Air Navigation and Transport. - Public Assistance Bill, 1939—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–181 of 367. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1939 ›
On the section, Sir, I propose, on Report Stage, to introduce an amendment to delete Section 2. Section 2 provides for the exclusion of Dublin City and County from the scope of the Bill, and, having fully considered the matter since the Second Reading debate, the desirability of bringing Dublin into line with the rest of the country appears to be beyond question. As Deputies are aware, in Dublin City and County a county scheme has not been adopted under the 1923 Act, and the old code of public assistance operates in Dublin City and County with some special provisions provided under the Dublin Poor Relief Act of 1929. Further amendments, consequential on the deletion of Section 2, will have to be drafted and circulated and considered on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:—
In page 4, in line 34 and line 35, after the word "surgical" where it occurs in those lines to insert the word "optical".
Comment on this
I understand, Sir. The purpose of this amendment is to clear up what is meant by the definition of "medical assistance" and to include something that may not be included in the section as it stands. The Parliamentary Secretary is aware that the boards of assistance at the present time are able to give assistance in the way of optical treatment to poor law patients, when the occasion requires, and it does not appear here whether that power is still retained.
Comment on this
As the Deputy says, the matter turns on the meaning of "medical assistance". As I understand the meaning, and as the Parliamentary Draftsman and my legal advisers understand it, surgical treatment includes optical treatment; so that there appears to be no need to make the amendment suggested by the Deputy. It is already included, and the powers that the boards of health have at the present time, in relation to the provision of optical treatment, will be continued under the Bill.
Comment on this
That satisfies me. If the Parliamentary Secretary says that there is no need to include the words, and that it is not a question of having any objection to including the words, I am satisfied.
Comment on this
I formally move amendment No. 2, standing in the names of Deputies Keyes and Corish:—
In page 5, line 1, to delete the word "general" and substitute the word "public".
Comment on this
I am sorry that Deputy Keyes is not here, because I cannot clearly understand what he had in mind in putting down this amendment. The words "home assistance" are inserted here to provide a convenient term by which to refer to the form of assistance which was formerly known as outdoor relief. Frankly, I confess that I do not understand what the Deputy had in mind, but at any rate, from a close examination, there does not appear to be any need to have the amendment inserted, and in fact it would be confusing.
Comment on this
There seems to be some doubt as to whether the manner in which home assistance is to be given remains the same as hitherto. Does the Parliamentary Secretary say that there is no contemplated change in that?
Comment on this
I formally move amendment No. 3, standing in the names of Deputies Norton and Pattison:—
In page 5, line 2, before the word "otherwise" to insert the words "whether in cash or in any other form".
That amendment is intended to make clear that assistance should have been in the form of cash as well as provisional assistance. In view of what the Parliamentary Secretary has said, I understand that that would be the position.
Comment on this
The insertion of this amendment would have no practical effect. It is merely a definition; it is not an operative section. Perhaps the Deputy would refer to Section 37 (2). For the Deputy's convenience, I shall read it for him. It is as follows:—
The Minister may by order make regulations governing the granting of home assistance and, in particular, regulating the nature of home assistance either generally or in respect of any particular class of person, and prescribing the times and places at which and the conditions subject to which home assistance may be granted.
As the Deputy sees, under Section 37 (2), the manner in which assistance may be granted will be prescribed by regulations to be made under the Act, but the insertion of this amendment in the definition clause would not serve any purpose whatsoever
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary give us the definition of a "joint district"? It says here that it has the same meaning as it has in the Local Government Act, 1927. I understand that it is the old joint poor law districts that were brought together during the amalgamation schemes, but the matter arises very frequently afterwards, and I should like to have a clear definition now so as to avoid misunderstanding later on. I understand that it means, in fact, a county, but I should like to know whether or not I am right.
Comment on this
Well, no. The expression "joint district" has the same meaning as it has in the Local Government Act, 1927. It may not be convenient at the moment for the Deputy to look up that Act, and I shall read it for him. The clause concerned is as follows:—
The expression "joint district" means, as the case may require, either (a) an area in a county consisting of a county health district which has no urban district adjoining thereto and situate in such county, or (b) an area in a county composed of a county health district and every urban district adjoining thereto and situate in such county:
Provided always that where an urban district adjoins two or more county health districts situate in the same county as such urban district, the Minister shall determine to which of such county health districts such urban district is for the purpose of this sub-section to be deemed to adjoin, and thereupon this sub-section——
I am referring now to Section. 8
——shall apply in such county as if such urban district adjoined only the county health district so determined by the Minister.
I am quite sure that the Deputy cannot follow all that clearly but when he sees it set out, and has time to study it between now and the Report Stage, I think he will be satisfied.
Comment on this
My difficulty will arise in dealing with Sections 6, 7, 8 and 9, where we have such phrases as "public assistance authority,""public assistance district" and "joint district." I take it that a joint district means, in practice, a county. Of course, there are certain other difficulties and differences that may arise where there are urban areas but, in fact, the general rule is that all counties, with a few exceptions, are joint districts.
Comment on this
Sub-section (2) of this section states: "In every public assistance district, public assistance shall be administered by the public assistance authority specified in that behalf by this Act in respect of such district." Now, I must also refer to sub-section (2) of Section 9, for the purpose of getting this matter clarified. Sub-section (2) of that section states: "The public assistance authority for a public assistance district consisting only of a joint district shall be the council of the county with which such joint district is co-terminus or in which such joint district is situate." Relating those two clauses, we find that sub-section (2) of Section 7 sets out that in every public assistance district, public assistance shall be administered by the public assistance authority which means the county council. Is that intended?
Comment on this
Is the machinery that already exists for the administration of public assistance to be taken from the board of health as such and given back to the parent body, the county council?
Comment on this
Does the Parliamentary Secretary feel that he has machinery to do that? There are some sections following which would let us out of the difficulty which that creates if they were permitted to appoint a public assistance board, but according to my reading of the Act they are not.
Comment on this
Might I remind the Deputy that this Bill when it becomes an Act will not be operative until the appointed day, and that the appointed day will not be fixed until other legislation that will be necessary for the implementation of this Bill has been presented to the House and passed by the House? That legislation will include the Managerial Bill and the Local Government Bill. When that legislation has been passed, and the managerial system has been adopted, the difficulties that the Deputy has in mind I think will not arise.
Comment on this
I have been endeavouring to study that matter, but I am afraid they will arise. I do not see any way in which they can be avoided. We have this joint district business running right through the Bill, and we have the other matter of the county council being the public assistance authority. Then we have the matter of the existence of boards of health, and they are going out of operation as far as public assistance is concerned immediately this comes into force. We have at the same time the question of the transference of officials. To be quite candid, I cannot reconcile all these provisions. I do not know what is going to happen under the Bill even with the very best intentions and even under the managerial system. The thing appears to me to be mixed up to some extent, and I cannot understand it. I want to know in particular, in regard to sub-section (2) of Section 7, is it seriously intended that the county council of a county is going to be the public assistance authority carrying out the detailed administration of public assistance?
Comment on this
Not only is it seriously intended, but it is clearly set out in the Bill. It is also set out in the Bill that the county council shall have power to appoint a committee or committees to administer public assistance for the district, or any part of it.
Comment on this
There is no doubt about it. It is clearly set out that the county council will be the public assistance authority.
Comment on this
They have the right where there is another type of district, not a joint district, to appoint an assistance board. I can follow that. They can appoint an officer of the board or various officers if they so require them. The county council apparently cannot appoint the board but they can appoint a sub-committee.
Comment on this
How is it any more undesirable than the appointment of a board? Is it the word "committee" to which the Deputy objects?
Comment on this
It is not the word "committee" but, after all, if you appoint a public assistance board under the Bill, you must appoint people who are elected by the people. If you appoint a committee you are not tied to that. You may appoint clergymen or outside laymen to carry on. I do not think that is sound.
Comment on this
Does that mean, in effect, that the Deputy is not prepared to give the county council, the duly elected representatives of the local people, the right to appoint a committee, that he cannot trust them? After all, it is not the Minister who will appoint these public assistance committees. It is the members of the county council themselves. Surely the Deputy does not ask the House to believe that a county council cannot be trusted to appoint responsible people as members of a committee to administer home assistance?
Comment on this
I do not think there is any necessity to introduce that point. I am endeavouring to be helpful as far as I can. I certainly do not think that county councils would not appoint the right people but I do not think a committee of that sort is good business.
Comment on this
A public assistance board of elected public representatives should be your aim because, mind you you are going to couple with this the managerial system which is going much further than this. It is a much tighter administration.
Comment on this
Is it open to them after they have appointed a committee to give that committee officials? Is that open to them under the Bill?
Comment on this
Officials of the public assistance boards are dealt with in this Bill.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary would help to clear up the position if he were able to tell us whether the public assistance committees visualised by the Bill will have much the same powers as the present boards of assistance, not alone in regard to public assistance, but generally. Could the Parliamentary Secretary indicate how the other duties at present discharged by the boards of assistance will be discharged in future?
Comment on this
The extent of the powers and the duties to be conferred on public assistance committees will be a matter for determination by the county council. They will have full discretion.
Comment on this
The difficulty is that there are three Bills to be brought in. It is very difficult for us to visualise this Bill in the absence of those other Bills—a Bill for general rating and a Bill dealing with the county managerial system. I understand that, in general terms, in future there will be only one public assistance authority in a county. What would be the position in the County of Cork where there are at present one county council and three public assistance boards?
Comment on this
So far as the City of Cork is concerned and the portion of Cork County that is at present attached to Cork City under the county scheme, there will be no interference.
Comment on this
No change. The rest of the county will be administered either by the county council directly or by committees appointed by the county council—as many committees as the county council may think well of appointing.
Comment on this
Will this be the situation: that when this Bill is in operation, there will be a public assistance board operating; that in a case of Cork versus the district around Cork there will be a public assistance board, with officials designated and appointed to that board to do their work? Outside that, in the remainder of Cork, public assistance will be done by small committees. Is that the intention for the whole country? Under Section 10, in every public assistance district which consists of a county borough and a joint district, those two are permitted to appoint a public assistance board and appoint officers for that board. They will have officials to carry on public assistance, but outside that a county council will have to carry it out through local committees. Is that the intention? At least, that is what is in the Bill.
Comment on this
Take North Cork. That has a very distinct board from the South Cork Board of Public Assistance and the West Cork Board. I think Deputy Brennan is trying to find out if a public assistance board has officials at the moment. There is no difficulty with the county council in appointing a committee to function as a public assistance board with the same authority as if they had to pay the officials, and the same thing applies to West Cork.
Comment on this
Is it not the county council that appoints the present committee? There is no difficulty.
Comment on this
At the present time in County Roscommon there is only one public assistance authority, that is the county board of health, which has its own officials. Now public assistance is going to be taken from the board of health, but the officials are going to remain in the board of health because they have other work to do.
Comment on this
The officials will be transferred to the county council as the public assistance authority under the Bill.
Comment on this
I can see difficulties where you have two different headquarters, and the headquarters of the board of health may be 30 miles from the headquarters of the county council. If the county council take over the committee of public assistance, they will look for some assistants to look after public assistance work while the remaining officials look after the county board of health work.
Comment on this
It will mean extra officials, because the public assistance committee will remain in the headquarters of the county council. I suppose that will come in under the managerial Bill.
Comment on this
What is worrying me is whether it is the county council or the Cork Corporation to whom these powers are going to be transferred, or does the Minister think it is now high time to carry out the wishes of the county board of assistance in this matter?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:—
In sub-section (2), page 6, lines 14 and 15, to delete the words "Subject to the provisions of this Act in relation to existing county scheme authorities".
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:— In sub-section (2) (c), line 32, after the word "situate" to add the following words "and wherever an urban district is situated within the public assistance district, administered as a joint district, such urban district council shall be entitled to elect one representative on such joint board".
This amendment arises on the question I raised on the Second Reading of the Bill with regard to the administration of the Boards of Public Assistance in the County of Cork. In the County of Cork there are several urban districts and I am particularly concerned with the South Cork Board of Public Assistance where the county is joined on, not only to urban areas, but also to the County Borough of Cork. We are already chafing under the weight of carrying the burden of the City of Cork, which takes two-thirds of our rates and only contributes one-third. That is not so much the object of this amendment as to get representation for the urban district in that area and the other areas of Cork on those boards. Six urban areas in South Cork—Kinsale, Macroom, Youghal, Midleton, Cobh and Passage—have no representation whatever on these boards. They have to pay rates and have to pay the cost of collecting the rates. They have no voice in the striking of that rate nor have they any voice in the administration of the spending of that money and I think it is only a fair principle of equity that these authorities should get representation on the general board of public assistance. I am asking that the Minister would give each urban district in the area one representative from the urban body on the joint board. I think it is very fair and I am not asking anything very much. I am sure the Minister will see it is a matter that he can easily accede to without breaking through any of his rules or in any way infringing upon the principles of the Bill.
Comment on this
If it is a different object, it must be raised on the section. An amendment is now being discussed.
Comment on this
My objection to Deputy O'Neill's argument in connection with the urban districts having separate representation is that already the urban districts elect the county councils. They are portion of the electorate for the county councils and they have their voice there. I think it would be nonsensical to increase the powers or the representation of the urban districts by having them, in the first place, electing the county councils, or at least having a share in electing them, and then afterwards having separate representation for themselves on urban bodies. I think that would be nonsensical.
Comment on this
Before Deputy O'Neill finally leaves us, I had better tell him that it is not proposed to accept the amendment. Deputy Corry has. I think, fairly fully dealt with the request for acceptance of the amendment to give special representation on the board of assistance to urban areas. I do not know if Deputies have yet grasped the fact that there will be only two boards of assistance in the State— the board of assistance in Cork and the board of assistance in Waterford, where we have a county council and a corporation co-operating for public assistance purposes. They have already adopted a scheme under the 1923 Act. As Deputy Corry very truthfully says, the urban ratepayers have an opportunity when electing county councillors to secure the proper representation they are entitled to on the county council. My experience is—it may not operate in Cork, but it does in the North of Ireland, which is considerably different from Cork in many respects— that in the North of Ireland people living in urban areas secure an undue proportion of representation on county councils. That is my experience.
Comment on this
On the Cork Board of Assistance there are ten representatives of the county council: I do not know how many of the ten belong to urban areas but, at any rate, they were appointed by the county council. Candidates who stand for election in urban areas to the county council are not confined in their vote to the urban areas. They very often get votes from the rural areas. I do not think that any case could be made for giving special representation to the urban areas on the board of assistance, in addition to the representation that the people themselves have vested in them as representatives on the county council.
Comment on this
The Minister has said that people in the urban areas are entitled to get representation. We can understand that, but, if they do get representation on the county council it does not follow that they then secure appointment on public assistance committees. I do know counties in which representatives have been put on, but in other counties representatives have not been put on. I suggest that Deputy O'Neill is asking too much when he says that for every urban area there should be one representative, but I think that where there are two or three urban areas there should be a representative for the group. There should be some provision in the Bill to bring that in, as the urban problem in so far as home assistance is concerned is entirely different to the problem which prevails in the rural areas. I am on the public assistance committee by rural votes. If the rural representatives want to get representation they can get it.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt, but does the Deputy appreciate that this amendment refers to boards of assistance and that there will be only two such boards. The amendment does not affect his area at all.
Comment on this
It does peculiarly refer to Cork, and I will ask the Minister, even if he is not accepting my amendment, to consider the position. I think that the position of South Cork, particularly as we are carrying the burden of Cork City on our shoulders, is one for special attention. I ask the Minister to give this special care and he will see further on the weight of my arguments. We have representatives of the urban areas on this board of assistance and we do not seem to get any under this Bill. I will ask the Minister to consider that and I will withdraw the amendment if he will give some assurance.
Comment on this
There is no use holding out any prospects, as the amendment could not be accepted. If he feels he has any real solid substance in his argument, I would suggest that he bring his weighty arguments to bear on the members of the Cork County Council and if he can persuade them that the urban areas are entitled to bigger representation on the county council than they are getting, it is a matter for their discretion, but he need not press for special provision to be incorporated in the Bill that the urban areas will get special representation.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary will see that county councils are specially precluded from nominating anybody except members of the county council. If there was a member on the county council who was represented in urban areas he would have no representation under the Bill. It happens in a number of cases that if you had a representative of every urban area in, say, the South Cork district, there would be no rural representative at all.
Comment on this
There is a representative there from Cobh, Mr. Corry; one from Midleton, Mr. Brasier, and one from Bandon, Mr. Crowley.
Comment on this
There is no such thing as a Bandon urban area, there is a Bandon County Council area, which includes a couple of urban areas, but neither of the urban areas has anybody there to represent them. I am afraid the Minister does not see that these urban areas should have representation on the central body.
Comment on this
You do not want the Minister to come along and insist that the representatives from the council should be elected on the county council so that they may later be placed on the board of assistance. Deputy O'Neill was a representative of the county council on the board of assistance and he walked away and left us and left the Kinsale urban area without a representative on the county council who could be put on the board of assistance. That was Deputy O'Neill's fault.
Comment on this
I was on the county council as the elected representative of an urban area. I want to get on the board of assistance as a direct nominee of the local urban area. I will not pursue the matter.
Comment on this
Surely to goodness the Deputy does not want two votes, one in respect of the county council and one in respect of the board of assistance?
Comment on this
I move the rejection of the section. I have just been made wise by the Parliamentary Secretary when he says that there will be only two boards of assistance—one, the board of assistance for South Cork and Cork City, and the other that for the City of Waterford—so that this section is only carrying on an injustice, a gross injustice, to the unfortunate rural districts concerned. This section is put in with one purpose alone as a definite decision of the Local Government Department that this injustice is to continue. The unfortunate position is that, whilst two-thirds of the rates in the South Cork Board of Assistance joint area are contributed by the rural district and one-third of the rates are spent in the rural district, one-third of the rates are contributed by Cork City and two-thirds of the rates are spent in Cork City. I think that the agricultural community are entitled at least to a fair crack of the whip. I do not think it is just to the agricultural community to throw this burden on them. In putting in this section—which is put in definitely and solely to cover these two joint districts, the joint district of Waterford City and county, and the joint district of Cork City and South Cork—the Local Government Department and the Parliamentary Secretary have shown their intention of carrying on this injustice to the unfortunate people of those districts. I cannot agree with the section, and I move its rejection.
Comment on this
I think there is a great deal to be said for Deputy Corry's point of view. I think that if the Parliamentary Secretary were to canvass the opinion of Cork, Waterford and other places in which a situation like that exists, where a town and a portion of a rural district are included, the rural district paying the greater portion of the rates while the city reaps all the benefits, he would, I think, be convinced that something ought to be done to relieve that situation. I know one particular town in County Roscommon which is getting more public assistance than all the others put together.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
I was asking the Parliamentary Secretary seriously to consider the question raised by Deputy Corry. It is obviously an unfair position where you have a large urban district and a county borough authority, such as they have in Cork and Waterford, together with a much larger rural district. There ought to be some compensation in the shape of a low rate for public assistance purposes in the rural district, if the greater portion of the money is to be spent in the urban district.
Comment on this
Deputy Brennan thinks there is a good deal to be said for Deputy Corry's point of view. It is a new alliance.
Comment on this
Nothing wrong, but what I wonder at is that it did not dawn on Deputy Brennan during the last 15 years that there was anything wrong with this scheme.
Comment on this
We are amending it now, but apparently we are not going to do so.
Comment on this
We are not amending it. We are implementing what the people of Cork City and county agreed to in 1924.
Comment on this
If it requires amending, now is the time to amend it.
Comment on this
Has Deputy Brennan received any representations from Cork that it ought to be amended?
Comment on this
We have heard the viewpoint of the rural area affected in Cork expressed. There is an urban area affected, too, and the viewpoint of that urban area is entitled to at least as much consideration as the rural area.
Comment on this
When they are getting two-thirds of the benefit, while paying one-third of the money, they ought to be well satisfied.
Comment on this
The Deputy might leave the position of Cork to the Cork Deputies. They are very well able to speak for themselves, and, as a rule, when one speaks, they all speak in rotation, so that the subject will be fully and adequately discussed, without any interference from Deputies from other constituencies. What I want to do, as I told Deputy Corry when he raised this point on Second Reading, is to preserve the agreement we made in Cork on the ground that it is not so easy to get the people of Cork to agree, and that I am reluctant to march boldly in and dissolve this happy unity which we have had for the past 15 years in Cork.
Comment on this
If they want to divorce the rural area from the urban area, I think they should take the first steps about a divorce themselves. I am not going to interfere and force divorce upon them. They have got on comparatively well. It has been a comparatively happy union, as happy as one would expect considering the elements constituting the joint board, and I advise the House to leave them alone.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary speaks as if this were a completely agreed and happy affair. It is not, and nobody should be better aware of that fact than the Parliamentary Secretary and the Department of Local Government, who have, during the past few years, received several protests from that joint board against this unnatural state of affairs in which the unfortunate agricultural community have to pay eightpence out of every shilling, and in which, out of every shilling spent, eightpence is spent in the city while fourpence goes back to the country. That is an unfair and an unjust position.
Comment on this
I welcome Deputy Hickey's interference and if he can put the case for the city, I should like to hear it, but certainly, while I am here as a representative of that area, I will do my duty by it. This section is definitely brought in to continue that injustice. I had hoped that, when we were getting changes in local government, the appeals and resolutions repeatedly sent to the Department on the matter would be dealt with, but, instead, we find this section included for no other purpose than to continue that injustice and to make it a permanent feature. I appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to withdraw the section. I think it unfair and unjust to ask any body of men to contribute to the support of another body of people who are very well able to look after themselves.
Comment on this
I can recollect, at a very early period of the existence of the present Public Assistance Board in Cork, the very frequent protests made against the very serious charge upon the rural area, an area which has passed through very lean times and which still has to carry on under this injustice. I do not think there is any similar anomaly throughout this country—certainly, it does not exist in County Dublin—of a rural area having to pay the lion's share of the contribution towards local assistance and reaping the smaller amount, while the city, where all the industry is, and which is supposed to be the wealthier portion, pays the smaller amount and reaps the greater volume of public assistance and is paid, as perhaps is right, on a higher standard. The board of public assistance has adopted a very efficient means of administering this, and it would perhaps be well if other counties followed their example, in as much as public assistance is not given to any new applicant unless he is first recommended by the superintendent or the home assistance officer. The most careful supervision is exercised by that board, and I am glad to say that there is a certain amount of unanimity——
Comment on this
It does not. It had to be inaugurated in Cork. It was inaugurated by another board with which I was connected, the North Cork Board of Assistance, by which it was administered very efficiently. The most careful supervision is exercised by the senior officials in the administration of public assistance. I support my colleague Deputy Corry on the opposite side in his efforts to get this section amended. We are both representing the same area and there are occasions in which we do find a certain amount of unanimity. The Parliamentary Secretary is aware of the innumerable protests that have been made by the board of public assistance against that injustice and these protests have always been carried by a large majority. I do not expect my friend, Deputy Hickey, the Lord Mayor of Cork to join us in this. The Deputy is only human. If he can grab for his own area a larger volume of money I can hardly blame him. I think the Minister ought to accede to our request and to remedy that injustice.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Corry and Deputy Brasier know well that the major revenue they have for the Cork County Council is from the suburbs of Cork. We are trying for some time to extend the Cork Borough boundary.
Comment on this
But the suburban residents do not want it and it is no wonder when they see the excellent results of the administration in the county council and compare them with the administration of the Cork Corporation. The county council administration is much more efficient than that of the Cork Corporation and much cheaper.
Comment on this
The Cork Corporation are paying £1,500 in rates to the Cork County Council and that is because of the narrow borough boundary in Cork——
Comment on this
Will the Deputies challenging a division please stand in their places.
Deputies W.J. Broderick, Brasier, Daly and Corry, stood in their places.
Comment on this
There are not sufficient Deputies challenging a division. Only four Deputies stood up and they will be recorded as dissenting.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:—
In sub-section (3), page 7, line 20, to delete the word "three" and substitute the word "seven".
The provision made in this section for the appointment of committees limits the membership to an entirely insufficient number. It is with some hesitancy that I invite members to visualise the position in Cork under this provision. The county covers a very extensive area. The complaint there, and perhaps in other counties, is that boards of assistance with a membership of ten are not sufficiently large for the purpose of local knowledge and local needs. The Parliamentary Secretary will, of course, say that it is open to county councils to appoint committees of a larger membership than three. But in case committees would be appointed of not more than three members, the position ought to be met in the Bill. The committees appointed should be sufficiently large and well-informed to administer this service as it ought to be administered.
Comment on this
Section 11 provides, as Deputy Murphy has appointed out, that a public assistance authority may "from time to time appoint such and so many committees as they think fit for purposes connected with the exercise or performance of all of their powers, duties and functions...." It is conceivable, and to my mind fairly probable, that county councils will appoint a number of committees within their administrative areas to deal with different aspects of public assistance— dispensary committees, hospital committes and committees to supervise boarded-out children, to mention only a few. To me, it would appear to be desirable that they should appoint such committees in comparatively small areas if immediate contact is to be kept with the people concerned. Taking the parish or dispensary district as the unit, if the county councils appoint two or three sub-committees for the purpose of administering different forms of assistance and if they are bound by statute to appoint a minimum of seven members, I doubt if sufficient persons would be found in the smaller districts to man all the committees that might be set up under the Act. I do not think there is any danger whatever to administration in making three the minimum number to serve on such committees. The machinery might, possibly, break down if the minimum were made as large as seven. I do not think that the proposal is a wise one and, consequently, I suggest to the Deputy that he should not press his amendment. On consideration, he may see that there is a strong case against it.
Comment on this
So far as I understand the machinery to be set up under this section, we are not concerned with hospital or dispensary committees but with public assistance committees——
Comment on this
"Public assistance" includes assistance in the various institutions, hospitals and dispensaries.
Comment on this
Yes, but the Parliamentary Secretary visualises the appointment of a number of committees. Some committee will be invested with responsibility for administering home assistance and it would seem to me that a committee of three for that purpose would be wholly inadequate and might result in injustice to the poor. That is my concern in the matter and I think the Parliamentary Secretary might look into it again and see if he can meet my point in some way. I am not tied to this particular amendment but to have three persons dealing with home assistance in a rural district or dispensary district might be very unsatisfactory to the recipients of home assistance.
Comment on this
I am not as much concerned with the membership of the committees as I am with the necessity for the formation of these committees. I am not aware of any committee which exists in County Cork but I am aware that a considerable amount of hardship is imposed on people who know not where to go to get assistance or to get instruction as to how they are to get into a hospital. Occasionally, they meet officials who are far from sympathetic and I think that that is an exceptionally weak link in the whole administration of home assistance and hospital treatment. The poor people who have to avail of these services have nobody to guide them or assist them but officials. I feel very much the omission to establish these local committees which would have local knowledge and sympathy with the unfortunate people who are seeking the assistance of these institutions.
Comment on this
Deputy Broderick is not aware that, under the 1924 Act, there was power to have such committees appointed. I doubt that any local authority availed of that power. On Second Reading I said that there was a big danger in this provision, and I say so still. There is nothing in this section which limits the membership of these committees to three.
Comment on this
It can go up to ten or a dozen, but the larger the number of people you have administering public funds without any responsibility to the electorate, the more danger there will be in such committees. Every local authority is, I think, aware of that. Where you have very small county councils and a large number of committees administering public funds without any responsibility to the people, you may get an undesirable position. It has been found that persons who act in this way have not the same responsibility as elected representatives of the people. That is the danger in this whole section.
Comment on this
I am perfectly aware of the provision in the 1924 Act. I did not refer to it save to point out that these committees do not exist. In Deputy Allen's view, the question has resolved itself into one of increased expenditure. I have not dealt with that point, but these committees have merely power to recommend; they have no power to pass expenditure. That is, so far as the 1924 Act is concerned. In this Bill they may have such power, and it is undesirable that anybody should have that power without responsibility to the ratepayers. Under the 1924 Act they have merely power to recommend. I am reminded by a colleague that, even in this Bill, they have not any executive power. They have only power to recommend. I have not read the Bill, and I do not know if I am correct in that.
Comment on this
They have full power if the county council, with the consent of the Minister, so decide.
Comment on this
The county council or the board of assistance?
Comment on this
Under this Bill, the county council, in all areas outside this famous Cork area, and Waterford.
Comment on this
Does not that bring you up against an extraordinary position? If the Parliamentary Secretary's statement is true, it makes confusion worse confounded. Am I to understand that the position is this, again using the headline of Cork: that the county council would have the power to appoint committees for which the City of Cork would be jointly responsible? If that is so, then we are going to have an extraordinary state of affairs.
Comment on this
The statement made was, as I understood it, that those committees would be appointed by the county council.
Comment on this
I said, outside the famous area that we have been discussing so long, affecting Cork and Waterford. I do not think the Deputy was present when we were discussing that.
Comment on this
There is one aspect of this to which I wish to direct the attention of the Parliamentary Secretary. He said he hoped that these committees would be set up to cover rather small areas, indicating parish or dispensary areas. There is nothing in the section, or in the Bill, so far as I can see, which would prevent a county council from establishing such committees in, say, electoral areas. An electoral area, as the Parliamentary Secretary and Deputies know, can be a pretty wide area, particularly in a large county. If you are going to have a committee of the kind visualised in sub-section (3), you may have one consisting of three or four members. I agree that under the section you could have one consisting of 23 or 24 members, but the section says "not less than three". We may assume, then, that in or about three will constitute the personnel of a committee.
Comment on this
Yes, in so far as it has wisdom. I suggest that it is possible to comply with the section by appointing a committee of three or four people. If such a committee is to administer public assistance in an electoral area, as distinct from a dispensary or parish area, you are going to have a very small committee to look after the needs of home assistance applicants over a very wide area. I think that would be a great hardship on many of those applicants. It would be impossible for such a committee to ascertain accurately the circumstances of the recipients or potential recipients, or to investigate them with the thoroughness that you could get if there was a larger committee functioning in that area, or if you had a committee functioning in respect of a smaller area. I think the Parliamentary Secretary should look into the matter with a view to ascertaining whether it is not possible to make the minimum something higher than three. Why not make it five?
Comment on this
If the intention is to have a number of those committees functioning over a county it would seem to me to be necessary to make some provision as to a meeting place for them. Has that been overlooked?
Comment on this
If Deputies had read sub-section (5) they would see that the quorum, procedure and place of meeting of those committees shall be such as may be appointed by regulations to be made by the public assistance authority which has appointed them.
Comment on this
If you appoint a committee of three, which is possible under the Bill, then you will appoint by regulation a quorum. That will be either one or two. If you appoint the quorum to be three it means that if one is ill, or absent for some other reason, the committee cannot function at all.
Comment on this
This debate may be very interesting from the point of view of a purely academic discussion: of trying to make debating points, but really there is not much substance in it so far. The whole discussion is based on the assumption that the county council cannot be trusted to do anything. I do not accept that premises at all. The county council have full power to determine the number of committees, the number of persons who shall constitute each committee so appointed, as well as to make regulations governing the quorum, place of meeting, duties, etc., that the committees are to discharge. Is the position being definitely taken by the critics of this particular section that we cannot entrust these simple powers to the county council?
Comment on this
If that is not the position, and if the county council can be trusted to do all these things, then I do not think that we need waste the time of the House further in discussing it.
Comment on this
Is it not the board of public assistance, and not the county council, that will appoint these sub-committees?
Comment on this
We have been dealing with that question for hours. The trouble is that the Deputy has not read the Bill.
Comment on this
Why not make the minimum number more than three so as to get over any difficulty of the kind that has been mentioned. I suggest that a larger number would be more reasonable so that you may be sure of getting a quorum.
Comment on this
I do not think the Parliamentary Secretary is quite fair in falling back on the county council all the time in endeavouring to draw a red herring across the discussion here. Now, this is not a county council meeting. This is the Parliament of the country where legislation is being framed. If this legislation proves unsatisfactory, the blame cannot be put on the county council hereafter. May I ask, what type of county council we will have when this measure is in operation? It is quite possible, and conceivable, that a county council will be simply one individual.
A situation might very well arise in which I would not be prepared to trust him. I know, of course, of all the virtuous people who have developed into super-men in this country. We have quite a lot of them throughout the country, but I am old-fashioned enough to prefer the collective wisdom of a public body, composed of people who know the local circumstances. Holding that view, I do not think that the Parliamentary Secretary has met the position at all.
Comment on this
The case has been put to the Parliamentary Secretary that the minimum number should not be as low as three. If the present minimum is insisted on, you may have a situation arising in which three or four will, in fact, represent the strength of the committee. The case has been made that three or four is an exceptionally small number in those circumstances, if the committee is to administer public assistance over a wide area. The Parliamentary Secretary asks can we not trust the county councils to do that. We can, generally speaking, but there are some things which ought not to be left to the discretion of the county councils. This is a national Parliament, framing legislation, and it ought to indicate broadly to county councils what the minimum number should be. We should not pass a function of this kind on to the county councils and say: "We trust you to do it." We should indicate broadly what the minimum number should be. The county councils are not such sacrosanct bodies at all. The Parliamentary Secretary or the Minister dissolved a number of them because they would not carry out their functions or because they functioned in such an unsatisfactory manner. County councils are not infallible or pontifical bodies at all. They have been found negligent on many occasions. We ought to indicate here that we regard five as the minimum number. The Parliamentary Secretary has made no case whatever for retaining the figure of three.
Comment on this
Then, if we cannot make the Parliamentary Secretary see reason we will make him walk.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the word proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 8:—
In sub-section (3), page 7, at the end of the sub-section, to add the words "provided, however, that the number of members so appointed shall, at least, be equal to the number of persons entitled to be elected to serve as members of the said public assistance authority in respect of the functional area of the committee."
The sub-section provides that the public assistance committee appointed by the county council may be composed either wholly of members of the county council or partly of county councillors, and the purpose of the amendment is to ensure that the public assistance committee should have at least as many members on it as there are county councillors for the district covered by the committee. In one particular county, at least, where a reduction in the membership of the county council was agreed to, the position, following the next local elections, if the changes contemplated had not taken place, would be that each member of the county council would be a member of the public assistance committee. This amendment aims at preserving a somewhat similar position. It would follow on much the same lines as have been already argued, and I think it is a reasonable amendment.
Comment on this
I must confess again that I cannot follow the argument, and I am not sure that the Deputy has brought out what he appears to have intended. The amendment conveys to me the idea that when these committees are appointed by the public assistance authority, at least half of them should be elected members of the local authority. If that is what the Deputy intends by the amendment, if that principle is adopted, it would mean that the whole idea of the appointment of these committees, especially in the smaller areas, would be definitely jeopardised. Let us take the case of boarded-out children. Members of a supervisory committee who are not elected members of a county council might be very useful members on such a committee. Again, if we are to have at least half of the members of such committees elected members of the county council, it will mean that such committees can only function for a fairly wide area. If, say, the average number would be seven, as the Deputy seems to anticipate, that would require at least three or four county councillors under the amendment, which would cover a very wide area. I do not think that there is any good case for the amendment. I think it is better to leave the discretion as to the personnel of the committees in the hands of the local authority.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:—
Before sub-section (5) to insert the following new sub-section:—
The law for the time being in force in relation to the qualification and disqualification of persons for membership of a county council shall, so far as it is applicable, apply to the persons appointed to be members of every committee appointed under this section.
It seems to me that the Bill, as it stands at present, makes no provision for the disqualification that obtains at present in regard to members of local authorities in connection with membership of committees. The Parliamentary Secretary and the House will be aware that members of local authorities who may suffer disqualification by being involved in contracts and transactions of that kind incur certain penalties. The purpose of the amendment is to see that that position is preserved in regard to the committees and that the disqualification would apply to members of the committee in the same way as it applies to local authorities at present.
Comment on this
The position is safeguarded by clause 6 of Article 12 of the Schedule of the Local Government (Application of Enactments) Order, 1898. The same thing applies to the next amendment.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Allen that these committees are going to be very dangerous. They will have no administrative responsibility. It may be all right to say that they will have the necessary local knowledge of applicants, to determine whether they are entitled to assistance or not, but they may act very generously in that respect, and for that reason, it would be very difficult to keep home assistance within a reasonable limit. If there is a home assistance officer, and if he is doing his job properly, by making the necessary inquiries to determine the means of applicants, he will get all the information necessary to enable local authorities to do their duty and to decide whether home assistance is necessary or not. I anticipate that committees of this sort, not having the responsibility of keeping home assistance within reasonable bounds, will act very generously towards local people. They will be parish committees dealing with a limited number of people, and their recommendations will be very generous. I know that these recommendations will have to be confirmed, but it will be very difficult to control home assistance expenditure.
Comment on this
If it is only a question of setting up committees many counties may not be inclined to do so. As far as I understand it, this Bill visualises county managers and we do not know what their powers will be. If the Parliamentary Secretary could tell us at this stage if county managers will have to determine whether committees should be set up or not, or whether they will be set up by the elected councils, it would help. We should know that. To a certain extent we are legislating in the dark. That is what I feel about the matter. If we could have a picture of what the Government proposals on the whole matter were we would be able to discuss this Bill to greater advantage. Will the managers determine if such committees are to be set up or will the elected councils do so? If the latter were to decide the position would be fairly safe. It would be different if the managers were to decide. That is the problem to be faced. I admit that certain committees that perform certain functions can be very useful, for instance, as the Parliamentary Secretary pointed out, in looking after boarded out children, but when they come to expend money in their own areas, the position might be different. It is well that it should be considered beforehand. Otherwise it might happen that the whole county managerial system might break down.
Comment on this
I should like to know if the Parliamentary Secretary could indicate if he would prefer that county councils should set up committees or if the innovation is to be tried out by county councils, if they so desired.
Comment on this
Yes, but the powers are not exercised. Does the Parliamentary Secretary attach importance to the setting up of committees, or is there anything to indicate that they will have merely a continuation of powers which already exist? Will he say whether he prefers to have committees set up or whether he prefers to have, matters of administration left to a single council such as a board of health? I think the point raised by Deputy Allen is one of considerable importance. If it is felt desirable, in the light of the two other Bills that are to be introduced on the subject of local government, to set up committees of this kind, it is important when considering this Bill at this stage to know whether, when we have county managers installed—if they are installed—it will be one of their functions to decide if these committees will be established or if the representatives of local electors will be permitted to decide that question, independent of the judgment of county managers? A county manager may well decide that he does not desire such committees, and he will function, or arrange matters in such a way that very little authority will be diffused to anyone as far as he can prevent it. What is the intention in that connection in respect to the two other Bills foreshadowed on the Second Reading?
Comment on this
Personally, I think such committees should serve a useful purpose, especially in relation to the supervision of boarded out children, and even in connection with home assistance, that is, if you get the best type of citizen to function on such committees. I believe a good machine could be set up, but whether it will become operative is another question. The power has been vested in the board of health but it has not been much availed of, and one would naturally be inclined to pre-suppose the same conditions applying in future. My personal view is that it would be a good thing if such committees could be got to take an interest in social affairs, and in the condition of poor people they have close contact with, and that they are in a position to advise.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:—
Before Section 12 to insert the following new section:—
It shall be the duty of every public assistance authority for a public assistance district which consists of a county borough and a joint district in a county adjoining such county borough or consisting only of a joint district, to appoint in respect of each parish situate within the functional area of such public assistance authority one or more public assistance wardens to perform such duties as may be assigned to them by regulations made by such public assistance authority.
Comment on this
May I point out to the Deputy that Section 38 (4) covers the point he has in mind in the amendment. It states: "The Minister may by Order make regulations..."
Comment on this
Does the Minister suggest that that sub-section fulfils the purpose outlined in the amendment?