We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Banking Commission Report and State Finances—Motion.

Contributions 108–233 of 233. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Nobody can say, when he buys a lb. of butter in Dublin to-day, or when he buys it in Ireland generally, that he is paying one farthing more than what is an economic price for the farmer.

Comment on this

What about the price of milk?

Comment on this

Yet, Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Sullivan—they who claim to be the friends of the farmers; they who want consideration for the farmer all along the line—keep on insisting on this "hidden taxation". Now, I have always been trying to get an explanation of that contradiction in the policy of the Opposition. I have never yet heard an attempt to reconcile the two things, and I wish to goodness some attempt would be made to do so. I am sure there are very many other Deputies here like myself who find it hard to reconcile these two things and would like to hear from some of those who are going to speak this evening an explanation as to what is in their minds. You cannot have it both ways. You cannot accuse the Government or arraign the Government on the ground that they are not friendly to the farming community or that they are not doing sufficient for the farming community, and then, when they have done the thing that is of most service to the farmers and that, in my opinion, is most appreciated by the farmers, come along and say: "Not only are you taxing the people directly but you are heaping up indirect taxation on their heads." You cannot have it both ways, and I think that Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Sullivan, in their speeches to-day, were very much endeavouring to have it both ways.

There are very few countries indeed where farming is prosperous to-day, and I think it can be held that in this country, as far as the Government are concerned, they have endeavoured to do as much as any other Government has done, and in fact the remedies that were applied here are practically identical with the remedies that were applied in Sweden, for instance, where, so far from there being any recrimination, there is general agreement that the measures taken by the Government —which, as I say, were almost identical with the measures taken here—are credited with rescuing the Swedish farmer from the worst effects of the depression and enabling him to continue his industry. Again, when people talk about rural emigration here as being phenomenal and as being caused by Government policy or something of that kind, and at the same time point to the great success of Denmark, Sweden, and so on, I wish they would have more regard to the facts. In Monday's issue of the News Chronicle I saw a report that some thousands of farm labourers had left Denmark for work in Germany, and that having got into Germany, they found that the wages they were given there were not sufficient to support them. They tried to get home, and, as they had not got passports, the difficulty in getting home was very considerable and a very ugly situation had arisen. Now, if Denmark, which is organised up to the hilt, and which is often pointed out to us here as a country which we could take as a model—if that situation prevails there, where thousands of farm labourers left for a country like Germany where wages are small and working conditions are very hard, I think it might not be considered so obviously due to Government dereliction of duty that people should leave this country for another country, in order to work in industry, where there are relatively high wages and relatively good conditions.

It would be very much better, in my opinion, if all these things were not made mere Party matters and if questions were considered more on their merits and with a view to finding some constructive line for remedy. You find that in the United States, also, it is calculated that the farmers' income has decreased by 30 per cent. since 1929, and you find that in Czecho-Slovakia, of the efficiency of which we heard a great deal in recent years—and particularly in recent months, when, from English sources, you hear a great deal about the wonderful efficiency and the wonderful charm and the wonderful culture of the Czechs—that, in the short space of 20 years, the rural population has fallen by 280,000 and from something like 55 per cent. the percentage of rural population as to the whole has changed to 32. That is to be found taking place in a country that is supposed to be a model of efficiency, and that was a model of good government, if we were to believe the English accounts that have been so numerous in recent months.

Deputy Dillon made one remark that I think is grossly incorrect. He said the bank managers—he may have said bank directors: either managers or directors—have expressed alarm at the rapidity with which farmers were withdrawing deposits. I happen to know from one bank director, at all events, that, so far from that being the case, the surprise has been in banking circles that, during the depression in farming and during the economic war, the withdrawal of deposits has been very very low: altogether less than £1,000,000.

Comment on this

I believe the Deputy will find that statement made by, I think, the Governor of the Bank of Ireland in the Report for 1938.

Comment on this

No, I certainly would not.

Comment on this

You certainly will.

Comment on this

My information comes from a director of the Bank of Ireland.

Comment on this

Look it up again.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy not look it up himself and support his case by an actual quotation?

Comment on this

I certainly will, when I am winding up the debate; and I think that the Prime Minister will not deny it, because he is too cute.

Comment on this

I deny it, on the very best authority.

Comment on this

Yes, but you will find that the Prime Minister will not deny it.

Comment on this

I will make no such absurd suggestion.

Comment on this

Well, let the Prime Minister deny it and I will correct him.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon will have the last word this time.

Comment on this

And the Taoiseach will be as circumspect as a cat on top of a wall as a result thereof. The Prime Minister is being warned off.

Comment on this

No; quite the contrary.

Comment on this

Here is a quotation taken from a book on agricultural economics that has just arrived in the library:

"The decline in the aggregate income of farmers as a group has been general, affecting all countries, but has been greater in the countries which export food. In the United States the purchasing power of farmers' income is estimated to have fallen by 30 per cent. In Germany the farmers' share of the national income has been increased slightly at the expense of food consumers."

May I remark another contradiction? The Government is accused of not stimulating production sufficiently: if they were in earnest about the job, if they were a good Government, they would have increased production more rapidly. How is one to reconcile that with the taunt of Deputy McGilligan when he made one of his rare appearances in the Dáil a few weeks ago, and with the taunt of Deputy Mulcahy also recently, that the Government was supplying cheap food to John Bull? Increased production, I presume, means not merely cheap food, but cheaper food.

Comment on this

It is making the people here pay in order that the British people may get food cheaper than we can get it here. What I mean is, that the Government by its policy is raising the price of bacon and the price of butter here, in order that bacon and butter may be pushed over to the British market and sold to the British people at lower prices than the same commodities are sold at here.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy cannot be as innocent as he pretends. He knows that the price on the British market is the best price we can get for our exports.

Comment on this

Certainly; why should we have to pay a bigger price here?

Comment on this

Then the Deputy is in favour of withdrawing the export bonus. He says——

Comment on this

I might explain——

Comment on this

Allow me to state my case. As I understand the Deputy, he wants butter and everything else, where there is an export surplus, sold here at the price that it fetches in the British market. If butter cannot fetch more than 70/- or 80/- a cwt. in the British market, that is to be the price in this country; if bacon is sold at a certain price in the British market, that must be the price in this country. I understand that to be the Deputy's case, and that if farmers cannot live on those prices, they can go to the wall.

Comment on this

The Deputy spoke about the jibes of Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Mulcahy on the ground that we were supplying John Bull with cheap food. I ask the Deputy is it not a fact that the people in this country who are exporting bacon and butter have to pay higher prices than they otherwise would have to pay, in order that Irish butter and bacon may be sent over to Great Britain and sold at a lower price.

Comment on this

In the name of goodness, how does that explanation make an improvement?

Comment on this

I am bringing the Deputy back to the question of the jibes.

Comment on this

I still think that they are jibes. Deputy McGilligan, at least, considered it was good Party propaganda. He as much as says, "I will not be here for a good while longer, and will have a `go' at the Government in a way that will appeal to the crowd." I am sure that was Deputy McGilligan's mentality, but Deputy Mulcahy is surely not so innocent as to think that he explained his jibe.

Comment on this

I have explained that the jibe was, in fact, a true statement of the case.

Comment on this

I am afraid I will have to leave it at that.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy will.

Comment on this

One would like to know what it is the Deputy is aiming at. Is he urging that the farmers should be left so that their income should depend on the British export prices, on the prices received for our exports to Britain? Is that to be their position, that, if they cannot live by that, there should be no attempt to compensate them? Is that his claim?

Comment on this

I am not saying that I will answer the Deputy at length, but it might do a lot better for the farmers than some of the things tried by the Deputy and which kept the Front Bench so silent up to now.

Comment on this

Now, one thing at a time. We would like to settle this question of butter. The Deputy and his colleagues claim to be a farmers' Party and in favour of more and more help for the farmers. He finds fault with the position that the farmers are getting a certain subsidy on butter. If all our butter was to be sold at a certain price—the price obtaining on the British market—butter would not pay and the industry would collapse. Yet the Deputy says that it should be sent out at the Irish producers' expense. Is not that so?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy hold that there should be no butter exports? If the British will not give us an economic price we are to refuse to trade and we will do without a good deal of the things that we require— oil, tea, and all the things that come into this country. Is that his case?

Comment on this

I am glad that the Deputy realises that he has to pay for these things.

Comment on this

I am not so innocent that I have only just begun to realise that we must pay for what we get.

Comment on this

The Deputy has only just begun to realise that, and that we must pay for the mistakes that we make.

Comment on this

I must repeat that I am very disappointed in this debate. I was hoping, from those who apparently gave notice of this motion and who one would expect would read the report of the Banking Commission very carefully—I was hoping that we would hear genuine expressions of opinion from them as to some of the main recommendations of that body. It is singular that up to the present there has been no mention at all as to what they advise should be the attitude towards the two main recommendations: that housing should be suspended and that land division should be suspended. Neither Deputy Dillon nor Deputy O'Sullivan made the smallest allusion to these two questions. Why? Are they waiting for the Government to make a decision on these questions, and then to assail that decision? Why could they not give us the benefit of their thinking on these two matters? They are very big questions for the country, and it would be of great use to us to hear what such important leaders as Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Sullivan think about such matters.

Personally, I did not intend to intervene in this discussion at all. I hoped that I would have had a day of real education, and that I should be able to hear all these things which have troubled me with regard to the Banking Commission Report explained in the clearest and most lucid way possible, and that I should have no further trouble with that document. So far from that, we got merely a Party reading of it, and a very shallow Party reading, in my opinion. The report is a very valuable one for its facts and for a number of its technical recommendations. It is valuable, too, in the sense that it brings out what, of course, was obvious to those who were directly in touch with things, that we cannot live beyond our income, that we have to pay our way as we go along, that if we get goods from abroad they have to be paid for by goods in exchange, and other facts of that kind. It is very useful so far as it brings out these points to people who have perhaps become a little over-confident and who thought that no such problem as merely paying their way would arise. To that extent, the report is very valuable, but I still think there are many contradictions in it. I am afraid I shall have to wait, but I hope that before the debate closes we shall hear some of these contradictions explained.

Comment on this

In rising to support the motion, I thoroughly agree with what the last speaker said, that this debate should proceed so far as possible on a non-Party basis and in a non-Party atmosphere, and, in reading this motion, I see nothing in it of a Party character. The object of the motion, as I understand it, is to give this Assembly an opportunity of expressing its approval of certain recommendations made by a non-Party and technical commission, the Banking Commission, and I think it is the duty of all of us here, no matter to what Party we belong, to pool our experience and to pool our brains, so to speak, in order to give support and effect to these recommendations. That, so far as I can see, is the object of the motion. I think it would be very much a matter of regret if this debate resolved itself into a debate in the real sense of the word, with an attempt by each side to score debating points off the other about things that do not really matter. I think we should wake up and realise the serious situation in which the country finds itself at present, and the responsibility which rests on each and every one of us to contribute, so far as lies in his power, to a solution of what is admittedly a very urgent problem indeed. It is no good quoting figures at length. The plain people of the country do not appreciate figures. They realise better than the most eloquent tongue in this House can put it the state this country is in, and it did not require, and does not require, the findings of the Banking Commission to prove that to the ordinary inhabitant. The situation that faces us is that something has to be done to save the country from ruin. We on this side have been called Jeremiahs, and we are told that we have a gloomy outlook on things. We are only taking a gloomy outlook, because we have to face facts. There is no good in going about pretending that we are better off than we are.

Comment on this

Or worse off.

Comment on this

We are not in any way pretending that we are worse off. We say that we must face facts, the facts as found in the Banking Commission Report and the facts which are known to the people, who do not require any elaborate or technical figures to bring home to them their situation to-day and their situation some years ago. I am not concerned with the causes which have brought about the situation. I do not think the debate should proceed on historical lines, or on debating point lines, but I am here as a representative to contribute, in my own humble way, to the discussion in order to find, if possible, some solution of the urgent problem that confronts us. We have only to look at the recent Dublin by-election to realise that, not only the Party to which I belong, and the Labour Party, but all the members of this Assembly, sitting here as a House, are rapidly losing caste in this country. In the first by-election held since the last general election, over 50 per cent. of the electorate did not bother to leave their homes to register their votes for one Party or the other, and they were electors residing in an urban district for whom there was no difficulty in going to the polling booth. It is up to the Government and to this Assembly to try to formulate some scheme that will put an end to the situation which exists and which is known to exist in the country.

I am not a great believer in quoting figures. We have listened to some interesting figures to-day, but there are certain facts which a plain person can understand, facts which it has taken a long time for people in high places to realise, but which the plain people realise. The first fact, and apparently there is not unanimity on it, is that things are indeed very bad in the country. Perhaps I may think them a little worse than other people, but, at all events, a situation has arisen which every Deputy and every Minister recognises calls for immediate action and urgent action on the part of the Government who are responsible for the carrying out of any plan put forward. The second fact is that we are a food-producing nation. I listened to Deputy Moore, who gave us some interesting references to the incomes of members of the farming community having gone down in America, CzechoSlovakia and in other places. I am not in the least interested in the inhabitants of other countries. We should accept the facts that exist here, that we are a food-producing country and that we are producing the type of food which is suitable for and wanted by the people who live in the European temperate zones and climates, and that we have the market ready at our door. That is fact No. 2. Fact No. 3 is that the market, and a willing market, is at our door; and fact No. 4 is that we do not at present supply our market with anything like the quantity of food and produce which that market could take.

These are four simple facts which the people can realise, with, or without a Banking Commission, and they are four simple facts which call, I submit, for some action on the part of the Government to improve the situation here. Before we can improve that situation, before we can increase production and before we can increase the marketing of our goods, there must be a demand for those goods before production. I submit that the organisation of the Ministers and of the Government in this country is all wrong. We have nine members of an Executive Council here responsible for Government policy. One of the nine represents the Department of Agriculture, a Department on its own. I submit that there should be only one Department, a Department of Agriculture and Industries which should be amalgamated together, and that in that Department Agriculture should take the prime place. There should be no two separate Departments of that kind. I submit also that there should be a Department of Exports, and I would amalgamate with that Department of Exports the Ministry or Department of External Affairs, to deal with the marketing of our produce in a specialised and technical way, to create a demand abroad for our produce and the advertising of our produce abroad. And once the demand is there, and has been created, we will not be able to supply in sufficient quantities the demand that would arise.

That is a fact that very simple people can understand. There are parts of the Banking Commission Report which I do not understand myself, but I do understand plain facts. I have come to this House; I do not seek to make any political capital out of the fact that a situation has arisen here as set out in the Banking Commission Report which it is the duty not only of the Government, but of Deputies on this side to deal with. It is our duty not to sit here and debate, but to go out and do something for the people. It is especially the duty of the Government to go out and do something for the people who gave them a mandate to sit and govern here. The Prime Minister laughs. Perhaps I am saying things that sound foolish here within the walls of this House, but they do not sound foolish down in the country where the people of this country live and have to earn their living. If the Prime Minister would go down the country and investigate for himself the situation which exists there he would not be able to keep that laugh on his face—if he could only appreciate what is happening.

Comment on this

There is nothing so foolish as some of the statements made by the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Deputy is only asking the Prime Minister to carry out his promises.

Comment on this

The Prime Minister describes my remarks as foolish. I am quite satisfied to accept from the Prime Minister that description; but I stand here as, I hope, an honest Deputy representing his constituency and bringing to the notice of the Prime Minister and of his Government facts which may sound foolish; but I am only stating facts and putting the actual situation in the country before the Prime Minister. Certainly if this is foolish then I suppose I am speaking foolishly here to-day.

Comment on this

Who is the actor now?

Comment on this

Oh, we will always give the Taoiseach best.

Comment on this

Now, in putting these facts before the Prime Minister I may be foolish but I am certainly not insincere. However I am willing to accept the charge of insincerity and to admit even that if it would help in any way to make the Government concern itself with matters of this kind. We are dealing with only three-fourths of our country here to-day. Unfortunately a good part of the country is cut away. First of all we should reduce our housekeeping expenses to such an extent that they would conform to that part of the country which exists to-day. We should first of all reduce our housekeeping commensurate with the size of the State in which we live. Owing to the historical trajectory of this nation since 1922 we have assumed the garb—I submit I am foolish again but not insincere—of some major European Power with Departments of this and Departments of that. We are acting as if some of the major European Powers were in competition with us for places in the sun. If one of these European Powers sees fit to increase its armaments we do the same. We are competing with European Powers in the matter of bombing planes and we are expending public money on bombing planes. When I mentioned that matter in a debate here the answer I got was that these were not bombing planes, but light bombing planes. But the Press in the last few days has been full of pictures of large bombing planes in transit over this country at the expense of the tax payers and generally at the expense of the people of this country. I submit, Sir, that we should not try to carry on as if we were some enormous European Power.

There is nothing infra dig or wrong in assuming the garb of what we are, a small and not a very rich country. There is nothing infra dig in housekeeping on that basis, but I am afraid what the Government have forgotten is that we are a small country of insignificant resources. But we are a magnificent country still and one with very unique resources. If the Government will only take time by the fore-lock and accede to the terms of this Motion then there may be some hope. The country is waiting for them to do something but so far they have done nothing. I submit, with respect, that this Motion before the House will give the Government a decent opportunity of bringing forward some scheme for alleviating the situation that exists. If the Government will only do that, this Motion will act as a source of prevention before it is too late.

Comment on this

I had thought that a good many Members of this House would have looked forward to this Debate as something which might have removed a good many of the honest doubts and difficulties which challenged Members with cross bench minds which all Parties entertain in this matter. We remember that there was a commission set up, the Banking Commission, for the purpose of examining into a whole lot of fundamental economic facts and conventions in relation to dealing with them in this country. A very great deal of importance and a very great deal of significance was attached to that particular report. A considerable amount of Party feeling was engendered by the suggestion that the very important facts and conclusions arrived at by that report had been kept back from the people. There were very many forecasts, fearful and terrible forecasts, in relation to the nature of the Commission's revelations, its directions and its recommendations. Now, that report has been in the possession of the people for a very considerable time. The conclusions which responsible people would form in relation to it should have now been solidified. I think everyone will have felt some surprise that an earlier opportunity for a formal examination of that Report was not sought by those who are professedly in favour of it. I am quite sure that it was not the duty of the Government to bring it forward, but we certainly looked forward to the day when it would be brought forward and to all the facts, conclusions and coordinations which it contained and which we expected would be brought out as an expression of policy by those who are in favour of the different and very diverse points of view which were put forward in the matter. Roughly speaking, the Banking Commission Report has divided itself into a Majority Report and a series of comments on the Majority Report. The suggestion has been that the Majority Report as such has been approved of by the solid, commercial, educated and conservative opinion in this country.

Therefore we would have been entitled to expect to-day that someone on his feet in this House would have expressed himself as accepting in principle the Majority Report of the Banking Commission. Up to the present I have never met in Ireland a single man who accepted in principle the Majority Report of the Banking Commission. I most certainly have not heard to-day anybody so profess. The central principle of the Majority Report of the Banking Commission is that there shall be no further borrowing, under any circumstances, for any purpose, including housing and the distribution of land, except a directly reproductive purpose. That is the main principle of the Majority Report of the Banking Commission, and, right or wrong, it is a courageous declaration. They put no tooth in it. Under no circumstances—not even for housing or the distribution of land—shall any further deadweight debt be incurred except for purposes which are immediately reproductive. Unless one does accept that principle—it is a principle without any condition and without any reservation—one is definitely turning one's back on the Majority Report of the Banking Commission. I do not want to have any doubt on that subject. They made no conditions, and those who say they follow them can make no conditions either.

Is there a single person in this House who accepts the principle that housing in this country in the future shall be limited to that amount which can be done immediately out of income? Is there any Party in this House that is prepared to declare that it will have nothing further to do with the redistribution of land? If you once say to yourself, "I am going to pick and choose between the things on which immediately reproductive expenditure can be undertaken," and if you are going to say to yourself, "I am in favour of the economical, solid, sound administration of this country in everything except in the things in which I want a different kind of administration," then there is nothing in the suggestion that you are in favour of a sound and economical administration. If one man is entitled to except housing and another man is entitled to except the redistribution of land, then, in turn, every other man in this House is entitled to choose those things which he is in favour of and say they shall not be subjected to that particular test. When the Drainage Commission reports, and when we come to this House and ask, perhaps, for millions of money—deadweight and, definitely, not immediately reproductive expenditure—who is going to get up here and say that he is not going to have drainage done? If one man can choose drainage, another housing, another distribution of land——

Comment on this

They have had a fair innings.

Comment on this

Why should not another man come along and say that, in relation to the rebuilding of the whole school system, he will make an exception? Why should not people whose minds are on the black areas of the West say that, in relation to reconditioning the lives of these people—the best of our people, the people to whom we owe most—they also must be left outside the ambit of expenditure which must be immediately reproductive? On that basis, what I want the House to understand is that there is not in this House, or outside it, or, in my personal opinion, in the membership of the Banking Commission, a single man who, with full advertence to the meaning of that resolution, accepts it in principle and is prepared to carry it out. Before the thing was published, the very people who signed that report were falling over themselves to subscribe, to advocate subscription to and to help the subscription of a £10,000,000 loan—dead-weight capital expenditure.

That being so, we turn from the whole of the majority recommendations of the Banking Commission Report as something which those who signed them either did not know the meaning of or did not mean. We turn away from all their recommendations with the duty on every individual of us to read the evidence and to form our own conclusions as to what ought to be the system of financial administration of this country. I speak as one definitely and openly a conservative in finance, one who does not believe that any miracles can be performed, who believes that hard work and prudence, sound administration, the doing of unpopular things, the facing of difficulties, and only those things, are going to produce results. But I am certainly not going to say that, with all the inequalities in the wealth, station and condition of the people of this country, nothing must be done to help the poor, the unfortunate, or those who carry the heavy end of the log, except what can be immediately done out of this year's income—and done safely out of this year's income.

The second thing that we have looked forward to in this debate was a discussion upon a subject which has disturbed the minds of a lot of people over the world for the last ten or 15 years, and which increasingly has tended to disturb the minds of the people of this country in relation to what is known as a social credit system of finance. At various times Deputies, in this House and out of it, have used what seemed to some of us loose expressions in relation to purchasing power, manufacturing purchasing power and the energising of industry by the use and development of the credit of the State. It is quite possible for people to use expressions of that kind and to know what they mean, and it is quite possible for them to use those expressions and not know what they mean. What would be very important, in my opinion, would be that on some occasion in this House, face to face, men who had different experiences in relation to the crude, ordinary things of life, would put their cards on the table and show what they did really mean, apart from hoping, by ideas of this kind.

Now, it is very curious to relate, but it is true to say, that the biggest impetus towards that kind of thinking in this country came from popular resentment of the basic principle which was laid down in the Banking Commission Report. Its illiberalism, its hide-bound conservatism, its reckless, uncalculated acceptance of the particular principle which I have put before you as its main principle, drove numerous conservatively-minded, quiet-thinking people practically Red in the matter of finance. A lot of people who previously had hardly thought about the subject took that particular line and the result has been that there has been a very large movement of popular opinion in favour of something in the nature of social credit reform.

Now, why I am stressing all that is because I want it to be clearly understood that I do not regard people, who at the present moment are speaking of these things, as speaking with a considerable amount of support amongst the people, but it is far more widespread, far more eloquent, than its merits, in my opinion, deserve. It was for that reason that I looked forward to-day to have those doubts, which some of us have, of the existence of any reality behind an idea of that kind, resolved. I had hoped that when the Labour Party had put down in a formal resolution here "the utilisation of the credit of the nation to stimulate such development", they would in fact have, in a student-like spirit, explained to us what they meant. Now, I think it is literally true to say that they have not attempted to do that. I am not now saying that in any sense of blame. At the moment they may feel that all their spokesmen are concerned with is in making a case for the necessity of something being done, but I think they will recognise that they cannot leave this case here to-day without a full technical explanation of what exactly they mean to do and how exactly they mean to do it. If they give us that explanation, they will be doing something which will be of great service to the House. If they can make clear to the House that some such miracle of this kind can be performed by currency manipulation or any other means, then they will have done a very great service to the cause and the purpose which they regard as the raison d'etre of their Party and the justification for its existence. They will, I think, agree with me that up to the present no such attempt has been made. Certainly, this debate must not end without such an attempt being fully made by them.

Personally, I should very much like to feel that there was some such solution. I agree with my colleague, Deputy Dowdall, when he says that the limit of credit is the production, the available exchangeable production, of the country, and that up to that limit you can multiply credit without any difficulty and without any danger.

Comment on this

We agree.

Comment on this

That is what Deputy Hickey will have a full opportunity of explaining to us later. My personal belief is that there is something to be done as between a restricted and an enlarged currency, but the amount that is to be done is relatively very, very small indeed compared to the things that can be done in other ways. I am deliberately asking for information; I am asking for help. I am speaking as one who, for 30 years, has tried to believe this thing, who has tried to find out some machinery by which it can be done, but up to the present I have not been able to do it. I have read, I think, every authoritative exposition which has been made of this particular theory. Up to the present I have found nothing that is anything but words.

Apart from currency manipulation there is another use, a Governmental use, which is being made of money and which is being confused with the other. I am dealing with it now simply and solely so that the cards on both sides can be put upon the table, and so that there can be no confusion in the matter. Certain countries like Germany and Italy—Germany especially at the present moment—are carrying out a great deal of their government by manipulation of their currency; by the control of money; by the power which the Government has taken into its hands to ensure that no money shall go in any direction except a direction approved by the Government; by systems of internal and external currencies; by restraint of the supplies of money in certain directions. They are doing, through the control of money, a great deal of the things which in other countries are done by legislation. If, for instance, this Government took control of all the moneys, it could say that agriculture shall be stimulated at the expense of industry; it could say that heavy industries shall be stimulated as against light industry; it could say that money shall flow conveniently into tourist development; it could say that money would go into industries that were paying wages of a particular character, or that were employing people of a particular character or in a particular place. In other words, if a government takes into its hands the possession of money, and decides to manipulate that, it can do a lot of things that are being done in the ordinary country by legislation.

But it is an entirely different proposition to imagine that the totality of the wealth of a country or the totality of its production can be altered by manipulation of that kind. I am putting to those who honestly believe something different the difficulties which I have in the matter, convictions which I have formed, deliberately for the purpose of making sure that before this debate ends they, knowing the difficulty of honest enquirers in the matter, will recognise they have the duty and will be able to discharge the duty of explaining what has not yet been explained— what they mean by "the utilisation of the credit of the nation to stimulate the development of industry."

Returning now for one single moment to the main proposal of the Banking Commission Report: that we must live in everything for the future on our immediate income; that expenditure must come down, all I can say is that if you could find agreement in this House in relation to anything in which expenditure could be reduced there would be an amazingly strong case founded on that agreement for reducing that expenditure whatever it was. I have never seen a sign of agreement of that kind. You are in precisely the same position if you go to the people who are in favour not merely of that wide principle but of the general atmosphere of the majority report. Some years ago the Associated Chambers of Commerce or their representatives solemnly met in Dublin for the purpose of considering the Budget before the Budget was introduced. They decided to go on a deputation to the then Minister for Finance, to ask him to reduce expenditure and taxation. Some very kind and sensible member of their body said, "Well, that is the sort of thing that has been said a great number of times to a great number of Ministers for Finance but if we as being probably the most responsible commercial body in the country were to go to him with definite recommendations as to what should be reduced or, if in relation to any particular tax which had to be taken off, what tax we would substitute for it, I consent. It would have an enormous effect and influence." That was agreed but, after an hour's discussion, they decided to go to the Minister for Finance and simply ask him to reduce taxation.

Until you can get out of that, until you can reach a stage in which there would be agreement, not merely that too much of the income is being taken by its government for the purpose of carrying on the corporate works of the people, but agreement as to the things you do not want done, you are not likely to get any further. What this country wants, in my opinion, is not so much emphasis on reducing expenditure but emphasis on getting value for all the expenditure. I think there is more room for effective saving, more room for reducing the burden on the community of corporate work in the mobilisation of public opinion behind the slogan: "Value for every penny of Government expenditure," than there is for any other slogan that I know. Those who want a sound economy in this country will, I think, find it along those lines and I invite them to mobilise along those lines.

Again, and in conclusion, I would say to those who believe that there is some other form of currency control which has in it magic possibilities for the betterment of this country, that their duty here to-day, having themselves challenged the issue, is to expose their hand, to tell us exactly what they mean and give us an opportunity of examining its merits.

Comment on this

I rise to take up very few minutes of the time of the Dáil on this particular debate. I do so in order to express both surprise and my protest at the particular way in which Parliament is being treated on such an important occasion as a debate of this kind, a debate which was specially invited by the Taoiseach himself when speaking on a previous occasion in this House, a debate dealing with such grave matters as the incidence and weight of taxation, the pressure of debt, unemployment and the general financial stability of this country. I think it is an insult to the Dáil and callous disregard of the people outside that a debate of this kind should have gone on for nearly six hours and that no member of the Government has intervened in order to state Government policy or attempt to put a case for debate before the Dáil. It is a definite and blatant shirking of the responsibilities of office. It may suit everybody to get the last word but, attached to every office, there are certain very definite responsibilities. Never before have I seen responsibility shirked in the manner in which it has been shirked to-day. Two Deputies from this Front Bench have spoken. The Leader of the Labour Party has spoken. A number of Deputies from different Parties have spoken but neither the Taoiseach nor any of his Ministers has so far intervened.

It might suit everyone of us to have the last word: by having the last word to get the better of an argument. But Government office carries certain responsibilities, and early intervention in a debate of this kind is certainly one responsibility. We had a Parliamentary Secretary just now giving us a long exhibition of shadow-boxing, fighting or attempting to beat down a non-existent case: trying to pretend that there was something either in the motion or in the amendment directly advocating social credit, and devoting the whole of his speech to a laboured attempt to mislead the public as to what is demanded from the Government.

What is demanded from the Government in the motion is to reduce direct and indirect taxation: to endeavour to curtail or slow down the pace at which the deadweight debt is increasing. In the amendment there is a demand that the credit of the country be more sensibly utilised towards reducing the growing masses of unemployed people in the country. With all that before us, the nearest thing we had to a Government spokesman has just sat down. I certainly say this definitely: that during all the time he was on his feet he directed attention neither to the motion nor to the amendment. The man who directed all his energy in an endeavour to mislead the country as to what was demanded either in the motion or in the amendment is—it is hard to believe it—an individual who sprang into fame and notoriety as the father of a plan for no income-tax in this country. Politics certainly makes strange bed-fellows. It also extracts strange confessions, but I think the strangest evolution that has been produced in this country inside the last 20 years is the development, from an embryonic non-income-tax advocate, to a stalwart of heavy taxation. He has had the audacity to throw out a challenge to other Deputies as to what suggestions they have for a reduction of taxation, and he was not interrupted by anyone suggesting "No income-tax". But it would be very obvious—"No income-tax"—if we were given to interruptions.

This Report of the Banking Commission was published nearly 12 months ago and, without exaggeration, this at least is true, that danger signals were flying in every second chapter of it. Things, to say the least, were not healthy and were not satisfactory when we found it necessary to appoint a commission to inquire into all the matters dealt with. But having appointed a commission and got a report of a very grave nature, one would expect that the Government itself would take an early opportunity to bring that report before the Dáil and have it discussed. And yet, it is only when a motion is put down by the Opposition that we get, at the very tail-end of a Parliamentary session, rather grudging permission to have it discussed, and when the opportunity arises for discussing it we have a blank wall of studied silence on the Government Front Bench as deliberately offensive as it is callous.

Now, it may be that the Government case is this: that circumstances are such that they see no prospect of an avenue through which they can reduce taxation. If that is their answer that case has got to be made, and not the frivolous type of question that we get from the Parliamentary Secretary as to where you would reduce taxation, how, and off what. If the Parliamentary Secretary paid more attention to the proceedings of the Dáil, beyond coming in here when the bell rings for a division, he would not have to think very hard to remember that on occasion after occasion the expenditure of public moneys was opposed by the various Parties in this Assembly. The last occasion was when the proposal was for the expenditure of many millions of pounds on the production of a ground army, of heavy bombers for the air, tanks, etc. The question was put at the time, if this is purely an army for defensive purposes in this country, and not offensive purposes elsewhere, why do we want all the paraphernalia of an army about to invade another country? We regarded that at the time, and stated it at the time, as a sheer waste of public money. We opposed all the expenditure, rightly or wrongly, and now we have had the twittish type of speech that has just come from the Parliamentary Secretary as to how money could be saved or what proposal we ever made for the saving of money. We had a huge, unequalled demand for new taxation to meet new expenditure, the demand coming in two directions, to meet it immediately out of revenue for this year; and a proposal to increase the public debt of the country to meet demands from that quarter. We opposed that, and new we are asked by the Parliamentary Secretary did we ever make a proposal to reduce taxation, and did we ever agree on economy in any direction. Every fourth spending measure introduced by the Government has been opposed, but the bell rang and the majority was against us.

That commission sat and its report was issued at a time when every possible means of abstracting taxation from the people had been utilised to the full; when income-tax has gone to a figure unequalled in times of peace in this country, when it has got a sudden jerk of an increase of 1/- in the £; when indirect taxation has been carried to an extent that years ago anybody would consider impossible in this country. When, in order to meet the growing demands of a Government prone to spend, we have reached the point where we cannot exempt from the tax gatherer's rake even the poorest pauper in the country, when tax after tax has been clapped on the immediate necessaries of life in the poorest homes, and when we have a motion down to discourage or deplore that set of circumstances, we have that motion debated for six or seven hours and complete silence from the Government Bench. On public platforms neither the Taoiseach nor any of his Ministers is so very reticent as they are in this Assembly. When an opportunity is given for making a speech and there is no opportunity to reply, then they are all very vocal. When it is a case of making a promise, or stating that there is a plan for this, that, or the other, then everyone of them is very vocal outside this Assembly. But in here, where the plan should be implemented—if it exists—the plan for lowering taxation is in practice a plan for rapidly increasing taxation month after month and year after year.

That report deplores the rapidly mounting deadweight debt and rapidly increasing taxation. The motion deals with the cruel indirect taxation as well as the direct taxation. The amendment deals with the growing unemployment in this country. It is my opinion at all events that the whole thing is a senseless vicious circle. We increase surtax, we increase income-tax, we increase rates, and we justify all that by talking glibly about social services. Because of the increasing overhead charges in any particular industry, we force economy at the other end. The result of all the increasing taxation is increasing unemployment through the dire necessity of economising in some direction in order to meet the exorbitant demands of the Government on taxpayers. When we have a situation like that, and when we have a report calling attention to these things, and when we have a motion inviting the Government to express their views, to state their plans or name their intentions in view of that dismal picture, we have the Taoiseach adopting the role of jovial interrupter. We have his Ministers beside him silent, and in the course of six hours we have no Government spokesman except an individual put up to make a speech against a non-existent motion. I wonder at times if the Government have ceased to take their responsibilities seriously, or if they ever commenced to take their responsibilities seriously.

We are debating this motion in a country whose export trade in agricultural produce alone has fallen from something in the neighbourhood of £35,000,000 to considerably below £20,000,000 a year, and we are facing that situation at a time when the Minister for Finance introduces a Budget and tells us that if war breaks out in Europe the position in this country will be so serious that it will be a case of tax all you can where you can. When we have Government Deputies—not Opposition Deputies— one after another getting up and sounding a note of warning, telling the Government that if things are not altered within 12 months or so the position will be really desperate; with our export trade shrinking so rapidly that one can almost say it has gone; with unemployment reaching an apalling and unprecedented figure; with direct taxation gone to a figure beyond the recollection of any living man; with indirect taxation carried to such a fiendish extent that no labourer can call his wages his own; and when there is an opportunity for discussing all those things, and when criticism is levelled at that state of affairs by one speaker after another from different quarters of the House, we are met with deliberate, studied, Government silence. As one Deputy in this Assembly, I wish to record my protest against the manner in which the Dáil is being treated. Sooner or later—when it was not done sooner, then let it be done later, at the end of the Government's seventh or eighth year in office—I would invite the Ministers to begin to face up to their responsibilities even when it is a bit awkward. One way to make at least a beginning is by not sitting silent— by not remaining open to the brand of moral cowardice and clever political trickery through sitting hour after hour in face of a motion and amendment such as we have here.

Two Deputies rose.

Comment on this

Minister! Minister!

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

The Minister would have risen in this debate long ago if those who were responsible for the motion and those who were responsible for the amendment had stated to the House the reasons which drove them to the conclusion, in the first place, that it was necessary to reduce the burden of direct and indirect taxation, and to restrict the creation of further deadweight public debt. I should have risen earlier, perhaps, if we had heard from the Labour Benches a reasoned speech in favour of their amendment. We had a long, prolix, turgid statement from Deputy Norton, who did not adduce any figures to prove his major premise that the reports of the Banking Commission indicate that there is now a serious depression in agriculture. It is quite true that, when this report was being drafted, not merely this country but agricultural and manufacturing countries the world over were just emerging from a very serious economic depression. Super-added to that we had the difficulties occasioned by the dispute with Great Britain, and undoubtedly those factors weighed very heavily with those who were responsible for drafting not merely the report signed by the majority of the Banking Commission but with those who were responsible for drafting the three Minority Reports as well.

But I think that any student of the Reports, and particularly any person who presumes to base his case in this House upon the words of the Majority Report, ought, in fairness, to have submitted to the House what were the causes to which the signatories to that Report ascribed the depression in Irish agriculture. As it has not been done, I should, perhaps, read what the Majority Report does say on that head:

"Before the agricultural depression set in, about 45 to 50 per cent. of the gross output of Free State agriculture was exported. In 1935-36, under the influence of the depression,"—the world depression—"the financial dispute with the United Kingdom, and the policy of replacing imports by domestic production of wheat and beet, and other products, only 34.4 per cent. of the total gross output was exported...

"The three main factors to be considered are, as just said, the following:

"Firstly, the agricultural depression, which began to make itself felt in 1928 in a drop in the price of wheat in the world markets, and in 1931 began to affect, also, prices of foodstuffs of animal origin, has, in the Irish Free State, as in most other countries, including the United Kingdom, given rise to some measures of Government action for the assistance of agriculture.

"Secondly, the financial dispute with the United Kingdom, of which an important feature is the imposition of special duties by the British Government, has led to the granting of subsidies in aid of Free State exports and has also in other aspects affected the country's agriculture."

It is quite clear from that that any references contained in the Reports of the Banking Commission to the serious depression in agriculture—and it is upon such references that the case, for the amendment, at any rate, has been made—referred to transitory causes, and causes which, in one respect at any rate, have completely ceased, and, in the other, are rapidly passing away.

Comment on this

The report deliberately denies that.

Comment on this

What does the phrase "depression in agriculture" usually connote? In its usual acceptance it would appear to describe a state of affairs characterised by a considerable reduction in the incomes of persons depending upon the land.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister has purported to read from the Banking Commission's Report. The extracts which the Minister has read from the report represent one-half of paragraph 74 of that report. The second half of that paragraph, which he has not read, specifically says that for the purposes of their study—

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order. Any Deputy or Minister may quote as much of any official document as he cares. The Chair has no control.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this

You having ruled, Sir, I presume I may speak.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is another point of order.

Comment on this

I am raising another point of order. Is it proper for a Deputy or Minister to read a paragraph from an official document in a mutilated form calculated to deceive Dáil Éireann as to the contents of the quotation?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As the Chair stated in first replying to the Deputy, Ministers or Deputies may quote as much as they desire or as little as they desire of any report or document.

Comment on this

I was saying that the causes to which the decline in agricultural incomes are attributed in the Majority Report have now largely disappeared, and disappeared because of the ending of the economic war by the signing of the Agreement with the United Kingdom, to which Deputy Norton, who deplores the depression in agriculture, took such voluble exception when he was on his feet. Having now ceased, because of the ending of the economic war and the lightening, during the past two years of 1937-38 of the world depression in agriculture, we now find that our cattle exports, which amounted in value to £2,361,000 in the period from January to May, 1936, have risen to £3,792,000 in the corresponding period of the present year. That certainly does not indicate any decline or any diminution in farmers' incomes, and it does not indicate any intensification of the depression in agriculture, which, admittedly, existed to some extent in the year 1936.

Comment on this

Perhaps you will give us the figures for 1932.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies must give as good a hearing to the Minister as they expected and got.

Comment on this

Not merely, however, have there been increases in the value of our cattle exported, but we have also increases recorded in the period January to May over the values in the same period last year in exports of milch cows, sheep, lambs, pigs and horses. The total increase in the value of the live animals exported in this period has been no less than 34 per cent. Perhaps I had better give the full figures for the value of the exports of live animals in the years 1935 to 1938. In the year 1935, the value of the animals exported came to £7,316,000; for the year 1936, it was £8,952,000; for the year 1937, it was £9,803,000; and for the year 1938, it was no less than £11,958,000.

But it was not merely in regard to our exports of live stock that the value of our export trade went up. We had the same tendency manifested in other principal agricultural exports. For instance, within the period January to May this year—I am giving the latest figures available—the export of bacon and hams came to £826,000; in 1938, that is last year, within the same period, the export amounted to £699,000; in 1937, the year previously, it was £620,000; and in 1936, it was £614,000. So that there has been an increase of over 33? per cent. in the export of bacon and hams within the first five months of this year as compared with the first five months of the year 1936.

Comment on this

Give us the figures for pigs.

Comment on this

I had better give the total figures for the year in regard to bacon and hams. In 1935, the total export was £1,427,000. For 1938, the value of bacon and hams exported from this country had risen to £2,257,000.

Comment on this

Give us the figures for pork and pigs.

Comment on this

I shall give a lot if I am only permitted to talk without interruption. The total exports of butter in 1935 were valued at £1,658,000; in 1936 they had risen to £1,917,000; in 1937 they had fallen to £1,589,000, but last year exports totalled £2,159,000, an increase of almost 33?% over the figures for 1935. The export of eggs during the first five months of this year amounted to £732,000; in 1938 to £614,000; in 1937 to £527,000; and in 1936 to £613,000. For the whole of 1935 they amounted to £995,000, and for the whole of last year to £1,176,000. These are not reckless statements. These are figures which I can stand over and which no one can controvert. We are not talking now in exaggerated terms of the poverty that exists here and there or using wild generalities. These are figures which show that there has been a continuous improvement in the position of agriculture and agriculturists over the years 1935 to 1939. They are the only sort of arguments that should be used in a debate of this sort where, presumably, people want to talk in terms of £s.d., because it is in terms of £s.d. of a fixed standard of value that the condition of the people can be most concretely expressed. To sum up, by giving a comprehensive total for the value of agricultural exports in the four years which we have been considering, we find that whereas in 1935 they amounted to £13,834,000, last year they had risen to £19,657,000 or had gone up in value almost 50 per cent. I should say also that the agricultural price index for 1938 stood at 111.9 and was higher than it had reached here since 1930.

Let us consider it from another point of view. We were told of the impoverished condition of our herds, and that they had shrunk. The figures do not show that. The last inventory up to June 1st, 1938, showed an all-round increase over 1937 in the live stock population, which had gone up by 2.6 per cent. The number of sheep went up 6.8 per cent., the number of pigs went up 2.6 per cent., while horses went up 2.9 per cent. In face of this evidence of improvement in the agricultural position, surely there is no justification for the major premise, on which the Labour amendment is based, that there is an aggravated depression in agriculture here. On the contrary, as I have shown, there has been a continuous improvement in agricultural conditions here over the past four years.

Let me get back to the motion. I presume it is intended to be taken seriously. We had a very eloquent speech from the proposer of the motion. I think it would have been a much more practical speech if it had been more closely related to the motion. I presume the terms of the motion were thought by those who put it down to be worthy of serious analysis. Let us see, therefore, what this motion that we have been discussing for the past six hours does in fact say:

That the Dáil is of opinion that in view of the contents of the Majority Report of the Banking Commission steps should at once be taken——

to do certain things.

Surely that presupposes that those who put down the motion made a careful and a critical study of all the reports of the Banking Commission, and that, for reasons which to them seemed well-founded they have pinned their faith to the recommendation set out in the Majority Report. At least, if they wanted the matter seriously discussed they would have given us the arguments in the Majority Report which led the members of the Opposition Party to these certain conclusions. What reference did we hear to the Majority Report from the proposer of the motion? We were told that there is in the Banking Commission's report abundant material to examine. Undoubtedly, there is in the Majority Report abundant material to examine, material which, no doubt, was accurate at the date it was given, but which is long out-of-date, as the figures I have quoted, showing the trend of agricultural production in this country over the past four years, amply testify. Much of the information available in the Majority Report is completely out-of-date by reason of the fact that what was, perhaps, if not the major cause, at any rate, a very weighty factor in the depression which we endured here from 1934 to 1937, has completely disappeared, and we have now the British market upon better terms than our farmers ever enjoyed that market before. In the light of that, all the figures set out in the report would have to be reviewed, revised and considered anew.

There are a great many recommendations in regard to what I might describe as the mechanism of our financial system, and particularly in regard to governmental accounting and public finance which, perhaps, do not need much revision even in the light of the changed situation. But apart from these there are statements of economic facts which no longer hold. Undoubtedly, a great many of the forces which impelled the majority of the members of the commission to make drastic recommendations, in regard to certain features of governmental activity, have disappeared, and the situation, in my view, is not at all as grave as it might have appeared to those who made the recommendations generally referred to in the years 1936 and 1937 when, I understand, the report was drafted.

It has been suggested that the Government has been unduly dilatory in making up its mind in regard to the recommendations contained in any of the reports of the Banking Commission. I do not know whether Deputies really have done more than look at the covers of the reports, or simply skimmed through them in the hope of finding some statement which would be useful to them as political ammunition. Certainly, there was no indication given by any of the speeches we heard from the Front Opposition Benches whether from the proposer of the motion or those who supported him, or by the speech of the Labour Leader, who was responsible for the amendment, that the Report of the Banking Commission and the appendices and the addenda had been seriously considered by them. Let us see what really the Report of the Banking Commission does represent in terms of material for investigation and consideration.

The Majority Report, as has already been indicated here this evening, is not by any means a completely self-contained document. There are appended to it four addenda by different members. They are not addenda dissenting from the main report. They do relate to matters which those who prepared and signed the respective addenda felt had to be dealt with at some greater length than in the report. But they are not, in the main, inconsistent with the recommendations of the report and, therefore, there is no point in a person who is presumed to hold a responsible position in the Labour Party—whether the presumption is too great for ordinary acceptance or not, I am not going to say—one who is presumed to hold a responsible position in this House as a leader of one of the principal Parties —there is no excuse for him to use the sort of slick trick-of-the-loopery he did when he alleged that this report has been signed by ten members of the commission. It was signed, not by ten, but by 16 members.

Comment on this

Is the expression used by the Minister a parliamentary expression?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It was not used in a personal sense.

Comment on this

It was not used in a personal sense.

Comment on this

It is scarcely one that would be used by a gentleman, a Minister.

Comment on this

In addition to these addenda, there is one note by another member of the commission who signed the Majority Report, and there are two separate reservations relating primarily to the question of housing and the question of land division by yet two other members. Apart from these reservations and addenda, there are 32 appendices to the Majority Report and, while a number of these may be purely statistical, there are others relating to the census of production, national income, social credit, Papal encyclicals, central banking, and the effect of State action on commodity prices, all of which call for individual consideration in relation to the main report. I am not for a moment suggesting that there is not in the Majority Report a complete set of recommendations, but it must be quite clear to any person that a final view can only be formed of these recommendations after a full examination of the addenda and appendices, which cover over 200 pages and, in addition, a full consideration of the three minority reports, two with appendices; and not merely that, but, as the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Flinn, has pointed out, in addition, the evidence taken before the commission must also be carefully considered in conjunction with the reports and with the evidence, which alone fills two half volumes.

That has to be done, and not merely that, but, as these recommendations affect a very large number of Government Departments and a very large part of the general machinery and operation of government in this country, it is quite clear that a considerable period of time must elapse before they are even put in form for consideration, with the necessary observations of the particular Government Department concerned and data and the necessary collation of all the various aspects that have to be considered by any Government in relation to any major matter. Before all these things are in form for our consideration, it is quite clear that a considerable period must elapse and, whether for good or ill, I think people must take this point of view in regard to all the very valuable work that we cannot accept it as Holy Writ. When I say that I am not for one moment inclined to decry the work of this commission and all the very valuable work done by all the members of the commission, in trying to express certain points of view, trying to secure for us data which are necessary. This commission has undertaken—I can say it, and I think it will be generally agreed—the first thorough survey of our economic resources, of our economic structure and conditions, that has been made here, so far as I know, within historical times.

I am not going to decry the immense value of the work done by these gentlemen. There is no person who would be prepared to pay a higher tribute to them than I, but I am not going to take, and I am certain my colleagues in the Government, and the members in the House, and the general public, are not going to take the members of the Banking Commission as working under the afflatus of Divine inspiration. They are just human beings, whose conclusions may have been well-founded in some respects, but whose conclusions in other respects may be completely erroneous, and it is our duty to give to the recommendations which they have made the same careful study which they gave to the facts upon which they based those recommendations. When we have done that, we will be in a position to put before the people a policy, based upon the study of these reports, which we can confidently recommend to the people and which, I am sure, the people will be prepared to accept in these circumstances.

I would like, again, to draw the attention of the House to this very peculiar motion. It states here "That the Dáil is of opinion that in view of the contents of the majority report of the Banking Commission steps should at once be taken..." It is quite obvious that that motion has been worded in such a way as to lead the people outside to infer that the members of the Opposition have adopted and accepted the recommendations of the Majority Report. But that is not written down here in this motion, and it is not upon what people outside might infer, or might be led to infer, from the sort of speeches we have been listening to and the sort of agitation that has been going on in the Press which supports the Opposition Party, and upon certain platforms which they sometimes grace, ever since the report of this Commission was published, that the House is going to divide. The division upon this motion is going to be taken, not upon the merits or demerits of the Banking Commission Report, either of the Majority Report or any of the minority reports, but it is going to be taken upon three specific things, all of which must be taken together. There are not going to be separate divisions on No. 1, No. 2 and No. 3. The whole lot have to be taken as one collective whole. The first thing that this House is asked to do is to take steps to reduce the burden of direct and indirect taxation. I would like to examine that in some detail.

Comment on this

You have just an hour and ten minutes.

Comment on this

First of all, it is quite clear that whoever drafted this motion did not guard against ambiguity. We have two phrases used here in direct juxtaposition, in opposition to each other—direct and indirect taxation. What was really meant, perhaps, was that the direct taxes, the taxes upon individuals per se, such taxes as income-tax and other taxes which were supposed to fall immediately and directly upon individuals, were to be reduced, and that, at the same time, taxes which fall directly and immediately upon commodities, and only fall indirectly upon those individuals who use commodities, were to be reduced, but I gathered by the speech that was made by the mover of this motion that that was not what he had in mind, but that what he did imply by direct taxation was that all taxes, whether direct or indirect, were imposed and collected by the State for the purposes of the Exchequer. I hope I am right in that assumption.

Comment on this

Is the Minister inviting me to interrupt him? I shall be glad to do so at some length, if he wants me to interrupt him.

Comment on this

I know that the Deputy is always glad to talk at length on any subject, but we are not always quite so eager to listen to him. What do we mean, however, when we say that, in the opinion of this House, the Government ought to take steps to reduce taxation? I do not suppose it is necessary for me to say to any member of the House that taxes are only collected for one purpose. We do not collect taxes merely for the sake of despoiling the citizen or in order to appropriate the taxes to our own personal use. We collect taxation here for the purpose of maintaining the public services, and therefore, when a Deputy gets up and says that, in the opinion of this House, taxation must be reduced, what he means, in fact, is that, in his opinion, and in the opinion of those who support him, certain public services ought to be curtailed. There is no way, to my mind, at any rate, in which taxation can be significantly reduced unless you curtail certain public services—at least, as far as I know. Of course, you may make minor economies here and there. You may cut down staff—some superfluous staff, let us say, in this Department or in that—but I do not think that the Government services, as a whole, are largely over-staffed. There may be occasional redundancies here and there, but it must be remembered that there is not the same freedom of action in connection with a Government Department as there is in connection with a private undertaking. Therefore, as I say, you may have redundancy occasionally in certain Government Departments, but on the whole there is no great redundancy, and, therefore, there can be no great economy effected, or any great reduction in taxation, unless you curtail certain public services, and not merely curtail certain services, but curtail the larger public services—those which involve the greatest expenditure—somewhat drastically.

Now, let us see what the position is in that regard. I am prepared to make this concession to Deputies, and particularly to Opposition Deputies, that, as compared with the year 1931-32, there has been an increase in taxation amounting to £4,701,000. Let us see where we are going to try, accordingly, to effect the reduction in expenditure that would be necessary to enable us to revert to the position of 1931-32. It is essential that the public should know what is involved in this cry to reduce taxation, because I am going to suggest to Deputies who ask the Government to reduce taxation to tell the Government how, in their opinion, expenditure ought to be curtailed in order that taxation may be reduced.

Comment on this

What plan had you before 1932, when you were going to reduce taxation by £2,000,000? Can you go back to that plan?

Comment on this

Yes, the Minister might get some inspiration from it.

Comment on this

Let us take the Services, one by one, and I am going to ask the House to grant me some indulgence because I want to have this matter cleared to the bottom.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Let us take the Central Fund services first. For last year the expenditure thereon amounted to £4,850,000, and of this £2,210,000 was for the service of debt. We have heard something in this discussion about the deadweight debt, and we were told by Deputy Dillon, who was very eloquent, that we were tottering towards bankruptcy and that, shortly, we were going to find ourselves in the position of Newfoundland or even of New Zealand; but what is our position in regard to the debt charges in 1938-39 as compared with 1931-32? I have given the House the figures for the year 1938-39—£2,210,000—but in 1931-32, this halcyon year on which Deputies opposite used to be harping back, the charge for the debt services amounted to £2,065,778; so that, notwithstanding all that we have heard from Deputies opposite, and notwithstanding the black picture that has been painted of the state of the public finances, we find that the amount which our people have to pay in respect of past expenditures has only increased by something less than £145,000 per annum over seven years, and the sum and substance of all this cry about the deadweight debt charges has been that it has increased at the rate of £20,000 per annum. Surely, nobody is going to say that that is an alarming weight for a community so progressive as our community, from the statistics which I gave for agricultural production, is shown to be.

Deputies, however, have grounded their demand for the reduction in taxation upon, apparently, their view of the Majority Report of the Banking Commission. How do Deputies think we are going to reduce taxation if we are to give effect to the recommendations of the Majority Report in regard to debt services? So far from that report suggesting that we are making an ample provision—and I think that we are not making an unduly small provision—but so far from the Majority Report suggesting that we are making an unduly large provision for the service of debt, they want us to make an even larger provision, and yet Deputies who, apparently, clamour that we should accept the recommendations of the Majority Report, and consequently impose additional taxation in order to make further provision for the debt charges, in the same breath tell us to reduce taxation. Now, which do they want to have? If we are going to give effect to the recommendations of the majority in regard to the debt services, we must increase taxation and increase it considerably. How do Deputies want us to do that and at the same time reconcile it with the demand to reduce taxation?

The next largest item in these Central Fund services is an amount of £1,162,000, which is represented by payments to the Road Fund. That is merely the handing over to the Road Fund, with certain exceptions this year and in two earlier years, of the amount that is collected by way of the motor vehicle duties.

Then we come to the next largest individual item, which is a sum of £599,000 in respect of the agricultural grant under the Local Government Act, 1898. Now, those who have put down this motion have been clamouring here in this House, that not merely should we provide this £599,000, but that we should provide almost another £2,000,000 in order to complete the derating of agricultural land. How will they reconcile their attitude to-day in regard to the reduction of taxation with their attitude during the last general election, when they were soundly defeated on this question as to whether we should in fact impose additional taxation to the tune of £2,000,000 in order that we might derate agricultural land?

There is another sum, of £476,000, representing the balance of the local taxation grant, also paid to the local authorities. Do the Deputies who want us to reduce taxation want us to cut that out? The only other items of any significance in the Central Fund services are the £250,000 annuity payable to the United Kingdom under the Damage to Property (Compensation) Act of 1926—an Act which the principal Opposition Party (the Party which is now the principal Opposition in this House) was responsible for putting on the Statute Book, in order that they might be in a position to fulfil a contract which they had made with a neighbouring Government. Do the Deputies who are clamouring for the reduction of taxation want us to cut that out: do they want us to dishonour their bond?

Comment on this

Why did you not keep the promises that were made?

Comment on this

This is a promise that was made before 1932. They made it in 1926, and we have to collect £250,000 as taxation in order to honour it.

From the figures which I have given, which relate entirely to the services charged on the Central Fund, it would appear that if taxation is to be reduced and if the conservative attitude which the Opposition have adopted during this debate is to be given effect to, economies must be made in the supply services. In connection with my Financial Statement, I circulated an important set of tables to this House. One of the most important, I think, from the point of view of a discussion of this kind, is Table No. 7. In that connection I set out there the figures for the realised expenditure upon all the public services for the year 1931-32, and for the actual expenditure for the year 1938-39 on those same services. I would like for a moment to set those figures before the House for their consideration.

I do hope that the Deputy who was responsible for moving this motion, when he comes to wind up this debate, will take up the challenge which I made, not merely in the Budget speech of this year but in the Budget speeches of earlier years, and tell the House and tell the people—because it is important that the people should know what is implied in a motion of this sort and that the House should have some further token that the Opposition are in earnest when they put forward a proposition of this kind—what particular services he would curtail— where he is going to make the economies which it would be necessary to make in order to enable us to reduce taxation. That is an issue which he cannot afford to shirk if he is honest and sincere, and I am giving him credit for being both. If he is honest—notwithstanding the fact that he is an astute politician—and if he is sincere in this matter, he will say categorically what the services are that he would put forward to the Government as services which should be curtailed in order that, as I have said, taxation might be reduced; because there can be no reduction of taxation without a curtailment of expenditure upon certain services.

Take Table No. 7, to which I have been referring. The first category of services set out in the table is one to which, for want of a better description, I have been referring as the social services proper. I have given there the Exchequer issue on the 12 services included in that category. Last year the total issues amounted to £9,781,000 and for the year 1931-32 the audited expenditure upon social services proper which were then in existence amounted to £4,552,000—an increase, all told, of, say, £5,230,000.

Comment on this

That is, between expenditure and estimate.

Comment on this

No; on this occasion, in order that there might be no possibility of a quibble or an evasion, I have given the audited expenditure for 1931-32 and the actual expenditure for 1938-39. The audit may change the figures for 1938-39, but it will not do so, as the Deputy knows, to any significant extent.

Comment on this

Is it because it is a more favourable figure that the Minister is taking it?

Comment on this

I am comparing the figures for 1938-39 with the audited figures for 1931-32, and I have told the Deputy that in regard to this category, which, for want of a better description, I have called social services proper, we expended in the year 1938-39 £9,781,000, that is £5,229,000 more than was expended in 1931-32.

Comment on this

Is the Minister borrowing to get that?

Comment on this

Yes, we are.

Comment on this

Deduct that.

Comment on this

We are borrowing £350,000 more, but if I refrain from borrowing that £350,000 more, I have got to increase taxation by a corresponding amount.

Comment on this

If we are on taxation let us keep to it.

Comment on this

No, we are going to keep to the services. It is of primary importance that the Opposition should come out in its true colours and tell us—for once they ought to be blunt and straightforward with the people— what services they propose to reduce.

The expenditure upon the first eight items in that table is undertaken upon services such as old age pensions, widows and orphans pensions, unemployment assistance, national health insurance, relief schemes and employment schemes, grant for milk, meals for school children and medical treatment for school children.

Comment on this

And the expenses for the Ministry of Local Government administration?

Comment on this

Yes; a very essential item in all social services, because the expense of administration is part of the cost. One can reduce the cost of administration by reducing the amount expended upon services and, therefore, all have to be taken together. The point about it is, however, that here are eight services which I think are of vital importance. This motion proposes that we should do certain things in order to stimulate profitable production and abolish poverty within the State. The eight services are to alleviate distress and they tend, therefore, in accordance with Part III of this motion, to abolish poverty within the State. I want to know, in relation to any of these eight services, whether the Leader of the principal Opposition and his Party propose to make any recommendations for their reduction which would enable a reduction in taxation, if the proposals were agreed to and were acceptable to the people and to the House.

I am leaving these eight services for the moment and coming to other services within the same category. The next heading in the table to which I have referred is the provision which is being made in order to assist the local authorities to deal with the housing problem, which is so grave and serious throughout the country. Under that heading, we provide both grants and contributions to local authorities in respect of the loan charges on moneys raised from State sources and otherwise for housing. Does the principal Opposition Party suggest or recommend—and this is a question which, I am perfectly certain, the people outside, who are taking, I have no doubt, a great interest in this debate, are going to ask the Party which has made itself responsible for this proposal—that we should curtail the provision which, at the present moment, we are making, and making, I might say, in conditions of great stress and stringency? The Deputy quoted my words, but we are undoubtedly, even in the midst of the present uncertain position, making a very large provision in order that the people may be properly and decently housed, and I am asking Deputies who want us to reduce taxation to say, if they do not propose or suggest any curtailment of expenditure on old age pensions, unemployment assistance and the rest, that we should curtail expenditure on housing, that we should ask the local authorities to suspend their housing programme, and that we should refuse to assist the local authorities to the extent of our ability to do so?

Apart altogether from what views Deputies might have in regard to the future, I remember quite distinctly, when the first Housing Act was introduced, the very warm welcome it received, no doubt very sincerely expressed, from Deputy Dillon. We could not at one stage possibly spend enough money on housing, and if I am any judge of Deputy Dillon's approach to these social problems, I would assume that if the question arose as to whether we should, or should not, curtail expenditure on housing, and if we proposed to do such a thing, Deputy Dillon would be up in arms against us and would probably go out, waving the Red Flag, and try to head a revolution against the established authority in the State.

Comment on this

Not the Red Flag, surely? The republican flag.

Comment on this

Again, we have all these other services which come under the control of, and are administered by, the Minister for Local Government. Deputy Mulcahy knows them well, and Deputy Cosgrave, no doubt, knows them equally well, because he was Minister for Local Government in the Cabinet of the First and Second Dáil, and I am certain that he takes a very great interest in all these social problems. Is there any one of these services administered by the Department of Local Government which Deputy Cosgrave would be prepared to recommend should be curtailed or suspended?

The only remaining item, with the exception of Gaeltacht Services, which is comparatively small, under the heading of social services proper, is the Land Commission expenditure and here, undoubtedly, there has been a jump of no less than £1,032,000 between the year 1931-32 and the year 1938-39. About £600,000 of the increase in expenditure under the Land Commission Vote is due to the halving of the land purchase annuities, and there is no escape, in my view, unless, and this is what Deputy Dillon, who sits for Donegal, may have had in mind——

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon sits for County Monaghan.

Comment on this

I forgot for the moment that the Deputy is, so to speak, a political bird of passage. I do not know for what constituency he will be sitting after the next general election.

Comment on this

The Minister need not be one bit uneasy. He will be at the top of the poll in County Monaghan.

Comment on this

A prospective candidate in Mayo in one general election, sitting for Donegal after the next general election, and, a year or two years afterwards, sitting for Monaghan.

Comment on this

The Minister travelled a bit himself.

Comment on this

I have had to leave my own constituency once and the Deputy can have that for what it is worth. Let me stick to this question of the Land Commission, because there is a service upon which there has been a very considerable increase in expenditure. As I have told the House, the expenditure on the Land Commission Vote, the actual issues last year, amounted to £1,032,000 more than for 1931-32, and, of that, no less than £600,000 has been incurred by reason of the fact that we halved the annuities payable under the post-1923 Land Acts. I ask Deputies opposite whether they are prepared to recommend that that concession should be done away with or withdrawn, and that a Bill be sent to the Oireachtas to enable it to be done. There is a sum of £600,000 there to be saved and, thereby, a £600,000 reduction in taxation. Are the Deputies, opposite, or any other Deputies, whether on the Government Benches or elsewhere, prepared to suggest that that concession should be withdrawn and that the full annuities under the post-1923 Land Acts should be payable by any of the existing body of tenant purchasers? That is the question I am putting to Deputy Dillon, not in the hope that he will give me an immediate reply, but that he will give me a considered answer sometime to-morrow, when he rises to close the debate. He will have a full opportunity then and I await with great interest what he has to say in the matter.

Comment on this

How much is the Land Commission itself costing?

Comment on this

Expenditure upon all the services which I have mentioned, and which was met from revenue, was £9,566,000 in 1938-39, compared with £4,552,000 in 1931-32, representing an increase of £5,014,000. The increase in the total supply services to be met from revenue in the same period, that is, all the services, and not merely those which I have described as social services proper—was £6,813,000 and, there, accordingly, the social services proper represent 74 per cent. of the increase in the cost. There is a very large sum. Is there any Deputy who is prepared to recommend that we should save that 74 per cent.? I am perfectly certain that there is not one. I know, furthermore, that if there were one, and if he stood for that policy in present circumstances, he would disappear from public life, temporarily, certainly, and, I feel, almost as certainly, permanently.

Comment on this

How much is the Land Commission itself costing?

Comment on this

The next block of services dealt with in this table, in the category which I have described as "Other similar services", is the educational services. On the education services, there was an increase in 1938-39, over 1931-32, of £469,000. There was an increase of £112,000 for secondary education—and, mind you, this is a reflection of the conditions existing in this State, both in town and country—due in a considerable measure to the increased attendance at secondary schools. There were many more people both in town and country able to afford to send their children to secondary schools in 1938-39 than there were in the year 1931-32. That fact certainly is not consistent with the lugubrious statement with which members of the Labour Party prefaced their amendment to this motion.

The next item in this table to which, perhaps, I ought to refer is Army pensions. We have increased Army pensions by £394,000. I remember in the year 1936-37 that leading members of the Opposition were pressing us to provide these £394,000 additional to the Army pensions because they thought it would be a good election stunt to make more generous provision for Army pensions than we had made. It would be very interesting, indeed, if they proposed now to try to secure any economy in that expenditure.

Take the next category in this table. That is the category of services which had been classified as developmental services. There is an increase there of £1,600,000 in the year 1938-39 above the amount in the year 1931-32. Of this sum no less than £1,064,000 additional expenditure is accounted for by agricultural and fishery services including afforestation. I do not know whether Deputies are going to suggest any economies under that head or whether they are going to try to reduce the expenditure which we make in order to develop and assist agriculture in this country, or whether they are going to tell us to stop these services or to drop any idea of developing the fisheries. There you have in respect of developmental services including expenditure upon turf, fisheries and afforestation no less a sum than £1,600,000 more spent in 1938-39 than was spent in the year 1931-32. There, Deputies have ample opportunities to reduce expenditure if only they have the honesty to say that their motion was seriously intended and that they are prepared to face the consequence of it.

There are a number of other services. Of the remaining 17 items in this Table 7 only seven showed any increase Two of these were:—Wireless Broadcasting where the increased expenditure paid for itself. The increased expenditure was met by an increase in revenue; and Stationery and Printing where the increase has been due to the rise in prices. There were a number of other services on which the increase in expenditure was considerable.

I would like the Party which has taken responsibility for putting down this motion to tell the House what its attitude is in regard to these services.

Upon Posts and Telegraphs we are spending £245,000 more than in 1931-32. That has been necessary in order to give the farmers and others the increased facilities for which they have been asking and in order to provide the increased remuneration for those engaged in that service. I never yet heard any Deputy on the Opposition side on any occasion upon which the Vote for Posts and Telegraphs was before the House suggest that any reduction should be made either in that remuneration or in the services which the Department provided. Here Deputies have an opportunity to-night when asking for a reduction to tell whether they want us to reduce this £245,000 additional expenditure that was incurred under Posts and Telegraphs this year. On the Gárda Síochána service we are spending £219,000 additional. The greater part of that expenditure is not within our control. The increase has been determined by the fact that the great body of the Guards came in here 15 or 16 years ago. By the incremental scales to which they are entitled under the conditions of their service there are increases in the salaries in some cases in consecutive years and in other cases at intervals of four years. But, as we have to do in the case of damage to property compensation, we are simply honouring the bond into which the preceding Government entered with these men when they were taken into the Gárda Síochána. There has been no additional development in that service; it is due to the incremental increases. That is largely responsible for the £219,000. Then there was the partial restoration of the boot allowance to the Gárda and the increase in rent allowance which became absolutely necessary and to which the Opposition as well as the Government agreed. The Opposition have now their chance of saying that these things should be taken back or that there should be a departure from the scale that was laid down. Deputies must say something like that if they want to save £219,000 on this item.

Public Works account for £138,000, additional. This is very largely expenditure upon necessary public works of one kind or another in order to provide accommodation with which the work of the Government must be carried out. Then there are other minor services amounting to £266,000 additional.

There is, however, I gather, one service upon which the Opposition are prepared to suggest reduction. That is the provision which we made for national defence for the year 1938-39. A sum of £520,000 was spent additional to what was spent in 1931-32. Now, my recollection is that last year we were told that the Government was not spending enough upon national defence. This year we have been told by the Opposition speaker who preceded me that in his view we could save considerably with regard to national defence. What is the Government to do? Deputy O'Higgins and certain members of the Opposition have one view as to how the defence of this country can be properly provided for. The Minister for Defence and his advisers have another view. I think if the safety of this country has got to depend upon whether we are to take the view of the Minister for Defence and his advisers who know the facts— if we are to choose between the view of the Minister and his advisers and the view of so eminent a politician as Deputy O'Higgins—then I think that the people of this country would feel safer and more secure if we took the official Army view in this matter. We have to make the provision which in all the circumstances and considering carefully what the position of this country might be in the event of a European war seems best to the Minister and his advisers. I think the view of the people of the country would be that we were fully justified in imposing additional taxation for their safety and security. That is what we are doing. That is the provision we are making for the defence of this country and of our people. Defence is the only service with regard to which the principal Opposition Party in this State has ventured to say we ought to save money. That is a very easy matter to do if one were to gamble and play with the lives of the people and the future of the country. I do not think we should be a rational Government or a Government capable of dealing with our responsibilities if for a moment we took the easier course and told the people: "We are going to save money upon your defence and upon your security; we are going to reduce taxation and we hope that, if a serious European situation does develop, you will be all right."

The sum and substance of all I have been saying comes down to this—that the present scale of taxation cannot be reduced without a corresponding reduction in expenditure or an increase in the dead-weight debt. The Opposition do not want an increase in the dead-weight debt. Neither do we. It is because we do not want an increase in the dead-weight debt that we have undertaken the unplesant duty of imposing taxation upon the people in order to provide for this increased expenditure. The Opposition, who put down this motion, have now to make their choice. If they want to have these services, they can have them only by maintaining taxation on the existing level or by doing what, I think, would be completely and wholly wrong— increasing the dead-weight debt. I do think, as I have said, that, before this debate ends, we should hear from the Opposition some considered statement as to how, in their view, we are to reduce taxation. We do not want any generalities. They are of no use to a Government. We must have specific suggestions. It is no use for the Leader of the Opposition, or Deputy Dillon or Deputy Mulcahy, to get up and say that it is not their responsibility to suggest what expenditure should be curtailed. They have taken upon themselves the responsibility of telling the people that, in their view, taxation can be reduced. There goes with that a concomitant responsibility to tell the people in what way money can be saved so that taxation may be reduced and I hope that, before this debate ends, they will rise to that responsibility and tell the House and the people what we are all so anxious to hear.

I have been dealing at great length with what is implied in the suggestion that we should reduce the burden of direct taxation. It is also suggested that we should reduce indirect taxation. As I said at the beginning, indirect taxation, in the accepted connotation of the term, means those taxes levied not directly upon individuals, in the first instance, such as income-tax, but upon commodities and, therefore, only indirectly upon individuals when they use or consume such taxed commodities. That is not the sense in which the term is used in this motion. In this motion, the term is applied to those devices which are designed to fix prices by direct State intervention. What are these devices? What does the Opposition mean when it asks the House to tell the Government it should reduce indirect taxation? The devices for fixing prices are enumerated in Appendix 12 of the Majority Report of the Banking Commission and, though the information contained in that Appendix is somewhat out of date by reason of the withdrawal, as a consequence of the agreement with the United Kingdom, of the British penal duties, nevertheless, in general, the price-fixing machinery is set out-in that Appendix. Any person who turns to that Appendix will immediately notice that the principal items enumerated in that Appendix go to the benefit of that class of the community in regard to whom we have heard so much from the Opposition Benches from time to time. I refer to the farmers. We were told, for instance, by the Deputy who moved this motion that we ought to give the farmers a chance to enable them to produce at a profit and to enable them to get economic prices. Here we have in this motion a demand that we should disband the machinery by which they are able to get economic prices. To repeal the various statutory authorities for these price-fixing devices would, perhaps, result in reduction of the cost of living but it would, undoubtedly, place the farming community at the present time in a rather precarious position. We come, again, to this inconsistency; it is merely one of the many which mark the Opposition attitude in regard to this matter—that they ask us to give the farmers a chance to enable them to produce at a profit and to secure economic prices and, then, when we respond to that demand by giving the farmers guaranteed prices for butter, beet and bacon, we are told by Deputy Dillon and those who speak the same language as he does that all this is concealed taxation, that it is taxation for private, individual purposes and, therefore, that the whole of it is nothing short of immoral and should be wiped out. If we do that, we are going, undoubtedly, to prejudice very severely the position in regard to the farming community.

I am afraid I shall have to detain the House for some time because, having dealt with No. 1 of the demands made in this motion, I want to turn for a moment to consideration of the additional demand that we should restrict the creation of further dead-weight debt.

Comment on this

I thought you were talking about that for the past half hour.

Comment on this

No. I was merely dealing with the services upon which the proceeds of taxation are being expended. The Budget of this year contains proposals for creation of additional dead-weight debt amounting to £2,005,000 and, perhaps, in regard to that large sum, the details of which I shall give in a moment, the Opposition might tell us which of the heads of expenditure they would abolish. We have, of course, Defence expenditure on Votes 11 and 65, amounting to £1,350,000. That is the amount we are proposing to expend on national defence this year. For the construction of air ports we are borrowing £246,000; for property losses compensation, £3,650; for afforestation, £55,000, and for employment schemes, £350,000. Property losses compensation is a rapidly disappearing service and this is perhaps the last year in which we shall have to borrow under that head. Take the case of the air ports, for which we are borrowing £246,000. Is it the considered opinion of Deputies opposite that we should stop the construction of airports, that we should refrain from erecting any port or from utilising the opportunities which our geographical position gives us, in developing this mode of transport? It is quite easy to take a decision in regard to that, but let the country know what it is. Our Party thinks that, availing of the opportunity which God has given us, we ought to go ahead and put ourselves in a position to take the fullest advantage of whatever developments in aviation may occur in the future.

We are also borrowing £55,000 for afforestation. There has been a very insistent propaganda in recent years in favour of an enormous extension of forestry operations. That propaganda has received the support of a very large number of Deputies on the benches opposite. As I have pointed out, we are borrowing £55,000 for that purpose this year. You can avoid the creation of dead-weight debt to that extent by deciding that you do not want to have this country reafforested. I do not know whether you do or not. I take it that you have never opposed the Vote in this House. The country does not know whether you do or do not but, if you want to avoid the creation of dead-weight debt, that is one of the services you can either suspend temporarily until the country gets into a stronger economic position, or abandon permanently, but, at any rate, the obligation rests upon you of coming to a decision.

For employment schemes we are borrowing £350,000. Do you want to discontinue these schemes? If we refrain from borrowing this £350,000, we can avoid creating dead-weight debt to that extent. Of course then we shall have come into conflict with demand No. 1 in the motion because we shall have to provide that £350,000 out of taxation. There may be a third course, to drop all these employment schemes. From the wide range of choice which I have put before you, you should tell us whether you are going to impose taxation for the purpose of providing these services, whether you are going to create further dead-weight debt by borrowing for them, or whether you are going to discontinue them altogether.

Perhaps before I leave that aspect of the matter, I might refer to the fact that, apart altogether from the borrowings for the purposes which I have mentioned, debt liabilities are being contracted in other directions. Thus, as I have already mentioned, under the Housing Act the State has accepted a capital liability of 1.3 millions in the year 1937-38 and 1.1 millions last year bringing the total liability for housing purposes to 31st March last up to no less than £7,250,000. As long as rehousing is being continued on the existing scale, as long as the provisions of the Housing Acts regarding the contribution to loan charges continue, the debt in respect of housing will continue to pile up at the existing rate. There again, Deputies who sponsored this motion ought to tell us whether they contend that housing assistance should be entirely withdrawn or substantially reduced.

Another reason for our mounting liabilities is that the work of the Land Commission involves a considerable increase in the dead-weight debt. By reason of the halving of the annuities under the Act of 1933 the capital liability of the State was considerably increased. Operations under the Land Acts, 1927 to 1933, increased the figure for 1937-38 by £294,000 and for 1938-39 £180,000.

Comment on this

Is that in respect of new land division?

Comment on this

That is in respect of new land division. The Opposition Party can tell us whether in future that should be discontinued. I hope if they say so for the purposes of the debate on this motion, they will also say down the country, in the rural constituencies, that they think it should be discontinued. I hope they will be prepared to defend that opinion before the people.

Comment on this

You will be all together the next time.

Comment on this

Perhaps we might turn to consider Part III of the motion and, incidentally, in that connection to consider some of the issues raised by the Labour amendment. I think, Sir, that it can be said that to stimulate profitable production and to abolish poverty within the State are the avowed aims of every Government in the world. That is a very desirable objective, a very clear one, but I am afraid that the means by which that objective can be reached are not equally clear. Indeed, I think no one can contend that the various measures which have been taken have resulted in unqualified success. We have had an opportunity here during the past eight or nine years of watching experiments which have been made in other countries in order to deal with this problem, in order to stimulate profitable production and to abolish poverty within the State. My view, for what it may be worth, is that the greatest measure of success has attended the application of the more carefully calculated and prudent policies. We have seen very spectacular schemes undertaken in the United States, France and other countries but I think the general consensus of opinion now is that these policies have added to the difficulties of the problem rather than assisted in the solution of them.

We are a very small country with very limited resources. For an agricultural country, a country that is almost purely agricultural, this is a rather densely populated country. We are not in a position to pursue, in relation to certain matters, a completely independent policy. We produce a very large agricultural surplus, much more than we could ever consume. We must, therefore, find a market for that surplus and, therefore, in regard to the operation of a closed economy, we are in a very different position from much more powerful States. For instance, I think no one would try to contend that our capacity to control our economy would be anything, say, like the capacity of the United States —a continental country with huge resources, both natural and financial. In the United States since 1933 they have tried to put into operation all these numerous and varied schemes which are connoted by the New Deal and which, so far as I can see, have little in common except their capacity for increasing expenditure. They have pursued a very eclectic policy. They have tried everything. They have not approached the problem with any sort of prepossession in favour of one course or another. They have been willing to try everything which seemed to offer a chance of success in order to deal with this problem of stimulating profitable production and abolishing poverty within the State. And what has been the consequence? In the five years from 1933 to 1938 the gross public debt of the United States has risen from $24,000,000,000 to over $39,000,000,000— an increase of two-thirds, at the phenomenal average rate of 13 per cent. per annum. Millions of dollars have been spent in the United States on public works, on direct relief and on veteran bonuses. The National Recovery Administration secured the adoption by industry of methods involving price fixation, the elimination of the cutthroat competition, the reduction of hours and the improvement of terms of employment. Agriculture was freely subsidised; prices of agricultural products were raised; all the limitation of production was discontinued and existing mortgages were re-financed. The Reconstruction Finance Corporation, using public funds, lent money for the rehabilitation of banks and of private industry.

When this expenditure to which I have referred was initiated, production recovered for a short time and wages began to rise. The year 1937, for instance, opened with production close to the 1929 level, with prices, wages and profits rising and with business in a high state of confidence. Yet, within a very short period, by the midsummer of 1937, a recession had set in as serious as it was surprising and by the end of the year general production was down by 30 per cent. and the price of primary commodities was much below the spring peak. That is what always happens when an inflationary policy has been adopted. You have stimulation of production, an increase in wage levels, an increase in prices, and then you have—in the word which the Americans generally adopted—the recession. They call it a recession because they do not like "depression" and they do not like "slump." That, however, did not discourage them. The inflationary policy, as they termed it, was not abandoned and proposals were drawn up for spending once again as a way out of the recession. The programme of Government spending and lending was expanded and the policy which I have referred to was vigorously renewed. Millions more were spent on public works. The Reconstruction Finance Corporation was authorised to make further loans. The system of the minimum reserve ratio of the principal banks was introduced; the policy of gold sterilisation was abandoned and the funds realised were added to the Treasury to find their way into general circulation. And with what results? Once again they were disappointing. There was a slight recovery. Just as in 1937, there was a slight recovery during 1938, but again this recession, this bugbear of all inflationists, set in in December last and agricultural production has again declined. There are no signs of the recovery everybody was expecting and had anticipated from this policy of pump-priming, of using the national credit to stimulate production and to absorb the unemployed. At no time did this policy of pump-priming in America, where such huge sums were devoted to it, succeed in reducing perceptibly the huge volume of the unemployed which was variously estimated there at between 7,000,000 and 11,000,000. The number on the relief rolls remained steady at 3,500,000.

Although the dollars and cents income of the average wage-earning family was the same in 1936 as in 1929, labour costs as measured by hourly earnings had increased by 24 per cent. The inevitable result was that prices were higher and the purchasing power of the average income lower. A falling off in retail prices and in the activity in the consumption goods industries preceded the recession of 1937.

I think that it will be admitted by any person who studies very closely and carefully, as I have tried to do, the history of this experiment in the United States that in the light of the experience there it is at any rate a prima facie indication of the futility of searching for a magic formula by which the average man can produce less and yet consume more. And America is not the only country where that policy has been tried out within recent years. There are many similarities between recent economic experience in France under certain governments and that of the United States under the present Administration. Both countries adopted what might be described and what were described by those who were responsible for them, as far-reaching recovery measures. In both cases the measures aimed at raising money incomes in order to increase production and employment through the increased demands for goods and services. In each case it has been accompanied by expenditure, huge expenditure on public works and similar measures. France, like the United States, has failed to regain the 1929 level of employment and production. Employment and production continued to decline in France until the Autumn of 1936, when the franc had to be devalued; when the currency had to be depreciated; when the French had to adopt Deputy Norton's policy of cutting adrift from their recognised parity. Deputy Davin had better make a speech himself.

Comment on this

I was listening very attentively to your lecture.

Comment on this

I have been listening for the last five minutes. It has been tedious.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not endured the tedium very long.

Comment on this

I have stuck it for an hour and a half.

Comment on this

Please continue.

Comment on this

I was saying, Sir, that employment continued to decline in France until the autumn of 1936 and then they tried Deputy Norton's specific; they devalued the franc; they reduced the currency. There was a momentary increase in industrial activity, but marked, of course, by an equally enormous increase in the national debt, a persistent rise in all prices and in the cost of living, and an increase in the import surplus. I move the adjournment.

Comment on this