told came to my mind.

Comment on this

I am quoting what I heard from the farmers themselves.

Comment on this

Yes, and so was this young fellow.

Comment on this

I explained that I was not speaking first-hand at all. I said I was gathering the impressions I received from other farmers, and I should not be misquoted in that way.

Comment on this

I am not misquoting at all. I am telling a story, and I say that this young fellow knew as much about farming as Deputy Childers knows.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEoin is trying to make political capital out of this for the Longford Leader.

Comment on this

That was how that young student knew the difference between a ewe and a wether. Perhaps Deputy Childers would tell the Minister for Agriculture now what a wether is.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEoin is talking nonsense.

Comment on this

The Deputy also advocated—and I do not want to misinterpret the Deputy at all—larger farms. He said that the small farms were not economic. I heard that before, too. That was the thing that so-called British economists advocated for this country at one time—that the farms were too small and that the people should be——

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir, I submit that I must not be misquoted.

Comment on this

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is a point of order. Deputy Childers is within his rights in protesting against being misquoted. His word must be accepted.

Comment on this

I have not misquoted the Deputy.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If a Deputy purports to quote he must do so correctly.

Comment on this

Well, I am not misquoting him. I am interpreting what he said. I have some notes of his speech, and he did advocate that the farms throughout the country at the moment were uneconomic because they were too small——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Childers denies that he made a statement, the denial must be accepted. The record is not available yet.

Comment on this

Very well, I will take that, but if Deputy Childers goes down to Longford and repeats what he said last Sunday, I will not accept it there, because you, Sir, will not be present to call me to order. If the Deputy repeats it I will point out to him that certain British economists who wanted to make this country into a certain thing felt that the farms should be larger, that they should be larger and larger.

Comment on this

That is not what I said.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Childers' denial must be accepted.

Comment on this

May I speak a little further?

Comment on this

I am not giving way to the Deputy. If that is his philosophy, I want to tell him——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not pursue that line further.

Comment on this

Then I have only, in these circumstances, to ask the Minister for Agriculture to see to it that he is not influenced by any so-called economist, whether he is on the Banking Commission or elsewhere, but that he will try to maintain the present farming population of this country in the position that they fought hard to get and keep. By doing that, by maintaining these small farmers where the best people in the world have been produced—including men like the Minister and you yourself, Sir—he will maintain the stock that has given you your doctors, your priests, your solicitors and every fine type that this or any other country could produce. Break that farming stock and you will break the best thing that this country has. I ask the Minister to see to it that whatever steps he takes in dealing with this problem he will take them with this object in view—that of maintaining this farming stock.

I had not intended to speak at such length and I am sorry for detaining the House so long. If I were not interrupted I would make one point, but Deputy Childers does not like it. I bow to your ruling. But I point out again to the Minister for Agriculture that he has the responsibility on him of maintaining that type of farming in this country, because in doing that he will be maintaining all the things that this country has ever regarded as of paramount importance—a fine peasantry, a nation's pride. Let him keep that there. The present policy of the Government is to break that poor fellow—to give him no help whatever. I am aware that some relief in rates has been given but it does not point in the right way. The Minister tells us that he is spending £40,000 upon fertilisers. I can get 10/- of that just as well as the poor small farmer down the road. Why should I? I say, therefore, that the Minister should examine that question very carefully. The farmer should be given that which he is entitled to and deserving of. That is what the farmer should get.

Comment on this

I do not intend to speak at any length on this Estimate, which has been already discussed for several days. But there are a few points to which I would like to refer. The main thing is that the farmer should not have been pressed to pay rates or annuities during the economic war. As has been pointed out already, the farmer has no longer the stock by reason of the fact of those seizures for rates and annuities and the forced sales throughout the economic war. But the economic war is now past and done with: I do not mean to have a rehash of it again. But it is necessary to explain that the economic war is the reason why the farmer finds himself unable to make up the annuities and the rates that are now due. I was told on several occasions during the last few months that no matter what help the farmer is given now by the Government it is useless to thousands of them because they have no stock, having lost it in the economic war, and they have not the wherewithal to meet their liabilities. As the farmers now stand they have neither capital nor stock.

I put it to the Minister that a commission has been set up to inquire into the position of the farmer and to suggest means of helping him out and putting him on his feet. I think while that commission is sitting it should be made possible that the farmer should be no longer pressed for the arrears of annuities. The same thing might be said in the matter of rates. As a matter of fact I was told recently by one farmer that at a particular fair he got good prices for his cattle. "But," said he, "what use is that, because on the one hand I had to pay most of it away in annuities, and there was the rate collector staring at me from the other side while I was selling the cattle?" That man finds himself in an impossible position.

This country cannot find it possible to find money for every class of person who finds himself in want. But I put it to the Minister that the farmer is the main stay of this country, and unless he is put on his feet everything else goes down. There is one way in which the farmer can be helped, and that is by relieving him of his arrears of annuities. The Agricultural Commission is sitting in the hope that it will be able to suggest some way of putting the farmers on their feet. Much has been said about feeding stuffs, the cost of living, and the cost of the farmers' machinery. I do think that with these two other points being dealt with in a business like way, the farmer would be able to meet the liabilities and calls now upon him. Actually he has not got the capital to furnish his farm with the necessary implements. Those implements cost a high price now on account of the extra tax. I think something should be done to put those things within the reach of every farmer, whether he be large or small. In regard to artificial manures, it has been mentioned that the 10/- grant is of no use to the small farmer, who does need the manure for the betterment of his land. That is true, because those farmers cannot buy a ton of any kind of foodstuff, much less manure for the land, although their land needs the manure far more than the land of the well-to-do farmers. I suppose there are some well-to-do farmers in the country. The whole matter should be carefully examined and revised in order to devise some way of putting the small farmer—who has been down and out for the last few years—again on his feet.

There is one other branch of the farming industry in which I am interested, and that one is the pig industry. Much has been said about it, and at this late hour I do not intend to have a re-hash of it. At the same time I think that a revision of the Pigs Marketing Board would do an enormous amount of good both for the producer and the consumer. There is some sort of loss in between, from the time it leaves the producer until it reaches the consumer, and none of us is quite clear exactly how it comes about. The farmers have many grievances in this respect. The pig dealers formerly kept the fairs in the small towns of this country going, but those fairs are now practically finished, and that is due to this Pigs Marketing Board. It is not doing good for anyone—certainly not for the producer, who finds that he is no longer the controller of his own pig. The pigs have to be graded, and the producer is not satisfied with the way in which this grading is done. He feels, in a word, that he is being "done." That is putting it very bluntly, but it is a fact. I have been told on numerous occasions that there is something radically wrong with this system of grading, and that it should be as it used to be, that the pigs should be graded alive rather than dead. The farmer has no redress. He is simply told that his pigs belong to class B or class C.,— pigs which possibly belong to class A. He has no redress. He simply has to take what he gets, and there is no use crying over spilt milk. I think the Minister should look into this particular matter, and on careful examination he will find that I have been stating the facts of the case.

Another problem which we have to face is the matter of emigration. We all know why it is happening; it is simply because the people cannot get a living on the land. It is not that they particularly want to go to England or any other place, but simply because they see all this struggling going on at home, and realise that there is no living there for them. While the cost of living has increased, they are getting a lower price for their produce. To put the whole thing in a nutshell, in this country there never before has been anything like the scarcity of money which there is in the farmers' households at the present time. Without wanting to make any political kudos out of anything I may say, we all must admit that the farmer is genuinely in a bad position, and it is the duty of the Minister and the Department to find some way by which his hardships can be alleviated. If the Minister will examine those few facts he will realise that something must be done in order to preserve the farmer, who is the mainstay of this country.

Comment on this

I should like to say a few words on this very important Estimate. I think it is agreed on all sides that the farming industry is a very important one in so far as this country is concerned, and I should like to ascertain from the Minister whether the position of agriculture to-day is anything better than it was six or seven or eight years ago; whether the industry as a whole is giving more employment to-day, than it provided say, seven years ago, because when all is said and done, the acid test of the success or non-success of any industry is the number of people earning a living in that industry. So far as I can ascertain the facts, I am of opinion that employment on the land is much lower to-day than it had been in the past 10 or 11 years, and I think it is the duty of the Minister for Agriculture to ascertain the reasons for that reduction in employment. I distinctly remember, when the Minister was hot on his scheme of wheat growing in this country, one of the members on the Front Bench of the Government gave it as his opinion that when the wheat scheme was in full swing it would provide employment for an extra 20,000 or 30,000 agricultural labourers. That Front Bench member on that occasion must have been convinced that that would be so; otherwise he would not have made that statement. I should like to know from the Minister at the conclusion of this debate what extra employment, if any, the growing of wheat has given. I am not expressing any opinions as to whether it is wise or unwise to grow wheat. I believe in the national interest it would be good policy to grow a certain amount of wheat, but then we have to consider the cost to the nation as a whole and the hardships imposed on other sections of the community. We also have to bear in mind the fact that even if we grew all the wheat necessary for the needs of the people of this country we would thereby absorb only about a million acres of land. As we have from 13,000,000 to 15,000,000 acres of arable land in this country, I should like to know what we are going to do with the balance. As I said, I want to know whether there has been that increase in employment which we were promised on that particular occasion. I want to know whether even an extra thousand have been employed. In fact, is the position at the moment such that, instead of an increase, there has been a decrease?

Everybody must know that agriculture has experienced a very trying time during the last four or five years. In fact, one might liken it unto a very healthy man who, in say the year 1932, was struck down with a very serious illness which lasted for four years. Nobody would expect that man to have the same vitality to pursue his ordinary employment as he had prior to his illness. The farmer is in that position. He endured an agricultural illness during the three or four years of the economic war, and, although he has recovered his strength somewhat, he is still badly bent. I think it is up to the Minister for Agriculture to take some steps to put those farmers in the same position as they were in prior to the commencement of the economic war. The Minister ought to consider the best means of helping the farmers at the present time. I am not one of those who advocate the granting of subsidies or loans. I find myself more or less in agreement with Deputy Belton that possibly it would have been better for the farmers of this country if they had been allowed to remain in their old position, that is if they had been allowed to pursue their own line of agricultural policy, the line which they believed would pay them best, but unfortunately the Government started to subsidise them and to change their policy. I think that was the first downfall of the agricultural industry in this country. I move to report progress.

Comment on this