We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 10—General.

Contributions 119–277 of 277. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Is the Minister suggesting that that was accountable alone for the drop in estate duty receipts? He can argue that if he wishes, but he knows perfectly well that it does not justify a decrease of £84,000. There are a number of items of that nature, and another item of that nature was stamp duty. The Minister this year is estimating for a further reduced figure of receipts from stamp duty, £930,000. A year or two years ago, the receipts were £1,050,000, and ten years ago, before the big item of stamp duty, that which arises from the Hospitals Sweepstakes, came into being, the return from stamp duty amounted to £430,000 or £450,000.

Will the Minister not admit that one of the great factors in the reduction of stamp duty, either last year or in the coming year, is the fact that the normal stamp duty in the country—apart from such duty as that contributed by the Hospitals Trust—is decreasing every year? The normal stamp duty that would be payable on such things as the sale of land and marriage settlements is decreasing. It is perfectly obvious that we are going to have those taxes continually decreasing if the present situation is allowed to continue. It may surprise the Minister to know that it is very hard to sell a farm of land in this country at the present moment. It may equally surprise him to know that not very many marriage settlements are being made. That is an item that is going to affect the revenue, an item which the Minister should take serious cognisance of—the fact that there is a reduction in the stamp duties which are being paid on ordinary transactions. It shows a state of affairs where the people of the country are definitely not interested in buying land, definitely not interested in marrying their families and settling them on farms.

I rather admire the ingenuity of the Minister, because he would have been able to convince everybody eight or ten years ago that a reduction in stamp duty or in estate duty or in any other duty meant red ruin and disaster; but the Minister is fortunate—and that is one of the things about him, he is always lucky. In the first five years he had "abnormal years", the abnormal years of the economic war. His Budget last year was influenced by the "settlement", and at that time he was going to enter upon his first year of normal expenditure and normal taxation. But this year he has been lucky enough to be able to discover another abnormal situation. If the Minister's Budgets of the last five years can be accounted for by the abnormal economic period, and his Budget of this year can be accounted for by the abnormal economic position, it may be just as well for this country that the abnormal periods still continue, because I would not like to be dealing with a Budget that the Minister would consider to be a normal one.

As far as these minor items are concerned—such as estate duty and stamp duty—they do not affect the total very much. They do not make a terrific lot of difference. But the actual amount of taxation being levied on the people shows a definite trend in regard to the financial position of the ordinary people. The reduction of estate duty is not to be explained alone by the fluctuation of stocks, but by the number of people living on their savings for the past five years; and the reduction of stamp duty is accounted for considerable by the fact that people are not interested in the buying of land and that, consequently, the normal transfers of land are not being made as they used to be made some ten years ago.

I can only hope that the Deputies on the opposite benches are as anxious about the plight of the farming community as they would wish us to believe they are, and that they will encourage their supporters and friends to carry on that normal activity and make transfers of their farms and have marriage settlements made in the normal way, and not allow us to drift into the position where no transfers of land will be made and no marriage settlements will be made until the people have become so old that they can scarcely walk.

Comment on this

What about the Incorporated Law Society's charges?

Comment on this

It may be argued that it was good business for the lawyers but there is far better business for the lawyers—let the old people die intestate, so that the lawyers can argue it out with the Minister for Finance as to what the duty itself would be. As a matter of fact, if I had the choice, I would prefer to argue my case with the Minister for Finance. I would make more out of it.

Comment on this

The lawyers would stop the transferring of property.

Comment on this

At the moment the people of this country cannot afford to make transfers of land and arrange marriage settlements. If they have £700 or £800 they are not prepared to put a daughter on to a farm and arrange a settlement for them with that money. They will not put the money into the land. If that is not right, what is the explanation of the peculiarly low marriage rate in this country, what is the explanation for the fact that the average marriage rate is so delayed? Is it the economic condition or is it some social factor? If it is not the economic condition it ought to be easily settled and the wise-acres that we have ought to be able to tell us what to do about it—if it is merely a social and not an economic condition. But I say it is an economic factor, and I put this to Deputy Corry or to Deputy Crowley: In their own constituencies, how many farms of land are there for sale that they cannot get buyers for?

Comment on this

Very few—in my county, anyway.

Comment on this

There may be very few in Deputy Crowley's county, because they would not dream of putting them up for sale—they would get no buyer for them—but the Land Commission would come in and take the land over and divide it.

Comment on this
A Deputy

That is all nonsense.

Comment on this

That is another reason for the lack of sale for the land. When a decent-sized farm is put up for sale, would-be purchasers are afraid to buy it because some local friend of Deputy Crowley would start an agitation at the cross-roads and there would be a demand for its division and eventually the Land Commission would have to come in and divide it.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is wandering.

Comment on this

I apologise for wandering, Sir, but you can hardly blame me if Deputies Crowley and Corry make me put these points.

Comment on this

Give him all the rope you can.

Comment on this

There is one man who would not need any rope and that man is Deputy Allen. Now, another nice item regarding which I would like the Minister's explanation is the deficiency of £68,000 in regard to local authorities. I put this point to the Minister: he maintains that certain amounts should be paid to him by local authorities under the operation of these Acts, but the local authorities say they should not be paid. The Minister is now introducing legislation to regularise his idea of the situation.

Is not that correct? The position of the local authority is that the Minister bases his figures on the total rateable valuation and is not concerned whether the local authority is able to collect the rates. He completely forgets that the local authority may have, in many areas, considerable property which may be derelict but on which rates are calculated for one reason or another. The Minister is going to get over that point by introducing legislation, for another great attribute of Fianna Fáil is that wherever they make a mistake they say, "We will carry on and we will rectify it later by legislation."

I was rather amazed that the optimist who is our Minister for Finance should use language such as he did use when referring to the Land Acts and the Housing Acts and the employment schemes. He said they are still likely to be active—a position which cannot but be regarded with uneasiness by the Minister responsible for the public finances. I do not believe that many years ago he regarded with uneasiness any payments that might be made under Acts for the division of land or under Acts for housing schemes or for employment schemes or for the provision of work. When the Minister introduced his Budget last year he was in very good form, he was rather buoyant about it, with the Settlement in the air. This year I think the Minister is rather mournful, that he is in a mood of despondency. It is quite possible that the later introductions to the Fianna Fáil Party may have converted the Minister to an orthodox method of dealing with the economic position. At any rate, his dreams have faded completely.

Comment on this

And you cheer him up.

Comment on this

He would need cheering up. The Minister who had to make excuses and who felt uneasiness in explaining the expenditure reduction during the economic crisis, and who explains that his Budget is in such a poor state because the year is an abnormal one, would need cheering up.

I wish I could cheer him up. He might be more cheerful if the gentlemen in the opposite benches, who insist upon muttering, had the pluck to get up and defend the Fianna Fáil Budget, and he might be more cheerful if Deputies Allen, Crowley and Corry got up and spoke in defence of the Fianna Fáil Budget. It is the old game over again. They want to create an impression in the country that all Fianna Fáil is not in agreement with this Budget.

Comment on this

We are, everyone.

Comment on this

Deputy Tom Kelly is the only one who is committed to it, along with the Minister himself. If Deputies Crowley, Allen and Corry wish to explain their position they cannot do it by interrupting people in this House. If they want to satisfy the people on these benches or the country as to what their ideas are about the Budget, they should get up and make a speech about it. But they are so shy! Deputy Corry is not shy. I believe he will get up, but I doubt if Deputy Allen or Deputy Crowley will get up.

As far as the other abnormal side of the expenditure is concerned, the Minister explained that by the expenditure on the Defence Force. The Minister has probably heard quite enough; for his own peace of mind, about the Defence Force. I believe that if the increased Vote for Defence in this country is going to be spent upon the development of our Volunteer force infantry brigade, it is an entire waste of money. I do not believe that the Minister or many of the Fianna Fáil Deputies are completely satisfied that the development of a Volunteer force of the nature which we have had for the last four or five years is the best possible way to spend money in adequate defence.

Deputy Professor O'Sullivan put the point very clearly—what did the Government expect would be our position in the event of a European line-up of nations? Are we going to face the position here that we may be invaded by a European power and, if so, are we going to face the position that we are going to have a defence adequate to repel that invasion? If we are, the sums that would be required for defence in this country would be entirely beyond the power of this country to pay.

One of the reasons I am referring to this is that the Minister criticised the Opposition, the Labour Party and everybody else in this House who was not in entire agreement with him, because they did not specify the various items of expenditure that could be curtailed. Supposing I suggested to the Minister that there were two items that could be curtailed. Would he agree with me if I said expenditure could be curtailed on Defence and on the Gárda—two very large items of expenditure which have increased in the past few years? Once upon a time the Minister would have regarded those two items as Votes that he would like to reduce to the smallest possible farthing, but the Minister then and the Minister now are two different people. I refer you, Sir, to barely ten years ago—25th April, 1929. In the Parliamentary Debates, Volume 29, column 926, the Minister says: "Expenditure must be cut down." This is our orthodox Minister for Finance when he was in Opposition:—

"Expenditure must be cut down. That is quite clear from the figures that I have put before you. Economies must be secured. I want to guard myself against misrepresentation, and I mean by that, not economies secured by the curtailment of the social services, but economies secured by more efficient administration."

If economies could have been secured by more efficient administration, where are the economies that have been secured by more efficient administration in the past seven years? The Minister continues:—

"There should be economy in every service which does not yield a due and proper return for the mass of the people who have to pay for it. There should be economies in the Army and in the Civic Guard."

Comment on this
Mr. Crowley

That is very old stuff.

Comment on this

Very old stuff indeed. I am quite sure Deputy Crowley would rather it were in the limbo of forgotten things than realise there was ever such a time as 1929-30, when he and the present Minister for Finance were telling everybody they could run this country on a Budget that would scarcely ask the people of this country for any money at all.

It was absolutely no trouble then. I will not even refer to the point that he was going to cut expenditure on the Army and the Civic Guard. I only take his own actual words—"economies secured by more efficient administration." If I were to test the Government's political record of economy, if the Minister for Finance believed that economies could be secured by more efficient administration and if he were able to carry out the task he set himself to do, he would have secured economies by more efficient administration without cutting social services. But, if I were to judge his record by the fact that there have not been economies but wild increases I would have to say that he did not know what he was talking about or that he was not able to carry out the economies he envisaged because the back-benchers of Fianna Fáil were too strong for him when they wanted him to spend more money in order to get some friends of theirs into the Army and the Civic Guards.

Last year the Minister was fairly cheerful in regard to his Budget. This year he is not even slightly cheerful. He has come around to the point where, literally speaking, he garbed himself in sack-cloth and ashes and explained why he was asking for this £35,000,000—the result of a five-years' economic war, an abnormal year, stock exchange tendencies and the danger of a war. I think he did himself more harm than good because I think he did something that no Fianna Fáil Minister, even the Taoiseach himself, was ever able to do before: when he concluded his statement he had succeeded in scaring the wits out of the Fianna Fáil Deputies in this House. He left them absolutely dumb-founded.

Deputy Kissane has arrived and I invite him, if he wants to say anything about it, to have pluck enough to make a speech and not add one more to the crowd of mutterers who are sitting on the Government benches. I do not want to be disorderly in this House.

Comment on this

Which Budget are you talking about?

Comment on this

Deputy Kissane would not know what Budget I am talking about, because, since he came into this House, I do not believe he ever read a Budget statement. He acted up to the best interests of his Party by sitting down and voting like a machine. But he did something other years that he did not do this year —he clapped loudly when the Minister's statement was ended. This year, like most of the other members of his Party, he was so dumbfounded that he was not even able to do that.

The Minister was even more pessimistic at the end of his statement than he was at the beginning. He mentioned again the point to which I referred, the question of stamp duties. He mentioned that they were likely to still further dry up. I hope that is not right, because I know that it will show a very bad outlook for the country. I wonder why the Minister had to descend to the little subterfuges that are reflected in the Budget. He thanked the Minister for Local Government and Public Health for his generous contribution of £150,000 from the Road Fund. I wonder why did he go to the bother of doing that. If he wanted £35,000,000 he might just as well have asked the House for the £150,000 as ask the Minister for Local Government for it. On what is that going to react? Moneys that should go back into road-making or road upkeep are taken by the Minister for Finance in order to help his Budget a little bit. He takes the sum of £100,000 from another Estimate—Public Works and Buildings. What does that mean? It means that £100,000 is being taken out of an Estimate that would tend to give a certain amount of employment. The first item—£150,000—is money that should be expended in productive labour, on road maintenance, and the second item—£100,000—is deducted from an Estimate that would also give a certain amount of employment. The Minister, who is always so fond of the unemployed, takes that money which should be used for employment schemes.

Why the Minister will not bother doing that I do not know, because his total is so grandiloquently magnificent compared with the totals that he used to criticise when on this side. Surely in these circumstances he need not bother about a paltry £200,000. I can hardly imagine the Minister since he got into office and into the habit of handling large sums of money bothering about such a paltry sum as that.

Is the Minister satisfied that, while he produces a Budget that may be a fairly popular one from the point of view of a lot of his friends down the country, it is not going to do great damage to the country? Many of his friends, of course, will now go down the country and say: "We have clapped on another bob to the incomes of the big fellows." Will not that have certain other reactions? Will it not abolish the differentiation that induced people to keep their money in this country rather than in England, where the rate was higher? How will it affect business people? A number of people in this country who are not millionaires may find that this additional 1/- will compel them to reduce the amount of employment they have given hitherto. I know, of course, that the Minister will not agree with me. Bad and all as the Budget is, the Minister wants to make it a popular one. He knows that his friends will be able to say, "We are after the big fellow all the time, and we are going to get the money off him."

Comment on this

The Party that the Deputy belongs to took the money off the old age pensioners.

Comment on this

The Civil War took it off the old age pensioners.

Comment on this

Even admitting for the sake of argument that this Party took a 1/- off the old age pensioners, let me put this point to the Deputy: that due to the activities of the Minister's investigation officers the people who are looking for the 10/- to-day are finding it very hard to get it. In many cases they have to wait a long time for it. In my opinion, they were better off with the 9/- that they were able to get under the easy system that prevailed in 1927.

When they were getting the 9/- the country had only to face a Budget of £22,000,000 or £23,000,000 a year, while to-day it has to face a Budget of £32,000,000, so that the 10/- to-day is not as valuable for the old age pensioners as the 9/- was in the old days. I observe that the Fianna Fáil chorus has come into the House. What a changed man the Minister for Finance is to-day from those dim bygone days when he was so lost in the clouds of fantasy that he merely came into this House and told the people what he could do without ever checking a figure. He is before the House to-day under the grim reality of his 1939 Budget. He is a sadder but a much wiser man. If the Fianna Fáil Deputies are satisfied with this Budget, if they think that it is in the best interests of the country to continue this abnormal expenditure—abnormal was the word used by the Minister—then I invite the members of the Fianna Fáil chorus to get up one by one and defend this Budget. I extend that invitation to Deputy Corry, Deputy Allen, Deputy Kissane and the rest of them.

Comment on this
Thomas Derrig Minister for Education (Mr. Derrig) Fianna Fáil

I think there is a certain feeling of relief, which the Opposition have some difficulty in restraining, that the Minister for Finance has been able in the difficult circumstances with which he has been faced, to give the country a Budget which does not press unduly upon the community, and in which a special effort has been made to be as lenient as possible on the poorer sections of it. Now, it is the duty of the Opposition, on an occasion of this kind, to examine from their point of view the state of the national finances: to show, as well as they can, that taxation is in excess of the country's requirements, that expenditure is extravagant and should be cut down, and so on. They would not be doing their duty as an Opposition if they did not take up that standpoint. It is the duty of the Government in office to justify their expenditure, and to justify to the country the taxation and the burdens which have been imposed on it in order to maintain the services which have been provided.

The Opposition, up to last year, took up the attitude that the moneys which the Government was spending and which undoubtedly the circumstances of the time tended to make them veer towards, whether that expenditure was on social services, on development purposes or for the relief of agriculture, were not, in fact, advantageous at all; that so far as the farming community was concerned, whatever advantage they were getting from Government expenditure—and that was very doubtful—was altogether weighed down on the other side by the losses which the farmers were suffering from the economic war. The economic war is finished. Therefore it is not now possible for the Opposition to argue that the losses in connection with the economic war far outweigh the advantages, to the agricultural community in general, which the Government have been making provision for in the annual accounts. One would imagine, therefore, that it would be reasonable to ask them the question: Must there not be a clear saving in respect of the sums of money which are allocated directly to agriculture or for development in rural areas, or in respect of that proportion of the moneys spent on social services in rural areas? If the only argument the Opposition had up to last year was that no expenditure of money, no widows' and orphans' pensions, no unemployment assistance or extension of old age pensions could possibly be of any account, are we not justified now in pointing out that they are rather illogical in not admitting that all the expenditure that goes into rural areas must at any rate be of some benefit to these areas? Is it not preposterous to pretend that two services like the old age pensions and widows' and orphans' pensions—to take only these two—are not the greatest benefit to rural areas, and that in all probability a larger proportion of these money is going into the rural areas than into the urban areas?

The attitude of the Opposition up to last year was: Settle the economic war and then we can manage our affairs in peace and contentment. Is it not extraordinary that they should now argue that all this expenditure is of no benefit when, in fact, we know that every rural parish in the country is benefiting from it? I am surprised that Deputy Cogan should ally himself with the Opposition in pretending that all this money that goes for the agricultural services, for development, and for social services does not go into the rural areas and does not benefit farmers.

Even if we assume that the Vote for the Department of Agriculture is of no benefit whatever, none of the money spent under any of the sub-heads, as the Minister pointed out last night, was criticised. There was simply a general attack which led one to believe that, as far as the Opposition were concerned, they took very little interest in the details of the Estimate, which might have been doubled or wiped out as far as they were concerned. If we turn to export subsidies on butter and poultry, we find that the amount is £606,000. That service was not there before the economic war, and a good many people expected that it might have been wiped out. Do Deputies who represent farmers think it should be wiped out? Certainly, it cannot be argued that it is not directly in support of agriculture. For the relief of rates on agricultural land, £1,870,000 is provided, and towards the reduction in land purchase annuities, £2,200,000.

Let us leave aside the £1,050,000 provided for the beet sugar industry, on the supposition that it is of no benefit to farmers in certain areas, and look at the increased provision made for pigs and bacon production and wheat, and we find that under all these headings there are very substantial increases due to Government action. In my Department a sum of nearly £5,000,000 is provided yearly for education. I notice that the amount for primary education comes to £3,749,697, as well as £250,000 for the construction of national schools. Does any Deputy suggest that a very large proportion of that expenditure does not go into the rural areas? Undoubtedly it does. When it is stated that the rural areas do not benefit that is, patently, an absurd argument.

Comment on this

Under what heading do these areas benefit except to provide sand to make the mortar?

Comment on this

The Deputy may be able to co-relate the sand to the value of the education we are providing. That is certainly a very flattering compliment !

Comment on this

It applies to only a few rural areas.

Comment on this

I say that about 80 per cent. of the expenditure under these headings goes to the rural areas, and the remainder to other areas. It could be easily argued on the basis of our population that in regard to social services various things have been done. Take the position of the Land Commission on afforestation. How could anyone claim that the whole of the money expended, with the exception of the cost of administration which, perhaps, is higher than it should be, does not benefit these areas, assuming that the idea should be to put the largest possible amount of it into labour? The Government is providing £185,424 for afforestation, and the Land Commission is also expending £1,792,000. I claim that practically the whole of that money, with the exception of administrative expenses, goes to the rural areas, in addition to the amounts set out in the Tables for social services and the relief of agriculture. The farming community should have regard to the fact, in justice to the Minister for Finance, that it is proposed to continue all these services, and that, so far as the impositions in the present Budget are concerned, whether they be farmers or labourers, they cannot claim that they have got the heavy end of the stick. If they did, no doubt the debate would be much more exhilarating. In reply to critics like Deputy Cogan, who think that on the whole these services are not worth what they are costing the community, we have to have regard to the needs and the demands of our own people, who expect that such services should bear some relation to those with which they are familiar in other places.

We are constantly hearing from the Opposition Benches that the farmers in Northern Ireland are better off than the farmers here, and that we should have derating and something else, so that our farmers would not be, as alleged, in a position inferior to that of their Northern competitors. The same argument might hold in regard to social services. Not only is it in our own interest to maintain a decent standard of social services but, if we are to have any hope for the reunion of our country, we have to make sure that the people we are asking to come into our territory will not lose substantially in the services to which they have become accustomed. Here they will get benefits in other directions, having regard to our circumstances, that will compare favourably with those in neighbouring countries. I thought the tendency of the Opposition should be to forget the economic war, except when they drag in the slaughter of calves or something else, of which they find it impossible to rid their minds.

The Opposition should, at least, be content with being in the position that they have not responsibility for this taxation, and that it is their privilege to be free to criticise it from many different angles. On the one hand, they can claim that the expenditure is of no advantage to the country, particularly to the rural areas, and, on the other hand, they can demand that derating and other services should be introduced that would cost still more money. In fact, they are in the happy position that consistency, even in the same debate, is not to be expected in their speeches.

They blame the Government for the unfortunate situation that ruled last harvest and which made farmers despair. They try to attribute to the Government some special malevolence in dealing with the farming community because they suffered as a result of the bad harvest and, having a feeling of despair, naturally asked themselves whether it was worth while continuing farming if such conditions were going to persist. Even making allowance for extreme statements, I think it is too much that an attempt should be made to foist upon the Government responsibility for losses farmers suffered through happenings over which they had no control. The Opposition went further. Deputy Cosgrave mentioned that we are losing our most valuable asset, as our young men and women are leaving the country. That is a statement with which we all agree, but the Deputy went on to attribute the exodus of the population from the rural areas to Great Britain, or wherever they may be going, to the high cost of production on the land. He said that was directly due to Government action. Whatever be the cause which has led to the flight from the land, surely that was not the only cause. There must be many other reasons. One reason is that wages, conditions, amenities and leisure are much more satisfactory elsewhere.

Another circumstance is that in an Irish farming household only one boy can expect to inherit the holding. The rest make their living in some other way. It is said that we should not have industries in the country. Strong protests have been made against the Government for developing secondary industries. It is said that we should give up that idea completely, which would add 100,000 to the ranks of the unemployed. If these industries were closed down, where would these people find employment? Would they find it in the Civil Service or the teaching profession? We know that the avenues in these directions are closing down. Unfortunately, the emigration of our young people has gone on in the past and is going on in the present. That is not due to increase in the cost of production on small holdings. As was stated here yesterday, about 80 per cent. of our holdings are, possibly, under £10 valuation. It would be, perhaps, more true for me to say that the de-rating of agricultural land would cost these households far more than they would gain than for Deputy Cosgrave to allege that Government action has so increased the cost of living that these people have been compelled to leave the country.

Comment on this

Would derating not benefit agriculture as a whole?

Comment on this

The fact is that the poorest areas in the country——

Comment on this

You will not apply yourself to that question.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have his usual two hours in which to make his speech.

Comment on this

I spoke with you when you advocated de-rating in Carlow national school.

Comment on this

You may speak after me on this occasion.

Comment on this

You are not shouting so loudly to-day as you were a few years ago.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

We know that substantial Government assistance is coming into those households along the West coast in one form or another. I venture to say that if any of those Deputies who tell us that the exodus from the poorest communities is due to the action of the present Government ask the people of Connemara, or areas like Connemara, what the present Government has done for them, they will receive a unanimous rebuttal of their own allegations. The Government has done well for them, and, on the whole, they are satisfied that, having regard to the conditions, they have not been by any means neglected. Therefore I submit that that is pure political propaganda and not worthy of Deputy Cosgrave.

Deputy Linehan dealt with the question of the marriage rate. He ought to have known that, for a considerable portion of the last century as well as of the present century, our marriage rate was at an exceedingly low level. I suppose that has been the case since the famine period. It is due to historic as well as economic reasons, and it would be absolutely absurd to claim that Government action has effected any great change in the position. We read the other day that in Poland—a much poorer country than Ireland— half the people are under 20 years of age. There is no reason why the position here should not be the same as in Poland if our historical circumstances were the same and if we had not the peculiar conditions we have in farming households whereby the man in the house cannot get married until he has got all the other members of the family settled. If these difficulties, which are not attributable to Government action, were not present, the position here would be the same as in Poland, as it was at one stage.

The Deputy also informed us that it was extremely difficult to get marriage settlements. The Deputy cannot allege that old age pensioners are not better off than they were, since they are getting £800,000 more than they were getting under the last Government. One of the deliberate efforts of the present Administration has been to get old people to give up their holdings to their children. Deputies from rural areas have told me that, whereas 10 or 20 years ago it would have been almost impossible to get the old people to give up their holdings to members of their families, that is now taking place in practically every case. If there are special circumstances in Deputy Linehan's area, or in the cases which have come under his notice, they are certainly no indication of the general position in that regard.

Deputy Cosgrave approached the question of the Budget from an investing point of view. It is a view with which one can have a great deal of sympathy. He is an experienced man of affairs, the former head of a Government and, naturally, it is of importance that any statement made by him with regard to the national finances should be carefully examined. Presumably, his statements were made with an anxiety to help and with the intention of suggesting ways and means by which the general condition of our country and our people could be improved. However, I was rather surprised to see the Deputy take up the attitude that the Report of the Banking Commission was a kind of bible—an infallible promulgation of principles to which we should all adhere. The document is being examined and, in due course, will receive from Government Departments whatever consideration may be necessary. Ultimately, I suppose it will receive the consideration of the Government.

In respect of the question of housing for example, I do not think that the report received a very favourable reception in the country. It was felt that viewing our present housing policy entirely from the point of view of piling up a dead-weight debt was not treating the housing problem in a reasonable way. That is an aspect of the matter to which regard should be had, and the Banking Commission might have considered that they would be failing in their duty if they had not brought out matters of that kind. Nevertheless, the Deputy, who admits that more has been done under the present Administration in that regard than under his Administration, ought to have tried to be a little more constructive. He tells us that investors are apt to look at the price of houses here and link it up with the question of tariffs. In that way, he says, our policy of protecting our own industries discourages investment in such truly human and important enterprises as housing.

In arguing thus, I think the Deputy is really proceeding on political lines rather than on sound economic or human lines. He says that the cost of building materials seriously affects this question. The building materials, in so far as they are affected by tariffs would be, I would say, confined almost entirely to cement, and that tariff was necessary because, in order to get our own cement industry going, we found it absolutely necessary to take certain steps to protect the matter in that way. We are, at any rate, in the position that we have added to our national productivity by having a cement industry of the most modern kind here, as well as by giving the amount of employment that is given there and, even though we are paying a somewhat higher price, we are keeping a great deal of money in the country that would otherwise be going out. We are training these young men in the rural areas who cannot, under any changes one reasonably can foresee, find employment in normal agricultural operations, and giving them some chance of finding employment in their own country, thus ending the exodus Deputy Cosgrave bewails.

If we take up the attitude that we are to have no industries, and make no effort to improve our industrial arm or secure employment for our people, then we should pursue the thing to its logical conclusion and ask why, when a native Government was being set up, it ever took upon itself the responsibility of trying to develop its resources or protect its industries? Why did we not say to the British, as some of our friends would apparently have us say to them: "We would rather continue as we were; we would rather not have these powers, because we feel we could not use them in the common national interest, so, for goodness sake, do not give us the powers to regulate our own lives lest we should not be able to do it satisfactorily."

The Deputy talked of over-estimation. I find that in the year 1928-29, which cannot be said to be a year when there were special difficulties or anything else of that kind affecting the budgetary situation, the actual overestimation was £974,000 on a nett Budget of £24,662,000. There may be some reason for complaint that we have not been able to get rid of this over-estimation in a year like the present, when we do not know what changes may obtain before the year is finished, or what extraordinary changes, indeed, might possibly necessitate an entirely new Budget and an entirely new taxation policy. We can congratulate ourselves, I think, and say that our financial genius is at least equal to Deputy Cosgrave's when with an estimate of £1,000,000 for over-estimation, we can bring in a nett Budget of £33,000,000.

The Deputy, in pursuance of his policy of examining the national finances from the investing point of view, referred to the fact—and, of course, it has been heralded by his supporters in the Press as a magnificent achievement—that for many years he was able to carry on with an income-tax of 3/6. Now we have to pay 5/6, equal to the British level, but at least practically all the things that have been provided have been for the benefit of our own people. Until the present year defence expenditure was maintained at the very minimum, at the bone. The Army of 5,000 men could not possibly have been maintained at less, having regard to personnel, and nothing whatever to be done with regard to equipping them or making any preparations to deal with emergencies. The cost was reduced to the absolute minimum.

The credit of the country, according to the Deputy, is in the balance. The credit of the country is bound up with the balance of payments and is bound up with our balance of sterling assets. We have done our damnedest to make the country bankrupt, he says, but we have not succeeded. Surely the Deputy, even though he is so vitally impressed by the Banking Commission Report, which he seems to have studied so closely, must realise there are other things that have to be considered from the point of view of Government policy, and that a Government in a modern State has to have regard to the general welfare and interests of the people as well as by all means having regard, in a narrower way, to the investor's point of view and to the point of view which, I admit, is of the greatest importance, of paying your way and making ends meet, and not imposing unnecessary burdens or hardships unless there is simply no other way out.

Denmark has been frequently held up by the Opposition as a country which we could with advantage follow in the way they have built up their trade in agricultural products, in the way they have organised their agriculture and made the greatest possible use of the advantages which nature and their own intelligence have given them. When Denmark started on the policy of agricultural production on a standardised scale, she had very substantial assets abroad, and during the course of time she repatriated all these assets and put the money, presumably, into agriculture, which is very heavily capitalised in that country. At the present time her assets abroad are small compared with what they were half a century ago. In this country, in spite of the fact that there has been a big repatriation of capital and many millions have been brought home, taken from foreign investments to be put into Irish investments ever since the present Government came into office, we still have very substantial assets abroad. There is always the question—of course, it is a matter that the Minister for Finance can speak of with more authority than I—whether these moneys are going to be any safer in neighbouring countries than they would be here in the event of war or some great emergency.

The Deputy also laid down the principle that borrowing is indefensible to provide employment. Certain economists have held that doctrine, but it does not seem to be always agreed, even by Governments in countries which are highly organised from the capitalistic point of view. We see that economists like Mr. Keynes think that you are quite justified in borrowing to a very great extent to provide employment. His theory always has been that, in addition to those whom you put to work directly, you create a certain amount of following employment. For every man you put into work, you possibly put at least a second man into employment, which results as from the first man being employed. So I think that while economists of the most orthodox school can hold, and possibly justify, this danger that borrowing, to give employment, is indefensible, it is to my mind a rather strange theory, particularly in these days when we have borrowings on an enormous scale for the purpose of creating armaments and navies—and borrowings to the tune of hundreds of millions of pounds for that purpose, and in these circumstances it would be an extraordinary thing if we were not permitted to borrow for certain portions of our requirements for the purpose of giving employment.

Comment on this

Is there a better way?

Comment on this

I dealt with the fact that Denmark seems to have prospered in spite of the fact that her whole external assets have been reduced almost to vanishing point or a small proportion of what they used to be in order to build up her agriculture and enable her to adopt the most modern methods. It is extraordinary that the Opposition are so little mindful of their interest in Denmark and their anxiety that we should set up the Denmark standards here, that they have devoted the whole of their time to examining what the Government should or should not do for agriculture. Everything from which agriculture suffers, according to them, is attributable to the Government and, presumably, also every evil there could be remedied by Government action. Does any sensible farmer or any intelligent member of the community believe that that is so? Do they realise that the agricultural industry, like every other industry, has to be tackled from the technical point of view, from the point of view of improving our efficiency to meet our competitors in a market to which countries from all the globe are sending their products?

We used to hear a great deal about the English market. We hear a great deal about our failure to fill the quotas on that market. The Minister for Agriculture for days on end has had to listen to abuse in connection with every deficiency in agriculture that the Opposition could bring to light. But with the exception of derating, he did not hear a single constructive suggestion. No suggestion of any constructive kind has been made to show how agricultural production here could be increased or to show how we could improve the situation of the producer or turn out our stuff in greater quantity and at less cost. As the Minister for Agriculture pointed out, the Opposition should encourage our farmers rather than discourage them. If the farmers are given the idea that they are working at a job out of which they are not going to get any profit, that they are working in a country in which the Government is neglecting its duty to agriculture and intends to do nothing for it, that is bound to be bad for the farming community. It is the duty of the Opposition to give them encouragement, to tell them that there are things that the Government should do. It is the duty of the political Opposition to call attention to these things. But there are a great many other things that the farmers could do for themselves either individually or through their co-operative organisations. It would greatly improve the position of the Irish farmers if constructive suggestions were made by all Parties in the State who claim to speak for the rural community.

Every Deputy in this House knows that we have false and unreal standards in this country. Every Deputy will have to admit that those who are in a position to speak with special importance, eminence and knowledge in this country have referred to the fact that we have standards that are unreal and artificial and standards that are beyond our means. Very often in regard to our own individual affairs it would not be appropriate or right to say that any particular class was in the invidious position that it was doing special harm to the community by maintaining unreal standards. It is quite obvious if one section of the community can by very little trouble and without giving of its best to the community in general still occupy an artificial position and have more from the community than those really entitled to it on the basis of hard work, and without giving honest value in return, that you will naturally in that state of affairs have other sections of the community asking why they who are slaving from morning till night should not have the same consideration and why the return to them should not be as good. I claim if that section were to follow the example of the other section and depend on a policy of trying to extract from the public purse as much as they could by organised or political action, that would not be in the national interest and probably in the long run not in their own interest either.

The farming community is organised in a peculiar way. It does not lend itself to organisation in the same way as other industries. The farming community meet with losses from the climate and other conditions, but at any rate the farmer has complete and absolute possession of his own holding of land.

Comment on this

And the Land Commission threatening to acquire his holding!

Comment on this

He is going to be there, and he knows that his family will be there for generations after him. He can look forward to having his descendants occupy the place that his ancestors occupied. It is because of these things that the farming community are of such importance in the life of a nation. I submit that they would be led astray if they were to follow those artificial standards and accept the idea now floating around that there is some artificial reservoir of wealth from which they can get money. Does anybody think that there is only a tap to be turned on and a stream of wealth will flow from some artificial reservoir? The farmers know that the country is depending on them. Each Party should emphasise that in the national councils. When money is being spent somebody will have to provide it, and the farmers know that in the long run the agricultural industry, which is our greatest source of wealth, will have to pay the lion's share.

The farmers' representatives are quite right to criticise national expenditure and to follow it closely. But I hope they will not follow a will-o'-the-wisp. Farmers know that new services cannot be organised without expenditure falling on the community, and incidentally on the farmers themselves. I believe that all Parties in the House should make a united effort to improve conditions in agriculture. I believe the Government could consider what further steps can be taken. The Minister for Agriculture has mentioned that that matter is under consideration. We know that the whole problem is under examination by the Agricultural Commission——

Comment on this

Oh Lord!

Comment on this

I maintain that if we are to meet our competitors in those markets about which we heard a great deal for many years—those markets to which all reference was painfully absent in this debate—it will not be sufficient to tell me that I should introduce rural text books into the school syllabus or give agricultural lectures or send out instructors who will teach agricultural processes to the children. Something is far more necessary than that if rural production is to be kept up to the standard, if that portion of our wealth which we expect to get from the land is going to be maintained, and if agriculture is going to do its share in maintaining that better standard of living and better conditions generally which the people on the land expect quite as much as other sections of the community.

We are told that there is a dislike of work among the young men in the country. That is a problem which the House ought to consider, and consider very seriously. If it is a fact that the young men are unwilling to work, if there is a general feeling that it is better to live in idleness, then I say it is not Governmental action altogether— it may be effective in certain directions —that is going to change either that habit of mind or the habit of mind which would seek to put an entirely false and unreal standard upon agriculture in this country. You have got to tackle it from the psychological point of view. You have got to educate public opinion, and, while we have our say on occasions of this kind on financial and economic matters, we have also to consider what the future of our country is going to be, what the attitude of our young people is going to be. It is not, as has been said in another direction, by debates or speeches or Press articles that we can get our young people to give of their best to the country, and to have that spirit of patriotism and self-sacrifice and anxiety to help their country and to help their people which has made the youth of other countries attain such a splendid place for their nations in the world. We have got to educate them ourselves. We have got to encourage them, and we have got to give them good example.

Comment on this

I feel very timid in speaking in this House, especially on this occasion when I am in the unenviable position of having to follow the learned Minister for Education. I am afraid that any remarks which I have to make will not help to cheer the Minister for Finance because, as a farmer, like all the other farmers in the State, I have been deprived of a sense of humour. What I have to say has probably been said by other speakers, but I believe it will bear repetition. The oftener attention is called to the despair and distress to which the farmers of this State have been reduced the better. We had hoped to get some relief under this Budget. We were promised a reduction of £2,000,000 and complete derating of agricultural land, but what we find is an increase in the Budget, and I believe the net result will be to make the rich poor and the poor poorer.

There are just a few points which I want to put before the fearless Minister for Finance in connection with my own country, where the people have consistently supported the Taoiseach for a number of years, and carried him on their shoulders from Loop Head to New Quay. In that particular area in West Clare, there is at the present time a deadly disease known as fluke, which has caused the loss of a large number of cattle and sheep. In addition, many of them have died for want of food, because the owners could not afford to buy it. I should like the Minister to take a particular note of that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would not that be a question for the Minister for Agriculture?

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

Yes, but the Minister for Agriculture has to go to the Minister for Finance——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The debate on the Estimate for Agriculture extended over five days and afforded ample opportunity for ventilating all those matters.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I quite agree and, if I may say so without being out of order, the debate on the Minister's Estimate last night showed the growing opposition to the agricultural policy of the Government. Only a small number were in favour of the policy of the Minister for Agriculture towards the farmers. In East Clare, we have a chain of creameries which are badly financed at the present time due to the scarcity of milk.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must get away from agricultural matters.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I am trying to speak on financial matters.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has a simple criterion. On what Minister devolves the responsibility for remedying the difficulties referred to? On the Minister for Agriculture rests the responsibility, if there is any.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I may be out of order, and I apologise.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is out of order.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

My understanding was that the Minister for Finance governed the Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In other words, that everything is in order, and the debate on all the Estimates might be repeated?

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I may be in order in stating that people in those areas are very badly in need of help of some sort. The Minister for Finance believes in a policy of borrowing. As he believes in a policy of borrowing, it is only reasonable to suppose that he believes in a policy of lending. I believe the only remedy for those people is to provide them with cheap loans and to derate agricultural land. At the present time it is no use for a farmer to approach a bank. He would not be allowed inside the door. As a matter of fact, I think he would be tried under the Treason Act for approaching the door of a bank. His only hope is to appeal to the Minister for Finance for some assistance.

Comment on this

He is raiding the banks too.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I believe there are 125,000 people in the country unable to pay their way at the present time. In my own county a great many people are unable to pay their annuities and rates, and if the shopkeepers' accounts were available they would make very alarming reading. The Clare County Council at their last meeting passed a unanimous resolution asking the Government for a moratorium in respect of annuities. A two-thirds majority of them are supporters of the Government, and have supported it for a number of years, but they are now beginning to realise that the Government must do something for those people who are unable to pay their way.

The Minister for Education suggested that there had been a change of front on this side of the House in connection with the economic war. We always advocated a settlement of the economic war, and are very proud that it has been settled. I suggest that the change took place on the other side of the House—on the Government Benches. They did exactly as we advised them to do. They settled the economic war. We quite well remember the occasion last year when they came back and said that they had restored the British market. I would ask the Minister to do something for the people of Clare who have nothing to sell and who have no means of paying their way. They are anxious to retain the homes for which their fathers fought and defeated the British in this country; they are just as anxious as were their forefathers to retain their homes for their children, but at present their children are leaving the country.

The Minister for Education told us that the farmer hopes to see his son or daughter occupying the homestead. I am quite well aware of the fact that a number of people in my county have not a single number of the family left at home. If that state of affairs is allowed to continue there will be disastrous results. We may be told that we cannot get money to relieve the farmers. It is rather strange that we could get millions to pay a debt to the ancient enemy; we could get millions to form a colossal army in this little State; we could get hundreds of thousands for tourist development, but we can get nothing for the national industry, agriculture.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What about the £10,000,000 for it?

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I would ask the Minister to do something to help the farmers, especially the farmers in that very distressed area in Clare.

Comment on this

In the fairly considerable experience which I have had of this House I have rarely heard of a more cheerless prospect than that held out to us in the Minister's statement yesterday. Indeed, the gloom of that statement has been more or less reflected in this debate. I think only a confirmed optimist could get much comfort either from the opening statement in this debate or the contributions which have followed that statement. As far as we, in this part of the House are concerned, the fact that strikes us most is the complete absence from the Minister's Budget statement of any hope of social progress in the coming year. The door seems to be definitely closed and barred against any extension whatever of social services. There is not any hope, judging by the statements made, of a remedy in the very many defects that exist in the social measures that have been passed. Widows' and orphans' pensions give an example, on the non-contributory side, of many such defects. But we must defer any hope at least in the coming year—and if one refers to the concluding paragraph of the Minister's statement even to a more distant date than the coming year—of getting any improvement in that measure or any advance in the rather miserable provisions afforded under it.

Unemployment assistance is exactly in the same position. There are few members of this House who are not aware of the fact that for the last 12 months more rigorous and more rigid means tests have been applied in connection with unemployment assistance than formerly. While the Minister is right in saying that the total amount expended has increased—that is, of course, because additional people have become unemployed—in a great many cases the amounts paid have been considerably reduced. I think that is a very disturbing and alarming feature. It would be bad enough if the story ended there, but the story goes very much further. Certainly, one of the most distressing features of the Budget is that the three notable economies made in its provisions are to be made at the expense of such people. A sum of £100,000 is to be saved on the Office of Public Works. In the last couple of years there was evidence of a good deal of increased activity in that Department. The wretched, miserable, disease-ridden old school-houses we have in many parts of the country were, to some small extent, beginning to disappear. I think it is not an unfair presumption that a good deal of that work will be held up during the coming year and that there will be less employment in that respect. That employment, I suggest, is of more value than employment on relief schemes because it affords a greater prospect of fairly constant employment.

A number of places in the country were taken over following the Agreement in connection with the ports. I have one particular case in mind, Bere Island, where a fair number of people received, under the British Government; fairly steady employment. The reduction indicated in the Office of Public Works Estimate in the Minister's statement yesterday would seem to me to indicate that there is less hope of continuing work in places like that than one would naturally expect. A sum of £200,000 is to be saved at the expense of the unemployed or the partly employed in this country. The prospect which that holds out for the homes of such people is a very serious one. It will mean in their case, less food, less clothing and less nourishment for the children, nourishment that these children should receive if they are to become healthy citizens of the future.

I view that prospect, at a time when things are bad enough, as indicating a situation that is becoming very serious. I am inclined to say, and I hope it is not considered an exaggerated view, that the working people are being reduced every day in this country to a state of beggary, and that that is going to be intensified under the principal economies announced in this Budget statement. In former years it was stated in this House by the Minister that, wherever economies should be effected, they should not be effected at the expense of the poor. I suggest to the Minister that that is what is happening and what will happen in the coming 12 months. Another aspect of the case is even still more serious from the viewpoint of the workers in the country, and from the point of view of their share in the employment afforded under local authorities. An additional £150,000 is taken from the Road Fund for the purpose of assisting the Central Exchequer. That will mean a considerable decrease in the amount of employment provided. It will mean that local authorities, freed in some respects from the irritating regulations with regard to the rotation of labour and other such accompanying conditions, will be able to do less in that respect. Altogether, the position is a very sad and disappointing one.

New taxes have been imposed, and I think it can be said that they, in any case, are preferable to taxes on food. We have accepted the situation that is involved in taxation in the manner prescribed by the Minister rather than a situation that would involve taxes on food, because in addition to uncertain and irregular employment on small and inadequate wages, high living costs have, as has been pointed out here very frequently, made very serious inroads into the incomes of working people and poor people. Certainly any method of raising money other than increasing such costs is preferable to us, and I think, in the end, to the people of the country as a whole. The need for raising a great deal of this money arises from a war situation. This is not the place to discuss the defence policy of the Government. The viewpoint of the members of this Party in that connection has been already expressed. Time will show what would be the best policy in that connection. Generally speaking, this is not the occasion to discuss it, but it does seem strange that in all countries and at all times, in a war situation or in a threatened war situation, there seems to be much less difficulty in finding money for services of that kind than there is in finding money for ordinary services. Money has at all times and in all countries been readily found for emergencies of that kind, in very striking contrast to the reluctance to find money for the maintenance of human beings in peaceful avocations in their own country.

There is one statement of the Minister for Education to which I should like to refer. I do not know if the Minister intended to suggest that there was a situation developing in this country in which people were becoming more reluctant to work. Perhaps the Minister only referred to that statement having been made by others. It is a statement that one hears occasionally. We had a somewhat similar statement here a week or two ago when the people were described as "loungers" and "scroungers." I protest against that statement and that viewpoint. I maintain that that viewpoint, and the statement that emerges from it, are not accurate or honest as far as the people of this country are concerned. Eighty thousand people have left the country to get a living elsewhere, and I think that decision of theirs affords evidence that the people are willing to work. Anybody who has knowledge, and I think most members of the House have knowledge, of the eagerness with which the people look for every opportunity of working even for small and uncertain periods, found very little evidence of that in this part of the country; and I think it is very regrettable that people should avoid facing up to the unhappy position that we find in the country at present by raising a smoke-screen of that kind, which is both unfair and unjust, and entirely misrepresents the attitude of the people who are looking for work.

The position in this country with regard to unemployment is likely to be intensified very considerably in the near future. We cannot blind ourselves to the fact that a certain measure which is going through the British House of Commons at present is bound to have a very considerable effect upon us. If, as a result of that measure, our people in another country find themselves liable for service in the army of that country, then I think very many hundreds of them will turn their thoughts and their footsteps towards this country. If they are to come to this country in the next few months, and to find that there is less money for employment, less prospect of work, and less hope of their getting even a precarious, uncertain living here, the position here is going to be very much worse than it is.

The Minister has, of course, this year certain difficulties. The uncertainty of the world position and the difficulties that Governments in all European countries find themselves in, have, of course, some effect on the position here, and nobody wants to make the Minister's difficulties—which are, after all, the difficulties of the country—any greater because of that position. But, certainly, this Budget of 1939,16 years after this State was established, with its provisions tending to curtail the opportunities for living in the country and for getting employment, is anything but a pleasant one, and I think it would be a mistake if Deputies, whose first responsibility is to people of that kind, were not in a position to express their opinion on that particular matter. These are the aspects of the Minister's statement and of the Budget on which I want to express my opinion. I sincerely hope that the extremely doleful and cheerless prophecies that darken the end of the Minister's statement will not be fulfilled, and that a position that looks extremely bad at present may be lightened even to some small degree before the end of the financial year.

Comment on this

All the statements made on this Budget can be boiled down into the statement made by Deputy Linehan. He alluded to Deputy Childers' request that politics should be kept out of the Budget debate, and said that only for politics and the political aspect of this, we could all admit that the Minister was entirely justified in his Budget. That was Deputy Linehan's statement, that only for politics he and the other Deputies on that side were prepared to admit that the Budget was absolutely justified.

Comment on this

Are you looking over here?

Comment on this

I am looking at Deputy Gorey. I always find a certain amount of amusement in looking at Deputy Gorey. Deputy Gorey is the most amusing person in the House and I listen to him very patiently. But when a Deputy, after that admission, spent one and a half hours telling us what was wrong with the Budget there must be something wrong with the Opposition. Both Deputy Linehan and Deputy O'Higgins alluded to our statements about the reduction we would make in the Civil Service when we came into office. We did make a reduction of £280,000 in civil servants' salaries, but we had to make it with the full force of the Fine Gael and Labour Deputies arrayed against us.

Comment on this

It was too bad.

Comment on this

It was too bad entirely. I have been looking through the speeches made on that occasion and it is most amusing to read what Deputy O'Higgins had to say on the Second Stage of the Public Economies Bill when one considers his speech this evening. We had the position that the Opposition took the stand that the salaries of men who were absolutely protected against any interference should not be touched, no matter what the need of the country in general was. That was the attitude taken up by the Opposition when, as they stated at the time, the farmers were in want and misery—that civil servants should still enjoy their complete salaries—and they went into the Lobby and voted on that principle when we endeavoured to save £280,000 by economies in the Civil Service. Deputies opposite should also remember that only about 12 months ago they forced a general election on this country because they wanted to increase the salaries of civil servants despite the wants of the country and the position in which they stated the country was.

Comment on this

They remember all about it and what was said.

Comment on this

You have very good reason to remember it.

Comment on this

Who helped you to win that election? Tell us about the ex-Unionists.

Comment on this

The Fine Gael Party are now complaining of overtaxation. I remember a statement they issued 12 months ago telling people that they would get pensions at 65, that they would give complete derating to the farmers, that they would guarantee 5d. a gallon for milk, that they would give family allowances, and that they would wipe out the land annuities altogether. Add all these to the Budget and see how much taxation they would be imposing. I wonder had they any intention of keeping those promises. Anyone listening to Deputy Cosgrave this evening would definitely come to the conclusion that they had not the slightest intention of keeping them. We are entitled to ask Deputies opposite which of the social services they are prepared to get rid of. They are voting for each one of them here in the House. They voted for the £800,000 extra that they lopped off from the old age pensioners when they were in office. They voted for the widows' and orphans' pensions which cost, roughly, £500,000, and they voted for unemployment assistance, for the relief schemes, and for every other item that is here of £5,500,000 in social services, which they neglected when they were in office, at a time when the country, according to themselves, was far better off than it is now.

That was the position. Take even one item alone, the £280,000 that we endeavoured to save from the civil servants. That would clear the entire loan charges or the entire contributions to local authorities in respect of loan charges for housing. Which of the two bodies could best afford to lost it? Is it the well protected civil servants or the unfortunate men down the country living in a one-roomed cottage?

Comment on this

Even though a good many of them had less than 50/- a week.

Comment on this

Even the man with £1,300 a year was protected, and very carefully protected.

Comment on this

What about the man with £15,000?

Comment on this

Even including the judges; they were protected also.

Comment on this

It is a good job that the Deputy is not one.

Comment on this

I am afraid that the jury over there are getting very obstreperous. That is one item, however, and from 1922 to 1932, while Cumann na nGaedheal were over here on these benches, they paid the salaries to the civil servants but they did not build one house for the agricultural labourer or the working man in this country. Take the length and breadth of it, and show us one agricultural labourers' cottages scheme or one local government building scheme that was undertaken while they were in office. Just show us one scheme. But no. While they were in office no encouragement was given to the agricultural labourer, and if he wanted to get married he had no house except he put up a tent by the fence, because that was the only encouragement that was held out towards the increased marriages of which Deputy Linehan spoke. That was the position from 1922 to 1932. In fact you might say it was the position from 1914, when the European War started. In all that period not one agricultural labourer's cottage was built in this country, in the whole length and breadth of the country, and now the people over there complain, even after supporting the housing scheme in this House, because the income-tax fellow has to pay an extra "bob" towards seeing that these housing schemes and labourers' cottages schemes are still continued. What is the complaint about? I defy any Deputy over there to stand up here and mention one single scheme that was brought in by Cumann na nGaedheal under which agricultural labourers' cottages could be built. There was not one. That was good enough for the agricultural labourers and for the ordinary poor man and working man in this country. So long as the income-tax was kept down and the civil servants were protected and the aristocrats were all right, that was all Cumann na nGaedheal cared about.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The administration of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government is not under examination now, nor should it be.

Comment on this

I am not discussing it, Sir.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has heard nothing else for the last ten minutes.

Comment on this

Deputies can take any other item here with regard to social services and examine it. Let us have one of these social services—any one of them—that the Opposition wants to get rid of now. There is a large number of them that they almost certainly admit they would be very anxious to get rid of, but they have not the pluck to get up here and mention them. They dare not do it. They dare not mention one of these schemes for the providing of social services for the ordinary working people of this country which were neglected by them when they were in office, and if the Minister for Finance has had to increase, and largely increase, his Budget over and above the Budgets brought in by Cumann na nGaedheal—and various comparisons have been made between them here to-day—you can clap against one portion of it, at any rate, the £5,500,000 extra for social services.

Deputy Cogan was very loud in his statements to-day to the effect that nothing was done for the farming community. I wonder would he go down to the County Wicklow, which he represents here, and tell the farmers there that the Milk and Dairies Act, which provided a decent price here in Dublin for the Wicklow farmers for their new milk, was no good to the farmers there? Will he go down and tell them that?

Comment on this

What about the milk strike?

Comment on this

A few milk strikes occurred in Deputy Cosgrave's time, but we did not see that Bill coming along. Deputy Cogan made allusions to the position in regard to the table here from the Minister for Finance. I do not accept all the items in the table as true. Some items in it are true. It is true in patches, but that is all. When, however, Deputies over there are speaking about derating, they must not forget the halving of the annuities. I took the 50 per cent. reduction in the annuities, in preference to derating, and I considered that I was making a very good bargain for the agricultural community in getting £2,200,000 off their annuities.

Comment on this

So the Deputy is satisfied that he got them off?

Comment on this

We got what it would have been impossible to get if Deputy Giles and others over there got their way.

Comment on this

It cost you a good many millions to get them.

Comment on this

Yes, it did, but it would have cost far less if Deputy Giles had done his duty to his country. The economic war would have lasted only about three months instead of being a four years' war.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must get down to the matter before the House and cease discussing the economic war.

Comment on this

I am only discussing——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not in order in many of his remarks.

Comment on this

Deputies can take the item that the Minister has here in regard to the beet sugar industry. In connection with those items of beet and wheat provision has been made here for a home market for the agricultural community that they could not otherwise get—a home market that was not open to them previously, and a home market which, in my opinion, was well worth protecting and catering for.

Comment on this

Why has agricultural employment fallen by 43,000 in the past three years?

Comment on this

Why is it that during the period Deputy Mulcahy was here as Minister for Local Government, nobody had any business registering at a labour exchange for employment unless he was an ex-member of the National Army? Because he would get no work.

Comment on this

Is that all that can be said about the £43,000?

Comment on this

If Deputy Mulcahy will give me the chance, some day I will bring up the order on that matter which he sent down to the Cork County Council, and I will read it for his edification lest he may have forgotten it— that first preference in all employment, road work and otherwise, was to be given to ex-members of the National Army. The man with five children, unemployed, was to remain unemployed so long as there was an ex-member of the National Army, with no family at all, unemployed. The single man was to get employment first, and the married fellows could take their turn. That was the position during Deputy Mulcahy's term, so that I do not think he should talk much about unemployment.

Comment on this

I am talking about 43,000 people fewer employed in agriculture.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry is in possession and must be allowed to make his own speech.

Comment on this

We have a line of policy advocated here by Deputy Dillon, the shadow Minister for Agriculture. I think, however, he was knocked out completely yesterday by Deputy Belton and I congratulate Deputy Belton on wiping the floor with him for once.

Comment on this

I do not remember the incident.

Comment on this

He made Deputy Dillon a back-bencher in one half-hour when he drove him to the back benches. He is no longer the shadow Minister for Agriculture—he is all a shadow. If, however, we are to adopt the policy outlined by Deputy Dillon, the farmers will be deprived of the £1,000,000 odd which they got for beet last year, and of the £2,000,000 odd which they got for wheat last year, and made totally dependent on whatever they will get across the water for their agricultural produce. Therefore, I say that the only hope, so far as the agricultural community are concerned, is, firstly, to protect the home market, and secondly, to see that they get an economic price for their produce in it.

Comment on this

That is very sound, if it can be carried out.

Comment on this

I do not agree for one moment that the price of beet for this season is economic.

Comment on this

You squeal when you are pinched.

Comment on this

I am rather unlike other Deputies. The Minister for Local Government recently, when making the concluding statement on his Estimate, said that every Deputy, except Deputy Corry, had praised the manner in which things in his Department were carried out. All the fault which Deputies have to find with administration and everything else is kept in their pockets or in their boots—their tongues are silent about it, anyway— for fear they would offend a civil servant. If they want to know the reason for my attitude, I have no scruple in giving it to them. The complaints on which I have heard Deputy Hickey and others very vocal down on local bodies, and the complaints which Deputy Hickey should have voiced here instead of Deputy Corry, were not voiced by him.

Comment on this

I never made the statements the Deputy attributes to me. I have always paid a tribute to the civil servants whom I have met in the Departments.

Comment on this

Particularly the civil servant who put the £3,800 for a hospital on you.

Comment on this

I never made any such statement about any civil servant, and I think the Deputy should withdraw that remark.

Comment on this

I should like to be very fair to the Deputy. I will withdraw the statement until such time as I bring into the House the Cork Examiner report of it.

Comment on this

Instead of the Irish Press, for once in your life.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies might settle that matter elsewhere.

Comment on this

I ask Deputy Corry to withdraw his statement, because it is not true.

Comment on this

I am withdrawing—until.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair does not know what the Deputy is referring to, but local matters should be settled locally.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, it was worse than a local matter; it was a national matter.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not relevant.

Comment on this

I agree, Sir. If we are to look at the other items set out on this table, we must realise that agriculture undoubtedly got enormous benefits from the present Government. We did not thank the Government for the £2,500,000 reduction in land annuities and we do not think that any Government is entitled to thanks, because the agricultural community had to fight a battle for it and the agricultural community got very little help from any other section in fighting that battle. I say that here openly.

Comment on this

The O'Neills and the Carpenters did not do much for you.

Comment on this

Even though we had to drive some of the Deputies opposite into the front trench.

Comment on this

The front trenches did not see you, anyhow.

Comment on this

That was the beauty of it. We had to do the scrapping from 1918 to 1923, and it was your turn then.

Comment on this

What did you do? Did the Deputy say "the running"?

Comment on this

We saw Deputy Gorey's back oftener than his face. I make no apology whatever with regard to that sum of £2,200,000 because the agricultural community were fully and absolutely entitled to it. On the other hand, the policy upon which this Government set out, of providing markets here at home so far as they could for the agricultural community is being very successfully carried out and it is, after all, the only final hope of the agricultural community.

If the threatened European War breaks out, if the European Powers decide that they are going to starve John Bull out, and if they decide to do it effectively by sending a good fleet of submarines and aeroplanes to sink every ship going into Britain with food, the home market will be the only market you will have.

Comment on this

The Deputy will soon have Hitler looking for him. He would be a useful man.

Comment on this

A useful man always. Undoubtedly, the protection of our home market and the preservation of that market is one item to which we will have to give greater and fuller attention. I think the Government, or whoever were responsible for setting up the arbitration board which dealt with the price of beet this year were very ill-advised from the point of view of the interests of the community in general.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter might have been discussed on the Vote for Agriculture.

Comment on this

My allusion to it arises from the item on Table 8, in which the Minister states that a benefit to the extent of £1,050,000 is being conferred on the farmer under that heading this year. I do not wish to go further into these items, but Deputy Murphy—and other Deputies also—made mention of the reduction in the Vote for Public Works and Buildings. Now, I think it was last year, my Party decided to send me to college—I allude to the Committee on Public Accounts. Deputy Linehan will remember that for several days we had to call particular attention to the fact that that particular Vote was grossly overestimated.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Public Accounts will be investigated on a motion made. It is not usual to discuss in the Dáil what happens at meetings of that committee.

Comment on this

The Accounts have been published, a Chinn Comhairle.

Comment on this

£100,000 for the Red Embassy in Madrid.

Comment on this

The money for the gates for the Phoenix Park, and other things of that description.

Comment on this

Yet they were able to increase their salaries.

Comment on this

Why did you not vote against the Estimate?

Comment on this

I spoke against the matter here. Deputy Linehan took up an hour and a half of the time of this House this evening, and this is what he said.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not repeat the speech.

Comment on this

We also had a statement from Deputy Linehan on the stamp duties. I would seriously suggest to the Deputy that the Incorporated Law Society should change their charges and show a little more justice, and a little less of the shark.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy cannot discuss the Vote he will have to resume his seat.

Comment on this

Deputy Linehan called particular attention here to the loss in stamp duty and gave reasons for it— the poverty of the agricultural community, and that people were not taking out administration.

Comment on this

Not at all. Stamp duty does not apply to administration.

Comment on this

The real reason why there is not so much stamp duty paid lies with the Law Society's charges for the little work they have to do.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That matter is not relevant.

Comment on this

The Chair is ruling too much.

Comment on this

Deputies on the opposite side of the House have no manners.

Comment on this

It is a good job that the Deputy is able for them.

Comment on this

Generally speaking, this Budget is a good Budget, inasmuch as the taxes that are put on are levied on those who are best able to bear them.

Comment on this

And there were no jokes.

Comment on this

My only regret is that income tax is not further increased. A man with an income can far better afford to pay an extra sixpence in the £1 than the unfortunate agricultural labourer down in the country or the man on the dole can afford to pay an extra halfpenny an ounce on his tobacco.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy vote for the tobacco tax?

Comment on this

I am glad to see, also, that the supertax has been increased.

Comment on this

I am glad to see that the Deputy is so self-sacrificing.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton is taking it very well.

Comment on this

I consider that this is an extremely good Budget. If the money has to be found, there are no persons who are better able to bear it than those who have incomes on which they can pay income-tax. As far as the petrol tax is concerned, I see that it will undoubtedly be an imposition on the farming community, for the simple reason that a large portion of their agricultural produce to-day must be borne by lorries, owing to the fact that their roads are now impassable for ordinary horse traffic; and therefore, we should not look on this Budget as a complete relief to the farming community. There is no use in the Minister pretending here that the farming community is not going to be hit. Every load of artificial manure and every lorry will carry a share of this Budget tax out of the farmer's pocket.

Comment on this

Now the Deputy is tumbling to it.

Comment on this

These are facts, and facts that cannot be contradicted.

Comment on this

The Deputy is contradicting himself.

Comment on this

I do not see Deputy Keating looking any happier to-day than when he was looking for licences.

Comment on this

I was looking for them in vain.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that he got a fair crack of the whip. I regret that in this Budget there is no provision to take the burden of paying for main roads off the farmers' shoulders. That is another burden which could very well be borne by the motor user. It is unfair and unjust that that burden of main roads and trunk roads should still be borne by the agricultural community, and in my opinion it is one of the items which will have to be tackled sooner or later, and the sooner the better. The agricultural community at present has enough to bear already.

Comment on this

That is another name for derating.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton is painful at times. However, I do not wish to delay the House further.

Comment on this